Latest / Ensombl Advice Australia / Insurance Podcast #8 - Niall McConville
Transcript
- 0:00The Ensembled Podcast is intended for professional financial advisors.
- 0:03This content is created in partnership with our sponsor,
- 0:05Zurich Australia Limited, ABN 9-2, triple zero, zero one zero,
- 0:09one nine five, AFSL 2-3-2, five one zero,
- 0:12and is limited to publicly available information.
- 0:14Before acting on any general advice, you should consider whether appropriate
- 0:17and obtain financial advice from a qualified financial advisor.
- 0:20Ensembled does not hold an AFS license and does not provide any financial advice
- 0:23or services or endorse any general advice.
- 0:25If a PDF or I AM exists, you should obtain a copy and review it thoroughly
- 0:29before making a decision.
- 0:59Zurich is proud to be supporting this episode.
- 1:15Experience Zurich and one-part advisor portals with new and improved digital capabilities
- 1:22and an enhanced range of self-service functionality.
- 1:25Helping make your business more efficient, saving you time,
- 1:28and removing complexity.
- 1:30It's everything you need in one place.
- 1:32Partner with us today.
- 1:36Today we have the pleasure of having a very seasoned veteran for life insurance
- 1:43across all facets of the industry.
- 1:45So I'm really excited.
- 1:47Welcome Mr. Namakonville.
- 1:48Good to be here, mate.
- 1:49I'm looking forward to having a good chat about all things life insurance
- 1:52or the next period of the year.
- 1:54It's very grand to cover.
- 1:55Yeah, yes, mate.
- 1:57But before we get into that, I had a quick sneak peek on your LinkedIn
- 2:00and BlackRock was the first thing that came up as your education.
- 2:04Now, from what I understand, you may have played Rugby with Brano Driscoll?
- 2:08No, he was a little bit sort of behind me, but I wasn't the school.
- 2:15I went to and he played one sport and that was Rugby BlackRock College.
- 2:17And the Lions Tour that were here recently,
- 2:20there was more players who played,
- 2:22came from BlackRock than there was Welch players.
- 2:25So it's a Rugby factory.
- 2:27Yeah.
- 2:28But Victor Costello and a few other were in my year.
- 2:31Victor Captain Darling caught a few times and stuff.
- 2:33So yeah, but I was in the Zed Monuses.
- 2:36They came to Rugby.
- 2:38I didn't like being in a field in February in Ireland.
- 2:41It was never, never any fun.
- 2:44Yeah, I've worked out as I've got older.
- 2:46Actually, I'm not any good at sports.
- 2:48I'm good at watching it.
- 2:50I played a lot of golf and I'm really bad.
- 2:51But sports, something I'm just never going to be all that gift to that.
- 2:55Yeah.
- 2:55Nice.
- 2:56Well, how'd you come out here then?
- 2:57How'd you get over from Ireland to Australia?
- 2:59A long story.
- 3:01But basically,
- 3:029-9-3 came here as a backpacker.
- 3:05Sort of traveling and experiencing the world.
- 3:09I just fell in love with Australia.
- 3:10Like I arrived here in Sydney,
- 3:129th of April,
- 3:139-9-3 from my mum and dad from Circular Key.
- 3:17And yes, I don't even just arrived.
- 3:18And I said, this is I'm going to live here.
- 3:20This is my, I just felt connected.
- 3:22It was incredible.
- 3:23And I was lucky enough to be able to stay very lucky.
- 3:28And I got residency and citizenship.
- 3:30And I'm like, have a look back,
- 3:31best country in the world.
- 3:33And yeah, just a no-brainer for me.
- 3:34What a great place I'm so lucky.
- 3:36They're best opening line ever.
- 3:38Thank you.
- 3:39It's great.
- 3:40Yeah, I'm very passionate about Australia.
- 3:41Like, I know my Irish,
- 3:42but Australia is my home and I just love this country.
- 3:46I'll drop it after this question.
- 3:47But tell me,
- 3:48Ireland versus Australia,
- 3:49who are you going for?
- 3:50Ireland and rugby.
- 3:51I've never managed to get behind the Walla Bees.
- 3:55I said, like, it's funny, isn't it, right?
- 3:57I love this country so much.
- 4:00But Ireland is definitely between Ireland and the Walla Bees here.
- 4:05I was in Dublin and last time the Walla Bees played.
- 4:08And then I went along to watch it.
- 4:10It was great. A couple of Australian meets were over.
- 4:12Following the October tour.
- 4:13And the Autumn tour and there's fantastic.
- 4:15Yeah, yeah.
- 4:16But I think as an Australian,
- 4:18it's hard to follow the Walla Bees as well.
- 4:20So yeah, it has been right.
- 4:21You've won some stuff.
- 4:22But my kids would be Walla Bees
- 4:24and my younger kid played schoolboy for Victoria.
- 4:28Rugby, so he sees all right.
- 4:31So the bet would be me and the boys.
- 4:33Yeah, I'm going to see each other.
- 4:34And obviously with the World Cup coming up,
- 4:35that's going to be a lot of fun.
- 4:37Yeah, yeah.
- 4:38All right, so back to life insurance.
- 4:41So you've moved to Australia.
- 4:43And again, if we move up the sort of LinkedIn career,
- 4:46first place I think you were with was common shore.
- 4:48Yep.
- 4:49And then moved into AIA,
- 4:50went into Telfra a long time
- 4:51and now licensey landmates.
- 4:53So that's at a bit of time in New Zealand.
- 4:55Yeah, yes, sorry.
- 4:56Yeah, yeah.
- 4:56So that breadth of experience is absolutely wonderful.
- 4:59How do the reason why I wanted to have a chat talk about it today?
- 5:01I started in the cold center
- 5:03in legal in general.
- 5:04In St. Leonard's here in Sydney.
- 5:05Yeah.
- 5:06Yeah, so it was good.
- 5:08All right, can you take me through those phases then?
- 5:11Yeah, so I got a, so I started in LNG in the cold center
- 5:15and what they called the advisor preferred program.
- 5:18Actually started with a guy called Chris Blackson Walker,
- 5:21who most people were really, he was two weeks behind or ahead of me, yeah.
- 5:25And just sort of then LNG got bought by common shore
- 5:31and then common shore.
- 5:34And then yes, it basically so I went from LNG to common shore
- 5:38and then I moved up to Brisbane from Sydney
- 5:40with common shore became a BDM.
- 5:42So that was the first time that I sort of got out of the cold center environment
- 5:46and started BDMing with common shore up in Brisbane for a few years
- 5:50and then AIA or ARG at the time I started going into the advisor market.
- 5:55So I became a state manager and Queensland
- 5:58up there, state manager of just me.
- 6:00There wasn't anyone else at that stage
- 6:02and then moved down to Melbourne, got a national role with AIA as we were then
- 6:07and then went to Tower, which became Tower
- 6:11and is the beast that it is today.
- 6:13And then you know what a great experience that was to be part of that business
- 6:18when in there.
- 6:19Can't remember the exact numbers, but I would say it probably had about 800 million of
- 6:23in-force and 300 staff from a journey when I left it had
- 6:266.5 billion in-force and 5,000 staff or 4.5,000 staff.
- 6:30Yeah, wow, what an amazing story.
- 6:33Yeah, I think it's just such a privilege to be part of that.
- 6:37So yeah, I've had a pretty good career.
- 6:39I've always enjoyed spending time with advisors.
- 6:42I'm a massive believer in the value of advice,
- 6:44which is why I think it's so sad where our industry is today.
- 6:47And you know, people need advice and I've just been so fortunate to be around
- 6:53advisors who always do a great, great work and service for their clients over the years.
- 6:59And then so moving from the manufacturer's side,
- 7:02I'll let you skip over a little bit that, but we'll come back to it.
- 7:04But then coming from manufacturer, then to New Zealand.
- 7:07Yeah, so I finished up with Tal and I just decided basically one day,
- 7:14I was 53 at the time, so three years ago, roughly,
- 7:17that it was time for me to do something different.
- 7:18I'm one of these people that I'm always like to be challenging myself.
- 7:22So I left Tal and then I got a phone call from Campbell,
- 7:26who's the CEO of Fidelife, just said,
- 7:28do you want to come over and do a bit of work over here.
- 7:31So I thought, why not contract ended up spending about 12 months over there?
- 7:34And it was fantastic.
- 7:36So I do two weeks in New Zealand, two weeks from home in Melbourne.
- 7:41And I did, looked after underwriting and claims,
- 7:45and I'm one risk and all the call centers and the admin.
- 7:48And it was just, and it was so different.
- 7:50Even though you think it's the same,
- 7:52I had a presentation that I used to deliver all the time.
- 7:55The differences between the Australian and the Kiwi market,
- 7:58because the Kiwis are always interested.
- 8:00Like commission, we were paying about 240% in first year comm.
- 8:04Boom.
- 8:04Yeah.
- 8:05Yeah, and the average is probably about 220.
- 8:07That sounds like the old Blacksmith's the world.
- 8:09Yeah, absolutely, it is, yeah.
- 8:11Yeah, it was very different.
- 8:12The advisors' businesses are very different.
- 8:14So here, all the advisors' businesses have become quite corporatized,
- 8:18or are becoming quite corporatized and bigger and bigger.
- 8:21And you're starting to see more and more
- 8:23advise practices where there's a CEO,
- 8:25and there's all these different entities in it,
- 8:28not just an advisor who is the CEO, who is the admin person.
- 8:32But in New Zealand, that's still the case.
- 8:34So a lot of advisors still working from home and stuff.
- 8:37So it's starting to transition over here,
- 8:39but they also look at what's happening over here
- 8:42and go, what I want to do, any of that.
- 8:44Yeah.
- 8:44You know, we want to make sure that we still control our industry,
- 8:47which they do.
- 8:48Yeah, okay.
- 8:49Yeah.
- 8:49But again, like that.
- 8:50So just we'll go into New Zealand straight away.
- 8:53So the regulation rights on Australia, we have ASIC,
- 8:58and then we have the AFSL's.
- 9:00Now AFSL's can be one man band,
- 9:02or they can be a large group like Bombora as a specialist,
- 9:05and then you've got the advisors, the next layer down.
- 9:07What does it look like in New Zealand?
- 9:08So basically in New Zealand, the advisors are licensed
- 9:10directly with the regulator, right?
- 9:12But they have what they call FAPS.
- 9:14So basically, they are a collection,
- 9:17they're like a licensee, and they'll do development,
- 9:20and they'll help the advisor,
- 9:21but they're not responsible for the advice that's provided.
- 9:23Right.
- 9:24So it's just a much simpler, cleaner process over there,
- 9:28I think, and the advisors also do a lot of health insurance.
- 9:31So health insurance is underwritten,
- 9:33where obviously here it's automatic issue, et cetera.
- 9:37So, and then there's Kiwi Saver,
- 9:39which is again, their superannuation,
- 9:43but it's a paying about six or seven percent,
- 9:45whereas we're at 12.
- 9:47And also in Kiwi Saver, all of the money basically goes into,
- 9:51not quite, I think, one pot,
- 9:52but there's no industry super funds.
- 9:54It all goes into one entity,
- 9:56and there's no fees, so there's no insurance,
- 9:59no admin fees, nothing that can come out of that,
- 10:02although you can take the money out and use it to buy a house.
- 10:05Right.
- 10:06Yeah, but they look over here with envy at our super system.
- 10:10So they look over at our advice industry
- 10:12and go, no, we definitely don't want the way you guys are here.
- 10:15But they look at our super industry and go,
- 10:18that's a great place to be,
- 10:19which it is like we're all very fortunate.
- 10:21We have an amazing, an amazing superannuation industry
- 10:24in this country.
- 10:25Like I look at my kids, my youngest kid's 19,
- 10:2812% of his salary is going into his super-signed.
- 10:31Yeah, like I'll tell you it was a 19 year old,
- 10:34I didn't want to save 12% of my salary.
- 10:36No, but I never put any of my own money in my super till I was about 45.
- 10:40Yeah, I paid off my mortgage or whatever amount of being,
- 10:43whereas, you know, but that was,
- 10:44and that was at three and four and five percent.
- 10:46I was accumulating my super at the beginning.
- 10:49Yeah, but yeah, the kid's announced 12%.
- 10:51Yeah, it's pretty amazing.
- 10:52They're going to have to be retiring with a lot of money.
- 10:54So is New Zealand then sort of like a cottage cheese in a way?
- 10:59Like every day in their own practice,
- 11:01it's a one-man banner.
- 11:01Are there any corporatism?
- 11:02Yeah, the starting has come, definitely.
- 11:04Yeah, and look, I was only there for 12 months, roughly.
- 11:07So I don't know the market intimately
- 11:09and I don't know all the advisors.
- 11:10But yeah, now that they're definitely starting to to corporatize
- 11:13and starting to grow.
- 11:15But there is a lot more one-man bands working from home
- 11:18than because you wouldn't see that here.
- 11:20Like I can't remember the last time I went to see an advisor
- 11:22and he or she was working from home.
- 11:24Yeah.
- 11:24But when I was beating him up in Queensland back in the day,
- 11:28that happened a lot.
- 11:29And I had a good chuckle.
- 11:30I went to see an advisor running to him one time
- 11:33and went into his house, he had to take a shoes off
- 11:35and I thought, I haven't had to do that for like 25 years.
- 11:39See that the kitchen table, you looked after his clients,
- 11:42did a great job.
- 11:44You know, the paperwork is not as onerous,
- 11:47but the clients still get really well looked after.
- 11:49This is a thing like, just because you have a 100 page document
- 11:54doesn't mean that clients in a data position,
- 11:57then if you have a 10 page document that provides advice,
- 11:59I think we've made particularly insurance way to complicate it.
- 12:03It doesn't need to be where it is today
- 12:06and it's one of the main reasons why the industry
- 12:09just doesn't have anyone doing advice and insurance anymore.
- 12:11Again, like jumping everywhere, but I'm sort of like,
- 12:14and so what is it New Zealand's doing that we could take?
- 12:17I think I understand the belief in education,
- 12:21obviously, is so important that the advisors provide,
- 12:23have a good educational level to be able to provide
- 12:26appropriate advice to clients.
- 12:28But I think the fact that we have such a high bar
- 12:30to be able to provide advice for say for everything.
- 12:34So you sort of either you either in or you're out here
- 12:37and in New Zealand, the bar is a little bit lower.
- 12:39And it means that because here people used to come in
- 12:42and start in insurance and then sort of work their way up.
- 12:45I don't have a problem with that.
- 12:47I think at the end of the day,
- 12:48if you're going to be providing insurance advice,
- 12:51like people used to in the banks,
- 12:53cover mortgages and very basic,
- 12:54I don't think you need to have a degree
- 12:55to be able to have that conversation with someone I get.
- 12:58If you're going to be very specialist
- 13:00and it's going to be key man by cell
- 13:01or it's a very complicated family situation,
- 13:04then absolutely you need to be better educated
- 13:06and everything and just trust involved.
- 13:08But we just have everything sort of lumped in
- 13:11and it's all or nothing.
- 13:13So I think in New Zealand it's a bit easier to be an advisor.
- 13:16I think the compliance costs are a bit lower
- 13:18because of all the documentation
- 13:20and everything it's not as deep.
- 13:22But the products are as good pretty much as they are here.
- 13:26They haven't had any of the rate increases
- 13:28that we've had here.
- 13:28So obviously why?
- 13:30They haven't had the experience.
- 13:31Yeah, right.
- 13:32Oh, Michael Renny from Swiss Free was doing a presentation
- 13:35and we were comparing, sorry, he was comparing TPD
- 13:38around the world and effectively he was saying
- 13:41the closest market to what Australia offers is New Zealand.
- 13:44But even own occupation, it's just the experience,
- 13:46the claims experience is like chalk and cheese.
- 13:49Yeah, like I remember claims that fed
- 13:50in some months we didn't have one TPD claim
- 13:53and I was amazed when I went over there.
- 13:54Wow.
- 13:55And even on IP they don't have the issues.
- 13:58I'm not saying it doesn't exist
- 14:00but the reality is here we know TPD is mental health
- 14:03is a massive issue.
- 14:05Yeah.
- 14:05And here as well, mental health workforce bullying
- 14:08is a big part of that mental health here as well.
- 14:11But I don't know why.
- 14:13I've tried to get my head around why it would be.
- 14:16They have a different compensation system in New Zealand
- 14:19where everybody is sort of like in a group policy for IP.
- 14:23So your employer pays a certain amount of money
- 14:27and everything that you get paid that
- 14:29and sometimes that offsets your IP and maybe your TPD.
- 14:32But yeah, TPD is where we were 10 plus years ago.
- 14:36Yeah, and profitable and just not seeing the claims.
- 14:40Yeah, right.
- 14:40Okay.
- 14:41Yeah, so from bigger issues over there,
- 14:43the market's very small.
- 14:45There is more life insurance companies in New Zealand
- 14:47than there is in Australia, population spot.
- 14:51Financially they're still doing okay.
- 14:53I think if you look at the participants
- 14:56in the life insurance industry in Australia,
- 14:58I think the advisors in the clients are pretty good.
- 15:02They got the great products well priced,
- 15:04the advisor could pay for their time for what they do.
- 15:07I think the life offices in the reentures
- 15:10potentially are not in such a strong position.
- 15:13It's quite capital intensive when you're paying
- 15:15at 220% first year.
- 15:18But the market over there is becoming global as well
- 15:21as in owned by global life insurance companies.
- 15:23There's only one New Zealand owned life office there
- 15:26and that was the one I worked for, Fed,
- 15:29and sort of same as here, right?
- 15:31So, but as I said, it's amazing when you think about it,
- 15:34there's more life insurance companies in New Zealand
- 15:36than in Australia and we have like 27 million people
- 15:38and they have five.
- 15:40Yeah, because they effectively New Zealand
- 15:41is the same size in New South Wales, right?
- 15:42Yeah.
- 15:43Yeah, or Victoria, whatever, yeah.
- 15:44Yeah, I like this.
- 15:45And premiums are I'm gonna guess average premiums
- 15:47a little bit lower.
- 15:48No, not much.
- 15:50Not much, maybe two and a half grand.
- 15:52I can't remember exactly what it was,
- 15:53but not significantly different.
- 15:55And yeah, it's just really, really amazing how, sort of,
- 15:59one is, one's got too many and potentially we don't have enough,
- 16:04but I think we're gonna end up with less
- 16:06and probably less life insurance companies, not more.
- 16:08Yeah, so obviously Zurich Clearview,
- 16:11that's the biggest latest news.
- 16:13If you agree to a couple of years ago,
- 16:14sustainability is a pretty big issue.
- 16:16Make Oracle, where are we going for life insurance companies?
- 16:21Is anybody coming into the market?
- 16:22Have you heard any rumors?
- 16:23Yeah, I think there is going to be,
- 16:25like, I don't know, I can't name someone
- 16:29who's going to potentially come to the market,
- 16:31but we would be an interesting market
- 16:33for an overseas player to have a look at.
- 16:35Yeah.
- 16:36Particularly if you come here and set one up
- 16:40from scratch potentially,
- 16:41I think the opportunity could be quite significant.
- 16:44Yeah.
- 16:45But you got to have scale if you're one of the,
- 16:47if you're a life office here today,
- 16:49because there's a lot of high fixed costs
- 16:51in regards to doing business,
- 16:54and a lot of them are carrying a lot of legacy systems,
- 16:56et cetera, et cetera.
- 16:57So the sort of, yeah.
- 16:59So I think we'll Zurich Clearview thing
- 17:01looks like it will go through.
- 17:02I think I know the A-Triple Cs
- 17:04coming a bit of a look at the moment,
- 17:05but I would expect that will go through,
- 17:07and I think that will be a really interesting play
- 17:09because from what I understand,
- 17:11the product's gonna stay open, the brand will stay,
- 17:14and obviously they've got a history
- 17:15of doing that with one path.
- 17:16So they'll have a platform where you go in
- 17:18and you do Zurich and you do one path,
- 17:20Clearview, I'm pretty sure it's three different re-insures.
- 17:23Yeah.
- 17:24I quite like that.
- 17:25Yeah.
- 17:26We know Neil sort of have that as well.
- 17:27I think that's gonna be an interesting place,
- 17:30not maybe for risk specialists,
- 17:32but for the, for advisors who do three or four cases a year.
- 17:35Yeah.
- 17:36I think the plot,
- 17:37because they're all used to the platform play
- 17:38with the hubs and the net welds.
- 17:40Yeah, thank you.
- 17:40Thank you.
- 17:41Yeah.
- 17:42Yeah.
- 17:43And that's, I think that is a very smart play
- 17:44by Zurich.
- 17:45I think I quite like that.
- 17:46Yeah, no, I agree.
- 17:48Yeah, it's, yeah.
- 17:49I mean, it's quite crystal ball for that as well.
- 17:50I do want to go through that.
- 17:51I think it'll turn out to be a good bite.
- 17:52Yeah.
- 17:54And if, and if we grow great,
- 17:55but in the meantime,
- 17:56unfortunately, we are shrinking with TPD
- 17:59and the sustainability issues associated with that.
- 18:02Yeah.
- 18:02Even if the life offices are.
- 18:03Yeah, yeah.
- 18:04We're at the numbers of the people.
- 18:06Yeah.
- 18:07Yeah, I expect we'll, we'll get more consolidation of,
- 18:09over time.
- 18:11And we also need to hopefully have new people come in
- 18:16and we need to always also have some smaller ones as well.
- 18:19They keep the bigger ones accountable.
- 18:22Yeah.
- 18:23And also it's good to have choice, you know,
- 18:24but we have, well, you know,
- 18:26we have three big supermarkets and whatever it might be.
- 18:29So we might end up with something like that.
- 18:31Australians think it's 11 oligopoly.
- 18:33It does.
- 18:34Listen, we do mind in four big banks and all that sort of stuff.
- 18:36And then, yeah, it's, you know,
- 18:38it's just interesting how it's all sort of played out.
- 18:41You know, I've seen some posters in life offices.
- 18:44I worked in where 50 years ago,
- 18:46there was 57 life insurance companies in Australia
- 18:49or whatever it was that they're like,
- 18:51now there's seven.
- 18:52Yeah.
- 18:53It's, I gotta tell you, as an advisor, it's pretty sad.
- 18:56Yes, yeah, it really sort of breaks my heart.
- 18:58Yeah, it is, it's, it's just, it's so, so sad
- 19:02that we are where we are today and it's, yeah.
- 19:06From, from an international perspective,
- 19:08so from what I understand, life insurance is,
- 19:11I think it's two thirds and mutuals are about a third,
- 19:13but for some reason in Australia,
- 19:15it's what, like we've got PPS.
- 19:17That's the only mutual look.
- 19:18Yeah.
- 19:19They would be less than five percent of the market.
- 19:20Yeah, I would have thought so.
- 19:21Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 19:22They go well.
- 19:23I think they're, they know their market very clear about it.
- 19:27And, you know, I think the advisors within our network
- 19:29who do support them with a lot of their business.
- 19:33Yeah.
- 19:34But they are quite niche-y.
- 19:35But yeah, look, there's obviously,
- 19:37I've had a few conversations with people about,
- 19:40we need mutuals back here.
- 19:42Is that, like, you go back to yesterday, right?
- 19:44And it was the A&P's and the A&P's
- 19:45and when they demutualized,
- 19:47this was all, you know, 80s sort of 90s.
- 19:48Yeah, yeah, yeah, it basically, yeah, I think,
- 19:53yeah, there's probably a very solid argument
- 19:55for life offices being mutualized,
- 19:57but, you know, that's, we're not gonna go back to that.
- 20:00So, yeah, at the end of the day,
- 20:01I think even though so, so Niffon is mutual.
- 20:04Yeah, yeah, she.
- 20:05Not.
- 20:05That's not tonight.
- 20:06Yeah, okay.
- 20:07It was, so when did she bought a towel?
- 20:10Yeah.
- 20:10A towel, when it bought,
- 20:11we can't remember exactly,
- 20:12but say 25% of the business at the beginning,
- 20:14when it was listed,
- 20:15then we bought 100% and a Diachi demutualized around then,
- 20:20because when it was immutual,
- 20:21it wasn't able from memory and what I was told,
- 20:24it wasn't able to buy 100% of entities.
- 20:26So it started expanding overseas.
- 20:28Yeah.
- 20:29Because if you're a Japanese life insurance company
- 20:31and you're domestic,
- 20:32that's not a good place to be
- 20:34because the population is shrinking fast.
- 20:36And so they all have to,
- 20:38that's why Niffon is here.
- 20:39It's why Diachi's throw growing overseas
- 20:41and Diachi started with minority shareholders,
- 20:45because of their constitution
- 20:47or because they were immutual from what I understand.
- 20:49And then they listed on the Tokyo stock market.
- 20:52Yeah.
- 20:53I'd say 12, I'll come every exactly,
- 20:54but shortly after or just before they bought all of the towel,
- 20:58and then they're able to buy 100% of the businesses.
- 21:00So just what they do now.
- 21:01So do you think the ownership of life insurance
- 21:03by overseas investors rather than the Australian banks
- 21:06is a good thing for sustainability
- 21:08or a good thing for the market?
- 21:09Yeah, I think it's good for a life insurance company here
- 21:13to be owned by a life insurance company.
- 21:15That's the first, yeah, important thing.
- 21:18I think the issue with the bank zoning
- 21:19the life insurance companies is the banks have a very,
- 21:23have a shorter term view
- 21:25than life insurance is a long term business.
- 21:27You can't run a short term.
- 21:29You just can't, like,
- 21:30if you're a listed life insurance company,
- 21:32quote, unquote, or wanna explain to the market
- 21:35what's happening and everything,
- 21:37it's just very hard to do, right?
- 21:39And then like I remember Jim Minto
- 21:41talking about it way in terror
- 21:43was listed how difficult it was
- 21:44just to educate the marketing.
- 21:45Your whole life insurance company makes money
- 21:47and how it operates and the analysts don't understand it.
- 21:52Whereas, you know, you get the likes of Nippon
- 21:54and Dai Chi and Zurich and AIA.
- 21:57These are global giants
- 21:59who really understand insurance
- 22:01and how long-term thinking.
- 22:03And, you know, we all know that Japanese
- 22:05are 50 year business plan is not unusual.
- 22:08Yeah, now it's a great thing to learn to tell
- 22:11as well as about business planning.
- 22:12It was fantastic.
- 22:14Doing a 10 year business plan is quite daunting
- 22:16when you first do it,
- 22:17but actually, once you've done it a few times,
- 22:19it's actually pretty good.
- 22:21And they don't hold you accountable.
- 22:22So what you said, you though,
- 22:24but it's sort of like a three,
- 22:26first, next three years,
- 22:27we sort of think you should know what's gonna happen.
- 22:29From year four to six,
- 22:31you should have an educated guess and from year six on,
- 22:34but you don't know.
- 22:35One of the times I remember,
- 22:37we did a strategy day in TAL.
- 22:40This is going by quite a few years
- 22:41and we got the NMG guys in
- 22:43and we had the brains in TAL in the room for the day
- 22:48and we talked about the industry
- 22:49and what was gonna happen.
- 22:51And I found, so we put together a pack
- 22:53and we resented it to the exec and the board and everything.
- 22:55This is what's gonna happen in the market here.
- 22:57I found it a few, about five or six years later.
- 23:00I don't think we got one thing right.
- 23:01Seriously, we couldn't go that more wrong.
- 23:03We talked about the banks are gonna own distribution.
- 23:06The banks are gonna do that.
- 23:07And none of that happened.
- 23:09It was really quite amazing.
- 23:10And then yeah, it's so you just don't know,
- 23:13but it gives you a good,
- 23:15just makes you just think about your business longterm.
- 23:17Yep, business planning, 10 year business planning.
- 23:20It's a really good exercise,
- 23:21even a small business like Bombora.
- 23:25We need to think longterm as well
- 23:28and just putting it down on a bit of paper.
- 23:30It's a really good thing.
- 23:31It's a good segue.
- 23:32So join Bombora went to.
- 23:35So I've been with the business for a while.
- 23:37It was on the board.
- 23:38Yep, for a while.
- 23:39So after I left Howell,
- 23:40I did a bit of consulting with them.
- 23:43And then I went to New Zealand,
- 23:45but I was on the board when I was over there.
- 23:47And then when I came back,
- 23:49I took over as MD on the first of July last year
- 23:54and why, finally, who most people would know,
- 23:57say he's at the business up,
- 23:58he's stepped up to be second of chair.
- 24:01And yeah, he and I are now working in the business
- 24:05and running the business.
- 24:06And yeah, so I've been full-time MD
- 24:09for whatever that is now, 10 months or so.
- 24:11Yeah.
- 24:12And what's that transition like being going from,
- 24:14you know, manufacturer to advice?
- 24:17Yeah, it's been, I think I'm in a really unique place
- 24:21with my experience to think about licensee land
- 24:26and what it looks like.
- 24:28I've really enjoyed it.
- 24:30Hardest part of my job is there's so much opportunity.
- 24:34And I can't do it all.
- 24:36And that is really, I really,
- 24:38because I love to be doing new things
- 24:40and drawing new things on when my learning curve
- 24:43is the steepest, it's one on the happiest.
- 24:45Yeah, and I've learned that about myself.
- 24:47And you know, once you start,
- 24:49once I start to plateau
- 24:51and I'm not growing anymore as an individual,
- 24:53then I start to sort of lose a bit of interest.
- 24:55But so it's just been great to be able to have a conversation
- 24:59with the advisors about sustainability of life premiums
- 25:03and give my, why I think that is and what's happening.
- 25:06And be able to then have a conversation
- 25:09with the life offices about what the advisors are looking for
- 25:12and why, you know, a good example is pre-assessments.
- 25:15You know, we need to get a lot better a pre-assessment.
- 25:18So need to really start talking to the life offices
- 25:22a lot more about how we pre-assess
- 25:25and what we need to just get better at pre-assessing
- 25:28so that when we put a case in, it completes,
- 25:30whereas a lot of the time,
- 25:32that doesn't necessarily happen.
- 25:34Yeah, so it gives me a unique view
- 25:36and that's been a really enjoyable part of it
- 25:39and working with the advisors every single day.
- 25:40It's been great too.
- 25:42So you started your career by talking to advisors
- 25:44and it was the preferred partner program.
- 25:46So I'm going to guess that they were the guys
- 25:47writing more risks than not all guys angles.
- 25:49You then go into, you know, one of the,
- 25:51I think there's the second highest level
- 25:53of retail distribution in Australia
- 25:55with the largest insurer
- 25:57and now back to advisor land with licensee.
- 26:01What would be some of the points, like we're,
- 26:04I guess what I'm trying to ask is,
- 26:07the foundation of advice is trust, right?
- 26:08With a client, a client to advisor is all about trust
- 26:12and from an advisor's point of view,
- 26:13where I'm sitting, my trust with insurers
- 26:16isn't necessarily as high as what it should be
- 26:18based on the experience in the market,
- 26:20steps that have been taken, am I not?
- 26:21I'm just doing that.
- 26:23So can I ask what other,
- 26:26what do advisors and insurers get wrong about each other?
- 26:30What are the, what are the falsehoods, right?
- 26:32So I can't sit here and just go,
- 26:34it's their fault, they're doing this,
- 26:36but there's a genuine reason behind it.
- 26:38So what are you saying that's causing
- 26:39the most amount of grief
- 26:40and the biggest dichotomy and use?
- 26:42Yeah, the biggest issue, obviously,
- 26:44at the moment is all the rate increases that are happening.
- 26:47And I agree about the trusting.
- 26:49I think it is the trust between the advisor
- 26:51and the client is key,
- 26:52but also between the client and the life office
- 26:54and the advisor and the life offices here as well.
- 26:56And a number of advisors have said to me
- 26:59that their trust with life offices is broken
- 27:02or are not what it used to be.
- 27:04I think the reality is that the life offices
- 27:07and advisors need to work in partnership together
- 27:10because they need each other.
- 27:13Yeah, the advisors need a thriving life insurance market
- 27:16where the life offices are all sustainable
- 27:18and make them money, right?
- 27:19This is the problem.
- 27:20Obviously, I don't know how all the life offices
- 27:22are actually performing,
- 27:23but based on an outsider who used to be inside,
- 27:27I think it's not going to be an easy place to be, right?
- 27:30And you've all got big parents who would all be expecting
- 27:33some sort of return on capital
- 27:35and that may not be an easy thing for them to provide
- 27:37at the moment.
- 27:38And then you look to the future as well.
- 27:40If you're a life office, then you go,
- 27:42where it's like our clients are getting older and older
- 27:46and the premiums are getting higher and higher.
- 27:48We are like Swiss Rea,
- 27:49you've been talking about this cliff moment
- 27:51for years and years and years.
- 27:52I think you mentioned Michael,
- 27:54I think that is a presentation I've seen him do
- 27:56for possibly 18 years, but he's right.
- 27:59And what's going to happen is it's going to fall off a cliff.
- 28:02And there's no one coming in behind it.
- 28:05And so I suppose it's trying to get back to your question.
- 28:08I think the big issue is the life offices today
- 28:11are in a very different place.
- 28:12They're trying to survive,
- 28:15trying to get some sort of return on the business.
- 28:19And there are maybe not in a position
- 28:22to work as closely with advisors as they would like to.
- 28:25Yeah.
- 28:26I know I've really answered the question.
- 28:27Yeah, no, what's your leg?
- 28:28Yeah.
- 28:29I'm trying to, I suppose them.
- 28:30How about a deficit like this?
- 28:32In your experience with all insurers,
- 28:33not necessarily just one.
- 28:36And again, they had a distribution.
- 28:37So what's your conversation like now?
- 28:40With when I was in the...
- 28:41Sorry, I had a distribution with the licensee, right?
- 28:43So your GM of Bombora,
- 28:45which is generating huge levels of new business
- 28:47and again, force, what does some of the key points
- 28:51on the conversations?
- 28:52Well, what am I talking to them about at the moment?
- 28:54Yeah, so I'm talking to them about
- 28:56we have an enforced book of 155 million across the market.
- 28:59Yeah.
- 29:00What are we doing?
- 29:00We as in both of us?
- 29:02Yeah.
- 29:02To keep that, right?
- 29:04Because we don't want clients to lapse,
- 29:06obviously they will eventually or claim,
- 29:08but we want to try and keep the business
- 29:10on the books as long as we can.
- 29:12The life offices, we did an advisor survey
- 29:15in December of all the life insurance companies,
- 29:18which is really interesting to get their feedback
- 29:20on everything from new business to underwriting
- 29:22to retention and everything and retention
- 29:24is the least well thought of service
- 29:27that life offices provide from an advisor point of view.
- 29:30So I've been talking to them about
- 29:31how do we just keep that business on the books?
- 29:33Then how do we try and keep more, get more clients
- 29:36and how do we pre-assessments?
- 29:38How do we work with that in regards to trying
- 29:40to improve that and create more business here?
- 29:43And I don't feel that they're quite ready
- 29:45for a lot of new ideas.
- 29:48Because as I said, they're just trying to grapple
- 29:49with TPD and trying to work out what's going to happen
- 29:52with TPD, so that's their focus.
- 29:55And in area, I think that we need to look at his younger lives,
- 29:58how to get more them in and the key to that's underwriting.
- 30:01Yeah, okay.
- 30:02Is there anything else that you're doing special?
- 30:03So I know some of the heroes of the industry
- 30:06go like Phil Thompson, right?
- 30:07He's average age is 40 years old.
- 30:10Yeah, and every client's getting a standard
- 30:11boss, every client's getting a fee,
- 30:12like he's just a machine at filling that life at the start.
- 30:17Again, as the largest distributor,
- 30:19what are you guys doing for our clients?
- 30:21Yeah, I'd know for the advisors and the younger lives, right?
- 30:23So talking to the existing ones,
- 30:25but then also thinking about financial advisors
- 30:27that are potentially passing off those 30 to 40
- 30:30to 45-year-old clients,
- 30:31because they're just not profitable.
- 30:32Yeah, and that's a big problem, Ron.
- 30:34Yeah, so a lot of our advisors would be getting leads
- 30:38that they say no to, like basically one of the advisors
- 30:41tell me when I first started for every 15 leads,
- 30:44he gets he steps one.
- 30:45Yeah, wow.
- 30:46And the other 14, he does nothing with.
- 30:48So we've set up, we've started doing general advice,
- 30:50which is a big change from one more, right?
- 30:53So we are a personal advice business
- 30:56that does each client one by one, by one, by one,
- 31:00by one, that's the way, right?
- 31:02It's a very thorough process,
- 31:03but this year we're really about trying to ensure
- 31:06more people with less paperwork.
- 31:07It's not about 20 good corners,
- 31:09it's just trying to get more people insured
- 31:11because we need to do that.
- 31:13So the GA model that we've put in place within
- 31:15Bambora, the advisors have, I suppose, four options now.
- 31:19They can either put on the GA person themselves
- 31:21and have them work in the office.
- 31:23So it's sort of, I mean, Bambora's
- 31:25like sort of dual license in that way.
- 31:26Yeah, they can be, they can be,
- 31:28they're not technically licensed,
- 31:29but yeah, they're in the Bambora network.
- 31:30Yep, yep, yep.
- 31:31And so they're a GA advisor,
- 31:33only do GA calls are recorded, et cetera, et cetera,
- 31:37and quality all listen to, et cetera.
- 31:40But that can happen.
- 31:41And we've got one practice that's doing that today.
- 31:45And I think we'll have more.
- 31:46Yep, we have another GA business
- 31:49that has just come into the network.
- 31:51So the advisors can refer in those lines through.
- 31:55Or we've got a referral option
- 31:57with two of the life offices
- 32:00that the advisors can use as well.
- 32:01So we're trying to open up the opportunities
- 32:04and that's starting to pay some dividends now
- 32:08or starting slowly to ensure more people.
- 32:10And for me, it's the same product at the same price,
- 32:14the same underriding, the same everything
- 32:15the customer is getting,
- 32:17then they get through personal advice.
- 32:19It's just general advice.
- 32:20Yeah.
- 32:21And the big thing at the moment
- 32:22is a lot of those clients are not
- 32:24getting any insurance at the moment.
- 32:25Yeah.
- 32:26So it's important that we start to at least.
- 32:28Yeah, no, I agree with that.
- 32:29I'm not sure.
- 32:30I'd rather have somebody have something.
- 32:31Yep.
- 32:32And then the other area that we're looking at
- 32:34trying to get more people insurities
- 32:35on the corporate group side.
- 32:37Yeah.
- 32:38So we think that's a really big area.
- 32:40Big area, our client advisors line bases
- 32:42would have a lot of people who are successful business people,
- 32:46maybe senior executives in businesses
- 32:49or run their own business.
- 32:50And we look after them from an insurance point of view.
- 32:53But mate, we've never really spoken to them about their staff
- 32:56and what we can do there.
- 32:57So we're starting to roll out a plan
- 32:59as we speak in regards to doing more corporate coverage.
- 33:02So we have 16, I think it was,
- 33:04corporate group plans across the Holboombore network.
- 33:07Like that's just so wrong.
- 33:08We're all going to say I had four at my last year.
- 33:10Yeah.
- 33:11Yeah.
- 33:12Across the Holboombore network.
- 33:13Yeah.
- 33:14Yeah.
- 33:15So we should have 170, right?
- 33:17Yeah.
- 33:17So, and then, and the life offices are starting to drop
- 33:21their minimums.
- 33:23And there's a couple at 20 now,
- 33:25which opens up the market, which is great.
- 33:27You know, it's just, it just means that it's another way
- 33:30for the advisors to build relationships with the clients.
- 33:33Because people get cover automatic settings levels,
- 33:36continuation options when they leave.
- 33:39And the advisor gets the personal advisor,
- 33:41do advice opportunities off the back of that.
- 33:43So it's a, it's a really nice, yeah, I do it.
- 33:44Yeah, great.
- 33:45It's a, it's a good commercial outcome for, yeah, parties.
- 33:48Yeah, yeah.
- 33:49It definitely is.
- 33:49Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 33:51And is that, that's, is it more popular in New Zealand
- 33:54around insurance through your employer?
- 33:57Yeah.
- 33:58So they don't do any, the group marketing New Zealand's
- 34:01much smaller than here.
- 34:02So when I was at Fed, we won this, from memory,
- 34:06the second largest group case in New Zealand.
- 34:09I think it was four million year in premium.
- 34:11Some of the life offices wouldn't get out of bed for that here.
- 34:14They don't have any of the big industry super funds.
- 34:16Yeah.
- 34:17But it got me, that's, but that's my time in New Zealand.
- 34:20Got me convinced why we have to do more corporate group here
- 34:23because it does work.
- 34:24Yeah.
- 34:25And they actually do group trauma over there as well.
- 34:27So I've spoken to the re-insurers here about,
- 34:29well, if you do, and that's the same people doing,
- 34:31doing the reinsurance market in Australian New Zealand
- 34:34about it, looking at group trauma,
- 34:36about at the moment it's live TPD and IP.
- 34:39The market over there definitely has been doing it
- 34:42for a bit more than here, but I think I was surprised,
- 34:46actually, when I started looking at corporate group here,
- 34:49I thought it would be very Excel manual process.
- 34:53It's actually a good, great technology.
- 34:56So it's actually more advanced than I thought it was
- 34:59the group market from a more advanced than retail, I'm guessing.
- 35:02I was surprised at what you could see online
- 35:05and do quoting and everything.
- 35:07So as I said, I thought retail would be a long way ahead,
- 35:09but it's not an, it's certainly a vise and advisor
- 35:12today doing risk insurance.
- 35:14I would 100% be doing GA.
- 35:16Yeah, I'll be breaking my client base up and going,
- 35:18well, all the younger ages, all GA,
- 35:21starting to get referrals from my clients,
- 35:23but for a while with their kids,
- 35:24and I'm doing them and I'm doing personal advice
- 35:27and I'm losing money, GA for those people,
- 35:29corporate group, and then personal advice for the people
- 35:33who need us or whatever they may be.
- 35:35Yeah, and people land to families and corporate debt
- 35:37and all this sort of stuff, right?
- 35:38But not everyone needs that.
- 35:40Yeah, no, it's good to see the focus on group, right?
- 35:42Because you said before that underwriting
- 35:43was the biggest hurdle for getting insurance
- 35:45and you know, bang, we just bypass it straightaway.
- 35:47Yeah, yeah, and the younger people as well,
- 35:49like so my oldest is 25.
- 35:52If he takes out insurance, he feels in the same application
- 35:55as I do and I'm 56.
- 35:57That doesn't make a lot of sense, Stary.
- 35:58Right, yeah.
- 35:59And the life offices need to start thinking about
- 36:03how can we attract young people
- 36:06to come into this industry and take out insurance?
- 36:08Yeah.
- 36:09And they got to start thinking outside the square.
- 36:11Because of the moment the square that we're in,
- 36:13it's not delivering the results
- 36:14and they really need to start thinking about that
- 36:16and it needs to be led by them.
- 36:17Yeah, someone like me can have a conversation
- 36:20with the individuals within the life offices,
- 36:22but just the size and the scale,
- 36:24the funding, the capital.
- 36:25Yep, need to come from one of the leaders in the industry.
- 36:28They need to leave this industry out of where it is today.
- 36:32Is superannuation as part of that conversation?
- 36:35As in the insurance system.
- 36:36Well, yeah, so like we, you know,
- 36:38one of the biggest frustrations and the advisors
- 36:41often will have clients saying,
- 36:42oh, mate, I've got covered through my super.
- 36:44Yeah.
- 36:44And the education in how much people have
- 36:46versus how much they need.
- 36:47I think the average mortgage is over 700 grand now.
- 36:49A average life cover in super is 200 ish,
- 36:52or there are probably about it.
- 36:53It probably feels about right to me.
- 36:54Yeah.
- 36:55And I think it is part of the problem
- 36:57because people do believe that they have a more,
- 36:59and what surprised me I saw the other day was
- 37:02industry superfund insurance is dearer than retail.
- 37:06I didn't know.
- 37:07One of my advices was talk,
- 37:08because you know, there's been a lot of rate increases
- 37:10happening at the moment for the industry superfund.
- 37:12And I'm one of the guys showed me 30, 35, 40, 45, 50,
- 37:16whatever, you know, the difference in premiums.
- 37:18It's about 30% cheaper in retail.
- 37:20And so you can do retail insurance,
- 37:23and you can still fund it out of super.
- 37:24So from a funding point of view,
- 37:26because obviously it helps,
- 37:27you got $700,000 mortgage and two kids
- 37:30and you're in your 40s.
- 37:31Not much cash.
- 37:32Yeah.
- 37:32You're right.
- 37:33So it's good to be able to still fund it out of super.
- 37:34Yeah.
- 37:35But if you can have a retail policy over a corporate group
- 37:38policy, actually to me,
- 37:40it's an absolute no-brainer.
- 37:42But again, we need to get the life offices
- 37:44to start thinking about how do we move it
- 37:46from one of the other of that,
- 37:48making it onerous for an underwriting point of view.
- 37:51And I've got no problem with doing a bit of underwriting.
- 37:54And you know, I think another thing
- 37:56that life offices should start looking at
- 37:58is enforce management every five years.
- 38:03Your clients just answer a couple of questions
- 38:05from an underwriting point of view
- 38:06and they get a rate decrease and they,
- 38:08or maybe they go on the new business rates today,
- 38:11because that's a real issue as well,
- 38:12is this the job that I see?
- 38:14Yeah, it's a real,
- 38:17yeah, like...
- 38:17It's a snake hitting your own face sort of thing, right?
- 38:19Yeah, it's a,
- 38:21but when I was a towel,
- 38:23I don't know how many times I stood up
- 38:25in front of all the staff.
- 38:27I used to do a town hall to say
- 38:28we will never, ever do durational process.
- 38:32And of course, we did,
- 38:32because at the end of the day, the market did it.
- 38:35Yeah, and if you don't follow,
- 38:36you knew business goes to zero.
- 38:38And it's a,
- 38:39and I know that can be a bit frustrating for people here,
- 38:42but the reality is a business needs new business.
- 38:45Once a business stops getting new business in the door,
- 38:47it starts dying,
- 38:49gotta be growing all the time.
- 38:50Yeah.
- 38:51And it just,
- 38:52it's just so important to have flows coming in
- 38:56and yeah, and durational,
- 38:59the, durational pricing on its own is not too bad.
- 39:04Long as the client's understand it,
- 39:06the issue we haven't had in this country
- 39:08is you've got durational,
- 39:09you've got age-based increases,
- 39:11you've got CPI increases,
- 39:13and then you've got all this
- 39:13out of cycle rate increases as well.
- 39:15So people are just getting five increases
- 39:18or whatever it might be,
- 39:19and that's a real issue.
- 39:21Do you reckon that's contributing
- 39:22to the likes of clear view and integrity?
- 39:25That's sort of thing.
- 39:26As in sustainability of life insurance in Australia.
- 39:29The pricing model.
- 39:30Yeah, well, I think it's,
- 39:31it's, we're getting to the stage now
- 39:33where the enforced pricing is unsustainable for consumers.
- 39:38Yeah.
- 39:39Right? And the worrying thing is that,
- 39:41I don't,
- 39:42because we, the issue we have with TPD
- 39:45isn't gonna go away any time soon, right?
- 39:47Because yeah.
- 39:47And you can't get rid of it
- 39:48by making changes to the policies.
- 39:50So what you have,
- 39:51you are stuck with in Verticomers, right?
- 39:54So yes, you can fix it for new clients,
- 39:57but that's gonna take 10 years.
- 39:59Yeah. Yeah.
- 40:00And we saw it with IP, right?
- 40:01Right?
- 40:02You've got the pre-IDI,
- 40:03host-IDI,
- 40:05rates going even higher
- 40:07with the old policies,
- 40:08because people, if they can,
- 40:09they're moving to the new one.
- 40:10Mental health,
- 40:11that's the big driver of the claims.
- 40:13Carl, while the life codes in our under review
- 40:15would PDA tell to look at a blanket exclusion
- 40:18for mental health.
- 40:19Yeah.
- 40:20Do you think that's gonna create
- 40:21the same problem again?
- 40:22Like we're gonna have a new class of product
- 40:23that's vastly different to the last.
- 40:25Yeah.
- 40:26So that legacy product
- 40:27is just gonna get hammered twice as fast.
- 40:29Yeah, I think the reality is on the legacy product,
- 40:33I don't know what will happen
- 40:34to change the current experience,
- 40:36except life offices will just keep putting their prices up
- 40:39until people can't afford it anymore
- 40:41and some would say we're already there.
- 40:42Yeah.
- 40:43I think if we go forward,
- 40:45we either have a mental health exclusion,
- 40:49or we don't.
- 40:50I don't,
- 40:50because the problem you will have
- 40:52is if advisor has the best interest duty,
- 40:55they will always have to wreck,
- 40:57because we talk to our advisor all the time,
- 40:59we're trying to get them to start using,
- 41:01thinking about the TPD, the new start.
- 41:04Yeah, the new start.
- 41:05The Zuri, I guess, yeah.
- 41:06And I must admit,
- 41:07it tells my favorite one,
- 41:09because what I like about it is
- 41:11the client's still covered
- 41:13under the current definition,
- 41:14but they just have to go through the process five years,
- 41:17so they get 20% of the sum in turn.
- 41:19And I believe tile's gonna roll that out
- 41:22across as the enforced book as well.
- 41:23Now, clients don't have to take it,
- 41:25but potentially they will,
- 41:26and they'll obviously get a discount.
- 41:28And I think that will be,
- 41:29I think that's a really potentially
- 41:31a good, sort of good way
- 41:33to just start thinking about it.
- 41:35Could, could,
- 41:36sorry to cut you off,
- 41:37could you change the assessment of mental health
- 41:40to what they're looking at for things
- 41:41like workers' compensation,
- 41:42you know, the personal impairment,
- 41:43yeah, as a reading scale.
- 41:45So, so again,
- 41:47we know mental health is real, right?
- 41:49Like, so I've got mates,
- 41:51I think everybody's being touched by suicide,
- 41:53leading cause of death.
- 41:54Depression anxiety stress,
- 41:56the drivers of the TPD claims experience at the moment.
- 41:59Mental health under the current life code,
- 42:02I think that the definition is something like,
- 42:04a broad range of things.
- 42:06And included in there are things like schizophrenia
- 42:08and bipolar and all the rest of it.
- 42:09My fear is that if we apply a mental health exclusion
- 42:12across the board,
- 42:13then people with schizophrenia by default
- 42:15are like, effectively they're going to be left.
- 42:17Yeah, that's a good point.
- 42:18And I think from, again,
- 42:21just to talk about Tau,
- 42:22I think the Tau one does pay 100%
- 42:26for some of those on day one.
- 42:28And then some of the other claims,
- 42:31events, so work,
- 42:32mental health, work force bullying,
- 42:34etc, a couple of those other ones
- 42:36are paid out over the five years.
- 42:37So I do, I do get your point about the blanket exclusion,
- 42:40but whatever we do, we have to do consistently
- 42:43because we can't have the new and the old in the market
- 42:46like we do today
- 42:47because the advisors have a best interest duty
- 42:49which they believe makes them have to recommend
- 42:53the best product of it.
- 42:54I don't believe best interest is to put a client
- 42:57in a product where you know the premiums
- 42:59are going to double in the next three years.
- 43:00I personally don't agree.
- 43:01That's the best interest.
- 43:02I get the product conversation.
- 43:04So that's the conversation we're having with our advisors
- 43:07is you need to start getting making clients be aware.
- 43:10This is what's happened with this product
- 43:12in the last three years.
- 43:13I can't tell you exactly what's going to happen.
- 43:15I can give you an estimate what it will be,
- 43:17but it'll probably be more than that.
- 43:18We have to start having those conversations
- 43:20so people understand,
- 43:21client doesn't want to go into a product.
- 43:22I would not want to buy a product today
- 43:25knowing that in two or two or three years' terms
- 43:27can be double what I'm paying today.
- 43:29I wouldn't need to sit in that.
- 43:30So I think we just need to change our thinking
- 43:33in regards to the old and the new
- 43:35and make 250 or break up the, just something.
- 43:38Yeah, I have to create myself.
- 43:40I said best product earlier.
- 43:42I got called up by Marshall Ross
- 43:43and I'm using that terminology and he's 100% right.
- 43:45It's not the best product.
- 43:47It's the most comprehensive definition
- 43:48or the most generous features.
- 43:50And the price you pay is a lot more in price.
- 43:53So like you said, best interest duty.
- 43:55It's a holistic duty, right?
- 43:56It is.
- 43:57It's price, it's product, it's sustainability of programs
- 44:00and it's all about it.
- 44:01It's what the client can afford as well to agree
- 44:03and not rely on, but into the future.
- 44:04You know, like I think again,
- 44:06with personal and vice world that we live in today,
- 44:08our advisors do a recommendation
- 44:09and they recommend whatever the clients need.
- 44:12Knowing the clients can't afford that.
- 44:15Right.
- 44:16Now, if I'm a client and I got seen advisor,
- 44:18I give them all my information
- 44:19and then I get this recommendation.
- 44:21That to me just,
- 44:23it's gonna be why, yeah.
- 44:25You know, and then I have, we have to reduce it
- 44:27and like you're the, like you're the expert
- 44:29I'm coming to you for advice, you know my situation
- 44:31and then you recommend I spend 15 grand a year
- 44:34in insurance when I don't have that disposable income
- 44:37to do so.
- 44:38So I think yeah, the best interesting is really,
- 44:41I think it's, I get the logic of why I was brought in
- 44:44but I think it's created a lot of issues
- 44:47within the industry and people are afraid of getting sued
- 44:50and accept it.
- 44:51Yeah, yeah.
- 44:52And just think with the things like durational discounts
- 44:54and a big up front, it's almost,
- 44:56it's in trenching what's falsely called churn, right?
- 44:59If your policy's five years old,
- 45:01you're 25, 30, 40% more expensive than what you can get
- 45:03somewhere else.
- 45:04And the best interest you do, you have to move them.
- 45:06Yeah, and you know, and we don't want to do that
- 45:08as noises, right?
- 45:09I want to take out a policy and I want to have it
- 45:11in 20 years.
- 45:12Yeah, that's why I bought level.
- 45:13Yeah, and you don't, you don't want to rewrite it
- 45:15for a very, one, you hardly make any money
- 45:17on your business anyway, because of the 60% commission
- 45:20which is one of the reasons.
- 45:21We're all getting a K-way passports.
- 45:22Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
- 45:23We should, you know, like that, that's,
- 45:25and again, that's an issue we have in the industry.
- 45:27We actually don't control what the advisors get paid.
- 45:31It's legislated, that, so to get that changed,
- 45:34we have to get the government to change.
- 45:37And we first shield Guardian.
- 45:38Not gonna hats.
- 45:39That's not happening.
- 45:40Well, it's not gonna happen.
- 45:41That's why we have to do more GA.
- 45:43That's why we have to do corporate group.
- 45:45I think we're going to get to the stage with AI
- 45:48where we are going to be able to do
- 45:50personal advice, digital advice,
- 45:52we're all right there, but more and more common.
- 45:54Yeah.
- 45:54The issue, that's great.
- 45:55We can give everyone digital advice,
- 45:58you know, for the younger ages and everything
- 46:00and it can be personal advice digitally.
- 46:02The issue though, is they will end up with an SOA,
- 46:06that just tells them what they need.
- 46:07They, they need to go and get it.
- 46:09And that's where the real implementation,
- 46:11implementation.
- 46:12So I think we'll start to see,
- 46:14we're definitely in one more,
- 46:15we're gonna start looking at how we,
- 46:17we, when that happens,
- 46:18we're ready to have implementation.
- 46:20Yep.
- 46:21There won't be advisors,
- 46:22but there'll be people who will implement
- 46:24and be expert and know all the life offers
- 46:27and know the under orders
- 46:28and be able to make things happen.
- 46:30I join the analogy between that and general insurance,
- 46:32they're the underwriting agencies
- 46:34who become more and more, I guess, powerful
- 46:36once in another word,
- 46:37because it is exactly that.
- 46:38They've got the relationships
- 46:39and they can funnel everything and go and troll it
- 46:41and help, they help the client and the advisor.
- 46:43Yeah, it's, yeah, it's, you know,
- 46:45you take the underwriting agencies of the life,
- 46:47pull them out as a middle man,
- 46:49almost between the advisor of the client and, yeah.
- 46:51Yeah, I think yeah, and, and so that will be,
- 46:54I think something that will be a big opportunity as well.
- 46:58Is this one of the things where you wish you had time?
- 47:00Yeah, yeah, it is and, and claims as well.
- 47:02Like, you know, I don't understand why advisors
- 47:07don't charge for claims.
- 47:08More and more of our network starting to our reckon
- 47:10where we had a business development day last month
- 47:14in Melbourne where we all talked about,
- 47:16this is the old advises we're in town
- 47:18and we all talked about who's charging for claims
- 47:20and what are they charging?
- 47:21And it was quite interesting in the room.
- 47:23Probably half are charging.
- 47:26One is charging per hour.
- 47:29The others that are charging
- 47:30are just taking like a flat fee or whatever
- 47:32might be depending on life, TBD, whatever it is.
- 47:35But the amount of time that you spend processing a claim
- 47:40is significant for a business
- 47:43and I don't understand why an advisor practiced.
- 47:46I know historically we've said we've got paid,
- 47:47but now they's going to get paid 60%.
- 47:49Yeah.
- 47:51And then 20% ongoing.
- 47:53I think that's a big, a big market that we're going to need.
- 47:55Well, it's going to get bigger and bigger over time.
- 47:58Yeah. Yeah.
- 48:00You see like, I think Trevor Batterspeed
- 48:02from TB Claims for a call for the guy, David Spigeri,
- 48:05all these guys are making businesses out of it.
- 48:07Yeah, compared.
- 48:08And we have a Bambora Connect, we have a claims service
- 48:11so the advises can refer through
- 48:12and we look after it and we charge
- 48:14and we're also non-Bambora practices.
- 48:16So the industry is full of businesses
- 48:20who use to write risk insurance.
- 48:22And they have 500,000 of in-force
- 48:25or whatever it might be.
- 48:26Nobody in the business knows anything about insurance
- 48:29whatsoever.
- 48:30Client rings up and goes, I want to put a claim in
- 48:32and they're like, oh my God, what do we do?
- 48:34They send the client to the live office.
- 48:36So we've got a few of those businesses
- 48:39and hopefully it will grow where they'll send it to us.
- 48:42Yep.
- 48:42We look after the client, we got the claim paid.
- 48:46And basically we have like a fee to just basically
- 48:49just collect paperwork and stuff, 500 bucks, whatever.
- 48:52And then it doesn't cost the client anything.
- 48:54Obviously the client doesn't have to take the service
- 48:56if they don't want to.
- 48:57But we feel that works quite well.
- 48:59Yeah.
- 49:00Yeah, okay.
- 49:01Can I go back quickly?
- 49:03You mentioned before around sustainability route,
- 49:04we've talked about sustainability industry as a whole.
- 49:07You guys are one of the leading risk specialists
- 49:10licensee in the country with lots and lots of advisors,
- 49:13lots of lots of businesses.
- 49:15As a licensee with control of your own APL,
- 49:19is there something that you're looking
- 49:20to do around sustainability
- 49:22or are you thinking about doing towards sustainability?
- 49:25As in premium sustainability?
- 49:26Yeah, correct.
- 49:28As it relates to new advisors giving advice,
- 49:32looking at past rate increases,
- 49:34is that impacting your thinking
- 49:36and are you trying to get that into the heads of the advisors?
- 49:41Not really sure, I'm understanding the question.
- 49:43So what you're trying to find out is,
- 49:44so at the moment, obviously we've got
- 49:45saying sustainability issues with the products
- 49:47that's in the market.
- 49:48So what are we saying to our advisors
- 49:50about trying to not have future clients impacted by that?
- 49:54Yeah.
- 49:54So we've got like a bit of a TBD house view
- 49:58that we've put together.
- 49:59So where we're trying to get the advice
- 50:01that I mentioned earlier on about best interest,
- 50:03trying to get the advisors to consider
- 50:05an alternative strategy,
- 50:06which is using the new TBD.
- 50:08Also trying to get the advisors to start thinking
- 50:11about moving clients from the old IP to the new IP
- 50:14and that's starting to happen more and more.
- 50:16So I would say that advises that.
- 50:19So the five year benefit period in the new product today
- 50:23doesn't have the the own to the any right.
- 50:26So it should have five years of own.
- 50:27Yep.
- 50:28So advises I'm seeing client hits 57.
- 50:31They've got age 65.
- 50:32So they've got eight years of ONOC,
- 50:35but I'm just going to put them in the new five year.
- 50:37So they're only going to get five years rather late,
- 50:39but actually it's significantly cheaper.
- 50:40Yeah.
- 50:41So that's starting to happen more and more.
- 50:43And look, I don't think we're going to be able
- 50:46to get the live offices to give us any sort of guarantee
- 50:50on premiums and rights.
- 50:51So the sustainability one like,
- 50:54but I suppose what I will say is if we get the product design
- 50:57right and we, I think with the current IP products
- 51:00has been the market for quite a few years now.
- 51:02As far as I know, there's only been one rate increase
- 51:04on the new IP product.
- 51:06That's it when your life office put their prices up.
- 51:09So that seems to be working.
- 51:11Yep.
- 51:12And claims are going through.
- 51:13We've had a couple of claims where the clients
- 51:15gone from ONOC to Anyok.
- 51:16So it's all starting to work, yeah.
- 51:19Maybe not privately, but it is starting to work,
- 51:21which is great.
- 51:22So hopefully with the new TPD,
- 51:24we can get in a much better place.
- 51:26Yeah.
- 51:27At the moment, it's only life's fine as far as I know.
- 51:29Chrome is fine as far as I know.
- 51:31It's really just the old sort of IP and the TPD
- 51:35that really where the issues are
- 51:37from the sustainability point of view.
- 51:38So again, future proofing, new TPD comes out in a couple of years,
- 51:42whatever it looks like.
- 51:44Do you reckon we good then?
- 51:46I would have, if someone had asked me that question 10 years ago
- 51:50and said once we fixed the IP, are we good then?
- 51:52I probably would have said yes.
- 51:53Claire wouldn't have occurred to me that TPD
- 51:55would have been where we are today.
- 51:57But you would think in theory, yeah, I like.
- 51:59I don't think people are going to start dying younger.
- 52:02But in theory, we could have something really bad
- 52:06happened globally.
- 52:07And I think when medicine people are surviving longer,
- 52:10I'm getting formers earlier.
- 52:12So yeah, I would say the answer to that probably is yes.
- 52:16Yeah, I would help.
- 52:17So anyway, we need to,
- 52:20I think also another thing, which is understand
- 52:22that the life office products are guaranteed and sureable,
- 52:25which is a really good benefit
- 52:26that I don't think consumers really understand
- 52:30how good that really is, right?
- 52:33No matter what happens, you're a health,
- 52:35do you take a policy out at 25 years of age?
- 52:38You take up skydiving.
- 52:39Without power suits, right?
- 52:40Yeah, yeah.
- 52:41You know, you can do anything you want.
- 52:43Yeah.
- 52:44That's a really good benefit, but that really restricts
- 52:47what life is your stock.
- 52:48Yeah, I believe you've got his price.
- 52:51Yeah, and that's the issue.
- 52:52And eventually you'll just price the lineup,
- 52:54which is what's happening at the moment.
- 52:56So yeah, I think another thing
- 52:58advisors should look at is, you know,
- 53:00sustainability comes from long-term thinking
- 53:03and long-term planning.
- 53:04And I think, you know, advisors need to think about
- 53:08the life offices that they support
- 53:10and just how long-term they think about things.
- 53:13It is a long-term business that you really have
- 53:17to be thinking about what your experience
- 53:20is going to be like in 10 and 20 years
- 53:22and what you do today in a life insurance company
- 53:25as a CEO or whatever, as a main decision maker.
- 53:29If you do your job well,
- 53:30you will personally not benefit
- 53:32from any of those great decisions that you made
- 53:34because they take 10 or 20 years to really go down.
- 53:36Yeah, down the line.
- 53:38Yeah.
- 53:38No, I think that's good advice,
- 53:39because as an advisor,
- 53:41you're going to have your practice potentially
- 53:42as an owner for the next 10, 20 years.
- 53:44Yeah, quite aligned with the client long-term.
- 53:46So I think it had a long time.
- 53:47Yeah, and we've got to try and write,
- 53:49I think, the sustainability of the life offices,
- 53:52whatever that might look like.
- 53:53Yeah.
- 53:54And I know our advisors,
- 53:55some of them have done that personally
- 53:58and they have very clear view in their head
- 54:00about who they support based on sustainability.
- 54:04Yeah, that's what I was trying to ask before.
- 54:05Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 54:07So yeah, look, I think,
- 54:08but there's no,
- 54:09we don't have a particular position
- 54:11as a licensee on it.
- 54:13Yeah, yes, it's there.
- 54:15Okay.
- 54:16Nice.
- 54:17All right, well, so for the advisors,
- 54:18it's great to see Paul Milbourne, for example,
- 54:20he started his own practice.
- 54:22There aren't many people out there
- 54:23that are supporting the one man band growing.
- 54:25So yeah, he's doing really well.
- 54:26He's got to just put on an advisor recently as well.
- 54:28So he's going really well.
- 54:30I love his social media.
- 54:33I like how he's sort of,
- 54:35because what he's doing as well,
- 54:37we don't even really have to,
- 54:39I know we have to write,
- 54:40find new clients and write,
- 54:41but actually there is thousands and thousands
- 54:44and thousands of clients out there
- 54:45who have insurance today,
- 54:46who have no advisor,
- 54:47or they've got no engagement with their advisor,
- 54:49and obviously Paul has talked about that
- 54:51in social media all the time.
- 54:53And, you know, if he can pick up some of those,
- 54:55that's a really good outcome.
- 54:56But he has a great business,
- 54:58and it's great to have him in the network.
- 54:59He's a bright thinker,
- 55:01and he's one of these people who embraces everything.
- 55:03And with AI at the moment,
- 55:04there's so many new things happening.
- 55:06Paul's, I'll have a go,
- 55:07that'll have a go,
- 55:07that'll have a go at that.
- 55:08It's fantastic.
- 55:09Yeah, but it's just nice to say
- 55:10that the Bumble are as a group,
- 55:12a supportive of that sort of thing, right?
- 55:14There's a theory out there
- 55:15for their financial advisors
- 55:17that you shouldn't touch risk
- 55:18because it's not profitable enough.
- 55:20And you go,
- 55:21well, if he's a guy who's exited
- 55:22a good corporate job to start his own business,
- 55:24then obviously there is some ways.
- 55:25Yeah, I can tell you that life insurance
- 55:27is really profitable if you're an advisor.
- 55:29So, you know, we own two and a half practices
- 55:32within the network.
- 55:33And one of our main strategies
- 55:34is to continue buying businesses
- 55:37within an outside of the network as well.
- 55:40The reality is that their prof,
- 55:42their license, a D life,
- 55:44the advisor business,
- 55:45the advice businesses are profitable
- 55:48because no one's doing risk insurance.
- 55:50So they're able to hire first year average premiums
- 55:53to probably eight, nine grand.
- 55:55Yeah.
- 55:55So yeah, so people have just decided
- 55:58that they don't want to do it
- 55:58because it is a specialist area.
- 56:01So, you know, either in my mind,
- 56:04if you're an advisor today,
- 56:05and you have life insurance clients
- 56:08that you don't look after in your business,
- 56:10you either need to start looking after them, sell them
- 56:13or outsource them to a business like ours
- 56:15where we can manage them for you
- 56:18and you keep them if you want
- 56:20and then but just look after them.
- 56:21So, because it's the industry's changed so much,
- 56:24you've imagined if you stopped doing insurance
- 56:26five, six years ago,
- 56:27and now you decided to get back into it.
- 56:30Everything's different, right?
- 56:31So yeah.
- 56:32Yeah.
- 56:33So as we wrap up,
- 56:34I don't know is there anything else
- 56:35that's going on in your world?
- 56:36Yeah.
- 56:37So it's great to see that you're gonna join us
- 56:39on the board of PFAN.
- 56:41Very excited to have you on board, mate.
- 56:43You know, it's such a great organization, PFAN.
- 56:47So for those advisors that don't know,
- 56:50PFAN is a pro bono organization
- 56:53where advisors give up a bit of their time
- 56:56for people who being diagnosed with MS and MND
- 57:00and provide them with a bit of advice.
- 57:04And you know, the reality is that they're not people
- 57:06who would generally get advice.
- 57:08So there are going to be people
- 57:10who are low social, economic and anything,
- 57:12but the advisors will really help them,
- 57:14particularly in the insurance side,
- 57:15like MS and MND is very much a, you get diagnosed,
- 57:20but you might not be entitled to a claim straight away.
- 57:22So you probably could be a couple of years in
- 57:24and maybe they've constantly their insurance.
- 57:26So the advisors give up the time
- 57:28and help them with center link and insurance needs
- 57:31and super and all that sort of stuff.
- 57:33So we've got quite a lot of advisors
- 57:36who I think it's 170 or something like that,
- 57:38who have sort of registered, yeah.
- 57:40But we're always looking for more
- 57:41because there's a lot of opportunity
- 57:43for us to help more people.
- 57:45And it's great if you're an advisor
- 57:47and you want to sort of give back to the community
- 57:49and one or two cases a year, that's it.
- 57:53We would really appreciate you sort of coming on board
- 57:55to PFAN and registering your interests
- 57:57and then we'll contact you.
- 57:59So yeah, I look forward to working with you
- 58:02in that regard and trying to get the message out more and more.
- 58:04Yeah, I'm pretty sorry about it.
- 58:06I think it's a good way to demonstrate professionalism
- 58:08for the industry as we move into that
- 58:10and demonstrate the community good that we do,
- 58:14not just with advice, but with individuals.
- 58:16Like you said, that can't necessarily afford it.
- 58:17Yeah, like it came from, I think AMP used to do
- 58:21the council many, many years ago.
- 58:23It's been around for PFAN, it's been around for quite a while
- 58:25and we definitely have looked out for a lot of clients.
- 58:28And if there's any sort of heads of licensees
- 58:30or anything that are listening to this,
- 58:32we'd be very happy to come along to your PDD
- 58:35and have a chat to your advisors and promote what it is
- 58:38because as you said, it took a great way to help
- 58:41the professionalism and lift the game.
- 58:42That's exactly it.
- 58:43Yeah, brilliant.
- 58:44Yeah, we'll make sure we get a link on this.
- 58:45I think that'd be great.
- 58:46Cheers.
- 58:47Thank you, cheers.
- 58:48Oh, brilliant.
- 58:49Well, thanks so much for coming on.
- 58:50This has been, honestly, like really, really enjoyable.
- 58:52It's cool hearing all sides of the coin.
- 58:54That's wonderful.
- 58:55Yeah, now it's been great to be here
- 58:56and yeah, look, hopefully people took something good
- 58:59from that and if you don't do a life insurance, do it.
- 59:01Yeah, do it properly, right?
- 59:03Either keep it in-house or outsource it, but do it.
- 59:06Like just your clients need life insurance at the end of the day.
- 59:10Average mortgage is 700K, all this sort of stuff.
- 59:12The Australian, the under insurance problem in this country,
- 59:15we've talked about it forever.
- 59:16It's probably the worst.
- 59:17Maybe the worst has ever been, yeah.
- 59:19I wouldn't be surprised.
- 59:21And it's a crime shame.
- 59:22And when I look to the future,
- 59:24it doesn't look a lot brighter apart from AI potentially doing,
- 59:30like I think we're nearly at the stage now
- 59:32where we're producing SOA documents out of AI.
- 59:35We are doing it, but now we haven't quite got it right yet,
- 59:38but it's not far away.
- 59:39And things are moving so fast in the next couple of months,
- 59:42I'm certain we'll be there.
- 59:44So I think the average advisor today might look after 120 clients.
- 59:48I think down the road, the average advisor will easily
- 59:50be at look after 200.
- 59:52So, but they won't have a lot of extra costs.
- 59:53So their profitability, their businesses
- 59:55is going to just continue going up and up
- 59:57and that I've no difficulty finding those extra 80 clients
- 59:59because there's a queue outside their door.
- 1:00:01Yeah.
- 1:00:02Yeah.
- 1:00:03Right industry, very good deposit.
- 1:00:04Yeah.
- 1:00:05Excellent.
- 1:00:06Yeah.
- 1:00:07Thanks again for coming on.
- 1:00:08No problem.
- 1:00:09Thank you.
- 1:00:10Bye.