Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Efficiency Is Alpha: AI Disruption & the Return to Sound-Money Investing
Transcript
- 0:02It all comes down to computers communicating.
- 0:06The information superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps
- 0:09and off ramps. Bitcoin is worthless artificial
- 0:14gold. Is it still rat poison?
- 0:17Probably rat poison squared. We need to get into the.
- 0:20World of OK, this is actually foundational.
- 0:23Technology. What the Internet of Money does
- 0:26is it creates a single network which can do a microtransaction
- 0:32to a giga transaction. The Internet is going to.
- 0:37Be one of the major forces for reducing the role of gun.
- 0:42The one thing that's missing that that will soon be developed
- 0:46is a reliable E cash. All righty, welcome back to
- 0:54another episode of Final Settlement.
- 0:56Today is July 1st, 2025. It's a Tuesday, beginning of Q3.
- 1:03What's going on in the world in markets?
- 1:06I'm joined as always by Liam Nelson and Michael Tanguma.
- 1:10And today, big show. We got a big show today.
- 1:12A lot of a lot of topics to get through.
- 1:14And we have a special guest as well, Clay Norris.
- 1:18Clay is a venture capitalist by day, a bitcoiner by night.
- 1:22Perhaps I'll, I'll let him sort of introduce his, his background
- 1:26and and how we got to know each other.
- 1:28But excited to have him on the show.
- 1:29Clay, how's it going, man? Yeah, I appreciate you guys
- 1:32having me excited to do this so I can get my quick elevator
- 1:37pitch here. I've so I've worked in venture
- 1:40now for the last seven years, work my way up from and I was
- 1:43associate to principal. I was most recently at a family
- 1:46office up in New York and now I'm spending on my own fund
- 1:50called Outlaw the GP of that. I've also been moonlighting a
- 1:54media business on the side for really the last six years called
- 1:58Confluence VC. That's given me a lot of access
- 2:00to interesting people in the venture world.
- 2:04Got connected to Liam while we were still in college so it's
- 2:07funny how things come full circle.
- 2:11And also say I'm a Bitcoin maxi and all of my all of my
- 2:17disposable income now goes back into Bitcoin.
- 2:19Everything that isn't required as the GP commit is going back
- 2:23into Bitcoin. So excited to be here.
- 2:26Awesome. Yeah.
- 2:27And this this kind of speaks to, you know, kind of where where we
- 2:31want to take the show from here. So, you know, historically we've
- 2:33talked a lot about Bitcoin, people building on Bitcoin news
- 2:38around Bitcoin, topics around Bitcoin, and we're going to sort
- 2:41of expand the the breadth of the show a little bit and get more
- 2:44into broader capital markets, broader venture.
- 2:47And so bringing on folks like Clay on a more recurring basis.
- 2:52You also folks like Cam Duty, which we've had on the show many
- 2:55times who sit in the traditional space, but also have a Bitcoin
- 2:58lens. And it's kind of indicative of
- 3:01just how we see the world moving in the sense of ventures
- 3:05changing and you need to have a sound money lens on capital
- 3:09allocation in general. And so this will be the first
- 3:13sort of instantiation of that. And so we have a number of
- 3:15topics to get through that are, you know, not necessarily
- 3:17Bitcoin specific, but we're going to be wide-ranging here.
- 3:20So excited to kick this off, Michael.
- 3:23I don't know if you had anything else to add to that.
- 3:25I think it was super well said. I think the thought for the past
- 3:2815 years is Bitcoin will get closer to traditional markets
- 3:31where there's capital markets, tech culture.
- 3:35Ideally, we're not early. This feels like a very opportune
- 3:37time to really capitalize on that from the venture side, but
- 3:40also from the kind of just like content yesterday was
- 3:44interesting with the Robin Hood as an example, because Robin
- 3:47Hood is not only one of the largest technology companies,
- 3:49they're one of the largest fintechs, potentially one of the
- 3:51largest, you know, financial companies, as well as getting
- 3:54into the digital asset space. And so I think it's just the,
- 3:59there's a no pun intended confluence of events happening
- 4:03that kind of like lead to really bringing that together.
- 4:05And then the point you said, Brian, about sound capital or
- 4:10sound money, I think it ultimately will revert back to
- 4:12that being the alpha like that you actually have to think with
- 4:16constraints and you have to think with returning capital and
- 4:19just being efficient. And so naturally, if that's
- 4:22true, then that's going to bleed into all areas of the market
- 4:25that aren't really historically talking about that.
- 4:27It's usually been Abundance so excited with the new format, new
- 4:31topics we'll be covering, and guests that will be going down
- 4:34the rabbit hole that we'll get to have join us every other
- 4:37week. Yeah, very well said.
- 4:40And maybe we start there. Maybe we start with the the slew
- 4:43of news around Robin Hood. Michael, you'd shared this in
- 4:48the chat. Start here.
- 4:49Just the aesthetic overall of the of all the announcements
- 4:53that they made at the event yesterday was very Casino
- 4:57Royale, Bond Villainesque. They're going to be talking
- 5:01about crypto and they did it was a full onslaught of crypto
- 5:05related announcements. I'll pull up this tweet here.
- 5:10So they're going to be you know, they're going full of the
- 5:12tokenization and we've kind of seen this coming for a while.
- 5:15We've talked about it on the show in the past of this feels
- 5:18like the next crypto trend outside of stable coins, which I
- 5:22mean is a form of tokenization, right?
- 5:23But you know, tokenizing other real world assets.
- 5:27And so they had a number of announcements around not only
- 5:31tokenizing existing public equities.
- 5:34And you know, caveat, this is specifically for investors in
- 5:37the EU, not not in the United States, but also pre IPO private
- 5:41companies so that, you know, they announced open AI and and
- 5:44SpaceX as two companies that people would be able to trade on
- 5:48chain. They also announced their own
- 5:51chain. That is for my, from what I can
- 5:55gather, built on or based on Arbitron, which is an Ethereum
- 5:59layer 2. And so yeah, lots of
- 6:03announcements. I think you could also have, you
- 6:05know, seen this coming in some sense of, you know, over the
- 6:07past 12 months, Vlad has been talking more about crypto as
- 6:11everyone has. And I know that, you know,
- 6:13anecdotally, they had been hiring in the sort of crypto
- 6:17sphere for a number of months as well.
- 6:20So I think it was just a matter of time before they they made
- 6:22this larger push to any, any initial thoughts on on any of
- 6:27these topics? There's a few things I want to
- 6:28get into, but we'll take the broader thoughts first.
- 6:31One just always excited when it gets into the crypto stuff for
- 6:35Brian to be joining us because he can he can go deep on the
- 6:38multi chain world. But maybe Clay, we, you know,
- 6:41get guests being polite. Where what are your thoughts?
- 6:45How do you how do you think about this?
- 6:48I mean, yeah, I think just at a really high level, I think
- 6:52there's just more and more demand into these private
- 6:54assets. And I think the way that the
- 6:56venture world has been going over really the last call like
- 7:0110 to 20 years is this idea that companies are staying private
- 7:05longer just means there's lower upside ability once they do
- 7:08become public. So I think from a retail
- 7:10investors perspective, like they're getting robbed with a
- 7:13lot of potential gains that otherwise they'd be given access
- 7:17to. I mean, like when Google, Apple
- 7:20and some of these other notable tech companies today, when they
- 7:22went public, they were only a few billion dollars in market
- 7:25cap. Now they're multi trillion
- 7:26dollars. Like everybody in the retail
- 7:28world was able to ride that wave.
- 7:31So I think there's there's just demand for these companies, but
- 7:34they're locked up in the private markets.
- 7:36And I think this idea of tokenizing some of those assets
- 7:38and making them available to retail investors is, it's
- 7:42interesting. I mean, I don't have really
- 7:44strong opinions about what happens from here because I
- 7:49think a lot of it is untested and unproven.
- 7:52But I'm, I'm interested to see what happens with the, with the,
- 7:59the Robin Hood test here. Yeah.
- 8:01I think that's very well said. I think that there's also a
- 8:04significant demand for exit from some of these privately held
- 8:09companies to even like this Spacex's that have done
- 8:12extremely well. There's just like different time
- 8:15frames that many of the LP's were not expecting when they got
- 8:19into any of these super large funds that haven't really
- 8:23returned capital quite as quickly as they were
- 8:25anticipating. And so there's just different
- 8:27time frames where you know, employees are looking to
- 8:30monetize their shares as well as some existing LP's of different
- 8:35time frames need to rotate into different assets.
- 8:37We know that there are a bunch of different endowments who need
- 8:40to return capital back to their investors or just to the school
- 8:44because they have different obligations now.
- 8:47And so I also think this is interesting as well because
- 8:51we've seen much of crypto not really having any value accrual
- 8:57narrative and other than, you know, Bitcoin being a stable
- 9:02store value and then you are stable coins being tied to the
- 9:05US dollar. And so I think I'm unsure what's
- 9:09going to happen with their own chain.
- 9:11We'll see maybe that's like AB and B type token.
- 9:15But on on the underlying asset, I think that there's massive
- 9:19questions about the compliance and legal aspects, but it's an
- 9:25interesting trend that I think we're only going to see more of
- 9:28moving forward. Yeah, I think there's two
- 9:32different topics. I know Brian probably wants to
- 9:34get into the token of cruel side, but like more structurally
- 9:37or no, I've been seriously like there's there's validity to
- 9:41discussing how it kind of well, I won't still stand her because
- 9:44I think I know where he's going to go with it and we can talk
- 9:45about that. But I think before getting into
- 9:47that, I think just like from a very like first principle
- 9:51perspective, I think all of this stuff and I know it sounds
- 9:56cynical, but I believe it to be true, just takes advantage of
- 9:59the financial illiterate. And mainly because so there's a
- 10:04notion of we're exporting the US dollar like that's understood to
- 10:07the rest of the world. They're going to offset our
- 10:09debt. It's the same thing with we're
- 10:10exporting the capital markets, the rest of the world.
- 10:12And then you're effectively allowing to your point, there's
- 10:15a lot of investors that have been illiquid.
- 10:18The other component of just structurally where from
- 10:22investment banking and all the process to IPO and all the
- 10:25amount of capital in private markets, there's been the
- 10:27ability to just keep people locked up for various reasons.
- 10:29Because also, if you're unprofitable, it's probably
- 10:31really nice to not have your people go through your books on
- 10:33a quarterly basis. But then the other aspect, the
- 10:38one that like most people just miss is this notion of private
- 10:41markets, like venture capital as an example, exists because of
- 10:44all the money that that's created.
- 10:46When you hear of like alts and the term alts has grown over the
- 10:48past, call it five years and private credit.
- 10:51Most people don't have the acumen to go and discern,
- 10:54especially retail investors already in the, you know, the C
- 10:59and BI can't get their play will know for when it comes to like
- 11:03investment, when you come into a fund, the exact 5O6B and C when
- 11:07it comes to being able to solicit and market those
- 11:10securities. There's a reason for that.
- 11:12And so now like bringing this all out, it reminds me a lot of
- 11:16kind of crypto in the sense that remember when like a six and Z
- 11:18would get into these tokens, get in early and then kind of dump
- 11:20on retail and it was a lot more liquid and easier to get out.
- 11:24And so I think this is the world we're heading to if it's not
- 11:28good or I mean, I guess it's kind of bad, but it's just the
- 11:30reality of it. And there's a better way to like
- 11:33store capital. And I think the market's just
- 11:35going to slowly come around to that.
- 11:37So I think that's the interesting thing for me is that
- 11:40everything's going to get digitized, everything's going to
- 11:41get securitized and people are going to love the high
- 11:43volatility and leverage. They announced perpetuals.
- 11:46I don't know if you covered that as well, but it's really just
- 11:51going to. I don't think people end up
- 11:53storing wealth or value in there is basically the genesis or the
- 11:58the summary. Yeah, I think that's all fair.
- 12:03It's, it's part part of a broader trend of access
- 12:07democratization of of access to various things.
- 12:10And whether or not the investors on the other end are discerning
- 12:14enough to know what they're investing in is a is a totally
- 12:17another discussion. But I think it's clear that the
- 12:19trajectory is more access versus less.
- 12:23You were right, Michael, in that where I wanted to take this was
- 12:26the value accrual component. Yeah, real quick, just before
- 12:29going. I guess I left out one of the
- 12:30missing pieces is that a lot of these are the majority of the
- 12:32companies lack fundamentals like they traded in saying riches
- 12:36like. So that's the core point like if
- 12:37the, if the market wasn't what it is and everyone had access to
- 12:41companies and we're producing dividends and returning the
- 12:43capital and had like sound. That's like I think the the
- 12:46missing part is most people don't understand that these
- 12:48companies are traded on vibes is the.
- 12:51Yeah, they, I mean, they they announced space action open AI
- 12:54who are, you know, like vibes possibly being entities.
- 12:59Yeah, exactly. So I think that's a massive part
- 13:03of it as well as just like it unlocks massive liquidity
- 13:06premium for these companies that they wouldn't have access to
- 13:09otherwise, which is, you know, massive big benefit to these
- 13:14privately held companies and they don't have to go through
- 13:18the M and A process IPO process as well.
- 13:21It reminds me like a great example of this is Weworks IPO.
- 13:25So when we work, Long story short, you know, at we work,
- 13:30they were supposed to, you know, IPO at 48 billion.
- 13:32They were doing tender offers like 6 to 12 months before to
- 13:36buy back shares from client or employees as like this thing the
- 13:39Ponzi get I'm getting out of here, sold, sold the shares.
- 13:43But in that world, if they didn't have to go through the
- 13:45scrutiny of the S1 and everything related, they'd be
- 13:47trading in an insane amount because it was all vibes in the,
- 13:50in the like the market side, the marketing side.
- 13:54And so it's a very similar example here is like everyone on
- 13:57the inside of these companies knows they're not worth what the
- 13:59market's saying. I mean, anybody that has like a
- 14:01head on their shoulders, because a lot of people just smell their
- 14:03own farts and think that they like, everything's great there.
- 14:06But there's people that get it anyway.
- 14:08It's yeah. Yeah.
- 14:14So, so back to value accrual, I think this, this is what's most
- 14:19interesting about all this to me is there's sort of a, a parallel
- 14:23to you know, what we saw yesterday with Robin Hood
- 14:27building on Arbitrum and also the stablecoin side of you know,
- 14:32USDC is multi chain. But like the economic value,
- 14:37where is it accruing? Where is it flowing?
- 14:39At least in the near term, the value seems to be accruing to
- 14:43the issuers or the corporate entities that are behind
- 14:46building on these chains. And the chains themselves seem
- 14:49to be more commodity like infrastructure.
- 14:52And so the, you know, example from yesterday is, is Robin Hood
- 14:57is, you know, making new all time highs.
- 14:59The stock is ripping. They announced they're building
- 15:02on Arbitrum and Arbitrum is basically flat.
- 15:05Like it had a little little pop, but you know, it's still 9080 to
- 15:1190% down from its all time highs like 2 years ago and similar.
- 15:17Similarly on the stablecoin side, it's like genius bill
- 15:20passes, we're going to proliferate stablecoins and
- 15:24Ethereum hasn't really reacted to that in a material way.
- 15:28And so I think this is this is kind of something I've thought
- 15:30for a long time in terms of people building on these other
- 15:36block chains outside of Bitcoin. The question always was, you
- 15:39know, does the value accrue to the native token if people are
- 15:42building on these things using stable coins, trading U.S.
- 15:45stocks on Arbitron, Like does the value actually flow to the
- 15:49native token? And, and, and to be fair, like I
- 15:52could be totally wrong about this.
- 15:53And in six months, you know, these assets could be much
- 15:55higher. And that could be a reflection
- 15:57of people, you know, placing their bets and seeing the
- 15:59activity on these chains. But right now it's flowing to
- 16:03Circle and Robin Hood. And so this speaks to, you know,
- 16:08if you're familiar with the show, Michael and I have had
- 16:11arguments or disagreements around Bitcoin dominance,
- 16:14whether it continues to grind up from here or go down.
- 16:17I think in order for it to go down, you would need to see
- 16:19value accrual to the native tokens because of this usage,
- 16:23whether it's stable coins or stocks being traded on on chain.
- 16:27And so I think that's the big question as we move forward,
- 16:30that's what we'll have that that's what would necessarily
- 16:32have to happen in order for Bitcoin dominance to come down
- 16:35in my mind dots. I mean, I don't think ever it
- 16:42was about the usage for like the asset like if Solana and
- 16:46whatever is happening there on chain to trade stocks, like the
- 16:49usage of it isn't the reason the price goes up.
- 16:51It's the speculative like acknowledgement that this might
- 16:56be, you know, stored and so like.
- 16:58Where is the speculative acknowledgement going?
- 17:00Is it going to the corporate entities issuing the things or
- 17:03is it going to the native token? I think that's the question.
- 17:06Well, so I think, I think it goes both because 1 like this
- 17:10just came out. I think this week Solana is
- 17:12having their ETF approved. So people are naturally going to
- 17:15buy Solana and they're going to do whatever they they do.
- 17:20And so I do think tokens are going to naturally get locked up
- 17:22for various reasons. But then to your point, I think
- 17:26long term in today, it really comes down to the company, which
- 17:29is the issuer. Because again, going back to
- 17:32first principles, if we realize we don't need tokens for all
- 17:34this, well then it probably ends up being like the independent
- 17:38company that's creating the value and orchestrating between
- 17:41the different market participants.
- 17:42And then they're just going to be making money.
- 17:45And then that will be the equity that's valuable in business.
- 17:49So I think it makes complete sense that circle is generating
- 17:52the revenue if they're playing in the middle and they're
- 17:54issuing and they manage both sides of the demand and the
- 17:58liquidity side. And then because the the one
- 18:03that came to mind is like Polymarket, I was thinking, I
- 18:06don't know if you had if we're going to go there, but you know,
- 18:08like Polymarket and Kelsey and those deals have been like top,
- 18:13big top of top of mind. And a lot of people probably
- 18:15reflect that. Eventually you'll need to be in
- 18:17like sensualist borderless form of money because you know you
- 18:21can there's a lot of things you can do when you can start to
- 18:23like if these things got the prediction markets got big
- 18:26enough and there was enough like reason to want to shut them
- 18:29down, you probably can on most chains.
- 18:31And so that naturally makes sense that you want to go to a
- 18:34permissionless, permissionless form of money.
- 18:36But then also if we agree that direction, well then it's
- 18:41ultimately going to and they're going to settle in BTC where
- 18:43you're going to derive the value around the infrastructure, which
- 18:46is my understanding. Cal, she's a little bit more
- 18:48like infrastructure as a service versus like polymarket is more
- 18:51of both sides of the marketplace.
- 18:53Either way, like you're going to go to the the highest liquid
- 18:55market, which would be Bitcoin. And so where's the token?
- 18:59There's no token there. It is all derives from the
- 19:01actual company building the business and that's the
- 19:03underlying equity. So I think that's a line.
- 19:05I'm agreeing that like I think the business will, it makes
- 19:08sense the business to generate the revenue.
- 19:10I think that these just probably aren't the winners over a long
- 19:12time horizon. Yeah, No, I I agree with that.
- 19:15And I think it's interesting like if you just think about
- 19:17polymarket like that is to my understanding that's built on
- 19:21Polygon, which is like a chain no one cares about.
- 19:25And so I think that just again speaks to like the actual users
- 19:28don't care what the underlying chain is.
- 19:31And you also see, you know, signs of this on the stablecoin
- 19:34side, which is, I would say more mature in the sense that USDC
- 19:38runs on a bunch of different block chains.
- 19:40So then as the issuer and the user like don't really care
- 19:44about where it's running as long as they can get get access to
- 19:47whatever is being issued. Leah, did you have thoughts on
- 19:51the, we can, we can sort of pivot to the, the prediction
- 19:54market stuff? So I know you had some thoughts
- 19:55around all that. Yeah, maybe I'll kick it to clay
- 20:00first, I guess. Like what?
- 20:01What is more interesting to you? Being focused on the user
- 20:05experience and actually getting the users to use your site or
- 20:10being primarily infrastructure as a service that's going out
- 20:13to, you know, the Robin Hoods of the world, etcetera.
- 20:16Or do you want one or the other? Do you want to do both?
- 20:19What's what's kind of the most interesting aspect here?
- 20:23Yeah. I mean, I would say in an ideal
- 20:24world, you get both. I feel like you asked different
- 20:26venture investors and they'll probably tell you different
- 20:28things. I mean, where my head is going
- 20:30is I would probably care more about like I'm agreeing with
- 20:35Brian, where like you can't really disagree with user
- 20:39patterns. And if they just, if their usage
- 20:44patterns tell you they don't really care what the underlying
- 20:47infrastructure is, I feel like that's your answer, but I don't
- 20:52know I would. I would be curious how different
- 20:55venture investors would would think about it too.
- 21:00Yeah. I'm kind of thinking about it
- 21:01like almost like a parallel to to the Coinbase versus finance
- 21:05deal, which is, you know, finance plan overseas like
- 21:07Polymarket is done. They've done a lot of their
- 21:11unregulated aspect as well, but they have a decent amount of
- 21:16liquidity because they haven't had to be slowed down, but being
- 21:18CFTC approved approved like how she has, but you know how she
- 21:23will have the benefits of, you know, having being integrated
- 21:28with Robin Hood's of the world and more.
- 21:30And so you know, the argument that I could see there is they
- 21:34end up getting more liquidity and and so, you know, being the
- 21:40most liquid, I think is the most valuable with all of this
- 21:43because it can be the biggest sign of where what the market is
- 21:47perceiving to be true. You know, it's, it's not
- 21:50necessarily going to be just is this going to happen, but it's a
- 21:55lot of sentiment as well and where, where people are
- 21:59thinking. But I think that there's a
- 22:01little bit more value in being the infrastructure provider that
- 22:05can have the most liquidity versus going straight to the the
- 22:08user long term, which is what I was most interested in here.
- 22:13Yeah, I think it's all relative on to the investor, what the
- 22:16entrepreneur is trying to do the the market.
- 22:18I think history shows the biggest companies start with the
- 22:22user because you can't really build infrastructure until you
- 22:24have like intimate and asymmetric information.
- 22:27Like Amazon is a great example and Coinbase, because Coinbase,
- 22:33like the, the angle I'm thinking about is Bitco Bigo is a
- 22:36wonderful business. They're a very large business.
- 22:38They're going to IPO, but most people don't know who they are
- 22:41and they'll market capital ultimately always be, I
- 22:45shouldn't say always, but will be a fraction of coinbases.
- 22:48They've always been infrastructure.
- 22:51I think Coinbase is going to wrap back into infrastructure.
- 22:54Like so they started with a user, they went institution and
- 22:56those are going to start working with banks and others.
- 22:59Umm, so I think that's the idea is it's almost very hard to like
- 23:04just come out the gate and provide infrastructure because
- 23:06you can provide it for what you think the market or what they're
- 23:10telling you, but you won't have like intimate knowledge of that
- 23:12growing market and then be able to build what they need.
- 23:16And I think like Amazon and books is a great example.
- 23:19Yeah, you get to iterate real time and realize what what works
- 23:23well, what people like, what they don't like and be able to
- 23:27then go out and provide that for a service like like others are
- 23:30going to do. And the venture component I
- 23:33think ties into the the entrepreneur because if you had
- 23:36somebody that wasn't Jeff Bezos trying to do what he did
- 23:39wouldn't make sense. In the same way if you had
- 23:40somebody trying to build infrastructure that was a
- 23:42consumer person or the way they started it would they would both
- 23:46like probably fail or not be as successful as you would imagine
- 23:49them sitting in the right shoes. So, so I think it's just
- 23:51relative to the opportunity. I don't think there's like a
- 23:53wrong or right. Yeah, no, it's almost said,
- 24:02Liam, I'm going to pull up a link that you you'd shared
- 24:06around AI disruptions causing winners and losers.
- 24:10I think this is a, a broader trend we've, you know, talked
- 24:13about a bunch in the show. But pulling up this link now
- 24:15from Bruce Richards if you want to give us sort of the TLDR on
- 24:20on what he's talking about here. Yeah.
- 24:23I thought this was super interesting, you, Liz.
- 24:25Marathon Asset Management is a large private credit
- 24:28organization. They do $40 billion in loans.
- 24:31And he's saying that they have been and will continue to avoid
- 24:35lending to software companies and that the reason behind it is
- 24:40essentially they are unsure which ones will and will not be
- 24:46disrupted by, you know, AI companies coming in that are
- 24:50just being force fed capital in order to go and disrupt their
- 24:55businesses. And I thought this was super
- 24:58interesting as it's kind of what we've been talking about before
- 25:01of these there's a big disruption of capital going to
- 25:08the biggest winners in the venture space.
- 25:10And of those large private companies, I think that they're
- 25:14that are like software, which has been a big trend in venture
- 25:17for you know the past decade plus and they haven't gone
- 25:20public. I think this is going to be a
- 25:22big issue if other private lenders are thinking the same
- 25:26way that there are issues related to the viability of
- 25:30software companies ability to continue to grow and not have
- 25:36their pricing go to to be deflationary as there are
- 25:40disruptors in the space. So I just thought this was super
- 25:43interesting and not not entirely sure how I, I really want to
- 25:50think about it in a big way other than the fact that just
- 25:54like there are LP's and these legacy funds that are, you know,
- 25:58trying to get out on, on a, in a big way.
- 26:02And I think that they're, they're kind of all pivoting
- 26:06towards AI. And so it's just really
- 26:07interesting that the legacy venture thesis has has really
- 26:13shifted in a massive way and there's kind of dried up in
- 26:15terms of the IPO potential for these software companies.
- 26:19I love that you brought this up. It like encapsulates a lot of
- 26:22the things I think we want to talk about today but in the
- 26:25future. From a micro example, I just
- 26:27think of this as an individual that had a certain amount of
- 26:30cash flow. And if he had a micro like a if
- 26:33we went back to community banking and he went to the
- 26:34person and he saw people getting laid off all across the street.
- 26:37And that person hadn't gotten laid off yet.
- 26:39But it's in his best interest to slow down the credit limit or
- 26:43slow down whatever extensive loan because that person gets
- 26:46laid off and he extended that loan like it was, you know, when
- 26:49everything was gravy, they're going to be in a hole.
- 26:51And he does that enough times and he's out of business.
- 26:53And that's effectively what this is at a larger scale because
- 26:57what we know about, you know, we kind of see it every day.
- 27:00I always joke with the podcast, it's kind of embarrassing how
- 27:03much we actually spend from any podcasts we do.
- 27:05But without sharing the number. When we first got quoted 2 years
- 27:08ago, it was like $1000 an episode for some human to like
- 27:12edit each pod. And I can promise you, we do,
- 27:16you know, 12 to 20 a month, if not more.
- 27:19And it costs US, you know, 11 thousandth of what the total of
- 27:23that, if not less. And so point being is all these
- 27:28companies, the writing's on the wall.
- 27:30And it also, I don't know how much we're going to end up
- 27:32taking it back to Bitcoin in this pod, but it's just true.
- 27:36Like if anybody had the the prudence or for forethought to
- 27:40raise some capital back in eighteen 17/16/2021 and park
- 27:45510% into BTC, they would have ultimately been able to help
- 27:50offset this and then would have just naturally, potentially.
- 27:53I wouldn't say naturally, but the idea is once you see
- 27:56something go up, you start to realize or ask why, and then it
- 27:59starts to impact and affect your business because you're like,
- 28:02well, why are we just wasting all this money when we could
- 28:03just be behind the BTC? So yeah, I think, I think it's
- 28:08going to be huge and I think it's going to be interesting to
- 28:10see how it plays out and where that money comes from and what
- 28:14looks like what a distressed companies look like.
- 28:16Do they end up getting merged like because if the price of
- 28:20software is collapsing like these companies have a big
- 28:22problem. Yeah, Clay, Clay, I'm curious if
- 28:30you have any thoughts on on this one.
- 28:32I have a few thoughts. I mean, like my entire thesis
- 28:35with Outlaws really predicated on this.
- 28:39I think the the new vanity metric for venture backed
- 28:43companies is this idea of growing revenue per employee.
- 28:45I feel like you talk to enough people, I mean, we just
- 28:47discussed this second ago, like efficiency is rewarded more than
- 28:51the old vanity metrics of growth at all cost, account growth, you
- 28:53name it. I think there's a lot that goes
- 28:57into building efficient businesses.
- 29:01The way that I'm thinking about it is that I think a lot of
- 29:04these back office functions and departments within an
- 29:07organization, I think they get consolidated to the point where
- 29:10there's one or two people that can handle the majority of the
- 29:12output for that department. I think where I have the most
- 29:16questions for all of these AI businesses that just like
- 29:21quickly ramp up revenue, I think retention on that revenue has
- 29:28really become the main focus. And I think there's plenty of
- 29:34examples now of companies that scale up to 2030 million in
- 29:36recurring revenue. And then like you see they stall
- 29:40at that because they just have a really bad churn problem.
- 29:45And I think you talked to some sales reps and you can start to
- 29:47understand a little bit as to why.
- 29:49Like one thing that I don't think a lot of these AI focused
- 29:54businesses have solved on the sales side is how to incentivize
- 29:57their reps. And so traditional SAS is easy.
- 30:01If you think about like if you're an AE for a SAS company,
- 30:03you're comped based on whatever that ACV is for the contracts to
- 30:08say it's like $100,000 ACV contract, you get 20% of that
- 30:11upfront. So like you're incentivized to
- 30:13sell as much as possible. And I've talked to a lot of
- 30:16friends that work for these AI businesses and they get comp
- 30:19based on usage. And so it's like their quota
- 30:23isn't necessarily clean. They don't.
- 30:26And they that also makes their sales process a lot longer.
- 30:31And so they say they like close a customer, they didn't have to
- 30:34activate that customer, get them comfortable with the product and
- 30:36they get paid in perpetuity, like a percentage of whatever
- 30:39that customer is spending within the business.
- 30:43I think it's harder to, at least from the people I've talked to,
- 30:48it's like it's easier to attract talent to those businesses.
- 30:51I think it's harder to retain them on the sales side because
- 30:55they just have like a lot less of an understanding of how much
- 30:58they're going to get paid. I don't know if that helps
- 31:03answer the question, but that's just some things that I'm I'm
- 31:05hearing about like why might be tough to sustain growth for some
- 31:12of these AI businesses? Yeah, that, that's super
- 31:16interesting. I'm, I'm curious like on the
- 31:18churn side, it is that more just indicative of sort of the low
- 31:24barriers to entry like what like what is what is causing that
- 31:27higher churn rate inherently in your mind?
- 31:32I think this idea of five revenue where everybody's just
- 31:35like in an exploratory phase and you want to test out different
- 31:40tooling, especially if you can figure out companies that don't
- 31:43lock you in the annual contracts.
- 31:44If you can just test things out and see if it how it goes.
- 31:47And like maybe is that there's this promise that it can remove
- 31:50some of your entry level work and you have 60 to 90 days to
- 31:54figure out if that's true. And maybe after those 60 to 90
- 31:56days, you realize it's just another tool that isn't going to
- 31:58be part of your core workflow and you abandon it.
- 32:01But technically like you're it's booked revenue.
- 32:07And so the the company is able to market that as book revenue
- 32:11back to their investor base. Everybody else's show that like
- 32:13the growth curve continues to go up, but I feel like especially
- 32:18for Series A investors, I, I feel like for a lot of these
- 32:22seed companies, it's probably not put into focus yet.
- 32:25But I think once you start getting to growth rounds to
- 32:28Series AB and beyond, I feel like a lot of the emphasis and
- 32:31diligence moves to retention graphs more so than just growth
- 32:36charts. Yeah, I don't, I haven't thought
- 32:39deeply about this, but I would not want to be anywhere near
- 32:42venture capital in in AI. There's a a book, the
- 32:47Technological Revolutions, I forget the name.
- 32:49It's gets quoted a lot by Carletta Perez.
- 32:51And it just effectively breaks down like disruptive cycles and
- 32:55the installation phase and the amount of capital that's
- 32:57destroyed. And it's basically what this
- 32:59sounds like is that there's a lot of capital, a lot of people.
- 33:02To your point, it makes complete sense that there's a bunch of
- 33:05churn because to your point, everyone is looking to try the
- 33:10next thing, their tension. And the people that are
- 33:12generally trying to trying to do the next thing already have like
- 33:15a something in their DNA that's always looking for the next
- 33:18thing. So they don't even spend enough
- 33:19time to figure it out. And then if you're spinning
- 33:23these things up and there's no actually real meaning, everyone,
- 33:26everyone knows this. Like it doesn't actually matter
- 33:28how much money you pay somebody. It matters how much like clarity
- 33:31of meaning and their work that they do.
- 33:33If you actually have an ambitious goal and have a good
- 33:36leader, like it's not necessarily obviously
- 33:38compensation matters, But if somebody doesn't have anything
- 33:41outside of like, I'm just building an AI company because
- 33:44it's an AI company or make people more efficient or
- 33:46there's, there's no real like it's just the next thing.
- 33:48People resonate with that and they just like are mercenaries.
- 33:51And so the thing I would be investing in as far as like AI
- 33:55is just anything that in Palantir was like, there's
- 33:57probably more companies, but I always think about Palantir in
- 34:00the notion of what they keyed in on is the fact that you want
- 34:03humans and then you want technology, right?
- 34:06And like that dance is what really is like the alpha or the
- 34:09mote. And so Palantir has all these
- 34:11like models and all this crazy shit, but then they have humans
- 34:13that can actually go and discern and really go through it.
- 34:16And when I think about like back office, like to your point, it's
- 34:19less about the software. There's software that's needed
- 34:21to do like 5 things, but it's like, who's the human or the
- 34:24shop that can plug in somebody to handle all of that because
- 34:28now they can use AI And how can it like generate revenue from
- 34:31that? Or the other one that the guy
- 34:33from former Morning Brew, Alex Lee Lieberman's trying to spin
- 34:37up is like McKenzie for AI or whatever, where it's like, I'm
- 34:39gonna go and like audit your processes and then I'm gonna
- 34:42come because that's like valuable in my mind versus like
- 34:45them trying to figure out they don't know shit.
- 34:47That's why I like they're McKenzie is like they've been
- 34:48telling people some other stuff. It's probably like 30 years
- 34:51already antiquated. So yeah, I think the AI spot is
- 34:56just going to destroy so much money.
- 34:57And that's just natural to like innovation cycles.
- 35:00I personally would be far away from from it unless you got like
- 35:03the right founder and you could get in early enough where you
- 35:06can trade on vibes and momentum and let somebody else you know
- 35:08buy your your shares or get it marked up enough to potentially
- 35:11get out. Yeah, I would agree.
- 35:16I, I think that the main beneficiaries of these, you
- 35:20know, companies are, are kind of just being the large MAG 7 as
- 35:25well as just large companies that have way too many people in
- 35:29their organizations and can continue to find better
- 35:33processes in order to, you know, continue to find efficiencies in
- 35:37their businesses. Ever since the AI kind of trend
- 35:41took off, there's been some like substantial growth across all of
- 35:46these companies, but there there hasn't necessarily been a big
- 35:51increase in cost and headcount has significantly gone down
- 35:54across most of them. But it's really only been
- 35:57rewarded to the top companies that are not, you know, only AI
- 36:01focused of we've now seen a significant jump in IPO activity
- 36:08as well as M&A activity over a billion dollars.
- 36:12The but Despite that, we're we're only seeing of the trend
- 36:17do more with less not really being picked up outside of the
- 36:20really largest firms in the space of the Microsoft's, the
- 36:25Googles that can use can improve their processes.
- 36:29I think that there's also a lot to be said about founders who
- 36:33can use the tools in order to bring more efficient products to
- 36:37market that haven't been there previously or just do it at a
- 36:40significantly lower cost and with a better form of money.
- 36:44And so to date, over 50 percent of all venture has been, you
- 36:48know, AI related, but and it's significant, it's down
- 36:53significantly from the 2021 levels despite all of this hype.
- 36:56And so there's a major amount of or major lack of funding still
- 37:03for non AI companies in the venture space, which I think is
- 37:08is a sign that things continue to be a little bit mispriced.
- 37:14Yeah. I mean, I think just real quick,
- 37:16I think we also benefit, right. Like it reminds me very much of
- 37:20like Uber DoorDash wars of like we probably these things are
- 37:23being subsidized. So we benefit anyway.
- 37:27Sorry to play. Yeah, I was just pulling up.
- 37:30I was pulling up a link that Clay shared.
- 37:32So this is along similar lines if you wanted to speak to what's
- 37:35being shown here. Yeah.
- 37:36I mean, I think this just shows kind of the trend line of how
- 37:41many NYC companies are labeled as AI agents for specific
- 37:48functions within a department. I think last batch had, let's
- 37:52see, 67 out of the 144. The batch before that it was 58.
- 37:57And I think you talked to some some venture folks that go to
- 38:00Demo Day and they're saying some of these companies are raising a
- 38:03$70 million post for like a tech like a seed deal.
- 38:07That seems ridiculously overpriced to me.
- 38:12But I think earlier we were talking about the Robin Hood
- 38:14stuff. We're talking about taking
- 38:15advantage of the financial illiterate.
- 38:18I do think there's a lot of financially illiterate people
- 38:21that work in venture now. And so I think when they hear
- 38:25these revenue numbers, they don't go a level deeper and they
- 38:28ask where the money is coming from.
- 38:30And they also don't clarify what these founders mean when they
- 38:33say ARR, because I think everybody in the founder world,
- 38:35they like are starting to dilute the definition of what ARR is.
- 38:40And I think a lot of these YC companies, they, they just sell
- 38:44their book contracts to each other.
- 38:47And so they like are able to prop up their revenue.
- 38:50So it makes a, it tells a better story at demo Day that they're
- 38:53able to say, we have 2 million in run rate.
- 38:55What's all just these other YC companies who aren't going to
- 38:58actually adopt the software, but it's technically booked and
- 39:00they're just able to market that off to other venture investors.
- 39:03They get more capital in the, in the door.
- 39:05I mean, I think that's a dangerous game, like a main
- 39:10reason why I don't like pursuing YC companies.
- 39:16Yeah, I think like a question I have is where all of the revenue
- 39:22is coming from. I think if I hear AC company say
- 39:26they got to like 0 to 2 million in revenue, like I think the
- 39:30next question I have is how they're defining revenue.
- 39:33If it's like book versus contracted versus actual, I'd
- 39:36want to see the, the breakdown of the customer profile.
- 39:40Ideally it's multiple and you don't have so much concentration
- 39:43risk, you know, 1 customer where if they pull the plug and decide
- 39:46to go with somebody else, it completely destroys the
- 39:48business. I just think having that level
- 39:52of granularity in your diligence process becomes more and more
- 39:56important because I think on Twitter you see like all these
- 39:59companies just posting their growth charts and that just
- 40:02tells you like, that's the tip of the iceberg.
- 40:04That just doesn't tell you the whole the whole story.
- 40:07It's a great, it's a great point because I don't know, I'm
- 40:09assuming this is real because it makes sense.
- 40:11There was something going viral on, I think it was on Twitter
- 40:15and it was like a guy that created LinkedIn profiles like
- 40:17Stanford. I'm sure you saw this.
- 40:20Like it was like Stanford and then, you know, wherever NBA
- 40:24worked at, like some, I don't even know.
- 40:26It wasn't Google. It's one like like maybe it was
- 40:29Uber or whatever and I forget he just like called, emailed.
- 40:32Do you know what I'm talking about, Liam?
- 40:35Yeah, it was like Palantir and like something like that, Like,
- 40:39yeah, what? Emailed somebody without a DAC
- 40:40or something like an idea and they're like OK like where's?
- 40:43The guest, well, it was a little more than like I think he
- 40:45referenced he sent it to a couple.
- 40:47I don't either 100 or 1000, but he referenced he already had
- 40:50like a term sheet and he want and he said he got like seven
- 40:52term sheets. He gets to Clay's point.
- 40:55Like it's just like you kind of get taught one thing and you're
- 40:59just going and it's just a a vibe thing.
- 41:01Again, I can't. And yeah.
- 41:05Yeah, I think, I mean that guy's probably going to get charged
- 41:10for something natural crime there, I'm sure.
- 41:15But now I saw that and then I mean that's like type of
- 41:17behavior that unfortunately happens a lot in venture.
- 41:21I mean like it's it's I get it from a pre seed and seed
- 41:25investors perspective, like you're incentivized to see as
- 41:28much as possible. So you'll take meetings wherever
- 41:31you can get them. I think the more established you
- 41:34become as a firm, the harder it is to meet with everybody.
- 41:38So you have to like put in some type of filters for yourself.
- 41:41And I think an easy filter is just like previous employers
- 41:43where you went to school. Like however you're able to tell
- 41:46your story like in a condensed manner.
- 41:49But ideally, like, yeah, in order to meet with those types
- 41:51of people, you got to make sure that everything they're telling
- 41:54you in that is, is true and they're not just lying on their
- 41:59resume. So yeah, I'm kind of hoping that
- 42:02that kid ends up getting in some sort of trouble.
- 42:05It's why kind of like it's very subtle and, and simple, but
- 42:09elegant and Cam Duty's Brickyard model, because once you build a
- 42:14brand like that, you have to go to the middle of nowhere
- 42:17Tennessee and spend 6 to 12 months like you kind of self
- 42:20select already and who you're going to see.
- 42:23And I think that's like an interesting.
- 42:26I don't think we're there yet, but there's a notion of like
- 42:28counter, you know, the whole like counter culture narrative,
- 42:32like probably why see people still go that are like world
- 42:35class similarly from like the Stanford's and Harvard's.
- 42:38But there's going to be a time where it's actually opposite.
- 42:40It's going to be a complete and we might already be there.
- 42:42Just depends on what the the right job is.
- 42:46But point being is like there's just going to be a natural like
- 42:50switch and and I think that's an example of it where it's like,
- 42:54OK, you want capital. Well, you have to come sit.
- 42:56I don't know if you're familiar with Cam duty and Brickyard, but
- 42:58you have to sit on site. I believe it's 12 months out of
- 43:00the year and just move there. It's like, well shit.
- 43:03And like that kind of tells you a lot about the individual.
- 43:06It's not to say that all founders have to do that, but
- 43:09it's like, if somebody's willing to go do that, they're at least
- 43:10willing to grind for 12 months and like, push everything out of
- 43:14the way, Which you can't say that for most founders,
- 43:17especially in Silicon Valley, because there's a whole other
- 43:19angle of being a founder that people are excited about there
- 43:22and actually building a business.
- 43:24So, yeah, I think heuristics like that are going to be
- 43:26growing and I think that will initially start to help with the
- 43:31differentiation from both sides, from founders finding the right
- 43:35venture capitalist and venture capitalist finding the right
- 43:37founders. Yeah, I love the sound money
- 43:42aspect that we have too. I mean, if somebody's willing to
- 43:46denominate their returns in Bitcoin, it's a telling sign
- 43:50that they are really just looking to get more capital
- 43:52rather than, you know, really live the founder lifestyle, go
- 43:57to whatever sort of parties there are the in the AI space
- 44:00and you know, kind of just do it for a clout, which many of these
- 44:04people are. Hey guys, thanks again for
- 44:07tuning into another episode of Final Settlement.
- 44:10We had an awesome Rep this week with Clay Norris.
- 44:12Clay Norris is a general VC in the traditional technology
- 44:16space. We're gonna start on a every
- 44:19other weekly basis having guests that come from the traditional
- 44:22finance tech business building space that are starting to
- 44:27integrate or think about how Bitcoin plays into the
- 44:29portfolio. Part of one of the goals of
- 44:30final settlement is really to help and articulate and Dr. how
- 44:35Bitcoin is going to get infused across all capital markets.
- 44:38Now a quick word from on RIM. As you may know on Ramp leads
- 44:42the space in multi institution custody.
- 44:44We work with businesses, institutions, endowments and
- 44:47individuals. We've increasingly seen an
- 44:49uptick on the public treasury companies coming to on Ramp for
- 44:52best in class custody. But at the core of our services,
- 44:56our private banking experience for individuals as the Bitcoin
- 44:59price appreciates it naturally that notion of the the plastic
- 45:03device or that harbor wallet gets heavier and heavier and it
- 45:06gets scarier and scarier. When you think about inheritance
- 45:09planning, the risk associated with all your capital being
- 45:11stored on a bearer asset that something bad you could happen
- 45:14to the other side of it is obviously custody with a third
- 45:18party custodian, which as most people educated know that you
- 45:22don't also want to leave all your assets there.
- 45:25And so multi institution custody is really that middle ground
- 45:28having three independent institutions work on your
- 45:30behalf. We mix technical governance with
- 45:33legal governance. So the assets are segregated on
- 45:36chain, but then also you have direct title and then each of
- 45:39the key holders work on your direct on your direction.
- 45:43I was recently moving some, you know, decent amount of capital
- 45:46in a single hardware wallet with a passphrase this past weekend.
- 45:50And if you forgot how daunting the experience is when you're
- 45:53moving significant amount of money or at least significant
- 45:55for the individual. And so I'd encourage you guys to
- 45:58book a consultation if you want to learn more and just
- 46:00understand how we can potentially help you, your
- 46:02family or network as you think about navigating the space and
- 46:05preserving your wealth in Bitcoin.
- 46:06But at the same time, not having to have the friction of all the
- 46:10different trade-offs with self custody or third party custody.
- 46:13At the end of the day, on Ramp provides our clients with Peace
- 46:16of Mind. And we'd love to talk with you
- 46:17again. You can book a consultation at
- 46:19on rampbitcoin.com. Now on to the rest of the show.
- 46:24Yeah. 100% Mike, you shared a Bill Gurley clip on this similar
- 46:32track of the sort of venture scape, venture landscape
- 46:35shifting. You want me to play the full
- 46:36clip? Yeah, it's actually really like,
- 46:39it really exemplifies almost everything we're talking about
- 46:41from somebody at the highest level.
- 46:43So we can listen to it and then we can.
- 46:45They are forced to play a game on the field.
- 46:47And this is, I think, the worst part of this whole world.
- 46:51There's a word that I sound called a gavage tube.
- 46:56Do you know what A gavage tube? So a gavage tube is what the
- 47:01French used to force feed the geese so that they can create.
- 47:07And what ends up happening in this world, because it's the
- 47:11same thing that happened in 2021, is the minute there's a
- 47:16company that has any amount of excitement about it whatsoever,
- 47:21someone's knocking on the door trying to give them 102 hundred
- 47:25$300 million. And I think for for founders
- 47:29that have struggled their whole life to raise money, this must
- 47:32sound like the most, you know, a ridiculous comment ever, but
- 47:38it's a reality. And I think you know it, right?
- 47:40Like, you know, this is a reality and what that does is it
- 47:46forces everyone to go all or nothing, swing for the fences.
- 47:50And I lived it in the Uber Lyft situation, but we're going to
- 47:54have that type of capital battle in every category under the sun.
- 47:59And you, you know, you mentioned the notion of like traditional
- 48:02company building. Traditional company building
- 48:05isn't spend 100 or 150 million a year in cash burn, but all the
- 48:11big AI companies are doing that, maybe more.
- 48:13I think Open the Eye said you're going to be 7 billion in a year,
- 48:19and that's not, you know, your grandfather's startup business
- 48:24or your grandfather's venture capital.
- 48:26That's a radically different world.
- 48:28And if you're a founder, you'd like to think the advice is,
- 48:32well, ignore all that and build your company the way you want to
- 48:34build it. But if your competitor raises
- 48:36$300 million and it's going to 10X the size of their sales
- 48:40force or 50 exit, you will be dead before you know it.
- 48:45Like you won't be around. So you are forced to play the
- 48:48game on the field. I guess the good news is the
- 48:51because these investors are so eager to throw money at you, you
- 48:54can probably take founder liquidity.
- 48:57I think that's bad for the company's potential long term.
- 49:00Success, probably. But because it fits you.
- 49:05Probably cut it. I mean, the end was basically
- 49:07like not a good outcome. He's like the founder should
- 49:09take some liquidity because he's building it like an
- 49:11unsustainable business. We're going to have Bill on.
- 49:14We're going to have Mike Maples on.
- 49:15We're going to have all these guys that are world class
- 49:18because eventually I thought that clip was really prescient
- 49:22and and interesting because this is somebody at the the top of
- 49:27the game when it comes to business building.
- 49:28Seen everything's was on Wall Street to start his career and
- 49:31he knows there's something wrong, but he can't put his
- 49:33finger on it. And I know they'll probably like
- 49:36push back here because I even push back on myself what I'm
- 49:39about to say, but I'm fairly confident what he described is
- 49:42completely wrong. And if you can't win the game,
- 49:46you shouldn't play the game like it's fundamentally unsustainable
- 49:49to do that and there's a lot of angles.
- 49:51I don't think there's a perfect one-size-fits-all if you have
- 49:54the money cannon at you. We did this thought exercise
- 49:57with we work on if they would have held Bitcoin, but I think
- 50:00about like Uber, Lyft, I think every company has their own path
- 50:05that they can go down when they face that dilemma and whether
- 50:08it's playing a different game, being more of a spoke
- 50:11specialized counter positioning to the incumbent, raising
- 50:14capital and saving it and watching the mistakes because
- 50:16ultimately somebody's destroying capital.
- 50:18They're making a lot of mistakes.
- 50:20I anchor back to the the Sony founder and and Japanese
- 50:24culture, and it's really kind of like this goes across all
- 50:28cultures, but Japanese and specifically because they're on
- 50:31an island. And so they really like had this
- 50:33high level in their culture around waste.
- 50:35It was like a sin. It was the worst thing you could
- 50:37ever do is just like waste money, waste food, whatever it
- 50:40is, because you had to import it.
- 50:41And that's how they effectively built Sony.
- 50:43And there was a lot of just kind of like doing more with less
- 50:45than the constraints made these world class products.
- 50:48And when you think about that as a small example, just now
- 50:52extrapolate that to just the money cannon and blowing all
- 50:55this capital is you're you're just it's fundamentally
- 50:57incongruent with the world. And so rather than play that
- 51:02game and be forced to it, founders should take a step back
- 51:04and say, well, what are the ways I can play?
- 51:07And if I can't, then maybe you just start a different business
- 51:09or you closed up. But you shouldn't like be 10
- 51:12years down the track and where Bill Gurley tells you, well, you
- 51:14can just take some secondary. So at least you got to eat
- 51:17because you're just built. You're just wasting money.
- 51:19You're wasting, you know, world's resources and I think
- 51:23this is all going to come to a head eventually because it's
- 51:25just the natural laws of the universe.
- 51:26You can't just keep wasting and everyone expected never anyway.
- 51:29So that's kind of like the thought that I think
- 51:32encapsulates a lot of the stuff we'll be talking about here
- 51:34where we think are like edges in the, you know, business building
- 51:37spaces, building with sound money principles and and sound
- 51:41capital. Yeah, I think that's exactly it.
- 51:44That's that's the notion of playing a different games
- 51:47because if you can't compete with the people throwing 300,
- 51:51you know, 300 million to a billion at the problem, then you
- 51:54have to fundamentally play a different game and use sound
- 51:58money to your advantage to bolster your balance sheet.
- 52:01Be more disciplined. Think about opportunity cost
- 52:05more than those people that are, you know, spraying the money
- 52:07bazooka. I think that's necessarily sort
- 52:10of the counter, because if you're anywhere in the middle,
- 52:12you're kind of screwed. So yeah, you kind of have to
- 52:15pick a side if you're going to try to play that game or play a
- 52:19fundamentally different game with sound money.
- 52:24I feel like he talks about the end I listed that episode too.
- 52:27I think he talks about the removal of small, medium and
- 52:32even relatively large outcomes in the asset class and how I
- 52:36mean it really is just pushing more companies to play that
- 52:40game. I mean, everybody talks about
- 52:42power law outcomes, but I think you breakdown portfolios for
- 52:46different venture funds. Like if everybody plays that
- 52:49same game of just prioritizing parallel outcomes and just
- 52:52avoiding companies that can still be good businesses but not
- 52:56have these crazy return profiles.
- 52:59I mean it ends up with especially when they're
- 53:01downturns, it just ends up with a lot of lost money.
- 53:05I think it now gets us to the position that we're in now where
- 53:08LP's that are into those funds, they become really turned off by
- 53:11the entire asset class. They have no interest in re
- 53:14upping in that fund and they definitely don't have any
- 53:16interest in joining any new fund for the partnership.
- 53:19And so, yeah, you just like dry up all potential capital.
- 53:22So I feel like there's a time limit on this type of game
- 53:25because like even in the Middle East, like I think Saudis, I
- 53:31think a lot of people have been told like if you run out of
- 53:33options in the states or in the West, you go to the Middle East
- 53:37because there's always money there.
- 53:38And it sounds like even a lot of the Middle East investors,
- 53:43they're getting concerned about private equity valuation
- 53:46practices, which is a totally separate conversation.
- 53:50But I just feel like all of this is leading to like there's there
- 53:53seems to be a timeline of how much longer this can go on
- 53:56before there's just something has to change or the asset class
- 54:01just never recovers. I don't know, That's too doom
- 54:04and gloom, but just doesn't seem great out there right now.
- 54:07I think it definitely, I mean, we'll it'll transition because
- 54:11capital formation and business building, you know, has always
- 54:14existed, right? Somebody has to have an idea and
- 54:17somebody has money and they want to invest.
- 54:21I think the I forgot Rosie to take.
- 54:26What did you say before that part about the Saudi stuff?
- 54:32Before the Saudi stuff. Yeah, there was on the Saudi, on
- 54:37the Saudi and just interesting like the crypto, a lot of crypto
- 54:41people went there because the regulations like a lot less LAX
- 54:43and similar with a venture. They're just like, it sucks
- 54:45because they have the money, but they're always like one step
- 54:47behind the like charade and what's happening in the state.
- 54:50So they just kind of get dumped on.
- 54:52But there was something else I was going to reference about,
- 54:56Oh, the game. So we was thinking about like
- 54:58when we explain when when we look at businesses that it's
- 55:04kind of like nonsensical or insane to be like one out of 10
- 55:07bets are going to make it. And the example I use is like,
- 55:09well, when you know, I got a bed to build on rim if there was a
- 55:15one out of 10 chance that I would succeed, so there's 90%
- 55:19chance of failure, I would just wouldn't get out of bed.
- 55:21Like it's just making any sense and that's what you're
- 55:24effectively like communicating or expecting somebody swing for
- 55:27the fences and there's a 10% chance you're going to win the
- 55:29rest. It's like, that doesn't make any
- 55:30sense. And that's not how businesses
- 55:31should be built. And to your point, I think that
- 55:34notion of like power law, the return profile and there's a lot
- 55:37of like misaligned incentives became the norm for people
- 55:40versus how do you just actually like return the capital, return
- 55:44some Capital plus whatever was invested.
- 55:46And then you have a call option on like, I think that's just a
- 55:49natural organic version because you can't, I like in building
- 55:52businesses to like if you have a child in like day one, you can't
- 55:56tell. You can't tell if it's gonna be
- 55:57Michael Jordan or not. Like you can only do your best.
- 56:00And then maybe they turn into Michael Jordan or somebody world
- 56:02class. But you have to like get it to a
- 56:04certain point. It can't like you can have
- 56:06ambitions for them to do that. But then you know, so you may
- 56:08start with the right framework. So I think it's just a natural
- 56:14comes down to the private sector in that asset class having so
- 56:18much liquidity and as it happens the turns into like a
- 56:21Frankenstein construct. It's all these like misaligned
- 56:24incentives. Now to your point, I'd be
- 56:26curious the guy's thoughts, the one in the way I kind of see how
- 56:29that transition would be seamless is we already see this.
- 56:32Now we're certain venture capitalists are interested in
- 56:34putting a certain component or portion of their capital raised
- 56:38in the BTC to help offset just doing the modeling out.
- 56:42I think you know, putting 10% held over 10 years probably gets
- 56:46you all ready to middle like quartile return just given like
- 56:49where VC or middle percentile returns given where VC returns
- 56:53historically are. So it's a downside protector and
- 56:57then also potentially getting venture investments to hold a
- 56:59small component of the Bitcoin because extends burn weight
- 57:03continuity if your bank gets shut down.
- 57:05And then naturally, the version I like most is it gives people
- 57:09A-frame of reference to like what real money is and then lets
- 57:11them think about capital and and time allocation in a
- 57:14fundamentally different way. I think that will eventually
- 57:17happen because it just makes sense.
- 57:18If Bitcoin adoption grows, will venture capitalists are going to
- 57:21whole Bitcoin and then they're going to understand its
- 57:23properties and then they would adopt that.
- 57:24And then over time, LP's are going to start to be like, well,
- 57:27why don't I just own the Bitcoin instead of investing in your
- 57:30fund like, and this naturally ends up going in a in a way
- 57:33where everyone just needs to return Bitcoin or you're not
- 57:35getting money or at least pretend, pretend like you're
- 57:38going to return Bitcoin or you're not getting money.
- 57:40Like, and that's how I think that is how you get this
- 57:43transition. Sorry, Lou.
- 57:45It really starts with the founder too, because if they
- 57:48want to start a business, they want to return more money than
- 57:52they have originally if they're self interested, right?
- 57:54And so most of them, like even Vlad was talking about Bitcoin
- 57:58in a completely different way than the rest of crypto and what
- 58:01he's focused on. He's like Bitcoins the only
- 58:03thing. And there was, you know, a lot
- 58:04of speculation of, you know, ultimately while they want to
- 58:08pump their own stock and, you know, hype up everything that
- 58:11they're doing, they're going to hold their own Bitcoin as well.
- 58:14And so they're going to be self interested and, you know, want
- 58:16the best outcomes for whatever they're talking about.
- 58:18And so they're also going to want to integrate it into their
- 58:22business because it just makes more sense.
- 58:24They they want to get more Bitcoin or otherwise, you know,
- 58:27why would they get out of that if they think that's going to be
- 58:30the best form of money? And so it's good to start with
- 58:32them. If they, if giving them too much
- 58:36money will odd hampen their ability to return more Bitcoin
- 58:41for themselves, they're not going to want to do it.
- 58:43LP's aren't going to want to do it and everybody along that path
- 58:47isn't going to want to do it. And so I think, I think that's
- 58:50just kind of the very early stages of where everything's
- 58:53moving. It's fantastically put because
- 58:56it's paradoxical, but like bringing on too much Bitcoin
- 59:00because it's not your money can actually a kneecap you from
- 59:04making more Bitcoin in the future.
- 59:06This is how we thought about building the businesses here.
- 59:08It's like you need the constraints.
- 59:10So for for all reasons, we've all had our checking account
- 59:13have a little too much cash and it goes out way too fast than it
- 59:15should. And it's the exact same example
- 59:17from hiring to the culture being like, OK, we have two money, too
- 59:20much money to pay versus finding the real people that want to
- 59:22come on board. And ultimately, it's to to
- 59:25Liam's point, the person changing, chasing more of those
- 59:28monetary units that's going to drive to build a more efficient
- 59:31business and getting everyone on that same boat chasing those
- 59:34units. And that's been the historical
- 59:37problem or where everything breaks down is around seeking
- 59:40higher valuations. Like the amount of crazy to your
- 59:43point, Clay on, you know, Silicon Valley metrics like it
- 59:46was just insane. I always remember that we were
- 59:49it's like it was desks. It was always like you got to
- 59:51sell desks. You end up giving them away for
- 59:52free because that's what like Mollison SoftBank and I like
- 59:55talking about the we were example because like, well, it's
- 59:58a joke today. They had not only world class
- 1:00:00talent, the best people, but it's also you saw at the highest
- 1:00:04level of operational scale, but you also saw that like.
- 1:00:07Fiat, like just in its purest form, how the craziness can just
- 1:00:11like distort all of business building.
- 1:00:14And so I like to think that just as good as like learning, you
- 1:00:18can take learnings and, and leverage them.
- 1:00:20I think the mistakes are probably more important than the
- 1:00:22learnings because, you know, the mistakes are the things that can
- 1:00:24kill you. The learnings can only make you
- 1:00:25a little bit better. So there's a lot from the we
- 1:00:28work that's We work days that have always stuck with me.
- 1:00:33Yeah, there's a, there's a nice convergence of sort of
- 1:00:36everything we've talked about for the past hour, like the
- 1:00:39first half of the conversation around disruption from AI tools
- 1:00:43doing more with less. Like saving a Bitcoin is just an
- 1:00:46extension of that mentality in my mind of if you're going to do
- 1:00:49more with less with your capital asset and you want something
- 1:00:53that's finite, scarce and actually grows your purchasing
- 1:00:55power over time that allows you to do, do more in the future.
- 1:00:58And so it's kind of these two ideas are converging.
- 1:01:01I think that's the transition that we're going to watch play
- 1:01:03out over the next decade is people recognizing these two
- 1:01:07forces sort of colliding in terms of, you know, deflationary
- 1:01:12forces from AI and then needing basically a, a better form of
- 1:01:15money to preserve your purchasing power into the future
- 1:01:18and, and actually get the most out of those tools effectively.
- 1:01:23So not only being efficient from an operational perspective, but
- 1:01:26also how you're actually storing value.
- 1:01:31Clay, you'd shared another link that I'm pulling up right now.
- 1:01:36This is not your mother's alpha is the name of the the report
- 1:01:41here. What are what are we looking at
- 1:01:42on the screen here? So I think these guys are some
- 1:01:46of the better fund of funds investors.
- 1:01:50It's level, it's Jay Coverman, Alberta Zut.
- 1:01:54And I mean, they've done a lot of thinking of just like what
- 1:01:57actually creates alpha for early stage fund managers and they
- 1:02:02just condense those notes into this piece.
- 1:02:05And I think the four that stood out, it's this idea of
- 1:02:08structural inefficiencies where smaller fonts just have more
- 1:02:12freedom. And I think that gives them a
- 1:02:15lot more alignment with founders, deep information
- 1:02:19asymmetry where they can just become sector as experts and
- 1:02:24specific verticals and they can leverage that information
- 1:02:27asymmetry to make better decisions.
- 1:02:30Non redundant sourcing networks. I think you're saying people
- 1:02:33that I think a lot of venture investors, they talk about this
- 1:02:36idea of having proprietary deal flow or like proprietary
- 1:02:40sourcing abilities. I think that is just not true
- 1:02:43for 99% of funds. But I do think there are a
- 1:02:46handful that do have pretty interesting sourcing networks.
- 1:02:49And I think speed and analytical edge, I mean, I think speed is
- 1:02:55and especially in the early stages, like being able to make
- 1:02:57decisions quickly. I think, I don't know, it seems
- 1:03:02harder to do that the more downstream you go.
- 1:03:06And I'd argue like the quicker you're making decisions as a
- 1:03:08Series A, series B investor, like I'd argue you probably not
- 1:03:12doing your fiduciary duty, like there's just too much to
- 1:03:15underwrite. But that's what they that kind
- 1:03:18of recapped is there their main sources of of alpha?
- 1:03:22I mean, I think all of these are constantly evolving, but going
- 1:03:26through that entire piece, I think it's I mean, I like
- 1:03:29listening to how LP's are evaluating the asset class as a
- 1:03:33whole. I think they they do a good job
- 1:03:35of jotting down some of their thoughts you.
- 1:03:38Know what that reminds me of? Yeah, we should share this in
- 1:03:41the show notes. I'd love to look at it.
- 1:03:43This just reminds me of a start up like at the end of the day,
- 1:03:46like venture firm is a startup, especially when it's first
- 1:03:49starting. By definition, you know, you can
- 1:03:52make the case that, you know, an A16Z or a founders fund or ABC's
- 1:03:56a larger enterprise, but the more successful they could run
- 1:04:00like a startup, meaning iterative, quick, like a lot of
- 1:04:04the functions that you share, domain expertise, actual edge,
- 1:04:07right? Like a startup that's very
- 1:04:09successful has like a learned secret.
- 1:04:11There's something that they know about the market that's allowing
- 1:04:14them to tap into growth and product market fit in the same
- 1:04:16way here, if you actually have proprietary deal flow or access,
- 1:04:20it's because you have some earned secret in the market that
- 1:04:23you're leveraging to make investments or connections.
- 1:04:25And so, yeah, this makes complete sense.
- 1:04:27And then it also makes complete sense of why most venture firms
- 1:04:30aren't run like this because they're not really run by like
- 1:04:33builders. They're run by people that have
- 1:04:35like looked at the mental or the legacy models of like what
- 1:04:38capital allocation look like. And they just kind of like
- 1:04:41cloned it over versus thought from first principles, like what
- 1:04:44would make me super dynamic, iterative, give me asymmetric
- 1:04:49edge knowledge. So yeah, I know this is very
- 1:04:52cool. And Ryan's, we have a lot of the
- 1:04:53stuff we're kind of working on at Early Riders.
- 1:04:57Hey guys, hope you're enjoying the podcast.
- 1:04:59It was a great RIP. Just wanted to do a quick note
- 1:05:02from early writers. We producing an insane amount of
- 1:05:06content at the firm from research to analysis.
- 1:05:10And then we have some exciting companies that we'll be
- 1:05:13announcing that we backed recently.
- 1:05:16If you're looking to break into the space and you're either
- 1:05:19trying to get more insights or looking to build in the
- 1:05:21ecosystem, you know, would love for you to sign up for our
- 1:05:25research and newsletter or shoot us a note on how you want to get
- 1:05:28involved. There's some very interesting
- 1:05:30things we'll be bringing to the market and so I encourage you to
- 1:05:32to stay close in case you're looking to get into this
- 1:05:36ecosystem at some point in the future.
- 1:05:38Hope you enjoy the rest of the show.
- 1:05:43Yeah, it's super interesting. All right.
- 1:05:46We're coming up a little over an hour.
- 1:05:48There was a few other links that I wanted to cover.
- 1:05:53One is these, these are both sort of more crypto related.
- 1:06:00Liam, you had shared something on the regulatory front which
- 1:06:03I'll pull up right now. And then the other headline from
- 1:06:06this morning around Deutsche Bank getting into crypto
- 1:06:12custody, which is something we've talked a lot about over
- 1:06:15the past 6 to 12 months or so. As as these banks come in, how
- 1:06:18are they going to do it? And it looks like they are
- 1:06:21effectively outsourcing it to someone, yet it still won't be
- 1:06:24ready until 2026. But up on the screen now, I have
- 1:06:28this market structure news if you want to speak to this, Liam.
- 1:06:32Yeah. I mean, this, all of this was
- 1:06:34pretty much going into where the money and valuations and raising
- 1:06:40has been over the last few months.
- 1:06:43And it's all gone to the largest players in this space.
- 1:06:46We've seen circle with a massively successful IPO.
- 1:06:50It was up 10X at one point. It's settling in around 7X up
- 1:06:55now. Finance received $2 billion
- 1:06:58earlier this year. Gemini is assuming to be going
- 1:07:03public, cracking rumors with them going public as well.
- 1:07:07Bitco sounds like they're going public too.
- 1:07:10And so we're, we're seeing capital being raised from a
- 1:07:14large amount of legacy player, I guess legacy players in the
- 1:07:19crypto space, because we're seeing a slew or a ton of very
- 1:07:25positive momentum as it relates to digital asset clarifications
- 1:07:32in the space. So at the same time, so I would
- 1:07:36say those they have a massive advantage because they have a
- 1:07:40really established client base, solid UX, like no name in the
- 1:07:45space, but they generally have a lot of, you know, some cost of
- 1:07:49old technology grafting to, you know, whatever old Ethereum L
- 1:07:54twos. They have a bunch of different
- 1:07:55communities and VC arms across all these different firms and,
- 1:07:58and have different, a bunch of different cohorts.
- 1:08:00Please. On the other side of that, you
- 1:08:02have the banks like DB, which is launching Crystal crypto custody
- 1:08:07by next year by partnering with another company.
- 1:08:11And these banks, you know, I think that they're mostly
- 1:08:14leaning into stable coins because, you know, they're
- 1:08:17banks, they want to make more dollars and stable coins give
- 1:08:20you the ability to make more dollars.
- 1:08:22They don't yet realize that the end goal is to get more Bitcoin,
- 1:08:27not more dollars. And so with that, I think that,
- 1:08:32you know, these banks are going to be slow to move.
- 1:08:34They get a partner with others. I would imagine that there are
- 1:08:38acquisitions being looked at from other players in the space,
- 1:08:41but I think that kind of and then one other cohort that we
- 1:08:46mentioned previously was the Robin Hoods of the world.
- 1:08:50But and they're going to be integrating a lot of the
- 1:08:54technology that, you know, these crypto players have, which, you
- 1:08:59know, being stable coins to lower cost, tokenizing equities
- 1:09:03kind of grifting off that as well as, you know, they continue
- 1:09:06to offer Bitcoin, but it's not really a core focus.
- 1:09:08So they'll be like somewhat of winners, but don't.
- 1:09:12And you know, the the banks and native players in the crypto
- 1:09:17space are are being rewarded with large amounts of capital at
- 1:09:20the moment. I do think that this is going to
- 1:09:23be kind of a buy the rumor sell the news type event as it
- 1:09:28relates to regulatory structure across broader digital assets.
- 1:09:31And you know, I don't see a lot of these circles, coin bases,
- 1:09:37Gemini finances of the world kind of continuing to gain
- 1:09:43additional market share and value accruing to them just
- 1:09:47because just like the earliest Internet companies, many of them
- 1:09:51kind of faded away into a relevance because they were
- 1:09:54unable to adjust based on, you know, consumer needs over time.
- 1:09:59They had some cost fallacies they had to stick to.
- 1:10:02And I do still think that there is a massive opportunity as it
- 1:10:08comes to infrastructure that well positioned to benefit from
- 1:10:12increased needs like like multi institution custody.
- 1:10:16So that's kind of just like an overview of everything that I
- 1:10:19see going on in the space right now is as I referenced earlier,
- 1:10:22the amount of IPO and M&A deals over a billion dollars is
- 1:10:27significantly higher than it has been anytime in the past.
- 1:10:30And so I think now many of these legacy funds just like kind of
- 1:10:36the AI trend in in narrative crypto is kind of benefiting
- 1:10:42from that as well, at least as it relates to the public
- 1:10:44markets. And but I think that the
- 1:10:48majority of of that is, is kind of going to be a buy the rumor,
- 1:10:53sell the news just because they're they're not necessarily
- 1:10:57the ones who I think will continue to be innovating and
- 1:11:01keeping up with where the consumer wants in the future.
- 1:11:05Are you are you shorting hood? You think hood's down only from
- 1:11:09here? You know, all time highs
- 1:11:11building on Arbitrum I'm. No, I'm not.
- 1:11:15I'm not touching anything in the public market.
- 1:11:17I think what you're describing though is, is like more of a
- 1:11:21medium to long term outcome. Like I think, I think a lot of
- 1:11:25this stuff could get super frothy in the near term.
- 1:11:29I think we're just like as you just listed off like all those
- 1:11:31companies that are yet to even go public.
- 1:11:33Like I think there's a lot, a lot of near term noise.
- 1:11:38It's going to be hard to discern for the average person, the
- 1:11:42average investor looking at the space specifically on the bank
- 1:11:48stuff like this DB announcement. As I mentioned, we've kind of
- 1:11:51talked about this a lot of like, OK, well how how are these banks
- 1:11:55going to actually get into custody?
- 1:11:57Are they going to build it themselves?
- 1:11:59Are they going to outsource it? Are they going to look at things
- 1:12:02like multi institution custody participating, but you know, in
- 1:12:06in sort of a more isolated fashion?
- 1:12:10This is kind of like my base case, like I think they are
- 1:12:13largely going to just outsource it because I think we've already
- 1:12:17seen signals of that trend with the ETF issuers outsourcing the
- 1:12:21custody of Coinbase by and large.
- 1:12:24And so I think you're going to continue to see similar
- 1:12:27announcements like this from more of the incumbent
- 1:12:29traditional banks that are tapping, partnering with or even
- 1:12:34acquiring more crypto native firms to, to help them figure
- 1:12:37out custody effectively. Clay, any any thoughts on this
- 1:12:43before we wrap or or anything else you wanted to mention?
- 1:12:47I feel like you guys got such a deeper understanding of all this
- 1:12:49stuff than me. I probably had the most
- 1:12:51qualified opinion on it, so I played the 5th.
- 1:12:57Fair enough. Fair enough.
- 1:13:00Well, Clay, thanks for thanks for joining us.
- 1:13:02This was a fun one. And as you mentioned, we'll
- 1:13:06we'll have more guests in the show going forward.
- 1:13:07So stay tuned everybody. Thanks for joining us.
- 1:13:12Yeah, feel free to give us feedback as well, what you want
- 1:13:14to see, what you liked and what you didn't like.
- 1:13:16And we'll continue to iterate from here too.
- 1:13:20Sounds good. All right.
- 1:13:21Thanks, boys. Thanks, guys.
- 1:13:22Thanks, guys. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:13:26week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:13:28valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:13:30rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:13:33All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:13:35notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:13:38reminder that Onramp Media is for informational and
- 1:13:40entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:13:43investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:13:46your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:13:48Visit onrampbitcoin.com/contact to schedule a consultation with
- 1:13:53one of our private Client Advisors.