Latest / Catalyst: A Podcast of Thought / Flow With Force: Chapter 3 - When Force Stops Working
Transcript
- Catalyst - Could It Be?: Have you ever noticed what happens the moment something stops working? A conversation, a relationship, your golf swing, your body, your work. Whatever it is, our first instinct is remarkably consistent. We don't usually pause, we push. We lean in a little harder, we think a little longer, we tighten our grip just enough to regain control. After all, that's how many of us learn to solve problems. More attention, more discipline, more force. And to be fair, that approach has served many of us remarkably well. Until, of course, it doesn't. Welcome to Catalyst, a podcast of thought. I'm Dr. G, an executive coach, trained ethnographer, and nonfiction nerd. I read wildly, annotate obsessively, and spend a great deal of time thinking about how ideas shape the way we live, lead, and notice the world around us. In this episode, I explore that moment when force quietly transforms into friction. Not because force is wrong. But because it has been applied without first asking what the situation actually requires. Because sometimes the answer isn't more force. Sometimes the answer is a different relationship with force itself. One of the more difficult realizations I've had over the past few years is that force and effectiveness are not always correlated. Positively, that is. Sometimes they are, sometimes they are not. In certain situations, adding more force doesn't simply stop helping, it begins to introduce new problems of its own. The golfer starts thinking about every muscle in the swing. The leader begins micromanaging capable people. The parent lectures instead of listens. The coach talks more and asks less. The situation tightens in an attempt to create control, and in doing so, quietly denies us of the very flow it was trying to create. There's a moment when force shifts, not visibly, experientially. You're doing more, trying harder, paying closer attention. Instead of things improving, they begin feeling strained, less fluid, less responsive. Less alive. That's easy to misinterpret. Force has almost always been associated with progress. When things stop improving, the instinct is rarely to simply pause. It's to increase force. Push harder, focus more, control more precisely, refine the process, tighten the variables. For a brief moment, it can even feel like all that force is helping. Underneath it all, something else is happening. What once produced clear results begins flattening. You put in more and receive less back, not nothing, just less. The relationship changes. Force no longer scales the way it once did. That creates tension because it challenges one of the deepest beliefs many high functioning people hold that if I apply enough force, I can improve the outcome. That belief works beautifully in many environments, until it doesn't. I experienced this phenomenon firsthand while playing golf. It starts in my hands, then my forearms tighten, then the biceps, ironically, completely unnecessary muscles for the task at hand. The shoulders, the chest, the neck. I flex them all. I'm ready for battle. I haven't even moved the club. My body, trying to help, begins preparing to control every possible variable before the swing even begins. Anyone who plays golf already knows what comes next. The tighter you become, the more variables you unintentionally introduce. Timing shifts, tempo disappears, feel, touch, evaporates. Fluidity, yeah, forget about that. You start steering instead of swinging, managing instead of moving. The most frustrating part is that in my head, the force feels productive. I feel engaged, focused, disciplined. Meanwhile, my golf ball is entering neighboring zip codes. That's what makes diminishing returns psychologically difficult to recognize. From the inside, it often still feels like commitment. Commitment and constriction are not the same thing. Over time, especially in complex environments or situations, force can shift from integrated participation to fragmented management. You stop moving as a whole in partnership. You begin micromanaging components, situations, people. This can occur professionally, relationally, emotionally. I once worked with a school system that wanted support in aligning curriculum across grade levels. The teaching staff had worked together for nearly a decade. Strong relationships, deep community knowledge, many even had their own children in the school system. My task was relatively straightforward, help guide curriculum alignment. Simple enough, except I didn't approach it simply. I approached it as someone unconsciously trying to justify his usefulness through over preparation. Using force to validate my identity. So I spent days building spreadsheets, tracking systems, alignment maps, curriculum structures, cross-grade analysis documents. Then came the PowerPoint. Of course, there was a wonderful PowerPoint. Hours and hours of preparation, frameworks, citations, lots of impressive citations, and visuals and Graphic designs and process designs, the whole nine yards and a tenth thrown in for good measure. I arrived pretty proud of myself. All the force I put into it, right? Ready to all the team with my vision. Weeks of preparation into an hour-long presentation. So I deliver it. And then I receive silence. The teachers glanced at each other, looked at their leader. Finally the principal gently politely said, Greg, thank you for all this work, but we already have a system for tracking our curriculum. We know where the gaps are. We've basically already planned the wedding. We just needed you to usher us down the aisle. Bingo bango bongo. That one hit hard. Deep down I already knew it before she said it. I had not really responded to their ask. I responded through force to my own internal need to demonstrate value. That's an uncomfortable realization, especially for fixers, right? Especially for those of us who will whose identities have been built around contribution through capability. Over time, the lines, I want to help and I need to prove my usefulness, meld together. The more tightly our identity is connected to effectiveness, the harder it becomes to recognize when force itself begins to interfere. This happens more frequently now. We live inside an optimization economy, professionally, relationally, culturally. We're told everything can and should be improved. Improve your productivity, sleep, body, parenting, focus, workflow, diet, routine. attention span, leadership style, and even your ability to recover from improving, well that needs improving too. The modern world increasingly treats human beings like endlessly adjustable systems, requiring constant calibration. To be fair, some optimization is useful, some refinement does matter. This Flown with Force podcast series is not anti-improvement, anti-optimization. There's a threshold where refinement stops serving function and starts serving anxiety, where awareness shifts into hypervigilance, as discussed in the last episode, where force becomes fragmentation. You stop trusting integrated movement and begin controlling isolated parts of it. This happens physically. Athletes know this. Musicians know this, public speakers know this. The harder you consciously manage every component of a highly practiced behavior, the more unnatural it often becomes. There's neuroscience underneath all this, embodied cognition. Much of human performance eventually relies on subconscious integration developed through repetition and trust. Excessive conscious intervention can interrupt that integration entirely. Your body often knows how to move before your mind learns how to stop interfering with it. This doesn't only happen in performance environments, it happens in life. I felt this deeply during the final years of my classroom teaching career. I was approaching 20 years in education. Our own children were they're getting older. I'd spent years learning how to work effectively, how to reduce hours without reducing effectiveness, so I could spend more time with my family. At least that's what I told myself. But something had shifted. I was phoning it in, as they say. Not catastrophically, but subtly. I often told my students and my own children, meet or exceed expectations. Though if I'm being honest, what it really meant was exceed expectations or see me disappointed. During my final years in the K-12 classroom, I wasn't even meeting many of my own expectations anymore. Physically, I was in the worst shape of my life. I hadn't exercised consistently in years. My attention was fragmented, my frustration threshold collapsed quickly, anger surfaced more easily. I was exhausted. Not the satisfying exhaustion that follows meaningful force. The kind that comes from constant internal management. I was no longer moving with my life. I was holding myself together inside of it. Lucky for me, my wife noticed. She helped me realize how I was shoehorning myself into a lifestyle through force. There's grief in that realization. Real grief. Sometimes the hardest truth is not that we have failed. It's that the strategy that once built our lives no longer sustains it. The identity that once protected us now constrains us. The force that once produced movement now produces friction. That kind of realization creates a very specific form of mourning, not dramatic mourning, quiet. Of an old relationship with yourself. I observed similar patterns among experienced educators transitioning into new teaching environments during my doctoral research. The dominant emotional experience wasn't excitement, it was grief. Every participant described some version of grieving the loss of their previous professional identity. You see, competence is often contextual. People don't just lose routines when environments change. They lose fluency, confidence, predictability, identity coherence. When old strategies stop producing familiar results, the instinct is often to intensify force, not to reconsider the relationship between force and the environment in which it's being used. That distinction matters enormously. Sometimes what feels like failure exactly Just misalignment between strategy and context. Often the body recognizes that misalignment before the mind does. A dozen years after changing my professional environment, I found myself in a similar but different relationship with concerted force. Although my mind, yet again, did not recognize the dynamic, my body certainly did. In twenty twenty five, my nervous system finally made the noise of strategic misalignment impossible to ignore. Gastrointestinal issues, inflammatory disorder, emotional fatigue, all signals, not punishment, signals. My body was informing me that constant internal force had become unsustainable. The most difficult part? Realizing how long I had mistaken tension for discipline. How long I had interpreted urgency as responsibility. How long I had equated control with effectiveness. That's one reason stepping back becomes so difficult when force stops working. Stepping back feels irresponsible to those of us conditioned toward increasing force. Using force, well, it feels passive, unproductive. It feels dangerously close to weakness. Stepping back is often the only way to accurately assess the relationship between your force and the environment itself. I learned this lesson again through instructional coaching. Early in my coaching career, I worked primarily with first year teachers. Observation, feedback, direction, critique. The process fit the need. Then I began supporting experienced educators, transitioning to new schools or grade levels. I used the exact same approach Observation, feedback, direction, critique. It went poorly, to say the least. The feedback surveys from these experienced educators included words like condescending, patronizing. Those words hurt. Those words were accurate, but they hurt. I was applying the same force based structure to a completely different environment. These well seasoned, highly competent teachers did not need heavy direction. They needed reflection. Clarification. Partnership. That shift changed my perspective significantly. Professionally and personally, soon thereafter, three simple coaching questions altered my entire relationship with helping others. The first, what's on your mind? Second, and what else? And lastly, how might I help? That's it. Three simple yet sequenced questions. Those questions were asking me to be more than just a subject matter expert. It asked me to restrain myself, to remain present, to participate without possessing. Slowly I began to realize something important. Sometimes to truly help, we must step back enough for integrated movement to return. Not withdraw, not disengage, just provide enough space. for the wholeness of the situation to reorganize itself. Many situations in life do not improve through additional blunt force force. They improve through more accurate force, force aligning to timing, to context, to a relationship, to a degree of influence. That distinction changes things. Here's what I hope stays with you. The answer may not always be force. Maybe it's just more accurate force. Maybe it's less about force and more about accuracy itself. Our body is always signaling us, like the difference between flow and force. We often forget that noise and signals are the same, same but different. When your body doesn't respond to control, you're left in a space that most of us aren't practiced in. You can't get ahead of it, can't solve it, you can only move through it. That's a different relationship. And that's not one that most of us choose willingly. That's where we'll begin in the next episode in the Flow with Force series, chapter four, When the Body Doesn't Listen. I'm Dr. G. Those are my thoughts. Thanks for listening.