Latest / Eyes Wide Open with Nick Thompson / Control and Agency on Reality TV Sets with Professor Tim Wilson
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, everyone.
- 0:00Before we get to today's shows, I just want to ask you for your support.
- 0:03The UCAN Foundation has partnered with MoveOn.org to launch a petition that demands that Netflix and other reality shows put a disclaimer on the front of all unscripted shows.
- 0:17And that disclaimer says that all episodes are for entertainment purposes only, and any content can be edited, manipulated, and presented in any other way for storyline purposes.
- 0:27So please, if you can, check out the link in the description right here.
- 0:31Go add your name to support, and let's get this petition out to Netflix and start making some real change in the industry.
- 0:36Thank you for your support, and thank you for your signature.
- 0:39Now, let's enjoy the show.
- 0:41The people who cast us knew what they were doing.
- 0:43Yeah.
- 0:46I can see immediately why you were cast.
- 0:48You can probably see why I was cast.
- 0:51And we might resent the way it worked, but that's because of the evil in the system, not because reality TV itself is...
- 1:02essentially malign.
- 1:03I don't think it is.
- 1:04I think it could be a force for good.
- 1:06I think so too.
- 1:07Democratized television.
- 1:09Are you going through life blind?
- 1:11This is Eyes Wide Open with Nick Thompson.
- 1:13On this podcast, we share knowledge and stories that build human connection while elevating stigmatized societal issues such as mental health, holistic wellness, culture, free speech, and more, all to ensure we show up in the world with our eyes wide open.
- 1:30Hello everyone, welcome to this week's episode of Eyes Wide Open.
- 1:33Before we get started, I just want to remind you,
- 1:36Again, please like, share, subscribe, leave a review.
- 1:39But I also want to thank all of you who have and all of you who are loyal listeners.
- 1:42The show has been growing.
- 1:43We've been doing some really good interviews lately.
- 1:45And all of these things help us get better interviews.
- 1:49They help us in the algorithm.
- 1:50They help get the word out.
- 1:51And they hopefully help more and more people go through life with their eyes wide open.
- 1:55But today's episode is a very special episode because I have Professor Tim Wilson, who is a
- 2:03really compelling and really interesting human being.
- 2:06He was also cast on season two of the circle.
- 2:09Not only was he cast on it, but he was a finalist and a winner on the show.
- 2:16But guess what?
- 2:18not treated like a human being.
- 2:20And it blows my mind that it's 2023.
- 2:24And I still have to say, every time I conduct one of these interviews or I go on an interview myself, I have to say, we're human beings.
- 2:31Everyone's a human being and we deserve to have basic human rights, basic labor practices, basic representation.
- 2:38But this issue in reality TV is much bigger than I ever thought it was.
- 2:43It's much more systemic than I ever thought it was.
- 2:45And every time...
- 2:47a new story or a new headline comes out, which they seem to be coming like a waterfall lately.
- 2:51It's just a pleasant reminder.
- 2:53I guess maybe an unpleasant reminder that this is a completely unproductive.
- 2:59unmanaged, unregulated, wild, wild west, and people are being completely neglected as human beings.
- 3:08So we're going to talk to Tim, we're going to learn a little bit about Tim, we're going to learn about how he ended up on the circle, how he ended up winning the circle, and everything that he's been through, personally, professionally, and the impacts of reality TV on him.
- 3:20So I hope you hear his story, and it helps you watch reality TV and think about how we view these shows with
- 3:31hello everyone welcome to today's episode of eyes wide open my guest today is professor tim wilson tim is a professor at moscow state pedagogic university he's a writer film director of five animated award-winning films former or as i say recovering politician and a finalist of season two of the circle tim welcome thanks for coming on the show
- 3:53Yeah, you suggest I've done rather more than I realize I've done, but I still don't.
- 3:58I think it's a work in progress.
- 4:01I'm even writing as well.
- 4:02I started writing an autobiography.
- 4:03Ah.
- 4:05Yeah, no, no, no.
- 4:07One day it will get produced.
- 4:10And I've written some novels.
- 4:11They won't get produced.
- 4:12They're just sort of...
- 4:13Fan fiction, or for you?
- 4:15Well, not fan fiction.
- 4:19They're just scurrilous, scurrilous, scurrilous.
- 4:21And I've gone back into the theatre, by the way.
- 4:24Oh, you have?
- 4:25Yeah, I've been... Last year I did... We have this wonderful form of theatre in Britain called Pantomime, which is just pure filth, really.
- 4:33You stand on the front of the stage and you talk directly to the audience.
- 4:36It's so nice.
- 4:37I kind of like it.
- 4:39Yeah, it's wonderful.
- 4:40We use sort of fairy tales as a basic thing.
- 4:42Julie Andrews started her career doing that.
- 4:45She was an egg in Humpty Dumpty.
- 4:48And I was an old man in a thing called Dick Whittington, which has a lot of opportunity for double entendre.
- 4:58Ah, okay.
- 4:59I've got very good at keeping very straight-faced when somebody is saying something to me, or when I'm saying something which is just...
- 5:10I really enjoy it except the costume last year the costumes were so heavy and we had a whole troupe of dancers dancing around I was terrified I was going to get run over on stage and we had so little rehearsal and three shows a day you know that is how do you perform three shows a day it's like going to the gym so then I got to ask you how do you go to the gym three times a day
- 5:35Well, I don't.
- 5:37I don't.
- 5:38You know, I... God, and your voice... You can barely keep your voice going.
- 5:43And we had COVID as well and train strikes.
- 5:45So at one point, we had almost no-one in the theatre because the train strikes killed off the audience.
- 5:49But it's what... Pantomime is what...
- 5:53Almost every single town and city...
- 5:56have pantomimes in Britain for about a month over Christmas, and it's what keeps the theatre alive.
- 6:02And it's very traditional.
- 6:03It goes back to the mid-Victorian period.
- 6:07It's got nothing to do with the tradition of pantomime, of performing without saying something.
- 6:12In fact, we say a great deal.
- 6:14It's the British understanding.
- 6:16It's the way the British made sense of Commedia dell'arte.
- 6:22They just mixed it up with what we call musical, what you would call Bordeaux, what other people would just call pure filth, and put it on as family entertainment.
- 6:32And it's wonderful.
- 6:34And there are jokes which, of course, the small children won't get, and the adults titter along.
- 6:40Those are the best jokes.
- 6:42And then there's a lot of slapstick, and I love slapstick.
- 6:46I really love it.
- 6:48I got hit a few times, which is great.
- 6:50And you have these incredibly fast costume changes.
- 6:56I can imagine.
- 6:59It was great fun, and I got a chance to do some of my accents.
- 7:02And in the second half of the show, I was the director of Love Island, which is a reality TV show.
- 7:08How ironic.
- 7:09I was supposed to play him as a, I think, as a Spaniard, and I thought, no, no, I can't do that.
- 7:16But I played him initially as a Greek, and then my voice started to go.
- 7:20So I think I ended up playing him as a Russian, and finally I played him as an Albanian, which I rather enjoyed.
- 7:27I love Albania.
- 7:30I love Russia.
- 7:31I love Greece.
- 7:32So I felt all of those imitations were...
- 7:37You know, I was punching up rather than punching down.
- 7:41Always a good place to be.
- 7:43And the thing I wanted to punch down about was, of course, reality TV.
- 7:46And I took a few, I had a few quips about reality TV, about The Circle.
- 7:51There was a line there, oh, I'm going to stay at home and watch repeats of The Circle.
- 7:58That's a television program that nobody watches.
- 8:01And I quite enjoyed that line.
- 8:03It's all in the delivery, right?
- 8:05It was all in the delivery.
- 8:07Yeah.
- 8:07I have to ask you, because I ask all my guests this, and it's my favorite question to ask them.
- 8:12And considering right before we hopped on this call, and I forgot to put it in when I was introducing you, you spent time as a monk, too.
- 8:20So we'll dive into that just for a few minutes.
- 8:22But before we do that, you are such a fascinating individual.
- 8:25And I told you before we started recording that as I was researching for the episode, I was...
- 8:32blown away by all of your life experiences and how interesting and diverse they were.
- 8:38But when you were growing up, what did you want to be when you were growing up?
- 8:42How'd that change?
- 8:43I wanted to be an animator.
- 8:45And I've become that in many ways.
- 8:47I saw my hero when I was 11 years old.
- 8:52I wrote to him.
- 8:53He got an Oscar.
- 8:54I wrote to him immediately, and he invited me up to – in fact, do you see Who Framed Roger Rabbit behind you?
- 8:59You don't see it.
- 9:00Yeah, I do see it.
- 9:01The blue jacket.
- 9:03He was the animation director on that, a fellow called Richard Williams.
- 9:06He was simply wonderful.
- 9:08And he invited me up to his studio when I was 11, and we remained in touch.
- 9:14And I did bits and pieces for him and with him.
- 9:17And I think my work is very much derivative of his.
- 9:23You know, he died about two years ago.
- 9:27He was very much one of my mentors and one of my heroes.
- 9:29And I just think it's so lovely when children can meet their hero.
- 9:33And I got slightly thrown off the tracks as I was growing up.
- 9:38Well, I got to meet one of my heroes a couple months ago.
- 9:40And you know what the thing about heroes?
- 9:44They have a tendency to let you down.
- 9:48And I loved your story because yours followed through.
- 9:51Not only did he respond to your letter, but he invited you into his studio and he mentored you.
- 9:55Like, that's a wonderful story to hear.
- 9:58Yeah, well, he wasn't the only one.
- 9:59I mean, when I went to university, I wrote to lots and lots of people I admired.
- 10:04And they all wrote back to me.
- 10:06And I shared a house with quite a famous poet.
- 10:10who was mad.
- 10:11She was completely loony.
- 10:12But we both had correspondence with one of the greatest actors in Britain.
- 10:19He was a fellow called John Gielgud, who was in a wonderful film called Arthur.
- 10:24He was the butler in Arthur, who came in and in a very pompous way would deliver these
- 10:31The sort of rather arch and rather naughty lines.
- 10:36And he was amazing.
- 10:39He didn't really discover film properly until he was much older.
- 10:44And then he did bit parts all over the place.
- 10:47Okay.
- 10:48But he was astonishing.
- 10:50And I think he was very useful as well.
- 10:53And I think of these people when I'm either performing or drawing.
- 10:58And I think, you know, these people...
- 11:01That was my education.
- 11:02I had a very good academic education as well, but my education as an animator was hands-on.
- 11:08My education as an actor was hands-on.
- 11:11And it's really the acting and the animating that's taken over.
- 11:18And somebody in a school, I went into a school, and somebody rather condescendingly said, oh, you draw for a hobby.
- 11:27And I said, no, I teach for a hobby.
- 11:30Which I think is getting it in the right place.
- 11:33And so when I went on to reality TV, I think they hadn't fully realized I was very comfortable with cameras.
- 11:41So I knew how to deal with a camera.
- 11:47And I'm one of the, I think I come to life a bit.
- 11:50Yeah, well, you're a performer.
- 11:52And I moved away from performing and I moved into directing and designing.
- 11:56So I understood how it worked.
- 11:58And there were times in the circle when I was on this show, I never volunteered to be on it.
- 12:03I never applied.
- 12:04I wanted to ask, how did they find you and track you down?
- 12:07Because you were headhunted basically for it.
- 12:10Everybody was.
- 12:10I mean, but the... Not everybody, but almost everybody.
- 12:14But I'd made a YouTube video called How to Write a Good Essay.
- 12:19If you ever want to write...
- 12:20If you ever want to find me, or if you ever want to write a good essay, if you've got to do any academic work, you write.
- 12:24How to write a good essay in YouTube.
- 12:26And I pop up immediately, and it made me...
- 12:30It gave me that sort of YouTube presence.
- 12:32I think, you know, I've got millions of followers from millions of hits from that.
- 12:38And I think they thought that I would be I would go on the show.
- 12:41I'd be the old fart who'd get knocked off quite quickly.
- 12:43And then they realized I was I was comfortable.
- 12:46I was really comfortable.
- 12:48I don't know what it was like for you.
- 12:50And when I went into the circle and when I went on to the set, I
- 12:53I just felt at home and I thought, you know, I've been avoiding going back to acting for so many years.
- 13:00And actually this is something I feel very comfortable doing.
- 13:03And acting yourself is still acting, which I think is something British equity needs to get his head round.
- 13:09Well, I think we could have a whole episode on that because I agree with you.
- 13:13You are 100% working, performing, whatever you want to call it, while you are on these shows for so many hours.
- 13:22In a quick elevator type pitch, what is the circle and how does it work and what happens to you when you're filming?
- 13:28It's a sort of debased Big Brother, but you're kept in a single apartment.
- 13:32You have to interact with other people on the show through a television screen and a specially constructed social media format.
- 13:41You never see them.
- 13:43So a lot of the other people who you are talking to could well be catfishing.
- 13:47That was a word that I was introduced to.
- 13:49That means pretending to be somebody that you aren't.
- 13:52And I was myself because they thought that...
- 13:56The more they learned about me, the more they realized that it wasn't very believable.
- 14:01And I was very happy with that.
- 14:03And because I've been an academic and because I've listened to, I've read, I've digested people's writing...
- 14:12I believe I can tell when somebody is older, when somebody is younger, when somebody is male, when somebody is female, just by looking at the text.
- 14:20So I not only knew that people were fake, I could tell their gender.
- 14:25Wow.
- 14:27And I thought it was hilarious.
- 14:30There was one character who was... a girl who was pretending to be her son,
- 14:38who is a bricklayer, a builder.
- 14:42And not only did I know that the son was not real, but I also knew that he was his mother.
- 14:50And production was constantly asking me, oh, yes, I've got to say, in these shows, there's a particular job called Voice of God.
- 15:00I don't know if... Did you have a Voice of God?
- 15:03We did not have a voice.
- 15:04Well, you know, we did.
- 15:06We did at some points, kind of, when you were in the pods, which is where you talk to each other through a wall.
- 15:12Every now and then someone would come in and be like, stop talking about that.
- 15:15Sit up straight.
- 15:33which we call blocking, you know, constipation.
- 15:39And I always thought it'd be great fun, when the circle re-airs, it should be sponsored by Ducalax or something.
- 15:49You'll never get blocked with Ducalax.
- 15:52You can't hear that, can you?
- 15:53Because that's advertising.
- 15:55But anyway, Ducalax, when you've really got to go.
- 16:00LAUGHTER
- 16:04Leave the circle with a plumb and a splash.
- 16:09Anyway, but they did, because they had me up there doing this blocking conversation at about three o'clock in the morning when I was really tired.
- 16:19So one of the things that happens in all of these shows is your phone is taken away.
- 16:24Your watch is taken away.
- 16:26If I wore one.
- 16:27And you very quickly lose a sense of time.
- 16:30You lose a sense of what hour it is.
- 16:32You lose a sense of how many days you've been there.
- 16:34I was there.
- 16:36I was incarcerated for about a month.
- 16:38We had one day a week off.
- 16:41But that day, we were still kept in the flat.
- 16:43How long did this go on for?
- 16:45A month.
- 16:46A month.
- 16:47So you were stuck in a house by yourself for a month.
- 16:51Yeah.
- 16:52Except it wasn't really by myself.
- 16:54I had runners coming in all the time.
- 16:56I had a psychiatrist coming in every time, sort of teasing more information out of me.
- 17:01Hi, the voice of God.
- 17:04Do you think that the psychologists were teasing information out of you to give back to production?
- 17:09A hundred percent.
- 17:11Yes.
- 17:12That's why I have concerns and are...
- 17:17Director of Mental Health Services at the UCAN Foundation, Dr. Isabel Morley, who is a psychologist and couples therapist, also has concerns that these are ethical issues at some point.
- 17:28These are ethical issues because what happens to you on these programs, particularly the longer you're sort of caught up in them, the longer you're trapped in them, imprisoned in them, the more you lose agency.
- 17:43And your agency is your ability to make decisions.
- 17:46So what happens is,
- 17:48It's a teacher trick that you learn very early on when you're a teacher, that if you want control in your classroom, if you don't want your children to rebel, you walk in and you tell them to do something that they're automatically going to do.
- 18:01And they do it, and they feel that they're being commanded to do it.
- 18:05Actually, you know, you're terrified they won't do it.
- 18:10Stand up, sit down, and put your hand up, and they'll all do it.
- 18:16So the initial attempt to get rid of your agency is to get you to do things that you would ordinarily do, like eat.
- 18:26And then you find they're encouraging you to eat at different times, or they're questioning what you're eating.
- 18:32You're also controlled about bathroom breaks, I think you would say, in the States.
- 18:36We would just talk about the loo, which is incomprehensible when you're in the States.
- 18:42Yeah, when I visited England, I have a good friend who lives in Harrogate, England.
- 18:49We should all have good friends in Harrogate.
- 18:52I love it over there.
- 18:54So we were getting ready to go out to dinner and I'm like, okay, before we go, I have to use the bathroom.
- 18:59And she lived here for a while.
- 19:01So she, she just forgot.
- 19:03So I come back down and they're sitting down and they've started a TV show.
- 19:07And, and I asked him like, well, I thought we were going like, oh, we thought you were taking a bath.
- 19:11Yeah.
- 19:12And I was like, no.
- 19:14They're like, oh, we just say the toilet.
- 19:16Like, I'm going to go use the toilet before we leave.
- 19:17Then we got all dressed up again and ended up going out to dinner.
- 19:21But anyway, yeah, yeah.
- 19:22So the bathroom breaks are, you can request them.
- 19:26Yeah, they wanted me to be extremely specific because they had a camera in the loo.
- 19:32What?
- 19:33They had a camera in the loo, which recorded us having a shower in the morning.
- 19:38Is that legal?
- 19:40Intimate.
- 19:41Well, it was focused on our head, but nevertheless, it was a bit sort of uncomfortable.
- 19:46And they had particular shots of us standing at the bathroom mirror talking.
- 19:54You know, it was to try and get different views.
- 19:57And they also had a camera which, if you left the bathroom door open, would look at you from behind and you get your reflection, all that sort of stuff.
- 20:05In order for the camera to crank out of view or to crank so it's looking upwards, that required quite a lot of effort.
- 20:16And there was another movement for the camera, I think, which was much easier.
- 20:20So you had to indicate what you were going to do in the bathroom.
- 20:24And I thought, there's no way I'm going to be giving you medical details.
- 20:28So I'm afraid I made it all into a sort of political joke.
- 20:32This is so abrasive.
- 20:34This is so abrasive.
- 20:36For me, a serious dump was a Farage.
- 20:39Mr. Farage ran a thing that produced Brexit, and I tried very hard in my small political career to get rid of Farage, and I found it very entertaining.
- 20:48In fact, it did make the final cut.
- 20:50I think I made some comment about this is worth a Farage, or I feel so nervous I'm going to have a Farage immediately, or something like that.
- 21:01Anyway, Farage now, I hope, will enter the dictionary as a...
- 21:06as a faecal moment.
- 21:08And the alternative was a Whiddicombe.
- 21:12Now, Anne Whiddicombe was an extraordinarily, is an extraordinarily bumptious lady who's also very keen on Brexit.
- 21:18And I thought, Whiddicombe, it just sounds like what it is, doesn't it?
- 21:22A quick Whiddicombe, and then I'll be out.
- 21:24But sometimes, I'm afraid, sometimes they'd say, oh, that was very fuss.
- 21:27I said, yes, it was just a lot of Theresa May.
- 21:30Theresa May was one of our worst prime ministers.
- 21:33Just hot air.
- 21:35So I enjoyed that, but it took me a few minutes to work out, you know, what I was going to say, because there was no way I was going to be medical.
- 21:47Did you feel...
- 21:49I can't believe you were there a month.
- 21:51I'm trying to wrap my head about... All of this ramping up continues.
- 21:56So once they've got you obedient and compliant, then they just keep... Then they can make suggestions.
- 22:04Like, surely you wanted to block Brooke.
- 22:08Surely you said you wanted... And at 3 o'clock in the morning, you don't remember.
- 22:11And the fans say, oh, we liked Professor Tim, but we didn't like it when you blocked your best friend.
- 22:18Why did you do that?
- 22:19And I said,
- 22:19think I have no idea why I did that I didn't want to do that I was clearly and I remember the conversations I remember I remember the prompting and I you know clearly they've got it in mind that that's what they were going to push me into doing and I remember at one point I had to block somebody and I was absolutely refusing to do it and I said I know what I'm going to do I'm going to
- 22:44Bum, bum, bum, bum, bum, bum, bum, bum, bum.
- 22:46Tim!
- 22:47And the entire production stopped for about two hours, and we were left in this little room, two of us on either side of a room, split by a wall so we couldn't see each other.
- 22:56Yeah.
- 22:58With alcohol.
- 22:59Oh, there's always alcohol.
- 23:01We were left for two hours.
- 23:02There was a lot of alcohol in those meetings.
- 23:05So there's alcohol late at night and voices from God.
- 23:08I mean, why are you not going to be persuaded to do things you don't really want to do?
- 23:13At that point, you just want to go to bed.
- 23:15And I wanted to get my cat and take my cat back to bed and just cuddle up for the night.
- 23:21How many hours a day were you guys being recorded, do you think?
- 23:23Well, Brooke, this wonderful girl who I eventually blocked, was a cook.
- 23:30She cooked.
- 23:30And she had a weighing scales, which she brought in with her, which had a timer on it and nobody realized.
- 23:39And so she was able to see what the time was.
- 23:41And she insisted that we were working until 3.30, 4 o'clock in the morning.
- 23:45And then they discovered that she had a timer and they took it away.
- 23:48I know that we, having been a monk, I'm quite good at waking up early in the morning, so I would wake up early.
- 23:58and they wouldn't let me get out of bed.
- 23:59And I certainly had time to go through the entire song sheet of great musicals.
- 24:08I did a musical a day.
- 24:10Did you guys get, like, windows or sunlight or anything?
- 24:12There were windows, but we were told to keep away from the windows, of course.
- 24:16There were real windows.
- 24:17I mean, it was a real block of flats.
- 24:20And they were worried that, you know, that we could see fans outside because it was going out in almost real time.
- 24:27It was.
- 24:28I didn't know that.
- 24:29Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 24:30This wasn't...
- 24:32I think some of the episodes went out literally in real time, but I think the majority went out... We were filmed and then we were edited, and it was out the following day.
- 24:44Holy cow.
- 24:45It was very, very intense, which means, of course, when they took decisions, that this conversation wasn't very relevant, and then when it became relevant later, they couldn't go back.
- 24:55So I had one great friendship with a fellow called Cy, who was a farmer, and I'd had a background in farming when I was a child.
- 25:02So we had conversations about Massey Ferguson tractors and castrating animals.
- 25:07And maybe it was a little niche, but we had quite a lot of these conversations.
- 25:11None of them went out.
- 25:12Wow.
- 25:13And when he was blocked by me,
- 25:16He was asked, you know, who would you like to go and see?
- 25:18And he said, I want to see Tim.
- 25:20And they said, no, no, no, surely you want to see this girl or you want to see that girl.
- 25:23And he said, no, I want to see Tim.
- 25:25And eventually he came to see me.
- 25:26But the audience couldn't work out why he wanted to see me, because they'd not had any evidence of any relationship between us, because the producers had decided it was too niche.
- 25:36So it made no sense.
- 25:37It made no sense.
- 25:39That's something I think, and this is why we have a petition, right?
- 25:44Which we're asking, we're working with moveon.org to petition to have a disclaimer put at the beginning of every reality TV episode indicating that these are highly edited for entertainment purposes and that what you're seeing is not a representation of reality.
- 26:01And I think when people watch these shows...
- 26:04I don't know, some people square the circle, but some people watch them and they're like, oh, well this didn't seem right.
- 26:09Or they don't stop and take the moment to reflect on, maybe what I'm seeing here isn't in context or isn't in the order of events that happened.
- 26:20When you start talking to people, because I was trying to take, you're trying to take legal action, I'm trying to take political action.
- 26:28I want serious political changes
- 26:31And I'm trying to take political action too, just to let you know that.
- 26:36We need to be working together because I don't know how much further I can take this in the UK because our present government is so hostile to the idea of any form of change.
- 26:46They've made their modest change.
- 26:49But in fact, what they've done is to give more power to production.
- 26:52So I think, number one, yes, we need to establish very clearly that what you've got is an edited version of reality.
- 26:59Even if you've got something like Big Brother where there's cameras on you all the time, you're still making a choice about which camera you're showing to the audience.
- 27:05And that in itself tells a story.
- 27:08Exactly.
- 27:09You know, you've got the wonderful... Have you seen the wonderful Hitchcock thing?
- 27:15Hitchcock talks about the MacGuffin.
- 27:17Oh, yeah.
- 27:18I love Hitchcock.
- 27:19The MacGuffin is what we are involved in.
- 27:21That's what we are as contestants in a game.
- 27:24The game is the MacGuffin.
- 27:25No one's interested in the game.
- 27:27The game is the excuse to keep these people involved in some sort of activity while they're being observed and exploited.
- 27:37That's one side.
- 27:38Another thing that Hitchcock said, he said, he said, you take a photograph, you take a shot, you've got a shot of a man, it's a shot of him, and then he smiles.
- 27:51And in between those two shots, in between those two moments, from the shot of the man to the shot of the smile, you can put a picture of a baby.
- 27:58You think, nice man.
- 28:02But if instead of the baby, you put a picture of a girl in a bikini, you think dirty old man.
- 28:08That's so interesting and true.
- 28:11Now, the point is, the production company is in charge of which shots you see.
- 28:16So the production is always telling a story.
- 28:19It's never reality.
- 28:20It's always been filtered through the lens.
- 28:24And so if you are being you, not being me, you have to be aware of,
- 28:33that your performance is going to be transmitted through the lens.
- 28:37Now, if you're giving so much...
- 28:40that the lens can't look away from you.
- 28:42You're in a little bit more control.
- 28:46If you're initiating conversations, you're very weak.
- 28:49If you're responding to conversations, which is what...
- 28:52Which is the Hitchcock situation, the... Hmm.
- 28:56The camera just cannot...
- 28:58They cannot avoid that.
- 29:00And I realised in the circle I was very comfortable responding.
- 29:07And I was very comfortable deadpanning to somebody.
- 29:10You know, somebody said, oh, what's a MILF?
- 29:12And I said, did I know what a MILF was?
- 29:16I might have done at some point.
- 29:18But once I realized this was a comic moment, I thought, I just have to play along.
- 29:24And I could sort of see it being edited at the same time.
- 29:27Now, yeah, I didn't know what a MILF was, but I knew that it was a dirty word.
- 29:32And I knew once I'd started on that one, they were going to do others.
- 29:37And they did.
- 29:37And I just... You know what's interesting about that, though?
- 29:43From... And I didn't realize how quick yours was edited and put out.
- 29:47So ours took eight, nine, ten months to come out.
- 29:50And then you've got that period of anxiety.
- 29:53Oh, my gosh.
- 29:53You have no idea the toll that that took.
- 29:57right at the beginning of the reality TV story, kill themselves because they're so anxious about how they're going to be portrayed in that edit.
- 30:04Yeah.
- 30:06Well, and that's the whole thing is I remember when I read the contract and there's a section in the contract that says they can misfame you, edit out of order, blah, blah, blah.
- 30:14I remember thinking, I don't have to worry about that.
- 30:15I'm just going to be me and I don't do anything.
- 30:18You know, I act with integrity.
- 30:19I don't do anything outside of my values.
- 30:21I'll be fine.
- 30:22But then I've imagined and I didn't get a bad edit.
- 30:26There's things that are out of context, but I've talked to so many people that did get a villain edit.
- 30:31or did get a bad edit, or the way that they edited even my relationship and my ex-wife, it was very, there's no context.
- 30:41So at the very best case scenario, you're missing real context.
- 30:46And context matters.
- 30:48Yeah.
- 30:48Well, I mean, I got a spectacular edit.
- 30:53I don't think there's almost anything in the show that I personally wouldn't have put there out of choice.
- 31:00Right.
- 31:01I got such a good edit.
- 31:02I enjoyed the show enormously.
- 31:04I was very, very tired.
- 31:08You actually, wait, you enjoyed the experience?
- 31:10Yeah.
- 31:11Okay.
- 31:12Okay.
- 31:12Oh, yeah.
- 31:13No, no, no.
- 31:13I'm different to a lot of people who complain.
- 31:15A lot of people complain because they feel they've had a bad edit, which they have, because they feel something's been out of context.
- 31:22In fact, almost all my friends, when I talk to them or when I get them to talk to journalists or stuff, the whole thing goes awry because they start talking about their edit.
- 31:32No, that's not really the, that's important.
- 31:36That's part of it.
- 31:37It's not the primary.
- 31:39This explains in some ways, this is like the icing on the cake, which explains why they're upset.
- 31:45This is what they can see.
- 31:46But if you start digging underneath it, what they're really upset by is the loss of agency.
- 31:54Yes, I couldn't agree more.
- 31:56And it's difficult to articulate.
- 31:59Um, but, but, but it happens to all of us.
- 32:02So I, I had a really good edit.
- 32:05You had a relatively good edit, but we both lost agency.
- 32:09And I think that's where, where I get fired up and why I wanted to be part of the UCAN Foundation was I'm a very, I was a very, and you are, you're a wonderful advocate and, and becoming a friend.
- 32:22I think it's, it's so interesting to me because it took me so long after everything, um,
- 32:28So we filmed in 2021, April, May, and June.
- 32:31So two and a half years.
- 32:33But then the show came out last year, right?
- 32:35And then after The Altar, which is a follow-up three episodes, came out last fall.
- 32:40Then I got divorced, which leaked to TMZ before I told my family.
- 32:44So that was an incredibly stressful situation.
- 32:46A couple months later, I got...
- 32:49publicly slandered and defamed.
- 32:52And then I lost my job.
- 32:53And then I was, uh, heading into an interview with, uh, the same psychologist I mentioned earlier, Dr. Isabel Morley, who was writing a piece for psychology today.com, uh, on the impacts of reality TV on people.
- 33:10So I did the interview with Dr. Isabel and, um,
- 33:14It was over two days, I think, and we did a couple hours each day.
- 33:17And we went from the moment they reached out to me on LinkedIn, where they asked me if I was interested, all the way up to where I was at that moment.
- 33:26And that was the first time that I had done that because you're just in...
- 33:30The fire hose is coming.
- 33:31You're also in a pressure cooker.
- 33:33I was trying to make my marriage work.
- 33:35I was trying to keep my career afloat that I'd worked so hard for.
- 33:40I was battling.
- 33:41I have never even.
- 33:42So I've suffered from depression for most of my life.
- 33:45And I was battling depression.
- 33:47All of this stuff with that undertone, but also this deep despair of the end of my relationship and the end of my marriage.
- 33:57And what I don't think people understand, and we had different shows, right?
- 34:03Totally different.
- 34:04But what people don't understand, just because it happened on TV doesn't mean that it wasn't real.
- 34:11Absolutely.
- 34:12And I lost that.
- 34:13I'm losing a marriage and a relationship.
- 34:15I didn't just lose that.
- 34:16I lost this life with a new family, right?
- 34:21I had become very close with her family.
- 34:23She was becoming close with mine.
- 34:25And we had this...
- 34:27This entire life that we had started integrating together, and no matter how hard we tried, we just couldn't get it right.
- 34:33And there was this undertone of the show in everything, right?
- 34:37And it's the undertone of what do we do after they're not telling us what to do all the time once we get married, right?
- 34:43How do we explain...
- 34:45what we went through together, why we're married, like to friends and family and all these people that, you know, you disappear for a couple weeks, you come, we're going through all this without any support and any real support, some platitudes thrown around.
- 35:00Sure, I'll give them that.
- 35:02And- The platitudes were pretty awful, yeah.
- 35:04Yeah.
- 35:04And it was hard for us to even find a couples therapist on our own because it was COVID and therapists were working 10 hours a day.
- 35:11And God bless them for doing that because people needed it.
- 35:14But we were just going through this.
- 35:16And when I finally got to that interview with Dr. Isabel and I sat there, it was December 22nd, 2022.
- 35:22And I hung up with her and I, and it all hit me.
- 35:25And I said, this is the worst day of my life because I'm feeling everything going in.
- 35:30And I went in with such good intentions and I, and I didn't think about, I mean, I didn't disagree with, with like Jeremy's lawsuit, um, the lack of food and water.
- 35:41But I was like, I can't worry about that right now.
- 35:43I'm trying to fix my marriage, you know, but when I sat there and I didn't have a job.
- 35:47Yeah.
- 35:47and I didn't have a marriage, and it was all done in the public eye, and I really had to reflect on what this was, I realized how horrible it was.
- 35:56And I realized that it had taken me to a place that I hadn't been in a very long time, a place of despair, a place of depression, a place of, I don't know if I wanna be here anymore.
- 36:12Summed up by a lack of agency.
- 36:14It is.
- 36:15And I felt like everything for a year and a half just happened to me and I wasn't in any control of my life.
- 36:21And the lies which surround that, which the production throw at you and throw at the media about you, which is that, oh, you can't deal with fame.
- 36:32You can't deal with the loss of fame or the acquisition of that is rubbish.
- 36:36It's so stupid.
- 36:38But that is such a good get out clause for them.
- 36:41Oh, it is.
- 36:41But and it wasn't even it.
- 36:43That's the thing.
- 36:43It wasn't that it was I had all this loss.
- 36:46I was I was losing everything.
- 36:48I had worked so hard.
- 36:49I went I worked so hard to to get my career where it was.
- 36:53You're no longer in control of it.
- 36:55And it just goes through your fingers.
- 36:57I effectively I lost my job.
- 37:02Because I couldn't go back to my job after being exposed so much on the show.
- 37:09On the world stage.
- 37:12And they exposed things about me which I didn't agree to.
- 37:16Do you want to share some of those or would you prefer not to?
- 37:18Well, there's no need to at this moment.
- 37:21But, you know, they define me as gay.
- 37:25which I mean, I certainly don't deny it, but it's not what defines me.
- 37:33And teaching at a university in Russia where there were very, very harsh laws coming out, which have only got harsher, it put me at risk.
- 37:47That is a blatant disregard for your safety and a blatant disregard for your career, a blatant disregard for your, your personal wellness, like I, and, and your partner and your life.
- 38:06And it's just, well, I, I, I, my, my, my partner is, is, is, is vulnerable and, and, and they made sure that he was on the show as well.
- 38:15Although,
- 38:16You know, that wasn't the agreement.
- 38:20How did they get him on the show?
- 38:23Because they spoke to him on the telephone every single day.
- 38:29Did you know that was happening?
- 38:33No.
- 38:33I knew that he was going to get psychological support, but I certainly didn't know.
- 38:37I was horrified.
- 38:42That sort of pressure...
- 38:44I mean, it's bad enough if it's going on to me to go on to other members of my family.
- 38:50It's unacceptable.
- 38:51But...
- 38:53Without your knowledge.
- 38:54Without my knowledge.
- 38:56And that's part of the deal.
- 38:59I mean, the other thing they did, I had quite a nice little niche market for doing titles and little inserts for BBC shows.
- 39:12And effectively, they stopped me doing that because the animations.
- 39:17Yeah, I have finally started doing them again.
- 39:21Did they pull the the we contractually own you for X amount of days, months, years?
- 39:28No, it was never as clear as that.
- 39:32And the best I could say is it was a form of ghosting.
- 39:37And, you know, they called around.
- 39:40It also went down to the thing of sort of, I thought, well, if I'm not going to go back to my university, I ought to do theatre properly and I need an agent.
- 39:50And they said, oh, we'll be your agent.
- 39:52And I said, well, no, no, I need a real agent.
- 39:55And somebody on the show introduced me.
- 39:59And after a while, it became quite clear that they had to get permission from the company
- 40:04And then quietly, you know, it all became impossible.
- 40:07And it wasn't the only time it happened.
- 40:10It happened a few times.
- 40:12And I just thought, this is a nightmare.
- 40:15The GLP-1 pills you've been hearing about are on Rho.
- 40:18Yep, they're here.
- 40:19With clinically proven ingredients for weight loss, now in a pill, and now on Rho.
- 40:25Two FDA-approved GLP-1 pill options, both at the lowest cash pay price available.
- 40:30Get real results from a daily GLP-1 pill, now on Rho.
- 40:35To see if you qualify, go to Rho.co slash choices.
- 40:39Rx only.
- 40:39Go to Rho.co slash safety for serious side effects and boxed warning associated with GLP-1s.
- 40:45Oh, I'm so sorry.
- 40:48And you just think, how...
- 40:51I have no control.
- 40:53No.
- 40:55Because I can write and because I can articulate things, various newspapers, I think when the third series was coming out, asked me for interviews and one of them asked me, one or two of them I think asked me for opinion pieces which I wrote.
- 41:11I don't think I've ever actually put in my invoice, so I've never been paid for them.
- 41:17You wrote from a passionate place.
- 41:19But I wrote and I said that it's...
- 41:22This is 18 months of sheer hell.
- 41:25It was worse than being held at gunpoint, which has happened to me on three occasions.
- 41:28So I know exactly what I'm talking about.
- 41:31And then shortly after that, I hemorrhaged badly.
- 41:38I was whipped into hospital.
- 41:39And even in hospital, the nurse who was standing next to me, just as the doctor was about to go in to look at my colon,
- 41:49the nurse leant over and said, weren't you on the circle?
- 41:52And the doctor said, that's just my finger.
- 41:55And it's funny, but it's a bit intrusive.
- 42:02And the next thing I knew, I had the newspapers calling me and under British law, they can't write anything unless I, they can't write anything medical unless I agree.
- 42:14And then I thought I should contact the production company.
- 42:19I did, and the next day the newspaper stopped calling me and they said they weren't allowed to write anything about me.
- 42:27And that is how these production companies control the media.
- 42:32But you don't know.
- 42:34So, as I say, ghosting is really the best description I can give.
- 42:39I don't know if I've said too much even now.
- 42:40But ghosting is the best description that you can give about this.
- 42:44I had conversations with the production company because I think they thought I was being too publicly critical.
- 42:52And they offered me a job as a producer.
- 42:57because I'd said that the show had become cruel and nasty.
- 43:01I think the show that I was in became cruel and nasty, and it broke its own rules halfway through the show.
- 43:10And it became very vicious, very, very vicious.
- 43:16And...
- 43:19But, you know...
- 43:21I saw through a lot of that.
- 43:24I didn't want to see what I didn't want to see.
- 43:26And as I said, I enjoyed the show and I enjoyed the filming and I would do, in a way I'd do that again, but I wouldn't put myself, I wouldn't put myself through that position where I was so vulnerable again, but I would certainly do, I would certainly do something with cameras and television.
- 43:47But I wouldn't want the aftermath.
- 43:51And the aftermath, I think, is about a lack, again, a lack of agency.
- 43:55We're denied agents.
- 43:56We're denied union representation.
- 43:58We're denied actually being treated as real workers.
- 44:02There was an investigation that took place just after I came out of the show
- 44:07And I didn't really... it wasn't really on my radar enough.
- 44:11And there were two TV shows in Britain.
- 44:15One was called Jeremy Kyle, which was quite a vicious thing.
- 44:20And the other one was called Love Island, and various people died, including the presenter.
- 44:27And so the government assembled a...
- 44:31a committee, the Digital Culture, Media and Sports Committee, and it took hearings from...
- 44:37It was supposed to take hearings from across the industry.
- 44:40Now, what it did was to take hearings from... ..production and from four people who had just been on the shows...
- 44:51So two of them were very, very warm towards the show.
- 44:55And two of them, I think, have been on the Jeremy Kyle, not so warm.
- 44:59And then because Boris Johnson called an election, all the committee, all the committees stop.
- 45:06And it's then down to the committee chair to reconvene.
- 45:10And he decided not to.
- 45:13And yet at the same time, around about that point, I was writing letters, and I was being sort of fobbed off with this and fobbed off with that.
- 45:20I've been on a complete merry-go-round for three years politically.
- 45:28And getting nowhere.
- 45:30I'm sure you were getting absolutely nowhere.
- 45:33On the basis of the testimony from production, the decision was to give an organization called Ofcom,
- 45:42sort of control of a new rule, which would give production companies 18 months control of people who've been on reality TV.
- 45:54What?
- 45:54Which is the worst of all possible.
- 45:56Isn't that the opposite of what's supposed to happen there?
- 46:00Yeah, what they wanted to do was to make sure that production paid for psychiatric help.
- 46:08The psychiatric help I got after the show, I was telephoned for a year or so after the show.
- 46:14And part of that involved a sort of tick box exercise.
- 46:18I enjoyed the chats and I liked the person who was doing it.
- 46:21But the point about psychologist or psychologist is, what exactly is the qualification?
- 46:27Because it's very vague.
- 46:28It's a very vague term.
- 46:30And the psychologist would go through it.
- 46:33Have you had any suicidal thoughts?
- 46:35And the last time we had this, I said, yes.
- 46:38And she then went further down the list, and nothing was ever done.
- 46:43Also, I telephoned their helpline.
- 46:47I wasn't the only one.
- 46:47Someone else telephoned the helpline.
- 46:49And I was told, oh, you're not employed by the company, therefore we don't represent you.
- 46:54And thankfully, this person telephoned me.
- 46:58I talked them down.
- 46:59But when I telephoned them, I was left on hold for 10 days.
- 47:04They never did ask me why I telephoned.
- 47:07Never.
- 47:09So what level of despair was I in to call them late at night, I think it was.
- 47:15And we had this conversation about whether or not I was properly employed.
- 47:18And that is the level of...
- 47:21I mean, the company apologized to me, of course, later on.
- 47:25But so what?
- 47:25They never asked me why I called in the first place.
- 47:28Because they don't care.
- 47:30No.
- 47:31And an apology... You know, I suppose they thought, well, he's still here.
- 47:36You know, they're checking a box with those things because they have to or they feel they have to.
- 47:42What happened to me?
- 47:43I had quite severe cancer, a T3.
- 47:46I'm going through scans at the moment, so I'm a little bit jittery.
- 47:49Anyway, so I thought I was going to die.
- 47:52And I thought that it was... And when the consultant removed my tumour, which he said was like a carrot, I call it George.
- 48:03And when the consultant removed George, he said, oh, it's about 18 months old.
- 48:09And I thought, I went back in my mind to that article I'd written for The Independent.
- 48:13And I thought, there it is in black and white.
- 48:16It's not a legal document, but it's an anecdotal document.
- 48:21I had a cancer growing inside me, which was about 18 months old, during a time that I said was 18 months of sheer hell worse than being held at gunpoint.
- 48:29Jeez.
- 48:30I mean, I think that speaks for itself.
- 48:33And it's about the loss of agency.
- 48:35And it's, you know, yes, people have bad edits.
- 48:38Yes, it's not reality.
- 48:40And yes, we should have some sort of health warning in front of these programs so that people watching...
- 48:48are being seduced into this Milgram fest into this Stanford prison, Zimbardo, whatever.
- 49:00Stanford prison experiment.
- 49:02Yeah, all these experiments.
- 49:04which are lethal.
- 49:06And they're participating in this, as if they're watching a gladiatorial combat.
- 49:12And they don't want anyone to win.
- 49:14They're not interested in winners.
- 49:16It's like the X Factor or Britain's Got Talent or America's Got Talent.
- 49:20They're not interested in the talent.
- 49:22They're interested in the disasters.
- 49:24That's why you have a boom, boom, boom, boom, boom.
- 49:26You don't have the boom, boom, boom, boom, boom to see who wins.
- 49:29You're looking to see who's going to cry when they lose.
- 49:33Yeah.
- 49:33And the drama that all leads into all of these moments.
- 49:38They're there for, they're there for the train wrecks.
- 49:40They're there for the messy.
- 49:41And I just had a reporter reach out to me through Dr. Isabel.
- 49:45Again, she's, I guess, sort of the co-star of this episode.
- 49:49I've talked about her a lot.
- 49:51Someone's doing a story.
- 49:53Someone's doing a story on the impacts of trauma on how people view reality TV.
- 50:01that it could actually be a trauma response.
- 50:03And I haven't actually said that before, but I've thought that.
- 50:07And the audience is damaged.
- 50:09Yeah.
- 50:10And they can't get enough, and it's like a drug, and it's really bad.
- 50:13I think it's hypnotic and compelling.
- 50:21One of the reasons why I was cast, I think, was because I'd never watched any reality TV.
- 50:26I hadn't either.
- 50:26I think that was part of why I was, but for a different reason, I think it was because I had a nice job.
- 50:31I had a condo, I had my shit together and I think they wanted to make sure they had enough people that had their shit together so that they could get a love story out of it.
- 50:39Yep.
- 50:39And I haven't watched the new season.
- 50:41The new season just came out of my show and people are like, this is ridiculous.
- 50:47Like they don't even want to watch anymore.
- 50:49Cause it's just so escalating.
- 50:51The drama just escalates, escalates, escalates.
- 50:53And in the case of the circle, they're putting these nasty twists.
- 50:57Well...
- 50:58You know, if you cast well enough, you don't need the nasty twist.
- 51:02The excuse for reality TV is, you know, if you've got a writer's strike, you're going to have more reality TV because you don't need a writer.
- 51:09In fact, you do need a writer because the writer sits behind and scribbles what they think is going to happen, and then you're manipulated into making sure that does happen.
- 51:16Into their storyline.
- 51:17So you wonder, where's the writer in this?
- 51:19Well, the writer's up in the gallery.
- 51:21But in principle, the only people who don't know what they're going to say, the only people who don't know that they're being...
- 51:28that they've got a script, are the players, are the performers.
- 51:34And so put in the right environment with the right characters, we will produce drama because we've been very well produced, very well cast.
- 51:44But what happens now is, I think, instead of looking for characters who are going to spark off each other, the production companies look for stereotypes and...
- 51:56who are going to fit a particular mold, who they think are then going to... 100% agree with that.
- 52:01I can't say for certain, because I obviously didn't experience that side of it, but I 100% believe that that is what's going on.
- 52:08And it's not just, it's with all of these shows.
- 52:11All of these fall into a particular pattern.
- 52:16And you have to go back to the Milgram thing.
- 52:20And the Milgram thing is acknowledged.
- 52:23If you go back to the history of this medium, it's there right at the beginning with the first modern reality TV show.
- 52:33But reality TV can go back further than that.
- 52:35You can take it all the way back to the… You can take it back to the 80s.
- 52:39No, you can take it back earlier than that to the 60s, to game shows, to talk shows.
- 52:47We had a thing called Saturday Night, Sunday Night at the London Palladium.
- 52:52And it would have a moment where contestants were brought onto the stage to play a game.
- 52:57That is reality TV, because reality TV is the democratization of television.
- 53:03You sit and watch it and you can be on it.
- 53:06And that's the lovely thing.
- 53:09So I think reality TV can make great drama.
- 53:13I think reality TV can democratise television.
- 53:16But reality TV also allows for control by production, which is out of control.
- 53:23And our government, the British government, has actually endorsed that and made it worse.
- 53:29And ours here hasn't even looked at it with any concern whatsoever until recently.
- 53:35Well, what you have to be really careful about is that you're not going to end up in a situation that we've ended up in, where it's even worse, and you can't pull back from it, because they say, oh, well, the people who should modify this document are Ofcom.
- 53:48It's always an excuse.
- 53:51And they go round in a circle, and each blames the other.
- 54:00And they rally people behind them, and then it's just nothing happens.
- 54:04And of course, I'm very much aware that when I send off one of these letters, they know who's written it, they know who I am, and they're determined that I won't get the photo opportunity of sitting next to the Secretary of State.
- 54:21They're determined that won't happen.
- 54:23Because that would change things significantly, I think.
- 54:27I think it would too.
- 54:28I know I've got some stuff, maybe by the time this has come out, it's, it's been, um, I guess detailed, but, um, there's, there's a lot of change that needs to happen.
- 54:40And I think we can produce reality TV ethically and within, whether that comes from unionization of cast members, whether that comes from legal regulation, whether that comes from regulatory boards, whether that comes from all of us saying we're done with this, um,
- 54:57I think it needs to happen.
- 54:59And I think if we're going to continue to do this and act like we're in the squid games or the hunger games, and that's what this is at this point.
- 55:06The stuff I was telling you before we came on today, sexual assault because someone wasn't allowed to leave.
- 55:13This is like, what is it going to take for people to wake up, open their eyes and say enough?
- 55:20We are not doing this to human beings for the entertainment of other human beings and then paying them with followers on Instagram and TikTok.
- 55:30We're not doing that.
- 55:31That is not how society functions.
- 55:34And why does, let me ask this.
- 55:35I have to do something on this.
- 55:37I don't know what yet, but why does every single reality show have a villain?
- 55:44Because it's scripted that way.
- 55:47It doesn't need to.
- 55:48It doesn't need to.
- 55:49It doesn't need to.
- 55:50There will be natural, quote, villains, but there will also be engaging, relatable conversations, relationships, friendships, group dynamics.
- 56:01But more than that, villains can be saved even in real life.
- 56:07I'm perfectly happy to imagine that Mr. Putin is a nice man.
- 56:10Well, he was – I mean, he didn't seem very nice when I shook his hand.
- 56:13But I can see that he could be rehabilitated somewhere.
- 56:19Well, hey, we've rehabilitated some people in this country that should be in prison.
- 56:24So anything is possible.
- 56:27The media gets behind it.
- 56:29There we go.
- 56:30Yeah, but people, I think people are fundamentally good.
- 56:36But reality TV wants to see people in these sort of black and white and very tribal.
- 56:44And I think we need to get beyond that.
- 56:46I think we need to see that people have got layers of nuance.
- 56:51Nuance, yeah.
- 56:53Yeah.
- 56:53And fundamentally, everybody's huggable and lovable.
- 57:00I think I agree with you.
- 57:03I think there's good in everyone.
- 57:04You just got to find it.
- 57:05And it's almost like, you know, you got to you got to check yourself before you you jump on these people as a viewer because you haven't lived this situation.
- 57:16And I have never talked, I mean, I've talked to some people on reality shows that are like, yeah, that wasn't a good person, or that person isn't my kind of person.
- 57:25But that doesn't mean they're a villain.
- 57:26That means they've got their own people.
- 57:28And I, listen, I had issues with some people on my show.
- 57:32And...
- 57:34I just, I let them be them.
- 57:36And if them being themselves isn't for me, I just don't deal with it.
- 57:39I don't associate.
- 57:40That's our decision as a human being.
- 57:42But to throw hate at people because of what you see on TV that you're perceiving as reality, it's so damaging.
- 57:49And it gives so much additional trauma to people.
- 57:54And people are spilling their trauma all over the internet.
- 57:58And it just makes me...
- 58:01It breaks my heart.
- 58:03I have a YouTube channel and what I try and do is cut through this tribalism, but it's so difficult sometimes.
- 58:12And people will say, oh, you're being inconsistent.
- 58:14I'm not being inconsistent.
- 58:15I'm trying to look at more than one view.
- 58:18And I think we've got two hands and I can quite happily say, I believe fundamentally in this with this hand and I believe fundamentally in that with the other hand.
- 58:27People are nuanced.
- 58:29Yeah.
- 58:30You know, my background academically is in theology.
- 58:36And I can argue until the cows come home for two sides of exactly the same issue.
- 58:45I don't see any problem with that.
- 58:47It's also critical thinking.
- 58:50It's critical thinking.
- 58:51Yeah.
- 58:51It's critical thinking.
- 58:52And, you know, I teach a lot of small children debating skills.
- 58:58And we say, oh, we're going to do this debate.
- 59:00You've got five minutes to work out a decent argument.
- 59:02But I don't believe in this.
- 59:03I say, well, that's why you're doing this side.
- 59:06Oh, my gosh.
- 59:07I can debate any side, most sides, I should say, without actually believing it.
- 59:13It's so good.
- 59:15It's a courtesy and a pleasantry.
- 59:18And it's...
- 59:20It's something which is very nice to have.
- 59:22But, you know, we need that debate, and that's what we lack in politics.
- 59:27I think it's also what we lack in ordinary society.
- 59:31It's what television...
- 59:33It's what actually reality TV could give us.
- 59:35It could give us that debate.
- 59:38rather than the tribalism and the, I believe, I don't care what you believe really.
- 59:43And I just want to hear that debate.
- 59:45And I want to hear that sort of reasoned encounter.
- 59:48And I also want to hear the points at which you agree with somebody because that's fun.
- 59:53It is.
- 59:54It definitely is.
- 59:56Let me, I want to ask you, you know, one last question here and then I'm going to give you an opportunity to ask me anything that you want to ask.
- 1:00:05But, um,
- 1:00:07What would you like to see changed?
- 1:00:10Maybe top couple things, three things, do three things.
- 1:00:13Top three things you would like to see changed in reality TV production.
- 1:00:18Oh, very easy.
- 1:00:20The unions must get involved.
- 1:00:23because this is about performance.
- 1:00:26And in Britain, the Equity Union, which we stole from you in the 1930s, very late on, you had it much before we had it, we had a thing called the Variety Artists Federation, the Musical Variety Artists Federation or something like that.
- 1:00:43And they had a principle that anybody who was performing had a right to representation.
- 1:00:48Yeah.
- 1:00:50And equity in the States and here takes a view that it guards the profession.
- 1:00:57It acts as the doorkeeper to the profession.
- 1:00:59Well, that's very good and very necessary as well.
- 1:01:03But we also need to be caring for those people who are performing in any situation.
- 1:01:08And reality TV is very much about people who are performing.
- 1:01:11And why should you protect them?
- 1:01:13Because they are... And they have been right the way back to the beginning of the...
- 1:01:1920th century, they can be exploited by production.
- 1:01:23So that needs to be an option.
- 1:01:26People may say, I don't wish to be unionised.
- 1:01:28I don't wish to be involved in that.
- 1:01:29That's fine.
- 1:01:30That's their choice.
- 1:01:31But the offer must be there.
- 1:01:33And equity in Britain doesn't seem to be very interested.
- 1:01:37It is participating in an academic...
- 1:01:39review at the moment, which I think began at the beginning of October.
- 1:01:43And I've spoken to the to the universities who are doing this.
- 1:01:47They called me.
- 1:01:48I'm delighted that we've spoken.
- 1:01:50And Equity is going to be observing that review.
- 1:01:53But that's as far as they go.
- 1:01:55When I when I spoke to the leader of Equity in Britain, he was extremely dismissive.
- 1:02:01And he said, well, you're you're not professional.
- 1:02:05You're only playing yourself and all that sort of rubbish.
- 1:02:07And I just think, and he wouldn't take the matter any further, no matter how much I push.
- 1:02:12And I can push.
- 1:02:14So that's number one.
- 1:02:15So I think unionization is essential.
- 1:02:18I also think it's essential that people who are on reality TV have independent and external representation by agents.
- 1:02:29And.
- 1:02:30Now, that's more difficult to arrange.
- 1:02:33It's not about them having agents who are going to represent them afterwards.
- 1:02:38It's about knowing that there's somebody who's not invested in the show who has their back.
- 1:02:44And take away the power that the shows have to completely control you after...
- 1:02:49I've thought about this a lot because the problem is the cheap approach for production companies is to have a list of cheap agents that they can just throw at the people that they've selected.
- 1:03:00Do you have an agent?
- 1:03:02No.
- 1:03:03Oh, well, here's an agent for you.
- 1:03:04And you think, oh, my goodness, how lovely.
- 1:03:06I've got management.
- 1:03:08That management does not have your best interests.
- 1:03:11I think this is where an organization like UCAN could come in.
- 1:03:17this is something if production companies were to work with UCAN, I would love to see a similar organisation develop in the UK.
- 1:03:25I would like to spearhead it, frankly.
- 1:03:29I think what you're doing is spectacular and exactly what we should be doing here.
- 1:03:34That may well be the answer to that part of the equation.
- 1:03:39Then I think we need to dump the idea that psychiatry solves all problems.
- 1:03:46Psychiatry is a very important part of the medical care that must be given simply because you're employed.
- 1:03:57And it's part of, I think it's part of that medical insurance.
- 1:04:04And I think we should stop thinking that the psychiatrist is part of the company and it should instead be a completely independent medical insurance that is provided by the company for a protracted period of time.
- 1:04:2118 months is not enough.
- 1:04:23You know, I've been saying that's, I think, my number one, what I want right now, because I think we can do it right now.
- 1:04:30I think there's obviously work to build a union and all that stuff.
- 1:04:33But if we could get independent mental health professionals that they pay and maybe, you know, we have, I think we're up to 500 mental health professionals in the United States that have joined the UCAN network.
- 1:04:47We could pay.
- 1:04:50pair people in almost every single state with an independent mental health counselor, where maybe they pay the foundation, the foundation pays the therapist, and it's independent.
- 1:05:03And even independent counselors being observers in the production companies.
- 1:05:11Absolutely.
- 1:05:12We have to get away from everything else.
- 1:05:16But also, we need medical help
- 1:05:20in production itself, broader medical health, because you don't know what can happen.
- 1:05:25And that has to be part of that package.
- 1:05:28Essentially, it comes down to one single thing.
- 1:05:33People who are employed in reality TV need to be recognized as employees and need to be treated as top-rate employees, which means they need to be paid.
- 1:05:45Mm-hmm.
- 1:05:46When this committee hearing was being conducted in the UK, in Parliament, the television channel, Channel 4, the bosses of the channel were there,
- 1:06:01And they refused absolutely to use the term participant.
- 1:06:05They insisted on the term contestant.
- 1:06:08Why?
- 1:06:08Because it demeans us.
- 1:06:10Because it belittles us.
- 1:06:12Because then you're competing for something.
- 1:06:15No, when I was talking to the people who produced the show and they were trying to get me to be a producer, they kept saying again and again, but did you enjoy it?
- 1:06:24But you enjoyed it, didn't you?
- 1:06:26And I thought...
- 1:06:27Well, I would say, yes, I did enjoy it.
- 1:06:29But then I suddenly realised if I say that I'm playing into their hands.
- 1:06:34and they can discredit you.
- 1:06:36I was doing it as fun.
- 1:06:37Well, I do lots of things as fun.
- 1:06:39I enjoy my work in the theater, but I get paid.
- 1:06:43I enjoy my work as an artist, but I get paid.
- 1:06:47I enjoy my work when I write, but I get paid.
- 1:06:50I enjoy my work in the university, but I get paid.
- 1:06:51Actually, that's not true.
- 1:06:52I've never been paid properly by Russia.
- 1:06:56In any other situation, I get paid even if I enjoy it.
- 1:07:01You know, even if I were a prostitute, I would expect money.
- 1:07:05and to be told oh you're enjoying it therefore you're not being paid the only thing you get the only thing you get treated the only thing professionally that you get that is like reality TV is jury service I think you might make more during jury service here in the states than you do in reality TV I'm so disappointed with the UK on so many levels but there we are um
- 1:07:35I will come over and be the revival of Robin Williams.
- 1:07:39Oh, there you go.
- 1:07:40That would be great.
- 1:07:40I love Robin Williams.
- 1:07:42I absolutely love him.
- 1:07:43So let me give you the chance to ask me a question before we finish up here.
- 1:07:47I know we've talked quite a few times now, but yeah, if there's anything you want to know about me or –
- 1:07:54No, what I want to know is, do you have a vision of the future for yourself?
- 1:08:02Not just for you, Ken.
- 1:08:03You, Ken, I know, and I think it's splendid, and you and Jeremy need to get as much help as possible to get that off the ground.
- 1:08:11It is off the ground, but it needs a version over here.
- 1:08:15But equally...
- 1:08:18What about you?
- 1:08:18You know, that is a really hard question.
- 1:08:23Wasn't prepared for that.
- 1:08:25And no, no, no.
- 1:08:27I'll be real with you.
- 1:08:29I've recently started thinking about that, where I'm like, I have been in this world.
- 1:08:36world for two and a half years.
- 1:08:39And last year, when I mentioned earlier that I had kind of hit rock bottom, I decided I was leaving this world.
- 1:08:46I went and made an effort to, I turned off all my notifications on social media.
- 1:08:52I do it on my time.
- 1:08:53I post what I want.
- 1:08:54I post when I want.
- 1:08:56I don't care what people think about me, but I did start to feel the
- 1:09:05When I decided to start UCAN with Jeremy and come back, and it was his idea, I just brought my flavor of adding other types of services to it.
- 1:09:14And being, let me tell you, being this kind of the initial spokesperson for it, for lack of a better word, man, I never knew trying to help people was so polarizing, was so triggering for people.
- 1:09:30But lately, I've been thinking to myself, who am I?
- 1:09:35You know, like my identity is not reality TV.
- 1:09:40It's not UCAN Foundation.
- 1:09:42It's not my job.
- 1:09:43It's who do I show up as in the world?
- 1:09:45And I will say, I think me working on UCAN and trying to organize reality cast members and taking the steps that I've taken here to do that.
- 1:09:58That's much more on brand, for lack of a better word for me, because I have been in politics.
- 1:10:04I have been organizing since 2008.
- 1:10:07I have been I follow politics like it's my like it's my job.
- 1:10:11I love it.
- 1:10:12And I want change.
- 1:10:14And so I, you know, after 2020 election here, I.
- 1:10:19batted for Bernie twice.
- 1:10:21And the second time, the loss and the way he took it, he didn't even take it on the chin.
- 1:10:26He just laid down.
- 1:10:28And he had a whole movement that I felt like he abandoned.
- 1:10:31And I just reminded myself right there, nothing's going to happen through electoral politics.
- 1:10:36Everything's going to happen from organizing and saying no.
- 1:10:39And so, yeah,
- 1:10:41That kind of became my stance on things.
- 1:10:43And now being able to see all these pieces of my identity kind of merge together into the organizing, the foundation, the helping other people, the podcast, right, where I'm talking about very important societal issues, being vocal and open and sharing mental health advice, mental health advice.
- 1:11:05content, working with people who are way smarter at it than I am and, you know, having them share their stories.
- 1:11:11I think my identity of who I'm going to be moving forward is starting to form.
- 1:11:17And I don't have it completely formed, but I'm starting to see
- 1:11:21and think to myself, like, where do I want to be in a year?
- 1:11:24Where do I want to be in two years?
- 1:11:25Like me, when am I going to focus on building the life that I want?
- 1:11:30That is for me.
- 1:11:31And I think I'm at this point now where I don't have the answer to that, but I know I need to find the answer to that.
- 1:11:36But I think you're doing it.
- 1:11:39That's why you, I think you've actually found your, your calling.
- 1:11:44which is so funny because I would have never in a million years when I, I said this to my friend yesterday, when I was growing up, I wanted to be a WWE wrestler.
- 1:11:53I wanted to be Hulk.
- 1:11:55I wanted to be Hulk Hogan or the macho man or the ultimate warrior, right?
- 1:11:59Or Jake the snake.
- 1:12:00And by the way, Jake, the snake followed me on Instagram.
- 1:12:03And I like, that was the biggest, that was the biggest funny thing.
- 1:12:07Granted I followed him first, but, um,
- 1:12:10You know, I just never in a million years imagined that this would be my life.
- 1:12:14But at the same time, I'm not surprised because when something's wrong, I can't not do something.
- 1:12:21Exactly.
- 1:12:23But that's your political training.
- 1:12:27But we both have that.
- 1:12:29And, you know, I don't think it stops really at reality TV.
- 1:12:34I think there's two other areas that...
- 1:12:39that we need to be looking at.
- 1:12:40We need to be looking at the music industry.
- 1:12:43We need to be looking at what I suppose would call cheap sofa television, television, all that sort of stuff, which is equally exploitative.
- 1:12:53And it's equally, it's all about the control of production.
- 1:12:57It is.
- 1:12:57It really is.
- 1:12:59These talentless individuals who are basically bureaucrats,
- 1:13:05who sent desperation and they exploit it.
- 1:13:11And the people who are giving their heart and their soul to entertain, they deserve more.
- 1:13:21They deserve more than what they're getting.
- 1:13:23I couldn't have said it better myself.
- 1:13:26I want to thank you for coming on and being vulnerable, sharing your story, talking about your family and your illness, which I'll be sending you nothing but support there.
- 1:13:40And, of course, I'm wishing you nothing but the best.
- 1:13:45So do me one last favor here.
- 1:13:48Tell my audience where they can find your social media, where they can find your movies, where they can find any of your writing, any of that.
- 1:13:53And we'll put links in the description as well.
- 1:13:57Well, the social media is, I think it's official professor underscore Tim underscore Wilson, though it was attacked the other day.
- 1:14:08I think I've got it back.
- 1:14:09Oh, my gosh.
- 1:14:10And that's Instagram.
- 1:14:11Is this the second time it's happened?
- 1:14:14And then YouTube is Professor Tim Wilson.
- 1:14:19If you just type in how to write a good essay, you come to me immediately.
- 1:14:24And I think I've put up links to my films already.
- 1:14:29there as well and i'm going to start doing do you see shakespeare behind me i'm going to start doing um some academic stuff on youtube as well that's outstanding so so so youtube will be the go-to place i think um all right i don't know whether i've got i've got to start discovering what patreon is i suppose i have really yeah um but i i would quite like
- 1:14:55I think as an academic, I'm really an entertainer, and I think that's what, in the end, I just have to embrace that reality.
- 1:15:03But I would like that entertainment to be smeared with a bit of politics and a little bit of education.
- 1:15:12This is the intersection of everything I feel like is me and has been my life, so I completely relate to that.
- 1:15:20It's there, and I think reality TV lies in the heart of that.
- 1:15:26So we were involved in reality TV.
- 1:15:29The reality, the people who cast us knew what they were doing.
- 1:15:35I can see immediately why you were cast.
- 1:15:37You can probably see why I was cast.
- 1:15:40And we might resent the way it worked, but that's because of the evil in the system, not because reality TV itself is...
- 1:15:51essentially malign.
- 1:15:52I don't think it is.
- 1:15:53I think it could be a force for good.
- 1:15:55I think so, too.
- 1:15:56It's democratized television.
- 1:15:59Yeah, I agree.
- 1:16:01That's what we need to make sure it is.
- 1:16:02And every other form of entertainment.
- 1:16:05The people who are entertaining are protected by unions, by agents, by this mass of individuals who support the performer because they know that production is mean.
- 1:16:22And always has been.
- 1:16:23We're not going to change production.
- 1:16:25We're not going to make production into a different animal.
- 1:16:28We just need to make sure.
- 1:16:29We need to regulate it.
- 1:16:31No, because that's the point.
- 1:16:33I don't think we can regulate it.
- 1:16:35We can do a little bit of regulation, but the main thing we have to do is to protect the performers.
- 1:16:39Right.
- 1:16:39Well, yeah, that's what I'm thinking.
- 1:16:41That's the regulation.
- 1:16:42Like, hey, guess what?
- 1:16:43You're only you're going to work eight hours and then you're going to get paid double time for the next four or whatever those look like.
- 1:16:49Yeah, absolutely.
- 1:16:51And if you're being filmed through the night, you're going to be raking it in.
- 1:16:54Yeah, exactly.
- 1:16:56Well, thank you again so much for coming on.
- 1:16:59I really appreciate it.
- 1:17:00And thanks to everyone for listening and make sure that you check out the links below and check out Professor Tim.
- 1:17:10Thank you for joining us on this week's episode of Eyes Wide Open.
- 1:17:13If you enjoy the show, the best way to support us is by sharing or dropping a review.
- 1:17:17For more information and content, check out engagewithnick.com or find me on Instagram at nthompson513.
- 1:17:25Don't go through life blind.
- 1:17:26Do the work so you can show up in the world with your eyes wide open.