Latest / Consumerpedia / 67 - Buying Eyewear
Transcript
- 0:02If you need corrective eyewear and three out of four adults in
- 0:05this country do, the choices seem endless, from comfortable
- 0:08contacts to thousands of fashionable frames.
- 0:12Even so, shopping for new specs or contacts can be a major
- 0:15hassle and an expensive purchase.
- 0:18I'm her Weissbaum, the Consumer Man, a contributing editor at
- 0:22checkbook.org. Welcome to Consumerpedia at
- 0:25checkbook.org, where the nonprofit that helps consumers
- 0:28select services, avoid trouble, and save money.
- 0:31Because we don't accept any advertising or take money from
- 0:34any business, we recommend you can rely on checkbook.org to be
- 0:38completely independent and objective.
- 0:40Now here's the host of Consumerpedia America's consumer
- 0:44expert, the consumer man Herb Weissbaum.
- 0:48In this episode, which eyewear stores offer the best advice and
- 0:51service, where to go to find the best prices on glasses and
- 0:55contact lenses, and who should you see to get your eye exam?
- 0:59Here to help bring all of that into Focus?
- 1:01Checkbook's Executive Editor Kevin Brassler.
- 1:04Hello, we're getting her. You know, buying glasses or
- 1:06contacts seems like a fairly straightforward process, but
- 1:09it's. Really very complicated.
- 1:11Just because of the way the industry is structured and all
- 1:14the things you got to do. Yeah, there are just so many
- 1:16conflicts of interest in the world of vision care and I, I
- 1:19think most patients are unaware of them.
- 1:20You know, most consumers don't know this, but there's one huge
- 1:23mega corporation out there that controls most of the eyeglasses
- 1:28frames industry. Plus, with contact lenses, I
- 1:31mean, there are huge price differences for the exact same
- 1:34products. And we found that most vision
- 1:37insurance plans strangely don't necessarily align with the least
- 1:41expensive options. So there's just a lot of sketchy
- 1:44stuff going on in this industry. And it's a business that serves
- 1:47an important health care need for most of us.
- 1:49Most of us need glasses or contacts.
- 1:51So let's start with the biggest problem you mentioned the lack
- 1:53of competition. There's a massive Italian
- 1:56company, Essilora Lazotica, that now controls most of the vision
- 2:00industry here in the US. Yeah.
- 2:02So I mean, it seems like there's healthy competition out there
- 2:05for eyewear, right? I mean there are dozens of
- 2:07different major chains, big box retailers like Target and Costco
- 2:12and Walmart, they sell a lot of eyeglass frames.
- 2:15Each of these different chains and stores sell difference of
- 2:18brands of glasses and hundreds of different models of frames at
- 2:21some of these stores. But really all that variety is
- 2:24mostly an illusion. As you mentioned, Esler
- 2:27Luxottica controls most of the trade.
- 2:30It is bought up mini eyewear brands outright.
- 2:34For example, it owns Ray Ban and Purcell, two major manufacturers
- 2:38of eyeglasses frames. It also acquired the licensing
- 2:42rights to make most of the frames for major designers.
- 2:45So that includes Armani and Brooks Brothers, Burberry,
- 2:49Bulgari, Chanel, Coach, Dolce and Cabana, Oakley, Ralph
- 2:54Lauren, Prada, Tiffany, and on and on.
- 2:56Oh. That's a lot of big names, but
- 2:58that's not all. They also own a huge chunk of
- 3:01the eyewear stores that we go to.
- 3:03Yeah, they're manufacturing most of the frames that are available
- 3:06to us, but they also own a lot of the stores that are selling
- 3:09them to us. So even though the name Esler
- 3:12Luxottica doesn't show up on their signs, when you go into a
- 3:15Four Eyes chain store or LensCrafters or Pearl Vision or
- 3:19even Sunglass Hut, even the optical departments at Target
- 3:23and several other big chains, you're actually shopping at a
- 3:26space or a store that this big manufacturer, right, owns or
- 3:30controls. And, you know, it's like that
- 3:32wasn't enough for them. Luxottica also has bought up the
- 3:36world's largest maker of prescription eyeglasses lenses.
- 3:39It also makes many of the contact lenses that are out
- 3:42there and in recent years it even bought up several vision
- 3:45insurance companies. So it's making most of the
- 3:48frames. It owns the stores that sells a
- 3:51lot of the frames out there and now it's it owns companies that
- 3:54make the lenses for them and even the insurance companies.
- 3:56So in reality, there's an illusion of competition in the
- 3:59marketplace that really doesn't exist.
- 4:01Right. So when you're in a store and
- 4:03trying to decide what to buy, in many cases, in many stores, all
- 4:08of the options are available were made by Luxottica.
- 4:11But you just don't know that because there's all these
- 4:13different brands, and many of them are designer brands.
- 4:16So if you're looking at, you know, a nice looking pair of
- 4:18Marc Jacobs frames, you know, they were made by Luxottica.
- 4:21And the weird thing is they were likely made in the same factory
- 4:24and maybe even on the same day as a nearly identical pair of
- 4:28frames that might cost only $60. The problem is it's not as if
- 4:33the sales staff of that store are necessarily going to point
- 4:36that out to you. They're not going to say, well,
- 4:37actually, you know, these frames were made in the same factory by
- 4:40the same company. You know, they just put a
- 4:42different label on the designer ones.
- 4:44And they're also not going to tell you probably, hey, you can
- 4:47go to Target and buy the same frames from the same company
- 4:49that made them and essentially get the same thing for a lot
- 4:53less money, you know, again, at a store that's owned by the same
- 4:56company because Luxottica owns the Target optical outlets.
- 5:00And as usual, when competition disappears, the consumer pays
- 5:03more. Bingo, right?
- 5:04I mean, you know, consumers don't know that instead of
- 5:07paying hundreds of dollars for a pair of designer frames that
- 5:10they can pay a heck of a lot less just by simply to moving to
- 5:13a different section of that store, right?
- 5:15Just going to the other side and looking at the generic frames
- 5:18that they're essentially going to get what came out of the same
- 5:21factory. And it's really a big problem
- 5:24that Luxottica is allowed to continue to buy up all its
- 5:27competitors. I mean, that's really alarming.
- 5:29It already owned pretty much all the factories that are making
- 5:32frames and most of the retailers, and now they're
- 5:35buying up the places that make the lenses to go with those
- 5:38frames and even the, you know, our vision insurance companies.
- 5:41So what does Lazonica have to say about all this?
- 5:44So Luxottica says, well, there's still healthy competition out
- 5:47there because, you know, its main rivals, at least in the US,
- 5:50are Walmart and Costco. And, and, and that's true.
- 5:53I mean those two companies sell a lot of eyeglasses.
- 5:56So I really urged consumers though to use non Luxottica
- 6:00owned stores instead of the big chains that are owned by
- 6:02Luxottica. And one reason is, is that when
- 6:05we shopped prices at hundreds of different eyewear stores in each
- 6:08of our seven metro areas where we published Checkbook, we found
- 6:11that Costco was really the big winner for price.
- 6:14And it also gets pretty good ratings from its customers for
- 6:18things like quality of advice and other customer service
- 6:20categories. We found that many of the big
- 6:23chains owned by Luxottica get really poor ratings.
- 6:26And so overall, I think you do better shopping at a non
- 6:29Luxottica outlet, either at a discount place like Costco or by
- 6:33going to an independent store that you know that most of the
- 6:36stuff they're selling might be made by Luxottica, but they
- 6:39might, you know, provide better advice on what to buy.
- 6:41So are there any other companies trying to cut into Luxottica is
- 6:44market dominance? Warby Parker is a name that'll
- 6:47be familiar to many of our listeners that comes to mind.
- 6:50How about them? So it and a few others started
- 6:52out as online only eyewear stores and they still offer
- 6:56stuff online. Warby Parker and a few similar
- 6:58companies. They now operate brick and
- 7:00mortar spots. Also, we found that Warby
- 7:02Parker's prices are quite low. I mean, most of its frames and
- 7:05lenses cost only $95, and it sells stylish frames.
- 7:10And, and like Costco, it got pretty good ratings from its
- 7:14customers that we surveyed for things like advice and customer
- 7:16service. But these companies really
- 7:19aren't yet making, you know, a big dent in Luxottica's
- 7:21dominance. And, and I doubt they ever will,
- 7:24I mean, the only way to describe Luxottica right now is as a
- 7:27monopoly. I mean, it really does control
- 7:29the industry and it often misleads customers into spending
- 7:32more than they need to. So.
- 7:34Before you go shopping, you may need to get an eye exam.
- 7:36And up next, we're going to talk to Kevin about where to go.
- 7:39To get. That exam, I'm her Weissbaum,
- 7:41and this is. Consumerpedia, powered by
- 7:43checkbook.org. Looking to get glasses or
- 7:46contacts? Checkbook has ratings for
- 7:49hundreds of opticians and optometrists in and around these
- 7:52seven cities, Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Seattle, San
- 7:57Francisco, Minneapolis, Saint Paul, and Washington DC.
- 8:00If you live in or around one of these seven cities and haven't
- 8:03joined Checkbook yet, get a free 30 day subscription to all of
- 8:06our ratings by going to checkbook.org/consumer Pedia.
- 8:12You can't buy prescription lenses without a prescription,
- 8:15so you may need to see an eye doctor for that, Right, Kevin?
- 8:18Right. So you likely won't be able to
- 8:19buy new eyeglasses unless you've had a vision exam done within
- 8:23the last year. The same is true for buying
- 8:25contacts. But for them, your prescription
- 8:28will also need to include the measurements from a fitting test
- 8:31to determine the right size of lenses that you need to buy.
- 8:34And that fitting test usually costs extra.
- 8:37Two types of providers do eye exams.
- 8:40The first type is an ophthalmologist, so these are
- 8:43physicians. They went to medical school and
- 8:45then they received additional training to become eye
- 8:48specialists. The other type that can do
- 8:50vision tests, optometrists. To become a licensed
- 8:53optometrist, you got to go to college and then do a graduate
- 8:56program. Both these types are properly
- 8:59referred to as doctors, but just keep in mind that
- 9:02ophthalmologists are M DS. There's also a profession called
- 9:06opticians. These are the folks that help
- 9:08patients pick out the right frames for them.
- 9:10They do measurements to make sure that, you know, our optical
- 9:13focus points get lined up and things like that.
- 9:16They do, you know, post purchase adjustments to make sure the fit
- 9:19is good on your glasses. But opticians aren't doctors,
- 9:22and in many states, you know, there aren't really even any
- 9:24requirements for them to have specific training.
- 9:27So is there any reason to choose one type of eye doctor over the
- 9:31other? I think as as with any consumer
- 9:33service, no matter what training and credentials the the service
- 9:36provider has, you know some are great at what they do and some
- 9:39suck. Good ophthalmologist and
- 9:41optometrist. They'll conduct accurate vision
- 9:43tests and provide solid advice on what to do next if you need
- 9:47glasses or contacts. If you need a new eye doctor and
- 9:51you've had some eye related medical issues, I think it's
- 9:54probably better to see an ophthalmologist.
- 9:56Although, you know, again, optometrists, they can treat
- 9:59simple eye problems too. And you know, I've been using
- 10:01the same optometrist for for more than 25 years now and she's
- 10:05great. And I haven't just used her to
- 10:07get eye exams done, I've seen her for other eye related
- 10:09problems. I think if you already wear
- 10:12glasses or contacts and you just need a new prescription so that
- 10:16you can go and buy more stuff, then it probably doesn't matter
- 10:20really. You know where you go, but if
- 10:22your vision has changed as you want to get an accurate
- 10:25prescription, but you don't want to get over treated.
- 10:28I've, I've been told by several eye doctors the a lot of their
- 10:31patients, you know, they kind of get stuck in between
- 10:33prescription levels. That's happened to me and it's
- 10:36better to under correct their eyesight a bit rather than over
- 10:40corrected because if you get over corrected your eyes can get
- 10:43used to that new prescription and it kind of creates this
- 10:45domino effect where you just need a stronger and stronger
- 10:48prescription over several years. You know One Stop shopping is
- 10:51convenient, so should you buy your glasses or contacts from
- 10:54your eye doctor? Kevin tackles that one next.
- 10:56I'm her Weissbaum, the Consumer man, and you're listening to
- 10:59Consumerpedia powered by. Checkbook.org.
- 11:03Consumerpedia Fast Facts Eyeglasses have existed in one
- 11:08form or another for centuries. Ancient Roman scholars and
- 11:11medieval monks used to blow glass to magnify manuscripts.
- 11:15Ben Franklin is credited with inventing bifocals in 1784.
- 11:19He got tired of switching eyeglasses to help his near or
- 11:22far vision. Would you spend $55,000 on a
- 11:25pair of glasses? That's how much the Golden Wood
- 11:27Prestige glasses handcrafted in Luxembourg will say get back.
- 11:31The frames feature a combination of 18 karat gold, precious wood
- 11:35and Buffalo horn with diamond studded accents.
- 11:40Many eye doctors sell contacts and glasses or have financial
- 11:43interest in an optical shop next door or are employed by that
- 11:46business next door. It's convenient.
- 11:48But Kevin, is it a smart move? Yeah.
- 11:50So, yeah, many states have laws that basically prevent eye
- 11:54doctors from selling glasses or contacts, or they prevent an
- 11:58optical store, a place that's selling glasses and contacts,
- 12:01from employing an optometrist or an ophthalmologist.
- 12:04There's usually like kind of loopholes here, right?
- 12:06Like, you know, they can't employ one, but there can be an
- 12:09outfit next door and there still might be a financial
- 12:11relationship between those two places.
- 12:13I've seen a lot of, you know, optical shops and states that
- 12:16don't allow these relationships where you can get your vision
- 12:19tested next door. You just have to kind of go out
- 12:21in the mall and come in a different door first.
- 12:24You know, this raises some big questions.
- 12:26I mean, one of the reasons these states have these laws is
- 12:28because of conflicts of interest, right?
- 12:30I mean, do some eye doctors prescribe eyewear that's not
- 12:33needed? Or do they suggest patients need
- 12:36new glasses with a different prescription than what they have
- 12:38now and they really don't need the stronger prescription?
- 12:41Do some of these places, do they push more expensive contacts
- 12:45when cheaper ones will do because they want to increase
- 12:47their sales and their profits? You know, another big problem is
- 12:51it's not really well documented, is that many eye doctors don't
- 12:54provide their patients with their vision prescriptions.
- 12:57Instead, they simply refer their patients to the sales staff and
- 13:00their eye word apartments or the place next door.
- 13:03And that's a problem because it makes the patient think that
- 13:05they can't shop around for better prices.
- 13:08And that's really important there.
- 13:09Is a federal. Regulation that requires all eye
- 13:13doctors provide their patients with their vision prescriptions
- 13:16and specs for contact lenses without even having to be asked.
- 13:20But many doctors, as we know, still don't do that.
- 13:23That's a problem. Yeah.
- 13:24And the keywords there are is they have to do it by law.
- 13:28They have to give you your prescription without you asking
- 13:31for it. They're supposed to
- 13:32automatically do it, and a lot of them still don't.
- 13:35It's very frustrating. I wear contacts and I have to go
- 13:39in for a vision test once a year.
- 13:41And again, I love my eye doctor, she's great, But I never buy my
- 13:45contacts from them. I mean, they just charge prices
- 13:47that are double what I can pay online.
- 13:49We'll talk about that in a minute.
- 13:51But I've often had to ask her staff to print out and give me
- 13:55my prescription when I check out.
- 13:57They're not just handing it to me automatically as they're
- 14:00supposed to do. And we know this happens way too
- 14:02often. It's not just my eye doctor.
- 14:04It happens so often that it's clearly a strategy by some of
- 14:07these stores, you know, and some of these doctors to keep the
- 14:10sale. It used to be that especially
- 14:13for contact lenses that eye doctors, you know, they argue
- 14:16that dispensing the contacts, selling their patients the
- 14:18contacts was part of their service because they weren't
- 14:21just giving their patients a prescription and a set of
- 14:24contacts. There were a lot of services
- 14:25involved, especially for patients who were new to
- 14:28contacts. You know, they may have, you
- 14:29know, a lot of times, for example, maybe not been happy
- 14:31with the brand they got and so it was easier to return them and
- 14:35they could get a different brand if you're doing that
- 14:37transactional in the same place. And a lot of patients who are
- 14:40new to contacts need help with instructions on putting them in.
- 14:43But still, you know, the federal law now is very clear.
- 14:46They have to give us our prescriptions without us asking
- 14:49for them. And the reason we should get
- 14:51them that way is because we should do some shopping around.
- 14:54So if you're new to wearing contacts, it probably makes
- 14:57sense to buy from your eye doctor or their affiliated
- 14:59office so you can get the best advice and care and follow.
- 15:02Up. Yeah, I think it makes sense at
- 15:03least to buy, you know, the first few months supply from
- 15:06your eye doctor because again, they are offering this service
- 15:10that you're not going to get if somebody just ships you contacts
- 15:12and you don't have any experience putting them in your
- 15:15eyes. So I think that makes sense.
- 15:17But if you've, as I have been using the same brand and have
- 15:21had the same prescription for many, many years and have
- 15:24decades of experience putting in contacts and taking them out,
- 15:27you don't really need that service from your eye doctor.
- 15:30And you for sure don't need to pay two to three times as much
- 15:33as what you can pay by buying them online.
- 15:36So how much can we save by buying at Costco or online?
- 15:39Our undercover shoppers collected prices for more than a
- 15:41dozen models of frames, plus lenses from hundreds of local
- 15:45shops plus online retailers. We also collected prices for a
- 15:50year's supply of contact lenses for six different brands.
- 15:55So for frames, we found that some online eyewear stores, you
- 15:59know, they're selling stuff that, you know, the same frames,
- 16:01the exact same frames and lenses compared to the big chains that
- 16:05are, you know, it's like 1/5 the cost.
- 16:07For example, one popular model of eyeglasses frames, we found
- 16:11that some local stores were selling it for, you know, six
- 16:13times more than the best price we could find online.
- 16:17I think if you want to shop in person, overall we found that
- 16:20Costco had the best prices among local stores and also Warby
- 16:25Parker, even though it's offering completely different
- 16:28products than what most other stores are selling.
- 16:30It's only selling its own stuff, but it also has very low prices.
- 16:34So based on what Checkbook found, it seems like the best
- 16:36place to shop for contacts is online.
- 16:39Just don't assume all online stores sell at the same price.
- 16:42You want the best deal, you got to shop around online as well,
- 16:45correct? That's true, yeah.
- 16:46You know, we found that overall that the lowest prices we could
- 16:49find were online. But among all the different
- 16:52online sellers, there was still a lot of price variation, you
- 16:55know, so for example, 1800 contacts, I mean, it advertises
- 16:59really heavily out there. It had lower prices than most
- 17:03local stores did for contacts, but it did not have lower prices
- 17:07than Costco. And its prices for a year supply
- 17:10for most of the different brands of contacts we looked at were
- 17:13hundreds of dollars higher than the lowest, lowest priced online
- 17:17stores. And we found that, you know,
- 17:19historically the big winner on price if you want to shop online
- 17:22for contacts is an outfit called contactlensking.com.
- 17:28Its prices usually are the lowest for most brands of
- 17:31contacts. If you want to shop at a local
- 17:33store, Costco tends to have the lowest prices for contact
- 17:37lenses. It is a very confusing process,
- 17:40but if you want to get the right product for you and at a good
- 17:43price, you really got to take the time to shop around.
- 17:45You really do. And I think this is one of those
- 17:47situations where you really need to put yourself in a position
- 17:50where you can trust the advice you're being given because as we
- 17:53mentioned at the top, I mean, there's just a lot of conflicts
- 17:56in this industry. And often those conflicts aren't
- 17:59obvious. It's not obvious that the
- 18:01salespeople to store steering you toward a designer brand.
- 18:04That's the same thing as the stuff across the store that, you
- 18:07know, it looks attractive. It looks like, oh, I think, you
- 18:09know, buying a designer frame will mean I'll get better
- 18:12quality merchandise. And that's not necessarily the
- 18:14true at all when it comes to eyeglass frames.
- 18:17Well. Hopefully you've cleared up a
- 18:19lot of things for a lot of people and if not put on the
- 18:22record, I can see clearly now by Johnny Nash and you'll feel a
- 18:24whole lot. Better about everything.
- 18:26Kevin. Thank you so much.
- 18:27Thank you, Herb. You'll find much more
- 18:29information about eyeglasses and contact lenses on checkbook.org,
- 18:34including tips on how to select eyeglasses and choosing the
- 18:37right type of contact lenses. Plus for subscribers,
- 18:41checkbooks, ratings of opticians and optometrists in the seven
- 18:44cities we cover. And with that, we come to the
- 18:47end of another episode. We hope you'll rate it for us
- 18:49and follow us on Apple Podcast, Spotify, or wherever you listen
- 18:53to your podcast. Remember, we release new
- 18:56episodes every other Thursday. Another way you can support this
- 19:00show is to follow us on Consumerpedia on Facebook and
- 19:03Instagram and at my Consumerpedia on X, formerly
- 19:06Twitter. I'm Herb Weissbaum.
- 19:09Thank you for listening. Consumerpedia is a public
- 19:12service of checkbook.org. We're a unique nonprofit that
- 19:15helps you save money and make smarter choices.
- 19:17You can count on Checkbook to help you find the best services
- 19:20and avoid the worst with local ratings that are accurate and
- 19:24unbiased. If you live in or around these
- 19:26seven cities and haven't joined Checkbook yet, check us out
- 19:30Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Seattle, San Francisco,
- 19:34Minneapolis, Saint Paul, and Washington DC.
- 19:36To get your free 30 day subscription, go to
- 19:39checkbook.org/consumerpedia. If you like what you've heard,
- 19:43we hope you'll become a supporter by using the link at
- 19:45the bottom of the show notes to make a small contribution each
- 19:48month. Consumerpedia.
- 19:50Empowering consumers to save money and make smarter choices.