Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / 2026 PayPal Value Trap or Fintech Bargain
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine holding the keys to a brand new fully loaded supercar.
- 0:06OK. But the market is pricing it
- 0:08like, I don't know, a beat up sedan from 10 years ago?
- 0:11Right. Yeah, total mismatch.
- 0:12Exactly. And that is basically the exact
- 0:15mathematical reality of PayPal Holdings right now in 2026.
- 0:18I mean, we are looking at a company processing nearly $2
- 0:21trillion a year, practically printing cash and yet it's
- 0:25trading at a 10 year low. It's wild.
- 0:27So today we're doing a deep dive to answer one massive question.
- 0:31Is PayPal a value trap that's about to be disrupted into
- 0:35oblivion? Or is it, you know, the ultimate
- 0:37fintech bargain of this decade? It.
- 0:39Really is the defining valuation disconnect of the year.
- 0:42I think you have these tech analysts who are panicking over
- 0:44the narrative while value investors are looking at the
- 0:47actual cash flow and, well, practically salivating.
- 0:50Right. The contrast is crazy, and to
- 0:52help us unravel this paradox, we are relying on a massive stack
- 0:55of research. This includes A comprehensive
- 0:57strategic equity research report covering Q1 2026 earnings, the
- 1:01202510K, and some really detailed deep value analysis
- 1:05models. There's a lot to dig into.
- 1:07There really is, and before we jump into those numbers, I want
- 1:10to share a quick message for you listening to access more
- 1:13advanced researches, applications and our latest
- 1:15published personal intelligent multi agent deep value
- 1:18intelligence. Welcome to explore and join Deep
- 1:21Values dot AI community to track total market temperature.
- 1:26Welcome to Search and download iOS App Buffett Indicator from
- 1:29Apple App Store. All right, so let's start with
- 1:31those hard numbers, right? Yeah, let's do it.
- 1:33The Q12026 results just dropped on May 5th.
- 1:36This is under the relatively new CEO, Enrique Loras.
- 1:40And at a glance, net revenues hit $8.35 billion, which is up
- 1:457% year over year. OK, 7%, not bad.
- 1:48Right. And total payment volume, which
- 1:51is basically just the sheer volume of money flowing through
- 1:53their pipes that surged 11% to 464 billion in a single quarter.
- 1:59Wow in 1/4. Yeah, just 90 days, which tells
- 2:03us the sheer scale of their utility hasn't vanished at all.
- 2:05Hundreds of billions of dollars are still moving through their
- 2:08infrastructure. But then, you know, you dig one
- 2:10layer deeper into the report and the narrative starts to fracture
- 2:12a bit. Oh, absolutely.
- 2:13Because GAP operating income actually declined by 3%, down to
- 2:171.49 billion. And for those listening, GAP
- 2:20just means standard accounting rules.
- 2:22So this is their true operating profit actually taking a hit.
- 2:25Right. Their operating margin
- 2:26contracted to 17.8%. Yeah.
- 2:29And if we zoom out to the full fiscal year of 2025, which they
- 2:32called a pivotal transition year, the picture gets even
- 2:35weirder, I think. How so?
- 2:37Well, they processed a record $1.79 trillion for the year, but
- 2:42the total number of payment transactions actually shrank by
- 2:454%, down to 25.4 billion. Yes.
- 2:48And their active accounts also essentially flatlined,
- 2:50stabilizing right around 439 million.
- 2:52Wait, so just 1% growth in users?
- 2:55Exactly. Only a 1% growth rate.
- 2:57So when you process more total money, but you facilitate fewer
- 3:01actual transactions with a stagnant user base, you are
- 3:03witnessing A profound structural pivot.
- 3:05I was actually trying to map this out visually while reading
- 3:07the report and it feels like a wildly popular nightclub A.
- 3:11Nightclub. OK, I'm listening.
- 3:13Yeah, like for 20 years, Paypal's goal was just to pack
- 3:15as many people through the front door as physically possible.
- 3:18Just total chaos, huge lines, everyone buying $5 drinks.
- 3:23Right, the classic tech growth model.
- 3:24Exactly. But recently it's like they've
- 3:27stopped trying to pack the general admission dance floor.
- 3:30Instead, they were focusing almost entirely on the VI IPS
- 3:33who are already inside getting them to buy, you know, $1000
- 3:35bottle service. I mean it's a highly functional
- 3:38analogy in financial terms. This is a deliberate shift from
- 3:42a high growth user acquisition phase into a deep monetization
- 3:46phase, right? PayPal is actively de
- 3:49emphasizing those low margin, high frequency transactions You
- 3:53mentioned the $5 drinks in the payments world processing a $5
- 3:57coffee purchase has terrible unit economics.
- 3:59Oh sure, once you factor in the fixed transaction costs, it's
- 4:03just not worth it. Precisely.
- 4:04So they are letting those tiny transactions go to competitors
- 4:08and they're focusing on pushing the average order value way up.
- 4:12Which they are driving through things like the PayPal
- 4:15Everywhere debit card, right? Yes, but the real engine here is
- 4:19their buy now pay later services, or BNPL.
- 4:23That BNPL segment hit $40 billion in total payment volume
- 4:28in 2025 alone. Yeah, they basically realized
- 4:32they don't need a million new users buying cheap coffees if
- 4:35they can convince their existing 439 million locked in users to
- 4:39finance $1000 couch. OK, so this pivot toward high
- 4:43ticket BNPL items explains the drop in transaction volume, but
- 4:47it also exposes a massive vulnerability, doesn't it?
- 4:50How do you mean? Because if you are intentionally
- 4:52relying on fewer, much larger purchases, you're stepping right
- 4:56into the crosshairs of the market's biggest fear right now,
- 4:59which is AI shopping assistance. Ah yes, the agentic shopping
- 5:02threat. Right, because if I'm financing
- 5:04$1000 couch, I'm doing a lot of research or increasingly I'm
- 5:07having an AI do it for me. And this brings us right to the
- 5:10core of the market's panic. To understand the threat, we
- 5:13really have to look at how Paypal's revenue is architected.
- 5:16OK. Let's break that down.
- 5:17Historically their Moat was a powerful 2 sided network effect.
- 5:22Consumers wanted PayPal because merchants accepted it, and
- 5:26merchants accepted it because consumers demanded it.
- 5:28Right, a perfect loop. Exactly, and over 2 decades they
- 5:32built up this invisible data vault of transaction history,
- 5:35giving them arguably the best fraud detection in the world.
- 5:38Which is why merchants love them so much.
- 5:40High approval rates, super low fraud risk.
- 5:42Yes. But the question is how do they
- 5:44actually monetize that? Well, about 52% of the revenue
- 5:48comes from branded checkout. And that's the literal blue
- 5:52PayPal or Venmo button you click on a website, right?
- 5:55Correct. That is a highly visible high
- 5:56margin business. But then another 35% comes from
- 5:59unbranded processing like Braintree.
- 6:01Braintree. Braintree operates completely in
- 6:03the background. You type in your credit card,
- 6:05Braintree processes it, but you never actually see their logo.
- 6:08Oh. I see so unbranded drives
- 6:10massive volume but at significantly lower margins.
- 6:13Exactly, and Wall Street notoriously punishes companies
- 6:17that transition from high margin branded products to low margin
- 6:20background plumbing. Which makes sense.
- 6:22And that is where this concept of the agentic shopping
- 6:25revolution from the source material completely changes the
- 6:28game. It really does.
- 6:29Think about the last time you bought something on your phone.
- 6:32Did you pick PayPal because you deeply love the brand, or just
- 6:35because your thumb was closest to that button and you know it
- 6:38saved you from typing in your shipping address?
- 6:40For the vast majority of consumers, it is purely about
- 6:43avoiding the friction of the checkout process.
- 6:46Right, so now introduce agentic shopping.
- 6:48These are AI driven digital assistants that don't just
- 6:52recommend products, they actually execute the purchase
- 6:55for you in the background. It's.
- 6:56A huge shift, yeah. If an AI bot is scanning the web
- 7:00for the best price on that couch, very verifying the
- 7:02inventory and executing the transaction via a back end API,
- 7:06it never sees a blue PayPal button.
- 7:09Right. It doesn't care about brand
- 7:10loyalty at all. Exactly.
- 7:12It optimizes for latency, price, and success rate.
- 7:16Here's where it gets really interesting.
- 7:18If an AI is doing my shopping for me in the background, does
- 7:21brand trust, the very thing PayPal built its empire on, even
- 7:25matter anymore? It's the ultimate question
- 7:28because the AI bypasses the human interface entirely, and if
- 7:31the human interface is bypassed, the branded checkout button
- 7:34becomes obsolete. Wow.
- 7:37This structural challenge is the exact reason the market is
- 7:40pricing PayPal like a tollbooth operator on a highway that's
- 7:44about to be bypassed by a high speed rail line.
- 7:47That's a great way to. Put it and the numbers are
- 7:48already showing cracks. I mean, in the fourth quarter of
- 7:512025, Paypal's branded checkout growth slowed to just 1%.
- 7:56Just 1% that is basically standing still, yeah.
- 8:00It's flat. If your highest margin business
- 8:02is only growing at 1% and you have Apple Pay dominating mobile
- 8:05plus AI threatening desktop, I mean the Moat looks incredibly
- 8:10fragile. And remember, the market doesn't
- 8:12price companies based on today's profits, it prices them based on
- 8:15the trajectory of tomorrow's profits.
- 8:17Right. The fear is that PayPal will be
- 8:18relegated to a low margin unbranded payment pipe just
- 8:22fighting over pennies with Stripe and ADN.
- 8:24Add in macro threats like central bank digital currencies
- 8:27or domestic real time rails like Fed now, and this whole
- 8:30narrative of Terminal Klein really takes hold.
- 8:33So the narrative is genuinely bleak.
- 8:35But this is where the research demands we separate the
- 8:38narrative from the math. Oh, absolutely.
- 8:40Because while the tech analysts are writing obituaries, the
- 8:43value investors are, well, they're backing up the truck.
- 8:46Let's translate some of these deep value financial metrics
- 8:50from the report, because the contrast is just staggering.
- 8:53We are looking at 2 totally different investing philosophies
- 8:56clashing in real time Here the growth investors have fled,
- 9:01which leaves the stock to be priced entirely by deep value
- 9:04mechanics. Right.
- 9:05So let's start with the PE ratio, the price to earnings
- 9:08multiple, it's sitting at a 10 year low of 9.32, which is.
- 9:12Incredibly low for a tech company.
- 9:14Exactly. Historically, PayPal averaged
- 9:16around a 38 multiple, but the metric that really jumped out
- 9:19from the models was the free cash flow.
- 9:21In 2025, they generated $6.42 billion in pure free cash.
- 9:26That's a massive cash engine. It is.
- 9:29And the report highlights their owner's earnings yield is
- 9:31effectively unheard of. It's sitting at 12.1% against a
- 9:34$45.4 billion market cap. We should probably unpack
- 9:38owner's earnings for a moment, just for clarity.
- 9:39Yeah. Please do.
- 9:40Warren Buffett really popularized this metric.
- 9:43It is essentially the true uncovered cash you could
- 9:47theoretically put in your pocket at the end of the year without
- 9:49degrading the company's ability to maintain its current
- 9:52operations. So at a 12.1% yield, Paypal's
- 9:55practically paying you like a high yield junk bond, but you
- 9:58get the balance sheet safety of a tech giant.
- 10:01Exactly which leads to the most aggressive action management is
- 10:04taking right now. They are funneling that massive
- 10:06cash flow directly into share buybacks.
- 10:09Oh. Man, the scale of these buybacks
- 10:11is wild. It really is unprecedented for
- 10:12them in. 2025 alone. They retired 86 million shares.
- 10:16That is $6 billion worth of stock.
- 10:19They effectively deleted 7% of the entire company's float in 12
- 10:23months. And they've authorized another 6
- 10:25billion for 2026, right? Yeah, if.
- 10:27You look at the timeline in the report, in 2022 they had 1.16
- 10:31billion shares outstanding. By late 2025, they were down to
- 10:36921 million. That is nearly a 21% reduction
- 10:40in total shares. And the math behind that is
- 10:42powerful. By heavily shrinking the number
- 10:45of shares, you artificially boost the earnings per share.
- 10:49Even if the actual net income of the business stays perfectly
- 10:52flat, each remaining share is entitled to a much larger slice
- 10:56of that pie. OK, but wait, I have to push
- 10:59back on the strategy for a second.
- 11:00Sure, go ahead. If Apple Pay and AI shopping
- 11:03assistance are breathing down their neck, shouldn't that $6
- 11:06billion have been spent on building better AI defenses or
- 11:12creating the next great consumer product?
- 11:14That's. The classic growth argument.
- 11:15Yeah, I. Mean buying back 21% of your own
- 11:18company feels less like incredible financial discipline
- 11:21and more like a red flag. Are they essentially admitting
- 11:25to the market that they have 0 innovative ideas left to invest
- 11:28that cash into? That is easily the most common
- 11:30critique of aggressive buyback programs in the tech sector,
- 11:33right? Because tech is supposed to
- 11:34innovate. Exactly.
- 11:37But if we evaluate this strictly through the lens of pure capital
- 11:40allocation, using the standard champion to buy deep value
- 11:43investors like Peter Lynch, which the sources reference, the
- 11:46math fiercely defends management's choice.
- 11:49How so? We have to look at their return
- 11:51on invested capital, or ROIC, which is currently sitting at an
- 11:55impressive 22%. Meaning for every dollar they
- 11:58actually put to work in the business, they are generating a
- 12:0122 cent return. Correct, The underlying cash
- 12:04engine is completely unimpaired. They're still highly efficient
- 12:08at extracting profit from the infrastructure they already
- 12:11built. Oh.
- 12:11OK, I see. But building new speculative
- 12:14tech products rarely guarantees a 22% return.
- 12:18When your stock is priced at a historically cheap PE of nine,
- 12:22the absolute highest yielding, lowest risk investment
- 12:25management can make is simply buying their own deeply
- 12:28discounted assets. So it's a statement.
- 12:30It's management screaming the market is wrong and we are going
- 12:33to exploit that mispricing ourselves that makes.
- 12:35A lot of sense, so let's actually look at what those
- 12:37discounted cash flow models say the assets are worth the.
- 12:40DCF models, yeah, let's get into it the.
- 12:42Research models use a standard 9.5% discount rate which is
- 12:47basically the required read a return an investor wants for
- 12:50taking on the risk. I want to look at the absolute
- 12:52worst case scenario. They modeled the no growth case.
- 12:56And the premise here assumes PayPal never grows its free cash
- 12:59flow by a single dollar ever again.
- 13:01Yeah, it just stays perpetually flat forever.
- 13:04Exactly. And even in that Doomsday 0
- 13:06growth scenario, the intrinsic value of the company calculates
- 13:10out to $67.37 billion, which equals $73.15 per share.
- 13:17That's a huge premium over where it's trading.
- 13:19Right and value investors always apply a margin of safety like a
- 13:22shock absorber for when things go wrong.
- 13:25If you apply a 30% margin of safety to that no growth case,
- 13:29you get a target buy price of $51.20 which?
- 13:32Is essentially exactly where the stock is hovering right now.
- 13:35Exactly. The implication is profound.
- 13:38At current market prices, you are essentially paying for a
- 13:41business that never grows again, which means any future growth
- 13:44they do manage to achieve is given to you completely for
- 13:47free. That's the essence of deep
- 13:48value. But mathematics don't move stock
- 13:51prices in a vacuum. You know the market requires A
- 13:53catalyst. You can have all the free cash
- 13:55flow in the world, but until someone fixes the core narrative
- 13:58and solves that deceleration in the branded checkout, the
- 14:01multiple will stay compressed. Which brings us nicely to the
- 14:04new leadership, because a structural pivot requires a
- 14:07totally different kind of executive.
- 14:10It really does. Enrique Lores officially took
- 14:12over as CEO on March 1st, 2026, and his background is
- 14:18fascinating when you contrast it with Paypal's history.
- 14:21Oh, it signals A definitive shift in the board's mindset,
- 14:24right? Because after the eBay spin off,
- 14:26PayPal was led for years by Dan Schulman, who was very much a
- 14:29visionary pushing hypergrowth. Then they had a short run with
- 14:33Alex Kris trying to aggressively monetize Venmo.
- 14:36And lores is very different. Yeah, Enrique Lores is not a
- 14:39tech visionary promising to put crypto on Mars.
- 14:42He is a 30 year operational veteran from HP.
- 14:45He is a mechanic who fixes supply chains, trims fat and
- 14:48enforces margins. Bringing in a seasoned operator
- 14:51like that is the classic playbook for a company
- 14:53transitioning from a disruptor into a mature utility phase.
- 14:57The board clearly lost patience with visionary narratives and
- 15:00they just demanded strict execution.
- 15:02And they tied his wallet directly to that.
- 15:04Execution to his compensation package is heavy on restricted
- 15:07stock units and a 200% bonus target.
- 15:10Right. So he only gets rich if the
- 15:11stock price physically moves. Exactly.
- 15:14So what is his mechanical fix for the branded checkout
- 15:18problem? Well, he immediately simplified
- 15:20the company into 3 distinct units.
- 15:22Check out solutions in PayPal, Consumer Financial services in
- 15:26Venmo, and payment services in crypto.
- 15:29Yeah, streamlining things, but. The actual tactical spearhead of
- 15:32his turn around is a massive, company wide push for biometric
- 15:37checkout adoption. Biometrics, meaning utilizing
- 15:39phase site or fingerprint scanning to authorize the
- 15:42payment right? Similar to how Apple Pay
- 15:44functions. Exactly.
- 15:45Currently, Paypal's baseline adoption for biometrics is
- 15:48around 36%. Laura's has set a hard target to
- 15:51reach 50% adoption by the end of 2026.
- 15:53Why target 50% specifically? I'm assuming there's some sort
- 15:57of psychological tipping point where merchants actually start
- 15:59altering their site design to favor PayPal if they know half
- 16:02the users can check out instantly you.
- 16:04Nailed it. It all comes down to cart
- 16:05abandonment mechanics. Every single second of friction.
- 16:08You know, remembering a password, typing in A2 factor
- 16:11SMS code, re entering a shipping zip code.
- 16:13It cost merchants billions in the lost sales globally.
- 16:16Oh I hate digging for my wallet to type in a zip code.
- 16:20I abandoned carts all the time because of that.
- 16:22Everyone does, and biometric checkout removes roughly 3 to 5
- 16:26seconds of friction from the consumer journey.
- 16:28It dramatically lifts conversion rates.
- 16:31So if loris hits that 50% threshold.
- 16:33It neutralizes Apple Pay's primary advantage.
- 16:36It makes the PayPal button just as seamless.
- 16:39And if merchants see higher conversion rates, they're going
- 16:43to keep the branded PayPal button prominently displayed
- 16:46right at the top of the page. It defends that high margin
- 16:49mote. It is a purely operational
- 16:51solution to a structural threat. He isn't trying to invent a
- 16:54flashy new product. He is just optimizing the
- 16:57existing plumbing to ensure the data vault remains accessible
- 17:00and frictionless. That makes total sense.
- 17:02So synthesizing everything from these reports, the Q1 pivot, the
- 17:06AI threats, the deep value math and the operational overhaul,
- 17:10what is the final verdict on PayPal in 2026?
- 17:13The. Overarching theme across all the
- 17:14source material is that PayPal has undergone a permanent
- 17:17identity shift. It is no longer a high growth
- 17:20fintech disruptor. It is a mature, highly
- 17:24profitable digital payments utility.
- 17:26The top line revenue growth will likely remain muted and the
- 17:30competitive threats, well, they're permanent.
- 17:32But the foundational cash engine, generating over $6
- 17:36billion annually with a 22% return on invested capital, is
- 17:40fully intact. So the nightclub might have
- 17:42stopped growing the line out front, but the VI PS inside are
- 17:46still paying premium prices. Exactly.
- 17:49And because the market is currently pricing the stock for
- 17:51terminal decline, the aggressive share count reductions present a
- 17:55textbook deep value opportunity. Just a classic mispricing, yeah.
- 18:00For an investor willing to absorb short term narrative
- 18:03pessimism, the models suggest a significant mathematical margin
- 18:06of safety. It's the ultimate test of
- 18:08trusting the cash flow over the headline.
- 18:10But before we wrap up this deep dive, I want to leave you the
- 18:13listener with a final thought to Mull over regarding that agentic
- 18:15shopping revolution we talked about.
- 18:17It's a. Fascinating concept.
- 18:19It really is. Think about a world where AI
- 18:21bots are entirely managing our daily purchases in the
- 18:24background. We naturally assume this means
- 18:27brand interfaces won't matter anymore.
- 18:29But maybe the battle won't be fought over who has the sleekest
- 18:31mobile app or the fastest space scanner.
- 18:34Maybe the true battleground is about who owns the underlying
- 18:38invisible infrastructure of trust on the Internet.
- 18:41And that is the hidden value of a 2 decade old data vault.
- 18:45Exactly. PayPal has 20 years of
- 18:47historical data linking specific merchants to specific consumers
- 18:51with proven fraud resolution. In a future Internet overwhelmed
- 18:54by AI agents, bot traffic, and synthetic identities, simply
- 18:58knowing who is real might be infinitely more valuable than
- 19:02facilitating how they click pay. That's.
- 19:04A really powerful point. Will a legacy giant's boring
- 19:07invisible data vault actually be the ultimate defense against an
- 19:10AI driven Internet? It's something you really have
- 19:12to think about A. Critical question for the next
- 19:14era of digital commerce for sure, Absolutely.
- 19:17All right, I need to share a required sign off before we go.
- 19:20Disclaimer All analysis is based on publicly available sources
- 19:23and may be subject to revisions or differing interpretations.
- 19:26All contents from this channel is for educational and research
- 19:29purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
- 19:32Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 19:35decisions. If you like to access wider
- 19:37topics, including life and investing philosophy, please
- 19:40subscribe to our sister channel, Deep Values.
- 19:42Don't forget to like this video. Much appreciated.