Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / 🚨Buffett Indicator at 219% + 🚨 Schiller PE at 39
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the deep dive. Today we are stepping back from
- 0:04the daily noise. We're looking deeper into the
- 0:06actual structure, maybe the structural integrity of the US
- 0:10stock market right now. Yeah, and the sources we're
- 0:12digging into, they use these really powerful, historically
- 0:15tested indicators. And honestly, the picture they
- 0:18paint is wow, it's pretty startling.
- 0:20Right, startling is a good word. Our mission here is to really
- 0:24pick apart what we're calling the market paradox is this
- 0:26incredible split. You know, you got all the long
- 0:28term fundamental science flashing red like extreme
- 0:32historically high valuation. But then you look at the short
- 0:35term mood, investor fear, it's basically gone, vanished.
- 0:40How can those two things exist at the same time?
- 0:42That's what we need to unpack. That divergent is absolutely
- 0:45central to understanding where we are.
- 0:46So we're focusing on three key indicators, ones with real track
- 0:49records and as of now, mid-september 2025.
- 0:52Here's that paradox in numbers. First, the Buffett indicator,
- 0:57big picture market size versus the economy, it's sitting at an
- 1:00incredible 217%, unprecedented. Then the Shiller PE or KP ratio
- 1:07that smooths out earnings over time, it's around 38, again
- 1:10signals extreme valuation pressure, 38.
- 1:13And yet the third one, the CBOE Volatility Index, the VIX, you
- 1:18know, the markets fear gauge, it's just lounging around 15.7.
- 1:21That's deep into complacency territory.
- 1:23OK, that really lays it out. Long term metric screaming
- 1:27danger, short term mood, saying nothing to see here.
- 1:31How does that even work? Let's let's start with the
- 1:34biggest view, the Buffett indicator, that macro barometer.
- 1:37Exactly. It's designed to do just that.
- 1:39It compares the total value of all publicly traded U.S.
- 1:43Stocks The market capitalization against the country's annual
- 1:46economic output, the gross domestic product, or GDP.
- 1:49So like a price to sales ratio but for the whole country?
- 1:52That's a great way to think about it.
- 1:53Yeah, a macro PS The market cap is the price tag on all the
- 1:57corporate assets. And GDP is well, it's the engine
- 2:00generating the revenue that's supposed to support those asset
- 2:02values. Got it.
- 2:03And the numbers right now? So the latest figures put the
- 2:05total market cap, we estimate around $65.47 trillion. 65
- 2:10trillion. And the annualized USGDP is
- 2:13running about $30.15 trillion, right?
- 2:17Do the math, divide market cap by GDP and boom 217%. $65
- 2:23trillion of market value sitting on top of a $30 trillion
- 2:27economy. Yeah, that image alone says a
- 2:29lot, but the key is history, right?
- 2:32How does 217% stack up? What was the peak mania level we
- 2:36always point to? Thatsusuallythe.com bubble peak
- 2:40back around 2000. That's the benchmark for, let's
- 2:43say, irrational exuberance. Back then, the indicator topped
- 2:45out around 159% A. 159% and we're at 217% now.
- 2:50Exactly. We are miles above that previous
- 2:53historical extreme. I mean, even Warren Buffett
- 2:55himself, the guy who popularized this thing called levels way
- 2:58lower than 217% playing with fire.
- 3:00It really suggests that the value the market is putting on
- 3:03stocks has become seriously disconnected from the actual
- 3:05economy supporting them. OK, but you know someone
- 3:07listening is thinking hang on, that indicator is outdated.
- 3:09They'll say look at globalization, Apple, Microsoft,
- 3:12they make tons of money overseas that's not in US.
- 3:14GDP and interest rates have been low for ages.
- 3:17Doesn't that justify higher valuations?
- 3:20So why should we even listen to this old metric if the rules
- 3:23have changed? That's a fair challenge, and it
- 3:26needs, you know, a bit of nuance.
- 3:27You're absolutely right that things have changed.
- 3:29Low rates, global earnings, the rise of tech companies that
- 3:32don't need lots of physical assets.
- 3:34All that has pushed the fair value baseline higher.
- 3:37OK, so we're maybe 50% or 60% was fair value decades ago.
- 3:41Today, a lot of analysts would say, yeah, maybe the new normal
- 3:44is more like 110%, maybe 120%. We definitely have to to factor
- 3:48that in. There's a butt coming.
- 3:49I feel it. There is, because here's the
- 3:51crucial point from our sources. Even if you adjust for that
- 3:54rising baseline, even if you draw a new trend line, 217% is
- 3:59still 2.2 standard deviations above that long term historical
- 4:02trend line. OK, stats talk.
- 4:04Yeah, translate 2.2 standard deviations for us.
- 4:08What does that mean practically? It means it's rare.
- 4:12Extremely rare. Think about it like this.
- 4:15If you look at the indicator's history over many, many decades,
- 4:19a reading of 217% is way out on the tail end of the
- 4:23distribution. It's like a heat wave that
- 4:25doesn't just break the local record, it shatters the global
- 4:29record, even after you account for overall global warming
- 4:32raising average temperatures. OK, so even adjusting for the
- 4:35new normal, this is still an anomaly.
- 4:37A massive anomaly. You can't just wave it away by
- 4:39saying things are different now. It's an extreme outlier, even by
- 4:42any new rules you might try to apply.
- 4:45That's it's a really important clarification.
- 4:47So the big picture, the macro view is wildly expensive.
- 4:51Let's zoom in a bit now to the companies themselves, the
- 4:53earnings. That brings us to the KP ratio,
- 4:56the Shiller PE. Why this one too?
- 4:59Why isn't the Buffett indicator enough?
- 5:01Well, the CPE ratio complements the Buffett indicator by
- 5:04drilling down into the price relative to actual corporate
- 5:06earnings, not just overall economic activity.
- 5:09And his method is really clever because it smooths things out.
- 5:12How does it do? That instead of just looking at
- 5:13the last year's earnings, which can jump around a lot, right?
- 5:16Yeah, definitely. It divides the current S&P 500
- 5:19price by the average of the last 10 years of earnings, and
- 5:22critically, those earnings are adjusted for inflation. 10
- 5:25years. Why Ken?
- 5:26Because 10 years usually captures a full economic cycle,
- 5:29you know, a boom and then a bust or at least a slowdown.
- 5:33This stops you from getting tricked by temporary highs or
- 5:35lows. A recession might make earnings
- 5:38look terrible for a year, making the PE look artificially high.
- 5:41A boom might make it look artificially low.
- 5:44The 10 year average? Smooth that out, and the
- 5:47inflation adjustment means we're comparing apples to apples
- 5:50across different decades. Makes sense.
- 5:52So this more robust smoothed out earnings metric, what's it
- 5:57telling us right now? OK, so the current TPE as of
- 6:00September 2025 is hovering around 38. 38 context.
- 6:04Context is crucial. The long term historical average
- 6:07for KPE is about 1717. Wow, so we're more than double
- 6:11the historical. Average more than double.
- 6:13And if you look back over like the last 150 years, there are
- 6:16really only two times it's been significantly higher.
- 6:18It got to about 30 just before the 1929 crash, around 27 before
- 6:23the global financial crisis in O seven O 8 right.
- 6:26The only time it was meaningfully higher than today's
- 6:2838 was right at the absolute peakofthe.com craziness.
- 6:32It touched 44 of them. So we're basically in the top
- 6:35three most expensive periods ever based on earnings power.
- 6:39That's exactly right. Top three and modern financial
- 6:41history. OK, so accepting it's high.
- 6:43Yeah. What does KE tell us about the
- 6:46future? It's not just history.
- 6:47It's supposed to predict future returns, isn't it?
- 6:50It is very strongly, and the message right now is frankly
- 6:54pretty sobering. There's a very strong inverse
- 6:57correlation. High starting KP means low
- 7:00future returns, meaning starting from a KP of 38.
- 7:03The historic Oracle data powerfully suggests that
- 7:05investors should brace themselves for annualized real
- 7:08returns. That's after inflation over the
- 7:10next 10 years that are probably near 0 or maybe low single
- 7:13digits like 1%, two percent, 3% maybe.
- 7:16Let's just underline real returns.
- 7:18Why is that distinction so important for people listening?
- 7:20Oh, it's everything, because if you get a, say, 3% return on
- 7:24paper, but inflation is running at 4%, you've actually lost
- 7:28buying power, right? Your real return is -1%.
- 7:31Right, you're poorer in real terms.
- 7:32Exactly. So KP is essentially flashing a
- 7:35warning. Prices are so high right now
- 7:38that even if companies keep growing earnings nicely, most of
- 7:41that future growth is just going to be used up, bringing the
- 7:44Super high valuation multiple back down to earth.
- 7:47It won't translate into big gains for investors.
- 7:50The market's price for perfection, basically.
- 7:52Perfectly put. No room for error, very little
- 7:55room for positive surprises to actually boost your wealth
- 7:58significantly from here over the long term.
- 8:01And while people still argue, oh, but low interest rates
- 8:04justify these high multiples. Yeah, you hear that constantly.
- 8:06Constantly. But it doesn't change the
- 8:08fundamental math. You can only pay so much for a
- 8:10dollar of earnings and expect a decent return.
- 8:13Maybe low rates explain why valuations can stay high for
- 8:16longer, stretch further, but they don't repeal the law of
- 8:19gravity that says starting super high usually leads to
- 8:21disappointing results eventually.
- 8:23OK, So 2 huge warning signs in the long term dashboard.
- 8:27Buffett indicator at 217%, EPE at 38, severe risk.
- 8:32Now for the paradox part, the short term, the VIX, the fear
- 8:36gauge. Why look at this 30 day
- 8:39emotional measure when the long term structure looks so risky?
- 8:42Because the VIX, the CBOE Volatility Index, it tells us
- 8:45about the market's current mood, it's emotional state right now.
- 8:48It measures implied volatility, what the market collectively
- 8:51expects in terms of price swings for the S&P 500 over the next 30
- 8:55days. And it gets that from options
- 8:56prices like insurance. Exactly, it's derived from from
- 9:00the price of options contracts. Think of options as insurance
- 9:03policies against big market moves.
- 9:05If insurance is cheap, it means people aren't worried about a
- 9:07crash happening soon. And right now insurance is
- 9:09cheap. What's the VIX reading?
- 9:11As we said, it's around 15.7 in mid-september 2025.
- 9:14OK, 15.7 and what's normal? Well, generally anything below
- 9:1820 is considered calm or complacent.
- 9:20The long term average VIX going back decades through all kinds
- 9:23of markets is usually somewhere between 20 and 22.
- 9:26So 15.7 isn't just calm, it's below average calm, extra calm.
- 9:30It's deeply calm, deeply complacent territory.
- 9:34So here it is, the paradox in sharp relief.
- 9:37Huge structural risk, the 270% in the 38 paired with almost 0
- 9:42short term fear the 15.7. It's like it's like knowing your
- 9:46house has major foundation cracks but everyone just having
- 9:49a garden party outside ignoring it.
- 9:51That's a perfect analogy. And importantly, that low VIX,
- 9:54that lack of fear, might actually be enabling the extreme
- 9:57valuations to persist, even grow.
- 9:59How so? Because when nobody's worried
- 10:01about the next 30 days, there's no trigger, no catalyst forcing
- 10:05people to reassess these sky high prices.
- 10:08There's no immediate pressure for prices to reflect the
- 10:10underlying risks. Everyone feels comfortable
- 10:12paying 38 times smooth earnings because, hey, the VIX says the
- 10:15next month looks quiet. But couldn't a low VIX just mean
- 10:18people are confident? Confident in the Fed having
- 10:20their back or confident earnings will stay strong.
- 10:23Why see it as fragility instead of strength?
- 10:25Because volatility. Unlike stock prices which can
- 10:27trend up forever theoretically, volatility is mean reverting it
- 10:31cycles. Meaning it goes up and down
- 10:33around an average. Exactly.
- 10:34The market simply cannot stay this quiet indefinitely.
- 10:38It's unnatural. So a reading as low as 15.7
- 10:43statistically implies a much higher probability of volatility
- 10:47increasing in the future just to get back towards that long term
- 10:50average of 2022. So the low VIX isn't a sign of
- 10:54permanent safety, it's actually a measure of the markets
- 10:57fragility. Think of it like potential
- 11:00energy building up. It's like compressing a spring.
- 11:02The longer and tighter you compress that volatility spring
- 11:05down to 15.7, the more violent the release is likely to be when
- 11:08something finally causes it to snap back.
- 11:11OK, let's try to bring this all together.
- 11:13If the Buffett indicator and the KP ratio are like the Geological
- 11:16Survey showing massive tectonic pressure building deep
- 11:19underground, then the VIX is like the local weather report
- 11:22saying clear skies, no wind today.
- 11:25Prudence says you listen to the geology, not just the immediate
- 11:27weather. Absolutely spot on.
- 11:29And we've seen this movie before right?
- 11:31The late 90s leading up to the.com bust valuations got
- 11:34extreme. JP hit 44 but the VIX wasn't
- 11:36consistently screaming danger the whole time, it had periods
- 11:39of calm. Even more telling maybe is 2006,
- 11:432007 right before the global financial crisis.
- 11:45Valuations were high, maybenot.com high, but high and
- 11:49the VIX It fell to what were then all time lows.
- 11:52Peak complacency, peak calm, right before the entire system
- 11:56blew up. And now we have valuations
- 11:58arguably higherthanthe.com peak on the Buffett indicatornear.com
- 12:03peak on key B combined with that 2007 level VIX complacency.
- 12:07It's a potent combination, a historically dangerous mix
- 12:10according to these indicators. So when a paradox this extreme
- 12:13finally breaks, history suggests it tends to go one of two ways,
- 12:16right? What are those paths?
- 12:18Generally, yes. Path 1 is the hard landing, the
- 12:21crash. Some catalyst, maybe external,
- 12:24like a geopolitical shock, maybe internal like a credit event or
- 12:27the Fed surprising everyone. Something suddenly shatters that
- 12:29low VIX complacency. The VIX spikes, fear explodes,
- 12:32and his extreme valuations correct violently, often very
- 12:35quickly over months. Think 2000, 2002.
- 12:38Think 2008. Sharp.
- 12:39Painful. OK, that's path one, the crash.
- 12:42What's path 2? Path 2 is maybe less traumatic
- 12:45day-to-day but still painful over time.
- 12:48It's the soft landing or maybe better called stagnation.
- 12:51A lost decade meaning no sudden crash but the market just goes
- 12:57nowhere for years. Maybe it drift sideways, maybe
- 12:59slightly down, maybe slightly up, but less than inflation.
- 13:02You get basically 0 real return for a decade, maybe longer.
- 13:06Why would that happen? Because the only way to fix that
- 13:09starting KP of 38 without a crash is for company earnings to
- 13:12slowly, painstakingly grow over many, many years until that
- 13:16multiple looks reasonable again. Fundamentals have to catch up to
- 13:19the crazy price. The classic example is 1966 to
- 13:221982 in the US. The market basically delivered
- 13:25no real return for 16 years. Wow, 16 years.
- 13:28Yeah. So given today's extremes, 217%
- 13:31and 38, either past the crash or the long stagnation, points
- 13:34towards significant disappointment compared to the
- 13:3610% or so average annual return people often expect from stocks.
- 13:40OK, so we're looking at maximum long term risk masked by this
- 13:44eerie short term calm. For you, the listener facing
- 13:48these numbers, how do you even begin to think about strategy
- 13:50for the next, say, decade? Strategy has to start with
- 13:53managing expectations. That's number one.
- 13:56You have to anchor your return forecast to what the FPE data is
- 13:59suggesting. Prepare mentally and perhaps
- 14:02financially for low single digit real returns.
- 14:06If you're banking on 10% a year like the old days, you're likely
- 14:09setting yourself up for a big disappointment.
- 14:11Whether we get the crash or the long grind, Job one is
- 14:15preserving capital in this environment.
- 14:17And within a portfolio, does quality matter more now given
- 14:20that high key suggests growth is already priced in, maybe
- 14:23overpriced? Absolutely crucial when the
- 14:25average stock is priced at these levels.
- 14:27Perfection is assumed everywhere, so you need to focus
- 14:30intensely on quality. Companies with really strong
- 14:32balance sheets, durable competitive advantages, moats,
- 14:36real pricing power, businesses that might actually be able to
- 14:39deliver the phenomenal growth needed to justify a high
- 14:42multiple even through a downturn.
- 14:43And avoid the speculative stuff. Definitely those companies with
- 14:47weak financials, unproven business models, lots of debt.
- 14:51They're the ones likely to suffer the most brutal multiple
- 14:53contractions when, not if, the VIX eventually wakes up and fear
- 14:57returns. And that low VIX, that 15.7.
- 15:01What does it tell us about psychology and maybe being
- 15:04contrarian? Well, it's the clearest signal
- 15:07you could ask for of widespread complacency, maybe even greed.
- 15:11And certainly an absence of fear.
- 15:13Which means, if you follow the classic advice, be fearful when
- 15:16others are greedy. Now's the time to be fearful.
- 15:19Exactly. And you see real world evidence
- 15:22of this thinking. Look at Warren Buffett's
- 15:23Berkshire Hathaway. Reports say they're sitting on a
- 15:26record cash pile over 160 billion dollars.
- 15:30Wow, that's a lot of shash. It's an enormous amount and it
- 15:32sends a powerful message, right? They are clearly reluctant to
- 15:35deploy that capital into the market at these current
- 15:37historically stretched prices. They're waiting, waiting for
- 15:41fear to return, waiting for better prices.
- 15:43That's contrarianism in action. Any other strategic thoughts?
- 15:46Diversification maybe? Yes, definitely.
- 15:48Consider geographic diversification.
- 15:50These extreme valuation numbers, the 217% and the 38, they're
- 15:54particularly acute in the US market.
- 15:56Other markets, maybe parts of Europe, maybe some emerging
- 15:59markets in Asia. They might not be cheap, but
- 16:01they often offer more reasonable starting valuations.
- 16:04Spreading your investments geographically could be a really
- 16:07important way to manage the risks posed by this very US
- 16:11centric paradox. OK, let's wrap this up.
- 16:14The key take away seems crystal clear.
- 16:16The market is presenting this profound disconnect maximum long
- 16:21term risk confirmed by historically extreme readings on
- 16:24the Buffett indicator 270% and the CPE ratio 38, yet
- 16:29simultaneously near total short term calm reflected in that VIX
- 16:33down at 15.7. Precisely.
- 16:36And that leaves us with a final maybe provocative thought for
- 16:38you to consider, given that history and the data strongly
- 16:41suggests these valuations are extreme.
- 16:43If a big correction doesn't come from some external shock like a
- 16:46war or crisis, what internal change, what shift in thinking
- 16:49among investors themselves beyond just fear returning might
- 16:52finally force the system to reconnect with economic reality.
- 16:55We'll belief in the Low Rates Forever story finally crack on
- 16:58its own. That underlying tension, that
- 17:00psychological component, is definitely something to watch
- 17:02closely as this paradox continues.