Latest / Honey Badger Radio / What about gender roles during the American revolution? | HBR Talk 309
Transcript
- 0:00There we go. I didn't think my scene was going to change for me
- 0:02for a second. But hello and welcome to HBr Talk three to nine.
- 0:08What about gender roles during the American Revolution. I'm your host, Hannah Wallen
- 0:14here with nonsense nihilator Lauren Brooks, and we're going to continue our talk about
- 0:19the context surrounding the development of voting in early America as part of our greater
- 0:27context around the development of voting in countries influenced by British colonialism and British common
- 0:37law English common law. But first, before we do that, we gotta
- 0:41do what we gotta do. As always, Honey Badger Radio dishes out a
- 0:46s. Morgas board of thought provoking discussions, and as experiences both recent and
- 0:51long past have demonstrated, the provoked thoughts are fighting back. They've made it
- 0:56clear that for people like us relying on third party payment platforms like Patreon to
- 1:00fund our work is treading on thin ice or building our house in the path
- 1:04of a rapidly growing wildfire. In light of this, we strongly encourage our
- 1:10supporters to switch at least their support for us to feed the Badger dot Com
- 1:12the most stable way to help us out and if you want to tip us
- 1:17directly instead of relying on any social media platforms, tip jar. The link
- 1:21for that is feed the Badger dot com slash just the tip. And as
- 1:25always, the same risk applies to our social media platforms, which is why
- 1:30you should further provoke the thought police by tracking our thought provoking discussions on Honey
- 1:34Badger Brigade dot com, where you can find your way to all of our
- 1:37content, as well as a link to feed the Badger dot com and a
- 1:40drop down menu at the top of the page and to find me, you
- 1:44guys might need that Kisse. I have been provoking thoughts on Twitter and they
- 1:49are mad. I have got two sex changes in the same night. Oh
- 1:55my god, yep, I became a man twice. How's it feel?
- 2:01Oh, very masculine, elevating. I am the patriarchy. Oh my god,
- 2:15it's it's it's amazing, it's it's it's amazing to me. How how
- 2:20sad empathetic that women have allowed themselves to become in mass like in general in
- 2:30modern America. And I'm going back and forth right between if I'm on Twitter,
- 2:36it's because I'm getting interrupted so much that I can't focus on the things
- 2:39that I'm studying because they take a little more work than Twitter does. Twitter
- 2:43is just like a thing, you know, like, well, I got
- 2:46time for this, or I can't walk away from from the room I'm in.
- 2:51But I can use this to distract myself in between things that I are
- 2:54interrupting my studies. Right But I'm looking at women's roles during the prior to
- 3:02and during the Revolutionary War here in America, and I just can't imagine if
- 3:09I pulled one of those women into the twenty first century and got her into
- 3:17a conversation with modern women about the issues around abortion, birth control, pregnancy,
- 3:30custody, child support, and all that, I think those women would
- 3:36actually get violent. I think it would kill the women. They'd be like
- 3:40pisans. What happened, What happened to our country? What did you do
- 3:46to our country? Because they were very loyal to their husbands, they cared
- 3:52very deeply about their families. They used all of the tools available to them
- 3:57to their own benefit and to the benefit of the people around them as best
- 4:00they could. They didn't all agree on everything, and they got really heated
- 4:05in their debates with each other about things. They didn't agree on, but
- 4:11they didn't play victim of their own choices. Yeah, and it just that's
- 4:17the thing that galls me so much. I get on Twitter and I get
- 4:19into this this this argument. I'm in this thread that's been going on since
- 4:23like February, and you know, no, it's it's might have been April
- 4:30of last year. Actually there's there's been this discussion has been going on for
- 4:33a long time, but the specific thread was started by a chick who was
- 4:43trying to promote the idea that it is not an abuse of men's rights to
- 4:47sort of draft them into child support, right, and so of course there's
- 4:54the discussion of what tools women have available to determine whether or not they are
- 5:00single moms with custody of a child at the end of the decision making,
- 5:06the whole string of decision making that takes place between hello and now you're a
- 5:13single mom. But they stop at like feminists stop at the part of the
- 5:23sex act that is fun for a guy, and they want to blame everything
- 5:27that happens afterward on that moment, because if you wouldn't acknowledge that the woman
- 5:31went on from that moment and didn't make decisions that were beneficial to herself and
- 5:39the people around her, didn't use the tools available to control the outcome so
- 5:44that it could be better for her and the people around her, And then
- 5:49is demanding money, you know for that, like they have no argument left
- 5:57when you start pointing those things out to them. Well, that's how that's
- 6:00how I get those Internet sex changes. And and I just keep I keep
- 6:05looking back. So our subject today because uh, you know, I've been
- 6:12having that discussion, and I've been reading this history, and I've been looking
- 6:16into all of the context related to men's voting rights being you know, completely
- 6:29connected, inextricably connected to conscription and women's voting rights just being accepted as rights.
- 6:40And there's not actually a valid excuse for that. So that's what we're
- 6:46kind of going to look at today. I have I'm gonna be jumping back
- 6:49and forth between different articles because conscription during the Revolutionary War was not quite the
- 6:57same as it is today. Obviously, they didn't have the lot system because
- 7:00they didn't have the equipment that would be used to track that. They didn't
- 7:08have anything to do with the modern system. They didn't have social security numbers,
- 7:13they didn't have like they couldn't easily track you down if you just chose
- 7:19to go running off into the inner part of the continent and not serve you
- 7:25know, it was it was less involuntary than it is today. It would
- 7:32be harder to chase you down and the rescue. Now, granted, not
- 7:36everybody could just go off into the woods and live there. There are other
- 7:40circumstances that might have prevented that. But I mean, just a reminder.
- 7:46One of my earliest ancestors into this in this country was sent here. He
- 7:54was he was conscripted in Britain. He was impressed into the British military,
- 8:01meaning he was kidnapped and shipped overseas against his will. He was not just
- 8:09drafted. And when he got here he decided fuck that and jump hip swam
- 8:16ashore, fled inland and went all the way into what is now Ohio,
- 8:24which at the time was part of Canada, so that he would not have
- 8:28to fight because he was fourteen years old. It wasn't his battle. He
- 8:31didn't want anything to do with that shit, and that was that, so
- 8:35it could be done. Wow, fourteen, that's insane to think about.
- 8:43Well, yeah, and so got we actually have a couple of different articles
- 8:50here. One of them is child Soldiers of the Revolutionary War. So both
- 8:58sides did have of very young people involved. But well, we'll point this
- 9:03out as I go through that article, and I'll try to do it more
- 9:09on a brief level. You'll notice something they say child soldiers. But but
- 9:16look and see if you see girls' names. Did you stop screen sharing?
- 9:24By the way, No, I did not. Can I don't think it
- 9:28did it? Did it? Just it ended for me? Okay, let's
- 9:31try that again. Share your screen go live must have cut me off.
- 9:39I don't know why. There we go, all right, so this stream
- 9:41should be available to you now, yeah, cool, all right. So
- 9:46we're gonna start with the American militia and the origin of conscription. This is
- 9:54actually a fairly old piece, and going to go through and read the whole
- 10:01thing about the author talking about revising it. He'd been intending to but it
- 10:09chose not to. But he does point out that there's actually a lot of
- 10:15documentation on which to base the information in this. So and I'm not going
- 10:22to go through and read like every page of it, but I don't think.
- 10:28But what I will point out is people do say that conscription was created
- 10:37in America for the Civil War, and this is what he starts with too.
- 10:41According to established mythology, American citizens were not conscripted until the Civil War.
- 10:46First the Confederacy and then the Union resorted to the draft to fill their
- 10:50depleting armies. Prior to that, this mythology holds, no draft existed in
- 10:54the United States. The US government fought the American Revolution, the War of
- 10:58eighteen twelve, and the Mexican War solely with volunteers. Toward the end of
- 11:05the War of eighteen twelve, the Madison administration did call for conscription, but
- 11:09this request failed due to Daniel Webster's stirring and frequently reprinted denunciation of the draft
- 11:15on the floor of Congress. Unfortunately, this Houseyon portrait is false in nearly
- 11:24every respect. So that's that's the first thing, Like, people don't realize
- 11:31this. I was taught in school that conscription started with the Civil War.
- 11:39So this has been misconstrued to school kids and to the general public for a
- 11:46long time because when I was in school where we're talking, I started school
- 11:52in the late seventies and graduated in nineteen ninety one. But he goes on
- 12:01to say the only US war fought without conscripts before the Civil War was the
- 12:05Mexican War. American government's state or national drafted men not only to fight the
- 12:11revolution in the War of eighteen twelve, but also to wage Indian wars and
- 12:16to suppress the Whiskey Rebellion. So conscription. This country started with conscription.
- 12:24It existed from the beginning. And that's something that people don't understand. Military
- 12:33experts privy to the compulsory nature of the militia in the implications of such arcane
- 12:37phrases calling forth the militia, have failed to communicate their knowledge to outsiders.
- 12:46This is this is how people don't understand. Indeed, the militia's coercive elements
- 12:52lasted until they were discontinued during the Jacksonian era. And I need to link
- 13:01this. I'm gonna I think I'm gonna link this in the low bar,
- 13:05or at least in the the uh uh the blog post, because there's probably
- 13:15something people should read. I'm not gonna read all the footnotes, but I
- 13:18think people ought to have access to it. So you see, there's there's
- 13:22quite a bit here. Oh wow, So yeah, that's all footnotes.
- 13:33So he has a lot He's not just talking out of his ass. This
- 13:37guy actually has done a significant amount of research to write this and explain this,
- 13:41and they're probably still teaching the wrong thing in schools. You're if you've
- 13:46got kids in school, they're probably if they're learning about conscription at all,
- 13:50they're probably learning that it didn't exist until the Civil War. So this is
- 13:54the part that we're gonna focus on right here. The colonial Pillow period in
- 13:58the American Revolution is it's what's relevant to what we're discussing. The malicious system
- 14:05was originally transported to the American colonies from England at the outset. It was
- 14:09grounded in the principle of universal obligation. And it says universal obligation. But
- 14:16who are they talking about, all right? They're not talking about women right
- 14:20now. And you remember when we've talked about the origin of the malicious system
- 14:26in British law and British culture, that came from the feared, which was
- 14:37sort of the early proto militia system of medieval England, when it was the
- 14:46king and his vassals and his knights and their knights, and the service was
- 14:52to the king, the service was to the vassals of the king and the
- 15:00men of the community could be they could be pressured into it, but they
- 15:05were more likely to be hired for it. So it was there was coercive
- 15:13there. There were coercive details in regard to it. But at the same
- 15:20time, you know that they preferred men who wanted to step up and defend
- 15:24their communities in their country, not men and boys who were forced into it.
- 15:31Because men who want to do it are going to do it better.
- 15:33Yeah. Yeah, And honestly, that's my argument against conscription today. You
- 15:43know, people, there are people of both sexes who want to be in
- 15:48the military, and it's it's mostly men. Like even today, when there
- 15:52are no barriers for women getting into the military and and and the barriers to
- 15:58women serving on the front lines are actually being systematically removed. Hey, I
- 16:06hear you can get a free you can get a free transgender surgery. If
- 16:11that's your gig, why would you do that? But I mean there's no
- 16:18barriers, but the military is still only fourteen percent women. Yeah, so
- 16:23transgender search. Yeah, I suppose. I don't know, maybe women want
- 16:30to go that want to go into the military might want to become men.
- 16:33Who knows. I've met plenty of female soldiers that were quite feminine and didn't
- 16:40want a sex change, And I'm not sure, Like, what would you
- 16:44do. You go into the military, you get a sex change, you
- 16:45now have to have consistent medical care for the rest of your life that would
- 16:51actually keep you from being activated for duty, right exactly. But I mean,
- 16:57geez that you think anybody on Biden's administration would think that far. No,
- 17:03But this is the direction that we're going in now, you know.
- 17:08But it just doesn't make sense. Our system is completely upside down and fucked.
- 17:14Everything is the opposite of what they they wanted to be. Our military
- 17:19is not as strong as we like to think that we are. But yeah,
- 17:26I don't know, God forbid one of these wars comes knocking on our
- 17:30back door. You know, we're screwed. We're screwed, all right.
- 17:36The military has a purpose. It's a very specific, unique, limited purpose.
- 17:41Right. The purpose of the military is to protect the nation from being
- 17:48taken over and controlled by another nation. That is it. That is all
- 17:52your military is supposed to be doing. If you're a malicious country, then
- 17:56your military is to get used like our country has been using our military to
- 18:04impose change on other countries against their will. But it's not supposed to be
- 18:11that way. Your military is supposed to be your defense against malevolence from other
- 18:17countries. So not that the law should take away people's right to make decisions
- 18:25about their bodies, you know, like if so, if you will decide
- 18:29you want to have a surgery, it shouldn't matter whether you want bigger tits
- 18:33or to cut them off or and become a man or whatever. The law
- 18:40shouldn't interfere with that, other than the fact that you consue your doctor if
- 18:45the doctor does a bad job and you get infected and have all kinds of
- 18:52problems that you shouldn't be having because the doctor should have done a better job.
- 18:56Right, that's it. That's the extent that the law should be involve
- 19:00But you know, the medical community can have their thing. The military should
- 19:06have their thing. The military shouldn't be a pathway that people use to get
- 19:11a surgery they want, or a series of surgeries, or any medical anything.
- 19:17You know. It's it's bad enough that it's used as a pathway to
- 19:23get rewards that pay for an education that actually leaves them in debt. Basically
- 19:32a pathway into certain business arrangements. This is really not that either. And
- 19:37if that's the primary reason that you're going in, then then you're not going
- 19:41to be as useful for the actual purpose of the military. And if the
- 19:47primary reason that you're going in is to get medical procedures done at the expense
- 19:53of the US government, then you don't belong in the military. Like not
- 20:00that you should have a right to pursue those medical procedures, but that you
- 20:04shouldn't have a right to exploit the military as your pathway to pursue those medical
- 20:10procedures. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, I totally agree with that.
- 20:15There is a little part of me that is kind of like, you know,
- 20:23I kind of support getting over on the government that's way, you know,
- 20:30And it sounds so fucked up, And you know, I don't really
- 20:33obviously it's wrong for all of the reasons that you just said, but you
- 20:37know, that part kind of makes me giggle a little bit, you know,
- 20:41And I just wish that I don't know, I wish that the military
- 20:48if anyone is listening, Department of Homeland Security, since you want to put
- 20:52us on your little fucking list, how about you take this whole military action
- 20:56down to the southern border. Oh what's that? No, No, we
- 21:00can't actually prevent other countries from literally invading US by walking across our very poorous
- 21:07border. Yeah, nobody on any side of the border issues would be happy
- 21:12if I was in charge. Like, make me a dictator for a couple
- 21:15of years, and I will piss everybody off because you know what I will
- 21:19do in regards to the southern border of the US, Like I will I
- 21:25will create a pathway for everybody to come through and then be sorted out and
- 21:33educated. M Like, that's fine, you can come here, but we're
- 21:38going to indoctrinate you. And that includes you know, if you're if you're
- 21:45part of a cartel. Okay, fine, we will take you and we
- 21:48will put you through cult deprogramming, and then we will indoctrinate you into the
- 21:59cons of you know, freedom and democracy. You know the concepts of altruism
- 22:14and care and consideration for other people having a conscience. Yeah. And you
- 22:18know, if anybody heard that and just you know, it felt a little
- 22:22icky, that's exactly what they do in China. That's exactly what you do
- 22:27in China. If you break the law there, they catch you, they
- 22:30imprison you. Oh, no, you're going to learn the ways of the
- 22:33CCP. You will obey one way or the other. You know, also
- 22:41the HRW or this. By the time you come out of camp, you
- 22:44will have learned that it's a great thing to be self supporting through your own
- 22:49labor and to be the person that checks on your neighbors when there's a storm,
- 22:53to make sure that nobody got hurt, nobody needs help, or if
- 22:57they do, you're there to help, and and to know your neighbors will
- 23:00do that for you. It's a great thing to step away from a a
- 23:06an insane, violent environment into a lifestyle where you're part of a community that
- 23:11has bonded together as a community over mutual investment in one's own welfare and the
- 23:19welfare the people around oneself through through meritocracy, absolutely being being able to demonstrate
- 23:29that you did a good job and being appreciative of the good job that other
- 23:32people do. Right, that would like that? That would be it?
- 23:37And then and then after a few years, I would I would abandon the
- 23:41position to be like, wait a minute, what and no, no,
- 23:48I wouldn't hold elections. I would dissolve the government and and and simply have
- 23:55a skeleton crew to uh, maintain an actual defensive military, and that would
- 24:03be it, Like, the defensive military would be something that the states did
- 24:07independently of each other, but in conjunction with each other and in communication with
- 24:12each other, because that's kind of what they did during the colonial period.
- 24:17But yeah, that would that would probably, like I said, it would
- 24:22piss everybody off because you know, you got the people that are like,
- 24:23no, don't bring people in across the border. And then then you also
- 24:27have the people that would be mad because of the indoctrination. But by the
- 24:32I done with it, you know, it would it would be an entirely
- 24:36evil and horrible thing to do to people because they would be in camps,
- 24:41but by the time they got out, they would be they would be ready
- 24:44to live their lives with freedom, independence, and and community with their neighbors,
- 24:52and they wouldn't need somebody to tell them what to do. Yeah.
- 24:59Yeah, like I said, it would be terrible actually because that that is
- 25:07essentially the same use of methods that the Wolke would use, you know,
- 25:15the the no bad bad tactics. Yeah, there are bad tactics. So
- 25:22the next best thing that you can do in a country because you would be
- 25:29taking away people's freedom. Under that circumstance, what's the next best thing you
- 25:33can do. Defend the borders, limit who comes through, then people who
- 25:40come through, and only let in people who are not going to attack your
- 25:45country, absolutely, you know. And and to be fair, to be
- 25:53fair, the people who are doing these jobs, they're well they're not really
- 26:00doing the job, but they're being paid to let this thing go happen,
- 26:06you know what I mean, Like it's there, it's the decisions are coming
- 26:10from all high. These people just come in and punch the clock, you
- 26:12know. But it's I don't know if I could do that again. I
- 26:22would be conflicted if I know that this border needs to be protected, but
- 26:26oh we're just looking the other way. I couldn't. I couldn't do it.
- 26:33Yeah, It's like I said, you know, if if if I
- 26:38was forced into a position because you wouldn't you couldn't pay me enough to make
- 26:44me actually want to become president of the United States or put into a leadership
- 26:51position like that. If I was forced into a position like that, those
- 26:56would be the two pathways I would look at. You know, I'm gonna
- 26:59end up setting on closing the border and limiting who can come in. But
- 27:06to explain why that has to happen. Now, you know what the alternative
- 27:11is. If we want to preserve a country like the United States and you
- 27:17want to let everybody in, the only way to achieve that is Campson indoctrination,
- 27:25Right, that's it. Otherwise you have to have a secure border.
- 27:30M like. So, so I'm done scaring the shit out of everybody.
- 27:36But what Dictator Hanna would be like? But back to back to this article.
- 27:41So so remembering that we talked about the evolution of the malicious system in
- 27:48England, and we now know, you know from the article that this system
- 27:53came into the the American colonies with the colonists, so it was it was
- 28:00never not practiced in in what would become the United States. At the outset.
- 28:06It was grounded in the principles of universal obligation, which universal meant men
- 28:11just just to be very blunt, Women were never part of this. Women
- 28:15never had to do this, not under the not under the English system,
- 28:21not under the British system. Right, maybe under the pre Roman system women
- 28:26might have been part of it. Back under the tribal systems, maybe there's
- 28:32some evidence that some women were. There's not evidence that it was equal.
- 28:38So so first and enrolled. Oh, practices differed widely from colony to colony,
- 28:49but everywhere the militia had two con coercive elements. First, it enrolled
- 28:55every able bodied male between certain ages, usually sixteen to six. All right,
- 29:02So if it'd be different if you had you know, for instance,
- 29:07back then, they couldn't do anything if you were born with the condition known
- 29:10as clubfoot, you're just kind of gonna deal with that for your life.
- 29:15Or if you were born without one of your arms, or if which was
- 29:22a frequent thing you had, you lost one to an accident. They couldn't
- 29:27treat infection. So if you had an injury that that went deep enough that
- 29:36you got any of the types of infections that could lead to gangreen, they
- 29:41had to cut it off. Ooh, they like that was not a medicine.
- 29:48Was kind of brutal back then, damn there was. There wasn't a
- 29:52lot they could do. They didn't have antibiotics, they didn't fully they didn't
- 29:56have a full capacity to understand what was causing the infections. They just knew
- 30:02that you know, your your arm was going bad, you had you had
- 30:07gangreen and it would spread and it would eventually get into your blood and kill
- 30:11you if it hadn't already. So sometimes sometimes people got a limb cut off
- 30:17to save their lives and they died anyway because they were already septic. Hmm.
- 30:22Right, So Catherine Scolly gives us three dollars Canadian and says, pair
- 30:29character punching the air with fist and bump written on his knuckles. It's cute.
- 30:36Oh yeah. So so when we were talking about every able bodied male,
- 30:41they had to have that stipulation because I mean, some people were not
- 30:47and and there wasn't anything they could do about it. And it was a
- 30:49more common thing than you think for somebody to not be able bodied. Also,
- 31:00Meredith, she gave us five dollars and said, HBr talk three oh
- 31:03nine, honey for the badgers. I want to point out that the Second
- 31:06Amendment was not simply about self defense, but also meant to distribute the responsibility
- 31:11of defense of the nation to the populace. That's correct. Take that into
- 31:15consideration when we look at conscription, because this is this is another factor,
- 31:21all right, you had to provide your own weapon. At that time,
- 31:25the military didn't issue you weapons and say you had to provide your own weapon,
- 31:30right, oh god uh yep, which even then guns were guns were
- 31:38an even bigger expensive tool than they are now. What about ammunition? You
- 31:44had to provide that yourself too, Jesus, and you got fined if you
- 31:52didn't. So they had to furnish their own arms and to muster for regularly
- 31:57scheduled training. They would get fined if they didn't. This mandatory training could
- 32:02be as frequent as once a week or more. But as the Indian threat
- 32:07receded, as the colonists stopped having conflict with the local Indian tribes, most
- 32:13colonies reduced the number of training days to approximately four per year. So got
- 32:20to remembers. The other thing is you think about a military that only trains
- 32:22four days a year, you would think, gosh, those guys aren't going
- 32:23to do anything right. But they didn't go sit at a desk job.
- 32:29The rest of the time. They went home and they chopped firewood or they
- 32:35froze in the wintertime. They had they grew their own crops, they plowed
- 32:42their own fields, They carried and lifted, they did heavy labor. Everyday
- 32:47life during that time involved heavy labor. For men, and pretty heavy labor
- 32:52for women too, although not quite as heavy as what men did, so
- 32:58nobody could just sit around and be wimpy that if they were skinny it was
- 33:04because they were starving. See. The militia thereby provided a compulsory system of
- 33:16universal military training, which in my opinion, is superior to waiting until wartime
- 33:24and starting to conscript people. I think, among other things, if we
- 33:34had a system today where all able bodied youth, male and female were taught
- 33:43what you need to know if you want to enlist in the military and defend
- 33:46the country during wartime, and that training was maintained throughout high school and what
- 33:54would be the time you're in college, whether you actually attend college or not,
- 34:00even if it was something that you did one weekend a month and you
- 34:05had to stay in shape for it, it would it would actually solve a
- 34:08lot of problems. Among other things, the the issue of uh, widespread
- 34:16obesity in the country would be greatly reduced, you know, but uh,
- 34:22you know, you would also have people would be very much aware of what
- 34:29it would mean for the country to go to war, and they would be
- 34:31very careful who they voted for because of that. So The second course of
- 34:39element was when the militia is called forth for active military service. This is
- 34:47only in dire emergency. Only for a short period would a militia district deploy
- 34:52it's enrolled manpower. UH. Normally, when a colonial government called upon its
- 34:59military for a milli military campaign, it would set quotas for each district.
- 35:06The districts would then try to fill the quotas with volunteers first, and sometimes
- 35:12the colonies would encourage volunteering with bounties. However, if volunteers were insufficient,
- 35:20the districts would then meet their quotas through drafts. Generally only the only legal
- 35:25ways of avoiding such militia drafts were either by paying a stiff fine or hiring
- 35:30a substitute. So again, this is another big difference between today's military service
- 35:38and the military service of the time. So, let's say you had a
- 35:49Let's say you had a job that you could not leave or your employer couldn't
- 35:53afford to lose you for that time period. Today, the employer or the
- 36:01network of employers for that type of job might have to appeal to the government,
- 36:07please exempt people who do this job from the military draft. And that
- 36:13was done during the Vietnam War for educators, educators were in very short supply.
- 36:19For a while, there was a huge shortage, and so if you
- 36:22were an educator, you could not be drafted during part of the Vietnam War.
- 36:30Close to the end of the war they eliminated that. But during part
- 36:37of the war that was a thing, and it wasn't because teachers weren't fit
- 36:43to serve. It's because you can't just hire a whole bunch of new people
- 36:49to replace them. They have to go through four years of school, take
- 36:52testing, get time in teaching under an experienced teacher, and then then get
- 37:00their certification before they can even contract with a school. So now the military
- 37:07could have just changed the rules. They could have said, well, you
- 37:10don't have to have a teaching certificate to be a teacher, because you didn't
- 37:15used to used to go to six six week or so study called normal school,
- 37:20and when you graduated from that you were a teacher. Wow. Yeah.
- 37:25So when my dad was a student, his teachers were normal school graduates
- 37:30and it was called normal n O r m AL normal, normal school.
- 37:36I went to weird school. I don't know what you guys, man,
- 37:39that's why, that's why I'm I'm I'm kind of a journalist and I'm more
- 37:44of a commentator and not a teacher. This is not education. I went
- 37:49to an interesting school. It was called skip Oh my god, I got
- 38:00accused of skipping school a lot. Is That's the other thing? Like I
- 38:06always say, I went to school, and I did in about two thirds
- 38:08of the time. The other third of the time I went to the hospital.
- 38:15I didn't spend that much time in the hospital, but I was admitted
- 38:19at least once a year. My poor parents, I can't imagine. They
- 38:23must have like spent spent my whole childhood on the edge of their seats.
- 38:27What is she going to do to herself next? How is she going to
- 38:30try to die this year? But in any case, yeah, so different
- 38:40things like that, if there's a shortage and the community feels like it's absolutely
- 38:47necessary to have this particular profession stateside, you know, or or away from
- 38:53the military, who can't lose these people, then they get exempted from the
- 38:59draft. And they do other things too, Like if you are the sole
- 39:05breadwinner for a family and you can't be replaced by another breadwinner in that family,
- 39:09sometimes that that that stipulation has been made in the past. The only
- 39:15son in a family is ineligible for the draft. If you have more than
- 39:22one son, then that's a different story. But the only son was ineligible.
- 39:25And I wonder how they will change if if they start drafting women.
- 39:31Will they say the only son and the only daughter or do you have to
- 39:35be an only child to be I know, to be to be exempt.
- 39:40All right, So there's there's a lot of standards that today that there's a
- 39:45maze of ways to get in and out. But back then, if you
- 39:51are in one of those situations where it would be a major burden for your
- 39:57family or major loss for your family beyond the norm of what a burden it
- 40:04would be and what a loss it would be for a family to have their
- 40:09their their their child go to war and not come back. Right. Uh,
- 40:14then you paid paid somebody else to take the job for you. You
- 40:22know, you could pay a fine, a stiff fine, and not go.
- 40:27So the threat of conscription was was there, and and it it existed,
- 40:35Like he says, the threat of conscription lurked behind every resort to the
- 40:39seemingly innocuous power to call out the militia. Right, but at the same
- 40:45time, it was still more democratic and voluntary than it is today. And
- 40:54yeah, people are mentioning saving Priyan Private Ryan in the in the chat,
- 41:00that is exactly the type of situation, right, all three of his brothers
- 41:02are gone, Suddenly he is now much more important to bring home. The
- 41:12military has that stipulation, we don't take all of the boys in a family.
- 41:17We don't take the only boy from family. And that does go back
- 41:22to the beginning that you don't because it used to be that families relied on
- 41:28their sons when you had the family farm, and most families grew a significant
- 41:37portion of their own food, or raised a significant portion of their own meat,
- 41:44or hunted for a significant portion of their own meat. They relied on
- 41:49the sons, just like they relied on the husband and father to provide these
- 41:53things once they got old enough to start doing that, which would be when
- 41:57they got old enough for military service, well for conscription into the military as
- 42:02soldiers. So enforcement of the military's coercive elements was sometimes lacks. There were
- 42:15hallowed restrictions upon employment of the militia. Draft. Colonial governments were not supposed
- 42:21to send drafted militiamen outside the colony. The Drafteese term of service was usually
- 42:25limited to three months. If they planned long offensive military expeditions, they relied
- 42:31on militia volunteers who specifically contracted for such expeditions. So you if you were
- 42:38going to leave the colony or you were going to do something for a long
- 42:40time for the military, they that was volunteer. They didn't just make you
- 42:47do that like they did with sending men to war during the twentieth century,
- 42:54where you would get drafted into the military and then you might be overseas until
- 42:59they could and you back. You might have a term of service, but
- 43:02you could be you know, your term of service could be extended, or
- 43:09if you got kidnapped by the other side, if you got captured by the
- 43:14other side, you know, they're not like they were necessarily going to go
- 43:16get you back. Yeah, So I don't know if I need to go
- 43:29through the rest of this. It say is there's differences in how the Northern
- 43:35and Southern colonies did this, But you know, he does go through and
- 43:43he mentions the volunteer component again. So later on colonial governments and successor state
- 43:50governments integrated them into general malicious systems. Volunteer units provided much of the cavalry,
- 43:57artillery, and elite infantry within the militia. Men could gain an exemption
- 44:01from the common militia by joining a volunteer unit, but many repained private fraternities
- 44:07with exclusive memberships. So again there were alternatives to being officially a part of
- 44:15the military, but you know, you kind of had. It wasn't just
- 44:21anybody could do that. So even in the seventeenth century it was there were
- 44:30still that coercive component. So, as he says, everything noted so far
- 44:39about the compulsory nature of colonial common militia is well known. Less common known
- 44:44is the fact that the common militia persisted without serious alteration through the Revolution.
- 44:50As the colonies made the revolutionary transition to states, they refurbished their militias to
- 44:54maintain better order fight the British and suppressed Tories. So were for people who
- 45:01aren't either American or British, Tories were loyalists to Britain in the colonies and
- 45:09they fought against the revolutionary colonists to remain part of the British Commonwealth. And
- 45:22I have some family members who are in Canada that live in Canada that are
- 45:30descendants of Tories that After the Revolutionary War, the Tories did not get treated
- 45:39very well for obvious reasons. And even if they even if they sort of
- 45:46reformed their opinions to well, now we're a country, so let's unite,
- 45:52they still there was a lot of conflict between people who had been pro revolution
- 45:59and people who had been to So it's definitely the need for military service to
- 46:12suppress that that. I don't want to say terrorism because it wouldn't be quite
- 46:19the level of terrorism, but I guess rabble rousing mischief was done quite a
- 46:24bit, and obviously there would would have also been fights, just conflict and
- 46:30fights between people. So the military was sort of the local police force at
- 46:35that time. So one of the things he's talking about here. During Virginia,
- 46:42during the spring of seventeen seventy five, the Patriot Committee increased the frequency
- 46:45of mandatory training days for every mail between sixteen and sixty to one per month.
- 46:52Compulsory militia preparations were far and more more widespread than blah blah blah.
- 47:00Then the famed contingents of minute men who volunteer to be ready at a moment's
- 47:04notice, So they were definitely maintaining a consistent force, and they were definitely
- 47:14you know, telling people, telling men in the the colonies and then later
- 47:20in the States, you will do this, this is required a few when
- 47:25this, oh go ahead, I was gonna say, I mean, you
- 47:30know it's it's one day a month. How how often how long do our
- 47:35you know, recruits go out when they when they draft these days they go
- 47:39I have no idea. They go into boot camp and they go into I
- 47:45think boot camp is like ten weeks. It's it's like the length of a
- 47:51course of study at university. Okay, I might actually be longer than that,
- 47:57although during the Vietnam War they shortened it at least six weeks. But
- 48:01uh, well, hm, they got desperate during the Vietnam War. Yeah,
- 48:08they were. They were allowing people into the military that were not allowed
- 48:12into the military, and then they started drafting previously because of you know,
- 48:16not being trustworthy or not being reliable physically or whatever. And then they also
- 48:22started drafting people that would have been exempt under you know, medical restriction or
- 48:29because they would have been considered not reliable. The the Alice's Restaurant routine that
- 48:37Arlo Guthrie does where he talks about going in uh to to uh register,
- 48:45after he's been after he's gotten drafted, and talking to the shrink and going
- 48:50I want to kill, kill, kill, kill, you know all that,
- 48:52and then and then they pendimental on him and said you're our boy.
- 48:59That was a common military on There were certain degrees of mental illness that the
- 49:02military would not accept prior to the Vietnam War that they they went ahead and
- 49:08said, okay, yeah, we'll we'll take you. You can be you
- 49:12can be a complete homicidal maniac. That's actually good for us, you know,
- 49:15go kill, and and that was that was acceptable. There was a
- 49:22there was a point during which they took people who were ineligible for military service
- 49:30due to their criminal history and said, well, actually we're going to consider
- 49:36your military service an active rehabilitation. So you can join the military and get
- 49:43get your slate clean by being there by being by being in then clean your
- 49:49slate all right right into the next life. Wash your slate in blood.
- 49:54Yeah, if you're lucky, it'll be somebody else's. Yeah. So they
- 50:00sent people who were too intellectually disabled to qualify for military service prior to the
- 50:07standards of the Vietnam War. They sent people who were too blind to be
- 50:15to qualify. Wow, Like, my dad did not get drafted, well,
- 50:23he did not get sent over. He he was. They tried to
- 50:30draft him when he was exempt, but he had tried to enlist prior to
- 50:36that, when he was young enough that he didn't really have the foresight.
- 50:40And this is the other thing, like they'll take young men who are of
- 50:45an age where they may not fully understand what they're getting themselves into. Right,
- 50:50he tried to enlist and they wouldn't take him because his eyesight was not
- 50:53good enough. His eyesight really was bad, like really bad. He went
- 51:01he memorized the eye test chart. So it's actually really funny story. If
- 51:09he memorized the eye test chart and he goes in and he reads it off
- 51:13for the the guy's like, wow, this is amazing, you know,
- 51:16and he's like he takes him outside and he asked him to read the license
- 51:22plate on a truck down the street, and my dad, without his glasses
- 51:25on, is looking around and he's like, what truck? What truck?
- 51:32So they kind of caught him out on that. He didn't get in.
- 51:36But then years later when they wanted to force him in, his eyesight was
- 51:42not a problem anymore. It's okay if you can't see. Ah. Yeah,
- 51:46so what if you need like two sets of coke bottles for your glasses?
- 51:52And when I tell you, I'm a multi generational nerd. My my,
- 51:58my grandfather, oh my outside of the family was an engineer. So
- 52:02anyway, but yeah, so it's very, very different. When the States
- 52:09put active military forces into the field. They even eventually fell back on militia
- 52:15drafts. Continental Army with military forces. The new National government was initially composed
- 52:20entirely of volunteers, but as the war dragged on, manpower shortages became acute.
- 52:25And this happens every time there is a war. Why obvious reason,
- 52:34Right, because men get killed despite monetary boundaries and land grants offered by both
- 52:46Continental Congress to the andy individual states. This happens, right because you can't
- 52:52pay dead people to come back from the grave. Right. Continental Army bid
- 52:58for recruits against the act forces of the thirteen state militias. So now you
- 53:04have the two I guess leaderships, the two governments within the United States competing
- 53:15for soldiers. Massachusetts began employing conscription in the early summer of seventeen seventy six.
- 53:24New Hampshire followed in seventeen seventy seven, the most remaining states fell in
- 53:30line upon recommendation of the Congress later that year. States used these drafts not
- 53:37just to man their own forces, but to also fill their quotas for the
- 53:39Continental Army. So when people tell you that there was no draft in the
- 53:47creation of the United States, they're bullshitting you. The fact that we have
- 53:57a government here to vote for, the fact that we have a United States
- 54:00of America happened on the blood of drafted men. Jesus. All right,
- 54:09but let's let's let's let's talk about the word men here because we're gonna switch
- 54:14stories now. So this story titled Child Soldiers of the Revolutionary War. And
- 54:21uh and this is kind of a PC title if you ask me, because
- 54:24I want you to look at that picture and find the girl in it.
- 54:30I can't see one anywhere. No, Now, that's not a photograph of
- 54:35actual it's a representation, obviously, because there was no photography. But this
- 54:40is this is what the reality was, right, think back, take a
- 54:47moment, thing, back to what you were doing at the age of seven,
- 54:52because or ten, I was in the first grade at seven mm hmm
- 54:58seven and I think I was in second Yeah, I was in the first
- 55:01grade. I had to start school until I was six, but uh,
- 55:06yeah I was. I was playing tag outside at recess. M like that.
- 55:13That's what I was doing at ten years old. I was in the
- 55:15fourth grade. Babies, It's just fucking babies at ten years old. When
- 55:27I was ten years old, the boys in my class were not bigger than
- 55:30me. They were not physically more muscle bound than I was. Yeah,
- 55:37there were there were things I could do in terms of athletic performance that none
- 55:46of the boys I knew could do. And even when I got older,
- 55:52obviously the acrobatic stuff I could do like nobody else I knew could do that,
- 55:57So boys or girls until I met an actual gymnast when I was sent
- 56:04junior high. But at ten years old, I was there was There was
- 56:08one boy in our class that was bigger than the other boys, but aside
- 56:14from him, everybody else we all pretty much had the same body types.
- 56:20We had not none of us had hit puberty yet. Right, my brother
- 56:27was stronger than me. But yeah, I like that. That was at
- 56:34at ten years old. Can you imagine at ten years old having a responsibility
- 56:38as big as military service put on you fucking way, no way. I
- 56:43didn't even like doing the dishes. So at the ten year yeah, I
- 56:49know, well at ten years old. Let's see, when I was ten
- 56:52years old, my mom broke her hand and then she was in we were
- 56:55in a bad car accident together and she was really laid up. So I
- 57:00debuted a lot of housework when I was ten years old. But I don't
- 57:05think it was like none of my classmates thought that was normal, except the
- 57:08one that lived on a farm, and like she thought that was pretty normal.
- 57:15So at the tender age of seven, Nathan Foutrell was the youngest drummer
- 57:19so far identified in a revolutionary war. He served with the North Carolina Militia.
- 57:27Richard Lord Jones, at the age of ten, was a fifer in
- 57:30the Connecticut Militia. He was the youngest known enlisted soldier in the terrible Fight
- 57:36for Independence. These interesting facts were shared by Cohen Daniels are Cohen Daniels,
- 57:44fourteen, State President of the Tennessee Society Children of the American Revolution, and
- 57:52his brother Ivan Daniels, sixteen, National Vice President of the Mid Southern Region
- 58:01and Honorary State President of for the Tea scar. At the September meeting of
- 58:07the Martha Dandridge Washington Chapter National Society Daughters of the American Revolution, Cohen spoke
- 58:17on the topic America's most Forgotten Veterans Children. The current state project for the
- 58:23TEA SCAR is titled Stitching History Together. This is this article, by the
- 58:28way, is not recent article if I remember it. This is old.
- 58:31No, this is this is recent. This is more recent than I thought.
- 58:36This was published last year. So this is there's there's another article that
- 58:40I have read about this that I don't remember as much mention of the organizations,
- 58:45but there are. There was a mention of TEESCAR, So they do.
- 58:53TESCAR does some some reenactment, and they do like that. Not not
- 59:00so much LARPing as display of this is what it looked like for for boys
- 59:07to be soldiers. But I want to skip a lot of the organizational description
- 59:15and get to here we go. Quite a number of according to Cohen,
- 59:21quite a number of child soldiers served in the Revolutionary War, often in the
- 59:27capacities of Feiffer, Drummer and Bugler. Right. And this is something that
- 59:31that got that goes back to if you look at British and the British Commonwealth
- 59:42militias. You saw a similar use of boys in the military. Uh And
- 59:47and that also goes back in Scotland as well to the bagpiper being young and
- 59:57the bagpiper had a pretty heavy job. And the drum and the fifers and
- 1:00:00the buglers. They didn't just play music. They weren't just like the bar
- 1:00:05trying to encourage everybody. There were particular series of notes and beats and you
- 1:00:15know, tones and so on that would would be marching orders. If you
- 1:00:20hear this, you do this. So they were not just there to boost
- 1:00:27morale. They actually were essential to the performance of the military. And because
- 1:00:34they were essential to the performance of the military, they were targets for the
- 1:00:43opposing military. Some also filled the ranks as spies, messengers, couriers,
- 1:01:00patrol and of course fighting soldiers and sailors. Indian patrol. Yes, because
- 1:01:07you have to understand during the Revolutionary War there were Indian tribes that that that
- 1:01:15joined with the British to keep the colonists from gaining their independence. Oh okay,
- 1:01:22yep okay. And it's it's not the first uh time. I mean
- 1:01:29the Seven Years War is the part of the Seven Years war that took place
- 1:01:34in the Americas is known as the French and Indian War. Okay, uh
- 1:01:40so, yeah, like you had, And there were there were tribes on
- 1:01:45both sides of that, and there were tribes on both sides of the Revolutionary
- 1:01:49War. There were tribes that thought if they sided with the colonists that they
- 1:01:54would be treated better than the British were treating them. And then there were
- 1:01:58tribes that expected the colonists to betray the Native Americans. And you know,
- 1:02:02if you look at history, the history of how the American government treated the
- 1:02:07tribes, I can't say that the tribes who cited were with the British were
- 1:02:13wrong, right, they lost, but they were not wrong. They were
- 1:02:19going to be betrayed. They got betrayed, right, and there was already
- 1:02:23a pattern there for them to make a note of. So it wasn't like
- 1:02:29they were just guessing. Yeah, but yeah, so they did, you
- 1:02:37know. And all of these roles, like a spy may get executed upon
- 1:02:43being found being caught right, or killed fighting when they get caught. Messengers
- 1:02:52Messengers carry marching orders, they carry information about needs for supplies. Their role
- 1:03:00is absolutely vital, and killing a messenger getting a messenger out of commission can
- 1:03:07cripple a military action. You know, it can cripple a military effort and
- 1:03:15cost an entire side the war. And of course Indian patrol if if you
- 1:03:27know, they're reporting back on the activities of tribes that are opposed to the
- 1:03:31colonial fighters and they get caught, they're going to get killed. So these
- 1:03:38were boys as young as seven years old who were risking their lives doing jobs
- 1:03:46for the military. And then of course there were also young soldiers that were
- 1:03:54fighting, and young soldiers that were on ships. Military musicians, it just
- 1:04:02explains here played an integral role in the battlefield. Child soldiers often worked on
- 1:04:11cannon crews called matross crews to assist in firing the cannons and carry water to
- 1:04:15cool the cannons and slake the thirst of cannoneers. They provided communication from officers
- 1:04:24to fighting men. Their instruments signaled attack and retreat. The success of the
- 1:04:30fighting men could hinge on the skills of the musicians. So this this was
- 1:04:35no small role. So you have here's this list that of boys that he's
- 1:04:44described here. The TESCAR has been involved in research to identify as many child
- 1:04:54soldiers as possible and collect information into a database so that they can honor these
- 1:05:00boys for what they did. Some of the names shared by Cohen and Ivan
- 1:05:05include Daniel Applegate, thirteen Pfeiffer at the Surrender of Yorktown. William Cross,
- 1:05:13who began serving as a soldier at fifteen, later served at the Battle of
- 1:05:17King's Mountain. Fiske durhand ten enlisted with his brother as a drummer in the
- 1:05:25Connecticut Infantry in seventeen seventy six. So we have one girl here, I'm
- 1:05:31pretty sure, possibly Elicia Garland. This still actually could be Elijah, and
- 1:05:38it could be a boy. So thirteen Piffer from North Carolina who was with
- 1:05:45George Washington at Valley Forge. James Gillies fourteen bugler for the American General lighthorse
- 1:05:55Henry Lee fourteen. Right, that's a eighth grader or a freshman in high
- 1:06:03school. M m R. Henry or Harry Lee. Ur fought with Harry
- 1:06:11Lee. Gillies was killed by the sword of one of the British of one
- 1:06:15of British Colonel Gosh, darn it, I'm gonna have to increase the size
- 1:06:21of this text. Guys, I'm sorry. Speaking of being blind. It's
- 1:06:29the font. There we go Banister Charleson's dragoons. I could not tell what
- 1:06:35the S was until I increased the size of the text because on my screen
- 1:06:41it's that because it's up against the t, it doesn't show the whole S.
- 1:06:47It's got like a tiny little bit of it's missing, all right,
- 1:06:49So then we have moralists. And actually I'm pretty sure that's Elijah not Alicia,
- 1:06:59because I it. I doubt that they had a girl do that that
- 1:07:03job, not that there were not female participants. Right. Presley Larkins twelve
- 1:07:12recruiter for Virginia Forces and a fifer having After having smallpox, he went blind.
- 1:07:18However, his vision was restored. And this is another thing. In
- 1:07:21the Revolutionary War, smallpox was rife. They didn't have any way to treat
- 1:07:28it other than basically you rested and they tried to manage your fever like there
- 1:07:35weren't There weren't antibiotics, there weren't anti virals. There were just drugs to
- 1:07:41help you treat the overt symptoms, and most of them were herbal remedies.
- 1:07:47So he was fortunate. Not everybody who went blind as a result of viruses
- 1:07:55like smallpox regained their vision. In fact, there is if I remember right,
- 1:08:03there was the it's It was assumed that Helen Keller's blindness was caused by
- 1:08:08virus as well. And I want to say scarlet fever, but I might
- 1:08:14be wrong. But various various viruses like that that would attack your system.
- 1:08:20If your fever got too high, you get a brain damage from it that
- 1:08:24would cause you to go permanently blind. You get nerve damage as well outside
- 1:08:28the brain. Uh and uh, you also had like you also had things
- 1:08:36that could happen to the structure of the eye, retinal detachment and stuff like
- 1:08:42that that can happen do to due to inflammation and a number of different factors.
- 1:08:48So you you just had If you recovered your vision like that, you
- 1:08:53were very lucky. When he recovered his vision, he went he returned to
- 1:08:57duty into the War of eighteen twelve. Wow William Prince thirteen was the personal
- 1:09:06fifer for Colonel John Sevier and fought at the Battle of King's Mountain. According
- 1:09:15to oral history, Cornelius Wilson eleven had his lip cut so badly by a
- 1:09:20British soldier's sword that he could no longer play the fife. So he became
- 1:09:27a drummer and continued to serve. Somebody actually attacked the boy with a sword,
- 1:09:41Thank God. William Addison was thirteen when he joined the militia in fourteen
- 1:09:46when he was wounded in the Battle of Utah Springs. His payment for that
- 1:09:53service is noted in the pay bank of Brigadier journal Francis Marion, better known
- 1:09:58as the brilliant and shrewd swamp Fox. Robert Harris fifteen assisted a gunner by
- 1:10:05loading, firing, and sponging out the cannon. Joshua Pewitt thirteen John Vaughn
- 1:10:12fifteen were members of the Matross crew, which used to use to stick to
- 1:10:16pull the debris from the old charge out of a cannon so a new charge
- 1:10:20could be loaded, which means they had to get in front of the cannon.
- 1:10:28John McAllister began to serve at thirteen and was promoted to sergeant at fifteen.
- 1:10:34From what fifteen year olds when I was in school couldn't get a permit
- 1:10:43until six months before their sixteenth birthday to drive a car, right, so
- 1:10:48prior to that you had not hit your first sign of adulthood. Fifteen year
- 1:10:58old couldn't take someone out on a date without relying on someone else for transportation.
- 1:11:02Yeah, fifteen year old will be a freshman or a sophomore in high
- 1:11:05school. A fifteen year old looks like a kid. At least a fifteen
- 1:11:11year old looks like a kid to me. But yeah, Sergeant at fifteen.
- 1:11:18Philip Russell fifteen was a teamster and a soldier in Virginia, charged with
- 1:11:24driving supplies which again would make him a target that included ammunition. All right,
- 1:11:33so that would really make him a target. Oh yeah, through the
- 1:11:39back country while guarding it from the British and the Indians. Magnus Tullock thirteen
- 1:11:45was a fifer who later became a fighter and saw five years of combat.
- 1:11:51He is buried at the in the Builders Creek Church Graveyard in Bluant County,
- 1:11:58Tennessee on April twelfth, twenty twenty three. The t Scar family are formally
- 1:12:02marked his grave. The Justice brothers, Simon eleven and John fourteen were captured
- 1:12:09by the British in the ninety sixth District in South Carolina, but were later
- 1:12:14released. In those days, according to Ivan, boys were considered to be
- 1:12:17adults at the age of ten. God damn it all right, we hear
- 1:12:28all about child marriage and girls. Yeah, right, under British common law.
- 1:12:36Under English law, even during the thirteenth century, the age of consent
- 1:12:43for girls was thirteen, three years older than for boys to be considered adults.
- 1:12:51Oh my god, sticks gives us two dollars And mentions about normal school?
- 1:13:02Was there a normal school prom, yearbook, glee club? I'm assuming
- 1:13:09I don't know. No, they're the normal school was only like six weeks
- 1:13:12long. So they would have just had six weeks of uh, sitting in
- 1:13:15a classroom, studying and going home and studying and then taking tests and proceeding
- 1:13:21on to the next lesson, and then they would they would be done.
- 1:13:26They might have a graduation ceremony, but at the end of it they got
- 1:13:29a certificate. So uh yeah, let's see, so adults. At the
- 1:13:42age of ten, James Servier Sevier, a son of frontier soldier and statesman
- 1:13:48Colonel John Sevier, saw actually, Sevier, i'm cnn r in there where
- 1:13:53there isn't one, fought at the Battle of King's Mountain and was given the
- 1:14:00task of counting the wounded. So here this is a this is a boy
- 1:14:03that had to actually go around the wounded in a battle like that would have
- 1:14:11been hit with musket balls. When you get shot with a bullet, it
- 1:14:16goes in and it goes out, and it's it's usually unless it's you know,
- 1:14:26like a weaker type of caliber, you're going to see a straight line
- 1:14:31front to back, it goes out or back to front wherever you're shot.
- 1:14:36But a musketball bounched around inside, broke bones, it tore through people.
- 1:14:45The exit wound would have been bigger. People would have been in agony.
- 1:14:50The men, the men that they ran across that were injured could have been
- 1:14:55These would have been men who were actively dying or men who were in just
- 1:15:01absolute states of torture. Not that getting shot today as a cakewalker or anything,
- 1:15:06but it was even worse then. And that's that's the men that were
- 1:15:12shot. No, they're there. They were fought with muskets and swords or
- 1:15:23you know, you also had men that were hit with cannonballs. You had
- 1:15:27men that were hit with debris from when cannonballs hit structures and and landscapes and
- 1:15:32and through rocks and things in the air. There would have been people with
- 1:15:36with horrific injuries that these boys would have been identifying m So after the this
- 1:15:50this organization makes this presentation. You know, the boys actually performed a number
- 1:15:58of songs that were played in their revolutionary war. And this is this is
- 1:16:01a really neat organization that that honors children who who were you know, forced
- 1:16:11to fight in war, who were in that situation. Nobody asked them and
- 1:16:18of course if they did, these boys wouldn't have known what they were getting
- 1:16:25into. Yeah, so this is this is basically uh, you know,
- 1:16:33you understand for males, not only was their obligation, but that obligation included
- 1:16:42roles that that were life risking, horrifying. These boys would have come out
- 1:16:49of this if they came out of it alive, they would have come out
- 1:16:53of it with PTSD. Their whole lives would have been changed. Right.
- 1:17:00So we when we look at that and we look at the draft, we
- 1:17:03understand the creation of the system that allows us the freedom to be governed with
- 1:17:13consent is it's entirely built in blocks of blood, in the blood of men
- 1:17:24and the blood of boys. So when we talk about the draft today,
- 1:17:30you know, we're talking about a long historical tradition from which women have been
- 1:17:36exempt. And when we talk about the connection of voting rights to that.
- 1:17:41We are talking about a long and historical relationship between the public and the government
- 1:17:48that has been fueled by the blood of men and boys. But are women
- 1:18:00useless in that? Do we have an excuse as a society for saying,
- 1:18:05well, women, women can vote, but they don't have to serve?
- 1:18:11And previous episodes we've discussed that, haven't we. Yeah, I believe so.
- 1:18:17The episode where we talked about the strength of women in neolithic times,
- 1:18:23for instance, and the existence of women warriors prior to modern times kind of
- 1:18:30indicates that maybe there are things women can do, right, Yeah, absolutely
- 1:18:36so in the Revolutionary War, there were women doing things that you wouldn't expect
- 1:18:46necessarily women to do. Now, this isn't to say that we're going to
- 1:18:55say, oh, women should be drafted and should be fighting on the front
- 1:18:58lines beside men, and men should be really eying on women to have their
- 1:19:00backs. And yeah, we know that that wouldn't be necessarily the best thing
- 1:19:05for men, but it shouldn't be a get out of responsibility free card for
- 1:19:10women. Yeah, so we're gonna skip down to all right, I had
- 1:19:32this, I must have jumped back up. It must have reloaded, all
- 1:19:36right, So yeah. Women often followed their husbands in the Continental army.
- 1:19:46This is where it was. Women often followed their husbands in the Continental army.
- 1:19:50These women, known as camp followers, often tended to the domestic side
- 1:19:57of army organization, washing, cooking, mending clothes, providing medical help when
- 1:20:02necessary. Sometimes they were flung into the vortexa battle. Such was the case
- 1:20:10of Mary Ludwig Hayes, better known as Molly Pitcher, who earned fame at
- 1:20:15the Battle of Monmouth. I think I'm pronouncing that right in seventeen seventy eight.
- 1:20:20Hayes first brought soldiers water from a local well to quench their thirst on
- 1:20:25an extremely hot and humid day, and then replaced her husband her wounded husband
- 1:20:31at his artillery piece, firing at the oncoming British. In a similar vein,
- 1:20:40Margaret Corbin was severely wounded during the British assault on Fort Washington in November
- 1:20:45seventeen seventy six, and left for dead alongside her husband, also an artilleryman,
- 1:20:50until she was attended by a physician. She lived, though her wounds
- 1:20:55left her permanently disabled. Recalls her as the first American female to receive a
- 1:21:01soldier's lifetime pension. After the war, Phyllis Wheatley, and enslaved African American
- 1:21:10living in Boston, took up the pen and wrote poetry, becoming one of
- 1:21:14the first published female authors in America and the first African American woman to be
- 1:21:17published. Her seventeen seventy three collection Poems on various subjects, religious and moral,
- 1:21:25was popular on both sides of the Atlantic. Her poems focused on patriotism
- 1:21:30and human virtues. She even wrote a poem about George Washington to His Excellency,
- 1:21:34George Washington in seventeen seventy five. So various things that women can do,
- 1:21:44Like we see men employed in the military in everything from these domestic roles
- 1:21:51to the propaganda department to you know, like they might not call it that,
- 1:21:57but basically getting people to agree with the war and intimidating the other side.
- 1:22:12These are not things that women can't do. New York teenager Sybil Luttington
- 1:22:17was the female equivalent of Paul Revere, though she rode twice as far as
- 1:22:23Paul Revere, and in a driving rainstorm in April seventeen seventy seven, her
- 1:22:28ride took her through Putnam in Duchess Counties, New York, where she roused
- 1:22:32local militia to fight a British force that had attacked nearby Danbury, Connecticut.
- 1:22:39The Daughters of the American Revolution erected in a heroic equestrian statue to Luddington in
- 1:22:45Carmel, New York. We're gonna skip Betsy Ross because there's some there's some
- 1:22:57belief that she actually did what she you know, she was reputed to do.
- 1:23:01There's also some beliefs that she didn't. Not really something that I'm gonna
- 1:23:10I don't want to get into that debate, but there's those were just some
- 1:23:15individual women. There are women who were spies in the Revolutionary War, but
- 1:23:20for the most part, aside from the few women that there was also a
- 1:23:26woman who disguised herself as a man and enlisted and fought, and she fought
- 1:23:33until she was injured badly enough that she couldn't get out of receiving treatment from
- 1:23:40a physician, at which point she was identified by the physician as a woman,
- 1:23:45and she was honorably discharged. But then she had to fight for her
- 1:23:47pension because she wasn't supposed to be in the military, because she was a
- 1:23:51woman, but she was not. She was taller than the men. She
- 1:23:59pretended to be a teenager, and she actually fought for quite some time,
- 1:24:04so it wasn't almost immediately. She had several other injuries prior to that one.
- 1:24:10I don't remember if it was in this article or another one that I
- 1:24:14read about her, but she she didn't seek treatment for injuries because she knew
- 1:24:19she would be identified. But eventually the injury that she had required a doctor's
- 1:24:26care and there wasn't anything she could do about it. And eventually she did,
- 1:24:30by the way, get her pension, So the government did make it
- 1:24:33right with her. But mostly what women did was a little different. Wives
- 1:24:41of the as wives of the common soldier often followed the Continental Army, so
- 1:24:45too did the wives of general officers. Let's see artillery. The Continental Army's
- 1:24:55artillery commander married the vivacious and popular Bostonian Lucy Flucker. There would be a
- 1:25:02ton of jokes I like's gonna be oh my god, So if you don't,
- 1:25:12if you're not familiar with original, the original cast is Saturday. But
- 1:25:18in any case, this woman deserves better than that. So the daughter of
- 1:25:23bust Undian loyalists once she and Henry were married, all ties between her and
- 1:25:28her family were cut. She married a revolutionary. That was it right.
- 1:25:34Henry and Lucy were devoted to one another, and she would join him whenever
- 1:25:39she could while he was on campaign she encouraged. She endured the bitter encampment
- 1:25:44at Valley Forge and became fast friends with a wife of General Nathaniel Greene,
- 1:25:49the equally popular Kitty. George Washington's wife, Marie Curtis, spent every winter
- 1:25:57with her husband whenever the army was camp. So even women who could have
- 1:26:04on the basis of being you know, being married to officers, so being
- 1:26:12above, they still went. And you think about it, You're in a
- 1:26:17situation where your partner, your husband, the person that you love the most
- 1:26:23in the world, is going to another part of your country to defend your
- 1:26:30country, and you don't know if you'll ever see him again when he leaves,
- 1:26:36and your choices are to sit back and let that happen, or to
- 1:26:41go and be close by to where he's going to be and do everything you
- 1:26:45can to provide care and back up as far as doing jobs and tasks that
- 1:26:55the soldiers don't have time to do for themselves. Or don't know how to
- 1:27:00do for themselves, wouldn't be able to do for themselves as well, for
- 1:27:04instance, repairing uniforms and such were those Sewing was pretty much the purview of
- 1:27:11women, so ordinary women also endured the horrors of the battlefield when those fights
- 1:27:21came to their doorstep. Sally Kellogg of Vermont and her family escaped the gods
- 1:27:28of war in seventeen seventy six when the War for Independence found its way into
- 1:27:33the northern reaches of Upstate New York and Benedict Arnold's makeshift fleet and the Navy.
- 1:27:41The British Navy clashed on Lake Champlain during the Battle of Alcour Island.
- 1:27:47As the Kellogg family made good its escape by water, Sally's family fell in
- 1:27:51between Arnold's fleet and the British fleet. She later recalled as the family rode
- 1:27:57to safety, the exchange of on fire between the ships could be seen and
- 1:28:01heard, so they're right in the middle of it. So women had to
- 1:28:08deal with the fact that the war was around them, so they couldn't just
- 1:28:13sit around and like, oh, I'm not involved here. Then there was
- 1:28:18let's see if it's I don't know if it's in this article. I think
- 1:28:21it's the other one. Yeah, so I have two articles here, the
- 1:28:32daily life of a soldier versus the daily life of women in war and the
- 1:28:38daily life of a soldier is described as here we go. Daily life defined
- 1:28:49by routine, fatigue, and preparation for battle. The soldier marched all day,
- 1:28:58had to carry a heavy low. He had in addition to his weapon,
- 1:29:05all of his bedding, his ammunition, any personal items he took with
- 1:29:11him. If he was lucky, he had an extra blanket, but of
- 1:29:15course, you know how much a blanket weighs, especially if it's a wool
- 1:29:18blanket. In camp, soldier usually spent eight hours or more practicing military drills
- 1:29:25and doing labor necessary for the maintenance of the army. They forged for food.
- 1:29:30They had to do. They had to hunt in order to supplement their
- 1:29:33rations. They wouldn't have had, you know, like we have now where
- 1:29:38the military stores up a lot of food and there's a system for making sure
- 1:29:43that the soldiers have enough food. They had to uh chop firewood, They
- 1:29:51had to maintain the the area that they lived in. They had to they
- 1:29:58had guard duty. They cooked together, you know, and then if they
- 1:30:02had downtime, and they weren't totally beat. They would play cards, marbles,
- 1:30:11world ice. But they might have guard duty at night, so that
- 1:30:19was outside of the fighting, right, that's their daily life. In addition
- 1:30:23to the fact that they would be shot at, that they would have cannons
- 1:30:27fired at them, that they would be attacked with swords, that they would
- 1:30:30be out in all kinds of weather, they would be completely exposed to the
- 1:30:34weather, that they would be responsible for killing people. Yeah, so some
- 1:30:48of the women had to flee their homes. But in terms of what women
- 1:30:55actually did as part of the war effort, there were things like, because
- 1:31:02the men were drafted, you had areas where there weren't enough men to do
- 1:31:10the work at home that men normally did, so some women took over those
- 1:31:15roles. What did they call themselves, I'm not sure if it's in here
- 1:31:26or not. Well, they Yeah, there was a name like substitute husbands.
- 1:31:32It's not the right name. But and then of course many chose to
- 1:31:35follow a male relative to the army and provide the services I described before,
- 1:31:41doing laundry or nursing, and they did get paid and they did get fed.
- 1:31:50Here we go, there's the woman's name was Deborah Samson that dressed in
- 1:31:55men's clothes and enlisted in the fourth Massachusetts Regiment of the Continental Army under the
- 1:32:00Robert Shirtliffe. First, she tried once and got busted, and then she
- 1:32:06did it again, Taller than the average soldier, claimed she was a teenager
- 1:32:11to avoid questions. She suffered multiple wounds, but refused to go to the
- 1:32:15doctor out of fear he would discover her secret. However, when she was
- 1:32:19hospitalized, it was an illness not an injury. So when she was hospitalized
- 1:32:25for an illness, a doctor identified Samson as female. Soon after, she
- 1:32:28was honorably discharged from the Army, even though she had broken the rules to
- 1:32:33be there. She went home to Massachusetts married. She did not forget her
- 1:32:42experiences and successfully petitioned the state government to pay for pay owed to her as
- 1:32:47a soldier that she had not received because she had been discovered to be a
- 1:32:51woman. In seventeen ninety seven, she became a minor celebrity when a book
- 1:32:56about her time in the Army, The Female Review, was printed. She
- 1:33:00went on a speaking to her and performed military exercises on stage, and she
- 1:33:03sought a veteran's pension and succeeded with the help of Paul Revere. So this
- 1:33:12was pretty much the one woman who enlisted and fought in the Revolutionary Army.
- 1:33:19But what women normally did again, sometimes they did help on the battlefield if
- 1:33:27they were in that situation where they were there in the support role, and
- 1:33:31circumstances pretty much made that the made that necessary that that's what they did,
- 1:33:40because when you are in an emergency situation, you deal with the emergency at
- 1:33:43hand, not what people are going to think about it later. So let's
- 1:33:53see if we have yeah, camp followers before the moments that brought them fame
- 1:34:01on the battlefield. Both Margaret Corbin and Mary Hayes had traveled with the army
- 1:34:06as camp followers. Both the Continental and British Army included thousands of women and
- 1:34:14children. Camp followers traditionally wives and children and soldiers. Statistics show that for
- 1:34:19the American Army there was at least one woman to every twenty four soldiers.
- 1:34:25For the Hessians, the German soldiers who served alongside the British Army, the
- 1:34:30ratio is one to fifteen. For the British Army itself, the ratio at
- 1:34:32one point was one woman to every eight soldiers. Wow, So now I
- 1:34:42know Night Motorcyclists isn't trusting this because women keep revising history. But this isn't
- 1:34:45new information like this is information that has been known since the time of the
- 1:34:51war itself. So again these are this is as I discussed this. We're
- 1:35:03not talking about women in the Revolutionary War because women are something special and great,
- 1:35:15or that it in any way takes away from what the men did.
- 1:35:20They have to understand the point of this is that when we hear that it's
- 1:35:27unfair to suggest that women should be as responsible for a draft as men are,
- 1:35:33that should either be drafting both sexes or neither, you can look at
- 1:35:40history and prove that it is actually perfectly fair to conscript both sexes instead of
- 1:35:49just one, or to exempt both sexes because they're even. Even if you
- 1:35:55don't conscript women to fight on the front lines, you can conscript women to
- 1:36:00do jobs for the military. Uh. Quick, silver tongue says, no
- 1:36:06Mike today. No. Unfortunately, Mike is visiting family, so he's not
- 1:36:11able to be here. So mhm, he will be back next week.
- 1:36:19Yes, he will be back next week. But yeah, so you look
- 1:36:24at this, We're still it is still men's blood that paid the price for
- 1:36:31this revolution, just like every revolution, and it is still men and boys
- 1:36:39who fought the battles, who won freedom, and who went into it either
- 1:36:48knowing or not knowing the risks. But that does not exempt women from responsibility
- 1:36:57for being a part of the defensive their country. Even like, if you
- 1:37:01look at someone like me, right, my health has always been shit.
- 1:37:08It's never been good. At its best, it was still not as good
- 1:37:15as most of the people around me. But there were things I could do.
- 1:37:21I worked as a nurse's aid, I I've worked as a baker,
- 1:37:30and I've worked as a cook. It is it would be unfair to say
- 1:37:40that if a military conflict were to happen on American soil and men were fighting,
- 1:37:49and the fourteen percent of the military that our women were fighting, even
- 1:37:55though I might not be qualified to do what they are doing, neither in
- 1:38:00terms of physical aptitude, physical capabilities, or competence with weapons and tactics,
- 1:38:09it would be unfair for me to sit on my ass and say, well,
- 1:38:12there's nothing I can do right, because their damn well is stuff I
- 1:38:15could do right. And that is the point. Yeah, these women,
- 1:38:24even though they weren't the ones going out and facing musket fire and cannon fire
- 1:38:31for the most part, like there were some names you know that that definitely
- 1:38:35did. But for the most part, what these women were doing was taking
- 1:38:42some of the other burden off of these men that would have been on them
- 1:38:46so that they could focus on coming back alive mm hm. And they had
- 1:38:56rules right to get that pay to be part of a to be a camp
- 1:39:00follower. These women and children performed a variety of duties. There weren't just
- 1:39:04lightweight things, right you could just throw things in a washing machine. So
- 1:39:10they're when they're laundering soldiers uniforms, you're talking about boiling water and you know,
- 1:39:16mixing it with cold water so that you have hot water, you know,
- 1:39:20or washing in ice cold water. You're talking about carrying water in big
- 1:39:29buckets because they didn't exactly have plumbing out there. They didn't have cisterns,
- 1:39:34they didn't have anything that, so they they're tote heavy buckets. Uh there.
- 1:39:40When they washed that laundry, they're sticking a washboard down into that water
- 1:39:45and plunging their hand down in over and over again to rub the laundry on
- 1:39:48the washboard. To get the stains out, they're supplod yep, the blood
- 1:39:55they're sewing, they're cooking, they're making. Were that the soldiers had the
- 1:40:02things they need. And as it says here, since soldiers did not often
- 1:40:06have time to clean their bodies, they didn't get to bathe, especially in
- 1:40:10the wintertime. Having laundered uniforms helped to keep soldiers cleaner and healthier than they
- 1:40:16otherwise might have been, and it boosted morale because it helped them look they
- 1:40:21they felt like soldiers, they looked professional. But even more important than that
- 1:40:28was the nursing right because they were going to come back wounded, and there
- 1:40:33aren't at that point in time. There's not a bunch of extra men and
- 1:40:40extra boys that could be that could do this right. They're suffering from either
- 1:40:48they're too young or too old, too infirm. Where they're they're suffering from
- 1:40:53injuries, they're suffering from diseases smallpox. Like night motorcyclists mentioned you have if
- 1:41:03they're not in battle, it's because they're disabled completely in terms of doing these
- 1:41:11things. So if you had, if you wanted people to apply bandages and
- 1:41:17people to bring them food and water when they're injured, people to basically play
- 1:41:26the support role. When military doctors had to amputate limbs and you had women,
- 1:41:32you had to have women there. Camp followers nursed the wounded and cared
- 1:41:39for the sick, working alongside the few army doctors. They served as merchants
- 1:41:44called settlers, so they went and got supplies and then sold them back.
- 1:41:48They were basically the canteen. Others were middlemen who purchased goods and sold them
- 1:41:57to soldiers. Camp followers supported the me by repairing clothing and other fabric goods,
- 1:42:01and tents were made out of fabric, carrying supplies, cooking food.
- 1:42:11They were so critical to the functioning of each army that they were considered a
- 1:42:15formal part of the armies and were issued issued food rations and pay for their
- 1:42:18work. So when you know, we go back to the beginning of the
- 1:42:28show, like these women would have slapped the shit out of the women that
- 1:42:34I talked to today on Twitter. Oh my god, Yes, they would
- 1:42:39have. I'd love to see that. Oh my god. Not only would
- 1:42:46they, the women today couldn't wouldn't last a day in these women's shoes.
- 1:42:51Yeah, impossible. No, Like, will you talk about what how women
- 1:43:00should be? What women should do. What is the ideal character of a
- 1:43:03woman. In my opinion, the ideal character of a woman is somebody who
- 1:43:11when she sees that something like this is happening in her community, she looks,
- 1:43:18doesn't doesn't step up and say, well, just because I'm a woman
- 1:43:21doesn't mean I can't do this or that and you have to let me.
- 1:43:28She looks for how she can serve, even if it's not glorious. Right,
- 1:43:35And I watched my grandmother be that woman and my mother be that woman
- 1:43:41throughout my life, throughout my knowing them in their lives, and that's how
- 1:43:48I learned how to be a woman. Right. A woman should not look
- 1:43:58at life in turns terms of everything men have. I deserve. Also,
- 1:44:05yeah, just because I exist, should be looking at life in terms of
- 1:44:16everything men do to earn what they have. There's an equivalent. There's a
- 1:44:23way for me to earn what I have to mhm. It doesn't have to
- 1:44:29be the same. It doesn't have to be as pretty or ugly, it
- 1:44:35doesn't have to be as deserving of what men go through. And more women
- 1:44:46don't even understand. For the most part, I think the horror of knowing
- 1:44:53that something might ripe through your flesh and kill you because you are where you
- 1:44:58are, doing what you're doing, and then going and doing it anyway is
- 1:45:03not something that women ever really have to confront and I can. I'm betting
- 1:45:09you that there are gonna be feminist chicks in the comments going pregnancy and bullshit,
- 1:45:16right, bull fucking shit. Right. You can't compare pregnancy to a
- 1:45:20musket ball or a bullet or cannonball, a sword, a knife. But
- 1:45:28Hannah, but Hannah, but Hannah. Some women die during pregnancy, don't
- 1:45:33you know how dangerous it is for a bullet? Also, pregnancy is voluntary.
- 1:45:41Women don't like to hear that either, But pregnancy from consensual sex is
- 1:45:46voluntary. You have a bunch of tools to stop that. So I don't
- 1:45:53even want to hear it. Right, But yeah, at night, motorcyclist
- 1:46:00says, women claim they are carrying a cannon ball in them. Well,
- 1:46:04I don't know how much a cannonball weighs, but most babies born today are
- 1:46:13not ten pounds. They're less than ten pounds, right, It's normal for
- 1:46:16a baby to be six or seven pounds. An eight pound baby is pretty
- 1:46:23good sized, right. My mind was a nine pounder and I had to
- 1:46:28have them cut out of me. Oo. So yeah, I I guess
- 1:46:35it depends on the size of the cannonball and the material it's made out of,
- 1:46:40but I doubt it. And then of course, obviously the other thing
- 1:46:44is cannonballs don't kick you. I swear to you guys. The whole time
- 1:46:49I was pregnant, my son was in there playing basketball. We walking along,
- 1:46:56comeling, cobling, comeling, come bling. You gotta be kidding me.
- 1:47:00Yeah, no, no, none of that. That was always funny,
- 1:47:01like that was that was hilarious. You could actually see when I got
- 1:47:06close to uh childbirth, he'd move. And babies will move left to right,
- 1:47:15they'll turn, you know, get into a more comfortable position, like
- 1:47:20especially if you're you go from standing to sitting, or you're laying on your
- 1:47:24left side and you roll over on your right side. The baby has a
- 1:47:27position that they prefer, and they'll move and you can see the the elbow
- 1:47:34or the knee or the arm like sticking out and going across the bellley.
- 1:47:42It's good. It's bizarre, like it's quite obvious that there is a living
- 1:47:47organism independently moving inside of you. It's an amazing experience. So when women
- 1:47:57who play victim of that, I don't. I don't have any tempt for
- 1:48:00that because I was constantly floored by it. But yeah, point being that
- 1:48:12you don't, there's there's a glorification that happens. It's maybe not necessarily right
- 1:48:17in terms of war and the sacrifices that men go through, and they should
- 1:48:27be honored, but they shouldn't be honored in a way that makes them feel
- 1:48:31obligated to do that regardless of the cause. Right, the honor should be
- 1:48:38that you understand, you value the cause, and you you risked yourself by
- 1:48:47choice, or you risked yourself because you had to, and that people people
- 1:48:54owe you because you did that. They owe you a level of respect for
- 1:48:58what you did and gratitude. Women shouldn't be looking at that and saying I
- 1:49:06deserve some of that. I deserve a piece of that, right, because
- 1:49:13you're not part of a team if you're only willing to be on the team
- 1:49:19to get that. You're part of a team if you look at the goal
- 1:49:26that the team is trying to achieve and you look for a way to further
- 1:49:30the team's progress toward that goal, even if it is something that other people
- 1:49:39are never going to consider equal to what other teammates did. Yeah, it's
- 1:49:45a slap in the face to the people who actually got in there and did
- 1:49:48the work, you know, But that's what they don't want to do,
- 1:49:53is the work. I look at it in terms of medicine because that's part
- 1:50:00of my experience, and in terms of sports teams, because that's part of
- 1:50:02my experience. I was really good at the hurdles when I was in school.
- 1:50:09I was also on the cross country team. Right I sucked as a
- 1:50:12cross country runner. I was the last runner on our team, and I
- 1:50:16was often the last runner in the entire race. Like I was that person
- 1:50:21that people were worried about whether she was going to finish or not, whether
- 1:50:27whether you were going to go running back through the course and find it a
- 1:50:31body on the ground because the individual that you were looking for had suffocated.
- 1:50:40And I never needed to be credited as being first place runners as part of
- 1:50:48that team. I never had to be the person that every oh, you're
- 1:50:53a cross country runner, that's so tough, look at how great you are.
- 1:50:55It was just I was just glad they let me be on the team,
- 1:50:59even though I saw and I was glad that on occasion I could contribute
- 1:51:04points right. And there was one time that we lost our first place runner
- 1:51:12to a hole in the ground. She didn't fall in, she sprained her
- 1:51:16ankle in it. But because of that I became important, which really was
- 1:51:24intimidating at the time. So running along and which for me meant stumbling blindly
- 1:51:30forward and catching myself with my feet, and you know, the whole time,
- 1:51:36I sound like I'm dying, and all of a sudden there's there's my
- 1:51:43coach and one of the other runners on the on the team yelling at me
- 1:51:46that Kelly is down and I have to beat the girl in front of me
- 1:51:51in order for us to maintain our lead. The girl in front of me
- 1:51:56is like fifty yards in front of me, and I have to catch up
- 1:52:00to her, and I'm just dying, and so I you know, I
- 1:52:05like the whole time. You know, the cheering of my teammates helped to
- 1:52:11sort of light a fire under my butt, and I sort of dredged up.
- 1:52:15All right, I'm going to do this because you could also see it
- 1:52:19wasn't close, but it was visible. There's the finish line, and so
- 1:52:29I didn't have a whole lot of time to catch up to her and beat
- 1:52:31her. Yeah, so I went into a there's a final sprint that you
- 1:52:36do at the end of a across country race if you can find that inner
- 1:52:41fire. Some people just don't. They can't. But when I did that,
- 1:52:46when I started that, I immediately started having an asthma attack. So
- 1:52:50if you ever heard the sound effects they use were when there's two guys with
- 1:52:56one of those big band saws, I think that's what it's called in the
- 1:53:00woods cutting down a tree, like the big long, you know, six
- 1:53:03foot long saw. That's what my breathing sounded like. Oh my god.
- 1:53:09And I stretched my legs out as far as I could, which you know
- 1:53:12that helped a lot because I was taller than the other girl, and I
- 1:53:15barely caught up to her. Well, at that point, she heard me
- 1:53:21coming and she stopped and she turned around. She looked at me because like
- 1:53:30this thing coming up behind her sounded like a train wreck happening. And I
- 1:53:38kept going. It's like I was sprinting in slow motion. And I kept
- 1:53:44going, and I could hear her coach going, what are you doing right?
- 1:53:49And she's just looking at me. Her jaw is on her chest.
- 1:53:56But I beat her. I beat that one girl, and that that that
- 1:54:00took us from second place into first place. Well and well made one point.
- 1:54:06There was one point difference between the two places. She was not on
- 1:54:12the team that we took down a peg either, so but it was funny
- 1:54:20and and that's like the probably the biggest moment I had in cross country the
- 1:54:25entire time I ran. And you know, she wasn't stopping to help me,
- 1:54:30by the way, she just was shocked. Wow. Oh, people
- 1:54:38know I have asthma, so I know exactly what you're talking about. Oh
- 1:54:43my god, you poor things. I passed out immediately after the race.
- 1:54:46I didn't thank God for my dad, because if you stop after a run
- 1:54:53like that, you cramp, kind of like getting the bins. So what
- 1:54:57he did was he threw my arm over his sho older and is his arm
- 1:55:00around my waist and walked me. And I remember getting to the finish line
- 1:55:09and him getting me into that position and putting my inhaler in my mouth,
- 1:55:13and I remember breathing in and getting the nasty taste from the inhaler because that
- 1:55:17it's like somebody stuck something that sucks all the moisture out of your mouth.
- 1:55:23And then then I was many yards away from the finish line, which they
- 1:55:32they have the way they do the finish line is they've got they set up
- 1:55:35like a funnel marking with the yardsticks poked into the ground and ribbon tied to
- 1:55:43it, so it's wider at the opening and narrower where you exit, several
- 1:55:48several yards away from that, and my dad is, you know, are
- 1:55:55you are you okay? You know, talking to me and everything. We
- 1:55:58had walked and I had moved my legs walking the whole time. It was
- 1:56:02completely unconscious. I did that a couple of times with him, where you
- 1:56:08know, he just kept me going. And he did that at every event.
- 1:56:15If I if my dad hadn't been there doing that, I would not
- 1:56:18have been able to even participate. Right, But I was never the most
- 1:56:23important person on the team, and it never occurred to me that that was
- 1:56:28a problem. It never should have occurred to me, because it wasn't right.
- 1:56:31The most important people on the team are the top five runners, and
- 1:56:38that's you know, you you work hard to push yourself to be good teammates
- 1:56:45to them and good backup and an inspiration, you know. The person.
- 1:56:50That's that they have to continue to beat you to stay in that top five.
- 1:56:56But if you have to think of yourself as as being the most important
- 1:57:00person on the team, you're in the wrong sport. And when it comes
- 1:57:06to things, when it comes to life, women should be ready to understand
- 1:57:11that about a lot of things. Men are bigger than us, They are
- 1:57:15stronger than us, They have thicker bones than we have. Men have a
- 1:57:20lot of physical characteristics that make them more suited for some things that we're not
- 1:57:26as well suited for on the whole, and so you find there will be
- 1:57:30a significant number more men doing those things than women. And that's fair.
- 1:57:36Women shouldn't feel left out right. What we should be doing is saying,
- 1:57:43well, what are we good at? What can we do? Let's do
- 1:57:46that. And that's what these women did. So when we look at the
- 1:57:58history of suffrage and conscription and fighting for human rights recognition and fighting for uh
- 1:58:11independent h like not self governance, but independent consent to be governed, it
- 1:58:26is it is irrational and unreasonable for for our society to say, well,
- 1:58:32women should have all the same rights as men, but should just be totally
- 1:58:38exempt from those dirty, ugly parts the ikey bits like, yeah, no,
- 1:58:47you're not exempt. Maybe you're maybe the dirty, ugly parts you handle
- 1:58:51aren't going to be the same as the ones they handle. Maybe you're the
- 1:58:56person who is holding somebody's hand and holding their leg down when the doctor has
- 1:59:02to cut off their foot. Oh that's horrible, right. Think of what's
- 1:59:11the scene in Gone with the Wind where Scarlett is working as a nurse and
- 1:59:17the man is yelling, don't cut, don't cut right before he gets his
- 1:59:20leg amputated because of Gangreen. It would still be a gut wrenching, horrifying
- 1:59:26thing to help with. His experience is obviously the worst experience in that situation.
- 1:59:34The doctor's experience is pretty terrible because that's certainly not the thing that's ideal
- 1:59:40for him to do. But just because just because your experience isn't the worst
- 1:59:46experience in that moment, doesn't mean that you shouldn't struggle to be a help,
- 1:59:54right, you have any other thoughts on the matter. It's just really
- 2:00:15sad to see how weak women have become, you know, and demanding.
- 2:00:24They just don't deserve they they're not deserving of it, you know, really,
- 2:00:30But I don't know, I don't really have any more thoughts other than
- 2:00:32that. God, the child soldier thing just really threw me. Yeah,
- 2:00:40imagine being fifteen years old and you're not only in the military, but you're
- 2:00:46expected to exercise authority and take responsibility for the people under you. Like,
- 2:00:58what were you doing when you were fifteen? Actually, I graduated high school
- 2:01:03when I was fifteen. Oh wow, that's awesome. Yeah, but I
- 2:01:08mean I really didn't do anything with it. You know, I wanted to
- 2:01:11go on to college, but I wanted to go out of state to a
- 2:01:14college I was accepted to for a nursing class, but because I was so
- 2:01:17young, my parents weren't having that you know. Yeah. So yeah,
- 2:01:25it is what it is, but kind of a difficult. It's it's hard
- 2:01:29to make that kind of decision as parents. You know, you were your
- 2:01:31kid to be a kid while they can be a kid. But sometimes the
- 2:01:35best time to learn new things is during that age when your brain still has
- 2:01:41that level of plasticity. Yeah, it is the best time. Yeah,
- 2:01:45there's a lot of things I wish i'd done when I was that age.
- 2:01:47I like, when I went to college, I shouldn't have gone with the
- 2:01:50intention of becoming a school teacher. If I had understood what the school system
- 2:01:55was at the time, I wouldn't i'd have I'd have gone for something else.
- 2:02:00Probably probably would have gotten a nursing degree, although at the time that
- 2:02:05I went, I had some issues that I should have addressed before ever setting
- 2:02:10foot at a university. But but all that aside, Yeah, I think
- 2:02:15most people, like when I was fifteen, I was scaring the shit out
- 2:02:19of some girl on somebody else's some other school's cross country team. I had
- 2:02:26my first paying job. I wasn't able to drive yet. I actually had
- 2:02:30to ride to events that I was photographing with the reporter that was covering the
- 2:02:38event because I couldn't I couldn't drive myself there. But but yeah, like
- 2:02:46and and and that's that's the sergeant age, right, the youngest boy age
- 2:02:53seven at that's that's a first grader. In the age of a first grader,
- 2:03:00a boy was responsible for playing the instrument that told the soldiers in his
- 2:03:09area within hearing distance of him to attack or retreat, or or do particular
- 2:03:16things in an attack or retreat. Like that's that's a heavy responsibility. M
- 2:03:26h. I mean, he was he was out there, you know,
- 2:03:30practicing with the rest of the soldiers too, you know, and he was
- 2:03:33a target. He wasn't just responsible for I have to do this right or
- 2:03:40people will die. On top of I have to do this right or people
- 2:03:44will die, it was I have to do this right under fire. Yeah,
- 2:03:48I have to do this right while my life is at risk. Like
- 2:03:54that's that's masculinity and comparison to femininity we have. Women don't have to be
- 2:04:01useless, they just choose to be here. Women don't have to be useless.
- 2:04:09Women don't have to be exempt from hardship mm hmm. But they also
- 2:04:15don't have to do that. They're not obligated to do that. So it's
- 2:04:23just unfair when people argue that, you know, we can't draft women because
- 2:04:30it's just it's just too hard for women to deal with with, you know,
- 2:04:34the the rigors of the military, when there are things that women clearly
- 2:04:38can do. But at the same time to say, well, women are
- 2:04:44just as capable as men. How many seven year old girls can you imagine?
- 2:04:51You tell take a seven year old girl and you tell her, all
- 2:04:57right, you're gonna learn to play this instrument and then you're gonna go out
- 2:05:00into this area where there are blood and got scary things that you've never seen
- 2:05:04before in your life, and you might be shot or stabbed. It's freezing
- 2:05:12cold, there's snow on the ground, wild animals might get you. All
- 2:05:16right, get out there. Yeah, yeah, no, no, but
- 2:05:26it is fucking hilarious. Seven young little boys have the responsibilities that grown women
- 2:05:35will not. They would oh no, they turned their nose a back,
- 2:05:40you know, they weren't expected to handle it. They did not ask women
- 2:05:43to do those jobs. God, So there we go. But it's nine
- 2:05:51o'clock, so I'm gonna go ahead and call it. So I think we
- 2:05:54pretty well established two things in this episode. From the beginning of the United
- 2:06:00States, from before we were states and when we were colonies, there was
- 2:06:10conscription. Men were obligated. Women were not. Right, that was one
- 2:06:15thing. But also that doesn't mean that women just should have a get out
- 2:06:25of responsibility free card, because obviously, even if you are not conscripting women
- 2:06:30to fight, there are things you can conscript women to do. M hm.
- 2:06:36So it is unfair for women to have no obligation at all. Absolutely,
- 2:06:45absolutely right. And so we look at I don't have any more super
- 2:06:53chows. I've read all the super chats. I like Quicksilver Tongue, and
- 2:07:00today's ten year old girls are responsible for promoting Taylor Swiss new concert on social
- 2:07:03media. Knew if if my girls were that young, like I think,
- 2:07:12I would have taught them not to give free advertisement to bimbos. They wouldn't
- 2:07:21be on social media at all. Oh my god, mister three or three
- 2:07:29wants the drill scene from Full Metal Jacket, but with women. Yeah.
- 2:07:36Mangaka ninety two says it's equally unfair for women to get to wash laundry while
- 2:07:42men get their brains blown out, and it is, yeah, yeah,
- 2:07:45it is. But at the same time, I think it's unfair. It
- 2:07:51would also be unfair to put a man's life in a woman's hands if she
- 2:07:58is not going to be able to hold up her end, right. I
- 2:08:05think if women do get drafted for combat, it's important that the women have
- 2:08:11their own units and they're not side by side with the men, because I
- 2:08:20don't think. I don't think women and men are equally yoked today until yeah,
- 2:08:30until that would change, would I would not object? I would not
- 2:08:35if women want to have fighting units that are all women and and risk their
- 2:08:41lives together. That's their business. But to turn to a man and say
- 2:08:48you have to depend on me to protect you, I think that would be
- 2:08:54unfair. Mm hmm. That that I would sacrifice is safety. The IDEF,
- 2:09:07I don't know what the IDEF is night motorcyclists. I found mixed to
- 2:09:13be a liability. The Israeli depends okay, yeah, yeah. I remember
- 2:09:18reading about when they when they started that, everybody's like, oh yeah,
- 2:09:22women and men can look at Israel's doing it. Israel's doing it. And
- 2:09:26then they discontinued it, did they They they're not mixed, They're I think
- 2:09:33they're they're segregated now hmmm, because I remember reading about that as well,
- 2:09:37that they found that when you put the men and the women together, there
- 2:09:43are two things that happen that are that are dangerous to the men. One
- 2:09:48of them is the women don't hold up their end, and the other one
- 2:09:50is that the men will sacrifice themselves to protect the women. Cheese, Yeah,
- 2:09:58I can totally, God damn. Yeah. So yeah, if you
- 2:10:07if you want women to fight, you have to have them as a team
- 2:10:09separate from the men, or you end up with that kind of problem.
- 2:10:18Quicksilver Tongue says, if you don't buy a ten year old girl the latest
- 2:10:22iPhone has probably counted as child abuse today. Ye if I had kids that
- 2:10:30age right now and I was responsible for them, forget about iPhone, they
- 2:10:37would not have phones at that age. Mm hmmm, absolutely no way.
- 2:10:46Like the only the only thing that could persuade me to give my kid a
- 2:10:50phone would be is if I was worried that they were not safe at school.
- 2:10:54And if I was that worried that they were not safe at school,
- 2:10:58I wouldn't send them to that school. Yeah. Absolutely, I mean I
- 2:11:03say this, I don't have kids, but in my hypothetical, if I
- 2:11:07had children's situation, I wouldn't be working. I would be home with them,
- 2:11:13probably homeschooling them. You know. It's just there would be no need
- 2:11:16for them to have their own phone. Yeah. Like, this is something
- 2:11:20that people don't understand today, And it's amazing to me how many people my
- 2:11:26age that don't understand this we grew up without. When I was a kid,
- 2:11:35the phone in our house wasn't just plugged into the wall, it was
- 2:11:39mounted to the wall. You couldn't even take the phone into another room to
- 2:11:46have a conversation. You went to where the phone was, and you had
- 2:11:50a chair by where the phone was you could sit down. Like a lot
- 2:11:56of people had phones that sat on a coffee table or something like that.
- 2:12:00There were, but but our phone was actually the the the type that you
- 2:12:07mounted onto a thing attached to the wall. Mm hmm. Yeah. Parts
- 2:12:13was in the kitchen. Yeah, we had a our house had my parents
- 2:12:20uh enclosed what had been a patio. They added a room there. They
- 2:12:26put it, they put they put a family room. It was like a
- 2:12:31living room be almost like a parlor, except that we used it all the
- 2:12:35time, so it wasn't just for when guests were over. And and in
- 2:12:39between the kitchen, which had sort of had a dining room area that was
- 2:12:46all like all open. There was no doors or closed walls in between us,
- 2:12:52so it was like one great big L shaped room. And on the
- 2:12:56post in between where the door to the outside used to be, that's where
- 2:13:01our phone was mounted. So you could be in the in the family room,
- 2:13:05or you could be in the kitchen. And we had a phone cord
- 2:13:07that was long enough that you could sit down. But then if anybody wanted
- 2:13:09to walk through the room, they had to walk over or under it,
- 2:13:15and so yeah, we uh, we had a rotary phone. But yeah,
- 2:13:22I just know, I don't think I would I don't think I would
- 2:13:28like the idea of having a ten year old with a smartphone. And my
- 2:13:35kids grew up with no privacy on the computer like they grew up with.
- 2:13:43And when when my stepdaughters had phones, their their mom gave them in high
- 2:13:48school and everything. You know, we kind of developed a habit of showing
- 2:13:54each other this is what's on the look. Look, I got this meme,
- 2:13:56I found this thing. This is funny. Haha, you know,
- 2:14:01I got this text. You know, blah blah, this video came from
- 2:14:03your uncle. And so even then, you know, they didn't really have
- 2:14:09screen privacy. It just it's it's a bad idea. Your kids should not
- 2:14:16have screen privacy from their parents. No way, it invites too many problems,
- 2:14:24you know. Like but but yeah, senior sixth gave us two dollars
- 2:14:31and said, just give them old school flip phones for for eighties style.
- 2:14:37Do those even still work? Yeah, I was just gonna say that,
- 2:14:41and my husband is nodding, head they still work. They are fragile though,
- 2:14:45Yeah, but well, and and actually in the eighties. I don't.
- 2:14:50I don't think flip phones existed in the eighties. The mobile phones that
- 2:14:56existed in the eighties came in a bag, It plugged into your cigarette lighter
- 2:15:01in your car, and it was like seven fifty a minute for phone calls.
- 2:15:07So yeah, it was really expensive and it was it was the size
- 2:15:13of a brick, and there was there were like maybe one or two companies
- 2:15:18that you could you could get them from, and you paid for a contract
- 2:15:22on top of that. By the way, it was expensive. You paid
- 2:15:26you paid through the nose to get the phone, and then you also had
- 2:15:31a monthly contract fee for service, which got you absolutely nothing except that you
- 2:15:37had a phone number and the phone number worked right, and then if you
- 2:15:43used the service, you had to pay buy the minute for your use.
- 2:15:50And there was no such thing as text messaging. So what most people had
- 2:15:58clear up into the late nineties instead was a little device that would be attached
- 2:16:07to a number. When somebody called it, it would beep and then you
- 2:16:09would go call them back, and that's a pager. If somebody has one
- 2:16:16of those today, you have just found a drug dealer. But it used
- 2:16:24to be you know, like doctors would have pagers, and people lawyers would
- 2:16:30have pagers. People who were on call would have pagers so that they would
- 2:16:35know that somebody was trying to get in touch with them because you couldn't just
- 2:16:39call them. So that's that. But yeah, it is after nine o'clock.
- 2:16:46I'm going to go ahead and call it. I don't think we have
- 2:16:48anything more to talk about on the subject. I think I've pretty much established
- 2:16:52that. You know, the feminists are kind of bullshitness when they act like
- 2:17:00it's the reason that women are exempt from any kind of service today is because
- 2:17:05women just have always been not expected to contribute anything to the war effort.
- 2:17:11Uh. You know, maybe maybe they haven't been on the front lines,
- 2:17:15maybe they haven't been doing the things that are frequently glorified by by war historians,
- 2:17:22but that doesn't mean that they just got to sit around on their butts
- 2:17:28like women today, and they were. Every bit is necessary, right,
- 2:17:31and and it's important for women to remember that that level of responsibility and take
- 2:17:39take it up and exercise it because you know, when you put everything on
- 2:17:45the men and then you still get to vote, you are more willing to
- 2:17:50vote to make those sacrifices. It's easier to sacrifice something that somebody else has
- 2:17:54to pay than when you have obligation, even if it's not the same sacrifice.
- 2:18:00Yeah, so that's my conclusion. So let me know what you think,
- 2:18:05you guys, let us know in the comments what what would you think
- 2:18:07would be the ideal way to handle equal obligation in terms of UH military obligation
- 2:18:18in wartime and service obligation in in in the country in order to justify equal
- 2:18:26voting rights. And with that, thanks everybody for listening, Thanks to my
- 2:18:35awesome co host for for for contributing to the conversation and being here for all
- 2:18:41of the weird stuff that we went through tonight. And thanks to everybody who
- 2:18:46works in the background to make HBr Talk happen. Good idol, Good night,
- 2:18:50y'all. We'll see you next Thursday. See you next Thursday.