Latest / Pedagogically Speaking / Here's What This Year Taught Me About Teaching
Transcript
- Ilana: I think what really changed my thinking this year has been about leadership. At beginning of this school year, I thought I knew what the challenges facing education was, and I would have talked about them passionately. I thought I knew what students needed. I thought I knew what the teachers I worked with needed, but this year some of my long beliefs. Not because changed, but because I kept seeing the same patterns ⁓ over and again, only in a scale. things have changed my this year. compensation absolutely matters. Working conditions, of course, matter the benefits ⁓ you know being able to mental health supports ⁓ to for a massage or physio ⁓ all of those things are important but really like ⁓ after more than a decade a half in ⁓ education really especially the last years I'm really convinced that leadership is one the Inclusion requires more support than we are providing. Movement and regulation more ⁓ most people think or give credit to. And leadership has a much bigger impact on teacher attention than most people are willing to accept. If we're to improve education, we need to be willing to change our minds when the evidence is right in front of us. biggest factors in whether teachers stay education, stay out school, whether they are thriving, or whether they're looking for a way out. A lot of you feeling that way. are emailing me and I really appreciate all the messages and the emails that you're sending me ⁓ because it's nice to know that, we're not alone in this. We need to be willing to challenge our beliefs about ourselves. When we are confronted ⁓ student behaviors or learning patterns that make us uncomfortable. You know, you want to feel seen as a teacher, you want to be acknowledged, you want to be appreciated recognized for everything that you're putting ⁓ your classroom and into the school. You want support and I think a lot of teachers themselves ⁓ ⁓ focused. learned for more a decade that creating a community, a sense of belonging in our classroom, helps students create You really want someone there to notice that you're putting in a lot of effort into what you're doing and into how you're teaching your class and into how you're creating those communities within your classroom. Helps create safe environments so that students can take risks with their learning, so that students can feel safe to challenge themselves, to not always get things right, to understand that there's bumps in the road with learning, and even to kind of understand that learning isn't linear. You're going to learn something, you're gonna forget it, you're gonna have to learn it again. And that's all okay. What's not okay is when your ego is directly tied. Someone like in leadership asking how you're doing and genuinely waiting for that answer, genuinely to hear what's happening ⁓ you and in your classroom and how you're with everything, you know, you want feel that the work that you're doing ⁓ matters and leadership plays significant role in creating that whole experience. to thinking that you can create a relationship with every student, to thinking that, the thing that makes me a good teacher is that I can build relationships with students. ⁓ there's lots of things that make you a great teacher. ⁓ unfortunately in 10 or 20 years you might find one student ⁓ you have a hard time connecting with ⁓ and okay. It shouldn't rock your world. And if it does, ⁓ you to just talk to someone then the is true. Micromanagement is damaging. Excessive ⁓ oversight, ⁓ important you that constant ⁓ It feels like such lack of of trust. And then there's the ending initiatives. Or write down all the other reasons why you know you're a great teacher, and keep that in mind. Because if you're not able to, like a colleague of mine, that can really upset system, especially if it's happening in a really high stakes time, like December report card writing. So remembering the reasons why you're a great teacher, and yes, creating relationships can be one of them, but ⁓ no one a hundred percent success rate, and that's okay. You know, you're a professional, teachers are professionals this idea of stacking things on more and more to do ⁓ exact same time, no extra prep time, no collaboration time, at least if you've got an ⁓ who ⁓ this and really if they are trying to ways ⁓ to it easier for you Another thing that really happened this year that I've talked about a lot on this podcast is the fact that, yes, relationships are important. But when people put pressure on you, You just need a relationship with a student, not taking into account that it's taken ⁓ more ⁓ one year. Maybe it's taken four years you create that relationship. ⁓ And it's still kind of rocky. Because that's just the of But even just that acknowledgement of it, finding a lot of times ⁓ well I'm busy too. And that's very ⁓ I to deal with because they're the leaders of the school, right? I think you know, teachers enter the profession because ⁓ of the deep caring have for students. Making sure students can trust you is that you have to cater to some of those whims it's hard for other people to come that. ⁓ And okay. That doesn't make you ⁓ not effective teacher. That doesn't mean you're all of a sudden not good at creating relationships. ⁓ It that ⁓ it take years to create a relationship with students ⁓ who have trauma. And as long as you just keep coming back and you And for learning as well, you know, and that professional trust, it matters. it disappears, when trust, ⁓ that that teachers are professionals, that understanding about teacher autonomy, when that is all out the door, morale follows it. And I you know. showing and being kind, even if ⁓ it seem to be working, that's fine. ⁓ Don't it personally. Okay? And if people are making you feel bad about that, ⁓ please think that has anything to do with you. Maybe people just need the reminders that, hey, ⁓ that relationship you a really long time. It's not gonna be able to I'm not gonna be able to do it in a week. Leadership really does shape the culture of the school. people willing to ⁓ of really stand by each other and make sure that you're doing okay and take that extra time? Or everyone just feel like No one cares, and then it shows up in your classroom, right? schools, when you walk into them, ⁓ it just feels like one of the most amazing teams that you can be a part of. It's supportive, ⁓ you Like people are helping each other solve their problems, they're ⁓ sharing When there's in in schools like that, it feels ⁓ absolutely collective, brings ⁓ everybody up. ⁓ And so, you know, both of those examples really show us how complex students are these days and the needs that they have. It's not just about teaching the curriculum, it's not about inspiring students ⁓ creating lifelong learners. There is so much more to teaching right now and it is getting more and more complex ⁓ our training is not reflecting that. I know that you want to support every learner in your classroom. I also know that you do not have the training necessary to do that. speaking about the trainings that you need, w trying to get to those trainings on pro D days, ⁓ getting school your school district to offer those trainings, ⁓ talking to that maybe have ⁓ experience in can be really helpful as well. I mean, have you walked into schools that felt like that? Have you also walked into schools that felt like it was just like a collection of individuals who just happened to be working beside each other? ⁓ certainly have experienced both. You know, some schools do develop extremely unhealthy, toxic cultures ⁓ gossip becomes normal. Where information is used as a currency, ⁓ know really spreads negativity and know, trust erodes. Collaboration breaks down you have pockets of people ⁓ who collaborate because trust each other. But ultimately unless you can do it on a pro D day or if you're lucky enough to have collab time, it is really hard to try to do that or after school. We do not have the time for ⁓ it. ⁓ we're about how education you know, we more complex students, we have more ⁓ needs in the and in our schools. And I just think it's so sad. It's also kind of interesting that the toxicity doesn't necessarily come from where people expect it to. It can be highly influential staff members who are contributing to those unhealthy norms. You know, sometimes high performers unintentionally create these environments that discourage others because you know culture is complex. We really also need to talk about the fact that when we talk about inclusion and it needing more than we're offering, EAs, education assistance or teacher assistance, I'm not sure what they're called for you, they are being stretched thin. need more teacher assistance or education assistance than we have. However, it's a very difficult role. ⁓ But at the end of the day, leadership does set the tone. And strong leaders, leaders who care about the entire school community, the entire staff, address concerns early. They create psychological ⁓ for while they're that professionalism. is starting to include more and more complex needs, behavioral needs, violence in schools, ⁓ be honest, the pay is not great, you Getting paid minute to minute and ⁓ the hourly wage, don't know that I would do it. I'm really grateful to the EAs out because they're so essential to learning in the classroom. But ⁓ that's tough And they create collective responsibility by about things in a very relational and human way of coming from things ⁓ with even. And that environments where people do respected and they do feel connected because ⁓ One thing that we hear a lot about is universal design for learning. How are you accessing student's ⁓ capabilities ⁓ your classroom? How are you ensuring that all the students learn? ⁓ it's so interesting because when I came up, so I've been teaching for 16 years, when I was coming up, ⁓ not in People don't stay at a school because it's perfect. I mean, sure, we could go on about perfection, but no perfect. People stay they feel valued and they feel seen. You stay when you feel trusted. You when there's a connection. Even if maybe you to leave because a school closer has a position ⁓ that you want. like university, but when I first started teaching, it was very it was very important. Like, well, you need to make sure that each you need to understand that there's no such thing as whole class lessons. We don't do textbooks anymore. You need to make sure that each individual student is learning. And I took that on completely. I was like, absolutely, because I was a student that really honestly had a really hard time in school. So I was super motivated teach students and in a way that I had never been taught that I knew that you might think twice before leaving because it is you do feel like you belong. There's that sense of community. There's a sense where we're all moving in the same direction. We're all pulling each other up. You know, like you don't want to go through your whole school career thinking you're dumb until you get to high school, right? And ⁓ so I really I super focused on that. I made sure I knew each I created learning profiles for each student in my classroom for I where they were at and ⁓ how to teach them and didn't do whole class learning because I didn't want to waste any students' time And when those conditions exist, you know, that's where teachers do their best work. So yeah, as I reflect today on this last day of school. I do think that these the three lessons that have changed my thinking the most. You know, requires more support than we're currently providing. Movement and regulation more in our classrooms for our students ⁓ for our ⁓ sanity. That is really difficult to ask every teacher to do. ⁓ We don't have the training for that. We don't have the time for that. Where's the to create 30 plus learning plans each individual student and update them throughout the year? There's no time for that. how can that get done? And I really think And leadership, true leadership has a profound impact teacher well-being and retention. I the common thread that's connecting three is is capacity. It certainly has been my theme this year. Students need support, need support, school communities need support, ⁓ and if we meaningful change, ⁓ we need systems match expectations with resources. ⁓ Are we matching the expectations we have of teachers with the adequate support and resources and time? know, this isn't ⁓ conversation about whether inclusion is important. It absolutely is. How do we get it to inclusion? ⁓ can we ensure that all students, no matter how come to us at school, are ⁓ having meaningful experiences ⁓ every So we really need to the philosophy of education ⁓ what realistically we can actually implement in our classrooms. And understand that the model that's given to us that is funded properly, it seems like it's like a good intention, but good intentions aren't ⁓ enough, I don't know. I finished my masters and ⁓ this podcast came out of that, I wonder if. you know, growth isn't about being right. It's about comfortable. ⁓ It's not defending own assumptions, you when there's no way to actually implement inclusion in the classroom in a way that supports all diverse learners and gives meaningful learning opportunities to everybody. You know, and then we don't always have the answers and we need to acknowledge that. I think acknowledge it deeply and ⁓ not this is my belief. I mean could try to change it if you want to, but this is ⁓ my belief that's where been for this amount of time. You know, that's not being open. It's about proving that always have the We wonder why teachers are burning out or quitting because teachers feel responsible for meeting the needs of the students that they aren't adequately s supported to actually meet those needs. happens when we keep ⁓ responsibilities ⁓ adding any capacity? But about ⁓ able to rethink what thought we knew. You know, what are things you're rethinking right When ⁓ Okay, let's switch it up and talk about movement and regulation. So they definitely matter. I've always known that they matter. I don't think I realized just how much they matter until I worked with two or just maybe three, actually three amazing colleagues this year that really helped me and gave me research to go over on just how much moving actually activates the brain. I always thought it was more about resting the brain, but I didn't realize it was actually about. We're in a space where we feel like we can listen we want to learn, when willing to let experiences change our minds. That's a really great place to be. Thanks so much for listening to this ⁓ episode Pedagogically Speaking. ⁓ If episode resonated with you, I'd love to hear what changed your thinking this year, ⁓ what challenged your assumptions, what lessons will you be carrying into next year? engaging the brain to do learning and help with executive functioning. You know, so these students who appear disengaged, do they just need to go for a walk? Do they li need to listen like on an audiobook and be on a stationary bike, which we're lucky enough to have? can we engage those students who struggle to sit still? Do they just need a standing desk? Like there's so many different Let me know in the comments. you next time. ways to engage students if with their learning and this idea of expecting students to be able to sit still, I think, can be really tricky. And so what resources do we already have that we can utilize to help those students? I think getting outside standing like anything that can be done. It is hard if you have thirty students and you don't have an EA. ⁓ So can you do? I found it easier to do this in New Zealand where Teaching outdoors was actually expected. coming to n and teaching in North America, people are always surprised when you take kids out to do reading or writing activities. And because even the even my were ⁓ surprised by then it was harder for the students to do. ⁓ And I this is a personal preference, but if you're really wanting to make sure that you can engage students with learning outside or in different areas. Start in term one so that they get used to it. So then and I it takes a long time and then by the time you're kind of and implementing it, they just think, ⁓ this we're just doing this outside today and that's fine. ⁓ I think it's just really un important to understand that movement ⁓ distraction, even though we sometimes think it is, like a student's tapping their pen. And know that it can get frustrating. One of things that helps me with that frustration is just looking around during a staff meeting and seeing what everyone's doing. Like how many people in your staff when you're actually like sitting there ⁓ with their you know, in front of them, like listening to whoever's the talking at that time. Very few, like maybe two out of ⁓ out of thirty in my case. just realize that that like even ⁓ adults struggle with that. And so I found it easier to to kind of give grace to students as well. ⁓ it can be a little demoralizing when you're like super passionate and you're teaching ⁓ it looks like kids are bored. But then it I think having those conversations with those students and be like, Hey, you know, ⁓ what could Are you like sometimes if they're old enough you can be like, Were you bored? or like what's going on there? And they're like, I just you know, I can hear you better when I'm looking out the window, right? Like or I can hear you better when I'm t like playing with my fidgets or when I've got putting my feet on the band on the desk, right? So just different things. Some people need to stand, some I was in a meeting the other day, I honestly even though it was like a comfortable chair, quote unquote, I was so uncomfortable I had to stand up and then like Because my legs hurt from sitting, I needed to just move around, right? And, know, students have that as well. So I just understanding that movement can help students access learning. and like can we help students regulate themselves before ⁓ they start And just understanding, you know, you might go past the classroom and everyone's sitting down and they're like looking at the teacher, ⁓ but you don't that how much more they're taking in than the students in your class, right? Like we need to like separate compliance from active learning or active listening, right? Because I think we all know students who are able to succeed when they're moving around rather than they're being restricted. I have lots of students thought that they were terrible writers. But then as soon as they could actually stand and write, or the windowsills in my classroom are raised, like when they could write there and like kind of lean. It a huge game changer. They were actually then accessing the visuals that I had put up. For spelling and for an editing checklist that they had never done before. ⁓ just move them to closer to the window and like, ⁓ yeah, look at that. It amazing. and I know lots of teachers who ⁓ use movement as ⁓ kind of helping students ⁓ work through assignment. So they'll initiate the assignment ⁓ and the will kind of like they could see, you know you do your check-ins and you're like, ⁓ okay, what are we stuck on? I'm stuck on this and da da da. Okay, w what do you think you need? Like it's always really good to try to help students with that metacognition. What so what are you feeling? What do you think you need? What what has worked in the past? Go for a walk, come back, and then they're ready to go for it because they've regulated their systems again, right? They've ⁓ of moved away from if they were on a Chromebook or if they were writing things down. And they've come back to with fresh eyes. And I think that happens to adults as well, right? Like lots of studies that we can only work for a certain amount of time before we need a break. And that's the same thing with students. So it's the goal is not can your students sit perfectly still still. ⁓ goal is how I ⁓ you how can I help these students to learn? ⁓ What do I need to get rid of for these students to be able to access their learning, right? So, okay, let's talk about the third thing. Leadership. This has been a big one for me this year. I have been really struggling with this idea of leadership. What is leadership? What is successful leadership? really also been struggling with the idea that just because I think something is good leadership ⁓ mean ⁓ people think things are good leadership. Like ⁓ have just really found leadership ⁓ be such a topic that I've been thinking about this year. And not because, you know, I want to go into admin or anything, but just because I feel like I've now had enough changes and I can, you know, like, and where you're having even like two admin and they they very different and they're different approaches. And then just being able to kind of think about that. And I that People talk about teacher retention, a huge part of that is like salary conversations, which I think is super fair. I don't know about where you are, but we have like ten steps our salary grid. ⁓ when you're starting out, you're really not making a lot of money. And that's when you, you know, are paying your school fees and There's just a lot of money going out, not a lot coming in. I know so many beginning teachers who work multiple jobs just to make ends meet. which is really hard ⁓ I it's harder too if you are also like a mom or a solo mom or a solo dad or a dad. you know, and are taking care of maybe you're taking care of your ⁓ elderly parents or people, but I think after years of education, yes, there's definitely merit to talk about salary, but I'm absolutely convinced that leadership is one of the biggest factors in whether teachers stay, thrive, or quietly start looking for a way out.