Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Putting Together An Ohio State All-Decade Team From The 2000s
Transcript
- 0:01Hello, everybody, Welcome to the buck Eye Weekly Podcast. I am Tony
- 0:04Gerdeman here as always with Tom or Tom. How's it going, Oh,
- 0:12Tony, we are continuing our series on the best Ohio State like the old
- 0:16decade Ohio State teams. The question that Isaac McIntyre asked us a few weeks
- 0:21ago that we thought, oh, this would be a good series of shows.
- 0:23So here's the second one of these series. And Tony, I think
- 0:26my big takeaway is the two thousands team was a little upsetting because it's all
- 0:32guys that feel like that was that guy just finished playing just a few years
- 0:35ago, and it's like, oh, that was in some cases more than
- 0:39twenty years ago. It's like you go to the grocery store or the gas
- 0:42station or whatever, and there's a little sign, the little digital sign that
- 0:45you you know, you must be born after you know, before this date
- 0:47to buy cigarettes or beer or whatever, and it's like, oh, that's
- 0:53some of that says two thousand and two. Now, like, oh boy,
- 0:56that's um the march of time, Amas undefeated, Tony and so in
- 1:00fact were some of the players on this team. So it should be should
- 1:03be a fun, fun team to go through yes time. In fact,
- 1:07there are children of members of this team on the current Ohio State football team,
- 1:12or at least one child as far as we know. And yes,
- 1:17it was a very very very long time ago, but the galaxy was right
- 1:22here. So that's good. You know, it's it was you know,
- 1:25it was close. It was a long time ago, but it was it
- 1:27was very very near. So let's get this started. Our all decade team
- 1:32from the two thousands will start at quarterback. There is one answer time.
- 1:36That answer is Scott McMullan, Grandville's own Scott McMullan. No, it was
- 1:41I went with I went. You know, I said in a lot of
- 1:44show, the first thing you do is you go, okay, who won
- 1:47the highest been great? That guy is on this team, and in that
- 1:49case that is Troy Smith, who had a really really he was He started
- 1:56his career just the absolute forgotten man. I was working in TV when you
- 2:01know, the class of two thousand recruits showed up and you know, he
- 2:06did the whole thing where they walked through the you know, into the hotel
- 2:08and all that kind of stuff. Yes, that has been a thing that
- 2:10long, and everyone was, you know, rushing over to justin's Wick.
- 2:15And then the guy who was the last player in the class who was like
- 2:20listed as a quarterback, but let's be honest, he's just an athlete,
- 2:22is you know, like whatever, we'll you know, maybe he'll return some
- 2:24cakes at some point was Troy Smith. And then in two thousand and four,
- 2:30you know, it was not a great season for Ohio State, but
- 2:34then had his real breakout game against Michigan that year upset in Michigan denied them.
- 2:38I think he denied them the outright Big Ten championship with that just incredible
- 2:42performance against Michigan. And then you know, had the agent thing and missed
- 2:47some time at the beginning of the year, and probably the fact that they
- 2:52were shuffling quarterbacks in that Texas game probably kept them from winning that game.
- 2:55And but then you know really kind of sees that job later on in that
- 3:00two thousand and five season, and then won the Heisman in two thousand and
- 3:01six, and you know goes down as the you know what now would be
- 3:07just sort of an average or maybe slightly below average level of offensive production,
- 3:12but back then was earth shattering. You know, can you believe this offense
- 3:15is so much more efficient and explosive than the ninety eight Ohio State offenses.
- 3:23That was That was Troy Smith was, you know, the trigger man for
- 3:25all of that stuff. Yeah, they were. They were running a spread
- 3:30offense in two thousand and six and they'd have four wide and I think it
- 3:34led to about twenty five yards passing for Troy Smith. I think thirty touchdowns,
- 3:38six interceptions, and basically Jim Tressell was the only guy who could stop
- 3:44Troy Smith that year. Penn State they had some success, but yeah,
- 3:47he was. He was fantastic and he's the only answer there now. In
- 3:53the last show, Tom I said, I went running back and fullback in
- 3:59the two thousands because I did it in the nineties, and then in two
- 4:01thousand and tens, I go one running back, three wide receivers. You
- 4:05have chosen to go two running backs sands fullback. Here? Is that correct?
- 4:11I have. I feel like the fullback kind of phased out midway through
- 4:14the decade, but they weren't really running three wides for the whole decade either,
- 4:18so I felt like this was kind of a compromise. You know,
- 4:20We've had a lot of time to think about it since the last time we
- 4:24recorded, so I you know, but I've decided I'm right on this and
- 4:27you're wrong, so because well then I'll just throw my fallback out there.
- 4:30That would be Jamar Martin, who was I think that the best of that
- 4:34era, and it was a throwback for sure. Special credit to Brandon Joe
- 4:40for being being there and being instrumental in the win against Michigan in two thousand
- 4:45and four as a tailback whatever. But I just you know, I there
- 4:49are two running backs from the two thousands that I have here, and before
- 4:54we get to them time, before I let you get to them, I
- 4:57will say Antonio Pittman deserves some consideration here. He does. He's one of
- 5:02those really underappreciated Ohio State players because he sort of fell between the two guys
- 5:08that I've got at the running back position and just sort of I think,
- 5:12you know, we talked about this a little bit the last time with Corey
- 5:15Stringer is maybe a little underappreciated because he was succeeded by Orlando Pace so quickly
- 5:19that everyone just sort of moved on to Orlando Pace and forgot about Corey Stringer
- 5:23to a certain degree. I think Antonio Pittman's a little bit in that boat
- 5:26too, because you know, he followed a pretty good running back in two
- 5:30thousand two. There was not a lot of running in two thousand and three,
- 5:32but then Antonio Pittman shows up, and you know it was a really
- 5:36really effective runner for them for a couple of years and then but you know,
- 5:42you had the five star immediately after him as well. So he just
- 5:46kind of, I think is one of those really underappreciated Ohio State players.
- 5:49But you know, go back and watch the Fiesta Bowl against Notre Dame,
- 5:54like he has the game ceiling run there. He has a big touchdown run
- 5:56against Michigan in two thousand and six, right, uh, you know he
- 6:02five five. Um, you know he's he's had he had some he had
- 6:06some really really big moments and was a very very productive player and you know
- 6:11didn't was you know, did not have a long NFL career. He's actually
- 6:14a fireman now. But you know he's he's someone all I think is not
- 6:19necessarily you pull I said, you mentioned last time you pull the average person,
- 6:24the average Ohio State fan off the street and asked them about the best
- 6:26running back in the two thousands. I think they're gonna say two names and
- 6:29not necessarily think of anyone else as a serious contender. I would have him
- 6:31as a contender certainly, but didn't have him as one of my top two.
- 6:36Yeah. I think the answers here then would be Maurice Clarette and Beanie
- 6:41Wells. And for my money, the first time I saw, like watching
- 6:45Murice Clarette in two thousand and two, he was the best running back in
- 6:47Ohio state history and in my opinion, and then seeing what Beanie Wells did
- 6:55in two thousand and seven, he that put him above. But when you
- 7:01look at their respective careers, if you need one guy that you can count
- 7:08on for one year, I'm not I'm not sure that the answer isn't Antonio
- 7:14Pittman because Maurice Claret had injuries, Beanie Wells had injuries when those two were
- 7:18at their best. Sure, and those are the two answers. I just
- 7:24think if if you you want to be sure that you're going to get thirteen,
- 7:29fourteen, fifteen games out of somebody, Antonio Pittman might be the correct
- 7:32answer based on the injury history of both of those players. Yeah. I
- 7:36mean, Clarette in two thousand and two was just kind of like playing.
- 7:41He had that shoulder thing, and just was just constantly playing half of games,
- 7:45and you know, you'd see him go out with the d that right
- 7:48arm dangling again, and you know, just he was so incredible when he
- 7:54was out there. But then when he wasn't, boy, that team took
- 7:57a big step back. And then wells he had that it was a broken
- 8:00bot bone in his foot or something right before that UCLA game in two thousand
- 8:03and eight, that just they had lost that game before they got on the
- 8:05plane. Like people talk about that the same way they talk about when Keith
- 8:09Buyers broke a bone in his foot in the nineteen eighty what five season,
- 8:15Just you know, it just an injury that really derails the whole season because
- 8:18it's such a crucial player for you. So yeah, I mean, I
- 8:22guess we're kind of defining two different kinds of things here. Who would you
- 8:26have if you, you know, you need to rely in this player ear
- 8:28to win you know, an entire season versus one game. But you know,
- 8:33I think all three of those guys are absolutely worth you know, having
- 8:37having in this conversation as we're as we're talking about the best players at Ohio
- 8:41State in the decade and nobody made the first guy miss better than Murray's claret.
- 8:46Nobody got to the second level and then playanted a defender better than Beanie
- 8:50Wells. So those are the two interests there. I am interested to hear
- 8:54your receivers because this is you know, Michael Jenkins, the all time receiving
- 9:01yardage leader in Ohio State history, was never first team All Big Ten,
- 9:07and he was one of the rare thousand yard receivers, especially back then for
- 9:11Ohio State. I think he was the fourth behind Chris Carter, Terry Glenn,
- 9:16and David Boston, and then Paris Campbell became the fifth in twenty eighteen.
- 9:22But I don't have Jenkins as one of my two. I instead have
- 9:30Ted Gin Jr. And Santonio Holmes, And every time I'm doing a list,
- 9:35I initially forget about Santonio Holmes until I see him, like, oh,
- 9:37he has to be there, because he was as good as anny Ohio
- 9:41State receiver. Ever, in my opinion, in terms of just after the
- 9:46catch, playing bigger than this position, was a fantastic punt returner, and
- 9:50I think an underrated guy, but also the number ten overall draft pick by
- 9:54the Steelers in two thousand and five, maybe in two six, two thousand
- 10:01and six. So I went with Gin and Holmes as my two, and
- 10:09I ted Gin never had a thousand yards. I think it like nine hundred
- 10:13and thirty some yards and two thousand and six, and that's just the era
- 10:20he was playing in, so that doesn't I don't hold him responsible for that
- 10:26basically, and I think that's a reasonable case to make. And I certainly
- 10:30would have had Gin and Holmes as two of my top three. I went
- 10:35with Jenkins and Holmes. I think Michael Jenkins, you know, who is
- 10:37Michael Jenkins playing with as a quarterback and supporting cast on some of those offenses
- 10:43that he was on, Versus who was Ted Gin playing on his offenses with,
- 10:46especially towards the end of his career, and Jenkins was super productive.
- 10:50Jenkins was a first first round NFL pick, just like the other two guys
- 10:54were. I went with Jenkins because I can get Ted Gin on this team
- 10:58in another way to other ways in fact, and we'll get to those labels.
- 11:01Don't worry, uh, you know, I think I think you know,
- 11:05and really you think about Ted gin career highlights, you think of Michael
- 11:07Jenkins career highlights everyone. I say, Michael Jenkins career highlights. Everyone right
- 11:11now, one percent of the audience is thinking the same play. And it
- 11:15was one of the most iconic plays in Ohio state history. Plus he had
- 11:18the productivity, you know, over the years, playing in an offense that
- 11:20was not a very productive offense, and for long stretches of the season.
- 11:24So I had him there, Santonio Holmes, you know that that's an easy
- 11:28one to me. M Gin was Gin was great. Gin was, you
- 11:33know, certainly one of the most dynamic and explosive players in Ohio state history.
- 11:37I go, you know, everyone thinks about the Ted Gin punt return
- 11:39against Michigan, or the Ted Gin the long touchdown pass against Notre Dame,
- 11:45or the end around against Notre Dame in that Fiesta ball where he's he picks
- 11:50up like ten yards of he gains ten yards on Doug Daddish in the span
- 11:54of about three yards, like it's it's one of the funniest gifts if you
- 11:58have. If you ever find that video clip of him running an end around
- 12:01against Notre Dame in the two thousand, it would have been six Fiesta Bowl
- 12:05him running past Doug Dadash like Doug Dadash is running his butt off so far
- 12:09downfield. That's an incredible play, and he's just this like he's just like
- 12:13this prop for ted Gin to run around that. This is one of my
- 12:16favorite gifts or video clips in Ohio State history. But you know, you
- 12:20look at Gin and you know the game that always reminded that sticks out to
- 12:24me was it was like the two thousand and four I think Michigan State game
- 12:28up in East Lansing and Ohio State did virtually nothing all game but one because
- 12:33ted Gin had one touchdown on an end around, you know, running the
- 12:37ball, hit a touchdown on a punt return, and he had a touchdown
- 12:41where Michigan State. I don't know what Michigan State was thinking, but they're
- 12:45like, Ted gain, go ahead and split our safeties. We're gonna play
- 12:48him real close to the wine for you. And he did and had a
- 12:50like a sixty yard fifty yard touchdown with maybe a minute left to win the
- 12:54game. So yeah, plenty, plenty of great moments for ted Gin as
- 12:56a wide receiver. But you know, like I said, I can I
- 13:00can get him on the team later. Yeah, No, that's a very
- 13:01good point. And Michael Jenkins. Having Steve bellisarians and Craig Krenzell as his
- 13:07quarterbacks not the best way to go about being productive. That Alamo ball for
- 13:13Ted Ginn was also awesome, the different things that he did tight end.
- 13:16For me, it comes down to two guys, and I went with Ben
- 13:20Hartsock over Jake Ballard. Hart Sock has been around, you know, he
- 13:26was he was a productive receiver, was thirty se catches in two thousand and
- 13:33three, was obviously very much part of the offense in two thousand and two.
- 13:37So I went with him as the ninety two thousands tight end. Yeah,
- 13:41I think he's one of those guys where, you know, anytime you're
- 13:43talking about tight end productivity, you get the since Ben Hartsock, you know,
- 13:50caveat, you know, he's it's the biggest Ohio State seat were receiving
- 13:54season for a tight end since Ben Hartsock. We've we've said that dozens of
- 13:58times over the last few years. And yeah, I think that I think
- 14:01that pretty much answers the question for me. Very productive guy went on to
- 14:05a nice NFL career now a broadcaster. He Yeah, I think he's I
- 14:09think he's was a pretty easy choice for me. Jake Ballard had some moments.
- 14:13Jake Ballard had a big, big catch in the two thousand and ten
- 14:18Rose Bowl two thousand and nine season, but Tony unfortunately happened one day too
- 14:22late to qualify for the two thousands team. So sorry, that's a tough
- 14:24break, but nothing nothing we can do about it. Tough but fair.
- 14:28The offensive line, I'll go here with the left tackle, Alex Boone,
- 14:33the only all Big ten left tackle and the two thousands there were there were
- 14:37not a lot of all Big ten guys, but you know I can.
- 14:43I'll say Alex Boone, I do want to give a I'll move to left
- 14:46guard real quick and go with Rob Simmons. But also a special consideration shout
- 14:52out to Mike Stafford, he walked on left guard from the two thousand and
- 14:56two team, who was one of the best guards in Ohio State history and
- 15:01was very instrumental in Murice Clarette getting to that second level and getting through that
- 15:05hall and was a very valuable member of that team before he got hurt and
- 15:11then suddenly the running game struggled as well. Yeah, he's he's one of
- 15:15those great you know, Ohio State has these you know, you have all
- 15:18these incredible players, and you're recruiting players from all across the nation, and
- 15:22then you've got to walk on offensive guard from Robber Arlington, who is like
- 15:26one of the like this secret weapon on this incredible two thousand two Ohio state
- 15:28teams. So yeah, I have Sims there as well. I had Boon
- 15:31there as well. I think those are those are good easy picks. I
- 15:35don't I don't think you're going to get much argument on either of them.
- 15:39I went with Nick Mangold at center over La Charles Bentley and Nick Mangold.
- 15:45He was he didn't start in two thousand and two, but he eventually took
- 15:48the job over and then he was a starter for the rest of his career,
- 15:50was an All American, ends up being a first rounder. I think
- 15:54that's a very very solid pick. I went with Alex Depanovich at right guard,
- 16:00Shane Olivier right tackle. I just think the two thousand and two offensive
- 16:03line is well represented here Olivia with the you know, winning a national championship.
- 16:08So that was my the middle and the right side of my offensive line.
- 16:12Yeah, and I have La Charles Bentley slash Nick mangolden center. This
- 16:17is this is one of these. Don't make me choose, please, They're
- 16:19they're both so good I had I'd like I like both of those guys as
- 16:23a pick, and you can you can take your choice. I mean,
- 16:26la Charles Bentley is now viewed as this offensive line guru who's taught you know,
- 16:30hundreds of players. He's got an offensive line academy down in Arizona,
- 16:34and you know, he was he was someone whose NFL career was cut short
- 16:37by injuries, but he was, you know, a dominant player at Ohio
- 16:41State. And Mangold. You know, Nick Mangold was a multi year starter
- 16:45at Ohio State and was you know, a like borderline NFL Hall of Famer.
- 16:48I think so he's you know, either of those guys. I don't
- 16:53think you can go wrong with either of them. Stepanovitch didn't Stepanovitch play center
- 16:57on the night on the two thousand and two team. He was a guard
- 17:00before that, right, Yeah, and then I think he let me I'll
- 17:03bring it up. I think he may have moved to guard then in two
- 17:07thousand and three, three, yeah, when Mangold took over. Yeah,
- 17:11but I mean that's that whole offensive line that was one of those, and
- 17:15Olivier too, is part of that conversation where it's just that whole offensive line
- 17:18was just so good, and you had this You're going up against this Miami
- 17:22defense and this incredible, this incredible dominant Miami defense that's just completely dominated people
- 17:27all season and and they just get completely held to a stalemate in Ohio State.
- 17:33The offensive line was just so solid, and I think all of those
- 17:36guys ended up in the NFL. Stepanovitch went to the Cardinals, Olivier went
- 17:41to the Chargers, Mangold to the Jets, Rob Simmons to the Seahawks.
- 17:45I mean just that was just such a such a talented offensive line all the
- 17:49way across the deck. And you know, you can you can win ugly
- 17:52if you can control the line of scrimmage, and they can control the line
- 17:56of scrimmage against pretty much anyone. So that was, Yeah, I think
- 17:59that's you could almost take that whole unit and just kind of throw them in
- 18:02there and I'd be kind of okay with it. But you know, Bentley
- 18:04and Boone I think definitely deserve to be talked about in that conversation as well.
- 18:08It's pretty crazy, crazy to see the two thousand and two offensive line
- 18:11starting offensive line listed by Ohio State. Can you tell me the left tackle
- 18:15in the left guard as they have it listed as they have it listed because
- 18:22Rob Sims eventually took over at left tackle, if I recall, I don't
- 18:29know how they would have it listed. Ivan Douglas as your left tackle,
- 18:32Adrian Clark as your left guard? Adrian Clark Okay, Ivan Douglass, I
- 18:37don't think he played left tackle that much that season. Did Didn't he have
- 18:41blood clots or something? There was there was some kind of medical something that
- 18:45he had that he missed. I think they generally go with like whoever started
- 18:48the most games. But all right, yeah, I have to go back
- 18:52to all of the box scores and the player participations and clarify, and if
- 18:56it's wrong, I will certainly send an email sternly worded to Ohio State.
- 19:00Time. Let's move to defense, because this is there's some names here that
- 19:07are going to be left off, and also some lack of names on this
- 19:12defensive line as well. So defensive ends I think are pretty easy. I
- 19:17went with Will Smith and Vernon Gholston. I don't think you know both were
- 19:22first rounders. Both were fantastic. Will Smith was the original jack position had
- 19:27Ohio State because he would play defensive end. He would also stand up and
- 19:30move around like a middle linebacker at times later in his career just messing with
- 19:33people. Vernon Gholston had arguably that he was the Bosses before the Bosses.
- 19:38He was Chase Young before Chase Young had fourteen sacks in two thousand and six.
- 19:42I think, so I went with those two, which means there's no
- 19:48Darry and Scott. There's no Cam Hayward basically, and I know a lot
- 19:51of people Cam Hayward played defensive tackle. He was a defensive end at Ohio
- 19:53State. Just to clarify for people, because I for some reason, I
- 19:56obviously he's a big guy. A lot of people always mentioned him as a
- 20:02defensive tackle, but defensive end at Ohio State. And he's not going to
- 20:07make my list because Will Smith and Vernon Golston do. Yeah, and Vernon
- 20:11Golston is one of those guys who I think the lack of productivity in the
- 20:15NFL. People look at that and go, he wasn't that good, and
- 20:18it's like, well you should. You should have watched him in college,
- 20:19because man, he was that good in college, especially that last season.
- 20:22I always when I think at Vernon Golston, I always think of the great
- 20:26Jim Davidson photo of him standing over Chad Henny, you know, one of
- 20:30the one of the great classics in that in that genre. But he,
- 20:34yeah, he was. That was one of the most dominant single seasons in
- 20:37Ohio State history. And Will Smith was just I think he was a multi
- 20:41year All American and if not, he should have been. He was.
- 20:42You know, again, like that Miami team in two thousand and two,
- 20:47the that Ohio State they were not ready for what that Ohio State defense was
- 20:51bringing that day. And Will Smith I think was a big, a big
- 20:53part of that. But yeah, two really dominant ends. And you know,
- 20:59I don't know if either of them would have made the twenty tens team
- 21:03if they were going up against that group, but you know that that's a
- 21:06pretty stack stack team. But yeah, that is Those are two two very
- 21:10easy choices for me. I won't get into a navern that's twenty tens.
- 21:12We could spend an hour on the defensive ends alone, and how could you
- 21:17not have this guy on? Well, it's a simple thing of mathematics.
- 21:18There's only two allowed, and there's eight guys defensive tackles that two thousand and
- 21:25two team. Is why, and I'll let you have the All American is
- 21:29why I have Kenny Peterson as one of my defensive tackles. Now, dari
- 21:33and Scott moved to defensive tackle in two thousand and three and was really good.
- 21:37Tim Anderson, I think was the only other defensive tackle that was an
- 21:40All Big ten guy and the two thousands for Ohio State. But Kenny Peterson,
- 21:45Miami could not handle him inside, so I went with him. But
- 21:51there's not a lot of guys to pair with the first guy, Yeah,
- 21:56Quinn Picock was an All American, So I think that's that's why you just
- 21:59sort of you're right that one in and pen and you move on. He's
- 22:03someone he was out of pick what I believe, and just you know,
- 22:07not on the you know, not not a you know, the the most
- 22:12memorable Ohio State teams. He was not like the big starter for any of
- 22:15the super super memorable Ohio State teams in the two thousands, but a really
- 22:21really impactful player on the injury of the defensive line that you know, that's
- 22:23one of those spots where you're not going to put up fourteen sacks in a
- 22:26season, but you can still dominate a game without putting up monster numbers.
- 22:30And that was kind of how he how he did, and he was you
- 22:33know, he got picked by the cults. I think he might have been
- 22:34a first rounder as well. But you know, this is just you're an
- 22:37All American and you get picked pretty high by the NFL. That's a lot
- 22:41of validation that, yes, you belong on this list. Next to him,
- 22:44I put Tim Anderson. I thought Tim Anderson was really underappreciated, you
- 22:48know, just someone who just shoot up that middle of that offensive line on
- 22:52you know, those dominant early two thousands Ohio State defensive lines. But you
- 22:57know, I can't I can't really argue with your choice either. No,
- 23:02and Tim Anderson is perfectly acceptable and one of those guys that will do whatever
- 23:07you need and every coach once won, So I'm good. I'm certainly good
- 23:11with that linebackers. To me, I think this is I think this is
- 23:17very easy based on the All Americans. And I have three first teamers.
- 23:22I have a j Hawk, I have met Wilhelm, and I have three
- 23:25time All American James Laura Nias. To me, there's some other guys,
- 23:30but they don't compare to the accolades of those are guys, the awards of
- 23:34those three guys, the impact of those are guys. Met Wilhelm in two
- 23:38thousand and two was a machine for that team. He was in the backfield,
- 23:42he was calling plays, he was raking Havoc. James Laura Nitis was,
- 23:48as I said, free time All American burst out to the scene in
- 23:51two thousand and six against Texas. I think Brett Musburger made him a star
- 23:55at that point. And you know, he made plays. He was around
- 23:57the football. I'm still not sure I've ever seen a better linebacker at Ohio
- 24:02State than aj Hawk. He was complete. Even as a true freshman for
- 24:07the Buck guys in two thousand two had maybe thirty or forty tackles, an
- 24:11interception for a touchdown was eight. Eventually became a part of the defense.
- 24:15And so those three guys, to me, were I'll stack them up against
- 24:18any decade. Yeah, those are three. Those are three very easy choices.
- 24:22And what's interesting to me about these guys is I don't remember what Matt
- 24:26help Wilhelm's recruiting ranking was, but a j Hawk was I think a three
- 24:30star. James Lauraitis was I think a three star like these were not the
- 24:33aj Hawk was not the big star of his recruiting class at linebacker. He
- 24:38came in the same year as Mike Deandria and Bobby Carpenter, and Hawk was
- 24:44just kind of like and Mike Coudla and Mike Coudla too, Yeah, Dan
- 24:48White, yep yeph and so he was like this kind of forgotten men.
- 24:52I told the Justin's Wick Troy Smith story earlier. Mike Deandria was the guy
- 24:56we we at the TV station took the hell copter up to Avon Lake to
- 25:02get go to Mike Deandrea's signing day. I don't know that we covered Ajayhawks
- 25:04signing day that year, even though it was down in Centerville. I mean,
- 25:07it's just that's that is. You know what that team, you know
- 25:12what that recruiting class was Deandrew, it was the supers deender. It was
- 25:17a superstar in the making. And then just gut Gut derailed by injuries and
- 25:21Hawk was just Hawk was just a football player. And James Lore and Knight
- 25:25the same thing. Just a just an incredible football player. Um Wilhelm was,
- 25:29you know, really the guy in the middle in that Miami in that
- 25:33two thousand and two defense that that first drive comes in stuffs Willis mcgay.
- 25:38He does the diamond cutter that Willis mcgay he did. And it was like,
- 25:41oh, they came to play tonight, and uh yeah that those those
- 25:45three I those are those are the same thing I had. I just thought
- 25:48it was very interesting that, you know, you look all these all these
- 25:52guys, all these incredible recruits at Ohio State had and it's like a bunch
- 25:56of three stars. And I don't remember what Matt Wilhelm was coming out of
- 25:59high school, but I don't know that they had recruiting services when Matt Helm
- 26:03came out of came out of high school. But yeah, that is interesting
- 26:07industring me that those those guys came with so little hype and turned into so
- 26:11such great players. Matt Well fifteen tackles for loss in two thousand and then
- 26:18in two thousand and two had nineteen and a half and just a machine.
- 26:22As I said, Corners, Tom, I'm gonna give you two, and
- 26:27I'm going to feel pretty good about them, and I'll take them maybe against
- 26:30anybody. Chris Gamble and Malcolm Jenkins. I'm set. I don't need to
- 26:36say anymore. I'll sit and listen. Yeah, I think you've probably got
- 26:41it there. I thought about asking your bodie too. He was he was
- 26:45really good as a corner. But you know, Chris Gamble just such impactful
- 26:49plays, just you know, when you needed a play when you needed to
- 26:53when the offense wasn't doing anything. Against Penn State, Chris Gamble was there
- 26:57to make a play on the defensive the ball when you needed to get the
- 27:02game ceiling interception against Cincinnati. Didn't know he had a kick return in the
- 27:07Cincinnati game. Now, we'll alle had the game sailing interception against Cincinnati,
- 27:11but Gamble had in the end zone against Gambel had one in the in the
- 27:14end zone late in the game. I don't think it was like the last
- 27:15play of the game or anything, but yeah, I mean it's just he
- 27:18just he had the big plays. He you know, I think you got
- 27:22to give him a little bonus for playing both ways. But yeah, just
- 27:25I mean and turned it turned came to a high state as a wide receiver,
- 27:27turned into a first round pick as a corner. Yeah, I think
- 27:30he's I think He's a great choice there. One of the single greatest just
- 27:36pure athletes in Ohio State history. That is they just it was just kind
- 27:41of like, well, we need a corner, okay, um you and
- 27:45just went out and turned into one of the most dominant players in the country
- 27:48at that position, just basically overnight. It's that's one of those things that
- 27:52was Who's a big story back then. I can't even imagine what kind of
- 27:55story it would be now if if if it, you know, you had
- 27:57a player do that. If you know this year Cardinal Tate just gets moved
- 28:00to corner and immediately turns in one of the most dominant players in the country,
- 28:03I think I think people's heads would explode. Yeah. I think these
- 28:07two corners maybe the most clutch corners and Ohio State in the last three decades
- 28:12because Malcolm Jenkins would have a pick six every year against Penn State. Like
- 28:17there, you know, he made plays, he was always around the ball.
- 28:21So those two guys were incredible. The safeties here, there's there's one
- 28:26easy answer, and I'll throw Mike DAWs out there. That's he's three time
- 28:30All American. I always have a special place in my heart from Will Allen,
- 28:34the way he was, how valuable he was in two thousand and two,
- 28:37and then he was an All American in two thousand and three. But
- 28:40I think the right answer here is Dante Whitner. Yeah, I guess.
- 28:45I mean, unless you doing free safety strong safety, then Will Allen is
- 28:48perfect. Yeah, I think Will. I think Will Allen is my choice
- 28:51here just just because I mean, Dante Whitner was a great player, and
- 28:53he was I think a top ten pick for the Bills. If not,
- 28:56it was like top fifteen pick for the Bills. But man, Will Allen
- 29:02just the most. He talked about how clutched the corners were, how many
- 29:07how many games did Will Allen win with a play, you know, right
- 29:11at the gun? The interception against Michigan in two thousand and two he had
- 29:15to tackle at the goal line on Ta McClendon. And against North Carolina State
- 29:18in two thousand and three. I mean, like these incredible down to the
- 29:22last play games where you know, Ohio State is, you know, either
- 29:26going to win or lose based on what Will Allen does right here, and
- 29:30he just seemed to always come up big. You know, I'm not going
- 29:34to fight you on Dante Whitner. But man, I think when I think
- 29:37of Ohio State safety two thousands, I think Mike DAWs and I think Will
- 29:42Ellen. I think Dante Whitner would be a great Nicol kind of because he
- 29:48was fantastic at blowing up screens and that, you know, But I think
- 29:51he might be a little redundant with Mike DAWs. In terms of the strong
- 29:53safety guy, Well, Allen, they would need a deep guy, and
- 29:57I have no problem with that because we talked about last landed defenses, We
- 30:00talked about cleaners and sweepers like that's that was Will Allen kickers here, I'm
- 30:07personally going with Mike Nugent and Andy Groom Andy Groom. I know b J.
- 30:11Sander won the Ray guy, but Andy Groom was He was Ray guy
- 30:17in two thousand and two. That guy was incredible. Mike Nugent not the
- 30:19kicker of the nineties, not very good in the nineties, much better in
- 30:23the two thousands. Nugent was. Nugent had the two thousand and one season
- 30:29where he had looked looked awful, looked like where did they get this guy?
- 30:36And then just two thousand and two just showed up and just was automatic.
- 30:38And was just automatic for the next three years. Picked boy he got
- 30:42was he a first rounder by the Jets? He got picked supercilly but second
- 30:45rounder by the Jets. Okay, uh just got picked. That That tells
- 30:49you exactly how dominant he was in college. And you know, we've talked
- 30:53about clutch. We've talked about you know, I mean, no one,
- 30:56no one was more clutch than Mike Nugent. Just you know, I was.
- 31:00I always think back to not not the greatest season, not the greatest
- 31:03game, but the fifty five yard or at the gun against Marshall in two
- 31:07thousand and four. Just it was just one of those He's running out there
- 31:10and everyone in the stadium is gone, not never in doubt, just go
- 31:12ahead and get your car keys out. He's going to hit it. And
- 31:15he did. He was just he was clutch. Groom was incredible. One
- 31:19of my favorite stories from the two thousand and two season was, you know,
- 31:22after the Fiesta Bowl, Remember they ran that fake field goal, and
- 31:26it was like Groom and Nugent running the option, and you know after the
- 31:30game that they were talking, you know, like Groom was basically saying,
- 31:34if I got one more block, I was gone. And Nugent's gone.
- 31:37If he had pitched to me, I was gone. And just you know,
- 31:41it's it's a funny story now because they won the game. That could
- 31:45have that could have been very bad had they not won the game, but
- 31:48uh, yeah it was. You know, those are those are two guys
- 31:49where if you want to play trestle ball, you've got to really be just
- 31:56perfect at the margins you've got. You can't miss field goals. If you're
- 31:59going to try and win every game by a field goal, you have to
- 32:01be able to down those punts inside the five yard line if you're gonna try
- 32:05and punt and play field position. And those were guys who let Jim Tressell
- 32:08play Tressell ball and ended up fourteen. And now, yeah, my mistake.
- 32:14I was thinking Mike Nugent was like a true freshman in ninety nine when
- 32:16he was kicking the ball into the tunnel. But that was that was later
- 32:21in his career or he started later than that, I should say. Anyway,
- 32:24the kickoff return punt return guy, I'm gonna go with the same guy,
- 32:29and I'm gonna go with Ted gin Junior, who had four punt returns
- 32:31as a true freshman in two thousand and four, only only finished with two
- 32:37I think kickoff returns in his career at Ohio State, which is still this
- 32:42still ties the school record two career kickoff returns, the most criminally, I
- 32:45shouldn't say criminally the most underutilized offensive player in Ohio State football history. Ted
- 32:51Gin Junior, my kick and mine punt returner. Yeah, he's this is
- 32:55I think one of the easiest choices you could have on any any of these
- 32:59teams at any position where I mean, Ohio State has not run a kickoff
- 33:04back for a touchdown since two thousand and what ten, Right, the two
- 33:07thousand and ten Michigan game was the last time they ran a kickoff back for
- 33:09a touchdown. And when Ted Gin was back there, every time the ball
- 33:13went in there like, oh this is this is definitely going to go.
- 33:15And like you said, I think he had hit one against Indian and one
- 33:19against Minnesota, I think. But you know, punt returns, he had
- 33:22you said four punt return touchdowns in two thousand and four. Oh, in
- 33:25two thousand and four, Okay, yeah, yeah, he was just he
- 33:29was just incredible. They they that's that's a you know, he punt returns.
- 33:35Highsted hasn't returned a punt for a touchdown since two thousand and fourteen.
- 33:37Right was up Jaylen Marshallvins Indiana was the last time they returned to punt for
- 33:40a touchdown, I believe. So basically, yeah, you've gone basically a
- 33:45decade without doing it, and Ted Gin did it six times in three years.
- 33:50That's uh, I mean, boy, that's uh. That that is
- 33:53a remarkably remarkably talented guy who just was so much better at those two things.
- 34:00And you know, like you said, boy, you put him on
- 34:02a Ryan Day era offense or you just you know, you any kind of
- 34:08even some of the Urban Meyer offenses. You put him on anytime since Ryan
- 34:12Day got there. How about that? You put him put him on the
- 34:15team with you know, justin justin Fields in twenty nineteen, twenty and twenty,
- 34:21Like, boy, oh boy, that's what could that guy do?
- 34:23That? That feels like you put him out there that swings the Clumson game.
- 34:28You put him out there, you know that just you just you're so
- 34:30much, you're so dominant. And you look at the two thousand and six
- 34:34season, the way that ended with him returning a kickoff for a touchdown against
- 34:37Florida and then breaking his breaking a bone in his foot, and that's that
- 34:40was just kind of the end of that game, like, oh well,
- 34:43we had our whole game plan based around him, and now he's not here,
- 34:45so um, now what? And there was there was no answer.
- 34:51One of my favorite stats still is that freshman year he returned fifteen points.
- 34:55He averaged twenty five point six yards per punt return. That is the most
- 35:00and the best average in school history for a season. The second most is
- 35:05eighteen point seven yards per return, so he's like seven yards better than what
- 35:09used to be the best of all time. And he was incredible. Absolutely,
- 35:15So there you go. The Ohio State football team of the two thousands,
- 35:22the aughts, if you will, as they are called, and a
- 35:25lot of good guys. They are a lot of a lot of first rounders
- 35:30and some very talented guys, and I'm interested to see how they fare moving
- 35:34forward when we start to divvythings up and compare and contrast. But that will
- 35:37do it for this episode. I want to thank you all for joining joining
- 35:42us. I hope you're enjoying the series. We still have a little bit
- 35:45more to go. Move it into modern times. Enough with this black and
- 35:49white stuff, so feel free to join us at Buckeye huddle dot com,
- 35:52end us up on a message board, let us know what you think.
- 35:54Also, feel free to rate and review this all of your podcast platforms of
- 35:59choice. And if you're watching this on YouTube, goad and hit the thumbs
- 36:01up, give us a light, go and subscribe. If you haven't hit
- 36:04the battle to be notified, find us however you can and tell us what
- 36:07you think. So thank you all for tuning in and we'll talk to you guys later