Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / When Office Romance Makes Headlines: Legal Considerations with Maryann P. Gallagher and Ellen E. Cohen
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to When Office Romance Makes Headlines
- 0:06and the legal considerations behind that. I'm
- 0:09Lorena Vazquez, Vice Chair of the Beverly Hills
- 0:12Bar Labor and Employment Section, and I will
- 0:14be moderating today's very exciting program.
- 0:17I am delighted to introduce our speakers, Marianne
- 0:21Gallagher and Ellen Cohen. Maryann is the founder
- 0:25of the law offices of Maryann Gallagher, which
- 0:28has recently joined forces with Jeannie Harrison
- 0:31Law. With over 30 years of courtroom experience,
- 0:36Maryann has secured landmark verdicts in sexual
- 0:38assault, sexual harassment, sexual orientation
- 0:42discrimination, disability discrimination, and
- 0:45whistleblower retaliation cases. Alan Cohen is
- 0:49the principal in the Los Angeles office of Jackson
- 0:51Lewis. providing comprehensive representation
- 0:54of management in employment disputes. She handles
- 0:58cases involving harassment, discrimination, retaliation,
- 1:02and wrongful termination in state and federal
- 1:04courts, as well as arbitration and administration
- 1:07hearings. Ellen takes a proactive approach in
- 1:10supporting her clients, providing valuable advice
- 1:13on a host of employment issues, including discipline
- 1:16termination, layoff procedures, accommodations
- 1:20under the ADA and FIHA. And now let's get started.
- 1:26Great. Thank you so much, Lorena. Today, we're
- 1:30going to be focusing on the legal risks and the
- 1:32duties associated with inter -office relationships.
- 1:36We've got a slideshow prepared for you that has
- 1:38a lot of materials, and hopefully you find it
- 1:41useful. I'll be coming out from more of a defense
- 1:44perspective, and Marianne's going to be coming
- 1:46for a plaintiff's perspective. Can we move on
- 1:49to the next slide? All right, so again, inter
- 1:54-office relationships in California, while not
- 1:56necessarily legal, they aren't just HR issues.
- 1:59They're really legal landmines. California imposes
- 2:02strict fiduciary duties on officers and directors.
- 2:05There's a duty of loyalty, duty of care and candor.
- 2:08Undisclosed relationships can undermine trust,
- 2:10decision -making, and trigger lawsuits and board
- 2:13investigations. Basically, it's not a good thing.
- 2:17And typically, we advise clients to use disclosure
- 2:20as a shield and not a sword because it could
- 2:23really get messy. Next slide. All right, so imagine
- 2:28a director who's secretly dating a subordinate.
- 2:31The director doesn't disclose it, and later the
- 2:33employee gets a plush assignment. When the relationship's
- 2:36exposed, shareholders allege the director put
- 2:39personal interests above the company's. This
- 2:41isn't necessarily a hypothetical. This is a very,
- 2:43very common scenario we see. where an individual
- 2:47director could be found. There could be liability
- 2:49for the individual officer or director who fails
- 2:52to disclose this relationship, and it affects
- 2:56their decision making. Non -disclosure can expose
- 2:59executives to personal liability for breach of
- 3:02fiduciary duties, and it could trigger shareholder
- 3:06derivative actions, which are becoming increasingly
- 3:08common in these kinds of scenarios. So again,
- 3:12We, as a defense attorney, I highly encourage
- 3:15my clients to develop a culture of transparency
- 3:18and regular training. Next slide. Why do inter
- 3:25-office romances make the news? Well, it's definitely
- 3:27more interesting than wage and hour stuff. And
- 3:30it's probably on the juicier end of employment
- 3:33law in general. But there's a whole slew of issues
- 3:37that come with it. There is conflicts of interest.
- 3:39Think of the McDonald's CEO that was ousted for
- 3:43a relationship with a subordinate. That was...
- 3:45all over the place. There could be breaches of
- 3:47fiduciary duty. California corporations code
- 3:50section 309 is clear. It says that directors
- 3:54and officers must act in the company's best interest.
- 3:57And this is a prime scenario to kind of trigger
- 4:01those breach of fiduciary duty suits. There is
- 4:04also You know, the idea that a single romance
- 4:07can trigger a derivative action, derivative suit
- 4:10by shareholders. And of course, there's harassment
- 4:12and discrimination claims, especially if the
- 4:14relationship bends badly, there's favoritism,
- 4:17there's a supervisor subordinate relationship.
- 4:20So mishandling and hiding of these office romances,
- 4:24especially at the executive level, can have swift
- 4:26and severe consequences, which is why we're here
- 4:29with you today. Next slide. So let's kind of
- 4:34get into the legal nuts and bolts of it. Under
- 4:36the California Corporations Code, Section 309,
- 4:39directors and officers owe a duty of loyalty,
- 4:41care, and candor. There is a case law showing
- 4:44that a secret relationship can trigger not only
- 4:49the lawsuits we spoke about for breach of the
- 4:51judiciary duty and shareholder derivative actions,
- 4:54along with personal liability, but it could also
- 4:56void the executive's actions and any decisions
- 4:59made by the board as a result. As a result, the
- 5:03board must independently investigate any of these
- 5:06potential conflicts or breaches of duties and
- 5:09document, document, document. An executive should
- 5:13always be aware that if they're in doubt, if
- 5:14they think that there may be an issue, they think
- 5:16that there may be entering a gray area with respect
- 5:20to a relationship with a subordinate, the school
- 5:23of thought is, if in doubt, disclose and recuse.
- 5:27There's any issues, always disclose and recuse.
- 5:31Next slide. So here's another scenario. A senior
- 5:37executive of a company starts dating a subordinate.
- 5:40He doesn't tell the board, but he's involved
- 5:42in promotion and pay decisions with respect to
- 5:44the subordinate. Other employees notice morale
- 5:46tanks, the whistleblower tips of the board. The
- 5:51company investigates and the shareholders alleged
- 5:53breach of duty. Court, this is becoming an increasingly
- 5:57common scenario, especially as social media becomes
- 6:01more prevalent, people have more contact with
- 6:03one another, they're able to communicate offline
- 6:06or at work and socially a lot easier, which is
- 6:10leading to more and more of these situations.
- 6:12Courts have held that directors and officers
- 6:15must fully disclose any personal interest, even
- 6:18if they personally think that it's not an issue.
- 6:20If there's any personal interest involved that
- 6:24could, in theory, impact their impartiality.
- 6:26Even if they think it doesn't, if in theory it
- 6:28could impact impartiality, it should be disclosed.
- 6:32This is supported by multiple court rulings,
- 6:36findings, things like that. As a defense attorney,
- 6:39we typically train executives and HR professionals
- 6:42about disclosure obligations, how to document,
- 6:45how to train, and establish a process for recusal
- 6:50and disclosure so that we don't get to those
- 6:52issues. Next slide. In general, undisclosed office
- 7:02romances can lead to all kinds of conflicts of
- 7:04interest, especially when you are dealing with
- 7:07executives. It could not only lead to personal
- 7:08liability, it can actually void the transactions
- 7:10and cause severe reputational harm. Next slide.
- 7:17So I'm going to talk about damages. Where's the
- 7:20money in these first type of cases? So in the
- 7:23shareholder, in the individual liability, it's
- 7:27shareholder versus individual. It's really between
- 7:30the the corporate players. So the shareholders
- 7:32will say to the person who had the relationship,
- 7:35either you didn't disclose it to us and you caused
- 7:38us harm, or you disclosed it to us, but you didn't
- 7:42follow our procedures and you caused us harm.
- 7:45So that's the first type of case would be the
- 7:47shareholders suing the individual. A lot of the
- 7:50cases on this are about where shareholders are
- 7:54stealing other people's employees, like they're
- 7:56getting ready to resign and they're taking a
- 7:58bunch of people, hey, come along with me. So
- 8:00those are the kind of the examples that they're
- 8:01using where under what Ellen was talking about,
- 8:04which is the corporate code 309, you can't put
- 8:07your personal interest ahead of the shareholders.
- 8:10So the remedies that you can get, which would
- 8:13again be the individual corporate. Director or
- 8:18officer having to pay back the shareholders is
- 8:21disgorgement of their salary. So if there's an
- 8:24issue where I guess in the harassment case, the
- 8:27scenario would be if he's having a relationship
- 8:30with somebody and during this whole period of
- 8:32time, he's either not disclosing it or he's abusing
- 8:36what the board is telling him to do, then he
- 8:40would have to pay back the money that he made
- 8:42from that period of time. So the disgorgement
- 8:45of salary, that's under 160 cal at fourth, 362.
- 8:49So that's one remedy. And then if we go to the
- 8:52next slide. Not only that, but. Shareholders
- 8:57who say our corporation has been damaged because
- 9:00of what this person did. Everything's open to
- 9:02them, just as if it were a tort. So they can
- 9:05get reputational damages. They can get fraud
- 9:09damages. They have a whole basket of money that
- 9:14they can go after. But again, from the plaintiff's
- 9:17point of view, we don't represent corporations
- 9:19usually. We don't represent shareholders. And
- 9:22going after an individual, especially after he's
- 9:24lost his job, isn't going to be the place that
- 9:27we want to go. So I can see where this violates
- 9:33the law of the fiduciary duty between the...
- 9:36executive and the corporation. But from a plaintiff
- 9:40standpoint, it's not a place that we would be
- 9:43looking at unless we represented the corporation
- 9:45to go after the individual. And then even then
- 9:49you have to think, are we going to recover? And
- 9:51how much money are we going to be able to recover
- 9:52from this individual? That's our individual liability.
- 10:00All right. So. We're still talking about the
- 10:04executive level employees. How do you manage
- 10:07these conflicts of interest? What are the best
- 10:08practices? From a defense perspective, and this
- 10:12is what I typically tell my clients, the best
- 10:14way to manage this risk is to have clear and
- 10:17consistent policies and enforcement of those
- 10:19policies. This is what you're expected to do.
- 10:22This is what you can do. This is what you can't
- 10:25do. And if you did it, here's how you fix it.
- 10:29Disclosure to the board and shareholders is required.
- 10:33It's always required. And recusals from decisions
- 10:37that may affect your, recusal from any decisions
- 10:44affecting your romantic partner is required.
- 10:46Otherwise, you're really opening the door up
- 10:48for a lot of legal consequences. So again, if
- 10:52an executive is in a relationship that could
- 10:54create a conflict, Disclosure is the first key
- 10:59to the board and to the shareholders. Then the
- 11:02next step would be recusal. How do you do that?
- 11:05Who do you talk to? There have to be clear policies,
- 11:07consistent policies and how that's enforced.
- 11:10Step away from any decisions involving the romantic
- 11:12partner and anyone that could be closely affiliated
- 11:16with a romantic partner. For example, a best
- 11:19friend, a family member, anything that may be
- 11:22tethered to that romantic partner, you should
- 11:24also consider. The other very, very important
- 11:28key here is documentation, documenting that disclosure
- 11:31process, investigation process, and recusal process.
- 11:35Recently, I actually had a case where I worked
- 11:38with a company, were an executive, disclosed
- 11:40her relationship, recused herself, and then the
- 11:43board documented everything. Steps were taken.
- 11:46Later, the transaction was challenged. There
- 11:48was a lawsuit involved. There was... all kinds
- 11:51of things going on as far as the steps that this
- 11:54executive had taken while involved in the relationship.
- 11:57But because this executive timely disclosed that
- 12:00relationship, recused herself early on, and it
- 12:04handed the reins over to someone else, some of
- 12:07those decisions were ultimately upheld as fair,
- 12:11and things were able to move forward as the company
- 12:14had intended. So again, The disclosure and the
- 12:18recusal process isn't just formalities. It's
- 12:20required. It's the best defense that we have
- 12:23as defense attorneys for litigation. Otherwise,
- 12:26the door is just open and there's really not
- 12:27much you can do there. And with it comes a written
- 12:31formal process for handling those disclosures,
- 12:35recusals. So danger areas. Danger areas, there's
- 12:45some very, very obvious ones. Promotions, compensation,
- 12:48disciplines involving your romantic partner,
- 12:51influencing over hiring and projects, those sorts
- 12:54of things. But there could also be those very
- 12:56slight, you know, appearance of favoritism or
- 12:58bias. You may not be, or the executive may not
- 13:01be intending to exhibit favoritism, may not necessarily
- 13:05be giving the promotion, but you're being invited
- 13:08to lunches, you're getting concert tickets. You're
- 13:12getting, you know, better seat at the conference,
- 13:15things like that. And those are the scenarios
- 13:18that trigger these kinds of lawsuits. So again,
- 13:23you're looking at the very obvious scenarios,
- 13:27but also you have to look for the, you know,
- 13:30is there a favoritism, something that may not
- 13:33be as obvious? And if you don't, and if the executive
- 13:36doesn't disclose, that's where we come in. For
- 13:39defense, there's personal liability for the executives.
- 13:42As Marianne noted, there's going to be reimbursement
- 13:44for unfair gains. There's damage to the corporation
- 13:47trust, which ultimately becomes one of the biggest
- 13:49issues for these companies we're working with.
- 13:53It's much easier to reimburse for unfair gains,
- 13:57for the most part. But reputational harm is something
- 14:00that stays with you for a very long time. Next
- 14:03slide. But again, not all workplace romances
- 14:10create a problem. There's times where it's really,
- 14:14you know, it is what it is. It's just part of
- 14:17life that people spend most of their adult lives
- 14:19at work. So these things happen and not every
- 14:22single one of these instances will create a legal
- 14:24problem. For example, if two employees in different
- 14:27departments start dating, And they don't report
- 14:30to one another. There's no subordinate supervisor
- 14:33relationship. Usually there's no legal issue.
- 14:36And I say usually because you never know. There's
- 14:38always facts that could pop up. Really where
- 14:42these issues come up is where there's a power
- 14:44imbalance, where you've got someone that's got
- 14:47the ability to influence the other person. in
- 14:54situations like that, that's where the California
- 14:56Corporations Code that we talked about kind of
- 14:59comes in, especially when it comes to these shareholder
- 15:02board actions. And we'll talk more about romance
- 15:07when they're not a problem in the context of
- 15:08the FIHA. Next slide. So I think this is me,
- 15:14but Ellen, I just had a question. Do you? Does
- 15:17HR contact attorneys when they're talking to
- 15:20these executives about how to do this or is HR
- 15:22handling it on their own? We get contacted fairly
- 15:26frequently with these sorts of scenarios. And
- 15:29thankfully, at least the last couple of years,
- 15:31we've been contacted early on. We obviously will
- 15:34come in when the lawsuit happens, but we do provide
- 15:36counseling and HR is. Very, very, very. It seems
- 15:40like, at least with the more sophisticated companies
- 15:43with HR departments, it seems like that's something
- 15:46that's on the radar. Typically, if there is a
- 15:52disclosure, we'll typically get looped in. And
- 15:56you would prefer that to happen. You would prefer
- 15:57that HR contacts legal instead of trying to handle
- 16:00this on their own. It certainly helps us down
- 16:03the line if we have to defend a lawsuit. So we're
- 16:08going to talk about harassment and discrimination
- 16:09in California law and how some of these scenarios
- 16:12fit into our harassment. So we've got the FIHA,
- 16:17the Fair Employment and Housing Act, which basically
- 16:19provides the basic law. It's 12940, government
- 16:23code. So there's strict liability. If the person
- 16:27who's doing, as Ellen referred to, there's a
- 16:31disparity in power. The person who's doing the
- 16:34harassment is the supervisor. He's got the power
- 16:37over the person who he's harassing. So there
- 16:39really isn't. Consent. I don't think there could
- 16:42ever be consent if you got like the president
- 16:44of the company, you know, tell him having a relationship
- 16:47with a younger woman that he controls and that
- 16:50he can decide what to do. So that's Department
- 16:52of Health Services versus peer court. So supervisors
- 16:56are always strictly liable. Corporations liable.
- 16:59There's no escaping it. That's always the big
- 17:01fight in these cases. They're always going to
- 17:03be making a motion for summary judgment. They
- 17:06haven't been doing it anymore as much in harassment
- 17:09cases. But if they do, that's where they're going
- 17:12to focus. So when you're talking to your client
- 17:15for predeposition, you have to make sure you're
- 17:19talking about how this person had power to control
- 17:22what she did. Like he told her what to do during
- 17:25the day, any of the power to say whether or not
- 17:28she would get a raise. Maybe he was involved
- 17:30in her reviews to show this. imbalance of power,
- 17:35which is really what the strict liability is
- 17:38focused on. If I can interject, as a defense
- 17:42attorney, we counsel our clients and we look
- 17:45at it from a different perspective. Was this
- 17:46person truly a supervisor in a way that would
- 17:50trigger the strict liability standard? And if
- 17:52that person didn't necessarily control the material
- 17:54terms of this person's position, they didn't
- 17:56control scheduling, they didn't control hiring,
- 18:00firing. performance review, things like that,
- 18:03we look at all those things in order to see if
- 18:04we can establish this person was not in fact
- 18:06a supervisor in order to avoid that strict liability
- 18:09standard. But it is a major issue in all of these
- 18:12cases, whether or not the person was a supervisor
- 18:15as defined by the FIHA in order to determine
- 18:18whether or not strict liability applies. And
- 18:21that's why it's such a fight because you're either
- 18:22going to have the individual harasser on the
- 18:24hook or you're going to have the corporation
- 18:25on the hook. So if he's a supervisor, the corporation's
- 18:28on the hook. And in fact, Marion, you and I had
- 18:30a case with a similar issue against each other
- 18:32where we had that same argument. Yeah, so you
- 18:37need to talk to your clients about this on both
- 18:39sides. They need to know. It is a question of
- 18:41fact, eventually, for as long as you have facts
- 18:43on both sides for the jury to decide. And then
- 18:47there's the negligent standard. That's if you
- 18:49have coworkers and the company knows about it
- 18:53and they have to take immediate corrective action.
- 18:57So it's immediate and it has to be geared toward
- 19:00preventing further harassment. And that's Myers
- 19:02versus Trenwest. That's a little bit harder to
- 19:05prove, but if there is a pattern in the company,
- 19:08and sometimes there is, of harassers going after
- 19:13multiple women and using their power, to get
- 19:17them to go out with them and promising them that
- 19:19they'll, you know, give them better shifts or
- 19:22they'll give them a raise. That's the coworker
- 19:25harassment. That's the kind of he might not be
- 19:28the supervisor per se, but if he has a trend
- 19:31of doing this and other women are coming forward
- 19:33and the company isn't doing anything, then that's
- 19:36the negligence standard. And then personal liability,
- 19:42the harassers liable personally for the harassment.
- 19:46If we can get the strict liability or the negligence
- 19:49liability on the company, they're liable as well.
- 19:52But the individuals is liable for harassment,
- 19:54but they're not liable for discrimination. Only
- 19:56the company is liable for discrimination. So
- 19:59these are some of the cases that are out there.
- 20:02So there's two different kinds of harassment
- 20:05that you can prove. Quid pro quo is if the supervisor
- 20:08conditions benefits on going out with him or
- 20:13having a relationship with her, or if she the
- 20:17employee feels pressured to continue with a relationship
- 20:20to avoid negative consequences, to avoid being
- 20:24fired, to avoid. him reporting her, then that's
- 20:28quid pro quo sexual harassment. And then hostile
- 20:31work environment is quid pro quos pretty much
- 20:34it is you know it when you see it because there's
- 20:36either statements that say, hey, you know, if
- 20:39you sleep with me, I'll make you HR, head of
- 20:42HR. Or if you don't sleep with me, you're not
- 20:44gonna become head of HR. So that it's usually
- 20:46the words that you're looking at, but it can
- 20:48also be words and conduct. The law says if he
- 20:52is pressuring her both with words and conduct,
- 20:56bullying her, yelling at her, freezing her out,
- 20:59if she refuses to engage in his sexual harassment,
- 21:03sexual affair, excluding her. I've had cases
- 21:08where like she'll be sitting in a meeting and
- 21:09there'll be five people in the meeting and he'll
- 21:11talk to everybody except for her. He'll give
- 21:14assignments to everybody except for her. So it's
- 21:16conduct as well as statements. And then hostile
- 21:20work environment is that's where there's... It
- 21:25says widespread favoritism, rumors, or resentment
- 21:29among other employees. So the issue is whether
- 21:32it's severe or pervasive enough to alter the
- 21:35conditions of the employment and create an abusive
- 21:38environment. And the law has come very far and
- 21:43wonderfully in the direction of hostile work
- 21:46environment and what severe or pervasive means.
- 21:49So we have our Casey standard, which says that
- 21:53one incident is enough, is sufficiently severe
- 21:56or pervasive to constitute sexual harassment.
- 21:59And that's Casey 2524. And that comes from the
- 22:03recent government code enactments. It's recent.
- 22:05It's probably like a few years out there now.
- 22:08And that's government code 12923. And that's
- 22:11where the court really took a look at this hostile
- 22:14work environment. What do you need to prove the
- 22:18severe or pervasive? and how it affects the conditions
- 22:22and your environment. And it says, Government
- 22:25Code 12923B is what says, a single incident of
- 22:30harassing conduct is sufficient to create a triable
- 22:33issue regarding the existence of a hostile work
- 22:36environment if the harassing conduct has unreasonably
- 22:39interfered with a plaintiff's work performance.
- 22:41So that's why. And even the cases in Nazir, it's
- 22:45N -A -Z -I -R, says that hostile work environment
- 22:48cases should be a subject of a motion for summary
- 22:52judgment. So we're not seeing, thankfully, a
- 22:54lot of motions for summary judgment on these.
- 22:56And then it talks about what the workplace should
- 23:00be like. What is... going to tell us what's severe
- 23:04or hostile. And then government code 12923D says
- 23:08the legal standard for sexual harassment should
- 23:10not vary by the type of workplace. It is irrelevant
- 23:13that a particular occupation may have been characterized
- 23:16by a greater frequency of sexually related commentary
- 23:19or conduct in the past. Like there were cases
- 23:22about writers for friends or people that wrote
- 23:25for these sexually charged shows. And they said,
- 23:29well, we talk, we use that language all the time.
- 23:31So what is this person complaining about? Well,
- 23:33the statute says, no, you can't just hide in
- 23:36the midst of these jobs a person who's being
- 23:40sexually harassed. And it says, in determining
- 23:42whether or not a hostile work environment exists,
- 23:45courts should only consider the nature of the
- 23:47workplace when engaging in or witnessing prudent
- 23:51conduct and commentary is integral to the performance
- 23:54of the job duties. So they're basically saying,
- 23:58you only look at the workplace if what the the
- 24:01words that were being said, like in this script
- 24:03issue where they were using words for a script.
- 24:05OK, if it's a use for words for a script, that's
- 24:08integral to what they were doing. So that's not
- 24:10really harassment. But if you're talking about
- 24:13a script and then he's saying, hey, you know,
- 24:16her boobs are bigger than your boobs or they
- 24:18go further, then that's kind of where the line
- 24:20is drawn. That's why all of this is fact centered.
- 24:23And it's not really the subject of a motion for
- 24:26summer judgment. And then 12923, government code
- 24:30A, talks about what is hostile or offensive or
- 24:35oppressive, intimidating work environment. And
- 24:38it says it deprives the victims of their statutory
- 24:40right to work in a place free of discrimination
- 24:44when the harassing conduct sufficiently offends.
- 24:48humiliates, distresses, or intrudes upon its
- 24:50victims so as to disrupt the victim's emotional
- 24:53tranquility in the workplace, affect their ability
- 24:56to perform their job, or otherwise interferes
- 24:59and undermines with the victim's personal sense
- 25:02of well -being. So that's really, I try and tell
- 25:04people, like if you're going to work every day
- 25:07and you're driving to work and this guy Joe Schmo
- 25:09is driving next to you and you're being harassed.
- 25:12from the time you leave your house, you're having
- 25:14your pit at your stomach. Oh my God, I don't
- 25:16want to go to work. Like what's going to happen
- 25:18to me today? Is he going to say something to
- 25:19me? Am I going to be in trouble? And Joe Schmo,
- 25:22who's not having any sexual harassment has none
- 25:24of that. So it's kind of, you really, it's very
- 25:26fact specific and you have to delve into these
- 25:29facts with your clients and talk to them about
- 25:32how do you feel when you're driving into work?
- 25:35How does it feel? Sometimes they'll say, A lot
- 25:37of my corporations will move a person, they'll
- 25:40move the rest or put the move them like he's
- 25:42still in view of this lady. He walks by her every
- 25:43day. Oh, we moved them. But how does that make
- 25:46her feel? Does that when he's walking by, does
- 25:48that disrupt your ability to concentrate on your
- 25:50job? Are you afraid that he's going to do something
- 25:52to you? So those are all fact specific information
- 25:55that you have to bring out from your client when
- 25:58you're talking about a hostile work environment.
- 26:00OK, so let's go to the next one. Marianne, I
- 26:02have a quick question for you. In your practice.
- 26:04And specifically in the context of workplace
- 26:08romances, do you typically see more quid pro
- 26:13quo harassment claims come through or hostile
- 26:15work environment? Mine's much more hostile work
- 26:17environment. Like that's I think that's more
- 26:19because quid pro quo got everybody's pretty smart
- 26:22right now. You know, don't be saying bad things
- 26:24at work. So they're not really saying the language
- 26:27and it's. And again, that's easy. Those are great
- 26:31cases, and usually they settle pretty fast. So
- 26:34those aren't really litigated as much. The hostile
- 26:36work environment is the hotbed of, because there's
- 26:39these, is it a supervisor? Was it severe or pervasive?
- 26:43Those are the facts that really have to depend
- 26:47on what comes out in the case. So that's why
- 26:48I think I see a lot more hostile work environment.
- 26:51I think from my perspective, I think we're seeing
- 26:54a pretty good balance of both. Really? I'll promote
- 26:59you and then someone's upset about it. I think
- 27:02quid pro quo is a big one. I think that it's
- 27:06probably the same rate at hostile work environment.
- 27:08So it's interesting that you're seeing. more
- 27:10on your end of the hostile work environment.
- 27:12Yeah. Yeah, the quid pro quo, because they have
- 27:14to do their training, their supervisor training.
- 27:16They show the videos with these little scenarios.
- 27:18So I think they're getting a little bit more
- 27:21supervisors. At least they're getting a little
- 27:22more informed as to how to say things or how
- 27:26not to say things or how to make it look like
- 27:28it's not quid pro quo. So that's why I think
- 27:31that's where the fight is usually on the hostile
- 27:34work environment. So then another form of sexual
- 27:38harassment is sexual favoritism. And this kind
- 27:40of comes into what we're looking at with the
- 27:43Coldplay, the whole Coldplay incident. How many
- 27:45different lawsuits lie in that little scenario
- 27:48of the concert? So you got, of course, her suing
- 27:52him, the shareholder, because he's the big CEO
- 27:55and he, I guess, hired her. So he has control
- 27:57over her. That could be quid pro quo sexual harassment.
- 28:01Sexual favoritism could be all the other people
- 28:03that are in this working with these two people,
- 28:06if he's showing preferential treatment to his
- 28:10partner, then the other employees around have
- 28:13harassment claims, if it says if it's widespread
- 28:16or severe enough to impact the workplace. So
- 28:20this applies to men or women. Women can have
- 28:23complaints for sexual harassment based on hostile
- 28:26work environment, sexual favoritism, if the boss
- 28:30is favoring other women and promoting them over
- 28:34you. The case on that, there's Miller versus
- 28:37Department of Corrections that we have in there
- 28:39is like it's a good read, because it's got all
- 28:42different kinds of Like what was going on in
- 28:45this place is just crazy. Like the guy was the
- 28:46warden of a of a prison and he's having affairs
- 28:49with three different women at the same time.
- 28:52And then our lady Miller is seeing all this going
- 28:56on. He would she was up for a job with somebody
- 28:59else and he promoted the other person over her.
- 29:02She complained they didn't do anything about
- 29:04it. So and then all the women started fighting
- 29:07amongst themselves. And our ladies look has to
- 29:09deal with all this going on at the workplace,
- 29:11which that's what It is widespread because it
- 29:15was just, it happened, I think that went over
- 29:17like the course of two years, but that was a
- 29:19woman suing for sexual harassment, hostile work
- 29:21environment based on sexual favoritism when it
- 29:24was a man dating and using other women and basically
- 29:29promoting them over her. So, and Miller, it says
- 29:33that, it says even though, what they're looking
- 29:37at is that, Hostile work environment, it sends
- 29:41a demeaning message which is conveyed to female
- 29:44employees that they are imbued by management
- 29:46as sexual playthings or that the way required
- 29:49for women to get ahead in the workplace is to
- 29:51engage in sexual conduct with their supervisors
- 29:54or the management. So that's how they define
- 29:57the sexual favoritism. So that is a really good
- 30:00case if you have a hostile work environment,
- 30:02if you have a woman with other women who are
- 30:04being given preferential treatment over her.
- 30:08Men as well, men can do it. In that case, the
- 30:10Coldplay case, everybody who worked under that
- 30:13HR lady in HR and anybody who was up for promotion
- 30:18or didn't get a job because she got the job,
- 30:21they all have complaints. Then we've got retaliation.
- 30:27We're going to talk about, I think a little bit
- 30:28more with Ellen and morale issues. But a lot
- 30:31of times these claims all lead to retaliation.
- 30:35an employee ends a relationship and then she
- 30:39gets fired or her boss does something to her,
- 30:41then that's retaliation. Or if another employee
- 30:43complains about this going on in the workplace
- 30:46and then that employee gets either demoted or
- 30:48they get fired. And then as Ellen mentioned earlier,
- 30:51it undermines morale and productivity and fairness
- 30:55in the workplace. So that's basically the hostile
- 30:58work environment, like the sexual harassment
- 31:01part. We can go to the next one. So now the employer
- 31:08has a duty to take all reasonable steps to prevent
- 31:11harassment and to act promptly when it occurs.
- 31:15And this is particular in the context of office
- 31:18romance, as Alan was talking earlier, with the
- 31:20risk of harassment and favoritisms are heightened.
- 31:23So this is a great case Jones versus Donovan
- 31:26correction facility. And again, there's two duties
- 31:29to investigate and to take immediate actions
- 31:33to prevent further harassment. I think a lot
- 31:36of times we see an investigation occur and we
- 31:39always hear unsubstantiated because it's just
- 31:41the harasser versus the harassing and nothing's
- 31:44done. So the guy goes back out there. That I
- 31:47think is always right for us to argue that they
- 31:51should have done more. They should have talked
- 31:52to other witnesses. They should have done something
- 31:55to make sure this woman was protected, but it's
- 31:58kind of like once, to me, once an employer finds
- 32:01unsubstantiated in HR, they're like, okay, we're
- 32:04good. We got like our unsubstantiated stance
- 32:06that we can like go on with the case. What do
- 32:08you think, Ellen? Well, I think, again, it depends
- 32:10on what the policies are and how it's the investigations
- 32:14conducted. If you have a situation where HR is
- 32:18trained, a complaint is made, witnesses are interviewed,
- 32:21the... processes followed, and ultimately the
- 32:25result, you know, interviews are conducted, steps
- 32:27are taken, and ultimately the finding is unsubstantiated,
- 32:29the finding is unsubstantiated. And we're able
- 32:32to use that in our defense of these cases, like,
- 32:34hey, look, here's the person that, here's when
- 32:37the complaint was made, here's how it was investigated,
- 32:40here's the timeline, here's how we got to that
- 32:42finding. I think that, you know, you have what
- 32:45you have, but I do agree that there's times where
- 32:48that stamp is used of unsubstantiated, but it
- 32:50all comes down to what are the policies? How
- 32:53are these folks trained and how is the investigation
- 32:55conducted? I think that if all those underlying
- 32:59things are met, I think that that unsubstantiated
- 33:01stamp is warranted and it's the defense that
- 33:06employers can invoke to support its findings.
- 33:13That's where we that's again another area right
- 33:15for discovery when we're taking the cases if
- 33:18we want to get the investigation file, we want
- 33:21to see who they interviewed, you want to go through
- 33:23their policies and procedures are always great
- 33:25they've got these great. Because Ellen and all
- 33:28these great lawyers write them and say, we don't
- 33:30tolerate any sexual harassment. We have a zero
- 33:32tolerance policy. But then here we go with our
- 33:36lady and that's harassment. And why are you tolerating
- 33:40that? Like, why aren't you taking any action
- 33:42against this guy? So it's a huge, huge issue
- 33:46in discovery. And that's why I agree with you
- 33:48in that summary judgments in these kinds of cases
- 33:51are tough because it's very very factual, and
- 33:54there's always a plethora of disputes. So I think
- 33:58that it really comes down to those small details.
- 34:01Who was interviewed? When were they interviewed?
- 34:03Who made the complaint? When did they make the
- 34:04complaint? Who investigated it? How was it investigated?
- 34:08And the documentation, it comes down to documentation.
- 34:13On our side, it's the Department of Health versus
- 34:15Superior Court, 31 Cal 4, 1026, that talks about
- 34:19looking at if there's an investigation, and let's
- 34:23say they say it's not substantiated, but then
- 34:25the person gets retaliated against. They either
- 34:27get demoted or they get terminated. Then that
- 34:29case says that if that is what's taking place,
- 34:33future victims will have a strong argument that
- 34:35the policy and the grievance procedure did not
- 34:38provide a reasonable avenue for the complaint.
- 34:42at that point, like, okay, maybe you did an investigation,
- 34:45but then this person got retaliated against anyway.
- 34:48So your policies are not providing the protection
- 34:51that they should be providing. And then, so I
- 34:57think this is more where employers are permitted
- 35:00to regulate workplace relationships for legitimate
- 35:02business reasons, such as supervision, safety,
- 35:05security, or morale. I think. I don't know Ellen,
- 35:08do you ever get arguments from people that want
- 35:10to have a relationship that you're not allowed
- 35:11to tell them what to do? No. I couldn't imagine
- 35:15that happening. By the time they get to us, we're
- 35:16not there anymore. We're past that. So you're
- 35:21allowed to have anti -fratenization policies.
- 35:24You're allowed to require employees to disclose
- 35:26romantic relationships for management so that
- 35:30the employer can take steps to manage the complex.
- 35:32You're all allowed to do that. Let's go to the
- 35:35next slide, because this one I have, this was
- 35:36Ellen's, which I've never heard of before, love
- 35:38contracts. I wanted to hear all about love contracts.
- 35:40I'm like, I've never heard of that before. So
- 35:42can you tell us about love contracts and do they
- 35:44exist? With these love contracts, we're actually
- 35:46seeing them a lot less now. Basically, it's an
- 35:49agreement that both parties acknowledge that
- 35:52they're in a romantic relationship. acknowledge
- 35:55that the relationship's consensual, they reviewed
- 35:58the anti -harassment policies, they agreed to
- 36:01report any future concerns or issues, and this
- 36:04can be used by lawyers to protect themselves
- 36:08if the relationship later ends and they say,
- 36:10you know, I'm being sexually harassed, this person
- 36:13was forcing me into a relationship, I didn't
- 36:15consent. But at the same time, if you have a
- 36:18situation where one of the parties to the employment
- 36:21contract is a supervisor or the love contract,
- 36:23excuse me, then really you've got an imbalance
- 36:27of power and how voluntary was that contract
- 36:31for the subordinate. So, you know, we're seeing
- 36:34them less and less. Some companies are implementing
- 36:36them. I think if done correctly, it could serve
- 36:39as, you know, based for defense, for employer
- 36:42for sexual harassment claim. But I I get nervous
- 36:45about them because again, it comes down to the
- 36:48facts and who is involved in the contract, how
- 36:52was the contract presented, things like that.
- 36:54I think what it really comes down to is training,
- 36:58documentation, communication, and including something
- 37:02in that contract or just making it well -known
- 37:05that if there's an issue, if things have changed,
- 37:09if there's a problem, doors open and but there
- 37:13have to be multiple channels to discuss those
- 37:15issues and address those issues. But I think
- 37:18love contracts are iffy, at least for me, I think
- 37:21that if done right, it could be successful, but
- 37:24there's a lot of issues that can go along with
- 37:26it. What if they, let's say it's a relationship
- 37:29and then one person says, I don't want to sign
- 37:31the contract. Do they have to sign a contract
- 37:34in order to proceed with the relationship? You
- 37:36don't have to sign the contract. Again, but it's
- 37:38all situational. I don't think you have to sign
- 37:40the contract to proceed with the relationship,
- 37:42but one, it depends on what the company's policies
- 37:44are. Two, who are the people involved? Are they
- 37:47two coworkers? Do we have a supervisor? Again,
- 37:50I think it's very, very situational and I think
- 37:52that's why some of these love contracts or these
- 37:55consensual relationship agreements, I don't know
- 37:57how useful they are in a lot of scenarios. I
- 38:01can't see it. For example, this astronomer scenario
- 38:04with the CEO and the HR person, they could have
- 38:06had a love contract, but in reality, you've got
- 38:09the CEO and the head of HR and had a big problem
- 38:12here regardless of whether or not they say it's
- 38:14consensual. So I'm iffy on them. Have you ever
- 38:21heard of anyone using a love contract as a defense
- 38:23where a sexual harassment case was brought? I
- 38:25have. I have in that they disclosed it, but This
- 38:29was a situation where, first of all, it was a
- 38:31couple of years ago. I haven't seen one for a
- 38:33while. But in this situation, it was two co -workers.
- 38:37They were in different departments. They were
- 38:39both executive level employees, but they didn't
- 38:43work directly together. And in this case, they
- 38:47disclosed it very early on. They signed this
- 38:49contract, obviously, because it came to me things
- 38:53that ended badly. And one of the parties to the
- 38:58love contract was not happy and super sexual
- 39:01harassment, but we were able to rely on that
- 39:04love contract in that instance because they disclosed
- 39:07it early on. There was a lot of communication.
- 39:12They had the same power at the company and they
- 39:15didn't work directly together. Interesting. But
- 39:19I haven't seen one for a while. How about you?
- 39:23Have you had one of any of your cases? I've never
- 39:25heard of it before. That's why I'm like, I never
- 39:26heard of this love contract thing. Like I never
- 39:28heard of anyone even like a company even offering
- 39:30it to any of my clients. And then so I think
- 39:36training and communication is that's what Ellen's
- 39:39talking about from the company side is making
- 39:41sure that you have the anti -harassment policies
- 39:43and talking to them and making sure that the
- 39:46employees understand the procedures for reporting
- 39:50if they have concerns. And again, for us from
- 39:54the plaintiff's side, that's information that
- 39:55we want to get in discovery. We want to see what
- 39:58their anti -harassment policies say. We want
- 40:00to see how they ensure that the employees know
- 40:04where to report because sometimes it's not as
- 40:05clear or who to report to. They're afraid because
- 40:08the person harassing them is a supervisor and
- 40:11usually the policy says report to your supervisor.
- 40:14But I know policies have been updated and now
- 40:16they're saying report to your supervisor unless
- 40:18he's the person. that's doing the harassment,
- 40:20then report to the person above him. But still,
- 40:24for a lot of my employees are like factory worker
- 40:26women, they're not gonna go above their boss's
- 40:29head to report him. So that's always an issue
- 40:32that we have. Can we do the next slide? Scenarios.
- 40:40I think these are, Ellen, since they're yours,
- 40:41we can talk about these together. Sure. I mean,
- 40:44these are just some of the scenarios that you
- 40:46come across in these sorts of cases. The supervisor,
- 40:49the days of subordinate, there's a breakup, denied
- 40:52a promotion, retaliation. That's where you get
- 40:55a lawsuit. Favoritism amongst teammates. team
- 40:58members. You've got the rumors where things end
- 41:01badly. You've got people spreading rumors about
- 41:04one another, the affected employee files a harassment
- 41:06complaint. You've got the unwelcome advances.
- 41:09These are all just some common scenarios that
- 41:10you see frequently in these kinds of cases. But
- 41:13at the end of the day, I think that policies
- 41:15and communication and that open door and having
- 41:17different channels of making complaints and communicating
- 41:20those things is kind of what we look at. Because
- 41:24ultimately, if you've got policies that address
- 41:27these sorts of scenarios to the best ability.
- 41:30I think that's where these can be curtailed,
- 41:32but this is what you would typically see. Next
- 41:36slide. And then the contentual relationship starting
- 41:39out and then turning sour, I think is a big,
- 41:42that's what the supervisor, that leads, that
- 41:45can lead to quid pro quo complaints where everything
- 41:48starts out good. Maybe they even have a love
- 41:50contract and then things turn bad and they break
- 41:53up. And I think that's like, I don't know how
- 41:58that would work. If you went to your HR and said,
- 42:02hey, I broke up with this guy, he's my supervisor,
- 42:04can you protect me? Would HR take proactive steps
- 42:07to make sure that you're not getting... harassed
- 42:10or retaliated against and normally that doesn't
- 42:12happen normally the you know the person who is
- 42:14broken up with and the supervisor the person
- 42:16who's broken up with is too embarrassed to say
- 42:18anything to anybody and then having to spend
- 42:20time with the supervisor and i think it's just
- 42:23i don't know how you can get around the person
- 42:26who is the person who's broken up with, let's
- 42:29say the supervisor man, taking action against
- 42:33the woman who rejected him in however ways that
- 42:37it is subtle, not so subtle, but just trying
- 42:41to get her away from him. So that's, I think,
- 42:44why what we're talking about is these relationships
- 42:46are so ripe for litigation, even if it's consensual,
- 42:50even if it strikes out consensual. My point always
- 42:53is, is it really consensual when you have a supervisor
- 42:56with a high person in power and somebody who
- 42:58doesn't have a lot of power in the company? I
- 43:00don't think those are truly, truly consensual
- 43:02because I think the person who, we have single
- 43:05moms, this is their job, they can't afford it.
- 43:07And that's the people that they target. They
- 43:10can't afford to lose their job. So these guys
- 43:12are like, okay, you know, you have to do this
- 43:13for me and I'll promote you. So that's always,
- 43:17whether that is truly consensual or not is a
- 43:19big fight. Again, factual issues and you have
- 43:22to delve out the facts with your client and talk
- 43:24to them about why did they do this, even if the
- 43:27supervisor saying it's consensual. One of the
- 43:30things that always gets us on these is the text
- 43:34messages, the text messages back and forth. can
- 43:37be, it varies. Sometimes I'd get ones where the
- 43:41guy's sending her, send me a picture of yourself,
- 43:44and then she would say, ha ha, or she would put,
- 43:47smiley face emojis were the biggest things. Whether
- 43:49a smiley face emoji is consent or not was a huge...
- 43:53to dispute when these first came out. Look, she's
- 43:56sending a smiley face. She obviously consents
- 43:58to what he's saying to her. She didn't have to
- 44:00respond at all because she could have said, I'm
- 44:03offended. Well, who's going to text that? Nobody's
- 44:04going to text it. A smiley face is just a vanilla
- 44:08way to respond without rebuffing him. That, again,
- 44:12comes through with your client. Why did you send
- 44:14a smiley face emoji? The ones with the kiss,
- 44:17the smile with a kiss. That was like the next
- 44:18level up. OK, it's not just a smile, it's a kiss.
- 44:21So all this stuff comes into consensual versus
- 44:25non -consensual. Is it truly consensual? And
- 44:28it's a lot of discovery. So always get your client's
- 44:31phone. Make sure you look at all the text messages
- 44:34and see what's going on. Instagram, there might
- 44:36be pictures out there of her and the supervisor
- 44:38at lunch or dinner. He's got his arm around her.
- 44:41He's like, look. we were at lunch and it was
- 44:44consensual. And she's like, what was I supposed
- 44:45to do? Like, am I supposed to punch him in the
- 44:47head and say, hey, don't touch me? So that's
- 44:50all, again, facts that you have to gather early
- 44:52on to see how strong the issue of consent or
- 44:56non -consent is. And it's messy. It's time consuming
- 44:59and it's very, very, very messy. And it's emotional.
- 45:02And the people involved have a lot of hurt feelings.
- 45:05And it's probably the toughest cases that I handle
- 45:09because it's so, so personally messy for the
- 45:12people involved. People are hurt. People, you
- 45:15know, sometimes are embarrassed. There's different
- 45:17things that come out. And I think that because
- 45:19of that, a lot of folks are hesitant to really
- 45:22come forward about it one way or the other. And
- 45:24that's where it gets more complicated with HR
- 45:26and when did HR know and when did they investigate.
- 45:29But I think these are some of the toughest cases
- 45:31out there because it is so personal. Next slide.
- 45:39And this is what we just spoke about. If the
- 45:42relationship ends badly, folks get upset. You
- 45:45have to figure out how you're going to separate
- 45:47them, what you're going to do, whether or not
- 45:50retaliation kicks in, whether or not there was
- 45:52harassment. And really what the employers, what
- 45:55I always counsel employers do is have clear policies,
- 45:58take prompt action, document, help mitigate the
- 46:01risk. Because at the end of the day, As an employer,
- 46:04you may not have access to the text messages,
- 46:06you may not have access to these people's Instagrams,
- 46:08but what you do have access to is company resources
- 46:11and the ability to investigate, to look into
- 46:14it, to implement policies and have that open
- 46:17channel of communications. Next slide. And we've
- 46:23touched on this over and over and over again,
- 46:24but really the supervisor -subordinate relationship,
- 46:27that's the hotbed of legal activity when it comes
- 46:30to sexual harassment, at least in California.
- 46:33I know that Marianne agrees with me. This is
- 46:36something that we're constantly addressing with
- 46:38respect to these kinds of claims. This is where
- 46:41legal risk really, really skyrockets. For example,
- 46:44again, a supervisor starts stating a direct report,
- 46:47later approves a promotion. Another employee
- 46:49alleges favoritism. So the direct report isn't
- 46:53the one actually making the claim. Now you've
- 46:55got others that are saying, well, I should have
- 46:57gotten that promotion. I was more qualified.
- 47:00Why not me? You've got a problem there. The breakup
- 47:03scenario. Now you've got, hey, you broke up with
- 47:06me. What are we going to do here? I'm getting
- 47:08less desirable duties. And again, this is where
- 47:11disclosure is key. These love contracts we talked
- 47:14about, I don't know. Some folks use them. It
- 47:18was probably more prevalent. several years ago,
- 47:21not as prevalent now, but one of the things that
- 47:25we recommend or, you know, like these One, what
- 47:29is HR doing about it? Two, what is the training
- 47:32and what steps are being taken? Sometimes it's
- 47:34not a matter of determining someone, it's a matter
- 47:36of separating them. But is that separation actually
- 47:38meaningful? Are they still working in the same
- 47:41area? Are they still walking by each other every
- 47:44day? Are they still sharing break room? Are they
- 47:46still parking their cars next to each other?
- 47:48So it's very, very fact specific. Next slide.
- 47:53So the key takeaways are this is the most legally
- 47:56risky kind of scenario where you've got that
- 47:59power imbalance, even if that relationship starts
- 48:01out as consensual. I think that I view it a little
- 48:04bit differently. I think there could be scenarios
- 48:06where it is consensual. I've seen scenarios where
- 48:08it's truly consensual, but it's very fact specific
- 48:11and it's tough. You have to really look at very,
- 48:14you have to look at everything. You have to look
- 48:16at job duties. You have to look at the people
- 48:19involved. You have to look at the personal text
- 48:21messages, emails. And it's a lot. So again, like
- 48:28with the executive level employees, early disclosure,
- 48:33keeping that channel communication open, ensuring
- 48:36that lines aren't being blurred at work with
- 48:39respect to benefits, duties, motions, things
- 48:42like that. That's where it's key. And we always
- 48:46counsel our clients. Upgrade your policies, make
- 48:48sure you're training managers to recognize risks
- 48:51associated with these imbalanced relationships.
- 48:53Whether you're the manager in the relationship
- 48:55or not, you need to know what to look out for
- 48:58because it could really cause a lot of issues.
- 49:03And Ellen, Gabrielle has a question regarding
- 49:05these love contracts or the agreements of disclosure.
- 49:09How do you handle confidentiality if you have
- 49:11two married couples, they're married to somebody
- 49:13else? Well, married to someone else as in? Like
- 49:18each person is married to somebody and they're
- 49:20coming to you and you know that they're married.
- 49:22They're like, we were going to have a relationship
- 49:23within the company and you're going to have to
- 49:25have them sign off on having extra marital relationships.
- 49:29I personally haven't seen a contract like that.
- 49:32As I said, I haven't seen them in a while. But
- 49:33what I would say is this, it's not the company's
- 49:37job to regulate the marriages of these people.
- 49:39Right? So what you're looking at is what is happening
- 49:42at work and how is it affecting the workplace?
- 49:45So for me, I think it would be, it wouldn't go
- 49:48to, are you married? Are you married? Because
- 49:49we're not, you know, that's not really within
- 49:51the scope of the workplace environment unless
- 49:54the two other individuals are also working there.
- 49:56And then you've got a whole other slew of problems.
- 49:59But I think that it would be a disclosure of
- 50:02a relationship between two people that are working
- 50:03together. So it wouldn't go to, you know, I'm
- 50:07married and she's married or he's married, whatever.
- 50:09It would be, I'm having a relationship with this
- 50:12person. I'm disclosing it to HR. But I wonder
- 50:17if it during a divorce, if they could ask the
- 50:19company for any disclosure relationships, they
- 50:21could find out when the relationship started.
- 50:23That would be good for the divorce, for the divorce
- 50:26case. Yeah. Let's go to our next slide. Off duty
- 50:29conduct. So off duty conduct is still. harassment.
- 50:34I think one of the cases is a guy was at home
- 50:37and he sent a picture of his down there to a
- 50:41woman and she was at home. He was at home. That's
- 50:45still considered harassment. The boss making
- 50:48you go to a party after hours and then making
- 50:52you drink too much and then going after the woman.
- 50:56That happens a lot. That's still harassment covered
- 50:58under the protections. So it says after Our romance
- 51:03turns sour. Two coworkers date outside of work.
- 51:06After a breakup, one starts sending harassing
- 51:08text and posting negative comments on social
- 51:10media. The other feels uncomfortable at work
- 51:12and files a complaint. Yes, the boss, the company
- 51:15should step in and talk to that person because...
- 51:18She's saying that I feel uncomfortable at work.
- 51:21It's affecting me at work, even though he might
- 51:23be sending them after hours at two o 'clock in
- 51:25the morning. She still has to be with that person
- 51:27and see him all the time. It's kind of like the
- 51:30Coldplay thing. Again, that was an after hours
- 51:32event that these two were at. The employees that
- 51:35were there can claim that that was offensive
- 51:38to them. And then it affected their work environment
- 51:40when they had to go back. And she's getting all
- 51:42these extra promotions and she's coming down
- 51:46on them for things that she's doing with the
- 51:48boss. There's such such good like facts and everything
- 51:52that that evolves around that case. Party fallout
- 51:56employees attend a weekend party where romantic
- 51:59romantic relationship becomes public rumors and
- 52:01gossip follow leading to workplace distractions
- 52:04and complaints of favoritism. Online interactions,
- 52:08that's where they're sending text messages and
- 52:11all kinds of things after hours. Some they share
- 52:14with other people, creating an embarrassment
- 52:17in a hostile work environment. So those are all
- 52:20kind of things that off duty, it bleeds into
- 52:25the... work environment. So that's the key is,
- 52:29is it making this employee feel during the work
- 52:32hours that it's impacting her ability to work?
- 52:35Are people spreading rumors about her and something
- 52:38that happened at a party? Are people spreading
- 52:40rumors about him giving her favoritism? All those
- 52:45kinds of things can lead to, again, a hostile
- 52:48work environment, and they are still actionable.
- 52:51I will say that Every year around January, we
- 52:55get a slew of calls and inquiries and issues
- 52:59brought to us relating to holiday parties. Christmas
- 53:01parties. Every year we know January is going
- 53:06to be all. And it's something that it's prevalent.
- 53:10You've got the open bar. You've got people socializing
- 53:13together. But more and more. More than that,
- 53:15we're seeing the online interactions, online
- 53:18interactions bleeding into work. And I think
- 53:20that's becoming more and more prominent as people
- 53:22are, they're online, a lot of them are working
- 53:24remotely and that's how they're communicating
- 53:26with one another. So we're seeing a lot more
- 53:28of that. And that's why there's new training
- 53:32kind of policies being put in place, specifically
- 53:35dealing with online interactions at work and
- 53:38outside of work. Let's go to the next one. Oh,
- 53:44we've already got, so we can go to the next on
- 53:46retaliation. All right. So retaliation, I see
- 53:49that we're kind of short on time. We're almost
- 53:52out of time here, but retaliation can be as serious
- 53:56as the original misconduct, as Mary Ann had said,
- 53:59and it's strictly prohibited, obviously under
- 54:01the fee hub. For example, if an employee reports
- 54:05a supervisor's inappropriate relationship with
- 54:07someone else and then is excluded from meetings,
- 54:10that's a form of retaliation. It doesn't have
- 54:12to be the person in the relationship making a
- 54:14complaint. Retaliation can include things like
- 54:17demotions, exclusion from events, undesirable
- 54:20assignments, but it could also be these subtle
- 54:22things like not ignoring them, not speaking with
- 54:26them. not inviting them to sit together for an
- 54:30outside lunch, things like that. It could be
- 54:32subtle. It could be obvious. It could be very,
- 54:34very subtle. And employers obviously have an
- 54:38obligation to protect their employees from retaliation
- 54:41under these circumstances. If someone brings
- 54:42a complaint, then the employer now has a duty
- 54:45not only to address that complaint whichever
- 54:48way is appropriate under the circumstance, but
- 54:50also ensure that that employee is not being retaliated
- 54:52against. Next slide. And again, as I mentioned,
- 54:58retaliation can be as serious as their original
- 54:59misconduct. And this could result in significant
- 55:03liability for employers, because even if they
- 55:05don't find there to be underlying wrongdoing,
- 55:08if that person brings a good faith complaint
- 55:10and is later retaliated against, there's a whole
- 55:13different cause of action for that conduct. So
- 55:18the employer needs to make sure that there's
- 55:20open reporting, that employees know that they
- 55:23can come with any issues. And retaliation won't
- 55:26be tolerated. And also documentation, always
- 55:30documentation, policies and documentation. And
- 55:33I think for us, from the plaintiff's side, the
- 55:35most important thing is retaliation isn't just
- 55:37termination. It's not just the final act. And
- 55:40like Alan was saying, and we've got samples in
- 55:42here, excluding people from meetings. prohibiting
- 55:46them from applying for other positions, turning
- 55:49them down for promotions. They'll come up with
- 55:51all these other reasons justifying why they did
- 55:54these things, but the court looks at the timing.
- 55:57Did you make a complaint? And then within a time
- 55:59period, and it can be up to a year, because it
- 56:01can be longer than a year, but if you have a
- 56:03great track record of work and then all of a
- 56:06sudden you make complaints and then you're all
- 56:08of a sudden the worst person, you're getting
- 56:09written up, you're not being invited to meetings,
- 56:12you're being denied promotions, those are the
- 56:15strong factual allegations that you look to for
- 56:18retaliation before the termination happens. Sometimes
- 56:21we might have cases where we're suing in the
- 56:23middle for sexual harassment case and then they
- 56:25fire the person. So you have to make sure that
- 56:27you add in your claim for retaliation for the
- 56:30termination as well and file your DFEH and make
- 56:34sure that's included because it can snowball
- 56:37even during in the middle of litigation, both
- 56:39for witnesses and for victims of harassment.
- 56:43And even though it could be so, I just want to
- 56:45add, we've seen scenarios where someone will
- 56:48say something like, well, I made a complaint
- 56:50and then they didn't save me the onion bagel
- 56:52for bagel day. And it's because I made a complaint.
- 56:56It's factual, but there's also things that the
- 57:01complainer can identify that's not necessarily
- 57:04tethered to retaliation. So it becomes a very,
- 57:07very, very fact -specific Inquiry, which again,
- 57:11it makes it difficult to really parse out. I
- 57:14think like the sexual harassment claims themselves,
- 57:18was there an adverse action taken? Did something
- 57:21happen to you? Because that complaint, I think
- 57:22it becomes, it's difficult in certain circumstances
- 57:26when it's not as obvious with the demotion or
- 57:28the write up or the termination. I think the
- 57:32other important point that Ellen made was even
- 57:34you don't have to prove the underlying. action.
- 57:36You'd have to prove that this was sexual harassment.
- 57:39You don't have to prove that this was hostile
- 57:40work environment. You just have to prove that
- 57:41you had a reasonable belief that something was
- 57:44going on. And if it turns out that it wasn't,
- 57:46you still can't be retaliated for making the
- 57:49complaint. You're still protected. Next slide.
- 57:53Now, again, we've touched on this before. Not
- 57:55every romantic relationship at work is you know,
- 57:59a violation, it's not something that can lead
- 58:01to a lawsuit. For example, if you've got peers
- 58:03in different departments with no power imbalance,
- 58:05the legal risk is very limited. But again, you're
- 58:08looking for transparency, you're looking for
- 58:12policies in place to ensure that if there is
- 58:14a conflict, if there is an issue, there's someone
- 58:16to talk to. I think what Ellen was talking about
- 58:20from an employer standpoint is beefing up your
- 58:23employee manuals and your policies for electronic.
- 58:26How do you guys do that? How do you monitor their
- 58:28off -duty electronic text and Instagrams and
- 58:31stuff like that? You can't monitor those, but
- 58:34you can have policies, for example, for a certain
- 58:37conduct of duty on social media that may impact
- 58:40really on the company. There's different things
- 58:43that you can do, but obviously you're not going
- 58:44to be monitoring people's email or personal emails,
- 58:48personal text messages, but you can have policies
- 58:49in place, say, prohibiting certain conduct outside
- 58:53of work. When you guys do investigations, do
- 58:55you always tell HR people to get their text messages
- 58:58and their social media during the investigation?
- 59:00Cause that usually tells sometimes a different
- 59:03story than what anybody's saying. It depends.
- 59:08I always want to know. I would always say, I
- 59:12always want to see what's on there. Cause it,
- 59:14it, you could see so many different things and
- 59:15what somebody's telling you face to face. So
- 59:19I think we're almost out of time, right? One
- 59:22minute. So, um, if you guys would like, we can
- 59:26keep going through the slides. Or would you end
- 59:30here? I think we're pretty much we we touched
- 59:34on everything that we need, I think. Is there
- 59:36anything else? I think we just kind of go to
- 59:38the key takeaways and you'll be getting the materials
- 59:42which have everything that we've discussed. There's.
- 59:45information in there about potential defenses,
- 59:48for example, pre -existing relationships, they're
- 59:51not necessarily problematic. If an employer took
- 59:53care to prevent and probably correct the harassment
- 59:56and the employer recently failed to use the complaint
- 59:58procedure, that could be a defense. But it really
- 1:00:01comes down to the facts, the policies, the training,
- 1:00:04and the people involved. Can we skip to key takeaways?
- 1:00:09Marianne, is that okay? Yeah, absolutely. Again,
- 1:00:14while these relationships aren't necessarily
- 1:00:16unlawful in theory, they can create significant,
- 1:00:20significant risks for the company, especially
- 1:00:22when you've got a supervisor -supporting kind
- 1:00:24of relationship. Disclosure policies and prompt
- 1:00:28actions, really kind of what we look at on our
- 1:00:31end. Mary Ann, what are your thoughts? I think
- 1:00:35from the plaintiff's point of view, the consensual
- 1:00:38relationships is important. Because a lot of
- 1:00:40times, someone will come to you and they'll be
- 1:00:42like, yes, I was dating my boss, but then things
- 1:00:44turn bad. And you think, oh, consensual relationship,
- 1:00:47once it starts, it's always consensual. But now
- 1:00:50you just have to track and be specific about
- 1:00:51the point when it became non -consensual, either
- 1:00:54when she said no and he didn't listen or when
- 1:00:57he retaliated against her when she rebuffed his
- 1:01:00advances. And again, don't just focus on ultimate
- 1:01:04termination, retaliation can be in actions and
- 1:01:07words and the way that he yells at her or screams
- 1:01:10at her. All those things are facts you want to
- 1:01:12gather that say that even consensual relationships
- 1:01:15running out can turn into either quid pro quo
- 1:01:20or hostile work environment and retaliation.
- 1:01:25Thank you. Thank you, everybody. Thanks, the
- 1:01:28island. It was so much fun to see you.