Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Six-Year Tesla Model 3 Ownership Review and Costs
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome back to the Deep Dive. Today we are cracking open a
- 0:12file that is absolutely crucial for anyone thinking about the
- 0:18long term economics of an electric vehicle.
- 0:20You've handed us a fantastic set of sources.
- 0:23We have the formal analyst true cost of ownership data from
- 0:26Edmonds and then we have something I think a little more
- 0:29valuable. The real world numbers.
- 0:31Exactly the six year 164,000 mile financial diary of a 2019
- 0:37Tesla Model 3 Long Range owner. This is where the story gets
- 0:40really interesting. It is so.
- 0:42Our mission today is to move past the hype, pass the
- 0:45marketing, and really figure out the true financial picture of a
- 0:49high mileage EV once that manufacturer warranty is gone.
- 0:53OK, let's unpack this. Does the, you know, the
- 0:55legendary EV maintenance savings?
- 0:58Does it actually outweigh the risk of these sudden massive
- 1:00component failures? And what about the drain of high
- 1:03insurance premiums? This is the moment that EV
- 1:06rubber really meets the financial Rd.
- 1:07I mean the early TCO narratives, they were extremely favorable.
- 1:11Oh, unbelievably so. We saw estimates, you know where
- 1:14the Model 3 TCO was around what, $4100 a year?
- 1:18Yeah, and that was just so much better than its competitors,
- 1:20like a BMW330I was closer to 9000 a year a.
- 1:24Huge difference. But that entire economic
- 1:27argument was built on two things.
- 1:29Government incentives for one, and the assumption that
- 1:33maintenance costs would be like near 0.
- 1:37But at 160,000 miles, that whole risk profile just inverts
- 1:42completely. How so?
- 1:43Well, you stop worrying about $100 oil change and you start
- 1:46worrying about a potential $15,000 repair.
- 1:48OK, let's start with the good news then, because the core
- 1:51mechanical promise of the EV, it really is fulfilled here.
- 1:55It absolutely is. Routine maintenance is just.
- 1:58I mean, it's shockingly cheap. No oil changes, no spark plugs,
- 2:03no complex transmission services.
- 2:05It's the dream. It's a genuine triumph of
- 2:07engineering simplicity. So simple, in fact, that those
- 2:10initial analyst projections look kind of ridiculous in hindsight.
- 2:14What? Do they project?
- 2:15Edmunds projected that over five years, the total repair cost for
- 2:18a Model 3 would be nearly $8300. OK, but the real world data from
- 2:24our high mileage driver tells a very different story.
- 2:28A completely different story. It just undercuts that analyst
- 2:31fear entirely. This owner, over six years and
- 2:35164,000 miles, spent a total of 5000 $748.
- 2:41And that's for everything. That's for.
- 2:42All tires and all unforced out of warranty mechanical repairs
- 2:47combined. Wow.
- 2:48If you take out the tires, the actual repair bills are truly
- 2:51minuscule compared to what you'd expect for a luxury car.
- 2:55So the savings are definitely real, but when repairs do
- 2:58happen, they sort of reveal this unique vulnerability of these
- 3:02high tech vehicles. Absolutely.
- 3:03The repairs aren't frequent, but they are expensive and they're
- 3:06very specific to the integrated electronic systems, right?
- 3:10For instance, the expected replacement of the little 12
- 3:13Volt lead acid battery that was after five years cost 112 bucks
- 3:17normal. Okay, that's nothing.
- 3:19But then came the severe failures.
- 3:21The parts nobody ever talks about.
- 3:23Exactly. The cabin heater, which uses a
- 3:25PTC heater, it failed. That cost over $1100, and that's
- 3:31part of the integrated climate control.
- 3:32Not a simple fix. Not at all.
- 3:34And then the Super Bottle, which is this incredibly complex valve
- 3:37system that manages all the cooling fluids for the battery,
- 3:40the motor, the cabin, everything.
- 3:43Would that cost? That was a $672 hit.
- 3:47These failures show that the real TCO risk is in the thermal
- 3:51management system, not the drivetrain itself.
- 3:53It's a fascinating trade off, isn't it?
- 3:55You swap frequent, cheap repairs for these infrequent, highly
- 3:59specialized and expensive ones. Speaking of frequency, though,
- 4:03the owner did have one surprisingly high recurring bill
- 4:06tires. Yes, the heavy high performance
- 4:09anomaly despite the manacle simplicity, the instant torque
- 4:12and just the sheer weight of that battery pack.
- 4:15It shreds. Them it shreds them.
- 4:16The owner went through five sets of tires in six years 5 seconds,
- 4:19which alone totaled over $3000. Rapid tire wear is a confirmed
- 4:24major recurring cost for these cars.
- 4:27OK, so we've established the owner saved a lot of money on,
- 4:30you know, wrenches and fluids. But the big question for you,
- 4:33the listener, is where did those savings actually go?
- 4:37What is the real financial Achilles heel here?
- 4:40It is, without any question, insurance volatility.
- 4:43The numbers here are, they're truly stunning.
- 4:47This owner's insurance payments over six years nearly $17,000.
- 4:53Just think about that for a second.
- 4:54The insurance bill, it completely dwarfed the combined
- 4:58cost of the tires and all the other out of warranty repairs.
- 5:01So it cost more than three times as much to insure the car as it
- 5:04did to fix and maintain. It exactly the insurance was so
- 5:08high it actually exceeded the Edmunds five year projection by
- 5:10thousands of dollars. Wait, let's break this down.
- 5:13If the owner saved say 5 to 7000 on mechanical maintenance
- 5:17compared to a normal car, right? But spend an extra 7000 on
- 5:20insurance compared to the projections.
- 5:23Yeah. Doesn't that just neutralize the
- 5:25TCO advantage? It is severely eroded, yes, the
- 5:28savings aren't gone, but they're dramatically offset.
- 5:30And it forces us to ask, you know, why are Model 3 Premium so
- 5:33uniquely high? OK, why?
- 5:35It really boils down to two things, performance risk and
- 5:39claim severity. High performance we get, but
- 5:41explain claim severity. Why is a Fender Bender on a
- 5:45Model 3 so much more costly for an insurer?
- 5:49It's the complex structure. The car uses aluminum frames,
- 5:52the battery pack is integrated right into the structure and
- 5:55every collision, even a minor one, involves these
- 5:58sophisticated high cost repairs. A small impact means you need a
- 6:03certified center, specialized labor, and this is critical.
- 6:07You have to recalibrate all the sensors and cameras for
- 6:10autopilot. So even a tiny bump can become a
- 6:12huge bill. A huge bill and it spikes the
- 6:15repair cost, which raises the chance it gets totalled out.
- 6:17We also can't ignore a claim frequency.
- 6:20The sources note the Model 3 has a high frequency of claims.
- 6:23One study showed nearly 30% of repairable EVs in their analysis
- 6:27were model threes. So more frequent claims that are
- 6:30also more expensive to fix. That's the combination high
- 6:32frequency and extremely high severity.
- 6:35It means insurers just assign it a much, much higher risk factor.
- 6:39So what does this all mean? The promise low maintenance is
- 6:41real, but the overall TCO picture is far less rosy because
- 6:46those savings are just being vacuumed up by high insurance
- 6:48premiums. That's it exactly.
- 6:50Let's shift to the component everyone fears most, the main
- 6:53traction battery. This 2019 long range model is
- 6:57way past its mileage warranty now.
- 6:59Well past the 120,000 mile mark. So what does the data say about
- 7:03its longevity at nearly 165,000 miles?
- 7:06You know, the longevity data is actually the story of great
- 7:09durability. The original EPA range was 310,
- 7:1210 miles. At almost 165,000 miles.
- 7:16The owner now observes a range of about 250 miles.
- 7:19So that's a total capacity loss of approximately 19%. 19% how
- 7:24does that stack up against the warranty?
- 7:26Well, compare that to the warranty floor.
- 7:27Tesla guarantees 70% retention over eight years, or 120,000
- 7:32miles. This car is still retaining 81%
- 7:35of its capacity. It really comproms the
- 7:37fundamental durability of the power unit.
- 7:39But the financial risk is still there because the mileage
- 7:41warranty is expired. So what is the owner and really
- 7:44you, the listener facing now? You're facing what's called a
- 7:47massive contingent liability risk, meaning it means there's a
- 7:51low probability of something happening, but if it does, the
- 7:54cost is catastrophic. And in this case, that's the
- 7:57battery failing. A catastrophic non repairable
- 8:00battery failure and the cost for replacement could be anywhere
- 8:03from 8000 to $18,000. So that exposure confirms that
- 8:07the battery pack is this single biggest financial worry once
- 8:10that warranty is gone. Absolutely.
- 8:12We're effectively managing risk instead of managing routine wear
- 8:16and tear. But Despite that 19%
- 8:18degradation, the car is still perfectly functional for daily
- 8:22use. Oh completely.
- 8:23The 250 mile range it has now is functionally the same as what a
- 8:27brand new 2019 standard range Model 3 offered off the lot.
- 8:31So Rd. trips are still possible. For sure, the supercharger
- 8:34network is spaced efficiently enough, usually under 100 miles
- 8:37apart, that long trips are still viable.
- 8:40The owner only noted real difficulty when external factors
- 8:43come into play, like putting a big bike rack on the back.
- 8:47It dramatically increases aerodynamic drag, and that can
- 8:50make 125 mile gap between chargers a little challenging.
- 8:55OK, let's. Talk about the final financial
- 8:57risk factor, the expensive full self driving feature that this
- 9:01early buyer purchased. Right FSD.
- 9:04The owner reports using the latest supervised version,
- 9:06describing it as driving almost like a good human driver.
- 9:10Which is high praise. You know, the system is clearly
- 9:13capable. It can handle rotaries.
- 9:15It can break for unexpected obstacles.
- 9:17It navigates complex environments well.
- 9:20But, and here's where it gets really interesting, Despite that
- 9:24capability, it is still a supervised system.
- 9:27The owner emphasizes that immediate human intervention is
- 9:30still necessary to prevent serious accidents.
- 9:32And it's needed for specific recurring glitches that the
- 9:35software updates don't seem to fix.
- 9:37Precisely, the system struggles with certain situations.
- 9:40It consistently ignores low 20 mile per hour school zone signs.
- 9:44That's a big deal. A huge deal.
- 9:46It fails to slow down for these big drainage dips you see in
- 9:49Utah that require manual breaking.
- 9:52And most worryingly, at complex intersections, it sometimes puts
- 9:55the car in the wrong part of the lane, forcing the driver to grab
- 9:59the wheel immediately. And for this owner, that big
- 10:02investment in FSD is now threatened by the Hardware 3
- 10:06versus Hardware 4 divide. This is a classic case of
- 10:09technological obsolescence. The newest, most advanced FSD
- 10:13software V 14 and beyond. It's being optimized for cars
- 10:17with the superior hardware for. So the millions of early
- 10:20adopters with the older hardware HW-3?
- 10:22They're essentially left waiting in line.
- 10:24Which creates functional obsolescence.
- 10:27The value of the software they paid for years ago is diminished
- 10:29because their hardware can't run the latest versions properly.
- 10:32That's exactly it. Tesla management has said they
- 10:34need to take care of these early adopters, but the timeline for a
- 10:38real hardware upgrade, which could involve new CPUs, cameras,
- 10:42wiring, it's uncertain and it keeps getting delayed.
- 10:45So it pushes HW-3 owners toward just trading in their cars for a
- 10:48new one. It pushes them to trade in for a
- 10:50new HW-4 equipped vehicle to get the full value of the FSD
- 10:54promise. It transforms what was supposed
- 10:57could be a lifetime software asset into a financial gamble
- 11:00tied to aging silicon. It absolutely does.
- 11:03The FSD investment is impaired until that retrofit promise is
- 11:06delivered. Or, you know, the owner just
- 11:08accepts they may never see the true cutting edge of the
- 11:10software they bought. So this deep dive gives us
- 11:13extremely valuable clarity, particularly for you, the high
- 11:16mileage EV owner. The data confirms the EV
- 11:20drivetrain's superior durability and that promise of negligible
- 11:24routine maintenance. That part is real.
- 11:26It is, however, those mechanical savings are heavily offset by
- 11:30high insurance premiums and the terrifying massive financial
- 11:33risk of out of warranty failures.
- 11:35The battery, the thermal systems and the hardware obsolescence,
- 11:38Yeah, the challenge of EV longevity.
- 11:41It isn't mechanical where it's managing these high cost
- 11:44integrated electronic and battery components that fail
- 11:47infrequently, but when they do, they fail catastrophically.
- 11:50So the whole cost of ownership model shifts.
- 11:52It shifts entirely. You go from dealing with the
- 11:54frequency of scheduled maintenance to constantly
- 11:57managing the severity of unexpected 5 figure risks.
- 12:01That shift from routine expense to catastrophic risk is the key
- 12:05take away you need to apply to your own financial planning.
- 12:09Thank you for sharing these sources and letting us
- 12:10synthesize them into this clear, actionable conversation.
- 12:15It was a necessary exploration, I think into the true financial
- 12:18reality of the high mileage electric future.
- 12:20If you enjoyed synthesizing sources into clear, interesting
- 12:23knowledge like this, be sure to follow the deep dive for more
- 12:26personalized insights derived directly from material like the
- 12:29notes you shared today. Thank you for listening.