Latest / The Checkout Point / Week 45 - Holiday Sales Forecasts: NRF vs Adobe's $275.1B Online Number, What Google's Mueller Says About AI SEO, and Early Black Friday Deals
Transcript
- 0:05[Max] Welcome to the Checkout Point, your quick dive into this week's ecommerce
- 0:08[Max] buzz with me, Alex, powered by Blicket.
- 0:12[Max] These 20 minutes pack the latest trends, news, and insights.
- 0:15[Max] Let's navigate the digital marketplace together.
- 0:18[Max] Ready?
- 0:19[Max] Let's go.
- 0:28[Rachel] I saw a holiday display in a store last week.
- 0:31[Rachel] Last week.
- 0:32[Rachel] There was a pumpkin sitting next to a snow globe.
- 0:34[Speaker 3] Though nobody asked the pumpkin how it felt about that.
- 0:38[Rachel] Right.
- 0:39[Rachel] The season starts earlier every year, and I mean, come on, we
- 0:42[Rachel] haven't even finished the candy.
- 0:44[Speaker 3] Early starts are fine, but what's the actual ROI of starting in
- 0:48[Speaker 3] October?
- 0:49[Speaker 3] That's what I wanna know.
- 0:50[Rachel] See, that's why you're here.
- 0:52[Rachel] I'd just buy the snow globe.
- 0:54[Speaker 3] Of course you would.
- 0:55[Rachel] And before anyone says it, yes, I know the stores aren't doing
- 0:59[Rachel] it just to annoy me.
- 1:00[Rachel] They're doing it because they hope it works.
- 1:03[Rachel] Every year, they pull the start line a little earlier and cross
- 1:06[Rachel] their fingers.
- 1:07[Speaker 3] Hope is not a line item.
- 1:10[Speaker 3] We're gonna poke at that hope today politely with a spreadsheet.
- 1:13[Rachel] So welcome to the Checkout Point week forty-five.
- 1:16[Rachel] I'm Max.
- 1:17[Speaker 3] And I'm Rachel.
- 1:18[Rachel] Okay, two things are bugging me this week.
- 1:21[Rachel] First, the holiday forecasts are out, and there are a couple of
- 1:24[Rachel] big numbers floating around.
- 1:25[Speaker 3] Mm-hmm, and big numbers always come with fine print.
- 1:29[Speaker 3] I've watched forecasts look great on a slide and then fall apart
- 1:33[Speaker 3] on the warehouse floor.
- 1:35[Rachel] Supply chain bottleneck energy.
- 1:37[Speaker 3] Always.
- 1:38[Speaker 3] Fine print is where the bottleneck lives.
- 1:41[Rachel] Second thing, where is holiday traffic even gonna come from this year?
- 1:45[Rachel] Because the answer might not be where you've been sending your budget.
- 1:48[Speaker 3] Wait, really?
- 1:49[Speaker 3] That sounds like a spreadsheet nobody wants to open.
- 1:52[Rachel] Oh, you'll open it.
- 1:54[Rachel] I promise.
- 1:55[Speaker 3] Fine, but no hand-waving.
- 1:57[Rachel] Deal.
- 1:58[Rachel] So anyway, let's start with the big question.
- 2:01[Rachel] How big is this holiday season gonna be, and how does the
- 2:04[Rachel] new NRF number stack up against the Adobe one you've heard before?
- 2:08[Speaker 3] Yeah.
- 2:08[Speaker 3] Let's see which one holds up.
- 2:15[Rachel] Okay, NRF first.
- 2:16[Rachel] The National Retail Federation says November and December retail sales grow four
- 2:21[Rachel] point two percent this year.
- 2:23[Speaker 3] To what, though?
- 2:24[Speaker 3] Percent is cheap.
- 2:25[Speaker 3] Give me the dollars.
- 2:27[Rachel] About one point zero one three trillion dollars.
- 2:30[Rachel] That's the exact figure.
- 2:32[Speaker 3] Trillion with a T.
- 2:34[Rachel] With a T.
- 2:35[Rachel] And last year, NRF's own numbers had growth at three point one
- 2:38[Rachel] percent, landing at roughly nine hundred and seventy-two billion dollars.
- 2:43[Speaker 3] So the jump is about a full point faster than last year.
- 2:46[Speaker 3] Sounds great, but what's the actual ROI of that headline?
- 2:50[Rachel] There she is.
- 2:51[Speaker 3] I'm serious.
- 2:52[Speaker 3] Inflation eats growth.
- 2:54[Speaker 3] If prices rise, you're not selling more stuff.
- 2:56[Speaker 3] You're selling the same stuff for more.
- 2:59[Rachel] Totally.
- 3:00[Rachel] NRF expects core goods inflation to average two point five percent.
- 3:04[Speaker 3] So roughly half of that four point two is just price tags
- 3:08[Speaker 3] going up.
- 3:09[Rachel] Right.
- 3:09[Rachel] The other half is real spending, real people actually buying more.
- 3:14[Speaker 3] Which is a lot less exciting on a slide.
- 3:16[Rachel] It really is.
- 3:17[Rachel] And the half part is rough math, but the direction holds.
- 3:21[Rachel] Growth that is partly just higher prices doesn't mean more orders landing
- 3:25[Rachel] in your queue.
- 3:26[Speaker 3] Right, and that's the trap.
- 3:28[Speaker 3] A merchant sees four point two in a headline, bumps the inventory
- 3:31[Speaker 3] order by four point two, and then wonders why the warehouse is
- 3:35[Speaker 3] full in January.
- 3:37[Rachel] The January pallet problem.
- 3:39[Speaker 3] It's always January.
- 3:41[Speaker 3] Then comes the clearance sale nobody planned.
- 3:43[Rachel] Wait, there's another number in there that matters more for us.
- 3:46[Rachel] NRF ran a survey in October.
- 3:49[Speaker 3] Uh-oh, I can feel a margin problem coming.
- 3:52[Rachel] Sixty-four percent of consumers said they'd likely wait for Thanksgiving weekend sales
- 3:57[Rachel] to do most of their shopping.
- 3:59[Speaker 3] Sixty-four, almost two out of three.
- 4:01[Rachel] Yep.
- 4:02[Speaker 3] Okay, that's a supply chain problem wearing a gift bag.
- 4:05[Speaker 3] Everybody shows up the same four days, and your inventory, your ad
- 4:09[Speaker 3] costs, your support queue, all of it spikes at once.
- 4:12[Rachel] And discounts get deeper because everybody's waiting for them.
- 4:16[Rachel] You know what I mean?
- 4:17[Speaker 3] I've lived this.
- 4:18[Speaker 3] At Amazon, we planned around those days like a military operation, and
- 4:22[Speaker 3] the shoppers who waited were never the full price ones.
- 4:26[Rachel] Never.
- 4:27[Rachel] Funny, I watched a client try to dodge that crush once.
- 4:30[Rachel] They pushed a promo out early because they wanted to get ahead
- 4:32[Rachel] of the holiday.
- 4:33[Rachel] The dashboard looked fantastic for a few days.
- 4:36[Rachel] Then it went flat, and the big spike showed up right when
- 4:39[Rachel] everybody else's sales started anyway.
- 4:42[Speaker 3] So the early push just-
- 4:44[Rachel] Moved the demand earlier, and it cost them margin.
- 4:47[Rachel] I remember telling them we threw a party and only invited people
- 4:50[Rachel] who were already coming.
- 4:51[Speaker 3] And the snacks were discounted.
- 4:54[Rachel] Deeply discounted.
- 4:55[Rachel] Okay, that's my story.
- 4:57[Speaker 3] Now, where does the Adobe number fit?
- 4:59[Speaker 3] Remind me because that's online only.
- 5:02[Rachel] Right.
- 5:02[Rachel] Adobe's forecast, published September twenty-eighth, puts US online holiday spending at two
- 5:07[Rachel] hundred and seventy-five point one billion dollars.
- 5:10[Speaker 3] For November first through December thirty-first.
- 5:13[Rachel] Yep, and that's up six point seven percent.
- 5:15[Speaker 3] Hold on.
- 5:16[Speaker 3] Adobe says online grows six point seven.
- 5:20[Speaker 3] NRF says everything grows four point two.
- 5:23[Speaker 3] Those aren't fighting each other?
- 5:25[Rachel] No, they're measuring different things.
- 5:27[Rachel] NRF is the whole retail pie.
- 5:29[Rachel] Adobe is the online slice.
- 5:32[Speaker 3] And the slice is growing faster than the pie.
- 5:34[Rachel] That's the read.
- 5:36[Rachel] Online takes a bigger share even in a decent year.
- 5:39[Speaker 3] Which matters if you're an online-only store.
- 5:42[Speaker 3] The bigger number says the whole market is moving carefully, and the
- 5:45[Speaker 3] Adobe number says your channel is where the faster growth is forecast.
- 5:49[Rachel] Right.
- 5:50[Rachel] But if you also have physical stores or you sell through a
- 5:53[Rachel] marketplace, the bigger number is more your world, and you'd wanna watch
- 5:56[Rachel] both.
- 5:57[Speaker 3] Fair, but I wanna know how much to trust the pie.
- 6:01[Speaker 3] Has NRF been right before?
- 6:03[Rachel] Um, so Retail Dive flagged this.
- 6:06[Rachel] NRF's forecast last year was a range, three point seven to four
- 6:09[Rachel] point two percent.
- 6:11[Speaker 3] And the actual?
- 6:12[Rachel] Actual was three point one.
- 6:15[Speaker 3] So below the bottom of their own range.
- 6:18[Rachel] Right?
- 6:19[Rachel] That's wild.
- 6:19[Rachel] They missed low end by a good chunk.
- 6:22[Speaker 3] And this year's headline number is four point two, which was the
- 6:26[Speaker 3] top of last year's range.
- 6:28[Rachel] Oh, nice catch.
- 6:29[Rachel] So the same number that overshot last year is the headline again.
- 6:33[Speaker 3] I'm not saying it's wrong.
- 6:34[Speaker 3] I'm saying if I'm building a staffing and inventory plan, I'm not
- 6:38[Speaker 3] betting the whole budget on four point two.
- 6:41[Rachel] Same.
- 6:42[Rachel] I'd plan for the middle and keep a little cash flexible for
- 6:44[Rachel] the weekend rush.
- 6:46[Speaker 3] That's a plan I can sign off on.
- 6:47[Rachel] And that's the thing about a forecast.
- 6:49[Rachel] It's a planning input, not a promise.
- 6:52[Rachel] You wouldn't build a bridge off one engineer's back of the envelope
- 6:54[Rachel] number.
- 6:55[Speaker 3] And you'd want a plan B for each outcome.
- 6:57[Speaker 3] If the number comes in light, what do you cut first?
- 7:00[Speaker 3] If it comes in hot, can your fulfillment team actually handle it?
- 7:03[Rachel] Ha.
- 7:04[Rachel] The honest answer to the second one is usually, "We'll figure it
- 7:07[Rachel] out."
- 7:07[Speaker 3] That is not a plan.
- 7:09[Speaker 3] That is a prayer with a calendar invite.
- 7:11[Rachel] Fair.
- 7:12[Rachel] So write down the trigger now.
- 7:14[Rachel] If the first big weekend lands light, here's what we cut.
- 7:17[Rachel] If it lands hot, here's who we call.
- 7:19[Speaker 3] Decisions made when you're calm are cheaper than decisions made at midnight
- 7:22[Speaker 3] on a sales day.
- 7:24[Speaker 3] Write the plan when nobody's panicking, and your future self will send
- 7:27[Speaker 3] a thank you note.
- 7:28[Rachel] Okay.
- 7:28[Rachel] Now let's go see where those shoppers are actually coming from.
- 7:36[Rachel] Okay.
- 7:37[Rachel] Here's a number that made me spit out my coffee.
- 7:39[Speaker 3] Go on.
- 7:40[Rachel] A writeup on a site called A Relevant Audience relaying Adobe's forecast
- 7:44[Rachel] says AI-referred traffic to retail sites is projected up a hundred and
- 7:49[Rachel] thirty percent.
- 7:50[Speaker 3] Wait, a hundred and thirty?
- 7:52[Rachel] One-three-zero.
- 7:54[Rachel] And the same writeup says social and affiliates are gaining share against
- 7:57[Rachel] paid search.
- 7:58[Speaker 3] Hmm, paid search losing ground.
- 8:01[Speaker 3] That's going to make a few media buyers sweat.
- 8:04[Rachel] Think of it like a mixing board.
- 8:05[Rachel] Nobody's saying paid search goes silent, but a few other channels get
- 8:09[Rachel] louder.
- 8:10[Speaker 3] Right.
- 8:10[Speaker 3] And gaining share is relative.
- 8:12[Speaker 3] It can mean someone else is shrinking, or it can mean everything
- 8:15[Speaker 3] is growing and some things grow faster.
- 8:18[Speaker 3] The writeup doesn't tell us which, and I'm not going to guess.
- 8:21[Rachel] Totally.
- 8:22[Rachel] Also, quick flag, this is a secondary writeup of Adobe's numbers.
- 8:25[Rachel] Adobe's own release is the primary source.
- 8:28[Speaker 3] Good, because a percent growth with no base is a magic trick.
- 8:32[Speaker 3] Up a hundred and thirty from what?
- 8:35[Rachel] Yeah.
- 8:35[Rachel] I can't tell you the base.
- 8:37[Rachel] The writeup gives the growth, and that's what I've got.
- 8:39[Speaker 3] Right.
- 8:39[Speaker 3] So a big jump off a small number could still be a
- 8:42[Speaker 3] small number.
- 8:43[Rachel] Could be.
- 8:44[Rachel] Doesn't make the direction less interesting, though.
- 8:46[Speaker 3] Interesting, sure.
- 8:48[Speaker 3] Let me ask the practical thing.
- 8:50[Speaker 3] If social and affiliates are gaining on paid search, what does a
- 8:53[Speaker 3] merchant actually do with that?
- 8:55[Rachel] Honestly, the writeup gives us a direction, not a playbook.
- 8:59[Rachel] But it's a reason to look at your own channel mix before
- 9:01[Rachel] the season starts, not in the middle of the rush.
- 9:04[Speaker 3] Sure.
- 9:04[Speaker 3] But what's the actual ROI?
- 9:06[Speaker 3] More AI referrals only matter if those people buy.
- 9:09[Rachel] Okay.
- 9:10[Rachel] Fair.
- 9:11[Speaker 3] I'm serious.
- 9:12[Speaker 3] At Amazon, we'd watch a traffic source spike, and everyone would cheer.
- 9:16[Speaker 3] Then you'd look at conversion, and it was people browsing with no
- 9:19[Speaker 3] intent.
- 9:20[Speaker 3] Great for a dashboard, useless for the P&L.
- 9:23[Rachel] The vanity metric parade.
- 9:25[Speaker 3] Exactly.
- 9:26[Speaker 3] A visit is not a sale.
- 9:28[Speaker 3] So if AI sends shoppers, do they arrive ready to buy or
- 9:32[Speaker 3] just curious?
- 9:33[Rachel] I don't know, and nothing in front of me says.
- 9:36[Rachel] Here's my take, though.
- 9:37[Rachel] Think about asking a friend where to buy a good blender.
- 9:40[Speaker 3] Uh-oh.
- 9:40[Rachel] Hear me out.
- 9:41[Rachel] If they say, "Go to that shop," you walk in already half
- 9:45[Rachel] sold, or they point you at the wrong store and you leave
- 9:47[Rachel] annoyed.
- 9:48[Rachel] Same recommendation, wildly different outcome.
- 9:51[Speaker 3] So the quality of the recommendation matters more than the count of
- 9:54[Speaker 3] recommendations.
- 9:56[Rachel] Funny, I lived a version of that as an analyst.
- 9:58[Rachel] A client got a big wave of visitors from one link on
- 10:01[Rachel] a popular roundup page, and everybody high-fived.
- 10:04[Rachel] Then I looked at what those people did.
- 10:06[Rachel] Most of them landed on a page, read it, and left because
- 10:09[Rachel] the page they were sent to wasn't what the link had promised.
- 10:13[Speaker 3] So the recommendation was wrong?
- 10:14[Rachel] The recommendation was fine.
- 10:16[Rachel] The landing page was the one that lied.
- 10:18[Rachel] We spent a week celebrating a traffic spike that was basically a
- 10:21[Rachel] very large group of people knocking on the wrong door.
- 10:24[Speaker 3] So the visits counted and the sales didn't.
- 10:27[Speaker 3] Wrong door, big crowd.
- 10:29[Rachel] Yeah.
- 10:30[Rachel] And that's where a sponsored piece on Retail Dive comes in.
- 10:33[Rachel] It's from Glance, published November second, and it's labeled sponsored, so keep
- 10:37[Rachel] that in mind.
- 10:38[Speaker 3] Noted.
- 10:39[Speaker 3] Ad with a byline.
- 10:41[Rachel] Basically.
- 10:42[Rachel] Its argument is that your catalog may already be visible to AI
- 10:45[Rachel] agents.
- 10:46[Speaker 3] Already?
- 10:47[Speaker 3] Without anyone doing anything?
- 10:49[Rachel] That's the pitch.
- 10:50[Rachel] And the next step, it says, is making that catalog trustworthy.
- 10:54[Speaker 3] Trustworthy how?
- 10:56[Speaker 3] Accurate prices, stock, product data?
- 10:59[Rachel] The headline is all I'd lean on.
- 11:01[Rachel] The writeup promises three barriers to what it calls agentic optimization, but
- 11:05[Rachel] I'm not gonna guess what they are.
- 11:07[Speaker 3] Fine.
- 11:07[Speaker 3] But think about it logically.
- 11:09[Speaker 3] If an AI agent recommends your product and the price is stale
- 11:12[Speaker 3] or it's out of stock, you paid for nothing.
- 11:15[Speaker 3] That's a supply chain problem showing up in a chatbot.
- 11:18[Rachel] Ooh, that's good.
- 11:20[Rachel] The shelf has to match the sign.
- 11:22[Speaker 3] And it ties back to the forecasts.
- 11:24[Speaker 3] Shoppers are cautious.
- 11:25[Speaker 3] A lot of them are waiting for deals, and they're comparison shopping.
- 11:28[Rachel] So a wrong answer from an AI costs you the sale to
- 11:32[Rachel] whoever has the right one.
- 11:33[Speaker 3] Right.
- 11:34[Speaker 3] In a cautious season, you don't get many second chances.
- 11:37[Rachel] Let me play that out for a small store.
- 11:39[Rachel] Say you change a price on your site, but the product feed
- 11:42[Rachel] that goes elsewhere updates later.
- 11:44[Rachel] Now a shopper or an agent shopping for them sees one price
- 11:48[Rachel] and meets another.
- 11:49[Speaker 3] And the shopper doesn't blame the feed, they blame you.
- 11:52[Speaker 3] That's trust, and trust is hard to win back when everyone has
- 11:56[Speaker 3] a dozen tabs open.
- 11:57[Rachel] Which is why I keep coming back to the unglamorous side of
- 12:00[Rachel] this.
- 12:01[Rachel] Somebody has to own the product data.
- 12:03[Speaker 3] And that somebody needs a name next to the task, not a
- 12:06[Speaker 3] committee.
- 12:07[Rachel] And a schedule.
- 12:08[Rachel] Like, who checks the feed against the site before the Thanksgiving weekend
- 12:12[Rachel] rush?
- 12:13[Speaker 3] Right?
- 12:13[Speaker 3] And who checks it again after the first wave of price changes?
- 12:17[Speaker 3] Ownership is not a one-time job.
- 12:19[Speaker 3] It's a checklist with a name on it.
- 12:21[Rachel] So wait, so does that mean the boring stuff like clean product
- 12:25[Rachel] data is suddenly the growth strategy?
- 12:27[Speaker 3] I'd bet on boring over clever.
- 12:29[Speaker 3] Yes, every time.
- 12:31[Rachel] Speaking of getting found by AI, here's what Google's John Mueller had
- 12:35[Rachel] to say about it.
- 12:36[Speaker 3] Oh, this is gonna be good.
- 12:37[Speaker 3] Go.
- 12:42[Rachel] Okay, so Mueller, Google's John Mueller, the search guy who answers everyone's
- 12:48[Rachel] search engine optimization questions with the energy of a man who has
- 12:51[Rachel] answered them before.
- 12:54[Speaker 3] Many times.
- 12:55[Rachel] Search Engine Journal ran a piece on November 2nd, written by Roger
- 12:59[Rachel] Montti.
- 13:00[Rachel] The gist is that Mueller doubts the short-term AI SEO tactics and
- 13:05[Rachel] says traditional technical SEO still matters.
- 13:08[Speaker 3] Wait, so the boring stuff survives?
- 13:11[Rachel] That's the pitch.
- 13:12[Rachel] After all that agent talk, it's a little funny.
- 13:15[Speaker 3] Is it funny or is it predictable?
- 13:18[Speaker 3] Every time a new channel shows up, somebody declares the old rule's
- 13:21[Speaker 3] dead.
- 13:22[Rachel] Both.
- 13:23[Rachel] The way it's framed, the doubt is aimed at the short-term tactics,
- 13:27[Rachel] and the technical basics are still on the table.
- 13:29[Speaker 3] But what counts as a short-term tactic?
- 13:33[Speaker 3] Because every agency I've dealt with has a shiny new one.
- 13:36[Rachel] Right, and that's where the second source comes in.
- 13:39[Rachel] Search Engine Roundtable covered an interview with Mueller by David Iwanow.
- 13:43[Speaker 3] Okay.
- 13:45[Rachel] Mueller says leaning on mass-produced listicles or AI-generated content to rank an
- 13:50[Rachel] AI search is risky.
- 13:52[Rachel] The reason is that search systems eventually discount spam tactics.
- 13:57[Speaker 3] Eventually.
- 13:59[Speaker 3] That word is doing a lot of work.
- 14:01[Rachel] It is.
- 14:02[Rachel] It means you can get a bump first, then the systems catch
- 14:06[Rachel] up.
- 14:06[Speaker 3] And I've seen that movie.
- 14:08[Speaker 3] Years ago at Amazon, a vendor stuffed thousands of near-identical listings into
- 14:13[Speaker 3] the catalog.
- 14:14[Speaker 3] Looked great for a quarter, then they were all buried, and the
- 14:17[Speaker 3] cleanup cost more than the lift.
- 14:20[Rachel] Ouch.
- 14:20[Rachel] So the ROI on spam is borrowed time.
- 14:24[Speaker 3] Borrowed time with interest, and someone still has to pay the content
- 14:28[Speaker 3] team.
- 14:30[Rachel] Always the content team.
- 14:31[Rachel] I saw a shortcut look like it worked once on the analyst
- 14:34[Rachel] side.
- 14:35[Rachel] A client had a page that suddenly climbed after a round of
- 14:38[Rachel] content tweaks, and the whole team treated it like a victory parade.
- 14:42[Rachel] A few weeks later, it slid right back, and I was the
- 14:45[Rachel] guy holding the chart explaining why the line looked like a ski
- 14:48[Rachel] slope.
- 14:49[Speaker 3] A ski slope.
- 14:51[Rachel] Up the lift, down the mountain.
- 14:53[Rachel] Fun ride.
- 14:54[Rachel] Terrible for the quarterly slide.
- 14:56[Speaker 3] Mm.
- 14:57[Speaker 3] But here's my question.
- 14:59[Speaker 3] If a chatbot is reading my pages, why does technical SEO still
- 15:03[Speaker 3] matter?
- 15:04[Speaker 3] Isn't it all just text?
- 15:06[Rachel] Mueller expects technical SEO to stay relevant.
- 15:09[Rachel] Those are the write-up's words, and I'm not going to invent his
- 15:12[Rachel] reasoning beyond that.
- 15:14[Speaker 3] Fair.
- 15:14[Speaker 3] Don't put words in the man's mouth.
- 15:16[Rachel] Totally.
- 15:17[Rachel] But the interview also touched on two things merchants live with.
- 15:20[Rachel] One is e-commerce product data.
- 15:23[Speaker 3] Ooh, that's my love language.
- 15:24[Rachel] Of course it is.
- 15:25[Rachel] The other is redirect chains.
- 15:28[Speaker 3] Redirect chains, the thing nobody wants to own.
- 15:31[Rachel] Right?
- 15:32[Rachel] You relaunch a site, you move some URLs, and then there's a
- 15:35[Rachel] hop, and another hop, and another hop.
- 15:37[Speaker 3] And every hop is a place where something can go wrong.
- 15:41[Speaker 3] I'd call that a plain old maintenance problem.
- 15:43[Rachel] And the thing is, it's invisible until it isn't.
- 15:46[Rachel] Nobody sees a redirect chain on a normal day.
- 15:49[Rachel] You find it when someone asks why an old link takes forever
- 15:52[Rachel] or lands in the wrong place.
- 15:54[Rachel] To be clear, the interview only touched on them, and I'm not
- 15:56[Rachel] claiming more than that.
- 15:58[Speaker 3] I'd frame it as an audit task.
- 16:00[Speaker 3] Pick your most important URLs, follow each one from the old address
- 16:04[Speaker 3] to the final one, and count the hops.
- 16:06[Speaker 3] It's an afternoon of work, and nobody is going to give you
- 16:09[Speaker 3] a trophy.
- 16:10[Rachel] Which is kind of the point.
- 16:11[Rachel] Product data and clean redirects aren't exciting.
- 16:14[Rachel] Nobody posts a victory lap about fixing a redirect.
- 16:17[Speaker 3] Nobody posts it, but I'd be curious what it does to conversion.
- 16:21[Rachel] Yeah, and neither write-up gives us a number on that, so we
- 16:24[Rachel] don't get to claim one.
- 16:25[Speaker 3] Good.
- 16:26[Speaker 3] I'd rather have no number than a made-up one.
- 16:28[Rachel] Same.
- 16:29[Rachel] What we do have is a direction.
- 16:31[Rachel] Don't build your plan on a trick that the systems are expected
- 16:34[Rachel] to discount, but you can fix what's broken on your own site.
- 16:37[Speaker 3] Right.
- 16:38[Speaker 3] A fix is something you can finish and check off.
- 16:41[Speaker 3] A trick is something you have to keep feeding.
- 16:43[Rachel] Which for most stores is a to-do list that's already sitting there.
- 16:47[Speaker 3] Ugh, mine has been sitting there since spring.
- 16:50[Rachel] Mine's got cobwebs.
- 16:52[Rachel] Okay, now the fun part, early deals.
- 16:54[Rachel] Merchants, this is where it gets real for your margins.
- 16:57[Speaker 3] Fine, show me the discounts, and then I'll ask what they cost.
- 17:06[Rachel] Okay, so I went looking for early Black Friday deals, and they're
- 17:09[Rachel] already here.
- 17:11[Rachel] It's November 2nd.
- 17:12[Speaker 3] Of course they are.
- 17:13[Speaker 3] Of course.
- 17:14[Rachel] Mashable ran a piece with the headline that the M5 MacBook Air
- 17:18[Rachel] is two hundred dollars off at Amazon, but there's a catch.
- 17:21[Speaker 3] There's always a catch.
- 17:23[Speaker 3] What's the catch?
- 17:24[Rachel] Honestly, the write-up teases it in the headline, and the excerpt I
- 17:27[Rachel] have just says Apple Intelligence is here, and you don't have to
- 17:30[Rachel] pay full retail to get in, so I'm not going to invent
- 17:33[Rachel] the catch for you.
- 17:34[Speaker 3] Fair.
- 17:35[Speaker 3] Saying a number I can't verify is worse than saying nothing.
- 17:39[Rachel] Totally.
- 17:40[Rachel] Second one, also Mashable, same writer.
- 17:42[Rachel] The Dreame L40 Ultra Gen 2 robot vacuum is two hundred and
- 17:46[Rachel] fifty dollars off.
- 17:47[Speaker 3] Is that the one that cleans its own mops?
- 17:49[Rachel] Yes.
- 17:50[Rachel] Reaches in corners, doesn't complain about pet hair.
- 17:53[Rachel] Better employee than most of us.
- 17:55[Speaker 3] Speak for yourself.
- 17:56[Speaker 3] Okay, but those are both reported as of November second.
- 17:59[Speaker 3] Deals move.
- 18:00[Speaker 3] By the time someone hears this, the price could be gone.
- 18:03[Rachel] Right, so treat them as a signal, not a shopping list.
- 18:06[Speaker 3] That's the right instinct.
- 18:07[Speaker 3] A competitor's price is a data point, not an instruction.
- 18:11[Rachel] Yeah.
- 18:11[Rachel] I watched a client once copy a rival sale banner word for
- 18:15[Rachel] word and then act surprised that their margins look different.
- 18:18[Rachel] Their costs weren't the rival's costs.
- 18:20[Rachel] Same banner, different math.
- 18:22[Speaker 3] And the signal matters for merchants.
- 18:24[Speaker 3] Remember NRF's October survey where sixty-four percent said they'd likely wait for
- 18:29[Speaker 3] Thanksgiving weekend sales?
- 18:30[Rachel] Wait, so people are waiting, and retailers are discounting now.
- 18:34[Speaker 3] Exactly, which makes early discounting a strategy question, not a reflex.
- 18:39[Rachel] Okay, but if the competitor's already at two hundred dollars off and
- 18:42[Rachel] you're not, you look like the expensive one.
- 18:44[Speaker 3] Sure.
- 18:45[Speaker 3] That's the bottleneck.
- 18:46[Speaker 3] Everybody's afraid to be the last one holding a full-price shelf.
- 18:50[Rachel] Full-price shelf.
- 18:52[Rachel] Sounds like a horror movie.
- 18:53[Speaker 3] To a merchant, it is.
- 18:55[Speaker 3] And there's more pressure underneath.
- 18:56[Speaker 3] Retail Dive reported that NRF's chief economist said higher diesel and memory
- 19:01[Speaker 3] prices are pressuring electronics gifting.
- 19:04[Rachel] Memory prices, as in the RAM stuff we've been seeing?
- 19:07[Speaker 3] That's the connection, yeah.
- 19:08[Speaker 3] Electronics are the classic early deal category, and the cost of building
- 19:12[Speaker 3] and shipping them is going up.
- 19:14[Rachel] So wait, deals start early, but costs are climbing.
- 19:17[Speaker 3] Right.
- 19:18[Speaker 3] Margins get squeezed from both ends.
- 19:20[Rachel] That's rough, because a two hundred and fifty dollar off sticker on
- 19:23[Rachel] a robot vacuum looks great to a shopper, but somebody's eating that.
- 19:27[Speaker 3] Somebody always is, and for a smaller merchant without Amazon's scale, eating
- 19:31[Speaker 3] it for a month is a very different thing.
- 19:34[Rachel] No way around it.
- 19:35[Rachel] You've gotta pick your spots: which products, how deep, and how long.
- 19:40[Speaker 3] And how long is the one people skip.
- 19:42[Speaker 3] An early deal with no end date turns into the new normal
- 19:46[Speaker 3] price in the shopper's head.
- 19:47[Rachel] That's the part that scares me.
- 19:49[Rachel] You can run a promotion for a short stretch, but a customer
- 19:51[Rachel] remembers the lowest price they saw, not the date it stopped.
- 19:55[Speaker 3] Before you cut anything, know your cost on that item today, not
- 19:59[Speaker 3] what it was in the spring.
- 20:00[Rachel] Boring advice, but I like it.
- 20:02[Speaker 3] Boring pays the bills.
- 20:03[Rachel] And for electronics specifically, that cost line is the one I'd check
- 20:07[Rachel] twice, since memory prices are named in the pressure.
- 20:09[Speaker 3] Right.
- 20:10[Speaker 3] If the product is electronics and your cost has moved, a deal
- 20:14[Speaker 3] that worked before may not pencil out now.
- 20:17[Speaker 3] Check the math per item, not per category, and write down what
- 20:21[Speaker 3] you'd stop discounting if costs keep climbing so the decision is already
- 20:25[Speaker 3] made.
- 20:31[Rachel] Okay, quick landing.
- 20:32[Rachel] Four stories, one takeaway each.
- 20:34[Rachel] Forecasts first, both come with fine print, so read the footnotes before
- 20:38[Rachel] you plan inventory.
- 20:39[Speaker 3] Shoppers are finding products through AI and social now, not just search
- 20:43[Speaker 3] boxes.
- 20:44[Speaker 3] Your product data has to be clean enough for a machine to
- 20:47[Speaker 3] read.
- 20:47[Rachel] Mueller says shortcuts get discounted eventually.
- 20:50[Rachel] Boring technical work sticks around.
- 20:52[Speaker 3] And the early deals, fun to watch, dangerous to copy.
- 20:56[Rachel] Wait, so what's the homework, Rachel?
- 20:57[Speaker 3] One action.
- 20:58[Speaker 3] Before you match anybody's early discount, pull your landed cost on your
- 21:02[Speaker 3] top ten sellers and write down the lowest price you can run
- 21:06[Speaker 3] without losing money.
- 21:07[Speaker 3] Then ask the question I always ask.
- 21:10[Rachel] What's the actual ROI?
- 21:12[Speaker 3] Thank you.
- 21:13[Speaker 3] Spreadsheet first, sale second.
- 21:16[Rachel] Totally.
- 21:16[Rachel] And if you want more of this, head to blicket.co and subscribe
- 21:20[Rachel] so the next episode just shows up.
- 21:22[Speaker 3] It's free, which is the only discount I fully trust.
- 21:26[Rachel] Nice.
- 21:27[Speaker 3] See you next week.
- 21:28[Rachel] And if your spreadsheet says the sale doesn't pencil out, blame Rachel.