Latest / Retail Fast Five / Is Macy's Turnaround for Real? | Fast Five Shorts
Transcript
- 0:00Macy's posted its fifth straight quarter of comparable sales growth and raised its full year guidance.
- 0:05As CEO Tony Spring says the retailer is now, quote, a different Macy's, which is operating from a healthier position.
- 0:12According to CNBC, Macy's fiscal second quarter comparable sales rose 2.7% company wide, well ahead of Wall Street's estimate of roughly 0.8% growth.
- 0:25Growth was driven in large part by Macy's quote, reimagined stores and the revamped locations central to its turnaround strategy.
- 0:32While Bloomingdale's comparable sales jumped 11.3% and beauty chain Blue Mercury rose 6.2%.
- 0:40Josh.
- 0:41Oh man, I have no idea what you're gonna say to me on this one.
- 0:43Is it time to plant the victory flag at Macy's and bow down in homage to Tony Spring or do you think there's still more work to do?
- 0:51I don't think there, it's time for victory parade yet.
- 0:56I think the, I think the flag is within reach or they can see the right.
- 1:01So maybe over the river and through the woods they see a flag over there, but it's probably still packed away.
- 1:08I think Tony Spring, he deserves credit for creating momentum obviously and putting the customer back at the center of Macy's strategy, which I think is really important.
- 1:18But one of the things I read, you know, they're, they're remodeling a lot of stores and closing some of the underperforming stores, which, it's kind of a short term know, focus and strategy, but that comes at a high
- 1:29price.
- 1:29And what, what I believe I read was that a lot of those investments are being made from the tariff refunds that they received.
- 1:36Right.
- 1:37So they received 90.
- 1:39I think they're investing 90 plus million dollars out of those tariff refunds, which feels like a little bit of a, a one time benefit versus like this long term operational strategy and brand improvement strategy.
- 1:52So yeah, I mean I think ultimately they're going to have to ask the, or answer the question which is what is the compelling reason to choose Macy's over their competitors?
- 2:00And so in retail, as you know better than anybody, right, one strong quarter or a strong year even doesn't erase like years of challenges.
- 2:09And so I think, right, you know, the real test is is can, you know, can Macy's turn it into kind of sustained, profitable growth across the entire fleet?
- 2:18And one of the things I noticed too was I know like Bloomingdale's and, and Blue Mercury, right.
- 2:25Really, really strong quarters and really strong performance.
- 2:28But I don't think the core Macy's stores have been nearly as strong.
- 2:32And so I think if, if, if they want to have long term success, I think they have to figure out the core Macy's brand and really drive that.
- 2:40I think I fundamentally agree with you on this point.
- 2:43You know, I think like, you know, I think number one, and I've been harder on Macy's than anybody, Josh.
- 2:48Like you know, pretty, pretty pointed at times, quite frankly.
- 2:51And I got to give credit where credit is due.
- 2:53I mean five, five straight quarters of comp growth is saying something because you're actually anniversary yourself.
- 2:58I mean you've been in retail a long time and that, that is the tell point when you're like, okay, you know, you're doing something at least better than you were doing before.
- 3:05It shows how good your good is when you can comp your comp, so to speak.
- 3:09So it's definitely nothing to sneeze at.
- 3:12Um, but Josh, to your point, and I don't know when the last time you were in Macy's was, but I went in there this past weekend and.
- 3:19Cause I was kind of like, okay, you know, what's in the water?
- 3:21Like, should I be drinking this Kool Aid?
- 3:23You know, like.
- 3:24And I went in there and I was kind of like, I don't get it.
- 3:27Like, I left confused.
- 3:28I was uninspired.
- 3:29I wanted to buy stuff and I didn't get, you know, hooked to buy anything.
- 3:34So I don't know, I just.
- 3:35In general, there's still some skepticism from me in terms of how much the dissolution of other competitors is still having on the numbers, particularly in the department store space.
- 3:48But with that said, the one caveat I would make to my argument is I think Tony Spring likely gets that.
- 3:54He understands the rub, so to speak, and is following his plan very methodically.
- 3:58And the great news is that the wound, you know, to put it in my terms, the wound has been cauterized and at least the bleeding has stopped.
- 4:05Which is saying something that I, I for one, and I'll, I'll call it like it is, I never thought that we were going to see that even.
- 4:12And so that is a remarkable achievement in and of itself, especially as you look back at the history of my commentary on this show.
- 4:19So that's my take, Josh.
- 4:21And.
- 4:22But you know, you know, maybe, hopefully, you know, for the sake of Macy's, they can all prove us wrong.
- 4:28Yeah, yeah, I was, I've been a Macy shopper.
- 4:30I've had a Macy's credit card before in the past, but every time I'VE had it multiple times, and then I've closed the credit card and I'm like, I'm just not coming back.
- 4:39You know what I mean?
- 4:40And so, like you said, there's no, like, differentiation that I've experienced.
- 4:44Now, to be fair, I haven't been there in probably the last year, but I would have to experience something new next time I go to a Macy's or I Visit, you know, Macy's.com to be like, oh, you know
- 4:55what, they've changed.
- 4:56Right?
- 4:57You gotta.
- 4:57You gotta.
- 4:58You wanna feel something palpably different.
- 4:59Yeah, I wasn't seeing that.
- 5:01Now the question becomes, like, you know, do you, for good retailing, do you to see something probably different, or do you just need to.
- 5:08Palpably different, if that's what I'm trying to say, or do you just need to be, like, better at what you do every single day?
- 5:13And that's probably where the jury is still out.
- 5:15I don't think either one of us know the answer to that question yet, do we, Josh?
- 5:19I don't think so.
- 5:20Yeah.
- 5:20All right, well.
- 5:22All right, well, kudos to Tony Spring, though, for doing a heck of a job for the first five quarters or the last five quarters of his tenure.