Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Michigan Sign-Stealing Scandal Goes National
Transcript
- 0:02Hello, everybody, Welcome to the Buckeye Weekly Podcast. I am Tony Gerdaman
- 0:06here as always with Tom or Tom. How's it going, Tony. You're
- 0:11not gonna believe what we get to talk about today. Surprise me, Tony.
- 0:18I think we're gonna be talking about Michigan and their signs, stealing,
- 0:22spying, scandal thing for what feels like about the fifth day in a row,
- 0:28but it every day. I think, Okay, well, we'll get
- 0:30you to like a Wisconsin preview show today, and then something else comes out
- 0:35and there's there was big news since since last we spoke, Tony. There's
- 0:39been big news from our own Mark Givler of bucke Huddle dot Com. From
- 0:43Tom Withers from the AP, from Pete Thammel from ESPN, from Ross Delacher
- 0:48from Yahoo, from various college football message boards for from the last you know,
- 0:53ten months or so, predicting the future. There's Las Vegas maybe getting
- 0:58involved Michigan all their John U. Bacon is throwing out names of people on
- 1:02the NCAA's Committees on Infractions that might be out to get Jim Harbaugh. Tony,
- 1:07there's some stuff to talk about today. Yeah, And initially I wanted
- 1:12to. I was wondering, is there just a name that we can give
- 1:17to this thing rather than the whole, the whole Michigan sign stealing thing.
- 1:19Is there a gate that we can put on this? I know people are
- 1:23calling a sign gate that seems pretty Do you do you do something with the
- 1:29name Stallions? Do do you do do like Gallop Gate? Or do you
- 1:34just stick it with Michigan Just call it Michigan Gate. Make them own this.
- 1:38I'm thinking, Tom, you know how when you've got this system where
- 1:44you you send people out into the world to go get you stuff and some
- 1:48some realms they call that that. They call those people smurfs. So my
- 1:51suggestion Smurf Gate Michigan Gate isn't bad. I really have loved Wild Stallions with
- 1:59a Why, and Wild Lengthy Banned in a Bill, and Ted's excellent Adventure.
- 2:04But yeah, I I don't think we've hit a winner yet for sure.
- 2:09There, so we'll have to we'll keep pork shopping. That good news.
- 2:13I think we'll have more future shows in which to workshop that. So
- 2:16I don't think we need necessarily to land in a final answer right here.
- 2:20No, So let's discuss we've got plenty of things to talk about. Mark
- 2:24Givler's report from Tuesday that Clemson was one of the teams that one of the
- 2:31games that kind of stallions had been purchased a ticket for and was going to
- 2:38go or send somebody out to scout Clemson, I believe at the time was
- 2:43like eight to o. So clearly they were looking like a college football playoff
- 2:49football or possibility. And so that gives you an idea of the level of
- 2:53advanced scouting because it goes well beyond the Big Ten. And then Peak the
- 2:59Animal comes out and corroborates that and says that there were the last two SEC
- 3:05championship games and other games outside the scope of the Big Ten as well.
- 3:13I even saw some dope on the internet saying that Mark and Buckehetele were just
- 3:17trying to get in on Famil's reporting when Mark's story came out before Famil's about
- 3:25Clemson. But once it's bad enough it's bad in the Big Ten, then
- 3:30when you start to involve other conferences, just Michigan's gonna have to be careful
- 3:36here because now you're bringing in other entities other than just the NCAA and the
- 3:39Big Ten. Yeah, you're inviting a broader group of people to be directly
- 3:46impacted by this. And you know, if I think that, you would
- 3:51be hearing many many more issues coming from the Athens, Georgia realm of the
- 3:57world. If Michigan had beaten Georgia a couple of years ago in the playoffs,
- 4:00was whatever they did in you know, whatever happened at the SEC championship
- 4:03game that year did not have any meaningful impact on the on field results that
- 4:08happened that transpired in the semi final there against the Georgia Bulldogs. But you
- 4:13know what's interesting, Tony is the name that you didn't say, I mean
- 4:15they they were, you know, he's obviously there's been linked to tickets at
- 4:20many potential college football playoff potential opponents. I didn't see TC you mentioned in
- 4:29there anywhere, did you seems that seems strange to me. How did how
- 4:32did that game go? Yeah? Well, funnily enough, it did not
- 4:35go well for Michigan. It seemed like a couple of pick sixes in that
- 4:41one, having trouble deciphering the secondaries, having trouble deciphering the CCU offense.
- 4:47I don't want to say it was a matchup game, as Ryan Day says,
- 4:50but it sure seemed like things were a little bit more even there,
- 4:55just based on the score to score, so even throughout that game, you'd
- 4:58have to assume everything else is even as well. Yeah, I just I
- 5:00mean, and again there's this is not a definitive proof that you know that
- 5:05it means three touchdown advantage per game or whatever. It's just, boy,
- 5:11that's interesting that that worked out in that way. And you look at the
- 5:16you know, let's say, inconsistency of results of Michigan throughout regular seasons in
- 5:23terms of what they did to Penn State last year, what they did against
- 5:26Ohio State last year, and then how they looked against TCU, and it
- 5:30just wasn't the same team. And at the time, I sort of chalked
- 5:31it up to, you know, maybe maybe Harbaugh's just not you know,
- 5:34he's staying a little true too true to what he likes to do, and
- 5:40if you have enough time to prep against Jim Harborough offense, you maybe are
- 5:44a little bit of an advantage. Maybe that's true. I don't know,
- 5:48I mean, there's there's I don't think there's enough anything there to make any
- 5:53kind of definitive statement, but it sure is an interesting and interesting confluence of
- 5:57events. I do also think it was interesting in Mark's piece where he talked
- 6:02about I also wrote about your photos and the sign the picture of the laminated
- 6:10signals, where Ohio State told Mark people from sources at Ohio State believe that
- 6:15that those are their plays. So again, as we've talked about in previous
- 6:19shows, they weren't just drawing those plays up during drawing up those diagrams,
- 6:25as they were learning the plays in real time at the game. This is
- 6:29comes from somewhere, and where it doesn't come from is the the All twenty
- 6:36two and the TV tape that so many people are Michigan fans. I've talked
- 6:42about where while you can get all of that from the All twenty two,
- 6:45and you can't. I had an NFL person that's got to reach out to
- 6:50me and say, like, the All twenty two never shows what is going
- 6:56what the coaches are doing pre snap because it's taking the whole, full full
- 7:00field into that's where where the camera is. You'll only start seeing the signals
- 7:08and stuff like as things may be broaden out or the camera goes up,
- 7:11like this isn't something that is part and of all the All twenty twos.
- 7:15You're not gonna get all the information you want there. You're not gonna get
- 7:17all the information you want from the TV. The only way to get all
- 7:20of the information you want is to be there in person. And the greatest
- 7:29Twitter response of all time Tom when Kevin Noon yesterday tweets out a shot a
- 7:36screenshot of All twenty two is this is what All twenty two film looks like,
- 7:41So keep telling me how science can be stolen from All twenty two and
- 7:45the response a heartfelt response, and I'm not even gonna mention the person's name.
- 7:49The response was because there are twenty two angles, not just this one.
- 7:58Something new every day, don't you. I learned that I still have
- 8:03the ability to laugh my butt off because that was the single funniest thing I've
- 8:07seen in a very long time. And I I hope each day, you
- 8:15know how Jim Valvando says, you'll laugh, cry every day, you know,
- 8:18get your emotions out. If I can find something that makes me laugh
- 8:22like that every single day, I'll be a much happier person. And maybe
- 8:24maybe it's all it takes is just a following this dude on Twitter Okay,
- 8:28So if just in case you were not in on the joke. The reason
- 8:31it's called all twenty two is because you can see all twenty two players who
- 8:35are on the field, because there's eleven on the offense and eleven on the
- 8:39defense. That's why it's called all twenty two. There are not twenty two
- 8:41angles. You usually get two angles. One is the sideline angle, looking
- 8:46the traditional TV angle, but much wider so you can see everyone on the
- 8:48field at the same time. The other one comes from behind the end zone,
- 8:52so you get sort of the vertical angle of the team coming directly at
- 8:56you or away from you. So's that's what that's what ALL twenty two is.
- 9:01And yes, I think we have both watched a decent amount of All
- 9:03twenty two and know you are not going to just be able to pull a
- 9:05team's full set of signals off of their you know, frequently, almost always,
- 9:11I'm gonna say almost always because I don't want to say always, but
- 9:13almost always. That starts as the guys are on the field and set and
- 9:18you know information and you're not you know, you don't have this like long
- 9:22break. It's chopped from play to play, so you don't have this like
- 9:26long break in the middle where everyone's signaling. You can see everyone signals like,
- 9:31no, you cannot get them from that, And you don't have to
- 9:33trust me, Tony. You know who you can trust on that, Connor
- 9:35Stallions, because if you could get all of this from the All twenty two,
- 9:39If you can get all of this from the TV tape, Tony,
- 9:41this sentence probably would not exist. ESPN has confirmed that Stallions has purchased tickets
- 9:46to more than thirty five games at seventeen stadiums around the country. He has
- 9:50used a network of at least three people who are af forwarded tickets to attend
- 9:52games. Tony, if you could get it all from TV and ALL twenty
- 9:58two legally, why would you have to have this elaborate system where you're sending
- 10:03people to all games in thirty five games at seventeen stadiums around the country.
- 10:07That seems pretty self evident to me. Yeah, it's it explains itself.
- 10:16And when you're doing something like this, you're doing it for an advantage.
- 10:20And it's not what I've seen from Michigan fan saying you can't buy your friends
- 10:28tickets to games. I mean, is this wrong? Is this is when
- 10:31did this become? Is this still America and the buying of the ticket and
- 10:39then maybe as a Tennessee game or I don't even remember anymore because all of
- 10:45these games, but he buys a ticket and then like three minutes later it's
- 10:48transferred, you know, And I know some people are upset with the going
- 10:54to see they're buying tickets for twelve of the thirteen Big ten venues and people
- 11:00like you know, wondering which Big ten team that he didn't go and scout.
- 11:03I think what has happened there. They're not scouting all thirteen Big ten
- 11:07teams or twelve or thirteen. They're scouting Ohio State four times, Penn State
- 11:13three times, stuff like that, so I wouldn't expect them to be necessarily
- 11:16scouting Indiana. Maybe. Well, there was also and I have there has
- 11:24been a good amount of overnet ink spilled over this this week, So I
- 11:26cannot tell you exactly where I saw this, but there was reporting. I
- 11:31think it might have been either Ross Allinger Repeat Family, but I could not
- 11:33tell you for sure that the thirteenth of those other stadiums does not have access
- 11:41to the third party. So if you bought it through stub Hub. Whatever
- 11:45school that is does not have access to the stub Hub data or whatever for
- 11:48whatever reason the way their ticketing system is set up. So it's not that
- 11:52they weren't purchased for that stadium, it's just that the school that school doesn't
- 11:56have access to that data. And again I will apologize that was not just
- 12:01like random dude on Twitter. That was in one of the one of the
- 12:05articles I've read from one of the credible national sources on that. I just
- 12:09can't remember which one it was, but yes, that's that's the explanation there.
- 12:15NBA fans, the Waight is over. Basketball is back. In DraftKings
- 12:16sports book, an official sports betting partner of the NBA, is celebrating with
- 12:20an unbeatable offer. New customers can score two hundred dollars instantly in bonus bets.
- 12:22Were throwing down five dollars on the NBA winner lose, it doesn't matter.
- 12:26You'll start the season with an instant dub and with DraftKings parlays, everyone's
- 12:28got a shot at even bigger basketball wins. String together multiple bets from the
- 12:31same game, or build your parlay across multiple games for a shot at making
- 12:35your payday even sweeter. Basketball is more fun when you're in on the action.
- 12:37Download the DraftKings Sportsbook app now and use code huddle up. New customers
- 12:39can get two hundred dollars and bonus bets instantly for betting just five dollars only
- 12:43on Draft Kings sports Book with cod huddle up. The Crown is yours.
- 12:46Gambling problem called one hundred gambler or visit www dot twenty hundred gambler dot net,
- 12:50New York. Call eight seven seven eight hope and why, or text
- 12:52hope and why. In Connecticut, help is available for problem gambling. Call
- 12:54eight eight eight seven eight ninety seven seven seven seven or visit CCPG dot org.
- 12:58Please play respond on behalf of boot Hell Casino and Resort, Kansas Icensee
- 13:01partner Golden Nugget Lake, Charles, Louisiana twenty one. Over Age varies by
- 13:05jistiction void and Ontario. Artist's expire one hundred and sixty eight hours after issuing.
- 13:07See sportsbook dot, DraftKings dot com, slash Basketball terms for eligibility and
- 13:11deposit restrictions, terms and responsible gaming resources. Speaking of random dudes on Twitter,
- 13:18Tom the message board posts from Tennessee board in December and then in January
- 13:28that have come out, which normally you would just ignore, but when I
- 13:37think Andy Staples tweeted these out, but I've seen them elsewhere. But so
- 13:43this one from December one in fall vall quest the post says, oh,
- 13:48do I have a story on that. One of my little brother's friends is
- 13:50a scout for them, meaning Michigan. They paid him, paid for him
- 13:54to travel to the Tennessee Vandy game and basically to steal the signs. He's
- 14:00from Nashville originally, so that he went anyway given even after the loss,
- 14:03but says that he and others are never allowed to talk to Harball directly about
- 14:09it. But this is back in December first, and then again in January
- 14:13seventeenth of twenty twenty three, he talks about it again and that this is
- 14:20there's conversation about this, and the only people they're apparently keeping it a secret
- 14:26from is maybe Jim Harbaugh, because the people that Stallion's allegedly is sending two
- 14:33or buying tickets for, they're telling other people about it. And then there's
- 14:37only there may be six degrees of Kevin Bacon, there are only two degrees
- 14:41of a message board. You can talk to one person and that person is
- 14:46connected to a message board and they're going to let everybody know. So it's
- 14:50just fascinating to see this where I obviously don't remember seeing these back in December
- 14:56and January, not that we would. It would never get anywhere because it's
- 15:00like, okay, yeah, whatever, And I don't know even how many
- 15:03people would know that that's against the rules. Until you find out that the
- 15:09NCAA is getting involved, then like, oh yeah, I remember this,
- 15:11and then this pops back up on a message board and pops back up on
- 15:16Twitter. But the other key part about this this January seventeenth one, and
- 15:22again it's a message board post. Some of it has proven to be appairently
- 15:24accurate, but we can't say all of it is. But one of the
- 15:28senses here is they meaning Michigan would pay his flights, lodging food, and
- 15:31seats right behind that team's bench for him to get video notes, et cetera.
- 15:37If that is all found out, then it's going to burn to the
- 15:39ground. And you would assume there would be like a lack of paper trail,
- 15:48but the paper trail so far have been very The rems have stacked up
- 15:56like basically walls of paper that you can follow down the yellow brick maze brick
- 16:00road. Well you have, I mean, he's he's got a bunch of
- 16:06transactions on Venmo that were public transactions until recently, which so the transaction history
- 16:11is going to exist. There. That something you could get from Venmo if
- 16:15you as a school were complying cooperating fully with the NCAA investigation as teams have
- 16:21claimed that they were going to do. Yeah, this is I think maybe
- 16:25the single most instructive thing here because this was sort of thrown out there nine
- 16:30months ago. There's no Internet clout to be gained by doing it. It's
- 16:33just like, you know, some guy on some board makes a post about
- 16:37this interesting thing that his friend told him, and then months and months and
- 16:41months later everyone kind of goes, oh oh oh. It's like this is
- 16:48not a perfect analogy in terms of the people involved in both ends of this.
- 16:52But do you remember when Osama bin Laden got killed and there was that
- 16:55one guy who was like live tweeting it from Abadhabad as it was happening,
- 16:57and then it was later like oh, oh, okay, that kind of
- 17:03person who's doing it live without any real expectation of like, oh, I
- 17:07bet this is Osama bin Laden getting clipped. That's that's a relatively reliable narrator
- 17:15in all of this because you look back now and it's like, oh,
- 17:18this guy has successfully predicted the future. So you know this is not all
- 17:23you know, one hundred percent gospel, but boy, this is not real
- 17:29spin Like this is Tennessee didn't lose a game to Michigan. Tennessee didn't even
- 17:32play Michigan. There's no there's no nothing to spin here. This is just
- 17:34an oh, an interesting story about a mutual friend. And you know,
- 17:38if if Michigan is paying flights, lodging food, and seats behind the team's
- 17:44bench for him to get video notes, et cetera, as the quote says
- 17:48directly, that's you know that that's going to be a problem. That's going
- 17:52to be a you know, that's going to be something that's very hard to,
- 17:56very hard to you know, sort of shove off as irrelevant. The
- 18:02fact that they are never allowed to talk to Harbad directly about it. Is
- 18:07you know, are you protecting the head guy or is this giving the head
- 18:11guy ap plausible deniability? Frankly, I think the answer is it probably doesn't
- 18:15matter because of the rules with the head coaches, you know, being responsible
- 18:21for everything that happens under them, whether it's someone who reports them directly or
- 18:23indirectly. That you know this is this is someone who would fall under Harball's
- 18:29umbrellas, stallions, would this you know that kind of stuff. Again,
- 18:36let's see what they're able to prove in terms of the paper trail here.
- 18:38But this does not seem like a particularly craftily run operation. I mean,
- 18:44the sec shorts Twitter account had a had a video on it and it was
- 18:48just basically, you know, you can just go ahead and find it.
- 18:51It's I will not do it justice. So you know how not incredibly clever
- 18:56this whole thing was, and how extremely obvious they made some of this stuff.
- 18:59There was a picture of a guy videotaping at an organ game, like
- 19:03videotaping the whole game on one of the boards. You know, again months
- 19:07and months and months ago. You know, you can you can go back
- 19:11and find this stuff, and it's just like this is just you're starting to
- 19:15see more and more and more corroboration. And between that and the daily drip,
- 19:22drip drip from Pete Thammil from Ross Dellinger from I think Pat forty has
- 19:26been writing about it a bunch. There's a bunch of these national guys who
- 19:30keep getting new information and it keeps, it keeps getting bigger, and generally
- 19:33when you get the drip drip drip, that always kind of you know that
- 19:40the drip drip drip doesn't generally stop on its own. You know, that's
- 19:42true with a faucet, that's too true with a news story here that is
- 19:45probably not just going to go away. And the more information comes out,
- 19:49the more it's helpful for the NCAA and or the Big ten making a case
- 19:55here. Even as we're recording this, by the time we get it posted,
- 20:03there's there may be something that is, you know, not necessarily out
- 20:06of date, but there's new information. And that's that's that's just the danger
- 20:11of living in the live news era that we live in, tom where anything
- 20:15can happen on any given day, and you wait, it's like, well,
- 20:18it's nine thirty in the morning, I wonder when I'm sure there'll be
- 20:22something by ten, And then it's like, oh, it's two thirty in
- 20:25the afternoon. I bet we'll hear something by four, and it's almost like
- 20:29clockwork right now with what is going on. I want to mention the Tom
- 20:34Wheather's from the Associated Press who covers the Browns talking Todwan Jones, former Buckeye
- 20:41write tackle about the Michigan sign stealing thing, and Duane said that they suspected
- 20:48that the Wolverines had their sideline signals and they made some changes. But Tom,
- 20:53as Dwan says, you can't change everything, and this has been one
- 20:56of the I don't know the hand holds the the life vests that Michigan fans
- 21:02have been using about the effectiveness of science stealing Ohio states. You know,
- 21:07they change things in twenty twenty two and they still lost. And changing some
- 21:12things and changing everything are two vastly different things. And if you've got information,
- 21:21and like you've got all of the signals, you've got so much information,
- 21:25you've got a lot of time invested, you can't expect you can't change
- 21:30things for an entire team, And you can't change everything in an entire team
- 21:36in such short notice and still be able to produce and perform on time,
- 21:41on schedule and tip top shape like you need to do against a quality opponent.
- 21:48So I think it was just one more strikedown of the excuses about how
- 21:56ineffective or inconsequential the stuff is. Yeah, there is only a limited amount
- 22:02of time during the week. These guys are not NFL players, for this
- 22:04is the only thing going on in their lives. There are restrictions in terms
- 22:07of practice hours, there's restrictions in terms of all sorts of stuff. And
- 22:11you can only do so much in terms of changing stuff up over the course
- 22:15of a week, because if you're changing stuff up every single week, first
- 22:21of all, it chews up a lot of time. Second of all,
- 22:23these people are not robots like you will have. You see missed signs in
- 22:27the major leagues, and if you have a team who's you know, you're
- 22:33signally in a play and one guys misses the sign, that's where you have
- 22:37the wide receiver go one direction in the quarterback throws the ball the other direction,
- 22:41or you know, one guy is blocking one play and everyone else is
- 22:44blocking another play and the play gets blown up. That's that's the kind of
- 22:48stuff that makes game changing plays happen. So there's only so much you can
- 22:52realistically do, so, you know, and also it forces if you have
- 22:56a reputation as Michigan has for doing this potentially in legal or illegal ways,
- 23:03whatever whatever way you want to chalk it up to. This is not the
- 23:04first time it's been rumored that this has been going on, and Michigan has
- 23:08been, you know, Connor Stallion's a report from MASSI speaking of things breaking
- 23:12in the middle of podcasts. The report from Richard Johnson of SI cites a
- 23:15long text conversation out with Connor Stallions about his connections to the Michigan football program.
- 23:19I'm close with the whole staff, he wrote. Particularly, he said
- 23:22he quote became close with CP and Jay Harbes, apparently referring to current linebackers
- 23:26coach Chris Partridge and running backs and assistant special teams coach Jay Harbaugh, who
- 23:30was the son of head coach Jim Harbaugh. Reading on quote, pre COVID
- 23:34stole opponent signals during the week watching TV copies, then flew to the game
- 23:37and stood next to then Michigan offensive coordinator Josh Gaddis and told him what coverage
- 23:41pressure he was getting. Stallions continued, these texts are part of a lengthy
- 23:45back and forth. In January and February twenty twenty one, between Stallions and
- 23:48a then student at at power five school who was looking to break into the
- 23:51college football industry, and then it says the specific acts Stallion's described deciphering opponent
- 23:56signals off TV footage is not against NCAA rules in the law last week,
- 24:00though he is now the now suspected Michigan's the suspended Michigan staffer has become a
- 24:03household name across college football following accusations and reports the orchestrated and an elaborate scheme
- 24:07to place unamed associates of his in stadiums of Michigan's opponents to scout and in
- 24:11some cases film opposing coaches signaled both acts very much against the rules. I
- 24:18got to tell you I have not been able to post anything this week without
- 24:22someone with thirteen followers and a block am avatar saying that's not even against the
- 24:26rules. And in the cases where I put in the initial post this is
- 24:32not against the rules, they were correct in many many other cases, Tony
- 24:36Less. So, you know, being able to get some of the information
- 24:41from TV copy and then knowing what you're looking for and getting that is one
- 24:48thing. Getting all of the information from being on site again if he was
- 24:53able to do all of this via AL twenty two and TV copy, why
- 24:57are all the tickets being just But yes, Tom, it's legal to steal
- 25:03signs. And it reminds me of something that I tweeted on Tuesday, where
- 25:08you know, if you steal a car and then you get picked up for
- 25:11speeding, and all you're gonna say is, like everybody speeds. I was
- 25:17only doing seventy five and a sixty five, Like everybody does this or not
- 25:21even speeding. You're just like everybody drives. What's the deal, what's the
- 25:25big deal? Everybody drives. Everybody drives to work, every but he drives
- 25:27to the grocery store. Yes, but how did you get the car?
- 25:32How did you get the film? How did you get the the diagrams?
- 25:37How did you you know? When? Did? Where? Did that come
- 25:40about? And the whole thing of this is just about stealing signs. This
- 25:45is just about a hamburger. It's it is such wishery and hopery that it's
- 25:55I still I would love to know what their thought process like for the Michigan
- 25:59fan base, some of the Michigan people covering this, what their reactions would
- 26:03be if this is Ohio State stealing signs. It's like it goes back to
- 26:08a Time to Kill the final one of the final scenes where Matthew McConaughey says,
- 26:15and now I want you to picture this is Ohio State, and then
- 26:18Michigan fans are all like, oh my god, guilty yeah, or not
- 26:26guilty, however you want to spend that a Time to Kill thing. I
- 26:29was gonna say, I haven't seen that movie in a long time, so
- 26:32I don't remember which which way I was supposed to be going. Either way.
- 26:34The Hamburgers thing is so interesting. I heard someone use that recently,
- 26:40you know, well, you gotta remember this. It went after them Harbaugh
- 26:42against Hamburger for Hamburgers, Like, Tony, are you familiar with the concept
- 26:47of an unreliable narrator in literature? Yeah? So, an unreliable narrator is
- 26:52the guy who's telling you the story in the book and then it turns out
- 26:56like, oh, this guy's completely full of crap, and a bunch of
- 26:59stuff that I thought was true turns out to not be true at all.
- 27:02If someone is telling you the initial case against Jim Harball was against about Hamburgers
- 27:04and nothing but Hamburgers, they are an unreliable narrator and you should not listen
- 27:07to them. There is there was COVID violations, is what the NCAA is
- 27:12looking at right now. Like this a lot of the stuff, remember all
- 27:15the stuff that Herm Edward's got in trouble with with, like illegal visits during
- 27:18COVID and that kind of stuff. That's what that's about. It not just
- 27:22Hamburgers. Like Hamburgers is like the whimsical shorthand. It's like ha Jim harball.
- 27:27Oh he probably had some milk with them, ha ha ha. There's
- 27:30actual like stuff there. This is not just some whimsical loose some extra stretch
- 27:33he was Hamburgers, Okay, like that. There's actual substance there. So
- 27:40you should probably bear that in mind when you're thinking about who you want to
- 27:41listen to U some of this stuff, but well, just the it's not
- 27:48just stealing signs. Oh god, it's not just Hamburgers. It's you know.
- 27:52And I saw one of the things with Adam King from the Channel ten
- 27:56I believe, posting the video of them having the signals of like the first
- 28:03series of the twenty twenty two game where you see kinder Stallions talking to one
- 28:07of the Michigan coaches, jesse Minter, I believe and saying it, just
- 28:12saying something, and then jesse Minter saying something, and then all of the
- 28:15players behind him reacting that it's going to be a pass, and I believe.
- 28:19On that play, Ohio State throws a touchdown pass. It's it's in
- 28:22the red zone, and so people are saying, well, see it's the
- 28:27play wasn't even successful. So how you know how beneficial is it to steal
- 28:32signs? And it's like, I don't. I don't think that the argument,
- 28:34that argument is as strong as you think it is, because you even
- 28:37had the signs and you couldn't stop it. So imagine what you would be
- 28:42unable to do if you didn't have any of that information. It's like with
- 28:47Techmobile, the original tech Mobile, you had four plays, you had a
- 28:49twenty five percent chance of stopping that play. Those are pretty darn good odds.
- 28:53If you know whether it's a passer run, you've eliminated one of those
- 28:56things. You've eliminated. I don't care about the play action pass anymore.
- 29:02I will just stay back. I'm not going to come up at all.
- 29:04And I can't remember who it was talking about it, but like I think
- 29:08it may have been James Franklin talking about if it's third and short or fourth
- 29:14and short and we're on offense and we're doing a play action and the safety
- 29:18stay in the cover too, and they just stay back there. If they
- 29:22do that once, like okay, you know they guessed, right. If
- 29:25they continue to do that in other third and short, short yarded situations,
- 29:27then you know they have your signals. That's the kind of advantage that has
- 29:33When you don't have to worry about the run or you don't have to worry
- 29:34about the pass and you can just focus on the other. That gives you
- 29:37an incredible advantage. That doesn't mean you're going to stop it, because everybody
- 29:41has some skill in this game, but to eliminate an entire half of your
- 29:48defensive playbook or the offensive playbook is an incredible advantage, right, And you
- 29:55know there's It was James Franklin, and that was that was the exact example
- 29:59he gave, and that's absolutely right. One thing that I think is worth
- 30:03I have really not seen a lot of people talking about this in this context.
- 30:06Remember all the Michigan people who were saying it doesn't matter that in Michigan
- 30:10had Ohio state signals or stole Ohio state signals because Ohio State changed your signals.
- 30:15Right, Ohio State changed your signals. So I'm going to go back
- 30:18and read the I think we talked about this earlier, the Dwan Jones thing
- 30:22from Tom Weathers from the AP. He said, the Buckeye suspected the Wolverine
- 30:25seither sidelines signals last year and made some changes, but couldn't change everything.
- 30:29They made some changes, so it was it was probably some changes. So
- 30:33therefore you didn't know immediately. You had some idea. Maybe you guessed right.
- 30:37Maybe the signals were similar but not exactly the same, so you didn't
- 30:41have the exact play. You knew it was a pass, but you didn't
- 30:44have the exact play because it was the first drive of the game and you
- 30:45were just figuring out, hey, maybe they've changed your signals a little bit,
- 30:48and then it you know, and then you figure out, Okay,
- 30:51you can't change everything, so maybe you're changing the indicator, maybe you're changing
- 30:55which guy is the dummy on any individual given play, whatever it is.
- 30:59Once you figure that out, then you have a better you know, you
- 31:02get better again later in the game and that stuff is legal. But the
- 31:04stuff before the game is not one thing that I pulled up. And this
- 31:08is not proof positive of anything. It's just I wanted to pull this up,
- 31:12and I decided I'm going to talk about this on the show, whether
- 31:15it proves something or not. Just here's another data point. This is the
- 31:21Michigan blog. MgO blog has for years done UFR, which is upon further
- 31:25review, they go back and look at play by play, charting each play
- 31:29which player did well, which player did you know? You get a plus
- 31:32or a minus. One of the things they track is called RPS, which
- 31:34is rock paper scissors, So it's basically, I, on offense have called
- 31:38the play that you know ants you're gonna blitz and I'm gonna throw a screen
- 31:42or I'm going to run a drawer or whatever, and it's going to be
- 31:45you know, this is going to be the perfect call for the defense that
- 31:48you're in or vice versa. Hey, you're you're running a fourth and one
- 31:52and but you're going to pass it and I'm going to keep both my safeties
- 31:56back. Even though that's not I have out smart as you. I have
- 31:57won rock paper scissors right twenty twenty one, offense against Ohio State, Michigan
- 32:02was a plus three. Defense against Ohio State, Michigan was a plus two,
- 32:07so that was you know, you had an advantage, but not an
- 32:09enormous advantage. Twenty twenty two offense, Michigan was a plus seven seven more
- 32:15plays that they had a schematic advantage on defense plus twelve. So they have
- 32:20gone from a plus two to eight plus twelve in one year. I'm not
- 32:24saying that this is proof positive of anything. Maybe they just got a lot
- 32:29smarter, but that is from m GO blog, the Michigan site. That's
- 32:32their numbers. Their numbers contemporaneously at the time. I wanted to go back
- 32:36and check Tony, you know, have a little bit more of a controlled
- 32:38group, going back to obviously didn't play in twenty nineteen twenty, didn't play
- 32:43in twenty twenty. Someone else did it on the offensive side of the ball
- 32:46for them in twenty nineteen, So the numbers are not the same. They
- 32:49were a plus six, but it was a different person grading and he said,
- 32:51I don't know if I'm in grade this the same way that Brian does
- 32:52so and then didn't they didn't grade a defense in twenty nineteen, and then
- 32:57they got murdered in twenty eighteen and they were sad I didn't do it then.
- 33:00So you go back several years and they haven't done it. So there's
- 33:02not a great control group there. But twenty twenty one to twenty twenty two,
- 33:06Michigan got a lot better at being in exactly the right call against Ohio
- 33:09State, for whatever that's worth. Twenty twenty two is when he was made
- 33:15a counter Stalings was made it full time staffer. Is that is that the
- 33:19timeline on that one? I believe that is correct. Yes, And so
- 33:25based on the s I think that just came out. He was also doing
- 33:29doing some of this in twenty twenty one as well, which I think is
- 33:31something that Pete Thamill's also reported. But he's been around the program since like
- 33:36twenty fifteen in some form or fashion. And I did see so much in
- 33:44the show. For me, here is just more than more than any other
- 33:46show is recently. Like you know, I saw on Twitter and it's it's
- 33:50a just a terrible way to live. But I did see a Reddit post
- 33:55on Twitter about is it is it any coincidence that Jim Harbaugh's worst year at
- 34:04Michigan is the year that no fans were allowed in the stadium of twenty twenty
- 34:09when you couldn't, you know, like none of this would have been possible.
- 34:14And I don't know. The COVID year may actually truthfully pre date this
- 34:21whole alleged thing. But this is the problem with having something like this because
- 34:25it creates, it invites a ton of speculation. Especially when a ton of
- 34:30the speculation is bearing out. It's like, well, this follows, and
- 34:34this follows, and they he bought tickets for a Clemson game, and he
- 34:38bought tickets for this game, never once buying a ticket for a Michigan game
- 34:43in any of these contests, which is another topic we can move on to
- 34:45in a second. But you know, I just so many interesting internest looths
- 34:52out there, I guess, well, and with that one, with the
- 34:55COVID year, I'm kind of willing to just sort of write off the COVID
- 35:00year as the weird one off that it was. There was a lot of
- 35:02stuff going on there. You had players missing every week, Penn State had
- 35:07an awful year that year as well. I'm I don't look at twenty twenty
- 35:10and go aha, you know, QD. I don't think that's proof positive
- 35:16of anything, but you know one thing that is. I mean you talked
- 35:20about the you know, skewing the outcomes, Tony. Do you know how
- 35:23many times Michigan has covered the spread out of their last twenty three games.
- 35:31I don't think they did it in a non conference this year, but tell
- 35:37me. According to CBS Sports, they are seventeen to five and one against
- 35:40the spread in their last twenty three games conference sorry, twenty three conference games,
- 35:45sorry, last twenty three conference games. Sow. You know, Brent
- 35:50Musburger talking about our friends in the desert, and it feels like, with
- 35:54the legalization of sports gambling, our friends in the desert maybe having a larger
- 35:59influence on college sports right now. And our friends in the desert don't tend
- 36:02to screw aroundless stuff. There was a tweet, and I don't want to
- 36:07get into the reading tweets from every one hour, but this one was interesting
- 36:10and it's from a Fox Sports Radio National CFB recap show host Aaron Torres.
- 36:15He said little note was told by an airsight airtight source. Tonight. At
- 36:20least one major sportsbook has been advised to take Michigan lines off the board for
- 36:22the time being. For those who still don't get it, this isn't a
- 36:25quote NCAA rules are dumb, unquote issue. It's a quote integrity of the
- 36:30entire sport unquote issue. So that's one of those things. And I shared
- 36:36that on Tuesday night, and I'll say here what I said on Twitter,
- 36:40which is right now. This is just a keep an eye on this kind
- 36:47of thing. But if you do see Michigan lines getting pulled off of the
- 36:52board places, that's going to be an indication that, you know, the
- 36:55people who spent who make a lot of money by people, you know,
- 37:00via people betting on Michigan games, are pulling those off, and they are
- 37:04telling you that something real significant is impacting this in a way that is not
- 37:08you know, in the pure standards of sportsmanship and in the you know,
- 37:12the pure spirit of competition. That's just something to keep an eye on.
- 37:16Again, I don't want to oversell this. I just there's been a lot
- 37:21of stuff floating around that one felt like it was from someone who was maybe
- 37:23credible enough that it merited sharing, just as a keep an eye on this
- 37:30thing. You know, there are coaches who are ticked about this Tony.
- 37:34I mean that there have been There's been plenty of them reporting citing you know,
- 37:37big ten coaches who are really ticked about this and want to see something
- 37:40done. I wonder if our friends in the desert are really ticked about this
- 37:45too, because, you know, Michigan, if Michigan is consistently outperforming expectations
- 37:51for reasons that can't be quantified, you know that that may cost sports books
- 37:57money. If you know, people are betting. Michigan is a fairly public
- 38:00teams, so people are you know, people are going to throw a couple
- 38:01bucks on Michigan. If Michigan's covering every week, well that's probably Those are
- 38:06probably bets that casinos are losing money on to a certain degree. So you
- 38:09know, and you have to you have to believe that the product in front
- 38:13of you is fair and being contested. You know, within the rules of
- 38:17the game, that you know there's not a Tim Donahey situation, that there's
- 38:22not a Dennis Lundie situation, and that you know this is being this is
- 38:27being contested, you know, in the way that you expect the game to
- 38:30be contested. So once you lose that, that becomes a pretty big issue
- 38:37in realms beyond just big ten coaches being mad. Yeah, it's there's more
- 38:43than just a small group of people angry about this, And it doesn't take
- 38:46much more than a small group of angry people if that group of people is
- 38:51influential, and there there are a number of influential people angered throughout many different
- 38:57spheres, whether it is the gambling people, the big ten coaches, national
- 39:02coaches, if you will, some you know, Kirby Smart didn't seem to
- 39:07be bothered by any of it, because I think the rough quote was,
- 39:12yeah, I don't remember much of that game basically where I thought that Michigan
- 39:15had our number or knew anything that we were doing that sort of thing.
- 39:17And if you remember the game, I don't know what was it like thirty
- 39:21to eleven something like that. Michigan was never in that one, and if
- 39:24they had had plays, maybe it would have been thirty to fourteen something like
- 39:28that. One last thing I wanted to maybe just touched on the race to
- 39:36pin this on Ryan Day as some sort of a whistleblower and to the want
- 39:44to bury the whistle blower rather than find out the truth or to say,
- 39:49hey, is there any truth to this? By some as funny, but
- 39:52then also John Ugh Bacon, a noted Michigan expert author, best selling author
- 39:59like a not necessarily all Michigan's version of Jack Park, but in that same
- 40:05kind of realm, but also will report and as a presence on Twitter putting
- 40:09a name to the whistleblower being Jim Stapleton, who is a Board of Trustees
- 40:17for Michigan and also on the NCIA committee. Now yes, he's on the
- 40:22NCAA Committee on Infractions. He served a ten year term as a lumni student
- 40:28athletic representative on Michigan's board in control of intercollegiate athletics. He served a ten
- 40:31year term as a gubernatorially appointed regent at Eastern Michigan University. Assisted in the
- 40:37formation of a group that purchased the Minnesota Vikings franchise in two thousand and six.
- 40:40Former senior vice president of Business Affairs to the Detroit Tigers. And he's
- 40:45also an attorney by trade. So it's not Ryan Day. Well, it
- 40:53seems like there's a new you know, there's a new scapegoat out there,
- 40:59and you know, I mean, don't let don't let the escapegoat, you
- 41:05know, don't let this you know today's version of Emmanuel Goldstein distract you from
- 41:08the fact that this is about whether rules were broken or not, like you
- 41:13can like Michigan boards are in there two minutes hate every day at this point
- 41:17over something new, and it feels like the substance of things is not really
- 41:22getting addressed, and it's just sort of like, go get that guy.
- 41:27And that's I mean, okay, but I said this. I think on
- 41:34the Bluckeist More Mornning episode we recorded at the Woody yesterday, when the response
- 41:38to stuff is just universally stupid and wrong, it's generally an indication that the
- 41:46reporting on a subject is probably fairly accurate and there's not a legitimate way to
- 41:52rebut it. It's yeah, but it's Ryan Day is the one. He's
- 41:58a cry baby. His teams are sawt hey. It's this guy. He's
- 42:00always hated Jim Harball. And I mean, I don't know. I don't
- 42:05know the guy at all. I had not heard the guy's name until John
- 42:07new Bacon said it on ninety seven to one on Wednesday morning. I have
- 42:10note. Maybe he does have it out for Jim Harball. I have no
- 42:13idea unless this guy has made this whole thing up of whole cloth, including
- 42:19you know, Venmo transactions from Connor Stallion's and you know that I don't I
- 42:23don't think that this guy is actually the issue this. You know, he
- 42:27may be taking the you know, he may be involved in the decision,
- 42:30but this is not you know, this is not something that this guy is
- 42:32going to do by himself. And this is not something that this guy,
- 42:37you know, forced Michigan to do. If you know the stuff they're accused
- 42:38of, it's it feels like a little bit of a distraction. And the
- 42:47last thing for me is the the latching onto the Venmo stuff and Michigan side
- 42:57of fans and even maybe a couple of media members throwing out the name of
- 43:01an Ohio State QC persons as a guy and using some Venvo receipt from the
- 43:09Notre Dame game that the person one of the people were attending, like you
- 43:15can't you can't advance scout a game, and they were attending the Ohio State
- 43:20Notre Dame game, which is vastly different than attending a game well in advance
- 43:27to scout something. You can't advance scout as the game is going on from
- 43:30a seat that is not equipped to do any of that. And throughout all
- 43:36of this reporting, Connor Stallion's like, none of the games that they're scouting
- 43:38were Michigan games. They're always future Michigan opponents. You can't the better place
- 43:45to scout this would be from the press box, you know, And it's
- 43:49it's not even scouting. It's like the better place to steal the signals would
- 43:52be from the press box. And this is not advanced scouting. This is
- 43:53going to a game. This is attending a game that you want to see
- 43:58because your guys are playing it, and it's a it's a venue that is
- 44:02it's college football history. This isn't the tom you would have to be to
- 44:09advance scout in real time. You would have to be able to move so
- 44:13much faster. I have to be, like, you know, you are
- 44:15one of these superheroes that can stop time. And it's just a ridiculous notion
- 44:21that you're thinking that this is equivocal to anything that has been done allegedly from
- 44:29the counter Stallion side, Right, that's a real, just very obvious distraction
- 44:34to what's actually going on here. Because the date on the this was two
- 44:39Ohio State staffers Ben mowing money. We had the public Venmo conversation yesterday.
- 44:45We don't need to repeat that, but ven mowing money on September twenty first,
- 44:49twenty twenty three, at nine six pm, so that would be the
- 44:52Thursday evening before the Ohio State Notre Dame game. The emoji on the on
- 44:57the thing was a shamrock leads me to believe it might be noted related.
- 45:00Tony. The issue with Connor Stallion's games is it was advanced scouting. This
- 45:08is attending a game that Ohio States playing in. You're allowed to attend games
- 45:14you're playing in because otherwise every game would be a forfeit. Does that make
- 45:19sense? I feel like that makes sense. I feel like having the team,
- 45:23staff members, families, what have you. There is probably a relevant
- 45:30portion of playing the game. It's a relevant piece of playing the game.
- 45:34So yeah, this is not at all the same thing. But yeah,
- 45:37there was a Michigan media member who was pushing that, and it's like,
- 45:40my brother in Christ, use your brain for three seconds and think it through.
- 45:45Look at the date that the Ohio State Notre Dame game was played,
- 45:49and look at the date of this transaction. This isn't advanced scouting two weeks
- 45:52in advance. This is someone buying a ticket the week of the game so
- 45:55that he and or his family could go attend. I had the tweet from
- 46:00that play that staffer after the game that showed video from the stands and said,
- 46:06you know, look, hey, look this is where he was sitting.
- 46:07Someone told me that that video he had taken from someone else and so
- 46:10it was not necessarily his seat. So I took that down. But you
- 46:14know, regardless, this is someone who was buying a ticket to the game
- 46:19that Ohio State was playing, in which you're allowed to do. Conner Stallion's
- 46:23being at the Michigan games. He's not stealing the opposing team signs in advance
- 46:30illegally during the game where they're playing that team. Someone else is out there
- 46:32doing that remotely at another school. That's the allegation. That's the issue.
- 46:37I keep seeing people saying, you're allowed to steal signs. Everyone steals signs.
- 46:40Yes, you're allowed to steal signs during the game where you're playing the
- 46:45team. You're not allowed to do it in advance. That's the issue.
- 46:49I genuinely don't know, Tony. Do are people seriously not understanding the distinction
- 46:53here or is this just a well, I've reached my conclusion on this,
- 46:58and so therefore, you know, I have to just say this because you
- 47:02know, otherwise I might have to acknowledge like, hey, there might be
- 47:07something going on here. Yeah, it's the intellectual dishonesty or just not being
- 47:13truthful with yourself in terms of what this looks like. And again, what
- 47:17it looks like not necessarily what it is yet, although it's getting worse and
- 47:21looking like it's getting worse and worse, and so I think a lot of
- 47:24people are are Michigan fans are like, but this is just it's all circumstantial.
- 47:29None of this is tying together to Michigan. But even even then if
- 47:34it does, then the response is going to be like, why is this
- 47:37even legal the NCAA, And this is already happening. The NCAA tried to
- 47:40get rid of this rule a couple of years ago. They said it was
- 47:44more trouble than it's worth to monitor it, and they didn't see it as
- 47:45being all that beneficial. And so people on the Michigan side have latched on
- 47:51to that, like, see, the NCAA doesn't even think it's a real
- 47:52thing. Except it's still a rule. It's still they did not get rid
- 47:58of that. And clearly, if you want to be if you want to
- 48:01look at the circumstantial evidence, it sure helps. Or else they wouldn't be
- 48:05doing it. You wouldn't be sending people out, you wouldn't be trying to
- 48:07get as much information as you can. So it certainly looks like it's going
- 48:13to it's helping. And so I think at once this is all, If
- 48:15this is everything is pinned back on Jim Harbaugh, then the reaction will be,
- 48:21why is this even a rule? Why is there anything wrong with this?
- 48:24And the rules today's society today, you know that whole thing. It's
- 48:29like it shouldn't even be against the rules because we're working harder, you know
- 48:31that sort of thing. We're being punished for our effort. He is enthusiasm
- 48:36and unmatched, unknown to mankind. You know what's wrong with that? You
- 48:38know? And they're just trying to keep us down, and then they're out
- 48:40to get us and all of the conspiratorial things that we see way too often
- 48:46today is just going to be handed down to the Michigan football fandom. And
- 48:52it's a difficult situation for Ward manual to be in if he wants to be
- 48:58like, this is completely unacceptable for what this program has purported itself to be
- 49:04for so long. And you've just seen that, you know, we'll become
- 49:08almost lord of the flies overnight in terms of what is okay and what is
- 49:13it what is just hamburgers and what is just stealing signs. Yeah, it
- 49:19feels like there's a lot of rationalization and you start you start getting into doing
- 49:22doing stuff that you wouldn't necessarily have thought you were willing to do. Just
- 49:28again, I feel like I've said this on hundred thousand times, like,
- 49:30let's let this whole thing play out. Let's see what the NCAA comes up
- 49:34with evidence. Why someone messaged me this morning DM me this morning. He
- 49:37was asking, you know, has has the NCAA gotten the video yet?
- 49:39From that you know that they were supposed to be getting. I have no
- 49:43idea. We will have to wait and find out. We'll see, we'll
- 49:45see what when they get the video, We'll see what is on that video,
- 49:47what they find on that video, We'll find it all eventually. It
- 49:52just this is just at this point, we are just sort of collecting information,
- 49:55and you know, you're starting to You're starting to have dots you can
- 50:00can connect a little bit, and it's making a little bit more sense,
- 50:02and you're getting some consistent themes and data supporting certain conclusions. Did I let
- 50:08it continue to play out? I do, Tony, before I let you
- 50:12go a little more from that SI story from Richard Johnson I mentioned earlier,
- 50:15I'm just going to read his tweet promoting it. Part of it was that
- 50:17Connor Science was apparently quote also working on a six hundred page manifesto to run
- 50:22the program in the future using data on about five hundred Navy players two four
- 50:27inform a recruiting theory. And then Matt Brown the Extra Points newsletter in Ohio
- 50:32State Grid with the quote two to the day says, weird, a Michigan
- 50:37man writing a huge manifesto has never gone poorly before Tony, I think we're
- 50:40done. It's so annoying that I did not know that that was coming because
- 50:46I was waiting to make that same joke. So I will edit this three
- 50:51two one, Tom It's crazy. Another Michigan man with a giant manifesto?
- 50:57What could possibly go wrong? Scene? Do we do? We have our
- 51:02name to see the unifilmer something like that, or we oh my the UNI
- 51:09signer manifesto, the uniconnor the unic hoonnors not bad? How how is?
- 51:22How is his last name stallions? And that's not gonna be the part of
- 51:24his name we use for this. I don't know Uni Stallions, you know.
- 51:28Look, Tony, good news. I think we're probably gonna end up
- 51:30doing another show on this at some point relatively soon, that we can continue
- 51:32to workshop these tremendous, tremendous ideas. So much workshopping that will go on.
- 51:38So I want to thank you all for tuning in. Please check us
- 51:42out at bucket huddle dot com, where all kinds of stuff is happening right
- 51:45now. If you're not get a member, now is a fantastic time to
- 51:49join. Also, continue to find us at YouTube dot com, slash bucket
- 51:52Huddle, at any pot podcast platform that you would day to use. We
- 51:55are there as well. So thank you all for tuning in, and we'll
- 51:59talk at you guys later