Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / What Credit Unions Should Really Prepare for After NCUA’s 2026 Priority Letter
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark Reel with another
- 0:01episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03I am here today with Todd Miller.
- 0:05Todd Miller.
- 0:06Todd Miller and Steve Farr.
- 0:09How you guys doing in Montana?
- 0:12Farrar: It's, the weather's Not bad.
- 0:14Not bad.
- 0:14A little cold, little windy,
- 0:16Treichel: little cold, little windy.
- 0:17We're recording this, what, January 26th, 27th.
- 0:23Monday, 26th Monday.
- 0:25The whole country other than Florida, where I'm at, is really cold.
- 0:29It's about 80 degrees outside and we're gonna have a cold snap's
- 0:34gonna fall in the sixties here as your weather moves towards us.
- 0:38But we're here today to talk about NCAA's priority letter.
- 0:42I did a 10,000 foot priority letter.
- 0:46Podcast last week when the week after the letter came out we, the three of us were
- 0:52on a cruise, the Q'S cruise with Scott Gladden and his team at Innovations and
- 0:57a bunch of credit unions from Florida and Georgia that we just got back from.
- 1:02It was good seeing you guys face to face for the first time in a while
- 1:05and meeting some credit unions.
- 1:06We had some discussions there about the priority ladder, and we're gonna talk
- 1:10about the Priority Ladder here today.
- 1:13In our pre-call, we said, Hey, it's short.
- 1:15So we, it's that's one takeaway we'll have, I'm sure.
- 1:18But with that, guys, I'm gonna let you do your intro.
- 1:22So in case somebody's listening the first time, and let's start with Todd.
- 1:27Miller: Good morning everyone.
- 1:28I was with NCUA for 34 years from 1987 to, june of 2021 I spent, I could
- 1:37break my career into three pieces.
- 1:38About the first third, I was an examiner, a problem case
- 1:41officer in the western region.
- 1:43Middle third of my career, I was a capital market specialist for 10
- 1:47years or so in the western region.
- 1:49Again, had a lot to do within development of n CUAs NCUA's exam
- 1:53programs around interest rate, risk, a lot of the teaching priorities around
- 1:58interest rate, risk, and liquidity.
- 2:00The last 11 years or so of my career, I was a director of special actions in
- 2:04the western region where I supervised problem case officers, capital market
- 2:09specialist, regional lending specialist over my career as involved with.
- 2:14Helping a lot of credit unions with no capital survive conserved a couple credit
- 2:18unions, returned them to the members.
- 2:21And unfortunately I was involved with closing a number of credit
- 2:24unions too, where the NCUA kind of failed along the way to do its job.
- 2:28But anyways, very enjoyable.
- 2:3034 years with NCUA.
- 2:32I retired a couple months and Mark said, Hey, you want to come help
- 2:35credit unions from the other side?
- 2:36And I said, sure.
- 2:37Sounds like fun.
- 2:39And it has been.
- 2:40Treichel: It has been a lot of fun.
- 2:41And Steve?
- 2:43Farrar: Yeah I can summarize mine also in the thirds if my first
- 2:47third is the same as Todd's.
- 2:49In fact, we worked together a lot during our first third of
- 2:52our careers and credit unions.
- 2:55And then I went to, followed you, mark when you went to central office.
- 3:00I started working at the division of Risk Management and did that for 15 years.
- 3:05And that one was highly diversified, but I was really involved in.
- 3:08All of the material exposures that NCA had.
- 3:11One of my duties was calculating the loss exposure to the insurance fund.
- 3:15So that made me meddle in all of the big anything that exposed the
- 3:20insurance fund to large losses.
- 3:21I got to do training of the problem case officers.
- 3:25That was really enjoyable.
- 3:26I missed that one more than anything.
- 3:28I finished up as the vice president of the CLF, and then upon retiring
- 3:34I did a short stint as a CFO in an NCOA conservatorship in Manhattan.
- 3:41And that was my first switching over to being on the other side and
- 3:44battling the NCOA examiners that were in our credit union at the time.
- 3:49And then since then, I've really enjoyed this ability to do
- 3:52the consulting on these areas.
- 3:54And like I tell everybody, it allows us to keep our saws sharp in, in the industry.
- 3:59And I think that's been a great opportunity.
- 4:02Treichel: Yeah.
- 4:02Yeah, I agree with that.
- 4:03All of that.
- 4:04And, I had 34 years at NCA Minnesota Dallas Concord.
- 4:10The best office ever NCA ever had was in Concord.
- 4:13We closed that at, somewhere along the line, moved it to Phoenix from Concord
- 4:17to Albany to dc to Albany, to dc and and now for the last six years helping credit
- 4:23unions and having fun on this podcast.
- 4:25But with that, so NCAA's letter 26 CU oh one, which means it's 2026 and
- 4:31it's the first letter of the year, NC a's 2026 supervisory priorities.
- 4:37I joked in the past at one juncture when they had 12 or 13
- 4:42priorities that if everything was a priority, nothing's a priority.
- 4:45And more recently they have less and you can ascribe to the less is more.
- 4:51But then sometimes they bury certain things into the less
- 4:54and it rears the priorities rear their ugly head along the way.
- 4:57So with that let's just walk through the letter.
- 5:00There's discussions on the front end about no regulation by enforcement,
- 5:05which we've talked about here.
- 5:07There's the obligatory reference to the Genius Act, and I say obligatory because
- 5:12Kyle Hoffman's big on, on that whole arena, and I'm sure he, as chair who
- 5:17signed it, made sure that was in there.
- 5:20And then they, they pivot into the supervisory priorities themselves.
- 5:23And the first one listed is a broad title balance sheet management.
- 5:29Guys, what do you wanna say about N NCAA's letter to credit unions
- 5:32on balance sheet management?
- 5:34What's there, what's not there, et cetera.
- 5:37Farrar: Mark, I just touched a little bit on that introductory section that they
- 5:40Treichel: Yeah.
- 5:40Do.
- 5:41Absolutely.
- 5:42Absolutely.
- 5:42Farrar: Steve, I don't think we can talk about, priorities in 2026 without
- 5:47addressing, that NCOA has to do their exam program with the big reduction in staff.
- 5:54Which of course you had hoped that they would be, focused as they said on shift
- 5:59the areas of focus based on their risk profile and appropriate what I see in
- 6:04the, our fellow regulators, that they're really clear and that they're going
- 6:08to shift to focusing on what they call prioritized material financial risks.
- 6:16So they really said they're gonna be backing off on, things like processes and
- 6:21procedures and only address those items that present the most material risk.
- 6:26And that was all that they would write their matters or crying
- 6:30attention on is those big issues.
- 6:32So I think that's important to think going forward, that you're
- 6:36dealing with, an exam staff that's gonna be stressed and hopefully they
- 6:40will be focusing on the big issues.
- 6:44Miller: I have another little take to it too.
- 6:46I highlighted four sentences in the whole letter, and a couple of them were
- 6:49actually right before the Genius Act.
- 6:52Improved efficiency in reducing burdensome work, creating a more
- 6:56efficient tailored exam program.
- 6:58Seems like that process was going on the whole 34 years we were at NCUA.
- 7:03And I think.
- 7:05When we were on the cruise, you did a whole little piece and you
- 7:08had podcasts on the chaos at the agency, 27% reduction in force.
- 7:15I think it boils down to is NCOA saying we're gonna do our job, but
- 7:18we haven't figured out how yet.
- 7:21And I talked to an examiner here not too long ago.
- 7:25They presented the reorganization plan to their staff in December and the
- 7:29way he characterized it is there's lots of, to be determined in all
- 7:34the slides they gave the examiners.
- 7:36So I think they know what their mission is.
- 7:39They're gonna focus on doing their mission.
- 7:42They haven't figured out how to do that with the resources that are probably
- 7:45not enough for them to do that in 2026.
- 7:48Treichel: Yeah, said.
- 7:49Yeah.
- 7:49This the language here, the creating a more efficient and tailored exam
- 7:53is a nice way to say we've got some chaos and we're in the middle of
- 7:58trying to figure out what that is.
- 7:59And there's clearly dust still in the air at NCUA and we've
- 8:03seen it trickle into exams.
- 8:05But the good people at NCUA are doing what they can.
- 8:09And it's if this is probably a bad analogy, but you're in a band together
- 8:13and you've got a repertoire of different songs and you show up and you decide
- 8:16that you're gonna, you're, these are the 10 songs you're gonna play instead
- 8:19of, those are the 10 songs and you maybe you wished you'd have practiced them.
- 8:23If you don't, it was gonna be then 10.
- 8:25But you, they have the knowledge, skills and abilities that
- 8:28they have from their, and the.
- 8:31And the muscle reflex of doing exams, right?
- 8:34And you just don't have as many resources.
- 8:37And you're hearing from over here that this is your team and you're
- 8:40hearing from over here that this is your supervisory examiner.
- 8:44And you go in and, you the clock ticks and you do the exam and the clock.
- 8:49It says you gotta be at the next place and you meet with the
- 8:51people and you just keep the ball.
- 8:53So they do triage, their own triage, right?
- 8:55They, each individual kind of has their own, has always had their
- 8:59own risk-based assessment in their brain on how they were gonna do it.
- 9:02But with less resources that becomes more important.
- 9:04Like part of the challenge is they lost a lot of talented long-term people.
- 9:10Farrar: Yeah Todd pointed out, the comment there that they're going to
- 9:13try and do more efficient and tailored exam programs, and we can't forget.
- 9:17The NCOA did send out the notice that says the tips on starting exam effectively.
- 9:22I think credit unions should keep that in mind and hold NCOA accountable
- 9:27on those timeframes that they've been giving the four week notice.
- 9:31And, so that your examiner is following that 'cause that will make for an
- 9:34efficient exam where the examiner isn't doing that, that as an impact on them.
- 9:38And you and and this letter clarified that, which is great.
- 9:43Another thing I, that happened in October though from the other financial
- 9:46regulators, they just thought, take this opportunity to discuss.
- 9:49They have finally, for the first time defined unsafe and unsound practice.
- 9:54It's always been a little bit of a nebulous concept.
- 9:57It was in some case law, which is just really difficult, but they did it.
- 10:01It's pretty short definition.
- 10:02I'll read through it or because it won't take but a second is defined as
- 10:06a practice act or failure to act alone or together with other practices, acts,
- 10:11or failures to act that is contrary to generally accepted standards of prudent
- 10:16operation and has materially harmed the financial condition of the institution
- 10:22or if continued is likely to materially harm the financial condition of the
- 10:26institution or present a material risk of loss to the insurance fund.
- 10:31So it's a simple definition, but we finally, have one,
- 10:37Treichel: so they've, I remember that having been proposed
- 10:40by the other regulators.
- 10:42So it's finalized now.
- 10:43Farrar: It's it was in a a proposed rule, but I think because of it
- 10:49being there, that would be a standard that would be used going forward.
- 10:52Treichel: Sure.
- 10:53It, and as great it is to have that definition, it
- 10:57probably provides some clarity.
- 10:59It still comes down to interpretation, right?
- 11:02You can't, no matter what year, what words you provide, you can have a
- 11:08little bit of wiggle room around.
- 11:09That'll be interesting to see if NCOA does anything to come up with their
- 11:13own definition or, copies that one.
- 11:19Anything else?
- 11:20On the paragraphs that I summarized before we get into the balance sheet management.
- 11:32Miller: Nope.
- 11:33I have a lot score.
- 11:33What does this mean?
- 11:34But those are for the end after we're done with this.
- 11:37Treichel: Okay, very good.
- 11:38Steve, balance sheet management, we've got loan growth has moderated in recent
- 11:45years while loan performance has declined the overall delinquency rate, enrolling
- 11:5012 month loss rate within the federally insured credit union portfolios at
- 11:53its highest point in over a decade.
- 11:55Any anything there that jumps out at your number crunching?
- 11:58I.
- 11:59Farrar: We don't generally agree with that statement.
- 12:02Miller: Yes.
- 12:03So it's like we had a client, they were growing about 8% a year and
- 12:08said, your growth is high and risky.
- 12:10It's the same thing in this statement.
- 12:11That's almost a summary of what they used in last year's letter.
- 12:15And it was true that loan quality was deteriorating over 2024.
- 12:21It's not true in 2025, it stayed virtually the same.
- 12:26And so they imply that asset quality is deteriorating, but
- 12:31that's not what the numbers show for the first nine months of 2025.
- 12:35Treichel: The stats don't support it.
- 12:36It's kind I remember one time when, you know, when NCA says
- 12:39they're gonna renew the 18% rate.
- 12:43For federal credit unions to charge, they have to show that they have to show some
- 12:46instability or rates, or that rates have gone up and down and tie it to some data.
- 12:51And I remember one period they had, there was like one blip where
- 12:54they able to say that it qualified.
- 12:56They're they're making a statement to make sure people are watching their
- 12:59loans, but the stats don't necessarily report what that sentence implies.
- 13:02Is that what we're saying?
- 13:04Miller: Yes.
- 13:07I think it's interesting.
- 13:08You look at last year, they laid out specifics.
- 13:11They talked about loan underwriting collections, concentration, risk board
- 13:16reporting on significant programs.
- 13:18That was in last year's letter this year.
- 13:21As I said, we're just gonna pick on whatever we think is going
- 13:24wrong in this specific institution.
- 13:27They do mention credit risk concentrations again, but overall they don't.
- 13:32Mention anything specific and at the end of the day, credit risk
- 13:36is what costs the insurance fund.
- 13:38Most of its losses and they're basically gonna say, we're gonna
- 13:42pay attention to credit risk.
- 13:44It's interesting, when you look down there at Lending Resources, those
- 13:47are all the same resources they cited last year, with the exception.
- 13:52They took a couple out about adjustable rate arms and they also
- 13:56took out a reference to evaluating real estate modification programs.
- 14:01And it's interesting that you take that out when you know they're concerned about
- 14:05real estate lending and really residential real estate and commercial lending were
- 14:10the only loan programs that really grew through the first nine months of 2025.
- 14:15Treichel: Interesting.
- 14:17Steve, any thoughts on that?
- 14:19Farrar: Yeah, I looked at, they're gonna focus on, the credit risk
- 14:22management underwriting standards and loss mitigation programs.
- 14:26Those are areas that I think has credit unions moved towards u using data that
- 14:31they have and the ability of AI and stuff.
- 14:33I think there's gonna be strong improvement in that area and that credit
- 14:37unions should be quicker to respond to what they're saying in general membership.
- 14:44So I, I am optimistic in that area as the early recognition of credit
- 14:49problems will help in this area.
- 14:51And I think as you use good systems to do your underwriting, that loan quality
- 14:58will continue to improve as long as there aren't kinda external factors that aren't
- 15:03really related to credit that don't affect the system, whereas like that issue with
- 15:09maybe having a 10% thing on credit cards, that certainly changes the whole model.
- 15:15Treichel: Sure.
- 15:15Farrar: So I think people are probably gonna be I think we see improvement in
- 15:22credit risk management in the industry.
- 15:24And I think this will be a big year.
- 15:26For credit unions to be able to improve that process.
- 15:30Treichel: And of course the 10% credit cards you're referring
- 15:32to is president Trump's mandates last encouragement that, that be
- 15:37something that would be put in place.
- 15:38I did a full podcast on that, and obviously that would take
- 15:42an act of Congress and it would impact a lot of things.
- 15:45And it's just not gonna play out.
- 15:46But it, it's an interesting interesting sidebar of all this.
- 15:50Now, one sentence that caught my eye on this was, when lending, servicing,
- 15:54or collection functions are outsourced, examiners will also assess the third
- 15:59party risk management practices as appropriate NCA with loan participations.
- 16:04But even them linking it to like outsourcing of collections,
- 16:08the collections kind of word caught my eye here.
- 16:10I'm wondering if they've seen some things where collections have
- 16:13been outsourced and they didn't like how it may have been handled.
- 16:16Of course, we know there've been a lot of different scenarios where participation
- 16:21loans have created some challenges and how they handled those with third parties.
- 16:25Any thoughts on that, what I just said, or that sentence at all?
- 16:32Miller: Oh, no.
- 16:32There's always been credit unions that have outsourced parts of their collection.
- 16:36Often, most often you see they prompt that early piece where you
- 16:40know, it's 10 to 60 days or they.
- 16:46Throw out the backend piece after we charge it off.
- 16:48And there, there has been some broads over the years in areas related
- 16:53to outsourcing collection actions.
- 16:56There has been consumer complaints, they're small and very isolated.
- 17:00And over time, this is something that's just, many credit
- 17:05unions have found it effective.
- 17:07There's always been a piece of the industry that has outsourced collections,
- 17:11either on the front or the back end.
- 17:14It'd be interesting to see if more of that goes on in the future.
- 17:17Because of various debt collection practices, you have more
- 17:21flexibility to keep things in house.
- 17:23There's things you can do in house that you can't do when
- 17:26you outsource it like that.
- 17:28Treichel: Great point.
- 17:29Miller: Interesting observation, mark.
- 17:32Treichel: Great point.
- 17:33So next category sensitivity to market risk and liquidity.
- 17:37I think if we only had someone who was a former capital market
- 17:41specialist or supervised capital market specialist, he might have something.
- 17:45Oh, wait, no, Todd's on the line.
- 17:46Todd, what are your, what's your thoughts on sensitivity
- 17:48and market risk and liquidity?
- 17:51Miller: It's been on the last couple supervisory letters.
- 17:54It's interesting.
- 17:55Last year they couched all of this under that category of earnings
- 18:02and the impact on earnings.
- 18:04I can tell you what we've seen is.
- 18:08NCA has got their supervisory test.
- 18:10There's a huge focus on, their NEV supervisory test.
- 18:15When you look at the numbers though, across the industry, interest rate
- 18:18risk doesn't seem to be an issue or it's not increasing anyway.
- 18:23It's actually ebbing a little bit.
- 18:24Liquidity seems to be pretty good across the industry, but NCUA is
- 18:28always sensitive to liquidity.
- 18:31I think they've always been overly sensitive to liquidity.
- 18:34The agency just seems to be risk averse to liquidity risk.
- 18:38They don't tend to like borrowings and things of that nature.
- 18:42I don't see a lot of change in how NCA is gonna look at liquidity and interest
- 18:46rate risk, to be honest, going forward.
- 18:48It's in the letter most years.
- 18:51I think it will always be their liquidity risk, especially can
- 18:54have impacts on the insurance fund.
- 18:57I think the interest rate risk is something that's interesting
- 19:00'cause it's part of strategic risk.
- 19:03Generally though, you can fix interest rate risk by spending a
- 19:06couple basis points of capital.
- 19:08Credit unions almost never fail from it.
- 19:10They get hurt by it.
- 19:12And sometimes when credit unions put themselves in bad interest rate
- 19:15risk positions, they make really bad decisions about credit risk
- 19:19to fix it rather than admitting they have a problem and fixing it.
- 19:23They try and mitigate it by taking on more credit risk and that can cause problems.
- 19:27I think it's just a bigger boogieman than the agency makes it out to be.
- 19:31At the end of the day, we can genuinely work through interest rate risk.
- 19:35Liquidity risk is a little bit different.
- 19:38Like Steve says, the models for forecasting liquidity risk, we see a lot
- 19:42of findings directed at people's tools for forecasting their liquidity risk.
- 19:47Hopefully over time those get better as well.
- 19:50And we do see lots of doors and exam findings, targeting
- 19:54liquidity forecasting models.
- 19:57I think that will continue, but I don't see this being any more different than
- 20:01it has been the last several years.
- 20:04Treichel: And generally we're seeing less of it in our conversations and
- 20:08clients where they, when rates shot up 500 basis points there was more of a
- 20:13shock and awe exam approach than now.
- 20:15There's still's coming up, but not out, not in every institution.
- 20:19Miller: When rates shot up, and then you'd have a model that does another 300.
- 20:24Of course everyone's gonna be failing and that's why they got
- 20:26rid of the extreme category.
- 20:29And I think another reason this is moderating, and this
- 20:31happens, every rate change.
- 20:33When rates change, you have to adjust your shares right away and loans catch up.
- 20:38And we've seen that with the rate change.
- 20:40Everyone's margins got compressions, NIMS got compressed, earnings got stressed.
- 20:46So there was a big focus on it.
- 20:48But really in 2025 now the loan rates are catching up and that interest margins are
- 20:52expanding again and looking a lot better.
- 20:56Earnings are improving.
- 20:57So there's gonna be a little less emphasis on that.
- 21:00I'll just throw something that's maybe not in this letter that probably should
- 21:04be talked about in earnings, and maybe it comes up in the next section, is there
- 21:08is a troubling trend in credit union's.
- 21:10Operating expenses are growing relative to assets and.
- 21:17That's been going on for a couple years.
- 21:19That is troubling long term to see expenses rising.
- 21:22And you're not seeing that in their competitive industries.
- 21:26The banking industry, their expenses aren't going up.
- 21:29Craniums expenses are going up.
- 21:31Can,
- 21:32Farrar: can I jump back?
- 21:33Just one more thing on liquidity, Todd.
- 21:35And it's one i one almost direct towards you.
- 21:37It has to do, they had a message in there on diversified funding.
- 21:41And I have concerns mainly the,
- 21:48because the competition is increasing daily.
- 21:53There's like 15 banks that were chartered in the last year and it was funny.
- 21:59They referred to them as novel.
- 22:03In approach.
- 22:04So certainly that's gonna increase competition.
- 22:07And usually in regulatory word, the word novel is very scary.
- 22:12But they're, they've streamlined their approval process for new banks and
- 22:16Miller: oh, two of those new banks were Ford and General Motors.
- 22:20Farrar: Yeah.
- 22:21So that hits on both sides on the lending and the savings.
- 22:24So there's, increased competition from private credit and non-bank entities.
- 22:29I just, you're,
- 22:33Miller: if,
- 22:36can you hear me mark,
- 22:38Farrar: of these big generational differences into how they approach.
- 22:42Their savings and it's huge between each one of 'em and so credit unions
- 22:46have to really be on top of that and how they're reaching out to
- 22:50try and build that share portfolio.
- 22:53Treichel: Steve, you, Steve, you were on fire there, but
- 22:55you were cutting in and out
- 22:56Miller: so Michael from Olden Lang talked about this on the cruise last week.
- 23:00He kinda had a whole presentation about, where do you find your members
- 23:04in this transfer of wealth and how do you keep them when you find them?
- 23:10It's a, so first off, look at 2025 credit unions paid down, borrow money.
- 23:14They did actually pretty good at collecting funds in 2025 and
- 23:18diversifying their balance sheet.
- 23:20But long term, yes.
- 23:22Steve, this is gonna be a big challenge for all the CEOs is where do you
- 23:26get your new members and where do you get your funding in the future?
- 23:29I have a population of two, a son and a daughter.
- 23:33Daughter, fairly loyal, still has the same bank account she opened 15 years ago.
- 23:39Son, no loyalty at all, man, entirely on rewards program.
- 23:45And when he doesn't have a rewards, his money is somewhere else.
- 23:48A lot of the younger folks are more focused on investing as opposed
- 23:52to leaving money in institutions.
- 23:55So funding sources are a big challenge.
- 23:57And how do you get new members and how do you get the new generation
- 24:01to come into your credit union?
- 24:05And being an orphan, meaning I've lost all my parents and my
- 24:09wife have lost all her parents.
- 24:11That money didn't, their money didn't stay where it was when
- 24:13they passed it on to the children.
- 24:15I think that is a big challenge long term for the whole industry is how do they
- 24:21gain new members and new deposits from the next generations coming up, who's,
- 24:26they have more information available at their fingertips at the internet.
- 24:30So it's not the branch down the street, it's, Hey, where's the best deal online?
- 24:35And it's a huge challenge for credit unions.
- 24:38They're still gonna bring in members with branch networks, but nowadays
- 24:41you can move across the country and you don't need to change your bank.
- 24:44Her daughter's in Nashville and she's still, keeping the same account.
- 24:48She opened here in Billings, Montana, because she's got remote capture on the
- 24:52checks does everything with Bill pay.
- 24:55Not a reason to move.
- 24:57And then I have a son, he'll move in a heartbeat just for a reward.
- 25:00No loyalty to anything.
- 25:02So I think that's a big challenge for the industry coming up.
- 25:05We don't talk about it.
- 25:06Neither of us are experts in it, but I think social media presences
- 25:11is gonna be huge to stay engaged with the generations coming up
- 25:16Treichel: In 15 seconds.
- 25:17No advice
- 25:18Miller: to co clients on how to do that.
- 25:19I just know they have
- 25:20Treichel: to do it.
- 25:20Yeah, you just know the war is coming and as you talk about that I grab my
- 25:25phone 'cause there, there's there's a podcast mentioned here on occasion, but
- 25:29it's called FinTech Takes And ironically the host is a guy named Alex Johnson
- 25:36who lives in Montana just like you guys.
- 25:39I don't know, there's something in the water there with all these
- 25:41smart people in Montana, but he's gone down some rabbit holes.
- 25:45He's a.
- 25:47Hi.
- 25:47Hi.
- 25:47The podcast if you like podcasts, I'm telling you this, you guys
- 25:51this, but to the listeners the fintechs Takes is a fabulous podcast.
- 25:55They have one episode a month called, this Is Not FinTech, ADV Investment Advice.
- 26:00And then they talk about really cool investment options out there, but
- 26:03they preface it with Don't buy this.
- 26:04We just think it might be cool anyway.
- 26:07Every once in a while he'll go down a rabbit hole on gambling, sports gambling,
- 26:11and he, without rambling about the problems that's creating, and every ad on
- 26:18the NFL games are tied to, the gambling.
- 26:21But he talks about the fact that's burning up savings ability, right?
- 26:25So it's a, just another way that financial institutions are not
- 26:28able to get access to funds because people are burning up the money by
- 26:32losing money, gambling, and they're.
- 26:34There is a sister podcast to that called Bank Nerd Corner with Kia
- 26:40Haslet and those two also are on each other's podcast, but check those out.
- 26:44Any thoughts on sports gambling?
- 26:46And Todd, I see you got a follow up point.
- 26:49Miller: A couple things.
- 26:49Like the last couple big bank failures were liquidity crisis.
- 26:53Yeah.
- 26:54Triggered by folks on social media.
- 26:56So basically you got crowd knowledge spreading very quickly, which
- 27:00triggered those liquidity runs.
- 27:02The gambling thing, and you can edit this out if you want, there, there's
- 27:06a couple interesting pieces to this.
- 27:08We have a lot of gambling in Montana and when I was an examiners to go
- 27:12through overdrawn accounts and you would see people got a paycheck and
- 27:15over two days they spent that whole paycheck, ATM withdrawals at casinos.
- 27:20And then the other side of that, I was at a credit union also here in Montana, and
- 27:23the collector comes up to me and he says, is there any problems if I go like on
- 27:27payday to the casinos to go collect money?
- 27:31And it's just I don't wanna hear about that.
- 27:33Don't tell me about it.
- 27:35I don't wanna hear about it.
- 27:37But you go collect your money at the casinos because that's where
- 27:39your members are spending it.
- 27:41I said you can edit that out.
- 27:42Probably not appropriate for your collectors to be
- 27:44in casinos on paydays, but
- 27:47Treichel: I'm gonna leave it in Todd.
- 27:48I'm gonna live on the edge.
- 27:50Miller: In his case I said, Hey, I don't wanna hear about it.
- 27:52I'm not telling you yes or no.
- 27:54Now the answer is probably no 'cause you go select money 'cause I'd rather
- 27:59not deal with your charge off problems
- 28:00Treichel: is collect the loans.
- 28:05Miller: So we digressed away from the supervisory letter, but that's okay.
- 28:08Treichel: We did, but that's okay.
- 28:09That's when it gets more fun.
- 28:11Earnings and capital.
- 28:12Earnings and capital back on
- 28:13Farrar: the operating expenses there Todd.
- 28:15That
- 28:15Treichel: Yeah.
- 28:15Yeah.
- 28:16Back to operating expenses.
- 28:17We, so we talked about a little bit about that issue and the challenges and
- 28:21some of it's inflation, some of it's credit unions needing staffing to be
- 28:25compensated so that they can keep 'em.
- 28:28But that's a pressure point for sure.
- 28:30Anything else on earnings and capital adequacy or the expense side?
- 28:34Farrar: Mine on that is we'd like to see credit unions put their capital to
- 28:37work and we think that's a good point.
- 28:40Not necessarily shared by every examiner who are risk averse.
- 28:45So they're people too, but what we think, Todd, how much of the increase
- 28:50in expenses do you think it's from replacing legacy systems to, scale up
- 28:56and increase the use of technology?
- 29:00Miller: I think it's a little bit of all of it, Steve, and
- 29:02it depends on the credit union.
- 29:04Certainly amongst our clients, we've seen a number of them
- 29:07have went through conversions.
- 29:08You see a lot of credit unions that are sitting there at that $8 billion range.
- 29:13They start spending a lot of money to get rid of for the leap to 10
- 29:16billion when their regulatory burden and all their capital planning and
- 29:20stress testing becomes much greater.
- 29:22They get a second regulator thrown into things.
- 29:25Certainly during COVID you get a hiatus on these conversions and moving
- 29:31forward when everyone's offsite, there was a holding pattern and
- 29:35people are playing catch up on stuff.
- 29:37I think some of it is you just had an explosion of inflation and now you're
- 29:43catching up with some of that with your staff salaries and things of that nature.
- 29:48Insurance costs are escalating.
- 29:50So I think it's just a little bit of everything.
- 29:53And, a lot of credit unions and if their earnings are positive, their mindsets
- 29:59aren't necessarily focused on that.
- 30:02And I know when Steve and I, we said we started out together in
- 30:05the late eighties, early nineties, NCUA was hyperfocused on expenses.
- 30:09And somewhere in the early nineties, 92, 93, as examiners we're told
- 30:15to not worry about expenses and told to not look at them.
- 30:19And that culturally has remained there.
- 30:22If earnings are present, examiners aren't supposed to
- 30:24have this discussion on expenses.
- 30:26But we've seen with clients here recently that they have.
- 30:29And they have started picking on expenses in select situations,
- 30:34sometimes unfairly even.
- 30:36But certainly as the industry, individual boards, credit unions, you
- 30:41need to keep an eye on those expenses.
- 30:42And it's a matter of can you grow your interest, income and fee
- 30:47income and stuff to overcome that?
- 30:49And it's back to what you said when you used the word scale, Steve.
- 30:53You gotta be able to scale up to keep that expense number under control.
- 30:59Big challenge.
- 31:01Farrar: Yeah.
- 31:01I know one of the other things I've been reading about is that how do
- 31:04you diversify that income stream?
- 31:07Is this we can do that when interest rates change.
- 31:10You can gain fees on refinances or real estate loans.
- 31:14But there, and I think we're trying to look towards new
- 31:17sources to diversify fee income.
- 31:20I think some of that does come with the.
- 31:22Technology innovation that we've seen in some of our clients
- 31:26Miller: are you create new loan products.
- 31:27Like one of the interesting things, if you look at the real estate
- 31:30lending, you're seeing a lot of growth in hybrid type loans.
- 31:34Again not your standard fixed rates, not your standard arms, but the
- 31:38hybrid loan categories are growing.
- 31:40Again, I think that's a lot of credit unions that are trying to put real
- 31:43estate loans on your balance sheet.
- 31:46I know even when I was still an examiner when I, before I retired in 2021,
- 31:51you're seeing a lot of this on the West Coast where people were creating
- 31:55their own year real estate products.
- 31:58Didn't meet secondary markets and terms, a lot of the credit did, but they were
- 32:02trying to create unique products to reach out to members, make housing more
- 32:06affordable, but still create a product they could keep on their balance sheet
- 32:09for interest rate and liquidity purposes.
- 32:13You're seeing AI unsecured type lending coming about, here's AI jumping into the
- 32:19marketplace, creating a new type of loan.
- 32:22But certainly, folks have to pay attention to cost and what's costing them and
- 32:27who's paying for it, who's your members that are generating profitability for
- 32:33you versus those that are not, and how do you make those that are not become
- 32:38profitable or break even type people?
- 32:41Big challenge.
- 32:42Farrar: Yeah.
- 32:43My hope is that the regulators, don't harm the ability of institutions to
- 32:48foster innovation in the industry.
- 32:52Miller: I had some summary comments about that at the end.
- 32:55Farrar: Let's revisit it also it's worth it.
- 32:57Treichel: I think you're implying that we may have seen that on occasion.
- 33:03It's
- 33:03Miller: Steve said, there's a risk.
- 33:07I'll just wait till the end.
- 33:11Treichel: That's good.
- 33:11You're, this is what you do to make sure the listeners wait all the way
- 33:16till the end for that final point.
- 33:17So it is gotta make a good one.
- 33:19All right.
- 33:19Operational risk management.
- 33:22Miller: We kind of skipped earnings and capital.
- 33:24I wanna just say one thing.
- 33:25Treichel: Earnings and capital.
- 33:26All right.
- 33:26Back to earnings and capital.
- 33:28Miller: We were talking about liquidity and it bled into it.
- 33:31It bled because in the prior years those were combined this year
- 33:33they separate 'em a little bit.
- 33:35But I think it's interesting in what they took out of this letter.
- 33:39'cause in the prior year they had guidance citations on risk-based
- 33:45capital planning and stress testing.
- 33:48Net worth ratio and UNK corrective action.
- 33:50And they took those out of this letter, but they took 'em out of the
- 33:54letter right at a time where in 2025 we were seeing doors and findings
- 33:59on capital planning and justifying your capital levels and sensitivity
- 34:05testing on your capital levels.
- 34:07And they took those little pieces out of that.
- 34:13This year, they're still in the wording somewhat that examiners will still assess,
- 34:19earnings, make sure you have capital.
- 34:21But last year it was very focused on capital in the letter, they
- 34:24had guidance specific to capital.
- 34:27We've seen a lot of doors and findings on capital, and I think it's
- 34:32interesting that those little pieces were removed from the letter this year.
- 34:39Treichel: Yeah.
- 34:40It'll be inter and then that, when, as you're saying that, I'm thinking the
- 34:44priority is the priority, but on the front end they talk about risk focused.
- 34:48And that they can pivot to wherever they want.
- 34:51And situationally those things will still get brought up if NCUA and
- 34:56your exam team thinks they need to be these are the priorities.
- 34:59It doesn't mean you're not gonna have to deal with other risks and every
- 35:02other type of risk, but great point.
- 35:04Todd.
- 35:04Steve, any thoughts on that?
- 35:06Farrar: No, I'm, that's good.
- 35:11Treichel: Excuse me.
- 35:12I'm gonna have to hit the cough button.
- 35:15Operational risk management.
- 35:18We got payment systems made reference two, two a one sentence
- 35:21paragraph on payment systems and another sentence on payment systems.
- 35:26Then they hit payment systems in the last last sentence there.
- 35:29I think they're worried about they,
- 35:30Miller: the justified keeping their payment systems specialists that
- 35:33they just added a couple years ago,
- 35:35Treichel: Or they're worried about Venmo linking to PayPal and
- 35:39stable coins and all the different clearings I was listening to.
- 35:43And
- 35:44Miller: Zelle.
- 35:44And
- 35:45Treichel: Zel and how all of those link together.
- 35:47And I'm, I have an accounting degree, but I'm glad I don't have
- 35:50to balance anybody's Fed account.
- 35:52Miller: We talked about
- 35:54it's right at the tip of my thumb, Venmo.
- 35:58On an earlier podcast, the number of young people that use Venmo
- 36:01accounts, it was a huge percentage.
- 36:03And I don't have those stats 'cause I didn't think we
- 36:06would talk about that today.
- 36:07But you mentioned the social media aspects to the Venmo accounts and
- 36:11the controls you need with that.
- 36:14The big scheme of things with payment systems here is you just have all these
- 36:18non-financial institutions entering into this payment systems arena.
- 36:25And, I think the explosion of your cryptocurrencies have
- 36:28a lot to do with that too.
- 36:29You need to create ways to transfer money here and there.
- 36:33It's because people like my son have money in 15 different
- 36:38banks 'cause of reward programs.
- 36:40How do you move money around?
- 36:41Let's not use the bank at all.
- 36:43Let's just use a third party thing.
- 36:45I do know the last car they bought, they use Venmo.
- 36:48Even though that's limited to, at that time it was limited to
- 36:51$10,000 at a pot probably to get around the BSA requirements,
- 36:56Treichel: know your customer.
- 36:57Yeah.
- 36:57Yep.
- 36:58Miller: It's just an interesting thing and the risks are growing there, and this
- 37:02was all under the cyber in prior years.
- 37:05This was under the cybersecurity title, which they don't really mention this year.
- 37:09They just mentioned this payment systems and, BSA is a separate type of
- 37:15thing, and BSA has always been on these priority letters in one form or another.
- 37:19And I think a lot of that is because they have enforcement requirements
- 37:23that in agreements with other regulators that they have to follow.
- 37:30Treichel: Along a lot.
- 37:30Yeah.
- 37:31The, we have BSAA couple sections down, but yeah, good point.
- 37:35On that, Steve any more thoughts on the, this topic, payments, payment
- 37:40systems, et cetera, before we pivot?
- 37:43Farrar: Yeah.
- 37:43I'm gonna drag out my dog ear proposed rule on corporate
- 37:47governance that I'm always grabbing.
- 37:49And, it talks about, the importance of internal audit programs.
- 37:57And I think those are gonna continue to become more and more important as we
- 38:01move into adopting these technologies.
- 38:05I think, it needs to be a priority in your institution that you can say we are
- 38:11very comfortable with the reviews that we're doing with these payment systems
- 38:16and even our compliance with the, we'll talk about layer compliance, but the
- 38:21fraud prevention and detection I think those people are gonna be real critical.
- 38:26And those that, that, that department also provides you a great source for your
- 38:31eventual people moving up in management.
- 38:34I, that, that has a lot of unintended positive consequences and not
- 38:40having a proper internal audit has terrible, unintended consequences.
- 38:45Treichel: That's a great point.
- 38:47Great point.
- 38:50Next up, fraud.
- 38:53Miller: Now we can talk about fraud,
- 38:54Treichel: fraud protection, prevention, and detection.
- 39:00This fraud.
- 39:01Fraud they bring up every once in a while.
- 39:02I, I used to do a chart.
- 39:04I don't have it here in front of me, but the priorities there's perpetual, there's
- 39:08occasional, and there's new the perpetuals are like the BSAs and asset quality.
- 39:14And up until this year, the perpetual was a separate category on cyber, but
- 39:20fraud is an occasional, it pops up every once in a while and I don't know if they
- 39:23just say, Hey, we haven't talked about fraud for a while, or there's something
- 39:26going on at NCA, but thoughts on fraud prevention and detection as it relates
- 39:31to the letter and or anything else?
- 39:33Miller: I think there's a couple pieces of this is the insurer.
- 39:36NCUA is probably worried about fraud that impacts the failure of the credit
- 39:42union, but on the credit union side, you have to look at fraud is how do
- 39:46we protect our members, and here's the thing about technology is the bad
- 39:53guys are always the early adopters,
- 39:55Treichel: right?
- 39:57Miller: And you mentioned you were telling someone on the cruise, about
- 40:02how you used an AI to create your voice that sounded close to yours.
- 40:06Some people wouldn't be able to, people that know you would be
- 40:09able to tell there's maybe not.
- 40:11There's a little fraud, whole AI things where they'll call you and it's the whole
- 40:14speaker and, and how do you protect your members, especially your older, less
- 40:20technology members from getting scammed.
- 40:23And it might not be the credit union's fault at the end of the day
- 40:27from a legal standpoint, but from a strategic reputation thing, it is
- 40:33going to fall on the credit union.
- 40:35If you let one of your members get scammed out of 40, $50,000 or what have you.
- 40:41And I think the big challenge for credit unions and the fraud thing, it's not only
- 40:45to protect against fraud from your own employees, but the bigger challenge is
- 40:49how do you protect your members from all the schemes going on out there today?
- 40:54Treichel: Yeah, great
- 40:54Miller: point.
- 40:55What kind of tools do you have in place to protect your members?
- 40:58That's a big one.
- 40:59And member retention is important and this is back to the social media
- 41:04thing, of grandma gets scammed and granddaughter starts putting a thing
- 41:09on Instagram or the TikTok or what have you, that has implications
- 41:17for you and the community and.
- 41:20And your reputation risk.
- 41:22So you know that's, I think, probably one of the biggest challenges
- 41:26for credit unions is how do you protect your members from fraud?
- 41:29NC is worried about the credit union doesn't fail because
- 41:32an employee steals money.
- 41:34I think the bigger challenge for management is how do
- 41:37you protect your members?
- 41:38Treichel: And along those lines, over the weekend my wife was looking
- 41:42at at Twitter slash x and she said, Hey, look at this situation.
- 41:47It was someone talking about a credit union somewhere in the
- 41:51Midwest saying, Hey my, a relative of mine is saying is reaching out to
- 41:56you saying that they don't have an account, and they do have an account.
- 41:59And there was some references to funds being turned over to the state.
- 42:04And I'm going there are achievement laws, so if it was a dormant account, it
- 42:08can, it could be tracked over that way.
- 42:10But then also it went on to imply that they'd reached out to the
- 42:13state and those funds weren't there.
- 42:14And there it was, on this particular financial institution's Twitter account.
- 42:20And there was really good responses from that institution saying, Hey, reach you.
- 42:24You can reach me at this number.
- 42:25Let me help.
- 42:26But the struggle is real.
- 42:30Farrar: Yeah.
- 42:30I would say if you, how would you respond to this question?
- 42:33How are you rolling out smarter controls that strengthen account
- 42:38security and accuracy, though?
- 42:41Treichel: Is that from your dogeared risk report?
- 42:44No.
- 42:44Farrar: No.
- 42:45It's not my own thought, but it was when I found and found useful.
- 42:49Treichel: I like it.
- 42:49I like it.
- 42:53All right.
- 42:53Fraud prevention, detection.
- 42:55Anything else before we pivot into what's not in compliance or what
- 43:00is in compliance, which is BSA?
- 43:05Miller: We talked about it.
- 43:06They have responsibilities to other agencies to enforce it.
- 43:10They have compliance people.
- 43:11It's always been part a required part of exams to look at BSA
- 43:17and those risk assessments.
- 43:19And like Steve came back to, one of the things NCOA looks
- 43:22at is they wanna know credits.
- 43:24Have you done your own risk assessment on this?
- 43:26And how good is that risk assessment?
- 43:29And that plays into your risk management process, into your
- 43:32internal audit processes.
- 43:34And this is one where, just having conserved credit unions, it doesn't
- 43:39get talked about a lot, but you get sideways with fend and they can issue
- 43:44fines really quickly, that can become significant really quickly too.
- 43:49Treichel: Yeah.
- 43:49The math can, a lot of times they end up not actually collecting the
- 43:52fines, but the fines can be, scary to the point where it can impact
- 43:56solvency and or your capital category.
- 43:59Even
- 44:00Miller: in my conserved credit unions, I turned this over to NCAA's legal counsel.
- 44:03It's man, go talk to the fence end people.
- 44:05We can't afford to pay it.
- 44:07NCOs general counsel did a pretty good job of getting fines mitigated
- 44:12or getting them negotiated down is as long as we got things fixed
- 44:16in a very short period of time,
- 44:19Treichel: yeah, we were able to argue because we conserved it and we are, and
- 44:23the federal government's now in charge.
- 44:24There's no need to do the fine.
- 44:26And that worked a few times as well.
- 44:28Not that's a reason to conserve, but it, the conservator helped.
- 44:32The conservatorship in that instance helped us save the reserves for
- 44:36the credit unions, its members.
- 44:37And then of course, obviously the fund on the backstop.
- 44:40Miller: In my case, it was always, I found out about 'em after we conserved
- 44:43that these fines were hanging out there or sometimes one times we self-reported
- 44:47a problem that we found and then they find us for self-reporting.
- 44:52We weren't complying and how do we fix it anyways,
- 44:56Treichel: that sounds like the internal audit staff that Steve says people should
- 45:00have at their credit unions go into the credit union, go into the examiner saying,
- 45:04we don't want you to have any surprises.
- 45:05So here's the things we're dealing with.
- 45:07And then their attachment shows up in their exam report.
- 45:10Haven't had that.
- 45:11We've had that.
- 45:12We've had that happen more than once, I think in 2025.
- 45:15But I digress.
- 45:16B, so the other takeaway here is usually this would say consumer compliance
- 45:21and we're gonna look at this and we're gonna look at this and we're gonna look
- 45:23at this and we're gonna look at this.
- 45:24And oh, by the way, we always have to look at BSA, but because
- 45:27it's not a democratic led.
- 45:29Todd Harper led letter to credit unions.
- 45:32It's a Republican led Kyle Halman led letter to credit unions.
- 45:38This is the lightest touch there's been on consumer compliance for many years.
- 45:42Even other republicans had more on consumer compliance than this letter has.
- 45:47Fair lending exams, other things, and, you've got the CFPB gutted
- 45:51this administration is not consumer compliance friendly.
- 45:55And on that pendulum is swog about as far as I've ever seen it.
- 45:58Any thoughts on any of that?
- 46:00Miller: I'll throw a guess out there and you could probably tell me in
- 46:03your time as executive director, whether my guess is right or not.
- 46:07NCOA is responsible for enforcing a, a.
- 46:11A multitude of these con consumer compliance regs until
- 46:15Aranian hits $10 billion.
- 46:17There's always been the question at one time, NCUA used to
- 46:20have compliance examiners.
- 46:22One of our first RDS and supervisors, Steve, Bob Blattner, Dan Murphy, started
- 46:27NCA as compliance examiners in Rose to be directors, regional directors.
- 46:33There's always this question, do you bring compliance examiners
- 46:36back into a, has not done it.
- 46:38So I think we've always rotated, focusing on different aspects
- 46:42of it for a couple reasons.
- 46:44One, it keeps the credit unions focused on it and two, it's a
- 46:48way to train your examiners.
- 46:50You can't train them all to be compliance examiners, but you train
- 46:54them on two or three things this year and two or three things that year and
- 46:58it keeps the generalist aware of all the consumer compliance regs without
- 47:04NCUA hiring a compliance examiner.
- 47:08But I also thought that was the intent of that.
- 47:10It just keeps people generally aware.
- 47:12I would say my career as an examiner, a lot of the compliance issues
- 47:16you find them as you're doing something else, not because you're
- 47:19looking for them specifically.
- 47:21And by having a rotating thing, it just rotates your training, keeps your
- 47:25examiners up to speed, avoids this whole issue of hiring compliance examiners.
- 47:31So you, as an executive, I don't know how close am I being Right to,
- 47:35that's the why they did it or not.
- 47:38That was just my kind of guess
- 47:40Treichel: I would say that you're closer to right than in the,
- 47:45your roughly correct category.
- 47:47If you, I've made that reference to someone at NCA who used to
- 47:49say the term roughly correct.
- 47:51As a little squishy you're much more close to the reality of what it is that you see
- 47:56on the seventh floor when you're trying to figure out what should be in there.
- 47:59You rotate it through key people fresh and the oth the other.
- 48:02Just pivoting the, there, there's a lot of good league programs, there's a lot
- 48:06of good America's credit unions program.
- 48:08Nafcu used to dirt and do certain things.
- 48:10Credit unions would actually train us because they had other good sources.
- 48:16The examiners would learn a lot from the credit unions until you saw something
- 48:19that went wrong, perhaps because of a lawsuit, et cetera, et cetera.
- 48:22But yet the and then Todd Harper was contemplating and I think did
- 48:27start doing some separate compliance exams under 10 billion, as a prep
- 48:32to getting ready for 10 billion.
- 48:34And now, oh, here, by the way, the CFPB has responsibility for over
- 48:3910 billion on consumer compliance, yet they don't have any staff.
- 48:42So it's interesting times for sure.
- 48:47So we're, I'm to the letter part where it talks about the conclusion,
- 48:51which means we're to the end where we're gonna talk about the
- 48:53other fun stuff that we deferred.
- 48:59Steve Todd,
- 49:00Miller: your favorite, though?
- 49:00It does say, Hey, record your exits and record your jcs.
- 49:04Treichel: It does, yes.
- 49:05Miller: Some of that sentence I highlighted.
- 49:07Treichel: I'm glad you that's one of the three sentences you highlighted.
- 49:10And again, Kyle Halman was a big proponent of recording your jcs.
- 49:15And he does give the hat tip to the fact that some states don't allow it.
- 49:19We've been involved in situations where our clients do it.
- 49:22We've recommended doing it just because it creates the actual official record.
- 49:26And I think the more com, the more NCAA has seen people doing it, they've become
- 49:31more and more comfortable that it happens.
- 49:34And you're going to have less of a chance of some rogue cowboy examiner,
- 49:39although a lot of those probably retired going down and saying some
- 49:42things that maybe they, they went, beyond where they're supposed to.
- 49:46So it does create a, a clarity of what's said,
- 49:51Miller: other rogue examiners will appear.
- 49:53I don't care.
- 49:54When you have a thousand employees, there's always gonna
- 49:56be a few rogues out there.
- 49:58Treichel: Yeah, it's, that's a fact.
- 49:59Life, I always say this life is a bell curve.
- 50:01Whether it's going out to dinner or whether it's the result of your NCOA exam
- 50:06or whether it's how well a credit union's doing in complying with the regulation.
- 50:10Everything tracks back to that bell curve.
- 50:12But
- 50:12Miller: one of my other duties, one of my other duties, I was
- 50:15a director of special actions.
- 50:17I also sat on NCA Supervisory Review Committee.
- 50:20We dealt with credit union appeals, and let's just say if you ever go down
- 50:24and appeal a path, having recordings could be extremely helpful to your case.
- 50:29Great point.
- 50:30And it makes that committee's job a hundred times easier.
- 50:32Treichel: Great point.
- 50:33And I'm sure you saw some instances it was like, whoa, that was said
- 50:36that then we're gonna vote this way.
- 50:39Miller: Always surprises when you sit on those committees of
- 50:42things that actually went on.
- 50:47Treichel: Great point.
- 50:48What other final thoughts here on this pod, on this topic or
- 50:51other general thoughts, guys?
- 50:53Miller: You opened the crews with a session on the chaos at NCUA,
- 50:58and you've talked about this on a lot of your other podcasts.
- 51:00And you have this conversation with many of our clients at the chaos at NCUA and
- 51:07Steve mentioned something, and I have this in really big letters at the bottom of
- 51:11my sheet, big box, it says, risk adver.
- 51:15Can I get it till the camera?
- 51:16Can you see it?
- 51:16It disappear on you.
- 51:17Yeah.
- 51:17Anyways, there's a big box at the bottom of my paper.
- 51:20It says risk adverse.
- 51:22And, here's what kind of happens that NCUA is.
- 51:25You start out as a new examiner you're nervous about all the responsibility
- 51:30it's laid on your shoulders.
- 51:33You tend to start out your career as a very risk adverse person, and then
- 51:37depending on your general nature, you become more comfortable with risk
- 51:42and how it's managed and controlled.
- 51:45Over time, you understand long-term implications that credit unions,
- 51:49if they're gonna remain here as an industry, they need to be in innovative,
- 51:53they need to take some risks.
- 51:55And you kinda learn, here's how do you help them manage and control
- 51:58risks with new programs and things.
- 52:00And then you have other examiners as they move through their career, that
- 52:03risk aversion never, ever leaves.
- 52:05And they even end up in management positions and they're still risk
- 52:08averse, but the whole part of the NCUA, they've lost 27% of their staff.
- 52:14And you've always had this kind of balance scale.
- 52:17You've got people that are comfortable with risk, people less comfortable.
- 52:21And I think a lot of the people that have left were your longtime employees.
- 52:24And those are the people that were probably more comfortable with risk.
- 52:28And so now you've got an agency, we're on the balance scales.
- 52:33A larger proportion of their staff than ever are gonna be risk averse
- 52:37type people and risk averse people.
- 52:41They try to do a CYA and make sure I'm not responsible for anything.
- 52:47So how does that play out here with what's going on?
- 52:51In the regions?
- 52:53The people that have left, it's not uniform across the agency.
- 52:57You've got a hodgepodge of, this region lost more supervisors.
- 53:01This one lost more specialists.
- 53:03The interesting thing is, there's no public information out there
- 53:06as to how this has played out or who's left or what's going on.
- 53:12It's interesting.
- 53:13NCUA hasn't done any public podcasts on that.
- 53:16They haven't done a podcast on this supervisory letter,
- 53:19which they've done in the past.
- 53:21Treichel: They're
- 53:21Miller: doing one late, no question.
- 53:22Treichel: They're doing one late February.
- 53:24They're gonna,
- 53:25Miller: oh, is that right?
- 53:26I missed that email.
- 53:27Treichel: 17.
- 53:28But
- 53:28Miller: anyways,
- 53:28Treichel: 17% of the year I'll be gone and they're gonna brief it.
- 53:31And I touched on, I mentioned this in oh, in my emergency podcast, I sent you
- 53:37guys my cool new emergency podcast music.
- 53:40I I appreciated your thumbs up feedback on that.
- 53:43But in that podcast I said at the board table, they said, we're
- 53:46doing something in February.
- 53:48And I channeled one or both of you and I said, hopefully they do
- 53:52more than just read the letter.
- 53:54'cause some of their recent podcasts have been just, we will read you the letter.
- 53:58Thank, do you have any questions?
- 53:59And then the questions sometimes du lead to some discussion.
- 54:03But anyway, all right, I digress.
- 54:05Where were we?
- 54:06Miller: So anyways, I think what's gonna happen is because you're
- 54:09gonna have this CYA thing, they talk about, individual exams.
- 54:14Let me go back to the front of the letter where they say focused on,
- 54:20anyways, somewhere in here they have a thing.
- 54:21We're gonna basically focus on individual characteristics of credit unions.
- 54:27What it really means is they're gonna be trying to find outliers.
- 54:31And I think what's gonna happen is if you look around, NC a's got
- 54:34all these risk reports, they got these things called rate reviews.
- 54:38A lot of these are very static.
- 54:40A lot of 'em have false positives.
- 54:42So even though you have a national supervision policy manual, which they
- 54:46tend to quietly be changing without talking to the public about separate
- 54:51issue, you're gonna find that almost all the risk trends are noticed in the
- 54:57regions before they're noticed nationally.
- 55:00And even though you have these national risk reports and
- 55:03rate reviews, all the regions.
- 55:06They generate their own risk reports based on what they're seeing and
- 55:11they see aggregate exam findings way before the national office does.
- 55:15So I think what you're gonna see is you're gonna start seeing
- 55:18some differences in the regions.
- 55:20'cause the regions are gonna start getting more involved
- 55:22in their own risk assessments.
- 55:25Credit unions at their supervisory level, they're gonna start driving.
- 55:29What happens within these credit unions, when you cut off time like
- 55:34this and they don't have resources to do their job, you're going
- 55:39to start seeing the CYA thing.
- 55:42So they're gonna lower camel ratings, they're gonna put doors and EFS
- 55:46in as an abundance of caution.
- 55:48There's gonna be less negotiations with credit unions about it.
- 55:52They'll start addressing symptoms, the issues, and not really the root causes.
- 55:56The problems, and this goes back to something that Steve said earlier
- 56:01is, when I was a director of special actions and my staff wrote doors, one
- 56:06of the first things I was looked at is this gonna do more harm than good?
- 56:10Because the last thing I wanted to do is see a door finding
- 56:14that does more harm than good.
- 56:15It addresses a problem, but does it create bigger ones?
- 56:19I think we're gonna see more of those because they're cut short on time.
- 56:23They're gonna address the symptoms as an agency just because of all the chaos going
- 56:29on, the experienced staff, they missed.
- 56:33We're going to see more doors and findings that do more harm than good because
- 56:37they're gonna be trying to do a CYA, and I think they'll be building a case for
- 56:43that with camel ratings and things that we don't have enough resources to do our job.
- 56:50Exam point's gonna go up, ES are gonna be complaining continually.
- 56:55I don't have a resources to do my job.
- 56:58And and it affects everyone.
- 57:00The examiners are less experienced.
- 57:02You're gonna have a whole bunch of new ess 'cause they lost a lot of supervisors.
- 57:06Maybe not in every region, but some regions lost a lot of supervisors.
- 57:10So you're gonna have less experienced supervisors.
- 57:13I don't know at the regional level, the quality control.
- 57:16I assume the same thing has happened there.
- 57:18You've got the most experienced people there, have left, you've got
- 57:21experienced executives left and.
- 57:24Smart people, they're going to figure it out.
- 57:27And NCUA is going to figure it out.
- 57:29But this chaos is gonna create some turmoil here for a period of time.
- 57:34And you're going to see, SES and regions doing their own thing
- 57:39to figure who the outliers are.
- 57:41And if you get people that deviate far from peer, they're going to
- 57:45get highlighted and targeted.
- 57:47So this whole chaos type thing I just think it's gonna make
- 57:51your examiners more challenging.
- 57:53Examiners are gonna wanna write findings and doors to move on.
- 57:57They're going to say, I found it.
- 57:58I didn't have time to fix it.
- 58:00They're gonna address symptoms, not root causes.
- 58:03So it's gonna be challenging for everyone.
- 58:05I've seen the thing on one of the LinkedIn posts, a person, Hey, I
- 58:08am glad for NCAA's budget cuts.
- 58:10My exam time's gonna be shortened.
- 58:12I have to deal with them less.
- 58:14And it's this is one of those, be careful what you wish for kind of things.
- 58:17Treichel: Yeah.
- 58:18Miller: Lot of things there go up, the pendulum will swing back the other way.
- 58:22NCOA did need to reduce staff, but 27% and you can't control
- 58:27where and how that's done.
- 58:28And they probably re, they probably don't have enough resources to do all
- 58:33their legislatively mandated requirements to protect that insurance plan.
- 58:38They're gonna pick and choose and triage and do the best they can.
- 58:42And, there, there's gonna be some casualties along the way.
- 58:45Treichel: Yep.
- 58:46It's just like a mass unit.
- 58:47And Steve I've got some thoughts about what Todd said, but Steve, I
- 58:50any other thoughts of that you have or any comments on what Todd said?
- 58:55Farrar: Probably a little different, but just from what we've observed
- 58:58throughout the year to say what I'd like to see a change in NCUA
- 59:02is more cooperative production.
- 59:04In the documents of resolution and how the problems will be fixed,
- 59:08not mandating from the examiner.
- 59:10That would, to me, would be a really big important step that
- 59:14we would stop hearing, that, they didn't even talk to us about it.
- 59:17We just, we just got this door and we just got it and, the meetings next week.
- 59:23Treichel: Great point.
- 59:24That's probably, if you had to, if you had to say what was the biggest bad
- 59:28trend in exams in our clients last year?
- 59:31That was probably, it reminds me of a Suzanne Vega song.
- 59:35It's a one time thing.
- 59:37It just happens a lot.
- 59:38We've been seeing that quite a bit.
- 59:40And then pivoting back to what Todd said, I wrote down in my red pen
- 59:44here, you have the CYA the, you have growing pains, but what NCOA is having
- 59:49is shrinking pains and something I've mentioned on the podcast here on occasion.
- 59:54Todd, you're talking about, the.
- 59:56The they're risk averse.
- 59:58They're less experienced that they may put their thumb on CYA,
- 1:00:03they may put their thumb on camel.
- 1:00:05And my underlying fear about the combination of the 27% and the combination
- 1:00:12of the changes they made to their camel requirements, they basically weren't able
- 1:00:17to do their exams in compliance with their requirements when they were fully staffed.
- 1:00:22So they tweaked that, then they go down 27%.
- 1:00:26Then they say, you don't have to do a 120 day contacting Camel fours.
- 1:00:31You don't have to do a 180 day contacting in camel threes.
- 1:00:36And one argument would be, wow, they don't have the, they don't have the
- 1:00:39staff, so they're not gonna overreact.
- 1:00:42And the, those on the border, if you're, you might be a two, you might
- 1:00:45be a three, will code you a two.
- 1:00:48Because I don't have the time to come back.
- 1:00:49A CYA mindset of that is, guys, you just told me I don't
- 1:00:53even have to do a follow up.
- 1:00:54I can make them a three and not have to go in there.
- 1:00:56That's perfect for me because I'm saying there's some risks there, but
- 1:00:58you're not gonna give me the time.
- 1:01:00Which goes into the whole, the camel when an exam, when you see an examiner who's
- 1:01:04not comfortable talking about camel, getting their cam, getting the camel
- 1:01:09questioned by a credit union, what they'll say is it's a it's just a resource tool
- 1:01:14that we use for where we have to go.
- 1:01:16And they've blown up the fact that it's a re, that it's a, that
- 1:01:20argument's gone because they're saying you don't necessarily
- 1:01:23have to go to the fours as often.
- 1:01:24You don't necessarily have to go to the threes.
- 1:01:26And I get why they did that, but it could have a perverse impact
- 1:01:30of it's easy for me to code you a three and then just not come back.
- 1:01:36'cause before I had to come back and I'd have to deal with it.
- 1:01:38So I think I, I don't think that's gonna be.
- 1:01:42Often, but it will happen.
- 1:01:43And I'm sure, also maybe we'll do a podcast on that when we have a client
- 1:01:46where it appears to have fit that category and deviation from the peer.
- 1:01:50They're gonna be doing more offsite statistical analysis.
- 1:01:53How many standard deviations are you away?
- 1:01:55You've got the rate reports, you've got the individual
- 1:01:57regional reports, but, all right.
- 1:01:58That's that's all I've got on this.
- 1:02:00Any other last comments before we wrap this episode of with flying colors, guys?
- 1:02:08All right,
- 1:02:09Miller: Steve, you didn't use the word, you texted me.
- 1:02:11You thought this whole letter was a word salad.
- 1:02:14Farrar: Well,
- 1:02:14Miller: I was trying, that's what you texted me last Friday.
- 1:02:17I was the word salad.
- 1:02:18Farrar: Yeah.
- 1:02:19I did I did take the letter and I had AI give me a summary and it took the, what is
- 1:02:24it, a five page, five page letter and it reduced it down to a page and a quarter.
- 1:02:29Treichel: And it's definitely a different type of letter than I've seen recently.
- 1:02:34And it, one thought that popped into my head is, and I know NCUA
- 1:02:38or at least until recently, wasn't allowed to let their people use ai.
- 1:02:41It had a little bit of an AI feel to it, the way it.
- 1:02:46Condense things and summarize things and that, and it might, and
- 1:02:49I may be totally off track there.
- 1:02:50It may be that Helpmann said, I want this to be more simple.
- 1:02:54And then what happens is he and I goes, yeah, but we gotta say, we
- 1:02:57gotta say a sentence about this.
- 1:02:58So if I'm only, if I'm not allowed to have more than four priorities or
- 1:03:02however many we have, I'll just weave it in here, and then I'll put six
- 1:03:05attachments that have 800 pages to it.
- 1:03:07So that really, it still encompasses everything.
- 1:03:10Said another way, it's a risk-based exam.
- 1:03:12This kind of tells you what NCA is thinking, but it doesn't mean
- 1:03:16that you won't have to deal with other things when NCA comes in.
- 1:03:20All right, guys, as always, thank you for your time.
- 1:03:23Stay warm.
- 1:03:24I'll do the same.
- 1:03:25And listeners watchers as always, I want to thank you for watching.
- 1:03:28Thank you for listening.
- 1:03:30Hope you'll listen again soon, or watch.
- 1:03:32And this is Mark TriCal signing off with flying colors.