Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Beyond the Merits: Legal Disputes from the Executive Perspective
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, I'm David Schrage, secretary of the Beverly
- 0:05Hills Bar Association's entertainment law section,
- 0:08and thank you for joining us. We have a fantastic
- 0:11program for you with an exceptional speaker who
- 0:14will be talking to us on the topic, Beyond the
- 0:16Merits, Legal Disputes from the Executive Perspective.
- 0:19But before getting into our seminar, We wanted
- 0:22to take a moment to acknowledge Lawyers Mutual
- 0:24Insurance Company, who graciously supports the
- 0:26entertainment law section. For five decades,
- 0:29Lawyers Mutual Insurance Company has been the
- 0:31only California -based company to continuously
- 0:34provide lawyers throughout the state with professional
- 0:36liability insurance coverage. Their experience
- 0:39and expertise are complemented by the fact that
- 0:41Lawyers Mutual is directed by a group of dedicated
- 0:43lawyers themselves. They offer special rates
- 0:46with competitive premiums for a wide range of
- 0:48areas of practice, including entertainment law.
- 0:50And you can learn more about them at lawyersmutual
- 0:52.com. I can also say firsthand that they have
- 0:55great people on their team who are true experts
- 0:57and have presented to our section before, and
- 1:00we are very grateful to have their support. I
- 1:03am delighted to now introduce our speaker, Michael
- 1:05Schwimmer. Michael Schwimmer is a commercial
- 1:08mediator and the founder of Schwimmer Mediation,
- 1:10where he brings a rare blend of experience as
- 1:12a lawyer and corporate executive doing business
- 1:15in the US and abroad. A former CEO and senior
- 1:19executive in major media companies, Michael draws
- 1:22on decades of high stakes negotiation and conflict
- 1:25resolution across such diverse areas as intellectual
- 1:27property licensing and distribution, investments,
- 1:31partnerships, M &A, finance, corporate governance,
- 1:34and employment. and among many others. Michael
- 1:37offers parties a pragmatic business -first approach
- 1:40to resolving complex commercial conflicts, and
- 1:42we are very fortunate to have him speak with
- 1:44us today and offer his uncommon and truly invaluable
- 1:47perspective. As you'll see from his presentation,
- 1:50he offers insight into what business executives
- 1:53in -house are thinking about, what they want
- 1:55from their outside counsel, and how to service
- 1:57these valuable relationships. And of course,
- 1:59he does it all from the perspective of someone
- 2:01who has actually been a lawyer on the front lines
- 2:03of these disputes as well. So with that, I will
- 2:06thank Michael again for sharing his expertise
- 2:08today. And now let's get started. Oh, great.
- 2:11Thank you, David. That was very kind, very kind
- 2:14words. I'm really happy to be here today. Thank
- 2:16you all for having me, for showing up. A little
- 2:22bit of housekeeping. I really encourage Q &A.
- 2:25If it's something that's germane to what I'm
- 2:28talking about, please jump in. I'll try to see
- 2:31it and talk about it. If not, please make sure
- 2:35to ask some questions so we get a little interactive
- 2:37at the end. My goal for today is, as David said,
- 2:43to provide insight. into what business people
- 2:48managers CEOs vice presidents whoever are thinking
- 2:52about when there's a legal dispute i think a
- 2:55lot of what i'm gonna talk about is also applicable
- 2:59to transactional layers and but but today's context
- 3:03is largely about. Is largely in the dispute context
- 3:07whether there's been an actual lawsuit filed
- 3:09or or or not. The caveat that I want to make
- 3:14is this is not a rejection of advocacy, a rejection
- 3:19of deep analysis of the merits at all. It's more
- 3:24of a framing so that council, whether the outside
- 3:28council or in -house council, can see disputes
- 3:31as an input into a broader context where the
- 3:35decisions ultimately get made by business folks.
- 3:39based on criteria that may not always be obvious
- 3:42to counsel. Just a minute on how I came to the
- 3:50topic, how I come to the topic. It's a topic
- 3:52that interests me enormously because it all comes
- 3:56from my own personal experience. I started out
- 3:58very, very briefly as a young litigation associate
- 4:02in San Francisco. And then pretty early on in
- 4:06my career, I moved to Brazil and practiced transactional
- 4:11law for a multinational law firm. And I found
- 4:17that I was much more interested in what my clients
- 4:19were doing than maybe what I was doing. And that,
- 4:22of course, let me go in -house. And I got closer
- 4:26to what I would call strategic business decision
- 4:31-making, but I was still not you know, not there
- 4:35in the sense that when your outside counsel was,
- 4:38hey, you know, we need you to file this lawsuit
- 4:39or defend this lawsuit. When I went in -house,
- 4:44of course, there were deals. There was litigation
- 4:48to manage. But it was only when I moved over
- 4:52to the business side that I began to have responsibility.
- 4:58for a broader set of interests, be that growth,
- 5:03profitability, operational stability, strategic
- 5:07initiatives. And when I did that, what I found
- 5:11was that I began to think about legal disputes
- 5:16and transactional deals in a different way. As
- 5:20opposed to being the sole focus of what I was
- 5:21trying to get done, they were a piece of the
- 5:24puzzle that fit within a larger picture. And
- 5:27that led me to thinking about the lawyers that
- 5:32I wanted to work with differently, thinking a
- 5:36little bit differently about what I valued. And
- 5:38that's kind of what leads to today. And hopefully
- 5:41I'm able to provide some insight that is useful
- 5:46for you that are here today. Now I'm going to
- 5:49try to share my screen. Give me one second here.
- 5:57And let's see, let's see, let's share and there
- 6:07we go. Okay, so here we are and beyond the merits,
- 6:18the executive lands on legal disputes. So the
- 6:21building blocks, Of course, for lawyers is how
- 6:24we were trained. It's how our legal system works.
- 6:28You gather up all the facts, the good ones, the
- 6:31bad ones. You look at how the law applies to
- 6:35those facts. You work really, really hard as
- 6:38an advocate to increase the likelihood of success,
- 6:41no matter which side of the dispute you're on.
- 6:45And there's obviously incredible skill and craft
- 6:48in doing all of those things. From an executive
- 6:52perspective, of course, there are different building
- 6:53blocks, but building blocks nonetheless. And
- 6:58the first question that comes up when there's
- 6:59a dispute is, what's the level of impact that
- 7:02this dispute could have on my business? Is it
- 7:06small and relatively immaterial? Is it sort of
- 7:09life -threatening, if you will? So you're just
- 7:12trying to gauge how much time How much focus,
- 7:16how much resource does this particular matter?
- 7:21How much does it deserve? Power dynamics is something
- 7:24that we're gonna talk about a lot today, but
- 7:28fundamentally, that's just, is this an opportunity?
- 7:34where we can flex? Do we need to put on our body
- 7:37armor because we're at serious risk? And who
- 7:41really has the leverage in this dispute? And
- 7:44last, there's risk. And how do you size that
- 7:47risk? And what does it mean ultimately to the
- 7:50company? Let me give you one sort of example.
- 7:54I'll give you a few war stories, if you will.
- 7:57There was a time when I was a CEO of a cable
- 8:00network. It was a small cable network. We were
- 8:02venture backed. We had a contract with a large
- 8:06satellite distributor and they paid us about
- 8:10a million bucks a month. And a million bucks
- 8:12a month for us was massive. And one day the monthly
- 8:18check came in and it was zero. And the paperwork
- 8:23attached to it said, amount owed, million dollars,
- 8:26credit taken, a million dollars, check equals
- 8:30zero. And when we dug into it, what we found
- 8:33out was they had gone back into the contract
- 8:35and found what they thought was a sufficient
- 8:39ambiguity to say that they had overpaid us in
- 8:42the past and they were taking back a credit of
- 8:44a million bucks. And the fact is, you know, we
- 8:48looked at it, our lawyers looked at it, there
- 8:50was no real ambiguity in our view. It was pretty
- 8:54crystal clear that they owed us the money. But
- 8:57the fact of the matter is, you know, there was,
- 8:59we weren't, you know, after we fought about it,
- 9:02but didn't get anywhere, meaning in conversations,
- 9:05there really just wasn't a scenario where it
- 9:08made sense for us to file a lawsuit. They were
- 9:10one of our largest distributors. We had a renewal
- 9:14coming up in less than a year they didn't have
- 9:17to renew the contract and so from a from a commercial
- 9:21perspective even though we were right in every
- 9:27imaginable way that they notice the money the
- 9:30fact of the matters we really had to swallow
- 9:32really really hard and just move on because the
- 9:36commercial dynamics meant that. You know, it
- 9:40wasn't, it just, it didn't really, the merits
- 9:42in this case just didn't really matter. We had
- 9:44to preserve the relationship. Um, and, uh, $11
- 9:48million for that year instead of 12 was, was
- 9:50a lot better for us than getting in a huge fight
- 9:53that would lead to a non renewal later on. So
- 9:57what are some of the things that, you know, executives
- 10:01think about? It's not an exhaustive list, but
- 10:04it's, um, But it does explain a lot. If you look
- 10:07at each of these items, and we'll go through
- 10:10each one separately, if you look at each of them,
- 10:13they can explain a lot of what's going on inside
- 10:15your client's head, inside their company. They're
- 10:21what I would call the components of a commercial
- 10:23ecosystem and every industry has an ecosystem.
- 10:27I don't care if you're selling burgers on a corner
- 10:30and your commercial ecosystem is who's selling
- 10:33you the meat, who's selling you the buns, how
- 10:35many of your competitors are down the street.
- 10:38or if you're a large movie studio. We all live
- 10:43within a commercial ecosystem and that ecosystem
- 10:46is made up of people that supply us things we
- 10:49need, people that buy our product, competitors,
- 10:53so forth and so on. And these are the things
- 10:57that really in a very strong way impact how executives
- 11:02are gonna think about a dispute when it comes
- 11:05up. So let's start with with power power is one
- 11:10of those weird words in society where you know
- 11:14we don't talk about a lot but it's there all
- 11:18the time and it's not a moral concept it's just
- 11:23it's just sort of a human attribute i would call
- 11:27it the single most important thing that i learned
- 11:30over the course of my career is how ultimately.
- 11:37Finding who has leverage is largely determinative
- 11:43of the path something is going to go and how
- 11:46people engage and what they're willing to do
- 11:48and what they're not willing to do. And so finding
- 11:51out who has the leverage and why they have it.
- 11:54And I'm not talking about leverage from a legal
- 11:56perspective. I'm talking about within the commercial
- 11:59ecosystem in which these companies, because I'm
- 12:01largely talking about commercial disputes between
- 12:04two companies. who has the leverage within the
- 12:09commercial ecosystem in which they're operating.
- 12:12And we'll talk about what kinds of leverage there
- 12:15are, of course. But the important thing to remember
- 12:17is that it's not the lawsuit that creates this
- 12:20leverage. This leverage is endemic to their...
- 12:24to their existence, to their presence in the
- 12:27market in the moment. It's independent of the
- 12:30legal merit. So finding out who has the leverage
- 12:33and why they have it is critical to understanding
- 12:37how executives are going to think about any given
- 12:39dispute. So one way I think about it is because
- 12:48here's the thing that that leverage is one of
- 12:51those things that people don't walk. Down the
- 12:54hall of their company and say you know i got
- 12:56i got there's a dispute and i have the power
- 12:59and i'm gonna exercise my power. I think it's
- 13:01something that is much more subconscious it's
- 13:03part of like no not to be too philosophical about
- 13:06it's part of the human existence. Exercising
- 13:11leverage is rewarded and in business it's rewarded
- 13:15largely in the form of market share increase
- 13:18profits and an absent a legal restraint. One
- 13:22could think of, say, antitrust law as a legal
- 13:24restraint. Absent a legal restraint, people are
- 13:27going to exercise probably about as much as they
- 13:30can. And one could even argue that in a capitalist
- 13:34system that it's required that they do, that
- 13:37their shareholders require that they exercise
- 13:39that leverage. But at a very simple level, I
- 13:42always come up with this image that pops in my
- 13:45head. If you give somebody a Ferrari and you
- 13:47say, you know, there's no speed limit, how fast
- 13:50do you think they're going to drive? right? They're
- 13:52just going to go fast. The fact that it represents
- 13:54a danger to other people on the road is not necessarily
- 13:57going to make them go a lot slower. It's an advantage
- 14:02that people have when they have leverage. In
- 14:06my experience, even if it's subconscious, it's
- 14:10going to be used. Let's talk about common sources
- 14:17of leverage. If you think about size, You know
- 14:22i guess people think about well it's a it's a
- 14:25big company and where it's a small company and
- 14:28then there's the relative size between. The two
- 14:32if you have two large companies i use it i was
- 14:36a long time in the pay tv industry and i work
- 14:40for a fortune 500 company back in the day. Dish
- 14:44Network, and we were always fighting with other
- 14:47programmers. And some of those were from very,
- 14:49very large media conglomerates. And we both had
- 14:55the resources to engage in whatever legal battle
- 14:59we wanted to. So the size of the company was
- 15:03not really an advantage for either one because
- 15:07we were both large. On the other hand, you can
- 15:12imagine situations where it's disparate. every
- 15:14once in a while there'll be a situation where
- 15:17we're being small actually has an advantage.
- 15:20That can be when there's a regulatory element
- 15:24to that where, whether it's the FCC or the DOJ,
- 15:28they don't want to see a larger company beating
- 15:30up on a smaller company. So maybe being small
- 15:34has an advantage in that case, but usually scale
- 15:38denotes bank account and the advantage that comes
- 15:43with. Where I think it gets more interesting
- 15:46is when when parties have a vulnerability in
- 15:52relation to each other. So the best way to think
- 15:55about it is, you know, you have a buyer or a
- 15:58seller. I have some other examples here. IP reliance
- 16:02is a big one. But if in any dispute, You can
- 16:08sit back and look at the facts, and if you really
- 16:11understand the business of both parties, you're
- 16:13gonna see pretty quickly where the leverage lies.
- 16:19And so, again, this is all before you even get
- 16:21to the merits about who's right and who's wrong.
- 16:25In my past, there was a situation where we got
- 16:28in a fight with Viacom. Viacom owned CBS, and
- 16:34they owned a bunch of cable networks, including
- 16:36MTV. And and they threatened to take down all
- 16:40the channels off of our satellite system. And
- 16:43and we thought we're in pretty good shape because
- 16:47at the end of the day we had hundreds of channels
- 16:49on our on our on our pay TV platform football
- 16:54season was over so we didn't have to worry about
- 16:56people not getting their game on CBS. And when
- 17:00those channels came down, and we happened to
- 17:02be in the middle of an antitrust lawsuit, and
- 17:04that's why it's germane to this conversation.
- 17:07When the channels went down, all of a sudden
- 17:10our phone started ringing off the hook, and it
- 17:14was mothers who were complaining that we had
- 17:16taken SpongeBob away from their kids, because
- 17:19SpongeBob was hugely popular on a network called
- 17:21Nickelodeon. And we didn't even realize the kind
- 17:25of leverage that they had over us based on the
- 17:28loyalty that that show had in people's households
- 17:33that had, you know, small children. So, you know,
- 17:37sometimes you don't know where the leverage is
- 17:38and it appears later. And that was certainly
- 17:41a case for us. So the other thing is stakes.
- 17:47So after you get through who has the leverage,
- 17:50what are the stakes? You have to be able to size
- 17:54them both from an opportunity perspective as
- 17:57well as a downside, depending on which side of
- 18:00the dispute you're on. Obviously, if there are
- 18:04no real stakes for either party, then you're
- 18:06probably not in a dispute to begin with. It got
- 18:09worked out between a couple of folks over a phone
- 18:12call. But if there are real stakes, Those takes
- 18:15can be financial, which is sort of the most obvious
- 18:18one. And when there's a lot of money involved,
- 18:23then everybody's all over it, right? Because
- 18:25it's a lot of money. But realize, for smaller
- 18:29clients, for smaller businesses, what might not
- 18:32seem like a lot of money could be really existential,
- 18:34right? So the financial element obviously is
- 18:38in relation to any individual business. But low
- 18:46dollar number, sort of low, how can I put it?
- 18:50You might have a case where there are low dollar
- 18:51numbers, but there's something very strategic
- 18:54at play. And that often happens when you're in
- 18:58the beginning of a new market, if you will, a
- 19:00new initiative where the business growth isn't
- 19:04there yet, it's not a robust. large division
- 19:08of a particular company, but it's something important
- 19:11to them. It's something that they want to lean
- 19:12into. And so you can find yourself in a dispute
- 19:16where there isn't much money at stake, but there's
- 19:20a lot of strategic value at stake. If you look
- 19:24at this list, obviously when competitors are
- 19:27suing each other, they want to put the other
- 19:32company in a disadvantageous ... Position for
- 19:34their own advantage that tends to be pretty pretty
- 19:38clear from the outset There are precedent issues,
- 19:42of course as well and there can be large precedent
- 19:45issues as you can imagine and things like class
- 19:48actions a lot in the entertainment industry When
- 19:53you have studios that are dealing with a lot
- 19:56of the same players at the same time, those could
- 19:59be agencies, those could be talent, those could
- 20:02be distributors. So even though the dollars might
- 20:06not be that large, it may be that breaking the
- 20:09way they're doing business in this case is gonna
- 20:12have ripple effects, which are just not how the
- 20:16company wants to do business going forward. So
- 20:20again, the stakes. pretty important in an executive's
- 20:27mindset, if you will, is how hard do we fight
- 20:30about this? Is it worth going all the way to
- 20:34the mattresses, or is this something that we
- 20:36should settle quickly and reduce our risk in
- 20:39order to make sure that we can preserve the value
- 20:43that we want to, especially as it relates to
- 20:44things like precedent and reputation or competitive
- 20:46position and so forth? You have the relationship
- 20:52between the parties, right? So that's a whole
- 20:59different angle, right? Like who's on the other
- 21:02side and what's your relationship to them? So
- 21:08if there's no prior relationship, then generally,
- 21:12that's not gonna be a huge factor in how people
- 21:14think about... their engagement with the dispute,
- 21:19how hard they lean in or not, because there's
- 21:24somebody on the other side of the lawsuit that
- 21:27they're not in an ongoing relationship with.
- 21:31This can be a situation like IP infringement.
- 21:35where the infringer is somebody that you're not
- 21:37doing business with or vice versa. It could be
- 21:39real estate where two companies are both claiming
- 21:43to have an interest entitled to a piece of property.
- 21:47They haven't done business together. They could
- 21:48be two banks with competing, you know, collateral
- 21:51or what have you. So it doesn't mean that it's
- 21:56not an important case. for them, and that winning
- 21:59isn't important. What it means is there isn't
- 22:00a relationship there that they have to worry
- 22:02about preserving, and that gives them a lot more
- 22:05flexibility. In ongoing relationships, and this
- 22:10is again, as I was talking about, very, very
- 22:12common, especially in the entertainment industry,
- 22:15because you have so many players that are constantly
- 22:19doing business together. So when I was at Dish
- 22:23and later when I ran Sling TV, we had hundreds
- 22:26of channels and hundreds of people that we did
- 22:29business with really like every day in a way
- 22:31by distributing their content out to millions
- 22:34of customers and disputes would happen. Sometimes
- 22:39lords would get involved in working those disputes
- 22:43out. But that was all in the context of a relationship
- 22:48that we still needed to maintain on a day -to
- 22:51-day basis, and there were managers within the
- 22:53company who were still communicating with the
- 22:55other side, who were still working on new initiatives,
- 22:58sometimes new marketing initiatives, even though
- 23:01we were involved in a lawsuit. So that's a very
- 23:03different kind of situation where it dramatically
- 23:06affects how I would ask counsel to engage, because
- 23:12winning and losing may have been important, but
- 23:16it's balanced against making sure that we continue
- 23:20to have a strong operating relationship with
- 23:23the counterparty. You have situations where you've
- 23:33done a deal with somebody, so theoretically you
- 23:36have a relationship with them. You don't have
- 23:39a long history with them. It was the only deal
- 23:40you ever did. Unfortunately, it went bad. But
- 23:44the question there is, do you expect to do business
- 23:48with them in the future? Would you like to do
- 23:50business with them in the future? And so there's
- 23:53a situation where the impact of the value of
- 23:56the relationship and how that affects how you
- 23:58think about it, it could be low, it could be
- 24:01high. It just depends on the situation between
- 24:04the parties and whether or not they have an expectation
- 24:07of doing business together. in the future. So
- 24:13again, another what I would call slice of the
- 24:17criteria that the business managers are thinking
- 24:21about. So existential risk, it's not that often,
- 24:31but you can imagine that there are disputes where
- 24:36if one party loses, they can go out of business.
- 24:40It's that serious, whether it's because of a
- 24:42financial issue or a strategic issue, or maybe
- 24:47it's IP related and it's going to take away their
- 24:52ability to use or sell a very core part of their
- 24:58value proposition. And so in situations where
- 25:02there is severe threat to the enterprise, I guess
- 25:08the best way to put it is that all bets are off.
- 25:12The things that I just took you through, they
- 25:17kind of fall to the wayside because you're in
- 25:20survival mode. So the executive is going to think
- 25:23about things differently if there's that level
- 25:25of risk to the enterprise. If you win, And the
- 25:32relationship is damaged. Well, you're going to
- 25:36have to pick up those pieces later. But picking
- 25:39up the pieces later is a better alternative than
- 25:42losing your business. So existential risk, again,
- 25:49it's worth understanding if whatever dispute
- 25:54you're involved in advising on rises to that
- 25:57level. So this is kind of a favorite of mine.
- 26:04I wouldn't put it at the top of the list along
- 26:08with power dynamics and stakes and relationship.
- 26:12But I think we live in a world where we're part
- 26:17of communities, communities inside our company
- 26:20and in the commercial ecosystem in which we operate.
- 26:26And I've been in both large companies and smaller
- 26:30ones and in which, you know, there were lawsuits
- 26:34going on. So what is the impact that these that
- 26:38these disputes have from a cultural perspective
- 26:42in a smaller environments? Say when I was I was
- 26:46running a couple of cable channels. What I found,
- 26:49to my surprise, is is that the The fight's really
- 26:54galvanized. Everybody's obviously super aware
- 26:57of it because in a smaller company, and I think
- 27:01at the time maybe we had 100 people, but in a
- 27:05smaller environment, word travels very, very
- 27:09fast and everybody knows we're either suing somebody
- 27:11or we've been sued. And it has this really fortunate
- 27:17effort of bringing people together. I'm like,
- 27:21oh, we're going to beat those guys and let's
- 27:23work hard and let's get everything we need to
- 27:25get together for the council, for council to
- 27:27help them. And I found that I could use the fact
- 27:30that we were in a lawsuit to really create quite
- 27:34an esprit de corps and a sense of, you know,
- 27:37underdog and battled. And that paid long -term
- 27:41dividends in terms of making sure that we all
- 27:44stayed together and had each other's back, that
- 27:46kind of thing. But the downside, of course, is
- 27:49that people get nervous. And when you're not
- 27:51part of a larger company... You know, people
- 27:55know that they feel that they're at risk. If
- 27:58it looks like there's a lawsuit that could, you
- 27:59know, significantly damage the company, then
- 28:02especially folks who are, you know, younger,
- 28:04maybe they're just buying a house or they want
- 28:06to buy a house. So they have small children and
- 28:08all of a sudden they're like thinking about,
- 28:09oh, what happens if we lose this lawsuit? You
- 28:12know, it's not great. I've seen people leave
- 28:15for larger companies just because they didn't
- 28:17like what I would call the risk profile of that
- 28:20kind of an environment. In an external perspective,
- 28:24well, let me before I go there on an internal
- 28:26perspective, I would say, if you're part of a
- 28:29larger company, and there are a lot of lawsuits
- 28:32flying around, you just don't want to make sure
- 28:35that your staff, your employees think of you
- 28:37as a bully, right? No one, you know, people these
- 28:40days, they want to be proud of where they're
- 28:42working. And they certainly don't want to go
- 28:43home feeling like they spent the day, you know,
- 28:46beating up on a bunch of other folks, when things
- 28:50could have been worked out differently. So there's
- 28:53a bit of a downside there but but not nearly
- 28:56as clearly as when was when in a smaller corporate
- 29:00environment from an external perspective. You
- 29:04know there is such a thing as a litigious reputation
- 29:07i think every every industry you know knows you
- 29:12know who are the folks that tend to work things
- 29:14out when things go sideways and you sit down
- 29:17and you work things out in the floors get involved
- 29:19you're still. trying to work it out. And then
- 29:23who are the companies that are the first chance
- 29:26they get? They're filing a lawsuit to gain an
- 29:29advantage and put pressure on the other side.
- 29:34And the downside to that, of course, is that...
- 29:39it has an impact on contracting going forward.
- 29:43Because if you're one of those companies that
- 29:46has a reputation of being in court a lot, then
- 29:50as you do deals going forward, folks are going
- 29:53to say, well, I need to make this indemnification
- 29:56clause from a paragraph to three pages. Or I'm
- 30:00kidding, but you get the idea that the drafting
- 30:03can get a lot tighter. when there's less trust,
- 30:07that you'll be able to work things out on a friendly
- 30:09basis. And things like partnerships, marketing
- 30:12partnerships, joint ventures, those things, where
- 30:16there is a lot of trust involved, become harder.
- 30:21Because especially in those sort of collaborative
- 30:23relationships, no matter what's written on the
- 30:27contract, you still need to be able to trust
- 30:29the other side. So this is where I think culture
- 30:32and reputation is sort of really an important
- 30:36factor for executives to think through as they
- 30:39are thinking about litigation, litigation strategy.
- 30:45So how does this all sort of show up in real
- 30:51life? I think it shows up with things that you
- 30:57see happening. You think you have a really strong,
- 31:01your client has a really strong claim and the
- 31:02next thing you know, They want to settle. They
- 31:05want to settle quickly. They want to settle early.
- 31:07They're not maximizing their leverage. Well,
- 31:10why? Well, there are reasons why, and my bet
- 31:15is, in many cases, it will relate to some of
- 31:18the things that we've already discussed. Why
- 31:20are people fighting for years over modest dollars?
- 31:24Maybe it's ego, but maybe there's something else
- 31:26involved that is more... strategic. Again, these
- 31:30things are largely independent of the merits.
- 31:33That's hence beyond the merits. Why are people
- 31:37escalating or not escalating when they could?
- 31:43Here, I think the issue is if you're outside
- 31:46counsel to a company and you're seeing your client
- 31:53Make decisions that that don't necessarily align
- 31:58with the strength of the case or what you would
- 32:00normally expect Then you know, you don't you
- 32:03don't want to be surprised, right? and so I believe
- 32:06like a deep understanding of your clients business
- 32:09and and What's important to them will avoid what
- 32:12I would call surprises and allow you to be much
- 32:14more attuned to To what's going on? So So let's
- 32:23talk about settlement mediation for a second.
- 32:26So obviously, the vast majority of lawsuits never
- 32:30go to trial. I think I heard it's somewhere well
- 32:34above 90 % don't. And so that means they're going
- 32:38to settle, and they might settle. sometimes even
- 32:42between the parties, just getting together in
- 32:44a room and talking about it. But they're often
- 32:48going to settle with the help of counsel, whether
- 32:50that's directly between counsel or in the context
- 32:53of a mediation. But the key here is before settlement
- 32:58discussions, before mediation, you don't have
- 33:04a lot of visibility into what the business dynamics
- 33:09are. And the reason is because you might have
- 33:14some nasty letters between the parties. Those
- 33:17are going to largely be for positioning purposes.
- 33:21You're going to have pleadings. Someone filed
- 33:23a complaint, someone answered a complaint, discovery,
- 33:26a bunch of interrogatories, some requests for
- 33:28admissions. But those are all very formal in
- 33:32nature, and none of it is confidential. And so
- 33:36the mediation is really the first place where
- 33:40the underlying power dynamics come front and
- 33:43center. And the business context is really where
- 33:48much of the action is happening because the settlement
- 33:54conversation in a mediation, it's not about advocacy
- 33:57in the sense that it's much less about arguing
- 34:02your case or why you'll get a summary judgment
- 34:04or why, you know, a particular case applies or
- 34:07doesn't apply. And so, you know, effective counsel,
- 34:12in my view, is going to come into that environment,
- 34:18you know, deeply embedded in their client's business
- 34:22thinking, because that's where it's going to
- 34:24matter the most is in a settlement conversation.
- 34:28Advocacy itself, which is what litigators are
- 34:33great at is just not as important in this environment
- 34:37as, quite frankly, deal -making. And it's really
- 34:41an opportunity for counsel to become a creative
- 34:44partner. And in order for you to be a creative
- 34:47partner, you really need to understand what your
- 34:50client's thinking and what they're thinking from
- 34:52a business perspective, of course. The confidentiality
- 34:55of the environment is what really allows that
- 34:58to happen. whether it's under rule 408 of the
- 35:01federal rules or whether it's the, you know,
- 35:03the confidential mediation agreement. But at
- 35:05the end of the day, when people can speak freely
- 35:07and they're sitting down in order to get a deal
- 35:10done, you know, that's when these underlying
- 35:13criteria, these underlying dynamics are really
- 35:17going to come to the forefront. So let's talk
- 35:22very, very briefly about boards of directors.
- 35:24Well, They come in all shapes and sizes. But
- 35:29they have a fundamentally different role than
- 35:33management. A board of directors, it's an oversight
- 35:38role. It's a governance role. It's not an operational
- 35:41role. And their job is not to do everything on
- 35:46a day -to -day basis to grow the company. And
- 35:50so they'll comment disputes with a with a different
- 35:53focus, primarily an investor focus. How do we
- 35:56preserve shareholder value? Realize typically
- 36:01no one on the board was involved in whatever
- 36:05led to the dispute in the first place. So you
- 36:07don't have personal egos involved, like sometimes
- 36:12a client may want to prove that they're right.
- 36:16Well, because maybe they made the decision to
- 36:18do a particular deal. But once it gets to a board,
- 36:22by definition, it's material. It's a big deal.
- 36:26The board doesn't have a personal stake in the
- 36:28outcome. There isn't an ego. And they certainly
- 36:30don't have an incentive one way or the other.
- 36:33It's not like they're going to get paid more
- 36:35or less. They don't have a bonus that's going
- 36:37to depend on the outcome of this case, whereas
- 36:40management obviously arrives from a very, very
- 36:43different perspective. It's helpful to understand
- 36:50if your client is bringing something to their
- 36:53board because that will explain both, one, you
- 36:56can help them position it, of course, and two,
- 37:00it may explain while there can be a different
- 37:04negotiating posture or a different litigation
- 37:07strategy post discussion with a board as opposed
- 37:10to before, and that's because a board may have
- 37:13brought. a different what I would call a viewpoint,
- 37:17a different temperature, a different rationale
- 37:20that it wants management to move forward with.
- 37:27So what does all this mean for business lawyers?
- 37:35And again, I think this is both useful for transactional
- 37:41lawyers as well as litigators, but it starts
- 37:45with having a deep curiosity for your client's
- 37:47business and really understanding the industry
- 37:52that they live in and how it all works and how
- 37:56that impacts the context of this particular dispute
- 38:00that you're connected to or ordeal that you're
- 38:03doing. Having expertise in what you do super
- 38:09important, having strong skills, really important,
- 38:13but I would go so far as to say those are table
- 38:15stakes. Like if you're an expert at what you
- 38:17do, great, those are table stakes because theoretically,
- 38:21every client wants to know that their lawyer
- 38:22is an expert. The differentiator is not that
- 38:27you have great subject matter expertise. The
- 38:32differentiator is that you deeply understand
- 38:35your client's business and that you deeply understand
- 38:38what they do on a day to day basis and how they
- 38:41think about this dispute and the criteria that
- 38:43they're using in order to determine what the
- 38:46best strategy is going forward. And if you are
- 38:50able to communicate that. As you work with your
- 38:55client, that can be a foundation for a tremendous
- 38:58amount of trust and loyalty that gets built between
- 39:03you and your client. I have a little bit of an
- 39:07ending caveat here. which is what we didn't talk
- 39:11about is the role of in -house counsel because
- 39:15a lot of times outside lawyers are not really
- 39:20working directly with the business managers.
- 39:22They're working with in -house counsel. That
- 39:24brings obviously a different element to it because
- 39:29in -house counsel sits in between management
- 39:33and outside counsel and there's some translation
- 39:37that goes on and they have a tricky job for sure.
- 39:42But that would be like a whole other hour of
- 39:45sitting here and talking about being an in -house
- 39:49counsel. I've been one working with in -house
- 39:51counsel from an outside perspective, which I've
- 39:54done, and working with in -house counsel from
- 39:57an executive perspective, which I've also done
- 40:00quite a bit. I would say that a lot of folks
- 40:05that have run businesses, they don't come from
- 40:08a legal background. And so it's pretty often
- 40:11for someone to ask their general counsel or ask
- 40:15their VP of sales or what have you, go talk to
- 40:20the lawyers and come back to me and tell me what
- 40:21you think we should do. I never did that. I loved
- 40:25working with lawyers. People would say, oh, you
- 40:29left the practice of law, so you escaped. And
- 40:31that just never resonated with me at all. I have
- 40:38enormous respect for lawyers, and I enjoy working
- 40:42with them. So what I would do is I would ask
- 40:44them to come into my office. I'd say, OK, no,
- 40:46no. Bring the lawyers in. Bring the in -house
- 40:48counsel. Bring the outside counsel. Let's all
- 40:51sit down and talk about what's going on and what
- 40:53this means for the business and how we can think
- 40:54about working on this. this particular problem
- 40:57going forward. So this is all very personal to
- 41:03me in the sense that it was part of my day -to
- 41:05-day for many years. I enjoy it a lot and I hope
- 41:08I was able to provide some useful concepts for
- 41:13you guys to think about. So with that, I am gonna
- 41:17stop sharing my screen and figure out how to
- 41:21do that. There we go. Okay. So, um, hi David
- 41:30Hey, Michael. Good to be back. Thank you very
- 41:32much for a fantastic presentation. Really tremendous
- 41:35insights. I wonder if maybe I could follow up
- 41:37with you and ask a few questions that occurred
- 41:39to me. Sure, sure. Along the way, backing up
- 41:43a little bit. One thing I thought was so interesting
- 41:44was when you talked about that circumstance where
- 41:47there's ongoing litigation between two businesses
- 41:49that are still working together. Imagine it can
- 41:52create some really thorny situations both for
- 41:54the business and for the lawyers. In your experience,
- 41:58How would you like to see the outside counsel,
- 42:01the litigator, navigating that with the internal
- 42:04business people as the person in -house? How
- 42:06are you communicating between the business and
- 42:09the lawyers about what's happening? I mean, is
- 42:11it an ongoing dialogue? I can imagine there can
- 42:14be a disconnect. How do you manage the potential
- 42:16situations? It gets a little complicated, but
- 42:19I think what you try to do, what I've always
- 42:22tried to do, is what do they say in banking?
- 42:24You know, you have that Chinese wall between
- 42:26like the analysts and the traders. you know this
- 42:29for me it was you know you sit down with the
- 42:34business folks and you say hey you know your
- 42:36day -to -day job is largely staying the same
- 42:38you're gonna work with that company you're gonna
- 42:40keep working on the projects that you've been
- 42:41working on you're gonna maintain that relationship
- 42:43and and and and if anybody asks you about the
- 42:47lawsuit it's like yeah yeah the lawyers are working
- 42:49on that right you don't you don't want people
- 42:51who are quote -unquote on the line you know serving
- 42:56the food every day to be involved in what's happening
- 43:00back in the kitchen, right? There is that relationship
- 43:04that requires, you know, care and feeding. And
- 43:10if you treat people, my view is if you treat
- 43:12people with the same good attitude that you treated
- 43:16them before, then you can bifurcate those things
- 43:20and the fight can go on in parallel. you know,
- 43:24with senior level executives and counsel in -house
- 43:28and outside counsel working through the problem
- 43:31without affecting the day -to -day relationship
- 43:34that goes on. What you don't want is you don't
- 43:37want folks at what I'll call that, that on the
- 43:43line operational level trying to figure out what
- 43:47they should do based on the litigation, right?
- 43:51Because they're not really equipped to do that
- 43:53unless they got specific instructions. So the
- 43:56best way is like, hey, let's just keep that separate.
- 44:01If you have any questions, come back to in -house
- 44:03counsel, come back to your business manager,
- 44:05and we can answer whatever questions you have.
- 44:07But don't try to work it out in real time with
- 44:11someone else on the other side who also is in
- 44:14the same position, has no authority to figure
- 44:16anything out with you. Well, and it's interesting
- 44:17because I think of it from the litigator's perspective
- 44:19sometimes, all right, well, I would think there
- 44:22might be some intersection. Somebody's going
- 44:23to have a deposition taken or something like
- 44:25that. So I would be worried about, is the litigator
- 44:27throwing a bomb into the middle of something
- 44:29that someone in the business has to deal with?
- 44:31It sounds like, for the most part, you're really
- 44:33trying to insulate that process. Yeah. No, you
- 44:36want to look. The business, it's a living organism,
- 44:39right? It has to operate in a healthy way. And
- 44:46so you can't, you know, that living organism
- 44:48needs to keep doing what it's doing. And if there's
- 44:52some adjustments, oh, we're not gonna provide
- 44:54them with these marketing materials anymore or
- 44:56whatever, then there may be certain adjustments
- 44:58that get made. But for the most part, the dispute
- 45:02is sort of severable from the day -to -day operations.
- 45:07Unless it's like we're not supplying, if the
- 45:09relationship is completely broken down. So you're
- 45:12not supplying them with the software anymore.
- 45:14Well, then there isn't the relationship to maintain
- 45:17because the relationship literally blew up. But
- 45:21I'm thinking more about my experience where I'm
- 45:26going to make it up. If you had a restaurant
- 45:27and a food service company, well, the restaurant's
- 45:29still in business. They still need the product
- 45:32from the food service company, and they got to
- 45:34keep deliveries going and keep. pushing the food
- 45:37out to the customers and whatever dispute they
- 45:41have on something else, they'll figure that out.
- 45:44It makes really good sense, especially when you're
- 45:46talking about larger businesses where it's not
- 45:48necessarily the core of stakeholders who are
- 45:51going to be involved in the day -to -day in the
- 45:53same way. I had another question for you that
- 45:57I thought was really interesting. You mentioned
- 45:59when the board enters and the dynamic that exists
- 46:03in these companies with the boards. I think for
- 46:05many of us, It might be a bit of an opaque relationship
- 46:09in terms of how the lawyers and the management
- 46:12executives interact with the board when a dispute
- 46:15like this comes up. I mean, what's your perspective
- 46:18on? when the conversations happen, what conversations
- 46:21need to happen, what's the best practice in terms
- 46:23of how management works with the board to escalate
- 46:25disputes or to navigate them, to insulate themselves,
- 46:29to engage outside counsel at the right time.
- 46:31What does that dialogue and partnership look
- 46:33like? Well, look, I think it all starts with
- 46:35where does the dispute fit in the business itself,
- 46:38right? So there's this concept of materiality.
- 46:41Certainly for a publicly traded company, the
- 46:45issue is, is this matter material? that tends
- 46:49to be the threshold where a CEO is going to say,
- 46:53okay, I should let the board know about this,
- 46:56right? Because it's material, because it could,
- 46:58in fact, it could impact our results for the
- 47:00year, it could impact our strategic initiative
- 47:02that we've been talking about and working on,
- 47:07that it has a material, that how the dispute
- 47:10gets. Litigated worked out whatever side it comes
- 47:15out on you win you lose like it could really
- 47:18make a difference So you're taking that to the
- 47:19board Hopefully you're taking to the board early
- 47:22and you're saying hey, I just want you to know
- 47:25this is what's going on This is our plan. This
- 47:28is how we plan to handle it We've engaged outside
- 47:31council to look at it for us. They're working
- 47:33with in -house council or you know, we just got
- 47:36the complaint yesterday We haven't hired outside
- 47:38council yet, but at the end of the day, you know
- 47:41when it's early then you're letting the board
- 47:44know and the board because they hired the CEO,
- 47:48the CEO is responsible for what happens underneath
- 47:51him or her, buck stops with him or her. And so
- 47:56the board is probably going to say, thanks for
- 47:58letting us know, good luck with that, keep us
- 47:59informed. and that to me would be a best practice
- 48:05is you don't want to surprise somebody. Let me
- 48:09put it this way. If your board is surprised because
- 48:12you're telling them about stuff that's late,
- 48:14that's not what I would call a long -term job
- 48:17security strategy. You want to let them know
- 48:22early and you let them know you have a plan.
- 48:27further along the way, once you get into things
- 48:30like, let's say you're on the side of you're
- 48:34a defendant, and you think this could be very
- 48:38expensive for you, you have to get your board
- 48:41involved. You have to get them involved because
- 48:45they need to bless a settlement, which is what
- 48:50I would call not even close to being within the
- 48:532026 budget, if you will. You want them on your
- 48:59side. So it's like everybody's putting their
- 49:01hand in the fire. The last thing you want to
- 49:04do is say, yeah, I settled this case. I signed
- 49:08with my authority on behalf of the company. We're
- 49:11going to be paying X number of dollars. And I'm
- 49:14letting you know that that happened last week.
- 49:16Yeah, that's not good. It's really managing expectations
- 49:20and all about. Yeah, it's all about managing
- 49:22expectations at that level. And by the way, I
- 49:25would go further. I would say if you bring that
- 49:28down through the relative ranks, I think you
- 49:31always want to manage expectations. Whether you're
- 49:34a coordinator, manager, director, VP, you always
- 49:38want to manage expectations of the person that
- 49:40you're reporting into. So I think no one likes
- 49:43surprises. I think it's a great observation,
- 49:46having worked in -house myself and then been
- 49:49in firms, that each organization, to your point,
- 49:52is an organism and has its own internal dynamics
- 49:54that have to be managed like that within a law
- 49:57firm versus in -house also. You sort of hear
- 49:59and understand it. The problem is that there's
- 50:03this thing that humans don't like to deliver
- 50:06bad news. No one wants to be - In Hollywood.
- 50:09and you know anywhere right because there's this
- 50:13idea that if I'm delivering bad news somehow
- 50:15I'm responsible for the bad news right and so
- 50:18and and and and those you know that's just that's
- 50:22an environment that that there can be a lot of
- 50:25problems in environments where where the bad
- 50:28news is getting swept under the rug right so
- 50:31hopefully there's an environment where it's all
- 50:33you know everybody's you know on the same team
- 50:35and they're just trying to figure out how to
- 50:37how to fix from And that makes me think of something
- 50:39you spoke about earlier, which is cultural considerations,
- 50:42both internally and externally. And I know that
- 50:44you also have a deep background working in Latin
- 50:47America. And I just wonder, from your perspective,
- 50:51what's your view on navigating these cultural
- 50:53considerations across cultures, not just as a
- 50:55business executive, where you know maybe the
- 50:58customs and how people work, but you're a mediator
- 51:00as well. I imagine this must come up when you're
- 51:02trying to settle cases. Yeah. So a lot of my
- 51:06work has been done in Latin America. And even
- 51:11in the US, I ran a Hispanic cable network. And
- 51:16then I've worked at a large Spanish language
- 51:20broadcaster. So there's a really interesting
- 51:25cultural element there. And that is that American
- 51:29culture is much more team -oriented. It doesn't
- 51:33mean that you don't have authoritative managers
- 51:35who tell people, go do this, go do that. But
- 51:39there is this expectation that if you're in a
- 51:41meeting and someone says, hey, OK, let's have
- 51:45a discussion about this. What does everybody
- 51:47think? Let's go around the room. People are going
- 51:50to raise their hand. They'll give their opinion.
- 51:52And I think this, or I think that, or we should
- 51:55consider this, or we should consider that. And
- 51:57that's all not only expected, it's encouraged.
- 52:03And in Latin culture, it's much more hierarchical,
- 52:11almost patriarchal. And so there's a greater
- 52:16level of deference to someone who is older than
- 52:18you, someone who has a title to you, certainly
- 52:22someone who's male versus female. And so it can
- 52:26be more challenging. to get somebody to give
- 52:31you their genuine opinion about something and
- 52:36to give you information, quite frankly, that
- 52:38you need because the communication path can be
- 52:43traditionally much more one way from top down.
- 52:48And it's harder to get the communication going
- 52:51up the chain. That's interesting. So yeah, I
- 52:54imagine when it comes to resolving your disputes,
- 52:56it's a key consideration in terms of how you
- 52:58explore these things. But I mean, you're speaking
- 53:01about the Latin American culture, but being in
- 53:03business, it must be something you think about
- 53:06across all the different cultures that you work
- 53:07with. I mean, entertainment is such a global
- 53:08business now. I think it's probably a more important
- 53:11consideration than it's ever been. Look, I think,
- 53:14you know, litigation is teamwork, right? You
- 53:19need to have the teamwork going on, you know,
- 53:21within the law firm, you know, with with in -house
- 53:24counsel or directly with management. And when
- 53:26everybody's on the same team, you know, your
- 53:30things are going to go better, right? Because
- 53:32you're surfacing the information, you're surfing
- 53:34the channels, you're making efficient decisions.
- 53:36There isn't the same amount of second guessing
- 53:38later. And and so, you know, but that you have
- 53:45to have you have people. You have to have an
- 53:47environment that promotes that. So the same concepts
- 53:51of what I'll call respect for your peers, respect
- 53:54for that your opinion might not be the best opinion.
- 54:00One way to think about it is crowdsourcing. Crowdsourcing
- 54:04the answer. among members of the team is the
- 54:07best way to get to the best answer. As opposed
- 54:10to a guy sitting at the head of the table, usually
- 54:12it's a guy, hopefully not always. And it says,
- 54:15oh yeah, this is what we should do and everybody
- 54:17go do it. In my view, it's not only not a fun
- 54:22environment to work in, it doesn't typically
- 54:25lead to the best answers. Well, and it also sounds
- 54:27like one of the key takeaways from your presentation
- 54:30today is, from the perspective of the in -house
- 54:32business executive, is Where are we actually
- 54:35trying to go as a team? What is the strategy
- 54:38of the business that needs to be understood that
- 54:41it sounds like you're kind of constantly keeping
- 54:42your eye on? You have to. And so that's just,
- 54:46you know, what I did as an outside lawyer and
- 54:50an in -house counsel is I just spent. as much
- 54:53time as I could reading at the time, it was the
- 54:55trade rags, reading everything I could about
- 54:57what was going on in my industry, lots of things
- 55:00it had to do with companies that I wasn't working
- 55:03for. So that when I was in those conversations,
- 55:06everything would make more sense because I wanted
- 55:10when I was sitting in the room with lawyers,
- 55:12I wanted to be able to understand how the lawyers
- 55:15were, how the business guys were thinking about
- 55:17things. and what the basis of their decisions
- 55:20were. And much of that is what I'll call a result
- 55:25of the commercial ecosystem. So I ended up, I
- 55:30guess that's why they kicked me out of the legal
- 55:32department, told me to go do something else in
- 55:35the business. So I think it worked for me. But
- 55:41yeah, the best lawyers are your partners, they're
- 55:43your team members. They understand what you're
- 55:46going through as a client. Well, look, I can
- 55:48see why they would have put you into that chair.
- 55:50Clearly, you're an expert in this area. And I
- 55:53think that another key takeaway from your talk,
- 55:56I think, is that sometimes the best experts are
- 55:59the ones who are sitting next to you as your
- 56:00clients and as the business executives that you're
- 56:03working with in -house as well. So we're at the
- 56:05end of our time for today. So unless you had
- 56:07any additional thoughts you wanted to share,
- 56:11I wanted to thank you on behalf of the Beverly
- 56:12Hills Bar Association for your presentation today.
- 56:15It was tremendously valuable. And thank you so
- 56:19much for offering your expertise today. Thank
- 56:21you, David. It was a pleasure to be here. Thank
- 56:23you. Thank you. Thank you everyone for joining.