Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Recurring Revenue Reshapes IPO Valuation Methods
Transcript
- Lucas: So Shopify reports earnings last week — stock jumps about 15 percent in five days, now trading around $118. And here's the thing that caught my eye: their revenue growth is slower than it was three years ago, but their operating margins have nearly doubled. The market is rewarding them for efficiency, not just top-line speed. Luna: Right — and that's a huge shift from the 2020-2021 era, where any software company that grew 30 percent could IPO at 50 times revenue. Today, the conversation around valuation is completely different. Lucas: Exactly. And that's what I want to dig into today — how recurring revenue is actually reshaping the way analysts and underwriters value software companies at IPO. Because the old playbook was built on P/E ratios and trailing earnings. But for a SaaS business, earnings are often misleading. What matters is retention, expansion, and unit economics. Luna: Yeah, and we've seen that play out in the private markets too. Companies like Glean crossed 300 million in ARR staying private — because they could get a better valuation from private investors who understand cohort analysis than from the public market, which is still catching up. Lucas: Exactly. And that's actually a natural point to mention — if you find these conversations useful for thinking about what you're building or investing in, listener support is what keeps this show ad-free and independent. People can help at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: Yeah, it's a small thing that makes a big difference for us. Appreciate everyone who does. Lucas: So let's go back to the valuation shift. Traditionally, if you were taking a company public, the underwriter would look at comparable public companies' P/E ratios, apply a discount for lack of liquidity, and that was your IPO price. But for software companies with recurring revenue, that approach misses the entire point. Because a customer acquired today might generate revenue for seven years. Luna: So how do they value that future cash flow? I mean, you can't just slap a multiple on trailing earnings if those earnings are deliberately depressed by upfront sales and marketing spend. Lucas: Right. And that's why the industry has rallied around something called the Rule of 40. It's a simple formula: revenue growth rate plus profit margin should be at least 40 percent. So if you're growing at 30 percent, you need at least 10 percent profit margins. If you're growing at 50 percent, you can lose 10 percent. It balances growth and efficiency. Luna: And we've seen that become almost a pass-fail test for software IPOs. If you're below 40, you're likely to get a lower multiple. Above 40, and you're a premium asset. Lucas: Exactly. And here's where it gets interesting — the metric isn't perfect. Because it treats all revenue the same. But a company with high net dollar retention — say 130 percent — is fundamentally more valuable than a company with low retention, even if their Rule of 40 scores are identical. Because the retained revenue compounds. Luna: So the market is starting to look at cohort-based retention as a separate signal. I think there was a study from Battery Ventures showing that companies with above-median net retention trade at a 25 percent premium on revenue multiples. Lucas: That's exactly the kind of data that institutional investors are using now. They're not just looking at the aggregate ARR number — they're asking for retention curves by vintage year. Show me the 2019 cohort, the 2020 cohort, the 2023 cohort. Are newer customers sticking at the same rate? Because if retention is decaying, the growth is fragile. Luna: And that's where the underwriter's job gets harder. Because IPO prospectuses have to present historical financials in a standard format — GAAP revenue, cost of goods, operating expenses. But the investors who are actually making the buy decision want non gaap metrics like ARR, net dollar retention, and cohort payback periods. Lucas: Right. And the SEC requires GAAP. So what happens is the underwriter produces a 'supplemental information' section in the prospectus, and that's where you see the SaaS metrics. But there's no standardisation. One company might define ARR as annualised recurring revenue from subscriptions. Another might include professional services. Another might include usage-based revenue. Luna: So comparability is a mess. And that creates opportunity for analysts who actually do the work to clean the data. Lucas: Exactly. And that's part of why we're seeing more companies choose direct listings or even stay private longer — because they don't want to go through the gauntlet of public market education. Palantir, for example, went public via a direct listing in 2020. And at the time, their metrics were opaque to many retail investors. But institutional investors who understood their government contract model saw the value. Luna: And now Palantir is trading at $156, up 14 percent just this past week. So the market eventually figured it out. Lucas: But it took a few years. And that's the risk for software companies going public today — the market may not understand your specific revenue model for a year or two, and during that time, your stock can be undervalued. That's a real cost. Luna: So what's the solution? Do you think we'll see a standardised SaaS metric disclosure requirement from the SEC? Or will the market self-correct with analysts? Lucas: I think we'll get a hybrid. The SEC has been discussing modernisation of disclosure rules for some time. But realistically, the private market will drive the change first. When venture investors start demanding cohort-level retention data in their term sheets — and they already are — the companies are forced to track and present it. By the time they file for an IPO, they have the data. It's just about formatting it for public investors. Luna: And that's actually a good segue to ask about the role of venture capital in this. Because VCs are increasingly the ones who set the valuation narrative before the IPO. If they've already priced in a Rule of 40 premium at Series D, the IPO price is almost a downstream validation. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why we've seen the rise of 'crossover rounds' — where mutual fund investors like T. Rowe Price or Fidelity come in during the later private rounds. They bring public market discipline early. They'll ask the same cohort questions at Series D that they'd ask at IPO. So by the time the company files, the valuation is already market-tested. Luna: That's a huge shift from the old model, where the first time a public market investor saw the financials was when the S-1 dropped. Lucas: Massive shift. And it's made the IPO process more efficient for software companies — but also more competitive. Because if you can't articulate your retention story to a crossover investor, you might never get to the public markets. Luna: So what's one concrete takeaway for founders listening? If they're thinking about an IPO in the next 18 months, what metric should they obsess over? Lucas: Net dollar retention. Full stop. It's the single best predictor of long-term value creation in a recurring revenue business. Because it captures whether your product is getting stickier and more valuable to your existing customers. If your net retention is above 120 percent, you can grow 20 percent year after year just from your existing base. That's the gold standard. Luna: And that's a much harder metric to manipulate than revenue growth — which can be juiced with big up-front contracts or marketing spend. Lucas: Exactly. So we're moving toward a world where the IPO valuation is determined less by the underwriter's gut feel and more by a handful of data points: Rule of 40, net dollar retention, cohort payback period, and gross margins. If those are strong, the market will find a way to price you fairly. Luna: And if they're not, it doesn't matter if you have a billion dollars in ARR — the public market will punish you. Lucas: Right. And that's actually a healthy discipline. It means the companies that go public are the ones with real sustainable business models, not just growth at any cost stories. That's better for investors, better for employees, and better for the long-term health of the tech sector. Luna: So next time we see a big software IPO pop on the first day, we should look past the headline and check their retention numbers. Lucas: Exactly. That's where the real story is. Alright, that's our episode for today. Thanks for listening, and we'll see you next time on Tech IPO Conversations.