Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Sub-$25K New Vehicles Disappear, Nissan’s Turnaround Plan, Shop Target In ChatGPT
Transcript
- 0:00[funky music] It is Thursday, December 11th. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly. We have Michael Cirillo with the OG mic, the first mic that started it all for Dealer Playbook, in the house.
- 0:11Today, we're talking about Target and affordability and something else. Oh, Nissan's turnaround plan. A lot of dealers are waiting on that, actually. We'll see if it happens.
- 0:22Michael, tell us the story about this microphone. This is the mic that started it all. Uh, I... W- when I-- when this mic first came out, guys, it was $54. You gotta keep it really close to your [laughs]...
- 0:36Adjusted for inflation, it is now a $1,000 microphone. [laughs] Yeah. It, it was 54 bucks. I, I mean, coming into the podcast, you know, as a sound engineer, we can be, we can be gear snobs. A bit.
- 0:47And I'm like, "54 bucks?" I just came from a studio where we had 3,000 and $10,000 microphones. And the Portuguese side of you rejoiced. Yes. And the Portuguese in me...
- 0:56Well, that, that is the conflict, the Italian-Portuguese conflict. [laughs] The Italian in me wants the best money can buy- [laughs]... and the Portuguese wants it for zero dollars. There you go.
- 1:05So that microphone is literally made for you. And you know what? The, the-- we launched the show, and people didn't know, and they, they all, they all marveled at the sound quality.
- 1:14They're like, "What mic are you using?" Well, the di... Okay, let me put some caveats on that. Number one, you just have a fantastic voice.
- 1:21[laughs] Number two, [laughs] right, number two, it's like you can give a guitar to anybody, but some people, like you can give a $100 guitar to John Mayer and he's gonna make it sound awesome. And you probably- Oh.
- 1:30You probably tweaked this signal a little bit, too, didn't you? Ran it through a little bit of something. This is, this is a direct USB right into the laptop. No, no nothing. Oh, that's US- it's not even XLR right now?
- 1:41All right, we're losing all the non-tech people. [laughs] Oh, but hey, uh, we have a few things, amazing things that are happening. We released our exclusive interview with Ryan Decker of Scout yesterday. It dropped.
- 1:55Now it is on, uh, where is it mostly, Nathan? YouTube channel is the place to get it? We're gonna drop it on LinkedIn, too, the full version. You can go to YouTube. Go to, um, uh, well, you can go to ASOTU.
- 2:06Actually, the best place to go is A-S-O-T-U dot B-E, ASOTU, very cute, and you'll see it up there right toward the top. But, or you could just search More Than Cars, Ryan Decker, or Scout.
- 2:17And we discussed, we talked through a lot of the things that have been a topic of conversation, how to build brand, uh, why they chose the model that they chose.
- 2:24And, um, you know, this is kind of the first interview they've granted to someone inside the retail auto side, so we're super grateful for that. Uh, hopefully, they were able to talk about what they're doing.
- 2:32Hopefully, we can learn a little something.
- 2:33And, uh, Kyle was saying this yesterday, like really the thesis is always what can we learn from the people doing progressive things, and how can we make dealerships the best place to be, right? It's just competition.
- 2:43How can we make the experience the best? So that's dropping today. We also had a webinar yesterday that you can still get.
- 2:50We had, um, John Church from Lithia, who's the category manager for procurement, give their whole blueprint on why and how they measure transporting people from service to home, like shuttle, and why they chose to go with Uber for Business and how they decided that.
- 3:04So a lot of great insights there. You can get that by going to asotu.com, A-S-O-T-U dot com, and it's right up there. You can just click on it, sign up. We'll send you the recording immediately.
- 3:14What's better than not waiting? Not much. Nothing's better. All right, today I wanna thank today's sponsor of the show, Mia.
- 3:20Um, there's real money hiding behind all those missed calls, especially the weird late night ones. And Mia never misses them and makes sure it doesn't get awkward.
- 3:29She answers instantly, handles real customer questions, and books real appointments, even if the caller sounds like they might be whispering from a parking lot somewhere.
- 3:38Uh, she's managed over a million customer calls already like a perfectly poised professional, generating millions in revenue and saving teams hundreds of thousands of hours. So it's Mia.
- 3:49Because opportunity doesn't clock out, so why should your phones? Thank you so much, Mia, for helping us get the show on the road. All right. Let's talk about some news.
- 3:58November brought a slight dip in overall new vehicle inventory, but the real headline for dealers is how quickly anything under $25,000 is evaporating from their lots, and how quickly EV day supply is rising.
- 4:10Here's the breakdown. Uh, US new vehicle inventory fell 1.6% to 3.09 units, a million units. But day supply ticked up from 70 to 73.
- 4:22Now, the sub $25,000 vehicles are practically mythical, spending get, like not even 36 hours on a dealer lot. Like, we're gonna have to start measuring this not in days, but in hours.
- 4:34So if it's under 25,000, it spent under 36 hours on a dealer lot. While EV supply went from 107 days to 126 days, so we're now in four-month territory. Hybrids sitting at a 60-day supply. ICE vehicles at 75 days.
- 4:50Minivans still, uh, the leanest day supply in ICE vehicles at 58 days. Toyota continues to run up the, uh, run the tightest ship in the industry with 31-day supply.
- 4:59So you got any of those $25,000 cars laying around, Michael? No, but I'm thinking about starting a dealership now that just focuses on sub $25,000 [laughs] cars. Yeah. You heard it here first, folks.
- 5:12If I see one of these pop up, I'm coming for you. You, you start a dealership, guys, that's like startercars.com- Yeah... and you gear it towards s- you know, 16-year-olds' first cars. You gear it towards,
- 5:27you know, subprime. You gear it toward, like... And, and that's just it. And you carry, like, 10 cars at a time. You rip through 'em. You sell another 10. You rip through 'em.
- 5:35I've seen some, I've seen some really creative.
- 5:37So, like, that's, that's an interesting concept for, like, a dealer group to start a, a separate brand, and some dealers do that, and they go subprime, and they d- But this, we're talking about a price point here.
- 5:47There, there's some groups I've seen that have gotten very, very creative with this. Um, Bur- Drivers Village up here in Syracuse has done that.
- 5:53And they used to talk about, you know, back in the day, a lot of used vehicle supply came from rental cars, right? So you'd buy these off rentals, and you'd supply- Yeah... with, like, late model stuff.
- 6:02But very few dealers were actually in what one of my mentors, his name's Lou Brego, he was the COO there for a while, um-He's like, "Very few dealers are willing to get in the used car business."
- 6:12And when he says that, high mileage, like, quality reconditioning, and providing value for maybe the third or fourth car in the garage or in the driveway because, like you just mentioned, you have kids that need cars, you need temporary, you need to just, just get back and forth to work.
- 6:27They even went so far as to have a little warehouse where as cars came in and they would, they would be able to, like, if they were gonna wholesale a vehicle, they would actually start to harvest some things off of these cars that they would set aside.
- 6:40Tires that had good tread wear when they knew the lease turn in already replaced tires. Whatever, whatever it was, they would start to stockpile things. And then when a used car, how could they keep it under 25,000?
- 6:50Well, they have a used set of tires that still has, you know, a year or two of life in them. They put those on there.
- 6:55So I think getting more creative in the used car business, if you're good at reconditioning, this is a, a real opportunity for you to, like, get your hands dirty a little bit more, and some dealers can pull this off.
- 7:05Or take Michael's suggestion. I wanna, I wanna search that domain now and see if we can find it. [laughs] I am domain... I am.com rich-.com-... in real estate... affluent.
- 7:16Um, but, you know, I think the same adage always applies. If it was that easy, everybody- Yeah... would be doing it Somebody would be doing it. Yeah.
- 7:22Well, and you know, what you're talking about reminds me of what we see in other retail sectors a lot.
- 7:28I mean, there's those, you know, those companies that buy Costco overstock, or they buy, you know, slightly older products that are still new in a box- That's right... or they're, they're, they were slightly used.
- 7:40And you can go in and it's a warehouse environment, and you're like, "Oh, yeah, they're, they're so much cheaper." And, and that's what they do.
- 7:45They're just looking for the best, most sellable thing that they can sell to you at a discount, so it's a win-win for everybody. And I mean, you know, who knows?
- 7:55I, I don't know that we've seen a lot of that in the automotive space. Obviously, there's lots of regulation and- Yeah... overhead and- Yep, yep... those sorts of things, but who knows where the future's coming.
- 8:03And I mean, sub 25,000 brings me right back to, you know, 26 of those 30 dealerships we visited in Kazakhstan where, uh- That's right... you can buy a brand-new car for- Ah... 14,000. Oh, the challenges abound.
- 8:15Speaking of who knows. Stop. Segway. Time. [upbeat music] I, I hope I say this name right. Christian Meunier isn't pulling punches.
- 8:25Nissan has now been drifting for years, and he says the US turnaround depends on sharper execution, stronger product, and, yes, better dealer performance. Uh,
- 8:35Meunier says Nissan has no North Star, no vision, and no direction, prompting him to bring headquarter staff back in office four days a week to accelerate decisions and rebuild momentum.
- 8:46Wow, I didn't realize they were still out of office. That's definitely a part of the problem. US sales have fallen 40% in a decade.
- 8:53Market share is down to 6.4%, and heavy discounting has trained shoppers to view Nissan as the cheap one.
- 8:59Nissan missed major product cycles, losing its early EV lead with the Leaf, delaying Frontier updates, killing the Xterra, and skipping US hybrids while Toyota surged.
- 9:08His plan, add hybrids, starting with the Rogue, boost factory utilization, revive the Xterra, and rebuild dealer relations strained by thin margins and aging inventory.
- 9:18Nissan needs at least 7 to 8% retail share to support its 1,067 stores. And as a reminder, they are down to 6.4%. Christian, uh, dealer council lead, Mike Resi, said, "Christian is the right man for the job.
- 9:33It's just a hard job." I mean, but Christian's gonna be a guy we read about a lot when he pulls this thing around or if he can pull this thing around. Absolutely. We, we talked about- Be one of those, uh-...
- 9:43comeback story, baby... comeback stories. A, a setback is a setup for a comeback. That's right. That's right.
- 9:49You know, I'm excited to see what Nissan does because I've, I've been looking at some of the product, and some of it seems really great. And we know a lot of Nissan dealers.
- 9:56We know what these margin compression, um, and with this product issues and just the, the leadership has done and the pressure it's put on dealers and dealership, especially in a time and an era when financing was a lot harder.
- 10:09Like, it doesn't help when your brand is struggling and you're trying to, like, pay for your real estate and finance your floor plan and your inventory.
- 10:15So, uh, we're all hoping that this is the beginning of a great turnaround because Nissan can do it. The question is, will they do it?
- 10:22Without a doubt, like, we had the whole More Than Cars team into Syracuse yesterday, and it's amazing what happens when people are in person. Mm. Right? Our company is, is hybrid right now.
- 10:33We have a headquarters, so a, a good portion of people do come in every day, but we also have a good portion of remote workers. But when people are together, speaking face-to-face, eye-to-eye, things, uh...
- 10:44Conflict gets resolved faster. General work moves faster. More innovation happens because, typically, you can't jump on a Zoom call and be like, "Hey, let's innovate something."
- 10:54It always happens in the in between, so I think that's a, a first move right there. I can't believe- I, I have-... they're still out of office... my unsolicited advice, as our producer Nathan would say- [laughs]...
- 11:04is, "Hey, rugged. Go rugged." The best Nissans were those rugged, like, the, the 2010- Xterra. Like, they're bringing it back. Bring it back. Bring back the 2010 version of the Pathfinder- Yeah. Oh, the boxy-...
- 11:18and, like, modernize on that concept... yeah. Yeah. Yes. Because if you look at, like, what other brands are doing, Kia's going rugged. Scout coming to market with super rugged look. Go rugged- Yeah...
- 11:29like Michael Cirillo. That's the new campaign. It's gonna feature you, cowboy hat, straw in your mouth. Go rugged, right? Yeah. [laughs] Signed, Michael Cirillo. I think. Wanna feel like a outback,
- 11:44strong man who can do anything. [laughs] Eats nails for breakfast. [laughs] That's what I was thinking. Exactly. Nailed it. [laughs] Se- segue that one for me. Uh, speaking of Target and ChatGPT- Stop...
- 11:59how's that for a segue? Segway time. [upbeat music][laughs] Uh, all right, check this one out.
- 12:05Target is jumping headfirst into AI commerce by embedding its shopping experience directly into ChatGPT, building on OpenAI's growing presence in e-commerce with Shopify and its, uh, Etsy integrations.
- 12:19Uh, I mean, it was only a matter of time. Yeah. Users can search, add to cart, and check out via ChatGPT using their Target account. Integration supports drive-through and pickup orders within the chat interface.
- 12:30Uh, I feel like this is gonna give us a real good gauge on whether or not people use those pickup order line, uh, [laughs] parking stalls- Kyle does... that are always empty. Kyle, Kyle does all the time.
- 12:40Of course he does. [laughs] This move mirrors Walmart's AI ambitions, but Target is first to market with a confirmed rollout. Uh, we got a quote here from Fiji Simo, the OpenAI CEO of applications.
- 12:52He says, quote, "Target is a great example of what that shift looks like when it's done with ambition and speed." Oh my gosh, there's so much to unpack just in that quote about success in life in general.
- 13:04Like- [laughs]... have ambition and relentlessly attack your ambition with such velocity. You know what I mean? I think m- we're gonna see more of this. I mean, I don't, I don't know if...
- 13:16Th- those that are paying attention, you're seeing the rollout of ads in new spots that you didn't used to see the rollout of ads j- Yeah... I mean, you look at the Uber app right now.
- 13:26There's slide ups while you're waiting. There's advertising in so many different places. I think this is a natural progression. It was only- Yeah...
- 13:32a matter of time for ChatGPT to start injecting more of this, um, I don't know, what do you wanna call it, pay-to-play placement- I don't think it's pay-to-play... inside of their platform. I think they just developed.
- 13:43I, I wonder, I wonder what the financial arrangement is. Um, and when does it say this is gonna come out? Because you figure if Target develops the integration and they work with OpenAI, there's- Yeah...
- 13:55really shared mutual value, 'cause OpenAI, just like any platform, I wanna make it so people have to never m- leave my platform.
- 14:01And if now they can shop at Target and do that within there, I think it brings a lot of value to OpenAI, and obviously it brings a lot of value to Target. So I wonder if there's any money changing hands.
- 14:10I would doubt it. I just opened ChatGPT 5.1 and I said, "Can you help me shop at Target via integration?" Actually, I spelled it wrong, integration. It says, "Yes, I can help with some limits.
- 14:22Here's what I can do for you at Target: Help you decide what to buy, compare brands, search Target's site for specific items and show price details and direct product links, build a T- Target shopping list.
- 14:33Here's what I can't do: directly connect you to your Target account." So, um- Hmm... I guess it's not launched yet. Let's see. Does it- Not there... did it say when it was gonna launch? Nathan, did you see that?
- 14:44I haven't seen... I can... Hold on. Let me pull it up. They're just saying they did it. "We've done it. We can't show you, but we've [laughs] done it." I guess it's- Yeah, wait for an ADA.
- 14:52That's what I just, that's what they said. Oh. [laughs] Yeah, the day we see Target and an ADA. Users can search, add to cart, and check out via ChatGPT using their Target account. Well, the point is, it's coming. Uh.
- 15:05And, I mean, if I'm hedging my bets right now- Mm-hmm... this is where, as a dealer, if I'm looking at my ad budgets, I would also... Okay, just follow me down this one for a minute. Okay.
- 15:13This is where I would start paying a little bit closer attention to Bing advertising, and I can't believe I'm giving this freebie away. Well, [laughs] yeah. When you look at- Still not too late. Not too late.
- 15:21[laughs] Yeah. When, when you look at, when you look at the integration of, um, Bing, Microsoft, ownership stake, OpenAI placements- Mm-hmm...
- 15:34opportunity to get in front of a audience searching in a slightly different way, I, I think there might be something coming down the gauntlet here in the near future- Oh... where they might get preference.
- 15:46You heard it here first. You did say that. All right. Well, listen. Stop. Well, I didn't wanna hit that button. I wanted to hit this button. [upbeat music] Keep checking out.
- 15:54Let us know in the comments or just DM us if you figure out how to use ChatGPT and Target, because, you know, we're just thinking about it. Until then, control the things you can control.
- 16:03Buy those cars under 25K, but take care of your people. Please. [upbeat music] And lead the way. Uh. And lead the way. Uh. And lead the way.
- 16:21Uh.