Latest / And Now For Something Completely Machinima / S6 E250 Trench Dogs: Body Horror & War in Blender EEVEE
Transcript
- Phil Rice 01:06 Hello and welcome to and now for something completely machinima, the podcast about machinima virtual production and related technologies. My name is Phil Rice. I'm here with my co-hosts Tracy Harwood and Damian Valentine. Damien Valentine 01:20 Hello. Phil Rice 01:22 So this week we are talking about Tracy's pick, and this brings us to a director whose work we've seen before. In fact, we've seen work in this particular world before. And I don't know about you guys, but I was very excited to to see some more of this world. So Tracy, why don't you tell us about it? Tracy Harwood 01:41 Yeah, sure. This is another Sats short. This one's called Trench Dogs by St Greaver, which was released in late August this year. Now, I wouldn't normally do this. I wouldn't normally bring another film by the same creator to the table for us to talk about so close to the first one that we took a look at, but actually this really stood out for me, and I really wanted to share it with you because it's it's it's disturbing and it's interesting to sort of say the least. Now we reviewed the Ursatz pilot. Well, I think it was March or April this year, and we were we really complimentary, really admired its painterly qualities. It's really strong voice acting and really unsettling, you know, details and exploration of war and dehumanization in that original sort of pilot. At the time, my reservations were that it was its length didn't really cut it for me. I thought the occasional murky imagery, an unresolved story, didn't really work, but I think it established a really distinctive, disturbing world that actually this short, Trench Dogs, really now develops for me. Although what's interesting is that the creator Saint Griever sees this particular short as a side story to the main pilot we first took a look at, so it's a more focused and emotionally accessible look at the world of Earthsat. It's it's I think strongest achievement is to make affection and bodily horror kind of coexist together. These characters care for their animals, their pets, and it you know it becomes sort of touching even as the circumstances of their survival, you know, together and individually remain absolutely appalling. St. Griever's work really brings together the this sort of illustration, biological invention, and a and a fictional military culture is institutions really reshape living bodies. the The creator's background actually is biology, and I think that provides him an interesting context for this attention to anatomy and also the social purposes of what's you know what's being portrayed really, what you can see is the bodies carrying the consequences of war. You've got medical intervention and continued service, where survival clearly becomes increasingly difficult to separate from the dependence on other organisms and systems. In our previous review, we discussed, as I said, this sort of painterly esthetic, this unusual animation style, the. These kind of character performances and this really disturbing treatment of replaceability and violence. We made references to Francis Bacon, Exinsky, Wilfred Owen, all of which I think helped us to kind of situate its really grotesque imagery within this kind of wider discussion of damaged bodies and and the experience of war, what in this what's happening here is that we see these kind of unknown, we see an unknown person or thing conducting interviews with different soldiers who have been spliced with animals so that their stories can be sent back home to loved ones, and we hear the voices of the humans talking about how they've been saved by their pets, and I think that's both emotionally and physically through various kinds of processes, seemingly as a way to kind of save them both, I think, and we see the kind of contrast between illustrated documents and these kind of rendered interviews, which is really quite effective. You've got these kind of this sense sense of anatomical drawings and lettering and all that kind of thing being used to sort of juxtapose what's actually being shown on the screen. And these interviews place these bodies in really dimp, cramped rooms among you know quite grotty furniture, equipment, and all the sort of damage and detritus that you might sort of see of a Of a war-ravaged environment, really, but it's the documents that explain what these beings are and really what the purpose of these interviews are all about. I believe one of the characters called Charlie. You kind of see this illustration as being quite central to what's going on, it gives you a way to understand what the bodily arrangement is all about, and the the dark sort of interview imagery makes it quite hard to decipher. But I think it's pretty disturbing. the The accompanying kind of psychological notes treat this case of Charlie as as a sort of an experiment, really, and it and it notes that his temperament is improved by the intervention that's been made to him as as he's been spliced with this pet. Tracy Harwood 07:37 So what it's implying is a kind of medical reconstruction, but more than the you know the the splicing of these lives, it's the kind of reconstruction that you might see that results in the change of character, maybe to both of them. So, I think a weakness still is that you've got this darkness that remains. It was something I criticized before, but it's still an issue here. It's so dark you can't always make out what it is you're looking at. You've got little points of amber light. You've got these really deep shadows. You've got this, you know, quite atmospheric environment. But the but the faces and bodily details can become quite difficult to distinguish. I think. What's astonishing are this main character's eyes, and also the teeth and the shoulder that catch a bit of the light, so you can kind of make out some of what's going on in in the in the scene, and it kind of creates this sort of uncertainty. But it encourages you to really take a deep look. Don't not that you want to look because it's not very nice to look at. To be honest, I think the drawings help remove a little bit of the horror of it, but I think that lighting is an it's an interest. I'd be really interested to hear what you got got to say about what your thoughts were on the lighting. I mean, for me, I think the the film benefits when you know when dark you know from this sort of darkness when it when it kind of withholds information purposefully, but it loses something when me as a viewer have to have to sort of struggle simply just to read what the character is doing. In terms of the writing, I think the sharpest piece is when the soldier begin begins discussing unsuccessful resurrections and and the redirection towards this poppy, and then you've got this kind of anatomical imagery. It's all very disturbing, I have to say. And what's going on? You know, in the in this character writing. Being videoed to to write home to his mother is is is a equally disturbing kind of look at at you know what on earth could possibly happen should this soldier even manage to get home. I think that's a very Interesting problem that you might sort of see through this really, in terms of pacing performance. I mean, it's there's nice variety in it. There's nice, you know, canine examples, for example. There's a nice people example that give it different character weights. There's quite a lot of characters in it, quite surprisingly. Even though you you very clearly focus on this central individual, I think the interview setup is is an interesting angle on it. I think that that enables you to ask some quite interesting questions about where you stand on what you're seeing as well, and I think some of the tension is tensioned, should I say, is is tensioned by the fact that what you're seeing is the interviewer positioning the interviewee so that you know he overcomes some of the shyness he's he's got about being shown on film to create this video for home. So yeah, it's really morbid, but also unexpectedly affectionate. I think, yeah, I think I think what you're seeing is some very interesting character designs, some very interesting play with our emotions as viewers of of the scene. In terms of the music, I think I'm a little ambivalent about the original music, although I think the sound design is astonishing. Frankly, I can share on the on the show notes who's created that. That in fact, the the original music has been released on an album ahead of this short having been released, which I think is also very interesting. Actually, written for this short. Yeah, I'm not. I'm not sure about the sound. If I'm honest, yeah. So I think overall, I'm kind of critical of it, but I definitely think it adds depth to that original ersatz concept. and I am not convinced that it's a side story. I think it's a really clever story that builds out this world that we've, you know, been shown through this other other short. Tracy Harwood 12:56 And actual fact, I was really quite moved by it, and not not not so much from the splicing of of a human with their pet, but from the the point of view of what that might do to to the person being a pet person, of course. But actually, that so much didn't get to me as what it did to the human. So yeah, I thought it was a fascinating film. Really intrigued to hear what you guys have got to say about it. Damien Valentine 13:32 Well, we're continuing the theme of cheerful and uplifting films this month. Tracy Harwood 13:36 Yeah, indeed. Damien Valentine 13:42 I. I so the film is dark, and I don't just mean the themes, but the the way the scenes are lit. But I think that adds to the atmosphere because if it was all bright and cheerful, it wouldn't really work. Phil Rice 13:55 Yeah, Damien Valentine 13:55 but there's a technical aspect to that as well as that if you're doing something that's fairly tricky, but you light it poorly, I don't mean poorly as in it's badly lit from a film perspective. You can you can still see stuff, but if it looks dark, you can hide things that you don't necessarily. I wondered about that Phil Rice 14:16 too. I wondered about that very thing too. If if some of that choice is a strategic one. I think some of it is stylistic for sure, but yeah, there's there's merit to what you're saying there. Yeah, absolutely. Damien Valentine 14:29 Yeah, it's one of those things where the style is also very helpful from the technical perspective, right? But you can you can do it from the other, obviously not this film, but you can do it the other way, you make something so bright that you can hide it because it's just too bright to see where you don't want things to be seen. This isn't one of those films, but I think it it it needs that darkness for the the you know for the atmosphere of this film, which kind of matches the tone of the. The first one that we looked at a few months ago, it does feel like a side story to me because it doesn't really continue that story, but it takes place in the same world, and it just kind of builds out a little bit, flashes some things out. It. it. I did like the way that you're seeing these characters and they're kind of spliced together with these different, you know, animals, and they're kind of presenting it in a way that that's not anything they're even remotely concerned about. It's just everyone does this, so we're not going to make a big thing about it. It's just kind of presented to the audience as it is. So when they're recording their messages for home, they're not explaining why they look different now. They're just operating on the assumption that everyone's going to know exactly what's happened, so we don't need to even talk about it. And I found that quite an interesting thing because you get left wondering, well, whoever receives this message, what are they actually going to? What's their reaction going to be when they receive it? Of course, you never find out in this film, but that could be another a side story. So the side story is to see what the reaction is when someone gets one of these messages and sees one. Phil Rice 16:23 What does home look like in this world? Yeah, it's a great question. Damien Valentine 16:28 I think that shows that a lot of thought has gone into. So we've seen these two films, and they're kind of focused on this war, and we don't really know a huge amount about what the war is even about. But it still makes you wonder what's like, what's home like? Like you just said, and what else could be there? Which I think shows that you know a lot of attention has been made, a lot of effort has been put into this story and developing it. So, what else can we see? It's kind of like I think we talked before, like in Star Wars, where you have these big scenes, and you're left wondering what's happening around the corner there, and this is one of those these two films, kind of have that same thing of what what's going on in this world that we can't see, and it makes you wonder. And you know, there's a lot of story potential there for for other things, and obviously we're going to get more in this world, so I'm kind of curious what those are going to be, and if is it going to be a continuation of the first film or this one, or is it going to be another thing that you know catches us by surprise? Because when I realized this was in the same stats world, I was expecting more of that, and this took it off in a different direction, which I liked. So you know, but it surprised me. So I'm curious what's going to come next. But yeah, I really liked it as much as you can enjoy a dark and twisted film like this. Speaker 2 17:54 Yeah, Damien Valentine 17:55 it's obviously very well made, and I appreciate that. It's not necessarily a story you watch for fun. It's a story you watch to have your, you know, it's very thought provoking, and I like that too. So it's an excellent pick. Phil Rice 18:15 Yeah, when I when I watched it, I couldn't help but think that like an appropriate riff on this would be a Halloween version of one of Damian's hashtag not my cat posts. No, yeah, it's dark and obscure. I think by design, I think it's primarily a stylistic choice. But like Damian mentioned, there are some some benefits there. To a couple benefits, one is just the the practical benefit of yeah covering over things that would break your immersion because they're not perfect. But the other two is the effect that it had on me, and maybe it does on other viewers too. Is I found myself watching more intently because I couldn't quite see everything, and it for me it didn't it didn't frustrate, and sometimes it can. Like a lot of Hollywood movies nowadays, the trend right now is is dark. The lighting. If you look at any movie made in the last four years compared to you know movies from the 80s or 90s or earlier, just like why don't they do that anymore? These these films were beautiful, you know. So it's a conversation that goes on a lot amongst film enthusiasts right now. Yeah, I was thinking Damien Valentine 19:48 that that nighttime battle scene in Game of Thrones where you can't see anything because they just didn't light it. Yeah, you hear the sound, but you want to see what's happening, Phil Rice 19:58 right? Damien Valentine 19:59 Yeah. Yeah, and yet, Phil Rice 20:01 and yet, there's no doubt that that had a what you could call a positive effect on the tension, because in in the real battle, in a real battle like that, you very often would not see everything you want to see, and so it's scarier, right? And so it had that it was successful in that effect, but there's man, it's a fine line, you know. If if it's a little too dark, then it's like, come on, man, you know, I want to actually see what's happening, but you don't want to see too much. It's it's a really it's it's an interesting dance that's done there. Damien Valentine 20:39 Yeah, Phil Rice 20:39 yeah. The the the the format of this it it opens as a like a PSA public service announcement, but then the format is very much like a modern, very modern interview style. Like this is not how interviews were done. Tracy Harwood 20:57 Yeah, exactly. Phil Rice 20:59 Past the midpoint of last century, it just was not done this way. This is a very modern style, and there's some anachronism to that. But I think that that fits with the world of airsats. I mean, the technology that they're using to recombine themselves wasn't around in World War One either. So the whole world of Airsats is is built on on anachronisms, and I think I think to delightful effect for the most part. So it didn't I didn't really get hung up on the fact that well this is World War One ish, but this isn't what an interview would look like then. I don't know. I noticed it because probably mainly because I'm a student of film and look at that stuff, but it didn't bug me. It didn't make me think, "Gee, what are they doing?" It was an interesting way to give a different window into the world that we saw in the first film. There's a lot less going on here narratively, at least in terms of like linear narrative, even in the first, even though the first film was admittedly it was there were deliberate holes in that to where you you never really felt like you got the full story, but there was progression. You know, there was there was an arc to it to a degree, and with this one, that wasn't the emphasis at all. But that's true to the form. You know that that makes sense, and it and it gave us a lot of insight into that world without trying to continue or fork off of that main narrative. This is this really is a sideshow, a side story, but it's not one that's detached from that world, it it's clearly part of that world. So I think it's okay. I think it its purpose definitely is world building. That's that's it. It is it. I think it accomplished what it set out to do, which is to broaden our understanding of the world that we've been experiencing that story in, and provides a lot of valuable insight. I think to that, I had a very different take on the purpose of this this film, and I don't mean the purpose of the filmmakers, but I mean projecting ourselves into the world. You talked about Tracy that there's some unseen person doing these interviews. So you figure there's some in the world of Airsats. There's an organization or some group that's been assigned the task of making this film, and that's the purpose that I'm talking about here. And I think it was not at all about. You made mention of this sense of were these procedures done to to save them Speaker 3 23:55 both Phil Rice 23:56 was the phrase that you used. Tracy Harwood 23:57 Yes, Phil Rice 23:58 I don't. I don't think that is the case at all. Tracy Harwood 24:01 Oh, okay. I Phil Rice 24:02 think the right verb would be exploit them both. I think this. I saw this, took this in as this is a piece of propaganda presenting horror as it's okay, And recycling these humans and animals for that purpose that they are it's purely exploitation. It's not about saving lives. They don't care about saving lives in this world. They care about the recycled parts, right? So this is a propaganda piece. It is intended for the home audience, but it's not a true representation of the purposes behind these. What do we call them? Surgeries. That's the way that I took it. I don't think there's anything humane, even remotely, about what they've done here, and I think they know that. Soldiers don't. I think the soldiers have been roped into this and and have been told a story of this is why we're doing this and this will help you know your mom or your brother or whoever back home. And okay, it is meant to put at home at ease, but I think it's to try and sugarcoat the absolute horror of not just the war, but of what they're doing to fight this war. I think if if it was presented as it is, no home supporters would support it. Right? It's so awful, and I think that there's really a really interesting messaging there, in terms of how we tell ourselves stories about the wars that our boys are sent off to, you know, and the way that it's painted to make it seem like well, it can happen both ways, right? It can happen where it's painted to where you know we're the heroes, we're the good guys, and and everything's going right, very Orwellian. Or if the media maybe isn't so much in alignment with the politicians, then you get something like the way the Vietnam War was treated in the U.S., where they were actually working against it to make it look worse Speaker 3 26:22 than an Phil Rice 26:23 already awful thing, right? So it's either way, those are propagandistic initiatives going on. I think that's what I think that's what this is intended to to be. It's kind of subtle. Tracy Harwood 26:37 Yeah, yeah. Phil Rice 26:38 I think I really think that that's what this is. And to answer the question that you raised, that both of you kind of raised in your own way about, you know, what happens when they go home, I think the answer to that is very easy. They're not going home, Tracy Harwood 26:54 indeed. Phil Rice 26:55 And all the filmmakers in the film, right? That whoever's producing this in the world of ersatz, they know that these soldiers are never going home. They will never have to worry about what what what that is going to be. These guys are not going to make it home. They're just collections, parts. They're going to get blown apart again, and reconstituted, and nothing's going home. I think that's that's what ersatz is mainly about. Is that these guys are in a meat grinder. The the animals are caught up in it too, and they're they're. It's not even about sending anyone home anymore. It's very dark. Like it's Speaker 4 27:37 well darker than the lighting in Phil Rice 27:39 the film. But that's really how it struck me is, and and I think the only reason that that doesn't just, you know, make me grab a a trash bin and hurl into it is because I think that there's something being said about war here that is important to be said. You know, I think it's an unflinchingly. It's weird because there's there's a lot of irony in the way this is presented, a lot of very dark satire. But ultimately, what is being said about war is the things we started to notice after watching the first film, right? Yeah, that this this is capturing a reality of war stylistically presented in this fictional you know world, but it's it's talking about the real nature of modern war in particular, Where bodies are just parts, you know, and it's a machine, and it's feeding itself to a degree, you know, and it just, yeah, there's nothing good that comes out of it. There is no winner. It, Damien, you brought up. We're not sure who this war is against. We probably will never be told that it doesn't matter. Damien Valentine 29:02 Yeah, like Phil Rice 29:03 it. And this is again, I'm I'm leaning again on Orwell, but in in 1984 by Orwell, the Winston, the main character, comments on the fact that they keep changing who it is that they're at war with, and they'll go and rewrite history to make it that oh we've always been at war with East Asia, but then it'll it's because it doesn't really matter, and no one's even really sure if the war is actually happening. Like it, it's war somewhere is happening, but it it's not to achieve a victory. It's not to change borders. It's not to change the world at all. Really, it has become this machine that is fed, and it it suits a purpose for keeping the populace under control, and probably for feeding some kind of what's the term military-industrial complex, right? People making money off of that death, and in the world of Orwell, they've figured out a way to control that and confine it to a certain geographical region that is inconsequential, and it just keeps going. And all the nations of the world, the big nations of the world in that world, they're all part of it, they're all doing the same thing. At least that's what what Winston. I think he ends up reading a book by a supposed revolutionary. Sorry if you haven't read 1984. I don't want to be a spoiler, but I read it Tracy Harwood 30:35 a long time ago. It's a Phil Rice 30:37 mind changing book. It's really really fantastic. Tracy Harwood 30:39 Yeah. Anyway, Phil Rice 30:41 so yeah, I get a lot of vibes of that from from this portrayal of war. That it's yeah, it's not about who it is. It's against. It's not about a victory. That it will never end. Speaker 5 30:53 Yeah, Phil Rice 30:54 that's the message of this. That there's no end. Damien Valentine 30:58 You just gave me a much darker thought about that as well, because when I was talking about it, I said this is these are messages for the the soldiers sending back to the people at home. What if that that's what the soldiers believe, but those people back home are never going to see this either? So the film crew is there that they're telling the soldiers this to boost their morale, but the only people at home who are going to watch this are probably the generals that sent them in the first place, or maybe whoever's Phil Rice 31:27 that very well could be. Yeah, I would think that the it would have the maximum utility for the military, because because one of the one of the realities of modern war is if you lose support from back home, then you know it. It's gonna hurt the war effort because ultimately they're sending you what you need for that war, right? So my assumption was that it's dual purpose. That that, but it very well could be that it's all a facade, yeah, and that that these the the word of these things, or maybe this is all just about placating these reconstituted soldiers into a sense of ease about this Frankenstein-like horror that they're being put through. It could be just that, and it would still work. Yeah, yeah. Anyway, and mother is Tracy Harwood 32:23 a euphemism for the supreme commander or something, Phil Rice 32:29 right? No, Damien Valentine 32:29 the soldiers actually believe these messages are going to go back to their loved Phil Rice 32:32 ones. Oh, they do. Sure, you can tell. You can tell by the way. That's lovely. Damien Valentine 32:36 Yeah, but those loved ones aren't never going to see these messages. So it'll be the generals who will watch it, maybe to try and make themselves feel better about what they're doing if they even care. But that's probably the extent of whoever sees it. Phil Rice 32:51 Could be. Could be. There'll be Damien Valentine 32:52 some highly edited version that the loved ones get where the soldiers still look like themselves or something. Right, right, Phil Rice 33:02 yeah. Either way, yeah. There's there's massive deception going on here. Was was what I got out of it, and the fact that that's so layered, right? It's not the, it's not Saint Griever deceiving Speaker 3 33:15 us. It's he Phil Rice 33:16 has constructed this world where that's a filmmaker within a film is always fascinating to me. Much, much. I always enjoy films where an actor is playing an actor and acting. I love that. It's just, it's, it's really cool to see the actors who can can pull that off. So, yeah, this is that type of thing. So, yeah, I, I feel the same way. I I love it, but not not because I enjoy it. Right? It's it's horrible. Tracy Harwood 33:45 It took me, but Phil Rice 33:47 it's amazing work, amazing craft. It Tracy Harwood 33:49 is amazing craft. Blend it's Blender Evie again. By the way, I didn't say that. It took me several weeks to actually watch it. I I picked it and then thought, I'm not sure I can watch Phil Rice 34:02 it. Tracy Harwood 34:03 And then when I did, I was, I I had a slightly different reaction to the one that I actually thought I was going to have. So Damien Valentine 34:10 sure, Tracy Harwood 34:10 it's yeah, really interesting though that that even was the case. Yeah, Phil Rice 34:18 supposedly there's another short that he's got in production. It says it's titled Canary, and that's Tracy Harwood 34:25 oh that I did see that. I can't imagine. You've already seen Phil Rice 34:28 that one. Okay, so no, no, no. Tracy Harwood 34:30 I haven't seen it. You saw that he mentioned Phil Rice 34:31 it. Yeah. Tracy Harwood 34:32 Yes. Yes. So we've got which doesn't Phil Rice 34:35 sound like another public service announcement. So I'm not sure what that's going to be. It could be that these supporting stories we can call them instead of side stories, right? That that maybe he's experimenting with some different film mediums to again just to give different lenses into this world. Yeah, yeah. Tracy Harwood 34:56 So this could be the the equivalent of both. Bird song, Speaker 3 35:01 right Tracy Harwood 35:02 in the in the tunnels or something. Damien Valentine 35:05 Yeah, you know they used to take a canary, and if the canary dies, canary in Phil Rice 35:08 a coal mine. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Damien Valentine 35:10 It's got to be something like that. Where Phil Rice 35:12 that's got to be, yeah, right. That is that's got to be the metaphor there for sure. Damien Valentine 35:15 But it probably won't be an actual canary in the story. It'll be some human or some spicy, probably. Yeah, acts like the canary. We'll find out. Tracy Harwood 35:25 Hashtag not my bird. Discussing that, yeah, indeed. Unless he's gonna, you know, sit there with feathers on. I can't see it myself. Yeah. Phil Rice 35:37 Who knows? Speaker 3 35:38 Well, Phil Rice 35:38 audience, what did you think of this. This is a little bit late for Halloween, but it fits the Halloween vibe for sure. We'd love to hear what you think. Drop us a comment wherever you watch or listen to this, or drop us an email talk@completelymichinima.com. My name is Phil Rice. On behalf of my co-hosts Damian Valentine and Tracy Harwood, we will see you next time. Tracy Harwood 36:02 Bye bye.