Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Recent Developments in California Property Tax Law with Gregory Broege
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to recent developments in California
- 0:05property tax law. I'm Philipp Beran, chair of
- 0:08the Beverly Hills Biossociation's tax section.
- 0:12The tax section is sponsored by Hoffman, Salk
- 0:15& Toscher Press. The Hoffman, Salk & Toscher
- 0:17Press BC advantage is experience and eye for
- 0:19innovation and genuine dedication to clients,
- 0:22their family, and their business. In addition
- 0:24to their national practice and civil and civil
- 0:27tax and criminal tax controversies and related
- 0:29litigation in federal and state court. The firm
- 0:32is also active in white -collar defense and commercial
- 0:34disputes. I'm delighted to introduce today's
- 0:38speaker, Greg Broush. Originally from the Jersey
- 0:41Shore, Greg began his legal career at Lays and
- 0:44Watkins and passed exclusively on California
- 0:47state and local tax, since joining what is now
- 0:51Ayelet, Polay, Ayyub, Matarisi and Broush in
- 0:552009. where he became a partner in 2016. Recognized
- 1:00as a super lawyer and an early rising star by
- 1:02the California State Board of Equalization, Greg
- 1:05has also received the Member Achievement Award
- 1:08from the Institution of Professionals in Taxation.
- 1:11He has held leadership roles in the LA County
- 1:14Bar Association and the Institution for Professionals
- 1:17in Taxation and regularly speaks at events. for
- 1:20bar associations, tax institutes, and CPA societies.
- 1:24He also teaches continuing education in state
- 1:26and local tax at Carl State LA and has been published
- 1:30widely in respected tax and legal practitioners.
- 1:34Greg, take it away. Hi, everyone. So I obviously
- 1:40can't hear you or see you, but there is a Q &A
- 1:43function. If you have a question during the presentation,
- 1:49feel free to put it in there. I'll try to monitor
- 1:51it. If not, I'll get to it at the end. But sometimes
- 1:53it's good to answer it while we're on the specific
- 1:56topic. Before I get into the kind of case law
- 2:00update that we're going to go through during
- 2:03the presentation, I always like to start every
- 2:06property tax presentation with one of the most
- 2:09important things, which is what are the appeals
- 2:11deadlines and how do you contest an issue that
- 2:14you might have with either your property taxes
- 2:18or your client's property taxes. Excuse me. So
- 2:23there's a couple of different appeals periods
- 2:25and they can be quite confusing. And they're
- 2:29also extremely important because in property
- 2:33tax, we have a system that's set up with a quasi
- 2:35-traditional administrative agency called the
- 2:38Assessment Appeals Board, which is separate and
- 2:40apart from the county assessor who actually assesses
- 2:43properties and values them. The assessment appeals
- 2:46board is the governmental agency that's set up
- 2:49to handle property tax disputes. And in almost
- 2:53every situation, other than exemptions and maybe
- 2:56other very limited circumstances, you have to
- 3:00go to the assessment appeals board first. And
- 3:01if you do not, go there, you have not exhausted
- 3:09your remedies and you could win your case, but
- 3:11not get a refund, which is generally a fairly
- 3:14big deal. So there's a couple of different periods.
- 3:18The first is the general regular filing period.
- 3:21We're in the regular filing period for every
- 3:23single county in the state of California right
- 3:26now. The filing period runs from July 2nd to
- 3:32either September 15th or November 30th. depending
- 3:36on what county you're in. If the county gives
- 3:38an assessment notice, you're on September 15th,
- 3:43San Francisco, Alameda, Ventura. Those are examples
- 3:47of counties where you have to file your regular
- 3:49appeal by September 15th. Most of the state and
- 3:52most of Southern California and Ventura County
- 3:54are all November 30th counties. This year, November
- 3:5730th is a Sunday, so you have until December
- 3:591st to file your appeals. A regular roll appeal
- 4:03is an appeal that challenges the assessment as
- 4:08of the lien date for that tax year. So the tax
- 4:11years are run on a fiscal year basis. They run
- 4:13from July to June. So right now we're in the
- 4:172025 tax year. It just started at the beginning
- 4:21of last month and it will run through June 30th
- 4:23of 2026. A regular rule appeal will challenge
- 4:27the assessment as of the lien date, which is
- 4:29January 1 of of each year. So the January 1,
- 4:332025 date is the lien date for the 2025 tax year,
- 4:38which runs July 1 to June 30. That is generally
- 4:43used for Prop 8, decline of values, which is,
- 4:46hey, I think my property is worth less than what
- 4:49my trend at base year value is. Or if you missed
- 4:53filing an appeal on either a supplemental or
- 4:55escape assessment, you can sometimes correct
- 4:58the issue, generally only on a perspective basis
- 5:02by filing a regular roll appeal. So there also
- 5:06are appeals periods that are outside the general
- 5:10regular filing period. And those are if you get
- 5:13a supplemental assessment. Now a supplemental
- 5:16assessment is issued on real property. If you
- 5:19have a change of ownership, or completion of
- 5:21new construction. They will value the property
- 5:24as of that date. So if you purchased a property
- 5:26October 10th, 2024, you will get a 2024 supplemental
- 5:30assessment, which reassesses the property to
- 5:34the fair market value of it as of October 10th,
- 5:372024. Now, it's clear it's the fair market value.
- 5:42So if the value's gone up from your prior roll
- 5:45value, you get a tax bill. If it's gone down,
- 5:48you'll get a tax refund. The appeals period for
- 5:54filing appeals on supplementals are either 60
- 5:59days from the date of mailing of the notice of
- 6:01supplemental assessment, or in certain counties,
- 6:06and Los Angeles is one of those counties, 60
- 6:08days from the date of mailing of the bill. So
- 6:12you have to be careful what county you're in.
- 6:15Most counties throughout the state are notice
- 6:17counties. However, sometimes it's confusing because
- 6:19like San Diego, they combine the notice and the
- 6:21bill into one document. LA is a bill county.
- 6:25Marin County is a bill county. So you got to
- 6:28make sure you're appealing the notice slash bill
- 6:31within 60 days of whatever is the operable document
- 6:35that leads to the appeal. Similarly, with escape
- 6:39assessments, that's when property escaped assessment
- 6:43as of a lien date. Those are also issued outside
- 6:46the regular period, and those also have a 60
- 6:49-day period, again, either from the notice or
- 6:53the bill, depending on what county you're in.
- 6:56And I should mention, in LA county, if the value
- 6:59goes down, then you're only going to get a notice.
- 7:01You're not going to get a bill. So then the 60
- 7:03days runs from the notice, if the value goes
- 7:05down. With escape assessments, there's an even
- 7:09kind of more confusing a little question, which
- 7:15is they issue what's called a notice of proposed
- 7:17escape assessment. That comes before the notice
- 7:21of enrollment escape assessment. If you file
- 7:23on that, your appeal is premature and invalid
- 7:26and void under the law. So you really, really
- 7:30gotta make sense. One, you don't sit on things.
- 7:32I just had somebody today email me bills from
- 7:34May 20th. 2025. They're outside of the period.
- 7:38There's nothing we can do to get at those bills.
- 7:40So you got to act quickly, and you got to make
- 7:42sure you are appealing the same thing. Someone
- 7:47just asked, a married couple own a house with
- 7:49their son, all as joint tenants. If the married
- 7:52couple transfer their share of the house into
- 7:54a revocable living trust, would it lead to reassessment
- 7:57of the property? Great question. Not a part of
- 8:00the presentation, but I'm happy to answer it.
- 8:03And the answer is not enough facts right now.
- 8:06If the married couple and the son bought the
- 8:09property all as joint tenants, then the transfer
- 8:12from the married couple of their interest to
- 8:16their trust would not be reassessable. However,
- 8:18if the married couple bought the property originally
- 8:21and then added the son as a joint tenant at a
- 8:24later time, or vice versa, the son bought the
- 8:27property originally and then added the married
- 8:30couple at a later time. Then the transfer of
- 8:32the married couple's interest to their trust
- 8:34would sever that joint tenancy and cause either
- 8:37a one -third reassessment or a two -thirds reassessment,
- 8:41depending on what the percentages are. So whenever
- 8:44anything's owned in joint tenancy, you got to
- 8:46know how it got into that joint tenancy because
- 8:49there's very complex change of ownership rules
- 8:51dealing with original transfers and non -original
- 8:54transfers. And you just can't look at it as like,
- 8:56well, they owned it. Now they own it in their
- 8:58trust. That's no problem. Well, that's generally
- 9:00not an issue. It's never an issue with tenants
- 9:02in common. It can be an issue with joint tenants.
- 9:05I see estate planners make that mistake a lot
- 9:08because it's a very kind of arcane little rule.
- 9:11So just be very, very careful. You gotta fully
- 9:13analyze the issue. With that, I'm going to go
- 9:19into the presentation. So there has not been
- 9:24a ton of... new case law in the property tax
- 9:28area or a ton of changes within the last year
- 9:32or so. There were some major changes like four
- 9:35years ago when they got rid of the parent child
- 9:37exclusion and they changed the over 55 basher
- 9:39exclusion. And the one major case that's outstanding,
- 9:43I was kind of crossing my fingers that it came
- 9:45out before this presentation on intangibles is
- 9:49that the California Supreme Court has been fully
- 9:52briefed. has had oral argument, but the California
- 9:55Supreme Court has yet to issue a decision. We
- 9:58can chat about that case a little bit, but obviously
- 10:01what the Supreme Court says is going to be the
- 10:03thing that matters a lot. Some of these cases
- 10:06are unpublished. Obviously, if it's an unpublished
- 10:11case, it is not citable. However, they are helpful
- 10:18in certain ways. One, they cite other cases throughout
- 10:22them. So you can find other citations. And two,
- 10:27you understand how the courts might feel about
- 10:32a certain issue. And because of that, I think
- 10:38they can still shed light on a lot of things.
- 10:40So the first case, kind of deals with how important
- 10:43the administrative process is in property tax.
- 10:49As I mentioned, for locally assessed properties,
- 10:53everything goes to the assessment appeals board
- 10:54first. For state assessed properties, and there's
- 10:57very specific things that go to the state assessment
- 11:00because they're taxed on a unitary basis because
- 11:02they're throughout the state, like electric companies
- 11:04and stuff like that. They're assessed by the
- 11:09State Board of Equalization, and they have to
- 11:11go to the State Board of Equalization for a hearing
- 11:14prior to going to court. Now there's different
- 11:16review standards for state assessed properties.
- 11:20They're reviewed de novo in court for locally
- 11:23assessed. And this is very, very important. So
- 11:25we get a lot of calls on this. There's a limited
- 11:28standard of review for locally assessed properties.
- 11:30If you lose at the board on a factual issue,
- 11:33you've kind of lost the case completely, because
- 11:36there's only review on a substantial evidence
- 11:38standard, which means that the court does not
- 11:40get to read away the evidence. They just check
- 11:43if there's evidence in the record to support
- 11:45the decision. If there is, whether they agree
- 11:47with it or not, they uphold the decision. So
- 11:49the... Assessment Appeals Board really acts as
- 11:52the trial court for locally assessed property
- 11:55tax cases. So this first case, the Lopoma case,
- 12:00is a state -assessed property. It's a power plant.
- 12:03And they wanted refunds for 2012 through 2016
- 12:09tax years. And they tried to do it a couple different
- 12:12ways. For 2012, they originally stipulated to
- 12:18a value at the State Board of Equalization. And
- 12:23then filed a suit for refund saying, hey, we
- 12:26actually want more. And you can understand why.
- 12:29These assessment, these local quasi -judicial
- 12:32hearings, especially in certain counties and
- 12:34certain areas, can sometimes get the reputation
- 12:37a little bit of a kangaroo court or very biased
- 12:41towards the government. Not always, but they
- 12:43can get that reputation. And so I think Paloma
- 12:46here was trying to... get to the court quicker
- 12:48to get a full kind of trial on the issues with
- 12:51hopefully a more impartial trier effect. So they
- 12:57stimulated to a value before the board and then
- 12:59tried to go to court. And the court was like,
- 13:02no, no, no, you can't do that. You can't short
- 13:05circuit the process. You agreed to the value.
- 13:08So you don't have a dispute. You can't agree
- 13:11to something before the board and then dispute
- 13:13what you agreed to. And so you have not exhausted
- 13:16your administrative remedies. You're just not
- 13:18allowed to be here on this 2012 case. It's very
- 13:22important that you have... a full hearing at
- 13:27the administrative level, or you can sometimes
- 13:29stipulate that it's a pure legal issue, that
- 13:32the courts are better to decide, but you're not
- 13:34stipulating to a value. And here they stipulated
- 13:37to a value and then challenge that value that
- 13:39they agreed to at the administrative level in
- 13:41court. And the court of appeals said, no, you're
- 13:44out of luck. You're stuck with what you stipulated
- 13:47to before the California State Board of Equalization.
- 13:57So in the later years, 2013, 2014, and 2015 and
- 14:012016, they didn't have that same stipulation
- 14:08issue. However, in their petitions to challenge
- 14:13the assessments made by the State Board of Equalization
- 14:16and in their refund claims, they were limited
- 14:21as to what they argued for. So let's just...
- 14:25really simple kind of, you know, fake math. This
- 14:29weren't the real numbers. Assume they thought
- 14:31the property, you know, originally was worth
- 14:34100 ,000, but then at trial, they were able to
- 14:37prove that it was really only worth 50 ,000.
- 14:39The court said, well, you don't get the refund
- 14:42between the difference because you'd, again,
- 14:44you didn't properly exhaust your administrative
- 14:46revenues. You only asked for 100 ,000. at the
- 14:50administrative level. Just because at trial you
- 14:53proved you should get an even lower value, you
- 14:55can only get to what you asked for. And that's
- 14:58why it's very important when you file your petitions
- 15:00and your applications for change assessment with
- 15:03the assessment appeals board, whatever you think
- 15:06the value is, go lower. because something might
- 15:08come up. Now, you can always amend them at any
- 15:10time, but people sometimes forget to amend them,
- 15:12forget to do it. And a lot of times, the application
- 15:14acts as a claim for refund. You need to make
- 15:18sure that you're not messing up at the administrative
- 15:21level. These simple forms, the two -page form
- 15:23that doesn't seem that much can cause major issues,
- 15:27because this taxpayer lost out on a lot of money
- 15:30here because of issues that were made at the
- 15:34administrative level. Also, one thing that's
- 15:42clear, too, is they don't want you to just present
- 15:45a bare -bones appeal at the administrative level.
- 15:47You need to do a full fleshed -out hearing. And
- 15:50at the State Board, again, no one thought that
- 15:53was that important because they had full de novo
- 15:55review at the trial court. In the assessment
- 15:59appeals board, that's where you really need to
- 16:01do it. You need to make sure that you are treating
- 16:04that like a superior court trial. It does not
- 16:07go there, throw whatever against the wall, see
- 16:09what sticks, and then, oh, we'll deal with it
- 16:11and clean it all up and trial. You have to take
- 16:14that assessment appeals board hearing, witnesses,
- 16:16testimony, documents, evidence, et cetera, et
- 16:18cetera, et cetera. The next case, again, a state
- 16:28-assessed case. But here, how it works with the
- 16:31state assessments is you get assessed at the
- 16:33state level. They then send the values down to
- 16:35the counties on a prorated basis, and the counties
- 16:38issue the bills. And with Prop 13, when Prop
- 16:4213 was enacted in the 70s, It restricted the
- 16:48tax rate to 1 % general levy of the value. It
- 16:52also imposed limitations on the value. Plus,
- 16:56voted indebtedness. And that's why if you notice,
- 16:58if you live in the city of LA, you're like at
- 17:011 .2 % tax rate. If you live in Glendale or Burbank,
- 17:06you're closer to 1 .1. If you're down in Orange
- 17:08County, you're barely above 1%. Um, if you live
- 17:12in like city of industry or like 1 .5 or 1 .6%,
- 17:15not that many people live there. It's kind of
- 17:18a family town. And those differences in the tax
- 17:23rate or the voted indebtedness that gets voted
- 17:24onto your, uh, tax bill, which is different than
- 17:27the direct assessments. The voted indebtedness
- 17:29are still based upon value. It's a percentage
- 17:31of value. Direct assessments are just pure. You're
- 17:35getting assessed $300 for the mosquito district
- 17:38or whatever. Um, so. As a part of the California
- 17:46Constitution, it says that utility companies
- 17:49should be taxed in the same manner, same extent
- 17:52and same manner, not utility companies, state
- 17:54-assessed properties, excuse me, should be assessed
- 17:56as the same extent and manner as the locally
- 17:59-assessed properties. Because of this very complex
- 18:03formula that they have for state assessments
- 18:07where they kind of weight all of the vote and
- 18:09the deadness, the property was not always at
- 18:12the same 1 % and change as the locally assessed
- 18:16property was. And while it doesn't seem like
- 18:20a difference, oh, well, the locally assessed
- 18:22property is at 1 .1524%, and we're at 1 .2044%.
- 18:29When you're getting assessed on billions of dollars
- 18:32of assessments like the state assesses, that
- 18:35number adds up significantly. And so they filed
- 18:38a suit and said, hey, you can't be, we're the
- 18:43same extent and same manner. You have to assess
- 18:46us exactly the same rates as the locally assessed
- 18:50property. Otherwise you're violating the California
- 18:52constitution. And this case had been, A similar
- 18:58case had been handled before by different court
- 19:01of appeal districts. And this district came to
- 19:05the exact same decision, which says, no. Oops,
- 19:12sorry, I thought there was one more slide. No,
- 19:14the issue is it's just in enacting legislation,
- 19:18but it doesn't have to be to the exact same rate.
- 19:21It's in the same manner coming up with a fair
- 19:23market value and doing all that stuff, but it
- 19:25doesn't have to be to the exact same rate. the
- 19:28debt service doesn't have to be the exact same
- 19:30rate. It just has to be a reasonable method that
- 19:33they're using to account for all the different
- 19:36voters and dentists in the county. And so the
- 19:38taxpayer ended up losing, even though you kind
- 19:41of look at the plain definition of it and you
- 19:44say same extent and same manner, that really
- 19:46sounds like it should be taxed at the same rate.
- 19:50But the courts, and if you'll notice, there's
- 19:52going to be a very consistent theme of the loser
- 19:56is is generally the taxpayer in a lot of these
- 19:58cases. And that's because the courts, even though
- 20:03you think they're more unbiased, they are generally,
- 20:07you know, you're the away team as the taxpayer,
- 20:09to put it in a sports methodology, sports analogy.
- 20:12You know, the government's the home team, and
- 20:15the officials are looking to give the calls to
- 20:17the home team if they can. This is something
- 20:22that happens a lot because, I shouldn't say happens
- 20:26a lot, but really surprises people when it happens,
- 20:29and happens more often than people would think.
- 20:32In this case, just a regular old house, a plaintiff
- 20:37purchased a property for 450 ,000, and I hear
- 20:40it all the time, oh, Prop 13, you just get assessed
- 20:42at your purchase price. That is not necessarily
- 20:46true. Actually, it's not true at all. The law
- 20:49is you get reassessed at fair market value. Now,
- 20:53if you have a transaction that is an open market
- 20:58transaction between a willing buyer and willing
- 21:00seller, and there's no exigencies on either of
- 21:02them, then the purchase price is presumed to
- 21:06be the fair market value of the property as of
- 21:08that purchase date. In most instances, you go
- 21:11and buy a a home in Encino and it was on the
- 21:14MLS and you're the winning bid, they're just
- 21:17going to enroll the purchase price 99 times out
- 21:19of 100. But they don't have to do that. They'd
- 21:22be in the county assessor. If they think that
- 21:25you bought something below market, they can put
- 21:28on a higher number. If they think you bought
- 21:30something at an above market value, they can
- 21:32legally put on a lower number. However, I have
- 21:34never seen them think someone bought something
- 21:36at a higher than market value. I've seen the
- 21:39opposite. I've never seen them go, boy, you really
- 21:40pay too much. We're gonna put something less
- 21:42on. So in this case, the buyer bought a house
- 21:46for 450 and the county came back and said 970.
- 21:50And that's pretty tough on the buyer, right?
- 21:52Because the buyer's probably projecting taxes
- 21:54of, OK, I'm going to pay taxes about $5 ,000
- 21:57a year based upon that purchase price. Oh my
- 22:00god, now I'm going to be over $10 ,000 a year
- 22:02because the county thinks they know better than
- 22:06what a property sold for. Now, the plaintiff
- 22:10then came and submitted photographs to the house
- 22:12to the assessor. And the assessor came to the
- 22:15hearing and said, OK, we agree. We were way too.
- 22:18Way too overzealous at 970, but we still think
- 22:22it's more than 450. We think it's 675. So they
- 22:26went, and that's what they recommended at the
- 22:28hearing. And they presented comparable sales
- 22:31to support that valuation. Because remember,
- 22:33for property tax valuation purposes, there's
- 22:35only three valid methods. The income approach,
- 22:39the comparable sales approach, and the cost approach.
- 22:42Those are the only three ways you can value property.
- 22:44Now, for single -family residences, it's almost
- 22:46always going to be valued on a comparable sales
- 22:50approach. Maybe some new construction will be
- 22:51the cost approach. And so they presented comparable
- 22:55sales. Now, the plaintiff showed up, and not
- 22:58understanding, one, the law and not understanding
- 23:00the importance of the assessment appeals board
- 23:01hearing, they didn't present any evidence, any
- 23:05comparable sales. All they did was they showed
- 23:09evidence of what bad state the property was in,
- 23:13but they didn't have any sales. They didn't have
- 23:15any adjustments to sales. They didn't do anything.
- 23:17They didn't have a valid valuation methodology.
- 23:19So even if the county board wanted the rule for
- 23:22the applicant, it would have been very difficult
- 23:25too, because they didn't present a valid valuation
- 23:27approach. So what's very important when you go
- 23:30to these hearings is you can't just critique
- 23:32what the assessor's doing. You have to present
- 23:36your own case, your own case in chief, to show
- 23:38that you're right, your value is right, then
- 23:41you can critique the assessor. That's not a problem,
- 23:44but you can't just go there and only say what
- 23:46they did wrong. You need to show what you did
- 23:48right. Also, be aware that it's the purchase
- 23:56price presumption, as I said. You know, it's
- 23:59overcome fairly easily legally. If either side
- 24:02puts in evidence of a different value, more than
- 24:055 % difference, then the purchase price presumption
- 24:08immediately goes away. And so once the assessor
- 24:13put in evidence of 675, there is no more purchase
- 24:15price presumption. And then the board just has
- 24:19to decide based upon the proponents of the evidence.
- 24:21Who do they think is more right? I always joke
- 24:23that when the purchase price is against the taxpayer,
- 24:25that presumption becomes a lot harder. But when
- 24:27the purchase price presumption is against the
- 24:29assessor, the boards usually are a lot more willing
- 24:32to overlook what the purchase price is. And you
- 24:34just, again, you just got to know kind of the
- 24:37situation that you're battling. So this one's
- 24:42a little older. This is from 2024, but it's an
- 24:45interesting case and it has an interesting background.
- 24:49It's a change of ownership case where a corporation
- 24:56owned property and transferred it out to the
- 25:01owners of the voting stock of the corporation
- 25:05proportionally. But the assessor said, well,
- 25:08no, we don't think that should be excluded from
- 25:11reassessment under the proportional transfer
- 25:13exclusion, which is if you have an entity and
- 25:15it transfers the property to its owners in exact
- 25:18same ownership percentages, it doesn't get reassessed
- 25:21because this corporation had non -voting stock
- 25:24as well. And the question became, hey, when you're
- 25:27measuring ownership interests of an entity, how
- 25:30is it measured? Well, for partnerships and LLCs,
- 25:32the law is really clear. It's capital and profits
- 25:34interests. But for corporations, the law wasn't
- 25:39super clear. For Section 62A2, it's just said
- 25:44the word stock. It says it's measured by the
- 25:48company stock. Now in Section 64, a section a
- 25:52little longer about transfers of ownership interests,
- 25:58transfers of ownership interests of legal entities,
- 26:02it clearly says the word voting stock. And so
- 26:05that was the debate, whether it's all stock or
- 26:09voting stock. And I got a question about the
- 26:11Kim case. I'll go back to that in a second once
- 26:13I finish the Prine case, then I'll answer the
- 26:15question. So the question before the court was,
- 26:22hey, we know it's voting stock when you're transferring
- 26:24interest in entities. But when you're transferring
- 26:26the property out of the entity, how do we measure
- 26:28ownership? And for years, just in practice, everyone
- 26:33just used voting stock. That was just kind of
- 26:35the practice. It was kind of mentioned in assessor's
- 26:38handbooks here or there, and that was super clear,
- 26:40but that was the practice. But the County of
- 26:45Los Angeles took the different approach. They
- 26:47went to the Court of Appeal, fully briefed oral
- 26:50argument. The Court of Appeal couldn't decide,
- 26:53and they sent out emails to me. a lawyer up in
- 26:57Northern California and the California State
- 26:59Board of Equalization said, hey, this is a confusing
- 27:01case. We understand that you guys do a lot of
- 27:03this work. Would you mind writing an amicus brief
- 27:06and telling us what your thoughts were? One,
- 27:10I almost deleted the email because it looked
- 27:12like junk to me until I was kind of ready. I'm
- 27:14like, wait, what's going on? I'd never heard
- 27:15of this before. Two, I wasn't super happy that
- 27:18the Court of Appeal asked me to do work for free.
- 27:21But when the Court of Appeal asks you to do something,
- 27:23you kind of do it. And so independently, All
- 27:28three of us kind of wrote an answer. And I really
- 27:30tried to write it because I actually was always
- 27:31very nervous about that issue. Like I was aware
- 27:34of that issue and always advised people, hey,
- 27:36this could come up. Like, it's not super clear.
- 27:39And I kind of wrote, I was like, look, there's
- 27:42competing statutory interpretations, right? canons
- 27:46of statutory interpretation. One is, hey, if
- 27:48you say it one place, you said voting stock in
- 27:50section 64, and you don't say it in another place,
- 27:52section 62, well, then you meant to not say it.
- 27:55And so it must be all stock and not voting stock.
- 27:58But there's other ones that says that you really
- 28:00should treat everything in similar, in the similar
- 28:03part of a code and a similar part of the law
- 28:05the same. And that's from the thrifty case and
- 28:07some from other cases. And there it's like, well,
- 28:09if you're using voting stock for the legal entity
- 28:11change of ownership, you can also You should
- 28:14also use it for Section 62A2. And oh, by the
- 28:17way, here's why. If you don't do it, you kind
- 28:19of open up this big loophole that will allow
- 28:22people to plan around changes of ownership. Interestingly,
- 28:26I said that. And so I said, at the end of the
- 28:28day, I think the best answer is voting stocks
- 28:30should be treated for both because of that. I
- 28:34said that. The State Board of Equalization said
- 28:36the exact same thing. The government agency tasked
- 28:39with coming up with the rules. And the Northern
- 28:41California attorney said the same thing. And
- 28:43the court of appeals said, thanks very much.
- 28:45Great job, guys. We disagree with all of you.
- 28:47And we're going to say it's all stuck. And then
- 28:49it went up to the California Supreme Court. They
- 28:51took the case. And they came down the exact same
- 28:53way. It's all stuck, which is interesting, because
- 28:56now you can do some stuff. If I own 20 % of a
- 28:59property and my business partner owns 80 % and
- 29:02I want to buy him out, that's usually fairly
- 29:04difficult, right? If I buy the 80%, I get 80
- 29:07% reassessed. If we put it into an LLC or a partnership
- 29:09and I pay 80%, I get 100 % reassessed. But if
- 29:16we put it into a corporation that I own 20 shares
- 29:20and the business partners own 80 shares, but
- 29:23his 80 shares are non -voting and my 80 shares
- 29:26are voting, that's a proportional transfer, no
- 29:29reassessment. And then I can buy out the 80 shares
- 29:33and there's no change of ownership because no
- 29:35one got over 50 % of the voting stock. I already
- 29:37had over 50 % of the voting stock. And that was
- 29:39the example that the state, that the Prine case
- 29:41even kind of mentioned in the decision. So I
- 29:43always say that that planning technique is blessed
- 29:47by the California Supreme Court. They knew it
- 29:49was an issue and they still decided the case
- 29:51that way anyway. So it's an interesting defeat
- 29:54for the taxpayer, but it opens that taxpayer,
- 29:56but it opened up some opportunities for taxpayers.
- 30:01as a whole. So I got a question, I'm gonna click
- 30:04back to the Kim case. It says, so in the Kim
- 30:06case regarding comparables, is it really a burden
- 30:09shifting thing for the owner to defeat the presumption
- 30:12of liability of the home team's evidence? I'm
- 30:15not totally sure what that means, but the problem
- 30:17is, is once the assessor, because in single family
- 30:20residences, the burden is actually on the assessor,
- 30:22not the taxpayer like it is in other cases. And
- 30:26if the assessor goes against the purchase price
- 30:28that qualifies from the purchase price presumption,
- 30:30it goes on that. But once they put in the evidence,
- 30:33the burden's gone now. Out. Doesn't exist anymore.
- 30:37Now it's just whose evidence is better. And in
- 30:40the Kim case, he didn't even put in any evidence.
- 30:43So the assessor did have the burden there. They
- 30:46put in their evidence. Now there is no more burden.
- 30:48Now it's preponderance of the evidence. Who's
- 30:51got the better case? And the applicant didn't
- 30:53present anything. And so by definition, you're
- 30:55going to have to go with the assessor in that
- 30:57case. So the next case is another change of ownership
- 31:10case. And oh, by the way, just on the prank case,
- 31:13just FYI, it's just really hard to win legal
- 31:16entity changes of ownership in court. any case
- 31:19using a legal entity, especially if it's transfers
- 31:22of entity interest, which this really wasn't,
- 31:24this was section 62A2. But just historically,
- 31:27the courts just don't seem to like them and just
- 31:29seem to find any possible way to say there's
- 31:32a change of ownership. In fact, since Prop 13
- 31:35was enacted, there's only been one case where
- 31:38the taxpayer has won a legal entity change of
- 31:40ownership case. And that was the Michael Dell
- 31:42case, the Ocean Avenue. versus County of Los
- 31:45Angeles case from 2014. That's the only time
- 31:47a taxpayer has actually ever won one of those
- 31:50cases. In every other instance, the courts seem
- 31:52to bend over backwards to try to get the assessor
- 31:55to lose. So just, if you're gonna do some legal
- 31:57entity planning, you're doing change of ownership
- 31:59planning, you gotta do it right. Because if you
- 32:02don't do it right, it's hard to fix it on appeal.
- 32:05It's hard to convince a court you didn't do it
- 32:08right. So just be careful with that. Someone
- 32:16says, on your example, and for Prang, wouldn't
- 32:18the purchase of the 80 % non -voting stock trigger
- 32:21the original Cohen rule on costful reassessment?
- 32:24No. And here's why. Because, as I discussed in
- 32:28the beginning, the original Cohen rule and the
- 32:31majority ownership rule found in section 64C1
- 32:34and section 64D measure ownership interest specifically
- 32:38by voting stock. So the non -voting stock does
- 32:42not count towards those tests. Because those
- 32:46rules are specific, voting stock, a transfer
- 32:49of non -voting stock does not count towards a
- 32:52Section 64 change of ownership. That's the thing
- 32:54we pointed out to the California Supreme Court
- 32:56by having two different definitions of what ownership
- 32:59of a corporation is. All stock for Section 62A
- 33:03purposes, voting stock for Section 64 purposes,
- 33:07you allow this kind of nuance to go. So no, it
- 33:10would not cause an additional co -owner, which
- 33:12is a Section 64D change of ownership. So the
- 33:16next case is Equinix LLC versus County of Los
- 33:19Angeles. And this was an extension of the Dianalyn
- 33:24case that came out a few, I don't know, 10 years
- 33:27prior to this. So when you have an over 35 year
- 33:32lease, you create a lease of 35 years or more,
- 33:36that's generally a reassessable event, right?
- 33:38So let's say we created a 50 year lease, right?
- 33:4420 years later, it's now 30 years left. If you
- 33:48extend that lease another 20 years and you go
- 33:49back up to 50 years remaining, as long as it's
- 33:51the same tenant, that's not a change of ownership.
- 33:54Now that was not always the position of the State
- 33:56Board of Equalization. They changed their position
- 33:58and the Diannellen Court confirmed that that
- 34:01over, under, over is not a change of ownership
- 34:05as long as it's the same taxpayer. Now what Diannellen
- 34:08also confirmed that wasn't in the rule is they
- 34:11said, hey, If you had a 50 -year lease, and through
- 34:15the passage of time, now you just have 30 years
- 34:17left, if you buy the underlying fee interest,
- 34:20there's no change of ownership, because you haven't
- 34:22met the entire definition of Section 60, transfer
- 34:25of present interest, beneficial use thereof,
- 34:27and substantially equivalent to the fee. And
- 34:29that's a playoff of when a lease does have 35
- 34:32years or more, it's clear right in the law that
- 34:35if you transfer the underlying fee interest,
- 34:37there's no change of ownership. If you transfer
- 34:38the lease, there is, and vice versa. Once the
- 34:40lease drops under 35 years, it was, if you transfer
- 34:44the fee interest, change of ownership, transfer
- 34:46lease interest, no change of ownership. What
- 34:49Diane Lynn said is, hey, if it's the same taxpayer
- 34:51that had the over 35 year lease, but it's now
- 34:54below 35 years remaining, by the way, that in
- 34:57term includes written or new options, then the
- 34:59transfer of the underlying fee interest to that
- 35:02lessee is not reassessable. And they said the
- 35:04rule on that's invalid. It's not a reassessment.
- 35:08So what these taxpayers tried to do is they tried
- 35:10to take that kind of analysis and said, well,
- 35:14we're not the lessee buying the underlying fee
- 35:16interest. We're a third party buying the underlying
- 35:19fee interest. But the person that is there is
- 35:22a lessee that used to have a 35 year or more
- 35:24lease and it's just dropped below time. It's
- 35:26the same lessee. So if it wasn't a change of
- 35:29ownership if they bought the fee interest, it
- 35:30shouldn't be a change of ownership if we buy
- 35:32the fee interest. It was trying to extend the
- 35:35reason of Dianna Lynn even further outside of
- 35:37the facts of Dianna Lynn. Unfortunately for them,
- 35:41the court said, hey, there's a rule directly
- 35:43on point. We don't think this is the same as
- 35:45when it's the fee owner buying it because we
- 35:47think at that point everything is changing. The
- 35:49three elements of the Section 60 test transfer
- 35:52of present interest, beneficial use thereof,
- 35:54and substantially equivalent to the fee. And
- 35:57so because of that, because all three are still
- 35:59transferring, we think there still is a change
- 36:01of ownership. Sorry, you lose taxpayer. And that
- 36:06was a published decision. Almost immediately
- 36:12thereafter, an identical case basically happened,
- 36:16almost identical, happened down in the county
- 36:20of San Diego. So San Diego had almost the identical
- 36:23issue, and they held the exact same way as County
- 36:27of Los Angeles, that it is a change of ownership.
- 36:29I'm kind of glad this case came out. I didn't
- 36:32really care one way or the other. I didn't handle
- 36:34these, so I didn't really care one or the other
- 36:35how it was decided. But that kind of... extension
- 36:39of the Diannellen case was kind of always out
- 36:41there. You'd have to raise it when you're planning
- 36:43things. And now that it's settled, you can just
- 36:45kind of drop it. If there's a transfer of the
- 36:48underlying fee interest when there's less than
- 36:5035 years remaining on the lease, unless it's
- 36:52to the lessee who had a term of over 35 years,
- 36:54it's a change of ownership and makes things a
- 36:56lot simpler on a going forward basis. So here's
- 37:02one where, you know, we finally get some, you
- 37:06know, kind of fairness for the taxpayer. So,
- 37:10and this is something that happens a lot actually,
- 37:17especially with like parent -child type of stuff,
- 37:19right? Properties owning the trusts, parents
- 37:22die. The kids just leave it in the trust. They
- 37:26eventually just sell the property. They don't
- 37:28realize, they're like, oh, the trust always owned
- 37:30it. Nothing happened, no change of ownership.
- 37:32They don't realize that for property tax, when
- 37:34the second of the parents to die died, it was
- 37:36a transfer, even though there wasn't a real world
- 37:39transfer. And then the county eventually figures
- 37:42out, oh, well that trust sold it, but that's
- 37:45not the trust doors. Oh, they died. Oh, there
- 37:47should have been a reassessment. And what do
- 37:49they do? They reassess and they send all the
- 37:52notices and bills to the address of the property.
- 37:56Well, the property was sold, right? So the person,
- 38:00and they go on the unsecured role, so it's not
- 38:02secured against the real estate, because they
- 38:04can't secure it against to a third party bonafide
- 38:08purchaser for value. And so the new owner gets
- 38:12it and goes, well, that's not me. whatever, and
- 38:15just throws it in the garbage, right? And by
- 38:17the time it gets back to the people who sold
- 38:20the property, well, they've missed all their
- 38:21appeals deadlines. They may have even missed
- 38:23their parent -child filing deadline, because
- 38:25the parent -child, you have to file within three
- 38:28years of the transfer date or before transfer
- 38:32to a third party, except there's a savings clause
- 38:35that says you can file within six months of a
- 38:37notice of supplemental or escape assessment,
- 38:39those notices that I was talking about. at the
- 38:42beginning of the presentation in terms of appealability,
- 38:45they also were important for filing the parent
- 38:47-child. Well, here, that's kind of what happened.
- 38:52They did not file for the parent -child because
- 38:54it just remained in the trust, and they sold
- 38:56the property. And eventually, the Orange County
- 38:59Assessor realized it and said, okay, well, we're
- 39:01going to reassess. And they sent the escape notices
- 39:05to the address of the escrow company. that handled
- 39:09the transfer to the third party, rascored us.
- 39:12And they're like, what's this? Again, they just
- 39:15kind of got rid of it. Eventually, it got back
- 39:19to the beneficiaries of the trust, and they found
- 39:24out, oh, shoot. You know, the tax collectors
- 39:28trying to collect taxes, they're like, what are
- 39:30these? And the tax collectors, well, we billed
- 39:32you for this. We sent you these notes. We never
- 39:34got anything. And had we gotten it, we could
- 39:37have filed a parent -child claim within six months,
- 39:39and there would be no taxes. It would all go
- 39:41away. Well, the assessor denied the application,
- 39:45and the AAB and the trial court also denied everything,
- 39:49because they said, well, it's not the county's
- 39:52fault. They sent it to an address. And just because
- 39:55you didn't get it, that's your problem, not their
- 39:57problem. And the Court of Appeal, I think, used
- 40:01a little bit of logic. They're like, no, wait
- 40:04a second. The law says, like, last address known
- 40:07to the assessor, you should. you should, you
- 40:14knew where these bills were going ahead of time.
- 40:16They could, especially in this case, it was going
- 40:17to a different address. It wasn't going to the
- 40:19property address. So they were getting all their,
- 40:21their bills at a different address. So like you
- 40:24were sending these bills for years to this address,
- 40:27and then you decide to send these escape bills
- 40:29to the escrow company. That's outrageous. We're
- 40:34gonna use the date of notice as when you first
- 40:37contacted them and they found out about it. And
- 40:39because of that, you now have a valid parent
- 40:41-child and this can all go away. So your assessments
- 40:44were invalid because you sent them to the wrong
- 40:47address. This happens a lot, and so you gotta
- 40:51be careful there. If you ever do get it, sometimes
- 40:54it's worth filing an appeal, even if you know
- 40:56you're outside of the appeals period and arguing
- 40:59like, hey, it was impossible for us to do this
- 41:02because you didn't send this to the right address.
- 41:04And because you didn't send this to the right
- 41:06address, you know, the law never requires impossibilities.
- 41:10It's a great, it's a great, it's in the California
- 41:12Civil Code. And it's been written into the property
- 41:15tax law by the California Supreme Court and Williams
- 41:17and Thicket. It's impossible to file on something
- 41:20when you've never gotten notice from it. And
- 41:22when they send it to a wrong address, they shouldn't
- 41:24get away with it. And so just be careful on that.
- 41:28Before I move on to another one, I got a question.
- 41:32And I like, by the way, I like the change of
- 41:33ownership question. So if you have any change
- 41:36of ownership questions, the more the merrier.
- 41:41This is a question about trust. Instead of gifting
- 41:44properties directly to children equally, instead,
- 41:48can you preserve proposition 13? And by the way,
- 41:52there is no such thing as preserving Proposition
- 41:5313. You're preserving your base year value. The
- 41:56whole system is Proposition 13. So you're preserving
- 41:58your base year value by gifting an option to
- 42:02purchase with the condition of moving into the
- 42:03property. So the only child who will end up with
- 42:06the property to avoid reassessment. Non -owner
- 42:08children who don't live there won't ever receive
- 42:10an ownership interest in the property. Yeah,
- 42:12so what often happens is the trust will say,
- 42:15there's three kids and... It'll just say, hey,
- 42:18the three kids get a third each of the interest.
- 42:22Now, if one kid wants the property, in order
- 42:25to get the full parent -child exclusion in that
- 42:27instance, you would have to equalize the distribution
- 42:32of the trust. So if there's three kids and the
- 42:36house is worth $900 ,000 with no loan, and there's
- 42:42$1 .8 million of cash, easy. 900 ,000 goes to
- 42:47the one kid and 900 ,000 of cash goes to the
- 42:49other two kids. But it never usually works out
- 42:52that easily that there's enough money to equalize.
- 42:55Usually the biggest asset is the home and a lot
- 42:57of people's trust. In that instance, you can
- 43:00do a non -priority distribution using a third
- 43:05party loan taken out by the trustee of the trust
- 43:07that's secured to the real estate. Or if you
- 43:10were ahead of a death, you can't do this after
- 43:12death, but ahead of the death, if you give a
- 43:15child the right of first refusal or the right
- 43:17of option to purchase, then you don't have to
- 43:20equalize the assessment. The child can just purchase
- 43:23the property directly from the trust. It will
- 43:26not be viewed as a sibling -to -sibling transfer.
- 43:29And they can qualify for the full parent -child
- 43:32exclusion, whether that's the old parent -child,
- 43:34if the transfer happened prior to February 21,
- 43:37or the new parent -child under Prop 19. And then
- 43:41someone says, can 1K get a loan to pay it off?
- 43:44The kid can cannot get a loan. An equalized distribution
- 43:47using a loan, here's the best example, house
- 43:49worth a million dollars, no other assets, one
- 43:51kid wants it, one kid doesn't, two kids. The
- 43:53trustee of the trust would go get a loan, usually
- 43:56have to go to a hard money lender because most
- 43:58banks won't make those loans. They will secure
- 44:02the property with a $500 ,000 loan. $500 ,000
- 44:06will be distributed to kid one. The property
- 44:08subject to the loan will be distributed to kid
- 44:10two, so they each got $500 ,000 of value. That
- 44:14old non -prolata equalized distribution using
- 44:18a loan still works under the current new parent
- 44:22child. Now, obviously, the new parent child is
- 44:24limited in its benefits, but you can still do
- 44:28that if necessary. So here's the one that has
- 44:44everyone who does property tax work waiting,
- 44:48especially if you have any hotel cases, because
- 44:50LA has kind of put all hotel cases on hold until
- 44:54they get the decision in Olympic and Georgia.
- 44:59There's three issues in Olympic and Georgia,
- 45:02but two of them. One deals with basically a kickback
- 45:06of transmitting occupancy tax from the city to
- 45:09Olympic in Georgia in order to incentivize them
- 45:11to build the hotels where they are. Another is
- 45:15a key money discount from the management company
- 45:18and whether that should be included in the cashflow.
- 45:20Those aren't as wide ranging of issues and it'll
- 45:22be interesting to see. where the Supreme Court
- 45:25comes down on those issues. Those were the two
- 45:27issues that were discussed in oral argument the
- 45:29most. Interestingly, the thing that wasn't really
- 45:31discussed in oral argument is the more wide ranging
- 45:34issue, which is what is the proper way to value
- 45:41a hotel or any property that is kind of a business
- 45:46that's operating at the real estate, right? And
- 45:50one more Prop 19 question. Prior to Prop 19,
- 45:54in addition to the parent -child exemption, do
- 45:56you state also qualified for $1 million for other
- 45:58properties? Is that statewide or county by county?
- 46:01Statewide. So it's $1 million per parent of trended
- 46:05base year value, not fair market value, but trended
- 46:07base year value. But it is all statewide. So
- 46:10if you already transferred a bunch of property
- 46:11in San Diego County and you went over the threshold,
- 46:14you don't have another million in the County
- 46:18of Los Angeles. There's two major ways, and the
- 46:24hotel is the most obvious example. One major
- 46:27way is kind of called the Lenhoff method, and
- 46:30the other is the Rushmore method. The assessor
- 46:33for years has used the Rushmore method to value
- 46:35hotels, which they say, when you're valuing a
- 46:38hotel, when you're valuing a property, you're
- 46:40supposed to use the revenue that the property
- 46:44can generate, right? And the basic example is
- 46:46an office building, like where I'm in right now.
- 46:48We pay rent and we're generally just paying rent
- 46:50for the real estate. There's very little intangibles
- 46:53or business value that we're paying for when
- 46:55we pay rent for our office space, right? But
- 46:58when you go to a hotel and you rent a room for
- 47:01$400 a night, you're not just paying for the
- 47:05room, right? You're paying for... the concierge,
- 47:09you're paying for the different services that
- 47:11the hotel provides if it's a resort, you're paying
- 47:14for the personal property, you're paying for
- 47:17the brand loyalty and the points that you're
- 47:19gonna receive if you only stay at Marriott's
- 47:22or if you only stay at Hilton's, right? You're
- 47:24paying for the booking system that they're using.
- 47:26You're paying for a lot of different things than
- 47:29just the real estate. And so the assessor for
- 47:33years said, well, we use the Rushmore method,
- 47:35and all they do is deduct out the franchise fee
- 47:38and the management fee, just the expense. And
- 47:42that takes out all intangibles. Everything else
- 47:44is related to the real property and the personal
- 47:47property. And the taxpayers for years said, that
- 47:50makes no sense. Why would I pay Marriott a million
- 47:53dollars a year to get a million dollars of value?
- 47:57I'm not going to pay Marriott a million dollars
- 47:59a year. I'm gonna pay Marriott a million dollars
- 48:02a year to get more than a million dollars back.
- 48:04Like, I need to get a return of the million dollars
- 48:07and a return on the million dollars. And for
- 48:12years, the assessor stuck with the Rushmore,
- 48:14and for years, they won almost every single time.
- 48:18And then it wasn't until this case that came
- 48:21out, it's called Elk Hills, that came out, I
- 48:23think in 2013, maybe 2011, 2011, 2013, that range,
- 48:29where the Supreme Court dealt with the assessment
- 48:32of intangibles for the first time in years, and
- 48:37laid down a test that basically said what the
- 48:39assessor was doing was wrong. Well, the assessor
- 48:42still said, eh, we don't need to follow the Supreme
- 48:45Court, because it's not specifically about hotels.
- 48:47It's about a power plant. And so even though
- 48:50it's clearly applicable to our evaluations, we're
- 48:52not going to follow it. Then a case came down,
- 48:56Half Moon Bay. which was about a hotel. And Happy
- 49:02Moon Bay specifically said the Rushmore method
- 49:04is an invalid method under California property
- 49:07tax law. And that's pretty clear, right? It was
- 49:13a published decision, binding on everybody. And
- 49:17a lot of counties, especially LA County and San
- 49:19Francisco County said, eh, well, it's not our
- 49:23county who fought that. So even though it is
- 49:25binding on us, we're not gonna follow it. And
- 49:27then another case came down, St. Francis, and
- 49:29they said, yep, yep, Rushmore's clearly, clearly,
- 49:32clearly invalid. You gotta, can't do it. And
- 49:37then LA finally got their time in the sun, and
- 49:39they have an Olympic in Georgia. And they said,
- 49:41well, we'll just try to get a competing Court
- 49:42of Appeal decision. And the Olympic in Georgia,
- 49:46which by the way, in an interesting move, the
- 49:48California Supreme Court granted review of the
- 49:51decision, but left. the Court of Appeal decision
- 49:54as citable. Usually when they grant review, the
- 49:57Court of Appeal decision is not citable anymore
- 49:59until they issue a decision. It's still citable.
- 50:02And the Olympic and Georgia very clearly said,
- 50:04hey, this is now like kind of settled. The Rushmore
- 50:06method is just invalid because you're not fully
- 50:09taking out the intangibles. You're just taking
- 50:11out the return of the intangible. You're not
- 50:13taking out the return on the intangible. Now,
- 50:16as I said, there's the two other issues that
- 50:18are kind of more specific to to the taxpayer
- 50:22in Olympic in Georgia. It's at the California
- 50:26Supreme Court. It's fully briefed oral argument
- 50:29was in early June, I believe. The oral argument,
- 50:34the questions from the court focused almost entirely
- 50:36on the first two issues and very little on. whether
- 50:39Rushmore is invalid or not, I expect the Supreme
- 50:42Court to confirm that the Rushmore method is
- 50:45invalid, which that's the last straw. Then the
- 50:48County of Los Angeles Assessor Office will finally
- 50:50have to... come back and figure out something
- 50:54that is not the Rushmore method in terms of the
- 50:56valuation of intangibles for hotels and valuation
- 51:00of intangibles for any other kind of properties
- 51:02that are similar to that. A senior assisted living
- 51:04facility is another good example, right? You
- 51:07pay a certain amount per month to live there,
- 51:09but it's not like an apartment building. It's
- 51:10not just pure rent. You know, you're paying for
- 51:13the help, you're paying for some meals, you're
- 51:14paying for all this other stuff. There's more
- 51:16than just real property. Even high -end apartment
- 51:19buildings, like some of these newer apartment
- 51:20buildings that have concierge services, and they'll
- 51:24go pick up your dry cleaning for you and everything,
- 51:27and it's all included in your rent. That's actually
- 51:29a lot of non -real estate payment that really
- 51:32should be deducted under the Elk Hills, Hatham
- 51:34Bay, San Francisco, and potentially Olympic in
- 51:37Georgia. So this is going to be really important.
- 51:44There's also a huge backlog of hotel cases that
- 51:46are coming down that the assessor is going to
- 51:49have to deal with when this case comes out. And
- 51:51we should get a decision fairly soon on that.
- 51:56So that'll change a lot and hopefully lead to
- 51:59a lot of refunds for taxpayers. So certainly
- 52:02something to kind of keep in mind on a going
- 52:08forward basis out there. And again, for all these
- 52:13type of cases, it's always very important. As
- 52:17you know, this case went to the assessment appeals
- 52:20board, then it went to trial court, then it went
- 52:21to court of appeal. If they had not made these
- 52:24arguments at the assessment appeals board, if
- 52:26they had not exhausted their administrative revenues
- 52:30at the assessment appeals board, they would have
- 52:33had no chance of of arguing this later at court.
- 52:40So it is, again, I can't stress enough how important
- 52:44it is on every type of question, change of ownership,
- 52:47value, or anything. You need to treat the assessment
- 52:51appeals board case. as a superior court trial
- 52:55and request findings if you're worried about
- 52:59the decision. Because if you don't request findings,
- 53:00I mean, I've gotten a lot of people who had property
- 53:03tax consultants or agents who aren't lawyers
- 53:05who are representing them at a property tax case,
- 53:09and they don't request findings. And then they
- 53:10get loose. And they said, well, can we challenge
- 53:13it in court? And it's like, well, even if you
- 53:15had something to challenge in court, we don't
- 53:17know what to challenge in court because you didn't
- 53:18get any findings. So we don't know how the board
- 53:20decided. So there is all these very sticky little
- 53:24issues in property tax that can really turn you
- 53:27sideways if you don't get that. So that's kind
- 53:32of the update. I was very specific, so I have
- 53:35to get to 1 .30, so I have six more minutes if
- 53:37anyone else has a Q &A that they want to put
- 53:41into our question, that they want to put into
- 53:44the question and answer box. I'd be happy to
- 53:49help answer it there. If not, I can fill the
- 53:52last couple of minutes with, I know, oh, here
- 53:55we go. Who is required to apply for the parent
- 53:58-child exclusion for transfer of residents from
- 54:00a trust to a beneficiary upon distribution of
- 54:04all trust assets? The trustee or the intended
- 54:07beneficiary? So that's a good question. So actually,
- 54:11the answer is both. So on the parent -child form,
- 54:16the transferor has to sign. And in a trust situation,
- 54:20obviously, if the parents have died, it's going
- 54:23to be whoever the trustee of the trust is. So
- 54:25the trustee of the trust is going to have to
- 54:28sign on behalf of the transferor, which are the
- 54:31deceased parents in a lot of instances. Or if
- 54:33they're alive, the parents would sign. And then
- 54:38the second page is the transferee has to sign.
- 54:41Now there, if there's multiple children, only
- 54:44one has to sign the parent -child form. So trustee
- 54:56is for transferor, transferee child, only one
- 54:59of them has to sign it. Now here's a great question.
- 55:03Prior to title being transferred, So do you do
- 55:08the deed, do you do the parent child before the
- 55:12transfer happens or after? Well, legally you
- 55:14can do it the moment the person dies. So you
- 55:17can do it before, but you can also wait until
- 55:19after. And sometimes it's a little less confusing
- 55:21if you wait until after, so long as you're within
- 55:23all the relevant time periods, because then on
- 55:26the form you can reference the deed transfer.
- 55:31out of the trust. So they know that that D transfer
- 55:34out of the trust relates back to that parent
- 55:37-child. Because I've actually had that happen
- 55:39where they were just taking forever. They filed
- 55:42a parent -child. It got approved as of the day
- 55:44of death. And then there was a D transfer out
- 55:46of the trust to the kid, and the assessor reassessed
- 55:48that. And we had to go back, challenge it, and
- 55:50show them, hey, that's actually just the transfer
- 55:52to the beneficiary. That's not reassessable.
- 55:54They always agree, but it just added more time.
- 55:57So I think it's you know, if it's okay on timing,
- 56:01it's sometimes better. So you can reference that
- 56:03deed on the parent child form, but you can't
- 56:05always do it. Sometimes you're coming up against
- 56:07deadlines and whatever. And the other thing you
- 56:10got to remember, cause this is happening so much.
- 56:12And I hate that the estate board put this into
- 56:14their rules. I actually don't agree. And I don't
- 56:17think this is what the constitutional amendment
- 56:19for prop 19 actually intended. But if you do
- 56:22not file for the homeowner's exemption within
- 56:25a year of date of death, regardless of if it's
- 56:27been deeded, out or not. Even if you timely file
- 56:30for the parent child, you're only going to get
- 56:32prospective relief. You're not going to get full
- 56:34retroactive relief. So you have to get the homeowners
- 56:40exemption on file within a year. And if you don't
- 56:44know who's going to live there, or if you're
- 56:45not sure, just file for everybody. It's just
- 56:48intended beneficiary, just file. Because you
- 56:50can always amend the homeowners exemption later,
- 56:52but get something on file that you can point
- 56:54to within a year. It should be on your little
- 56:56list now. If someone comes and they said their
- 56:58parents passed away or something, you've got
- 57:00to file that within a year. I have another question,
- 57:05off -topic sort of, any updates on the ULA mansion
- 57:08property slits? 50 -50 decides that the documentary
- 57:11transfer tax and LA City's efforts to combat
- 57:13the technique. Yeah, so some people have tried
- 57:16to get kind of smart. And, you know, right now
- 57:18the lower level threshold for ULA is like 5 -3.
- 57:23Originally it was Five, but they trended up.
- 57:26So say you're selling a $10 million house today.
- 57:29Well, I'll sell you a 50 % tenant in common interest
- 57:32for five million, a 50 % tenant in common interest
- 57:34for the other five million. I'm under the thresholds,
- 57:36no ULA. The city set up a task force to capture
- 57:40those exact type of transactions, and they are
- 57:43for the most part catching them and assessing
- 57:45them. So I would... I would not be trying to
- 57:50do that. I don't think that's the brightest planning
- 57:51technique. I think there might be some better
- 57:53ones. Obviously, there's no panel who's your
- 57:56interest with ULA. So if you want to take a run
- 57:59at it and hope they don't discover it, I know
- 58:00some have definitely gotten through the cracks.
- 58:03If not, you'd have to file a appeal and challenge
- 58:05it. And I don't think you're going to win at
- 58:07the administrative level on that. Nothing's gotten
- 58:08the court on that yet. But I think that's a ripe
- 58:12argument for sham transaction, substance over
- 58:15form type of thing for the city. Someone said,
- 58:19what about ULA selling business billing, but
- 58:21still applies. ULA only applies to the transfer
- 58:24of real estate. So it doesn't apply to a transfer
- 58:26of a business. It only applies to the transfer
- 58:29of real estate. I have another question. How
- 58:32does a stepparent surviving a parent impact an
- 58:35eventual parent -child transfer? They're still,
- 58:38stepparents. are still considered parents. So
- 58:44you can still, a step parent, I'm not totally
- 58:46sure what the question is there. A step parent
- 58:48can still transfer to the child. There is a special
- 58:53rule though for the grandparent, grandchild that
- 58:55the step parent then is like kind of carved out
- 58:58as a non -parent. So it depends on what the question
- 59:01is. But there's very specific rules on step parents.
- 59:06If the property is never transferred from a trust
- 59:08after a parent's death, there is no reassessment.
- 59:11That's incorrect. So even if it stays in the
- 59:15trust, it is a reassessable event. Now, maybe
- 59:17the county doesn't catch it because they don't
- 59:19know about it, but that doesn't change that it
- 59:21was a reassessable event. We look through trust.
- 59:24When the trustors die, it is a reassessable event
- 59:27the moment they die, even if you don't ever take
- 59:29the property out of the trust for the next 30
- 59:31years. The reassessment occurred. Now, again,
- 59:33there's a difference between what they might
- 59:35catch and not catch. But just because it remains
- 59:38in the trust does not mean it's not reassessable.
- 59:42Another question, can you please clarify when
- 59:45appeal can be filed for a client value that does
- 59:47not become apparent until after an arm's length
- 59:49sale at a price below assessed value? after expiration
- 59:53of a tax year. Boy, I'm not sure what that means.
- 1:00:00So decline in value appeal has to be filed as
- 1:00:03of, in the regular filing period. So it has to
- 1:00:06be filed between July 2nd and either September
- 1:00:1015th and November 30th. the value as of January
- 1:00:141 of 2025, and you are allowed to use any comparable
- 1:00:18sales that occurred before that date and up to
- 1:00:2090 days after that date. So if you bought a property
- 1:00:23and then something sold just recently, say something
- 1:00:26sold June of 25, that's not relevant to a 2025
- 1:00:30appeal. That sale would be relevant to a 2026,
- 1:00:33the client value appeal. I hope that answers
- 1:00:35the question. How far back can a county go for
- 1:00:38a reassessment? after a person dies and it never
- 1:00:41gets reported. So if it's a death, it's not reported
- 1:00:45timely and there's no deed or anything like that,
- 1:00:47the answer is eight years. They can always reassess
- 1:00:50and they can go back eight years of back taxes.
- 1:00:53So if it happened in 2002, they can reassess
- 1:00:55in 2002, but they can only issue eight years
- 1:00:58of back taxes. And with that, I think we're...
- 1:01:03For ULA, if you heard anything about the assessor
- 1:01:05accumulating multiple deeds from family members
- 1:01:07and entities, yes, not the assessor. The assessor
- 1:01:10has nothing to do with ULA. It's the city. And
- 1:01:13yes, they have been doing that. I think with
- 1:01:15that, we're actually over the thresholds at the
- 1:01:17time. Thanks so much, everybody. And thank you
- 1:01:20for all the questions. I really appreciate it.