Latest / 323 Bourbon Library Podcast / 10/29/26 EPISODE 037: 2026 MAKER'S MARK CELLAR AGED - BOTTLE BREAKDOWN
Transcript
- 323 Bourbon Library Podcast: All right, folks, welcome back in to another episode on the 323 Bourbon Library Podcast. My name is Ronnie. John Carlo here. Yep. And tonight, folks, we are reviewing potentially a bottle that we might have in the bottle of the year competition. We'll see. We'll see. I've heard a lot of great things about this. I I posted recently about getting it, and people are like, it's really good. So now I'm excited. Remember, last year's was good. So we are reviewing this year 2026 release, Maker's Mark Cellaraged. And I thought let's give a little bit of history about Maker's Mark and why this line. This is the fourth iteration. So these have been coming out 2023, 2024, 25, and now in 2026. but let's talk about Maker's Mark a little bit tonight. So Maker's Mark has a storied history rooted In breaking industry traditions. It is a breakdown of its or here's here's the breakdown of its origins and evolution. So in this is not a brand that goes back into the 1800s, 1700s, like a lot of brands. So this brand started 1953. It was founded by T. Samuels, who purchased the disused Burks Distillery in Loreto, Kentucky, along with his wife, Margie Samuels. Bill Samuels Sr. famously threw away The family's 170 year old bourbon recipe by burning it. He wanted a smoother, sweeter whiskey that didn't rely on bitter rye. He replaced rye with soft red winter wheat, creating maker's mark signature wheated bourbon. Mash bill is roughly 70% corn, 16% wheat, and 14% malted barley. So Margie Samrels is the vis visionary behind the brand's iconic disign. She named the whiskey Maker's Mark, stamped with a pseudo guild like mark featuring a Roman numeral four, representing the fourth generation of the Samuels family to make whiskey. She also designed the signature hand-dipped red wax seal and the squarish bottle shape. That's pretty cool. Shout out to her. Big shout out to Margie. and for decades, Maker's Mark resisted releasing older age-stated bourbons. Arguing that traditional Kentucky heat caused oak tannins to overpower the whiskey after roughly six years, ruining the intended flavor profile. To satisfy consumer demand, the for older whiskeys coming without compromising their signature fruit and wheat flavor profile, Signet MakersMark launched their seller-aged series back in 2023. Instead of aging entirely in a traditional multi-story Rickhouse, Where seasonal temperature swings extract heavy oak tannins. Barrels are aged traditionally for about seven years and then moved to a lead certified subterranean limestone cellar. Love to go visit that if you could. That'd be cool. the cooler, stable environment of the limestone cellar slows down extraction. This allows the whiskey to gain deeper maturity, complexity, and darker notes without becoming overly woody or bitter. So the Maker's Mark Cellar Age series has evolved into an anticipated annual limited release, while all editions share the foundational Maker's Mark weeded mash bill of 70 70% corn, 16% soft red winter wheat, 14% malted barley, and they undergo a secondary maturation in their subterranean limestone cellar. Every year features a completely unique blend, ratio, proof, and flavor profile. So we got a little breakdown of the four releases. So the first one, 2023, it was a blend of 87% 12 year old and 13% 11 year old. it came out at 115.7 proof, $150. They say the flavor notes on that were creamy vanilla, creme brulee, cotton candy, butterscotch, maple syrup, and baking spice. for twenty twenty four the blend went up a little bit. So instead of instead of twelve and eleven, it went to thirteen and twelve years. So eighty five percent thirteen year old, fifteen percent twelve year old, and the proof went up to a hundred and nineteen point three. MSRP also went up to one seventy five. Do you think those were the same? Barrels? Barrels. Just the age older. You know, that's a good question. I don't know if they pulled like, hey, we distilled all these and then we moved them at the same time. It could be. but they don't vary their mash bill, so it's it's a great question. I don't know, maybe it'll s maybe we'll talk about it in a little bit, but I don't know if they had any rhyme or reason of which barrels they pulled to put in the cellar. But it sounds like for all of they seven years normal Rick House and then The rest of the time sellers. So the first year, six years. Now it's seven years. anyway, so that second year, 175 bucks. It went up twenty five dollars. MSRP. This one got a little more dark chocolatey, brown sugar, rich coconut coconut, velvety oak, long warming mouth coat finish. I'm gonna probably skip over the tasting notes here on out. Twenty twenty five, they introduced it was seventy-five percent eleven year old. So the bulk of it was actually younger than the previous two releases, ten percent thirteen year old, but they now introduced sixteen percent of a fourteen year old. wow bourbon. The proof did drop here to one twelve point nine, and then th this year It is got the it the eleven year old component dropped by almost twenty five percent, right or literally by twenty five percent to forty nine percent eleven year old, now thirty-three percent twelve year old, and the most ever fourteen year old bourbon at eighteen percent went into this blend. But also this bottle we're gonna crack is the lowest proof version of all of at a hundred and twelve point one. MSRP still still rode out here at a one seventy five. so let's see here. So we're gonna talk through the age evolution. We might have already hit on some of this. the rele twenty twenty three release pushed the envelope by introducing eleven and twelve year old stocks. twenty twenty four, they leaned heavily into a thirteen year old stock, eighty five percent of the blend making it the boldest and highest proof version. And then the 25 and 26, they started introducing the 14-year-old stucks. while dialing in the cast strength back down to 112-proof range for a softer, more rounded integration of oak. so this particular release of 2026 was released September 1st of this year, and it's the fourth installment in this limited edition series that I've I don't have the 23, but I have the 24, 25, and 26 versions of this. I need to Go just pay up for and get a I probably need to buy on secondary a twenty three. So we can do a all four all episode blind. Let us know in the comments. Should we do that? Do you want to see a maker's mark cellar age four way blind? Let us know in the comments if you have an extra bottle too. Yeah, if you got a if you got a case of twenty three year old cellar age, hit me up. I'll we'll we'll we'll strike a deal on something, I'm sure. so this is the lowest proof version at 112.1. And the I'm gonna skip over the flavor profile. Let's get this thing poured up. We'll come back to the what they say the flavor profile is after we've tasted this whiskey. Get that wax off. Funny that I in culinary school I used to sneak in little bottles of bourbon. Really? But it was it was always maker's mark. For cooking with or just cooking with, not drinking. Okay, okay. it was my pastry class or huh. It was some sort of Just to add a little bit of like zhuzh to it. Well, I would put I would pour the bourbon in my caramel sauce. Okay. So it'd be a bourbon caramel sauce. Ooh. Ooh. Well, listen, buddy. You might need to just show up here with some more bourbon. I'm gonna say before I crack this thing, the nice thing about makers mark, I don't know what they do, but their wax just peels so effortless effortless effortlessly. Yeah. Where some of these other brands that are wax in their bottles, No shout-outs here, but rare character. Yeah. I dude, I had a like I've think I've like broken a couple of pocket knife blades trying to get the the wax off of those. This one just effortlessly. Let's get the pop on this thing. So no to all you wax toppers. Get your wax top blends correct. Yeah, get a get a softer box. Let's get that pop. Nice pot. Nice. Alright, a couple glugs here. Let's get this thing poured up. See how good it is. People said in the comments when I posted that I found a bottle of this or my buddy got me a bottle of this. They're like, it's really good. You're gonna love it. Remember last year's was good. Last year's was do you know what? We got last year's behind us. We might let's taste this. Yeah, let's let's And maybe we'll come back and we'll do a little comparison. Last year to this year. All right. See. Legs around there. man, this thing is nice. Nice and sweet off the top. Very sweet. Yeah, and initially like some creamy vanilla, nice red fruit. I don't know if it's like cherry or raspberry or I like that. Wow. A nice nose. I remember liking twenty twenty-five. some of the makers when they do their wood stave finishes, it's it it feels like they're just doing too much. A lot of them get really, really oaky. Yeah. Just just stick with the bourbon. Stick it down, stick everything in the fucking cellar. Just put everything underground, let it age for twenty nine years, just bring it out. It like this nose is incredible. It's sweet. It's rich. It's got those dessert notes that I love. A little bit of oak spice on it. Yeah, I get the baking spice off. Which is why I think in culinary school I used to use it a lot. 'Cause of those baking spices. I'm gonna taste it. Yeah, go ahead. I'm join this nose. I hope it drinks as well as its nose smell. Hm. Yeah, you should try it. Wow. This being the lowest proof of them, it definitely has a little bit of like warmth to the back side of the finish on this. It does. Yeah. But the but still has the fruit. A little sweetness in there. Like the oak on it. Oak. Yeah. I'm always skeptical to say drying. Like yeah. But you get a little tannic type of oak note. Yeah. some people don't like the word dry. Yeah. Listen, I it just depends. Sometimes I've noticed lately, and I and I I'm saying this, but I don't confuse it. I'm not saying this bourbon's giving it to me. Some bur some older whiskies right now, or just whiskies in general, are giving me this like not a Kentucky hug. It's like a this is gonna give me heartburn later. Yeah, like almost like I need to take a go out and get some, you know Tums or something. Yeah. I I get and I'm like, what is that? I'm like, that is not, I don't enjoy that feeling when I'm drinking whiskey. And it's not all of them. Nope. It's just every now and then one does it. And I don't know what causes that. I don't because I've noticed it on proofy ones. I've noticed it on non proofy ones. And so it's just a little aside here. I'm like, what is that shit? Because I don't want to it put that on the label. You know what does that to me? Scotches. Give me the I need a I need a Tums or a Yeah, the the juzh, yeah. I don't like that. Yeah, so I don't drink Yeah, this is nice. Back to it. Red fruits. Nice sweetness. Confectioner, sugar, caramel, all that. It is. Let's see what they say. Let's see what they say we should taste on it. so they say we should be tasting floral vanilla. Actually, you don't like floral flavors. Floral vanilla. No, I get just nice, clean rich tobacco, cedar, caramel, toffee, nutmeg, dark leather, transitioning into a long warming finish where the fruit and the oak stay in harmony. I definitely get the long warming finish. These are tasting notes. it just says the flavor profile on the listing there from the from maker's mark. Yeah, they I guess they could have broken down into nose and palate and all that. I think for me I like the fruit the fruit and the sweet on the nose. Those carry over, but they mute a little bit on the front of the palate. They're not like s some bourbons you give like it almost like a dessert. This isn't giving me it's not giving me that. But it still has a little bit of the sweetness. For sure. It's a nice and it's nicely balanced. It's good. Yeah. And then you get the oak and the spice and the long like Kentucky hug on it. Yeah. I don't know. The question is we went into this. Is this is this last year deserving is it better than last year's? Grab that bottle. This might help us to determine if we should put it in our year in blind of best whiskies. Get some glasses there. That way we can side by side this. Let's pop up. So we got the twenty twenty five for those that aren't watching. pretty close in proof. Hundred and twelve point nine proof. This one is only sixteen percent the fourteen year old, seventy-four percent eleven year old. Okay. So not three, just two. Boon. So sounds good. Little deeper banging bungier sound to it. All right. This will be this will help us determine if it's really like incredible. Cause I think I did have this the 2025. I did have the twenty twenty-five in my blind. Put the twenty Best of the year. Best of the year. I don't remember where it finished. It didn't win. but it was in the competition. I'm gonna get the nose on both of these. So does that mean if this year's better, is this one going in is this year's going in the competition? Well, if it's if this year's is not better than last year's. Yeah, no, it's not going to be. But if it is better. I don't know, then I guess we have to determine. Yeah. Last year, what did we have? I think I had twenty-two. whiskies. I didn't I didn't category them up. We just did twenty two whiskies and we tasted them all in one night. And that's how I picked the best of. this year we'll be a little more methodical. We'll introduce everybody from the podcast to that the panel. anyway, let me nose these side by side here. Wow. I like this year's nose weighing. You do? Way better. Way better? Yeah. I don't know. Last year's has this like what is it? Little bit more red fruit on last year's on the nose. On the nose smells sweeter. This year I get more caramel toffee on the nose. You for sure get the red fruits more on last year's year. And you get a sweeter nose and more sugary nose on this year's. Yeah. It does feel a little older on this year in the twenty twenty six. A little more leathery. I'm gonna try last year's. Based on those, I like this shirt. Based on those the nose better, we'll see what the taste like. This year's I'll let you say what you think before I respond. No, so that's a good sip. I'm gonna have to go back to the twenty six before I can make I did back to back on both of them. you did? Yeah. Okay. We go in for the twenty six. You said the twenty twenty six nose was better than the twenty twenty five. For me, yeah. Yep. And what do you think on the palette? torn on the palate. Yeah. See I'm all I'm I'm I think I'm a little let me let me go back. I'm torn on the palate because I think this has more depth of flavor the twenty five. Five, I think. But my profile that I prefer is a little sweeter, and I think the twenty six is a little sweeter. I think the twenty six is a better sip. Yeah. That's interesting you say death. So twenty six gives me a little more age. I get like that dark caramel. There's a leathery note in the the twenty six that I like. Maybe the twenty five mix maybe depth is not the right word. It's more of it's like I get different flavors. Layers. Yeah, though you get the fruit, the sweet, the oak. The this one feels maybe a little more what's the word? Like when it's pulled together, congealed. Yeah. It's a bit weird sounding word for a bourbon, but it's more It's not a jello. No. There's a word and I can't think of it. Hmm. These are close. They're both good. They're both really good. man, I am struggling to think do I does the twenty twenty five we got some fucking sh cracker banger cracker bottles on this year's best of and I'm like, is this even gonna compete? I think it I think it will. I think it will do all right. I don't know if it'll clear the first bracket. I don't think so. Just for folks, if you're if you're really interested in our year in bracketing, we have currently have sixteen bottles f in the one hundred and fifty dollar bracket and up. Correct. And we've got I think nine bottles in the one hundred and fifty dollar and down bourbon bracket and then like Eight seven or eight in the rye category. So we're gonna we're gonna have three categories of best of this year, which we haven't done in the past. It was just one bottle. But now that we've got the podcast going, we've got several people that are participating in that. I felt I felt like we could we can really stretch and get some good stuff here. So I don't know, final verdict. What do you think? Should we put it in the year end? Okay. I'm gonna have to go back through my notes and see what's actually in there. But I don't know. It's pretty good. It's pretty good. I'm but that but that one fifty and up category is pretty tough. It is tough. And there is a bottle, there is one of the bottles, one of the sixty bottles I think I need to pull out of the category. Mm. No offense to them, but it's it's so limited. It's crazy. I think there were like sixty bottles or something. It was a single barrel, there were sixty bottles. No one will get one. Or if you got one, you got one. You probably have already drank it or you put it in the your bar and you're not to sell it. so I might pull that out. We may put this in there in lieu of that bottle. Good. Just to see how it does. Yeah. Anyway, all right. We'll do it. We'll do it. We're gonna add it onto the can onto the best of 2026 list. Now I don't know if it'll make a splash. I'm gonna say that. But I think for right now we should add it. We'll maybe have to do a little auditing here in the in a month or so when we're like finalizing our list. Yeah. It's a very good pour. I think it's really good. I enjoyed it. Do you think it's better than twenty twenty five? I think so. I think it's better than twenty twenty five by a little margin. I wanna say yes. By a little by a small margin. Yeah, it's not over it's not like amazingly better. No. But it's better. It's better. Yeah. Anyway. hey guys, thank you guys for following along. We're talking about makers mark, seller age twenty twenty-six release. We are gonna have it in the competition, I believe, at this moment for a contender for best of twenty twenty six. I'm gonna be honest, I'm skeptical it can win. Very skeptical. Because there are some hitters on that hitters on that list. anyway. Thank you all for for following along. If you're listening to us on Spotify, Apple Music, YouTube, we get a bunch of comments on YouTube. If you're listening on Spotify or Apple Music, please leave us a review. Five star comments, whatever. Help us continue to grow the channel. We appreciate your support. And if there's something you want to see us blind or review, let us know in the comments. And we will try to get it scheduled for an upcoming episode. We'll even give you a shout out. Yes. For recommending it. that sounds good. Cheers, folks. We appreciate it. We'll see you next time.