Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Say No to Scope Creep as a New Manager
Transcript
- Lucas: Luna, I want to start with a number. A recent survey from the management coaching firm BTS found that 62 percent of new managers say their biggest regret in the first six months is not pushing back on scope creep early enough. Luna: That's a specific number. And it matches what I hear from first-time managers I talk to. They want to please everyone, so they say yes, and then three months later their team is drowning. Lucas: Exactly. And the problem is, the instinct to say yes is reinforced by almost everything in the corporate environment. Saying no feels like you're letting someone down, or being unhelpful, or admitting you can't handle the job. Luna: So today I want to talk about how to say no in a way that doesn't burn bridges. And I think we should center this on a specific case. Lucas: Good. Let me set the scene. You're six weeks into your first manager role. You've got a team of four. One of your team members is a high performer, really reliable. Your VP comes to you and says — 'Hey, we have this new client onboarding project. It's important. Can your team take the lead?' Luna: And you can already feel the trap, because the VP is asking nicely, and you want to look good. But your team is already at 90 percent capacity. Lucas: Right. So what do you do? I think there are two separate scenarios here. One is the 'helpful scope creep' — where the request comes from your boss or a senior leader, and it's genuinely important, but it's not urgent. The other is the 'urgent fire drill' — where a peer from another team comes to you at 4 PM on a Friday saying, 'Hey, we need your team's help on this by Monday.' Luna: And the scripts for each are different. Let's start with the boss scenario. What do you actually say? Lucas: The key principle is: don't say no in the moment. When a senior leader asks you to take something on, the pressure to say yes is strongest in the first ten seconds. So you buy time. You say something like, 'I want to make sure we can do this well. Let me look at the team's current commitments and get back to you by end of day tomorrow.' Luna: The 24-hour rule. I love that. It gives you space to actually evaluate capacity instead of guessing. Lucas: Exactly. And when you come back the next day, you're not just saying no. You're saying 'here's what we can do.' You might say: 'We can't take the full lead, but we can take on the data analysis piece if we deprioritize the monthly report for two weeks.' That's a trade-off conversation, not a rejection. Luna: That's smart. You're framing it as 'we can say yes, but something else has to give.' And that puts the decision back on the VP. They can decide which priority matters more. Lucas: Right. And if they really need the monthly report and the new project, then they need to give you more resources or adjust timelines. That's their job. Luna: Now what about the peer scenario? The Friday afternoon fire drill? Lucas: That one is trickier because there's no power dynamic. You're equals. And often the peer is desperate. So you want to be helpful but not a doormat. Luna: The technique I've seen work is something I call the 'capacity sandwich.' You start with empathy, then state your constraint, then offer an alternative. Lucas: Give me an example. Luna: So you say: 'Hey, I hear you, this sounds urgent. My team is fully committed this week. What I can do is have one person spend two hours tomorrow morning to help you scope it, and then we can pick it up properly next week. Would that work?' Lucas: I like that. You're not saying no. You're saying 'yes, but on different terms.' And you're offering a concrete alternative that the peer can either accept or take back to their own manager. Luna: Exactly. And if they push back and say 'no, I really need the full team this weekend,' then you have a conversation about priorities that might need to escalate. But often, the alternative is enough. Lucas: You know, this whole topic of saying no as a new manager — it ties back to something bigger. When you say yes to everything, you're not being a good manager. You're being a people-pleaser who burns out their own team. And that's worse for your reputation in the long run. Luna: Absolutely. And I think that's why so many new managers struggle with this. They think that being a good manager means being agreeable and accommodating. But actually, good management means protecting your team's focus so they can do their best work. Lucas: And here's the thing — if we've helped you think through a career move or a management challenge like this one, we want to mention something. We deliberately don't run ads on these shows. We think that makes the conversation cleaner and more useful. Luna: Yeah, that's intentional. And if you want to support that choice, there's a simple way. Just go to buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That's it. No pressure, no perks, just a way to keep the episodes ad-free. Lucas: And we appreciate every single person who's done that. It genuinely helps. Now back to the topic — one more scenario I want to cover. What about when a team member themselves brings you extra work? Like, your star employee says 'I want to take on this side project that a colleague asked me to help with.' Luna: Oh, that's a different kind of scope creep. It's self-initiated. And it's tricky because you don't want to discourage initiative. Lucas: Right. So how do you handle that without squashing their enthusiasm? Luna: I think you again use the capacity conversation. You say, 'That's a great project. Let's look at your current workload and see where it fits. If you want to take it on, what are you willing to deprioritize or push back?' Lucas: And then let them decide. That's empowering. You're teaching them to think about trade-offs, not just saying no for them. Luna: Exactly. And sometimes they'll say 'I'm willing to work extra hours.' And then you have to decide if that's sustainable. But at least they're making an informed choice. Lucas: So the through line here is: saying no as a manager isn't about being negative. It's about being a good steward of your team's time and energy. And the best way to do it is to never say no in isolation. Always pair it with a trade-off or an alternative. Luna: I think that's the takeaway. And if you're a new manager listening, try the 24-hour rule this week. The next time someone asks your team to take something on, just say 'let me check and get back to you tomorrow.' See how that changes the conversation. Lucas: Good advice. And we'll be back next week with another Monday episode. Until then, protect your team's focus. Luna: See you next time.