Latest / The MaineHealth Podcast / WTKE: When Quality Becomes Everyone's Job -- A 5-Star Journey
Transcript
- 0:09Hello and welcome to Working Together with Kelly Elkins. I'm your host,
- 0:12Kelly Elkins, your Chief Operating Officer for MaineHealth.
- 0:15In this podcast series, I will be joined each episode by guests who are participating
- 0:20on teams focused on how we can support and enhance how we work together across
- 0:25MaineHealth so that we can achieve our vision of working together so that our
- 0:29communities are the healthiest in America.
- 0:31In particular, we will highlight work we are doing and further development of
- 0:35our operating model for MaineHealth and how we are creating structure and processes
- 0:39that make it easier for you to do your work.
- 0:42Today's episode is titled, When Quality Becomes Everyone's Job, A Five-Star Journey.
- 0:48In today's episode, we're diving into what it really takes to achieve and sustain
- 0:53CMS five-star performance, not as a one-time win, but as a system-wide way of operating.
- 1:00We'll explore how we at MaineHealth are approaching this goal and making quality
- 1:04and patient safety and experience everyone's work, not just a report card.
- 1:10To join me in the conversation today are my guests, Dr.
- 1:13Omar Hasan, Chief Quality Officer for MaineHealth, and Helen Troy,
- 1:17Vice President, Quality and Safety for MaineHealth. Welcome to the podcast!
- 1:21Thank you, Kelly. Thank you. Glad to be here. So excited to have this conversation today.
- 1:26And, you know, as always, I think we like to start with the why.
- 1:30And then, Omar, I thought Maybe I'd start with you to talk to us a little bit
- 1:34about why did we at Maine Health make achieving CMS four stars or higher across
- 1:41all of our care delivery areas a strategic focus in our most recent strategic focus?
- 1:47Kelly, that's a great question. I think it boils down to our vision of working
- 1:51together so our communities are the healthiest in America.
- 1:54I think the star ratings are the most visible and publicly available way in
- 1:59which our patients and our communities can gauge how good or how bad we are
- 2:03and whether or not we are living up to our ideal, to our vision.
- 2:07So I think it's not really strategic calculation. It's a values and vision alignment.
- 2:14Think of it this way. If you're doing right by our patients,
- 2:17then the ratings should reflect that.
- 2:19All this being said, I would not be honest if I didn't mention that these ratings
- 2:24are also looked at by patients, by their families, in deciding where to go for care.
- 2:30Our insurance companies, the peers of healthcare services, the employers,
- 2:34pay attention to them as well.
- 2:36And lastly, our physician and nurse colleagues, referring physicians,
- 2:39would look to them. So striving for four stars or better is not just good stewardship,
- 2:44it's alignment with our mission and our community's trust. Yeah, no, very well put.
- 2:50So Omar, let's dive maybe to the next level and maybe just a little deeper.
- 2:56When we think about why should our patients and communities care about CMS five
- 3:02stars, what exactly are we measuring that would be meaningful for our patients
- 3:07and communities to know?
- 3:08That's a great question, and I think it's an important one, too.
- 3:12CMS, which, as you know, stands for the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services,
- 3:17has a rating system that is based on five buckets.
- 3:21How often patients will survive a serious medical condition like a heart attack
- 3:25or a stroke after coming to our hospital?
- 3:28How often patients will come back to the hospital after they have been discharged
- 3:33to home after an inpatient stay?
- 3:36There are measures on the safety of care received in the hospital,
- 3:40things like a healthcare associated infection or complications from surgery.
- 3:44And there are also measures of the timeliness and effectiveness of care,
- 3:49such as the time patients spent in an emergency department before being sent
- 3:53back home after receiving the care that they need, or how quickly we can turn
- 3:57around imaging results when somebody has a suspected stroke.
- 4:01And then finally, patient experience is a part of the measurement as well.
- 4:06And that's measured through standardized patient experience surveys that we call the HCAP survey.
- 4:12Hospitals are rated from one to five stars. And what's important to note is
- 4:17that this methodology compares hospitals that are similar to us based on their
- 4:22size and their complexity.
- 4:24So it is a relative ranking.
- 4:26We are, in effect, being graded on a curve, so to speak.
- 4:30Even if we achieve the target on most or many of the measures,
- 4:34we might still not get the four or five star rating that we see if the other
- 4:38hospitals in our bucket are doing better than us.
- 4:41And that's important to keep in mind. I also want to point out that starting
- 4:45in 2026, CMS will be adding a rule where if you don't meet the threshold for
- 4:51patient safety in the bucket of patient safety,
- 4:54you're not going to get a four or five star rating no matter how well you do
- 4:58in the rest of the categories.
- 5:01And that just emphasizes the importance of patient safety in general and the
- 5:05importance that CMS attaches to that. Yeah, absolutely.
- 5:09And, you know, you referenced the hospitals, but there's also applicable measures for some of our.
- 5:16Non-acute care hospital-based spaces, right?
- 5:19When we think about behavioral health, we think about home health and hospice
- 5:24service delivery, right?
- 5:26There are some measures we're also tracking in those spaces as well to see how
- 5:30we are performing. Absolutely.
- 5:32CMS measures quality not just for our hospitals, but for all of the other sites
- 5:37of care that you just mentioned.
- 5:39So home health gets a star rating, as does hospice.
- 5:42In fact, ambulatory patient care also has a star rating and dialysis facilities as well.
- 5:48All of these are presented by CMS on a website called Care Compare,
- 5:54and that's simply the web address, carecompare.org or .gov, I think.
- 5:59And you can go in there and look at the quality of care.
- 6:01You'd be surprised, or perhaps not, to note that Maine Health,
- 6:05Home Health and Hospice, Chan's Home Health and Hospice, and the other facilities
- 6:08are listed on there as well.
- 6:10To your point, from a patient perspective, a community perspective,
- 6:14these measures really measure things that directly impact the patient and is
- 6:20a good reflection of why they should have trust, right, and trust in us in terms
- 6:25of being a care delivery provider.
- 6:27But it is also a bit of a scorecard to say, how are we performing against our
- 6:33peers, which is why this work involves everyone, right?
- 6:38Not just those that are like yourself and Helen, who lead quality and safety efforts.
- 6:44So maybe let's talk a little bit more about that. And Helen,
- 6:48from your perspective today, how are you doing that?
- 6:49What role does leadership play, particularly in moving the performance forward,
- 6:56whether that's at a system level, like roles you and Omar play,
- 6:59regional, community, in the different care settings?
- 7:03But how important is it for leadership to help make us improve in this space?
- 7:09Well, frankly, I think it's where it starts.
- 7:11And actually, depending on the level of engagement, involvement,
- 7:16and ownership, it's exactly where it can stall out. And so there are various
- 7:21levels of leadership across the system.
- 7:23And so what engagement looks like, what ownership looks like can look different.
- 7:27So from the system perspective, it's clear that we need to have a direction.
- 7:31We need to crystallize that direction. We do that through the balanced scorecard.
- 7:35We need to make sure that we are assessing and allocating resources appropriately.
- 7:41And when our frontline care team members are unable to remove barriers,
- 7:45that we as a leadership team, and especially at the system level,
- 7:48look to remove those barriers so that the work that they're doing is done with
- 7:53ease, it's effective, it's efficient.
- 7:54That level of commitment really does foster an engagement.
- 7:59It creates a situation where our care team feels as though it's not extra work
- 8:04and they're not striving to assist others in achieving their balanced scorecard measures.
- 8:10Rather, it's a team effort where we're owning all of the work.
- 8:14And regionally and locally, I think it's even more personal.
- 8:17And I want to mention that there's individual cultures, patient populations.
- 8:22Organizations have different strengths.
- 8:24They also have different challenges. And so...
- 8:27What the four-star performance looks like at each organization will look different,
- 8:31but we can imagine that the care to critical access hospital or a larger medical
- 8:37center may be different by way of pathway,
- 8:40but how you tailor that pathway to the unique characteristics is really where
- 8:44we're looking to leaders to assess these things and manage them day to day,
- 8:50strategically, month to month, quarter to quarter.
- 8:52And really, at the end of the day, leaders at all levels, we're asking them
- 8:56to model quality, have that mindset that improvement is everybody's role.
- 9:02And it's not the work of any one department.
- 9:05Rather, it's a unified effort by all departments. Yeah.
- 9:08No, I couldn't agree more that, you know, leadership has to set the tone.
- 9:14The direction, the support and advocacy for this work. But let's talk a little
- 9:18bit about where the work happens.
- 9:21How are we engaging our frontline, our physicians, our advanced practice professionals.
- 9:28You know, everyone on the care team to in this work and how does it feel for them to.
- 9:35So it feels like they're improving care and not chasing a score for a scorecard benefit only.
- 9:43We need to remind ourselves as leaders that we can't ask care team members to move numbers.
- 9:50Right. And we'll lose them. Yeah. And so what we really need to be thinking
- 9:53about is, one, the reality that most of our care team members,
- 9:58if not all, come into health care to help people.
- 10:01Right. And so we need to frame the conversation with an experience,
- 10:06a story around how patient care looks when it's, you know,
- 10:10delivered within our care settings and how as it unfolds that we coordinate
- 10:15and align to those things, the best practices that we know will help us to achieve
- 10:19the desired results that we all know we want for our patients.
- 10:24Quick example of that might be that we really do intentionally tell patient
- 10:28stories at meetings at all levels of the organization.
- 10:31So, for example, readmissions could be if you weren't to tell a story about
- 10:36a percent of patients who were coming back with an unplanned visit within 30
- 10:41days, or we could take it to a more personal level,
- 10:45which is the patient who was under our care returned to our hospital because
- 10:49something unfolded that wasn't right, and so it was unplanned.
- 10:54Infections are another great example, surgical site infections,
- 10:57catheter or central line infections.
- 10:59And I think here, again, it's a number, it's a count, and we look at it every day.
- 11:07But really what is happening is that the patients who are under our care are
- 11:10getting sicker when they're in our care.
- 11:13So really it's longer length of stays, more complications, and more outcomes,
- 11:17all of which people who are getting our care aren't expecting.
- 11:20So it lands differently when we talk about data differently.
- 11:23And just adding that level of context and personal element really does remind
- 11:28people that these measures are about people.
- 11:31Right, because it's a person behind that number, to your point, and that is a connector.
- 11:36Our care team having awareness of how we are performing, right, is also important.
- 11:42So how do you balance that connecting them to purpose with really making the
- 11:48numbers feel like real people, which they are?
- 11:51So how do you balance that with sharing data and being transparent about the
- 11:56data with our frontline teams, but that it feels more like it's aimed towards
- 12:02truly improving the care, not really creating pressure or fear?
- 12:06I think data without context can feel like judgment.
- 12:10It's also about how we provide the data, tailor the data, again,
- 12:16to the care teams that we're communicating with.
- 12:19We know individuals do not respond well to judgment. It doesn't promote that
- 12:23psychological safety that we're looking for.
- 12:25So our primary or one of our primary strategies is to build literacy around data. And.
- 12:35Reminding individuals how the data is calculated, making sure they understand
- 12:39national performance, national benchmarks, where is our performance in relationship to those benchmarks.
- 12:46So when we're sharing data, we're presenting the data with context,
- 12:51additional information, if you will.
- 12:53And in that scenario, as you can imagine, it's better than just handing over
- 12:58a piece of paper with a report, with read,
- 13:01without a lot of explanation, which could put people in a place of maybe unintentional
- 13:07defensiveness because they're feeling as though this is potentially a punitive situation.
- 13:11So I guess an example, just real time that I hope people are appreciating is
- 13:16intentional for us as a system, is that we are talking about data daily.
- 13:22We do data in our huddles.
- 13:25Each organization has a daily huddle where safety events, the no harm index,
- 13:30which is a safety composite metric of various harm events are reviewed.
- 13:35And we are looking to leaders to add context in the moment at the huddle.
- 13:39We're also asking leaders to cascade that down to their team.
- 13:43That, in essence, creates a shared opportunity to see this as our problem,
- 13:48where we can then do problem solving together as a collective effort.
- 13:52And I think, again, it's an example of psychological safety where data is a
- 13:56tool. Yeah. It's not punitive. Yeah.
- 13:59Really, really appreciate that because data is a tool.
- 14:02It should be a powerful tool and it provides us insight and direction,
- 14:08but it should not be our sole purpose of being, right? It really is to really
- 14:14improve care and how it's delivered.
- 14:16And we use that data, to your point, to find areas of opportunity.
- 14:20So maybe highlight a few of the areas where we've had the biggest operational
- 14:27or clinical focus that you think is really helping drive some meaningful improvement.
- 14:32And then what are we doing to sustain that so it's not just a one-time correction
- 14:37that might drift away in the future? Yeah.
- 14:41There have been definitely some intentional areas for focused improvement.
- 14:46And although this may seem as though this is a hospital-centric discussion,
- 14:51the no harm index actually is in all of our care areas.
- 14:54I'll speak to those on the hospital side because it's a really great example
- 14:58of how we did targeted projects, we did local improvements, and then we took
- 15:03the learning from that and spread it across the system.
- 15:05So infections are an example, post-operative complications, falls,
- 15:10and pressure injuries are all harm events that are within that no-harm index.
- 15:15They're measurable, and they're a direct connection to, and I'm going to bring
- 15:20it back to the CMS star rating, the safety of care domain, which is one of the
- 15:24heavier-weighted composites within the CMS star rating.
- 15:28All of these things are preventable. There's large bodies of knowledge that
- 15:32speak to the fact that the ways in which you can prevent these harm events through
- 15:37evidence-based care is no longer debatable.
- 15:40It's just how do you actually tailor them for the right patient,
- 15:44the right care scenario, and then make sure that that care is delivered reliably
- 15:49every patient, every organization, every time.
- 15:52And so I mentioned targeted projects, which we did in the southern region,
- 15:57in particular with catheter-associated indwelling urinary catheter infections.
- 16:02Along with surgical site infections, patient safety indicators.
- 16:07There was a lot of shared learning happening there. In tandem with that,
- 16:11we've been doing reviews of all of our harm events across the entire system since 2023.
- 16:17And so that also has built out for us a great amount of understanding around where our gaps lie.
- 16:23And so through that, we've built system policies. And now we've translated these
- 16:29complex policies that are important.
- 16:31But we built them out into a simple framework called bundles.
- 16:35And that's where those targeted evidence-based care asks by risk,
- 16:41by patient clinical type, can be implemented. But more importantly,
- 16:45we can talk about it with our care team members in a uniform way.
- 16:50We can also mentor, manage, and monitor for adherence and support our care teams
- 16:56in ways that will actually enhance that adherence for reliability.
- 16:59And then two more quick projects. Coastal.
- 17:03We're excited that region actually has taken on readmissions.
- 17:07All of these measures that I speak of are actually within the CMS star rating.
- 17:11So these are actually targeted projects based on our response to data or opportunities
- 17:16for improvement or even opportunities to standardized care so that we all could
- 17:21learn from each other and gain a level of appreciation for the benefits of certain
- 17:27practices to be applied everywhere.
- 17:29And for readmissions, really, it's about those care transitions.
- 17:32Are we progressing the plans of care based on patient risks?
- 17:36Medications are an example of that, follow-up appointments, education.
- 17:41Again, all things to avoid breakdowns and ultimately avoid their return within
- 17:4648 to 72 hours or obviously within that 30-day window.
- 17:50And then one last example is the patient experience. And this one is one that's
- 17:54been ongoing for us as a system.
- 17:56We've appreciated everybody's partnership in this. and really it's about communication.
- 18:01It's communication amongst ourselves as a team and communication with the care team and the patients.
- 18:09Communication happens in many ways. It happens in handoffs. It happens when we care plan.
- 18:15It can even mean soft skills. So having that empathy that we know everyone has,
- 18:20but just being mindful of that and calling it out.
- 18:23And so there's a lot of design that's going into the ways in which we communicate
- 18:28with each other and then thinking about how we communicate with our patients
- 18:31so that the experience is positive,
- 18:34not only from a care coordination perspective, but also from a patient's perception perspective.
- 18:39Yeah, thank you for those examples.
- 18:42And, Omar, I don't know if you have any comments. When I hear about this work,
- 18:48it also sounds like the ingredients or the foundational elements of creating
- 18:54a highly reliable organization environment.
- 18:57As we think about sustainability and having consistent and demonstrated outcomes
- 19:06and really just being reliable and how we deliver care.
- 19:09I don't know if you have anything else you want to add to that perspective of
- 19:13how we're sustaining or how we're thinking about creating that high reliability environment.
- 19:19You're right, Kelly. We aspire to be a high reliability organization,
- 19:23And I think in many ways, we are getting there.
- 19:26I want to take this time to highlight the core principles of a high reliability organization.
- 19:31And I think most people are familiar with them, but I will recount them just
- 19:35so we are able to convey them in the context of improving our performance on
- 19:41the CMS hospital quality star rating.
- 19:43So the first principle is preoccupation with failure. And this is really an
- 19:48awareness of the potential for failure, the near misses, the good catches that
- 19:52allow us to prevent things from going wrong before they actually happen. Yeah.
- 19:57The second principle is a reluctance to simplify operations or interpretation
- 20:02of the signals that you are witnessing.
- 20:05And it really gets down to understanding the root causes of what may lead to
- 20:10latent safety threat, as they say.
- 20:12The third principle is sensitivity to operations. And this means recognizing
- 20:17that your work is fitting in within a complex jigsaw puzzle,
- 20:23along with the work of so many people around you all of the time.
- 20:27The fourth principle is commitment to resilience and awareness of the unpredictable
- 20:32nature and the highly complicated nature of healthcare delivery so that you're
- 20:36always aware of what's going on around you.
- 20:40And more importantly, you're able to bounce back to normal operations even after something goes wrong.
- 20:46And then finally, the one I like the most, deference to expertise.
- 20:50The acknowledgement for leaders like myself that expertise likely resides with
- 20:55a person who is actually doing the work and hence closest to the safety threat.
- 21:00I do want to take a moment to also point out that one of the key elements of
- 21:04sustaining is celebrating the good work that's happening all across MaineHealth.
- 21:09So we have the excellence awards at MaineHealth, but I would encourage our
- 21:15leaders to go out and round in the clinical care areas and not just learn about what's happening,
- 21:21but also acknowledge and celebrate the good work that our care team members are doing.
- 21:26Because I think celebrating the excellent work that goes on around all of our
- 21:30healthcare facilities is equally important to sustainability.
- 21:34Yeah. No, thank you for raising that, Omar. And it's true, right?
- 21:38It's that real-time recognition, celebrating in the unit.
- 21:43And then we do thank you for raising it up.
- 21:46We now have a system-wide excellence award category around quality and.
- 21:53Really allows us to reward and recognize just exceptional performance by an
- 21:59individual or team in this space.
- 22:01But that shouldn't be the only time we're doing that. So thank you for pointing that out.
- 22:05As we wrap up, I want to give you both an opportunity to, you know,
- 22:10answer a question, which is,
- 22:13what does a four-star or higher environment actually feel like for a patient
- 22:20or family receiving care within MaineHealth.
- 22:24My mother-in-law, about a year ago, actually had stroke symptoms and was brought
- 22:29to Norway Hospital. She had an emergency department visit.
- 22:34She was admitted where they were working her up.
- 22:37Ultimately, in her workup, she began to have additional cardiac symptoms, stroke symptoms.
- 22:44I was in regular communication with the emergency department staff and the nursing
- 22:48staff because, of course, I didn't live in Norway, but I was the health care proxy at the time.
- 22:54And so I just can't speak enough about how that time to just keep me updated was critical.
- 23:01But then I knew what was happening because, of course, I understand things from behind the scenes.
- 23:06They emergently transported her through one call to Maine Medical Center where
- 23:11she was admitted to the new Malone Family Tower.
- 23:14She had multiple tests, a lot of providers, some imaging.
- 23:19She had cardiology, infectious disease, neurology.
- 23:24At one point, we even did palliative care consults because we were unsure.
- 23:28She had a septic emboli, which is, are the healthcare professionals who might be listening.
- 23:33She had mitral valve vegetations, and so she was continuing to have debris cascade
- 23:40up. And so she was having multiple mini ischemic events.
- 23:44Ultimately, what this really meant is that she was immobile.
- 23:47She had altered mental status.
- 23:50She at one point needed an indwelling urinary catheter, a central line for antibiotics
- 23:55and also for anticoagulation.
- 23:58I guess really the point here is to say that all along that acute trajectory,
- 24:05I had communications by all those providers.
- 24:08I was in the MyChart looking at the information, but I was also hearing from
- 24:12all of them, and they were talking amongst themselves in a uniform way.
- 24:16And so the care plan was really clear. I also, because of my exposure to health
- 24:20care in our system, saw all of the different things that you would like to see
- 24:24in place, like the fall risk assessments tailored day-to-day,
- 24:28the removal of the lines immediately.
- 24:31The care coordination, the early discharge planning.
- 24:34We transferred her to New England Rehab.
- 24:37She had continued involvement with our healthcare professionals while she was
- 24:42in these other transitional settings.
- 24:44And I could go on, but I will say that she's now home and she's independent
- 24:50with a walker and she's driving. And at one point, we just hadn't quite expected
- 24:55even close to this good of an outcome.
- 24:57And honestly, it's really about the coordination of care, the right interventions
- 25:03at the right time, and then making sure that those things that were not needed were no longer used.
- 25:09And then we escalated in coordinated care across a continuum in what,
- 25:13in my mind, was quite a seamless fashion. Yeah.
- 25:15Well, one, thank you for sharing that. I'm so glad to hear that she's...
- 25:20Seemingly a full recovery and great quality of life. Now, let me, can I ask you a question?
- 25:26Do you think all that went so well because folks knew who you were and that
- 25:31you are a leader in quality and safety for the organization?
- 25:35Such a good question. I like to be in the background.
- 25:38I do feel it's important to trust in my colleagues and to trust actually in
- 25:43the systems we've built. And so my family laughed because they know do not say
- 25:49who I am or what my role is.
- 25:51So it's kind of a running family joke. But no.
- 25:54And a matter of fact, at one point in time, a provider was doing a family meeting
- 25:59and I wasn't there. So I was on the phone and they mentioned my name and I happened
- 26:03to work with him closely. And he said, oh, Helen Troy in quality.
- 26:07And so, you know, it got discovered at that point.
- 26:10But that was far into the plan of care, almost at the point where she was ready
- 26:14for discharge. So the answer is no.
- 26:17I really do feel, by and large, it's the intentional work of the leaders.
- 26:21The care teams, and then, of course, the support that we give them to be successful.
- 26:26So it was really nice to see itself play out.
- 26:28Frankly, it's why I do what I do. So to be able to know that that will be there
- 26:32for my family and maybe me at some point, it was emblematic of why I love my role.
- 26:36Omar, any parting thoughts for our listeners? Well, I'd like to begin by thanking
- 26:41each and every one of our care team members for all the work they've done over
- 26:46the years leading up to now.
- 26:48I think that we truly have a highly engaged care team across the board.
- 26:53So my gratitude to everyone. The one message I hope people take away from this
- 26:58is that whatever your role might be at MaineHealth, whether you are unloading
- 27:04supplies, carrying food into a patient's room,
- 27:07helping register a patient, or you're a doctor or a nurse, whoever you may be,
- 27:12or you're a leader in an administrative role.
- 27:15All contribute to improving patient safety and the quality and the experience
- 27:20of care for our patients.
- 27:22So please, when you come into work, know that, you know, you are appreciated,
- 27:27you have the gratitude from the community, from our leadership at MaineHealth,
- 27:31and that you all have a stake and a role in improving the quality of care at MaineHealth.
- 27:37Thank you for that and echo those comments, and it does take everyone.
- 27:42I think as we've talked about the five-star journey and particularly what it
- 27:47feels like for our patients, I can't think of any other real motivator than
- 27:51we need to do this for our patients.
- 27:54And so thank you both for diving into the topic today.
- 27:57Really appreciate it and can't wait to have you all back and hear what's next
- 28:03for quality and safety. So thank you.
- 28:05Thank you. Thank you. Well, I hope that you found this episode informative and
- 28:09provides a deeper insight into one of our major areas of focus as we continue
- 28:13to enhance how we work together as MaineHealth to achieve our vision of working
- 28:18together so that our communities are the healthiest in America.
- 28:22If you have ideas for topics for
- 28:24future podcasts, please email those to workingtogetheratmainehealth.org.
- 28:30Thank you and have a blessed day.