Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Follow the Red Flags: Recovering Stolen Wealth in Elder Abuse Litigation with Stewart Levin, Esq.
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome everyone in the webcast audience to the
- 0:10Elder Law Committee of the Trust and Estate Section
- 0:13of the Beverly Hills Bar. I'm Terry Maggety,
- 0:16the chair of our committee. And the first thing
- 0:19I do before we start the program, we want to
- 0:22show appreciation for our sponsors of this, this
- 0:26committee. First sponsor is the one that's been
- 0:31with us for the longest time, Sanborn team. That's
- 0:35Nancy Sanborn and Brian Joy. They're real estate
- 0:39brokers who work in the trust probate conservatorship
- 0:44space and We really appreciate them. They've
- 0:47been our sponsor for many many years. So thank
- 0:51you the Sanborn team our next sponsor is a sponsor
- 0:58that's really Someone people we know the people
- 1:02but the the organizations we know if you're working
- 1:05in probate downtown that's or downtown any any
- 1:09places really and that's the people i'm talking
- 1:12about are the folks from bond services of california
- 1:15and from liberty mutual surety um they're also
- 1:19our sponsors they do a a wonderful job they provide
- 1:24great service and i don't need to Anybody who
- 1:28works in the probate court knows that. Just spectacular
- 1:32service to all of us. They deal in the same space,
- 1:38trusts, conservatorships, probates. Thank you
- 1:42Bond Services of California and Liberty Mutual
- 1:46Surety. Then we also have Pickford Escrow Company.
- 1:53organization that works in our space and is very
- 1:57expert in the type of deals we do in trust, probate,
- 2:03conservatorships. So thank you very much, Pickford
- 2:06Escrow Company. And finally, last but not least,
- 2:11California Title Company. There are also in our
- 2:15world lots of special title issues that pop up
- 2:18all the time. And it's nice to have a title company
- 2:21that really knows those issues in our probate
- 2:24trust and conservatorship space. So thank you,
- 2:28California Title Company. And now it's my pleasure
- 2:34to introduce our speaker. Stuart Levin, it's
- 2:39so nice when we have a speaker that I don't need
- 2:43to look at someone's bio because Stuart's got
- 2:46a long bio and he's been practicing for well
- 2:50over 30 years in the elder abuse litigation arena.
- 2:57But I don't need to look at anything because
- 3:00I've seen Stuart in action. So Stuart is an expert
- 3:05litigator. and he does trials. He's an excellent
- 3:09trial attorney. He's an excellent strategist,
- 3:12and it's been such a pleasure to see him in action.
- 3:18I've just observed firsthand, you know, staying
- 3:22calm in the middle of the storm, which a lot
- 3:25of these cases are storms, and just looking at
- 3:30things very analytically and strategically to
- 3:34get a great result. I mean, I've seen it over
- 3:38and over with Stuart. So it's such a pleasure
- 3:40to have him here to talk. And the title of his
- 3:47talk today, Follow the Red Flags, Recovering
- 3:52Stolen Wealth in Elder Abuse Litigation, something
- 3:57that I've seen Stuart do. So now we'll be honored
- 4:02to hear to hear the details of that. And I'm
- 4:06going to turn it over to Stuart now, and I'm
- 4:09going to sign off, but I'll be back later in
- 4:14the program to help facilitate any questions
- 4:16and answers. So Stuart, the floor is yours. Thank
- 4:20you, Terry. Good afternoon, everyone. We could
- 4:22go to the next slide, please. So as with all
- 4:28pieces of litigation, there's a winner and a
- 4:30loser. The only point I want to make right now
- 4:33is that If we are on the side of undoing financial
- 4:36elder abuse and it's like into a chess game,
- 4:40we're wiped. Next slide, please. So I'd like
- 4:46to begin by telling a story. There was a man
- 4:49who died leaving 17 camels to his three sons.
- 4:57and he had an estate plan and the man's estate
- 5:00plan said, one half of the camels go to my oldest
- 5:03son, and one third of the camels go to my middle
- 5:09son, and two camels go to my youngest son. So
- 5:17the sons were puzzled and they had no idea what
- 5:20to do. Seventeen didn't seem to divide like that.
- 5:24So they went to a wise woman who told them, I
- 5:27will give you one of my camels. So now they had
- 5:2918 camels. The oldest son now got half, which
- 5:36was nine. The next son got six and there were
- 5:38three camels left over. Then the wise woman said,
- 5:44now I will take my camel back. And that left
- 5:47two for the youngest son. So the reason I like
- 5:52to start with that story is the way facts come
- 5:56in a case, they never seem to divide and there
- 5:59never seems to be two left over for the youngest
- 6:02son. There's always problems and you have to
- 6:05kind of get to the bottom of the case to understand
- 6:09how to make the facts work for your case. In
- 6:12financial elder abuse cases, nothing happens
- 6:15by accident. An elder does not willingly become
- 6:19a victim. These are stories by individuals whose
- 6:22trust has been betrayed, who are misled, manipulated
- 6:26or defrauded by those they relied upon. We see
- 6:29suspicious transfers to individuals who have
- 6:32no legitimate claim, dispositions that run counter
- 6:35to a long established estate plan, transfers
- 6:38that are contrary to natural family relationships
- 6:42or historically close relationships. And when
- 6:45we see these odd transfers and the products of
- 6:50financial elder abuse, we are seeing red flags
- 6:53that point to misconduct. So just like in a football
- 6:56game, when the red flag is thrown, that means
- 6:59there's been a violation. So whenever we see
- 7:02the red flags, which are generally brought to
- 7:05us by our client, we have to look for the underlying
- 7:10violation. There's always a story. There's always
- 7:13a reason why things happen. And our job is to
- 7:17uncover the underlying misconduct to get the
- 7:20actual story that happened so we can tell it
- 7:23to the trier fact or tell it to the jury. Next
- 7:27slide, please. Once you have your story down,
- 7:32it's much easier for a jury or even a judge to
- 7:36process the information because as we were all
- 7:40apparently used to sitting around the campfire
- 7:42in the olden days and all there was to do was
- 7:45tell stories, we're hardwired to want to hear
- 7:48a story. So if you can put together all the facts
- 7:51just before trial or during your discovery process,
- 7:55you're going to be able to tell a powerful story
- 7:57and get the processing of information on your
- 8:00side. Next slide, please. There is currently
- 8:06an epidemic of financial elder abuse. It's a
- 8:10crisis that continues to grow. As people get
- 8:13older, their property, particularly in California,
- 8:17appreciates in value. Their mind is more vulnerable.
- 8:21There was a study in Harvard Business School
- 8:22that says that even competent people who are
- 8:26aged 85 often make very bad investment decisions.
- 8:31So there's a piece missing as the human being
- 8:34gets older. And that's the piece that unscrupulous
- 8:38individuals can take advantage of. If a person
- 8:40goes into a bank with a gun and they rob a bank,
- 8:44they'll be lucky as it were to depart with a
- 8:46couple hundred thousand and they'll probably
- 8:47end up in jail. But if a person commits financial
- 8:50elder abuse. their rewards are much, much higher
- 8:54and the risks are much, much lower. So this is
- 8:57a very attractive proposition for unscrupulous
- 9:01individuals. In addition, financial elder abuse
- 9:06violators are often very narcissistic. They don't
- 9:11think they're robbing a bank. They don't think
- 9:13they're doing anything wrong. They think they're
- 9:15helping the individual that they are financially
- 9:18abusing. And that's why a lot of these cases
- 9:21go to trial. And even when people lose the trial
- 9:25and the judge or the jury has decided that they
- 9:28did commit financial exploitation of an elder,
- 9:31they just think everyone else is wrong. So these
- 9:35cases are epidemic and they require a lot of
- 9:40litigation commitment. Next slide, please. So
- 9:46here's here's A little bit of a summary of the
- 9:50key statute in the Welfare and Institutions Code.
- 9:54Financial abuse occurs when a person or entity
- 9:56does any of the following, takes, secretes, appropriates,
- 10:00obtains, or retains any interest in real or personal
- 10:04property for wrongful use or with intent to defraud
- 10:07or both, or assists in doing any of the described
- 10:11acts, or does any of the foregoing through undue
- 10:14influence. And in this context, wrongful use
- 10:18is considered to be when a person or entity knows
- 10:24or should have known that his conduct is likely
- 10:27to be harmful to the elder or dependent adult
- 10:30because these cases also apply to dependent adults.
- 10:36So let's take an example of how we can apply
- 10:39this because it's a very powerful statute. I
- 10:43had a case recently where an elder over the age
- 10:46of 65 made an unsuitable investment. At the time
- 10:50the elder made the investment, it seemed like
- 10:53a good investment. The elder indicated he understood
- 10:57the investment. He signed a piece of paper saying
- 11:00he understood the investment, he understood the
- 11:02risks, he understood the permutations. So for
- 11:05a person under 65 who's not a dependent adult,
- 11:10This is likely a defensible case. But what happens
- 11:14when you aim the elder view statute at this kind
- 11:16of situation? So in this particular case, I did
- 11:21a videotape deposition of a managing agent of
- 11:26the corporation that was responsible for selling
- 11:29the investment. By this time, the investment
- 11:31had gone south. So what were they doing? Even
- 11:36though the taking or secreting or appropriating
- 11:38of the money might not have been with wrongful
- 11:42use, that is, with knowledge that the conduct
- 11:46was likely to be harmful or was harmful, by that
- 11:49time, a few years down the road, everyone knew
- 11:52the investment had gone south and they were continuing
- 11:55to retain the elder's money. So this is critical.
- 11:59And they knew that it was harmful to the elder
- 12:02because the elder had lost money. There's two
- 12:06types of evidence you want to get when you're
- 12:10doing discovery in these cases. One is your standard
- 12:13discovery. You always want to be the person who
- 12:16does the subpoena. You don't want to rely on
- 12:18anyone giving any information for free because
- 12:21it's often not complete information. So you want
- 12:26to subpoena medical records, you want to subpoena
- 12:28bank statements, you want to subpoena whatever
- 12:32you can. But in addition, there's the kind of
- 12:35discovery where you can create evidence. So in
- 12:38this case, I had the managing agent. The managing
- 12:40agent acknowledged there was harm to the elder
- 12:43because the money was lost. Then I asked the
- 12:45managing agent, do you have authority to give
- 12:49this elderly person back their money? So managing
- 12:52agent, he did have authority. So I asked them,
- 12:56are you willing right now to commit on the record,
- 13:00in video? to give this elderly person back their
- 13:03money, and he said no. So now you have basically,
- 13:07he's admitting to statutory financial elder abuse,
- 13:10he's ratifying the conduct, and now you're going
- 13:13to expose that corporation to powerful financial
- 13:17elder abuse remedies, which we'll get to in a
- 13:19minute, plus with ratification by corporation,
- 13:23the prospect of punitive damages. So if you get
- 13:28someone who's a managing agent, and they come
- 13:31in to the deposition as they often will because
- 13:36they're well coached and they don't want to ratify
- 13:38the conduct and ratification is necessary to
- 13:40get punitive damages. So they're basically saying
- 13:44to whatever you ask them, well, I don't know,
- 13:46I was not involved. So your job in the deposition
- 13:49is to lay out all the evidence of the case right
- 13:53in front of them and educate that managing agent.
- 13:56So now they do know. They can't say, I don't
- 13:58know anymore because you've educated them on
- 14:00the record. And now you can ask them, given your
- 14:03knowledge of the situation, does what happened
- 14:06meet your policies and procedures? Do you approve
- 14:09of what happened? Do you have authority to give
- 14:11the elderly money back their investment? Are
- 14:14you willing to do that? So this can be very creative
- 14:18use of discovery and it's often not expected.
- 14:22So there's the evidence you get in discovery.
- 14:25and the evidence you create during discovery.
- 14:28Now, another form of elder abuse is assisting
- 14:32in taking, secreting, appropriating, obtaining,
- 14:35or retaining real property or personal property
- 14:38of an elder for wrongful use or with intent to
- 14:40defraud. So how do you get to assisting? Well,
- 14:45very often we have a fact situation. where someone
- 14:49wants to get their name on a deed. So they come
- 14:51up with a reason why their name should be on
- 14:53the deed. For example, let's refinance the loan
- 14:57on your property. Let's make it a 30 year instead
- 15:00of a 15. That's reduced the interest rate. The
- 15:03elderly person may be property rich, but not
- 15:05have a lot of income at that point. So this person
- 15:08offers to co -sign the loan. And in order to
- 15:14co -sign the loan, that person's putting up their
- 15:16financial information. So they are very involved
- 15:20in the whole process. And the idea is that they
- 15:24get the loan. Title is transferred to the elder
- 15:28and the new person, often by design and joint
- 15:31tenancy. And then the plan is to then put title
- 15:37back in the name of the elder once they get the
- 15:39loan, only somehow that never happens, and the
- 15:43person rides out the clock till the elderly person
- 15:46dies. So not only are we suing at that point
- 15:50to undo the transaction and to sue the person
- 15:55who was directly involved in it, but whoever
- 15:59assisted in it. That's the loan broker, the lender.
- 16:04Sometimes there'll be an attorney who was involved.
- 16:07because those can be deep pockets. So you're
- 16:09not only going after getting the property back,
- 16:12but you're going after a deep pocket and that
- 16:14can be important. And let's have the next slide.
- 16:19So one of the reasons it's important to have
- 16:21a deep pocket is that in financial elder abuse,
- 16:26you just have to win by preponderance of evidence
- 16:29and you get attorney's fees. You get reasonable
- 16:33attorney's fees and costs. you not only can get
- 16:36reasonable attorney's fees, but if you are on
- 16:39a contingency fee arrangement, as I often am,
- 16:42you can ask for a multiple of your reasonable
- 16:46attorney's fees. Recently, we had a case where
- 16:52we got attorney's fees with a load star, and
- 16:56it was like 1 .7 our normal fee, which ends up
- 16:59being a very healthy fee. So if you have a deep
- 17:03pocket available, attorney's fees and costs can
- 17:06be very helpful. And if you're suing a corporation
- 17:09where they are deep pocket, that can really incentivize
- 17:12settlement. Next slide, please. Another extremely
- 17:19powerful remedy is double damages under probate
- 17:23code 859. So if there's the person finds that
- 17:28there's been bad faith, wrongfully taking concealed
- 17:32or disposed of property belonging to an elder,
- 17:35or it's taken concealed or disposed of property
- 17:37by these of undue influence and bad faith, or
- 17:41through the commission of elder or dependent
- 17:44adult financial abuse. So just if you qualify
- 17:48under the elder abuse statute that we just looked
- 17:50at, which also applies equally to dependent adults,
- 17:55you not only can get attorney's fees, with the
- 17:58possibility of a multiple on your regular attorney
- 18:01fee, hourly fee, but you can get double damages.
- 18:04And these double damages are not like punitive
- 18:07damages. They are a true penalty. You don't have
- 18:10to show the financial wherewithal of the defendant
- 18:14to get them. And this can be very, very useful
- 18:18because sometimes you're only going to get half
- 18:22of the property back. And in that case, if you
- 18:26get half of the property back and you get double
- 18:28damages, you actually can do very well. Let's
- 18:32go on to the next slide, please. In order to
- 18:37get double damages, you do not have to show bad
- 18:41faith within the context of financial elder abuse.
- 18:45So this is a critical holding in the case of
- 18:48needing versus stealing. Next slide, please.
- 18:55Another incredible value of the double damages
- 18:57is you can actually, if you're suing, for example,
- 19:02a situation where your client is a beneficiary
- 19:06of a trust and the trust was originally divided
- 19:09between let's say three siblings. And one of
- 19:12the siblings approached the elderly parent, the
- 19:16aged parent just before they died and was able
- 19:20to get a gift of a valuable piece of real property,
- 19:24which California, especially LA County, can be
- 19:26worth quite a sum. So your client not only sues
- 19:31to undo the transfer, but also asks the court
- 19:35to award double damages. Now, if the double damages
- 19:38mean that the property's put back into the trust,
- 19:43then the perpetrator of the double damages is
- 19:46going to, in effect, where there's three beneficiaries,
- 19:49get one third of the double damages back. So
- 19:53this court ruling said, no, if you plead right
- 19:58and you argue correctly, you can actually ask
- 20:02for the double damages to be paid directly to
- 20:05your client who is the proponent of the double
- 20:08damages and who is the successful claimant of
- 20:11the double damages. And another point here is
- 20:15there's a split of authority What double damages
- 20:18mean? Does it mean, for example, if the property
- 20:19is worth a million dollars, you also get an extra
- 20:23million? Or does it mean that if the property
- 20:26is worth a million dollars, you get the property
- 20:27back? Plus you get twice the value of the property,
- 20:30which would be two million dollars. And that
- 20:33seems to be the latest findings in cases that
- 20:38the double damages relate strictly to the damages.
- 20:41So now if you have a successful case where someone
- 20:45took property, for example, and you go all the
- 20:49way to the mat, you not only can get attorney's
- 20:52fees, you can get a multiple on your attorney's
- 20:54fees, you can recover the property. And above
- 20:56and beyond that, you can get double damages of
- 20:58the value of the property taken. And that double
- 21:01damages can be for your client only. So that
- 21:07can help drive settlement. And it can also incentivize
- 21:10you to take a case all the way through trial.
- 21:13Next slide, please. One of the ways you can demonstrate
- 21:22financial elder abuse is through undue influence.
- 21:26Undue influence, and we'll get to that in a bit,
- 21:29has a number of characteristics. And it seems
- 21:34to be the kind of thing that is sort of in the
- 21:37eye of the beholder because people do have the
- 21:41right to decide what to do with their money and
- 21:43property. And that's why, for example, if someone
- 21:46signs a trust or some sort of agreement, even
- 21:52though that trust agreement is never executed,
- 21:55that is still considered financial elder abuse.
- 21:57And you can sue to undo that trust and get attorney's
- 22:00fees because whenever someone makes a choice
- 22:04what to do with their property, that is one of
- 22:06the bundle of rights, the choice of where you
- 22:09want your money and property to go. So when someone
- 22:13does make a choice, they are actually exercising
- 22:18their rights as a property owner, and courts
- 22:21can be very loathe to upset choices. For example,
- 22:27there was a famous case, and this was before
- 22:30the caregiver statute came into being, and this
- 22:32may have been one of the reasons why, where an
- 22:35elderly person left six pieces of property to
- 22:37his caregivers because they had been taking very
- 22:40good care of him. And his family lived out in
- 22:43the East and in the Midwest, and they didn't
- 22:45have that much to do with him. So even though
- 22:48there was a great historical relationship, just
- 22:51barely in the last six months of his life, he
- 22:53changed his entire estate plan, leaving everything
- 22:56to his caregivers. And the judge was like, well,
- 23:00it's his money and property. No one has a right
- 23:02to inherit. He can do whatever he wants with
- 23:04it. So there's no undue influence. And that's
- 23:06why you really want to try to get that presumption
- 23:11of undue influence, because now you're going
- 23:13into the case and they have to disprove undue
- 23:16influence. And that is just like it's hard to
- 23:20prove undue influence. It's hard to disprove
- 23:22undue influence when there's that presumption.
- 23:25So that presumption, there's two possibilities.
- 23:29One is the standard possibility. There's a confidential
- 23:33relationship, such as a close relationship between
- 23:37the transfer or in the transfer E on, let's say
- 23:40a D. Now, usually you can get the defendant to
- 23:43admit there's a confidential relationship because
- 23:46they're going to want to talk up how close they
- 23:48were to the transfer or because if they weren't
- 23:51close, if it was just the stewardess on an airplane
- 23:54and they met on a flight and never saw each other
- 23:56again, why is there this transfer of valuable
- 24:00property? So confidential relationship tends
- 24:02to be very easy to prove. Active participation
- 24:06in the transaction. The best thing is when the
- 24:12person comes up with a deed, his or herself,
- 24:16and just gets the person to sign the deed. There
- 24:19are permutations to this. What happens if the
- 24:22person doesn't sign the deed but drives the person
- 24:26to the notary or calls the notary and has the
- 24:31notary come over? or drives the person to the
- 24:34attorney's office, just is somehow participating.
- 24:39Certainly, if the person is participating by
- 24:43providing their financial statement to get their
- 24:45name on the property, that would be active participation.
- 24:50But your job is always to look for that participation,
- 24:54that active participation, and then undo benefit.
- 24:58is often very simple to prove because if there's
- 25:01a pre -existing estate plan that's contrary,
- 25:04for example, if someone was leaving equal shares
- 25:07to their kids and all of a sudden everything's
- 25:10going to one kid or someone is leaving to various
- 25:14charities and various persons that person had
- 25:18a stock relationship with and suddenly it's this
- 25:20new friend on the block, that's an undue benefit.
- 25:23Very often, the undue benefit is not that hard
- 25:26to prove either because almost by definition,
- 25:30because this is being challenged, there's a lopsided
- 25:33transfer to someone who doesn't deserve it. The
- 25:37other way you can get a presumption of undue
- 25:38influence is under the caregiver statute. So
- 25:42if someone is providing care and they're a paid
- 25:45caregiver, then unless certain requirements are
- 25:49met, there's going to be a presumption of undue
- 25:52influence. There was a recent case that was decertified,
- 25:56but It said that under the caregiver statute,
- 26:00so basically anything a person does can be considered
- 26:03care. Shopping for groceries, helping with medications,
- 26:08cleaning the apartment, taking the person out
- 26:11on trips, providing companionship. There's a
- 26:15wide umbrella of things you can put and get caregiver
- 26:18status. So then what's very often litigated is
- 26:22payment. So there's this recent case that said
- 26:24that someone was getting free room and board,
- 26:27but they were not getting paid anything. And
- 26:29they were providing care for this person. And
- 26:32the court held, yeah, that's payment. You're
- 26:34getting free room and board, that's payment.
- 26:38If the person was involved in drafting the will.
- 26:44And this comes up sometimes for attorneys because
- 26:47if there's no independent review and the attorney
- 26:50makes herself the sole trustee of the person's
- 26:54trust, that can, through other means, fall under
- 26:58the same presumptions of undue influence as under
- 27:01the caregiver statute. So these are just tools
- 27:04in your toolkit. They're quivers in your arrow,
- 27:09and you should always try to be using them whenever
- 27:11possible. Under civil code section 39, there's
- 27:17something which is a little off the beaten track,
- 27:19which I've often found to be very powerful and
- 27:23code sections 39 says that a conveyance or other
- 27:28contract of a person of unsound mind, but not
- 27:32entirely without understanding, which is before
- 27:36a person's incompetence has been judicially determined
- 27:39is subject to rescission. So basically, It kind
- 27:44of gives you that presumption of undue influence
- 27:47because you can rescind a deed or a contract
- 27:50where a person is mentally on shaky ground, their
- 27:54unsound mind, which basically means maybe they
- 27:57need help with financial transactions, they can't
- 27:59balance their checkbook, but they are competent
- 28:02on every other way, shape or form. And you can
- 28:06use Civil Code 39 to rescind the deed or the
- 28:11transaction you want rescinded. In order to implement
- 28:16Civil Code Section 39, you have to first request
- 28:21rescission of the document. Like you have to
- 28:23send a letter asking for rescission of the deed.
- 28:28That used to be a problem because people would
- 28:30often just file lawsuits instead of sending a
- 28:33letter. But now there's a case that says that
- 28:38if you simply file a lawsuit, and you seek precision,
- 28:43that's deemed to be notice of precision. That's
- 28:46Guscetti versus Dugan. And you can email me if
- 28:48you need any citations that are not in the outline
- 28:52that you think might be beneficial to you. Next
- 28:54slide, please. Right, so here's undue influence.
- 29:03Undue influence means excessive persuasion that
- 29:07causes another person to act or refrain from
- 29:10acting. That's a hard nut to crack. So that's
- 29:14why you want to go for presumption of undue influence
- 29:17whenever you can. Next slide, please. Okay. Now
- 29:25we're getting into what if a person makes a will?
- 29:29And you want to undo the will because your contention
- 29:33is it's a product of undue influence, financial
- 29:36elder abuse, and Historically, people sort of
- 29:42shied away from these things because it's a very
- 29:45low threshold to be mentally competent, like
- 29:48a person can. Can just they can have moderate
- 29:54dementia, they can be very forgetful, they can
- 29:58not have much of an idea what's going on, but
- 30:02next slide, please. So they're not mentally competent.
- 30:09if the following is either of the following is
- 30:13true. Next slide, please. Okay, so the first
- 30:18part is the individual does not have sufficient
- 30:21mental capacity to be able to understand the
- 30:23nature of the testamentary act, understand and
- 30:26recollect the nature and situation of individual's
- 30:28property, or remember or understand the individual's
- 30:31relations to living descendants, spouse, parents,
- 30:33and those whose interests are affected by the
- 30:35will. So Most people know they're signing a will,
- 30:38so they're going to understand the nature of
- 30:39the Testimony Act. With enough prompting, person
- 30:45can understand and recollect what they own. Then
- 30:50you have C, remember to understand individuals'
- 30:52relationships to people whose interests are affected
- 30:56by the will and their family members. This is
- 31:01a very low bar and frankly, If an attorney wants
- 31:06to do a will and he wants to just prompt the
- 31:10client and keep on doing videotapes so the client
- 31:13gets it right and then have the client sign the
- 31:15will, it's pretty easy to get through this unless
- 31:18the person is just really, really out of it.
- 31:22But nonetheless, I would not give up hope. Let's
- 31:25go to the next slide. Here's problem two, where
- 31:34you can possibly allege successfully that the
- 31:39person lacks mental capacity. If a person suffers
- 31:43from a mental disorder with symptoms, including
- 31:45delusions or hallucinations, which delusions
- 31:48or hallucinations result in the individual's
- 31:51devising property in a way which, except for
- 31:55the existence of the delusions or hallucinations,
- 31:58the individual would not have done. So basically
- 32:01there has to be a delusion or hallucination that
- 32:04is the driving force in the contents of that
- 32:09will or trust. Let's go to the next slide. Okay,
- 32:18let's go to the next slide for a minute. Okay,
- 32:23so a person can have an insane delusion. That's
- 32:27the spontaneous production of a deceased mind.
- 32:31He can believe that in the existence of something
- 32:33which does not exist, he can believe that what
- 32:37does not exist does exist, and he can have a
- 32:40belief which a rational mind would not entertain,
- 32:44which you cannot undo by argument or evidence
- 32:46to the contrary. But a person can have these
- 32:50false opinions or beliefs or insane delusion,
- 32:54but in order to undo the will, This is the critical
- 32:57part. Moreover, such an insane delusion must
- 33:01have operated to cause the production of the
- 33:03will, which is under attack. So how do you do
- 33:08that? So I had a case, for example, where there
- 33:12was a devious daughter who wanted her mother
- 33:17to change her will and to cut out her brother.
- 33:22So even though it was a rather large estate,
- 33:24she wanted the mother to get out her brother,
- 33:27and that's not necessarily an easy thing to do.
- 33:30The mother had somewhat dementia, but she wasn't
- 33:34out of it. She would qualify in the first prong
- 33:37of having testamentary capacity. The daughter
- 33:42made a point of driving him to the mother that
- 33:46her brother had somehow been involved in the
- 33:48death of their father, which was really not true.
- 33:51The father died of a heart attack. The brother
- 33:53happened to have been present, but she was able
- 33:56to get her mother to entertain this false opinion
- 34:01or belief that her mother decided was true. And
- 34:05because her mother decided that was true, she
- 34:08changed the will and she cut out her son, who
- 34:11is the brother of the perpetrator of the financial
- 34:15abuse. Of course, she told her attorney this
- 34:19is why she was doing it, because she believed
- 34:22that her son had killed her husband. This was
- 34:27a case where we were able to undo the will because
- 34:30this was a good example of an insane delusion.
- 34:35Another example, which is interesting is there
- 34:39was a Holocaust survivor who It was in her 90s.
- 34:43And when she came out of the concentration camps
- 34:46with her husband, back in the day, they went
- 34:49to Israel. They connected with relatives. The
- 34:56relatives really took care of them, helped them
- 34:59on their feet in every way imaginable. And eventually,
- 35:04this lady and her husband came to the United
- 35:07States. where the lady came up with this incredibly
- 35:10successful business. But as she got older, she
- 35:15could no longer go to Israel every year as she
- 35:17had previously. In addition, she was very lonely.
- 35:22She didn't have any immediate family around.
- 35:24She didn't have any children. Her family was
- 35:27really these people in Israel who could only
- 35:29visit infrequently. This lady, which can often
- 35:34happen to lonely people, met a person who was
- 35:37about half her age. She's in her 90s. He's in
- 35:41his 40s. And this guy understood that this is
- 35:45a very wealthy person. And he started taking
- 35:48her out to lunch three days a week. He would
- 35:50take her out to dinner. He would hang out with
- 35:51her. He became her best friend. And she started
- 35:55taking him to meetings with her bankers. So at
- 36:01this point, I subpoenaed all of the, this is
- 36:05after her lifetime. We wanted the relatives in
- 36:07Israel wanted to undo the will. We subpoenaed
- 36:10all of her bank records. Subpoenaing bank records
- 36:13is basically often not an easy thing to do. And
- 36:18basically at this point, I subpoenaed all the
- 36:21bank records, including all of her meetings with
- 36:23her wealth management people. And the bank did
- 36:27not want to give it to me. I used to have very
- 36:30long discussions with an outside lawyer designated
- 36:33by the bank to handle this. And it was basically
- 36:36a product of cajoling and just saying, I'm going
- 36:40to file a motion and ask for sanctions. And finally,
- 36:43I get these meetings that have all these notes
- 36:46and the friend is there and the bank has a little
- 36:49puzzle. Why all of a sudden are you putting this
- 36:53guy on your bank accounts. Why is he now involved?
- 36:58Like the bank could see something as weird. So,
- 37:01you know, as a Holocaust survivor who basically
- 37:04probably had to lie to live, she just told the
- 37:07bank, well, all of my relatives are dead. I don't
- 37:10have any relatives. And when she went to her
- 37:13lawyer, she said the same thing. All of my relatives
- 37:16are dead. I don't have any relatives. So basically
- 37:21my My take on this was to use this as an insane
- 37:24delusion and argue that this was an insane delusion
- 37:28that operated to cause the production of the
- 37:30wheel, which is under attack. And also, let's
- 37:34go back up a little bit. Back up the slides,
- 37:39please. Back up the slides again. No, the other
- 37:47way. Keep on going. OK, fine. Stop. Right. So
- 37:59here, in order to have testamentary capacity,
- 38:02a person has to remember and understand the individual's
- 38:06relations to those whose interests are affected
- 38:10by the will. And she had a prior estate plan
- 38:13that basically was leaving everything to these
- 38:15relatives in Israel. So because she was going
- 38:18around saying all of her relatives were dead,
- 38:21I could successfully argue that this lady did
- 38:24not understand her relationship with people whose
- 38:27interests were affected by the will because she
- 38:30was under the impression, the misoppression,
- 38:32they were all dead. So in this case, the friend
- 38:37did what is commonly done by perpetrators, which
- 38:41is another form of just simply elder abuse, which
- 38:44is isolation of the elder. and he did this by
- 38:48becoming a gatekeeper for her communication.
- 38:51So anytime the relatives from Israel would call,
- 38:55he would get on the phone or he'd have the call
- 38:57transfer to his cell phone and he would just
- 38:59say this elderly lady was not available. So that's
- 39:04the kind of thing that happens. You kind of have
- 39:06to dig in and get to the bottom of it. The red
- 39:08flags are there. You have to understand the story
- 39:11of how this occurred. Okay. Let's go down back
- 39:18to where we were before on the slides. Another
- 39:23thing that comes up in these situations very
- 39:26often is, next slide, please. Okay, sorry, go
- 39:34back the other way, please. So what happens is,
- 39:38again, apart from changing a will or a trust,
- 39:42again, The other target is just real property.
- 39:46Again, because if you can get your name on title
- 39:49to a deed again, please, you're ahead of the
- 39:52game. Now, very often, once more. So very often
- 39:56what happens is, again, people want to get their
- 40:01name on a deed. It's fine. People want to get
- 40:06their name on a deed, but they don't necessarily
- 40:09want to advertise that while the person is a
- 40:12lot. because if they advertise all person is
- 40:14alive and it gets recorded, then that makes a
- 40:20better public record. The property tax bills
- 40:23are going to change and very often the loved
- 40:26ones of the person who's the transfer or is going
- 40:30to find out what happened. So one technique used
- 40:34by elder abusers is they get a deed signed and
- 40:40then they don't record it. So the peculiar thing
- 40:43about conveying title is under the statute, in
- 40:48order to convey title for there to be a valid
- 40:51transference of title, there has to be an intent
- 40:54to transfer title and there has to be an intent
- 40:58to receive title. So if this is not met, then
- 41:03even though the deed was signed, there's no transfer
- 41:04of title. If the deed is recorded, then there's
- 41:08a presumption that on that date, there was a
- 41:09transfer of title. But we're talking about unrecorded
- 41:13deeds, which can be valid transfers if they're
- 41:15used correctly. So for example, I had a case
- 41:19where one of the children decided it would be
- 41:24in their interest to get more of a share of real
- 41:28property than their siblings, and she had her
- 41:31father sign deeds over to her. And she was able
- 41:36to persuade the father to sign deeds over to
- 41:38her as safekeeping to help prevent anyone from
- 41:44stealing the property from him. Now, just as
- 41:47a side note, in all of these situations, whether
- 41:50it's signing a trust or will or deed, the act
- 41:53of signature takes less than several seconds.
- 41:57So every elderly person is actually somewhat
- 42:01vulnerable. And that's why I always advise people
- 42:05if they're doing estate planning, it can be helpful,
- 42:11and there's a California Supreme Court case on
- 42:13point, it can be very helpful to create a situation
- 42:17which is the exclusive means of amending a trust
- 42:22or rescinding, pulling real estate out of a trust.
- 42:26And that exclusive means can involve jumping
- 42:29through several hoops, which an elder abuser
- 42:32would likely not know about, or a brand new attorney
- 42:35likely would not know about, and that, those
- 42:39hoops can be set forth in a separate amendment,
- 42:41which are kept apart from the regular trust.
- 42:45But that aside, in most instances, I would say
- 42:4895 % of the trust I've seen, it's rather easy,
- 42:52just takes the signature, change the trust. So
- 42:55in this case, the person went to an attorney,
- 43:00deeds were signed in favor of the elder abuser
- 43:04child. They were not recorded because after all,
- 43:08safekeeping was the story and the elderly person
- 43:12simply kept possession of the deeds. Time went
- 43:16on, the elderly person got severe dementia, lost
- 43:20her mind basically, and at that point, the child
- 43:24went and recorded the deeds. When I followed
- 43:29the lawsuit, I'm looking at deeds that have been
- 43:32created by an attorney, that were properly done,
- 43:36that were properly recorded, and I have the defense
- 43:39lawyer telling me, please take the deposition
- 43:42of the attorney. If you'll take the deposition
- 43:44of the attorney, we can just resolve this case
- 43:47rather quickly. So I took the deposition of the
- 43:51attorney, and it turned out that he had filed
- 43:54a gift tax return. And when he filed the gift
- 43:57tax return, he had had the opportunity to consult
- 44:01with his client, consult with the the child who
- 44:05is now the transferee on the deeds. And when
- 44:08he filed the gift tax return, whether he made
- 44:10a mistake or not, he filed the gift tax return
- 44:13using the date of recording as the date of transfer.
- 44:17Because on the gift tax return, you have to put
- 44:19the date of transfer for purposes of computing
- 44:22any gift tax. So at trial, he wanted to validate
- 44:27his documents, as very often lawyers do, and
- 44:31they sort of look at things in a very narrow
- 44:34sense. They don't necessarily care what's right
- 44:36or wrong. They just, whatever their client signed,
- 44:39they want to uphold and they want to basically
- 44:41validate their own competence. So he was saying
- 44:44that when the deeds were signed, there was an
- 44:47intent to convey title and therefore the deeds
- 44:50were valid. But when I pointed out when he was
- 44:55on the stand that he had signed the gift tax
- 44:57return penalty perjury, and of course he would
- 44:59not purge himself. to the government and setting
- 45:02up the foundation, it came out that now the deeds
- 45:06had been actually transferred after the mother
- 45:10had lost her capacity to have intent to transfer
- 45:13title, and therefore those deeds were invalidated.
- 45:17Now, the question comes up, did I sue the lawyer?
- 45:22And the answer is absolutely not. So even though
- 45:26the lawyer was aiding and abetting, You don't
- 45:30want to be in a position because these cases
- 45:32are difficult enough and the rewards are rewarding
- 45:35enough. You don't want to be in a position where
- 45:37you have some crackerjack malpractice defense
- 45:40lawyer getting on board. Because at that point,
- 45:46the testimony simply could have come out differently.
- 45:48It could have been pitched at a different angle
- 45:50and the lawyer wouldn't have been so vulnerable
- 45:54to successful cross -examination as he ended
- 45:57up being. This also raises the point. What happens
- 46:04if you're involved? You're filing under 850,
- 46:08859 for double damages. You want to rescind a
- 46:12deed or a trust or a will. So you're in probate
- 46:15court. Besides your probate petition by statute
- 46:22under 855, you can also throw in civil claims.
- 46:27So when you're throwing in a civil claim for
- 46:29financial elder abuse, you should understand
- 46:32that with financial elder abuse, you don't get
- 46:34to rescind documents. You get monetary damages.
- 46:38So if you're getting monetary damages in addition
- 46:43to rescinding a document, that's fantastic. Now,
- 46:46when you're going for monetary damages, that
- 46:49gives you the right to a jury trial. If you have
- 46:52the right to a jury trial for your financial
- 46:54elder abuse, case, you have to maintain that
- 46:58by letting the court know right away that you
- 47:00want to maintain that constitutional right to
- 47:04a jury trial. And then when you actually get
- 47:07in front of a jury, what I found just very interesting,
- 47:11one out of 10 seniors, at least, are victims
- 47:14of financial fraud or financial elder abuse.
- 47:18So if you start asking the jury on voir dire,
- 47:22Do you know anyone or do you have family members
- 47:24or do you have a loved one who's been the victim
- 47:26of financial abuse? All these stories are going
- 47:29to come up and a lot of these jurors are going
- 47:32to be invalidated as jurors right there during
- 47:36Vardir. So I have found that it's actually more
- 47:39helpful not to raise that issue with prospective
- 47:42jurors and just sort of hope that it'll be a
- 47:46mine waiting to explode. when they go back and
- 47:49do their deliberations rather than exploding
- 47:51the mind and getting that jury, that juror invalidated
- 47:55right away. OK, another another example I just
- 48:06want to talk about two minutes is sometimes you
- 48:09just get really lucky. I had a case where a daughter
- 48:13went in, her mother was dying and on a ventilator.
- 48:17the daughter brought in a brand new lawyer. Somehow,
- 48:21I don't know why this lawyer did it, but for
- 48:23fees sometimes even lawyers will decide that
- 48:27what they're doing is justified. And they had
- 48:29this lady sign a brand new trust and a brand
- 48:33new deed in favor of the daughter while she was
- 48:35dying on a ventilator. We filed the case and
- 48:41lo and behold, this lady at 93 sprang back to
- 48:46life. She not only sprang back to life, she's
- 48:48off the ventilator, and her mind was clear and
- 48:51sharp like a tack. And the trial judge said that
- 48:54this was a blessing. I've never had a lady this
- 48:57age come and testify so clearly. And when we
- 49:02were in closing arguments and the defense lawyer
- 49:04gave his closing argument, the judge said to
- 49:07him, do you want me just to overlook the testimony
- 49:09of this 93 -year -old lady? Is that what you're
- 49:12asking me to do? We got a verdict in our favor.
- 49:17And this was another one of these cases where
- 49:20people are so narcissistic and birds of a feather
- 49:23tend to fly together that the defense, the defendant
- 49:26and her lawyer both were sending me hate mail
- 49:30saying that I had created a family problem. And
- 49:33really, the mother intended to create this deed
- 49:36and trust the way it was done. So I hope I've
- 49:42given you some insight. When you see a red flag,
- 49:46you have to know there's a red flag because there
- 49:48was a violation of something that should not
- 49:53have happened. And you have to look under the
- 49:56red flags, under the hood. Things happen for
- 49:58a reason. Things don't happen without a reason.
- 50:02And when they do happen, it's your job and function
- 50:05as an attorney not just to spot the red flags,
- 50:09but to stop spot the underlying story. to engage
- 50:13in the discovery till you understand and it clicks
- 50:16what actually happened. And then when you take
- 50:20your depositions and you do your discovery, you
- 50:22now have a story that you are implementing it
- 50:25and you have a game plan and all the pieces of
- 50:27the puzzle fit together. So I wish you success
- 50:32in these cases and they can be very gratifying
- 50:36because you're not only collecting money, you're
- 50:38restoring wealth which was illegally and immorally
- 50:43and wrongly taken from elderly people who deserve
- 50:46our respect. Thank you. Fantastic, Stuart. What
- 50:50an action -packed, you know, almost an hour.
- 50:54And we have a question, which is a very good
- 50:58question, because maybe it opens up to a whole
- 51:02discussion. Standing. The question is, who has
- 51:07standing to sue if the elder is in denial about
- 51:10the abuse, but is legally competent and not subject
- 51:15to a conservatorship? So, you know, if you can
- 51:18take a crack at that question and maybe just
- 51:20talk a little bit about standing to bring these
- 51:23actions. Right. So if the elderly person is mentally
- 51:27competent. You have a shot at getting a conservatorship
- 51:33because if you can demonstrate there's been financial
- 51:35elder abuse and there's harm to an elder, that's
- 51:39one thing. But what I've seen is there's dubious
- 51:42competence, someone brings a conservatorship
- 51:45action, and it really backfires because the PVP
- 51:48attorney gets involved, advocates on behalf of
- 51:51the elder, the perpetrator. is dressing up that
- 51:56elder in a brand new tuxedo, and everything is
- 51:59spotless, and everything is arranged, and everything
- 52:01looks good. And the elder is saying, yeah, I'm
- 52:03very happy. This is what I want. And then at
- 52:06that point, the elder who might have had a very
- 52:10quasi -competent job of their estate planning
- 52:14gets an attorney involved and kind of quashes
- 52:17downstream the opportunity for a post post -lifetime
- 52:23or post loss of competence elder abuse action
- 52:28that might have been very successful. So, yeah,
- 52:31if the person's competent, these things are very
- 52:34difficult. And at that point, I usually tell
- 52:37people, look, the person's competent. You're
- 52:40claiming you have this meaningful relationship
- 52:42with the elder. Go for it. Go take that person
- 52:46out to lunch. That person was influenced. by
- 52:50someone else who's spending a lot of time giving
- 52:52that person a lot of attention. Why don't you
- 52:54and your family do that? And that's not something
- 52:58within the legal sphere, but that's just something
- 52:59I tell people because yeah, when a person's competent,
- 53:02part of their property rights is to do whatever
- 53:05they want with their money and property and no
- 53:06one has the right to inherit. So that's a great,
- 53:10great point. A couple other questions. uh one
- 53:18and there is uh dealing with statute of limitations
- 53:21so how i'll repeat her question uh or how long
- 53:26is the statute of limitations do we measure by
- 53:30what date you know she says date of confiscation
- 53:33discovery uh what happens if you do not allege
- 53:37specifically elder abuse but did allege undue
- 53:41influence so i'll let you take a crack at that
- 53:44stuart OK, well, one thing I learned from Mr.
- 53:46Terry Maggity is resulting trust is incredibly
- 53:50useful. I had a case where there was a transfer
- 53:54of property to a sibling unbeknownst to my client
- 53:59from the mother. And then she was told that the
- 54:03mother lost the property. And this was like 50
- 54:05years ago. And then she found out about it. And
- 54:08with the resulting trust, it's four years from
- 54:12the date that you demand your rights under the
- 54:16resulting trust. So the facts fit the resulting
- 54:19trust. It was 50 years ago. I did my demand.
- 54:23It was no. And we actually got through for summary
- 54:26judgment and even went to appeal on a rip and
- 54:28won. Because if you plead a resulting trust or
- 54:32constructive trust, it can actually be four years
- 54:37from the date that you demand what's rightfully
- 54:39yours. And the other point is If the person is
- 54:42incompetent, it tolls the statute of limitations.
- 54:46So you can have a person who gives away money
- 54:48signed to trust, signed to deed, goes incompetent
- 54:54for five years and then dies. And even though
- 54:56it happened more than four years ago, which is
- 54:57the financial elderly statute of limitations,
- 55:00you can then start the ball rolling on date of
- 55:02death because all the time the person was incompetent
- 55:05doesn't count. So everything is very factually
- 55:08specific, but I hear the question and that's
- 55:11one of the challenges of making sure you're getting
- 55:14this file on time. The other another question,
- 55:21which is these are all good questions, but let's
- 55:25say you do, you know that you do the 120 day
- 55:28notice, you know, to you have a right to contest
- 55:31beneficiary within within six within 120 days,
- 55:36four months. The 120 days pass. Can you still
- 55:42bring in action for financial elder abuse? Right.
- 55:46That's a great question. So don't forget under
- 55:48financial elder abuse, you're asking for monetary
- 55:51damages. You're not asking for cancellation of
- 55:55the trust. So many attorneys do feel that you
- 56:00can still fall for financial elder abuse because
- 56:02it's a four year statute. I've seen judges wave
- 56:06the magic wand in favor of that. I currently
- 56:09have a case that's on appeal with where that
- 56:12issue is embedded in that. I'm not convinced
- 56:15either way. But the point is you're not contesting
- 56:18the trust. So therefore you should not be bound
- 56:21by the 120 day statute. And if your share of
- 56:24this trust went south and that happened because
- 56:27of financial elder abuse and all you're doing
- 56:29is seeking financial damages, not recovery of
- 56:33the property, then it seems like that would still
- 56:37work. Other questions. Let's see. This is from
- 56:45a 30 ,000 foot look up. Any tips for claims against
- 56:52insurance companies who sell dubious annuities
- 56:55to seniors? So basically the way it works with
- 57:01an annuity is there's going to be a large commission
- 57:04and then there's going to be a cap on how much
- 57:10the person who buys the annuity can make. And
- 57:12let's say it's based upon the S &P 500. Let's
- 57:15say it's a 10 -year annuity. So statistically,
- 57:19over the last 100 years, over any 10 -year period,
- 57:22the S &P 500 has gone up considerably. So therefore,
- 57:28you can argue right away that the annuity is
- 57:30likely to cause harm to that elderly person,
- 57:33because statistically, the chances are they're
- 57:36going to lose money with that annuity. And that's
- 57:39the whole way annuities are set up. So the company
- 57:41can make a ton of money. The broker can make
- 57:44a big commission and the senior is subsidizing
- 57:47all of that. So it depends how you look at annuities.
- 57:52If you look at them as sort of a financial scam,
- 57:55then could be a great case. If you look at them
- 57:59as a legitimate business investment and somehow
- 58:02it's great, could be. Bad case. But then also
- 58:07going down the line, what happens in year seven
- 58:11or eight when the client wants their money back
- 58:13because they need the money and the company is
- 58:16retaining the money and it's causing harm to
- 58:19the elder because now the elder needs that money,
- 58:21doesn't want it tied up anymore. Let's say the
- 58:24elder lost all their money. Now it's causing
- 58:27harm to the elder. So you have retention causing
- 58:30harm to the elder. So that's a financial elder
- 58:32abuse case. These kinds of cases, you have to
- 58:36be creative, but I think the statute is a very
- 58:39powerful statute. It's practically a strict liability
- 58:42statute. We've got another question, which I'm
- 58:46gonna add in a word. It is, what is the estate
- 58:50planner's responsibility? I'm gonna add in, or
- 58:54liability, if the client who has dementia or
- 58:59has delusions, wants to change his will or trust.
- 59:04Person with dementia or delusions goes into mild
- 59:09mannered attorney. What is responsibility and
- 59:16liability? So is that attorney going to be on
- 59:18the hook? Right. So my understanding is the attorney's
- 59:23duty is to the client unless the attorney actually
- 59:28understands this person is incompetent. For example,
- 59:32let's take our case where the elderly lady said,
- 59:35all my relatives are dead and therefore didn't
- 59:40understand the nature of their relationship to
- 59:42their objects of their bounty or their prior
- 59:46trust beneficiaries. Let's say these relatives
- 59:49start calling the attorney's office and saying,
- 59:52hey, what's going on with our Cousin, we're trying
- 59:56to get a hold of her, could you help us? To now
- 59:58the attorney actually realizes, slam dunk, that
- 1:00:02there's something wrong with this person's competence,
- 1:00:05that could be a problem. Or, and this is a much
- 1:00:08more likely scenario, a husband and wife come
- 1:00:11to the attorney, and one of the people has dementia,
- 1:00:15and the attorney does not get a conflict of interest
- 1:00:17waiver, and everything is going, let's say, to
- 1:00:20the competent husband's side of what he wants.
- 1:00:24and the demented person side of things is not
- 1:00:26getting a fair shake, that could, I see, create
- 1:00:29liability for an attorney. Of course, if the
- 1:00:33attorney does something outrageous, as happened
- 1:00:36in one case where the attorney actually got a
- 1:00:39kickback commission helping facilitate the sale
- 1:00:42of insurance company, insurance policy, that's
- 1:00:45a dead -banging financial elder abuse case. I
- 1:00:48guess it depends on the facts and circumstances,
- 1:00:50and that's why we lawyers have to always Do our
- 1:00:53research. I'm going to try to squeeze in one
- 1:00:56last question before we end with it. OK, we have
- 1:00:59our last question is, can can these claims be
- 1:01:04applied to officers of a corporation where the
- 1:01:08elder is a substantial shareholder? So I guess
- 1:01:11the idea when you're when you're pinpointing
- 1:01:13your defendants. Can you can you can an officer
- 1:01:19of the corporation be? beyond the hook for something
- 1:01:22here. Anything come to mind? You just have to
- 1:01:28look. If the author of the corporation did anything
- 1:01:31that fits under the statute, then yes. But if
- 1:01:36the author of this corporation is just doing
- 1:01:42what he is supposed to be doing or she's supposed
- 1:01:44to be doing and exercising their best judgment,
- 1:01:46then that may be the fit. It's too abstract for
- 1:01:51me to say, but it's always worth looking at the
- 1:01:53statute because I just see more of that statute
- 1:01:57every time I look at it. Excellent. Stuart, this
- 1:02:01was, I'm going to repeat, an action -packed hour.
- 1:02:06I learned a lot. And I've been doing these things
- 1:02:09for a while, so I really enjoyed and got a lot
- 1:02:13out of the seminar, which I'm sure everybody
- 1:02:16else in the webcast audience did too. So thank
- 1:02:19you so much. And we have some kudos here even
- 1:02:23in the questions. Thank you for sharing your
- 1:02:26knowledge. It was an excellent presentation.
- 1:02:28I agree. And so I'm sure the folks on the webcast.
- 1:02:32So thank you, Stuart. Thank you, everybody. in
- 1:02:36the audience and we'll plan to see everybody
- 1:02:38at the next program. And thank you for the opportunity.
- 1:02:41Have a good afternoon. Okay, bye -bye. You may
- 1:02:44be eligible for CLE credit in your state. Visit
- 1:02:46bhba .org slash podcasts for more information.