Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: Floating Offshore Wind 2025
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to energy Voice out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:05podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:09the UK energy market. This week myself and my
- 0:14colleague Michael Bear have been on the show floor at the
- 0:18floating offshore wind Conference 2025 here in
- 0:22Aberdeen. I'm Aberdeen Features lead Ryan
- 0:25Duff and to start things off, I was speaking to Stephen Bull of
- 0:30VAR Vargron and Barry McLeod of Flotation Energy about Green
- 0:36Volt and how likely it is to go ahead in the wake of Sea Knock
- 0:41stepping away from electrification.
- 0:43So the big question in the room, I don't think it was quite
- 0:46touched on there. We touched on oil and gas, but
- 0:48Sea Knock, we didn't really get into the nitty gritty.
- 0:51What's next for you guys? You're going to have to look for
- 0:53an off take agreement. Are you still engaging with Sea
- 0:56Knock or is there other developers that's going ahead?
- 0:59I'll go to you on that one. Yeah, I think it's not a
- 1:02surprise to us what's happened with the position, with scenic.
- 1:06You know, I think as I said in the in, in the conference
- 1:09session earlier, there's a big challenge with the oil and gas
- 1:12sector at the moment. You know, they're really
- 1:15struggling with the energy profits levy, the fiscal regime,
- 1:19you know, the, the, the, the EIA, the Finch requirements.
- 1:24You know, there's, there's a, there's a, there's a big,
- 1:27there's a big challenge on oil and gas and we, we recognise
- 1:30that. And so for some of the operators
- 1:32to say, look, we're gonna, we need to pull back from this just
- 1:35now. That's only natural scenic
- 1:38weren't the only operator that we're talking to.
- 1:40You know, we've, we've continued had very good engagement across
- 1:43the the oil and gas operators and you know, we have to wait
- 1:46and see when the time is right. And, and right now with the the
- 1:49challenge that they're under that that's, it's just not the
- 1:52timing for them. But we need to press ahead
- 1:54anyway. We've got responsibilities to
- 1:56deliver the Greenville project with the CFD.
- 1:59So, you know, it's, it's, it's good that we can do that.
- 2:03But does that create leasing issues?
- 2:05Stephen, I'll go to you on this one.
- 2:08You got a TOG project targeted oil and gas.
- 2:11Surely part of that lease is specifically finding an off
- 2:14taker for oil and gas? Or is there a way around that to
- 2:18sort of go all power to shore if you can't find someone to off
- 2:21take I? Think as Barry said, oil and gas
- 2:24itself and electrification is, is a tricky business case.
- 2:27It's it's tough for now, obviously with low oil prices as
- 2:29well. Even in Norway, it's got the
- 2:31world's highest offshore tax regime and they can't make
- 2:34electrification work on new projects today.
- 2:36So I think it's it's, it's a tougher one.
- 2:38It's one definitely that Crown Estate Scotland was still, you
- 2:41know, obviously ensure that that would like to happen.
- 2:44I think the most important thing is that we just build out the
- 2:47offshore wind projects and I think that electrification will
- 2:49come over time. And you know, Barry, you touched
- 2:53on the energy profits levy, which I guess a couple of years
- 2:56ago people might have been going renewables conference speaking
- 2:59about oil and gas tax. But it does feel like it's a
- 3:02really big issue right now the the Nationals have got on the
- 3:05front page every morning when it's when it comes to looking to
- 3:10this next budget. How crucial is it that we see
- 3:13some sort of change in oil and gas policy for projects like
- 3:17Greenville to go ahead? Yeah, I think, I mean, we need
- 3:20to call out for what it is. There's a, there's a crisis
- 3:22going on in UK oil and gas at the moment.
- 3:25And, and I think that's unnecessary.
- 3:27You know, I think if we take a, a pragmatic approach to the
- 3:30energy mix and the energy transition and recognise it's
- 3:32going to take a number of years. You know, we need to have that
- 3:35energy mix continuing on. And it's particularly pertinent
- 3:38for supply chain and and skills where there's that transferable
- 3:43nature. So, you know, I, I'm really
- 3:46hopeful that Treasury listen to the recommendations from the OE
- 3:49UK ask and, and make some changes so that we can see, you
- 3:55know, oil and gas being sustainable to, to enable a just
- 3:59transition. Stephen, we're seeing operators
- 4:03slash investment electrification isn't a cheap thing to do.
- 4:08Is it likely that even after EPL changes that operators are going
- 4:13to want to stump up the cash or, you know, we're hearing
- 4:16operators say they're already looking to leave the UK.
- 4:19Is it too little too late? No.
- 4:21I think there are, there are many, many years left of the of
- 4:24the North Sea on the UK and then Norwegian side as well.
- 4:27So I think the whole of the North Sea itself, we're going
- 4:29through a regeneration in terms of offshore wind.
- 4:32We're going to continue producing gas and oil in the UK
- 4:35for many, many years to come. So I think really making the
- 4:37case for decarbonisation, it will come.
- 4:40I think over time, I think it will come when also we see more
- 4:43infrastructure, more floating offshore wind, easier to to link
- 4:46up towards that as well for for oil and gas.
- 4:48So it's necessary we're going to go towards net zero.
- 4:51We need to help decarbonize the oil and gas industry.
- 4:54You know, the the topic of final investment decision for
- 4:57Greenville was brought up in that panel session and I think
- 5:01the question was actually a little bit polite.
- 5:02To you, Barry, because. It's it was saying Q426 for FID.
- 5:08How likely is that? Pretty sure it used to be 25 for
- 5:12FID for Greenbolt. How is decisions like CNOC
- 5:16backing away impacting the financial viability of
- 5:20Greenbolt? It, it, it's not we've, we've
- 5:22got a pathway forward. You know, I think we always knew
- 5:25that these projects were going to be challenging, you know, but
- 5:29as I said, I think we need to, to recognise the challenge that
- 5:33oil and gas have at the moment and continue pressing on.
- 5:36You know, we've got obligations to meet, we've got dates to, to
- 5:39meet for target commissioning windows for the CFD, you know,
- 5:43and I think we've got good support from the likes of Crown
- 5:45Estate Scotland to enable us to do that.
- 5:48But recognise the challenge that, that there is at, at the
- 5:52moment in, in the sector. And it's not only a challenging
- 5:55time in oil and gas. You know, we, as we heard this
- 5:57morning in the opening session, it's a, it's a challenge for,
- 6:01you know, the strong headwinds in, in, in renewables as well.
- 6:04And, and, and so, you know, I think about we're taking our
- 6:07time, we're making sure that we're doing the right level of
- 6:10engineering. So we've got that right level of
- 6:11maturity to enable us to to get to that financial investment
- 6:15decision. You know, just to just to be
- 6:18very clear, Barry, it was all it was.
- 6:20It was framed almost as a yes. No question on the panel that
- 6:24will you reach final investment decision by the end of 26, Is
- 6:28that a yes or is that a no? We've got great confidence that
- 6:31that the project will move ahead.
- 6:32You know, I think we've got good levels of maturity now.
- 6:35We've got strong engagement with the supply chain.
- 6:38So you know the right ingredients are there to make
- 6:41this recipe work. I feel like that's still not a
- 6:45yes or no, but we'll, we'll, we'll move swiftly on.
- 6:49Stephen, we were we were speaking about lessons learned
- 6:53over over the industry. Greenbelt's kind of dealing with
- 6:56that. A winner's car sag was how it
- 7:00was described as our first mover.
- 7:03You're having to solve a lot of problems here.
- 7:05What are the problems still to solve it?
- 7:07Has many things to solve, but I mean, the floating offshore wind
- 7:09industry is, I mean, in general, it's, it's a forward-looking
- 7:13industry, A lot of technology development.
- 7:15There's a lot of optimism around it.
- 7:17It's been going on for many, many years.
- 7:19I think for us in this project, it's quite a privilege to be
- 7:21honest, to be where we are and actually develop this project.
- 7:23And what's great about it is that there's so many other
- 7:26developers are cheering us on. So we're usually ruling a bit of
- 7:28competitive space against each other here.
- 7:30We're actually, you know, you hear you hear that people want
- 7:33to actually let us succeed and to actually build on what they
- 7:36can learn from us as well. So I think, you know, we're
- 7:38moving in the right direction. And Barry, you, you touched
- 7:42Duncan card and that was I believe the the first floating
- 7:45grid connected offshore wind farm.
- 7:49There's been a lot of a lot of headlines around that over the
- 7:52past few years. And you were speaking about
- 7:53learning from that. You know, you spoke about grid
- 7:58infrastructure, you spoke about port collaboration.
- 8:02When it comes to the lessons learned from Kincard and Tim
- 8:06Pick when he was offshore wind champion described the fact that
- 8:09one turbine went off to Norway as a national disgrace.
- 8:13What are the lessons being learned now?
- 8:15I think yeah, I mean, absolutely it's it's a test and demo
- 8:18project can card and you know, and there's there's key lessons
- 8:21that we have learned from it. So you know, one of the things
- 8:25is, and we spoke about in that last session about major
- 8:28component replacement, you know, recognizing that we're going to
- 8:30have to change out these components during the lifetime
- 8:33of of the wind farm. And you know, we've looked at
- 8:36the failure rates and we know that we're going to have to do
- 8:38that. So once, you know, you're going
- 8:39to have to do that, you don't want to be shipping these, you
- 8:42know, towing these large turbines across to Norway or
- 8:48back to the Netherlands or something like that.
- 8:50So we're working, you know, with partners, with ports, we're
- 8:53talking to them about being ready to, to have that ready for
- 8:57when Greenville starts so that we've got facilities, local
- 9:00facilities here, you know, and I think that's a fantastic
- 9:03opportunity for, for, for other developers and other projects
- 9:06coming behind Greenville. You know an issue with floating
- 9:10wind in UK ports is depth. How?
- 9:13How are you finding you know what what ports are being made
- 9:16available for maintenance on a scale like that occasion I
- 9:21referenced earlier? I think you know, the ports
- 9:25around Cromartie are ideally suited in terms of natural water
- 9:30depth. You know, the, the ports need to
- 9:32invest a little bit more to do some more dredging and I mean a
- 9:36little bit more. There's a lot of, you know, the
- 9:38likes of the flow misfunding is going into Port of Cromartie
- 9:40Firth, for example. We're lucky in Aberdeen that
- 9:43we've got the New South Harbour. You know, they talk about
- 9:46needing to do a little bit more dredging, but they've got the
- 9:49facility, there's a fantastic facility.
- 9:51So you know, we are blessed here in Scotland, in the North East
- 9:55of Scotland that that you know, with a bit more investment, a
- 9:58bit more development, we can we can get there.
- 10:01Now we're getting to the end of the year, people are looking
- 10:04into 26. What should we expect from
- 10:06Greenbolt next year? Steven, I might start with you
- 10:08on that one. Towards 26, yeah, we will see,
- 10:13we hope very soon some exciting announcement around there.
- 10:16We're in the middle of a very exciting process with our supply
- 10:19chain partners. So we actually want to see them.
- 10:22We're looking forward to actually announcing, making
- 10:24investments, announcing CC the project development come along
- 10:27and that we know people can actually pick up on that as
- 10:29well. So again, seeing is believing
- 10:31when you see those investments coming, but we're saying that
- 10:33there the process and the progress in the project is is
- 10:35good. Well, thank you very much for
- 10:37your time Stephen and Barry. That was a great chat from
- 10:40Vargron and Flotation about Green Volt.
- 10:42Stick around after this break to hear from me Forward.
- 10:46Be the first to hear breaking energy news through the Energy
- 10:50Voice app, available to download for free.
- 10:53You get features like saving the articles you want to return to,
- 10:57access to the Energy Voice supplement.
- 11:00You can read exclusive E Forward content and even listen to the
- 11:04Energy Voice Out Loud podcast. If you work in the UK energy
- 11:08sector, stay in the loop by saving the Energy Voice app to
- 11:12your home screen. Download the app through the
- 11:14Apple App Store or Google Play for breaking energy news on the
- 11:19go by searching Energy Voice app.
- 11:24So it wasn't just myself and my colleague Michael that was on
- 11:27the show floor at Floating Offshore Wind this week.
- 11:30Sebi Gulzarri Munro from E Forward was also in attendance
- 11:34and she's been speaking to Claire Mac, the chief executive
- 11:38of Scottish Renewables, the company behind this whole event,
- 11:44GB Energy. Am here at the Floating Offshore
- 11:48Winds Conference 2025 with Claire Mac of Scottish
- 11:52Renewables. Now Claire, you've been here for
- 11:54the last couple of days. Tell me, what's the vibe?
- 11:57So it's interesting because we know that the sector's in a
- 12:00really challenging space. You know, we are more expensive
- 12:03technology when it comes to the energy mix because we're an
- 12:06earlier stage. It's new, it's innovative and
- 12:09it's something that we're looking to do into the future,
- 12:122030 and beyond in terms of deployment.
- 12:15And I expected the vibe to probably be a little bit
- 12:18downbeat, if I'm being honest. That's what I'd expected.
- 12:20It's not what I've got. Everybody's very much in a very
- 12:24pragmatic mode of thought. You know, very much about
- 12:27resilience, very much about right.
- 12:29Let's face the challenges head on.
- 12:31We recognise that public opinion is driving political activity
- 12:34and the energy system is something in particular that has
- 12:37become a real key flashpoint. And we've got some brilliant
- 12:41support as well, yesterday from Kate Forbes, CFM.
- 12:43Kate Forbes and today from Michael Shanks, Minister for
- 12:46Energy as well around what they see in terms of the opportunity
- 12:50for floating. So that's very much what we're
- 12:52doubling down on. But are we walking the walk when
- 12:55it comes to floating? Because obviously we had the AR
- 12:587 allocation run for floating offshore wind.
- 13:01It was a smaller pot than people were perhaps expecting and a
- 13:05smaller pot than what people might expect we need for this
- 13:09industrial ambition. So think we need to, we need to
- 13:12get this into a bit of perspective, which is we have
- 13:14annualised nice auction rounds. 8 will come very close on the
- 13:18heels of AR 7 which has actually been delayed.
- 13:20So that's one thing to bear in mind.
- 13:22Yes, the pot was smaller than we were expecting and pipeline is
- 13:25absolutely key, but keeping a steady drum beat is also really
- 13:29important and that is what will happen.
- 13:30I think the lesson from AR 7 is what do we really need to see
- 13:33from AR-8? And I think we recognise that
- 13:36government have probably played it in that way that they have
- 13:38more flexibility within AR 7 for fixed bottom projects, because
- 13:42those are the ones that are effectively shuffle ready and
- 13:44they can go. And then we can start to think
- 13:46about what we need to do in order to not just procure
- 13:49volumes of electricity, which is what they what they they CFD is
- 13:52great at, but also what do we put alongside that to, to grow
- 13:56this sort of new wave of industrialisation that we're
- 13:58looking for that to come from floating?
- 14:01And we've talked about the headwinds that are facing, you
- 14:04know, the offshore wind sector is facing, one of those is
- 14:08transmission charging. And we've had recent decisions
- 14:11from off GEM that some people are interpreting as essentially,
- 14:16you know, you know, I mean, I don't want to be rude here, but
- 14:21a blowback, let's just say, to the, the Scottish offshore wind
- 14:24sector. What do you have to say to that?
- 14:26So we've been talking to government about a long term
- 14:29solution for for tenuous for transmission charging and and
- 14:32that is that will continue to be the conversation.
- 14:35We recognise that Scotland has this particularly acute issue,
- 14:38which is that transmission charging does make our projects
- 14:41less competitive than projects in other places in the country.
- 14:43And that has to stop. We're very clear about that.
- 14:46The value of an electron from Scotland should be the same as
- 14:49it is from elsewhere in the country.
- 14:50So I think we've got to remember that where the resources and
- 14:53there were the, the off game decisions were about kind of
- 14:56creating a short term fix, which we will be looking again to
- 14:59government to give us that understanding.
- 15:01Because transmission charges form a really key part of the
- 15:04ongoing operating costs of projects and therefore those
- 15:06kind of project viabilities going forward.
- 15:08And the biggest issue with them was that they're they're they're
- 15:10volatile and unpredictable. Everybody recognises the need to
- 15:15pay costs for the transmission system.
- 15:17We're just in a really interesting time of change.
- 15:19So you would never be able to really light upon a key golden
- 15:24nugget of a system that would work right here and now that
- 15:26would take us into the next 10 to 20 years because there's so
- 15:28much change happening. We're in a heavy investment
- 15:31phase at the moment in the transmission network because we
- 15:34need to be. That won't always be the case,
- 15:36but we are going to be looking at owning and managing and
- 15:38operating much bigger system in the future.
- 15:40And again, that's something that needs careful thought.
- 15:42But yeah, look into government for what's going to happen for
- 15:45those projects that are coming through Arkansas 7 And but what
- 15:48is the long term fix? And as a sector, we've put
- 15:51together some ideas that will come out around about Christmas
- 15:53time on that. Well, the sector is putting
- 15:56together ideas and it does feel like here, whilst people
- 15:59recognise the challenge, there is still everything to play for.
- 16:03So watch this space. It's all about the supply chain,
- 16:07or certainly so much of it is when it comes to the industrial
- 16:11opportunity. And here at the Floating
- 16:12Offshore Wind conference have found Rob Gilbert, the Director
- 16:17for supply chain at Great British Energy.
- 16:19Now Rob, you basically wrote an article just before we came to
- 16:23this conference talking about exactly that.
- 16:27Tell us. So I think I'm not, well, I'm
- 16:29not the only person who wrote an article.
- 16:30So you obviously wrote an article as well talking about
- 16:32the the once in a generation opportunity that the floating
- 16:36offshore wind market represents for the UK.
- 16:39And I think the important thing that that I was saying in my
- 16:42article is that we can we concur with that.
- 16:43We think as industrial opportunities go for the UK,
- 16:47particularly in the energy sector, the potential of the
- 16:50floating offshore wind market is immense.
- 16:53In my world in supply chain, you know, that is really about
- 16:56supporting the manufacturing businesses that will create the
- 16:59parts and components, employ the people around the regions that
- 17:03really will sort of power the energy transition.
- 17:06And ultimately, as we've sort of talked about, we really want to
- 17:09see that energy transition not just built here, but really made
- 17:13here and say floating offshore wind is an enormous opportunity
- 17:16I think for the UK in that context.
- 17:17But there's something really about the early support, you
- 17:23know, if we actually do want to grasp the industrial
- 17:25opportunity, if it's not just talk and we're going to walk the
- 17:28walk. Is that there because is the
- 17:31current regime, the contracts for Difference regime, quite
- 17:34right, do you think? Think if you, if you look at
- 17:38fixed offshore wind and where the CFT has obviously been a,
- 17:41you know, amazing success in driving cost down and really
- 17:45getting, you know, deployment accelerated and, and into the,
- 17:47into the market. It's been very, very successful
- 17:50at doing those things. But it, but it wasn't the first
- 17:52regime that was put in place. We had a, a, a renewable
- 17:55obligations process first that really helped the technology for
- 17:59fixed offshore wind get through that early stage kind of tricky
- 18:02phase where the technology's unproven and it hasn't been
- 18:06commercialized at scale. We're sort of in a similar place
- 18:09with plating offshore wind was we're now talking about it as
- 18:11sort of deep water wind. Because actually the important
- 18:14thing I think and and this is the sort of the context of of
- 18:17this whole industry at the moment is that we're talking
- 18:19about lots of different technologies that are all at
- 18:21varying levels of maturity. And what we've got to do is find
- 18:25a regime that probably is able to support that early technology
- 18:30proving, scale it up and really work out what the winds are
- 18:33going to be and how we sort of really get behind and support
- 18:35those at the same time as providing surety and certainty
- 18:38that we're going to be able to also bring price down.
- 18:40So that we see that, you know, the value that the kind of
- 18:43immense value that's been delivered in that sense to the
- 18:45existing CFD for fixed. And I think that the, you know,
- 18:48if I'm, you know, sort of being being candid and I think, you
- 18:51know, Minister Shanks was on stage earlier today saying,
- 18:54saying something similar. You know, for for too long the
- 18:56sort of infrastructure has been, you know, we've been really good
- 18:58at deploying it, but we've got to ensure that more of it is
- 19:01made here as well. Yeah.
- 19:03So it's about capability and not just deployment, it's how you
- 19:05put it in your article. And certainly the two of us were
- 19:08both talking about the the sheer magnitude of this industrial
- 19:13responsibility actually that we've got to create this
- 19:17industry actually. But but my question also is, is
- 19:20that to what extent is it possible?
- 19:23I mean, you know, we live in, you know, a globalised world.
- 19:27We live in a world where it is easier to ship parts from, you
- 19:33know, let's say, China or elsewhere.
- 19:36What can we do? You've talked differently about
- 19:39Tier 1, Tier 2, Tier 3 companies.
- 19:41I'm really interested to understand like how we can
- 19:44actually realistically anchor supply chain here in this
- 19:48country. It's a really great point.
- 19:51You're right. We were both talking about that
- 19:52sort of the opportunity, that industrial potential.
- 19:56And, and I think if you, if you look at the sort of angry,
- 19:59there's a, one of the things I said in my, in my article is we
- 20:01have to, we have to get past this slightly self defeating
- 20:04narrative that we can't do things cost competitively in the
- 20:06UK. We absolutely can do and we do
- 20:09in a number of other sectors. But in order to get there, you
- 20:12have to have the scale and the certainty, and you have to link
- 20:16innovation with commercialization with
- 20:18industrialization. And we have a brilliant
- 20:20innovation ecosystem. We got some phenomenal
- 20:22businesses doing really like cutting edge engineering.
- 20:25We have to help those businesses find a route to market, but
- 20:27they're not always these large scale multinationals.
- 20:30We really want to support those businesses coming into the
- 20:31market, but we don't really have enough of them sort of here that
- 20:35are UK based based businesses. So the I think from a great
- 20:39British energy standpoint, one of our key pillars is how do we
- 20:42support the UK based Tier 1, tier twos and tier threes to
- 20:46supply into those businesses, bring that innovation forward,
- 20:49you know, and ultimately find roots for those.
- 20:51You know, we talk about scaling up those future national
- 20:54champions. We want to really support those
- 20:55businesses and find find ways to help those businesses.
- 20:58Well, Rob, I know you are working incredibly hard behind
- 21:01the scenes and I know we're going to be hearing a lot more
- 21:04from great British energy going forward, so it's still all to
- 21:07play for. Thank you very much, Rob.
- 21:10Thank you very much, Sebby for joining us on this week's
- 21:12episode. Those were some really
- 21:14interesting chats. Now join us after the break as
- 21:17we catch up with Tim Pick. Energy Voice leads the global
- 21:21energy conversation, which is why we're excited to introduce
- 21:23our newest offering, E Forward. E Forward is the essential and
- 21:28exclusive community of senior North Sea leaders driving the
- 21:31movement to secure clean energy. The energy transition is not
- 21:34just a climate issue, but an economic imperative.
- 21:37We have a leading position in this race and E Forward can help
- 21:40you take advantage in a discreet environment where thought
- 21:43leaders and recognized experts can collaborate on moving energy
- 21:46forward. This is the specialist
- 21:49membership designed exclusively for North Sea innovators,
- 21:52offering a focus program of events, valuable data-driven
- 21:55insight and an exclusive digital hub.
- 21:58This is where you can set the agenda and shape the energy
- 22:00transition. If you're 1 of Energy's forward
- 22:03thinkers, it's time you joined us.
- 22:05Visit E forward dot Energy. That's EFWD dot energy to learn
- 22:10more and to join this exclusive community.
- 22:14So Tim Peck used to be the offshore wind champion, and now
- 22:19he's the Chair of the Offshore Wind Growth Partnership.
- 22:23We were speaking about the allocation of public and private
- 22:27funds to support the supply chain, what could be described
- 22:31as a turbulent time for floating offshore wind.
- 22:34So thank you very much for joining me today, Tim.
- 22:37Just before we started recording, we spoke about a
- 22:40comment that Energy Voice reported on a couple of years
- 22:42ago around King Cardin and around when one of its turbines
- 22:47needed to go off our maintenance.
- 22:49It was shipped all the way to Norway.
- 22:50At the time you were the UK's offshore wind champion and you
- 22:54described that as a national disgrace, feelings aside of how
- 23:00how well that was that was covered.
- 23:03I'd be interested to hear what you're thinking now, because
- 23:06since Labour have taken over, since they've came into power
- 23:10last year, there's been a lot of focus on the supply chain.
- 23:13There's been a lot of changes to to support mechanisms to try and
- 23:17incentivize local content. Is the dial shifting at all?
- 23:22I think the, I think the dial is shifting.
- 23:26You know, that national disgrace comment was interesting.
- 23:28And I and I, you know, I don't blame you for quoting it quite
- 23:32so extensively. It was, I think it was some kind
- 23:35of frustration that we hadn't tried hard enough for the UK
- 23:39supply chain over quite a period of time.
- 23:43Look, there was a, there's a health that had been focused
- 23:46during that period on getting cost down and we did, we need to
- 23:49do that again. But if I think about the two
- 23:52weaknesses of the industry that continually get attacked, one is
- 23:55cost and the other is where is the delivery on jobs and supply
- 23:59chain and local content. But you know, we're seeing some
- 24:03healthy progress in terms of the incentives.
- 24:05So we've seen the Crown Estate Institute new requirements in
- 24:09the Celtic Sea leasing round, which we will see in January,
- 24:13the outcome of AR 7 and the clean industry bonus reforms
- 24:17there. And more broadly, I guess we
- 24:20have seen announcements of Scottish Government on support
- 24:24for the supply chain. We have seen the outcome of the
- 24:27foamies port funding from desness and we've we've seen the
- 24:33Crown Estate play more in in sort of recycling that rental,
- 24:37that leasing fee income back into helpful stuff in the supply
- 24:41chain. And the body that I chair, the
- 24:44Offshore Wind Growth Partnership, which is private
- 24:45sector funding from developers has got some increased
- 24:49firepower. And we are we've just launched
- 24:52our biggest ever grant funding opportunity for supply chain.
- 24:55So I think the supply chain is in the room as it has never been
- 24:59before. And I look, I think, I think
- 25:03that has a huge amount of support from the new government.
- 25:07It responds to concerns raised by the unions.
- 25:11And we and we will see probably in the next 12 months, we will
- 25:15see the fruits of our labour there and hopefully some things
- 25:20we can really, really proud of and that really do move the
- 25:22dial. Yeah, it's, it's interesting
- 25:25you're speaking about in the next 12 months, right, See,
- 25:27we'll see some changes because this week I've been speaking to
- 25:30more E we've got plans to to develop a manufacturing site
- 25:34right here in Aberdeen, but they're changing how they're
- 25:38looking at that plan, which are scaling back to a logistics yard
- 25:41because they just don't have the surety of project yet.
- 25:45And I keep hearing this term, I'm getting kind of fed up of
- 25:47hearing actually the chicken and egg situation.
- 25:50People who've read my Offshore Wind Champion report will know
- 25:53I'm quite frustrated with the the way that we we have this
- 25:57market mechanism. It's designed to put extreme
- 26:00cost pressure on developers and to get that price discovery for
- 26:03the benefit of consumers. Let's not forget that.
- 26:07But what it does as a side effect is it obscures the
- 26:10market. So for if you're a supply chain
- 26:12company or a port in Britain and you're looking at the offshore
- 26:15wind market, you're sort of looking at it through the
- 26:18bathroom window and you're looking at customers who are not
- 26:24certain they've got a project. And so they can't give you an
- 26:26order. Obviously you can look at the
- 26:29wider European and international markets.
- 26:31But if this is your home market, it's important that that's that
- 26:34we find ways to to try and bridge that.
- 26:37So I think that chicken and egg is still there, but we're
- 26:40starting to see some incentives alongside auction mechanisms,
- 26:44etcetera to try and take some of the risk out of that.
- 26:48I was just in a panel on Celtic Sea.
- 26:51Now Celtic Sea does not have the benefit.
- 26:53We're in Aberdeen, has the benefit of a vast history of
- 26:56subsea engineering, etcetera. The companies here have grown up
- 27:00on oil and gas. They're in a transition in the
- 27:04Celtic Sea. There isn't that subsea back
- 27:07story. And so it's, it's very much a
- 27:10Greenfield and they're, they're really experiencing this.
- 27:13There are some great skills that don't get me wrong.
- 27:15And look at the steel industry, some of the ports are really
- 27:18well positioned, but they're really grappling with this
- 27:21chicken and egg problem. And you know, we, if I look back
- 27:27at my own report, I had discussed, you know, is there a
- 27:31need for some sort of backstop for, for some of these key
- 27:37developments? So, and you and you can see even
- 27:40in the government's new industrial strategy, there's
- 27:43talk of a market demand guarantee for electrical
- 27:47componentry, for example, to try and help people get off the
- 27:51ground. So, you know, it's a well
- 27:53recognized problem. No one has yet come up with the
- 27:56with the answer apart from just ripping up entire structures
- 28:01like the CFD. It is interesting if you go back
- 28:04in time to rocks or frankly the very first CFDS which were fit
- 28:11enabling CFDS, they did allow that more certain flow through
- 28:15to the supply chain. And people who were involved at
- 28:18that time will tell you that, for example, the Siemens factory
- 28:20in Hull was only possible because of fit enabling CFDS.
- 28:24So I do sort of wonder whether there's an opportunity,
- 28:28particularly in the floating space, to do something a bit
- 28:31differently, but it would, it would be quite a radical change
- 28:36and not something I'm currently aware is being.
- 28:38Discussed it was something that was discussed this morning and
- 28:41the and the staying afloat panel session that kicked off Day 2
- 28:46where they were speaking about CFDS, the allocation rounds you
- 28:51know they're they're pointed to in other parts of the world as
- 28:53being, you know this great measure that's helping sort of
- 28:58speed up projects. But for UK developers that have
- 29:02got issues, it's maybe less about throwing the baby out the
- 29:05bathwater for want of a better phrase, but more about tweaking.
- 29:09And that sounds like what you're discussing here.
- 29:11This idea that we can. Yeah, I think it's.
- 29:12Security, you can't please everybody.
- 29:15The CFD does a couple of things well it does.
- 29:18It provides that sort of bankability protection for
- 29:22investors where equity and their investors into these projects so
- 29:25they don't have to worry about what the wholesale price is
- 29:28doing. You, you know, some would argue
- 29:30they should worry about that. And it's, and it's creating
- 29:33slight different effects in the market.
- 29:36And in terms, you know, you've had the whole locational pricing
- 29:39debate recently, which which really add that kind of
- 29:42conversation. But if you're talking about pure
- 29:45capital raising, it's a pretty good instrument.
- 29:48It does put extreme auction pressure on and so historically
- 29:52put a very good downward pressure on cost.
- 29:56Obviously we've seen a rise recently that's the flow through
- 30:00of you know, supply chain constraints and frankly interest
- 30:03rates going back to what might be perceived as a more normal
- 30:06level. If you think about the UK
- 30:08offshore wind fleet has largely been built out today in a very
- 30:12benign interest rate environment.
- 30:14So cost of capital has been lower and it's and you've seen
- 30:19that sort of price reduction that happened through to AR-4.
- 30:24Now we're seeing a rebound. Let's see what happens in the
- 30:27coming years. Obviously don't know where
- 30:29interest rates are going. We could all make money if we
- 30:32did the the in terms of that pressure on innovation and cost
- 30:39reduction. Sometimes hard to see where
- 30:42that's coming from, but you know, this whole question of
- 30:46Ming Yang's entry into the market and the pressure that may
- 30:48put on Siemens of Vestas is very interesting.
- 30:51Certainly as a Ming Yang have definitely been the talk of the
- 30:53conference themselves that I think they've got a dedicated
- 30:55meeting room just up here where we're now.
- 30:58But I'd, I'd be quite interested to cycle back to sort of the
- 31:02public and private funding that you discussed at the start of
- 31:06this conversation, starting the, the public funding, looking at
- 31:11sort of GP energy and its involvement.
- 31:14You know, I think coming up to the election, it was very all
- 31:18guns blazing. We can invest in projects, we
- 31:20can invest in ports, we can invest in supply chain.
- 31:23And now that the, the budget has to be allocated, it's maybe a
- 31:27little bit more muted than what was previously thought of when
- 31:31we're, when we're looking at the areas they're investing in.
- 31:34I heard someone earlier today say, are they, are they, are
- 31:37they, I think they use the phrase are they eating Snibs
- 31:40dinner? Are they Scottish Enterprise?
- 31:43Sorry, dinner. You know, it seems like they're
- 31:44sort of investing in the same area as Scottish Enterprise and
- 31:49Snip. Is this, do you see GB energy as
- 31:52being an enabler or is it kind of just a doubling up of what's
- 31:56already there? I don't think it's a doubling
- 31:58up. I think these organizations have
- 31:59slightly different focuses. GBSNIP I guess is has a much
- 32:06broader perspective on the Scottish economy, whereas GB
- 32:09Energy is very much an energy focused business.
- 32:13We will see where it actually deploys capital going forward.
- 32:17I think it's in all our interests.
- 32:18So that's disciplined and focused in areas that really add
- 32:21strategic value to the UK. But we as part of our role at
- 32:27the Offshore Wing Growth Partnership, which I chair, we
- 32:30have established something called the Industrial Growth
- 32:33Plan Strategy Board, which brings all those organizations
- 32:37together in the offshore wind context to try and ensure that
- 32:40there's some level of coordination, that the funding
- 32:44mechanisms can work in a complementary way and not sort
- 32:47of conflict with each other that we don't overburden applicants
- 32:52with, with requirements and, and you know, generally trying to
- 32:56make it more efficient. And in fact, we recently, there
- 32:58was recently a publication from Renewable UK called the
- 33:02Investment Prospectus, which tried to lay out for the supply
- 33:05chain. These are the things you can
- 33:07apply for and these are the sort of eligibility criteria for each
- 33:11and the type of thing that's being targeted.
- 33:14But let's face it, even if you add up all this cash from
- 33:17national welfare and SNIB, wider Scottish Government, you know,
- 33:22GB Energy ourselves, there is a huge demand from the supply
- 33:26chain in this country, huge demand from ports.
- 33:30I think we're, I think we're still somewhat scratching the
- 33:32surface, but but equally that capital needs to be relatively
- 33:38scarce so we don't start dumping into white elephant.
- 33:40You know, I've felt you moving towards the Celtic Sea in the
- 33:45conversation a couple of times and I've been very mean and kept
- 33:48you on on the nitty gritty of numbers.
- 33:50But I would like to focus on that.
- 33:53You've just come out of the Celtic Sea panel here today too,
- 33:57and I'd be interested to hear your takeaways from that.
- 34:02And specifically, we spoke just before we started recording
- 34:05about glass. This massive floating offshore
- 34:07wind farm is set to come to the West Coast and they were saying
- 34:12yesterday that we need a Green Vault and we need projects like
- 34:16it beyond that for us to have the runway to deliver what we
- 34:19want to do. Where is the Celtic Sea in in
- 34:23this in its timeline for deployment?
- 34:25So I think you've got two issues here.
- 34:27You've got the maturity of the technology generally and there's
- 34:31clearly a global effort, several different countries putting a
- 34:35bit of money to work. And in our case, support for
- 34:40floating offshore wind comes effectively through consumer
- 34:42bills. So you need to be careful with
- 34:43that. But we've done our part.
- 34:46France is doing it's part and always doing it's part.
- 34:49South Korea's doing it's part, the aggregated learnings of all
- 34:52of that into the industry are helpful.
- 34:56And we need to find ways to sort of build on those to make to, to
- 34:59to allow it to move forward, iterate the technology and bring
- 35:03it to a state of maturity where you can deploy it at scale.
- 35:07If I look at the Celtic Sea specifically, we've been in what
- 35:11I call the Manana phase of the Celtic Sea for quite a long
- 35:14time. And I certainly, if I look at it
- 35:16from a ports and supply chain perspective, they're sort of
- 35:19tomorrow, tomorrow. Tomorrow has gone on for a long,
- 35:21long time. But now people's eyes have been
- 35:25drawn to the 2 project development areas, the Equinor
- 35:27one and the and the EDF one. But we need to remember that we
- 35:31already have consented test and demo projects ready to go.
- 35:36They need to win CF DS and get moving.
- 35:39And then we also have a couple of smaller scale sub commercial
- 35:43projects out there going through the planning system.
- 35:47And so we've got that journey to go on in the Celtic Sea.
- 35:50But I, I'm as impatient as anyone to see that first tow out
- 35:56of a foundation with a tower with a turbine on top of it from
- 36:00a any port in the Celtic Sea. And I will go down there to
- 36:03watch it because I think it will be an absolutely momentous
- 36:06thing. And if you think about
- 36:09situation, let's assume it's towed from Port Talbot or from
- 36:12Bristol, it will be towed down the Celtic Sea within sight of
- 36:16many thousands of people. And I think it will be a sort of
- 36:19moment in our industrial heritage.
- 36:23And I've talked about this before.
- 36:24You know, I think it's a that's a spectacle that you would take
- 36:28your kids to watch. And, and I think we need that as
- 36:31an industry. We need to be on the front foot
- 36:33with the public, giving them a really positive message,
- 36:36shouting from the rooftops about the innovation, the jobs, the
- 36:42just the amazingness of this industry and getting back on the
- 36:47front foot around the challenging the narrative on
- 36:50constraint payments, explaining where things are on cost
- 36:54reduction and just sort of being more confident.
- 37:00Thank you very much to everyone appearing in this week's episode
- 37:04of Energy Voice Out Loud. If you want to catch up with
- 37:07everything that happened live on the show floor here at the
- 37:11Floating Offshore Wind Conference in Aberdeen, you can
- 37:14go over to energyvoice.com where we have a handy tag page where
- 37:18all of our articles from this conference are located.
- 37:22That does it for us this week, but you can find us in the same
- 37:25place, same time next week.