Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Systemic Failures: Mental Health Crisis and Legal Complexities in British Columbia
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for our regular segment, joined by barrister and solicitor, with Mulligan Defene Lawyers.
- 0:04Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Legally Speaking on CFACS.
- 0:07Adam Stirling: Morning Michael.
- 0:08Adam Stirling: How are we doing?
- 0:08Adam Stirling: Hey good morning.
- 0:10Adam Stirling: I'm doing great, always good to be here.
- 0:11Adam Stirling: Some interesting stories on the agenda today.
- 0:13Adam Stirling: Let's dive in.
- 0:16Michael Mulligan: There are, and I've got a couple of cases to talk about, but I thought it might be worth just starting with a little bit of legal background on that awful case out of Vancouver involving the death and the person having their hand severed.
- 0:31Michael Mulligan: Yes, just so people know what is currently in place in terms of a legal scheme that could be used to address this sort of thing.
- 0:39Michael Mulligan: Hopefully it will become a common fact pattern.
- 0:42Michael Mulligan: Yeah, hopefully it's become a common fact pattern.
- 0:46Michael Mulligan: But the real tragedy there is that sort of an event is both utterly unexpected and predictable, in the sense that we have in British Columbia a circumstance where we have thousands of people who are profoundly mentally ill, many of whom also have serious drug addiction and use issues, who are simply left on the street, and that is because we in the past closed the facilities that used to afford secure treatment for people who are very seriously mentally ill.
- 1:22Michael Mulligan: Who's viewed as not humane and more humane to have people treated in the community, and if indeed there was treatment, that may well be so, but it is not so, and it's important to know that it isn't a lack of a legal regime that can address these things.
- 1:42Michael Mulligan: We have in British Columbia an act.
- 1:43Michael Mulligan: It's called the Mental Health Act, and the Mental Health Act has an existing scheme which allows people to be involuntarily admitted for treatment in a mental health facility where they are a danger to themselves or others, and there's a process there for people to be certified and doctors to review it and a review board to review it after a period of time.
- 2:09Michael Mulligan: It's a well-established and intricate system designed to do exactly that.
- 2:13Michael Mulligan: But having an act called the Mental Health Act doesn't do you any good if there isn't a physical place for the persons to go.
- 2:23Michael Mulligan: That is what we are missing, you heard, in this particular case.
- 2:28Michael Mulligan: We'll have to wait for it, of course, as you said, to all unfold, but the press conference from the police chief describing the background of the suspect in the case in terms of serious mental health problems and the danger in the community, that is what the Mental Health Act, those sections, are aimed directly at.
- 2:49Michael Mulligan: But having an act and having those provisions and we have them already it doesn't require any legislative change at all.
- 3:02Michael Mulligan: What it requires is the facility for the person to be admitted to.
- 3:04Michael Mulligan: What good is it if the police bring somebody like that or the many other thousands of people who are in profound need of help in to the hospital, wait, and we've seen in Victoria's reports just the other week of the police waiting what was it?
- 3:18Michael Mulligan: Seven hours to see a doctor, right, and then having a doctor look at the person and say yes, yes, this person is seriously mentally ill, they're a danger to themselves, they're going to die of an overdose of drugs, they're a danger to somebody else, they're reacting erratically.
- 3:32Michael Mulligan: But I'm sorry officer, there's no work for them to be.
- 3:36Michael Mulligan: And even if they're admitted, you know there could be provision to admit somebody you know, on the review of one doctor, and they can then be in a facility for 48 hours.
- 3:44Michael Mulligan: There's this whole scheme.
- 3:45Michael Mulligan: But if the room doesn't exist, the doctors don't exist, and they don't exist, the person's back out.
- 3:53Michael Mulligan: And so while it's, of course, tragic and random and awful to hear about those things, it's also completely predictable and the answer isn't, in my view, to wait until one of the thousands of untreated mentally ill drug-addicted people lashes out and severs somebody's hand.
- 4:12Michael Mulligan: We know this is needed.
- 4:15Michael Mulligan: Deal with it before that happens.
- 4:17Michael Mulligan: Don't wait and try to deal with it as a shoplifting problem or as some total tragedy like this.
- 4:25Michael Mulligan: Get ahead of it.
- 4:26Michael Mulligan: This isn't new news, and it's not a legal problem and it's not a bail problem.
- 4:33Michael Mulligan: It's a problem with not having the resources necessary to deal with those things in advance.
- 4:39Michael Mulligan: And so we have thousands of people that are living on Pandora, and the answer is not to have moved them to church parking lots.
- 4:47Michael Mulligan: The answer is to address those underlying problems, and if we don't address those underlying problems, versions of this are going to continue to happen.
- 4:55Michael Mulligan: They will just absolutely continue to happen, and it's no longer a random act of violence in a real sense, because we know those things are going to occur.
- 5:03Michael Mulligan: Just listen to the chief of police.
- 5:05Michael Mulligan: So we'll have to wait and see what happens in that case, but it's pretty clear, in my view, what we need to be doing If we don't want those things to happen in the future.
- 5:13Michael Mulligan: We shouldn't just wait around for them to occur and then be aghast at the terrible human consequences of it.
- 5:19Michael Mulligan: We should get ahead of it.
- 5:21Michael Mulligan: It's not a humane circumstance to leave people who are in that state on Pandora or put them in a parking lot.
- 5:27Michael Mulligan: That's just outrageous.
- 5:29Michael Mulligan: And so I must say that was my reaction to that hearing the police chief talk about it and being somebody who's in the system and seeing some of these things, it's not just random.
- 5:38Michael Mulligan: We have the legislation.
- 5:39Michael Mulligan: What we need is a place where people can get that help they need so that this doesn't happen again.
- 5:44Michael Mulligan: Need is a place where people can get that help they need so that this doesn't happen again.
- 5:46Adam Stirling: Yeah, that's my, that's my opening.
- 5:47Adam Stirling: Well, and it makes sense, and we're accustomed to triage being an issue in acute medicine and in emergency rooms, but we're not accustomed to triage resulting in care being denied to a patient and that patient violently attacking us because of it.
- 5:58Adam Stirling: It's a novel instance of there being not enough medical resources that are harming public safety, and I think that's important to emphasize that.
- 6:06Adam Stirling: So I'm glad you did.
- 6:08Michael Mulligan: Yeah, no, it's just part of the ongoing just failure of the health system in the province.
- 6:13Michael Mulligan: Right, when you have people waiting 13 hours to in emergency departments, or police sitting there with somebody who's in a mental health crisis and danger to themselves or other for seven hours all night long, the officer having to sit there with the person and what else is to happen, you can't just leave that person in the hospital for the nurses to deal with, for heaven's sake.
- 6:31Michael Mulligan: So it's understandable why that's required, but it's just a demonstration of just how profoundly short we are and the resources needed to prevent these things, and that's why they are happening and that's why things like tinkering with the bail wording was just hopeless.
- 6:46Michael Mulligan: Uh, it's clear, in my view, what we need to do.
- 6:49Michael Mulligan: We just haven't done it.
- 6:50Adam Stirling: Yeah, that's right yeah, yeah, and for our audience's benefit you already told us of the bail.
- 6:55Adam Stirling: We can't legally use the bail system for either punishment or for medical treatment.
- 6:58Adam Stirling: It specifically says in the statute it can't be used that way.
- 7:01Michael Mulligan: So if we tried, it would get defeated in court anyway, as intended and and which of the thousands of people who are profoundly mentally ill and addicted to drugs do you wish to detain on bail?
- 7:12Michael Mulligan: yeah, we catch them stealing cheese at the supermarket all of them yeah, that's not going to work out and, moreover, we shouldn't just wait until the person goes and commits some minor crime or major crime and and then worry about the bail circumstance.
- 7:26Michael Mulligan: Why don't we get a little bit ahead of that so that people aren't having this sort of thing occur?
- 7:30Michael Mulligan: It's not acceptable and it's predictable, and I don't know how many more examples of this we need to have pointing the finger at just some wording change or the problem somehow is the bail wording in the criminal code.
- 7:40Michael Mulligan: It's like, if you haven't properly identified what the problem somehow is, you know the bail wording in the criminal code.
- 7:44Michael Mulligan: It's like if you're, if you point, if you haven't properly identified what the problem is, things you do trying to fix that are not going to succeed, and you know people should listen to the chief of police in Vancouver and focus on what might actually have an impact rather than pointing the finger at changing the wording of things.
- 8:02Michael Mulligan: We already have the legislation for it.
- 8:04Michael Mulligan: We just need the places for people to go to get that sort of secure treatment, and unfortunately, there are people who just need secure treatment.
- 8:12Michael Mulligan: We shouldn't get angry with them.
- 8:14Michael Mulligan: If you're suffering from a profound mental illness, you need help.
- 8:18Michael Mulligan: You know we shouldn't get angry and we shouldn't wait for you to steal cheese or lash out to cut somebody's hand off.
- 8:25Michael Mulligan: Get ahead of it.
- 8:25Michael Mulligan: That's what's required.
- 8:27Michael Mulligan: That's what we are not doing and that's why we see these things repeatedly.
- 8:31Michael Mulligan: You know, and they're all slightly different versions of you know, hot coffee on babies, or random people being attacked, or somebody stabbing, dying, or somebody's hand being severed, right, yes, each one of those things is randomly tragic in some level, but it's completely predictable.
- 8:46Michael Mulligan: And I must say, the responses to these things have put people in parking lots or things of that sort.
- 8:53Michael Mulligan: Or you know what?
- 8:53Michael Mulligan: Can we?
- 8:54Michael Mulligan: Can we detain somebody when we catch them stealing money to buy the drugs they're using while they live in a tent on Pandora?
- 8:59Michael Mulligan: It's just completely misguided.
- 9:02Michael Mulligan: And so you know, as I said, we shouldn't get angry with the people.
- 9:05Michael Mulligan: If you have a profound mental illness, if you have a drug addiction that's going to kill you, we need to deal with that.
- 9:10Michael Mulligan: We have the legislative scheme.
- 9:11Michael Mulligan: That's not the problem either.
- 9:12Michael Mulligan: We need the resources to do it, and it's just so upsetting when you see that those aren't provided and these are the consequences of it.
- 9:19Adam Stirling: So that's my cut on that All right Back on the air with Legally Speaking, joined by Michael Mulligan, barrister and solicitor, with Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 9:32Adam Stirling: Michael, thank you for that explanation of Canada's mental or, excuse me, British Columbia's Mental Health Act, the bail system and these troubling random repeat offender problems you and I have discussed for a couple of years now.
- 9:42Adam Stirling: What else is on our agenda for today.
- 9:45Michael Mulligan: The next case on the agenda ironically also involves a very serious injury to somebody's hand.
- 9:50Michael Mulligan: He still has the hand and this was a case that involved a civil claim against the province of British Columbia Ministry of Public Safety's Solicitor General involving injuries caused by a police dog and the fact pattern involved police got called to a domestic dispute in progress, a report of a woman being dragged out of bed by her ankles and making some threats.
- 10:16Michael Mulligan: The male making some threats.
- 10:18Michael Mulligan: He apparently left the house with a knife, keyed her car and had made some threat to the person's cat.
- 10:28Michael Mulligan: So that was the fact pattern the police showed up at.
- 10:31Michael Mulligan: When the police got there, the man was out of the house and in a barn in the back of the property and two officers showed up, one of whom decided to draw his service revolver or not revolver service handgun, not a revolver and pointed at the man.
- 10:49Michael Mulligan: Told the man that he was under arrest.
- 10:51Michael Mulligan: Told him to put his hands up he did that.
- 10:53Michael Mulligan: Told the man to walk out of the barn he did that.
- 10:55Michael Mulligan: Told the man to get down on his knees he did that and so the man's kneeling outside the barn.
- 11:02Michael Mulligan: The other officer is standing there with a dog attached to a long lead.
- 11:06Michael Mulligan: The officers then tell the man, kneeling with his hands up, to lay out prone on the ground.
- 11:13Michael Mulligan: He doesn't do that.
- 11:15Michael Mulligan: He's described by the judge as appeared calm, nonviolent and was speaking to the officers.
- 11:21Michael Mulligan: The man's explanation for not wanting to lay down on his stomach on the ground is he said that there was a large puddle in front of him.
- 11:27Michael Mulligan: Ultimately, the judge found that the ground was wet, but it wasn't a large puddle, so I don't know quite what that amounts to.
- 11:36Michael Mulligan: So water, but not a large body of water.
- 11:39Michael Mulligan: The officer who's holding the dog on the lead decides to release the dog, and the dog runs at the man and winds up, seriously biting him on his hand, causing injuries.
- 11:53Michael Mulligan: It had to be the hospital.
- 11:54Michael Mulligan: He's off, work for a couple of months, caused pain and other things, and so the case involved whether the police had legal authority to release the dog on the man, and there are some special provisions in the criminal code.
- 12:09Michael Mulligan: The police have authority to use force that other people would not be permitted to use force for.
- 12:15Michael Mulligan: Some of those include section 25 of the criminal code.
- 12:19Michael Mulligan: It allows the police to use force to prevent harm to themselves or others.
- 12:28Michael Mulligan: It also allows force to be used for the purpose of arresting somebody, which is interesting.
- 12:33Michael Mulligan: Those provisions have some special provisions that would permit the use of force intended to cause death or grievous bodily harm even, for example, if somebody is taking flight to avoid an arrest, although there's a limiting provision there that they can't use that kind of death or grievous bodily harm level force if that could be prevented in a less violent manner.
- 12:57Michael Mulligan: So that's the sort of special provisions that allow police to use additional use force to carry out their duties.
- 13:05Michael Mulligan: And so here the judge was analyzing were those covered by the decision to release the dog.
- 13:13Michael Mulligan: And ultimately it was interesting that the judge, I think, was impressed by the general quality of the evidence from the police officer who released the dog and took pains to point out that the officer appeared to be somebody who took obvious pride in serving his community, had a difficult job and had to make split-second decisions, but here found that there just wasn't a legal basis to release the dog on the man and there was some frank evidence that he was asked.
- 13:46Michael Mulligan: The officer was asked about things like you know what other kind of force could be used.
- 13:49Michael Mulligan: There was a frank admission that you know the officer with his gun out couldn't shoot a man who's kneeling with his hands up.
- 13:58Michael Mulligan: That would be murder.
- 13:59Michael Mulligan: Yes, I think it's true, yeah.
- 14:01Michael Mulligan: And then there's discussion about well, could you have tasered him and, you know, could you have backed up and done this and that?
- 14:06Michael Mulligan: But ultimately the judge concluded that this was not permitted by those provisions.
- 14:12Michael Mulligan: And I should say, you do see, with some frequency in my line of work, injuries caused by police dogs, and some of them are very serious.
- 14:22Michael Mulligan: And so here the result was that, even though the officer had to make a quick decision, it was not the right decision and wasn't legally justified.
- 14:31Michael Mulligan: Had to make a quick decision, it was not the right decision and wasn't legally justified, and so the province has been ordered to pay the man $20,000 for lost income.
- 14:37Michael Mulligan: He was off work for a period of time due to the injury, and he was awarded an additional $40,000 in non-pecuniary damages for the ongoing pain and suffering in his hand.
- 14:46Michael Mulligan: It was apparently quite a serious injury.
- 14:48Michael Mulligan: So, cautionary tale, and I think, important to know, there is authority to use quite a bit of force by the police, including in some cases, deadly force, when they're arresting somebody.
- 15:00Michael Mulligan: But real care has to be exercised, because even when they're split-second decisions, if it's split-second and wrong, it can result in not only serious injury or death but in this case, even when that doesn't occur, pretty significant financial consequences.
- 15:16Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest from the BC Supreme Court on the police dog injury.
- 15:23Adam Stirling: All right.
- 15:23Adam Stirling: As our audience knows, we had an encampment at the University of Victoria for a significant amount of time.
- 15:28Adam Stirling: It was protesting the ongoing conflict involving Israel and Gaza.
- 15:32Adam Stirling: That encampment ended up voluntarily disbanding recently at the request and any number of, perhaps legal threats that I've heard speculated from the University of Victoria, never coming to fruition as far as we know, because, of course, the conflict was resolved.
- 15:47Adam Stirling: Not the same situation, though, at other institutions elsewhere on Vancouver Island.
- 15:52Adam Stirling: There's ongoing issues, are there not?
- 15:55Michael Mulligan: What can you tell us?
- 15:56Michael Mulligan: Yeah, so one of those cases just resulted in an interim injunction to end an encampment, and this was one up at Vancouver Island University, just a little bit up the island.
- 16:07Michael Mulligan: And it's these interim injunction applications.
- 16:11Michael Mulligan: We've talked about that before.
- 16:14Michael Mulligan: Many people would be familiar with the test that's generally applied when one party is seeking an interim injunction, like in order to stop doing something.
- 16:21Michael Mulligan: Yeah, what you know.
- 16:23Michael Mulligan: Well, the case is still outstanding.
- 16:26Michael Mulligan: And one of the things which is interesting, I thought was worth noting in this decision, was it pointed out that that general test.
- 16:32Michael Mulligan: There's sort of a three-part test.
- 16:34Michael Mulligan: You have to assess the merits of the case.
- 16:35Michael Mulligan: You have to see whether there's irreparable harm and that doesn't mean serious harm, it means like harm you couldn't easily sort out by payment of money later.
- 16:44Michael Mulligan: And then there's a balancing of interests right in terms of which party would suffer greater harm with or without the injunction.
- 16:51Michael Mulligan: But one of the interesting things the judge points out here I think people should know about it is that when you're dealing with an application for an interim injunction involving trespass of private property, that same balancing that comes from that RJRGR McDonald case does not generally apply, and the reason for that is that for trespass that's when somebody is occupying land that belongs to somebody else that's actionable without any proof of damages, which sort of makes sense.
- 17:24Michael Mulligan: Because, let's say, I don't just decide that every day I'm going to come and stand in your driveway, right, just kind of stand there or set up a tent and just live in your front yard or something like that.
- 17:34Michael Mulligan: Right, there may be no apparent financial loss flowing from that.
- 17:38Michael Mulligan: Right, if I just say, oh, I just pitched my tent on your yard, what's the problem?
- 17:42Michael Mulligan: Right, but one of the functions of having private property is that it's not really a meaningful concept if anyone else can just show up and live there.
- 17:51Michael Mulligan: Right, hey, here I am, I'm back, I'm living in your front yard, and so when there's an application for an interim injunction on the basis of trespass, you don't go through.
- 18:01Michael Mulligan: A court would not go through that RJR balancing test.
- 18:04Michael Mulligan: Well, you know who would be more prejudiced here.
- 18:06Michael Mulligan: You know, the yellow spot on your lawn from my tent versus my desire to live on your lawn.
- 18:12Michael Mulligan: That doesn't apply.
- 18:14Michael Mulligan: The idea is get off the lawn.
- 18:16Michael Mulligan: It's not your house, you can't be there.
- 18:19Michael Mulligan: Now there is a retort to that, which can in some cases.
- 18:25Michael Mulligan: There is a decision from the previous Chief Justice Hinkson saying that, well, there can be some analysis under that RGR McDonald test where there are charter issues to be decided.
- 18:35Michael Mulligan: And so here, not surprisingly, the encampers were arguing hey, we've got a constitutional right to be encamped at Vancouver Island University, but the reason that got short shift in this decision is that we there's a previous court of appeal decision that determined that the university of Victoria is not subject to the charter.
- 18:56Michael Mulligan: And that goes back to just a fundamental principle of how the charter works in Canada, one of the very early charter cases, and the idea there is that the charter is applicable to the government, not other private actors.
- 19:12Michael Mulligan: Right, like you don't have a constitutional right of any kind to camp in your yard, right?
- 19:21Michael Mulligan: The reason that could you know?
- 19:22Michael Mulligan: That's just not how the charter works.
- 19:25Michael Mulligan: It's like the charter doesn't impose obligations on private people or private parties or corporations or anyone else.
- 19:31Michael Mulligan: It applies to the government doing things to people, not.
- 19:34Michael Mulligan: You know what has Adam done with his driveway and how?
- 19:37Michael Mulligan: Dare he say you can't live here, right.
- 19:39Michael Mulligan: And so the problem with that charter argument is that it doesn't apply to the University of Victoria.
- 19:46Michael Mulligan: It's very unlikely to apply to the university, to Vancouver Island University, and so the judge didn't have much trouble, even though the judge did take the time to analyze whether that might have some application here.
- 19:58Michael Mulligan: The conclusion was pretty quickly no, it's very unlikely that's going to have any application here.
- 20:05Michael Mulligan: And so the net result was the granting of the interim injunction to stop the encampment.
- 20:11Michael Mulligan: And it's also important to know.
- 20:13Michael Mulligan: You know people talk about sort of freedom of speech and freedom of protest and all those things.
- 20:17Michael Mulligan: Again, that doesn't apply to a private place, right?
- 20:21Michael Mulligan: You have no right to come into your living room and protest, right.
- 20:26Michael Mulligan: The fact that you are protesting, that's fascinating, but that doesn't afford you the right to do so anywhere you want, and it doesn't afford you the right to in this case, you know, with the injunction being sought wasn't trying to seek an injunction that would prevent somebody from holding up a sign or marching or saying something.
- 20:45Michael Mulligan: It was.
- 20:45Michael Mulligan: You know, get the tents and crates and so on out of there, you can't live here.
- 20:49Michael Mulligan: And so the injunction was granted, and that's the latest from Vancouver Island University.
- 20:55Adam Stirling: All right, we've got about 60 seconds left in today's segment.
- 20:58Adam Stirling: How shall we spend them?
- 21:00Michael Mulligan: Sure Final case.
- 21:01Michael Mulligan: It's a case involving a lime green Porsche, described as the color of Kermit the Frog, and the reason the case was interesting is it involves this issue of a summary trial and when you can have one.
- 21:12Michael Mulligan: The lime green Porsche case involved a dispute about what a contract was to import.
- 21:20Michael Mulligan: The, it turns out, person who had the possession of the Porsche paid $179,000 for the lime green Kermit the Frog Porsche, but there was a dispute about whether that was the whole amount due or whether they had to pay 25% tax that was due on it.
- 21:34Michael Mulligan: So there's a dispute and both parties wanted to have one of these things called a summary trial, which is like a trial decided in chambers in Supreme Court, based on reading affidavits.
- 21:44Michael Mulligan: The idea is it's like quick, we get the dispute sorted out cheaper A good idea.
- 21:49Michael Mulligan: The problem why it wasn't applicable here is that there was a fundamental dispute about what was the agreement.
- 21:54Michael Mulligan: What do these people say to each other?
- 21:56Michael Mulligan: What was the?
- 21:56Michael Mulligan: You know?
- 21:57Michael Mulligan: Was that check supposed to include the tax or not?
- 21:59Michael Mulligan: And so, while that's a good process and is a good way to inexpensively and quickly resolve legal disputes, it doesn't work if the judge is just unable to figure out like well, what was the agreement about this Kermit the Frog-colored car?
- 22:13Michael Mulligan: And that just can't be sorted out by reading these two completely conflicting affidavits.
- 22:18Michael Mulligan: And so that's what a summary trial is afflicting affidavits.
- 22:22Michael Mulligan: And so that's what a summary trial is.
- 22:23Michael Mulligan: That's why it works in many cases, but why it doesn't work when the underlying problem is really what went on, not what is the legal effect of something.
- 22:28Michael Mulligan: So that's summary trials.
- 22:30Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan, with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking during the second half of our second hour every Thursday.
- 22:35Adam Stirling: Michael, thank you, pleasure as always.
- 22:37Adam Stirling: Thank you so much.
- 22:38Adam Stirling: Have a great day.