Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Ramsay Bolton (Game of Thrones)(2016 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:00Who is the most hated villain of all time? Is it Darth Vader?
- 0:05Is it Draco Malfoy? Is it Con from Star Trek to Voldemort Saurn?
- 0:14Is it Newman? Is it Biff from Back to the Future? Is it
- 0:19Skeletor or is it Agent Smith. Well, up until a couple of years
- 0:24ago, most people would say that the most hated villain of all time was
- 0:28none of these people. It was Jeffrey Barraffian. Everyone hated Jeoffrey Barrathian.
- 0:36But George Martin has created a villain, another villain even more hated than Jeoffrey,
- 0:42and that villain's name is Ramsey. After making my episode on the Psychology
- 0:50of Jeoffrey Barrathian one or two years ago, I got many many emails asking
- 0:56for another episode on the psychology of Ramsey Snow or Ramsey Bon. For months,
- 1:03I would get these emails, and I didn't want to make an episode
- 1:06about Ramsey because I thought he was just too evil and too one dimensional to
- 1:12make an interesting episode out of it. It's just like, well, what
- 1:15can you say about his personality is psychology? He's just like he's messed up.
- 1:19But more and more people asked, so h and the season six is
- 1:23about to come out, so I thought, well, okay, I'll start
- 1:26looking into it. And when I looked into it, I found that he's
- 1:30actually quite a complex character. He's he's yeah, definitely evil, but there
- 1:37are some things that you can definitely point to in his development that might help
- 1:44us understand why Ramsey is the way that he is. This is the Psychology
- 1:49in Seattle podcast. I'm your host, doctor Kirk Honda. I am chair
- 1:55of the Couple and Family Therapy program at Antioch University, Seattle, and I'm
- 2:00also a licensed therapist. Today it's just me and I thought I would analyze
- 2:06Ramsey, Ramsey Bolton, Ramsey Snowe. I thought I would give the history
- 2:09and at the end I'll provide my diagnosis and some quotes from the books and
- 2:16the TV show. All right, Well, first off, I just want
- 2:22to provide a little bit of an intro. About ten years ago, I
- 2:27received the audiobook from a friend of mine. He gave it to me and
- 2:31he said that this new book called Game of Thrones is amazing, And I
- 2:38remember I was bored in the car. And this is before podcasting, so
- 2:43it was all audiobooks for me. When I commuted and I put in this,
- 2:47this audiobook, and at first I hated it. I thought, how
- 2:52is how is this amazing? It's so there's so many names, and I
- 2:58don't understand where they are are they seem to be on Earth but not really
- 3:02on Earth. And so I just kept listening because I didn't have anything else
- 3:08to listen to. You, But I was pretty sure that I was going
- 3:10to give up on it pretty soon. And then suddenly it just hit me.
- 3:15I think it was when Edward and Robert are talking in the catacombs underneath
- 3:23Winterfell and again all these names of people and blah blah blah and references to
- 3:29things long past, and I'm just I don't know I was, but somehow
- 3:35the feeling of the story, or the vibe that George Martin really captures well
- 3:43just got to me. And I said to myself, I don't care that
- 3:47I don't know all the references. I just love this story. I know
- 3:52enough about each of the main characters to follow the story, and it feels
- 3:58like a real world because they're all these names that they keep throwing around without
- 4:02really explaining. Similar to Tolkien. Right when you read Tolkien, it's the
- 4:09same thing you find that the main characters you can follow, but you just
- 4:13get all these references to this broader world and it makes it feel realer,
- 4:19if that makes any sense. So suddenly hit me in. I was hooked,
- 4:24and I became a huge fan. Then I consumed all the books,
- 4:30and then I heard that a TV show was being made, And at first
- 4:34I was worried greatly because I've seen what happens when TV producers decide to make
- 4:45TV shows out of my favorite nerd books there before, and to some extent,
- 4:51as time goes on, I'm getting tired of the Lord of the Rings
- 4:55movies, especially the Hobbit movies. I mean, I watch them and they're
- 4:59okay, But but back when I was a kid, when I loved Tolkien
- 5:01in the seventies and eighties, there were movies made from the Hobbit, and
- 5:06the Hobbit one isn't so bad, but the Lord of the Rings, like
- 5:12cartoon slash live action, is terrible. The Dune TV series was a little
- 5:19silly at times, so I was I was skeptical, but when it came
- 5:25out, I was very pleasantly surprised that it was actually really well made,
- 5:30and I really liked it. Just the production just seemed way beyond what I
- 5:34thought it was going to be. I thought it was going to be like
- 5:38a bunch of b actors running around in cardboard costumes and bad acting. I
- 5:45just or in my head, I thought I was going to be like,
- 5:48what was that TV show in the nineties was Zena Zena the Warrior Princess or
- 5:53whatever. That's That's just how I imagined it was going to be. But
- 5:58it ended up turning out really well, and then surprisingly it became hugely popular
- 6:03among non nerds because back in the days, as a lifetime nerd and just
- 6:13to flash my nerd credentials, I have been playing Dungeons and Dragons since almost
- 6:19the time of Dungeons and Dragons inception, when Gary Gygax first put pen to
- 6:26paper. I've been playing a dozen dragons and still do as a forty five
- 6:30year old professional man. So professional man, that's a funny, man.
- 6:34I'm a professional man. No, I'm a professional and I'm also a man.
- 6:41So as a nerd, when anything that is super nerdy, like a
- 6:46Song of Ice and Fire, whenever it becomes popular, I'm always like,
- 6:51why this out of all the thousands of nerdy things, that nerds are interested
- 6:56in why this so suddenly? And I think it's just because it's such an
- 7:00amazing show. But at the same time, it is a little perplexing that
- 7:04that people would be interested in this subject matter because it's so I don't know,
- 7:10it just isn't the typical thing that people interested in, like, you
- 7:12know, Two and a Half Men and that kind of stuff. And now
- 7:16season six is about to come out, depending on when you're going to listen
- 7:19to this, so I thought I would oblige the listeners by analyzing the psychology
- 7:28of Ramsey Bolton or Ramsey Snow, depending on where you are on the storyline.
- 7:34Okay, so just to be clear, Ramsey is a character in the
- 7:40book series titled A Song of Ice and Fire. Some people might be surprised
- 7:45that A Game of Thrones is actually only the first book in the book series
- 7:49called A Song of Ice and Fire, so the TV show really should be
- 7:51called A Song of Ice and Fire. But I can see why they went
- 7:56with Game of Thrones because Game of Thrones is a much better title than A
- 8:00Song of iceon Fire. I mean, a Song of iceon Fire is really
- 8:03kind of a kind of a silly name when you think about it, and
- 8:07the Game of Thrones was first introduced in the mid nineteen nineties. I think
- 8:11I think it became a hit TV series about five years ago. Again,
- 8:16it was penned by the American American author George R. R. Martin or
- 8:20just George Martin. And whenever I hear, or listen or see interviews with
- 8:28Martin, I am always thinking he's a I think he's a gamer. I'm
- 8:33pretty sure that many of his stories are merged out of Dungeons and Dragons games.
- 8:37I don't know if i'm I don't know if that's apocryphal, but he
- 8:41just seems like an older version of nerds that I played D and D with.
- 8:46And it's just so awesome because, you know, for him to rise
- 8:52to such power even though he's it just seems like, you know, one
- 8:56of our fellow nerds has risen to popularity. Okay Ramsey. The character was
- 9:05introduced in the second book, which was published in ninety eight, A Clash
- 9:09of Kings. He is not a point of view character in the novels.
- 9:13If you haven't read the novels, the books, each chapter is from a
- 9:18different point of view, so it'll say, like, you know, Sansa,
- 9:22and then that chapter will be completely from Sance's point of view or Tyrian.
- 9:28And there's only certain characters that Martin actually tells the story from their point
- 9:33of view. Well, Ramsey is never It's never told from his point of
- 9:39view, so his actions are always witnessed and interpreted through the eyes of other
- 9:43people, such as Theon Great Joy, So there are chapters in which the
- 9:48story is told from Theon's point of view. And Ramsey is mostly a background
- 9:54character in the novels. The novels rarely focus on him. He's usually he
- 10:01usually comes in and out of other people's story. In the TV show,
- 10:07Ramsey wasn't introduced in the second series he aired the second season. He was
- 10:11introduced in the third season, and he's portrayed. He's portrayed by a Welsh
- 10:16actor by the name of I think it's you and Rayon. I don't know
- 10:22how to pronounce his name, but ew and Rayon looks about Ryon looks about
- 10:26right. I'm part Welsh, so uh, there's that and Rayon if I'm
- 10:37pronouncing that right. Had previously auditioned for the role of John Snow, which
- 10:43is interesting. He originally was auditioning for John Snow's character. He did not
- 10:48get that part, but Kit Harrington did get the part of John Snow,
- 10:54and you and Rayon and Kit Harrington are actually quite close friends, even though
- 11:01they've never been seen on screen together. So it's a little interesting to know
- 11:05that John Snow and Ramsey Snow are actually good friends even though they're mortal enemies
- 11:13on the screen. Ewan said regarding when they've asked him recently, They're like,
- 11:20well, so do you think you know Ramsey's going to die soon?
- 11:26And Ewen is like, yes, I would love it if this guy died
- 11:31a horrible death, because everyone dies in this show, and I'm sure Ramsey
- 11:37is no different from anyone. And he said, I've just bought a flat
- 11:43in London, so I hope that that day doesn't come too soon. But
- 11:48that day is definitely coming, no mistake about it, and I hope when
- 11:52it does it's epically nasty and preferably dragon related. He needs to go out
- 11:58with a bang, God knows. I don't want him to become a white
- 12:03Walker. So it's just interesting that he has no idea the future of the
- 12:09character, and he hopes that he goes out with a bang and he doesn't
- 12:11want his character to become a white Walker, although if he did become a
- 12:16white Walker, then maybe his contract would be extended so he would be able
- 12:20to afford that flat in London. Okay, let me talk a little bit
- 12:26about the public reaction to Ramsey. Some say that he's worse than Jeoffrey,
- 12:33and some say he's not as bad as Jeoffrey, And I don't know what
- 12:37to think about that. I personally think Ramsey is worse than Jeoffrey. I
- 12:43mean, Jeoffrey was terrible, you know, don't get me wrong, But
- 12:48to me, Jeoffrey seemed more vulnerable and more insecure and acting out of a
- 12:56childishness, you know, Jeffrey free. It might be surprising to some in
- 13:01the books, Jeffrey is only like eleven and twelve throughout the entire story that
- 13:05we see him. He becomes king at eleven and dies at twelve or something,
- 13:11so he's really quite young. And although Jeoffrey did horrible things and seem
- 13:18to take some pleasure in it, Ramsey is. He's a serial killer.
- 13:22He's a monster. But it's hard to compare these two guys and say who's
- 13:28worse. But I think if you just did the a tally of the amount
- 13:33of suffering that people have endured at the hands of each of these people.
- 13:39I don't know. Maybe Jeoffrey made more people suffer because he was in more
- 13:43He was in power for a long time. Anyway, I don't know,
- 13:46what do you guys think now? The other thing is is reading online there
- 13:52are plenty of people who really love him, who don't despise him. They
- 13:56actually seemingly identify with him, and that's interesting. I would suspect that it's
- 14:03because people identify with his power. He has a lot of power and people
- 14:09fear him, and you know, if you feel powerless and disrespected a lot,
- 14:16I think maybe it's tempting to want to identify with a character like this.
- 14:22I don't know. Maybe you have some inner sadists that you have yet
- 14:28to realize or you need to suppress. I suppose Freud would say that we
- 14:35love characters like this because they get to do things that we want to do
- 14:39that we can't do because of social norms. There was an online poll that
- 14:48received one hundred and forty five thousand votes, and it was asking people to
- 14:56tell them who was there most who's the worst person on television? And Ramsey
- 15:05won the contest. He beat out Jeoffrey, He beat out Moriarty, who
- 15:11was in the in the What's it called, Oh, Sherlock Holmes show Hannibal,
- 15:20the TV show about Hannibal Pete from mad Men. He beat out him.
- 15:26And he even beat out from Parks and Rec Jeremy jam and Tammy.
- 15:31And that's saying something because Jeremy jam is terrible, but Tammy is awful from
- 15:37Parks and Rec. And so Ramsey even beat out Tammy. So let's saying
- 15:41something. God, I love that show, all right. But perhaps the
- 15:46biggest media reaction regarding Ramsey was in the last towards the end of the last
- 15:52season. It was that scene with Sansa on their wedding night and Ramsey and
- 16:00Sansa get married, and you're just thinking, well, maybe Ramsey is gonna
- 16:07be a nice guy, because there seemed to be some evidence that Ramsey was
- 16:10gonna be nice to Sansa because he respected her, looked up to her something.
- 16:18But of course, George Martin never lets us down in terms of letting
- 16:23us down, and he proceeded to write a scene in which Ramsey actually rapes
- 16:32his new bride. In the books, it's actually not even Sansa. He
- 16:37doesn't marry Sansa. He marries Jane, but he still rapes Jane that night.
- 16:45I think he pronounce it Jane. Anyway, I remember watching the scene
- 16:51at the end of last season, and this happens in Game of Thrones frequently
- 16:55where I'm thinking to or saying out loud, oh my God, do not
- 16:59let this happ happen in front of my eyes. Don't do this. I
- 17:03can see where you're heading, and don't do this. Don't do this.
- 17:07And and I'm going, oh my god, you're doing this to my brain.
- 17:11You're making me watch someone that I care about, Sansa, who's been
- 17:18through just horrible things, just from the very beginning of the show. You're
- 17:22going to make me watch the most evil, vile character in the show rape
- 17:30one of the most innocent, nicest characters in the show. You're gonna make
- 17:34me watch this. And this is awful, and it was intense, it
- 17:40was highly disturbing, and of course, in the land of Twitter, the
- 17:45Times, the Twitter Times, there was a media backlash. Many people were
- 17:49outraged about the scene. For instance, Missouri Senator Claire McCaskill described the rape
- 17:56as gratuitous and disgusting. Producers of the show later said that these protests from
- 18:03people resulted in them making changes in the story for future episodes, so they're
- 18:11like, oh, well, we thought people wouldn't react this badly, so
- 18:15maybe we should scale us back a little bit for future episodes. The thing
- 18:21is is season six is actually beyond the books. This is the first season
- 18:26that readers of the books will have no idea what's happening. The books and
- 18:33the TV show are end at the exact same point. There's a number of
- 18:37actually interesting things in the books that they haven't shown yet, that have already
- 18:45happened in the timeline of the TV show, and it's unsure if they ever
- 18:48will show it. There's one thing in particular, if you've read the books
- 18:52where you're like, I wonder if they're really going to show this major plot
- 18:56side plot, because it's a pretty major side plot. But it's actually and
- 19:00if you if you know the side plot, you know that it's it's kind
- 19:04of it's it doesn't really fit well into the TV show. If if they
- 19:10put it in the TV show, it's it's it's probably gonna annoy the the
- 19:15watchers, the audience, because it involves kind of a dubious magic premise and
- 19:22uh so, I don't know, we'll see what happens there, and it's
- 19:26not really needed it to move the main plot forward. But anyway, so
- 19:34let's see Ewan Rayon if I'm pronouncing that right. The guy who plays Ramsey
- 19:41said told the press. He said, I think if after the rape scene,
- 19:45he said, I think if more people put their effort into charities that
- 19:49help women in the world today deal with the terror of rape, and less
- 19:53effort in social media about a fantasy show, then maybe things could change.
- 20:00I think that's actually quite a smart thing to say. I don't know if
- 20:03that goes over so well with people, but I think you're very right.
- 20:08Yeah. I mean, if people generally speaking put as much effort into actual
- 20:15advocacy to actually help human beings rather than just ranting and raving with outrage on
- 20:23the internet, then yeah, the world would be a better place for sure.
- 20:27That isn't to say that we don't have a right or should not vocalize
- 20:33our opinions about these things, because that's important too. But if you're really
- 20:38upset about rape, for instance, and all you do about it is tweet,
- 20:45then you really should look yourself, look at yourself in the mirror and
- 20:48say, what else could I be doing to actually reduce the rate of harm
- 20:56to other human beings in this world? And I don't know the answer to
- 20:57that, but you know, maybe there's something you could actually do anyway.
- 21:02The actor also said to the press, I think it could have been done
- 21:04in a much more brutal way. They didn't over sexualize it or make it
- 21:10too gratuitous. They didn't trivialize it, and I thought it moved the characters
- 21:15forward this. I think the actor who plays Ramsey is a smart fellow.
- 21:21I would agree with that that it wasn't overly sexualized. For one, there
- 21:27are plenty of shows that would make it very especially shows in this genre,
- 21:33you know, HBO, Showtime shows where they will occasionally sprinkle in pornography.
- 21:38Essentially, they could have made this more sensual, shall we say, and
- 21:44they did not do that. They also could have made it more gratuitous.
- 21:49And to me, and I'm just one person, it didn't feel gratuitous or
- 21:55over the top. It affected me and I didn't like the scene, but
- 22:00it was powerful. And maybe he was the director and the writers and Martin
- 22:07were trying to make us feel like theon slash Reek. Maybe they were,
- 22:12because you know Reek, I think was there. Wasn't he having to witness
- 22:17this? Maybe he was making us do that. Plus, if you're really
- 22:22gonna make us hate hate Ramsey, then this one really really did that.
- 22:30Plus, these sorts of things happen now, and they particularly happened back then
- 22:36there. If you're a history buff like I sort of am, rape of
- 22:41women was routine back then, and it was not pretty, and wives were
- 22:52raved too. I mean, it wasn't until recently that rape of wives by
- 22:56husbands it wasn't until recently that that was even illegal, which is just insane.
- 23:03I mean that that law is essentially it's it's like saying a husband can
- 23:10kill his wife if he wants to, which I suppose is probably still legal
- 23:12in some countries. Anyway, this is getting dark. Let's let's move let's
- 23:17move away from this. The actor also was asked how he felt about actually
- 23:26acting in the scene, and he said, I was dreading it and I
- 23:29couldn't sleep at night. So that shows that at least he has a conscience,
- 23:33which is which is a good thing for him and people around him.
- 23:37Okay, so I'm gonna tell you kind of a detailed history of him in
- 23:44the books and in the TV show. So so get ready for for this,
- 23:48because I you know, I read the books, but it's been a
- 23:52while and I don't think I realized how much detail we we knew about Ramsey.
- 23:59To me, Ramsey was until recently in the books, he was a
- 24:03very distant character, and I when I was thinking, when people are asking
- 24:07me to do an episode on him, I was like, I don't think
- 24:10we have enough data to go on. But actually, when I started looking
- 24:12back into the story, there's actually a lot in there sprinkled in that we
- 24:18know about him. It's usually it's often mentioned by other people, and a
- 24:22lot of it isn't directly observed, so to speak, in the books.
- 24:25But anyway, okay, So Ramsey Bolton also known as Ramsey Snow, also
- 24:32known as the Bastard of Bolton, also known as the Bastard of Dreadfort,
- 24:37which is the castle that the Bolton House Bolton rules. He's also referred to
- 24:45as the Bastard son of Lord or No. He is the bastard son of
- 24:49Lord Ruce Bolton, and he is currently in the storyline the only son Ruth
- 25:00Bulton. His father is Lord of the Dreadfort, and the Dreadfort or Dreadfort
- 25:07is an old fortress in the North. If you're familiar with West Ros,
- 25:11you know the North is south of the Wall, but north of all the
- 25:18other parts of the kingdom. And it's a wide expanse. You know,
- 25:23think Scotland, I think is what it's a it's modeled after. Okay,
- 25:32so let's look into his childhood. What was his childhood like, well before
- 25:37he was born, how he was conceived. Let me just tell you this
- 25:41story because it's a nasty one. You know, a nasty villain is conceived
- 25:47in a very nasty way. So Ruth Bulton, the you know, the
- 25:53lord of Dreadfort. Dreadfort, Ruce Bulton was hunting one time and he saw
- 26:03a woman and he decided he wanted to rape her. She was just working
- 26:11or something and he saw her and he's like, oh, I'm going to
- 26:14rape her. And he decided that he was going to practice this banned tradition.
- 26:22There's an old tradition in Westros where a lord or a king has the
- 26:27right to have sex with new brides. There used to be this old thing
- 26:33where where new brides had to have sex with the lord or the king or
- 26:38the ruler of that area. New brides had to have sex with him,
- 26:45you know, soon after getting married. And this is a thing, you
- 26:51know, this is a thing in history, and it's just like, my
- 26:52god, my god, can you imagine that? Can you imagine every new
- 26:57wife having to have sex with Barack Obama or something? I mean, that's
- 27:02that's what it's akin to. Or you're the mayor of your town. I
- 27:06mean, Jiminy crickets, you know. So this tradition gets banned because although
- 27:12Westros is a terrible place to live, it's apparently not as bad as it
- 27:18was before. And Ruth Bolton sees this woman and decides, you know what,
- 27:23I'm gonna I'm gonna bring back this tradition called the first Night. It's
- 27:27called the first Night. I'm gonna have sex with this woman because it's my
- 27:33right as lord of this land. Well, it turns out that, you
- 27:37know, she's married, and her husband isn't too keen about this. So
- 27:41he hangs the man from a tree. He he he's a miller. He's
- 27:48a he's a miller, and I think they they mill corn and this kind
- 27:52of stuff. But he he hangs the man from a tree because he accuses
- 27:59him of not informing him as lord of the land of the new marriage,
- 28:04and he says, you should have told me about this, and the man's
- 28:07probably saying, but I this is a rule that I thought was long ago
- 28:14banned. I didn't know I was supposed to tell you. And he says,
- 28:15well, too bad. I'm really interested in raping your wife and you're
- 28:19standing the way, so I'm going to hang you from the tree. Hangs
- 28:22him from this tree, and then he proceeds to rape the woman under the
- 28:30tree that the husband is hanging from. So trigger alert, post trigger alert.
- 28:38This this episode is going, as I've told already, the rape of
- 28:44Sansa and now the rape of this of this woman. There are going to
- 28:48be graphic depictions, and I mean, I mean, I don't know if
- 28:53they're graphic, but you know, you know what I'm saying. So if
- 28:57it's difficult to hear this stuff, by all means, do not listen.
- 29:03Okay. So he rapes her while the husband is swinging from the tree above,
- 29:11and then he leaves and he's saying to people, he's saying, you
- 29:17know what, that was not as pleasurable as I thought it was going to
- 29:21be. I was. I'm actually quite disappointed that it didn't feel as good
- 29:25as physically. It wasn't as good as I thought it was going to be.
- 29:27So so I don't know, I want to think about that. But
- 29:33a year later, the woman arrives at Dreadfort and talks to Rus and says,
- 29:41this is your baby and I've named him Ramsey, and he's your son.
- 29:49Ruce is I think married at the time, and he says, okay,
- 29:53why don't you come in here, and then he is about to kill
- 29:57her and the baby, but then he saw that the baby, baby Ramsey,
- 30:03had his eyes, and he decided not to kill them because it was
- 30:08taboo to kill your own children or your own family members at the time,
- 30:15so he decides not to do that. Ramsey's mother told Ruse that her husband's
- 30:25brother, her dead husband's brother, stole the mill from her and made her
- 30:30homeless, and so Russ was worried that his lieged Lord Rickard Stark Edward's father,
- 30:41remember that the Warden of the North or whatever Rickard Stark at ARD's father
- 30:48rust this is is he's a bannerman of the Stark family. And so he's
- 30:52worried that Rickard Stark is going to find out that he raped a woman and
- 30:56killed her husband, so he but at the same time he doesn't want to
- 31:02kill his bastard son and this woman, so he tries to clean up the
- 31:08situation by going to the dead husband's brother who took the mill, and he
- 31:15cuts out his tongue so that he can't tell anyone about what happened to his
- 31:22own brother, you know, the miller man who was hung from the tree,
- 31:26cuts out the tongue of the dude and says, give the mill back
- 31:30to this woman, and then he gives the woman Rus gives this the you
- 31:37know, Ramsey's mother the mill, and gives her a pig and several chicks,
- 31:45several chicken chicks and a bag of stars every year on the condition that
- 31:51she not tell anyone, even Ramsey, what happened. So again Ruse is
- 31:56worried that he's going to get in trouble with Rickard Starr and pays off the
- 32:00woman essentially and says, don't tell anyone, including this baby, that you
- 32:07know what happened. Later, when Ramsey was older, he convinced himself that
- 32:14Ruth Bolton fell in love with his mother at first sight, and Ramsey likes
- 32:20to think of their union as being very, very romantic. So this is
- 32:22like twenty years later when Ramsey knows about the whole situation between his mother and
- 32:29father's biological parents, and instead of believing the stories of this rape and the
- 32:34killing of this man, he makes up this story that it's oh, it's
- 32:38very poetic and romantic, because that's just how Ramsey is. Okay. So
- 32:45Ramsey was then raised in poverty as a child, as a bastard, as
- 32:52the bastard son of a poor miller's widow. So this woman is a widow
- 32:57and she is poor, very poor, and she's raising this this this son.
- 33:04Around this time, Rus fought for Edward Stark in the Civil War against
- 33:09House Targerian known as Robert, known as Robert's Rebellion, and Russ proved his
- 33:17worth as a soldier in the Battle of the Trident. So, just if
- 33:22you're familiar with the whole backstory to the Game of Thrones, Russ actually fought
- 33:28for Edward Stark and you know the usurpers Robert Robert Barrathian's Rebellion in which Robert
- 33:36became king. So he was on the good side of that situation. And
- 33:42since Ramsey was raised by a poor widow, he knows nothing about courtly behavior,
- 33:49so that'll come into play later. So he there's a whole culture among
- 33:54the the gentry people and the rich and the land, and Ramsey was raised
- 34:05in a different situation and therefore doesn't understand how to conduct himself. And incidentally,
- 34:13in the books, he comes across as being crass and blunt, and
- 34:17he swears a lot, and he taunts people. He's not seen in the
- 34:23books as a refined person. He comes across as a lower class person essentially
- 34:30okay. So Ramsey reportedly liked his mother and speaks highly of her, so
- 34:37maybe she was an okay mother for him. Unsure, okay. So Ramsey
- 34:44grows up as a poor bastard kid with a single mother and he's twelve years
- 34:52old and she decides that the mother because Ramsey is so difficult. So Ramsey
- 35:01is a very difficult child. And the mother decides to go back to rus
- 35:07Bolton, even though she is worried that Ruth might kill her like he almost
- 35:13did last time. And the Ramsey's mother tells Ruth Bolton says that she needs
- 35:20help in raising Ramsey because of how difficulty he is, and Ruce doesn't know
- 35:25what to do, so he he wants to get rid of her, essentially,
- 35:31and he offers the woman a servant. He says, well, how
- 35:37about I give you a servant? Would that help out? And the woman
- 35:40says, oh, yeah, it'd be great. I'm too poor to afford
- 35:44a servant, so sure give me a servant. Well, Russ gives this
- 35:49woman the worst servant of all time. And his name is is Hek.
- 35:55I think you pronounce it heck, but everyone has called him Reek because he
- 36:01reeks. He smells really bad, and he has some sort of birth condition
- 36:08in which he smelled. His skin smells terrible. There were even rumors that
- 36:15his blood smelled terrible or something. So due to some birth defect, this
- 36:20this boy named Hek smelled terribly and everyone called him Reek. And he bathed
- 36:28three times a day and he wore flowers in his hair trying to mask how
- 36:34bad he smelled. But he still smelled terrible. So Russ was being a
- 36:38dick by giving her this stinky servant to try to get rid of her.
- 36:44You know, She's like, I'm having I'm having a hard time raising your
- 36:46bastard son. He's he's a very difficult child. Well, how about this
- 36:50smelly servant? Will that get you off my back? So Reek goes in
- 36:55serves this woman in Ramsey. We never find referring to Ramsey's mother is this
- 37:01woman because they don't mention her name. Well, Ramsey and Reeq become very
- 37:07close friends, so to speak, or they become very close. They do
- 37:12a lot of things together, and Ramsey starts ordering Greek around, and their
- 37:19hints that Ramsey was very cruel to Reek. So Ramsey is twelve thirteen,
- 37:25fourteen, and he has this new servant to order around, and Ramsey is
- 37:34being a total dick. And what I'm imagining is that the mother is like
- 37:38happy that Ramsey is just out of the house and has a companion to boss
- 37:44around and she doesn't have to deal with them anymore. So some of you
- 37:47might be saying, wait a second, I thought theon was Reek. Well
- 37:51I'll get to that, okay. So eventually the mother is fed up.
- 37:58She can't deal with Ramsey. He's such a difficult child that she defies Ruth's
- 38:05uh, you know, request or demand to not tell anyone about Ramsey's identity,
- 38:10and the mother tells Ramsey that Rus is his father, that he's a
- 38:16he's he's a bastard son of the lord of this land. Basically, she
- 38:24wants him, she wants Ramsey to get out of the house. She's like,
- 38:28let me tell you something, son, since you're a total handful and
- 38:32I can't stand you. Did you know you know what? You know who
- 38:37your you know your real father is You've always wanted to know. Well,
- 38:38it's it's Lord Ruce Bolton. So how about you go to him and let
- 38:45him deal with you. I have to tell you that this story is is
- 38:49so contemporary and modern. There are the bastard stuff is you know, but
- 38:55the I've been with many families in this situation where single mothers will uh when
- 39:05a child is in their teens young teens, that they will get fed up
- 39:08and you know, they love their son and their or their daughter, but
- 39:12they they don't know what else to do, and they'll send him off to
- 39:16the biological parent that is absent and say, look, you deal with It's
- 39:22just it's a very common story. So anyway, and this this worked for
- 39:30the mom because Ramsey was like, what, hello, let's go to Let's
- 39:37go to Russ, and let's see how I can parlay this into something good
- 39:43for me. And so Ramsey goes to Rus and somehow Russ lets him into
- 39:47his home and and takes him under his wing as his bastard son. And
- 39:52Reeke comes with Ramsey. Okay, now Roose Bolton at this point has a
- 40:00true born son, a non bastard son, Domeric, who was older than
- 40:07Ramsey. So at this point Ramsey's like, Okay, I'm a bastard son.
- 40:13Which sucks and double sucks is there's this older son who's who's not a
- 40:19bastard and will be is the heir to Ruth Bolton. So when Ruse Bolton
- 40:24dies, Demeric is going to get the kingdom and or this land, and
- 40:29I'm just going to be the bastard son of Rus and I'll always be considered
- 40:35to be uh, not honorable or not important or you know, I won't
- 40:40have power. Well, what did Ramsey do? You could just take a
- 40:45guess. I'm not sure if if this is exactly explicitly described or you know,
- 40:54told in the book, but it's at least hinted at, if not
- 40:59just explicitly told that Ramsey murders America is his older half brother with poison.
- 41:06So that makes Ramsey, even though he's a bastard son, makes him potentially
- 41:10a logical choice as the successor for rus Bolton. Okay, so let's get
- 41:19into another thing that's referred to about this is all. This is all prior
- 41:24to the first book. So this is all stuff that they talk about that
- 41:30in the timeline of the story happened prior to a game of Thrones. Okay.
- 41:34One of Ramsey's hobbies as a teenager is to have young women stripped naked
- 41:39and released into a forest, into the Bolton Forest. He then hunts them
- 41:45with a pack of female feral dogs that are trained to hunt human beings.
- 41:52If the women don't run and make it a fun hunt for him, he
- 41:59punishes the women by raping them and then flaying them alive, so again post
- 42:06trigger alert. If they don't make a good hunt for him, he punishes
- 42:10them by raping them and then flaying them alive, meaning he ties them to
- 42:20essentially to like a cross, like a Christian cross, but it's more like
- 42:23an X. He ties them to an X and he proceeds to cut off
- 42:30their skin while they are living. It's very painful. From what I understand,
- 42:38Then he eventually kills him, and then he feeds the bodies to his
- 42:43dogs. But if they run and make a good hunt for him, he's
- 42:50happy with that. Soft He takes these women and releases them into the bolting
- 42:54forests and say you better run, because I want a good sport. Well,
- 43:00he still rapes them once they're caught, because they're always caught, but
- 43:04he doesn't flay them alive. He just kills them quickly, and then he
- 43:08flays their dead bodies. And then he honors these good runners by naming new
- 43:17dogs after these women, and he makes trophies out of their skins. And
- 43:25it's indicated later that in all likelihood, Reek, his childhood companion and slash
- 43:32servants, then proceeds to rape the dead bodies. So if you weren't disgusted
- 43:39enough with Ramsey and Reeque, I'm sure that pushed you over the top.
- 43:46Reek likes to have sex with with dead with dead women's bodies after Ramsey has
- 43:55raped them. Jiminy Crickets, it's all fictional, Kirk. It didn't really
- 44:00happen. It's happened in real life, but this is just fictional. It's
- 44:06just fantasy. Okay, so reek, just so we know and understand he
- 44:15was just as cruel as Ramsey. Again, he seemed to practice necrophilia.
- 44:22He just a little bit more of his background prior to the Game of Thrones
- 44:25begin. It's told that he once doused himself in perfumes that he stole from
- 44:31Rus's wife to try to rid himself of his terrible smell, but he was
- 44:37caught and whipped for his crime. A year later, he stole perfume again
- 44:45from Rus's wife, but this time he drank it as a way of trying
- 44:50to make himself infused with good smells, and he almost died. So there's
- 44:58that. He's not a smart fellow. He's a smelly dumb fellow. Also,
- 45:06it's told that no one in the Dreadfort could stand to be near him
- 45:09because he smelled some bad, not even the horses. So he slept in
- 45:15a sty with the pigs, which probably didn't help his smell all too well,
- 45:20but that's where he slept. He slept with the pigs. Okay,
- 45:25so that's reeke a little bit more about Ramsey. In his childhood, he
- 45:30had some buddies. Once he became known as you know, Russ's bastard son.
- 45:35He had some buddies and he called them the Bastard's Boys, the Bastard's
- 45:39Boys. It sounds like a rap group from the eighties. We're the Bastard
- 45:45Boys, and we're here to say we like to flay. Hey, hey,
- 45:51hey, oh boy. Also, Russ makes the Bastard Boys spy on
- 45:58Ramsey, on Ruth's behalf, so there's there's treachery all around in the Roof's
- 46:04household. Also, just a little side note that all of this history,
- 46:10all this childhood is in contrast to John Snow, who is the Bastard of
- 46:15winter Fell. John Snow was raised by his biological father at Ard Stark.
- 46:22So we have two. We have two bastard boys in the North. One
- 46:29is treated with respect and one is treated not with respect, and we see
- 46:34two very different personalities when they become adults. So the moral of the story
- 46:42is, if you have a bastard son, do not do what Roos did
- 46:49and instead do what Edard did. Okay, Now, a Ramsey, as
- 46:55I said earlier in the books, was not introduced until Alash of Kings,
- 47:00which is the second book. Ramsey is a young man at this point.
- 47:05It's unclear how old he is. Some say he is the same age as
- 47:10Theon, and Theon I think is around nineteen or twenty, and so he's
- 47:15probably he's in that range. And in the you know, the old medieval
- 47:22world, the West Ros world, that's an older man, you understand,
- 47:28because again, as I said earlier, Jeoffrey Barathian was eleven or twelve at
- 47:35the time of him being King. Rob Stark was I think fourteen or fifteen.
- 47:42So he was King rob Stark and kicking ass as a as a king
- 47:49in the North, and he was I think the oldest he was sixteen or
- 47:53something like that. Sansa is I think thirteen ten fourteen. She's the younger
- 48:00sister of Rob Stark. So so Ramsey being twenty ish is means he's quite
- 48:08a bit older than a lot of our main characters. So it's just something
- 48:14to take note of. He's a fully developed adult male, whereas many of
- 48:20the other characters are still children for the most part. Okay, So in
- 48:25a Clash of King second book, we start off with Ruth Bolton is still
- 48:29basically on the good side of the of the line. He's you know,
- 48:35he's one of Rob Stark's Bannerman and Ruth Bulton is at war. I mean,
- 48:43if you remember the TV show, you remember Ruce Bolton was actually a
- 48:45good guy in the beginning, and they are they're marching south to fight how
- 48:51Slannister following the execution of Edward Stark by Jeffrey Barrathian. And the word for
- 49:02it is that Housepultan is a vassal family of how Stark, if you're into
- 49:07that sort of nerd history talk a vassal family, or in the in the
- 49:14George Martin language, that he's a bannerman. So because Rus Bulton is at
- 49:22war and away from Dreadfort, Ramsey becomes the castellan of Dreadfort. So he
- 49:30basically becomes the the de facto ruler of House Bultan's castle and lands. Okay,
- 49:39so his father, Ruce Bulton is, like I said, in Southern
- 49:45West Ross fighting in Rob Stark's army during the War of the Five Kings.
- 49:52You're probably familiar with that time. Let's see if I can identify the five
- 49:58kings. You had. You had Jeoffrey, you had Stanis, you had
- 50:05Rob Stark, you had Renley Brathian, and the fifth king is bail and
- 50:14Grayjoy. So those are the Five Kings who are fighting in the War of
- 50:19Five Kings. When Ramsey receives the news that the neighboring lands of house Hornwood
- 50:30they have lost both the Lord and the lord's heir, Ramsey attacks House Hornwood,
- 50:40taking Hornwood Keep and forcing the widowed Lady Hornwood to marry him so that
- 50:49Ramsey can have her lands, which is wonderful of him to do. And
- 50:54instead of just being content with, you know, Okay, I just did
- 51:00a terrible thing and I'm probably going to be punished for this at some point,
- 51:04because that's the whole thing. Like this shows how impulsive and how stupid
- 51:12Ramsey is. Now in the end he sort of by dumb luck, ends
- 51:17up being okay, or you could just say because of how ruthless he is,
- 51:22he's okay. But if things would have gone a certain way, what
- 51:25would have happened was if rob Stark had not been betrayed at the by the
- 51:31phrase, and it looked like Rob Stark was going to win this whole thing,
- 51:38and Rob Stark became King of all Westros, then at some point House
- 51:44Hornwood would have said, so, while the War of Five Kings was going
- 51:51on, we lost our lord and the heir to House horn and suddenly the
- 52:00southern Northman Ramsey comes in and and just takes over. And that doesn't seem
- 52:07very fair, does it. And King rob probably would have said, yeah,
- 52:14that's that's a pretty much of a dick move. Let me punish Ramsey
- 52:19for you, and blah blah blah. So I'm not sure if that's exactly
- 52:24what the context was, but anyway, so Ramsey does that, and now
- 52:31he has both House Bolton and now he has House Hornwood, and he decides
- 52:38not to lay low, but he decides to rape Lady Hornwood is his new
- 52:43wife, his first wife, and he forces her to sign a document proclaiming
- 52:47him the Lord of Hornwood. He then locks her in a tower without any
- 52:52food, and in typical fashion where you just think, okay, well that's
- 52:57probably enough to do to somebody. I mean, you know, he takes
- 53:01her land, he rapes her, he locks her in a tower, he
- 53:06doesn't give her any food, he makes her turn over all her lands and
- 53:09castle to him. Isn't that enough, Ramsey? Isn't that enough? Haven't
- 53:15you done enough? Ramsey? Ramsey? He's Ramsey snow at this point?
- 53:21Well, he then flays the skin off of her fingers. He flays the
- 53:25skin off of her fingers, and she is forced to chew off her fingers
- 53:31to end the pain, because when you flay skin off, it's apparently very
- 53:37painful because you have all these raw nerves just exposed to the elements. And
- 53:43so she's sitting there in the tower and she's like, well, there's there's
- 53:46only one way to get rid of pain, and I have to I have
- 53:50to chop my fingers off. Well I don't have any knife around, Well,
- 53:52I've got I've got sharp teeth. So here goes And then as she's
- 53:55starving, she starts to become delirious and desperate and she actually consumes these fingers.
- 54:05She eats and consumes her fingers for sustenance. So that's that's great.
- 54:13And then to top it off, she dies from starvation. She is mercifully
- 54:20put out of her misery, but not after unnecessarily suffering for a long time.
- 54:28Okay, Ramsey then continues his raping and murdering because now he's in charge.
- 54:35He's in charge of house Bolten Lands, he's in charge of house Hornwood
- 54:38Lands, and he roams the countryside raping and murdering, particularly young women because
- 54:45he can, because he's terrible. Sir Rodrick Cassell the Master of Arms at
- 54:52Winterfell, because you know, at this point Rob Stark and all the army
- 54:55and all the bannermen are down south fighting. Roder Cassell was left behind at
- 55:00Winterfell and he's sort of kind of in charge of the law to some extent.
- 55:05So he leaves winter Fell because he hears about Ramsey and all of his
- 55:08terribleness. Sir Roderick leaves winter Fell to find Ramsey to put an end to
- 55:15his crimes. So again, even before rob Stark wins the war, there
- 55:22are people interested in law, and Sir Roderick is is very capable. So
- 55:29Roderick Roderick's party comes across Ramsey shortly after he has raped and killed yet another
- 55:35peasant girl. At as as Roderick is arriving to the scene, Reek,
- 55:43the hee heek slash Reek person is raping the dead body. As I said,
- 55:50he's he's into that sort of thing. Shame on you, Reek,
- 55:53but you'll get your come up and in about five minutes. So when spots
- 56:00Sir Roderick approaching, he's like, holy crap, that's it. My time
- 56:07has come. It's over for me, but he says, wait, I'm
- 56:10a smart, cunning fellow. I'm gonna I'm gonna figure out a way out
- 56:15of this. So he he realized. He realizes that there is only one
- 56:20way out, and he decides to disguise himself. So he pulls Riek off
- 56:27the dead body and he says, Reek, we have to switch clothing.
- 56:31So they switch clothing and on Reek. He puts all of his sigils and
- 56:38whatnot to mark Reek as the leader, you know, as the lord,
- 56:46and he tells Rieke he gives him their one horse, and he tells them
- 56:50because the other horse got lamed because the the woman actually ran far and was
- 56:55was a good was a good runner and one of the horses was lamed.
- 57:00But anyway, so they only have one horse. And Ramsey tells Rieke to
- 57:04put on these clothes as a lord and act like a lord and ride for
- 57:07for Dreadfort because Reek, because Ramsey knows that Roderick is going to catch Reek.
- 57:15Because he knows that that's just going to happen. So Reek has learned
- 57:22over the years that you must obey, you must obey Ramsey or else.
- 57:30So Reek totally obeys Ramsey and puts on his clothes and acts like the lord
- 57:36and gets on the one good horse and rides for the Dreadfort. As as
- 57:42Ramsey expected, Sir Roderick's men chase down Reek and they kill him. They
- 57:47think that he's Ramsey and they say, okay, yay, no more,
- 57:52Ramsey. Ramsey's done, no more of this terribleness. We've we've done a
- 57:58good deed today, but they've only done sort of a ten percent good deed
- 58:04because you know, Reek was no alter boy himself, so they got rid
- 58:07of that. But Ramsey's still quite alive because he's he's pretending he's Reek.
- 58:14Also as as to really drive home the disguise, and this is again George
- 58:22R. Martin and his wonderful I don't say this, it's you know,
- 58:28it's sort of accurate storytelling, but just it's so terrible. Anyway, the
- 58:31girl, in her fear or in her death had had soiled herself. Let's
- 58:38just say, I don't know before, no, they indicated before she died,
- 58:44so in her fear she soiled herself. So just you know, just
- 58:51put that into the scene here. And while while Reek is running from Sir
- 58:58Roderick and his men, Ramsey takes this dead woman's pooh and smears it all
- 59:07over himself to really drive home the disguise that he is Reak and not in
- 59:13fact Ramsey. These are the details in these books that you just don't get
- 59:22in the TV. You know, they always say the books are better than
- 59:23the TV show. Well, in this instance, is it is it better?
- 59:30Well, I mean it is, it's I mean not this detail.
- 59:34But they're actually really well written. I like this style every every scene.
- 59:38In fact, just as a side note, the character on the TV show
- 59:43that really exemplifies George R. Martin's writing style is Tyrian. Whenever Tyrian is
- 59:50on screen, you always know there's going to be some snappy dialogue and it's
- 59:54it's going to have every every scene has a has sort of an interesting arc
- 1:00:00to it that holds your attention. Well, that's the way all the books
- 1:00:05are, particularly first and second book. You're really the way it's written.
- 1:00:12It's very compelling. There's always these little quips that happen and funny little things
- 1:00:19that are said, but there's also terribleness, like Ramsey wiping a dead girl's
- 1:00:27whooh all over himself after she was chased down and raped, and blah blah,
- 1:00:36blah. Anyway, So when Roderick's men come back after killing Reek,
- 1:00:40whom they think is Ramsey, they come back to Ramsey, who's this guy's
- 1:00:47as Reek, and they take him as a prisoner to Winterfell. I think
- 1:00:53they debate, They're like, should we kill this Greek character? Now let's
- 1:00:57bring him back because Roderick wants to keep him alive because they want to keep
- 1:01:04him as a as a witness for Ramsey's crimes, hoping that after Rus Bolton
- 1:01:12hears Reek's tale, Ruce would abandon his claim of the Hornwood lands. So,
- 1:01:19you know, because to Russ, he's sitting there thinking, oh,
- 1:01:22I just I a raven has arrived and wouldn't you know it, My my
- 1:01:29bastard son has has married the widow of a of a local house, and
- 1:01:37I just doubled my lands. That's good. Good for you, Ramsey.
- 1:01:43Well, Roderick at this point thinks that rus is a good person. And
- 1:01:47Roderick is like, well, I'm gonna keep this Reek around because I'm gonna
- 1:01:51I'm gonna keep him as a witness for what Ramsey did and and I'm going
- 1:01:54to convince Ruth's Look, you you've got to give house Hornwood back to someone
- 1:02:00else, because this whole thing was a terrible travesty and atrocity. And you
- 1:02:07know, the Bulletins don't deserve the Hornwood lands at this point, and so
- 1:02:13so Roderick does not kill Reek. This is a a tragedy decision. Tragic
- 1:02:21decision, because wouldn't have been nice if Rodrick had just said, ah,
- 1:02:24fuck it, let's just kill this Reek, and then all of us wouldn't
- 1:02:28have to deal with Ramsey. But alas that did not happen. Okay,
- 1:02:34then Theon gray Joy takes Winterfell, and this is where Theon enters the Ramsey
- 1:02:44story. Okay, I will tell you the whole Theon gray Joy story,
- 1:02:46but you know, Theon's a piece of work himself. He's no Geoffrey Barrathian
- 1:02:53or Ramsey Snow, but you know he's he's another character that everyone hates,
- 1:03:00particularly in the beginning. Now people are have kind of come around because he's
- 1:03:05been victimized so much. But I'll get to that. So when Theon gray
- 1:03:10Joy takes Winterfell, remember that Ramsey disguises Reek is a prisoner in Winterfell.
- 1:03:17So when Theon gray Joy and the Ironborn find Ramsey in the dungeons. They
- 1:03:23they figure he's Reek because they don't know what Reek or Ramsey looks like because
- 1:03:28they don't have Facebook back then. So they go, okay, well we
- 1:03:32got this Greek character, and Reek convinces Theon to keep him alive and let
- 1:03:43him serve Theonreek is like, let me serve you. So Reek Slash Ramsey
- 1:03:47becomes a servant to Theon and he quickly becomes one of Theon's most trusted attendants.
- 1:03:57He helps Theon hunt the escaped brand and rick On Stark. He he
- 1:04:02helps cover up the fact that the Stark boys escaped by killing two peasant boys
- 1:04:08who were of similar age to the Stark boys, and then Theon flayed the
- 1:04:14corpses to avoid recognition. So I don't know if you remember that part,
- 1:04:17but Theon wants to you know, capture brand and Rickon so that they don't
- 1:04:25come back and exact revenge, and Reek Slash Ramsey cat captures two boys that
- 1:04:33are similar and then they proceed to you know, disfigure the bodies and then
- 1:04:39they claim that they caught them so that because Theon just wanted to show off
- 1:04:45and felt humiliated that he didn't actually capture the two boys anyway. Theon then
- 1:04:55approves of Ramsey killing three of Theon's men who knew the truth about the fake
- 1:05:01boys. So Ramsey's like, let me kill let me kill three of your
- 1:05:06men that know, and then then it'll only be the two of us that
- 1:05:10know that you never actually caught Brandon Rickon and Theon's like, oh yeah,
- 1:05:14go ahead and kill those guys. That sounds like a good idea. Theon
- 1:05:17then uses the winter Fell kennel master as a scapegoat and has him executed for
- 1:05:27the murders of Theon's men. So murder is just you know, any any
- 1:05:32problem for Theon and Ramsey can be solved by a good murder. Theon then
- 1:05:40contemplates killing Reek and Greek slash Ramsey. Uh, and it would have been
- 1:05:45nice if Theon would have done it, just like it would have been nice
- 1:05:47if Roderick would have done it. But alas, Theon fears that the Reek
- 1:05:55slash Ramsey character has a hidden written account of everything that happened, and so
- 1:06:01he doesn't kill him, just yet another tragic turn of events. There.
- 1:06:09Then, when the Northerners attack winter Fell to take it back from Theon and
- 1:06:15the Ironborn, the Reek Ramsey guy sneaks off to the dread Fort to gather
- 1:06:24reinforcements for Theon. So Reek slash. Ramsey sneaks off to the dread Fort
- 1:06:30and says, I'm gonna come back with reinforcements, and Theon's like, I'm
- 1:06:33a little skeptical, but any you know, I need all the help I
- 1:06:36can get. So Ramsey gets himself cleaned up, and he puts on armor
- 1:06:43to hide his identity. He has a helm, he you know, he
- 1:06:45puts on a helm that makes it impossible to see his face. And he
- 1:06:50he gets all the he gathers up an army from around House Bolton and House
- 1:06:58Hornwood, and Sir Roderick Cassell figures that the Bolton army has arrived to help
- 1:07:06them take back Winterfell from Theon and the Ironborn. So again, just so
- 1:07:13you understand here, so Cassell, Roderick is actually outside the winter so in
- 1:07:21case you're maybe you're following, but if in case you're not. So Winterfell
- 1:07:26was the Stark family castle. Rob Stark leaves with all the men and then
- 1:07:32it leaves it in Roderick Cassell's hands, and then Theon gray Joy suddenly appears
- 1:07:40with the Ironborn and capitalizes on the fact that all the armies most of the
- 1:07:45armies are in the South fighting the Or of Five Kings, and Theon gray
- 1:07:49Joy takes Winterfell. Well. Roderick is outside of the castle at this point
- 1:07:56and starts gathering other northern Men because they all stick together in the North to
- 1:08:02take back Winterfell. And so when the Bolton army arrives, they think,
- 1:08:09oh, it's just another group of Northmen arrived to help us take Winterfell back.
- 1:08:15But when Roderick offers Ramsey his hand in friendship, he doesn't even know
- 1:08:20who this man is. He's like, oh, well, I see the
- 1:08:23banner of Ruce Bolton. I don't know who this general is or whatever,
- 1:08:28but I'm gonna go to him shake his hand. Ramsey slices Roderick's arm off
- 1:08:33and then proceeds to surprise all the Northmen who are there and slaughters them.
- 1:08:42So Ramsey kills Sir Roderick, and he routs the Northman army and lifts the
- 1:08:51siege that was happening on Winterfell. And Theon's like, yay, who is
- 1:08:59this army that arrived and helped me so much? Because again he thinks Reek
- 1:09:04was Reek. He doesn't realize it was actually Ramsey. So Ramsey gets cleaned
- 1:09:09up anyway. So then Ramsey is let into Winterfell because Theon's like, yay,
- 1:09:16let these guys in. They freed us from the attackers. And Ramsey
- 1:09:23then proceeds to kill all the Ironborn, kills all theons men, and he
- 1:09:28decides to burn Winterfell, which is nice, and he takes the On prisoner,
- 1:09:33poor Theon, and Ramsey makes Then he captures a lot of the women
- 1:09:41of Winterfell. And what does he do. He does what he always does,
- 1:09:45which is he turns all of those women into hunted prey, in which
- 1:09:51his women or his female feral dogs that are all named after women he's killed
- 1:09:57before they hunt these and then he proceeds to rape them and flay them.
- 1:10:05Okay, so that's all in the second book. Now, how about the
- 1:10:11third book, A Storm of Swords, which was published in two thousand,
- 1:10:15sixteen years ago. Jimminy crickets a long time ago. I don't think I've
- 1:10:19said Jimminy crickets as often I have said today. Okay, In this book,
- 1:10:26Ramsey keeps Theon at the Dreadfort where he flays him. Right, So
- 1:10:33this is where the books and the TV show diverge in terms of the details
- 1:10:38here because in the books they don't describe all the torturing of Theon, they
- 1:10:44don't depict it, they just show the end result of everything. So I'll
- 1:10:49get to the TV show in a second. But in the books Ramsey,
- 1:10:54it's just sort of alluded to that Theon is a prisoner at the Dreadfort.
- 1:11:00Ramsey sends a small piece of theon skin to Rob Stark, so Rob Stark's
- 1:11:03still alive this point, Ramsey sends a small piece of Theon's skin to King
- 1:11:09rob Stark as a gift to show that vengeance is being exacted for the murder
- 1:11:14of Brand and Rickon Stark. So remember that King rob Stark at this point
- 1:11:18has heard that Brand and Rickon are dead and that Theon is the one who
- 1:11:24killed them. And Ramsey is trying to gain favor at this point for King
- 1:11:31Rob by saying I've caught your your Theon, the person that you've that you
- 1:11:38hate him. Look what I'm doing. I'm I'm flaying his skin, I'm
- 1:11:41torturing him. So so aren't we friends? But then this is presumably because
- 1:11:49Ramsey doesn't doesn't even know this is in the works. Ramsey's father, Lord
- 1:11:55Ruse Bolton murders Rob at the Red Wedding, the Red web Dang, the
- 1:12:00Terrible Red Wedding. Then Housepoltan is rewarded by by king is it Joffrey or
- 1:12:11Tommen one of the two? By the Lanisters, you know people. He
- 1:12:17how Spultan is rewarded by Ruce being named Warden of the North, just as
- 1:12:23Edard Stark was. So Ruce Bolton is now Warden of the North, and
- 1:12:28Ramsey then becomes betrothed to a girl posing as Aria Stark. Her name is
- 1:12:34Jane Poole. So in the TV show this is Sansa Stark, but in
- 1:12:42the book it's sort of a weird storyline actually when you think about it,
- 1:12:46but perhaps more accurate to history. But you know, like things like this
- 1:12:50actually happening. But I actually like that in the TV show they they did
- 1:12:56something different because to bring Satza back to Winterfell felt more fitting, I guess.
- 1:13:01But anyway, so in the books it might be surprising that they in
- 1:13:09order. So Ruth is thinking, Okay, I just took over as Warden
- 1:13:12of the North. I just betrayed King Rob Stark. All the northerners hate
- 1:13:17me. At this point, I am I'm a terrible person to all them,
- 1:13:21and I just sided with the enemy and I betrayed their king. Well,
- 1:13:28the king has the king in the South has named me Warden of the
- 1:13:30North. But that doesn't mean that everyone's going to follow me. Someone could
- 1:13:34rise up and decide to off me. Well, what's one way I can
- 1:13:39try to calm things down so that people will accept the fact that I'm in
- 1:13:43charge. Well, what if my son marries one of the Starks, Well,
- 1:13:47that will mean that Winterfell will stay in the Stark family essentially, because
- 1:13:51when I'm dead, Ramsey will be Lord, will be Warden of the North,
- 1:14:00and his wife will be a Stark, and so therefore everything's cool.
- 1:14:03Well, they can't find any of the Starks because they've either killed them or
- 1:14:10they're on the run. So at this point, Aria and Sansa are are
- 1:14:15on the run. A little Finger has Sansa and Aria at this point is
- 1:14:21I don't know where she is. Maybe she's with the Hound, I'm not
- 1:14:26sure. But anyway, they find this girl, Jane Poole, and they
- 1:14:31just announced that she's Aria Stark instead and say, well, you know this
- 1:14:36is Aria everyone, and she's now going to marry Mary Ramsey and this will
- 1:14:43legitimize the Russ Stark union, and I can be Warden of the North.
- 1:14:48Blah blah blah. Also King Tom and also is Tom and at the time,
- 1:14:54so King Tom and Barathia. This is after the the death of Jeoffrey
- 1:15:01Brathian. King Tom, and Brathian makes Ramsey Bolton a Bolton instead of Ramsey
- 1:15:10snow. So in order for a bastard to become a lord or an heir
- 1:15:15to the lordship, I think a king is the only person who can really
- 1:15:23announce that. So he makes that so because he wants to reward Bruce Bolton
- 1:15:30for his treachery in the Red Wedding. So this point in the third book,
- 1:15:38Ramsey has finally arrived. He's finally an official heir to the Bolton House
- 1:15:44and his father is Warden of the North, which is kind of like a
- 1:15:47mini king, you know, as they say, the North is just as
- 1:15:53big as all the six kingdoms in the South combined, so it's more,
- 1:16:00but you know, it's it's a big deal. And so now Ramsey is
- 1:16:03basically prints of an entire country. He went from being a poor bastard boy
- 1:16:11with a stinky friend to being the heir to the Lord of Winterfell, which
- 1:16:17is, you know, a big deal for him. Okay. The fourth
- 1:16:23book, A Feast for Crows two thousand and five. This takes place at
- 1:16:29the same time as a third book, if I remember right, So there's
- 1:16:31not really anything to tell. Then it just kind of obliquely refers to a
- 1:16:35lot of things that happen to the third book. Okay, fifth book,
- 1:16:40and just it's only I'll get through this and then I'll analyze this personality.
- 1:16:44I just think his stories is so interesting. I just really want to tell
- 1:16:46the whole thing. The fifth book, A Dance with Dragons, published in
- 1:16:53to twenty eleven, so it's six years in between each book. Ramsey tortures
- 1:17:02Theon In this book. He makes him take on the identity of Reek,
- 1:17:09so this is the third Reek. First we had the Heac Reek, then
- 1:17:12we had the Ramsey Reek, and now we have the Theon Reek. He
- 1:17:16never allows Theon to bathe, and he covers Theon in shit. Ramsey also
- 1:17:24removes the skin on several of Theon's toes and fingers, leaving him in agony
- 1:17:30for days, before cutting off the fingers and toes. Ramsey removes several of
- 1:17:36Theon's teeth because he hated Theon's smile. George Martin also implies in the books
- 1:17:45that Ramsey cut off Theon's penis, but it's not exactly referred to. In
- 1:17:49the TV show, they definitely say that he cut off his penis. There's
- 1:17:57it should be indicated here that they're there's no known reason why Ramsey keeps Theon
- 1:18:01alive, but only for his own sadistic pleasure. I mean, there are
- 1:18:08other possible reasons, like maybe maybe Theon or maybe Ramsey missed his old friend
- 1:18:14Rieke, you know, because Riek he basically set up Reek to be killed,
- 1:18:18so maybe he wants to have his old friend back and sort of created
- 1:18:23essentially his old friend. Maybe he feels guilty for killing the first week.
- 1:18:28Probably not, but maybe there's also theories. It's like, well, maybe
- 1:18:32he kept Theon alive so he could bargain with the Iron Barn with bail on
- 1:18:35grey Joy, and but he doesn't seem to really do it. He doesn't
- 1:18:42see in the books, he doesn't seem to use Theon as a bargaining chip,
- 1:18:46so it just seems like Theon is just kept alive for for Ramsey shits
- 1:18:54and giggles all right. So in book five, Ramsey gathers an army to
- 1:18:59march south to attack the iron Ironborn occupied Mote Kaylin from the rear. So
- 1:19:06Ramsey makes Greek Theon Greek slash Theon go to the iron Born. This is
- 1:19:13in the TV show too. He makes Theon go to the iron Born in
- 1:19:17mote Kalen, so the Ironborn are Theon's people. He makes Theon go to
- 1:19:24go to Mote Kalen to convince the Ironborn to surrender and in exchange for their
- 1:19:28lives. So Theon goes into the besieged Mote Kalin and says, look,
- 1:19:34if you hand over Mote Klen to Ramsey Bolton, I personally promise as one
- 1:19:43of your kin that you will be able to live. And you're you're gonna
- 1:19:47die if you stay, because you don't have any more food. And eventually,
- 1:19:53you know, Ramsey's gonna win. And so let's just make it easy
- 1:19:57on everybody. We'll let you go, We'll let you go free. And
- 1:20:02this convinces the Ironborn. They're like, well, Theon's one of us.
- 1:20:05And he makes a good deal and it's right, we're all doomed and so
- 1:20:11okay. So now at this point it's unclear if Ramsey was actually going to
- 1:20:15be able to take mot Klen because the Ironborn are fierce warriors. But after
- 1:20:19theon slash Reek convinces the Ironboard to give up, Ramsey actually absolutely wins mot
- 1:20:26Kylen, and of course, Ramsey being Ramsey, Ramsey just does Ramsey all
- 1:20:31all day long, and he decides to renag on his promise and he has
- 1:20:36them all flayed alive. At some point you think you just get bored of
- 1:20:45flaying people, but he doesn't. He so he flays all the Ironborn alive,
- 1:20:49even though he had promised to let them go free. Now it should
- 1:20:55be Indica. It should be mentioned here that Rus doesn't really like Ramsey's behavior.
- 1:21:00He's getting tired of Ramsey doing his Ramsey thing, and he tells Ramsey
- 1:21:05that he needs to be more discreet because he's becoming famous for his sadism,
- 1:21:11which isn't good for house Boltzen. If you're going to lead, you have
- 1:21:15to be softer than that. You can't do those things, or else people
- 1:21:20aren't going to follow you. So again, it's not as if Ruce is
- 1:21:25saying don't do these things because they're wrong. He's only saying don't do these
- 1:21:29things as they don't really serve us in the end. Okay, So,
- 1:21:33now Ramsey gets married to the person who is impersonating arias Stark, Jane Poole,
- 1:21:43And at this point only Ramsey, Rus and Theon Slashriek know that the
- 1:21:48girl is not Aria Stark. So Ramsey and his father and Theon are the
- 1:21:54only ones who know that it's not actually Aria Sark. Everyone else thinks that
- 1:21:59it is Aria Stark because remember that Theon and Ramsey have killed most of the
- 1:22:06people who would even know what Aria Stark looked like. And Ramsey repeatedly abuses
- 1:22:14and rapes this Jane Poole, who was acting like Aria Stark, repeatedly abuses
- 1:22:20and rapes her while Theon watches. This is in the book. Now it
- 1:22:25should be noted that in all likelihood, Jane Poole was quite young, because
- 1:22:30if she was going to look like Aria Stark, she would have to be
- 1:22:32of similar age. And I think Aria at this point is like nine or
- 1:22:36ten, and so Jane Poole would have been around that age, is my
- 1:22:41guess. And so just picture that in your mind another terrible thing. And
- 1:22:48then Jane and Theon are rescued and freed by Matce Raider. So this is
- 1:22:55where the books in the TV show starts to go quite quite different. So
- 1:23:00you remember who Mance Raider is, right, Well, Mance Raider goes to
- 1:23:05Winterfell and and rescues and freeze Jane Poole and Theon. I remember Jane is
- 1:23:14Everyone thinks that she's Aria and Theon is Reek. And Mance Rader actually was
- 1:23:23sent by John Snow at the wall at Castle Black because John Snow had heard
- 1:23:29that Aria Stark was was, you know, being married forcibly to Ramsey.
- 1:23:35And so when John Snow hears about that, he's like, Mance, you
- 1:23:39gotta do this solid for me. You got to go back to my old
- 1:23:43home, Winterfell, and you got to free my sister because we all thought
- 1:23:47that she was dead because at this point, no one knows, you know,
- 1:23:53prior to Aria Stark suddenly showing up as Jane Poole, it was unknown
- 1:23:57if Aria Stark was even alive because they want or if she got killed when
- 1:24:02the Fall of the Starks happened, you know early on. Okay, So
- 1:24:09John Snow sends Mance Trader. Matce Trader shows up and freeze Aria but doesn't
- 1:24:15realize it's not Aria, it's Jane Poole and freeze Theon just as a as
- 1:24:18a because I think they were, you know, paired up at the time
- 1:24:24as as fellow, you know, slave whipping boys of Ramsey, Jane and
- 1:24:30and Theon could relate to each other. John Snow later receives a letter from
- 1:24:35Ramsey claiming that he had captured Manz and killed Stanisprathian, who was writing to
- 1:24:45besiege Winterfel, had left Castle Black to take Winterfell. So after so John
- 1:24:53Snow's like, okay, Mance, you gotta go save my sister. And
- 1:24:56then he receives a letter saying that Ramsey had captured mans and killed Stannis.
- 1:25:02So this is the end of the book and the end of season five last
- 1:25:08year. You remember that After John Snow reads Ramsey's letter, John decides to
- 1:25:14head to Winterfell with the Knight's Watch to kill Ramsey. But John Snow is
- 1:25:19stabbed by the Knight's Watch before he can leave Castle Black, and in the
- 1:25:29book, not the TV show, George Martin does not reveal how much of
- 1:25:33this letter is true from Ramsey. So we don't know if any of this
- 1:25:39has happened. So again, in the books, John snow just receives this
- 1:25:44letter that Mance has been captured and that Stanus is dead, but we don't
- 1:25:46actually know if that's happened. We don't actually even know if the letter was
- 1:25:49written by Ramsey because it didn't have a flayed skin on it. Whenever Ramsey
- 1:25:58would send a letter, he would put some flayed skin on it as a
- 1:26:02calling card that this is indeed from him, and this letter didn't have that.
- 1:26:05So now in the TV show they show all this happening essentially, so
- 1:26:12maybe it really did happen, But in the books it's a lot less clear
- 1:26:16and it's a total cliffhanger. And even in the books it's basically a cliffhanger.
- 1:26:21All right, So that's a history. Now let's get a description of
- 1:26:25him, because the description of him in the books is actually quite different than
- 1:26:30the depiction on the TV show. There's a lot of differences in the way
- 1:26:33that George Martin describes people in the way that they're depicted in the show.
- 1:26:39I feel like the show is trying to appeal to modern sensibilities instead of actually
- 1:26:45trying to provide what would have been typical of that of the historical time that
- 1:26:49is trying to portray. There's a lot of things that happened in the medieval
- 1:26:54times that would look quite silly to our eyes in twenty sixteen, and so
- 1:27:00so I think, probably smartly so the producers decided to not necessarily go with
- 1:27:06all of George R. Martin's descriptions. But anyway, so Ramsey Bolton in
- 1:27:13the books is described as being very ugly. Now, the character who plays
- 1:27:18Ramsey is not ugly. In fact, a lot of people are ugly in
- 1:27:21the Game of Thrones books and in the TV show they're very rarely ugly as
- 1:27:28ugly as I think they are in the books, like Brian of Ptarth.
- 1:27:33In the books, you get a sense that she is just she is heinously
- 1:27:38ugly. But in the TV show's actually she's actually played by a very attractive
- 1:27:43woman. Now, she's tall, and they you know, make her look
- 1:27:46very you know, I don't know, not very ladylike, but she's not
- 1:27:51ugly the way that ugly people can be. You know, the picture I
- 1:28:00had in my mind of Brionn what in from reading the books was was just
- 1:28:05terrible, you know, and same with with with Ramsey. Ramsey is described
- 1:28:10as as being extremely ugly and has a has pink and blotchy skin, so
- 1:28:15just imagine that. And he has long, dark, dry hair. It's
- 1:28:21long dark, you know, like uh, split ends hair. He's described
- 1:28:30as being big boned with us and slope shouldered, and he's He's described as
- 1:28:36having a fleshiness to him, indicating that he will be fat when he's older.
- 1:28:43Like that description, a fleshiness about him, predicting he'll be fat when
- 1:28:48he's older. His nose is broad and his mouth is small. His lips
- 1:28:55are wide and meaty and wormy looking. You just have to read these books
- 1:29:00because the way he describes he say, his lips are wide and meaty and
- 1:29:05they look like worms. And he has a wet lipped smile, a wet
- 1:29:11lipped smiles so gross. His eyes are small, close set, and oddly
- 1:29:17pale, like two chips of dirty ice, Like two chips of dirty ice,
- 1:29:24small and close set. Ramsey sometimes wears a garnet cut in the shape
- 1:29:30of a drop of blood in his right ear, so that's kind of creepy.
- 1:29:35In battle, Ramsey wears dark armor with a red helm and a pale,
- 1:29:42pink cloak. So this is his way of making his armor look like
- 1:29:49he has the face and shoulders of a skinless and bloody man whose mouth is
- 1:29:54open in a silent scream. So again he has you know, regular color
- 1:30:00armor, and then the top of his shoulders it's pink as if he's you
- 1:30:04know, being flayed, and then his head is red because it's it's perhaps
- 1:30:10more flayed, and then the front of his helm look looks like he's screaming.
- 1:30:15So just imagine if they had done that in the TV show. I
- 1:30:18think a lot of people would have been like, uh what, But that's
- 1:30:21what they describe. And some things really are just better left in books because
- 1:30:26when you read that, you just think, oh my god, that sounds
- 1:30:29terrible, But if you actually depicted it on the screen, it would look
- 1:30:31sort of silly. Ramsey's weapons included the falcion, a dagger, and a
- 1:30:39flaying knife, of course, and all with hilts of yellow bone. So
- 1:30:45again he's supposed to be ugly, pink and blotchy skin, long, dark
- 1:30:49dry hair, big boned. He his broad nose, small mouth, his
- 1:30:56lips are wide and meaty, and he has a wet lips smile and his
- 1:30:59eye are a small, close set and oddly pale. So he's not a
- 1:31:03pleasant looking guy. Now the actor is a good looking young man, so
- 1:31:08you know, piece all that together, all right. Now, let's get
- 1:31:12into his character. What is his personality like? What's he like? Well,
- 1:31:16he's vicious, he's unpredictable, he's fearless. He's very cunning. He's
- 1:31:25an effective manipulator. He's very cruel. He's very cruel, there's no remorse.
- 1:31:31He's described as savage and wild. He takes delight in torturing other people.
- 1:31:40He is a serial rapist and a serial murderer. He is a rumored
- 1:31:46cannibal, but unconfirmed. He is particularly good at thinking on his feet.
- 1:31:55He's very cunning and smart in that way, but he is less smart when
- 1:31:59it comes to politics. So he's smart on his feet in terms of figuring
- 1:32:03out how to get by, but the big picture stuff, he's kind of
- 1:32:06stupid, as I was talking about earlier, when he decided to attack Hornwood
- 1:32:14and marry the woman and you know, torture her. It was shortly after
- 1:32:18that that Sir Roderick arrives to kill him, and he would have been killed
- 1:32:25if he didn't pull off such a great disguise, and so and then he
- 1:32:30managed to convince Theon to let him be his servants. You know. So
- 1:32:35he's he's good at sort of getting by, but there are so many times
- 1:32:40when he easily could have been punished and killed for what he was doing,
- 1:32:44but somehow he just was really lucky. He also really enjoys playing mind games
- 1:32:49with people, and he also doesn't seemingly get angry. He doesn't seemingly have
- 1:32:56rage. Instead, he gets very playful with his revenge. One of Ramsey's
- 1:33:02favorite tricks is to kill his enemies after they have surrendered to him. He
- 1:33:08loves to do that. He is also quite fond of the old Bolton custom
- 1:33:14of flaying his enemies alive. So this is an old, ancient house Bolton
- 1:33:19custom of flaying their enemies alive, and most Boltons, if any, practice
- 1:33:27that anymore because it's probably barbaric, but Ramsey loves it. He's like wait,
- 1:33:33our ancestors used to play people alive. That is, I am all
- 1:33:36over that. He does many cruel things that don't really help him. As
- 1:33:41I was saying earlier, he has no reason to rape the Jane Poole character
- 1:33:48or the Sansa character on the TV show. He has no reason to raper.
- 1:33:51I mean, why do that. That's there's no reason for that.
- 1:33:55If you're really gonna try to rule the Nor and you're eventually going to be
- 1:34:02Warden of the North, wouldn't it serve you to have Aria or Sonsa on
- 1:34:10your side at least? It just doesn't make any sense. Plus, the
- 1:34:16Jane Poole or Sansa character could have sacrificed themselves to kill him and said,
- 1:34:23you know, I'm gonna kill him and then I'm gonna kill myself. So
- 1:34:27it just seems reckless to himself even to do these things. He had no
- 1:34:32reason to torture Lady Hornwood. He could have he could have he could have
- 1:34:36just killed her one or he could have just stayed married to her and been
- 1:34:44the lord of both the heir to the Lord of both Hornwood and and dread
- 1:34:49for it. So it's like, why why do all this horrible, sadistic
- 1:34:53shit when it doesn't actually even help you. So, so that's just another
- 1:34:58part of his character. The way he fights in battle is described. It's
- 1:35:03not really depicted in the TV show, but he's described as a fierce fighter
- 1:35:09in battle, but he's also described as being undisciplined. He lacks form or
- 1:35:15finesse in battle. He is described as wielding his sword like a meat cleaver.
- 1:35:20I think his dad says he swings that sword like a meat cleaver,
- 1:35:25which is an interesting visual. Ramsey was never formally taught to fight, because
- 1:35:30remember he was raised by a poor woman and not in house bolt and so
- 1:35:36he and he appears to have been taught by the original Reek or hek heat
- 1:35:42Heak character. So this this smelly servant was the one that was training him,
- 1:35:47and so his his fighting style is very unconventional and fierce and you know,
- 1:35:57savage. However, on the TV show, Ramsey is depicted as being
- 1:36:02a deadly hunter and archer and he easily kills six of his own men within
- 1:36:09seconds, and so he's quite different in the books and the TV show.
- 1:36:14This is something that kind of bugs me a lot about TV and movies is
- 1:36:16they often make the heroes and the villains into being extremely proficient with weapons and
- 1:36:27with the whole kung fu influence, which I enjoy, I think has gone
- 1:36:30a little too far. I mean, they make everyone into these acrobatic,
- 1:36:34ridiculous fighters that it just would never happen, you know, And I would
- 1:36:41like to think that Game of Thrones is trying to be at least somewhat accurate
- 1:36:45to the time, aside from all the magic and the White Walkers and all
- 1:36:48that stuff. But anyway, in the books, Ramsey is known for his
- 1:36:54ostentatious taste in clothes, which is definitely not happening in the TV show.
- 1:37:00In the books, he dresses in velvet, he dresses in silk and satin,
- 1:37:05and he usually wears the Bolton colors of pink and red. So just
- 1:37:13imagine that he normally in the books is dressed in pink and red velvet,
- 1:37:16silk and satin clothing, and the TV show he's definitely not doing that.
- 1:37:23Okay, So before I get into a diagnosis, let's talk about the development
- 1:37:28of his personality. How did his personality develop? Well, let's look at
- 1:37:33this. Let's look at what we know his you know, his family house,
- 1:37:38Bolton is the Flade, that's you know, their sigil is the flayed
- 1:37:42Man, and they have this history of flaming their enemies alive. Well,
- 1:37:47it seems, you know, presumably prior to him knowing that he was the
- 1:37:53son of Ruth Bolton. Presumably he wasn't flaying people back then, so he
- 1:37:58started this practice atter he knew that he was a Bolton. Well, it's
- 1:38:02possible that he's overcompensating to become accepted by his father. You know, imagine
- 1:38:09this, He's rejected as a bastard boy all his life and then he finally
- 1:38:14figures out, Wait, I'm the bastard of the lord of this land.
- 1:38:17And then he goes to Ruce Bolton and Ruth bolten't isn't super excited to have
- 1:38:24this bastard, particularly because at this point he has a son to Merrick I
- 1:38:29think his name is, And so at this point Ramsey is like, I'm
- 1:38:34a bastard's son. How can I get my dad to like me? Well,
- 1:38:38what if I really really took on the house Bolton practices like flaying people
- 1:38:45alive? What if I became really good at that. Well it's possible that
- 1:38:49this need to be accepted by his father motivated this and might have created his
- 1:38:57brain development circumstance chances that led to him being such a sadistic person later on,
- 1:39:04because we're not quite sure that he was a sadistic person growing up,
- 1:39:11so he definitely became one but you know, so maybe it was Maybe it
- 1:39:15was trying to get his dad's attention, trying to get his dad's approval.
- 1:39:19It's also possible that he was trying to reject his poor, disgraceful childhood by
- 1:39:26overly identifying with House Bolton. By really identifying with House Bolton, he could
- 1:39:31reject his shameful childhood. And one of the ways to do that is to
- 1:39:38become the ultimate Bolton by flaying people alive. So it's just, you know,
- 1:39:45I think it's a minor hypothesis for me, but it's one. Another
- 1:39:51I think a pretty solid hypothesis is genetics. Now, again, all these
- 1:39:57people are fictional characters, so they don't exist. But you know, let's
- 1:40:00say that they do exist. Well, genetics could be a factor. Ruth
- 1:40:05Bolton, Ramsey's biological father might be a psychopath, might be someone biologically who
- 1:40:16was prone to psychopathy. You know, you don't have to look too far
- 1:40:21in Ruth Bolton's history to see evidence of psychopathy. He killed the miller,
- 1:40:29he hung. You know, he sees this woman, he wants to have
- 1:40:30sex with her, and instead of just being like, oh, well,
- 1:40:33you know, can't do that, or even just cat calling, her or
- 1:40:40something, you know, just stick to the normal crappy male behavior. But
- 1:40:45instead he kills her husband, hangs him from a tree, and then proceeds
- 1:40:49to have sex with the woman underneath the hanging husband's body. I mean,
- 1:40:57you know, you're a sicko. You're so so. Ruth Bolton might be
- 1:41:00biologically predisposed to psychopathy, and so therefore he passed on that predisposition to Ramsey,
- 1:41:10which is, you know, I think definitely a possibility. Also,
- 1:41:16Ramsey's mother was very likely suffering from a number of psychological issues during her pregnancy,
- 1:41:24because remember she's just working one day and then the lord of the land
- 1:41:29comes by, kills her husband and then rapes her, and then you know,
- 1:41:34a month later, she's like, holy crap, I'm pregnant, my
- 1:41:39husband's dead, my mill has been taken over by my dead husband's brother.
- 1:41:45I'm now homeless, I have no money, and I'm pregnant and I'm grieving
- 1:41:51the loss of my loved husband. So when we go through that kind of
- 1:42:00ecological experience, it affects our biology and therefore can affect one's pregnancy. And
- 1:42:05it's possible that Ramsey Bolton, while in utero, was experiencing issues as a
- 1:42:16result of the mother's psychological suffering that created the conditions for him to become the
- 1:42:24person that he became. So I think that's a pretty solid hypothesis right there.
- 1:42:32Another one of the minor hypotheses is that, given that he was a
- 1:42:38bastard as a child and known to be a bastard, he might have been
- 1:42:41bullied by other people and therefore wants to get back at everybody by bullying them.
- 1:42:47Okay, so we have those issues that Another hypothesis is, and this
- 1:42:53is again pretty solid, I think, is his upbringing and his attachment upbringing.
- 1:42:59His mother might not have ever really accepted him as her real son.
- 1:43:04She was raped by this terrible man who killed her husband, and now she
- 1:43:12is giving birth to this man's son. Well, it's very easy to have
- 1:43:17somewhat of a complex about that boy. He looks like the evil person,
- 1:43:25you know. It might threaten the ability to develop the necessary attachment that one
- 1:43:31needs to develop. Well, so it's possible that that happened. We don't
- 1:43:34have any indication of that, but that's possible. She was trying to get
- 1:43:41rid of him frequently, and finally tried to get rid of him when he
- 1:43:45was about twelve, by telling him that he was Ruth's son, even though
- 1:43:51that might have led to her own death. You know, there are several
- 1:43:55moments where she could have been killed and she probably knew it, particularly when
- 1:43:59she told Ramsey that Ramsey was Ruth's son. You know, if Ramsey went
- 1:44:05to the Dreadfort and said, my mom told me that I'm your son,
- 1:44:12Ruce, given his track record, could have easily just killed the boy at
- 1:44:15that point and then wrote out or sent, you know, some men out
- 1:44:19to kill her to shut her up. Because again, if Eduard's Stark or
- 1:44:25whoever was in control at the time were to find out about this rape,
- 1:44:29they could charge Rus with a crime. And so even though Ramsey's mother knew
- 1:44:36about this threat, she still told Ramsey about the truth because she wanted to
- 1:44:44get rid of them. So there's there's a potential here that she wanted to
- 1:44:47get rid of them for many years. And this is going to affect you.
- 1:44:51Even if you've got some difficulties, even though you act, you know,
- 1:44:56like a difficult kid, if if you know that your mom is trying
- 1:44:59to get rid of you, that doesn't bode well for your personality. Also,
- 1:45:04he's had no father attachment. Presumably there's no talk of a stepfather or
- 1:45:09anything. And so when you don't have a father attachment, research shows that
- 1:45:15you are at higher risk for problems in your personality and problems in your adult
- 1:45:19behavior. Also, when the mother was raising Ramsey, it's likely that she
- 1:45:28was suffering from PTSD or other trauma related issues, grief and loss. She
- 1:45:34was probably depressed, so she was probably not altogether present as a parent.
- 1:45:41She's also a single mom and she's struggling with poverty at this point. And
- 1:45:45when you have only one parent and that only parent is suffering psychologically, you
- 1:45:53will often have attachment injuries as a product of that because you don't feel secure
- 1:46:00and your attachment to the one person that you're supposed to feel secure with.
- 1:46:05So then later when Ruse finally does take him in, Ramsey knows that he's
- 1:46:11you know, he's not good enough, he's a bastard boy. And that
- 1:46:14would also affect the way your personality formed as a teenager. Knowing that your
- 1:46:19second you're a second rate human being, that must have hurt him, and
- 1:46:25so that's that's going to affect his personality as well. Okay, so another
- 1:46:29factor that might have played a role in the development of Ramsey. Bolton's personality
- 1:46:34might have been the effect of Reek slash Heat the first or Heak the first
- 1:46:42the first week. He his personality might have played an important role in the
- 1:46:47development of Ramsey's later development in the teen years because Reeke smelled so bad since
- 1:46:57he was born. Reek was rejected as a child in all likelihood throughout his
- 1:47:02life, and Riek probably gained acceptance from other people by being a loyal servant.
- 1:47:12He might have learned that the only way he is going to get any
- 1:47:15kind of positive social accolades or attention is to be a loyal servant and to
- 1:47:25not assert his own needs or not to be a pest to anybody. So
- 1:47:31he probably internalized important internal representation the first week. He probably internalized a common
- 1:47:44interaction between him and others, maybe particularly his parents, in which in order
- 1:47:49to gain love he had to be a sub human he had to be something
- 1:47:57that was contemptible and also someone that was very loyal and subservient. And as
- 1:48:08he internalized this experience as we all do, he might have recreated it in
- 1:48:15his important relationships in his life later on in life. We don't know how
- 1:48:19old the original Greek was, but at the very least we know that he
- 1:48:25was at least a teenager at the time, if not quite a bit older.
- 1:48:29And as he comes into contact and has a significant relationship with Ramsey,
- 1:48:35he might have socialized Ramsey to agree with a projective identification when we have when
- 1:48:44we have internal strife psychologically between different internalized elements, we will externalize them,
- 1:48:54sometimes through projective identification through enactments, as a way of trying to alleviate the
- 1:49:00inner pain. Now, of course it doesn't usually work if it is done
- 1:49:03in the typical dysfunctional way to actually alleviate any sort of conflict in pain or
- 1:49:10psychic pain, but it does have a fantasy of relief in it. So
- 1:49:15he might have socialized Ramsey to abuse him and reject him, to treat him
- 1:49:21as a sub human. He might have socialized Ramsey or Reek might have socialized
- 1:49:28Ramsey to treat in this way as a way of trying to secure his relationship
- 1:49:33with Ramsey because he really wanted Ramsey to accept him, but he was also
- 1:49:39recreating a painful part of his past with Ramsey and this was probably difficult for
- 1:49:46Reek. And in this interaction it creates an internalization for Ramsey in which he
- 1:49:56internalizes a relationship in which he is dominant, in which Ramsey is abusing someone,
- 1:50:03and this is his version of love and attention as well. Ramsey,
- 1:50:11as any other human needs love, needs connection, needs attachment, and here
- 1:50:16he is with perhaps one of his very first important attachments outside of his mother,
- 1:50:23and it involves a tremendous amount of abuse, rejection, and dominance.
- 1:50:30So he internalized this, and then Ramsey then is left to struggle with this
- 1:50:40internalization and then proceeds to, through projective identification, defend against this inner turmoil
- 1:50:46by recreating it in many other relationships later in life, in which Ramsey continues
- 1:50:51to abuse people and reject them and make them feel inferior. This is m
- 1:51:00way of eking out some level of attachment and closeness with other human beings,
- 1:51:09and of course it's dysfunctional, highly dysfunctional, but it is it is a
- 1:51:14hypothesis to what led to the development of Ramsey's personality. So those are all
- 1:51:20the main factors psychologically that I can think of off the top of my head
- 1:51:26regarding the development of Ramsey's personality. We have his perhaps over compensation to become
- 1:51:33accepted by his father or by his house Bolton with the Flayed Man. We
- 1:51:40have his potential genetic factors, we have potential bullying as a child, being
- 1:51:47a bastard child, and in particularly we have his his upbringing with his mother
- 1:51:54and his early attachments and also his mother being affected from the true and loss
- 1:52:00regarding the circumstances around Ramsey's conception. And we also have as early relationship and
- 1:52:08attachment with Reek and how Ramsey might have internalized that. So now in the
- 1:52:17next part of the analysis I want to move to is why are why do
- 1:52:23we watch? Why do we as the as the audience read these books and
- 1:52:30watch the TV show? And why do we like watching Ramsey on the screen?
- 1:52:35Why is it so engaging? Because there are other villains that are horrible
- 1:52:42that are in TVs and books and TVs that are in TV shows and books
- 1:52:47and movies and stuff that don't actually engage us as much as Ramsey does.
- 1:52:54There are many villains that go unnoticed. So what is it about Ramsey?
- 1:52:59What is it about Game of Thrones in general, a song of ice and
- 1:53:02fire in general that makes it compelling? Well, of course, it's no
- 1:53:08one will ever be able to answer that question. But so I'll just end
- 1:53:13it there, no just joking. I have a few ideas speculations to along,
- 1:53:20you know, to answer his question, and specifically around Ramsey and maybe
- 1:53:25even Jeoffrey as well. We keep watching because we want satisfaction and we want
- 1:53:31revenge against Ramsey and Joffrey. We eventually had satisfaction when Jeoffrey died. But
- 1:53:41I don't know about you, but when Jeoffrey died spoiler alert, it wasn't
- 1:53:45as satisfying as I was hoping it would be. It happened rather quickly.
- 1:53:50He died in a very painful, you know, agonizing manner. It didn't
- 1:53:57look pretty, but it only lasted for thirty seconds or something. You would
- 1:54:01want Jeoffrey to suffer for years, perhaps what Circe Lanister is heading into.
- 1:54:11But even that, it just doesn't seem you just want someone to really,
- 1:54:15really suffer for I don't know. Maybe I'm just a terrible person, but
- 1:54:19that's that's just me and I think we keep watching Game of Thrones partially because
- 1:54:25we can't wait for Ramsey to get his just dessert, as they say.
- 1:54:30But there's really no evidence that George R. Martin is going to give us
- 1:54:35that. There are very few examples of happy endings in the storyline, and
- 1:54:43there are more examples of horrible endings to you know, plot lines and people
- 1:54:50in this In this story, I mean, let's look at the evidence.
- 1:54:54Edward the Undeniable hero and star of the first book. In the first season
- 1:55:01of the TV show, he is honorable, he's good, he is you
- 1:55:09know, you just you just want to see him kick ass. And he's
- 1:55:13beheaded by Jeoffrey rather unceremoniously. Cal Drogo at first, we're a little scared
- 1:55:19of him, but we eventually learned to really like him, and we see
- 1:55:25his relationship with Danari's develop and he lets he lets her ride him, and
- 1:55:32uh, you know, cal Drogo turns out to be a big teddy bear,
- 1:55:39a very capable warrior teddy bear, but a teddybear. Nonetheless, if
- 1:55:44I'm remembering right, maybe I'm remembering cal Drogo falsely, but that's my memory
- 1:55:48anyway. And you know, he's a super macho dude and he's powerful,
- 1:55:53but he's ultimately he's ultimately he ultimately dies from a minor wound that gets infected.
- 1:56:01He just gets a nick and over time, just you know, is
- 1:56:05what happened in the old days, an infection set in and then he died.
- 1:56:11So he didn't even die in a wonderful way. Same with Edward.
- 1:56:15He just gets beheaded by an executioner, even when he didn't really expect to.
- 1:56:23Cal Drogo dies from an infection. King Rob Stark the next hero after
- 1:56:30Eduard. You figure, well, you know, there's surely they won't kill
- 1:56:33Rob. I mean they killed Edward. You know Rob's gonna at least live
- 1:56:38for a while. No, he's executed rather unceremoniously by Ruce Bolton in the
- 1:56:43phrase during the Red Wedding. Right, and then you have Prince ober and
- 1:56:49Martel the Viper. He has his head smashed in by the mountain. That
- 1:56:56was horrible too. You have Egret on Snow's girlfriend, the Wildling, Wilding,
- 1:57:03Wildling. She dies. It was a wonderful death, I have to
- 1:57:09say, but she dies very very quickly. King Renley Brathian dies from when
- 1:57:18he gets killed by Melissandra's ghost baby. A lot of people were rooting for
- 1:57:27Renley Brathian after King Robert died. You're thinking, now, among all the
- 1:57:32five kings, you know, Renley seems like the one that we want to
- 1:57:36live. He is gay, in the show, and so you figure maybe
- 1:57:43maybe George R. Martin will take it easy on the gay kid, but
- 1:57:45nope, he gets killed too. Caitlin Stark, the ultimate mother figure on
- 1:57:51the show. She's killed unceremoniously by the Boltons in the phrase although if you're
- 1:57:59a reader of the books, I'll just leave it there, okay. King
- 1:58:03stanis Brathian, whom many people were rooting for toward the end. He you
- 1:58:09know, was I mean, we weren't necessarily rooting for him in the beginning,
- 1:58:11but toward the end, you're in season five, you're just like,
- 1:58:14well, surely this guy will last a little longer. But he's likely been
- 1:58:21killed by Ramsey's men in the books, and defeated by Ramsey's men in the
- 1:58:28TV show, and then seemingly killed by by Brienne and then of course John
- 1:58:33Snow the ultimate hero and star of the show from the very beginning. He's
- 1:58:38the guy that everyone identifies with, seemingly and he's killed unceremoniously by his own
- 1:58:45allies, by his own by his fellow soldiers. He is killed for seemingly
- 1:58:54crappy reasons, although you know, if you're reading the news, it would
- 1:59:00seem as though John Snow is not really dead, so you know, maybe
- 1:59:05we can count on John Snow surviving. And if you've played the Telltale game,
- 1:59:14which I highly recommend, the Game of Thrones video game made by tell
- 1:59:18Tale, they are choose your own adventure game. They're not action. It's
- 1:59:24more like watching an episode of Game of Thrones where you get to participate in
- 1:59:30some of it. It's really amazing. I highly recommend it. And if
- 1:59:34you've played that game, you realize that there are several that instead of following
- 1:59:41the Stark family, the video game follows the Forester family. And this is
- 1:59:45a George R. Martin endorsed product, so it fits completely in the universe.
- 1:59:51In fact, Dean Klige does voiceing the woman who does Sirceed. She
- 1:59:58does voiceing the Marjorie. She she hurt, you know, the actress that's
- 2:00:04Marjorie. She does voiceover for it and plays you know, their characters.
- 2:00:10There's several people, so it's very it's very much like just in fact,
- 2:00:14if you're a Game of Thrones fan, you really just should play this game
- 2:00:16because it fills out some of the story and you get to see other scenes.
- 2:00:24Essentially that's happening in the world of Game of Thrones, for instance,
- 2:00:28during the Red wedding, you're there and you have another kind of mission to
- 2:00:33take care of at that wedding, and you're not you don't see the actual
- 2:00:39red wedding or not red wedding, sorry, the wedding of which, wait
- 2:00:44am I getting by terminology? What was the wedding called in which Jeoffrey died?
- 2:00:48That? No, that's not red wedding? What am I talking about?
- 2:00:51The purple wedding? That was called the purple wedding. That's the wedding
- 2:00:57that he died in. Anyway, they like to call a lot of people
- 2:01:00die in weddings, and they assign colors to them. So what did they
- 2:01:03call the purple wedding? Is because its face turned purple because he was choking
- 2:01:06to death. Probably that's probably why it's called his face turn purple. So
- 2:01:12it's called the purple wedding. Anyway, you're a character and you're at the
- 2:01:14Purple wedding, and you have something you have to do socially because you're trying
- 2:01:19to fight for your Forester family, not the Stark family. And anyway,
- 2:01:26and so in the game, you play several of these Forester family kids,
- 2:01:31and just like the Stark family, there's like six or seven of them,
- 2:01:35and spoiler spoiler alert, but many of the characters die. Many of the
- 2:01:42main characters in this family die. It's worse than the Stark family, frankly,
- 2:01:47and so even the video game, where normally in video games you win,
- 2:01:54right or at least you have a chance to win, in this Game
- 2:01:58of Thrones Telltale game, you lose pretty much all the time. Like I
- 2:02:04think, I think it was it the second second season. They call him
- 2:02:08seasons, they don't call him like different versions. I think I've I just
- 2:02:11finished the second season not too long ago, and it's just getting worse and
- 2:02:15worse for the Foresters too. So there's really no evidence that George R.
- 2:02:21Martin is going to give us satisfaction with Ramsey or with Denari's or with John
- 2:02:29Snow, there's there's not a lot of evidence of that. Now, I
- 2:02:34keep thinking this must have somewhat of a happy ish ending at the end.
- 2:02:41I mean, this can't end on a horrible note. I mean, people
- 2:02:45are gonna rite in the streets if Ramsey doesn't get his just dessert right.
- 2:02:49But I've thought that before, and Martin has proceeded to just make it worse
- 2:02:58and worse for us. So personally, let me, you know, I
- 2:03:00should analyze Martin honestly because why is what makes it so easy for him to
- 2:03:10kill off our most favorite characters? And presumably Martin loves these characters too,
- 2:03:15write and he just loves putting people through crap. Maybe he's slightly masochistic himself
- 2:03:21or even sadistic himself anyway, So there's a chance also that I think which
- 2:03:30is definitely a factor, is that without just think about the movie or the
- 2:03:34TV show or the books without Ramsey Bolton, Without Ramsey Bolton, say Ramsey
- 2:03:40dies somehow, well, then who are you going to fight against? Who's
- 2:03:45the main person you're going to fight against? Certainly there are other people that
- 2:03:50are quote unquote evil, but the show really needs that that element of a
- 2:03:59villain like this, And I want to remind people that this sort of villainy
- 2:04:03is actually quite accurate to history and the time. When you see things like
- 2:04:11Star Wars, it's like, oh, you know, it's it's fun fantasy.
- 2:04:14But when you watch games or games, when you watch TV shows like
- 2:04:17Game of Thrones and read books like this, it's it's loosely based on things
- 2:04:24that actually happen in history. And that's what makes it so much more interesting
- 2:04:27to me. When you are, as I said before, a mild history
- 2:04:31amateur buff, you just learn how fascinating history is. And to see a
- 2:04:41show like this that somewhat mirrors what happened in our history is quite satisfying to
- 2:04:46me. Okay, so let's talk about the diagnosis. What is How would
- 2:04:55I diagnose Ramsey? Well, with Josh Yo Free, it was a little
- 2:05:00bit more difficult compared to Ramsey. Ramsey's very easy to diagnose, to tell
- 2:05:05you the truth. With Jeffrey was a little harder because Jeoffrey was much younger,
- 2:05:10Remember, and it's harder to diagnose children, and Jeoffrey was eleven or
- 2:05:17twelve because they're still developing their personalities. They don't necessarily have a clear sense
- 2:05:24of self. They're easily influenced. And so with Ramsey it's easier because he's
- 2:05:30an adult by the time we see him in the story. Also, Jeoffrey
- 2:05:35might have just been suffering from a tremendous amount of insecurity and he might have
- 2:05:42been just massively misguided. But with Ramsey, Ramsey is clearly pathological. He
- 2:05:51particularly because no one really wants him to be doing these things. You could
- 2:05:58have argued that Jeoffrey pressure to assert his dominance or something, But with Ramsey,
- 2:06:05there are so many times where he's clearly doing dysfunctional, anti social things
- 2:06:12just because he likes it, and there's a lot of reasons why he shouldn't
- 2:06:15be doing it, Like the whole story about as he hunts that girl down
- 2:06:21and Sir Roderick comes upon him. He was just hunting this girl down because
- 2:06:28he thought it would be fun, and he very likely knew that there was
- 2:06:31a chance he was going to be brought to justice by somebody. And so
- 2:06:36this is more stronger evidence that he was acting on his own volition. It
- 2:06:42wasn't just some insecurity or he wasn't being influenced it. This was emerging from
- 2:06:46within him. Okay, so let's look at the main diagnostic behaviors. First,
- 2:06:53he hunts girls with reek, He hunts them down and kills them and
- 2:06:59rapes them, lays them. He kills his half brother because his half brother
- 2:07:04is a competitor. Now there's some debates for that that is the true thing
- 2:07:10that happened, but you know, anyway, he Ramsey, he marries in
- 2:07:15prisons, tortures and kills Lady Hornwood to get her lands. He tortures and
- 2:07:21enslaves theon. He takes pleasure in raping and torturing other people. He takes
- 2:07:30his time with it. He is a methodical, you know, well thought
- 2:07:36out torture of other human beings. He revels in it. He purposely keeps
- 2:07:45people alive so he can make them suffer for days or years. He will
- 2:07:49keep someone alive. That is really quite particular because there are people who have
- 2:07:58the tendency to harm other people, but at some point they will have some
- 2:08:05tinge of humanity and compassion and will put the person out of their misery.
- 2:08:11Now, this is not a good thing but overall, but for most people,
- 2:08:16even most psychopaths, they have some shred of humanity and will not torture.
- 2:08:24At some point in the days of torturing someone, they will have second
- 2:08:30thoughts. Ramsey doesn't have evidence of a second thought at any point, so
- 2:08:35this is another thing to take notice of. He also, as I said,
- 2:08:41basically, he doesn't show any remorse. There's never an ounce of remorse.
- 2:08:48He seemingly doesn't even understand the possibility of remorse. When Russ talks to
- 2:08:56him and says, hey, why don't you lighten up here because this is
- 2:08:58a problem Ramsey seems to his response, he just indicates that he just doesn't
- 2:09:07have any remorse. There's just no remorse. Okay. So when we see
- 2:09:11behaviors like this, we immediately look at Cluster B personality disorders. He's definitely
- 2:09:18one of the cluster B, right, And there are four in Cluster B.
- 2:09:22There's histrionic borderline, narcisistic, any social, histrionic borderline. If you
- 2:09:28know those diagnoses, you know that he doesn't fit those very well. The
- 2:09:33two that he really seems to fit in the DSM are narcissistic in any social
- 2:09:39And let's look at narcissistic first. And my main hypothesis or my main thesis
- 2:09:43here is that he does some extent fits narcissistic personality disorder, but he doesn't
- 2:09:50fit the common profile. I mean, much better fits the antisocial profile.
- 2:09:54And when I talk to people that don't treat these sorts of orders and don't
- 2:10:00have experience, and I'll say, what do you think do you think narcissistic
- 2:10:03any social, They'll often say, oh, he's both, you know,
- 2:10:05because I think for many people, they when they hate someone, they just
- 2:10:11want to pathology. They just want to label them with every bad label.
- 2:10:15And they think, well, if I say he's not narcissistic, I'm basically
- 2:10:20saying that he's not a problem in life. And so that's just when you're
- 2:10:24diagnosing an important bias to consider. So by me saying he does not suffer
- 2:10:31from a narcissistic personality disorder, I'm not saying that his behavior is not problematic.
- 2:10:37And I'm also not saying that he doesn't have narcissistic elements, if not
- 2:10:41full blown, full blown, major portions of his personality are narcissistic. But
- 2:10:48if we are to accurately diagnose him, we have to remain as unbiased as
- 2:10:56we possibly can, and he doesn't fit the profile. So anyway, let's
- 2:10:58this go through some the criteria for narcissistic. Well, first off, a
- 2:11:03need for admiration is typical to narcissistic personality, and yeah, sort of he
- 2:11:09sort of needs admiration at times, but it doesn't really fit the flavor of
- 2:11:16the typical narcissistic personality disordered. Person Number two, a lack of empathy.
- 2:11:22Absolutely, there's really no ifans or butts about that one. He lacks empathy,
- 2:11:30as many narcissistic people do. Does he exaggerate his achievements. Not really,
- 2:11:37He's not really a boaster. He's not shy about his achievements. But
- 2:11:41when you know a narcissistic person, you know that they have a particular flavor
- 2:11:48of exaggerating their achievements, and Ramsey doesn't really fit that. Does he expect
- 2:11:54and or require recognition and admiration all of the time? Well, again,
- 2:12:00sort of. He kills people for not recognizing how great he is. Someone
- 2:12:03called him after he was made Ramsey Bolton by King Tom, and he ran
- 2:12:09into someone who didn't know that yet and had called him Ramsey Snow and so
- 2:12:15Ramsey Bolton killed him, killed him or her because of that. So you
- 2:12:18could say he needs and requires recognition and admiration, But you know, I
- 2:12:24think he would just use any excuse to kill someone, and it's not really
- 2:12:26necessarily because they don't give him admiration. Is he preoccupied with unlimited power?
- 2:12:35Not really. Does he like power, absolutely, but he again doesn't fit
- 2:12:41the flavor of a person who's preoccupied with unlimited power. What you will hear
- 2:12:48from people who suffer from narcissist personality disorder. Is this again, this preoccupation.
- 2:12:56It's something they think about and talk about a lot, and all their
- 2:13:00efforts, sometimes literally all of their efforts go into acquiring power and whatever that
- 2:13:07means to them and their culture around them, whether that means moving up the
- 2:13:13corporate ladder or getting more money or whatever markers are in their cultural pocket,
- 2:13:20they will be obsessed with and seemingly everything will spawn from that for them.
- 2:13:30And Ramsey doesn't have that. If he was truly dedicated to unlimited power,
- 2:13:35he would actually curb his sadism because his sadism, as Russ would tell him,
- 2:13:39is getting in the way of ultimate power in the North. So he
- 2:13:46doesn't fit this criteria. Does he believe he is special and can only be
- 2:13:50understood by other special people? No, that he doesn't fit this criteria at
- 2:13:58all. Really does he believe he's special? Yeah? Probably? Does he
- 2:14:01have a sense of entitlement? Yeah, you could say that. But again,
- 2:14:05if you know people with narcissism, you would know that people with NARCISSM
- 2:14:11have a particular flavor of believing they are special and can only be understand understood
- 2:14:18by their special people. They will tend to if they go to a party,
- 2:14:24they will tend to discount anyone in the party that doesn't have any outward
- 2:14:30display of being special themselves, and they will only seek the opinions or they'll
- 2:14:37only value the opinions of very special people in the room, and they'll compete
- 2:14:41with that person. They'll be envious of that. There's just this obsession and
- 2:14:45preoccupation with the specialness of themselves and the specialness of other people. And if
- 2:14:50you know a narcisistic person, you know what this is like. If you
- 2:14:54don't know, if none of these narcissistic traits are really jumping out at you,
- 2:15:00you as someone you know, then in all likelihood you're a narcissistic Just
- 2:15:03joking. It's late in the podcast, so excuse me, but no.
- 2:15:11If you don't, if you can't think of someone that really fits these criteria,
- 2:15:16then lucky you because you haven't come across someone like this. But it's
- 2:15:22really quite particular, and unless you know someone like this, don't assume that
- 2:15:28you could even imagine how extreme they can be in this area. A few
- 2:15:35more narcissistic personality traits exploitative. They will typically be exploitative. Yeah, he's
- 2:15:41somewhat. I mean, well, yes he's very exploitative, but in not
- 2:15:46in a narcissistic sense. Is he envious of others? Well not kind of
- 2:15:52right. He wanted the lands of the hornwood lands and he took that.
- 2:15:58So yeah, you could say there's some of that. Is he arrogant,
- 2:16:05you know, sort of, but not in the narcissistic way. Now again
- 2:16:09some of you are saying, I can't believe that you are calling this guy
- 2:16:13not arrogant and not exploitative of other people. He is very exploitative, He
- 2:16:18is very entitled, He is very arrogant. And what I have to say
- 2:16:24is, again, yes he doesn't care about other people's feelings, and I
- 2:16:31would not call him not arrogant. But if you know someone with a narcissisic
- 2:16:35personality disorder, you know that the degree at which these people are arrogant and
- 2:16:41the degree at which in which they have a sense of entitlement is so much
- 2:16:46greater than the personality presentation of Ramsey Bolton. You'll understand that Ramsey doesn't really
- 2:16:56fit narcissistic personality disorder. So just just be careful about that kind of stuff.
- 2:17:01And this is partially why in the clinical world that a lot of misdiagnosing
- 2:17:09takes place is that people have a hard time understanding the degree at which need
- 2:17:16to which things need to be met in order for them to meet criteria,
- 2:17:20and particularly around personality disorders, if you're a trainee or just someone who doesn't
- 2:17:28know much about personality disorders, you have to understand that the only people and
- 2:17:33I'm not just saying I'm not just saying this because I'm one of these people.
- 2:17:35I'm saying this because it's true, is that only people that are experienced
- 2:17:43at diagnosing personality disorders can diagnose personality disorders. I've said this before another podcast,
- 2:17:48But if you want to diagnose depression or panic attack, or you want
- 2:17:56to diagnose I'm not I'm not going to put ADHD in there, because actually
- 2:18:03that's probably not true. But adjustment disorders, these kinds of things. They
- 2:18:07these are particularly depression. I would say these are easy things to identify in
- 2:18:11yourself and other people. If you just ran down the criteria of major depressive
- 2:18:16disorder, it's pretty hard to mistake what the diagnoses is getting at. What
- 2:18:24the diagnosis is getting at. When it comes to ADHD, it gets a
- 2:18:28little bit more difficult because again, degree and flavor come into account when it
- 2:18:33comes to personality disorders, it is extremely difficult to lock down, mostly because
- 2:18:43when you are interacting with someone with a personality disorder, it feels a very
- 2:18:48particular way. When you interact, or when you have someone in your life
- 2:18:54that is borderline, they will feel very particular and they will make you feel
- 2:19:01a very particular feeling. When you're interacting with someone who's any social same thing
- 2:19:09when you're interacting with a psychopath, when you're interacting with someone with narcissistic personality
- 2:19:13histrionic, Each one of these personality disorders will make you feel a particular way,
- 2:19:20and they and those feelings that you have as a person who observes the
- 2:19:26self and has experience and knows how to interpret human communication transference kind of transference,
- 2:19:33as someone who understands that, you now have that ability to diagnose and
- 2:19:39understand the degree at which some criteria need to be met in order to justify
- 2:19:45the diagnosis. I said this before when I was talking about Donald Trump.
- 2:19:50Some people were saying he has narcissistic personality disorder. And I listen to podcasts
- 2:19:54and stuff and or other media discussions and they'll say Ronald Trump has narcisstic personality
- 2:20:01stort or. I had listened to this other podcast where this guy, I
- 2:20:05think it was, what's it called the Cracked podcast, Cracked podcast, and
- 2:20:11the host, the main host O'Brien, was talking about how our culture is
- 2:20:18now filled with people with narcissistic personality disorder. And he didn't just say that
- 2:20:22in passing. He was saying it over and over again, that our culture
- 2:20:28now suffers from narcissistic personality disorder. And I was just I was just rolling
- 2:20:33my eyes because it's it's such an ignorant thing to say, because narcissistic personality
- 2:20:41sort is very particular. Now, if you want to say narcissism is on
- 2:20:46the rise, and you want to define narcissism as a particular thing, then
- 2:20:50fine, and if you can measure that then great, But narcisistic personality sorder
- 2:20:56is very particular. And when when you know someone with this disorder, you
- 2:21:03will feel very different and you will suddenly see the degree at which narcissistic traits
- 2:21:11can actually have, the degree which they can go, how high they can
- 2:21:16actually go, the degree. You know, there are some people that that
- 2:21:22have you know, some narcissism. Frankly, I have narcissistic personality traits,
- 2:21:26but I'm not. I don't have narcisstic personality disorder, but I have some
- 2:21:31narcissistic traits, like, for instance, I have this podcast in which I
- 2:21:33talk about things and act like I know what I'm talking about all the time.
- 2:21:37That is that is a narcissistic behavior. Well, I would say that
- 2:21:41ninety nine point nine percent podcasters have narcissistic traits. Why else would we be
- 2:21:48so compelled, particularly when we get no money for it or very little money
- 2:21:52for it. Why would it be so compelled to yam or into a microphone
- 2:21:56and make everyone listen to us. Well, it's because we have a narcissistic
- 2:22:00need compared to other people. And there are pros and cons to that personality
- 2:22:07trait. The pro is that I have a podcast, I suppose, And
- 2:22:11the con is that sometimes when I'm at dinner parties, I talk too much
- 2:22:18and people think, boy, that guy talks too much because in the moment,
- 2:22:24I'm so wrapped up in my own head and so wrapped up in what
- 2:22:28I want to say, and so wrapped up in wanting other people to listen
- 2:22:33to my scintillating thoughts that I lose sight of the fact that no one else
- 2:22:39really wants to hear any of that. So that's that's narcissist, that's narcissism.
- 2:22:43That's being narcissistic compared to the average human being. But I am nowhere
- 2:22:50near the criteria for narcissistic personality disorder, so to have narcissist traits and so
- 2:22:58our cult. So when the Cracked podcast O'Brien's talking about narcissism rising and our
- 2:23:03culture. Fine, you know you can say that, but to you know,
- 2:23:07say, narciss personality disorders on the rises or or one hundred percent prevalent
- 2:23:13in our culture now is just eye ruly to me. So if you're a
- 2:23:20clinician and you want to understand personality disorders, then then just start start interacting
- 2:23:26with more clients, particularly difficult clients, because narcisstic personality disordered clients will be
- 2:23:31difficult in all likelihood. And if you're a family therapist, you might,
- 2:23:37for instance, So this is just a suggestion. A teenager, a mom
- 2:23:43brings in a teenager and the mom says, I want you to treat my
- 2:23:46son, and you start to assess the situation and you learn that the parents
- 2:23:52are divorced or they're together and they're in conflict. Well, a common thing
- 2:23:58for people to do, in my experience is to take the easy road,
- 2:24:01and Okay, I'll treat the teenage boy. We'll meet for an hour every
- 2:24:05one or two weeks, and I'll work on his self esteem and he'll complain
- 2:24:09about his family, and I'll think about, boy, he's dealing with some
- 2:24:11tough stuff in his family, and that'll be that. Well, I challenge
- 2:24:16you to invite both of the parents, and because a lot of the times
- 2:24:20what you will find not a majority, but some of the time you will
- 2:24:26find that one of the parents has a personality disorder and they are not seeking
- 2:24:31treatment for themselves because they don't think anything's wrong with them. And as you
- 2:24:35engage with this person, you will get a very particular feeling from this person
- 2:24:39and you will start to see, oh, I understand how this system works,
- 2:24:43and I understand how each person and their personality comes together in the system,
- 2:24:48and you'll have an ability to have an effect on that system. Will
- 2:24:52you be able to cure that person, that parent of the personality disorder now,
- 2:24:58but you can help this system change to be more functional given that someone
- 2:25:03has a personality disorder in that system. I am going way off topic,
- 2:25:09so I will rain it back in. Okay, So we looked at three
- 2:25:13of the cluster bees. We have histrionic, borderline, narcissistic. Now let's
- 2:25:16look at any social the fourth of the cluster bee. This is the most
- 2:25:20fitting diagnosis for Ramsey Bolton. Remember that it's similar to psychopathic personality disorder,
- 2:25:30which is not in the DSM. Most people outside of psychology and people in
- 2:25:35psychology will tend to use the term psychopathy or psychopath instead of antisocial personality disorder.
- 2:25:43But in the more official language of psychology and therapy, antisocial is the
- 2:25:50preferred term for most people, and it's also similar to sociopathic personality and this
- 2:26:00social personality disorder. Also, it shouldn't be confused with a social antisocial.
- 2:26:07In the general public, they use that word to mean a social meaning that
- 2:26:13someone is not very social, someone who's introverted or stays home a lot,
- 2:26:18they'll call that antisocial. But actually antisocial means against social norms or rules,
- 2:26:24and meaning that the opposite of social rules. So you have anti social and
- 2:26:30pro social. So to give to a charity or to hug someone who wants
- 2:26:35to be hugged. These are pro social behaviors. To flay someone alive,
- 2:26:41this is an anti social behavior. Okay. So antisocial personality disorder is defined
- 2:26:46in the DSM five as mainly a disregard and violation of the rights of others
- 2:26:52occurring since the age of fifteen. This very much typifies in Ramsey Bolton's behavior
- 2:27:00the age of fifteen and before. He has a massive disregard and is a
- 2:27:05massive violator of the rights of other people. That is very fitting to him.
- 2:27:11And we need at least three of the following criteria met in order to
- 2:27:16apply the diagnosis the diagnostic label of antisocial and he has all of them.
- 2:27:22So not only does he have at least three of the following he has all
- 2:27:26them and those are illegal behavior. He definitely acts illegally right now. It's
- 2:27:35sort of funny in the Westerost world because it's they have different kinds of laws.
- 2:27:41But you know, he doesn't. He doesn't follow the social law that
- 2:27:46you don't kill and rape innocent people's that's he does that frequently. Okay.
- 2:27:52Is he deceitful, does he lie? Does he disguise himself and does he
- 2:27:58con other people. Does he manipulate other people for his own gain all the
- 2:28:03time? He lies frequently, he disguises himself sometimes when he tried to get
- 2:28:11out of the murder, he disguised himself as Reek. And does he manipulate
- 2:28:15in con people? Yes, he is very manipulative and effective in this way.
- 2:28:20Right, he manipulated everyone into keeping him alive and believing he was Reak
- 2:28:28and then getting on theon's good side and then yeah, anyway, so he's
- 2:28:31he's very deceitful. Is he impulsive, Yes, he's quite impulsive. He
- 2:28:37does what he wants, particularly in the Telltale game video game. He is
- 2:28:43extremely seemingly impulsive and horrible. But honestly, he in comparison to shall we
- 2:28:52say, real people with antisocial is not as impulsive as real people. Antisocial
- 2:28:58people that I have known are particularly impulsive. They will act seemingly without any
- 2:29:09known guide to their behavior, and they'll get in fights a lot. They'll
- 2:29:15say nasty things to people, they will make sudden decisions, and basically because
- 2:29:24they don't have empathy for other people, they don't follow the normal rules in
- 2:29:31life. So for the rest of us that aren't anti social, we have
- 2:29:35a healthy amount of empathy for others, and so that will guide our behavior.
- 2:29:39So if we're out at the grocery store and someone gets in our way,
- 2:29:46we will get upset and there will be a part of us that might
- 2:29:48have some anger and even rage, But we refrain from doing something harmful to
- 2:29:56that person because there's a part of us one that doesn't want to harm an
- 2:30:01other human being, But there's also another part of us that doesn't want to
- 2:30:05be humiliated in society. We don't if we were to push that person down.
- 2:30:11We worry about what other people around would say about us. So we
- 2:30:18have empathy for the tribe. We worry about what they think about us.
- 2:30:24Well. Antisocial people don't necessarily care. This is the difference between narcissism and
- 2:30:31antisocialists. Narcissistic people very much care about how society sees them. They're preoccupied
- 2:30:39with that. But with antisocial they don't care about that because they don't they
- 2:30:45don't think they're special. They just simply lack empathy for other people and just
- 2:30:50they just don't care, and so it's not even on their radar and it
- 2:30:56doesn't affect them the way it affects us, and so they will act very
- 2:31:01impulsively. As a result, it'll seem impulsive to us, but in reality,
- 2:31:07to them, it's just they're acting on another set of rules that says
- 2:31:11that, you know, why would you care about what other people think?
- 2:31:15It would be Let's see if I can come up with an analogy. It'd
- 2:31:16be like when you are walking down a street in the summertime and there are
- 2:31:26occasional ants underneath your feet, and you occasionally step on an ant on accident.
- 2:31:35Well, if the ant community could see that, they would be horrified
- 2:31:39at what you just did. You just walking down the sidewalk, You didn't
- 2:31:43even care to look down at your feet, and you stepped on five ants
- 2:31:50in the process of walking on the street. You have no remorse, and
- 2:31:54you're you're so impulsive, Like you should have looked down and you should have
- 2:31:58walked around these ants, Like that's so impulsive of you. Well, you
- 2:32:03don't think of yourself as being impulsive? Do you just think of yourself as
- 2:32:07like, I'm just walking on the street, and oh I didn't I didn't
- 2:32:09even see the ants there, and I don't even I don't even know why
- 2:32:13anyone? Why are you? Why is why is everyone? Why are the
- 2:32:16all these ants getting anger at me all of a sudden. Well, it's
- 2:32:20a bad analogy, But sometimes when I say analogies like I just wonder,
- 2:32:22like what's going to come out of my mouth, and it's just like off
- 2:32:26the top of my head. But I think it's to some extent getting my
- 2:32:28point across in that the impulsiveness issue I think is attributed not to say ADHD,
- 2:32:39which is an executive function issue that leads to impulsivity. I think it's
- 2:32:45to people outside of the anti social world. It seems impulsive because they simply
- 2:32:50just don't care. They don't have the same editing system to their behavior,
- 2:32:56and so it seems impulsive. Anyway. Is he aggressive, boy, boy,
- 2:33:01Yes, he is just terribly aggressive. Does he have disregard for the
- 2:33:05safety of others? Holy crap, yes he does. Is he irresponsible?
- 2:33:11This one he meets kind of, you know, kind of irresponsible. Again,
- 2:33:15antisocial people in the real real world tend to be extremely irresponsible in general.
- 2:33:22This is something that antisocial psychopaths in the TV and TV and books don't
- 2:33:30really aren't really normal. You know. Often the psychopaths and stories are very
- 2:33:39responsible and very cunning, very smart, and very they always seem to get
- 2:33:43their way. Well, the vast majority of psychopaths and people who suffer from
- 2:33:48antisocial personality disorder do not in the end, actually get what they want because
- 2:33:54they lack empathy. They actually, to some extent lack the ability to figure
- 2:33:58out how to make things good for themselves because they can't necessarily predict how other
- 2:34:03people are going to act because they don't have empathy, and so they can
- 2:34:07act very irresponsibly even for themselves. They can drink a lot they you know,
- 2:34:11there's a lot there's a lot of substance abuse in the cluster bees,
- 2:34:16and they can act very irresponsible, so you know, losing a job,
- 2:34:22going to jail every now and then, not being very good with money,
- 2:34:26not taking care of people around you. So Ramsey Bolton doesn't really exhibit this
- 2:34:35in some ways, he's actually quite responsible and so so he doesn't really fit
- 2:34:39this one. And the last one is lack of remorse and empathy, and
- 2:34:43he absolutely absolutely misses or meets this criteria. In my opinion, the antisocial
- 2:34:50person and disorder criteria in the DSM, lack of remorse and empathy should really
- 2:34:54be something that needs to be met. So in the DSM. The main
- 2:35:03criteria criterion is disregarded violation for the rights of others occurring since the age of
- 2:35:09fifteen. Well, in my mind, that should be replaced with a consistent
- 2:35:16lack of remorse and empathy for other people that results in the disregard and violation
- 2:35:24of rights of others because you can and this happens. Make an argument for
- 2:35:28many people having antisocial that don't actually, in my mind, fit the spirit
- 2:35:35behind the diagnosis. For instance, I've talked about this before. I think,
- 2:35:41is someone grows up in a bad neighborhood, like a very bad neighborhood.
- 2:35:46You know, there are famous bad neighborhoods in the United States, And
- 2:35:50just think of a young black man, a young black kid, growing up
- 2:35:54in these neighborhoods. Well, he's being discriminated against. He has a lot
- 2:35:58of danger around him. There are people getting shot and killed and mugged and
- 2:36:03beat up, and there's gangs, and so he learns that the only way
- 2:36:09to survive is to fight back and assert your manliness and assert how you're willing
- 2:36:15to throw down like the best of them. And so you start to throw
- 2:36:18down, you start to fight, and you start to retaliate and someone you
- 2:36:24know attacks someone in your neighborhood, and you and some other friends go to
- 2:36:30the other neighborhood and you strike back, because if you don't strike back,
- 2:36:33the other neighborhood is just gonna They're going to know that your punks, and
- 2:36:37they're going to know that they can walk all over you. And that means
- 2:36:39very very bad things for you and your friends and your families. And so
- 2:36:43you will, in the process of engaging in that process, that very normal,
- 2:36:48understandable, natural process, you will disregard and violate the rights of others.
- 2:36:54You will go to this other neighborhood and you will do a drive by
- 2:36:58shooting, or you will mum someone's sister, or you're you know, you're
- 2:37:01gonna do bad things. And that's the context in which someone lives. Now,
- 2:37:05am I excusing it? No, it's a complicated thing. But but
- 2:37:11that boy could absolutely have a normal personality, one that does not have a
- 2:37:16disorder, one in which he does absolutely have empathy for other people, one
- 2:37:22in which he absolutely has a conscience and he absolutely has remorse when things happen,
- 2:37:28even when he does those things that he participates, and he he has
- 2:37:33remorse. So, according to the DSM. He could fit the criteria because
- 2:37:37you only need three of the following things. So again, this this black
- 2:37:43kid, is he doing stuff that's legal? Yes? Is he aggressive?
- 2:37:46Yes? Does he have disregard for the safety of others? Yes? Is
- 2:37:50he irresponsible? You could make a case he's being irresponsible. So he already
- 2:37:54missed that meets the criteria for antisocial. But he does have remorse, and
- 2:37:58he does have empathy, and to me, that misses the mark completely antisocial.
- 2:38:05The main hub of everything comes from, in my opinion, the lack
- 2:38:11of remorse and empathy is the same for psychopathy. To be diagnosed as a
- 2:38:16psychopath, you can meet all a lot of the other because the psychopathy list
- 2:38:24of criteria is even longer, and you can meet many in a similar way
- 2:38:28that it is said to andy social. And yet you can still a part
- 2:38:33of your personality have empathy and remorse for other people. And to me,
- 2:38:37that just is ridiculous. To me anti and I think most people agree.
- 2:38:45Most clinicians agree that that the key element of anti social well, I don't
- 2:38:50know if I can say this actually, but many people I talk to the
- 2:38:54key element of anti social psychopathy, sociopathy is the lack of remorse, lack
- 2:38:58of empathy, and everything stems from there, right, But for many people
- 2:39:03these are labels they apply particularly maybe in the criminal justice system. They apply
- 2:39:09it to an individual who has just a history of doing a legal behavior,
- 2:39:13and that to me misses the spirit meant behind the term personality disorder. You
- 2:39:22can commit many different behavioral problematic behaviors, but unless there's an underlying pervasive personality
- 2:39:31problem, then they don't fit the diagnostic criteria in my mind of a personality
- 2:39:37disorder. Now I'm I'm sure if you look more closely at the DSM five
- 2:39:41language you could find some kind of exception to what I'm saying. But anyway,
- 2:39:46my point is is that when you're looking for the key feature of psychopathy
- 2:39:52in any social it's this lack of empathy, and that all other things stem
- 2:39:58from that. It is similar to my thesis that with borderline everything. There
- 2:40:05are many different confusing criteria criteria for borderline even more confused, way more confusing
- 2:40:13than any social by the way, But it's my thesis that everything stems from
- 2:40:18for borderline people, from a tremendous fear and complex regarding rejection. And once
- 2:40:30you understand that Once you understand that they're extremely sensitive to rejection and everything stems
- 2:40:37from that sensitivity, then it all starts to make sense. The impulsivity,
- 2:40:43the lack of empathy themselves, the relationship instability, the latching onto someone and
- 2:40:50then rejecting them. I mean, it all starts to make sense. The
- 2:40:52suicidal, the suicidality without actual behaviors, it all starts to make sense.
- 2:40:58And the same within social If you understand that the key broken element of the
- 2:41:05personality is a lack of empathy for other human beings, then you understand that
- 2:41:09a lot of things stem from that. Okay, so that's antisocial, and
- 2:41:16then we have sadistic personality disorder. This is not in the DSM anymore.
- 2:41:20It used to be in the DSM three, and when the DSM four came
- 2:41:24out in the early nineties, they excluded sadistic personality disorder. I don't understand
- 2:41:31why they got rid of it, because there is no other diagnostic category that
- 2:41:37describes sadism in the DSM, except for what is in the paraphilic chapter in
- 2:41:48the DSM five, which is sexual sadism disorder. But this is just a
- 2:41:54small percentage of sadistic personality people so I call for a return of sadistic personality
- 2:42:03disorder. So we need to add to Ramsey Bolton sadistic personality disorder. So
- 2:42:09he's anti social slash psychopathic dissocial personality disorder and he suffers from sadistic personality disorder.
- 2:42:22Again, this needs to be added because psychopaths and antisocial personality disorder people
- 2:42:28are not necessarily sadistic. It's important to understand when you are a psychopath,
- 2:42:33this means you don't care about other people's feelings, but it doesn't necessarily mean
- 2:42:39you desire to harm other people. In fact, the vast majority of people
- 2:42:43with antisocial and with psychopathy do not actually enjoy harming other people. They will
- 2:42:50harm others in an instrumental way, meaning that, if, for instance,
- 2:42:56you and a psychopath are in competition for a promotion, they will have no
- 2:43:01problem manipulating the situation in their favor and harm you in the process. But
- 2:43:07they don't get off on harming it. What they do get off on is
- 2:43:11getting the promotion like anyone else. They desire promotion just like anyone else,
- 2:43:15and they don't have any qualms with harming you in the process, whereas you
- 2:43:20will. You might actually compete similarly with this person, but you'll feel bad
- 2:43:26about it on the inside and you probably won't compete as well because of that
- 2:43:30empathy. But sadistic personality disordered people actually wake up in the morning and like
- 2:43:37the way you crave that cup of coffee in the morning, they crave to
- 2:43:41harm other people. And this is a personality disorder that should be in the
- 2:43:46DSM, but it does not. And it should be noted that in movies
- 2:43:50and TV shows, psychopathy and sadism are often conflated. People often consider psychopathy
- 2:43:58to be the same as being a sadist, but they're not. They're not
- 2:44:03the same. They're related, and they go hand in hand sometimes but not
- 2:44:07usually. And sadistic personality disordered people are actually quite rare. Understand there are
- 2:44:13very very few people that suffer. Maybe that's why they got rid of it,
- 2:44:18is that it's very rare. It's very common in the movies and TV
- 2:44:20though. Okay, now, as I said before, Indias and five,
- 2:44:26sexual sadism disorder is included and the criteria are over a period of at least
- 2:44:31six months. So yes, he's been doing sadism statistic behavior of the past
- 2:44:37six months and it's a recurrent and intense sexual arousal from the suffering of others.
- 2:44:45So it's unclear if he is getting intense sexual arousal from the suffering of
- 2:44:50others or if he is just having intense pleasure suffer from the suffering of others.
- 2:44:56You'd really have to ask him or study him a little bit more,
- 2:45:01because you know he did rape. He does he does love to rape,
- 2:45:07but he might just enjoy sex and also have no problem with raping h So
- 2:45:16you know, whereas a sexual sadist, the only way they can even have
- 2:45:22sex, or the main way that can even just be aroused, is when
- 2:45:28someone else is genuinely suffering. Not like normal S and M people who want
- 2:45:35to play around with S and M sexual sadists actually get off on actual harm
- 2:45:43of other human beings where it's not a game. These are your your rapists,
- 2:45:50the you know, the vast but and this is something I just really
- 2:45:52want to make sure everyone understands because that I don't think people really get it
- 2:45:56because there there's there's a notion of there that men, if given the chance,
- 2:46:01would rape if they could, and the fact is that's just not the
- 2:46:07case. That is not the case for the vast majority of people, including
- 2:46:11men, they could never rape someone because they have a normal level of empathy,
- 2:46:18and they could never have they could never be sexually aroused in the context
- 2:46:24of them harming another human being. Now are there situations in which non sadists
- 2:46:31rape people. Absolutely. You know, when people are drunk, and I've
- 2:46:35talked about before, when you deprive young men of any kind of physical affection
- 2:46:41and warmth and love and they get drunk at a party and they're just like,
- 2:46:48they just need human connection and they don't know how to get it,
- 2:46:52and they're just so desperate and they're unhinged, and they have a group of
- 2:46:58other boys around them. Can they turn to rape, Yes, But what
- 2:47:05you'll find is those boys will wake up the next morning and feel terrible about
- 2:47:07it. A sexual assadist will wake up in the morning and go, oh
- 2:47:11my god, that was great. I want to do it again, and
- 2:47:13I want to do it again. I want to it again. And so
- 2:47:16it's sexual sadism. So any social is rare, Sadistic personality personality disorder is
- 2:47:24even rarer, and sexual sadism disorder is a part of sadistic personality disorder.
- 2:47:30So anyway, pretty dark stuff. Isn't it. Let's read some quotes to
- 2:47:35close out this long ass episode. Let's read some quotes. I think it's
- 2:47:41around the TV show Ramsey. He is talking to Reek here and he says,
- 2:47:46strip off their skins, Lord Bolton, he used to say a naked
- 2:47:52man has few secrets, but a flayed man has none. So he's talking
- 2:47:58about his dad. He's saying, my dad used to say that a naked
- 2:48:03man has few secrets, but a flayed man has no secrets. So that's
- 2:48:09pretty brutal there, all right. Ramsey is now talking to theon gray Joy
- 2:48:20in this quote, and he says, Ramsey, Snow, my wife called
- 2:48:26me this before she ate her fingers, but I say, Bolton, So
- 2:48:33you know, there's that one. And as he as Ramsey is sacking Winterfell,
- 2:48:41remember he decided when you know, he takes out Sir Roderick and then
- 2:48:48Theon lets him into Winterfell, and then he suddenly turns on Theon. He
- 2:48:52says, save me the phrase and burn the rest, burn it, burn
- 2:48:56it all. He burns down Winterfall. Here's Ramsey Bolton talking to Theon again.
- 2:49:03If you think this has a happy ending, you haven't been paying much
- 2:49:07attention that's such a great line. If you think this is going to have
- 2:49:13a happy ending, then you haven't been paying very much attention. Okay again,
- 2:49:16Ramsey saying to Theon as he flays his right pinky, this isn't happening
- 2:49:26to you for a reason, well, one reason, I enjoy it.
- 2:49:31So this really plays into his sadistic personality. This isn't happening to you for
- 2:49:35a reason, well, one reason I enjoy it. So that sadistic fucker.
- 2:49:45Okay. Here's a conversation between a lot of conversations between Theon and Ramsey.
- 2:49:50Theon great joy. He says, please mercy, mercy, and then
- 2:49:52Ramsey says, this is mercy. I'm not killing you, just making a
- 2:49:56few alterations. He cuts off his finger and his dong. Here's when Ramsey
- 2:50:09is talking to Theon after he cuts off his dong. Ramsey talking. People
- 2:50:15talk about phantom limbs. An amputee might have an itch where his foot used
- 2:50:20to be. So I've always wondered, do eunux have a phantom cock?
- 2:50:26The next time you think about naked girls, will you feel an itch?
- 2:50:30Sorry? I shouldn't make jokes. My mother taught me not to throw stones
- 2:50:35at cripples, but my father taught me aim for their head. Oh.
- 2:50:43I don't know why I'm laughing. It's so awful. Maybe that's why I
- 2:50:46like the show and others too. It's just it's just I don't know.
- 2:50:50There's something comical about a sadist. I suppose. All right, here's again
- 2:50:56Ramsey talking when he is flaying a man, someone that he's flaying I think
- 2:51:03alive. Did you know my ancestors wore the skins of their enemies as a
- 2:51:09coat. So he's educating this man about the history of his house as he
- 2:51:16flays him by pointing out that his ancestors used to wear the skin of their
- 2:51:20enemies. All right, here's another one. Ramsey is saying, and if
- 2:51:26it's a boy, he's talking to his father. You know what if your
- 2:51:31wife, your new wife, has a boy, And Ruce Bolton says,
- 2:51:35you're worried about your position, Ramsey says, my position is quite clear.
- 2:51:41I'm your son until the better alternative comes along. So here Ramsey is highlighting
- 2:51:48the fact that his father will discard him if if Ruce has a son with
- 2:51:54the fray woman. But everyone knows is that Ramsey would just kill the child
- 2:52:01if it was a boy, so it doesn't matter. Ramsey is now talking
- 2:52:07to Reek as Ramsey forces himself onto sans in the TV show. So he's
- 2:52:13raping Sansa at this point, and he is talking to the on and he
- 2:52:18says, you've known Sansa since she was a young girl. Now watch her
- 2:52:22become a woman. Well that's pretty dark there, all right. Here is
- 2:52:30Ramsey and Sansa talking. Ramsey says, I'm Lord Bolton's eldest son. Sansa
- 2:52:37says, but you're a bastard. A true born will always have the stronger
- 2:52:41claim. Ramsey says, I've been naturalized by a royal decree from dot dot
- 2:52:48dot. Sansus interrupts and says Toeman Brathian, another bastard. So touche,
- 2:52:56sans you got him on that one. Good for you. Here's Ruth Bolton
- 2:53:01talking to Ramsey. He says his father, power tastes best when sweetened by
- 2:53:09courtesy. You had best learned that if you ever hope to rule again.
- 2:53:16Bruce is telling his son, Look, dude, you gotta be courteous because
- 2:53:20that's when power really works out the best. So cool your jets on the
- 2:53:26flaying of the your you know, cool your jets on the raping and the
- 2:53:30flame. If we're gonna rule, stop it all right. Here's Rob Stark
- 2:53:35talking to lowther Fray about Ramsey and he says this Ramsey was a monster and
- 2:53:43a murderer, and he died a coward, or so I was told.
- 2:53:48And again remember that Rob Stark was told that Ramsey had died, but in
- 2:53:52fact he had not died by Roderick's hand. He Roderick had killed Reiku just
- 2:54:00looked and dressed like Ramsey. Here's a great quote from Ruce. He's talking
- 2:54:05to Reek Slash Theon. I think so, Ruce Bolton, this is so.
- 2:54:11This is Ramsey's father talking to someone about Ramsey, and he says his
- 2:54:16blood is bad. He needs to be leeched. The leeches suck away the
- 2:54:20bad blood, all the rage and the pain. No man can think so
- 2:54:26full of anger Ramsey, though his tainted blood would poison even leeches. I
- 2:54:31fear so. So his own father recognizes that there's something wrong with that boy.
- 2:54:39Okay, here's Theon talking I will kill that man talking about Ramsey.
- 2:54:46Theon is saying, I will kill that man. I swear to the drowned
- 2:54:48God, to the old gods, the new gods to every fucking God and
- 2:54:52fuck every fucking heaven. I will kill that man. Actually I should.
- 2:54:58I should mention The first George R. Martin you know story I read was
- 2:55:05something that was written I think it was written before before a Game of Thrones.
- 2:55:11He wrote a short story that was printed in I think it was Dragon
- 2:55:16Magazine. For you nerds out there, there's a magazine for dungeons and dragon
- 2:55:24lovers called Dragon Magazine, and a I've I had a subscription to that magazine
- 2:55:31again because again super nerd here, and I think George R. Martin had
- 2:55:35written this story, short story for it, and it was about the Iron
- 2:55:39Born and it was about the drowned Gods. It was really interesting because these
- 2:55:45priests of the Drowned God were initiating their new young priests into the church.
- 2:55:54And the way that they did that was they had this ceremony and they would
- 2:56:00go into the sea. They would wade into the sea, and the new
- 2:56:05recruits would submerge themselves in water, so it's sort of like a baptism,
- 2:56:11and they would purposely drown themselves until their heart stopped, and then the other
- 2:56:18priests would pull them out of the water and give them CPR essentially, and
- 2:56:24if they were revived, then they were born again essentially, and they became
- 2:56:28priests for the drowned God. But if they just died, then it meant
- 2:56:33that they weren't worthy or something. And the way George Martin writes, it
- 2:56:39was just an extremely compelling short story. And I didn't usually like to read
- 2:56:43the short stories and dragon, but this one I remember, it really stuck
- 2:56:46out to me. Okay, let's just read a couple more quotes. Here.
- 2:56:50This is Ruth Bolton talking to Ramsey. I place far too much trust
- 2:56:54in you. End quote. Here's Circelis vowing to have Rus and Ramsey flayed
- 2:57:03after learning they have they have in their possession Sansa Stark. So it's interesting
- 2:57:09that Circe is sort of sticking up for sans. So Circe says to someone,
- 2:57:16she says, I will skin him and is bastard like the wretch of
- 2:57:20their bloody sigil, like that wretch on their bloody sigil. Sorry, I
- 2:57:26will skin him and his bastard like that wretch on their bloody sigil. So
- 2:57:31that's interesting. I wonder if that's for telling what will happen to Russ and
- 2:57:37Ramsey, will Circe exact revenge for us? They seem to be kind of
- 2:57:43setting up in the story the possibility for us to like Circe because she's been
- 2:57:48suffering so much. You know that scene where she walks through town naked and
- 2:57:54everyone's throwing crap at her Like it's it's a good story to to make us
- 2:58:01sympathize with her to some extent, although I don't. I don't know Circe.
- 2:58:07I mean, Circe you can have some some love for Maybe she'll come
- 2:58:15around, you know, like Jamie did. But anyway, I'm off track
- 2:58:20anyway, So what's the final word I can say about Ramsey Bolton. The
- 2:58:24final thing I'll say is that as a as a character, again, I
- 2:58:28realized he's much more complex than I originally thought. There are definitely reasons as
- 2:58:35to or things you can point to in his history as to why he developed
- 2:58:41antisocial personalit disorder and statistic personality disorder, but it is somewhat of a mystery.
- 2:58:50If I were if he were my client or someone I was assessing,
- 2:58:54and I was to just hypothesize as to the main factors, I would say
- 2:58:58they are are. Thus that genetics played a role, that the in utero
- 2:59:07experience of his development played a role in damaging his nervous system development, that
- 2:59:16his early childhood attachment, when compounded with his genetic predisposition for antisocial set the
- 2:59:28ball rolling in a sense to have him never develop a compassion and empathy for
- 2:59:35other human beings. And by the time Reek came along, he already had
- 2:59:41the beginnings of antisocial personage and sadism, and Reek just became a convenient target
- 2:59:48for that when Ramsey was a teenager. That would be my sense, because
- 2:59:54there are many people that have similar histories in their childhood. There are many
- 3:00:00people who suffer from abuse, who have mothers who were raped and who were
- 3:00:05suffering from mental illness as they were raising their children. There are many children
- 3:00:09that grow up in that circumstance but do not develop antisocial So there seems to
- 3:00:16be emerging evidence that you to some extent need to have a biological disposition,
- 3:00:24whether that's running in your family, because clearly Rus has antisocial traits, if
- 3:00:28not full blown disorder, and so there seem to be some genetic roots in
- 3:00:35this, But also there just can be random genetic realities that occur when a
- 3:00:43fetus is formed that can in all likelihood create the disposition for personality disorders such
- 3:00:50as this, And so that would be my hypothesis that genetics meets a mother
- 3:00:58who is who is suffering, and God knows what her parenting style was.
- 3:01:03Like you put those two things together and you get a Ramsey. And if
- 3:01:09you did it a hundred other times, you wouldn't have got a Ramsey.
- 3:01:11But in this instance, the roll the dice created a Ramsey. And so
- 3:01:18we now have a wonderful character to hate on the TV show Game of Thrones
- 3:01:24and in the books the book series A Tale of Ice and Fire, Song
- 3:01:30of Ice, Song of Ice and Fire. It's a terrible name anyway.
- 3:01:35All right, Well that does it for another episode. Let me know what
- 3:01:37you think. You can email me at contact at Psychologyanseattle dot com. Let
- 3:01:41me know what you think of this. And boy, I can't wait for
- 3:01:43season six. People have been watching the previous or the yeah, the trailers
- 3:01:48for season six and they're very skeptical. I remember that one trailer with all
- 3:01:52the masks on the wall. Everyone was getting angry about that one. But
- 3:01:56I have faith, mostly because even if this season isn't very good, I
- 3:02:01just love this story so much I'm I'm, I'm, and they have been
- 3:02:05consistently well produced and well written that I'm positive I'm gonna like it now.
- 3:02:11I'm guessing as we move forward, there's going to be a fair amount of
- 3:02:15people that will start dropping off because they liked the show kind of but they
- 3:02:20weren't as much of a fan as I am. And so that's my prediction.
- 3:02:24I predict that season six were going to see a lot of people starting
- 3:02:30to turn away from the series. It's just a guess, and I really
- 3:02:35hope that the story stays well written and the plot is good. I'm really
- 3:02:41curious what they decide to do with the story because I'm pretty sure Martin was
- 3:02:48saying that he wanted to finish this series in seven books, which would imply
- 3:02:54there would be, you know, only two or three more seasons TV seasons
- 3:02:58left. It's sort of weird because the TV series is going to come out
- 3:03:03before the books do. But at the same time, the books are quite
- 3:03:09a different experience than the TV show. So when the TV show is done
- 3:03:15and the next couple of books come out over the next ten years, because
- 3:03:18it takes them forever to write these things, I'll still read the books because
- 3:03:22the books just have not only just is it so much more interesting to read
- 3:03:26the books, but there's a lot of side plots that don't even get included
- 3:03:31in the TV show. So anyway, let me know what you think.
- 3:03:35Contact at Psychologystyle dot com. And if you're a patron, please tell the
- 3:03:39people about the podcast. And if you're not, then please become a patron
- 3:03:46of the podcast because when more people become patrons, I can dedicate more time
- 3:03:52to doing in episodes like this. It took me a long time to prep
- 3:03:54this episode. I'm gonna tell you as you can tell. I had all
- 3:03:58these quotes and and it takes a long time. And so if you want
- 3:04:01other episodes like this, please become a patron by going to patreon dot com.
- 3:04:05All right, well that does it for this episode. Thanks for joining
- 3:04:07me. Please take care of yourself, take care of other people, and
- 3:04:11avoid the Ramses of the world. And if you're a Ramsey, get treatment
- 3:04:16so that you can be a better citizen of this society, because you deserve that.