Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Mediating Tenant/Landlord Habitability Cases
Transcript
- 0:02Good afternoon, and welcome to mediating tenant
- 0:05and landlord habitability cases. I am Elizabeth
- 0:13Dryden, co -chair of the Beverly Hills Bar Association's
- 0:16real estate section and a partner in Glazer -Wiles
- 0:18real estate department. Beverly Hill Bar Association
- 0:21members are invited to join the real estate section
- 0:24meeting via Zoom at 3 p .m. on Thursday, July
- 0:2730th. The meeting is open to all Beverly Hill
- 0:30Bar Association members, whether or not they
- 0:32are members of the real estate section. We hope
- 0:34to see you there. I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:37our speaker today, Andrew Wesley. Andrew is a
- 0:40full -time mediator with Signature Resolution,
- 0:43where he handles complex landlord -tenant business
- 0:46and employment disputes. He brings 40 years of
- 0:50legal and dispute resolution experience, and
- 0:53since 2020, he has mediated and settled hundreds
- 0:56of cases, many of them emotionally charged. Before
- 1:00turning to mediation full -time, he spent decades
- 1:03as a trial lawyer and advocate for housing justice
- 1:05in California. He's the co -author of California
- 1:09Landlord Tenant Litigation, a leading practice
- 1:11guide from Lexix Nexus, and he writes regularly
- 1:14for San Francisco Apartment Magazine. He's also
- 1:17a longtime volunteer with the AIDS Legal Referral
- 1:20Panel, which has recognized him twice for his
- 1:23pro bono work. Now let's get started and turn
- 1:26it over to you, Andrew. Thank you, Elizabeth.
- 1:30Welcome, everyone. I'm Andrew Wesley, and welcome
- 1:33to today's webinar on mediating tenant landlord
- 1:38habitability cases. Next slide, please. Yes,
- 1:44I am a full -time mediator with signature resolution.
- 1:48And before that, I was a litigator for 40 years,
- 1:52and these types of cases were my specialty. Also,
- 1:57I was a settlement judge with the San Francisco
- 1:59Superior Court Settlement Judge Pro Tem handling
- 2:03the settlement calendar on these kinds of cases.
- 2:08Through all of these lenses, as a litigator,
- 2:10an author, now as a full -time mediator, I've
- 2:14watched these kinds of habitability disputes
- 2:17evolve into some of the most complex, high stakes,
- 2:21and financially volatile cases in civil practice.
- 2:25And so I'm going to bring some insight, hopefully,
- 2:29to the table. And let me give you a roadmap of
- 2:35what we're going to cover today. Our goal of
- 2:39the next hour is to unpack habitability disputes
- 2:44from the specific perspective of resolution.
- 2:50We'll break it down into three sections. If we
- 2:53can maybe go back on the slide three. Yes, thanks.
- 2:56We'll break it down into three sections. We'll
- 3:00cover the legal landscape, which will include
- 3:03the statutory and common law framework that establishes
- 3:07liability. Then we'll jump into damages and math.
- 3:13Why do these numbers escalate so dramatically?
- 3:17We'll talk about local rent -controlled ordinances
- 3:20and mandatory trebling. And then we'll jump into
- 3:24the mediation room. We'll talk about the practical
- 3:28obstacles, specifically insurance gaps, asymmetric
- 3:33risks, and emotional volatility that we need
- 3:39to navigate to get the cases settled. If you
- 3:43have any questions in the Q &A button, which
- 3:46I think you find in your Zoom panel under the
- 3:48More label, You can add your questions there
- 3:53as we go. It gets a little bit kind of wonky
- 3:57to address them along the way, so we'll turn
- 4:01to those at the end. Great. Let's dive into the
- 4:05legal landscape and take a look at slide number
- 4:09four here. To understand how to resolve a habitability
- 4:13case, we first have to look at the landlord's
- 4:17baseline legal duties. In California, every residential
- 4:22rental agreement includes an implied warranty
- 4:25of habitability. Here's what to know. This isn't
- 4:30something landlords can opt out of. The implied
- 4:34warranty of habitability imposes an absolute
- 4:37obligation to maintain the leased premises in
- 4:41a habitable condition throughout the entire duration
- 4:45of the lease term. The warranty of habitability
- 4:48is codified in Civil Code Section 1941. The standard
- 4:54for a breach relies on the existence of substantial
- 4:59defective conditions, and Civil Code Section
- 5:041941 .1 sets out the explicit objective minimum
- 5:10characteristics required for a residential dwelling
- 5:14unit to be deemed fit for human occupancy. 1941
- 5:19.1 includes such things as effective waterproofing
- 5:23and weather protection, plumbing and gas facilities
- 5:27that conform to applicable law, heating facilities,
- 5:32electrical lighting. There are quite a few things
- 5:36listed there. Let's turn to slide five. Beyond
- 5:42the strict contract based statutory mandate,
- 5:47we've got the tort side of the equation. Negligence.
- 5:52Civil Code Section 1714 is California's fundamental
- 5:57tort statute, which dictates that everyone is
- 6:01responsible for injuries caused to another by
- 6:05their want of ordinary care or skill in the management
- 6:09of his or her property or person. A landlord
- 6:13owes a tenant a duty of reasonable care to provide
- 6:17and maintain the premises in a safe condition.
- 6:21To evaluate whether a landlord acted as a reasonable
- 6:24person under the circumstances, courts and by
- 6:29extension mediators and attorneys have got to
- 6:33weigh the likelihood of injury, the probable
- 6:37seriousness of that injury, the financial and
- 6:40practical burden of reducing or avoiding the
- 6:44risk and the degree of control the landlord actually
- 6:48maintained over the risk -creating defects. You'll
- 6:51see on all of these slides in brown case citations,
- 6:57statutory citations, and sometimes jury instruction
- 7:03references. Those are all there for your benefit.
- 7:07They support all of the propositions that are
- 7:10covered in the slides. Let's turn to slide six.
- 7:17When evaluating risk at the mediation table,
- 7:20the defense needs to consider evidence code 669,
- 7:25the doctrine of negligence per se. A landlord's
- 7:30failure to exercise due care is legally presumed
- 7:35if the following elements are met. The landlord
- 7:39violated a statute, ordinance, or public regulation.
- 7:44The violation proximately caused death or injury
- 7:48to a person or property. The injury resulted
- 7:53from an occurrence that the statute or ordinance
- 7:56was specifically designed to prevent, and the
- 8:00plaintiff belongs to the class of persons the
- 8:04law was adopted to protect. Can the presumption
- 8:08be beaten? Yes, but it requires the landlord
- 8:12to prove that they did what might reasonably
- 8:15be expected of a person of ordinary prudence
- 8:19acting under similar circumstances who actively
- 8:24desired to comply with the law. It's often a
- 8:27very steep uphill climb in front of a jury, but
- 8:31definitely accomplishable. Let's turn to slide
- 8:35seven. Two critical defense concepts frequently
- 8:41debated in mediation are notice and the opportunity
- 8:46to repair. Let's talk about notice. The tenant
- 8:51must establish in order to prove liability that
- 8:55the landlord knew or should have known of the
- 8:58defect, meaning either actual or constructive
- 9:03notice. We'll talk about these concepts and specific
- 9:09case examples in a couple of minutes. Next slide,
- 9:13slide eight. Let's talk about a landlord's opportunity
- 9:18to remediate. There's a fascinating tension in
- 9:22California case law here. Cases like Paviani
- 9:27list a quote unquote reasonable time to correct
- 9:33the deficiency," unquote, as an express element
- 9:37of a habitability claim. However, the Supreme
- 9:41Court, in the Knight case, held that at least
- 9:46in the context of an eviction defense, a breach
- 9:50of the implied warranty exists regardless of
- 9:55whether the landlord had a reasonable time to
- 9:58repair it once they had notice. Consider the
- 10:02following example. A Maine sewer line backs up
- 10:06into a tenant's apartment on a Friday afternoon.
- 10:10The tenant immediately texts the landlord. The
- 10:14landlord responds instantly, calls three plumbers.
- 10:17None can get there until Monday morning. The
- 10:21tenant leaves to stay at a hotel, refuses to
- 10:24pay rent for the month, claiming immediate breach.
- 10:28The defense will walk into mediation. citing
- 10:31the Paviani case, screaming, we acted in good
- 10:34faith. Two days over a weekend is not a reasonable
- 10:38opportunity to repair. The plaintiff will fire
- 10:42back with the Knight case. The moment that raw
- 10:45sewage hit the floor, the unit was uninhabitable.
- 10:49Our obligation to pay rent is suspended instantly,
- 10:53regardless of your weekend plumber search. Let's
- 10:56go one step further. The tenants previously had
- 11:00two sewer line backups. And this time, the third
- 11:02time, the tenant says, enough is enough. They
- 11:06declare a constructive eviction, turn in the
- 11:08keys, and sue. Did the tenant overreact? The
- 11:13tenant will argue three backups is too many.
- 11:16No reasonable tenant should be expected to live
- 11:18through this. But Linda will argue that the tenant
- 11:22overreacted. My job as a mediator is to show
- 11:26how both sides face real trial risk on the simple
- 11:29issue of timing and a landlord's obligation or
- 11:34non -obligation to have an opportunity to remediate.
- 11:39Next slide, please. To round out our legal landscape,
- 11:44let's look at three boundary lines that set limitations
- 11:48around a landlord's liability. Boundary line
- 11:53number one, tenant fault. Under Civil Code 1941
- 11:58.2, if the tenant caused the uninhabitable condition
- 12:03through their own negligence, abuse, or improper
- 12:07use, the landlord has an absolute defense to
- 12:11the habitability claim. Consider the following
- 12:14example. A tenant sues for severe toxic molds
- 12:19in the bathroom and bedroom. and presents medical
- 12:22bills for asthma flare -ups. During an inspection,
- 12:26it's revealed that the Senate has stacked boxes
- 12:28of old newspapers and clothes tightly against
- 12:31every exterior wall, completely blocking airflow.
- 12:36The Senate also routinely runs a portable humidifier
- 12:39in a room with a window shut tight. Under Civil
- 12:43Code 1941 .2, the Senate has an obligation to
- 12:47keep the premises clean and sanitary. When I
- 12:50get a case like this, I ask the plaintiff, how
- 12:53do you think a jury is going to react when the
- 12:55defense shows photos of your floor -to -ceiling
- 12:57newspaper stacks blocking the vents? And then
- 13:00I ask the landlord, even with the tenant's lifestyle,
- 13:04did you ever send a cleanup notice or offer to
- 13:07install a passive vent? It shifts the room from
- 13:10an all or nothing legal battle to a realistic
- 13:13percentage of fault negotiation. Slide 10, please.
- 13:19Boundary line number two on a landlord's liability.
- 13:25No strict liability. It's vital to rebind plaintiffs.
- 13:29California does not impose strict liability on
- 13:34landlords for injuries caused by premises defects.
- 13:39Next slide, please. And finally, boundary line
- 13:43number three on a landlord's liability. Once
- 13:47a tenant takes possession of the private living
- 13:50space, the landlord's general duty of continuous
- 13:54inspection within that unit suspends. Hold on
- 13:59a minute. I know there's a lot of pushback against
- 14:02that. There are exceptions which trigger a landlord's
- 14:06duty to inspect during the course of the tenancy.
- 14:11One example would be substantial conditions which
- 14:15exists at the commencement of the tenancy. That
- 14:18might trigger a landlord's duty to inspect after
- 14:21the tenancy commences. A landlord's actual or
- 14:25constructive knowledge of a problem might also
- 14:29trigger a landlord's duty to inspect. In fact,
- 14:33it generally does trigger that. When a landlord
- 14:37is found to have a duty to inspect after the
- 14:41tenancy commences, This only charges the landlord
- 14:44with what a reasonable inspection would have
- 14:46disclosed. Consider this example. A roof has
- 14:51a slow hidden leak in the attic. Over two years,
- 14:55the drywall in the tenant's bedroom ceiling slowly
- 14:58weakens, but does not show any visible water
- 15:01stains. One night, the ceiling collapses on the
- 15:05sleeping tenant. The landlord's argument? Add
- 15:08no duty to inspect. I haven't been inside that
- 15:11bedroom in two years. I didn't want to disrupt
- 15:15the tenants' right to quiet enjoyment. The tenants'
- 15:18argument? You had a duty because the roof is
- 15:21a common area and a reasonable inspection of
- 15:24the roof and attic would have revealed dry rot.
- 15:29This highlights the conflict between tenants
- 15:32and landlords even on such a simple issue as
- 15:36duty to inspect. Next slide, please. Slide 12.
- 15:42Exculpatory clauses. Dead on arrival. Landlords
- 15:46often try to point to lease terms where tenants
- 15:49supposedly waive their rights to sue. But under
- 15:53California Civil Code 1668 and the An -Rui case,
- 15:59exculpatory clauses are entirely invalid as against
- 16:03public policy. Furthermore, Civil Code 1953 -85
- 16:09explicitly voids any residential lease waiver
- 16:14executed after 1976 that attempts to modify or
- 16:19waive the landlord's legally imposed duty of
- 16:22care. Next slide, please. Now that we've covered
- 16:29habitability rules, let's look at adjacent claims
- 16:32that almost always accompany these lawsuits.
- 16:36Those are quiet enjoyment, constructive eviction,
- 16:39and wrongful eviction. Let's talk about the covenant
- 16:43of quiet enjoyment, which is codified in Civil
- 16:47Code 1927. Every lease carries an implied covenant
- 16:53that the tenant will not be disturbed in their
- 16:55possession by the landlord's actions or inactions.
- 17:00Whether express or implied, This covenant means
- 17:03that a tenant must not be disturbed in their
- 17:05possession by the landlord's actions or inactions.
- 17:09These claims come to me as a mediator in any
- 17:11number of ways. For example, landlord ignores
- 17:16a tenant complaint of a noisy neighbor or maybe
- 17:20even criminal behavior, leaving the tenant no
- 17:23reasonable option but to move out and to pursue
- 17:25claims. Another way it comes to me, landlord
- 17:29construction. which drives the tenant out. This
- 17:33kind of claim is often accompanied by a landlord's
- 17:36lack of information to the tenants of what the
- 17:38project will entail, the timeline, to give the
- 17:43tenant an opportunity to take matters into their
- 17:45own hands, to bring peace into their lives. The
- 17:49concepts of quiet enjoyment and habitability
- 17:54overlap, as does the concept of constructive
- 17:59eviction. Next slide, please. Constructive eviction
- 18:04occurs when a landlord's acts, omissions, or
- 18:08disturbances render a substantial portion of
- 18:11the premises entirely unfit for the purpose least,
- 18:16depriving the tenant of beneficial enjoyment
- 18:19for a substantial period. Critically, in the
- 18:24Stoiber case, It was held that the tenant must
- 18:29abandon the premises within a reasonable time
- 18:32to claim constructive eviction. A landlord's
- 18:37failure to address substandard living conditions,
- 18:41the topic of this webinar, habitability, often
- 18:44drives a tenant out. Very common that habitability
- 18:49leads to constructive eviction. And then finally,
- 18:55next slide, please. Let's cover the topic of
- 18:59wrongful eviction. If a landlord wrongfully recovers
- 19:03possession, whether through actual physical lockout
- 19:07or through inaction, the tenant can recover the
- 19:12full range of damages. Wrongful eviction overlaps
- 19:18with constructive eviction, which overlaps with
- 19:22habitability. Wrongful eviction which we'll cover
- 19:26further in this webinar, is super important because
- 19:32it often triggers liability under local ordinances.
- 19:39Let's turn to the next slide, please. I'm going
- 19:42to need another. Now that we've talked about
- 19:47governing principles, let's talk about the habitability
- 19:49lawsuit. Next slide, please. Let's start with
- 19:54statute of limitations. When evaluating a case
- 19:58at mediation, I need to look at the calendar.
- 20:02Different claims that are often included in the
- 20:05same case have wildly different lifespans, which
- 20:10affects the historical damages a plaintiff can
- 20:13claim. Personal injury or death on a negligence
- 20:18claim to your statute of limitations. Property
- 20:23damage, three years. Breach of habitability on
- 20:28a verbal lease, two years. And breach of habitability
- 20:32on a written lease, four years. And critically,
- 20:37punitive or statutory penalties, which we commonly
- 20:42see in local ordinances, and this would include
- 20:45travel damages, there's a one -year limitations
- 20:49program. limitations period. Limitations, statute
- 20:56of limitations can be its own topic for its own
- 21:00webinar. We get into topics such as when does
- 21:04the limitations period even commence running?
- 21:08The tenants living with substandard conditions
- 21:10throughout a period of time, they declare a constructive
- 21:14eviction and move out and sue for wrongful eviction.
- 21:18Does the limitations period start when the conditions
- 21:22first started? Does the limitations period start
- 21:25when the tenant first moved out? These are concepts
- 21:29that are embedded deeply in some of these litigations,
- 21:37but it's really important to know that you need
- 21:40to think this out before even filing the case.
- 21:44Next slide, please. Let's get to the heart of
- 21:48why these cases become massive financial exposures.
- 21:51The math. The warranty of habitability allows
- 21:56a tenant to seek both contract and tort damages
- 22:00simultaneously. Tenant can sue for past breaches,
- 22:04even if they've already moved out at the time
- 22:07they file. Next slide, please. The power of the
- 22:14rent differential. When the tenant is constructively,
- 22:20and this is particularly important when we have
- 22:24rent control, rent control where the rent that
- 22:28the tenant is paying might be substantially less
- 22:32than the market rent. When a tenant is constructively
- 22:36or wrongfully evicted, the core elements of their
- 22:41long -term economic damage is the value of the
- 22:45unexpired term. which is widely known as rent
- 22:50differential. The formula, which has been upheld
- 22:54in the cases cited on that slide, is mathematically
- 22:58unyielding. Rent differential is the difference
- 23:05between a fair market rent and a rent controlled
- 23:10rent multiplied by the length of time the tenant
- 23:15likely would have stayed. Next slide, please.
- 23:21Let's look at the math. The rent differential
- 23:25calculation is often the biggest wake -up call
- 23:28for a landlord in the mediation room. Imagine
- 23:33a 20 -year rent -controlled tenant who's 45 years
- 23:36old paying $1 ,000 a month in rent -controlled
- 23:40rent. Because the tenants lived in the unit for
- 23:4420 years, that exact same unit would now command
- 23:49substantially more. The tenant's expert claims
- 23:53the market rent is $3 ,500. The landlord's expert
- 23:57claims the market rent is $2 ,500. Let's split
- 24:02the difference and use $3 ,000. That's a $2 ,000
- 24:08monthly difference between the rent -controlled
- 24:10rent the tenant is paying and the fair market
- 24:13rent. which translates to a loss of $24 ,000
- 24:18per year. The tenant's 45 years old. The defense
- 24:25argues that the tenant would have moved in two
- 24:27years to be closer to their family. The plaintiff
- 24:32argues, at a rent -controlled unit in Prime neighborhood,
- 24:35I'd already lived there for 20 years. I was never
- 24:37gonna leave. My actuarial life expectancy is
- 24:4135 years. A jury settling on a 20 -year expectation
- 24:47translates into base damages of $480 ,000. Next
- 24:55slide, please. Now, if we apply the mandatory
- 25:02trebling found in AB 1482, the Tenant Protection
- 25:07Act, or most local tenant protection ordinances,
- 25:14suddenly a single habitability and displacement
- 25:18dispute has escalated into a $1 .4 million liability
- 25:26before adding a single dime for emotional distress
- 25:31or attorney's fees. And by the way, under California
- 25:36case law, actual damages do include attendance
- 25:41rent differential. Next slide, please. Beyond
- 25:49rent differential, some California statutes pile
- 25:52on severe penal mechanisms. Let's cover some
- 25:56of those before we launch into the mediation
- 25:58room. Civil Code 1942 .4. If a landlord demands
- 26:05or collects rent when a unit lacks Civil Code
- 26:091941 .1 minimum standards. And if a housing inspector
- 26:14has issued a written notice and the condition
- 26:17sat unabated for over 35 days without good cause,
- 26:23and the tenant didn't cause it, the landlord
- 26:25is liable for actual damages plus special statutory
- 26:29damages between $105 ,000 and mandatory attorney's
- 26:36fees to the prevailing party. This section doesn't
- 26:40necessarily give a separate claim a high monetary
- 26:46value, but the attorney's fee provision of 1942
- 26:52.4 is critical. Next slide, please. Let's talk
- 27:00about Civil Code 789 .3. If a landlord cuts off
- 27:05utilities, changes locks, or removes windows
- 27:09or doors to force a tenant out, they face actual
- 27:12damages plus statutory penalties. Again, statutory
- 27:19attorney's fees attach. We'll talk about attorney's
- 27:24fees separately in a couple of minutes, but statutory
- 27:28or contract attorney's fees often become the
- 27:32main drivers or amongst the main drivers at mediation.
- 27:38Next slide, please. Civil Code 1940 .2, harassment.
- 27:47Landlords who use threats, force, intentional
- 27:51privacy violations, or threaten to disclose citizen
- 27:56status to force a vacancy face a civil penalty
- 28:01of up to $2 ,000 per violation. Next slide, please.
- 28:11Attorney's fees. One of the most important aspects
- 28:14of habitability claims is the potential recovery
- 28:17of attorney's fees. They come in two varieties.
- 28:22Contract attorney's fees. If there's a prevailing
- 28:26party fee clause in the lease, it triggers. And
- 28:31under Civil Code 1717, If the lease allows the
- 28:37landlord to recover legal fees when they win,
- 28:40the tenant is automatically granted under that
- 28:42section, reciprocal right. But even without a
- 28:49contractual lease provision that allows attorney's
- 28:51fees, statutes like Civil Code 1942 .4, which
- 28:56we just covered, 789 .3, which we just covered,
- 29:01and AB 1482, And also, local ordinances provide
- 29:08independent paths for tenants to collect their
- 29:11legal fees. And sometimes, the fee provision
- 29:16is a one -way street when it comes to attorney's
- 29:20fees. Because under AB 1482, for example, attorney's
- 29:26fees are recoverable only by a prevailing tenant.
- 29:31Every mediator comes to the mediation table with
- 29:35their own war stories, with their own stories
- 29:38of attorney's fees. Consider this example. The
- 29:43actual physical damages in a mold case might
- 29:46be quite low, $15 ,000 in rent abatement, $5
- 29:50,000 in medicals. But the plaintiff's attorney
- 29:54comes to mediation having already logged 200
- 29:57hours of work at $700 an hour. If there's a lease
- 30:04provision allowing attorney's fees or a statutory
- 30:07attorney's fee provision in play, which is almost
- 30:10always the case, if the plaintiff wins anything
- 30:15in habitability damages, they're the prevailing
- 30:18party and can file a fee motion for their $150
- 30:23,000 or $160 ,000 and counting of their fees.
- 30:29or $300 ,000 or $400 ,000 or fill in the blank.
- 30:38I go into the defense room and I say, you might
- 30:41have a 70 % chance of beating their mold exposure
- 30:44argument at trial. But if you lose even on a
- 30:47minor habitability claim, you write a check for
- 30:51$160 ,000 or $320 ,000, fill in the blank. together
- 30:57with your own lawyer's fees. Is it worth risking
- 31:01a quarter million dollar payout or a half million
- 31:03dollar payout over a fifty thousand dollar gap
- 31:06in settlement? This perfectly illustrates why
- 31:10the tail whacks the dog in these mediations,
- 31:13the attorney's fees. Next slide, please. And
- 31:18finally, if a plaintiff can show by clear and
- 31:23convincing evidence, that the landlord acted
- 31:26with oppression, fraud, or malice, a jury can
- 31:31award punitive damages under Civil Code 3294.
- 31:37Next slide, please. Now that we understand the
- 31:41legal and mathematical realities, let's talk
- 31:44about what actually happens in the mediation
- 31:46room and how we resolve these cases. We're moving
- 31:51from the sterile world of statutory text and
- 31:54spreadsheets into the highly strategic, emotionally
- 31:58-charged, and multilayered chess match of the
- 32:01mediation itself. To settle these cases, I cannot,
- 32:06as a mediator, just be a messenger shuttling
- 32:10numbers back and forth. I've got to be a coverage
- 32:13attorney, an actuary, a psychologist. sometimes
- 32:19even an amateur structural engineer. Next slide,
- 32:25please. Insurance. Insurance is the ultimate
- 32:31wild card in habitability mediations. Landlords
- 32:37often arrive at the mediation table with a belief
- 32:42that they've got full coverage. They assume that
- 32:46because they pay their premiums, Their commercial
- 32:49general liability or landlord policy will shield
- 32:52them from any tenant claim. They're met with
- 32:57immediate sticker shock when they discover that
- 32:59their policy contains explicit exclusions for
- 33:02things like wrongful eviction, intentional acts,
- 33:07or harassment, maybe even for attorney's fees.
- 33:12They may even have a full habitability exclusion.
- 33:16This routinely triggers a mediation within a
- 33:19mediation. Before I can even begin talking to
- 33:23the tenant about their demands, I need to spend
- 33:26hours resolving the deep structural divide between
- 33:29the landlord and their own insurance carrier.
- 33:34Advice to all practitioners may sound basic.
- 33:39Read the policy. Read the policy. Read the policy
- 33:44and then read it again. Don't read it for the
- 33:48first time at mediation when I need to educate
- 33:51one or both sides about something that is as
- 33:57monumental as coverage. Next slide, please. If
- 34:06the insurer provides its offense under a reservation
- 34:10of rights but denies indemnity for the bulk of
- 34:14its damages, which is almost always going to
- 34:17be the case if there's a punitive damages claim,
- 34:22the landlord and their own carrier become immediate
- 34:25adversaries. The carrier will often demand a
- 34:29massive personal contribution from the landlord's
- 34:32personal assets to fund a settlement. Why? Because
- 34:37the carrier's claims adjusters looking only at
- 34:40the covered claims, like negligent water intrusion,
- 34:43for example. while ignoring the uncovered claims,
- 34:47like mold -induced asthma or retaliatory harassment.
- 34:53This conflict often requires independent Cumus
- 34:55counsel under Civil Code 2860 to step in and
- 34:59protect the landlord's interests. As a mediator,
- 35:03I need to manage this three -way dynamic. I have
- 35:06to reality test the carrier's reservation of
- 35:10rights position. while simultaneously counseling
- 35:13the landlord on the devastating risk of personal
- 35:16exposure if they refuse to contribute and the
- 35:20carrier walks away from the mediation table.
- 35:24Next slide, please. Furthermore, if the habitability
- 35:31issues spanned several years, I need to deal
- 35:36with time on risk complexity. Multiple carriers
- 35:41across multiple policy years will spend hours
- 35:45arguing over how to apportion their respective
- 35:48contributions. As a mediator, if I can't extract
- 35:53liquid insurance funds to bridge these gaps,
- 35:57the case will reach a stalemate. Next slide,
- 36:01please. Consider the following example. I'm sorry,
- 36:08if you can go back to 31, sorry. Consider the
- 36:14following example. A tenant alleges mold exposure
- 36:19and breathing issues spanning four years. During
- 36:25years one and two, the landlord was covered by
- 36:28carrier A, an occurrence policy. In year three,
- 36:32the landlord switched to carrier B, which has
- 36:35a strict organic pathogen mold sum limit of $25
- 36:40,000. And in year four, the landlord switched
- 36:44to carrier C, which has an absolute mold exclusion,
- 36:48but covers wrongful eviction. While the tenant
- 36:52sits in caucus eating lunch, I, the mediator,
- 36:56am in the defense room watching three insurance
- 36:58adjusters argue about when the injury actually
- 37:01manifested, how to allocate the time on risk.
- 37:05and whether carrier B's $25 ,000 sub -limit caps
- 37:09their duty to indemnify. As a mediator, I always
- 37:14set up a pre -session call as far in advance
- 37:19of the mediation as possible to tackle these
- 37:22issues so that they're not saved for the mediation
- 37:26day. It allows me to demand that defense carriers
- 37:30meet prior to the mediation to hammer out a temporary
- 37:33cost -sharing agreement Otherwise, the first
- 37:36four or six or eight hours of the mediation will
- 37:39be spent on coverage disputes. Next slide, please.
- 37:47The absolute tilt of the playing field is a massive
- 37:52psychological barrier for defendants. Because
- 37:56of mandatory statutory penalties and potential
- 37:59trebling under local ordinances and under AB
- 38:031482, A landlord's exposure is completely decoupled
- 38:09from the tenant's actual out -of -pocket loss.
- 38:14It creates a classic tail -wags -the -dog scenario.
- 38:18I've seen plenty of cases where a jury might
- 38:22only award $10 ,000 in actual habitability damages,
- 38:27but because of statutory fee -shifting provisions
- 38:32the landlord is looking at $250 ,000 in plaintiff's
- 38:36attorney's fees. I come armed to mediation with
- 38:40those kinds of examples. The cost of defense
- 38:44and the threat of the fee award become the primary
- 38:47drivers of the settlement. To counter the reality
- 38:54of fee -shifting leverage, defense counsel ought
- 38:58to always consider when to deploy a CCP 998 offer
- 39:04to compromise. By serving a precise early 998
- 39:11offer, the defense can potentially cut off the
- 39:14plaintiff's rate to post -offer attorney's fees
- 39:17and shift their own post -offer costs onto the
- 39:21plaintiff. In mediation, a pending, well -crafted
- 39:26998 offer is the ultimate anchor to bring a high
- 39:30-flying plaintiff's demand back to Earth. Next
- 39:35slide, please. Quantifying the value of a rent
- 39:42-controlled tenancy is an actuarial battlefield
- 39:46and a reality at mediation. Experts can give
- 39:51us a sterile clinical opinion on a unit's fair
- 39:54market value But the real dispute in mediation
- 39:58is almost always the projected duration of occupancy.
- 40:03Fence arguing that the Senate would have moved
- 40:05in a couple of years, the Senate stating under
- 40:09oath that they intended to stay for 20 years
- 40:12or the rest of their natural life. In a strong
- 40:16just cause jurisdiction, a residential tenancy
- 40:20is functionally tantamount to a life estate.
- 40:25Bridging the gap, Atmediation requires creative
- 40:28bracketed negotiations, realistic assessments
- 40:32of the tenants' actual long -term life plans,
- 40:35discussions of things like job changes, expanding
- 40:38families, and retirement plans. Next slide, please.
- 40:45And finally, we must never forget the human elements.
- 40:50Landlord -tenant disputes are fundamentally about
- 40:53home and displacement. When a tenant alleges
- 40:57harassment or horrific living conditions, the
- 41:00mediation table becomes a pressure valve for
- 41:03years of built -up frustration regarding things
- 41:06like dignity, safety, personal space. Conversely,
- 41:14landlords often feel personally attacked, financially
- 41:17exploited, taken advantage of. As a mediator,
- 41:24If I ignore this emotional volatility and try
- 41:30to force a purely clinical numerical valuation
- 41:33too early, the numbers won't move. The parties
- 41:38need to feel heard and validated regarding the
- 41:41human element before they can realistically sign
- 41:44a release. Let's talk about some tools to resolve
- 41:54emotional deadlock. Here's a structured look
- 41:59at how I as a mediator can utilize non -monetary
- 42:02face -saving terms to bridge a massive financial
- 42:05gap when the mathematical negotiations have stalled.
- 42:10The parties are stuck on a $50 ,000 gap, $100
- 42:14,000 gap. It doesn't matter. Delaine looks furious
- 42:18because she feels the tenant trashed the property
- 42:20and embarrassed her. by calling code enforcement.
- 42:25The sentence traumatized by what she felt was
- 42:27a patronizing, aggressive property manager. I
- 42:32acknowledge the financial gap, of course, but
- 42:34temporarily pause the numbers. I meet with each
- 42:38party individually to ask, what does a successful
- 42:43future look like for you outside of the dollar
- 42:45amount? This often covers the underlying needs.
- 42:50reputation preservation for the landlord, housing
- 42:54mobility for the tenant. I might suggest non
- 42:57-monetary terms, maybe a mutual no disparagement
- 43:03clause, ensuring that neither party can trash
- 43:07the other online or in the tight -knit local
- 43:11community. I might suggest a clean reference
- 43:15letter. a pre -drafted neutral reference letter
- 43:18stating the tenant paid rent on time and vacated
- 43:21voluntarily, allowing her to secure her next
- 43:25home. And then we can discuss the package deal.
- 43:29Often a tenant might accept less money if they
- 43:32feel their dignity has been restored and their
- 43:34future housing secure. Simultaneously, a landlord
- 43:38might pay a little more if they get absolute
- 43:41closure, a clean hand back of the keys, and a
- 43:45guarantee that their reputation is legally protected.
- 43:50Next slide, please. Let me make a few closing
- 43:57comments and then turn to some of the questions.
- 44:00Mediating these cases requires really a unique
- 44:05mix of mathematical tracking, sophisticated insurance
- 44:11navigation, and deep emotional intelligence.
- 44:15When you understand the math of the rent differential,
- 44:18the tactical leverage of a 998 offer, reality
- 44:22of exclusions, insurance policy, you can accurately
- 44:28guide your clients to a safe, predictable settlement
- 44:31rather than risking a catastrophic troubled verdict
- 44:34at trial. These cases should be mediated as early
- 44:40as possible. with a skilled mediator. Let me
- 44:46dive into some questions. I appreciate your patience.
- 45:12Let's see what we got here. Owen, let me jump
- 45:17into this here. When dealing with a tenant who's
- 45:23got severe housekeeping or hoarding issues, how
- 45:27do you handle the allocation of comparative faults
- 45:30and mediation when the landlord's deferred maintenance
- 45:33is also objectively terrible? scenario from Civil
- 45:43Code 1941 .2. You walk into a mediation room
- 45:46where the roof has been actively leaking for
- 45:49a year through landlord fault, but the tenants
- 45:52blocked every window, vent and door with personal
- 45:55property. The goal here as a mediator is I've
- 46:00got to break through the all or nothing mindset.
- 46:04Both sides usually walk into mediation thinking
- 46:07they've got a slam dunk. The landlord thinks
- 46:10the hoarding completely exonerates them. The
- 46:13tenant thinks the structural leak completely
- 46:15overrides their lifestyle. I separate the rooms.
- 46:19I've got to ask the landlord, even if the tenant
- 46:22did all of those things, did you document it?
- 46:27Did you issue a three day notice to perform covenant
- 46:29or quit? If they didn't, the jury might see them
- 46:33as an absentee landlord who didn't, who did not
- 46:36care. And so they got sued. The reframe. Then
- 46:40I go to the tenant, show them the defense's structural
- 46:43expert photos. The jury might award habitability
- 46:47damages for the leak, but they will completely
- 46:50slash the emotional distress and medical damages
- 46:53if they believe the tenant's own environment
- 46:55compounds in the mold's growth. This shifts the
- 46:59case from a liability debate to a percentage.
- 47:07based discount negotiation. Let me look at some
- 47:12other questions here. Emotional distress multiplier.
- 47:23We've talked a lot about the massive leverage
- 47:25of rent differential and trebling in rent controlled
- 47:29jurisdictions. But what about valuing a habitability
- 47:34case in a jurisdiction without local tenant protections
- 47:37or mandatory traveling where emotional distress
- 47:40is the primary driver? When you move outside
- 47:45of a strict rent control bubble, you lose the
- 47:48predictable mathematical hammer of the rent differential
- 47:51formula. You're no longer calculating a life
- 47:55estate value. Instead, the plaintiff's leverage
- 47:59shifts entirely to the unpredictable world of
- 48:02general damages, emotional distress. For a defense
- 48:07carrier, emotional distress is terrifying because
- 48:11it can't be neatly calculated on a spreadsheet.
- 48:15A lieutenant has compelling testimony, photos
- 48:19of horrific conditions, maybe even corroboration
- 48:23by other neighbors. maybe even medical notes
- 48:27showing a severe anxiety or respiratory distress.
- 48:32The jury can award whatever they think is reasonable.
- 48:36In the mediation rooms, I focus heavily on the
- 48:39plaintiff's credibility and the landlord's bad
- 48:42actor optics. If the landlord is a corporate
- 48:47entity that ignored 20 emails about a roof leak,
- 48:51the jury might use emotional distress damages
- 48:54as a de facto punishment, even without a punitive
- 48:58damages instruction. I'll counsel the defense
- 49:04that no rent control is not the same as no risk.
- 49:10A sympathetic tenant can easily walk away with
- 49:13a six -figure emotional distress verdict, which
- 49:17will then automatically trigger the tenant's
- 49:19right to claim hundreds of thousands of dollars
- 49:22in one -way statutory attorney's fees under 1942
- 49:28.4 or a lease provision. Let me dive back into
- 49:34the Q &A pool here. What about property management
- 49:47or other agents? What can be applied to them
- 49:49versus the landlord only? Property managers are
- 49:55agents of the landlord and have the same liability
- 50:00as a landlord. Under most local ordinances, the
- 50:11term landlord is specifically defined as including
- 50:15a property manager or agent of the landlord.
- 50:20Sometimes we might have a situation, for example,
- 50:24where a property manager might have made recommendations
- 50:28to a landlord that they've got to fix the roof
- 50:32and they've got to do it quickly and they are
- 50:35stalled by the landlord and the property manager
- 50:39has done virtually everything they can do to
- 50:43alert the landlord about the terrible problem.
- 50:46but ultimately the landlord did not approve the
- 50:50budget. The Senate in the meantime declared a
- 50:52constructive eviction. The Senate has a direct
- 50:56claim against the property management company
- 50:59if they paid rent directly to the property management
- 51:02company or if the property management company
- 51:06acted as the agent of the landlord, which invariably
- 51:09they do. The Senate's communicate directly with
- 51:12the property management. Now, the property management
- 51:17company might have a claim for indemnification,
- 51:21that's true against the property owner. Under
- 51:24the facts that I just described, it sounds like
- 51:26they probably would, but the tenant can look
- 51:30directly to the owner and directly to the property
- 51:33management company both. And often at mediation,
- 51:40we might have two different policies that we're
- 51:43looking at. We might have the landlord's general
- 51:46liability or landlord policy. We might have the
- 51:50property manager's Arizona emissions policy.
- 51:54And so we almost always see property managers
- 51:58and landlords alike as defendants in these lawsuits.
- 52:04Thank you for that question. Let me jump into.
- 52:09Thank you for all these great questions. What
- 52:26if the landlord did nothing to mitigate the effects
- 52:29of construction soot, dirt, and noise coming
- 52:33from a neighboring building? The landlord had
- 52:36noticed that this was harming the tenant who
- 52:37has respiratory issues and they had numerous
- 52:40additional pulmonology visits. So let's first
- 52:45talk about construction being done by the landlord
- 52:49of the property that the Senate lives at. In
- 52:54the county or I practiced, which was San Francisco
- 52:58County and other Bay Area counties, construction
- 53:02was a really common issue. We've got in the San
- 53:07Francisco Bay Area, the mandatory seismic retrofit
- 53:10ordinance, which mandated and still mandates
- 53:13that landlords bring their buildings up to seismic
- 53:17code. This can often mean significant construction.
- 53:24landlords get themselves into trouble, not just
- 53:27because of the actual magnitude of the construction,
- 53:32but on account of their failure to provide meaningful
- 53:36information to their tenants to allow their tenants
- 53:38to plan accordingly. It can be a catch -22 when
- 53:43a landlord comes forward and says, you know,
- 53:45I'm being a good landlord here. I'm being mandated
- 53:48to seismically retrofit my building. I'm on it.
- 53:51I'm doing it. This is for the safety of the renters.
- 53:55But separate from the direct impact, we often
- 53:59see landlords who fail to give meaningful information
- 54:05to the tenants on a project timeline to allow
- 54:08the tenants to plan accordingly. Even some good
- 54:11faith landlords, you know, they're not doing
- 54:13the work. Their project manager, their construction
- 54:16crew is doing it. Ask a contractor, hey, do me
- 54:20a favor and give me Monday through Friday the
- 54:22hours that the noise is going to be, you know,
- 54:25loudest. That's a tall task. Now let's go to
- 54:30the direct question. Is the landlord doing nothing
- 54:33to mitigate the effects of construction work
- 54:35coming from a neighboring building? If the landlord
- 54:39had no control over what's going on in the neighboring
- 54:44building, no ownership or management responsibilities
- 54:48or anything like that, that would be a very difficult
- 54:53argument for a tenant to prevail on that the
- 54:55landlord owed the tenant some duty outside of
- 54:59the direct tenant landlord relationship of that
- 55:03property. A landlord would surely argue You've
- 55:08got the same power as I do over the adjacent
- 55:14building, which is zero. I'm not your guarantor
- 55:19of safety in the world. Go for it, tenant. Best
- 55:30of luck to you. Let's take another question here.
- 55:48Question here, do I ever use mock juries and
- 55:52how? I, as a mediator, don't use mock juries.
- 55:55A lot of counsel do. But it brings up a different
- 55:59topic related. Mediation prep and things I see
- 56:04at mediation. And I'll end with this topic. What
- 56:08do I see at mediation that really moves the needle?
- 56:13How can somebody really move the needle at a
- 56:17mediation? Well, let's be more specific. The
- 56:21cases where a tenant might declare a constructive
- 56:24eviction and then sue under a local ordinance
- 56:27for trouble damages and rent to parental for
- 56:3020 years and all of those kind of things. Those
- 56:33kinds of cases are often in a different category
- 56:36than a habitability case where the tenant has
- 56:39not moved out, has not declared a constructive
- 56:41eviction, might have lived without heat or hot
- 56:44water or like a leaking ceiling for an extended
- 56:46period of time. that substantially impacted a
- 56:49family, but we're not talking about rents and
- 56:52parental damages or anything like that. A strict
- 56:55habitability case without an add -on for constructive
- 56:59eviction or wrongful eviction. What separates
- 57:02those kinds of cases at mediation? A picture
- 57:06tells a thousand words. Photographs of living
- 57:12conditions. Council have come before me plaintiffs
- 57:16council have come before me with day in the life
- 57:19videos Even even if it's not a video of the actual
- 57:24conditions that existed at the time Sometimes
- 57:26a tenant doesn't think to take a video They haven't
- 57:30you know considered suing or anything. I haven't
- 57:32even spoken with counsel yet It might not be
- 57:35until after the habitability is restored that
- 57:39they speak with an attorney for the first time
- 57:41so day in the light videos can to a whole host
- 57:43of things. They can point out the conditions.
- 57:48They can allow me to meet the plaintiffs in a
- 57:53different way than I would at mediation when
- 57:55everybody's super nervous and all. They allow
- 58:00me to meet the tenant in their own home environment.
- 58:04They allow me to see exactly what they're talking
- 58:07about. which can be very different than reading
- 58:10it in papers. So what can really make a big difference
- 58:15in a mediation are those kinds of personalizing
- 58:20devices, photographs, videos, day in the life,
- 58:29sketches, the brief. I can get a habitability
- 58:34case settles without those kinds of things. But
- 58:37those kinds of things really do make a difference.
- 58:41For the people who spend the time on them, thank
- 58:44you for that. It really gives me a lot more to
- 58:48work with. Let me see here. Can you speak to
- 58:57the liability of a landlord with neighbor disputes,
- 58:59other tenants too noisy, smokes weed, has too
- 59:01many visitors, how to handle disputes that are
- 59:04listening to them? The question really goes to,
- 59:08and this is really important. Thank you for asking
- 59:10that question. Neighbor on neighbor disputes.
- 59:13What's a landlord's responsibility there? What
- 59:17do we do with those? I'm gonna stay a couple
- 59:19extra minutes. I see time is ending, but I'll
- 59:22take a couple minutes to address the question.
- 59:24Thank you for your patience. It's important.
- 59:27Neighbor on neighbor disputes. your upstairs
- 59:32neighbor is super loud, your other neighbor,
- 59:36you know, smokes against the non -smoking policy.
- 59:39They come in all kind of varieties. Here's what,
- 59:44what's a landlord's responsibility in a situation
- 59:46like that? Well, it's hard to say. It's factually
- 59:51specific, but here's what I can say. A landlord
- 59:54cannot just sit back and say, you people who
- 59:57are acting like children, better figure it out.
- 1:00:01I don't know, you know, leave me out of it. That
- 1:00:04under the mobile air estates case versus Andrews
- 1:00:09and other cases too, a landlord has an obligation
- 1:00:12to do something. What they have to do really
- 1:00:16depends upon the facts, okay? Landlord might
- 1:00:19have to come on down during, you know, normal
- 1:00:22hours and hear for themselves what's going on.
- 1:00:27a landlord, you know, it really depends upon
- 1:00:31the facts. The times when landlords screw it
- 1:00:34up and really subject themselves to significant
- 1:00:37liability are not generally the kind of cases
- 1:00:41where, you know, the landlord was actively trying
- 1:00:46to do something about it, maybe even, you know,
- 1:00:49issuing notice to the tenant to cure or quit.
- 1:00:54But there are cases really where the landlord
- 1:00:56says, you know, I don't know what you expect
- 1:00:58me to do about it. You wouldn't believe how frequently
- 1:01:03that happens. That is an absolute invitation
- 1:01:07to a lawsuit by a tenant. Excuse me. Sorry about
- 1:01:12that. That's an absolute invitation for a lawsuit
- 1:01:16by a tenant. A landlord, property manager absolutely
- 1:01:22ought to think in terms of being proactive. It
- 1:01:28doesn't necessarily mean that you have to evict
- 1:01:31the offending tenant because this he said, she
- 1:01:35said, that happens a lot. But a landlord who
- 1:01:39sits back and does absolutely nothing is buying
- 1:01:43themselves liability. Here we are at the end
- 1:01:52of the presentation. I really appreciate your
- 1:01:55thoughtful questions, your attendance here. I
- 1:02:02am here at signature resolution. These are the
- 1:02:05kinds of disputes that are very familiar to me,
- 1:02:09not just as a mediator, but in my own practice
- 1:02:12of decades and as a settlement judge pro tem
- 1:02:15in the court for 20 years. Have a good rest of
- 1:02:20the day and thanks for attending.