Latest / The Bitcoin Way Podcast / Why Smart People Reject Bitcoin | Brett Hansen
Transcript
- 0:00Why do smart people, like otherwise really smart or successful people, why are they so averse to this idea of Bitcoin?
- 0:07Even if you as an American and a relatively financially privileged person do not get Bitcoin, it doesn't change the fact that 5 billion other people will need Bitcoin.
- 0:16As much as like the news wants to play it off, like, I don't know that our threats are necessarily physical anymore. I think they're more psychological.
- 0:25We all come to this common conclusion that you have to self custody it.
- 0:29You have to be a participant in the network.
- 0:30You have to hold the keys.
- 0:32We'll just stop and question the underlying base layer of money and just question what it actually is.
- 0:55Today on the show I have Brett Hansen, author of Bitcoin Not Crypto and The Belief Machine. Some fascinating reads and incredible conversations we had about Bitcoin and how Bitcoin serves as a mirror about our beliefs. Very philosophical for the first 30 minutes. Then we get into what led him to Bitcoin, some of the practical takeaways later on. He's got a great unpopular opinion that you're going to want to hear at the end as well. Stay tuned and enjoy this chat with Brett.
- 1:20Hey everyone, like I said in the intro, I have Brett here. Brett, welcome to the Bitcoin Way podcast.
- 1:26Thanks for having me on. I appreciate the opportunity.
- 1:29It's good to see you again. Glad we get to chat. So this is going to be a fun conversation because unlike many of these interviews I do where I've read the books of the person I'm talking to, I haven't read your book, but I take it on good authority from our friend Stacy that this is going to be a fascinating chat and I want to learn more and then I'm going to get your book and dive into it.
- 1:47But you have a pinned post on X that I want to talk about first. And it's, I guess, to some degree, maybe the origin story of the book. You're talking to a guy about Bitcoin. He's curious. You're giving him all the right answers on a lot of things. And then he asks you a question. First of all, I would love to know what the question was. He asks you a question that you're not really prepared to answer. And it got you thinking about sort of the nature of what people believe and how people approach things. And Bitcoin will get into as a mirror of our beliefs.
- 2:16Could you tell a little bit about that story? Give us the background and then how that led into the belief machine
- 2:21Yeah, so it's actually the prologue to the book
- 2:26And really what it is, is I was at a company dinner at Marino and we're getting ready to go out on this boat
- 2:33And I was sitting at the table and the vice president of the company, I was sitting next to him
- 2:37And he's like, hey, you're into this Bitcoin, what's that all about?
- 2:42I was able to recite all the things, you know, why Bitcoin is important, inflation, you know, self-custody, property rights, things like that. And the whole table is listening to me, right? So it's like everyone at my company is like for the first time hearing me talk about Bitcoin.
- 3:02and I mean they all know I have
- 3:05Bitcoin vanity plates, whatever. So it's not something that they're not aware of
- 3:10but it was the first time they actually heard me speak
- 3:13publicly and so openly about it.
- 3:17And the question he asked me was, how was it insured?
- 3:21And I was able to recite everything, right? I was able to go down
- 3:25the line, why it was important to me and right there he gave me
- 3:28why it would be important to him.
- 3:31Right?
- 3:32So a lot of it is we have these conversations
- 3:36and we have a lot of information
- 3:37and we're usually pretty excited as Bitcoiners
- 3:40when somebody takes an interest
- 3:42in hearing what we have to say.
- 3:44Right?
- 3:45Because we've done the work.
- 3:47We, I mean, at least for myself,
- 3:49I don't have a lot of people in my everyday life
- 3:51I get to talk to about this.
- 3:54So we tend to go off and, you know,
- 3:57recite all these things about why it's important
- 3:58to us and are able to recite these facts that we've read, but not necessarily understood.
- 4:08And really what his question was, is he built an entire life and he was trying to protect
- 4:14it.
- 4:15He's thinking about how do I protect my wealth going into the future?
- 4:20How is this insured?
- 4:21He's looking at it from the perspective of FDIC insurance and chargeback and everything, right?
- 4:31And he'd never encountered something such as Bitcoin where he was actually in control of his own destiny, if you will, or own freedom with his money.
- 4:44And I just thought it was a really interesting question and a good jumping off point for the book.
- 4:49because the whole underlying thing that got me writing this was why do smart people, like otherwise really smart or successful people, why are they so averse to this idea of Bitcoin in general?
- 5:03Like why are you know why do 24 out of 25 people not own Bitcoin kind of thing right Um if it even that much I don know What conclusion have you come to on that question Why do most people not own Bitcoin
- 5:21So that's really the whole book, right? And I think what it comes down to
- 5:27comes down to a couple of things. One, Bitcoin sits underneath the logical argument. Facts don't change minds. And I don't necessarily even know data changes minds because belief sits much deeper than all of that. It sits in your preservation of identity. It sits in your need for social belonging, your need for a coherent worldview.
- 5:56And I think what Bitcoin actually does is it undercuts a lot of those things. And I also think the more successful a person is in say a FIA position, more averse they could be to the idea of Bitcoin because those things are built on top of it, on top of their, you know, their status. Right. And I don't necessarily know that belief is separate from belonging.
- 6:23So to be that person who goes in and say, hey, have you guys heard about this Bitcoin thing? It takes real work to take the criticism and be laughed at or called a fool or what are you talking about? Magic internet money. It takes a certain type of individual to continue to do the work.
- 6:44I think after something like that when so much ridicule or negativity in the past was put out about it, about Bitcoin.
- 6:57So is the unique individual that you're describing who might be that one of 25 say, what's the attribute?
- 7:09what is it about that person
- 7:11is it
- 7:12the point you make that I think is compelling
- 7:15is it seems like there
- 7:17are very few
- 7:20highly successful people
- 7:21like billionaire type
- 7:23people, we've got a few of those voices who are in Bitcoin
- 7:25but most of them are
- 7:27disinterested, it's rat poison
- 7:29we see a lot of that narrative
- 7:31and it seems to me in my own
- 7:33personal experience that the people who are just
- 7:35generally more affluent
- 7:36maybe the
- 7:39The belief that they have is that all systems are working properly. And so I don't need there. I'm not looking for a solution to anything. I can afford my groceries. I can afford to send my kids to private schools. I can't afford my home. Um, I have job security. I have all these things. There isn't something structurally broken, so I'm not going to try to fix it. Is that maybe what you're alluding to? And then how would you explain the people who do come into Bitcoin?
- 8:09in light of that.
- 8:11Sure. So I think you're exactly right. We may not look at it like this, but beliefs are investments. How they determine our entire worldview and the way that if our worldview is never questioned and we're by all accounts successful, we're moving through life easily, we have ease and comfort,
- 8:38you know we have you know maybe all the things we want outside of ourselves though I would argue that you know everything comes with from within but I digress there's it attacks that coherent worldview right I think that what happens is like you alluded to is what are you talking about I can I can buy my groceries like nobody wants to be taken as a mark that their government that the system is not a marketer.
- 9:08and the systems that they've built their entire lives around have been playing them the whole time. And it's a slow bleed, right? It is a slow bleed. It's not like it happens all at once. And I think it plays into a type of loss aversion where we think a loss aversion in a portfolio or something like that, the pain of losing money is greater than the joy of hitting it.
- 9:38But really I think that it's this type of where the pain of losing a coherent worldview or questioning it is immediate and acute and the gains are abstract and in the distance.
- 9:55and you don't need
- 9:57the way I've always thought about Bitcoin
- 9:59well, not in many ways
- 10:02is that you don't know you're going to need it
- 10:05until you need it
- 10:06and you build the ark before the flood
- 10:08a lot of times
- 10:10especially affluent people
- 10:12or even just someone who can get by day to day
- 10:16at least the people I talk to
- 10:18there's a pinch
- 10:19but it not quite painful it just a dull ache of I just got to work hard and then we sold this narrative right Oh you just got to work harder Oh you know you not doing enough You need to do more Like you not smart enough Like all this stuff And it like well maybe on some level but I don necessarily think that it causes people to be like that imminent danger that would cause them to be like oh shoot I need to do it
- 10:49do something about this because we don't think the government or any authority is going to really, at least in the United States, come and take our stuff where like how quickly we forget like.
- 11:04Yeah. Yeah. You know, often that happens.
- 11:07And nobody wants to feel like they're being stolen from and, you know, taxes are so high, but then it's like, well, is it worth like getting upset about it or doing any, what can I actually do?
- 11:18and then you just kind of get put in this lemming state of, you know, I'm just trying to get by and now I can sit and watch Survivor and decompress for a minute. And it's like, we'll just stop and like question the underlying like base layer of everything of money and just question what it actually is. And really all this book, all I'm trying to do, I don't prescribe anything. Like I give a few tells.
- 11:48But I don't, it's not like a preachy thing like you got to do this, this is the answer. Because it requires constant examination, whether you're not own Bitcoin or not. Even if you are a Bitcoiner, like, you need to continue to examine these things, like, constantly, just because you did it two years ago, and you decided on this idea. And now you, you know, kind of have this territory of what you think the world is.
- 12:18And I think we should view it more as a map because a map gives you direction and a territory is a place to defend. And once things become defending, we stop weighing the options and thinking critically about it and we immediately reach for a defense. And that goes for Bitcoiners or non-Bitcoiners.
- 12:41Yeah, it's interesting. I don't want to make the next five minutes about me or anything, but I think about my own story with Bitcoin. And when I got into Bitcoin, I knew the Federal Reserve existed, really had no idea its role in our world.
- 12:59I was a diehard Republican MAGA type guy
- 13:05and I was a lot of things
- 13:10I would say I was always maybe a bit more curious than the average person
- 13:13when it came to health and fitness I tried different diets
- 13:17I was kind of an experimenter I guess you could say
- 13:20but I was pretty entrenched in a number of beliefs and world views
- 13:24that if you told me that a few years later
- 13:28I would have parted ways with some of those beliefs. I would have never in a million years believed you. And now I'm like, I'm an anarchist who mostly eats meat, does all these crazy things that make sense when you've gone down a number of rabbit holes.
- 13:45I guess my question and the reason I'm saying all this is like how would you in light of your book in light of sort of some of the conclusions you've come to like what does that tell you about me about people who have gone on this journey like what's is what I'm sharing reflective of kind of people who have gone through this process of thinking about the you know about their beliefs more deeply.
- 14:11You know, all I have is my own experience, right? So I'm much the same way. Like when I came to Bitcoin, like I knew a Federal Reserve existed. Beyond that, I knew very little about money, the way the financial system worked. And, you know, even now I'll still defer to experts.
- 14:35The thing I will say is I've never
- 14:40I've yet to meet somebody who
- 14:42Became a Bitcoiner
- 14:44Where it didn't improve their lives
- 14:46Remarkably in some ways
- 14:48Whether that's just discovering new things
- 14:52Whether it opened new doors
- 14:53And you know what, maybe it was a new community
- 14:56That provided new ideas
- 14:57I think all those things play a role
- 15:01But for me
- 15:04I think stability looks a lot like truth
- 15:09It's stable, what are you talking about?
- 15:14And a world view can drift away from
- 15:17reality, if you will
- 15:21if it's stable
- 15:24And what I think Bitcoiners are very good at
- 15:29and I don't know what came first
- 15:32but I think they very good at sensing a type of destabilization or a sense of like just cognitive dissonance of like this isn you know this doesn quite match And you know you know the friction of like holding an idea or a belief of you know what what the world is supposed to be like
- 15:56and then you have two options.
- 15:59You can change the belief
- 16:00or you can adjust your interpretation of the evidence.
- 16:04I think there's something about a Bitcoiner
- 16:06or somebody who has maybe become convicted in Bitcoin
- 16:13where they're able to change the belief
- 16:20instead of just simply ignoring the evidence
- 16:23or adjusting their interpretation.
- 16:25right? Cause that's usually the easier thing to do. And you know, we do it too. Like, um, and I, I don't know, I don't, I can't put my finger on exactly what the thing is. Um, and maybe, maybe they're the person in, in the, like the ash line experiments who, who said, you know what? No, that, that line is, you know, they're not the same size, that line shorter or, you know, whatever. Um, if you know about the ash line experience.
- 16:52Yeah, yeah
- 16:52Yeah, so like
- 16:54and maybe it's just
- 16:55and only a quarter of the people did it
- 16:57I'm just saying like maybe
- 16:58and I don't know what it is
- 17:01maybe you just met them
- 17:02at a certain time in their life
- 17:04where they were open to it
- 17:05you know
- 17:06Yeah, yeah
- 17:09I think there is something to be said about that
- 17:12it's just like the
- 17:13you know, like when the student is ready
- 17:14the master will appear
- 17:16Yeah
- 17:17kind of thing
- 17:17and I think Bitcoin is
- 17:19is in some ways like that
- 17:21master teacher
- 17:22if you're willing to dig in on it.
- 17:25So what is, for someone reading this book,
- 17:30you're going to have two cohorts of people read this, right?
- 17:33You're going to have Bitcoiners
- 17:34and you're going to have non-Bitcoiners approximately.
- 17:37What do you anticipate and hope
- 17:42that each of those groups would get out of it?
- 17:44Like I as a Bitcoiner, I read your book.
- 17:46What am I going to take away?
- 17:48What's going to change in my thinking
- 17:51or my behavior because I've read your book.
- 17:53I think they're going to get the same thing out of it.
- 17:56I think a Bitcoiner is going to read it and think
- 17:59I'm talking about people outside of Bitcoin
- 18:04and them being a Bitcoiner
- 18:07and maybe like some of their experiences.
- 18:09I mean, there's a lot of anecdotes in there.
- 18:12But really, really the way this book is framed
- 18:16and the way it uses Bitcoin is a constrained environment.
- 18:21Because Bitcoin is one of the very few systems where we're in direct contact with consequence. We are responsible. And I think every other system around us kind of disperses that consequence a little bit so it's never truly felt.
- 18:42So I think Bitcoin is a very useful place to look at belief because it brings the abstract ideas in contact with that constraint.
- 18:55So to answer your question, they're both going to get, I hope, would get the same thing out of it.
- 19:02And that is the work is never done.
- 19:06You can notice the tells.
- 19:09You can examine the beliefs.
- 19:11but they are so ingrained in us like language that they require constant to be constantly looked at.
- 19:26The way that, you know, just even in the way, like, I don't know the way this sentence is going to end and the words are just like appearing before me and I'm speaking them.
- 19:38That's how quick beliefs come to us.
- 19:41in my opinion when they're fused with our identities. And I'm not saying don't hold your
- 19:49beliefs and don't feel emotions about them and all that. None of that. Feel all of it and hold your
- 19:57beliefs. But I think a stronger conviction arrives when you stop letting somebody else's conviction
- 20:04be a stand-in for yours.
- 20:06And you actually examine the belief,
- 20:09you stress test it,
- 20:11you see where your actions actually,
- 20:16whether your actions align with your words
- 20:20or the kind of person you say you are.
- 20:23And I mean, you can take anything in Bitcoin,
- 20:25you can take self-custody and responsibility.
- 20:30You can, I'm a responsible person,
- 20:32but I won't take the time to read the code or I won't take the time to learn how to dice roll. Things like that. So you're responsible or patience.
- 20:50would be another example. We all would say we're patient people. Losing your mind in traffic
- 20:56isn't quite the same thing of watching, holding something that actually costs you.
- 21:07And I think Bitcoin puts your idea of who you are in that relationship of something that will cost
- 21:16because it's your financial future.
- 21:19And I think it allows you to discover exactly who you are
- 21:25significantly more deeply.
- 21:29If you're willing to work like that.
- 21:30Yeah, yeah.
- 21:31I think that's an interesting way of framing it
- 21:32because I was going to push back a little bit and say,
- 21:36well, Bitcoin doesn't really put the constraints on
- 21:38that you're describing
- 21:39because there are people who are using custodians, for example,
- 21:43not something that we're a big fan of at the Bitcoin way.
- 21:45however that in and of itself is kind of the tell like that's that's the point you're making it's like
- 21:52bitcoin as it as it exists external to anything else any exchanges any third parties like it it
- 22:01it allows for you to decide to what extent do i accept these constraints and what to what extent
- 22:07do i offload personal responsibility patience anything else like if you're doing leverage
- 22:13plays. You're saying that the belief that you have is that it's more important for you to risk something to have more in the short term than it is for you to nurture this asset, this form of money into the future and allow its purchasing power to be whatever it is. If you're not willing to take time to learn how to roll dice and to set up an air-gapped hardware wallet and to do any number of other things, then you're effectively
- 22:42making a statement with your actions. Is that maybe a fair way of summarizing some of what you've said here?
- 22:49Very fair. Absolutely.
- 22:51Yeah, that's an interesting point. I think that the beautiful thing in my view, and I'd be curious to hear your thought, is that beliefs can change. I believe that they're deeply entrenched.
- 23:07and I think the biggest thing that has helped me on this journey
- 23:15is I don't think I thought I was the type of person
- 23:20who could change core beliefs.
- 23:23And somewhere along the line it happened
- 23:25and now the fact that I believe that I can change fundamental beliefs
- 23:29is maybe the biggest superpower
- 23:32because I'm very comfortable at this point being like,
- 23:35I was so wrong about so many things, or at least that's my opinion at the moment, is I believe I used to be wrong about a lot of things. I'm very open to being wrong about things now. I guarantee you I haven't figured it all out, and I'm going to have further changes in my beliefs moving forward.
- 23:51Absolutely. And I think the ability to adapt when new information presents itself is a sign of intelligence. I think that we should be, none of us were given a playbook to how to, if you're claiming a monopoly on truth and you're walking around with all of these things fused into your identity, I think that's the point.
- 24:20right is like these get fused into our identities and like an example maybe I didn't make in the book but I make after the fact in an essay is that you know I was a your job title right like the way people earn money fuse with their identity what do you do well I do a lot of things but like usually the answer is how they earn their money and then instantly there's like this
- 24:50I think we're very good at this as people and there's a reason for it.
- 25:15like it are our minds developed or evolved in a much different world than they did today where all of these were threats were actual physical right and you know thinking quick and having snap judgments and the need for belonging saved you like it it allowed you to survive and maybe thrive.
- 25:43Where today the threats are abstract right They institutions As much as the news wants to play it off I don know that our threats are necessarily physical anymore I think they more um psychological you know to be honest and they at least slower moving you know like you you can
- 26:11like you can, you can, you can die because you just continue to eat horribly crappy food for
- 26:17your whole life, but you're, you can still live to 70 and our medical system can, you know,
- 26:23kind of keep you on life support or whatever. Whereas if you had a lion attacking you, uh, you know, 500 years ago, you had an immediate threat that you had to contend with. Those are much further and fewer between.
- 26:36They certainly are.
- 27:06I'm
- 27:36the whole point is freedom,
- 27:38but now you're giving up your freedom.
- 27:42Yeah.
- 27:43It was never really freedom to begin with.
- 27:45It was like freedom as long as I'm sufficiently comfortable.
- 27:49And not that there can't be a balancing act
- 27:52between those things where you say,
- 27:53this thing is an important thing to me.
- 27:56I'm not going to die on the hill though.
- 27:57There are things that I think people have,
- 28:00there's judgment that we have to make
- 28:03on a lot of topics.
- 28:04but I completely agree with you.
- 28:07And that's different for everyone, right?
- 28:08Like, you know, we all have our own lens
- 28:11that we look at the world through
- 28:12and our own circumstance
- 28:13and we can never pretend to walk
- 28:15in somebody else's shoes.
- 28:17So on that same foot though
- 28:19it doesn't do any good to like judge somebody else
- 28:23then for making those decisions
- 28:25if they did honestly weigh the options.
- 28:29You know what I mean?
- 28:30Like just because you don't necessarily
- 28:33think it's a good idea. It doesn't mean it was a bad idea for them if they actually did the research and put the work in. My thought is though, or my fear, and really what I try to do with this book is that it takes constant work. You have to constantly be looking at it. And the machine doesn't change just because you look at it. It's the same mechanisms in all of us over and over.
- 29:03and you can walk away from a party having analyzed 12 people and found projection and all these things in other people but not looked at yourself once.
- 29:17And that's really what this book is asking everyone to do is to actually look at themselves and take a beat.
- 29:25Yeah, that's one of the most interesting things as I've zoomed out on the world because of Bitcoin. One of the things that I talk about a lot and has become most evident to me is what a drug tribalism is.
- 29:42and I think a lot of these beliefs are
- 29:46and I find it in myself, man, because there's a part of me too
- 29:48where I'm doing a lot of things that I genuinely believe
- 29:51and I've thought very deeply about that I want to be doing
- 29:54and I name them. I'm homeschooling my kids.
- 29:57I'm saving my productive value in Bitcoin.
- 30:00I'm opting out of the
- 30:03fiat medical system and sick care system
- 30:06but there's a part of me though where it's like
- 30:10oh I'm buying local
- 30:12food you know from a local farmer
- 30:14I'm like doing all these things and I'm like
- 30:15I think these are all good decisions
- 30:18that I've made but then you also
- 30:20risk being the
- 30:22type of person who is like
- 30:23yeah like I just because I'm a contrarian
- 30:26by nature to some degree so like
- 30:28the tribe that I'm
- 30:30establishing for myself is
- 30:31I'm the guy who just does everything completely
- 30:34differently and I'm not going to do anything
- 30:36that the rest of the world is doing and like that
- 30:38in itself is a tribe and like you
- 30:40you begin to box yourself in to where
- 30:44like I've shared this on the show before like I haven't
- 30:48eaten dessert in four years and so now
- 30:52it's like if I wanted to have dessert I could afford to have dessert
- 30:56but now I'm like I'm the guy who doesn't and so now it's like everyone's going to
- 31:00make a call yeah it's like I've bucketed myself in by like creating this tribe
- 31:04of one or this tribe of just a handful of us who are like the purists you know when it comes to
- 31:08X Y or Z subject And I think that a dangerous place to be as well And you have to think long and hard about the way in which you approach any of these topics or areas of your life
- 31:22We do not operate outside of belonging. We don't. As much as we, at least, okay, I can only speak for
- 31:31myself. I cannot operate outside of belonging. In much of my life, I would, in all aspects,
- 31:39be a lone wolf. I always have been. I was an only child, right? I'm very comfortable being alone,
- 31:49being alone with my thoughts. Even when I used to go out, I used to like going out by myself
- 31:54because I didn't have to worry about anyone else. I could just go have my fun and whatever I got into,
- 32:01I got into. And like you're saying though, that is like its own kind of thing. And now I'm, if I show up with somebody else, like now all of a sudden like, oh, why is Brett here with someone else? That's weird. Like, who is this, who's this girl? Like, and now all of a sudden just into like this whole thing. But like, so the, what you're describing really is the second half
- 32:31of act two and act three of this book. And really what, what, what I, I act one is like, just
- 32:39I'll lay out the machine. This is how your brain kind of works though. The way I see it, it's not like a,
- 32:45a footnoted, um, psychology book. It's an observation of your, your experience of my own
- 32:53machine. Right. And that I think is pretty general, right? Like here, here's some traps.
- 33:00you can fall into. And then what happens when you can't hide from it? And a Bitcoiner I think is going to read it as what happens when you realize the system is F'd. Like what happens? And like living inside of that world with that kind of discomfort and that need to belong and that need for a tribe, but no one around you sees it. Right?
- 33:27And then the third piece is, you know, what is left after you accept it. So it kind of, it's, it's, and it's, it's really is my own journey. Um, like I'm very much in this, this book about, um, you know, just through different anecdotes and whatnot, but, you know, kind of like the, I think the last three are like the will, the truth.
- 33:55then conviction
- 33:58conviction without consensus
- 34:00so when no one around you sees it
- 34:03you gotta be there and then no savior
- 34:06because you're not free from the machine
- 34:09you can't step away from the thing
- 34:12the best you have are being able to notice it
- 34:15and it is its own
- 34:16it's all a cage
- 34:20there's no way you can
- 34:23escape your own mind.
- 34:26Your thoughts determine your reality
- 34:28and you can watch your thoughts
- 34:33and have the...
- 34:36kind of curate your reality that way.
- 34:39But it's all still just a lens
- 34:42we're observing the world through.
- 34:46And kind of just understanding
- 34:48that we are wearing a lens
- 34:51and everything really is perspective.
- 34:53Yeah, it's fascinating, man. I could talk about this stuff just sort of philosophically all day. I want to give our listeners a little bit of, let's sink our teeth into Bitcoin specifically here for a little bit. So you also wrote a book, Bitcoin, Not Crypto, a very different sort of book than The Belief Machine. Could you maybe talk a little bit about, and it sounds to me like that book was sort of the, not to sound critical, but it's more like the real thing.
- 35:23Regurgitation of the why Bitcoin is different
- 35:26which I understand that kind of put you in a pickle
- 35:29with this VP who is talking to you from your company
- 35:31but I think that's a very important book that you have written
- 35:34that people are trying to sort out
- 35:37dude, I have people texting me
- 35:41they know I'm into Bitcoin and they're like, hey, what do you think about XRP?
- 35:44And I'm like, I'm not into XRP, I'm into Bitcoin
- 35:47I don't know why are you even asking me this
- 35:50but it's just obvious confusion. What prompted
- 35:52What wanted you to write that book and what was the general theme?
- 35:55Saylor, Yazbeck Yeah, so it started off as a crypto book. It did. It started off of like, hey, I'm reading all this book. Maybe I can show people I know stuff too. I would call it a performance. And really in the process of writing it, I came to the conclusion
- 36:21that nothing else is Bitcoin and Bitcoin is sound money for a digital age And there nothing else out there like it So really the process of writing for me is very it just evolves
- 36:35I think I had nine drafts of that book and looking at those drafts, it started off like,
- 36:42hey, this is why blockchain technology is going to save the world.
- 36:47And it turned into everything else shitcoin.
- 36:51Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 36:52Yeah, like who cares about all that stuff?
- 36:54Yeah.
- 36:54No, and really like what it allowed me to do is really optimize for clarity and focus my energy on the things that aligned with myself, which was Bitcoin like the whole time.
- 37:08What happened with that book is the argument of why Bitcoin is sound money for a digital age and everything else is trying to be the better, faster version of it. And it's just not. It's just not it. And it gives all the properties of money and Bitcoin and going off the gold standard. And it is. It's exactly a regurgitation.
- 37:38I mean, I think there's some banger lines in it.
- 37:42Yeah, yeah.
- 37:44It sounds like the greatest hits of many of the resources that exist in Bitcoin.
- 37:50It's like you take elements of podcasts you've heard and great Bitcoin books you've read
- 37:55and you condense it and consolidate it into something that people can read and walk away understanding.
- 38:02I understand that you refer to it as somewhat performative.
- 38:05performative. Is it still a book that you're, you're proud of the result and you feel like it's a useful
- 38:10resource? I think that's exactly what it is. It's a, it's a resource. Um, it's not a reflection of you.
- 38:18It's a, it's a, it's a reflection of some of knowledge you had that you wanted to share with
- 38:23the world. Yeah. And so the reason I call it a performance is like, just the reason I did it
- 38:30was to help people. And I wanted people to understand why Bitcoin is different than everything else. Because I noticed everyone around me falling into the same traps as your friend texting you, hey, XRP, bro, it's not even on the same planet. What are we talking about here? And just having so many of those conversations, and I'm like, I'm just going to put it all into a resource. And I think that's the best way to put it.
- 38:59but it doesn't have any soul.
- 39:02And I call it a performance just because
- 39:05really I was just showing I knew this stuff
- 39:09and was able to synthesize it into a digestible manner
- 39:13for somebody else.
- 39:15But it just doesn't have soul.
- 39:18The way this book, The Belief Machine,
- 39:21it kind of picks up where that left off.
- 39:24The Bitcoin Not Crypto was kind of leading up
- 39:27to that dinner in the marina.
- 39:28Vice President and then really the belief machine picks up right there where like it's still like so tell me about this and I'm still doing the thing but then it's kind of like another evolution over following years or whatever of what kind of like how I came to look at this stuff.
- 39:51Yeah, interesting. So what was it for you? Maybe talk a little bit about briefly about your Bitcoin origin story. Like what led you to Bitcoin and what was it that stood out?
- 40:01yeah so I learned I first heard about Bitcoin in 2012 when my poker buddy was mining it right there playing poker he's got GPUs and whatever also like and the dude just hung out and played League of Legends all day it's not in sold weed like whatever so like I didn't think much of it and like he was using it on Silk Road.
- 40:31yeah so that's all I ever thought Bitcoin was throughout most of my my time and then I never looked at and then you know COVID hit and we all had more time whatever I came to it like everyone else did as a number go up thing but then I didn't buy it right away like I didn't like just FOMO in I like researched it a lot and I read all the things before I bought it
- 41:01and that's not like I'm just saying like that's just the way I needed to do it for myself
- 41:08and really what I came to understand is that Bitcoin is about property rights
- 41:13that's how I started to look at it
- 41:15I started to look at Bitcoin is about property rights
- 41:18and it's the only thing that I can own
- 41:21and that's why it became valuable to me
- 41:23I was like there's only 21 million of these things
- 41:26I want to get my chunk of that
- 41:29So I stack what I can, when I can, while I can.
- 41:33And I can't control all the stuff that happens around it.
- 41:39but as long as there's 21 million and I can own it.
- 41:44Yeah.
- 41:45So why were you so...
- 41:48I don't feel like most...
- 41:50I assume you and I are within a few years of each other,
- 41:53same generation.
- 41:55Why most people don't think about...
- 41:58I think about my friends and I think about pre-Bitcoin me.
- 42:03The idea of property rights was probably abstract,
- 42:07very abstract.
- 42:08And I would have said,
- 42:08Oh yeah, we need private property rights in some generic kind of sense. But I don't think it would have been anything that I had thought about. For me, when I got into Bitcoin, it took me a little... I had to begin to... And I still am quite a novice when it comes to macroeconomics and many of these disciplines.
- 42:31But I had to kind of understand the unsustainable path of central banking that we were being robbed from, that I needed something scarce that was, you know, unmanipulable and that. Why for you was it property rights that made it so compelling?
- 42:48Well, that's what it boiled down to. Like all of those things, to me, boiled down to property rights.
- 42:57and the
- 42:59got it and and the thing
- 43:01like the stories that I
- 43:03always like seemed like
- 43:05the value proposition to me
- 43:07like really were like
- 43:09the ability to
- 43:10transfer wealth
- 43:13without the need
- 43:15of an intermediary
- 43:16and without the need
- 43:19of
- 43:20yeah just somebody else
- 43:23in the middle taking their
- 43:25cut
- 43:25Right so like
- 43:28Inflation and you know
- 43:30The silent theft and then like
- 43:32People you know in
- 43:34Other countries who
- 43:35Probably need bitcoin for
- 43:38Significantly different reasons
- 43:40Like those were the stories that I was talking
- 43:42Like people like
- 43:43Refugees or whatever being able to just
- 43:46Take their wealth I'm like oh shit like they
- 43:48Could just like take their entire wealth
- 43:50And move
- 43:52And then as long as they can get on
- 43:54on the internet, it's there.
- 43:56They have it.
- 43:58And for me, those were always the most powerful stories.
- 44:04And the amount of people that are unbanked or underbanked,
- 44:09obviously what caught my attention was number go up.
- 44:14But then as I just kind of worked through it,
- 44:18I just saw once you understand the value of something,
- 44:22you stop letting other people determine its value for you. So like my conviction and my value in Bitcoin is its ability to secure. It's, it's my property. It's the only thing I actually own. I don't, I mean, I own my house, but if I don't pay taxes and I got to get a permit to build a deck, do I really freaking own it? I don't know. Like there's, I think there's, I don't know. I, I get out there.
- 44:52on Bitcoin a little bit,
- 44:54like just as far as like valuing it and fiat
- 44:56and, you know, things like that.
- 44:59Like I just, it doesn't,
- 45:02that's the thing I'm trying to escape.
- 45:03Why would I value that in it?
- 45:07And I, you know, you'll say,
- 45:09people will say,
- 45:09well, we live in a fiat world.
- 45:11Well, we choose to live in a fiat world.
- 45:12We don't necessarily, you know.
- 45:14Right.
- 45:15Everything's a choice in life.
- 45:16It's just your balance of expectations
- 45:19versus reality and how much ease
- 45:20and comfort you want in your life.
- 45:22Yeah, that's a really good point. I think you're hitting on a point too that I really appreciate. So I think you know the Microseed guys, Daniel White and Fritz. One of the things Daniel talks about is Bitcoin is a non-sovereign right of exclusion. And he's like a Bitcoin is property guy. He's less of a monetary maximalist, which is something he and I have had some interesting discussions about.
- 45:52But what I really do appreciate more and more, talking to guys like him, who would disagree with most of the folks at the Bitcoin way, Bitcoin is money, is that we all come to this common conclusion that you have to self-custody it. You have to be a participant in the network. You have to hold the keys. It is not Bitcoin if you don't do those things.
- 46:15and back to your point about the belief machine, it also says something about you and where you're willing to compromise.
- 46:23Where do you draw that line? Unfortunately, I think many people draw the line far too close to safety and far too distant from freedom, honestly, is maybe a way of framing it.
- 46:36It interesting though because I think I hear more people talking about the evils of central banking understanding that inflation is this arbitrary enslavement or most people say theft I think of it as slavery but they acknowledge this evil of central banking and that how they I need to protect my wealth I need to protect the labor that I put into the world What been your experience orange filling people with this message
- 47:12I would say everyone or the vast majority of people I've gotten to
- 47:17one, I don't think you orange people, orange pill people
- 47:20I think they orange pill themselves
- 47:21you just give them the tools to do so
- 47:23I think Bitcoin is something that is internal
- 47:27I think understanding Bitcoin is something, a journey
- 47:30only somebody can do by themselves
- 47:33and I think you can show them the way and give them the tools
- 47:37but ultimately they're the ones who need to swallow the pill
- 47:40and accept what it shows them.
- 47:48Because that's the other piece.
- 47:49I mean, I think you can give them the bill,
- 47:51maybe you can even force feed it,
- 47:52but they have to accept what it shows them.
- 47:56And that's something only an individual can do for themselves.
- 48:02But the vast majority of people who have purchased Bitcoin
- 48:10based on my recommendations have been people who have felt a pinch, right? It's mostly like retired union workers or that are heading into retirement, to be honest. Like, so just in my day job, I was a structural engineer. Now I like inspect construction sites and I just work with union dudes all day and gals to some extent.
- 48:40get women in the trades, I guess, would be,
- 48:43or get people in the trades in general.
- 48:47But all of them are heading in and they see the fact,
- 48:51and it is, it's to the central bank and to the inflation.
- 48:55They have worked their entire lives.
- 48:57They see their pensions and what they're going to get for it.
- 49:02So they're coming to a point where they're finally looking,
- 49:06where they're actually going to come into consequence
- 49:10with their entire life's work and see what it's gotten them.
- 49:17And they get to visualize it.
- 49:19And now they see it's probably not enough.
- 49:24We're going to give them the lifestyle they expected.
- 49:27Right.
- 49:28And that is a very hard thing for some people to look at.
- 49:33And unfortunately, to be honest,
- 49:36The reason why they're buying Bitcoin is so they can get more fiat.
- 49:41Yeah.
- 49:43The same way, you know, I, Bitcoin caught my attention in general.
- 49:48I just wasn't that close to a consequence yet that I had time to like sort through the information and make a little more just a less hasty.
- 49:59I don't want to call it hasty, but, you know, a less like under the gun decision kind of thing.
- 50:04but these guys are like five years away from retirement.
- 50:08And like, the thing is, is they're just,
- 50:11that's why I say like, you can only orange play yourself.
- 50:14I don't see them, at least this cohort,
- 50:18like developing any sort of conviction.
- 50:21I see them having their coins on Coinbase
- 50:25or Robinhood or whatever.
- 50:26And as soon as it gets enough and they retire,
- 50:28they're probably gonna sell.
- 50:31Unfortunately, that's just the way I like,
- 50:34they haven't had it, they haven't internalized Bitcoin. So I would say I have been an absolute failure at orange pilling people. And I think that's a common story though. I feel like not necessarily like all the nuance and details of it, but I think like we convince people like, Hey, this is a good thing. Maybe they see our own demeanor change, I think.
- 51:02and then it causes somebody else to be interested.
- 51:08But until they actually internalize and understand what they hold,
- 51:15to be honest, I think it's just a number-go-up chase.
- 51:19Yeah.
- 51:19I think what it sounds like it ultimately comes back to
- 51:22is this tension of freedom and safety.
- 51:26In the West, in the United States, for example,
- 51:29people feel relatively free.
- 51:32If you ask an American are you free They would say yes And so they don feel a need to pursue freedom so much as they need to pursue safety because safety is a bit more tenuous and it a balancing act constantly where I think a lot of Americans would say well freedom is kind of given to me I inherited as an American I have constitutional rights blah blah blah And I could go all day into that But if you look at someone on the other side of the world who is not free and understands that freedom is something to attain I might need the ability to freely pick up my wealth and carry it with me somewhere completely away from my home because this is not a safe place to be or because at any moment they could confiscate my land they could confiscate my gold
- 52:29they could confiscate whatever
- 52:31there's like this very obvious use case
- 52:34and actually that's part of what I've tried
- 52:36to use to orange, it doesn't work
- 52:37I've tried historically to orange pill people by
- 52:39saying even if you as an
- 52:42American and a relatively
- 52:44financially privileged person do not get Bitcoin
- 52:46it doesn't change the fact that
- 52:475 billion other people
- 52:49will need Bitcoin and that
- 52:52means the number is going to go up and so maybe
- 52:54you should get some if nothing else
- 52:55if you don't want freedom or anything
- 52:57you'll cross that bridge when you realize CBDCs are coming
- 53:01surveillance states growing, the forever wars aren't going to stop
- 53:05you'll eventually be forced to take the orange depository
- 53:09kind of thing
- 53:10but in the meantime, understand that there are billions of other people who really don't care about
- 53:16what's going on in your life, they have an immediate need
- 53:18and when they wake up to what Bitcoin is, all bets are off
- 53:22100%
- 53:23100% agree with you
- 53:26The point I want to make is as an American or whoever, as a free person, one, I would argue that actual freedom is in your mind and that you'd be trapped by any number of things whether or not the government says you're free.
- 53:47right so and I would also argue that if your emotional state is changing with the price action
- 53:55if the numbers up you're up if it's down you're down are you free no you're just
- 54:02you're just yeah you're just in another system um and you know it is the same thing no but it kind
- 54:12I mean, when you're emotionally like getting charged by the way somebody else values the thing, you're not, you're not free at all. You're beholden to the thing. Like you, you are, you like your emotional state is getting determined by something outside of yourself.
- 54:29I agree with you
- 54:32I'm also empathetic to people
- 54:34I'm young enough that if Bitcoin goes to $5,000
- 54:37and my purchasing power is greatly diminished
- 54:40because we do live in a world denominated in fiat
- 54:43I've got time to ride that out
- 54:45I'm empathetic to people who are nearing retirement
- 54:49they're in Bitcoin for all the right reasons
- 54:51and they're like
- 54:52but I still need to make it to the end of my life
- 54:56and hopefully leave something for my family
- 54:58and so I don't want to minimize
- 55:00I'm cautious not to minimize that
- 55:02even though I can be something of a
- 55:04you know, Puritan, toxic
- 55:07Bitcoin Maxi kind of guy
- 55:08that people just have different life
- 55:10circumstances
- 55:11Incredibly fair
- 55:13and absolutely
- 55:14again, you never know what it's like to walk in somebody else's
- 55:19shoes
- 55:19and you know, one to kind of go back
- 55:22back to this book is like
- 55:24I really do try to make that point
- 55:27as well
- 55:27that it's, again, it's really easy to judge
- 55:31other people and your interpretation
- 55:36of their actions, but you really don't know.
- 55:41And you know what?
- 55:42Just watch your own bother.
- 55:44All I can control is myself and my own worldview,
- 55:49and that's what I should really be focusing on,
- 55:52not what makes somebody else happy or unhappy
- 55:56unless there's something I can do to facilitate
- 55:59some happiness there.
- 56:02Yeah, I think that's an astute point.
- 56:04All righty, man.
- 56:05I've got one more question for you,
- 56:07but first, is there anything we haven't covered
- 56:08that you were hoping to
- 56:10or any topics we didn't get into?
- 56:13No.
- 56:14Okay, then my final question.
- 56:16Okay, you ready?
- 56:17What is an unpopular opinion that you have?
- 56:20You get bonus points
- 56:21if you offend some Bitcoiners with it.
- 56:23You know, I think I probably already made it and you pushed back on it. So I don't know if I can make it now, but like-
- 56:33Say it, say it.
- 56:33Well, I think that like denominate, Bitcoin is a peer-to-peer cash system. That's what it is in my mind. I don't think anyone can argue with that. But in a peer-to-peer cash system, the two people in the transaction or whoever's in the transaction are the people who determine the value.
- 56:52Mm-hmm.
- 56:55And so is the unpopular opinion that we're defaulting to a faulty denominator or an assumed denominator?
- 57:07We price the thing in fiat.
- 57:09We price the thing in the exact system that it designed to be parallel to or escape Mm And I don think it even remotely close to the same thing Like I right
- 57:22And then you're a thing that just drives me nuts.
- 57:28And I haven't found a way around this is like, so we have these, I can't price anything in
- 57:33Bitcoin and everyone does it.
- 57:35Right.
- 57:35So I have, I have, you know, books to sell was use that one.
- 57:40Yeah.
- 57:40Nowhere in any of my websites through, you know, BTC pay server or in any website have I ever found where it's not doing a backdoor calculation back to fiat. It drives me right. Like, why can't I set a price at, you know, 40,000 sats and just leave it? Why isn't the price for you? Unit of account is the final boss. And until we overcome that Bitcoin is not money.
- 58:06yes
- 58:08I don't know
- 58:09it's
- 58:12here's the thing man
- 58:14so this is the challenge
- 58:17philosophically
- 58:19I agree with you
- 58:20and practically
- 58:22what people have to do
- 58:25in this world
- 58:27is they have to go turn around and buy things that they need
- 58:29that are
- 58:31denominated in fiat
- 58:32and if
- 58:35if you sell, let's say all you do is sell books to make a living and you sell them for, what's 40,000 sats in fiat terms? I don't even know.
- 58:44But yeah, that's kind of your point. So you get all these thousands and thousands of sats, there's still some, I'm trying to think of how to articulate this because the point that you're making is a valid one.
- 59:00However, because everything else in the world that is needed is denominated in fiat, the exchange rate, practically speaking, matters to some degree.
- 59:13Because you're having to pay for Amazon or wherever you're selling your book, you have to pay for that, you have to pay your website, all in fiat.
- 59:23And so how many sats amount to enough fiat for you to pay those actually makes a difference.
- 59:30makes a tangible difference, even if philosophically you and I can agree like, hey, let's just have this whole thing external. At the end of the day, I have to come back into the fiat world, whether I want to or not, if I want to have a house and if I want to go to the grocery store. I'm working toward building these circular economies where we can denominate in Bitcoin. But even those people who are at the margins of participating, they still have to go step out into the fiat world.
- 1:00:00I don't disagree with you at all and I absolutely get your point.
- 1:00:17But you should have the ability, I think what you're saying to some degree is like, give me the choice, like BTC pay server or whoever. If I don't want to nominate in fiat, let me just completely ignore.
- 1:00:30and opt out of the fiat world and you're not really given that possibility. Is that right?
- 1:00:34Bitcoin isn't there yet. If I, if I can't do those things, right. If I can't go on a, say like, you know, cause you can buy goods and services in Bitcoin. You absolutely can. Right. And even, you know, square terminals, um, you can use your Bitcoin in. I think, I think it's the amount of how far are you willing to go.
- 1:01:00goal for the idea.
- 1:01:01Yeah, I completely agree.
- 1:01:03Because I think with anything,
- 1:01:04there are ways
- 1:01:06you can absolutely do it.
- 1:01:08The adjustment happens
- 1:01:10in what your expectation is
- 1:01:12and your desire for ease
- 1:01:15and comfort in your life.
- 1:01:17You can absolutely live
- 1:01:18on a Bitcoin standard.
- 1:01:20Well, you can absolutely
- 1:01:23live on a Bitcoin standard
- 1:01:24and the question is
- 1:01:25how far are you willing to go?
- 1:01:26So for example,
- 1:01:29if the Bitcoin way
- 1:01:30we operate on a Bitcoin standard. However, we have one expense, at least that I'm aware of that. I mean, we couldn't have our podcast here if I wasn't willing to pay Riverside or StreamYard or someone in fiat. Like they do not accept Bitcoin. We could push for that. But like how much time am I going? And this is sort of that I could probably go bark up that tree all day long and be like, except Bitcoin, except Bitcoin, except Bitcoin. They're probably not going to, but I could say, hey, at least I made a fair effort. So while we operate on a Bitcoin standard, technically there is like an expense.
- 1:02:00where we simply can't.
- 1:02:01But I get paid in Bitcoin,
- 1:02:02we only accept Bitcoin,
- 1:02:04all of our payments to partners
- 1:02:05are made in Bitcoin,
- 1:02:07all of that.
- 1:02:10Again, this is kind of me
- 1:02:12being philosophically aligned with you
- 1:02:14and then trying to be practical
- 1:02:15about the retiree example
- 1:02:16that we were talking about.
- 1:02:18I haven't done this research
- 1:02:23in a little bit.
- 1:02:24I think there aren't any local farmers
- 1:02:26in close proximity
- 1:02:27that can provide me exactly what I want
- 1:02:29that accept Bitcoin.
- 1:02:29I could go spend a lot of time trying to orange bill farmers or I could drive five hours and go pick up once a month food from a local farmer and bring it back perhaps and pay in Bitcoin.
- 1:02:43I've got four kids in a life and property tend to and so practically speaking it just isn't going to happen even though I would love to do that.
- 1:02:51as it inches closer to where, okay, we just gradually try to be the change we want to see in the world. And you and I both make a little bit of progress in our communities. And then there's some other community that's forming. And then we begin to overlap. And now I get access to more Bitcoiners who are selling things that are useful. I think it happens organically without me having to go to the ends of the earth, just because I would love to live on a Bitcoin standard. That's kind of where I sit at the moment.
- 1:03:21Absolutely fair. Like I can't say I would be willing to do that either. But again, the system of Bitcoin in its current state showing us how our actions align with what we believe.
- 1:03:40Yeah, that is, I mean, that's a fair point and actually probably a very good place to wrap up because it brings us, I think, pretty full circle to everything we've talked about. Brett, it's been a blast, man. Thank you so much for the time. Why don't you tell people where they can find the book, follow you, anything else you want to share with them?
- 1:03:57Yeah so you can follow me on xbecause21 B 21 The Belief Machine and Bitcoin Not Crypto are available on Amazon TheBeliefMachine is the website where you can find ideas surrounding The Belief Machine evolving essays from conversations like this just how the ideas surrounding the book evolve You can also order signed copies there
- 1:04:27But I really appreciate your time
- 1:04:30Thank you for having a great conversation with me
- 1:04:32Support everything you do
- 1:04:34And thank you very much
- 1:04:36I appreciate it, Brett
- 1:04:37Great chatting with you
- 1:04:39And we'll be in touch again soon
- 1:04:40Right on
- 1:04:41Thanks
- 1:04:41Cheers, man
- 1:04:42And that's a wrap again
- 1:04:43Hope you enjoyed my conversation with Brett
- 1:04:45Be sure to go check out his book, his website
- 1:04:47Go follow him on X
- 1:04:48Anywhere else you might want to find him
- 1:04:51And of course, if you need help taking your Bitcoin
- 1:04:53Into proper 100% self-custody
- 1:04:55go to thebitcoinway.com slash podcast.
- 1:04:58You can schedule a free 30 minute consult
- 1:04:59with a member of our team.
- 1:05:00We can not only help you with self custody
- 1:05:02and doing it the right way,
- 1:05:03the first time counterparty risk-free,
- 1:05:05100% you control the keys,
- 1:05:07but we also have online privacy,
- 1:05:09privacy phone services.
- 1:05:10We even have a plan B residency option in Panama.
- 1:05:13You're going to want to check that out.
- 1:05:14If you're in many parts of the world
- 1:05:15that are going downhill fast,
- 1:05:17again, that's thebitcoinway.com slash podcast.
- 1:05:20Be sure you're subscribed to the channel.
- 1:05:21Make sure you like this video,
- 1:05:23comment, engage in some way,
- 1:05:24help us speed the algorithm. We would really, really appreciate that. You can also follow us
- 1:05:28on x at the Bitcoin way underscore. I'm there as well at the other M Jordan. And until next time,
- 1:05:34stay safe, stay sovereign. And remember the yield on Bitcoin is freedom.