Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Trial Tutorials: Dealing with Bad Facts and Bad Witnesses with Teresa Johnson, Daniel Kramer
Transcript
- 0:03Hello and welcome to Trial Tutorials, dealing
- 0:06with bad facts and bad witnesses. I'm Alapoli
- 0:09Castro, CLE advisor for the Beverly Hills Bar
- 0:12Association, and today I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:14our speakers. Daniel Kramer and Teresa Johnson.
- 0:18Daniel Kramer is the founder of Kramer Trial
- 0:21Lawyers. He specializes in representing families
- 0:23and individuals involved in catastrophic personal
- 0:26injury and wrongful death matters, as well as
- 0:29employment discrimination and retaliation lawsuits.
- 0:32Daniel's verdicts on behalf of his clients have
- 0:34been featured in multiple legal industry publications,
- 0:37such as the Daily Journal. Five of his verdicts
- 0:40were ranked as the top 50 verdicts in the state
- 0:42of California, multiple years in a row. top verdict.
- 0:46Daniel has been a finalist of Calais Rising Star
- 0:49Award and has received prestigious top attorney
- 0:52awards from numerous publications and organizations,
- 0:55including Super Lawyers and Best Lawyers in America,
- 0:57just to name a few. He is a frequent speaker
- 1:00and published writer on topics related to advanced
- 1:02trial and litigation strategies, and he chairs
- 1:05the personal injury section of Beverly Hills
- 1:07Bar Association. Teresa Johnson is a trial lawyer
- 1:11and partner at Kramer Trial Lawyers, practicing
- 1:14in the areas of plaintiff's personal injury,
- 1:16wrongful death, and employment litigation. Many
- 1:19of the verdicts Teresa has secured on behalf
- 1:21of her clients have been ranked by top verdict
- 1:23in the state of California and across the nation
- 1:26for the respective years in which they were obtained.
- 1:29Teresa serves on the Board of Governors for CALA
- 1:31and was a finalist for the CALA Rising Star Award
- 1:34in 2021 and 2023. Teresa is also on the Board
- 1:37of Directors for the Los Angeles Trial Lawyers
- 1:40Charities. She's a frequent speaker and published
- 1:43writer on topics related to litigation and advanced
- 1:46trial tactics. We can't wait to hear what they
- 1:48have to share with us today. So let's get started.
- 1:51Thank you very much. Welcome, everybody. Thank
- 1:53you for tuning in on this great series of programs
- 1:57BHBA has. So we're going to dive right in. I
- 2:01think there's an important distinction before
- 2:04we start is that this this program is going to
- 2:08be about bad facts. But not about bad cases.
- 2:12So I think there's an important difference that,
- 2:16you know, I'm sure we all I have bad cases that
- 2:19end up not being good cases or righteous case.
- 2:22I mean, they all start out righteous, but it
- 2:24turns out that maybe some evidence comes out
- 2:26or a witness says something or a client does
- 2:29something that. we thought was true and not being
- 2:32true and then it sort of becomes a bad case and
- 2:36A case that either should settle or it just you
- 2:38really shouldn't be moving forward to trial So
- 2:41this tutorial is not going to cure your bad cases,
- 2:44but it will hopefully help you deal with Facts
- 2:49that you know traditionally or maybe in a vacuum
- 2:53seem like quote bad facts, but actually can be
- 2:59or framed in a way that they become just part
- 3:02of your client's story. And I think especially
- 3:07nowadays, and I know this is not just to plaintiff
- 3:10lawyers, this is to both sides and all different
- 3:13types of practice, not just personal injury or
- 3:15employment, it can apply to a business case or
- 3:18a contract dispute or who knows what criminal
- 3:20case. But I think that nowadays what I find is
- 3:25that Well one we all know there is no perfect
- 3:28case. There is no perfect client. There's no
- 3:31perfect person and I think in today's world even
- 3:35more so it's almost like the to perfect client
- 3:40or the to perfect defendant to perfect company
- 3:43Almost doesn't seem real to a jury any longer
- 3:47And so in a way, you know showing vulnerability
- 3:52or showing the rough around the edges client
- 3:56or human story can actually make them more relatable
- 4:01to a real jury. And I find that some of our best
- 4:05results have been with a client that, you know,
- 4:07has some warts or maybe some skeletons in the
- 4:10closet. And as long as we are open and honest
- 4:14and upfront about them. Then it no longer becomes
- 4:17a bad thing. In fact, it makes that story a jury,
- 4:22many jurors, because everyone has shit happens
- 4:25to them, bad things in their background, tough,
- 4:27tough situations. No one's perfect and no jurors
- 4:30are perfect. And so then there's something that
- 4:32they can now connect to as long as we as the
- 4:35attorneys have been upfront, completely transparent,
- 4:40open and honest about it. that you know it actually
- 4:43can make for a good fact and a good story so
- 4:47so even though the episode is titled bad facts
- 4:50i i want to be very clear that it's all in quotes
- 4:53and we want to help you rethink about these things
- 4:57that you're scared of that keep us all up at
- 4:59night because we all have them Teresa and i just
- 5:01finished a trial last week that had some a lot
- 5:03of quote -unquote very tough bad facts that we
- 5:08had to overcome, but we did it by being open
- 5:10and transparent about it. So that's really how
- 5:12we're going to start. Teresa, let's get started
- 5:17here. I'm going to share my screen. And if you
- 5:20have any questions and anything you want to throw
- 5:23in there, please do so. When I'm not talking,
- 5:26I'm going to be monitoring it and we'll throw
- 5:28it in there if it applies. And Teresa is going
- 5:30to be doing the same. So please feel free to
- 5:32do it. How are you doing, Teresa? Doing really
- 5:34well. Thanks for having us, everyone. It's nice
- 5:36to see you all. One thing I just want to add
- 5:39real quick before we start, Dan, is this all
- 5:43really starts from being open with your client
- 5:46from the very beginning and making sure that
- 5:48you have that trust so you're getting all the
- 5:50bad facts from the very beginning. By the time
- 5:53you get to trial, which is what we're focusing
- 5:54on, none of this should be a surprise. You should
- 5:57know everything and you should know it well before
- 6:00the defense does so that you know how to combat
- 6:02it. in litigation and all the way up to and including
- 6:06during trial. So make sure that you start that
- 6:09from the very beginning in your relationship.
- 6:12Get all that information, the good, the bad,
- 6:14the ugly so that you know and you can be prepared
- 6:16and one step ahead every single way all the way
- 6:20up through trial. Yeah, that's a that's a really
- 6:22good point. And I think it's hard, right? I mean,
- 6:26our clients, again, whether you're on the plaintiff
- 6:29or defense, you know, they're scared to talk
- 6:31to attorneys and They're in this situation not
- 6:35by really choice at all on either side. And so
- 6:38to be open with your client initially to get
- 6:42them to give you all the bad stuff because it's
- 6:44hard for any of us. Frankly, like whether you're
- 6:46talking to a friend, a spouse, therapist, doctor,
- 6:50we like to sugarcoat everything because we don't
- 6:52want to look bad in anyone's eyes. And so it's
- 6:54hard to get a client especially to an attorney
- 6:57to say like just give it give me all the good
- 6:59bad and the ugly we do not judge and sometimes
- 7:02that takes us being vulnerable this is what we
- 7:05do in jury selection like if you if there's something
- 7:07about about you that may seem like a weakness
- 7:11or a vulnerability, share it so they will connect
- 7:14with you. And a lot of times those personal stories
- 7:17will get the client to trust you, like Theresa's
- 7:20saying, in order to get those quote unquote skeletons
- 7:23or bad facts. So with that, let me share my screen
- 7:27and we're doing kind of. We did this last year,
- 7:29but we're going to apply it. I know you all have
- 7:31been focusing on this Nathan Taylor verse vacations
- 7:35by the sea, and we will be talking about those
- 7:38facts. We've added some to make it a tougher
- 7:40case for the plaintiff. Like, I think we made
- 7:42the guy a drug addict. He has a felony conviction.
- 7:44He may be an undocumented immigrant. We're not
- 7:46really sure. We just do some really, really tough
- 7:49stuff about this guy, about our boy Nathan Taylor
- 7:52here that makes the case a little harder because
- 7:55I want you all to see how we would deal with
- 7:57these tough facts and how we really frankly have
- 7:59in most of our trials because we've dealt with
- 8:02a lot of tough facts, tough clients. What you
- 8:05start to see is there are pattern forms and the
- 8:08pattern really becomes like, okay, this bad fact,
- 8:11how you handle it is going to be very similar
- 8:13with every type of bad fact. This may be fact
- 8:17fact specific, but you can really apply the same
- 8:19blueprint for all of your type of cases. And
- 8:22we're going to use kind of a movie theme. We
- 8:24did it last time. And so we're going to use some
- 8:28some movies. So maybe you might recognize some
- 8:30of these. All right. So let me hope I can share
- 8:33here. There we go. That's obviously us. We don't
- 8:37need that too much longer. So bad facts like
- 8:42we talked about. Got Hannibal Ector here to talk
- 8:46about the bad facts because every client deserves
- 8:49a defense even Hannibal Ector deserved a defense.
- 8:53Let's talk about some bad facts. We want to create
- 8:56or had for this case. So our guy Nathan, you
- 9:00know he before he went on this cruise before
- 9:02he met his wife. He got in some trouble at least
- 9:05in our little hypothetical and let's say when
- 9:09he was 18. I'm literally just making this up
- 9:14right now, but did some carjacking with some
- 9:18buddies in college. It was charged with the felony
- 9:21and it's going to come into evidence. So that's
- 9:26another point for this little scenario is that
- 9:30one, you always try to mill out the bad stuff.
- 9:33So we're not saying like if you can keep out
- 9:36the felonies, do it. If you can keep out drugs
- 9:38and alcohol, do it. If you can keep out Any of
- 9:41the bad stuff 100 % try to do it first do motions
- 9:45and lemonade. We do motions. Let me for all the
- 9:48bad stuff because it's a lot better not to have
- 9:51to deal with it. We're assuming for this scenario
- 9:53that it's coming in, but I do want to make sure
- 9:56that you all for all the bad stuff do emotion
- 9:59eliminate because frankly a lot of this would
- 10:02be in a lot of stuff we deal with should be irrelevant,
- 10:04but we just are assuming that a judge is going
- 10:07to deny your motion and lemonade. In the case
- 10:10we just tried, our client had some wine before
- 10:15the incident. It was a premises liability case,
- 10:18a tough kind of trip and fall case where she
- 10:20fell and had a concussion, mild traumatic brain
- 10:22injury. But there was evidence by her own admission
- 10:25that she had some wine before the incident, which
- 10:28kind of goes to our next slide. But the hospital
- 10:34record said that, you know, she really didn't
- 10:37have any. There was no evidence of BAC at all.
- 10:41The alcohol tests were normal and the defense
- 10:44didn't have any expert who could say that her
- 10:47drinking wine had any that she was impaired because
- 10:51she drank like a glass of wine a couple hours
- 10:53before half a glass. Obviously, the defense wanted
- 10:55to bring it in. But like, what's the relevance
- 10:58if they don't have an expert who's going to say
- 10:59that? in any way contributed to her fall. We
- 11:03have the hospital saying she did not have, she
- 11:05was definitely not above the legal limit. She
- 11:07didn't even have anything show up. So the first
- 11:09thing we did is mill it out and the judge saw
- 11:12through it and said, yeah, like what is the relevance?
- 11:15It's, you know, more prejudicial than probative.
- 11:17So stuff you want to do motions and lemonade.
- 11:21And Teresa is a fantastic writer. We have motions
- 11:24limited for most bad facts. Don't we Teresa?
- 11:27Probably or they could be modified. So if anybody
- 11:30needs samples, don't hesitate to reach out. Yeah,
- 11:33100%. So so our guy Nathan, not only is he an
- 11:36ex con, he also, you know, he was drinking and
- 11:39partying on the cruise ship on the day of the
- 11:42incident. So had to deal with that. We also in
- 11:47this one this is not a fact we made up but it
- 11:50comes up in a lot of personal injury cases is
- 11:52where you have a plaintiff who is You know needs
- 11:57medical care and they go to the attorney the
- 12:01attorney then sends them to a doctor Now, let
- 12:03me tell you this for all my plaintiff brothers
- 12:06and sisters out there I do not recommend you
- 12:11do this unless your client really needs it. So
- 12:15What we see a lot is that attorneys just get
- 12:18the case, and the client may have great insurance,
- 12:22great primary care physicians, people they really
- 12:25like. They've been going to for years for every
- 12:27other ailment, and then the attorney may scoop
- 12:29them out of that and then send them to. lean
- 12:33doctors. Now, I think lean doctors are great.
- 12:35They do help people that can't afford treatment
- 12:38and they delay their pay for years often at times.
- 12:41And there's ways that we do it in closing argument
- 12:43where we flip it. And I can talk a little bit
- 12:45about that to make it more of a class argument
- 12:48that the defense is trying to make. But I just
- 12:51do recommend that you always try to have your
- 12:54client treat through their own insurance first,
- 12:56no matter what. And it really should be a last
- 12:58resort situation where the client really can't
- 13:02get care. Maybe they don't have good insurance
- 13:04that then you say, look, here's a list of doctors
- 13:08that I recommend that I think will treat on a
- 13:10lean. And then you let them decide based on their
- 13:13own research. It's just it's one, it's cleaner.
- 13:16It's better. Frankly, it's better for your client.
- 13:18If they can go through their own insurance, they're
- 13:20happy with their own doctor. It's much better
- 13:22at trial. It takes away this bad fact from the
- 13:25defense. looks like um Daniel it looks like the
- 13:52uh zoom session had some sort of lag if you could
- 13:55begin your um this maybe about the start of this
- 14:00slide or so just so that we could maybe you know
- 14:02go back and sorry about that so uh what i was
- 14:07saying was that just if you are a plaintiff attorney
- 14:11doing attorney -referred lien treatment is a
- 14:15last resort situation. If they have insurance,
- 14:17have them go through their insurance, only if
- 14:19they've tried exhaust every other avenue to get
- 14:23care, then you would wanna give them a list of
- 14:26doctors who you know would treat on a lien that
- 14:28would be good doctors. But nonetheless, the defense
- 14:31or the other side, especially in this Taylor
- 14:33versus Vacations by the Sea case, they're gonna
- 14:36argue it. And initially we do a lot of focus
- 14:39groups, focus groups hang on this kind of stuff.
- 14:41They think it's all a conspiracy that it's ambulance
- 14:45chasing, it's build up to rack up medical bills
- 14:48and all that. So it is a tough fact that we have
- 14:50to deal with, but we also just have to reframe
- 14:53it because at the end of the day, if you really
- 14:56just fundamentally sit down and think about it.
- 14:58the doctors are delaying payment for much longer
- 15:04than a hospital would or maybe a insurance PCP
- 15:08would years to people that may not be able to
- 15:11afford the type of best surgeon in Beverly Hills.
- 15:14But now this indigent plaintiff is able to get
- 15:17the best care because these doctors are willing
- 15:18to say You can pay me later. Don't worry about
- 15:21it. I want to give you care now. And then we
- 15:25flip it on the defense and we say the defense
- 15:26is saying, especially if it's a corporation,
- 15:28we say, guess where the CEO of this defendant
- 15:30is going to go if they have spinal issues. They're
- 15:32going to go to the best doctor in Beverly Hills.
- 15:34They're just going to do it. They're going to
- 15:35find and pay for the best. But they're saying
- 15:37our client should get below average care, do
- 15:41the Medi -Cal thing. And really just, you know,
- 15:45this is way too expensive for someone like them.
- 15:48That has a lot of power in and of itself, especially
- 15:50in today's world. I've used that argument at
- 15:52trial for a, our client was a Mexican immigrant
- 15:56who didn't have any insurance, couldn't afford
- 15:58anyone, had to go to the clinic if he had problems.
- 16:01And the defense tried to use that argument and
- 16:02the jury hated it because we made it a whole
- 16:05class argument. So there's ways to flip this,
- 16:08but I just recommend when you're working up a
- 16:10case to do it the right way to take away the
- 16:12defense power. So. In this case, keeping with
- 16:16the movie theme, our boy Tom Cruise right there.
- 16:19You know, we're talking about assumption of the
- 16:20risk. You know, Nathan Taylor, he, you know,
- 16:25the facts, the tough facts in this case is that,
- 16:27you know, he's at the pool. He sees everyone
- 16:31belly flop. He decides to do a little different
- 16:33one. The defense is going to argue like, yeah,
- 16:36I mean, sure, we were hosting it, but this guy
- 16:39assumed the risk. So you got to talk about. Obviously,
- 16:46you want to frame it from it's been like with
- 16:49the alcohol too, right? It's that the cruise
- 16:51ship and we've had many cases where we've had
- 16:54drunk clients and but. what we find when we go
- 16:57into the marketing of the defendant. It's like
- 17:00their whole promotion is alcohol, you know, go
- 17:02party where the party ship where the party cruise
- 17:05where the party hotel come drink have fun. I
- 17:07find every single advertisement where they have
- 17:09like champagne glasses clicking or half off drinks
- 17:12happy hour. They show a real party environment.
- 17:15So, you know, it's reframing it to say that yeah,
- 17:19our client may have been drunk, but this is they
- 17:21they weren't getting drunk and then getting behind
- 17:23a wheel. That would have been irresponsible.
- 17:26They were at a place that thought was safe to
- 17:28consume and drink and have drinks and the bartenders
- 17:31encouraged drinking and they're offering shots
- 17:34with every beer and they're coming around pouring
- 17:36shots on the cruise ships, you know on the on
- 17:38the passengers now. So all this stuff. So then
- 17:40it becomes like well, if you know your guest
- 17:44and they are guests especially here as probably
- 17:45it's a common carrier, you know that they're
- 17:48going to get drunk and drink then you need to
- 17:50be extra vigilant. because you know drunk people
- 17:53who are spending money to buy drinks are going
- 17:56to get drunk. So you have to be extra careful,
- 17:58especially when you're encouraging them to drink.
- 18:00And then you tell them all, come on, do this
- 18:02belly flop contest in the pool, knowing they're
- 18:05drunk. You never said only sober people that
- 18:08can do this. So you then kind of flip it on them.
- 18:11And like when they turn around and point the
- 18:13finger back at the drinking, ask them, how much
- 18:14are you making from the alcohol? So that kind
- 18:16of thing. So assumption of the risk was one of
- 18:20the other bad facts we saw in this case. We're
- 18:22also making Nathan kind of an asshole. You know,
- 18:25he's just kind of a jerk. He just said, you know,
- 18:28doesn't come across that great, but he really
- 18:31is injured. So that's just another time. Another
- 18:34thing you got to deal with a client who just
- 18:37comes across. just, you know, kind of hard shelled,
- 18:42so to speak, or, you know, kind of short tempered.
- 18:45He just doesn't seem that friendly. And this
- 18:48is where what Teresa is going to talk about is
- 18:50really kind of, you know, there's a reason they're
- 18:54like that. And it's really getting to the root
- 18:56of why they're like that. Another one, you know,
- 19:01I don't know whether it applies to Nathan Taylor
- 19:03or not. I did want to bring up undocumented plaintiff
- 19:06because they have rights in our legal system
- 19:08just like anyone else in the tort system at least.
- 19:12And unfortunately, their rights are going away
- 19:14quickly, as we know. But, you know, they do have
- 19:17rights in the tort system. And so how do you
- 19:21kind of deal with that? And this can also be
- 19:23combined with, you know, someone maybe doesn't
- 19:25speak English. And I don't want to even call
- 19:27that a bad fact. But it is a fact that some jurors
- 19:31are going to be biased against. And so, you know.
- 19:35This program could be called bias -inducing facts,
- 19:38as well as bad facts. Probably bias -inducing
- 19:41is more appropriate. But someone who's undocumented,
- 19:44maybe someone who's lived here for 30 years,
- 19:46doesn't speak English, someone with a strong
- 19:48accent, maybe where they're from, all these things,
- 19:51this all would be combined under what would be
- 19:54a bias be, and then how would you overcome that?
- 19:58The biggest thing is, like Teresa said, with
- 20:01the pre -trial workup. And Teresa, I want you
- 20:03to talk a little bit. I know you're going to
- 20:04talk about direct exam later. But if you can
- 20:07go into a little more detail about what your
- 20:11method is kind of to find their story. And before
- 20:16you get there, I think one thing to think about
- 20:18is, in so many of these shows, like Tony Soprano,
- 20:23Mad Men, Breaking Bad, all those, You have these
- 20:27guys who do some bad, terrible things, but as
- 20:30the audience, we all end up rooting for them
- 20:33at the end of the day and we root for them to
- 20:36succeed. And so obviously in the history of storytelling,
- 20:41this has been a common theme. They're not always
- 20:44the heroes, not always the perfect person. They're
- 20:47not always Clark Kent or Superman. Oftentimes,
- 20:50they're real human beings. And in a way, sometimes
- 20:52you connect with them more based on their weaknesses
- 20:56or their character flaws, because we see some
- 21:00of those flaws in ourselves. Obviously, I don't
- 21:02think anyone on here is as bad as Walter White
- 21:04or Tony Soprano maybe. But I just think it's
- 21:08like that can create a bigger connection. with
- 21:12a jury, but it's a matter of just getting them
- 21:14there. And that's where we talk about learning
- 21:16their story. So Theresa, why don't you tell us
- 21:18a little bit about what your method is for really
- 21:21learning the client's story so that we can overcome
- 21:24those bad facts. Yeah, I think it starts early,
- 21:27right? This isn't something that you leave right
- 21:29before trial is happening. You have to start
- 21:33early and really develop that relationship and
- 21:35that trust with your client. And so there's the
- 21:38kind of two parts first is that your relationship
- 21:40with your client and getting to know them? clients
- 21:44everyone they're all people they're they're They're
- 21:48not going to be people that you might want to
- 21:50be friends with right away or people that you
- 21:51connect with right away but there's always something
- 21:53you can learn about your client and That's just
- 21:56from talking with them spending the time with
- 21:59them really getting to know them that you're
- 22:01going to be able to connect with and I think
- 22:02that's really important because Sometimes on
- 22:05the surface, you could look at somebody and say,
- 22:07oh, they're kind of strange or maybe, I don't
- 22:10know, I really just don't get them or I don't
- 22:13understand them. But that's on us as the attorneys
- 22:15to be the ones to find that out and like the
- 22:18says, learn their story. And that's starting
- 22:20from way back. So when we're prepping clients
- 22:22for trial, we're learning their entire life history.
- 22:26We spend hours and hours with them, meeting in
- 22:29person if we can, going to their homes to see
- 22:33where they live. And just really learning from
- 22:36day one. Who are they? Where did they come from?
- 22:39What is their family like? How did they grow
- 22:41up and and spending the time often I'll have
- 22:45these meetings for Weeks before I'm even talking
- 22:48about the incident and really prepping them for
- 22:50trial Because I want to get to know who they
- 22:52are and you always work in a find something about
- 22:54what makes them click what makes them unique
- 22:57and special and something that's gonna you're
- 23:00just gonna connect with in a way that you're
- 23:02going to be able to convey that to the jury.
- 23:04Ultimately, we had this trial that we just finished
- 23:07on the surface, the client, she's kind of scatterbrained.
- 23:10I mean, she has a traumatic brain injury, but
- 23:12you talk to her and you're like, just I don't
- 23:14really understand. But the more time I spent
- 23:16with her and I got to know her history and her
- 23:18background, where she grew up, what she did for
- 23:21work, kind of just like what kind of motivated
- 23:24her. It really gave me an understanding for her
- 23:27in a whole new way that I was able to bring.
- 23:30to light for the jury I think during opening
- 23:32statement but also during direct of her because
- 23:35I knew who she was just at her core what kind
- 23:37of drove her and and for this client it was her
- 23:40love of music and piano and and that was something
- 23:42we really developed over I don't even know how
- 23:44many hours I spent with her but it was it was
- 23:46a lot. The other part I think too is talking
- 23:49with friends and family or co -workers or people
- 23:52in their life to kind of get that second opinion
- 23:55as to who they see your clients because you'll
- 24:00get to know your client, but you'll get to learn
- 24:01a lot more from talking to people in their lives
- 24:04too, who've seen the changes in them. And it's
- 24:08also just a nice way to see kind of some outside
- 24:10perspectives of the changes that they've gone
- 24:12through, but also the type of person they are.
- 24:15And it's always really inspiring to me too, when
- 24:17you have so many family and friends who are willing
- 24:20to step up and talk about their experience with
- 24:24this person. Shows that this person has a lot
- 24:27of people in their life who's willing to to do
- 24:30this for them. And that's really inspiring sometimes
- 24:32as well. Yeah, just a couple a couple things
- 24:35to add on is that, you know, I start I know Teresa
- 24:40does too, like literally the first the first
- 24:43time we're really meeting with the client to
- 24:44prep them is that, you know, like I want to start
- 24:47with the day you were born and then like I'll
- 24:49talk about elementary school. like what their
- 24:52parents were like, their siblings go into high
- 24:55school, like first jobs, like marriages, divorce,
- 24:57kids, like all those issues. Because like Teresa
- 25:00says, there's there's a story. There's a story.
- 25:03Not all of it's going to be revealed at trial.
- 25:05Certainly the vast majority isn't. And. um to
- 25:09kind of play on the movie theme you know like
- 25:10we are the directors who are going to have hundreds
- 25:13of hours of footage of film and then our job
- 25:16is to edit and edit it down to that final hour
- 25:20and a half hour 45 minute two hour movie for
- 25:23the jury to see obviously trials are longer than
- 25:25that but my point being is that i just don't
- 25:27know where the story is like the real story you
- 25:30know like we represented a a guy who was seriously
- 25:33injured who was a meth addict like in and out
- 25:37of homelessness sort of you know and so we had
- 25:39to like really learn his story and find out you
- 25:41know about how he was you know abused as a kid
- 25:44and how that like his dad you know kicked him
- 25:47out of the house at like 11 or 12 and then he
- 25:50didn't have a choice to then go to the streets
- 25:52but that then you know when when the jury hears
- 25:55that because if they hear oh he's a drug addict
- 25:57or he's he's had trouble he struggled with drug
- 25:59addiction you know they just say okay they write
- 26:01him off but if they understand like kind of where
- 26:03the root of it was Then it's like, OK, like that
- 26:08doesn't mean that he's not seriously hurt. Or
- 26:11does it mean the defendant should get a catch
- 26:13a break and get a discount just because the person
- 26:16they hit, you know, has had demons? That doesn't
- 26:19mean they get a discount. And it's wrong of them
- 26:22to try to, you know, throw this guy out like
- 26:25a piece of trash. That's just wrong. And then
- 26:28you make that the story. But you really got to
- 26:30find out, OK, what kind of led him to this path?
- 26:33What led? Nathan Taylor to car jack, you know
- 26:37when he was 18 that led to the felony so so all
- 26:41those things like like this is why it's this
- 26:43is where it all starts because So many of these
- 26:45facts again. We're talking about bad facts. Not
- 26:47a bad case So many of these facts can be overcome
- 26:51if not all of them when you really get down to
- 26:53it and then the defense If you're doing a personal
- 26:56injury case or employment case on the plaintiff
- 26:59side, the defense then looks like the asshole
- 27:01because they're attacking this person because
- 27:03of their skeletons. When why is that even relevant?
- 27:06Why does that even matter? Like what like like
- 27:08what does that have to do with the fact that
- 27:10they were negligent and they cause serious harm?
- 27:13It's totally irrelevant. It has nothing to do
- 27:15with it. And then the jury is going to get angry
- 27:17at them. And so then and then the jury and you
- 27:19always want the jury to protect. your client
- 27:22in your case against the bad actor. So so I think
- 27:27like this is what we talk about kind of flipping
- 27:28the bad facts. You know, so someone asked in
- 27:32Ronnie asked a good question. Can't the information
- 27:34of someone being undocumented be quashed promotion
- 27:36eliminate? Yes, 100%. There's case law and there's
- 27:41you know, that immigration status is not relevant
- 27:44to anything they say. And the judge will probably
- 27:47keep that out. I guess my fear and why we put
- 27:51that in there is because if jurors see someone,
- 27:55you know, maybe they're a Hispanic client has
- 27:57been here for a few years doesn't speak any English.
- 28:00Assumptions are going to be made in that bias
- 28:02regard. Even if the judge says you can't consider
- 28:04it, they're still going to consider it. And so
- 28:07it's something that you should you. I'm not saying
- 28:10you should address it. during your jury selection,
- 28:12but it's there's different ways to approach it
- 28:15to find out who are going to be my bias jurors
- 28:17who, you know, are not are going to just believe
- 28:21that that that, you know, he should the plaintiff
- 28:24should not be given any money or should be given
- 28:26less money just because of their immigration
- 28:29status or just because of the language they speak,
- 28:31because that's a real thing you got to be concerned
- 28:32about, even if the judge does it on a motion
- 28:35and eliminate. So that's kind of the way we approach
- 28:38approach that. So Another thing that I think
- 28:42is important on these bad facts is to do focus
- 28:48groups. We, this is, you know, we do focus this
- 28:50from our old office, but we probably do like
- 28:53six to eight focus groups a month. And people
- 28:56hear that and they're like, God, that must cost
- 28:58like tens of thousands of dollars. It actually
- 29:00doesn't. um we run them ourselves we pay you
- 29:05know usually 20 to 25 dollars an hour maybe 30
- 29:08maybe a little more um like 100 for two hours
- 29:11or it's it ranges but you know we'll get uh 10
- 29:16to 11 people just in our conference room we'll
- 29:18post it on craigslist and then so we're only
- 29:21paying for the money for the the people to show
- 29:24up and we test out you know these kind of bad
- 29:28facts and we see how the focus group will respond
- 29:33and oftentimes we get a lot of our good sound
- 29:37bites and counters to the to this stuff from
- 29:40these focus group jurors because they will say
- 29:43something like you know what like like I just
- 29:46said like why does it matter if if he had a felony
- 29:49like what does that have to do with it or give
- 29:51us like little little you know little vignettes
- 29:54or little you know bumper stickers like statements
- 29:57to to say that we can then roll into our theme
- 30:00so because we're all attorneys and we all have
- 30:03this attorney mindset it's almost better to have
- 30:05to present the bad facts to a focus group of
- 30:10a cross -section of people and have them, you
- 30:12know, give you ways to kind of reframe the story.
- 30:17So we do a lot of focus groups. I think that's
- 30:19a really good way to test out these bad facts.
- 30:22You want to do it. especially before you get
- 30:24in front of a jury, because you don't want that
- 30:26to be there, especially during jury selection
- 30:28or your many openings. That's usually where you're
- 30:30going to present your bad facts to the jury for
- 30:31the first time. You don't want that to be the
- 30:34first time you're testing out to see how real
- 30:37people respond to X, Y and Z. So we do a ton
- 30:43of these. So let me talk a little bit about voir
- 30:46dire, because I think this is the most important
- 30:48part of where You have to address all this stuff.
- 30:54You know all the bad facts that are coming out
- 30:57and the first place you do it is that you kind
- 31:00of start by you want to establish what are your
- 31:03danger points every single case that we try I
- 31:06usually sit down with kind of a blank Word document
- 31:09and I just write down like all the stuff that
- 31:11scares the shit out of me that keeps me up at
- 31:12night about the case, you know drinking before
- 31:16the incident or Doesn't speak English you know,
- 31:20of 30 years living here, uh, you know, has two,
- 31:25two felonies. What happened? All the stuff. What
- 31:27else, Theresa? What other stuff do we, I mean,
- 31:29we've dealt with so many of attorney referred
- 31:30treatment, um, that we've talked about, you know,
- 31:33my, maybe minor impact, maybe, um, you know,
- 31:38had preexisting X, Y, and Z who knows just all
- 31:41the stuff that I'm like, I know the defense is
- 31:44going to It's going to hammer. So I kind of put
- 31:46that as a list and I'll start saying like here
- 31:49it'd be, you know, assuming the risk. The guy
- 31:51did a dive when he should have done a belly flop.
- 31:54We're going to ask for millions of dollars. That's
- 31:56that's a bias point. That's a that's a potential
- 31:58bad fact that a lot of jurors have a lot of strong
- 32:01feelings about if you know, if you're on the
- 32:03plaintiff side a non corporate defendant, I know
- 32:06in this case you have a corporate defendant.
- 32:08And so this is for the defense attorneys on this,
- 32:11you know, that's it's the anti -corporate bias
- 32:14that you got to be worried about. You have a
- 32:17huge cruise conglomerate and how are you going
- 32:21to get jurors to understand that we're not just
- 32:24a cash register, that even if we were worth billions
- 32:27of dollars, that you need to treat us just like
- 32:31we're an individual. So a lot of these bad facts
- 32:34we're talking about mostly from the plaintiff's
- 32:35side, but from the defense, you got to worry
- 32:37about that. So how do you get... How do you get
- 32:40you know a jury to understand that like just
- 32:43because you're a corporation Doesn't mean that
- 32:45you have to double what a reasonable amount is
- 32:49But but sometimes some of our bad facts is, you
- 32:52know Teresa and I have tried many cases where
- 32:54We've had like a grandmother on the other side
- 32:56who hit our client in a crosswalk for example
- 32:59And it's like but we were asking for you know
- 33:0315 20 million dollars or something like that
- 33:05because there were serious injuries. And so how
- 33:07do I get a jury? to be willing to appraise the
- 33:11value and sign their name to a verdict at $15
- 33:15million when on the other side, it's like Betty
- 33:19Crocker. That's really tough to do, right? So
- 33:22that's a bad, that's a tough fact. I don't have
- 33:24Amazon over there. So that's something you got
- 33:26to kind of think about. You got to ask in jury
- 33:28selection. And then, you know. Honest mistake
- 33:33a lot of times in our negligence cases like,
- 33:36you know, we worry that there's just it's an
- 33:37honest mistake that it was just They were trying
- 33:40their best, but they just you know, we all make
- 33:43mistakes So that's a that's kind of a fact that
- 33:46you have to deal with on the plaintiff side alcohol
- 33:48We talked about attorney refer to treatment So
- 33:50these are the things that like this is an example
- 33:52of how we kind of sit down and we'll write a
- 33:54list of the the bad facts whatever they are for
- 33:57your case, you're gonna see how in jury selection
- 34:00you can you know, frame it in a way that is not
- 34:05gonna, and I'll talk about this, not gonna snowball
- 34:08too much negativity right out of the gate, you
- 34:11know, but it's going to find out who are exposed,
- 34:16who are the badgers for you, and also who are
- 34:18the goodgers. So the first place you wanna do
- 34:22this is in the mini opening, and in California,
- 34:27under CCP 222 .5D, the trial judge must allow
- 34:32a mini opening from both sides if they request
- 34:37it. And so I always recommend you do a mini opening
- 34:42before your jury selection. And in your mini
- 34:45opening, there are kind of two schools of thought.
- 34:49I used to probably about five years ago. My thing
- 34:52was I want to make it. make our case sound as
- 34:55terrible as possible. You know, just say like
- 34:57my client, Nathan Taylor, ex con was drunk and
- 35:03jumped into a pool head first and hit his head
- 35:06and we are suing the cruise ship for $10 million
- 35:10or $30 million for causing his injuries. You
- 35:14say that and you're going to get like Everyone's
- 35:18gonna be like, why are we here? What are we doing
- 35:21here? This case sounds terrible. And then you're
- 35:24gonna get a whole snowball of people who are
- 35:30gonna just think your case is terrible. And sure,
- 35:33within that wave of bad people, you will pick
- 35:35up very bad jurors that you'll get for cause.
- 35:39But the problem is, is you'll also get potentially
- 35:42really good jurors who... You couldn't even find
- 35:46out if they were good jurors, but they just the
- 35:48way you framed it in your mini opening so negatively
- 35:51that all of a sudden you could have lost lose
- 35:53some really good jurors that you think are bad
- 35:56just by how they're responding to that mini opening
- 36:00because you didn't give them like a preview of
- 36:03coming attractions, for example. And so in a
- 36:06mini opening, I have Walter Cronkite back here
- 36:09because you want to be very neutral. You don't
- 36:12want to be too negative, I think, because, you
- 36:15know, again, like I said, you could lose some
- 36:17good jurors, but you want to be very like kind
- 36:20of matter of matter of fact, certainly in your
- 36:22presentation, you don't want to argue your case,
- 36:24all the good facts, you want to leave your best
- 36:25facts kind of hidden. But you want to just present
- 36:29it that, you know, you'll hear that, you know,
- 36:32Nathan Taylor, he was on his cruise ship with
- 36:34his wife and. they had been drinking and having
- 36:38fun on the cruise and he volunteered to do this
- 36:41belly flap contest that they all invited people
- 36:44to do and he jumped in whatever I mean whatever
- 36:47you want to do for the for these facts but then
- 36:50you want to weave in kind of your bad facts that
- 36:53he didn't really have the ability to to his insurance
- 36:56didn't cover a lot of the care so he came to
- 36:59us we gave him a list of some doctors to see
- 37:01he went and saw these doctors who you know have
- 37:03been treating him for a long time And I want
- 37:07to be honest with you. He had a, you know, kind
- 37:09of a rough upbringing had gotten in some trouble,
- 37:11but it cleaned up his act. And you'll hear whether
- 37:13or not that really matters to anything you have
- 37:15to decide. And then so like, like, so I would
- 37:18weave in the bad facts, but also say, and you'll
- 37:20hear whether or not, you know, what the defense
- 37:22is going to say, they're going to say X, Y, and
- 37:24Z that, you know, he shouldn't have done this
- 37:26or they did nothing wrong. You'll hear from the
- 37:28evidence and the experts and decide for yourself
- 37:30whether that's even really true or not. So just
- 37:33keep an open mind because you want to kind of
- 37:35leave them thinking. like, well, you know, maybe
- 37:38there is some more to the story and you want
- 37:40to leave them wanting more, but hide the, you
- 37:43know, your best facts, weave your good, your
- 37:47bad facts into the story without making them
- 37:50sound like something you're apologizing for or
- 37:52that you're scared of. And then always say, you'll
- 37:54hear and you'll decide whether or not what they're
- 37:56saying is true. and you'll hear from lots of
- 37:59experts in medical records, and you'll find out
- 38:01what the real evidence is. And so that gives
- 38:03them something like, okay, he may have the goods,
- 38:05we just don't know it yet. So that's my new philosophy
- 38:08now, because my goal again used to be try to
- 38:11get as many cause challenges as possible on the
- 38:14bad stuff, but I just think that... It's not
- 38:19a stats game where you're trying to like just
- 38:20rack up all the cause challenges. I think it's
- 38:23really kind of how you frame things. You still
- 38:25get cause challenges. You still want to expose
- 38:26your badgers. I think there's a different way
- 38:29to frame that. Just before you go to Vardar real
- 38:32quick on mini opening, I think one thing that
- 38:34Dan said is really important is the weaving in
- 38:37of the bad facts. You're not hiding the bad facts
- 38:40or you're also not just dumping all the bad facts
- 38:44out. one after another. So it's kind of an art
- 38:47of how you're weaving them into the story because
- 38:49you're hiding them either and not addressing
- 38:53some of the bigger ones because the defense is
- 38:56obviously going to bring them up or the other
- 38:58side is going to bring them up and you don't
- 39:00want to be the one seen as hiding them or trying
- 39:02to make it seem better than it is. So it's about
- 39:04how you weave them into the story so that it's
- 39:07not just this bad info dump on the jury for the
- 39:10cause challenges either. A hundred percent. I
- 39:13mean, And again, in a case of tribe where the
- 39:17gentleman had been here 30 years, didn't speak
- 39:19English. And we'll say, I just weaved it in.
- 39:21I say, he came from Mexico in the 80s, and he's
- 39:24lived here for about 40 years. And he's going
- 39:27to testify through an interpreter. He only speaks
- 39:30Spanish. And then I'll just say that, and then
- 39:33go on and then say he got hurt when X, Y, and
- 39:36Z happened. So it. It's it's a bad fact to me.
- 39:39I'm not highlighting it too much, but I'm saying
- 39:41I'm definitely saying it. Reese is 100 % right.
- 39:43I got to put it out there the bad stuff because
- 39:46some jurors are going to like their ears are
- 39:47going to peak like poke up a little bit. That's
- 39:49the phrase. I don't know. But you know, they're
- 39:51going to they're going to listen and they're
- 39:54going to be like, wait a second. You know, that's
- 39:55that seems kind of like why is he not learning
- 39:57the language? And so I'm going to I'm going to
- 39:59get those bad jurors to tell me about that. But
- 40:02100 % you got to weave it all in. But weave it
- 40:04in the right way as part of the story. And that's
- 40:06only if you learn their story. So for jury selection
- 40:10for bad facts, you know, I kind of like a like
- 40:13a soft intro to a topic and I'll show you what
- 40:16I mean by that. I think it's really powerful
- 40:18if you can, you know, confess that, you know,
- 40:24either yourself that, you know, you heard this
- 40:29is a trip and fall that happened at midnight
- 40:31or, you know, even on the on the on the the Spanish
- 40:36speaking, you know, I got to be honest. If that's
- 40:39the issue I'm going on with my set of questioning,
- 40:41it's like, you know, I when I first met. You
- 40:45know, Mr. Jones or whatever, like he had been
- 40:48in this country for 30 years and had spoke English,
- 40:50and I got to be honest, like I part of me feels
- 40:53like if you're going to live here, you really
- 40:55should try or at least learn the language, especially
- 40:56that long. Does anyone else feel that way? Because,
- 41:00look, I've confessed to my feeling because it.
- 41:02It's a real feeling that I may have had. And
- 41:04a lot of these bad facts that we're talking about,
- 41:07most of us as attorneys, when we heard about
- 41:10it, felt like that's a problem or that concerns
- 41:14me. So just be why not just be honest with the
- 41:16jurors about that? Like, you know, I had heard,
- 41:19you know, we're talking about alcohol here and
- 41:21he'd been drinking. And some of my first thought
- 41:24is that if someone's drinking, you know, it's
- 41:28probably it's got to be, you know, if they get
- 41:30injured, it's probably their fault. And I had
- 41:32that initial feeling. Did anyone have anyone
- 41:34else have that? And then so you kind of like
- 41:36so I've been honest about my feelings. Anyone
- 41:39else feel that way you find out that you talk
- 41:41to them more and then you kind of you give them
- 41:44other hypotheticals like well, you know what
- 41:46if it was at a bar or football game like you
- 41:49think that companies should have to keep their
- 41:53you know property more safe for knowing that
- 41:56there's drunk people there or should they just
- 41:58keep it safe for sober people only? What do you
- 42:00think about that? And so there I'm introducing
- 42:03kind of a new topic. And it's like the people
- 42:05that are going to say, no, it doesn't matter.
- 42:08It's not the company's responsibility. If someone's
- 42:09been drinking, there's no way it could be the
- 42:12property owners or cruise ships responsibility.
- 42:15If someone gets hurt, that just I just can't
- 42:18make that leap. And then you find out more about
- 42:20that person. And maybe they're just they'll say
- 42:22they can't be 100 % neutral in this case. But
- 42:25it all starts with how you kind of. massage the
- 42:28top again. Again, if I just start out right away,
- 42:32who has feelings against people that get drunk
- 42:36and get hurt and blame other people? If I start
- 42:40there, I could start with a snowball effect of
- 42:43people coming at us like, well, yeah, of course.
- 42:47So let me show you how we do it. I like to scale
- 42:51and group. And what I mean by that is I'll say
- 42:55you know for example in this last case I like
- 42:58to give the jurors an option of where to lean
- 43:01so they don't have to be locked into one side
- 43:02so I'll say you know some folks feel that property
- 43:06owners or property managers should always be
- 43:08on the lookout for safety hazards to prevent
- 43:11an injury and then I'll walk to the other side
- 43:13of the the jury box and I'll say others feel
- 43:16that that's too high of a burden and property
- 43:19managers property owners have a lot they have
- 43:21to work, deal with, and they really should fix
- 43:23things when there's a complaint or someone's
- 43:25already been injured. And then I'll go back to
- 43:27the middle and I'll say, who leans more towards
- 43:30that group that thinks it's too high of a burden?
- 43:32And so they're not forced to be in a box, but
- 43:36they can say, yeah, I kind of feel that way.
- 43:38I kind of feel that, you know, people sue too
- 43:40much or, you know, property managers. And you'll
- 43:43find out the people who have either. the property
- 43:45owners, and they don't like these type of lawsuits,
- 43:47but they're not in a box. And so they should
- 43:50feel safe about saying, yeah, being open about
- 43:52which way they lean, because they're not putting
- 43:55themselves like, I am X, Y, and Z, I am this.
- 43:59They're not, they're just saying, I sort of feel
- 44:00that way. And people are a lot, people don't
- 44:02like, human beings don't like being themselves
- 44:04put in boxes and labeled as a certain thing,
- 44:07because there's gray areas of all of us. And
- 44:10so, but I want to find out who sort of feels
- 44:11that way and then follow up with it. So, you
- 44:16know, the assumption of the risk. So here's an
- 44:18example. It may not be right on right on point
- 44:23with this, but how like, for example, say a motorcyclist
- 44:27is given motorcycle case where the motorcyclist
- 44:31wasn't wearing a helmet, but they were severely
- 44:34injured with orthopedic injuries, no head injury.
- 44:37And but it was like spinal injuries or leg injury
- 44:41lost the leg who knows just anything below the
- 44:43below the neck and but the defense in the judges
- 44:47letting the fact that the motorcyclist wasn't
- 44:49wearing a helmet come in. So you know and so
- 44:55one way I think not a good way to ask the question
- 44:58about this bad fact is who has bias or disagreements
- 45:00with motorcycles not wearing helmets. I mean
- 45:04everyone I think motorcyclists should wear helmets.
- 45:06I think every single person in the world agrees
- 45:08with that. But if I ask the question this way,
- 45:10and I made this mistake even this year on a premises
- 45:13case asking kind of about people's view of, you
- 45:17know, slip and falls or where people should watch
- 45:19where they're going because everyone agreed with
- 45:20that. And then it can turn into a snowball effect.
- 45:24And when I say snowball, I mean that everyone's
- 45:26going to agree with this. And then it's kind
- 45:28of and then if everyone's agreeing to a bad fact
- 45:30of your case, that that's a bad thing for you.
- 45:33Then you're not really finding out the bad jurors.
- 45:36So maybe we frame it that you start off by saying,
- 45:40I think we all agree that motorcyclists should
- 45:42wear helmets. Right. And then everyone raised
- 45:44their hand. But but if a motorcycle is doesn't
- 45:47and his injuries are entirely are his injuries
- 45:49entirely his fault if someone else crashes into
- 45:52him, even if he hurts his spine or his leg and
- 45:55not his head. And then you're getting it. So
- 45:57so you're not you're not asking the prejudge
- 45:59the case. But you're sort of reframing the idea
- 46:03that, you know, the helmet doesn't really matter.
- 46:06The defense doesn't get a discount because of
- 46:09that. They can't escape liability when it really
- 46:12is not like, really, why does it matter? They're
- 46:15just trying to label this motorcyclist is just
- 46:17unsafe in general, even though the helmet or
- 46:21lack thereof didn't really have a big impact
- 46:23here. It's like if a drunk driver's rear ended,
- 46:27you know, does that make I mean, Does that make
- 46:30the drunk driver at fault just because he got
- 46:33behind a wheel when he was drinking, you know,
- 46:36I mean, so you want to like introduce these concepts
- 46:38but do it in this way because if you ask who
- 46:40has bias against people who drink and drive,
- 46:42I mean, everyone does everyone should but it's
- 46:45really it's really going to how does that affect
- 46:47this if someone has felonies, you know, should
- 46:50they like are they is there should they be compensated
- 46:54less because they have a felony or you know,
- 46:56there's just with every bad fact. you could just
- 46:59plug in your bad fact and do it kind of this
- 47:02way. The alcohol drugs, you know, here's another
- 47:05one who has biases against people who drink heavily
- 47:07or do drugs. And there may be, you know, people
- 47:10that have those biases, but I think maybe the
- 47:12way to frame it is you wanna see some people
- 47:14believe that when someone chooses to drink, even
- 47:16just casually, they are fully responsible for
- 47:19whatever happens next no matter what. So this
- 47:20is what we talk about the scaling. And then I
- 47:22go to the other side. Other people believe like
- 47:24while people are responsible for their choices,
- 47:26others around them, especially companies or hosts
- 47:28can share, still share the responsibility for
- 47:31creating a dangerous situation here. Who here
- 47:33feels that way? Just a little bit. Someone who
- 47:35drinks what happened. So you see how we've kind
- 47:38of taken the same formula with whatever your
- 47:42bad issue is. And then you have framed it. not
- 47:46super negative and you just find and then you
- 47:49give them an opening to to see both sides and
- 47:53a lot of times what you'll start seeing which
- 47:54is I love it when this happens in my jury selections
- 47:56is that you'll get that debate started and you'll
- 47:59get people on this side people on this side blah
- 48:02blah blah blah and it's kind of a dance and then
- 48:04you're just kind of like the maestro of it and
- 48:07then you you you always want to follow up with
- 48:09who your bad jurors who are the jurors that you
- 48:11think are bad for your case All you have to say
- 48:14is like, well, thank you for sharing that. And
- 48:16you don't want to go right hard on cause right
- 48:18away. And you just say, you know, does anyone
- 48:20else sort of feel that way even a little bit?
- 48:23And you'll have three more hands. You'll follow
- 48:24up with them and they'll maybe see something
- 48:26new. That's bad for you. Anyone else feel that
- 48:28way? And then eventually you'll work your way
- 48:30back down and then they'll say other things and
- 48:34you could probably then lock those, you know,
- 48:36five or six bad ones for cause. And but you only
- 48:40get there by kind of giving them that safe space
- 48:43to tell you about their bad feelings. Teresa,
- 48:46any thoughts? No, I think that's all great. We
- 48:48have a question that's more if this is a bench
- 48:52trial and how you would address framing potential
- 48:56bias that a judge could have in opening, which
- 48:58I know we're going to touch on opening shortly.
- 49:02Yeah, so in full candor, we've I don't think
- 49:04we've ever done a bench trial. But with that
- 49:07said, I don't see why it really should be any
- 49:10different. Judges are human beings, too. And
- 49:13I think it's all about how you frame and I'll
- 49:15show you here. It's all about how you frame the
- 49:18story and who is the protagonist who's the main
- 49:22character in the way you are telling the story.
- 49:25I'm a big believer. David Ball, who's a great
- 49:28author. You know, I still do believe strongly
- 49:32in his teaching that you always frame the story
- 49:37from the bad actor's perspective the whole time.
- 49:41And if that could mean you go back 20 years in
- 49:43this last trial, Teresa's opening, we kind of
- 49:45reframed it so that we were starting way back
- 49:48to how neglectful the property manager was. And
- 49:52then when I had that was like. 30 years ago and
- 49:56we jumped ahead 10 years and talked about when
- 49:58the dangerous condition was created and then
- 50:00how it was just left there and neglected and
- 50:02then eventually on May 13th, 2019, a woman blah,
- 50:10blah, blah, blah, blah. And so I haven't even
- 50:12reduced the plaintiff until I've laid all that
- 50:14foundation of the bad actions because even in
- 50:19a passive negligence case, like most premises
- 50:23cases are, there always is a bad action. And
- 50:25like in our situation, I would probably frame
- 50:29it from the cruise ship. And if you have these
- 50:33facts, how they sit around in the boardroom and
- 50:36they talk about, our bottom line, we really make
- 50:40a lot of money from selling alcohol. and how
- 50:43we really want to push alcohol. And then I would
- 50:46set a scene where I would have the GM or the
- 50:49managers and all that talking about, we've got
- 50:51to push the booze, push the booze, push the booze,
- 50:53do this, do that. I would just make that the
- 50:57whole thing. And then eventually, they're seeing
- 51:00where this is going to go. It's like, you know,
- 51:03Romeo and Juliet that the jury already knows
- 51:06that there's a bad injury because you've said
- 51:07that in the opening, but they don't really know
- 51:09how we got there. And Romeo and Juliet, the first
- 51:12line that Shakespeare said is that, you know,
- 51:14they both died. They both die at the end. So
- 51:16you know the ending and then it goes into the
- 51:18story. But the whole time the audience is listening
- 51:21and it's like, well, I know how terrible this
- 51:23is going to end. And that makes you even more
- 51:25like it's just like such a powerful way to tell
- 51:27a story. And so, you know, that's why You do
- 51:33the same thing with a judge I don't know why
- 51:34would should be any different you frame it from
- 51:36the bad actors actions and walk through the story
- 51:38and again your story in your opening statement
- 51:40as I'll show you can start The day before the
- 51:45week before the incident a month before, 30,
- 51:4740, 50 years before the incident. It could be
- 51:49an institutional problem. And so it's all about,
- 51:52so don't think your story has to start with the,
- 51:54with the incident itself. Yeah. I think Christine,
- 51:57just to follow up on that question real quick,
- 51:59think about how maybe you would do an opposition
- 52:01to emotion for summary judgment and how you'd
- 52:03frame the statement of facts. You're not just
- 52:05starting, or at least the way I tend to do them
- 52:08is I don't, I don't just start with the incident
- 52:10itself. I try and back up to lead up to how we
- 52:13got to the incident so that the judge has an
- 52:15understanding, like Dan said, of how you get
- 52:18to the final incident happening. Somebody else
- 52:21had a quick question about religious and ethnicity
- 52:23bias. I think a lot of this that we've been discussing
- 52:26would apply the same way, right? You hit head
- 52:30on if you're concerned about those things, probably
- 52:33similar to maybe the immigration status issue
- 52:36or not speaking English. Same type of thoughts
- 52:40and questions you could ask. Yeah, so with that
- 52:43one, I get asked that one a lot about my clients
- 52:49from the Middle East or Israel or who knows where
- 52:52and obviously with everything going on, it's
- 52:55something that we're worried that a jury is going
- 52:57to give less than for or be just biased against.
- 53:01And I think a lot of times I would not hit it
- 53:04head on with like, hey, my client is X, Y, and
- 53:07Z religion. Who's biased against that? Because
- 53:09no one's going to admit that. I mean, no one's
- 53:11going to admit they're racist. They're going
- 53:13to say I'm the least racist person there is,
- 53:16you know, stuff like that. So he's just not going
- 53:18to get what you need. People are going to clam
- 53:20up. I think judges, if you kind of hit that hot
- 53:24topic right out of the gate, I think they will
- 53:27shut it down and they'll just read it like you
- 53:29can't consider it. So I would either you know
- 53:34approach it more of if they have an accent, different
- 53:38language. I would just kind of soft, very softly
- 53:41approach it that way. In terms of religion, it's
- 53:45a tough one. I just don't think, I think a judge
- 53:47is gonna shut that down. But, and if it's really
- 53:50a huge hot topic, I would ask the judge for a
- 53:53questionnaire about it because that's a safer
- 53:56space for people to write those things. And I
- 53:59think you can convince a judge to say, look,
- 54:02I have this very, you know, I'm really concerned
- 54:04about this given things going on in the world
- 54:06right now and you know. Um, it's, you know, it's
- 54:09very obvious what my client's religion is. They
- 54:11have to either wear something or there are just
- 54:13whatever it is. And then you, um, you may want
- 54:17to just address it with a questionnaire because
- 54:18you don't think people will be open about it
- 54:21in public in the public setting of your courtroom.
- 54:23You also tell the jurors, if there's anything,
- 54:25any bias that you may have that you don't want
- 54:27to share, that's okay. We can do it all in chambers,
- 54:30but please let us know what your biases are.
- 54:32And then, you know, another maybe even better
- 54:35way to do it is that you just talk about their
- 54:37oath and there's an oath they're gonna take if
- 54:41you get any hint that there's an oath they're
- 54:42gonna take that you know they can't consider
- 54:46you know sex religion sexual orientation all
- 54:51those things and you know is anyone gonna have
- 54:56trouble you know following that oath and then
- 54:59you may find that which is kind of funny is that
- 55:02you know some people who may have those unfortunately
- 55:05racist or religious biases, sometimes they take
- 55:10their oath even more seriously. And so there's
- 55:14different ways to approach it. It's a tough one.
- 55:16I don't have a one size fits all answer. I just
- 55:19would not come right out with saying, my client
- 55:21is this religion, who's biased against that?
- 55:23I just don't think you're gonna get that answer.
- 55:25So I would get the judge's guidance. I would
- 55:27try to do a questionnaire and then I would...
- 55:30figure out is there some way to find out who
- 55:32are the real bias people against someone from
- 55:34this country maybe or you know just try to like
- 55:38softball it in there i know that doesn't directly
- 55:40give you an answer but that's how i would do
- 55:42it somebody else had a question about bias against
- 55:45trial counsel if that's ever something that's
- 55:48comes up or it gets addressed in front of a jury
- 55:50and honestly i don't think it ever really has
- 55:52is like something where either because of myself
- 55:56is the the question was specific to As an Asian
- 56:00-American trial attorney if that's something
- 56:01I've ever addressed and I've never never brought
- 56:03that up in front of a jury before or had that
- 56:06really Brought up by jurors. I guess Dan. Do
- 56:10you have any thoughts on that? Yeah Obviously,
- 56:14I I can't speak as an Asian -American trial lawyer,
- 56:17but you know certainly My opinion is that these
- 56:21things that we worry about I I think the only
- 56:23thing that matters to jurors is if you're credible
- 56:26I think it doesn't matter if you're a trial lawyer
- 56:28that has an accent. You were born, you're Asian
- 56:31American. You were born somewhere else. You're
- 56:34Middle East. It doesn't. I truly don't think
- 56:37and I know this is I'm saying this as a white
- 56:39dude, which is like take that for what it is.
- 56:41But. Jurors care way more about credibility.
- 56:45I mean, look at all this massively successful
- 56:48trial lawyers we have, especially in Los Angeles.
- 56:49They come from all shapes and sizes, all walks
- 56:52of life, men, women, doesn't matter, all races,
- 56:54all ethnicities, all that. So, you know, obviously,
- 56:58if it was just, you know, jurors only trust a
- 57:00certain ethnicity, I don't think they would be
- 57:01successful. So I do think what's the most important
- 57:05by far. than anything else is just being credible
- 57:09and keeping your credibility. And that means
- 57:12being transparent and being brutally honest with
- 57:16all the bad stuff. Don't try to sugarcoat it.
- 57:19Don't try to hide it. Don't run from it. Just
- 57:21be honest the whole time. I think that's all
- 57:24jurors care about. Frankly, I don't know. That's
- 57:28probably the best way I can answer that. Yeah.
- 57:30I'll be honest, it's never been something I've
- 57:33been concerned about that a juror is going to
- 57:37treat my client poorly or not be as neutral or
- 57:42as impartial as possible because of who I am.
- 57:47I think the way that I try and see it is that
- 57:50the bad jurors are gonna make themselves known
- 57:52for one reason or another throughout jury selection,
- 57:56where I don't have to really be the center of
- 57:57any of that attention about. about me specifically.
- 58:01And as long as I'm just being myself with them,
- 58:04I think that goes a long way. Just being who
- 58:06I am and my style is very different than Dan's
- 58:08style and trial. But as long as I'm being authentic,
- 58:12that's my way to connect with the jury. And it
- 58:14seems to be working overall. The bad jurors will
- 58:18make themselves known for something else anyhow.
- 58:20Yeah. And honestly, they'll They'll be honest
- 58:24if they don't feel like they trust, I mean, they'll
- 58:26say that, be like, I just don't think I, like,
- 58:28I don't trust you. Like, I encourage that, like,
- 58:31give me all the bad stuff. Like, you know, it's
- 58:34a personal injury case. Like, if you, you know,
- 58:36like, if someone says you're an ambulance chaser,
- 58:37this is a money grab, I'm open with, like, like,
- 58:40please tell me, or like, I want them to tell
- 58:42me that stuff. So, so let's talk a little about
- 58:45opening statement. I talked a little bit about
- 58:48kind of the way we structure things and a lot
- 58:49of our opening statements. We have, you know,
- 58:51a kind of a soft intro either. We'll say the
- 58:54rule or do some kind of one -sentence introduction.
- 58:58We'll talk about what good, you know, in this
- 59:00case, good cruise ships do safe cruise ships
- 59:03talk about what bad cruise ships do just kind
- 59:05of in the hypothetical and the not just directly
- 59:09tied to to the defendant. And then at that point
- 59:12we say we will go through the story. And this
- 59:16is, again, going back to where do you start your
- 59:19story? And sometimes it can be years before,
- 59:22like I said. And then the things we had to look
- 59:25into, this is a lot of this from David Ball.
- 59:28And so we do that. And then why are we here?
- 59:31Just really taking down the defenses, the loss,
- 59:34dismantling the lost defenses, who was the client,
- 59:36and then kind of the ass. So this is generally
- 59:38not all the time, but this is generally how we
- 59:41kind of frame our, you know, put our openings
- 59:46together and where you're going to deal with
- 59:50the bad facts is really in these two sections
- 59:53here. The things we had to look into you can
- 59:55either do it from the perspective of look we
- 59:58before we came to trial we you know we heard
- 1:00:00our client was drinking on this cruise ship so
- 1:00:02we don't see like was alcohol the really the
- 1:00:04cause like is it all on him we had to look into
- 1:00:06that so he went and we spoke with a toxicologist
- 1:00:09we went and spoke with you know cruise ship safety
- 1:00:14guy. I don't know. I'm sure that's the official
- 1:00:15title. But, you know, and they say, No, you're
- 1:00:18supposed to and then they say, No, you're supposed
- 1:00:20to, you know, Anticipate drunks on a cruise ship.
- 1:00:24You're encouraging drinking. You've got to be
- 1:00:26even more careful. Your safety has to be even
- 1:00:29to a higher level because of how much because
- 1:00:32people aren't driving. People are drinking. So
- 1:00:34you always got to be on the lookout and keep
- 1:00:36drunk people safe because that's how you make
- 1:00:38money, right? So I've taken the bad fact. I've
- 1:00:41had the question about it. I'm there. I'm then
- 1:00:43sitting like a juror would and then how we look
- 1:00:45into it. So that's kind of how we we would we
- 1:00:50would introduce the bad facts and then so you
- 1:00:55know the story and the client before the client
- 1:00:58before is really where you where you humanize
- 1:01:00who the client is I do it really late in the
- 1:01:03game because I really don't want I think I just
- 1:01:06don't even want the client the jury thinking
- 1:01:08about who my client is too early I know a lot
- 1:01:11of people right out of the gate and kind of the
- 1:01:13introduction area will say, let me, let me tell
- 1:01:16you, there's a story about Miss Smith and she's
- 1:01:19from Tuscaloosa, Alabama, blah, blah, blah, blah,
- 1:01:23blah. And so I just don't know if people care
- 1:01:27at that point. You know, jurors like, well, I'm
- 1:01:29from here. I'm dealing with my issues. So I again
- 1:01:33want to frame it always from the bad actor's
- 1:01:35perspective. And then hopefully by that time
- 1:01:37I've earned the opportunity for them to care
- 1:01:39about actually who my client is as a person.
- 1:01:41I think if you do it too early I think people
- 1:01:43just kind of tune out everyone has a story and
- 1:01:45they just they're not invested yet that's why
- 1:01:47I don't like doing it that early. So you know
- 1:01:51these are kind of the things that I would probably
- 1:01:52bring up in my opening statement I would massage
- 1:01:54them in you know he was drinking and then later
- 1:01:58on in the story I talk about you know kind of
- 1:02:02what he had a tough upbringing he did this he
- 1:02:04made you know, a lot of mistakes. I'm not going
- 1:02:06to sit here and tell you he's a he's a nun or
- 1:02:08he's a priest. He did X, Y, and Z. And he did
- 1:02:11that. And he's like he's turned his life around.
- 1:02:13He still has struggles. But, you know, you're
- 1:02:15going to hear no one's going to say that that
- 1:02:17made a difference in how he what caused his injury
- 1:02:20or anything like that. But I want to be honest
- 1:02:22with you about the about, you know, who he is
- 1:02:25as a person, something like that, not apologize
- 1:02:27for it. Just be honest about it. It's part of
- 1:02:28who he is. It's part of his story. So Teresa,
- 1:02:32do you want to talk a little bit about direct
- 1:02:34exam? Yeah. So I think it's really important
- 1:02:38when you have a client, maybe especially somebody
- 1:02:42who on the surface might not seem that likable,
- 1:02:45for example, or has maybe they went on a lot
- 1:02:49of vacations after. after the incident. Maybe
- 1:02:52Nathan goes on more cruises again after this
- 1:02:55incident happens or something. Those are things
- 1:02:57that can be brought up on direct examination
- 1:02:59and potentially through some of your other damages
- 1:03:01witnesses as well. So I always think of it as
- 1:03:04like you're using your other witnesses to paint
- 1:03:07the picture as to who your client is before your
- 1:03:10client even gets on the stand. And that includes
- 1:03:12both the good and the bad. So you use these other
- 1:03:16witnesses, your damages witnesses, maybe it's
- 1:03:19a partner or Maybe it's a friend or family member
- 1:03:23to kind of put into context some of those bad
- 1:03:25facts. So for example, if we think about maybe
- 1:03:28Nathan going on cruises afterwards, maybe you
- 1:03:32get his wife to talk about on the stand what
- 1:03:34it was really like for him being on those vacations,
- 1:03:37but why he decided to take them. If that's the
- 1:03:40fact that's going to come in at trial, it's not
- 1:03:42a great fact to know that he went back on all
- 1:03:44these cruises. But maybe the reality is that
- 1:03:47He took these trips because his family needed
- 1:03:50him to get out of the bedroom because he was
- 1:03:52just sitting at home all the time and he was
- 1:03:54in a really bad headspace all day. So you get
- 1:03:56the wife to talk about why they encouraged him
- 1:03:59to take this trip and what it was like for him.
- 1:04:01He wasn't going on outings. He was sitting on
- 1:04:04the cruise ship all day, you know, just kind
- 1:04:06of being there, but at least it was a change
- 1:04:08of scenery. That actually happened in a case
- 1:04:10we had at trial last year we had to talk about.
- 1:04:13why she went to Panama after three or two months
- 1:04:16after she had been in this horrible car crash
- 1:04:19but the reality was that she she needed to do
- 1:04:22this and she talked to her doctors first so we
- 1:04:24we brought the story to life the bad facts through
- 1:04:28that um maybe you have a client again who's who
- 1:04:32on the surface just seems tougher or is harder
- 1:04:34to understand so you get somebody who understands
- 1:04:37him to talk about who he is and why why he is
- 1:04:41the way he is um We had a trial this year where
- 1:04:46we had these witnesses talking about kind of
- 1:04:48how our client would navigate life before and
- 1:04:51why they were a hard worker, building up their
- 1:04:53character and their credibility. So that by the
- 1:04:56time that person, our client got on the stand,
- 1:04:58it was understandable why he was a little rougher
- 1:05:01around the edges or maybe a little more tougher
- 1:05:03appearing than some other people would be. Because
- 1:05:07we had all these other witnesses who painted
- 1:05:08the picture as who he was before he got on the
- 1:05:11stand. Yes, you can present all of these witnesses
- 1:05:14before you do the plaintiff. The plaintiff goes
- 1:05:17last or as close to last as possible. So you
- 1:05:20have already filled in this picture as to who
- 1:05:23they are before your plaintiff even says a word.
- 1:05:26And maybe you don't even have your plaintiff
- 1:05:27there at all during the trial or you limit how
- 1:05:31much the jury is even seeing them so that the
- 1:05:33picture is really being filled in by your other
- 1:05:35witnesses. You can use your co -authors to do
- 1:05:38this too. Oh, go ahead. No, no, I was just gonna,
- 1:05:40I think that's an important point. We've kind
- 1:05:43of we've had we've done it many different ways.
- 1:05:45We've had the client there throughout the entire
- 1:05:47trial We've had them there just for vaudeer opening
- 1:05:51direct and then closing We've had them there
- 1:05:54just for vaudeer and direct and closing I think
- 1:05:57now we're settling on honestly not having the
- 1:06:00plaintiff there at all except for direct examination.
- 1:06:03And I know that sounds blasphemous to a lot of
- 1:06:06attorneys out there. I just spoke on Monday in
- 1:06:08San Diego and a lot of the older school attorneys
- 1:06:10were like, that's crazy. You got to have your
- 1:06:12client. Like my belief, our belief on that I
- 1:06:15think is just that, you know, um, The especially
- 1:06:19in a personal injury case that the jurors are
- 1:06:22gonna just judge and judge and judge every single
- 1:06:26thing that the client does it's free sabrosa
- 1:06:28really and There's just no there's no like I
- 1:06:32just don't see anything good That's gonna come
- 1:06:34out of them sitting there and looking at your
- 1:06:36client If maybe the client's seriously injured
- 1:06:39and it's a obvious injury, they walk with a limp,
- 1:06:42they're in a wheelchair. Well, guess what? They're
- 1:06:44going to be very desensitized if they've been
- 1:06:46there the whole trial by the time they testify.
- 1:06:48If your client has invisible injuries, they're
- 1:06:50going to look and be like, they look fine to
- 1:06:52me. They look any different than I do. I look
- 1:06:55worse than them. So they're going to judge every
- 1:06:57little aspect of them. So to me, I just want
- 1:06:59to take away that the jurors, they don't know
- 1:07:02what the rules are. They don't know whether or
- 1:07:04not Clients are supposed to be there whether
- 1:07:06they're even allowed to be there They may think
- 1:07:07they're not allowed to be there It really doesn't
- 1:07:09matter and frankly judges will shut down if the
- 1:07:12other side tries to say well, where's the client?
- 1:07:14It's not relevant to anything at all. And so
- 1:07:18our belief I think again, this is suffered It's
- 1:07:22always evolving our practice our trial practices
- 1:07:24constantly evolving is that we just want The
- 1:07:27story like Teresa said to be built up through
- 1:07:29other witnesses and then the plaintiff comes
- 1:07:32in and testifies this last trial. Teresa did
- 1:07:35a phenomenal job. How long did you put the client
- 1:07:38on for 15 minutes tops top those 10? Yeah, it
- 1:07:42was just it was it was just to the point. It
- 1:07:45was just in the jury appreciated it jurors nowadays
- 1:07:49also have very short attention spans. And if
- 1:07:52you're sitting there dragging out an hour and
- 1:07:54a half long direct talking about all the bad
- 1:07:55shit that's happened to him. And how terrible
- 1:07:58everything is like people don't this is like
- 1:08:01people don't like, you know whiners And so I
- 1:08:04thought it was just a very powerful direct that
- 1:08:06Teresa did But we did it by, you know developing
- 1:08:09her story ahead of time. So she didn't have to
- 1:08:11carry that weight Yeah, and and one other quick
- 1:08:14point Maybe you have a case where you don't have
- 1:08:16that many friends and family that you can even
- 1:08:19call as a witness That happened in our last trial
- 1:08:22and we were able to still develop the story through
- 1:08:25the doctor testimony for treating physicians
- 1:08:28who had seen her for years, who could talk about
- 1:08:31how consistent she was, how credible, motivated
- 1:08:34she was, and that goes a long way too. So just
- 1:08:37think outside the box if you don't have some
- 1:08:41immediate family members that can provide that
- 1:08:44testimony. I do think it is helpful though, and
- 1:08:46maybe you don't even have family, but if you
- 1:08:48have acquaintances, we've used hairdressers before,
- 1:08:51we've used... former partners like an ex girlfriend,
- 1:08:56dance instructors, yoga teachers. It doesn't
- 1:08:59have to just be family members who bring this
- 1:09:01test. In fact, it's better. It's better if you
- 1:09:03can have a 10 minute the guy at the bodega. Well,
- 1:09:07it's not New York, but like, you know, a guy
- 1:09:10that they would go get a sandwich from every
- 1:09:12single day. And he would see, you know, your
- 1:09:16client walk in, walk out. Everything was great.
- 1:09:18And then didn't see him for months. Next time
- 1:09:20we saw him, he was like, you know, It's just
- 1:09:22struggling. You can just tell look on his face
- 1:09:24like that 10 minute five minute witness 10 minute
- 1:09:26witness paints a much better picture. Here's
- 1:09:30let's see. We have some questions here. Good
- 1:09:32ones from Joanna. How do you handle a bad fact
- 1:09:35that opposing side somehow brings up that you
- 1:09:38did not know about? Yeah, that's that's tough.
- 1:09:40That is like this is why we do like everything
- 1:09:46we can. As soon as we sign up a case, we do a
- 1:09:48background check on our client. We do deep dive
- 1:09:50social media investigations of our own client.
- 1:09:54We tell our client, don't post, don't do this.
- 1:09:57And if you do, if you're deposed, be 100 % honest
- 1:10:00about everything you've ever done. Don't deny
- 1:10:02anything. So I think the situation you're talking
- 1:10:05about happens to all of us. Happened the last
- 1:10:08trial. The defense has some kind of found from
- 1:10:11a friend of a friend of a friend was tagged and
- 1:10:13then they were able to find link that back to
- 1:10:14your client. It's tough. I mean that is a situation
- 1:10:18where you're talking about real impeachment there
- 1:10:20and that is very hard to overcome. You just have
- 1:10:25to constantly. Talk to your client about being
- 1:10:30honest. And if the defense is starting to go
- 1:10:33down a path on direct that you believe they are,
- 1:10:37you know, trying to hang your client like, well,
- 1:10:40did you do this in 2025? It's like something
- 1:10:43like, whoa, where's that coming from? You prep
- 1:10:45your client and be like, if they start asking
- 1:10:47very specific questions, don't hide it. If if
- 1:10:51you know where they're going and they're talking
- 1:10:52about something, just be honest about it. Because
- 1:10:55again, We as attorneys can't fix a client who's
- 1:10:59not truthful. We just can't. And so it's just
- 1:11:04making sure they know from the very beginning
- 1:11:07that you having a long history of neck problems,
- 1:11:11you going on this trip because you were severely
- 1:11:14depressed and your doctors told you to get out
- 1:11:16or else it'd be worse. That is not gonna hurt
- 1:11:19your case. I can work with that as your attorney.
- 1:11:22What I can't... do and I can't help you is if
- 1:11:24you're not truthful, if you lie, then I can't
- 1:11:28help you and I can't spend that to a jury. I
- 1:11:31just can't and once we lose credibility, we lose
- 1:11:33the case. So Joanna, I know I don't know if that
- 1:11:38answers your question at all. But but you know,
- 1:11:42that is kind of how I would recommend try to
- 1:11:45prevent that. Christopher asked when Teresa had
- 1:11:49played in the box for 10 minutes. How long was
- 1:11:50the cross? It was probably about 30, 40, 30 or
- 1:11:5540 minutes. And then my redirect was pretty short
- 1:11:58as well. Um, so Joanna's follow up is, uh, unfortunately
- 1:12:03this has happened not to our client, but an expert
- 1:12:06witness we used, um, that they used to create
- 1:12:10fake five star reviews on their website. It was
- 1:12:13very damaging. That's interesting. Um, one, I
- 1:12:17don't, I've never had reviews be able to come
- 1:12:20in. either way, whether they did, whether they
- 1:12:23were real or fake or anything like that, because
- 1:12:25when it's hearsay. So but look, I mean, this
- 1:12:28goes to the credibility. If it's if it's a non
- 1:12:32client, I mean, that's tough. So if you're hit
- 1:12:36with that on redirect, you know, sometimes you
- 1:12:42just got to like jump on the sword. And, you
- 1:12:45know, you recognize that that was wrong. But
- 1:12:48does that, you know, It's almost like, does that
- 1:12:53anyway impact your ability to give this kind
- 1:12:56of opinion in this case? It's tough. Look, I
- 1:12:58mean, I don't have an exact answer for you on
- 1:13:01that one. You just got to hope the expert can
- 1:13:03say, yeah, we shouldn't have done that. We were
- 1:13:07trying to build the business. We were trying
- 1:13:11to develop this, but that doesn't take away.
- 1:13:15That that shouldn't harm my client's ability
- 1:13:17to get justice, right? I mean, that's at the
- 1:13:19end of the day what you're hoping for. What do
- 1:13:22you do if defendants lie and fabricate alleged
- 1:13:25conduct of well? So if the defendants lie and
- 1:13:31fabricate alleged conduct of your plaintiff,
- 1:13:33then you shove it right up there. I mean, there
- 1:13:35should be that you should be able to hammer them
- 1:13:38for that. If they're saying your plaintiff. Did
- 1:13:40something in their background that is a lie.
- 1:13:45then you hammer their experts to say, did you
- 1:13:47see any evidence of this anywhere? The defense,
- 1:13:50and what we do is we'll say the defense attorney
- 1:13:53said this X, Y, and Z in opening or they're insinuated
- 1:13:57this, this, and this. Um, do you, have you seen
- 1:13:59any evidence of that? So are you saying what
- 1:14:01they're saying is not true? Like they made that
- 1:14:03up. Did you see any evidence anywhere? And you,
- 1:14:05you reviewed thousands of pages of records. You
- 1:14:07see that anywhere. So that's not true. Is that
- 1:14:11true? Is that what you're saying to this jury
- 1:14:12that what she said is not true? I would like
- 1:14:16go all out on that to really hammer them. So
- 1:14:20I know we're kind of over time. I apologize for
- 1:14:23that. Teresa kept talking too much. So I'm sorry,
- 1:14:25guys. You can blame her. But anyway, please feel
- 1:14:30free to email us. These are email addresses.
- 1:14:34We have a ton of samples. We can make your life
- 1:14:37easier. And we've probably seen it. We try a
- 1:14:41lot of cases throughout the state of California.
- 1:14:44We love being in trial. We've seen all the moves
- 1:14:47from both sides. And so we'd be happy to help
- 1:14:51or give any advice we can. So thank you, everybody.
- 1:14:55We really appreciate it. Thank you to Beverly
- 1:14:57Hills Bar Association for putting out this trial
- 1:15:01series. And thank you, everyone. Get out there
- 1:15:04and try cases. Bye everyone.