Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Joffrey Baratheon (Game of Thrones)(2014 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:00So let me ask you a question. Who's the most hated villain of all
- 0:04time? Who's the most hated villain and TV and books and movies and in
- 0:11history? Who's the most hated villain of all time? Is it Darth Vader?
- 0:17Is it Malfoy, Sylar of Heroes? If remember him? Kahn of
- 0:22Star Trek, Voldemort, Saarn Newman? Is it Newman? Is it Biff
- 0:29from Back to the Future. Oh, that's Sanse from Karate Kid from the
- 0:34original Karate Kid? Remember him Kubla Kai or something? Is it Skeletor is
- 0:40it Agent Smith from The Matrix? Well, I challenge you to come up
- 0:46with a more hated villain than the following character. It's Jeoffrey Barathian of Game
- 0:55of Thrones or the book series A Song of Ice and Fire. I don't
- 0:58know of any other villain that has hated more than Jeoffrey Barrathian. And if
- 1:03you're a fan of the books or the series, you will know fully well
- 1:07what I'm talking about. No one compares to him. Darth Vader, you
- 1:11can have some sympathy for. Eventually Malfoy, same sort of thing. Even
- 1:15Syler you have some sympathy for, you know, Saurron is horrible, but
- 1:22he isn't horrible in a hundred different ways the way that Jeoffrey Barrathian is.
- 1:27So I've been asking around preparing for this episode, and everyone says, when
- 1:33I say, you know, you know, is there any worse villain than
- 1:37Jeoffrey Barrathian? And no one can seem to come up with someone worse than
- 1:41him, unless they've never read the books or watched the show, and then
- 1:45in which case they say, what are you talking about, nerd. And
- 1:49it's interesting too, because if you're a history buff like me, you'll see
- 1:53many parallels between him and many infamous rulers throughout history. There are multiple figures
- 2:00in history that rise to the horribleness that is Jeoffrey Barrathian and even surpass it.
- 2:09So it's interesting to contemplate that a person like this actually did rule kingdoms
- 2:19and lands. So as a thought exercise for this podcast, I imagined what
- 2:24it would be like if Jeoffrey were a client of mine, you know what,
- 2:29what would be my assessment? So in this episode, I'll present my
- 2:32psychological assessment of King Jeoffrey. I'll provide background and analysis and that sort of
- 2:38stuff. So there will be spoilers, and if you're a fan, then
- 2:43this might be fun for you, And if you're not, then I have
- 2:46no idea if this will be fun for you. But here we go.
- 2:50So, Prince Jeffrey Barrathian, as he starts off when the series begins,
- 2:57is the eldest son and heir of King Robert Barrathian and Queen Circe Lanister.
- 3:02So he's the oldest. He's the oldest child. He has two younger siblings,
- 3:07Princess Marcella and Prince Tolman. He's twelve years old at the beginning of
- 3:13the book series. Some of you might be surprised by that, but that's
- 3:17the situation. He's twelve when the books start, and incidentally, he dies
- 3:23when he's thirteen. Again spoiler alert there. But you know, the entire
- 3:28span of what we know of him occurs from the ages of twelve and thirteen.
- 3:34So just something to think about, because I think a lot of times
- 3:37people think of him as being like seventeen or something, but he's really quite
- 3:40young. He's described in the books as having the quote unquote Lanister. Look,
- 3:46he's tall for his age, he's handsome. In the books, he's
- 3:51described as much more handsome than the character on the TV series, so it's
- 3:59just something to think about as well. He has blonde, curly hair,
- 4:03and he has green eyes, and he is said to have pouty lips,
- 4:09and he always wears the finest clothing, as many Lanisters do. All right,
- 4:14So that's just a brief description of him. What do we know about
- 4:16his childhood? Well, Jeoffrey was spoiled by his parents, particularly his mother.
- 4:23Being the heir to the throne. He was treated like a god since
- 4:27birth. It's something to think about. It's a different sort of society.
- 4:31The society of WESTUS is different. I guess it'd be like if you were
- 4:38the president's child or if you were Branjelina's child. You get treated differently than
- 4:45other children get treated, and he was treated that way. His father,
- 4:50King Robert, was deeply disappointed with Jeoffrey, and Jeoffrey probably knew this.
- 4:57In fact, it's pretty much for sure that he knew this and was not
- 5:00happy about that and was hurt by that. The King felt little affection for
- 5:05Jeoffrey and showed signs of even hating him. So imagine you're a young boy
- 5:13and you know that your father hates you. That's quite a blow to your
- 5:18self esteem and your self worth and self concept. Jeffrey in the books,
- 5:25he craved his father's respect and approval. For example, once, after learning
- 5:30a kitchen cat was pregnant, he killed the animal and cut open its belly
- 5:35to see the kittens inside. Quite shocking, he brought one of the unborn
- 5:41kittens to his father and King Joffrey. His father was so shocked and so
- 5:46upset that he hit Jeoffrey in the face so hard that it knocked two of
- 5:53his teeth out, two of his baby teeth out. He was young,
- 5:56and so there were multiple kind of stories like this, indicating that Jeoffrey didn't
- 6:01always know how to please his father and would frequently mess things up, and
- 6:08that the father would abuse him physically or verbally or emotionally. And Queen Circe,
- 6:15Jeoffrey's mother, said in the books that her husband, Geoffrey's father would
- 6:21have beaten Jeoffrey if she hadn't stopped it. So that's what Jeoffrey's childhood was
- 6:28like. Jeoffrey reportedly bullied his younger brother Toman. He drank a lot of
- 6:34wine, as many children apparently did back then. In Westros, which is
- 6:40just another thing to note. Okay, So this brings me to the beginning
- 6:46of the book series, and there's one story that I think depicts his character.
- 6:53So, Jeoffrey was writing with Sansa, Sansa Stark, and he was
- 6:59drinking wine and getting drunk and Jeoffrey, Geoffrey was trying to impress Sansa,
- 7:05being a young twelve year old. And I think at this point Geoffrey and
- 7:09Sansa were betrothed to get married and so and Sanso was enamored with Geoffrey and
- 7:17Jeoffrey and Sansa came upon Santa's younger sister, Aria and Aria's friend Micah,
- 7:24whom is a butcher's boy, and Aria and Micah, the young girl and
- 7:29the young boy are practicing sword fighting with wooden sticks and Jeoffrey, Prince Joffrey
- 7:36is drunk and commands Micah, the butcher's boy, to spar with him.
- 7:42Presumably he wanted to show off to Sansa and maybe even Aria. And he
- 7:48sees himself as a as a warrior, you know, he thinks of himself
- 7:53as a as a powerful warrior. I'm guessing because whenever he would spar with
- 8:00the guards that they would always let him win because you let the heir to
- 8:03the throne win, because you don't want the air to throne disliking you.
- 8:07So Jeoffrey challenges Micah the butcher's boy to spar with him. The butcher's boy
- 8:13refuses because he knows it will be bad for him and he's terrified of Prince
- 8:20Jeoffrey. Geoffrey bullies Micah with his own sword, which is called Lion's tooth.
- 8:24You know, it's an actual sword against a stick, and you know,
- 8:28again he's presumably doing this to impress Sansa. Aria, the young girl,
- 8:33smacks Jeoffrey with her stick, and in the confusion, Micah, the
- 8:39butcher's boy, runs away, scared because he's terrified of Geoffrey, because Geoffrey
- 8:43has a reputation, you know, of being cruel. And Jeoffrey at this
- 8:48point tries to kill Aria with his sword. So Aria, you know,
- 8:52is trying to defend the butcher's boy and then hits Jeoffrey and then Jeoffrey and
- 8:58Aria is using a that's non lethal, and then Jeoffrey takes a swipe at
- 9:03Aria with his own sword, which is you know, terrifying, and then
- 9:07in defense of Aria, Aria's dire Wolf, her pet dire wolf Nymeria,
- 9:13attacks Joffrey and slightly injures him. You know, the dire Wolf isn't trying
- 9:18to kill Jeoffrey, but is just trying to protect Aria, as a good
- 9:20pet will do. And in the melee, Jeoffrey loses his sword lions Tooth.
- 9:26The sword Lions Tooth they name their swords in Westros. Aria takes the
- 9:33sword from him and throws it into the river, and Geoffrey is humiliated.
- 9:39Later, Jeoffrey tells his father and the others in the court that he had
- 9:43been attacked by Micah and the dire Wolf for no reason. So he lies
- 9:48and says, you know, these two people just attacked him for no reason.
- 9:52And the king doesn't know what to do. He's trying to please his
- 9:58son, and you know, he doesn't want to humiliate his son, so
- 10:01he's trying to work something out. The Queen Circe, being the evil lanister
- 10:05that she is, orders that Micah, the Butcher's boy, be killed along
- 10:09with Aria's Direwolf, and the King goes along with this decision. But Aria's
- 10:16Direwolf cannot be found, and incidentally, I'm trying to think does Direwolf ever
- 10:20get found? I don't know, but can't be found, And so Queen
- 10:26Circe insists that Sansus Direwolf Lady the Direwolf the name is Lady, should be
- 10:31killed instead, and to follow in the tradition of the North. Ned Stark
- 10:37is sadly forced to execute Sansus Direwolf himself in the Stark tradition, and eventually
- 10:45Sir sand Or Klegane or the Hound. He eventually finds Micah and cuts him
- 10:50in half with one swing of his sword. Later, Renley Barrathian, the
- 10:56King's younger brother, openly at his nephew Jeoffrey for being beaten and disarmed by
- 11:03a girl younger than him. So this whole incident, I think depicts Jeoffrey's
- 11:09personality, his tendencies, his behavior, his motivations, and also the world
- 11:15in which he lived. You know, not only was he a big jerk
- 11:18face to people, but he had his mother and father, the King and
- 11:24Queen, whom would please him and do what he wanted to and get back
- 11:31at his enemies. And he was a bully, but he was also ridiculed
- 11:35by people frequently. So there's that story. Another story here a little shorter,
- 11:43is that, if you remember from the books, on the TV show,
- 11:46Bran Brandon Stark was pushed out of the window by Jamie because Brand saw
- 11:52Jamie and Circe having some mommy and daddy time and it was thought he might
- 12:00die, you know, Brand was he didn't recover quickly, and the doctors
- 12:07thought that Brand might actually just die a slow death, and Geoffrey overheard his
- 12:11father, the King, saying that it would be merciful if Brand just died
- 12:16quickly instead of slowly, and so Geoffrey, overhearing his father say this,
- 12:20to impress his father, he hired a thug to kill Bran. So,
- 12:24if you remember again from the books and the TV show, a thug breaks
- 12:30into Brand's room while he's unconscious recovering from his injuries and tries to kill Bran,
- 12:35tries to slit his throat, and Brand's mother stops the assassination, and
- 12:43I believe one of the dire Wolves comes in. It's he probably Brand's dire
- 12:46Wolf saves the day. And incidentally, Tyrian was implicated in this attempted murder.
- 12:54So that's just another story of Jeoffrey trying to impress his father, which
- 12:58is a theme failing miserably at that task and just causing a lot of problems
- 13:07around him. So that's another story that depicts his personality. So moving forward
- 13:13in the story, in the TV show and the books, and incidentally,
- 13:16I have read the books. Well, I haven't read the books. I
- 13:18listened to the books. Sometimes I wonder if it's okay for me to say
- 13:22I've read the books when I've actually listened to the books. I've read parts
- 13:26of the books. Does that make it better. It's funny that we put
- 13:28privilege on reading a book as opposed to listening to a book as opposed to
- 13:33watching the TV show. You know, it's definitely a ranking culturally in terms
- 13:37of our social construction around what is more impressive. But anyway, I've listened
- 13:41to the books. They're really fantastic to listen to because the actor, you
- 13:46know, will have different voices for the different characters, puts a lot of
- 13:54emphasis on things. Anyway, the point is is that I've listened to the
- 13:56books well before the TV show came out. Makes me super cool. So
- 14:01in the story The King, he eventually dies, as you know, and
- 14:11around that time, Ned Stark, the hand of the king at the time,
- 14:15discovers that Jeoffrey and his siblings are actually bastards born of incest between Circe
- 14:22and her twin brother Jamie. So Ned discovers this, Ned confronts the queen
- 14:26with this information and threatens to out the information, which would make Jeoffrey not
- 14:31the heir to the throne. Circe, in an attempt to preserve Jeoffrey's rights
- 14:39to the throne and maybe even her own rights to be the mother of the
- 14:43future king, protects Jeoffrey's right to the Circe She secretly arranges for King Robert's
- 14:52death so that Jeoffrey will be king quickly so she'll have power, so she
- 14:58can and put Ned down because he's threatening her power in her family's power.
- 15:05So Circe has a number of different measures in place to make sure that the
- 15:11king is dead, and one of them works in that she gets somebody to
- 15:16I think, get the king really drunk on a hunting expedition and a wild
- 15:22boar guts him and he slowly dies. Then Ned, after King Robert dies,
- 15:28produces the King's will saying that Jeoffrey is not the king, and Circe
- 15:33tears it up, and then later when Jeoffrey is king, he claims that
- 15:39Ned is a traitor and executes him against everyone's wishes, including Circe. Nobody
- 15:46wants Ned to be executed because everyone knows that that will be horrible politically,
- 15:50and after Jeoffrey kills Ned, it is horribly politically for the kingdom, and
- 15:56it causes a massive civil war rob star Ned's sun rises up in the north
- 16:03and starts marching south and probably would have eventually won if it wasn't for the
- 16:10Red Wedding, the horrible Red Wedding. So Jeoffrey at this point is elevated
- 16:15to king quite suddenly, and he's elevated to king at a time when there
- 16:21is a lot of political unrest, and this was most likely quite anxiety provoking
- 16:27for him. He didn't know who to trust, and even his uncle,
- 16:32the hand Tyrian, even he seemed to be against Jeoffrey. So just imagine
- 16:37what it would be like. I mean, whether or not you like him
- 16:41or not, which I'm sure you don't, but just imagine what it would
- 16:42be like to be suddenly you're the king of the Southern Kingdoms or seven Houses
- 16:48or I don't know, but this you're king of something. You're King of
- 16:52Westrs and the country is in a civil war. You're twelve years old and
- 16:57you don't know who to trust. You know that no one thinks you're competent,
- 17:03and many people hate you, but you have all the power at your
- 17:07disposal, so that that would be a quite interesting situation to be in.
- 17:12I mean, just think back in your own life to when you were twelve
- 17:17years old. What is that like, sixth grade, fifth grade or something.
- 17:21Imagine being president of the United States. When you were in the sixth
- 17:26grade, you're suddenly president of the United States. Imagine how many stupid decisions
- 17:32you would make, and imagine how scared you would be. You know,
- 17:36so you know, if you have any kind of heart in your chest,
- 17:38you might have a little bit of empathy for Jeffrey in that situation. I
- 17:41don't know, but any compassion you have for him will be quickly snuffed out
- 17:47by me reminding you that Jeoffrey sadistically ordered his guards to beat Sansa whenever her
- 17:53brother's victories in the North occurred. So whenever Rob Stark would win in the
- 17:59North, Joffrey would have his guards beat Sansa, which is quite a horrible
- 18:04thing to do to somebody. He also forced her to look at her father's
- 18:10severed head, which was I think on a pike somewhere. He claimed he
- 18:15would beat Rob Stark in single combat, which no one else believed but him.
- 18:21He was a terrible king, and the people began to hate him.
- 18:26He was nearly killed in a riot as a result. In order to combine
- 18:33the houses of Lanister and Tyrrell, he was offered Marjorie Terrell's hand in marriage,
- 18:41and he quickly dropped Sansa like a sack of potatoes. He also declared
- 18:47that he would rape Sansa after his wedding, even though she was married to
- 18:52his uncle Tyrian eventually, which is a horrible thing to say and intend to
- 18:56do. When he heard about Rob Stark's death at the Red Wedding, he
- 19:00wanted to serve Rob's head to Sansa at his wedding, but I believe people
- 19:06stopped him. So again, this is another story about his personality shining through.
- 19:11That he loved to harm other people even though no one around him approved,
- 19:19so it just tells you something about who he was. He frequently alienated
- 19:25himself from the few allies that he had including the new hand of the king,
- 19:29his grandfather, Taiwin Lanister. This was one person that he could depend
- 19:33upon, and for some reason he even alienated him, so he had very
- 19:38few friends. In some ways, you could you could say that his only
- 19:42ally was his mom, and she proved herself to be the sort of mother
- 19:47that would love any child for any reason, as most mothers would. And
- 19:51then we all rejoiced when during his wedding to Marjorie, Marjorie's mother, Olena
- 19:57red Wine and p Bailish conspired to kill the king and poisoned him. Some
- 20:06of you might not know this, because I don't know if they showed it
- 20:07in the TV series, but Elena RedWine and Peter Bailish were the people that
- 20:15conspired to kill Jeoffrey. For a number of reasons. Elena didn't want her
- 20:21daughter, Marjorie to suffer as Jeoffrey's wife. Everyone knew that Marjorie was in
- 20:27all likelihood going to get abused somehow by Jeoffrey, and so Elena didn't want
- 20:33that for her daughter and knew that. And Elena knew that Marjorie, once
- 20:38made queen, could choose her husband, and she could choose Tommon, which
- 20:44you know, we all know this, that's what's occurring. And presumably little
- 20:48Finger conspired to kill the king because he wanted Sansa for himself and he also
- 20:55wanted to make allies with people who didn't like Jeoffrey. So, you know,
- 20:59Peter little Finger loves Sansa because Sansa is his mother's daughter, because he's
- 21:04in love with his He's in love with Sanza's mother, and he implicated Tyrian
- 21:10in the killing of King Joffrey. It's very complicated, but he essentially gets
- 21:14rid of Tyrian to separate Sansa so that he can have Sansa for himself.
- 21:18Anyway, But long story shirt, King Joffrey Geoffrey Barrathian died at the age
- 21:23of thirteen after being king for about one or two years, and that's the
- 21:30end of his life. So what can we say about his personality. Well,
- 21:33here are just some descriptions of his personality that I came up with.
- 21:36When things went wrong in his life, he tended to blame other people.
- 21:41In fact, he probably always blamed other people. He was reckless, he
- 21:45was cruel to people. He was vicious. He was not bright. He
- 21:49was not the brightest bulb in the pack. He made many bad judgments throughout
- 21:56the book and even in the historical accounts. He was strong willed, he
- 22:02had an uncontrollable temper. He was sadistic, and I'll get into more of
- 22:07that later. He had little sense of right or wrong. He was narcissistic.
- 22:12He thought he could do anything. He thought the world revolved around him.
- 22:15He was psychopathic. You might say he was antisocial. He was definitely
- 22:22dishonest and cowardly, and he was incompetent as a king. Okay, so
- 22:27let's analyze this guy. Why did he do so many hurtful things? Why
- 22:33was Jeoffrey the way that he was? Again, this is a fictional character,
- 22:37so it's fiction, but as a thought exercise, let's try to come
- 22:41up with reasons as to why Jeoffrey would have done what he did, why
- 22:48his personality was the way that it was. Because the fact of the matter
- 22:52is is that he did not benefit from a lot of the horrible things that
- 22:56he did. So a lot of the things that he did were counter to
- 23:00probably his goals, which were presumably to be respected, to be liked,
- 23:06to get what he wanted out of people. You know, why would he
- 23:08do so many things that basically was shooting himself in his own foot. So
- 23:15the first possibility that I want to look at is his relationship with his father.
- 23:18As I was mentioning earlier, it was clear that his father hated him.
- 23:22His father disapproved of him, and probably neglected him emotionally. Jeoffrey was
- 23:30hurt and angry about this and wanted love and approval from his father but did
- 23:36not get it. At the same time, he was a prince and heir
- 23:40to the throne, so he was elevated in his society, and this might
- 23:44have led to severe narcissism and insecure attachment. He was constantly trying to impress
- 23:52his father, and maybe in his child mind he thought he could impress his
- 23:56father by being a fierce warrior like his father, And maybe he thought that
- 24:02if he was without fear and he was cruel to his enemies the way his
- 24:07father was, maybe that would impress his father. So maybe it was that
- 24:11Jeffrey was not bright enough to understand that his actions was not actually impressive to
- 24:19his father, but maybe in his perception, his cruelty and the way that
- 24:26he bullied other people, maybe that would get his father to love him.
- 24:30So, getting back to the narcissism. Bit he was very insecure as a
- 24:36person as a result of possibly his relationship with his father. And again,
- 24:41at the same time, he's heir to the throne. He's like basically he's
- 24:44the next king, and everyone treats him as that. So on one hand
- 24:47he feels horrible about himself, he feels terrible, he feels worthless. But
- 24:52on the other hand, he has a lot of worth and a lot of
- 24:55power. And so sometimes people will develop the narcissistic personalities as a way of
- 25:03coping with extremely low self worth. And when your self worth is challenged,
- 25:08you strike back very quickly and harshly to assert your dominance and your superiority as
- 25:15a way of protecting even yourself from the notion that you are in fact worthless.
- 25:22Even though you're not actually worthless, you just feel that you are.
- 25:25So that might be one of the reasons, or a few of the reasons
- 25:27why Geoffrey was the way that he was. So now let's look at his
- 25:30relationship with his mother. I wouldn't be a stereotypical therapist if I didn't blame
- 25:37it on the mother, right, So it's difficult to tell from the books
- 25:40what his relationship was really like with his mother. It was clear that his
- 25:45mother really cared about him and loved him or in whatever way that she could.
- 25:51But for instance, she stopped her husband from beating him, so she
- 25:56cared about Jeoffrey enough to do that. But the Lanisters aren't really known for
- 26:03being warm and fuzzy, so maybe she wasn't particularly emotionally warm with him.
- 26:08It's hard to tell, but maybe she was, you know, maybe hard
- 26:11to tell, but so maybe there was an attachment issue there with her that
- 26:15might have been at play. He was definitely spoiled by her and would let
- 26:22him get away with things, and so this might have added to his narcissism
- 26:26and sense of entitlement. You know, all children need to understand where their
- 26:33limits lie. Anyone who has raised children knows that people don't come out of
- 26:40the womb with a very clear understanding of their entitlement. Three year olds say
- 26:48it's mine and give me it, and I feel like throwing this rock at
- 26:52your head, and I'm going to do it because I want to. And
- 26:56you know, slowly, over time with parenting, children learn the difference between
- 27:00what they have the right to do and what they don't. And you know,
- 27:03for instance, they might have the right to say that their toys are
- 27:08their toys, and they get to and they get to play with their toys
- 27:11when they want to, but they can't take someone else's toy, even though
- 27:15they have an impulse to do so. Well, if the father was not
- 27:19around and the mother was spoiling him, and he was not feeling very good
- 27:26about himself, Jeoffrey might have grown up with a severe sense of entitlement and
- 27:32an attitude, an unchecked narcissistic attitude of entitlement that that young children will have
- 27:40but they usually will grow out of through appropriate parenting. And maybe Jeoffrey wasn't
- 27:45given that parenting by his parents. Such another idea as to why Geoffrey would
- 27:49have been the way that he was. Another reason, aside from his relationship
- 27:55with his father and mother, is the relationship between the parents. There's a
- 27:59lot of evidence in the books that he was deeply affected by his parents abusive
- 28:04and conflictual relationship. His parents, Robert Barrathian and Circy Lanister. The King
- 28:11and Queen were noticeably not happy with each other. The King was drinking all
- 28:18the time and having sex with all sorts of different women, high and low
- 28:23born women and having children. He had I don't know, something like thirty
- 28:27different bastards around the city, and he, I think would beat her,
- 28:33and she, you know, would obviously not be happy about those sorts of
- 28:37things. And she wasn't a very warm and fuzzy person herself, and I
- 28:40don't think she ever even wanted to marry him. And the fact that they
- 28:42never had kids sort of tells you something about their relationship, you know,
- 28:47since all of her children were actually Jamie's children. So Jeoffrey grew up in
- 28:52this environment seeing his parents very upset with each other, and we all know
- 28:56that that takes a toll on a child's develop And just to exemplify this,
- 29:03another story for you at the Hands Tourney. At the Hands Tournament when Ned
- 29:08became the hand and the king through a tournament, Jeffrey was being very charming
- 29:15with Sansa because they were betrothed. To believe at the time, Jeffrey was
- 29:19being very charming and was nice to Sansa, and Sansa is you know,
- 29:26she's just extremely happy about how everything's working out, that she's going to be
- 29:32the queen, and it's because in her mind it was all you know,
- 29:34prince and princesses and all the wonderful romantic stories, and it was all turning
- 29:40out the way that she thought it would. But then at this tournament,
- 29:44the king, King Robert, Jeoffrey's father, shouts at the Queen that she
- 29:49can't tell him what to do. You know, he gets in an open,
- 29:55loud fight and verbally abuses his wife and in front of everybody, and
- 30:00Geoffrey too, And immediately joff becomes distant, and he becomes sort of cold,
- 30:08and he quickly distances himself from Sansa, and Sansa notices this. So
- 30:15this is a story in which we can see that Jeoffrey was deeply affected by
- 30:19the conflict between his parents. That for any child, they desperately want a
- 30:26secure base upon which they can venture off into the world and return to when
- 30:30they need to. And when your parents are fighting with each other, the
- 30:34secure base is not there, and that is extremely disturbing to children and can
- 30:41cause a lot of distress and anxiety and insecurity about who loves you. You
- 30:47know, if your parents can't love each other, then by implication, they
- 30:52might not love you, or if you displease them somehow, the way that
- 30:56they displease each other, maybe you'll be rejected in the same way. This
- 31:00is the toll that parental conflict and divorce has on children. Not that divorce
- 31:06always causes this well, not that this sort of thing is always a significant
- 31:12issue in someone's personality. But if you've ever been through a divorce as a
- 31:17child, you will know that it doesn't feel good. It's disheartening. On
- 31:22the other hand, if you see your parents fighting all the time, and
- 31:25over time you just wish they would break up because you can't stand them being
- 31:30around each other anymore. Then by the time they get divorced, you actually
- 31:33are happy about it. But going back to the time when they were fighting,
- 31:37that is not a pleasing experience for children by any stretch of the imagination.
- 31:42So that's another reason as to why Jeoffrey might have been disturbed. He
- 31:48absorbed all this negativity and the result of that might have been a lot of
- 31:55his cruelty and his bad decision making. So we've looked at his relationship with
- 32:00his father, is a relationship with his mother, and is the relationship between
- 32:04the parents. Another possibility that I thought of was that he was frequently seen
- 32:10as looking like a girl. For instance, John Snow and others thought that
- 32:16Jeoffrey looked like a girl and remarked as such. You know, he was
- 32:21very pretty and had curly locks and was very fair, and you wonder what
- 32:28kind of effect that could have on a young man. He's twelve years old
- 32:34and he wants to assert his manliness, he wants to be king. His
- 32:38father is very macho and very manly, and everyone thinks he looks like a
- 32:44girl, and there's a lot of oppression around that in Westros. It seems
- 32:50as is in our society. You know, if you grow up in our
- 32:53society and you are a young boy and people think that you're a very manly
- 33:00then you get made fun of and sometimes that can take a toll on your
- 33:05personality and you want, you might want to start acting really ultramacho just to
- 33:10compensate for this. And what's one way to act super macho, Well,
- 33:15you become extremely aggressive and hostile and assertive and make people fear you. That
- 33:23is associated with masculinity, unfortunately, and so maybe that was one of the
- 33:29reasons why Jeoffrey did what he did, was because he was trying to assert
- 33:32his manhood. Another reason to look at is genetics. We all know that
- 33:37Jeoffrey was the offspring of incest. Circe and her twin brother Jamie were having
- 33:45an affair or some kind of relationship and had the three children. And inbreeding
- 33:52can cause many genetic issues. I'm not a geneticist or a biologist, so
- 33:58I don't know much about it, but I know that much. I tried
- 34:01to look up research regarding whether or not incest and inbreeding can lead to sadism
- 34:08and personality problems, and I only found a little bit. But there's not
- 34:14a lot of research on this, and so I don't know if we know
- 34:17the answer that question as to whether or not inbreeding can cause antisocial behavior.
- 34:22It seems possible, but you know, lots of things seem possible that are
- 34:27not shown by science. So you know, maybe that was a factor too.
- 34:30But certainly we can think about people in history who were sadistic and not
- 34:37the result of incest, So you know, it's unclear as to whether or
- 34:42not that would have been a factor. All right, So we've looked at
- 34:44the relationship with mother and father, relationship between the parents, This looking like
- 34:47a girl issue and the inbreeding issue, and now we have other biological factors.
- 34:54For instance, the mother was a big drinker, as many people were.
- 35:00She drank to cope. She was under a lot of stress and didn't
- 35:04have a lot of support and would turn to alcohol to numb her distress and
- 35:10her relationship with her husband, the king, King Robert was, as we
- 35:15know, was very stressful, and she might have been drinking, maybe even
- 35:21heavily during the time of her getting pregnant with Jeffrey. She was also potentially
- 35:29under a lot of stress during the pregnancy, so alcohol, excessive alcohol and
- 35:34stress can cause problems genetically. The mother, you know, just to describe
- 35:39why she would have been in soma's stress around the time of her pregnancy with
- 35:44Jeoffrey. This is her first child, and she probably suspected it was Jamie's,
- 35:50and she was probably terrified that once the baby was born that it would
- 35:55be clear that the baby was not King Roberts, who had dark hair and
- 36:00dark features, whereas Jamie and Circe had blonde and fair features. And so
- 36:07if the child is very blonde and looks a lot like Jamie, which he
- 36:10did, the mother was probably quite stressed out during the pregnancy about what would
- 36:15happen as a result of that. So the mother during the pregnancy was quite
- 36:22stressed out, which might have caused some issues regarding fetus developments. And again,
- 36:29I'm not a biologist, so I don't even know the language for such
- 36:31things, but I know that much. So another possible reason as to why
- 36:42Geoffrey was the way that he was can be informed by systems theory. Family
- 36:47systems theory is quite weird to many people, but I have been studying it
- 36:52and thinking about it for a long time, so it comes pretty easily to
- 36:58me, and I find that the explanations that it provides can sometimes be very
- 37:04useful. However, many people think they're quite wacky. So let me lay
- 37:08this down for you. So, according to family systems theory, families operate
- 37:15as a whole. That you have individuals within the system, but the system
- 37:20also has its own life, so to speak, its own psyche, so
- 37:23to speak, its own motivations. For instance, one way of looking at
- 37:29the family of Robert and Circe and the children is that there was a big
- 37:36problem in this family. You had a physically abusive relationship that the father was
- 37:43beating the mother, The mother was cheating on the father, the father was
- 37:49cheating on the mother, The parents hated each other, and yet there seemed
- 37:54to be no resolution. In my head, I just imagine the two of
- 37:59them going to couples there. Maybe I'll do an episode on that in the
- 38:00future. But anyway, so you have a family that is quite distressed and
- 38:07doesn't seem to have any solution ahead of them. Well, one of the
- 38:12ways that systems will try to find solutions. And again I'm phrasing this as
- 38:20if the system is an entity in and of itself. So when a system
- 38:23is distressed, when a family system is under distress, it tries to seek
- 38:30solutions to its problems, and each individual within the system unconsciously will carry out
- 38:38behaviors that will lead to solutions along these signs. And maybe this is confusing,
- 38:44but for instance, Jeffrey might have been elected by the system to act
- 38:50the way that he did in order to distract the family in such a way
- 38:53that they did not have to face their problems. So another way of ribing
- 39:00this is that you have big problems between the parents and Jeoffrey, say is
- 39:07four or five years old, and Jeoffrey feels this tension as everybody does,
- 39:12and Jeoffrey is trying to get them to stop. He wants them to come
- 39:16together, as all children do, and he starts experimenting with different behaviors.
- 39:22He doesn't know. He'd you know, if you ask the four year old
- 39:24Jeoffrey, why are you know? What's your motivation today? He would just
- 39:28say normal four year old stuff. But inside, unconsciously, people do things
- 39:35based on the effect. And so when he, for instance, was a
- 39:40good boy and was quiet, that did not solve the problem. The parents
- 39:45continued to fight, and so when he was a good boy, he wasn't
- 39:49rewarded for that. But when he's a bad boy, it's possible that that
- 39:53stopped the fighting temporarily. So even though he was being punished or yelled at
- 39:59by father, the overall tension in the family was being reduced because the family
- 40:05was temporarily distracted from their problem and now it's focused on Jeoffrey's four year old
- 40:08behavior. So it's possible that Jeoffrey was rewarded for this, and that the
- 40:14family depended on Jeoffrey to fulfill this role and to fulfill this purpose of distracting
- 40:21the family from the real problem. And over time this begins to become rigid
- 40:27and Jeoffrey ends up having his role become a part of his personality and the
- 40:32part of his routine way of thinking to the point where if Jeoffrey was in
- 40:37a different system that didn't need him to act that way, he would still
- 40:40continue to act that way out of habit. So that's a systemic way of
- 40:45looking at why Jeoffrey might have been the way that he was. Okay,
- 40:49So another reason that I thought about that I alluded to earlier was that Jeoffrey
- 40:55was spoiled. It doesn't seem that the parents had a very good approach to
- 41:01him. The father rejected and abused him, while the mother just gave him
- 41:07whatever he wanted, it seems, and so that is not good parenting.
- 41:14As any parent would know that when you neglect a child and abuse them,
- 41:17that's not good, and that when you let them get away with literally murder
- 41:22that is also not good. They need limits. So that is another possible
- 41:28reason as to why he was the way that he was. I've had clients
- 41:31like this before, and by the time they're fifteen fourteen years old, it's
- 41:37difficult to repair the damage done that spoiling does to children. But it can
- 41:44be done, but it just takes a lot of time. So another reason
- 41:46that I thought about was he was possibly traumatized. A lot of personality disorders
- 41:52are associated with trauma, and he was clearly abused by his father. Trauma
- 42:00that I thought about was that his mother basically killed his father, and rumors
- 42:06were around at the time and he probably heard them, and it was no
- 42:12mystery that his mother hated his father, and when his father died, it
- 42:16was rumored that the mother had been a part of that. And imagine the
- 42:21trauma involved in that. Imagine how traumatic that would be for you, as
- 42:23a twelve year old boy that you discover or at least a lot of people
- 42:29think and there's reasons to believe that your mother has killed your father. I
- 42:32mean, that must have been traumatic for him, just really difficult. So
- 42:37there are other traumas as well, like he was nearly killed in a riot,
- 42:42and also in Westros he saw a lot of death and he saw a
- 42:46lot of people's lives treated very inhumanely. So these are a lot of traumas
- 42:53for someone to go through. Not that he was particularly unique in this way
- 42:57in this world, but he went through a lot offficult times. And sometimes
- 43:01traumas can result in personality disorders like sadism. Maybe the sadism maybe he had
- 43:09a disposition for the potential to be a sadist and these traumas pushed him over
- 43:15the edge biologically and he became sadistic as a result. So another possible reason
- 43:23for why Jeoffrey was the way that he was was be One angle of looking
- 43:30at it is through life stage. You know, there are different stages in
- 43:34life, so to speak, and there's a lot of research in this,
- 43:37and some people think that these models are not useful, but sometimes they can
- 43:42be. So, you know, what do most thirteen year old's twelve year
- 43:46olds go through, Well, they are still somewhat often defiant of authority or
- 43:52they're developing defiance to authority. They're trying to find themselves. They're often the
- 43:58most insecure people. You know, think of middle school, when in early
- 44:02high school when people are at their most insecure. So he was at that
- 44:07stage in life and he might have been trying to find himself and in an
- 44:14effort to individuate, In an effort to find himself, he might have turned
- 44:20to these aggressive behaviors as a way of trying to discover who he was a
- 44:25lot of people are like this when they're twelve and thirteen, not not the
- 44:30majority of people. But you know, a good number of people have very
- 44:35dubious morals, will say and later end up growing out of it. So
- 44:40might Jeoffrey have grown out of this if he was given enough time? It's
- 44:45an interesting, you know thought to have Might he have learned? Might he
- 44:50have come around? Doesn't seem like it, But but I've heard, I
- 44:54mean, I've heard and worked with clients who will tell me about things like
- 45:00this, where they will say, man, when I was thirteen and fourteen,
- 45:02I was horrible to my parents. I was abusive verbally and physically.
- 45:09I one time hit my own grandmother in the face. I you know,
- 45:15lots of just horrible stories. And they would never do anything like that as
- 45:20an adult, because the brain hasn't fully developed yet, and people are still
- 45:25trying to figure out who they are and what's and the difference between right and
- 45:30wrong and how to navigate certain impulses and certain desires that adults often will figure
- 45:37out, but twelve to thirteen year olds might not yet. So maybe Jeoffrey
- 45:43was a victim of his own development in that situation. You know, you
- 45:46wonder what it would have been like if Jeoffrey's family wasn't royal, wasn't royalty?
- 45:53What if they were just a regular, you know, farming family,
- 45:57would Jeoffrey have been the same way because the pressure would have been different and
- 46:00the life would have been different. It's just interesting to think about. Okay.
- 46:05So the last area I want to go into as to you know,
- 46:08possible explanations for why Geoffrey was the way that he was has to do with
- 46:15psychodynamic reasons psychodynamic analysis. So, due to the pain he was feeling on
- 46:23the inside from all of these difficulties that he experienced in life and his own
- 46:28inner struggles, his ego employed a number of possible defense mechanisms to cope and
- 46:36ameliorate this inner psychic pain. So this is the premise behind defense mechanisms and
- 46:42psychodynamic understanding, is that when you have inner pain, and we all suffer
- 46:47from some amount of particular inner pains in our personalities, we use defense mechanisms
- 46:55to protect ourselves from that pain. And it's a natural thing that everybody does.
- 47:01Where did this pain come from for Jeoffrey? Well, as I mentioned
- 47:06earlier, lots of attachment issues. He internalized his relationship between his parents.
- 47:15He internalized the relationship between his parents. You know, when children are growing
- 47:19up, they will internalize things around them. They'll internalize their relationships with their
- 47:25significant others, with you know, with their with their caregivers and their parents.
- 47:30They'll even internalize their relationships they see outside of them. So Jeoffrey had
- 47:36internalized this very conflictual, abusive, terrible relationship between his parents. It becomes
- 47:43a part of him. He takes it in and the outward conflict becomes an
- 47:49inner conflict. Inner voices inside of him begin to rage against each other.
- 47:54Parts of his personality start to war against each other. This was results in
- 48:00internal conflict and negative self talk and a desire to find relief through defense mechanisms,
- 48:07one of which is denial. So he might have employed the defense mechanism
- 48:13of denial. For instance, he had to have known that he was not
- 48:19the king's son. There were many rumors and it was obvious to anyone who
- 48:22was paying attention that Jeoffrey was not the king's son and in fact was Jamie's
- 48:28soon And so I suspect that a part of him knew this, but it
- 48:32was too difficult to accept. It meant that he was a monster. It
- 48:37meant that he was not the heir to the throne. It meant that he
- 48:42was a disgrace, a bastard a result of incest, and this would have
- 48:46created tremendous shame for him and also a fear for his life. So you
- 48:52can imagine the inner struggle that would be going on for him. And so
- 48:55one way to deal with that struggle is to go in to deny, to
- 49:00say that it's not true, it's not happening. I am Robert's son.
- 49:05It's obvious, you know. And this probably took a toll in his personality,
- 49:10this level of denial, this pressure that needed to be kept on the
- 49:15acknowledgment that he was not the king's son. This denial might have led to
- 49:21strain in his personality that led to him being cruel to others. Another defense
- 49:25mechanism is acting out. Acting out is performing an extreme behavior in order to
- 49:32express thoughts or feelings the person feels incapable of expressing otherwise. So instead of
- 49:38communicating his fear and his longing for his father, instead he acted out and
- 49:45was hostile. When a person acts out their problems, it can act as
- 49:52a pressure release and often helps the individual feel calmer and more at peace and
- 50:00more equilibrium. So he's sitting alone and he's feeling terrible, and he's watching
- 50:06his parents fight and he doesn't know what to do with it. So as
- 50:12a sort of catharsis, he found that when he was cruel to other people,
- 50:15this released him of this innertention and he felt better afterwards. So that
- 50:21might have been another reason as to why he had this habit of being cruel.
- 50:25Another defense mechanism is reaction formation. Reaction formation is the converting of unwanted
- 50:34or dangerous or distressing thoughts, feelings, or impulses into their opposites. So
- 50:39it's sort of weird, but I've seen people do this. So let's say
- 50:44that Jeffrey really wanted to be tender with people, and he really wanted to
- 50:49be loved, and he really wanted attention, and he really wanted acceptance,
- 50:52but instead, because this is so dangerous for him to express, because he
- 50:58doesn't feel he can trust any I mean, imagine Jeoffrey saying, father,
- 51:02I want your love. I feel so rejected by you. You know what
- 51:07would his father have said? His father probably would not have reacted very well
- 51:12to that, so or at least you could imagine Jeffrey believing that to be
- 51:15true and so because it's dangerous to express and to even acknowledge those longing feelings,
- 51:22a defense mechanism might be employed to deal with that by converting it into
- 51:28its opposite, which is cruelty and rejection and getting people to hate you.
- 51:32So he might have chosen cruelty and getting people to hate him as a way
- 51:39of reacting to what his real desire was, which is for love and for
- 51:45people to love him, and for tenderness in the world. So reaction formation
- 51:50might have been another reason as to why he was the way that he was.
- 51:54Another defense. Another defense mechanism that I thought might have been at play
- 52:00was displacement. Displacement is when someone redirects their thoughts or feelings or impulses at
- 52:08one person toward a different thing or person. So the classic example is the
- 52:15father gets, you know, verbally abused by his boss at work, and
- 52:22he comes home and then he kicks the dog. So that's a classic displacement
- 52:27example. So it's possible that Jeoffrey, because he was so hurt by his
- 52:32father and as a result, so angry at his father, he might have
- 52:37displaced all that anger towards his father towards other people. We often will displace
- 52:43anger that we feel we can't express. Like you know the example with the
- 52:46boss. You have someone's boss yell at you. Well, if your boss
- 52:52yells at you and you don't feel very secure in that relationship, you might
- 52:55not feel very safe in saying I'm angry at you. You might just take
- 53:01it and then go behind his back and talk crap about him. Well,
- 53:07it's very possible that Jeoffrey did not feel safe to say to his father that
- 53:12he was angry, and so the anger has to come out some way,
- 53:15and so he directed it toward other people that were easy targets for him to
- 53:21be cruel toward. So it could be displacement at play. Other things at
- 53:24play that I won't go into are superiority complex and downward social comparison. Another
- 53:32psychodynamic idea that might have been at play was compartmentalization and dehumanization, But for
- 53:39the sake of time, I won't go into him. The last defense mechanism
- 53:43I want to go into is projective identification, and this is one that I
- 53:49use often as a way of understanding people's odd behavior. I was thinking that
- 53:55Jeoffrey internalized his father's rejection and potentially his mother's lack of warmth and his parents'
- 54:05relationship with each other. So a way of looking at this is that he's
- 54:09in his relationship with his father and his father is rejecting him, and he
- 54:15sees that. He sees that his father is rejecting him, he also sees
- 54:17himself that he is being rejected, and so he internalizes this relationship. He
- 54:22internalizes both his father rejecting him and himself being rejected, and it becomes this
- 54:29internal representation in his psyche that becomes bolstered over time over repetition. His father
- 54:36continually rejects him, he continually feels rejected, and this becomes a part of
- 54:42his personality. And one of the things that happens over time is that this
- 54:47internal representation starts to battle with itself. That there's a part of Jeoffrey that
- 54:53hates himself, and there's a part of Jeoffrey that feels hated even by himself.
- 54:59And this happens in eternally and largely unconsciously, and so this is,
- 55:02you know, creating a lot of innertention. Well, one of the ways
- 55:06to cope with this intertention is to externalize it, and it, you know,
- 55:12it temporarily feels better to externalize an internal conflict. There's a lot of
- 55:17tension that builds up over time if you if you can't find relief, and
- 55:22if it's just occurring internally for somebody. So instead of having this war go
- 55:29on inside of him, where a part of him hates himself and another part
- 55:31of him feels hated, he externalizes one side of that and he had and
- 55:36he identifies with one side, So he identifies with the rejection part, and
- 55:40he imposes the feeling of rejection onto other people. So he creates social situations
- 55:49in which they feel the way he feels, and he acts the way he
- 55:52feels as though he and he acts the way he thinks his father is acting
- 55:57towards him. So he creates social situations in which he rejects other people through
- 56:02cruelty and through hostility while elevating himself. This is an externalization of something that
- 56:08was originally internalized from his family from multiple different directions. This is projective identification
- 56:17in that you project a part of yourself onto other people. He's projecting his
- 56:23weak, rejected self onto other people and socializing them or manipulating them to feel
- 56:31that way. And then in this way he has the fantasy that he no
- 56:37longer is rejected because they're rejected. It's someone outside of him that's rejected.
- 56:43It's not him. And this is how we all seek sometimes to relieve ourselves
- 56:49of innertention. We will project parts of ourselves onto other people, manipulate them,
- 56:54socialize them to act accordingly to our projection, and then react against it.
- 57:01It feels better to us. It's the lesser of two evils, because
- 57:05it's not ultimately a good thing to experience, but it's better than having the
- 57:09inner conflict without relief. Looking through this lens, we see examples of this
- 57:16throughout the books. He was attracted to situations in which he could project his
- 57:22weak and inferior self concept onto other people. For instance, as I talked
- 57:27about earlier, when he came upon the boy Micah the Butcher's Boy play fighting
- 57:32with Ariya. Well, Micah the Butcher's Boy is a weak person compared to
- 57:39Prince Jeoffrey, and Prince Joffrey knows this. Prince Joffrey rides up on a
- 57:44horse and has a actual sword and this Butcher's Boy just has a stick.
- 57:49And he sees Micah as this pathetic person and projects his inner pathetic self concept
- 57:55onto Micah, and in an effort to snuff out his own inner pathetic person,
- 58:01he tries to snuff out Micah. He's trying to punish Micah for being
- 58:07pathetic, but in reality he has an ongoing inner conflict where he is abusing
- 58:13himself regarding his own pathetic self concept. So he ridicules others for being weak,
- 58:21but in reality, it's himself that feels weak. So I hope that
- 58:24made sense. Let me know if it didn't. All right, So those
- 58:29are the various reasons. Just again to review, we have his relationship with
- 58:34his father, his relationship with his mother, the relationship between the parents,
- 58:37the issue of looking like a girl, potentially genetics in breeding. There were
- 58:43other biological factors like the mom's drinking or the stress the mother had during the
- 58:46pregnancy. I provided a systemic explanation in which Geoffrey was elected by the system
- 58:52to be this way in order to distract from the problems in the family.
- 58:58Geoffrey might have been spoiled, and that might have been a reason as to
- 59:00why he did what he did. He was traumatized, and that might have
- 59:05been a factor. His life stage of trying to individuate might have been a
- 59:09factor, and then I provided a lot of defense mechanisms that might have been
- 59:14at play that would have resulted in his behavior. All right, so what's
- 59:17my diagnosis? Well, looking in the DSM five, which has all sorts
- 59:23of problems with it, but it is the manual that all of us professionals
- 59:28use. If I'm using the constructs that the authors of the DSM five put
- 59:34forth, I would say that he fits the construct of the conduct disorder,
- 59:39which is described as a repetitive and persistent pattern of behavior in which the basic
- 59:45rights of others or major age appropriate societal norms or rules are violated. In
- 59:51other words, a person who violates others' basic rights and is cruel to others
- 59:57frequently. It has to be there need to be at least three of the
- 1:00:01following fifteen criteria in the past twelve months. So let's look at these criteria.
- 1:00:08So, the first category of criteria are the aggression to people and animals.
- 1:00:15So does he often bully, threaten, or intimidate others? Yes?
- 1:00:22So we got one. Does he often initiate physical fights? I would say
- 1:00:28no, but you could interpret it as yes because he would use his guards
- 1:00:32to abuse people. So that's an unsure one. Has he used a weapon
- 1:00:37that has caused serious physical harm to others? Yes, he swung a sword
- 1:00:44at Aria and frequently orders his guards to do horrible things. So we have
- 1:00:49two so far. Has he been physically cruel to people? Yes? Three.
- 1:00:54Has he been physically cruel to animals? You could say yes, the
- 1:00:59cat incident was cruel and strange, so yeah, but that's yes. So
- 1:01:05we have four out of five. Has he stolen while confronting a victim?
- 1:01:08This is a weird way of describing this in the DSM, but essentially,
- 1:01:13have they mugged? You know, has the person mugged someone or stolen someone
- 1:01:17in a physical way? And I could say probably not, but it might
- 1:01:24be forgetting something, So we'll say no to that one. Has he forced
- 1:01:29someone into sexual activity, Well, he certainly planned on it. He planned
- 1:01:34on raping Sansa, so we'll say maybe on that one too. The next
- 1:01:40category is destruction of property. So has he deliberately engaged in fire setting with
- 1:01:46the intention of causing serious damage? I don't think so. Has he deliberately
- 1:01:52destroyed other's property other than the fire setting, Yes, he For instance,
- 1:01:59when he was given gifts at his wedding If you remember, he took his
- 1:02:02brand new Valerian sword and chopped a very coveted old book that Tyrian and Sansa
- 1:02:10gave him at his wedding day. What do you call his sword again,
- 1:02:15widows widow's whale? I think what was the name of his st is his
- 1:02:19sword? Widow's whale? What a classy name? Okay, all right.
- 1:02:23The next category of in conduct disorder is deceitfulness or theft. Has he broken
- 1:02:30into someone else's house, building, or car. No, he wouldn't need
- 1:02:36to because he's the king. Does he often lie to obtain goods or favors
- 1:02:40or to avoid obligations? We would say yes, he lied when he got
- 1:02:46back to court after the incident with Ariya and the butcher's boy, So yes
- 1:02:52he does lie. But does he often lie? I don't know. That's
- 1:02:57I'm sure. Has he stolen items of non trivial value without confronting a victim,
- 1:03:04for instance, shoplifting and this sort of stuff. Again, he's the
- 1:03:06king. He doesn't need to do any of that, So it's unclear as
- 1:03:08to whether or not you would do that if he was not the king.
- 1:03:10All right. The next the last category, is serious violation of rules?
- 1:03:15Does he often stay out at night despite parental prohibitions? Doesn't apply to him.
- 1:03:23Has he run away from home overnight? Again doesn't apply to him.
- 1:03:28Is he often truant from school? Again? Doesn't apply to him. So,
- 1:03:31you know, does he have at least three of the criteria? Yes,
- 1:03:36he has about half of them, so he does meet three of the
- 1:03:39fifteen. He does meet at least three of the fifteen criteria. Does the
- 1:03:43disturbance and behavior cause clinically significant impairment in social, academic, or occupational functioning?
- 1:03:50This is always a debatable criteria to try to figure out. You know,
- 1:03:54did Joffrey's conduct problems present problems in his life? I would say yes,
- 1:04:00because eventually someone killed him. So there are different specifiers. First,
- 1:04:06is child onset type. These individuals show at least one symptom characteristic of conduct
- 1:04:13disorder prior to the age of ten years old. We would say that yes,
- 1:04:16this was a childhood onset type of conduct disorder. There's another specifier with
- 1:04:21limited pro social emotions. To qualify for this specifier, an individual must have
- 1:04:27displayed at least two of the following characteristics persistent over at least twelve months and
- 1:04:31in multiple relationships and settings, lack of remorse or guilt, callous lack of
- 1:04:38empathy, unconcerned about performance, and shallow or deficient affect. So yes,
- 1:04:45he definitely lacked remorse or guilt, he lacked empathy. He was he did
- 1:04:51not express feelings or show emotions to others, so we would specify not only
- 1:04:59that the conduct disorder was child onset type, but it was also with limited
- 1:05:03pro social emotions. Also, the last specifier category is whether or not it
- 1:05:08was mild, moderate, or severe. So let's see, I'm guessing it
- 1:05:12severe. Many conduct problems in excess of those required to make the diagnosis are
- 1:05:16present, or conduct problems cause considerable harm to others, so yes, we
- 1:05:21would say that he was severe. So diagnosis DSM five is conduct disorder with
- 1:05:29child onset type, with limited pro social emotions and severe. So that is
- 1:05:33as diagnosis as I see it. Some people might wonder why I wouldn't apply
- 1:05:40the anti social personality disorder or the narcissistic personality disorder or the old diagnosis of
- 1:05:47sadistic personality disorder, And the reasons for that is that he's too young and
- 1:05:51I won't go into that because that's a long topic to talk about, But
- 1:05:57essentially, teenagers are generally not diagnosed with personality disorders, and conduct disorder is
- 1:06:03seen by many to be a personality disorder of childhood. So often people with
- 1:06:09conduct disorder will develop antisocial personality disorder or some other personality disorder later in life,
- 1:06:15but not always for sure. All right, so let's go into the
- 1:06:25last section here. I just want to talk about sadism in general, because
- 1:06:29I think the construct that is in psychology that best describes Geoffrey Brathian is sadism.
- 1:06:39He was sadistic. What's the definition of sadism, Well, there have
- 1:06:44been many definitions over the past one hundred plus years, but basically most people's
- 1:06:49definitions center around one particular element, and that is that sadists derive pleasure from
- 1:06:58the suffering of other So this suffering of others can either be initiated by the
- 1:07:03person or can be vicarious, meaning they see suffering happening. For instance,
- 1:07:09they might like to watch ultimate fighting because they get to see one guy beat
- 1:07:15the crap out of another guy. So the sadist isn't doing the beating,
- 1:07:18but they like to see someone get beat so it's vicarious sadism, or they
- 1:07:24might actually just like to do the beating themselves. So, and this isn't
- 1:07:30to say that everyone that loves ultimate fighting is a sadist. That is definitely
- 1:07:34not the case, but sadists might be attracted to it. Another element that
- 1:07:39is often brought up as a definition of sadism is that not only do they
- 1:07:45derive pleasure from harming other people, but they also get off on controlling others
- 1:07:49and humiliating them. But this isn't always included in the definition, and to
- 1:07:55me it seems a little bit tertiary to the main issue of someone driving pleasure
- 1:08:02from harming other people. So just know that for some people they define also
- 1:08:08statists as getting off on controlling other people. Now, this isn't to say
- 1:08:13that all harm to other people indicates that someone is a sadist. For instance,
- 1:08:18some people have to resort to control or harm of other people, but
- 1:08:24these people might not actually take pleasure in it, if that makes any sense.
- 1:08:28So in other words, if someone's provoked to be controlling or harmful,
- 1:08:32this doesn't necessarily indicate a sadistic personality. So for instance, if you have
- 1:08:40an abusive husband, he might be a sadist, but he might not be.
- 1:08:44He might be controlling and abusive because he has difficulty controlling his emotions and
- 1:08:49because he is disturbed emotionally and he resorts to control and aggression to monit to
- 1:09:00modulate his own emotions. Whereas sadists, they just enjoy harming other people or
- 1:09:05seeing other people get harmed. It's a form of pleasure to them. It's
- 1:09:11not something that they resort to. So it's an important distinction to make.
- 1:09:15It's quite disturbing to think about, right, that there are some people out
- 1:09:17there that actually get off on harming others. But it's true. So some
- 1:09:23related constructs in psychology that I won't go into, our antisocial personality disorder or
- 1:09:30sociopathy or psychopathy. These three different diagnoses have a lot of overlapping elements with
- 1:09:41each other and with sadism. All three of you know, antisocial, sociopathy,
- 1:09:45and psychopathy, they all have many different criteria. But sadism is a
- 1:09:50very simple construct to understand. I mean, when you're trying to describe psychopathy
- 1:09:57to people, sometimes it takes a long time to describe, but sadism doesn't
- 1:10:00take much time at all because it's just the simple trait of taking pleasure and
- 1:10:03harming other people. So sadism to some extent is easier to teach and understand.
- 1:10:12Just as an example. To put this in real world context, research
- 1:10:15has shown that Internet trolls are sadistic often, so you know, as a
- 1:10:23Internet person myself, I will say that I've been the victim of many online
- 1:10:28sadists that love to just hurt my feelings. It's very strange. It's like
- 1:10:33they know exactly what to say or often they do that can hurt my feelings.
- 1:10:40I mean, how do they know how to do that. It's because
- 1:10:42they have built their life to some extent around learning how to harm people because
- 1:10:47it makes them feel good. They get a lot of pleasure going online and
- 1:10:51tearing people down. A lot of people think that, you know, they'll
- 1:10:57go on the internet and they'll just be like, man, the human race
- 1:10:59is seriously fed up. But that is not an accurate representation of the human
- 1:11:03race. The vast majority of people online don't comment at all. It's only
- 1:11:10the sadists in general that tend to comment, and so all those comments are
- 1:11:15sadists that are in the confines of their own homes and have the anonymity of
- 1:11:19the Internet to be able to do things that they couldn't do in real life
- 1:11:25because if they did this in real life, they'd get their ass kicked or
- 1:11:28they'd go to jail or something. So the Internet is this place where they
- 1:11:32have free reign to be as sadistic as they want, and they do it
- 1:11:36all day long because they take so much pleasure in it. So it's just
- 1:11:41another way of looking at Internet trolls and YouTube comments. So other constructs that
- 1:11:46are often in the literature are sexual sadism and satomasochism and sadistic personality disorder.
- 1:11:55So these are all different from just having a sadistic personality or a sadistic personality
- 1:12:00trait. Again, I won't go into too much detail, but sexual sadism
- 1:12:05refers to the sexual arousal by making other people suffer. So sexual sadists are
- 1:12:13often rapists, or at least they have fantasies of rape. So sexual sadists
- 1:12:17specifically get pleasure from sexually harming other people, which is different from just general
- 1:12:24sadism. And then this is also different, I think, very different from
- 1:12:28sato masochism or s and M as you might have heard in you know,
- 1:12:31the kink community. Some A lot of times in literature, sadism and sato
- 1:12:36masochism get sort of lumped into the same thing, and I really think that
- 1:12:40that's irresponsible, and I think that they're very different things because S and M
- 1:12:45is consensual. People like to play out these roles where they are a sadist
- 1:12:53or they are being you know, you know, dominated by someone else.
- 1:12:58That's the masochistic part. But it's all consensual, you know, if you
- 1:13:01enter into a consensual S and M relationship. To me, there's nothing sadistic
- 1:13:05about that. It's role playing. People like to role play all sorts of
- 1:13:10things. They like to play all sorts of games and it feels good.
- 1:13:13But that's quite a different thing. I mean, if you took, in
- 1:13:15my estimation, the people that I know that do S and M, if
- 1:13:18you took any one of those people and actually ask them to actually harm another
- 1:13:23person, they wouldn't be able to do it because they have a normal conscience.
- 1:13:27So sato masochism, in my mind, is quite different from sadism.
- 1:13:31Now, can a sadist take part in the kink community in S and M
- 1:13:38behavior, Absolutely, But to confound sato masochism with sadism, I think is
- 1:13:44oppressive to the kink community. Also, the last one here is sadistic personality
- 1:13:49disorder. This was something that used to be in I believe the DSM three
- 1:13:54and you know, and that was could put early nineties mid nineties. The
- 1:14:00three went out of style and back then they actually had a personality disorder called
- 1:14:04sadistic personality disorder. Why they took it out, I have no idea,
- 1:14:09because it's not as if they replaced it with anything. Maybe they just subsumed
- 1:14:13it under antisocial I don't know, but it seems to me like it would
- 1:14:16have been a good idea to keep it or at least have it return.
- 1:14:20But anyway, and the last thing that I'll say about the literature regarding all
- 1:14:26these topics is that there's not much research in this area in sadism. I
- 1:14:30think people are frightened of sadism, so they don't go into it very often.
- 1:14:35Plus it's not in vogue right now, so I know, there's just
- 1:14:39not a lot of research. So if you're planning on doing some research,
- 1:14:42I recommend looking into sadism because there's probably a lot of gaps in the research
- 1:14:45that you could fill. There are a number of psychological instruments or surveys or
- 1:14:53measures that have been developed by researchers to measure whether or not someone is sadistic.
- 1:15:00There are two of them that I found. One that's called the Comprehensive
- 1:15:03Assessment of Sadistic Tendencies or the CAST. Another one is the Short Sadistic Impulse
- 1:15:10Scale, which is a self report tool that seems to work. So again,
- 1:15:15you give someone a survey and you ask them a bunch of questions,
- 1:15:18and depending on their answers, you determine whether or not that person is sadistic.
- 1:15:25So just looking at some of the questions on the CAST or the Comprehensive
- 1:15:31Assessment of Sadistic Tendencies, So these are some of the questions and the respondent
- 1:15:36is asked to rate from one to five, with one being strongly disagree in
- 1:15:42five being strongly agree. So this assessment measure, it measures whether or not
- 1:15:51someone is sadistic, but it also tries to figure out what type of sadists
- 1:15:56they are, whether or not they're a direct verbal sort of where they're you
- 1:16:00know, meaning they like to directly verbally harm other people, whether they're a
- 1:16:04direct physical type of satist meaning they like to directly physically harm other people,
- 1:16:11or whether they're a vicarious satist, meaning they like to watch other people harm
- 1:16:15other people. So questions within the direct verbal sadist type are things like I
- 1:16:21was purposely mean to some people in high school. So if they rate this
- 1:16:27one towards the strongly agree side of things, this could indicate that they are
- 1:16:30a direct verbal satist. The five other questions here are I enjoy making jokes
- 1:16:36at the expense of others. I have purposely tricked someone and laughed when they
- 1:16:41looked foolish. When making fun of someone, it is especially amusing if they
- 1:16:45realize what I'm doing. Perhaps I shouldn't have, but I never got tired
- 1:16:51of mocking certain classmates. I would never purposely humiliate someone. So the reverse
- 1:17:00is the indicator of whether or not someone is a sadist. So this is
- 1:17:04these are all verbal direct sadist sorts of behaviors, going into the direct physical
- 1:17:12type of sadism. I enjoy physically hurting people. I enjoy tormenting people.
- 1:17:17I have the right to push certain people around. I have dominated others using
- 1:17:23fear. I enjoy hurting my partner during sex or pretending to. So these
- 1:17:29are all indications of someone being a direct physical sadist and of the vicarious questions
- 1:17:38are the following. In video games, I like the realistic blood spurts.
- 1:17:43I like the realistic blood spurts, so that's kind of interesting. I love
- 1:17:46to watch YouTube clips of people fighting. I enjoy watching cage fighting or mma
- 1:17:54where there is no escape. I sometimes replay my favorite scenes from gory slasher
- 1:17:59film. I enjoy playing the villain in games and torturing other characters in professional
- 1:18:05car racing. It's the accidents that I enjoy the most. So upon reading
- 1:18:11these questions, I'm a little bothered by them because a lot of people,
- 1:18:16a lot of people like gory video games for instance. You know, it
- 1:18:20seems it seems like this vicarious sadus category will capture a lot of people that
- 1:18:28I personally would probably not characterize as sadistic, but that they just like to
- 1:18:33watch a lot of violence, you know, because I consider these kinds of
- 1:18:39behaviors like watching YouTube clips of people fighting and watching you know, ultimate fighting,
- 1:18:44very different from actually enjoying physically harming other people. I mean, these
- 1:18:47are two very different acts. So I don't know if I like this this
- 1:18:53vicarious things. I mean to me, what would indicate vicarious sadism is if
- 1:19:00you liked watching beheading videos and really got off on it and got a tremendous
- 1:19:06amount of pleasure from watching you know, the faces of death and people actually
- 1:19:13being beaten. You know. For instance, for myself, I don't watch
- 1:19:16videos on the internet that I know will have actual people being hurt because I'm
- 1:19:23traumatized by it. But but if I actually liked watching these things and really
- 1:19:28got off on it, then you know, I would say that's an indication
- 1:19:32of sadism. But watching cage fighting, I mean, I don't think that's
- 1:19:38a strong, in my opinion, indicator of sadism. Well so, but
- 1:19:43maybe if they can, you know, aggregate all these questions together and they
- 1:19:46score high on a lot of them, maybe that's an indication. So I
- 1:19:50don't know. So just some stats on sadism. Men, according to research,
- 1:19:56are more likely to be sadistic, but make no mistake about it,
- 1:19:59women can be sadistic too. According to a review of lots of the literature,
- 1:20:04it seems about thirty or forty percent of sadists are women, which might
- 1:20:09surprise people. So again, getting back to Joffrey, we can definitely say
- 1:20:14he was sadistic, right, I mean, he clearly enjoyed hurting and terrorizing
- 1:20:17other people. He didn't do this because he had to. He didn't do
- 1:20:20it for political reasons. He did it purely because he liked to do it.
- 1:20:25I mean, everyone didn't even want him to do it. You know,
- 1:20:28when he cut off ned Stark's head or ordered someone to do it,
- 1:20:31everyone was saying, no, don't do that. It's terrible his own mom,
- 1:20:34everyone's but and politically, it's going to be terrible for you. But
- 1:20:36he just wanted to see Ned Stark get beheaded. He loved it, and
- 1:20:41you know when they depict it in the TV show, he just loves it,
- 1:20:44you know, even though it didn't serve him. Well, so what
- 1:20:47does the literature say regarding the causes of sadism. Well, some say,
- 1:20:54and there's some emerging research indicating this that genetics and brain by all play a
- 1:21:00role in the cause of sadism. I found some research that indicates that sadists
- 1:21:06don't have different childhoods from non sadists. So a common belief is, oh,
- 1:21:13he's a sadist, Well, his childhood must have been horrible, right,
- 1:21:15It's a very common belief. In our culture. But some research is
- 1:21:20coming out saying that sadists don't have different childhoods from anyone else. You know,
- 1:21:26when you take sadists and assess their childhoods, they're just as likely to
- 1:21:31have abuse or ideal childhoods as a non sadist would. So that's interesting.
- 1:21:42Some people postulate that it's normal to be slightly sadistic, and that sadistic acts
- 1:21:48are pleasurable because the brain is seeking equilibrium. So to go into some explanation
- 1:21:55on this, we might have evolved to cope with the stress of harming other
- 1:22:00people by developing a pleasure reaction to counterbalance the inner pain of harming other people.
- 1:22:08So, you know, just to put it into Caveman terms, if
- 1:22:12you have a group of people and they need to you know, assert their
- 1:22:17territory by harming a rival tribe, they have to actually potentially kill other people
- 1:22:27and do it effectively without any remorse. And so in those circumstances, because
- 1:22:34I mean, normally speaking, us humans don't like harming other people because we
- 1:22:41are rewarded for being nice and we're punished in our brains for being mean to
- 1:22:46people. But sometimes, you know, tribe on tribe wars happen, and
- 1:22:50you have to be mean to another tribe, and so, so our brains
- 1:22:54might have evolved a mechanism to reward us with a little bit of pleasure upon
- 1:23:00harming people in certain situations. You know, you can imagine after killing the
- 1:23:05rival tribe, everyone jumping around and celebrating and feeling elated. Well, that
- 1:23:12might be because of an evolved psychological mechanism that helps us in that situation.
- 1:23:16Because if we treated all humans with the same morals that we treat our own
- 1:23:24families, then you could see another tribe coming along and eliminating you. And
- 1:23:30so. And there's a lot of speculation that I'm putting forth because maybe tribes
- 1:23:34didn't actually exist like this in the past, But I think you get my
- 1:23:38point. So, this psychological mechanism of rewarding us for harming other people in
- 1:23:45normal people is very small, meaning that the mechanism only kicks in under certain
- 1:23:51circumstances, whereas with satis it might kick in all the time. So it
- 1:23:57might be kind of a broken psychological mechanism, an overactive reward mechanism for harming
- 1:24:04other people that should only be reserved for specific incidents of harming other people,
- 1:24:10if that makes any sense. And this mechanism might be the reason why we
- 1:24:15love to watch sports so much, and we love to play video games so
- 1:24:18much, and we love violent films so much because we get a little charge
- 1:24:25of pleasure harming other people and watching people get harmed, because again, our
- 1:24:30brain is trying to reward us for the assertion of our tribal territory. But
- 1:24:36this is at best speculation at this point. More research is definitely needed along
- 1:24:43these lines. And there are a lot of authors over the years that talked
- 1:24:47about this, about sadism, Freud going way back to the early nineteen hundreds
- 1:24:54talked about how aggression originates from the death instinct. I won't go into that,
- 1:24:59but but to me, all of them are just providing speculation because it's
- 1:25:03so difficult to determine the cause of human behavior. I mean, the brain
- 1:25:08is such a complex thing, and human behavior is so complex it's difficult to
- 1:25:13reduce it to a simple explanation. Okay, so that is my analysis of
- 1:25:18Jeoffrey Brathian. I was thinking about doing a number of episodes on Game of
- 1:25:25Thrones because I love the books, because I've read them. I mean,
- 1:25:29I you know, listen to them. So if you're interested, let me
- 1:25:33know and I will do other Game of Thrones analyses and if you have a
- 1:25:39particular topic you want me to do, let me know. You can email
- 1:25:42me at contact at Psychologyinseattle dot com. That's contact at Psychology Inseattle dot com,
- 1:25:47or you can go to our website Psychology Incatta dot com and go to
- 1:25:51the contact us page. You can also donate, which is always nice,
- 1:25:56nice way to show your appreciation. Running this show does cost a certain amount
- 1:26:00of money and I have yet to make back the money that I've spent on
- 1:26:04it, so it'd be nice if you donated, and also just be nice
- 1:26:09to hear from you, to hear what your thoughts are. I often wonder
- 1:26:13what people are thinking as I'm talking. You know, I'm talking away and
- 1:26:16you're listening away with your earbuds in, and I'm just wondering what's going on
- 1:26:20in your head, because if you're in the room with me, I'd be
- 1:26:21like, what do you think of that? And you'd be like, I
- 1:26:24think that's stupid, and you're a dumb person. So sometimes I wonder what's
- 1:26:30going on in your mind, So please email and let me know. So
- 1:26:34what's the final word on Jeoffrey. I will say that when I experienced him
- 1:26:40in the books and in the TV show, I hated him. I had
- 1:26:45no compassion for the guy. But when I actually started to analyze his life
- 1:26:50and look at the circumstances in his life, I started to have a little
- 1:26:56bit more compassion for him. I don't have any compassion for his actions.
- 1:27:00He was a terrible, evil human being, and the world of Restros is
- 1:27:04better off with him dead. But I can see possibly why he would have
- 1:27:10been the way that he was, and he had some struggles, he had
- 1:27:15some issues that he had to get through, and when I look at him
- 1:27:18as if he were a client, I do have compassion for him, and
- 1:27:24I do wonder what things would have been like if his father wasn't abusive,
- 1:27:30if his parents' relationship was stronger, if he wasn't raised as a prince,
- 1:27:35and if he wasn't raised in a spoiled way. I wonder what he would
- 1:27:42have been like. Would he have been different? I think, so it's
- 1:27:45just a guess. Of course, he's a fictional character and this is all
- 1:27:48ridiculous, and so I will end with that. Well, that does it
- 1:27:53for another episode of psychology. In Seattle. Thanks for joining me and please
- 1:27:59take care of yourself. Apper were too