Latest / Signal & Noise: Bringing Clarity to Media, Data, Tech and AI / Stop Blocking the News: Brand Safety, Performance, and the Case for Journalism
Transcript
- 0:14Hey, everybody. Welcome back to Signal and
- 0:16Noise. Today, Rio and I have a guest
- 0:19that I've known for quite a few years that most of you, most of
- 0:22our listeners know. He's on the speaking circuit.
- 0:26He's been in the industry, talking, marketing
- 0:28transformation for decades. His name is Lou Pascalis and
- 0:32we're super psyched to have him on the show.
- 0:35For those of you that don't know Lou, he's formerly a marketing
- 0:40and customer strategy executive ran media investment and data
- 0:45enablement for Bank of America American Express.
- 0:49He was briefly the president and COO of the Mobile Marketing
- 0:53Association and he's currently running his own advisory as
- 0:57service as the CEO AJL advisory. And he also, you know, in his
- 1:02spare time, which must not be much, is the chief strategy
- 1:06officer of Adfontis Media, which ties into the theme of today's
- 1:11episode, brand safety performance in the case for
- 1:15journalism. So super psyched to have Lou in
- 1:19Rio. You've got some, some thoughts
- 1:21to share on the topic. You're certainly passionate
- 1:24about it. Lou's obviously passionate about
- 1:26it. So what do you think?
- 1:30It's a great episode Blue is a wealth of information and strong
- 1:33opinions. No shortage of those.
- 1:36This is a cool topic. It's becoming more and more
- 1:38important with the rise of AI surge, the decline of referral
- 1:42traffic right to to publishers. It's interesting too, Brett.
- 1:45I think that this is a topic that's very important, but I
- 1:48don't think it's generally gotten enough interest to
- 1:50coverage over the especially over the last few years.
- 1:53So I think this it's changing, which is a really good sign.
- 1:57Anecdotally, I remember I, I wrote an art, I self published a
- 2:00lot of stuff on on Medium. I wrote an article on called
- 2:05Publisher Blues about 25 bad years for for the news media.
- 2:09I've got some interest, but I compared that to an article I
- 2:12wrote around the same town on clean rooms, which got 10 times.
- 2:15So I mean, clean rooms are cool. It's a good topic, but I just, I
- 2:18find it interesting that there's just so like not as much
- 2:21interest in this topic that really does affect all of us so.
- 2:25Yeah, it's, it's, it's definitely a downstream effect
- 2:27on the entire advertising industry, right?
- 2:29It's the it's where all of the content we absorb is coming
- 2:33from. And a lot of these publishers
- 2:35are under threat. It's what the book from Ari Area
- 2:39Papero is about. Yield, right?
- 2:42So I haven't read it yet, but I'm.
- 2:44You that don't know and it's how Google built a bought, built and
- 2:47bullied it's way to advertising dominance, which ties very much
- 2:50thematically into this topic of of publishers, content producers
- 2:56being disintermediated. Yeah, it's interesting too.
- 2:58I mean, I think like last this week was actually the ad monster
- 3:02sell side summit in Nashville. I couldn't go.
- 3:04I mean, I Nashville in August, I mean, that's, I don't think
- 3:08that's. That's like, that's like Japan
- 3:10in August. But but it's such a cool town.
- 3:13I really would have loved to go. And apparently, like I I was
- 3:15just reading, you know, today that Tony Katzer from IEB tech
- 3:18lab talked a lot about kind of the post browser world, right,
- 3:23you know, singing a ice scraping Blues.
- 3:25That was the headline today on a on AD monsters.
- 3:27So it's just an important topic as as we start to see referral
- 3:31traffic drop and it it is, you could argue, a threat to news
- 3:37media. On that Tony Katzer topic, they
- 3:39just published some a framework which is kind of counter to the
- 3:43cloud flare sort of pay per crawl framework for how we can
- 3:48basically better compensate publishers for the value of
- 3:53their content. And I thought that was pretty
- 3:55interesting. I think they published that
- 3:56probably right before this event intentionally to really get some
- 3:59press around. Let's start to institute some of
- 4:02these rules in terms of blocking LLM scrapers, allowing
- 4:06publishers to opt in to LMLLLMLLLM scrapers right when
- 4:11they want to, and then and then developing a a repeatable way to
- 4:15do value exchange so they can get paid for access, more or
- 4:20less. Well, getting paid for access,
- 4:22we talked about this, you know, we have one upcoming with, with
- 4:25Jessica Hope from, from Hearst as well, which is, which is
- 4:28going to be a really good one too.
- 4:30If we talk about kind of some of the strategies they're taking
- 4:32which seem to be working. And Hearst has had a pretty good
- 4:34year. I I think I was reading the
- 4:35other day their, their revenues up at 9% this year.
- 4:39So I think they, they are, they are, they are doing some things
- 4:41right. But Katzer did call it
- 4:44apparently I was reading an extinction level event.
- 4:47Yeah, publishers do do kind of full out of ad tech as a result
- 4:51of this. Google has basically said, you
- 4:53know, if you don't want to be scraped by our AI, we're not
- 4:57going to scrape you for search, right?
- 4:58We're not going to index you so. And he's calling for the
- 5:01separation of LLM for Jim and I and paid search script and he's
- 5:06calling for a breakup of those two capabilities from Google,
- 5:10right? Yeah, so.
- 5:12Interesting times. And I guess with that, let's
- 5:15just let's kick it off right? Hey everybody.
- 5:18Welcome back to Signal and Noise.
- 5:20We've got a very special guest today, the Lou Pascalis for our
- 5:25listeners that are in the ad tech and Martech space.
- 5:28He's about as well known a person in the industry as you
- 5:33can imagine. So welcome to the to to the, the
- 5:37podcast, Lou. That being said about how well
- 5:39known you are in the industry and how you've been on the
- 5:41speaking circuit for a number of years.
- 5:44I've seen you going all the way back to my Nielsen days, but we
- 5:47certainly sort of got to know each other a little bit at New
- 5:50Star TransUnion. I'd love to hear, you know Lou
- 5:54Pascalis, introduce yourself in your own words to our audience
- 5:57for those that don't know your background and who you are in
- 6:00the ad tech martech industry. Well, look, I appreciate the
- 6:03opportunity and well known could be infamous and hopefully I can
- 6:08dispel that in the next couple seconds here.
- 6:10Yeah. So I started in the advertising
- 6:11business in the late 1980s at a small family owned company
- 6:16called Harrison Julio Gallo. And Gallo was a big advertiser
- 6:20in a small category. And so I learned the ropes from,
- 6:25you know, Ernest himself, who was very value conscious.
- 6:27And, you know, I used to like to say, if you got something that
- 6:31was worth a dollar for two cents, he'd ask if why you
- 6:34couldn't have gotten it for a penny.
- 6:36And so it was really about, in those days, understanding the
- 6:39marketplace dynamics. And so I transitioned from that
- 6:43to briefly having my own company into product integration space,
- 6:46sold out, successfully joined American Express, ultimately ran
- 6:51media there, content marketing, launched a mobile marketing
- 6:55practice. I think that's where we met and
- 6:59then was recruited from there by Bank of America in 2013 and went
- 7:05over to Bank of America to run global media and was given a
- 7:09couple of other areas including marketing data enablement and
- 7:13marketing data use governance. And that really set me up for
- 7:18the era that we're in now where I think, you know, it was almost
- 7:22like getting my second MBA as I like to say in data compliance.
- 7:26And the bank was very risk averse and so really challenged
- 7:30us to, you know, make a good business case for the use of
- 7:34data. And I love the standard that we
- 7:36had there, which was just because we have permission to do
- 7:39something doesn't mean we should.
- 7:42And it created a very high governance bar.
- 7:44And I think where we're at now is an industry, particularly in
- 7:48the era of agentic AI and the ability to really mine data at a
- 7:53granular level, we're going to need to understand the
- 7:56permission provenance. So I do a lot of speaking on
- 7:58that. And today I have my own company,
- 8:00AJL Advisory. I have two dozen paying clients,
- 8:05most on the tech side try and understand how to talk to
- 8:07marketers, some on the marketing side, really trying to figure
- 8:11out how to connect what the marketing discipline is to the
- 8:14CEO and CFO growth agenda where I have had some experience in my
- 8:18career and really, really enjoying it.
- 8:20It's fulfilling, it's rewarding, it keeps me busy.
- 8:23That's. Awesome.
- 8:23Thanks for that. Yeah, thanks for that
- 8:25background. I mean, we're really excited to
- 8:26have you on the pod today. This is kind of a continuation
- 8:30of a topic we've been digging into with different guests about
- 8:33really what's going on with with with the news media, right?
- 8:37And it's kind of it's a great topic and it's very timely
- 8:40because in many ways I look at it's almost like a paradox.
- 8:43And in some ways the news has never really mattered more,
- 8:46right? We've got tons of like
- 8:48bombarding, bombarded with information, a lot of it
- 8:50disinformation, a lot of it AI slop now, right?
- 8:54And people need accurate information in order to make
- 8:56informed decisions on what they're doing, who they're
- 8:59voting for, etcetera. But at the same time, the news
- 9:02media is under tremendous strain, right?
- 9:04And some, including me, believe it potentially jeopardizes the
- 9:08future of the industry itself. You look at some numbers since
- 9:112005, US has lost more than 3000 local newspapers shrinking from
- 9:167500 to roughly 4500. Brett, we talked about this last
- 9:20episode about how that the industry is really look, the
- 9:23revenue it takes in has been halved since from 2000 to 2020,
- 9:28which is really kind of shocking, right?
- 9:30And these recent closures and the numbers really point to the
- 9:34future where communities really don't have a primary source of
- 9:37local reporting, right? And you look at like what, why
- 9:40is a lot of this happening? I think a lot of brands when
- 9:44they make decisions CM OS when they make decisions about where
- 9:46to advertise, many of them just avoid news out of fear, right,
- 9:50which I think a lot of that's miss misguided.
- 9:55But that's one thing we're going to talk about today, Lou, love
- 9:58the future new study that you collaborated with Stagwell on.
- 10:01I love that that found that there's no negative impact on
- 10:03key brand metrics when ads run next to quality news, right,
- 10:06which I think's not surprising even on really, really tough
- 10:09topics, right? In a lot of ways, the way the
- 10:14industry's handled this over time, whether it's over broad,
- 10:17you know, keyword blocking lists or different tactics, just
- 10:20avoiding news all together. This is demonetized a lot of
- 10:23legit news content, despite the fact that this study and others
- 10:26have shown that there really maybe is no negative impact.
- 10:30And this money really could have gone to fund better reporting
- 10:33and better quality journalism, right?
- 10:34And then you look at what's going on with AI right now with,
- 10:37you know, referral traffic really falling off a Cliff.
- 10:39This is going to be another, you know, death by 1000 cuts, right?
- 10:44This would be another, another cut impact in the industry,
- 10:47right? And publisher monetization is
- 10:49already falling, which is which is really which is bad, right?
- 10:52So over the next hour or so, we're really looking forward to
- 10:55talking to you about this, looking at brand safety risk
- 10:58versus over caution, talk about how brands and CM OS and
- 11:03marketers maybe should be investing in quality news and
- 11:06investing in good journalism, right?
- 11:08And when we look at where to put their ad dollars, we talked
- 11:11about how, how AI is shaping this, how the business model of
- 11:13journalism is changing a little bit with the goal of giving some
- 11:16practical steps to marketers that they can look at
- 11:19immediately this month, this quarter to help support
- 11:22trustworthy reporting and and good journalism overall.
- 11:25So with that said, let's get into it.
- 11:27And I and Lou, I started out with the the future of new study
- 11:30with Stagwell, which again, I've worked for Stagwell for a long
- 11:32time. I think they're fantastic
- 11:33organization. As I mentioned, I found there's
- 11:37no adverse impact on purchase intent or favorability when ads
- 11:41run next to negative, you know, but high quality news, love.
- 11:43You could maybe talk a little bit about this, about the study,
- 11:45about the findings and about why they're important.
- 11:48Yeah, sure. You know, I agree with you.
- 11:51I think what Mark Penn in particular and his leadership
- 11:53team have done at Stagwell is incredibly impressive when they
- 11:57did the initial study. You know, a lot of times when
- 12:00you see these studies, you look at the N and it equals 12144
- 12:04adults. They studied 50,000 US adults,
- 12:09right? This is meaningful.
- 12:10This is, you know, material. They leveraged Harris Poll,
- 12:14which is one of their, you know, internal agencies.
- 12:17And I found so much in the initial study, which is now over
- 12:22a year old, but still very compelling.
- 12:23And we did a a similar version in the UK with 20,000 US adults,
- 12:27which is similarly large. If you look at the relative
- 12:30populations of the two. And, and, you know, the things
- 12:33that stood out to you, to me #1 Rio, you correctly said there is
- 12:37virtually no impact in purchase intent when ads run adjacent to
- 12:43prove they have swing content. I think that's part of the
- 12:48evolution that we've gone through.
- 12:50You know, we've, we've, I think in the last decade, we've become
- 12:53less sensitized to, OK, there's going to be unsettling news
- 12:58every day and there's going to be ads next to it.
- 13:02And I'm not going to blame the advertisers for being adjacent
- 13:04to the ads. You know, when it's initially
- 13:06started on the marketer side, we were trying to avoid ISIS
- 13:12beheadings in UGC. And yeah, it was really black
- 13:18and white. You need to be away from that.
- 13:20But it's it's actually grown. If you get the reference to
- 13:24Seymour in the Little Shop of Harm or Horrors, the Venus
- 13:27flytrap, that gets bigger and bigger and ultimately eats its
- 13:30owner. And now everything can be
- 13:33construed as a potential adjacency issue.
- 13:37And that gets formatic and where there was a tipping point in the
- 13:40culture. And the tipping point was the
- 13:42George Floyd incident in Minneapolis and the ensuing
- 13:46Black Lives Matter movement. And what happened there was a
- 13:50bit extraordinary inside of the enterprise.
- 13:53Corporate Communications, which enjoys a very privileged
- 13:56relationship with the CEO, said Perhaps we could get out of news
- 14:02for a little while because it's very provocative right now.
- 14:07And that is metastasized into something permanent now.
- 14:11And in many cases, I think you've got marketers that are
- 14:15doing that for reasons I don't fully understand anymore.
- 14:21So if you ask them, are you advertising the news, say
- 14:25absolutely, when in fact they have policy whether or not, and
- 14:30you have to be. Yeah, you have, you literally
- 14:33have, you have. So you have three kinds of
- 14:35problems today with the demonetization of news.
- 14:38You have people who are avoiding the category altogether.
- 14:43One very good friend of mine who was a very accomplished CMO,
- 14:48stayed on stage at an event that I was at.
- 14:52Why would I advertise in news when I can reach the same
- 14:56audience elsewhere without the risk?
- 14:59This is a friend of mine, a highly respected leader, and I
- 15:04went tearing into the green room to say, wait, how?
- 15:08How can you? You know, how can you say that
- 15:10because #1. You can't the same.
- 15:11Audience, right? You can't have the same audience
- 15:14even in that same stag. But one of the things that's
- 15:16buried in there that is a long time media buyer, I can tell you
- 15:19was like a gold nugget. 11% of people surveyed self identified
- 15:26as news junkies in the study definition.
- 15:29A news junkie is someone who is only consuming news when they're
- 15:33consuming media of any form. That's unduplicated reach.
- 15:37Unduplicated reach drives the outcome of every campaign.
- 15:43And so news delivers that. They also deliver a very
- 15:46affluent and influential audience.
- 15:48They deliver an audience that has, you know, the highest
- 15:51likelihood to have multiple graduate degrees in a household,
- 15:53to take vacations abroad, all the other things that say that
- 15:57they have the means to purchase things, right.
- 16:00So you can't leave that on the table.
- 16:02But unfortunately, the marketer hasn't been able to make that
- 16:05case. So that's the news.
- 16:06Blocking. Then you get the domain level.
- 16:10Blocking the domain level is, you know, we don't advertise in
- 16:14The New York Times because it's it's too provocative.
- 16:18And I think that is risky too. And I'll come back.
- 16:20Around to that specific publications.
- 16:22They block specific publications and they end up blocking a lot
- 16:25of them. You know the problem with both
- 16:27keyword blocking and domain blocking is it's like a Roach
- 16:29motel. If you remember the ads for
- 16:31that, the keywords check in, but they don't check out.
- 16:34And so they've, one of my favorite things to do with
- 16:37clients is asked him when's the last time you audited your
- 16:39keyword blocking list? And the answer, yeah, Yeah, the
- 16:43answer is never. We've never audited our keyword
- 16:45blocking list. And so you have things like
- 16:46Hillary Clinton in there. Well, she's now a grandma living
- 16:49in Scarsdale, NY You know, she's not a deal.
- 16:51Maybe it's time to take her out of the penalty box.
- 16:55But. But this domain level blocking
- 16:57is accretive over time. And you know, he just ended up
- 16:59blocking more and more and more publications.
- 17:03But then the one that's really insidious and I think the one
- 17:06where which was limited by the technology that we had available
- 17:10to US six or seven years ago, but is no longer limited to that
- 17:12technology is keyword blocking. Because keyword blocking ignores
- 17:16context. And as we all know, context is
- 17:19everything, particularly in news.
- 17:21And so a lot of the traditional ad verification companies really
- 17:28have a keyword blocking core with their clients.
- 17:32I'm also working with a company called Mobian, which is Jonah
- 17:35Goodheart's third venture, maybe 4th.
- 17:39And. Architecture Podcast.
- 17:41Recently or is that great? Yeah, I listened that a week and
- 17:43a half ago. Yeah, it was great.
- 17:45And you know, the, the, the gist of it is what he's doing is he's
- 17:49looking at individual article or page level context and
- 17:53understanding it not just from a suitability standpoint.
- 17:57And we'll get into the difference between safety and
- 17:59suitability, but also from a what he calls personas
- 18:03perspective to try to understand who am I talking to based on
- 18:07their interest in this content. And the technology has evolved
- 18:11and he's, you know, leveraging AI and leveraging, you know,
- 18:13more sophisticated models, not just in news, entertainment,
- 18:16lifestyle, sports, whatever it is.
- 18:18So I can actually reach those audiences that are very
- 18:21passionate about that because to your earlier point, interesting
- 18:25news is growing. We are in a tumultuous period of
- 18:28time. People want to understand the
- 18:31impact of tariffs under day-to-day kitchen table issues.
- 18:34You know, should I be stocking up and stuff comes from abroad
- 18:38because it may go up significantly?
- 18:40Should I accelerate my car purchase?
- 18:42Because these tariffs are really going to change the dynamic.
- 18:45And so you're seeing green shoots in a number verse,
- 18:48particularly young people returning to journalistically
- 18:52driven news sources. These are very valuable.
- 18:55If you think about how hard we've worked as an industry to
- 18:57reach young people, Well, they're actually self selecting
- 19:00in the news. So we need to challenge domain
- 19:06blocking, we need to challenge domain blocking, and we need to
- 19:08challenge keyword blocking. And there are tools out there to
- 19:11do that today, and that unlocks real value for marketers.
- 19:15So it's interesting. So it sounds like you're saying
- 19:17there's been a gradual changing of perspective, let's say, where
- 19:20people are acknowledging, OK, like it was over, you know, some
- 19:24of these massive keyword block lists, these domain level blocks
- 19:29of legit publishers, maybe, maybe that was overzealous.
- 19:32There's an acknowledgement that's happening, but it sounds
- 19:34like the practices haven't caught up with that.
- 19:36Is that fair to say? No, I, I think, I think two
- 19:38things are changing. One, the demand for news, which
- 19:42had been declining is now starting it to to pop up.
- 19:47We saw that before the last general election where, again,
- 19:51young people were moving away from social media as their
- 19:55primary source of news and moving to things, whether it was
- 19:58traditional news sources or podcasts.
- 20:00A lot of people refer to the last election as the podcast
- 20:02election. And there are studies that say
- 20:05more people, more voters got their news from podcasts to the
- 20:09other source. So that's OK because, you know,
- 20:12podcasts are easily rated. And there are a lot of
- 20:15journalists who now have their own podcast as either a side
- 20:17hustle or they've evolved to that.
- 20:20So demand is increasing. On the marketer side, it's it's
- 20:24hand to hand combat. I don't want to diminish the
- 20:27challenge that you have. Marketers sort of looked at the
- 20:31brand safety issue as set and forget and as you know that
- 20:36doesn't work. The culture changes.
- 20:38What's acceptable today might not have been acceptable two or
- 20:42three years ago. We're constantly seeing the
- 20:47content of time in consumers consume facts, right?
- 20:53And so you really need to make it a more dynamic practice.
- 20:56I was very fortunate, Bank of America, that my boss really
- 21:00believed in the importance of setting up a branch safety and
- 21:03suitability practice. And so we were able to take a
- 21:05very senior leader on my team staffer with two other internal
- 21:09resources, build an agency team around her and set some of what
- 21:13I think today, 10 years on, are still some of the best standards
- 21:16out there. And it was I, I think, I think
- 21:19we used more Harvey Balls than any other I've ever been in
- 21:22probably, you know, involved with because we had to really
- 21:25get in the nuance of it. You have to work it to get it
- 21:28right. And on one hand, you're
- 21:29protecting your branch, We're protecting, you're protecting
- 21:32shareholder value. On the other hand, you still
- 21:35want to deliver the growth, the audiences that will drive the
- 21:38growth that news can bring you when you've got it rated
- 21:43correctly. And so now we're in an era where
- 21:46that can be done, but we still have to challenge because if you
- 21:48look at the marketers To Do List, understand what a Gentek
- 21:51AI means to my go to market staff that accordingly rethink
- 21:55my entire marketing stack, rethink my tech stack, explain
- 22:00to new ROI, move to a customer long term value framework.
- 22:04Oh, and I got to fix brand safety and suitability.
- 22:07That's going to be at the bottom of the list.
- 22:09And so you really got to get in there and talk about, hey, this
- 22:12is going to make your media value much your return on
- 22:15investment much better, which natural we've had success.
- 22:19Yeah, it ties back to that unduplicated reach story, right.
- 22:21You know, as long as you prove the value and you've, you've,
- 22:24I've seen you give these presentations, you did it
- 22:25one-on-one of my, my own events at Brave New Worlds, right?
- 22:29The quality of context, right? The quality of audience, the
- 22:33household income, all of that defends what's going to really
- 22:37drive impact for an advertiser. How do you actually get them
- 22:40over that hump, though? Because I think they're going to
- 22:42come back to that notion of, yeah, what about the bias?
- 22:46What about the real article? You know, reliability.
- 22:48Yes, it sounds like it's at the marketer level, like CMO level.
- 22:50This needs to ultimately change the most.
- 22:52Because it is. It is.
- 22:54Change right I. Mean, Yeah, I think there's two
- 22:56ways in. I think the first thing you have
- 22:58to do is to drive reappraisal based on value.
- 23:02And that is, you know, we've been very fortunate to add
- 23:05Fontan's Media, where I also serve as chief strategy officer,
- 23:08where we rate the news on bias and reliability.
- 23:11We've got case studies that very definitely show that is
- 23:15returning to now. We were able to work with
- 23:16companies like The Trade Desk and some of their biggest
- 23:19advertisers. And we now have case studies,
- 23:22one from a financial services company where we created a pre
- 23:25bid segment for them based on their risk appetite for bias and
- 23:29reliability. And everything has some bias.
- 23:31There's, there's virtually no publication out there that isn't
- 23:35a little biased and a certain amount of bias is OK.
- 23:38It's when you get into the extremes that you want to avoid
- 23:42for obvious reasons. And reliability is just another
- 23:45less polarizing way to say truthfulness.
- 23:48And so we look at reliability in a number of dimensions.
- 23:52And we were able to create this pre bid segment for this
- 23:54financial services company and they saw 70% decline, the cost
- 23:59of customer acquisition 70%. And on top of that, their CPM
- 24:05actually went down because news is being sold at a discount
- 24:07today. That won't always be the case, I
- 24:09believe. I believe we'll start to be able
- 24:11to get back to premium pricing for news because it delivers a
- 24:14premium audience. But right now the marketplace
- 24:17dynamics are such is that you can actually really take
- 24:21advantage of the audience. They deliver a lower price than
- 24:25other alternatives like sports, for example, has gone to the
- 24:27road that. Is just crazy.
- 24:28Yeah. Yeah.
- 24:29And by the way, I love the study you put out with that fantas,
- 24:32You know, like Vanessa. Yeah, she's just down the road
- 24:34for me. It was funny.
- 24:35I've been meaning to go to that when her wife has a Brazilian
- 24:38restaurant right if I'm not mistaken.
- 24:40It's phenomenal, I highly recommend it if you love Yeah
- 24:43Brazilian cuisine and they have a lot of fun.
- 24:45I'm on their mailing list now so I get a lot of invites to a lot
- 24:48of fun events every weekend. So little Brazil, it's called.
- 24:51Yeah, yeah. So with that case study, was the
- 24:54were you able to scale that out? Did they double down on that
- 24:56integration with? Yeah.
- 24:58So they've now embraced news and they've returned to it.
- 25:01We've done another one with a movie studio where we had
- 25:03similar results. And it's so easy to do now
- 25:09because we built these pre bid segments in virtually all of the
- 25:14DSPS, we partner with Trade Desk and launching something called
- 25:18News Navigator, which truly makes it so easy for the
- 25:22marketer to experiment with news.
- 25:25And you know, they've got a group of publishers And So what
- 25:29they're doing is they're just with News Navigator, you're
- 25:31adding news inventory to other inventory and you're bidding and
- 25:36marketers are seeing are seeing tremendous, tremendous results.
- 25:40And as a result, you know, we're on revenue soon news publishers
- 25:46in 2025 just from News Navigator alone, because, you know, their
- 25:51CEO and founder, Jeff Green is really committed to the open web
- 25:54and particularly news. And so he invested in technology
- 25:58and others have, you know, not been able to prioritize.
- 26:00Again, everything comes down to prioritization.
- 26:02And, you know, he saw it as almost a civic mission to ensure
- 26:07that, you know, the 4th Estate is vibrant and able to deal with
- 26:12the reality that we're in today. And look, they're on their back
- 26:15foot in a number of fronts. There is a war on truth.
- 26:18And, you know, that call's coming from inside the house.
- 26:21So there's a war on truth, and that call's coming from inside
- 26:23the house. And then you've got the eugenic
- 26:26stuff that you mentioned where it's very hard to discern what
- 26:30is, you know, real quality journalism.
- 26:32And then what is I, this happens to me, I have the YouTube
- 26:35premium product and you know, I'm a military history nut and
- 26:38I'm constantly watching stuff. And I was watching something the
- 26:41other day that had like 4 or 5 facts wrong in the 1st 2 minutes
- 26:45in the comments. And I said, this is terrible.
- 26:48You, I don't know what you're doing.
- 26:50And but you know, it's very clear that was driven by AI.
- 26:53And you know, if you think about journalists and maybe a bit of a
- 26:58grandiose way, they are the Knights of truth.
- 27:01They are on the frontline trying to uncover what the truth is, in
- 27:05some cases at great peril to themselves to ensure that people
- 27:09are informed. And it's not just the electorate
- 27:12at election time, although that's incredibly important.
- 27:14And it's the reason the framers, the Constitution called
- 27:17journalism out in the Bill of Rights, the only profession in
- 27:21the Constitution or the Bill of Rights called out by name
- 27:24because of its important role to ensure that the electorate is
- 27:27for informed and that elected officials are held accountable.
- 27:30But it's just it's the everyday, as I mentioned earlier, the
- 27:33kitchen table issues where people just need to know, what
- 27:36do I do now? Think about, you know, should I
- 27:40send my kid to Harvard if I live in a foreign country?
- 27:44Given all the turmoil right now about, you know, students coming
- 27:48to United States on visas to study, maybe I shouldn't do
- 27:52that. And and that's change, Yeah,
- 27:55many of them are not. And, and I think that's storage
- 27:57detriment. But that's down to Scopus
- 27:58conversation. At the end of the day, news has
- 28:00become more important than ever, and it's a better conduit for
- 28:03marketers to grow the return on their investment.
- 28:06Yeah, that's interesting. I mean, maybe we can pivot a
- 28:09little bit here and talk about, we've talked a lot about
- 28:12programmatic. So maybe a programmatic reality
- 28:14check, we can call it I, you know, I read that you had called
- 28:17it the worst thing and the only salvation for for news media.
- 28:20I find this interesting. We've talked a lot about it on
- 28:22this podcast about how for publishers open exchange CPMS
- 28:27have been very low, many of them under a dollar.
- 28:29How when you look at, you know, the take rate and all that, you
- 28:32know, the tech tax, right, it's less than $0.50 on the dollar
- 28:35ends up in publishers pockets. I think because that we've seen
- 28:39a big push for Drexel deals and other things to, to, to change
- 28:43things a little bit. So love your love to hear what
- 28:46you think about this, what, what can be done to change it.
- 28:49What did you mean by that quote exactly etcetera?
- 28:51Yeah. So the actual quote that I've
- 28:53been saying for about almost a decade now is that programmatic
- 28:58is the worst thing that ever happened to advertising and it's
- 29:01the only salvation for marketing.
- 29:03And what I mean by that is it's the first and only instance that
- 29:07I'm aware of where marketers get real time signal about where
- 29:12they can put place they're at. And so it allows us to
- 29:17understand context. It allows us to understand much
- 29:20more on an on an almost deterministic level and in real
- 29:25time where my ads are running. I I said to the leadership at
- 29:30Twitter about a decade ago, at some point your data will become
- 29:33more valuable in your ad inventory.
- 29:36And that launched an entire work stream with their data team
- 29:40because the leadership got behind it and we were a little
- 29:42bit ahead of the time, but it was all about real time signal.
- 29:44If you remember, Twitter in its heyday was all about breaking
- 29:49news anywhere in the world. The Arab Spring doesn't happen
- 29:52without Twitter, right? And so if I can understand that
- 29:56immediate context, I know something about the person, what
- 30:02their interests are. If you knew what I, you know,
- 30:04followed, you'd know that I'm a Formula One fanatic.
- 30:07And the only time I go on X now, the only time is for whenever
- 30:11there's a Formula One race that I'm watching live because
- 30:13there's an entire community of friends that I've never met that
- 30:17are all sitting there snarking about why did Ferrari just
- 30:21change to medium tire? You know, like the crazy stuff.
- 30:24That real time signal really tells you.
- 30:26My passion, my interest, my ability to be receptive to a
- 30:30message, your ability to tailor that message using dynamic
- 30:34content optimization so that it breaks through the clutter.
- 30:37So it's about the signal and the ad inventory is secondary.
- 30:42But unfortunately, like everything else in this
- 30:44industry, the buyers and their agencies used it as a mechanism
- 30:50to hammer price down and commoditize things.
- 30:53Isn't impressive in a high Canadian news publication worth
- 30:57the same as an impression in a cooking show that's running on
- 31:03YouTube? I would argue it's not.
- 31:06I would argue on a number of factors, including latency.
- 31:09I mean, if it's a real time news thing, you know a lot more about
- 31:12me than if I'm watching some video on demand about how to
- 31:15make, you know, Chateau brillant.
- 31:19So I think if we want the era of AI to finally get there.
- 31:26And I, I found this great quote a couple of weeks ago.
- 31:28I'm not going to quote, and I said it to the former Twitter
- 31:31leadership via text, all the guys that were involved in
- 31:35approving, you know, this experiment that we were doing
- 31:38with them. We were just a little too early
- 31:40guys. And, and it was a very clear
- 31:42argument that look with AI third party data signal is begun is
- 31:49going to become vital to marketers.
- 31:51You hear a lot about first party data and everybody is
- 31:54weaponizing their first party data.
- 31:56But at the end of the day, most of the first party data that I
- 32:01have is very, very similar to the first party data that my
- 32:05biggest competitor has. And so I look at first party
- 32:08data and an analogy of the kitchen as salt and pepper, very
- 32:12important on the kitchen table, helps flavor the food, etcetera.
- 32:16But the kitchen, they have a whole spice rack full of
- 32:20Rosemary and thyme and turmeric and basil and sage.
- 32:25That's third party did that. Third party did it tells me what
- 32:28I meant, what people are interested in what they're doing
- 32:32right now. Gives me signal to A to to a
- 32:35penned by creative so that it's hyper resonant.
- 32:38The great Rob Norman is fond of. He said this to me.
- 32:41Wow, a decade ago, he said, I fear that the end of the four,
- 32:47the we're reaching the end of the forced fueling economy.
- 32:49The idea that you would you would trade attention to a
- 32:52commercial for access to content.
- 32:54And again, this was a decade ago and and, and you know, if you
- 32:57play that out, you therefore must engineer relevance into
- 33:00every interaction. So how can I make this ad more
- 33:03relevant in this situation? So the person stops what they're
- 33:06doing and engages my ad, and we now have the ability to do that.
- 33:10Programmatic signal interpreted by AI and served by dynamic
- 33:14creative in real time allows me to win the moment, right?
- 33:19Every impression is an opportunity to make a good
- 33:22impression. I think if you combine the
- 33:24contextual signal with that too, it becomes pretty interesting.
- 33:26Maybe that's, you know, what's something that X, you know, X
- 33:28can do, right? I mean, it's, I've always
- 33:30thought that advertising products are just so
- 33:31unimpressive, right? I mean, I've never bought
- 33:33anything that I've seen on seen there, but you know, I compared
- 33:36that to to Facebook. I'm not embarrassed to say I
- 33:39actually have bought a lot of stuff because of Facebook ads,
- 33:41right, that have been super highly targeted and apparently
- 33:43they have plenty of intense signal, right, because they were
- 33:46able to serve me up things I ended up being interested in.
- 33:48And you know, and I think X has always been more, I mean, I, I
- 33:53look at the ads there, they're more upper funnel right
- 33:55awareness. So maybe they can do that.
- 33:57Maybe pulling in 3rd party signals can do it, I don't know,
- 34:00but they haven't cracked the. Code.
- 34:01I don't think X is going to be focused on ads in the future.
- 34:04I think very clear signal the departure of Lindy Acurino and
- 34:09the fact that X got folded into XAII think X to Elon represents
- 34:16a feeding mechanism to rock so that he'll understand behaviors,
- 34:22he'll be able to use it as a training model.
- 34:26And I just, you know, he, I think he raised $16 billion for
- 34:30XAI. And, and I think that at it's at
- 34:34it's height under Elon X ads was returning about 2 1/2 billion
- 34:40dollars. So I think he's willing to walk
- 34:42away from ads and just focus on it as signals of intent or
- 34:47interest for my AI product. And I don't think it's a good
- 34:50proxy for where the industry is going.
- 34:53But I think everywhere else, yeah, people are going to start
- 34:56to realize marketer, excuse me, publishers are going to start to
- 35:00realize I have this wealth of signal that I can actually
- 35:05leverage, which in most cases has some uniqueness to it.
- 35:09And the more that publishers start to think about what can I
- 35:13do with this unique signal, whether it's geographic, whether
- 35:17it's contextual, whether it's intent or interest, all of those
- 35:22things are going to require some craftsmanship.
- 35:25But in order to combat this era where we're moving from search
- 35:29to solutions or answers, where people aren't visiting the page
- 35:32and referral traffic is going to go to 0.
- 35:34As Nick Thompson said at The Atlantic a couple months ago, he
- 35:37pulled his team together and said it's going to go to zero.
- 35:40Well, it was 0 before Google. And so now you're going to have
- 35:45to build demand and demand is going to have to come from the
- 35:47consumer with great content, great editorial.
- 35:51And we all have subscriptions, probably too many of them of
- 35:54things that we read because the content is great.
- 35:57But then great intrepidity, great entrepreneurialism in
- 36:01terms of what we do with the signal that we get and how we
- 36:04breakthrough the marketers. And I think it's going to
- 36:06radically decommoditize the industry, might be a challenge
- 36:10for currency, but I don't think it's going to be a challenge for
- 36:14marketers who really want to be more relevant and engineer
- 36:17relevance into every one of their impressions.
- 36:21Looking at signal, looking at relevance, right, I mean, just I
- 36:24think one challenge for publishers has been, OK, we have
- 36:27signal, we have great audience. So we have great, we have, we
- 36:30have all these assets, but how do we actually package this up
- 36:34to get brands to get CMOS, to get marketers to get agencies,
- 36:37they're doing the buying interested in this.
- 36:39And I think a lot of it comes down to direct sales.
- 36:41What do you think publishers need to do in order to be better
- 36:45at direct sold campaigns? We see they're getting higher
- 36:47prices, better CPMS, they're keeping more, they're keeping
- 36:51more of the of every dollar. What do you think they need to
- 36:54do to get better with this? They need to hone their
- 36:58narrative. I think that a lot of publishers
- 37:00tend to have a one-size-fits-all.
- 37:03It's almost like a media kit from 25 years ago.
- 37:06And they spent a lot of time talking about their editorial
- 37:10content, as they should, and the unique position in that regard
- 37:16and the number of people and surprises they might have or
- 37:18whatnot. But I think they need to
- 37:20actually, for every calorie they put into that side of the
- 37:23narrative, put another calorie into data and insights, right?
- 37:29You know, there's a few people out there in the industry, I
- 37:31think of Edwin Wong, who recently left Fox to go over to
- 37:34Uber ads, who have spent your entire career doing that is
- 37:37mining this rich cornucopia. And you know, if you talk to a
- 37:41typical CRO, they're going to say, Gee, is that really worth
- 37:45the round trip? But I think there's a modern
- 37:49group of CRO's that are recognizing that our value, our
- 37:52differentiated value is a combination of the great
- 37:55customer, consumer or reader experience that we create and
- 38:00the great insight that we have about them, which is more
- 38:04actionable. It's not like a comScore
- 38:06insight. There's nothing wrong with
- 38:07comScore, but you know, I don't want to, I don't necessarily
- 38:10need to know that our readers are three times more wealthy
- 38:13than the average reader. But yeah, that sounds like an
- 38:15old radio ranker report. If you're about radio, every
- 38:18single radio salesperson comes to your office with a ranker
- 38:21report that says we're number one in 2:00 AM to 4:00 AM day
- 38:26part in this market. Yeah, and and and they kind of
- 38:29lose credibility. No, it's like, what are you
- 38:32doing with data science? How are you helping me connect
- 38:35to my audience? What is your, you know, your
- 38:38strategy working with, you know, the the infosomes of the world
- 38:43or the live ramps of the world to really connect your signal in
- 38:47a deterministic but highly Safeway to my signal so that we
- 38:51can deliver better experiences. How can I measure differently on
- 38:55your platform? Right.
- 38:56So it's becoming much more adept at the science of digital
- 39:02marketing. And I mean, digital.
- 39:04You said earlier that we've lost a lot of newspapers in this
- 39:07country, particularly locally. And we have, I'm more concerned
- 39:11about news platforms. And most of those local news
- 39:13platforms started out as newspapers, but today they're
- 39:17valued. The community is more digital
- 39:20than print. And I think we have to accept
- 39:22that. You know, I still get the New
- 39:26York Times delivered to my door because I'm old school and I
- 39:28like to thumb through it. But I read a lot of other
- 39:30publications online now and I'm some point, I'm sure Brett will
- 39:35go away, but local news won't. And so like, that's wonderful.
- 39:40If you think about the importance of data signal, you
- 39:43get a lot more data signal as a publisher in a digital
- 39:46environment than you do in print, right?
- 39:49So I think it's weaponizing the data in a full throated way,
- 39:55hiring more data scientists to do that, doing more data
- 39:59partnerships and maybe not just talking to the buyers and a
- 40:04client only. My biggest and most important
- 40:07partner at Bank of America was the chief analytics officer.
- 40:11And she and I work together to really understand at a very
- 40:14granular level, OK, what are we delivering?
- 40:18How can we take advantage of this signal?
- 40:21Is it valid our permissions there?
- 40:23Do we have the right governance model in place?
- 40:25And are we creating experiences that really breakthrough?
- 40:28And in those days, we really didn't have dynamic creative
- 40:30optimization. It was more of a manual process
- 40:33where we were looking for, at the end of the day, more bespoke
- 40:37allies that could be more tightly targeted.
- 40:40That was four years ago. The sophistication of what we
- 40:43can do now is so much better than that.
- 40:45But publishers need to pivot because what they've been
- 40:49selling isn't working, and what they could be selling would be a
- 40:54renaissance of revenue. Yeah.
- 40:56Well, and, and so to me, that is the crux of how you ensure fair
- 40:59compensation, fair value, willingness to pay, right?
- 41:03Because as you enrich your data at the at the publisher level,
- 41:06it's more valuable, right? Because you're able to more
- 41:09hyper personalized content, optimized hyper target
- 41:13audiences, right? Which gives the publisher
- 41:15leverage to say this is worth more than you may think it is.
- 41:18Moving them out to prove it out right.
- 41:20Yeah, move them out of the commodity zone.
- 41:22So you wrote a really good article.
- 41:23This might be a good pivot to which I which I love when you
- 41:27talk about preserving the vitality of the open web.
- 41:29You referenced it in your your question before last right as we
- 41:32search as we move from an era of search to to one of answers.
- 41:36You had a really good sub stack article called Beyond IP
- 41:38Protection, the risk of losing context in the AI era and.
- 41:42One of 10 people who read it. Thank you.
- 41:44So I was like, oh, Lou's got a sub stack.
- 41:47Let me let me check this out. So a part of it was, was tied to
- 41:49fair compensation and you're and you're, you're.
- 41:52Let me see if I can summarize. The thesis here is that you
- 41:54talked about cloud Cloudflare, which we, we referenced a couple
- 41:58of minutes ago. And, and you basically said, I
- 42:00think we're going to solve this through a combination of
- 42:02technology, potentially industry regulation.
- 42:05Those things in combination will help us solve sort of some of
- 42:08the brand safety issues to ensure that that publishers
- 42:13well, brain safety, but also LLM issues, right, of not being
- 42:18fairly compensated as a publisher for your content
- 42:21that's being scraped by the LLMS. But you, you kind of said
- 42:25that that's a like in Maslow's terms, that's like that's a need
- 42:29that you need to to fulfill. But there's a bigger problem at
- 42:33stake here. And this is when you really laid
- 42:35out this, this idea of losing context and nuance, right?
- 42:40When AI becomes your content source or a lot of consumers
- 42:43content source, right? They're just doing these black
- 42:46and white summaries that take out sort of the empathy, the
- 42:49reason why we're, you know, can you dive into that?
- 42:52Because I thought that was pretty fascinating.
- 42:54Yeah, and warning to your viewers, this is going to get a
- 42:56little wonky, so. Forgive me.
- 42:59Like it, Lou? Well, I so the piece I wrote,
- 43:03which I was very passionate about, was in response to this
- 43:07Cloudflare announcement. I'm scraping content from
- 43:15publishers of any kind and then incorporating it into their
- 43:19answer environment. And I started to think about
- 43:24that. I'm like, OK, this is a
- 43:25necessary first step. It is stopping the theft of
- 43:30content, theft of content. But in and of itself, it's
- 43:35insufficient. Once you stop the theft, then
- 43:39you've got to have the monetization and and let's be
- 43:41honest, you know, I think increasingly people are going to
- 43:45turn, you know, in my case, perplexity is, you know, my new
- 43:50Google. I very, very rarely use Google.
- 43:52I use perplexity for everything. Yeah, I'm.
- 43:54With you on that. Yeah, it's just I get AI get a
- 43:57fulsome answer and they are decent about putting footnotes
- 44:01back to the sources, but that doesn't include monetization.
- 44:05And so I think people are just going, I think it's, you know,
- 44:08it's the easy button, forget the answer where I don't have to go
- 44:11to a bunch of links to really form my own opinion.
- 44:14And while that's unfortunate when you talk about referral
- 44:17traffic and journalism, I also think it's the new reality we
- 44:21need to deal with. And so publishers need to get
- 44:26fair value for their work. And I think that's going to be
- 44:28really hard because fair value for the work has to recognize
- 44:33the sort of lifetime value of that content inside of the
- 44:36perplexity engine right there. Perplexity is going to use that
- 44:40information over and over and over and over again.
- 44:44So how do you decay that over time?
- 44:46You know, New York Times. Too, right, They're going to
- 44:49need the updated fresh and they've got to be published
- 44:51their so sure validated Fact Check content, right?
- 44:54I mean, it's gold. But but it but but it calls for
- 44:57like a pay scale that is dynamic.
- 44:59And just overtime, right there was a lot of great press about
- 45:04the New York Times striking a deal with Amazon for $20 million
- 45:07so Amazon could leverage New York Times content.
- 45:10And, you know, the New York Times, Meredith Coppet Levy
- 45:13under CEO, who I've known forever, always on their front
- 45:16foot in this space. I'm not sure that's the right
- 45:19number. I don't need what it is.
- 45:21You know what the right number is.
- 45:24But over time, Anana believes that that information might be
- 45:28worth more than $20 million, which is a drop in the drop in
- 45:31the bucket. Yeah.
- 45:33And so we've got to get to fair monetization, which I think is
- 45:36going to take some experimentation.
- 45:39The music industry went through this about 80 years ago with the
- 45:42rights management. And you know, the Foley editor
- 45:44gets this and the. Gets this.
- 45:51Yeah, and it's messy and I think we have to get there because if
- 45:55the LLMS don't have original content to scrape, then they run
- 45:58out of fuel, right? So they need to make sure that
- 46:01the ecosystem is healthy. And at the same time, the
- 46:04ecosystem needs to defend the content, negotiate for the
- 46:08content. But what I was really trying to
- 46:09get at my piece and Brett, thank you for really thank you for
- 46:12reading it and getting there is that in all of that, what I
- 46:16found is that the answers that you get in any, you know, Chachi
- 46:20PTI, use them all. I have subscription to everyone.
- 46:24Claude perplexity, they tend to boil it down to sort of the
- 46:29dragnet answer, just the facts, ma'am, just the fact.
- 46:33In any event, they they strip away the context, the nuance,
- 46:37the back story. And I see that as a loss on
- 46:40several levels. First and foremost, that back
- 46:43story really helps me to understand a lot of the dynamics
- 46:47that what we're seeing, right? Like, it avoids this sort of
- 46:50work where we seem to go in our culture, which is an ad hominem
- 46:53attack. Well, I don't agree with this
- 46:55person. Why not?
- 46:56Well, I don't like that person. Well, do you understand why
- 46:58they're taking that position? No, I don't.
- 47:00I just don't like that. Regardless of the facts, right?
- 47:05Regardless of the facts, it's a factoring conversation, and that
- 47:08seems to lead to the ultimate problem that I think we're
- 47:10facing in our culture, which is polarization.
- 47:13If I can't create at least a bit of understanding about why I got
- 47:18to this conclusion, and it's unlikely that you're going to
- 47:22have any empathy for me. And, you know, in an ideal
- 47:25world, I might say, Gee, Brett, I disagree with you greatly on
- 47:28this topic, but I really respect your reasoning on how you got
- 47:31there. And that empathy creates a
- 47:34greater perspective. And it makes it harder for me to
- 47:37say I'm going to like Brett. Yeah, because at least now I
- 47:41have respect for him. And so when I'm flying and I'm
- 47:45struggling with the articulation of this, as you can tell, I'm
- 47:48trying to make the case for original content.
- 47:52And again, not just journalism, but journalism is a great
- 47:54example here because journalists semaphore does this really well.
- 47:58They'll give you the counter argument, they'll give you
- 48:01expert opinion. And it's all, it's all labeled
- 48:04in very clear ways so that you can really consume the content
- 48:07and say, all right, I understand what's going on.
- 48:09I understand the back story, I understand the counter argument
- 48:12and I'm more well and sound and a well informed electorate is
- 48:17what the Bill of Rights asked for in the Constitution of the
- 48:20United States. And so I'm hoping that the the
- 48:23oligarchs who all have their own LLMS, their own AI solutions
- 48:28will recognize the importance of this.
- 48:31Jeff Bezos owns the Washington Post.
- 48:34You know, I think that I I genuinely want to believe
- 48:39oligarchs for good is a is something, you know, that could
- 48:43be a thing. Certainly Lorraine Powell Jobs
- 48:45and what she's done with the Atlantic, you have to say, wow,
- 48:48she's been great. I think Marc Benioff has been
- 48:50great for time. I think up until this
- 48:55administration, Bezos was really an ardent supporter of the Post.
- 48:59I think he's had to adapt a little bit to survive the
- 49:02current climate. But at the end of the day, we
- 49:07need to find a balance between just the answer and the
- 49:10important context. So I, when you said well
- 49:13informed, it seems to me that most of the social media, the
- 49:16digital platforms that were involved with on a day-to-day
- 49:19basis, it's less about well informed and more about well
- 49:21engaged, right? The algorithmic logic's all
- 49:24about keeping you in tune and feeding you more information.
- 49:28That's like the information that you just ingested and engaged
- 49:31with and people like you ingested and engaged with.
- 49:34So they're taking all that signal and they're saying we're
- 49:36going to just drive hyper engagement.
- 49:39Like you see it with teenagers, right?
- 49:41They just go down these sort of paths where it's like, what are
- 49:43you looking at on TikTok? Well, it's, it's the it's rigged
- 49:47to encourage engagement versus they.
- 49:50Call the strategy, engage and enrage.
- 49:53OK. And it's and it's the most
- 49:54provocative, the stuff that makes you angry, that gets you
- 49:57more engaged. If you think about social media,
- 50:01you know, the comments are always you're a idiot, you know,
- 50:04whatever, it's not. GI told you.
- 50:08Yeah. Especially on X Yeah, actually
- 50:11one of the one of the pro bono clients that I'm working with is
- 50:14a new social platform called Spread, and I highly recommend
- 50:18it. Spread does not allow you to
- 50:19comment. It only allows you to share
- 50:21content. And at first I was very much
- 50:23against that because, you know, as a marketer, I was LinkedIn to
- 50:28market and by taking articles I think are interesting, writing
- 50:33two or three sentences on top of them and sharing them with my
- 50:35followers. So it's it's part of my
- 50:37marketing strategy. Spread doesn't let me do that,
- 50:39but I really love going to Spread now because the people I
- 50:42follow on the platform, and they've done a wonderful job of
- 50:45of recruiting journalists to the platform and the journalists
- 50:48like Ann Applebaum are constantly posting their own
- 50:51content. And so it's a curated
- 50:53environment. It's like what Twitter used to
- 50:54be in its heyday, A curated environment of content I want to
- 50:58consume. Yeah, and you're not falling
- 51:00into the doom scrolling loop I guess.
- 51:03It's factory map lifting. And so I think that the business
- 51:07challenge for the social platforms is how do I get out of
- 51:13the business of enraging my people in order to keep them
- 51:16engaged. And you know, they become less
- 51:18important to news. Most of the major platforms have
- 51:20moved away from news in any any kind of meaningful way.
- 51:25And you know, they give very when they do have news in the
- 51:28platform. The Rev share is terrible.
- 51:30It's terrible. It's terrible.
- 51:33I mean, yeah, they're safety billions of dollars a year.
- 51:36Apple News gives $0.70 out of every dollar back to publisher.
- 51:39No other social, no social platform come close that doesn't
- 51:43believe in the importance of news.
- 51:45So I think we've got a lot of luck to do in this space.
- 51:49I think that there's going to be experimentation, turmoil, more
- 51:53heartbreak. I think it's going to be
- 51:54Darwinian, but at the end of the day.
- 51:57Darwinian, not not Orwellian. You think it could be both?
- 52:01Yeah, I guess I had a question and, and, or comment, right.
- 52:03I mean, I think it's interesting about, I mean, I think Lou
- 52:06telling publishers you should be striking deals with the with the
- 52:10AI companies that are creating new LLMS because they need your
- 52:12content. You should they they should be
- 52:14paying you. And then you look at the amounts
- 52:15of deals, 20,000,030 million maybe it seems like a lot for
- 52:18the times, but you know, for Amazon, it's nothing, right.
- 52:21But I think part of the problem too is when you look at the the
- 52:24AI companies like value capture, right?
- 52:27Like they're making people are using them, but like I'm paying
- 52:29them 20 bucks a month, right? So they're really not profitable
- 52:33yet. So I think they should be
- 52:34hammering out deals. I think it should be.
- 52:36I think that will be part of the publisher business model in the
- 52:38future. I believe that.
- 52:39But I think that that's only going to be one piece of the
- 52:41publisher business model. If they hang their hat and oh,
- 52:44that that revenue stream from licensing content is going to
- 52:47save us. I don't think it's going to be
- 52:48enough, right? I don't disagree.
- 52:50I don't disagree. I do think on the one hand,
- 52:54there's no future where these AI platforms are not going to have
- 52:59advertising revenue as part of their growth agenda.
- 53:03You know, it's the same thing that we saw in the streaming
- 53:06services early on. Oh, we'll never take ads.
- 53:09Yeah, guess what never comes quickly.
- 53:12It's the Eric Suford quote, right?
- 53:14Everything. Is an ad network.
- 53:16Everything is an ad network. So how do you prevent it from
- 53:19making some of the kind of stumbling on the scene stumbling
- 53:22blocks as we experienced in other, like in programmatic
- 53:25media as a result, right as they move towards advertising CTV,
- 53:29same thing. How do you make CTV advertise in
- 53:32a way that's not as annoying and disruptive and interruptive as
- 53:35linear television? I think you, I think you got to
- 53:38start with confidence that right now is fleeting in CTV.
- 53:42You've got a premier audience, you've got a favorable ad to ad
- 53:45ratio in comparison to all other media right now.
- 53:49And you should be able to command a price premium because
- 53:52of the data exhaust, because of the fact that you've got login
- 53:55viewers. And with the right privacy
- 53:57policies in place, you can leverage that insight and create
- 54:01a much more relevant ad for that environment.
- 54:05But you've got to recognize as an advertiser that if we turn
- 54:10this into another race to the bottom where, you know, I'm
- 54:13going to go with anybody who's CPM is 2 cents lower than yours.
- 54:18And you know, by the way, I worked for five CMOS in my
- 54:21career and always in an investment role in media.
- 54:26I was never asked anything about CPM.
- 54:30What they want to know is did you deliver your business goals,
- 54:35customers, new growth, whatever it might be, brand favorability,
- 54:38and did you stay in budget? Yep.
- 54:40Let me ask you, where do you want your bonus at?
- 54:43You know it's it's not about CPM.
- 54:45We CPM is a very bad and horribly gained KPI.
- 54:52If you ever spending time with Adam Heimlich, CEO of and
- 54:54founder of Chalice, you know it's a ridiculous, ridiculous
- 54:59KPI and everybody's gaming it. Yeah, and.
- 55:04Never short of opinions. Yeah, for sure.
- 55:06Well, in a low CPM rate could also be a red flag.
- 55:09It could be that, hey, if I'm paying this low CPM for CTV,
- 55:14it's not appearing on the television glass.
- 55:16It might be appearing on mobile. It might be fraudulent.
- 55:20It might not be appearing at all.
- 55:22I think, you know, out of the ability.
- 55:24Yeah. I mean, there's a lot of packing
- 55:25peanuts in there if it's a low CPM and you shouldn't be buying
- 55:28packing peanuts, right? But I think this gets out of
- 55:30like who's doing the buying and I think this has been one of the
- 55:32challenges. So, OK, the brands have been
- 55:34historically very concerned about it.
- 55:36So I do think that I've seen, I've noticed some changes at CMO
- 55:39level, OK, maybe we should be advertising, but then you've got
- 55:42the technology that's maybe impeded a little bit.
- 55:44But I think the role of the agencies are also important here
- 55:47because they're the ones doing most of the buying, right?
- 55:51So like, like translating what the brand wants, what they're OK
- 55:56with, what type of content they're fine being, having their
- 56:00ad show alongside translating that into the actual blocking
- 56:04and tackling of the buys itself, which are a lot of times done by
- 56:06agencies. I mean, it's like you have an
- 56:08intermediary in there representing the brand doing
- 56:11this. Do you think that slowed down
- 56:13this kind of, I think transition back to being comfortable with
- 56:16advertising? Look, as someone who spent their
- 56:19entire career relying on agencies, I am a big fan of
- 56:23agencies. I would not be sitting here
- 56:25talking to two of you without them.
- 56:26I'm trying to eat valet parking your car out front.
- 56:31Being said that, there have been some big disintermediation
- 56:35moments between the agency and the brand marketer.
- 56:39The first one comes from the area of procurement.
- 56:43So when I was at American Express, I had a great mind
- 56:47chair team. And one day the head of the mind
- 56:50chair team called me and said, hey, your head procurement was
- 56:53just in here. And he told us to ignore
- 56:55everything you said and simply try to get 10% more inventory
- 57:01for 5% less cost. And you know, Brett, as you
- 57:04know, in my youth, I was a hot head and I went storming up to
- 57:09the CM OS office like I need to see now, you know, And
- 57:14fortunately, RCMO, who is very charismatic, called the
- 57:18programmatic guy's boss's boss's boss and clarified my role
- 57:23versus programmatics role. But it is a parable, 99% of
- 57:28times it doesn't happen. So you've got an agency who is,
- 57:31you know, bonus which is a materially material part of
- 57:35their compensation in most models now is highly tied to
- 57:38efficient acquisition of media. Yep.
- 57:41And the procurement person is the one who is blessing that
- 57:45number. And if you as ACMO have not
- 57:48wrangled procurement and agreed that low cost CPM is not the
- 57:54metric, but how about reducing the cost of customer
- 57:57acquisition? That could be a metric, right?
- 58:00And that one is not really gainable.
- 58:02We got this many new new customers for media and we spent
- 58:05this much on media. Therefore, 1 divided by the
- 58:08other equals cost per customer. So we need to get off these
- 58:12really bad proxies that tend to commoditize and not recognize
- 58:16value. I think the second
- 58:18disintermediation that's happened has been, and I'm going
- 58:21to tell a short story here. A few years ago, David Stable
- 58:25invited me to go up to his office and visit him when he was
- 58:28moving out of three Columbus Circle, the WPP offices there.
- 58:33And so we were talking and, you know, it was late in the day and
- 58:37so I asked him. I said, you know, what's the
- 58:38biggest change you've seen in your very storied career about,
- 58:43you know, marketing as a display?
- 58:45He said, I'll tell you what, when I started in this business,
- 58:48the agencies were being asked in by the CEO and being asked
- 58:52questions like what new products should we launch?
- 58:56What kind of people should we be hiring?
- 58:58Where should we put our next store?
- 59:01Really? You know, the question is that
- 59:03go well beyond how we think about agencies in 2025.
- 59:08And then he said, you know, today we're lucky if we see the
- 59:11CMOA couple three times a year. And what's happened is the
- 59:16agencies have been sort of squeezed out of the C-Suite and
- 59:21seem to be the proxies for the CMO.
- 59:25The CMO who's having a difficult time articulating the return on
- 59:29investment of marketing and many more have been receiving their
- 59:32community as a cost center as a result and not the investment
- 59:35center that it is. And they've been replaced by
- 59:39consultancies, McKenzie, Accenture, Bain, BCG, all of
- 59:46which are whispering in the ears of the rest of the C-Suite debt.
- 59:51I'm not sure your marketing is effective.
- 59:53I'm not sure your marketing agencies really understand where
- 59:57the puck is going. And so they've lost influence in
- 1:00:00the C-Suite, which is is terrible because, you know,
- 1:00:04consultancies do many things well and they have an invaluable
- 1:00:08role in helping, you know, facilitate change.
- 1:00:11They don't build, they don't build capability.
- 1:00:13So my, my, my agency is my go to market capability.
- 1:00:17And I need to partner with them. I need to let them make a fair
- 1:00:20profit. They need to be transparent with
- 1:00:23me about where that profit is coming from.
- 1:00:25I don't like principle based media, but it's becoming
- 1:00:27increasingly the norm. That's another conversation.
- 1:00:30But at the end of the day, we we've got to recognize as
- 1:00:34marketers that the agency needs a clear brief and not a conflict
- 1:00:39with programmatic. And they need to be our partner
- 1:00:43in innovation. And that innovation is messy,
- 1:00:45and often times money gets wasted in the pursuit of
- 1:00:49learning. That's OK.
- 1:00:50And we need to tell them that's OK as long as we're building for
- 1:00:53the future and we're not slavishly, you know, committed
- 1:00:57to a past which is rapidly disappearing.
- 1:01:00Yeah, it's interesting. I mean, I don't think agencies
- 1:01:02are really part of the problem, but I think they're part of the
- 1:01:04solution, right. I think that you really they
- 1:01:06need to be on board with this in order to accelerate this kind of
- 1:01:09OK, we're comfortable advertising on new sites again,
- 1:01:12how we want to change our the way we're looking at brand
- 1:01:15safety, brand suitability. That's interesting too.
- 1:01:17I mean the role of procurement, I've seen some like crazy like I
- 1:01:20saw one RFPA few years ago where procurement said we don't expect
- 1:01:24any margin immediately. We expect you're going to find
- 1:01:26it somehow. I mean like that's your race to
- 1:01:28the bottom. And I saw another where a big
- 1:01:29company was trying to outsource all their ad buying offshore
- 1:01:33because they thought it would be lower cost.
- 1:01:35I mean like just makes no sense to me.
- 1:01:38So, yeah. And then you have, you have some
- 1:01:40clients are going for 180 day payment terms.
- 1:01:42There's no other industry in the world that goes to 180 day
- 1:01:45payment. And that's just take 180 day
- 1:01:48payment terms tell you that. No.
- 1:01:50And so the agency has to front, front front the client who has
- 1:01:53plenty of money in most cases. So look, I think generalizations
- 1:01:57are generally bad and I think in some cases agencies are part of
- 1:02:00the problem. I think in all cases they should
- 1:02:03be part of the solution. But we need to get closer.
- 1:02:05We as marketers need to get closer to our agency and not
- 1:02:08trust the top of the house. What I found is when you're
- 1:02:12talking to our horsey Dune at at publicist, when you're talking
- 1:02:18to Brian Lesser at WPP Media, there is tremendous alignment.
- 1:02:24Yes, we're philosophically aligned.
- 1:02:26It's the mid level that often doesn't get the brief, they're
- 1:02:30still down there trying to buy based on price and not
- 1:02:33understanding where the park is going.
- 1:02:35And so I, I, one of the things I, I've learned in my
- 1:02:37consultancy is to a diagnosed, are we talking to the, what
- 1:02:40people or the, how people? The, what people are typically
- 1:02:43the senior ones who have a vision for the future, what
- 1:02:47we're going to do in that future and, and, and really want to
- 1:02:50drive differentiation and change to how people generally are
- 1:02:54transactors. They're mid level.
- 1:02:55Their KP is, are very much about, you know, value and
- 1:03:00really measurable, tangible things.
- 1:03:03And they don't care about the ESG agenda.
- 1:03:05They don't care about, you know, diversity.
- 1:03:07They care about performance. And if something is $0.02
- 1:03:10cheaper than the other thing, then we're going to put 100% of
- 1:03:12the budget on that. And that we we need to make sure
- 1:03:14the brief goes through the agency to the people with their
- 1:03:17hands on keyboard. Which sounds like a leadership
- 1:03:19challenge. I think it is.
- 1:03:22I think it is. You know, I was very fortunate
- 1:03:25when I was at Bank of America. We built our own team within
- 1:03:29Publicist called Group Connect, which is still thriving today.
- 1:03:34And everybody was part of the same piano, the teacher
- 1:03:37planning, buying digital measurement, the Epsilon team,
- 1:03:42you name it, We're all one team. And that allowed me to go in and
- 1:03:47meet with them on a more regular and, and comprehensive basis.
- 1:03:50It allowed the leaders of that team to ensure everybody was on
- 1:03:53the same page. And I think that model, which I
- 1:03:57believe is pioneered by Phil Cowdell for Ford many, many
- 1:04:00years ago when he was ACEO of Mindshare, I think that model
- 1:04:07works better for large, large brands, the top 100.
- 1:04:12I think as you get into smaller agencies, it's less of a concern
- 1:04:15because, you know, everybody is more connected to the top of the
- 1:04:19house. But I think you really have to
- 1:04:21diagnose as a client, is my message getting through to all
- 1:04:24levels of the agency? Do they feel empowered?
- 1:04:26Are we on the same mission? And is procurement giving them
- 1:04:30the room to learn, to experiment and to potentially fail in order
- 1:04:35to succeed? Ultimately, predictions for the
- 1:04:37future. Luke, love to hear like, what do
- 1:04:38you like next? Three to five years?
- 1:04:41I mean, maybe that's too far. Things are changing so quickly.
- 1:04:43Where do you see things going? Do you see improving?
- 1:04:46Do you see it getting worse? What do?
- 1:04:47You think? I think it's, I think it's going
- 1:04:50to be Darwinian, as we said earlier, for all sides of the
- 1:04:55ecosystem. I think savvy marketers will
- 1:04:59recognize the magnitude of change and move away from
- 1:05:03certain 20th century ideas like a campaign.
- 1:05:08I think we are now in an era of always on marketing.
- 1:05:13I think we are so connected to the culture and consumers are so
- 1:05:18bombarded with information and advertising that we need to
- 1:05:24almost start like my content team did at Bank of America when
- 1:05:28I was there with a daily standup meeting.
- 1:05:32What's going on in the culture today and how can we take
- 1:05:34advantage of that or how do we avoid getting caught up in that?
- 1:05:39And then we need to leverage new pathways to market dynamic
- 1:05:44creative, creative that comes from a common framework but has
- 1:05:49a custom delivery so that it really breaks through in
- 1:05:52environments. And I think we need to work in
- 1:05:55them. There was a great piece in the
- 1:05:56last three coming up this did today.
- 1:05:58They were covering the MMACEO summit and it was a competitive
- 1:06:03quotes and the end of the quotes that really resonated is that
- 1:06:06Unilever moved from four or five ads in the campaign over 400.
- 1:06:10And I think that's a step in the right direction.
- 1:06:12But I think if we ultimately realized the full potential of
- 1:06:14programmatic media connected to AI driven creative optimization,
- 1:06:18that 400 might become 5000 variants for the same ad in
- 1:06:22order to take advantage of situations it would.
- 1:06:23Have been possible pre AI for sure.
- 1:06:25Yeah. Absolutely, absolutely.
- 1:06:27This is why I think AI is a force for good when harnessed
- 1:06:31correctly. When we stopped talking about
- 1:06:32it, it's like I was going to take my job, which is such a
- 1:06:35tedious conversation. No, it's going to empower you to
- 1:06:38do your job much better. Yep, AI is not going to take
- 1:06:41your job. It's the person who knows how to
- 1:06:43use AI better than you that will.
- 1:06:45It's interesting what dynamic created because that was always
- 1:06:47such a problem, right? Like when we'd advise clients
- 1:06:49you should be doing this and then they said, well, we can't.
- 1:06:52We can't by producing the content, getting it approved,
- 1:06:54getting it. The versions and variations are
- 1:06:56way too difficult. Yep.
- 1:06:58Well, and you guys hit an emotional nerve with me because,
- 1:07:02you know, I spent 3 1/2 decades defending the immediate
- 1:07:05investments in every way. And I, I, I liken it to a
- 1:07:08proctology exam on the telephone pole.
- 1:07:11It's not comfortable, OK, and, and you know, but, but the
- 1:07:15creative was always the exogenous variable.
- 1:07:18Well, we built this campaign to reach, you know, high net worth
- 1:07:22customers, but the creative wasn't ready, so we ran a credit
- 1:07:25card ad instead. Nobody cares.
- 1:07:28Well, it didn't work. Well.
- 1:07:29Well, yeah, because we built the campaign for a completely
- 1:07:31different audience. Yeah, but the media investment
- 1:07:34didn't seem to work. It's like I'm sick and tired of
- 1:07:37creative getting a hall pass. And I think finally, because the
- 1:07:41mark, because the tooling is there and because consumers, you
- 1:07:45know, thumb so fast now that unless you're making hyper
- 1:07:49relevant ads, you have no opportunity to stop them in
- 1:07:52their tracks and engage them. So I think it will be a
- 1:07:56renaissance for creative. But I do think the interesting
- 1:07:59dynamic, and this goes back to the era of Mad Men.
- 1:08:03I think it's going to be the media signal, the data exhaust,
- 1:08:07the ability to weaponize my first party data along with that
- 1:08:10third party media signal that's going to inform that creative
- 1:08:13variation. So you're still going to have an
- 1:08:15ECD and EC is going to say, you know, I think that this year
- 1:08:19these are the major themes that will really breakthrough.
- 1:08:22But then you're going to contextualize it in a very in a
- 1:08:26very discreet way. How to win in this impression in
- 1:08:31CTV on this show on Tuesday of next week, that kind of level of
- 1:08:36detail. So I think that's going to be a
- 1:08:37big change. I think the skill set and the
- 1:08:40orb structure inside of both the marketer, you just see it's
- 1:08:44going to change. You know, I need a lot more
- 1:08:47math. I think you're going to bring
- 1:08:48analytics and media together. I think you have to.
- 1:08:53I think the. Just to go back into media too,
- 1:08:55I think. They break it.
- 1:08:56Down. Everyone did it, but I think
- 1:08:57that that has to happen. I think so too.
- 1:08:59And so I think, and I think that the overriding dynamic is going
- 1:09:02to be real time signal. You know, I love the name of
- 1:09:07this podcast signal and noise because we're going to need to
- 1:09:10make sure that the signal we're getting from third party media
- 1:09:13is quality. You know, the Anas work with
- 1:09:16supply path optimization still shows that one and two
- 1:09:20programmatic impressions are not measurable, non accountable, not
- 1:09:22viewable or made for advertising sites.
- 1:09:26That's not useful signal. So we're going to have to
- 1:09:29prioritize high quality signal that actually allows me to
- 1:09:34understand situational context in order to make my a smarter
- 1:09:39than my AI smarter than my competitors.
- 1:09:41So I think the dynamic will, will change as a result of
- 1:09:46changing out a lot of the roles on the client side.
- 1:09:49And I think, you know, I think this has already happened, but
- 1:09:52I, I think it's worth saying my entire career, the TV 30 or 60,
- 1:09:59I think we're going to stop doing all planning based on the
- 1:10:03new TV creative. And I think we're going to start
- 1:10:06doing audience based planning. And I do think my last comment,
- 1:10:09my last thing that's going to change the way that we do
- 1:10:11segmentation. And the past segmentation was an
- 1:10:14annual, a biannual exercise. It was binary so that if you're
- 1:10:17a multi homeowner, you can't also be a world traveler, when
- 1:10:20in fact we know that that's false.
- 1:10:23But all product development, all audience targeting, all campaign
- 1:10:27measurement was based on that very false, very stale
- 1:10:30segmentation. I think today you can do what is
- 1:10:33effectively real time dynamic segmentation at scale.
- 1:10:37And that signal allows me to understand that there are 50,000
- 1:10:43people in the market today for this product, not to 6,000,000
- 1:10:46that a propensity score would tell me could buy the product
- 1:10:50about 50,000. And one of my clients, my one of
- 1:10:53my interesting clients, Gum Gum is working on exactly that with
- 1:10:57something called the mindset graph, which is really
- 1:10:59understanding what your interest is right now, what is your
- 1:11:01intent and can I tailor my message to match that.
- 1:11:05And so I think we're going to really look at that as almost
- 1:11:08like a daily segmentation schema as opposed to a biannual
- 1:11:11segmentation schema. Looking at segmentation going
- 1:11:14from like annual and also looking at Eminem going from
- 1:11:17this annual process into something more real time on the
- 1:11:19planet I. Was thinking back to the the
- 1:11:21brave new worlds that you spoke at and Michael Kasan was on the
- 1:11:25stage. I think it might have been after
- 1:11:27you and he missed he said he said something that I'd love to
- 1:11:30get an idea when you think about hyper relevance and targeting
- 1:11:33and and limiting your audience down to those specific
- 1:11:36intenders. What about the, the, the brand
- 1:11:37awareness you're trying to drive the Halo effect, the
- 1:11:39serendipitous, he talked about serendipity and how we can't, we
- 1:11:44can't lose that in advertising, which kind of ties back to your
- 1:11:47Mad Men conversation, right? I didn't know I needed a Rolex.
- 1:11:50I wasn't in tender, I wasn't in market.
- 1:11:53I may not even be of the right household income.
- 1:11:55But how do you ensure that you don't eliminate that sort of
- 1:11:58Halo effect of brand awareness building with all of this sort
- 1:12:02of data-driven hyper relevance, hyper targeting, hyper
- 1:12:06segmentation? I think it's a critical question
- 1:12:09and I'm glad you went there as as a lifelong brand marketer,
- 1:12:12I've always felt that there is no difference between the upper
- 1:12:19funnel brand activity and the lower funnel outcomes.
- 1:12:22People see it as like two different disciplines.
- 1:12:24In many cases it's split inside of marketing organizations.
- 1:12:28We tried to prove that to Bank of America for years, for like a
- 1:12:31decade. We just kept showing the data,
- 1:12:34right, how top effects mid effects low.
- 1:12:36And if you eliminate this and focus on your direct mail and
- 1:12:39put 70% of your budget into direct response marketing,
- 1:12:42you're going to have lower ROI, lower, you know, higher cash.
- 1:12:45Short term it might be fine, but it.
- 1:12:46Falls off a Cliff. Yeah.
- 1:12:48Yeah, I, I call it the man stocking.
- 1:12:50You're basically stocking the pond with more demand, right.
- 1:12:52So I think that what you raise, you know, kind of gets into an
- 1:12:57area that's very hot right now, which is sponsorship,
- 1:13:01particularly sports sponsorship, particularly women's sports.
- 1:13:04So I think that's the kind of environment, an example of how
- 1:13:09you maintain your brand messaging, activating those
- 1:13:13sponsorships, which are becoming increasingly important. 10 poles
- 1:13:17inside of a marketing because a lot of the other things have
- 1:13:19gone away from a real time standpoint.
- 1:13:21A lot of the other, you know, prime time isn't what it used to
- 1:13:24be. We've saw like a 2 1/2% decline
- 1:13:26in total spend in the upfronts this year.
- 1:13:31And you know, I think that that trend is likely to continue.
- 1:13:33Cable, it was more like a 10% decline if I'm correct.
- 1:13:37I think it's still going to be around activating my sponsorship
- 1:13:41and then looking at my ESG portfolio, which is still
- 1:13:44important to the marketer. It might not be something they
- 1:13:46talk about as much in the current administration.
- 1:13:50Certainly DE and I seems to be under assault, but at the end of
- 1:13:53the day, the things that we as an enterprise stand for that
- 1:13:57we're passionate about, You know, Bank of America was very
- 1:14:01committed to green bonds. And so, you know, they raised AI
- 1:14:06think it was a $3 billion fund for green bonds.
- 1:14:10Green bonds you lose money on, they're not as profitable, but
- 1:14:12it helps companies. And I remember the very first or
- 1:14:15one of the very first initiatives was helping
- 1:14:17Baltimore become a smart city by helping them elect, you know,
- 1:14:20change the electrical grid so it was more reliable, do other
- 1:14:23things to make the Internet speeds faster and create a, you
- 1:14:26know, an incubator for next Gen. companies.
- 1:14:28And it worked magically. And, you know, Baltimore needed
- 1:14:32a shot in the arm. Well, those kinds of things,
- 1:14:35those stories should be told. Some of that I think is best
- 1:14:38done in content marketing where context also matters.
- 1:14:41And I think increasingly you're going to see more content like
- 1:14:44stories, one in spaces previously occupied by ads.
- 1:14:48The big difference being good content rarely has a Click to
- 1:14:52apply or Click to buy link in it.
- 1:14:55It tells a story and if it's done well, it competes for
- 1:14:58attention. And I know of examples of that.
- 1:15:00But a lot of times content gets Co opted into long form
- 1:15:04advertising and that's not going to win.
- 1:15:06So marketers still need to get the brand out there.
- 1:15:08They still need to position the brand heroically.
- 1:15:11They need to do that for four different constituencies, not
- 1:15:14just customers, but also employees and shareholders and
- 1:15:20board members. Board members can be the
- 1:15:22toughest. Judges and board members are
- 1:15:24some of the toughest when it comes to brand safety and
- 1:15:26suitability. They're the ones that text a
- 1:15:28screenshot to the CEO at 5:30 in the morning saying why is your
- 1:15:32ad running on Breitbart and. Wrong advertisement.
- 1:15:36Why is this running yet? That's the exactly, exactly.
- 1:15:39And so, you know, I think you really need to make sure that
- 1:15:43you're building the brand so it's inoculated from a lot of
- 1:15:48those potential concerns and that people say, I know what
- 1:15:50that brand stands for and that brand represents the same things
- 1:15:52or vies the same things I do. That's what I do.
- 1:15:55As we were running one campaign for a, for the multi dweller
- 1:15:59unit division of a of a telecom member.
- 1:16:01And like they were really clear like when when these conferences
- 1:16:03take place, we want you to be marketing within this Geo fence,
- 1:16:08which is a hotel where all where all the execs were going to be.
- 1:16:10It's so fun how that is in a very important constituency.
- 1:16:13Yeah. How are you doing a frequency
- 1:16:15capping on that? Wow, that's a lot of
- 1:16:18concentration. Yeah, well, they wanted to make
- 1:16:20sure that they they knew their money was being well spent.
- 1:16:24It's funny, yeah. I think that I think that's a
- 1:16:26good way to end. And thank you, Lou for joining
- 1:16:30us on Signal and Noise. This was a phenomenal
- 1:16:32conversation. Appreciate the time as always.
- 1:16:34You, you we went well over, but I'm sure our listener base is
- 1:16:38going to be thrilled to hear the the detail because I think we
- 1:16:41went pretty deep in a couple of different areas, so.
- 1:16:43We did. And I really appreciate the
- 1:16:45forum where where you know, 2 of you have so much experience with
- 1:16:48this. So it's easy to make that have
- 1:16:50that conversation. And I really appreciate the
- 1:16:52opportunity and I, I hope, I hope your listeners do as well.
- 1:16:56Thanks again.