Latest / Two Talking Fools Podcast / The Sophie Cunningham Controversy: Trans Athletes, Women’s Sports & the Fairness Debate
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome back to the late-night madness on WFool Radio.
- 0:08You tune into the only show where chaos comes complimentary.
- 0:14The only duo bravely.
- 0:32Shabba, welcome back. Welcome back to the podcast.
- 0:36Welcome. We're just doing an audio today. Welcome back to the Two Talking Fools.
- 0:40We are, we're doing it from my house, if you can't hear my dog in the background.
- 0:46I'm in his best life right now. He really is.
- 0:49We are the Two Talking Fools. We are just two average, and I mean average girls
- 0:54taking their phone calls to the podcast. Yeah.
- 0:59Welcome back has been quite some time since. Shabba and I have gotten on here
- 1:06and did just a regular good old podcast like the good old days.
- 1:09A regular degular podcast. The good old days when we were sitting in Cumberland
- 1:14Farms parking lot when we first started out.
- 1:18Shabba's currently going through old yearbooks of mine and.
- 1:24She saw her photo. Dude, I had the biggest ears, guys. I had the biggest ears.
- 1:29Holy shiitake mushrooms.
- 1:32Whew, those bad boys were huge.
- 1:36She complains about her ears. I have a schnoz of a nose. It's all relative.
- 1:43I mean, I think it's okay to admit our misfortunes.
- 1:50But I just have to ask you a question. That's what I'm looking for.
- 1:52I look at your ears now, and they're not in disproportion with your body.
- 1:57Thank you, Bessie. I appreciate that. And ears don't get smaller.
- 2:00Do you know that? like ears only get bigger.
- 2:03They say that your ears and your nose are the things that continue to grow.
- 2:09Okay, so I don't know how to take that, so do my ears get bigger or did I just
- 2:15finally grow into them maybe?
- 2:18No, what I'm saying is I don't think you ever had big ears to begin with.
- 2:21I think just— No, don't lie. I'm looking at your ears right now like,
- 2:24okay, hold on. I saw the evidence.
- 2:28Okay, look at, like, do that. Now see, you're already pushing up on your lobe.
- 2:33You're pushing up on your bottom lobe. Be more accurate. Okay,
- 2:36that's good. Just touch it, okay? Okay.
- 2:40Mine bigger like again i have a bigger ear see isn't that funny so it's just like okay.
- 2:49Welcome back to two talking fools podcast there's a lot going on there's a couple
- 2:54things that we were talking about and i was hesitant to talk about them but
- 2:58i'm like you know what they're going on in the world we should talk about them,
- 3:03real life events real life events,
- 3:06the first thing want to talk about is,
- 3:09sophie cunningham yeah go queen pop off queen go sophie.
- 3:16Where do you even start with the whole thing where do you start with the whole
- 3:20thing you know i'm feeling really bad because i have the utmost respect for
- 3:27her as somebody who simply was just saying.
- 3:32We need to keep female sports female, meaning those who were biologically born female.
- 3:40I don't think you have to pick a political side necessarily to want to just protect girls' sports.
- 3:47Now, if we think back, women had to fight for a lot of things.
- 3:51Women had to fight for equal opportunity.
- 3:53Women had to fight for rights to vote. Women had to fight for the ability to
- 3:57be able to work and not just be housewives.
- 4:00And if you're a housewife, more power to you. I'm just generally just listing
- 4:04off things that will not always equal for us. And then if we accidentally got
- 4:10knocked up, like, now we're like, you know.
- 4:13Right. Okay, exactly. So, like, there we have. Exactly. We've worked.
- 4:18We've come a long, we've come a long way.
- 4:21And now it's like everything nowadays is like, it has to be one side or another.
- 4:28So she responded that it's not politics for her. She just personally feels that
- 4:33female sports should remain female sports.
- 4:38Simple. simple and then unfortunately of course like everything else,
- 4:43I had to turn political because everything it everything does everything has
- 4:47to be political everything has to be a political it has to be a political thing
- 4:50and the wildest thing to me is like,
- 4:53I feel like a lot of people that.
- 4:56Make these things political justify it by saying well I have to know because
- 5:02if you vote for this person or if you feel this way about this person like you're
- 5:06either stupid or you're a fascist or like whatever.
- 5:10And I'm talking about both sides. Like I'm saying literally both sides. Both sides.
- 5:15And so you have this woman here that is, has been like,
- 5:20Like, one of the best athletes out there, okay? A lot of little girls that look up to her.
- 5:25This chick was playing sports from, like, way back in the day.
- 5:28I think she was even playing, like, football for, like, a quick moment.
- 5:32And then that came out, well, oh, well, she was playing football,
- 5:35so then it couldn't have mattered then. And, like, you know,
- 5:38all these little things. Like, you try to dig for stuff from people's past.
- 5:41And it's like, I don't understand. Like, all she said is to keep girls' sports for girls. Right.
- 5:50And then she even said she doesn't have any issues with the trans community.
- 5:53I didn't take it that she did.
- 5:56I mean, when she made that statement, I was like, thank you.
- 5:58I didn't take that as if she had any hatred towards any different group of individuals.
- 6:05She just said, let's keep girls sports for biological girls.
- 6:10I don't think that there's anything wrong with that.
- 6:13But unfortunately, like I said, everything's political.
- 6:16So if you feel that particular way, you must be one side over the other.
- 6:19You know what I mean? It's crazy.
- 6:22It's so crazy. Now you have people coming for her. They're coming straight for the jungler.
- 6:29It's getting nasty, dude. It's getting really nasty out there. And it's wild.
- 6:35I can admit it. I'm not huge. I feel like I haven't been a huge somebody who
- 6:41chooses to watch WNBA simply because over the last few years,
- 6:45it has become increasingly very political.
- 6:49You can't watch a sports game without somebody trying to make some sort of standard.
- 6:54You know what I mean? So it's not even enjoyable anymore. Well,
- 6:56that's why I also appreciate what Caitlin Clark said, which was she just believes
- 7:01that, like, we're here to play basketball.
- 7:03Let's keep it about basketball. Let's keep it about basketball.
- 7:06I think that's an okay thing to do is to keep more of this stuff out.
- 7:11But then people could say, oh, she didn't take a stand. Like,
- 7:13I think a couple people have even said that.
- 7:15Like, well, of course she said that. That's an easy way out.
- 7:17It's like, no, it's not. It's actually not an easy way out saying that.
- 7:20It's not an easy way. Like, she wants to just play the game.
- 7:22She doesn't want to get involved in all of the drama and all of the nonsense.
- 7:26Sense just play the freaking game right enjoy the game for what it is right
- 7:30you know what i mean i just it's crazy like i think everything has to be political
- 7:34no matter what you do or say everything's political these days and then okay so i'll play,
- 7:39i will play it from an athlete's position.
- 7:45If you look at the last flagrant two-fowl that Sophie Cunningham had on her
- 7:52in this last incident, if that were a guy— Dude, that was downright assault.
- 7:57I'm sorry. That was downright assault.
- 8:00Imagine if that were a guy. Imagine if that were LeBron James that put that same force into that.
- 8:05Like, so when you talk about the trans community, the only thing I will say
- 8:10is that there's a reason why I don't play softball with men is because I'm legitimately
- 8:17scared of getting hit in the face.
- 8:18I'm not trying to play any sports with men. Get the fuck out of there.
- 8:21And there's women that do.
- 8:22Yeah, I want to play with two sports. But there's a lot of us that are like,
- 8:25listen, we can barely keep up with the women in our… In your league.
- 8:29Like, softball is a perfect example.
- 8:31I'm playing with women from 20 years, 18 years of age to almost 68, 70 years old.
- 8:38And there are some scary-ass players.
- 8:41Scary-ass players. So never mind. These are women. Never mind men.
- 8:46You hit that ball hard enough. My God, you take somebody right out with the right hit.
- 8:50That's the scary part of it. Whether it's basketball, softball,
- 8:54field hockey, it don't matter. Well, it was funny because I was actually thinking
- 8:58about field hockey this past year.
- 9:00Imagine. My youngest, she's a little brute. As we know, she is a brute.
- 9:05She don't give a shit. She is a brute. That kid is a brute.
- 9:10And she came home with waltz. When I say waltz, like massive.
- 9:15I'm not talking about like a fist size bruise. I'm talking about massive bruises.
- 9:19Like right where her ribs are. She had another one like right where his thigh
- 9:23was. I think it was a cheap shot with a stick.
- 9:26Like bruises. That kid has come home with so many bruises because she plays deep guts.
- 9:31And I'm like, could you imagine a high school male,
- 9:36playing on a team with her no and they're playing and she's playing defense absolutely not like,
- 9:43it's just i don't understand like it's not it's not a political thing guys it's
- 9:48more of a safety issue i don't i don't understand how anybody can make that political i don't,
- 9:53i really don't when they were younger it's fine middle school and under it's
- 9:57fine they're still all developing they're still growing like you know what i
- 10:00mean but i'm like once you get to high school and above.
- 10:05Why do you think in grammar school they come up with, you know,
- 10:0911 through 13, 13 to 15, 15? Why do you think they come up with these?
- 10:13Because you want to play amongst your peers to make it as fair as possible.
- 10:18Right. As fair as possible. Right.
- 10:22Taking the stronger gender and mixing that in, I'm so sorry,
- 10:26doesn't even make it fair. And there's no arguing.
- 10:29You know what I mean? There's no arguing. Why is it? Okay. Like, let's be real here.
- 10:34Why is it like, I know something needs to be done at work, something needs to be moved.
- 10:40Excuse me. Sometimes I will do it, right?
- 10:43If it is something extremely heavy, and I know I do not have the physical capability
- 10:49of doing so, and I'm not a small girl, like, let's be real. Like,
- 10:52I'm a curvy female. I got meat to me.
- 10:55But if I can't do it, I'm not doing it. You know what I'm doing?
- 10:58I'm calling one of the men that I work with and being like, hey,
- 11:01can you guys help with it?
- 11:02And they take care of it. And there's a reason for that. Guys are built differently.
- 11:06100 muscle structures are different like everything's different about a man like,
- 11:11let's be real it's not it's just it's so annoying to me how political like i
- 11:17keep i can't emphasize that enough like how political things get,
- 11:21men are built differently than women they are they are they're built differently they are,
- 11:28and that's just and it's that's all i'm saying from my standpoint is to have
- 11:32a male okay it's like having he's kind of a big he's kind of a bigger male to
- 11:37be doing a comparison here but,
- 11:40there's talks of a couple players i think from overseas that are like oh we'll
- 11:44play in the wnba that are trans players or something like that or we'll become
- 11:47trans or i i don't i'm not sure if the whole.
- 11:50Please do not quote me on this because i'm not quoting myself but imagine having
- 11:54a shaquille o'neal play against like pagebackers like get out of here could
- 11:58you imagine that what or a david robinson or carl malone
- 12:02or like a dominique wilkins like you have any of these guys playing the wmba
- 12:06they're smashing these girls could you could you literally no no no.
- 12:12That'd be so wild and then what do you say oh,
- 12:17okay well then you know oh we'll adjust this like what are you gonna adjust
- 12:20to make it fair like there's nothing fair about that and if you're not an athlete,
- 12:25with all due respect, I really don't think that you have any.
- 12:29I think a big part of this comes into play. Like, if you're an athlete,
- 12:32you understand it's not fair. It's not the same. Men play at a different level.
- 12:35Women play at a different level. In order to be competitive with one another,
- 12:39they have to be separated.
- 12:41That's all there is to it. But if you're not an athlete, if you don't like athletics
- 12:46or understand athletics, how do you even have a say in this if you're just coming
- 12:50at it from a political standpoint?
- 12:51There is a 100% athletics portion to this.
- 12:56So I, I've been seeing on like TikTok and Instagram reels and stuff like that,
- 13:02which I'm pleasantly surprised about where you have trans, trans women,
- 13:09who are coming out and saying that they also agree that trans women should not
- 13:14be in sports with biological women.
- 13:18And I'm like, oh my God, like, you know, to hear this, I'm like,
- 13:20are people like watching this?
- 13:22Like for a trans woman to come out and say that, there's this person out of Massachusetts.
- 13:27I want to say that their female name is Davina, but like...
- 13:32Their first name was David. I'm trying to be mindful of, like, how I say things.
- 13:36And so Davina shares her journey on social media, and she has a young child.
- 13:43Like I said, she's out of Massachusetts. Very interesting to watch.
- 13:46And she shares her story about how she explains to her daughter,
- 13:51like, how he trapped this.
- 13:53And when she brings the daughter to school, I think she might have shared custody with her ex.
- 13:58And so she'll ask the daughter, do you want me to wear makeup and wig to drop
- 14:04you off? Or do you want me to be how I am without it?
- 14:09And so based off of what the daughter says, Davina will dress that way.
- 14:14Well, Davina has spoken out about some of this stuff where she also,
- 14:21doesn't like she doesn't understand how the argument is like,
- 14:26trans females should be treated the same way as biological women,
- 14:32because they're not the same and it was just crazy hearing that from somebody
- 14:36who's trans because I always want to hear insight from everybody like
- 14:39you know how how does somebody how does one person feel about this and granted
- 14:42she's one person but there's a lot of trans women that are coming out and saying
- 14:46they don't agree Okay. Let me ask you this.
- 14:49And if there's anybody that knows, I want to know. Yeah. Please clarify and educate me. Oh, yeah.
- 14:56How many trans men do you see playing...
- 15:01Sports. Biological male. Yes.
- 15:05How many? You don't. Why? I don't know. That's a valid question.
- 15:11Probably because regardless of how much testosterone or other things it takes
- 15:16to make them biologically transformed to a man, I still don't think it's enough,
- 15:22to change their overall build.
- 15:26Muscle structure, in order to compete at a fair level with other men.
- 15:33I agree with that. I do agree with that. That's an excellent point,
- 15:35my friend. I've actually wondered the same thing myself.
- 15:38And so then based on that, I would say it all goes back to, you know,
- 15:42is it fair for a biological male to play with women? And if we're just talking
- 15:50about that, I don't believe it's fair.
- 15:52It's not. But I also wondered where any of this came from.
- 15:55Like, I feel like back when we were in school, like this wasn't even a topic
- 15:59of discussion like you know what I mean you respected people's differences you
- 16:03did you respected people's differences and you just let like things were just
- 16:06the way they were it wasn't this like,
- 16:09in my opinion what feels like this almost backwards way of thinking where like
- 16:14you give women the opportunity to have their own league for all of these different
- 16:18sports programs but then at the same time you're telling them that they're like,
- 16:24discriminatory if they choose not to play with a trans female
- 16:29like all right how do you take that away like you give those rights or
- 16:33i should say give those rights like women earned those rights they earn those
- 16:37spaces they've earned those safe spaces but then at the same time you try to
- 16:40take that away from them and if they're uncomfortable then they're discriminatory towards a group,
- 16:45i'm like that's wild what yeah.
- 16:48I don't think it's exclusivity the same way that the Fever coach said it was.
- 16:56You know, her response to it was that she doesn't believe that exclusivity is good anytime.
- 17:03And I understand what she's saying. In an ideal world, I suppose you would have
- 17:08enough trans athletes that wanted to compete at that level that you could create
- 17:13its own league. Correct. Right?
- 17:15I just don't think it's there yet. but I don't think it's exclusivity.
- 17:19I think it's still trying to understand these waters.
- 17:21Right. I don't think it's fair to say that. Right. I don't know.
- 17:25I think that's a very interesting topic. And I think we live in a very sensitive
- 17:33time all around where people can't have open discussions without feelings getting hurt.
- 17:41And therefore, if you don't agree with somebody, You know, on one hand,
- 17:46you're either like transphobic or a bigot or a fascist or whatever.
- 17:55And then on the other hand, you know, you're an idiot, you're a snowflake, you're like, whatever.
- 18:01It's like there's no happy balance. But to me, that's not a political thing.
- 18:04It has everything to do with equal rights. But when we talk about equal rights,
- 18:09I'm specifically talking about equal rights for women.
- 18:13Right. So we go back to make everybody comfortable, but then you're taking away
- 18:17those same rates that when fought for. To me, that just doesn't make any sense.
- 18:22Right. In some regards, people may even call it contradictory. Right.
- 18:26And I have nothing but the utmost love for the trans, you know,
- 18:29the trans community. I don't discriminate towards anybody. I think we should
- 18:33let people, you know, just be how they want.
- 18:37It's the greatest time to be alive, especially if you want to be what you want.
- 18:42I mean, I'm a little mad that some of these trans women look better than I do.
- 18:45Like, I'm a little mad about that. That'd be so for real, some of them.
- 18:49I'm like, oh my God, it's not even right that you are legitimately hot AF.
- 18:55And I'm just sitting over here in this average land. And I'm like,
- 19:00there's this other, um, there are some wicked.
- 19:03There's this baddie. She's a little, she's a little on the wild side,
- 19:07but her name's Morgan something.
- 19:10And she's on Tik TOK, like fire, red hair, fire, fire, red hair.
- 19:14And she like scares off these guys because when they see her they're like oh
- 19:17my goodness you're so beautiful and then she talks about being trans and stuff like that but she even
- 19:22is another one who has said that trans women are not women like they're not it's not the same
- 19:29and I was like shocked I'm like oh my goodness there's you know it's another
- 19:32trans person that's coming out openly saying this and she is open about being
- 19:36trans she doesn't hide it
- 19:38and like some of her videos are crazy because she'll go on these like calls,
- 19:41like, what is it, Omegle or whatever?
- 19:43Like, you can, you randomly can call and talk to people from,
- 19:46like, all over the world and you don't know who you're going to end up talking to. What?
- 19:49Yeah, something like that. I don't know if it's Omegle or what.
- 19:51Wait, what, girl? Yeah, you literally, there's that.
- 19:54You can go on and you... What is this for, dating or just for fun? Random conversations.
- 19:59I think this is fascinating. You have no idea who you're going to talk to.
- 20:03You have absolutely no idea who you're going to talk to.
- 20:05And so she does this, and these people, when they see her.
- 20:09They're like, oh, my goodness. And they, like, fall in love because she's absolutely
- 20:13stunning. She really is absolutely beautiful. She's, like, beautiful.
- 20:18But these guys are only thinking one thing because if you look at her,
- 20:20they're like, mm, you know what I'm saying? Going to get some. Right.
- 20:23So when they're creepy like that, what she'll do is she does this scary thing
- 20:26where she's, like, you know, she'll, like, be, like, flirting with them.
- 20:30And then all of a sudden she, like, does this, like, scary voice and face or whatever.
- 20:34And then usually they'll click off. You have some that are a little on the freaky side.
- 20:38So then they start laughing and like they'll play along whatever and she's like
- 20:41you're like you're crazy too and then she'll get to know them there was this
- 20:45one guy who was like acting as if he was jesus or whatever,
- 20:49and oh he's so sweet there's this guy that was acting like he was jesus and
- 20:53the guy was so polite and she did the same thing to him and he just like was
- 20:57so calm the whole time he was dressed up as if he was jesus it was like the craziest thing
- 21:01but yeah she will post these videos and that's why i'm always intrigued because
- 21:05i'm like oh my god what is the coming of this one Like, what happened with this
- 21:08one? Like, what does this guy do?
- 21:09But she even said, she's like, I acknowledge trans women are not biological women.
- 21:17We are different. And that's what she says. And I'm like, wow,
- 21:21there's a lot more people in the trans community that are also in agreement
- 21:25that, like, you have to acknowledge that there are differences.
- 21:29Right, right, right.
- 21:32And again, you're talking, it goes back to athletics.
- 21:36We're not talking about everyday life, living your life. At least that's not
- 21:39what I'm talking about. You live your life as you see fit. Exactly.
- 21:42I agree with that. But when it comes to athletics, I think men born men should
- 21:48play against men. Women born women should play against women.
- 21:51Right. And maybe the conversation should be, maybe instead of allowing trans
- 21:57to play women's sports, maybe the trans should be allowed to play men's sports. Correct.
- 22:02Why isn't that ever a thing? I don't know. That's a great question.
- 22:05I think that's valid. What do you guys, like, those of you who are listening,
- 22:09like, if you're still listening, we hope we haven't, you know,
- 22:11upset anybody, but we need to have these conversations.
- 22:14What are you guys thinking? Like, what do you think about this?
- 22:17No, and I don't think that you can get upset when it comes from a place of honest,
- 22:21genuine conversation. Right, and you just want to know people's input.
- 22:23And you just want to talk. Like, we have to be able to create a safe space where people can talk.
- 22:28Even if you don't agree with how we're necessarily talking, then by all means,
- 22:33please shed light. We can have dialogue without killing each other.
- 22:38I'm so for real on that. Why can't we do that? We are going to go because we
- 22:42have another topic we're going to talk about.
- 22:44Oh, and Shama just really impressed me. She actually brought out the calendar,
- 22:50the one that she had replaced from the one that I bought her,
- 22:52the dollar calendar from the Ocean State Dog.
- 22:54Look at that full. Well, I liked my big calendar, and then I'd go to meetings,
- 22:59and it was nice because it was visible, because as you get older,
- 23:01you know, your eyesight changes, but I wear small purses now.
- 23:04I don't wear big, clunky purses, and I need my calendar with me.
- 23:08And I know some of you by this point are like, Shava, just use your damn phone.
- 23:12I don't trust technology enough, so if I lose stuff on my calendar,
- 23:15I'm so screwed. I need it, like, physically.
- 23:18I mean, I could do both, I suppose, but yeah. Anyways, I digress. Love you guys!
- 23:25Yeah, we're going to go. We're just babysitting my dog, Cooper.
- 23:28And as you can hear, he is having fun with his toys. And driving is crazy.
- 23:34On to the next episode. Peace.
- 23:37Oh, twotalkingfools.com. That's really important for me to say.
- 23:41Two Tongues. Shake the boo.