Latest / Secrets of the Centuries / The History of the Ottoman Empire - 1299 - 1922
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine you are an entrepreneur today. You are,
- 0:03you know, launching a brand new venture. Right.
- 0:05And your ultimate dream, your absolute best case
- 0:08scenario, is that maybe your company survives
- 0:11your lifetime. If you're lucky. Right. You are
- 0:13incredibly lucky. And if you build an absolute
- 0:16juggernaut, maybe it lasts a century. Yeah. Now
- 0:19I want you to picture a small band of nomadic
- 0:21warriors in the year 1299. They build a startup,
- 0:24essentially, on the dusty, fractured frontiers
- 0:27of Anatolia. Yeah, just completely off the radar.
- 0:29Exactly. But this operation doesn't just survive
- 0:32a few decades. It scales into a global monopoly
- 0:35that spans Europe, Asia, and Africa. It is wild
- 0:38to think about. It dictates global trade routes.
- 0:41It rewrites the geopolitical map. And it holds
- 0:44onto power for over 600 years. It is genuinely
- 0:48one of the most staggering arcs in human history.
- 0:51I mean, we were talking about a political and
- 0:54military entity that outlasted rival dynasties,
- 0:57survived the Black Death. and somehow adapted
- 1:00to centuries of technological revolutions before
- 1:03finally fracturing in the 20th century. So today
- 1:06we are taking a massive stack of historical primary
- 1:09accounts, military logs, and modern historical
- 1:12analyses to unpack the entire lifespan of the
- 1:15Ottoman Empire. It is a lot of material. It is
- 1:19a ton. And our mission for this deep dive is
- 1:21not to just barrage you with a timeline of unpronounceable
- 1:24names and dates. We want to figure out the underlying
- 1:27mechanics. The how and the why. Exactly. How
- 1:30does a tiny obscure faction in 1299 maintain
- 1:34a stranglehold on the known world for six centuries?
- 1:37And just as importantly, how does a machine that
- 1:40powerful eventually suffer what amounts to a
- 1:42catastrophic corporate style collapse by 1922?
- 1:46To answer that, we really have to look at this
- 1:47narrative as a master class in adaptation versus
- 1:50stagnation. OK, let's unpack this. Well, when
- 1:52you dig into these primary texts, you uncover
- 1:54a fascinating structural paradox. The very institutions
- 1:59like the exact military and political innovations
- 2:01that made the Ottomans completely unstoppable
- 2:04in their early days. Those are the precise mechanisms
- 2:07that tore them apart from the inside centuries
- 2:09later. I kept thinking of it like a massive multi
- 2:12-generational family business. Oh, that's a good
- 2:15way to look at it. Right. Because you have the
- 2:17explosive startup phase driven by these visionary
- 2:19risk taking founders. Sure. Then you enter the
- 2:22golden age of ruthless management and massive
- 2:25expansion where they are innovating faster than
- 2:27anyone else on the market. Right. They are just
- 2:29out competing everyone. But then inevitably the
- 2:32later generations take over. The internal culture
- 2:35rots. They try some desperate rebranding to keep
- 2:37up with new competitors. And eventually the whole
- 2:40thing just goes bankrupt. That is a remarkably
- 2:43accurate framework. And to truly understand why
- 2:46the foundation ultimately cracked, we have to
- 2:49start by looking at how they poured the concrete
- 2:51in the first place. Right. We have to look at
- 2:53how they completely subverted the traditional
- 2:55rules of empire building to rise at all. Okay,
- 2:58let's set the scene. It is roughly 1299. We are
- 3:01in Anatolia, which is modern -day Turkey, and
- 3:04we meet a leader named Osman the First. Yes.
- 3:07But going through the early records, I was struck
- 3:10by how little we actually know about this guy.
- 3:12The origin story feels almost like a fable. Yeah,
- 3:15that is a persistent headache for Ottoman historians.
- 3:18There is a severe lack of reliable contemporary
- 3:21information about Osman's actual life. I mean,
- 3:24we barely even know his real name, right? Right.
- 3:27Well, we know the empire's name. Ottoman is a
- 3:29European derivation of his name, which was Uthman
- 3:31in Arabic. But separating fabricated lore from
- 3:35historical fact here is incredibly difficult.
- 3:37What do the texts actually say about his background?
- 3:40According to later imperial myth -making, he
- 3:42was the son of a man named Ertugul and the grandson
- 3:44of Soliman Shah, which would tie him to the Kayi
- 3:48tribe of Oghuz Turks. For the listener who might
- 3:51not be deep into Central Asian history, who exactly
- 3:54were the Kayi tribe? There were a branch of nomadic
- 3:56pastoralists. These were people who lived in
- 3:58the saddle, moving herds across the steppes.
- 4:02characterized by deep clan loyalties and a highly
- 4:06mobile martial culture. But the sources are kind
- 4:09of conflicted on whether he was actually from
- 4:11that tribe. Deeply debated. Even that specific
- 4:14lineage to the Kayi tribe is fiercely contested
- 4:16today. The later Ottomans likely embellished
- 4:19it to legitimize the rule over other Turkic tribes.
- 4:22It's classic founder mythology. You want to trace
- 4:24your roots back to something legendary to prove
- 4:26you have the right to rule. Exactly. But whether
- 4:29he was actually the grandson of Suleyman Shah
- 4:31or not, Osman possessed an incredible eye for
- 4:34geopolitical market timing. Oh, absolutely. He
- 4:37looks around his neighborhood and sees two massive
- 4:39legacy empires completely falling apart. His
- 4:42timing was impeccable. To his east, you have
- 4:44the Seljuk dynasty in Iran and Mesopotamia. And
- 4:47they were struggling, right? They were once a
- 4:49powerhouse. But by the end of the 13th century,
- 4:52the Mongol invasions had effectively shattered
- 4:54them. They were reduced to a bunch of squabbling,
- 4:56decentralized principalities. Just totally fractured.
- 4:59Exactly. And to his west, the Byzantine Christian
- 5:02Empire, based in Constantinople, is just a shadow
- 5:05of his former self. Because of the Crusades?
- 5:07It had been severely weakened by internal civil
- 5:10wars and the disastrous aftermath of the Fourth
- 5:13Crusade. So, Augsman looks at this massive power
- 5:16vacuum and realizes there is an opening. He steps
- 5:20into that void by leading what the texts call
- 5:22Ghazi troops. I want to make sure we define that
- 5:24clearly because it comes up constantly in the
- 5:26early records. It's a crucial term. A Ghazi was
- 5:29essentially a frontier warrior motivated by a
- 5:32potent mix of Islamic holy war and frankly, territorial
- 5:35plunder, right? Precisely. The concept of Gaza
- 5:38or holy war was the ideological glue, but it
- 5:41was deeply pragmatic. These were highly mobile
- 5:44light cavalry units. So they were fast? Very
- 5:46fast. And they were drawn to Oresman not just
- 5:49because of religious fervor, but because he was
- 5:51a competent leader who promised them land and
- 5:54wealth taken from the Byzantines. He starts staging
- 5:57a series of raids against Byzantine outposts,
- 5:59slowly carving out a sphere of influence. But
- 6:02the accounts make it clear this wasn't an overnight
- 6:04blitzkrieg. Early on, these Ghazi warriors were
- 6:07missing a crucial piece of the puzzle. Yes, they
- 6:09were. They were incredibly fast, disruptive raiders,
- 6:12but they didn't have the heavy siege equipment
- 6:14necessary to take fortified Byzantine cities.
- 6:16I mean, you can't exactly knock down a 50 -foot
- 6:18stone wall with a horse and a bow. This was the
- 6:21technological wall they hit, quite literally.
- 6:23They could dominate the open plains near the
- 6:25Sea of Marmara and they could cut off supply
- 6:27lines, but they couldn't close the deal on major
- 6:29urban centers. Because siege warfare was just
- 6:32a different beast back then. Completely different.
- 6:34To take a walled city in the 14th century, you
- 6:37needed massive siege engines, trained engineers,
- 6:41and the logistical capacity to sit outside a
- 6:43city for months or even years. Just starving
- 6:46them out. Right. Feeding your own army while
- 6:48starving the defenders. It took decades of relentless
- 6:51grinding pressure before they finally captured
- 6:53the major city of Bursa in 1326. And that's right
- 6:56around the time Osman dies, right? Exactly. So
- 6:59that victory at Bursa is a watershed moment.
- 7:02Osman's son, Orhan, the second sultan, takes
- 7:04over and Bursa becomes their first real capital.
- 7:08Yes, they finally have a permanent base. This
- 7:10is where the whole operation pivots from being
- 7:12a band of raiders into a structured state. Orhan
- 7:16realizes that if they are going to hold these
- 7:18cities and expand further, they can't just rely
- 7:20on volunteers who show up for a summer raiding
- 7:23season and then go home to tend their flocks.
- 7:25It is a critical maturation point. You cannot
- 7:28build an empire with gig workers. Right, gig
- 7:31workers. Orhan needs a permanent professional
- 7:34military. Initially, he consults his brother,
- 7:37Aladdin, who suggests organizing a paid infantry
- 7:40force. How does that go? They try it, but the
- 7:44traditional Turkish cavalrymen are independent,
- 7:47and they really chafe under strict infantry discipline.
- 7:50It isn't yielding the absolute control Orhan
- 7:52wants. So he pivots? He pivots. He turns to a
- 7:56scholar and statesman related by marriage, Kundalikara
- 8:00Halil. And Halil proposes a system that fundamentally
- 8:03alters the trajectory of world history. The Devashirme
- 8:07system, which gives birth to the Janissaries.
- 8:10And I have to admit, reading the mechanics of
- 8:12how this worked was genuinely jarring. It is
- 8:15very dark. The term Janissary comes from Yenicherry,
- 8:18meaning new soldier. Halil's advice was to institute
- 8:22a blood tax. on the newly conquered Christian
- 8:24populations in the Balkans and Anatolia. A blood
- 8:27tax. Yes. Ottoman officials would systematically
- 8:31enter Christian villages and conscript a percentage
- 8:33of their strongest, most intelligent young boys,
- 8:36typically between the ages of 8 and 14. Wait,
- 8:40so they are forcibly taking children from the
- 8:42families they just conquered, bringing them back
- 8:45to the capital, converting them to Islam, and
- 8:48turning them into an elite salaried infantry
- 8:50force legally classified as slaves to the Sultan.
- 8:53That is exactly what they did. I found myself
- 8:55staring at the page asking, why on earth wouldn't
- 8:58you just hire mercenaries? I mean, European monarchs
- 9:01hired Swiss guards or German lands next all the
- 9:03time. They did. So why go through this incredibly
- 9:06complex, traumatic process of kidnapping and
- 9:09brainwashing kids? How could you ever trust them
- 9:11not to immediately slit your throat the moment
- 9:13you handed them a sword? To understand the logic.
- 9:16You have to look at the structural flaw of traditional
- 9:19feudal militaries and mercenaries. What's fascinating
- 9:22here is the psychology behind it. Okay. If a
- 9:25king relies on noble lords to provide knights,
- 9:28those lords have their own wealth, their own
- 9:30castles, and their own political ambitions. They
- 9:33will betray the king the second it benefits them.
- 9:35Right, they have competing interests. And if
- 9:37you hire mercenaries, well, they fight for gold.
- 9:40The moment someone pays them more or the battle
- 9:42turns against you, they abandon you. So the Sultan
- 9:45is trying to solve the problem of divided loyalties.
- 9:48Exactly. The Janissary system was a masterpiece
- 9:52of dark psychological engineering. Wow. By taking
- 9:56these boys at a young age, the Ottoman state
- 9:59severed every single tie they had to the outside
- 10:01world. They lost their biological families, their
- 10:04native languages, their local cultures and their
- 10:07religions. They erased their entire past. And
- 10:10in place of all that, the state provided them
- 10:11with a new family, the Janissary Corps. and a
- 10:15new singular father figure, the Sultan. They
- 10:19were forbidden to marry, right? At least during
- 10:22their active service years. At least during their
- 10:24active service years. Forbidden to marry, forbidden
- 10:27to engage in commercial trades, forbidden to
- 10:30own significant private property. Their entire
- 10:33existence, their identity, their physical survival,
- 10:37and their social status were entirely dependent
- 10:39on the survival and success of the Sultan. So
- 10:42if the Sultan falls, they fall. Exactly, it created
- 10:46a standing army of warrior monks who possessed
- 10:50an almost fanatical devotion to the throne You
- 10:53have to imagine being part of an organization
- 10:55where your entire identity and survival are intrinsically
- 10:58tied to the CEO I think of it like an artificial
- 11:01immune system. The Janissaries were these white
- 11:03blood cells created in a lab, designed with one
- 11:06single purpose, to protect the host body, the
- 11:08Sultan, from all outside threats, without being
- 11:11corrupted by the local politics that constantly
- 11:14tore other empires apart. That is a very apt
- 11:16analogy. And while Orhan laid the groundwork,
- 11:19it was his son, the third Sultan, Murad I, who
- 11:23truly institutionalized the Janissaries into
- 11:25the most feared infantry in Europe. But Orhan
- 11:28also paired this military innovation with some
- 11:31incredibly aggressive and opportunistic diplomacy,
- 11:33right? Oh, absolutely. The Orhan era is wild
- 11:36diplomatically. He actually allies with a Byzantine
- 11:39Emperor, John VI Cantacuzenos. He does. And he
- 11:42marries the Emperor's daughter, Theodora. Then
- 11:45as a favor for helping John in a civil war, Orhan
- 11:47gets permission to send his troops into Thrace
- 11:49to raid. Which was a massive mistake by the Byzantines.
- 11:53Right. And then his son, Suleyman Pasha, just
- 11:57casually occupies a fortress at Gallipoli after
- 12:00an earthquake damages the walls in 1354. Just
- 12:03walks right in. And when the Byzantines ask for
- 12:05it back, Orhan basically refuses, claiming God
- 12:09opened the gates for them. It was a catastrophic
- 12:11miscalculation by the Byzantines to invite the
- 12:14Ottomans across the Dardanelles. That foothold
- 12:17at Gallipoli established a permanent Ottoman
- 12:20presence in Europe. It's a beachhead. Exactly.
- 12:23It acted as a magnet drawing thousands of ambitious
- 12:26Turkish warriors from Anatolia who wanted land
- 12:29and loot, fundamentally shifting the balance
- 12:31of power. So by the time Orhan dies and Murad
- 12:34I takes over in 1362, the Ottomans are deeply
- 12:37entrenched in the Balkans. And Murad really ramps
- 12:40up the pressure. It does. But he doesn't just
- 12:42conquer and destroy, he uses a vassalage system.
- 12:45He allows native European rulers to keep their
- 12:48thrones if they swear allegiance, pay tribute,
- 12:50and, crucially, provide auxiliary troops for
- 12:53the Ottoman army. This is how you scale an empire
- 12:55rapidly. Because it can't be everywhere at once.
- 12:58Right. You don't try to micromanage the local
- 13:00administration of every Bulgarian or Serbian
- 13:03village you take. You co -opt the existing power
- 13:06structures. It's like franchising. Yes. The vassal
- 13:09system meant the Ottomans could punch way above
- 13:12their weight class. because they could suddenly
- 13:13call upon vast reserves of Christian European
- 13:16troops to fight alongside their Ghazi cavalry
- 13:19and their elite Janissaries. Which culminates
- 13:21in 1389 at the Battle of Kosovo. A massive turning
- 13:25point. The Ottomans are facing a massive coalition
- 13:28of Serbian forces, and the accounts of this battle
- 13:31describe an absolute meat grinder. Both armies
- 13:34suffer catastrophic casualties. Brutal fighting.
- 13:37In fact, both leaders, the Serbian Prince Lazar
- 13:40and the Ottoman Sultan Murad I, are killed during
- 13:44the battle. Yet the Ottomans emerge victorious.
- 13:47Right. Not necessarily through brilliant tactical
- 13:50maneuvering, but simply because their vassal
- 13:52network gave them deeper reserves. They could
- 13:55absorb the losses and the Serbians couldn't.
- 13:58Kosovo effectively broke the back of Serbian
- 14:00resistance and opened the deeper Balkans to Ottoman
- 14:03expansion. But, you know, explosive unchecked
- 14:06growth always attracts the attention of dangerous
- 14:09rivals. The apex predators. Exactly. And just
- 14:12as the Ottomans seem to have cracked the code
- 14:14of empire building, they hit a wall that almost
- 14:17erased them from history entirely. The Timurid
- 14:20disaster. OK, so Murad dies at Kosovo and his
- 14:23son Beyazid I takes over. Yes. Bayezid is known
- 14:27as the Thunderbolt. He is aggressive. He's expanding
- 14:30into the Balkans. He completely annihilates a
- 14:32massive European crusader army at Nicopolis in
- 14:351396. He is having an incredible run. The man
- 14:39is arrogant and he has every reason to be. He's
- 14:42arguably the most powerful Muslim ruler on earth.
- 14:45But then he picks a fight with a Turko -Mongol
- 14:48warlord named Tamer. Which was a terrible idea.
- 14:52Timur, sometimes known as Tamerlane, was a strategic
- 14:55genius and a figure of absolute terror. He's
- 14:58playing on a whole different level. He had built
- 15:00a massive empire stretching from India to Russia,
- 15:03heavily modeling himself on Genghis Khan. Bayezid
- 15:06and Timur began exchanging these incredibly insulting
- 15:08letters, disputing control over border territories
- 15:11in eastern Anatolia. Just massive egos clashing.
- 15:15Exactly. And Bayezid fundamentally underestimated
- 15:17the sheer scale and discipline of Timur's war
- 15:20machine. This all boils over in 1402 at the Battle
- 15:24of Ankara. I was reading the tactical breakdown
- 15:26of this battle, and it is just a masterclass
- 15:29in asymmetrical warfare by Timur. Timur played
- 15:32him perfectly. Bayezid is marching his elite
- 15:35army, including his Janissaries and his Serbian
- 15:37vassal cavalry, out to meet Timur. But Timur
- 15:40completely outmaneuvers him. He does. He bypasses
- 15:43Bayezid's main force. besieges the city of Ankara
- 15:46and forces Bayezid to turn around and march his
- 15:48army into a trap. Timur dictated the terms of
- 15:51the engagement flawlessly. By the time Bayezid's
- 15:54forces arrived, they were exhausted and thirsty
- 15:57from forced marches in the Anatolian summer heat.
- 15:59It's brutal. And Timur had achieved the ultimate
- 16:02logistical checkmate. He diverted the local river
- 16:05and poisoned the remaining wells. He literally
- 16:07cut off the water supply. Yes. It is such a visceral
- 16:11detail. It's a reminder that all the elite troops
- 16:13in the world can't beat basic logistics. It doesn't
- 16:17matter if you have the most elite, highly trained
- 16:19Janissary infantry in the world. It doesn't matter
- 16:21if your armor is impenetrable. If your soldiers
- 16:24haven't had water in two days under a blazing
- 16:27sun, the army is going to collapse. Absolutely.
- 16:30The Ottoman army disintegrated. Several of Bayezid's
- 16:33recently conquered Anatolian vassals actually
- 16:36defected to Timur mid -battle. Wow. Just switching
- 16:39sides right there. Timur completely destroyed
- 16:42the Ottoman force and achieved the unthinkable.
- 16:45He captured the Ottoman Sultan alive. Bayezid
- 16:49is taken prisoner and he dies in captivity less
- 16:51than a year later. And with the CEO dead and
- 16:55the army shattered, the empire descends into
- 16:57a decade -long civil war known as the Ottoman
- 16:59Interregnum. The Interregnum is a period of sheer
- 17:02geopolitical chaos. It is very Game of Thrones.
- 17:06Bayezid's remaining sons, Issa, Musa, Suleiman,
- 17:10and Mehmed spend the next 10 years tearing the
- 17:13empire apart to claim the throne. I tried mapping
- 17:15out the shifting alliances and the sources and
- 17:17it's dizzying. It's a mess. Suleiman takes the
- 17:20European territories and sets up in Idirna. Mehmed
- 17:23takes part of Anatolia. Issa and Musa fight over
- 17:26the old capital of Bursa. They are assassinating
- 17:29each other's commanders, making alliances with
- 17:31the Byzantines, then breaking them, allying with
- 17:33Serbian warlords, fleeing exile, returning with
- 17:36new mercenary armies. It is nonstop betrayal.
- 17:40At one point, Suleiman defeats Musa, but then
- 17:43Suleiman's own troops turn on him because he
- 17:45was allegedly a severe alcoholic who alienated
- 17:47his generals. Which allows Musa to come back.
- 17:49Right. Which allows Musa to capture and execute
- 17:51him. Then Musa decides to lay siege to Constantinople
- 17:55because the Byzantines had helped his brothers.
- 17:57which terrifies the Byzantine Emperor into begging
- 18:00Mehmed for help. So Mehmed crosses over. Mehmed
- 18:03crosses over, fights Musa, eventually defeats
- 18:06him at the Battle of Chamorley in 1413 and has
- 18:09him strangled. And Mehmed I finally reunites
- 18:12the Empire. He does. But looking at this critically,
- 18:15the Interregnum is the ultimate stress test.
- 18:19Their army was obliterated, their invincible
- 18:21sultan was humiliated and died in a cage, the
- 18:24heirs spent a decade burning their own cities
- 18:26to the ground, Logically, the Ottoman experiment
- 18:29should have ended right there in 1402. Most empires
- 18:32would have. So how did this state actually survive
- 18:35this? Well, this connects to the bigger picture.
- 18:38It survived because the administrative foundation,
- 18:41the vassal system, the bureaucracy, the tax collection
- 18:45systems we discussed earlier, had become deeply
- 18:48entrenched. It was bigger than any one person.
- 18:50Exactly. The local populations in the regional
- 18:53elites realized that a unified Ottoman state
- 18:56even a fractured one, offered more economic stability
- 19:00and security than returning to a patchwork of
- 19:02warring microstates. So they wanted the empire
- 19:05to survive. The concept of the Ottoman state
- 19:08had outgrown the individual personality of the
- 19:11Sultan. The engine was so well built that it
- 19:14kept idling even while the drivers were fighting
- 19:16over the steering wheel. The machine outlasts
- 19:18the man. Mehmed I manages to stabilize this machine
- 19:23until his death in 1421. His son, Murad II, takes
- 19:27over, and his reign is just a relentless grind
- 19:31of putting out fires. Constant warfare. He's
- 19:33fighting off pretenders to the throne funded
- 19:35by the Byzantines. He's warring with Venice.
- 19:38He's fighting the Hungarians. He's exhausted.
- 19:41And in 1444, he does something that completely
- 19:45baffled me. The abdication. He abdicates the
- 19:48throne to his son, Mehmed II. Abdication is incredibly
- 19:52rare in this era. Murad II essentially wanted
- 19:54to retire to a life of philosophy, poetry, and
- 19:58religious contemplation in Anatolia. He just
- 20:00wanted out. He leaves the administration of a
- 20:02massive, multi -continental empire to Mehmed
- 20:06II, who was roughly 12 years old at the time.
- 20:09Which immediately triggers a crisis. The European
- 20:12powers realize a middle schooler is running the
- 20:14Ottoman Empire, so the Pope organizes a massive
- 20:17crusade, led by the Hungarian general John Hunyadi,
- 20:21to wipe them out. They saw their chance? And
- 20:23the accounts say young Mehmed is so overwhelmed
- 20:26that he writes a letter to his father practically
- 20:28demanding he come back. He writes, if you are
- 20:31the sultan, come and lead your armies. If I am
- 20:34the sultan, I hereby order you to come and lead
- 20:37my armies. It's a brilliant piece of adolescent
- 20:40logic, really. And it forces Murad's hand. Murad
- 20:43returns, takes command, and absolutely crushes
- 20:47the Crusader army at the Battle of Varna in 1444.
- 20:50And then he tries to leave again. He tries to
- 20:53retire again, only to be forced back to the throne
- 20:56a few years later to put down a Janissary revolt.
- 20:58He spends the rest of his life leading campaigns
- 21:01until his death. Before we move on to what Mehmed
- 21:03II does when he finally grows up, there is a
- 21:06fascinating subplot during Murad's reign. At
- 21:09that battle of Arna, fighting against the Ottomans
- 21:11is a small contingent sent by a man named Vlad
- 21:14Dracul. Yes. For context, who was Vlad Dracul?
- 21:17Vladrakul was the voivode, or prince, of Wallachia,
- 21:21which is in modern day Romania. The voivodes
- 21:24were essentially frontier warlords caught in
- 21:26the meat grinder between the expanding Ottoman
- 21:28Empire to their south and the kingdom of Hungary
- 21:31to their north. So they were just trying to survive.
- 21:34Exactly. They constantly shifted legions to survive.
- 21:37What's crazy is that Vlad Rakul sent troops to
- 21:40fight the Ottomans, despite the fact that Murad
- 21:42II was currently holding his two youngest sons
- 21:46hostage in the Ottoman court. Hostage -taking
- 21:49was standard diplomatic practice. If a vassal
- 21:52swore loyalty, they handed over their children
- 21:54to ensure they wouldn't rebel. Right. Those two
- 21:57boys were raised alongside the young Mehmed II.
- 22:00One was named Radu. The other was Vlad III, who
- 22:04history remembers as Vlad the Impaler. or Dracula.
- 22:09Growing up in the same palace as the future sultan.
- 22:12It's incredible. The psychological seeds planted
- 22:14there are wild and that leads us directly into
- 22:17the era of peak power. Because having survived
- 22:20near death, the empire enters its golden age.
- 22:22Yes, characterized by this fascinating mix of
- 22:25brutal military innovation and surprising social
- 22:28tolerance. When Murad II finally dies in 1451,
- 22:32Mehmed II, no longer a 12 -year -old boy, but
- 22:35a highly educated, ambitious adult, takes the
- 22:38throne for the second time. And he has a singular,
- 22:42consuming obsession, capturing Constantinople.
- 22:45Previous sultans, including his own father, had
- 22:48tried and failed. Constantinople was protected
- 22:50by the Theodosian Walls, a triple -layered defensive
- 22:53system that had withstood every siege for a thousand
- 22:56years. But Mehmed II understood that the rules
- 22:59of warfare were changing. He invested heavily
- 23:02in a new experimental technology, gunpowder artillery.
- 23:06I want to focus on the sheer logistics of this
- 23:08because it's staggering. Mehmed hires a Hungarian
- 23:12cannon founder named Urbán to cast super weapons.
- 23:16These things were massive. The texts describe
- 23:19a bombard that was over 26 feet. long, capable
- 23:23of firing a stone ball weighing over a thousand
- 23:25pounds. But how do you even get a weapon like
- 23:28that to the battlefield in 1453? The logistics
- 23:31were a monumental feat of engineering. Moving
- 23:34Urban's monster cannon from the foundry in Edirne
- 23:37to Constantinople required a team of 60 oxen
- 23:40and hundreds of men just to keep the carriage
- 23:42from sinking into the mud. Just an absolute nightmare
- 23:45to transport. Oh, completely. And once in position,
- 23:49the cannons were so massive they could only be
- 23:51fired a few times a day. And they had to be constantly
- 23:53swabbed with warm olive oil to prevent the barrels
- 23:56from cracking out of the immense thermal stress.
- 23:59It's brute force industrial warfare. The psychological
- 24:02terror must have been unimaginable for the Byzantines.
- 24:04For 50 days, these deafening explosions are physically
- 24:08pulverizing walls that had stood for a millennium.
- 24:11And Mehmet wasn't just relying on artillery.
- 24:13When the Byzantines blocked the Golden Horn Harbor
- 24:16with a massive iron chain to protect their fleet,
- 24:19Mehmed did the impossible. The Greased Logs.
- 24:22Yes. He ordered his engineers to construct a
- 24:25pathway of Greased Logs over the steep hills
- 24:27of Galata. And under the cover of darkness, his
- 24:30troops physically dragged dozens of warships
- 24:33over land. Just pulling ships over a mountain.
- 24:36Bypassing the chain entirely and dropping them
- 24:38directly into the harbor behind the Byzantine
- 24:41defenses. It completely broke the defender's
- 24:43morale. On May 29, 1453, the walls are breached.
- 24:47The last Byzantine emperor dies fighting in the
- 24:49streets, and Mehmed takes the city. And he immediately
- 24:52makes it his capital. He renames it Istanbul,
- 24:56and he adopts a fascinating new title, Kisar
- 24:59-i -Rum, or Caesar of the Roman Empire. Mehmed
- 25:02didn't view himself as destroying the Roman legacy.
- 25:05He viewed himself as absorbing it. That is such
- 25:08an important distinction. He saw the Ottoman
- 25:10Empire as the rightful successor to Rome, blending
- 25:12Islamic governance with Byzantine imperial traditions.
- 25:16He allowed the Eastern Orthodox patriarch to
- 25:18remain in the city and manage the affairs of
- 25:20the Christian community, which stabilized the
- 25:23population and restarted the local economy. Here's
- 25:25where it gets really interesting. That pragmatic
- 25:28tolerance brings us back to the dynamic with
- 25:30his former childhood hostages, the sons of Vlad
- 25:32Dracul. Right. Radu, the younger brother, actually
- 25:35converted to Islam, stayed in the Ottoman court
- 25:37and became a trusted general for Mehmed. But
- 25:40Vlad III returned to Wallachia and became an
- 25:44absolute nightmare for the Ottomans. Vlad the
- 25:46Impaler understood Ottoman military tactics intimately
- 25:49because he was trained by them. He knew their
- 25:52playbook. He waged a horrific campaign of psychological
- 25:55guerrilla warfare. He couldn't beat Mehmed's
- 25:58massive armies in open combat, so he utilized
- 26:00scorched earth tactics, poisoned wells. and staged
- 26:04daring night raids to spread terror. The accounts
- 26:07of Mehmed's pursuit of Vlad are chilling. Mehmed
- 26:10marches his army into Wallachia and encounters
- 26:12the forest of the impaled, thousands of Ottoman
- 26:16soldiers and civilians executed on stakes. It's
- 26:19meant to break Mehmed's resolve. And surprisingly,
- 26:22it kind of works. Mehmed withdraws. He is quoted
- 26:25as saying something to the effect of, I cannot
- 26:27take land away from a man who does such marvelous
- 26:30things. And surely a man who had accomplished
- 26:33this is worthy of greater things. Many read that
- 26:36quote and assume Mehmet was intimidated. Right,
- 26:38because it sounds like he's backing down. But
- 26:40if you analyze the strategic reality, it reveals
- 26:43the mindset of a ruler operating with absolute
- 26:45security. When you are the undisputed superpower,
- 26:49you can afford to respect your enemies. Mehmet
- 26:51had just conquered the unconquerable city. He
- 26:54was the head of his superpower. So he's just
- 26:57being pragmatic. Yes. He recognized Vlad's ruthless
- 27:00competence, but he also realized that chasing
- 27:02a guerrilla warlord through impoverished forests
- 27:05was a massive drain on resources. He had the
- 27:08luxury of walking away, leaving Vlad's brother
- 27:11Radu to handle the regional proxy war, while
- 27:13Mehmed focused on richer conquests in Greece
- 27:16and the Mediterranean. The wild contradictions
- 27:18of these rulers. Mehmet II blows up the walls
- 27:21of Constantinople but expresses awe at Vlad the
- 27:24Impaler's brutality. Exactly. And that theme
- 27:27of calculated strategic tolerance becomes even
- 27:30more pronounced with his son, Bayezid II. Bayezid
- 27:33takes the throne in 1481, and while he's generally
- 27:37a more cautious ruler than his father, his most
- 27:40consequential decision occurs in 1492. The year
- 27:431492 is universally known for Columbus's voyage,
- 27:46but in the Mediterranean basin, it is defined
- 27:48by the Ahambra Decree. Ferdinand Isabella. Ferdinand
- 27:52Isabella of Spain issued an edict expelling the
- 27:54entire Jewish population and eventually the Muslim
- 27:57population from the Iberian Peninsula. And Bayezid
- 28:00II sees this not just as a humanitarian crisis,
- 28:03but as the geopolitical opportunity of the century.
- 28:07He sends his navy, commanded by Admiral Kemal
- 28:09Reis, to physically rescue these banished populations
- 28:12and transport them to Ottoman territories. And
- 28:15he backed it up with a full force of the law.
- 28:17Bayezid issued firmans, imperial decrees, to
- 28:21all provincial governors explicitly stating that
- 28:23these refugees were to be welcomed. With severe
- 28:26consequences if they weren't. threatening death
- 28:28to anyone who treated Jewish refugees differently
- 28:30or denied them entry. I am curious about the
- 28:33actual impact here. How exactly did taking in
- 28:36hundreds of thousands of refugees benefit the
- 28:39Ottoman state machinery? It was an immediate,
- 28:41massive injection of human capital. The Jewish
- 28:44and Muslim populations of Al -Andalus were among
- 28:47the most educated in Europe. And the brain drain
- 28:49from Spain directly fueled the Ottoman economy.
- 28:52Exactly. They brought advanced knowledge of medicine.
- 28:54modern banking practices, new techniques in gunpowder
- 28:57manufacturing, and the printing press. Bayezid
- 29:00II famously remarked that Ferdinand of Spain
- 29:02had impoverished his own kingdom to enrich the
- 29:05Ottoman Empire. The refugees settle heavily in
- 29:08cities like Thessaloniki and Istanbul, turning
- 29:11them into bustling cosmopolitan hubs of global
- 29:14trade. It proves that diversity and tolerance
- 29:16were strategic assets, not just moral choices.
- 29:19And all of that wealth and institutional stability
- 29:22sets the stage for the absolute zenith of the
- 29:25empire under Suleiman the Magnificent, who takes
- 29:28power in 1520. Suleiman inherited a juggernaut.
- 29:31His father, Suleiman I, had already doubled the
- 29:34size of the empire. By conquering Egypt, right?
- 29:36Yes. Suleiman used massed musket fire and field
- 29:39artillery to crush the Shia Safavid empire in
- 29:42Persia and then completely dismantled the Mamluk
- 29:44Sultanate. powerful slave soldier dynasty that
- 29:47controlled Egypt and the holy cities of Mecca
- 29:49and Medina. So Suleiman steps into the role of
- 29:52sultan and effectively the caliph of the Islamic
- 29:54world with overflowing treasuries and an invincible
- 29:58military. And Suleiman pushes the boundaries
- 30:00even further across North Africa into the Indian
- 30:03Ocean and deep into central Europe. I was looking
- 30:06at his campaign against the island fortress of
- 30:09Rhodes in 1522. The Knights Hospitaller were
- 30:12heavily entrenched there, disrupting Ottoman
- 30:15shipping. How do you dig out an elite order of
- 30:19Knights from an island fortress? Through sheer
- 30:22engineering attrition. The Ottomans engaged in
- 30:25massive sapping and mining operations. What does
- 30:27that entail exactly? They physically dug tunnels
- 30:30under the stone fortifications of roads and packed
- 30:33them with gunpowder, literally blowing the walls
- 30:36up from underneath. That is insane. The logistical
- 30:40capacity to maintain a massive fleet, feed 100
- 30:43,000 men on a barren island, and conduct complex
- 30:45subterranean demolition for months is a testament
- 30:48to the sophistication of the Ottoman war machine.
- 30:51And then in 1526, he marches into Hungary and
- 30:54faces King Louis II at the Battle of Mahaks.
- 30:57This is another example of superior military
- 31:00mechanics. The Hungarians rely on heavy armored
- 31:03cavalry charges, the classic medieval European
- 31:05tactic. But Suleiman uses chained artillery.
- 31:09Yes, the Ottoman gunners would chain their cannons
- 31:12together to prevent cavalry from breaking through
- 31:14the lines, creating an impenetrable wall of firepower.
- 31:17So the cavalry just hits a wall. When the Hungarian
- 31:20heavy cavalry charged, they were funneled into
- 31:23kill zones and absolutely shredded by disciplined
- 31:27artillery and Janissary musket fire. The entire
- 31:30Hungarian army was annihilated in a matter of
- 31:33hours. King Leis II himself drowns in a river
- 31:36trying to escape. Right. But just like his grandfather
- 31:38Mehmed, Suleiman displays this bizarre duality.
- 31:42Suleiman executes his enemies but weeps over
- 31:45their bodies. The accounts record Suleiman touring
- 31:48the battlefield. finding the body of the young
- 31:51Hungarian king and weeping. He says, may Allah
- 31:54be merciful. It was not my wish that he should
- 31:57be thus cut off before he scarcely tasted the
- 32:00sweets of life. It is the empathy that is only
- 32:03possible through absolute dominance. Suleiman
- 32:05wasn't fighting out of desperation or fear. He
- 32:08was fighting a war of imperial administration.
- 32:11When your state is that overwhelmingly powerful,
- 32:13you can afford to mourn your enemies because
- 32:16they never truly posed an existential threat
- 32:18to your survival. So how does an empire at its
- 32:21absolute peak start losing? It happens when a
- 32:24well -intentioned reform completely breaks the
- 32:27leadership pipeline. OK, let's talk about the
- 32:291600s, the innovation that killed the empire,
- 32:33cages and coffee shops. We are talking about
- 32:36the mechanisms of succession. For centuries,
- 32:40the Ottoman protocol for transferring power was
- 32:43essentially a brutal game of survival of the
- 32:45fittest. Fratricide. When a sultan died, his
- 32:48sons, who were usually governing different provinces
- 32:51and had their own private armies, would race
- 32:53back to the capital. Whoever seized the treasury
- 32:56and the support of the Janissaries became the
- 32:58new sultan. And then constitutionally, he would
- 33:01execute all of his surviving brothers and half
- 33:03-brothers to ensure there were no rival claimants.
- 33:06It is abhorrent to modern sensibilities, but
- 33:09from a cold, systemic perspective, it guaranteed
- 33:12two things. First, that only the most capable,
- 33:15politically savvy, and militarily competent son
- 33:18took the throne. And second, that the empire
- 33:20would not be torn apart by the kind of continuous,
- 33:24generation -spanning dynastic civil wars that
- 33:26plague Europe. But in 1603, a 13 -year -old boy
- 33:30named Ahmed I ascends to the throne. And he makes
- 33:34a completely unprecedented decision. He decides
- 33:37not to execute his younger brother Mustafa. He
- 33:40spares his life. It was a humane choice, likely
- 33:43influenced by the sheer psychological trauma
- 33:45of previous successions. I mean, Ahmed's own
- 33:48father had 19 of his brothers executed upon taking
- 33:51the throne. Exactly. But the consequence of this
- 33:53humane reform fundamentally broke the Ottoman
- 33:56leadership pipeline. Because they couldn't just
- 33:58let the spared brothers roam free to plot rebellions,
- 34:01they had to isolate them. They created the kafas,
- 34:04or the cage. Instead of being sent out to the
- 34:06provinces to learn how to govern, lead armies,
- 34:09and manage economies, future sultans were placed
- 34:12under luxurious house arrest deep within the
- 34:15Topkapi palace. They were surrounded only by
- 34:18deaf mute servants and the women of the harem.
- 34:20They had zero contact with the outside world.
- 34:23Think about the psychological toll of that. You
- 34:26have a system that is optimizing for absolute
- 34:28stability, no more civil wars over succession,
- 34:32but In doing so, you completely destroyed a capacity
- 34:36for innovation. Well, without a new system to
- 34:38train heirs, it doomed the empire to weak leadership.
- 34:40You take guys who have lived their entire lives
- 34:43in paranoid, claustrophobic confinement, constantly
- 34:46fearing they might be strangled the next day,
- 34:48and suddenly, you hand them the keys to a multi
- 34:51-continental empire. The results were disastrous.
- 34:54When Mustafa I, the brother Achmed spared, eventually
- 34:57takes the throne, he exhibits severe mental abnormalities.
- 35:02Well, of course. Almost certainly a product of
- 35:04his lifelong isolation. Subsequent sultans lacked
- 35:08any practical political or military experience.
- 35:11They became pliant puppets controlled by powerful
- 35:14court factions, the Grand Viziers, and the Queen
- 35:17Mothers. And nature abhors a power vacuum. With
- 35:21the sultans effectively neutralized by their
- 35:23own upbringing, the elite artificial immune system
- 35:26we talked about earlier, the Janissaries, starts
- 35:29mutating. The military filled the power vacuum,
- 35:33marking the transition from a state with an army
- 35:35to an army holding the state hostage. The Janissaries
- 35:39shift from loyal soldiers to a corrupt political
- 35:42mafia. They forced the state to allow them to
- 35:45marry. They began enrolling their own freeborn
- 35:48sons into the Corps, destroying the meritocratic
- 35:51Dev Shimei system. They got involved in commerce,
- 35:55running protection rackets and monopolies. This
- 35:58culminates violently with Sultan Osman II in
- 36:001618. He's 14 years old and he correctly identifies
- 36:04that the Janissaries are the problem. They are
- 36:07failing on the battlefield and they are draining
- 36:09the treasury at home. So he decides to discipline
- 36:12them. His approach to discipline however reveals
- 36:14his lack of political experience. He tries to
- 36:17slash their pay and enacts petty punishments
- 36:19in the capital. He orders their coffee shops
- 36:22to be closed. I found this detail fascinating.
- 36:24Why attack the coffee shops? Because the coffee
- 36:27houses in 17th century Istanbul weren't just
- 36:30places to get a caffeine fix. They were the primary
- 36:33social and political hubs where Janissaries gathered,
- 36:36gossiped, plotted mutinies, and criticized the
- 36:38government. It was their headquarters. Closing
- 36:41them was seen as a direct attack on their political
- 36:43assembly. It's like a tech company that stops
- 36:46firing its underperforming executives out of
- 36:48kindness, only to have those executives form
- 36:50a union that murders the CEO because he tried
- 36:53to take away the break room espresso machine.
- 36:55That is essentially what happened, but with lethal
- 36:58consequences. In 1622, the Janissaries rioted,
- 37:02stormed the palace, dragged the 14 -year -old
- 37:04Sultan Osman II to the Yetikule Fortress, and
- 37:08strangled him. He was the first Sultan killed
- 37:10by Janissaries. Does a system require cruelty
- 37:13to function? How do you even begin to fix a system
- 37:16that broken? A few decades later, Murad IV tries,
- 37:20and his strategy is to swing the pendulum back
- 37:23to sheer draconian brutality. Murad IV recognized
- 37:26that the state was dissolving into anarchy. To
- 37:29break the power of the factions and the Janissary
- 37:31mafia, he instituted a reign of terror. He banned
- 37:35alcohol, tobacco, and, once again, coffee. Just
- 37:39go and scorched earth on their habits. He would
- 37:42disguise himself, patrol the streets of Istanbul
- 37:44at night with an executioner, and personally
- 37:46kill anyone found violating his edicts. He was
- 37:49trying to force the empire back into shape through
- 37:51sheer willpower and violence. But the tragic
- 37:54irony is that the man who executed people for
- 37:57drinking coffee or wine actually dies of alcoholism.
- 38:02Yes. Murad IV Reyn was a temporary forceful corrective.
- 38:06But you cannot fix deep structural rot with a
- 38:09sword. The leadership pipeline in the cage was
- 38:12still producing incompetent errors. Which pushes
- 38:15us into the 1700s and 1800s. With internal leadership
- 38:19in chaos and the military calling the shots,
- 38:21the Ottomans are forced into a corner by a rapidly
- 38:24modernizing Europe. Specifically, Russia. The
- 38:27psychological breaking point was the devastating
- 38:29defeat at the Battle of Yen in 1683. The famous
- 38:32siege. The Ottomans invested massive resources
- 38:36to take the Habsburg capital, but they were routed.
- 38:39This defeat shattered the aura of Ottoman invincibility.
- 38:43It led to the treaties of Karlovitz in 1699 and
- 38:46Constantinople in 1700, marking massive territorial
- 38:49losses. And while they are losing territory abroad,
- 38:52the Janissaries are still throwing tantrums at
- 38:55home. In 1703, we get the Edirne event. where
- 38:59the Janissaries deposed Mustafa II over unpaid
- 39:02salaries and his choice of capital. And this
- 39:05internal instability made them incredibly vulnerable
- 39:08to constant grinding wars with Russia over Crimea
- 39:11and the Balkans. With Russia styling itself the
- 39:15protector of Orthodox Christianity to justify
- 39:17invasions. This constant bleeding forces the
- 39:20Ottomans into this humiliating diplomatic dance.
- 39:23I was reading about Selim III's correspondence
- 39:26with Napoleon at the end of the 1700s. Yes, Napoleon
- 39:29actively played on this. He was flattering him
- 39:32as the most high and invincible prince. But Selim
- 39:35is paralyzed. He was flattering him as the most
- 39:38high and invincible prince. But Selim is paralyzed.
- 39:42He's receiving fan mail from Napoleon while simultaneously
- 39:44getting bullied by Russia, and then the humiliation
- 39:47reaches its absolute nadir during the Oriental
- 39:50Crisis of 1840. where the entire Ottoman Navy
- 39:53defected to Egypt. Defected to their own governor
- 39:57in Egypt. And they have to require European powers
- 40:01like Britain and Austria to save the Sultan.
- 40:04Yes. I mean, how embarrassing this era must have
- 40:07been. Is this just a 200 year long death rattle?
- 40:11This raises an important question. Was it a decline
- 40:14or an impossible adaptation? The Ottomans weren't
- 40:18just passively dying. They were trying to pivot
- 40:21a medieval land -based conquering machine into
- 40:24a modern, diplomatic nation state. Like trying
- 40:27to rebuild a plane while it is in a nosedive.
- 40:30Precisely. In 1826, Mahmud II finally accomplished
- 40:35what cost Usman II his life two centuries earlier.
- 40:38Mahmud secretly built a modern artillery corps
- 40:41and finally destroyed the Janissaries. Wow, so
- 40:44he just wipes them out. Yes, and begins the Tanzumont
- 40:47reforms to westernize the empire. The Tanzimat
- 40:50reforms and the Hati Humayun, the 1856 equality
- 40:54decree, were massive progressive leaps. But they
- 40:57were too little, too late. Which brings us to
- 41:00the final collapse, World War I and the Phoenix,
- 41:04from 1900 to 1922. The desperate attempts to
- 41:08modernize culminate in a revolution by the youth.
- 41:10The Young Turk Revolution in 1908. by university
- 41:13students and the military, the Committee of Union
- 41:16and Progress, reinstating the Constitution and
- 41:19sidelining Sultan Abdul Hamid II. But they stepped
- 41:21into leadership at the worst possible moment.
- 41:25The disastrous Balkan Wars of 1912 and 1913 stripped
- 41:28them of almost all European territory, Italy
- 41:31taking Libya. And this trauma radicalizes the
- 41:35leadership. By 1914, Enver Pasha makes the ultimate
- 41:38fatal gamble. Entering World War One, via the
- 41:41Turco -German alliance. Ignoring warnings from
- 41:45their own Paris ambassador that it would shatter
- 41:47their remaining strength. It's like a gambler
- 41:49at the casino who has lost his house but bets
- 41:52his car because he's sure the next hand is a
- 41:56winner. How did a group of forward -thinking
- 41:58university students end up steering the ship
- 42:01straight into the iceberg? The tragedy of the
- 42:04Young Turks is that they wanted to save the state.
- 42:07But nationalism had already infected the Balkans
- 42:09and Arab territories. Right. The Ottomans were
- 42:12an inherently multi -ethnic, decentralized empire,
- 42:16trying to survive in a 20th century world obsessed
- 42:19with ethno -nationalism. And the aftermath of
- 42:21the war is total liquidation. The armistice of
- 42:24Mudros, the Treaty of Sevres, partitioning the
- 42:26empire among Greece, France, Italy, and Britain.
- 42:29But the twist is Mustafa Kemal. He leads the
- 42:32Turkish War of Independence, tossing out the
- 42:34sultan. Mehmed VI is exiled in 1922. and establishing
- 42:38the Republic of Turkey with the Treaty of Luzon
- 42:41in 1923. The only way forward was Mustafa Kemal's
- 42:45ruthless severing of the imperial past to save
- 42:47the Turkish core. It is a breathtaking historical
- 42:50arc. We tracked Osman's tiny band of raiders
- 42:53to Mehmet's cannons, to Suleiman's global dreadnought,
- 42:57to the Janissary Mafia, to a complete collapse
- 43:00and rebirth. And if there is one structural insight
- 43:03to take away from these centuries of texts, it
- 43:06is something we might call the success paradox.
- 43:09Walk me through that. The Ottomans created the
- 43:11Janissaries and the Devshirme child tribute system
- 43:13to bypass traditional feudal politics and ensure
- 43:16absolute loyalty. Right, to fix a specific problem.
- 43:19But by creating a perfectly efficient military
- 43:21class with no outside allegiances, they accidentally
- 43:25built a class that only cared about itself. When
- 43:28your tools of survival become your masters, Your
- 43:30collapse is just a matter of time. That is a
- 43:33profound thought to leave on. Look at the organizations
- 43:36or even habits in your own life that helped you
- 43:38succeed early on. Are they the exact things holding
- 43:41you back today? Are you refusing to dismantle
- 43:44your own internal Janissaries? Well, on that
- 43:47note, we want to thank you for joining us on
- 43:49this deep dive. I encourage you to question the
- 43:51history of the institutions around you. Thanks
- 43:54for listening.