Latest / Modern Marriage with Monica / Dr Kevin Jenson
Transcript
- 0:00Every time I heard somebody preach on
- 0:02fornication or sexual immorality,
- 0:06every pastor had a different definition
- 0:08of what that meant. And I said, if
- 0:12there's a word that means everything, it
- 0:14also means nothing. And even in a
- 0:17marital relationship, a lot of sex is
- 0:20not about love and connection. It's
- 0:22about using the other person as a sex
- 0:24toy because I need them to get off
- 0:26because God says that's the only way I
- 0:28can do it. We finally get to today and
- 0:31we read our English Bibles and we're
- 0:32like, "Flee fornication." We're like,
- 0:34"Flee premarital sex. Flee having sexual
- 0:37thoughts. Flee having sexual desire
- 0:39within your body." And none of that is
- 0:42present in that original concept. And I
- 0:45have friends who are still holding on to
- 0:47this. They're like, "Oh, I can't do it
- 0:48until I get married and I haven't done
- 0:50it for 20 years." But why? It's not
- 0:52there in the Bible. Prostitution is
- 0:54never called a sin in the Bible when
- 0:56we're referring to a female prostitute.
- 0:58So the virgin as the as the daughter of
- 1:01her father could be sold for four times
- 1:03the amount of money as a daughter who
- 1:06was not a virgin. Today you are going to
- 1:09want to buckle up because we have Bible
- 1:12scholar and sex educator Dr. Kevin
- 1:15Jensen here to discuss what many
- 1:18Christians believe to be just taboo
- 1:20topics. things like premarital sex,
- 1:23lust, masturbation, pornography. And I'm
- 1:27just going to warn you guys because what
- 1:28you're gonna learn today just very well
- 1:31might blow your mind when you realize
- 1:32just like I did that many of these
- 1:35concepts that were taught really are not
- 1:37found in the Bible. Or maybe they are,
- 1:40but we misunderstand the translations.
- 1:42So, Dr. Kevin Jensen, thank you so much
- 1:45for being here.
- 1:46>> It is a pleasure to be here. I'm excited
- 1:48to talk with you today. Before we dive
- 1:50in, I'm super curious like many times it
- 1:53doesn't seem like Bible scholar and sex
- 1:55educator really go together. Is there a
- 1:58story here? Like how did this happened?
- 2:00>> Right. I I love that question. I think
- 2:02there's there's been a frustration of
- 2:05mine when it comes to people talking
- 2:07about faith and sexuality that either
- 2:10they know maybe a lot about one person,
- 2:12the person that they married, or maybe
- 2:14they know a lot about scripture. And
- 2:17there's very few people that have done a
- 2:18deep dive into sexuality on a practical
- 2:20level as well as into faith. And when
- 2:23we're speaking about sex, it's no, it's
- 2:25not a theoretical practice anymore. This
- 2:28is something that is deeply personal,
- 2:29physical, and embodied. And if we don't
- 2:32understand what's actually happening
- 2:34here, how can we then have a really
- 2:36useful conversation about something like
- 2:39ethics or morality or God's design for
- 2:42sexuality so long as sexuality is this
- 2:45big gaping hole in our understanding of
- 2:48what it actually is and what it has
- 2:50capacity to be. So I became a Bible
- 2:53scholar and sex educator kind of by
- 2:55accident. I've always been steeped in
- 2:58the Bible. I began to study sexuality
- 3:00and then eventually I published a book
- 3:03called Sacred Not Sinful, a new
- 3:05Christian sexual ethic. And after I did
- 3:08that, I realized I probably need to go
- 3:11to seminary because I had reached the
- 3:14bottom of the barrel of what I could
- 3:15find with my existing skills. And I
- 3:19suppose you've probably found this in
- 3:20your own research, but once you start
- 3:22asking questions and start opening a
- 3:25book like the Bible, you often end up
- 3:27with more questions than answers. And so
- 3:30this is how I became a Bible scholar and
- 3:33sex educator is this attempt to
- 3:35integrate these two things instead of
- 3:38keeping these worlds divided. it is
- 3:40thought that sex and uh religion or
- 3:44church that's not to be intertwined. And
- 3:47I'm like, well, if that's not where we
- 3:50talk about it, if we can't can't talk
- 3:52about it within a faith-based
- 3:54perspective, then where are we to to
- 3:56discuss these things? So then people
- 3:58have to go online. And that's how I
- 4:00found you. It's such a niche topic and
- 4:03this this combination. So, I'm super
- 4:06excited that you're here today to help
- 4:08us learn some things. When we talk about
- 4:10sex, like when does that really come
- 4:12online? Going back, you're like, as a
- 4:14kid, you don't think about it. So, what
- 4:16makes that shift? And what makes that
- 4:17shift is hormones. Especially with boys,
- 4:19they get that surge of testosterone
- 4:21running through their body, and suddenly
- 4:23sex is all they're thinking about. Now,
- 4:25I'm not a boy, but I can only imagine.
- 4:28I'm on testosterone now as a female, so
- 4:31I can just imagine how that is for for
- 4:33uh young men. So these young men, oh
- 4:35yeah,
- 4:35>> they now have this hormonal surge.
- 4:38They're thinking about sex all the time,
- 4:40>> but yet they're getting this conflicting
- 4:41message from their parents and from
- 4:43church that all sexual activity outside
- 4:46of a marital setting is immoral and it's
- 4:51going to violate God's will. And which
- 4:53means there's no premarital sex, there's
- 4:55no masturbation, there's no looking at
- 4:57pornography. And and I kind of see like
- 5:01maybe how all this worked in the times
- 5:03biblically. The these people were
- 5:05marrying at much younger ages. We now
- 5:07are marrying at 30 years old average. So
- 5:10I'm like I can see how it might have
- 5:11worked back then, but I just don't see
- 5:13how that works nowadays when men are
- 5:15marrying at 30. Are they never to to
- 5:18touch their own bodies? Like how how
- 5:19does this work nowadays?
- 5:23>> Yep. I think I had this question when I
- 5:25was a teenager. Like how is this
- 5:27supposed to work? Because we don't have
- 5:29that social system to put you into the
- 5:32only acceptable place to experience
- 5:34sexual desire, which is a committed
- 5:37partnership. According to the Christian
- 5:40tradition, it has been marriage makes it
- 5:42moral. And so, as long as you're a human
- 5:45being and you've passed puberty, you
- 5:47want something you're not supposed to
- 5:49want. And so either you repress it,
- 5:53which I grew up in purity culture, which
- 5:56the goal is to learn how to repress it,
- 5:58to shut it down, to say no. And I
- 6:01learned how to do that because
- 6:04the Bible said I had to. Somewhere in
- 6:06the scripture was this verse that said,
- 6:08"Thou shalt not have premarital sex." Or
- 6:10there was somewhere that said, "Looking
- 6:12at pornography is sinful." And I
- 6:16believed that because I would look at a
- 6:18verse in the scripture like in the Ten
- 6:19Commandments that says, "Thou shalt not
- 6:21commit adultery." And what my teachers
- 6:23would say is, "Well, look, it's right
- 6:25there in the Ten Commandments. Sexual
- 6:27desire outside of marriage is bad."
- 6:31And while they're not wrong, the term
- 6:33for adultery in the Bible is very
- 6:36specific. It is referring to something
- 6:39that doesn't have anything to do with
- 6:41pornography, that doesn't have anything
- 6:43to do with premarital sex, and that
- 6:46doesn't have anything to do with sexual
- 6:48desire itself
- 6:50until the days of Jesus when looking
- 6:53with desire to possess someone, he calls
- 6:55it adultery, which is a whole
- 6:57conversation all of itself. So when
- 7:00you're a young person in this context,
- 7:02the Bible is used to say God wants you
- 7:05to avoid everything to do with sex. But
- 7:07your body says, "Well, I want everything
- 7:11to do with sex." I've been here. I can
- 7:14imagine so many of your listeners have
- 7:15been here. And if they're coming from a
- 7:17Christian background,
- 7:19the only solution to this is to see if
- 7:22you can hold it until you get married.
- 7:25Once you get married, then it's all
- 7:27okay. And in fact, one of the reasons
- 7:29why a lot of partnerships end up
- 7:31struggling with sexuality is because
- 7:34they have grown up, and this is not just
- 7:36in Christian context. It's our entire
- 7:38ethical framework, including our
- 7:40language. We've grown up with this idea
- 7:43that says sex, sexual desire is bad. And
- 7:47then you got married and now sex and
- 7:49sexual desire is good. But you spent
- 7:52your whole life trying to orient the
- 7:54other way around. and it the switch just
- 7:56does not flip overnight. And so I think
- 7:58that's where some of the initial problem
- 8:00comes from. So that's that's kind of a a
- 8:03number of different a number of
- 8:04different points. Um but what what
- 8:06stands out to you here?
- 8:08>> Well well I I think it's very
- 8:10interesting is that you do say that it
- 8:12is very difficult to make that switch.
- 8:14You're like sex is bad. Sex is bad.
- 8:16Don't do it. Don't do it. Don't do it.
- 8:17And all of a sudden, and I think it's
- 8:19much easier for men to flip that switch
- 8:22because the biology mandates it. But for
- 8:25women who don't have that higher level
- 8:27of testosterone where libido is not
- 8:29naturally uh giving us that biological
- 8:31prompting, I think it's a much more
- 8:33difficult switch to make. And I don't
- 8:34think some women ever get there. They
- 8:36never really truly embrace their
- 8:38sexuality. And it's I view it very much
- 8:41like a gift from God. Like we have so
- 8:45many different ways as women to have an
- 8:46orgasm. So I'm like God has our back
- 8:48here ladies. Like
- 8:50>> why are you not
- 8:51>> why are you not made like making this
- 8:53had this more of a priority. So um yeah
- 8:56there's a there's a lot there. The
- 8:57sexual identity is is a is a tough is a
- 9:00tough cell for females.
- 9:02>> Yeah. And let's just talk about sex
- 9:04education for a minute while you're on
- 9:06this because the female body actually
- 9:08has greater capacity for sexual pleasure
- 9:11than the male body. But so many people
- 9:13don't even understand this. I think it
- 9:15was about the 1960s when the female
- 9:17orgasm just became a topic of
- 9:19conversation in the United States when
- 9:21they're like, "Oh, women can have
- 9:22orgasms, too. How did we ever not know
- 9:24this?" And what I find absolutely
- 9:27fascinating is that in biblical times,
- 9:30you'll see writings like in the
- 9:31Proverbs, they considered female sexual
- 9:34desire to be something much beyond the
- 9:37male sexual desire. Females had much
- 9:40more sexual desire than males in that
- 9:42context. Somehow they knew this. I don't
- 9:45know exactly where we forgot it, but
- 9:48we're speaking to people who grew up in
- 9:50this context where we lack sex
- 9:51education. And if you don't have
- 9:53education,
- 9:55uh especially if you have a female body,
- 9:59how can you actually know what sex means
- 10:01beyond five minutes of somebody putting
- 10:03something into your body and basically
- 10:05using you as a tool of masturbation?
- 10:08That's what happens if we don't have
- 10:10education around sexuality and what it
- 10:13can be. And if men don't have another
- 10:15outlet for their sexuality besides that,
- 10:18they think, "Hey, I have to get married.
- 10:20So now that doing this thing that I knew
- 10:21I wanted to do from the time I was 15
- 10:24years old, now God is okay with that.
- 10:27But if I never learned how my body
- 10:29functions, my partner never learned how
- 10:31her body functions,
- 10:33then how are we actually going to
- 10:35experience what sexual connection has
- 10:37capacity to be?
- 10:39>> In your studies, have you found when you
- 10:42were questioning these things? Like, is
- 10:45it really is is sex only moral within a
- 10:48marital framework? Is it really is that
- 10:51what the Bible says? What what did the
- 10:53your studies bring you to the conclusion
- 10:56of?
- 10:58>> Ah, such a good question. And I think
- 11:02you've already spent hours learning with
- 11:04me on my YouTube channel. I I unpack all
- 11:08of these different questions because in
- 11:10in the biblical context, they didn't
- 11:12really have a word for sex. And there's
- 11:15never anywhere that says sex is good or
- 11:18sex is bad. The Bible doesn't give us
- 11:22that kind of explicit claim. That's how
- 11:25we in a in a western European
- 11:28post-Enlightenment way of thinking.
- 11:30That's the kind of answer we're looking
- 11:32for. We want to open the Bible, find the
- 11:34verse that says, "Thou shalt not have
- 11:35premarital sex." And we're like, "See,
- 11:37God said it. That's what we do." But
- 11:39that's not the way that the scriptures
- 11:41are written down. We're looking at texts
- 11:44that were recorded 2,000 years ago for
- 11:46for the New Testament books and up to
- 11:494,000 years, maybe even older for some
- 11:52of the ancient poetry that we have in
- 11:54the Hebrew texts. And the way that they
- 11:57thought about and interacted with the
- 11:59world was very different than the way
- 12:01that we think about and interact with
- 12:02the world.
- 12:04So, all of that to say, I don't have an
- 12:07easy answer to your question. I do have
- 12:10what I think is a beautiful answer to
- 12:12that question and that comes from my
- 12:16study of
- 12:18I guess we could say three different
- 12:19words and maybe we want to talk through
- 12:21all three of them.
- 12:23>> Sure.
- 12:23>> One of those words is lust.
- 12:26>> This one is the easy one to talk through
- 12:29because most people know Jesus teaching
- 12:32whoever looks upon a woman with lust has
- 12:34committed adultery with her. This is
- 12:35usually where we go when it comes to
- 12:38questions and conversations about
- 12:39pornography because what could
- 12:41pornography be other than an outlet for
- 12:45lust?
- 12:47Now, in in the Greek New Testament, this
- 12:51word for lust is epithemea.
- 12:55And what blew my mind is that later on
- 12:58in the New Testament, Jesus said that he
- 13:01was doing it.
- 13:04So he says, "Whoever looks on a woman
- 13:05with a man."
- 13:06>> Okay, I just learned something new.
- 13:12>> That was a shock. And this has been my
- 13:14entire experience of studying this
- 13:16question is that I'm finding things in
- 13:18the scripture that look nothing like
- 13:19what I expected, that don't give me that
- 13:21clear answer, but they call me to
- 13:24something. Because the more you study
- 13:25this word epithea, the more you find out
- 13:28that it is connected to this root. And
- 13:30in men's work, we we talk about this a
- 13:32lot. this this thumos this core of your
- 13:35identity it's like a deep powerful word
- 13:38epithea is something that is around that
- 13:40deep core sense of self and motivation
- 13:44so this term epithea is used in the
- 13:47Greek to indicate you are orienting your
- 13:49life around something
- 13:51>> okay
- 13:52>> when Jesus says don't orient your life
- 13:54around this desire to possess a woman
- 13:58he's saying something that is incredibly
- 13:59powerful and liberating
- 14:02because In that day, women were often
- 14:05treated as property. And if you were a
- 14:07male, you could set your desire upon a
- 14:10woman and you would go by her. It's it's
- 14:13a little bit crass, but this is the this
- 14:16is the structure of that context. And
- 14:18Jesus is saying, you know what, you are
- 14:20doing a violation to something when you
- 14:23set the core of your desire upon another
- 14:27person.
- 14:28>> Okay. So yes, because there is that just
- 14:30negative connotation associated with the
- 14:32word lust. Lust isn't necessarily a a
- 14:35bad thing. Is that correct?
- 14:37>> It is not a bad thing, but it can be set
- 14:40on bad things. You can lust for
- 14:42breakfast and you can lust for donuts.
- 14:44And one of those is going to be really
- 14:46good for your long-term health.
- 14:48>> Gotcha. Okay. So in the context of um
- 14:51lust and the viewing of pornography is
- 14:56that is does that meet the definition?
- 15:00>> It potentially can. And here's here's
- 15:04where I want to draw a distinction and
- 15:05and help to untangle a little bit of
- 15:07where we've come with this word lust
- 15:09>> because I I was speaking with a pastor a
- 15:12couple of years ago and and he's a
- 15:15married pastor and he liked to talk
- 15:18about how much he lusted over his wife
- 15:21and what he meant is here's how much
- 15:24sexual desire I have for this person.
- 15:28But when it came to experiencing sexual
- 15:30desire or arousal outside of being
- 15:33directed toward his wife, he felt really
- 15:35bad about that because, you know, you're
- 15:36you're not supposed to experience sexual
- 15:38desire for anyone except the person you
- 15:41marry. Again, we're back to the purity
- 15:43culture teachings which are kind of
- 15:45they've just filtered into society. So,
- 15:48we have that popular meme of the guy
- 15:50looking at some other girl who's not the
- 15:52one he's with. This is a this is a
- 15:54cultural viewpoint. We're like, sexual
- 15:57desire is supposed to only be oriented
- 16:00toward your partner. But that is almost
- 16:02never the case. And in fact, your
- 16:05sexuality can be activated, can be
- 16:08aroused by any number of people, any
- 16:10number of things, any number of
- 16:12situations.
- 16:14So if you are feeling your sexual desire
- 16:17aroused by something, that's a beautiful
- 16:19thing because God created that sexual
- 16:22desire. and having that be activated
- 16:24within you is making you aware of
- 16:26something taking place within your own
- 16:28body.
- 16:30But now if I turn around and I say I
- 16:32have sexual desire, therefore I have to
- 16:34have that.
- 16:36And if I don't have that, my whole life
- 16:38is ruined. I think this is what Jesus is
- 16:41getting at is that once you are
- 16:43approaching another human being with
- 16:46this deep desire, this burning desire
- 16:48like you were talking about, you have
- 16:50already violated something in that
- 16:52relationship. Can they trust you if your
- 16:55entire life orientation
- 16:57is built around this need for them to do
- 17:01something for you?
- 17:04>> Okay. I think it's kind of hard to open
- 17:06up and trust a person when that desire
- 17:09is ruling their life. Yeah.
- 17:12>> So, so that that's a fine line going
- 17:15between a healthy desire that a man
- 17:17should have for his wife versus
- 17:19>> Yeah.
- 17:20>> versus an is there a such thing? Can you
- 17:22actually less can you have an excessive
- 17:25desire
- 17:26for your wife?
- 17:28>> This was a question asked by some of the
- 17:30leading researchers on porna. actually
- 17:33said, "Can a man commit porna?" Uh,
- 17:35which is translated today as fornication
- 17:37or sexual immorality. Can a man commit
- 17:40porna with his wife? Uh, it's a very
- 17:43interesting exploration. I'm not sure
- 17:44that the results were actually very
- 17:46conclusive, but it's an it was an
- 17:48interesting exploration because it
- 17:51recognizes that marital status is not
- 17:54the thing that makes sexual desire
- 17:56healthy.
- 17:57>> Okay. Marital status can create a
- 18:00beautiful space to cultivate sexual
- 18:02desire, to cultivate intimate
- 18:04connections,
- 18:05but it doesn't all by itself suddenly
- 18:08change the horny 16-year-old boy who
- 18:11didn't get a good sex education into a
- 18:14married 26-year-old man who still hasn't
- 18:17gotten a good sex education and is not
- 18:19sure exactly how he can please his
- 18:22partner or how he can even be satisfied
- 18:24himself in that connection. So I think
- 18:27that question is important um of of one
- 18:30of can you commit this within a married
- 18:32relationship and I would argue the
- 18:35answer is yes.
- 18:38If you don't learn how to hold your own
- 18:40desire how can you approach somebody
- 18:43else with an invitation to meet you
- 18:45intimately in a way that is safe?
- 18:47>> I I would think the excess desire for
- 18:50your wife is not the problem. The
- 18:52problem is are you expecting her to meet
- 18:56that desire every single time without
- 18:58con her consideration into it? I think
- 19:01that's that would be more unethical. And
- 19:03in that case, this is where I would
- 19:05almost make the case for masturbation. I
- 19:07mean, there's naturally going to be a
- 19:08discrepancy the majority of the time in
- 19:11sex drives. So, so if you're always
- 19:14having to go to your wife and she's been
- 19:17told 1 Corinthians 7:3-5 that she must
- 19:20always be available for her husband all
- 19:22the time. You know, this guy wants to
- 19:24have sex every day and she's good with
- 19:25once every two weeks.
- 19:27>> Like that's a lot of pressure and burden
- 19:29of performance upon the wife. Sometimes
- 19:31he can just sit with that energy and not
- 19:32have to do anything with it. But at
- 19:34other times, it's very healthy and
- 19:36actually even the loving thing to do is
- 19:39to take care of his own sexual desire on
- 19:42his own and not have her be so burdened
- 19:46because he's biologically just made
- 19:48different.
- 19:49>> And I I love that nuance you're drawing
- 19:51out that it's not the desire itself that
- 19:54is problematic.
- 19:56It is possible for a desire to grow
- 19:58until it consumes your life. That's what
- 20:00Jesus is talking about by the word lust.
- 20:02This is what lust means. anytime you see
- 20:03it in the scripture, it doesn't mean
- 20:05sexual desire. It means any desire that
- 20:08grows out of proportion and consumes
- 20:10your life. If sexual desire does that, I
- 20:14think that's a place where you want to
- 20:15reach out to somebody and say, "Yes, I
- 20:17need help. This is consuming my life.
- 20:19Something is not working."
- 20:21But let's remember again that God
- 20:23created sexual desire. And your body
- 20:27functions as it's designed. You will be
- 20:31aroused. you will be turned on just like
- 20:33you will breathe in air and your heart
- 20:35will beat. And let's just say for some
- 20:38reason you were never able to fully
- 20:41breathe. Like somebody has a mask over
- 20:43your face and you feel like you're
- 20:44suffocating and unable to get the air
- 20:47that you need.
- 20:49Your whole life is going to revolve
- 20:50around this need for air
- 20:52>> because you were designed to have air.
- 20:55right
- 20:56>> now. Imagine that air is that that
- 21:00feeling of of of calm, that feeling of
- 21:03integration that comes after an amazing
- 21:06sexual experience, that feeling of home,
- 21:09that feeling of, "Wow, I went through
- 21:11all of that and I made it here."
- 21:14Your body is designed for that state.
- 21:17The body releases all of these amazing
- 21:20hormones through sex. And that happens
- 21:23whether it's with a partner or whether
- 21:24it's by yourself. And sometimes
- 21:27that happens whether or not the genitals
- 21:29are involved.
- 21:31>> I like that your goal is to not give the
- 21:35direct answer. Yes, this is right or
- 21:36yes, this is wrong or this is what the
- 21:38scripture said. You actually just say
- 21:40let's explore this together. So I'm
- 21:43telling you from my what my conclusion
- 21:45has come to is that in certain times
- 21:48masturbation could be the loving choice.
- 21:50And that's the the view in which I view
- 21:53everything in relationships is is this
- 21:55the most loving choice. So when some a
- 21:58wife will get upset that her husband uh
- 22:02after she has been the one to say no I'm
- 22:04not interested uh or or she has
- 22:07completely cut off sex altogether. I
- 22:10believe that that is sin because that is
- 22:12not the loving choice for him. you
- 22:15especially when you're have dedicated
- 22:17and said I'm I'm I'm the only outlet
- 22:19here for you.
- 22:20>> We've all agreed to this. Um so I do
- 22:23believe I do believe women are sinning.
- 22:26It's it's immoral sexual immorality to
- 22:29withhold for extended periods of time.
- 22:32Um, and is also uh immoral and unloving
- 22:36to try to tell a man how he is beholden
- 22:40to only her in that regard that he also
- 22:43doesn't own um and can enjoy that
- 22:46different version of sexuality. Because
- 22:49sometimes,
- 22:50>> you know, when you're taking care of
- 22:51your own business, then you can have
- 22:54beautiful experiences all on all on your
- 22:56own. and and to say that that's not
- 22:59biblical is or beautiful or immoral, it
- 23:02just doesn't sit right with me. Now I
- 23:05want to highlight one of the things that
- 23:07you said is when a person is the only
- 23:11acceptable sexual outlet
- 23:14and I think this is where we get to the
- 23:16problem like we talked about this even
- 23:18from the very beginning of our
- 23:19conversation is that when when the
- 23:22Christian interpretation of sexual
- 23:23ethics says the only way that you are
- 23:27allowed to experience sexual energy is
- 23:29through intercourse with your married
- 23:30partner
- 23:32and then suddenly the married partner
- 23:34does not want to do that, you're kind of
- 23:37you're stuck, right?
- 23:40>> And so there's something that has to
- 23:41give. Either the partner has to give,
- 23:43you have to give. And I appreciate what
- 23:46you're saying is that is it fair to ask
- 23:48either partner to give something that is
- 23:50so totally opposite what they're what
- 23:52they're prepared for. And I agree. I
- 23:55think the problem though is caused by
- 23:57this assumption that the Bible says
- 24:00somewhere the only person you are
- 24:03allowed to experience sexual desire with
- 24:05is your partner.
- 24:08>> Okay. So, if I'm if I'm understanding
- 24:10you correctly, you're saying you haven't
- 24:12found anywhere in the Bible
- 24:14>> that says that sex outside of a marital
- 24:16setting that is is prohibited or ungodly
- 24:19or a sin. You have you found it? Have
- 24:22you found anything that points that
- 24:23direction?
- 24:25Well, let's talk about that second word
- 24:27that we mentioned earlier then. Uh
- 24:29because lust is the first of three terms
- 24:31that really give us the the scope of a
- 24:33biblical sexual ethic. And the the
- 24:35second term is the term adultery.
- 24:38>> Okay.
- 24:38>> So, the easy answer to your question is
- 24:40no. There is nowhere the Bible says that
- 24:42sex outside of marriage is a sin.
- 24:45However, it does say that sex with
- 24:48someone else's partner without their
- 24:50consent is a violation of that partner.
- 24:55This is a this is a context in which
- 24:58again we're looking at a patriarchal
- 25:00context. The scriptures are written
- 25:01across about 4,000 years of history in
- 25:04societies where
- 25:07where women were considered to be less
- 25:09human than men. You can look at the
- 25:12teachings of Aristotle if you want to
- 25:14understand this a little bit more. But
- 25:15but e even Aristotle all the way down to
- 25:18Aquinus who's one of our our famous
- 25:19church fathers would speak about women
- 25:22as half men or incomplete humans because
- 25:24they didn't have a male body. They
- 25:25considered the male body to be the thing
- 25:28required to be fully human. And it is
- 25:31absolutely a tragedy to look at that
- 25:33kind of perspective and to see how often
- 25:35it steeps into both our modern sexual
- 25:38ethics as well as the treatment of women
- 25:40across time is it's appalling. It's a
- 25:44reflection of a cultural paradigm that
- 25:46has been harmful to women in a lot of
- 25:48ways. So that is the framework then in
- 25:51which we get the Old Testament writings
- 25:53and a lot of the laws related to thou
- 25:57shalt not commit adultery. To commit
- 25:59adultery meant that a woman who belonged
- 26:02to a man. She was his possession by
- 26:06right of marriage. She was his and only
- 26:08supposed to bear his children. That's
- 26:10why he married her was because he needed
- 26:12to make sure that there was there was a
- 26:15way that his children could come into
- 26:17this world and he wanted to make sure
- 26:19that he wasn't giving his his financial
- 26:22property the inheritance to the children
- 26:24of some other man because in this time
- 26:27you would live through your children.
- 26:29The idea of immortality was, "Oh, well,
- 26:31I live on through my children." And
- 26:34imagine if that woman who you had in
- 26:36your life to bear your children was
- 26:38actually bringing forth another man's
- 26:39child. This would this would be totally
- 26:42unacceptable.
- 26:44So, a man could have sexual connection
- 26:47with any number of women, with
- 26:49prostitutes, with concubines, with
- 26:51unmarried women. But there was one woman
- 26:54who was off limits according to the Old
- 26:57Testament scriptures. that was a woman
- 26:59who belonged to another man.
- 27:02So that is what the term adultery is
- 27:04referring to. And that's why when you
- 27:06say, well, is there anywhere in
- 27:07scripture that says sex outside of
- 27:09marriage is a sin? The answer to that is
- 27:12different if you're a man or if you're a
- 27:14woman. Because if you had a female body
- 27:17in that society, there was only one
- 27:19person you were allowed to have sex
- 27:20with. That was with your husband. If you
- 27:24had a male body, there were many
- 27:26different people you could have sex with
- 27:28as long as they didn't belong to another
- 27:30man. So, there's this dual standard that
- 27:32we see through the Hebrew scriptures up
- 27:35until the New Testament where Jesus
- 27:38teaching when he says, "Whoever looks
- 27:39upon a woman to lust after her, to
- 27:43desire to possess her, to set his life
- 27:45on having her,
- 27:48is committing adultery with her.
- 27:51This is the first time that a woman can
- 27:53actually be sexually violated.
- 27:56>> Gotcha.
- 27:57>> And and I think that's just incredible.
- 27:59So in the New Testament then you have
- 28:01you have the 1 Corinthians 7 passage
- 28:04that you mentioned earlier where not
- 28:06only does a man have authority over the
- 28:09woman's body, the woman for the first
- 28:11time maybe ever has authority over the
- 28:14man's body. That is absolutely
- 28:17revolutionary.
- 28:19there is this progression through
- 28:21scripture that is elevating women to the
- 28:24point of men and so having having these
- 28:28same these same rights
- 28:31where my question is then and I haven't
- 28:33been able to find a good answer to this
- 28:35so if you run across it I would be
- 28:36curious but
- 28:39because men throughout time had been
- 28:42able to have sexual connection with any
- 28:43number of people now that women have
- 28:46this elevation in their status is are
- 28:50they also permitted that kind of
- 28:53interaction?
- 28:54>> If you don't have the history of the
- 28:56fact that women were property, uh they
- 28:59had no rights. They couldn't divorce. It
- 29:02was what it was. And so you don't see it
- 29:05being addressed from the women's
- 29:06perspective because it was always about
- 29:08protecting the men.
- 29:10>> And the things that were important uh to
- 29:13note back then took that that lens and
- 29:15that that angle. also speaks into the
- 29:19woman's worth about being a virgin.
- 29:21>> Yeah, it's it's fascinating. And the way
- 29:24that I put this in my book is that thou
- 29:26shalt not commit adultery is referring
- 29:28to property law, not to sexual ethics.
- 29:32This the specific thing with regard to
- 29:33virginity. There's a couple of reasons
- 29:35why you would value that. One, you would
- 29:37want to know that the woman was able to
- 29:39safeguard her body and keep any other
- 29:42men from that body. So when you married
- 29:45her in order to bear your children, you
- 29:48would know that she could continue
- 29:51continue that habit. Whereas if she was
- 29:54not a virgin, she might after you're
- 29:56married decide she wants to have sex
- 29:57with somebody who maybe maybe they're
- 30:00more sexually aligned, maybe they have
- 30:01greater compatibility, and now she's
- 30:03carrying another man's child. That is
- 30:06unacceptable. And the reason why that's
- 30:08unacceptable is because that other man's
- 30:10child should not inherit your wealth. So
- 30:13the virgin as the as the daughter of her
- 30:16father could be sold for four times the
- 30:18amount of money as a daughter who was
- 30:21not a virgin. And if she was sold as a
- 30:24virgin and then the husband finds out
- 30:27that she wasn't,
- 30:29the penalty for that was actually death.
- 30:32Like this was such a big deal to them.
- 30:36But there was never any question about
- 30:38whether or not the husband had had a
- 30:40sexual experience with somebody else,
- 30:42whether or not he was going to. It
- 30:43didn't matter. What mattered was keeping
- 30:46that womb exclusive property of the man.
- 30:49>> I like how you said the it's a it was a
- 30:52property law issue versus a sexual ethic
- 30:55issue.
- 30:57So that I think that's the important
- 30:59distinct thing and the lens in which you
- 31:01need to understand what's being written
- 31:03about when you look at these scriptures
- 31:05there. Um that was and the fact where
- 31:08you talked about in first Corinthians
- 31:11was the first time where women started
- 31:14getting more rights like before is like
- 31:16oh no you have you have authority over
- 31:18man's body that that was unheard of that
- 31:20was a radical stance to to proclaim.
- 31:23>> Yes it was.
- 31:24>> Okay. So adultery biblically simply
- 31:28means it's and it's a property issue.
- 31:30Once again, it's not from a moral point
- 31:32of view. If this is a this is a property
- 31:34of somebody else and you cannot violate
- 31:36someone else's property. Is there any
- 31:38other scripture that speaks to it from a
- 31:41from an ethical point of view?
- 31:43>> So in terms of property law, I think
- 31:44we've mostly covered that and and that's
- 31:47where where adultery comes in. But
- 31:49there's another thing that I that I want
- 31:51to
- 31:53well, there's another word that's
- 31:56important for us to look at. We're
- 31:58looking at three of the major terms that
- 31:59that take us through the scriptures. We
- 32:01looked at we've looked at lust, at least
- 32:03in the Greek. We didn't we didn't take a
- 32:05look at it beyond that. Um, but
- 32:07recognizing it as desire and wanting to
- 32:10stay ruling over your desire is key.
- 32:13Second piece is not violating somebody
- 32:15else's property. that is the teachings
- 32:17on adultery. The third word and the word
- 32:20that becomes most interesting to me is
- 32:22the word in Greek porna.
- 32:25This is actually where we get the root
- 32:27of the word pornography from. So you'll
- 32:29recognize the the the initial root
- 32:31there.
- 32:35This word
- 32:37is the reason why I became a Bible
- 32:38scholar and sex educator.
- 32:42Because every time I heard somebody
- 32:44preach on fornication or sexual
- 32:47immorality, every pastor had a different
- 32:50definition of what that meant, of what
- 32:54that was. And they would use it to say
- 32:56everything from homosexuality
- 33:00to
- 33:02oral sex to premarital sex was sinful.
- 33:08Some people would even say that certain
- 33:09sexual positions were porna. And I said,
- 33:14if there's a word that means everything,
- 33:17it also means nothing. And I started to
- 33:20ask, well, what did it mean to the
- 33:24authors of the biblical text? And how
- 33:26can we find out?
- 33:28And the deeper that I went into this
- 33:30study, I began to find some people have
- 33:32taken a number of different angles to
- 33:34answering this question. And if your
- 33:36listeners are or people that really want
- 33:38to do some deep dive, and maybe you'd be
- 33:40interested in this as well, one of the
- 33:42best authors on this question is a woman
- 33:46named Kathy Gaka. And I'm not sure I
- 33:49pronounced that last name correctly.
- 33:50It's g a ca. But Kathy gives a
- 33:54philosophical background of porna.
- 33:57And the way that that word comes to us
- 34:00today. It has a really long convoluted
- 34:03journey.
- 34:04And if it's all right with you, I'd like
- 34:06to give us just a little bit of an
- 34:08overview of how we got from the biblical
- 34:10use of porna to today where it means any
- 34:13sex outside of marriage is a sin. Does
- 34:15that sound good?
- 34:16>> Please. Yes. take us down that path.
- 34:17>> Okay, there are a couple of interesting
- 34:20stops. And so the the word is originally
- 34:24Greek. It comes from a Greek root that
- 34:27means to sell and it was eventually used
- 34:31to mean to sell sex or to sell sexual
- 34:34services which is the word prostitution.
- 34:37Now in that context though there were
- 34:40many different words to indicate
- 34:41prostitution. Porna was used as a basic
- 34:44commodity exchange. If you were going to
- 34:48there were other kinds of of prostitute
- 34:51relationships.
- 34:53They're skipping my mind at the moment,
- 34:54but there's different levels of class
- 34:56and expense. And at the higher level,
- 34:58you'd have somebody more like a cortison
- 35:00who was an educated woman, somebody you
- 35:02would take with you out into public. But
- 35:05a prostitute was somebody who you would
- 35:07just use when you wanted to get down and
- 35:10dirty and get it done with. and they
- 35:12were typically from the lower classes of
- 35:14society and oftent times sexual slaves.
- 35:17So this is this is a loaded term but is
- 35:21rarely ever used after 400 BC. It kind
- 35:25of showed up in Greece and then it kind
- 35:26of vanished
- 35:28but it was picked up by the writers of
- 35:31the Septuagent who were translating the
- 35:34Hebrew scriptures into Greek about the
- 35:37same time. This is 400 years before
- 35:39Jesus.
- 35:40So this is about 400 BC. The Septuagen
- 35:43is being written and they use this term
- 35:45Pora as a sub a substitute for some of
- 35:48the Hebrew terms.
- 35:50>> Okay?
- 35:52>> And
- 35:54at the same time, so the word's being
- 35:56picked up by the scriptures in the Greek
- 35:58and it's also being picked up a little
- 36:00bit by some of the philosophers. So
- 36:02Kathy Gaka looks into how the
- 36:04philosophers used porna as and
- 36:08anexuality as a whole to measure the
- 36:11value of somebody's philosophical
- 36:13beliefs. They're like if you're willing
- 36:15to give up sex for your beliefs, it must
- 36:17be a pretty powerful belief, right? So
- 36:20when you get to the New Testament, the
- 36:22time of Jesus and Paul, this word porna
- 36:25has a couple of different meanings that
- 36:26are already imposed on it.
- 36:29the the Hebrews are using it to say,
- 36:32"Oh, all of the all of the non-Jewish
- 36:34people are porna. They just do all the
- 36:37wrong things sexually." So, they're
- 36:38turning it into something that's a
- 36:40little bit vague. But in their own
- 36:42scriptures, which is the majority of the
- 36:44time this term has been used, the word
- 36:46porna is it means unfaithfulness to God.
- 36:51>> It doesn't necessarily mean to sell like
- 36:53it originally meant. It more means to
- 36:56sell oneself out.
- 36:59And the way this shows up throughout the
- 37:01Hebrew scriptures is over and over
- 37:03again, the nation of Israel is depicted
- 37:05as the wife of God. Now, a wife, as we
- 37:08remember, was supposed to only have sex
- 37:09with one person. There's sexual
- 37:11exclusivity here. But she would do
- 37:13something called play the [ __ ] She
- 37:16would act like a prostitute because a
- 37:18prostitute is somebody who sold their
- 37:21sexuality in exchange for financial
- 37:23gain. This was not something that was
- 37:25bad. And prostitution is never called a
- 37:27sin in the Bible when we're referring to
- 37:30a female prostitute.
- 37:32And it wasn't considered a sin. It was
- 37:34considered shameful. It was considered
- 37:36like, you know, it's not something you
- 37:38do if you're a higher class person. And
- 37:40if you're a woman, you you don't really
- 37:42want to be a prostitute. You would much
- 37:43rather be a wife. You have much more
- 37:45cushy situation there. And maybe a
- 37:48concubine. Concubines also that was that
- 37:50was a pretty nice uh place to be. But a
- 37:52prostitute was the independent woman who
- 37:55got to decide how she made her money,
- 37:57how she lived her life.
- 38:00So all of these things are kind of
- 38:02coming together when we get New
- 38:03Testament text and they say something
- 38:05like flee porna.
- 38:09And so we look in this, this is 1
- 38:10Corinthians chapter 6 and and the King
- 38:13James, they translate it as flee
- 38:16fornication.
- 38:18In the English language, fornication
- 38:21today means sex outside of marriage.
- 38:25But fornication at the time the King
- 38:27James was written meant going to a
- 38:28brothel.
- 38:30So it still had a little bit of that old
- 38:32porna prostitution connection. And
- 38:36fornication
- 38:37was the same word used by Jerome who
- 38:40translated the scriptures into Latin is
- 38:42this was 400 AD. Now he used a Latin
- 38:45term fornicatio.
- 38:47Now, I'm I'm nerding out, so I hope this
- 38:50isn't too deep, but for
- 38:51>> fascinating.
- 38:54No, we'll nerd out together.
- 38:57>> All right. Fornicatio,
- 39:00it refers to this kind of a meeting of
- 39:02joints. It's an architectural term. And
- 39:05if you ever see like an ancient Roman
- 39:08city, you're going to see all these
- 39:09places with fornixes that look like
- 39:11this. This is the entryway, the passing
- 39:14through a wall. And these gates were
- 39:18where you would meet a prostitute.
- 39:22>> And so this is why Jerome, who's
- 39:24translating the Bible from Greek into
- 39:26Latin, picks fornicatio as the word.
- 39:30He's like, he's still trying to give the
- 39:31illusion that somebody is selling their
- 39:33sexuality.
- 39:35Now, we finally get to today and we read
- 39:38our English Bibles and we're like, flee
- 39:40fornication. We're like, flee premarital
- 39:42sex. Flee having sexual thoughts. flee
- 39:45having sexual desire within your body.
- 39:47And none of that is present in that
- 39:50original concept.
- 39:52>> Well, that's a that's a mic drop, right?
- 39:54I'm sorry, but that's a mic drop right
- 39:56there. None of that is present. But that
- 39:58that is the message. We are told over
- 40:00and over again that that's what
- 40:02fornication means is sexual immorality.
- 40:04This broad scope and you're saying that
- 40:06it has nothing to do with that.
- 40:09>> No,
- 40:11>> that's huge.
- 40:11>> No, it's our TED talk is done here.
- 40:14We're done.
- 40:16If
- 40:16>> we could just end the podcast on that.
- 40:18Okay, go ahead. Let's because I know I'm
- 40:20I'm liking this path. Let's continue.
- 40:22>> I mean, that's why I ended up publishing
- 40:24this book. Um I have to hold it up
- 40:26because I love it. But sacred I have it.
- 40:28I bought it, by the way.
- 40:29>> Sexual ethic. I love that. And and and
- 40:32the the section you've probably seen
- 40:34like I I touch on adultery. I touch on
- 40:36lust and but porna is the is the hinge
- 40:41here. And so I'm in a New Testament
- 40:44class right now. We're studying First
- 40:45Corinthians. And so I'm reading some of
- 40:47the leading New Testament scholars on
- 40:49what does flee fornication mean? And
- 40:52they will say something like this. Don't
- 40:54commit fornication with a prostitute.
- 40:57This is a linguistic nightmare
- 41:00because fornication in the English
- 41:03language means sex outside of marriage
- 41:05or you're having a one night stand. But
- 41:07that's not what the text says.
- 41:09It says to flee prostituting yourself.
- 41:14>> Flee selling yourself out to money, to a
- 41:18government, to some economic system as
- 41:20opposed to
- 41:21>> or to another god.
- 41:23>> Yeah.
- 41:25>> And in fact, in in this Greco Roman
- 41:28context, when you became a Christian,
- 41:31you were suddenly no longer
- 41:32participating in the socioeconomic
- 41:34society, which revolved around temples
- 41:36and sacrifices. And you would you would
- 41:38go to the marketplace and you would eat
- 41:40meat that have been sacrificed to idols.
- 41:42It's a big topic in first Corinthians.
- 41:44You would go to the marketplace and and
- 41:47you would as part of exchange, right?
- 41:50You're using currency of the government.
- 41:52If you're part of a guild, you usually
- 41:54have to participate in some sort of god
- 41:56worship. And so to become a Christian,
- 41:58you're turning your back on your social
- 41:59economic security.
- 42:02>> Okay? Now remember the way porna is used
- 42:04throughout the old testament prophets is
- 42:06somebody is seeking economic security by
- 42:09exchanging their faithfulness to their
- 42:11partner God and giving that faithfulness
- 42:14to another lover who's going to provide
- 42:16them with money and financial security
- 42:18in return.
- 42:19>> So Paul who is a Hebrew scholar who is a
- 42:22teacher of the law is like what would be
- 42:24a good word to use to talk to these
- 42:27Christians about selling out to the
- 42:29economic system in the world around
- 42:30them. I got it. Porna.
- 42:34Why? Because the intimacy that you share
- 42:37with God is like the intimacy of a
- 42:39husband and a wife. And when you sell
- 42:42out on that intimacy, that is the same
- 42:45thing as when a woman plays the
- 42:47prostitute. And we all know how bad that
- 42:48is. We don't want to do that to God.
- 42:52Wow.
- 42:53That's fascinating.
- 42:56There's a lot there. So fornication is
- 42:59what we're told it means premarital sex,
- 43:02sex outside of marriage. The like we
- 43:04have pastors every Sunday that are
- 43:06teaching sexual immorality based upon
- 43:09this word fornication. I don't know I
- 43:11don't know the process to become a
- 43:12pastor. Where where are they getting
- 43:14this idea? And how do how do how do you
- 43:16have what appears to be a very
- 43:19reasonable
- 43:20and quite compelling argument to your
- 43:23translation for what you believe this
- 43:26word fornication means? How come pastors
- 43:28aren't are coming to the same
- 43:30conclusions?
- 43:31>> I I knew that in order to dig deep and
- 43:34really lay a foundation for this
- 43:36understanding, I needed to learn Hebrew
- 43:38and Greek.
- 43:40You can either learn Hebrew and Greek in
- 43:41state universities who don't really care
- 43:43too much about the ethics. They're just
- 43:45concerned about the language and the
- 43:46literature. Or you can go to
- 43:49conservative theological seminaries that
- 43:51will kick you out if you don't agree
- 43:53with their sexual ethics.
- 43:56So for me, if I even wanted to study and
- 43:59get access to the level of research that
- 44:01I've done, I was either going to have to
- 44:04give up consistency and integrity with
- 44:06what I believe is a is a biblical model
- 44:08of sexual ethics, or I was going to have
- 44:11to learn it totally detached from the
- 44:13Christian tradition. I was fortunate to
- 44:16end up at a seminary, Union Presbyterian
- 44:18Seminary, that has this crossover of the
- 44:22reformed tradition without trying to
- 44:24impose upon you. Here's how you have to
- 44:26live your life to be a good Christian.
- 44:28They're like, maybe the way that I
- 44:31express my relationship with God looks
- 44:34different than the way that you do, and
- 44:36maybe we can have space for that. Even
- 44:38though I will still go to our library
- 44:40and all of the leading researchers are
- 44:42still saying exactly the same thing.
- 44:44They're like porna means fornication.
- 44:47And so the roots of this are very very
- 44:51old. I've been I've been kind of
- 44:54stirring around in them lately. I I went
- 44:56we have we have some ancient Bibles and
- 44:59some ancient is like 500 years old. And
- 45:04so I I was going and I'm looking in
- 45:06them. I'm like, well, okay, so how are
- 45:07these different than our texts today?
- 45:09What words do they have? Then they have
- 45:10this word porna which means we need we
- 45:13need something called a lexicon. And we
- 45:15look at a lexicon to say well porna in
- 45:17Greek means what in Latin means what in
- 45:20English? And I had to go back 400 years
- 45:23before I found this lexicon that was
- 45:25very clear and it showed that the Greek
- 45:29word porna has as its root to sell. We
- 45:33need to understand that every time we're
- 45:35looking at today as fornication or
- 45:37sexual immorality, it means to sell
- 45:39something. You're engaging in some kind
- 45:41of transaction.
- 45:43So that's that's our modern that's our
- 45:46modern puzzle is that people don't let
- 45:48you speak and people don't let you study
- 45:50if you have a different approach to
- 45:52sexual ethics. And and I think part of
- 45:54this is is because it's so personal to
- 45:58an individual that if you're a married
- 46:01couple who has stayed together for say
- 46:0350 years because you believe that God
- 46:06says that's what you have to do and you
- 46:09hated every minute of it and then I come
- 46:11along and say I don't know why you did
- 46:13that because it's not there in the Bible
- 46:16or someone who has for 20 years like
- 46:19this was my experience 20 years of
- 46:22sexual ual desire, no way of being able
- 46:25to express that, still regrets to this
- 46:28day of having missed out on so many
- 46:30moments.
- 46:32If if I'm coming to somebody that is
- 46:34still holding on, and I have friends who
- 46:35are still holding on to this. They're
- 46:37like, "Oh, I can't do it until I get
- 46:38married and I haven't done it for 20
- 46:40years. Going to hold it." And I'm like,
- 46:42"But why? It's not there in the Bible."
- 46:44Suddenly their whole life orientation
- 46:46gets challenged and like you must be you
- 46:49must be from the devil because I've
- 46:51spent my whole life fighting this
- 46:53temptation.
- 46:54>> Right? So let let's talk about like a
- 46:57real life scenario. A lot of people just
- 46:59are not opting to get married at all. U
- 47:02many will choose to cohabitate
- 47:04and of course there's sexual relations
- 47:06going on in those situations and these
- 47:08are these are good people and these are
- 47:10in committed relationships but they're
- 47:12not married. Um, but these are
- 47:14consenting people who really love each
- 47:16other and
- 47:17>> doing everything outside of a a a
- 47:20marriage contract and a marriage
- 47:21commitment. With your understanding of
- 47:24what the scripture actually says, would
- 47:25those people be committing porna?
- 47:28>> Possibly. Again, I'm an academic. I'm
- 47:31sorry. I don't have the yes or no. But I
- 47:33I will I'll tell you why I say possibly.
- 47:36The way that this term is used in the
- 47:38New Testament is to sell yourself to
- 47:40something. It could be an economic
- 47:41system. But remember how we talked about
- 47:44lust being an overpowering desire.
- 47:46>> Yes.
- 47:47>> Because porna can also happen when you
- 47:50let that desire begin to control your
- 47:51life. So one of the things that that
- 47:54Paul will often do is he'll is he'll say
- 47:57this, don't commit porna, practice
- 48:00self-control.
- 48:02Which as a scholar and and through my
- 48:05this is the method that I use to study
- 48:06the scripture. I'm like, well, so porna
- 48:09is the opposite of self-control. And now
- 48:11we understand something about this. And
- 48:13what Paul is most likely indicating here
- 48:15is that when you let some desire govern
- 48:18your life,
- 48:20any desire other than your desire for
- 48:22God,
- 48:23you are now not being faithful to your
- 48:26relationship with God. And sexual desire
- 48:29being an incredibly powerful desire. If
- 48:32I believe it's a sin to have sex, if I
- 48:34believe that having sex without being
- 48:37married is separating me from God, I
- 48:39think I'm actually going to experience
- 48:40that separation.
- 48:42>> The belief that it's going to that
- 48:45itself that is creating that potentially
- 48:48the porna whereas if you didn't believe
- 48:50that it was a sin, then it wouldn't be.
- 48:53>> It's not the not the not the full scope
- 48:55of it. That is a part of it because
- 48:59well, let's talk for a minute about the
- 49:00couples who who they believe that any
- 49:03sex other than married sex with their
- 49:04partner is a sin. If they're going and
- 49:07masturbating secretly, they're going to
- 49:09be experiencing the effects of shame.
- 49:10They're going to be keeping secrets from
- 49:12their partner. They're going to like
- 49:13they're they know they're doing
- 49:15something wrong and they're doing it
- 49:16anyway. So now they feel bad about
- 49:17themselves and they're ultimately being
- 49:20governed by a desire because there's no
- 49:23there's no alternative option. But if we
- 49:25can teach them how to understand their
- 49:28body, how to channel that desire, how to
- 49:31experience the body and how to choose
- 49:34their response to that sexual desire.
- 49:37Suddenly
- 49:38that can be part of their relationship
- 49:40with God. And they can pray and they can
- 49:42say, "Oh God, here is my experience.
- 49:44What can I do? How can I love myself in
- 49:46this scenario? How can I love you? How
- 49:48can I love my partner?" And now whatever
- 49:51it is they're doing is moving them
- 49:53deeper into connection with God.
- 49:55>> Let's stick with the donut analogy. You
- 49:56probably don't want to eat a donut every
- 49:57single time you crave a donut, right?
- 49:59That just is not going to be healthy.
- 50:00That's not going to be But not to say
- 50:02that the craving itself is bad.
- 50:05>> It's just that you if you choose to eat
- 50:08the doughnut,
- 50:09>> you shouldn't be beating yourself up
- 50:10about eating the doughnut. You like
- 50:12enjoy the experience. choose it
- 50:14periodically knowing that it's within
- 50:17the whole scope of delights in the
- 50:20world. I'm choosing to eat this
- 50:22doughnut. I'm not going to feel bad
- 50:24about it. I'm not going to make the
- 50:25choice to eat the doughnut every time,
- 50:27but when I do, I'm going to enjoy it.
- 50:30And then it's done without that guilt
- 50:32and shame.
- 50:33>> And this is the shift when we talk about
- 50:34sexual ethics. So the question you've
- 50:36asked me a few times is you're like,
- 50:37"Well, does the Bible say sex outside of
- 50:39marriage is a sin?" I'm like, well, if
- 50:41you think that sex outside of marriage
- 50:42is a sin and you do that, oh my
- 50:44goodness, by all means, you are going to
- 50:46have so much shame, so much
- 50:47disconnection, so much harm come into
- 50:49your life. And again, if you're if
- 50:52you're having sex outside of marriage in
- 50:53a way that's harming your partner,
- 50:55harming other people in a way that you
- 50:58know you don't want to, but you're doing
- 50:59it anyway. This is the idea. Sin is
- 51:02about missing the mark of what we're
- 51:04called to. This is this is another
- 51:06beautiful Greek and Hebrew term. It's
- 51:08saying, "Hey, you are called to
- 51:10something." And I think the call,
- 51:12similar to what you said, is toward
- 51:14intimacy, toward this feeling of
- 51:16wholeness and connection with God and
- 51:18with your body and with other people.
- 51:20And when we behave in ways like say
- 51:23eating the donut all the time, sure, it
- 51:25gives a dopamine rush, but then what
- 51:27about the stomach ache that comes after?
- 51:28Or what about the fact that you need
- 51:30another one in in 30 minutes? If we're
- 51:33stuck in this feeling of donuts are bad,
- 51:36we're going to try to ignore these
- 51:38little signs that maybe there's
- 51:41something else that we want. And I'm I'm
- 51:43speaking of this just to be very
- 51:44explicit in in terms of pornography.
- 51:47This was my own experience as I started
- 51:49looking at my desire for God and my
- 51:52desire for pornography. I really I to
- 51:55this day I enjoy some of the beauty that
- 51:58gets displayed in pornography.
- 52:00But as long as I was approaching that
- 52:03with shame, with realizing I was
- 52:05sinning, I couldn't pause to ask myself,
- 52:08why do I like this? And what do I
- 52:10actually want? And what am I looking
- 52:11for? And now sometimes I know I'm just
- 52:16going to I could be going to porn. I
- 52:18could be going to Instagram. I could be
- 52:19going to donuts actually because all of
- 52:22these things give your body a dopamine
- 52:24hit. And if I'm going to get a dopamine
- 52:26hit and I realize that now I can pause
- 52:30and say, "Hey, I'm not coming here
- 52:31because I want to appreciate something
- 52:33beautiful or I'm not coming here um or
- 52:38to to use this in a more negative
- 52:39sense." I think a lot of people use
- 52:41pornography as a substitute for intimacy
- 52:44because it still releases those those
- 52:47hormones and and sometimes it's like
- 52:50opening a good book or watching a movie
- 52:51or playing a video game. It allows you
- 52:53to escape from life for just a moment.
- 52:56And with a male body, it's usually
- 52:58pretty quick to get to that dopamine
- 53:00hit. Like, you know, you can do a
- 53:01minute, five minutes, and you're there
- 53:03and suddenly life feels good again. But
- 53:06if you're doing that without facing your
- 53:09problems, if you're seeking intimacy and
- 53:11you get to the end and you realize
- 53:12nobody's there, or if you do this and
- 53:15you think that God is displeased,
- 53:18you're going to eventually realize this
- 53:21isn't everything I wanted. And at that
- 53:24point, you need somebody who's there who
- 53:25can help you pursue. Maybe intimacy
- 53:28means learning how to connect with
- 53:29people and have a good conversation.
- 53:32Maybe maybe you're touch starved because
- 53:34men in today's world are starved for
- 53:36touch. We don't touch one another
- 53:37because we're like, "Oh dear, if you hug
- 53:39for longer than two seconds, you must be
- 53:41gay." And you know, if you're
- 53:42heterosexual, that's kind of that's kind
- 53:44of frightening. And if you're in a
- 53:45church that will kick you out for that,
- 53:47there's no way you're going there. So,
- 53:50if we're seeking touch, what are some
- 53:52good ways that we can begin to
- 53:54experience connection with our bodies?
- 53:57What are some good ways we can
- 53:58experience intimacy with other people?
- 54:00Or if it's just drive, you're like, uh,
- 54:03I want to express this thing. Sexual
- 54:05desire is your creative power and you
- 54:09can create, you can create art, you can
- 54:11create a business, you can create all
- 54:13kinds of things with your life. But
- 54:15unless we learn how and this is this is
- 54:18something
- 54:20I have a number of friends who teach
- 54:22this is they teach how can a man be able
- 54:25to hold his sexual energy and choose to
- 54:28direct it in a way that is true to
- 54:30himself, true to his connection with God
- 54:32and true to his partner.
- 54:35But that takes work. It takes education.
- 54:37It takes understanding the body. It
- 54:38takes getting rid of some of these ideas
- 54:40that, hey, this thing that I want is a
- 54:42sin and realizing, oh, this thing that I
- 54:44want, maybe there's something good
- 54:46behind it.
- 54:47>> Many times I come across as quite pro
- 54:50pornography and and I and I'm not. I'm
- 54:53just not into shame. Um, and I'm not
- 54:56into somebody trying to a wife trying to
- 54:59control her husband and what he does,
- 55:02especially after she's already declined.
- 55:03Because my thought is, well, if she was
- 55:06really that concerned with it, then she
- 55:09would make herself more available. I
- 55:11have an order of operations that I like
- 55:13men to go into. If he is feeling that
- 55:15sexual energy and would like to have an
- 55:17experience with his wife, you're giving
- 55:18her the opportunity for that intimacy in
- 55:21that specific regard. If she says no,
- 55:24then at that point, then he chooses what
- 55:26to do with that sexual energy instead of
- 55:29saying, "Well, these are my only options
- 55:31because my wife says that's the only
- 55:32options." I want him to choose it for
- 55:33himself. Now whether he chooses to
- 55:36redirect that energy or whether he
- 55:39chooses to experience his own activity,
- 55:41that's fine. But that's his choice. And
- 55:43I just don't like the control behind
- 55:45what most women bring when they are
- 55:47married. Well, and if we suddenly open
- 55:49up this option for him of masturbation
- 55:52or creation or or even just learning to
- 55:56breathe that energy in and to experience
- 55:58it and to just be so thrilled that he's
- 56:00turned on and aroused, like it feels
- 56:02amazing. If we can help a man direct his
- 56:05energy inward to appreciate his own
- 56:08body's function, this this to me is is
- 56:10huge because as long as I'm going to as
- 56:14long as I'm seeking sex for the sake of
- 56:16gratification,
- 56:18my partner is going to feel that. But if
- 56:21I can seek sex for the sake of
- 56:22connection because I don't need them
- 56:25just because I'm turned on. I would like
- 56:28to share this with them because this is
- 56:30an invitation. Now I've I've completely
- 56:32flipped the tables on my partner where
- 56:34I'm no longer the one who's coming. I
- 56:36need this. Please help satisfy this
- 56:38problem that I have. Fix me. And I'm
- 56:41saying, "Oh, look at this. You've turned
- 56:43this on in me." Um, I love that. I love
- 56:46myself. I'm so excited about this. You
- 56:48can share this with me or I can hold
- 56:50this and I'm fine either way. coming to
- 56:54it as an empowered man into that
- 56:57invitation is now a hey do you want to
- 56:59cultivate intimacy together
- 57:02and the sad part is when a woman does
- 57:04not know her own body enough and his
- 57:06capacity and when a man does not know
- 57:08how to activate that in her that
- 57:12invitation is going to sound different
- 57:13coming from both ways and that means sex
- 57:15is not necessarily a place that this
- 57:17couple can experience intimacy and so
- 57:20for me kind of what I what I what I
- 57:22would encourage people to do is to seek
- 57:23the education kind of like what you're
- 57:25providing is first let's free our minds,
- 57:28open up these possibilities. Let's let
- 57:31go of this idea there's one narrow way
- 57:33that we can do this and realize from a
- 57:36Christian perspective God is infinite
- 57:37and diverse and your sexual expression
- 57:39is going to look like nobody else. If
- 57:42you can do this in a way where you are
- 57:44holding your energy, not being dominated
- 57:46by desire, not violating another person,
- 57:49and you are intentionally cultivating
- 57:51love,
- 57:52you're going to have to get educated on
- 57:54how to do that. You can't just be
- 57:56ignorant and show up and say, "Hey, I
- 57:58asked for sex and they said no." I think
- 58:00we both have to get down there,
- 58:01especially if the couples want to work
- 58:03this out together and learn how does her
- 58:05body work? How does his body work? What
- 58:08works for them? Where does he hold it?
- 58:10and where can they share? But as long as
- 58:13they're thinking, "Oh dear, you know,
- 58:14we're restricted to missionary
- 58:15position," which some pastors will
- 58:17teach. They're like, "Porna means
- 58:18missionary position for whatever reason,
- 58:22that's the only one you can do." They
- 58:24have no options. And so really what my
- 58:27work is here is to to liberate people to
- 58:30have those available options. And now to
- 58:32say, do you want to love each other?
- 58:33Well, go learn. Go learn from somebody
- 58:36who's a little bit sketchy. according to
- 58:40your comfort level.
- 58:41>> Find out about the capacity of your
- 58:43body. Touch yourself in places that you
- 58:46haven't met before.
- 58:47>> So, I understand what you're saying
- 58:49about the sexual uh redirection and it's
- 58:52a viable option. I don't see how that
- 58:54plays out realistically in dead bedroom
- 58:57situations where the wife just said,
- 58:59"You know what? This is off the table.
- 59:01>> I'm no longer interested in sex. It is
- 59:03what it is. You're just going to have to
- 59:04accept it." And that's where many I'm
- 59:07I'm talking probably millions of men are
- 59:10in this this position. So what what do I
- 59:13tell these guys who are living in these
- 59:16situations of what to do or or what what
- 59:19their options are biblically? They
- 59:20they're good men who don't want to sin.
- 59:23>> It's going to be challenging especially
- 59:24if you have a partner that is asexual.
- 59:27So maybe maybe your partner does not
- 59:30want to have sex at all. That is just
- 59:32not part of their conditioning. that's
- 59:34not part of the desire. I'm sure that's
- 59:36probably not the way that it was
- 59:38originally in the relationship. And we
- 59:40all grow and we all change over time.
- 59:42So, one of the things that I think about
- 59:44here is what is the what is the meaning
- 59:48of a shared activity?
- 59:51And by that, I'll give us an example.
- 59:53There's a there's a a man and a woman
- 59:56that I know who they are not allowed to
- 59:59have lunch with anybody of the opposite
- 1:00:01sex. This married couple thinks that
- 1:00:03that would be cheating to have lunch
- 1:00:05with someone of the opposite sex.
- 1:00:07Another person is
- 1:00:08>> stupid. I don't know if it's cheating,
- 1:00:09but it's it's a dumb idea.
- 1:00:11>> It could be. And and there's other
- 1:00:14people who are like, well, don't even
- 1:00:16talk to a person of the opposite sex.
- 1:00:19And maybe there's some who are like,
- 1:00:20well, you know, I'm fine if you dance
- 1:00:23with somebody of the opposite sex, or
- 1:00:25maybe snuggle with somebody of the
- 1:00:27opposite sex. Um, provided that I know
- 1:00:29you're coming home to me. provided I
- 1:00:31know you're not leaving me. And then
- 1:00:33there are some couples who they are fine
- 1:00:36with somebody sharing an actual sexual
- 1:00:38experience with somebody else
- 1:00:40because they know that they're going to
- 1:00:42be coming back because they know that in
- 1:00:44fact this is their way of loving one
- 1:00:46another because if I'm the male partner
- 1:00:48and sex is a value of mine and I know
- 1:00:51that my partner hates it, I think it
- 1:00:54would be more loving for my partner to
- 1:00:56find another way to satisfy that sexual
- 1:00:59desire. I think my partner could love me
- 1:01:02best by helping me walk through that
- 1:01:03process of finding another way to
- 1:01:06satisfy that desire as opposed to me
- 1:01:09forcing something or her forcing
- 1:01:11something and making that happen in
- 1:01:13marriage. Because again, if we're back
- 1:01:15to this sexual ethic thing, the whole
- 1:01:17married equals moral has been the
- 1:01:19paradigm of Christian sexual ethics for
- 1:01:21centuries.
- 1:01:23sex. Let me let me talk about this for
- 1:01:26just a minute because this goes all the
- 1:01:27way back to 300 AD. This is about the
- 1:01:31time of Emperor Constantine, the Council
- 1:01:32of Nika.
- 1:01:34300 to 400. This is years centuries
- 1:01:37after Christ. But by this time,
- 1:01:40Christianity had become so antisex
- 1:01:44that people would argue that any sex at
- 1:01:46all was porna.
- 1:01:50>> Any sex. It didn't matter if you were
- 1:01:51married or not. Clement, who was the
- 1:01:54bishop of Rome, was like, "This is a
- 1:01:56problem because if Christians aren't
- 1:01:58having sex, where's procreation
- 1:01:59happening?"
- 1:02:01>> And so he writes and he's like, "Well,
- 1:02:04because it's necessary to make babies.
- 1:02:08God can't be against it."
- 1:02:10>> And and so this this whole thing of
- 1:02:12married equals moral goes back so far.
- 1:02:15But even and even at the same time, St.
- 1:02:18Augustine who's one of the most
- 1:02:19influential theologians in the Christian
- 1:02:22tradition. He equated sexual desire with
- 1:02:24the original sin. So a I realize that
- 1:02:28I'm fighting against I'm pushing an
- 1:02:31uphill battle here on the basis of
- 1:02:33understanding porna the way that I do. I
- 1:02:36think the way that I read it is in line
- 1:02:38with the scriptures. I think it is a
- 1:02:41definite push against Christian
- 1:02:43tradition. And I think Christian
- 1:02:45tradition has been so incredibly
- 1:02:47harmful, especially to women, but also
- 1:02:49to men, because we get to in our in our
- 1:02:52culture today now, you have that 20-year
- 1:02:54gap of having sexual desire activate
- 1:02:57before you're married. And instead of
- 1:02:59learning how to navigate that sexual
- 1:03:02desire in a way that's healthy, you
- 1:03:03learn how to be ashamed of it, how to
- 1:03:05hide it, how to maybe let it break out
- 1:03:06and offer excuses for that, which is
- 1:03:08terrible. I think this is where this
- 1:03:10word that we're not saying but like
- 1:03:11sexual violence comes from. It comes
- 1:03:14from this repression of that. I think
- 1:03:16the sexual violence we see in our world
- 1:03:18comes from this sexual ethic that
- 1:03:20assumes married is what makes it moral.
- 1:03:22And even in a marital relationship, a
- 1:03:24lot of sex is not about love and
- 1:03:26connection. It's about using the other
- 1:03:28person as a sex toy because I need them
- 1:03:31to get off because God says that's the
- 1:03:33only way I can do it. But if the Bible
- 1:03:36never says anything against
- 1:03:38masturbation, the whole story that came
- 1:03:40around the 1700s with Onanism is just
- 1:03:42ridiculous. Has nothing to do with that.
- 1:03:45It has everything to do with using the
- 1:03:46partner as a sex toy. And like if you
- 1:03:50want to do that, that's fine. But if
- 1:03:52you're if you're dehumanizing them
- 1:03:54because God said you had to in order to
- 1:03:57have an orgasm,
- 1:03:59I just want you to know there's another
- 1:04:01way. And even though it pushes against
- 1:04:04so much of Christian tradition, I think
- 1:04:06it has the incredible support of the
- 1:04:08text. I think we have the teachings of
- 1:04:10Jesus. We have the teachings of Paul. We
- 1:04:12have the teachings of prophets all in
- 1:04:15this angle saying, "Hey, how can your
- 1:04:17sexuality be a cultivation of intimacy
- 1:04:20with your partner
- 1:04:22as opposed to being governed by lust or
- 1:04:24just this is the only thing that I'm
- 1:04:26allowed to do?" So, I'm trying to I know
- 1:04:28I know it may be a bit of a stretch,
- 1:04:30especially for some of your Christian
- 1:04:32listeners, but I'm trying to push open
- 1:04:34this door and say, "Hey, can you take
- 1:04:36this journey with God of asking the
- 1:04:38question, what does the Bible actually
- 1:04:39say about this?" Not, "What messed up
- 1:04:43stuff have we inherited from the
- 1:04:45Christian tradition that has put me in
- 1:04:47this dead bedroom relationship in the
- 1:04:48first place?" because I will partially
- 1:04:50blame this ethic for the problem. But
- 1:04:53that has also slammed shut all of the
- 1:04:55other doors and and left us in this
- 1:04:57space where what you're telling me is
- 1:04:59you're like the only way to resolve this
- 1:05:00is if the woman who may hate sex has to
- 1:05:04be the one to fix it because God says
- 1:05:06there's no way. There's just no way I'm
- 1:05:09going to land there.
- 1:05:10>> Well, Kevin, I really appreciate all
- 1:05:12your insights. It's been really amazing.
- 1:05:15Uh, where can people find you and get
- 1:05:18more information about what you have to
- 1:05:19offer in your book?
- 1:05:21>> sacredsinful.com.
- 1:05:24You can basically link to all of my work
- 1:05:26there. You can get a book there. You can
- 1:05:28access the Bible study. We might have
- 1:05:30referred to this a couple of times, but
- 1:05:32it's on my YouTube channel. And I spend
- 1:05:34about two hours going into each one of
- 1:05:36these terms. Porna gets almost four
- 1:05:38hours because what I don't want to do is
- 1:05:41bring my answer and say listen to Dr.
- 1:05:43Kevin Jensen instead of St. Augustine.
- 1:05:45Sure.
- 1:05:46>> Maybe. But that doesn't fix what's going
- 1:05:48on inside of a person. I want to help
- 1:05:50people walk through this journey of
- 1:05:52questions and find out where is it that
- 1:05:55your relationship with God opens the
- 1:05:57door for the kind of experience of
- 1:05:59sexuality you're looking for. We're not
- 1:06:01looking for where's the sin and avoid
- 1:06:03it. We're looking for where's the
- 1:06:04sacred.
- 1:06:05>> Real quick before I do let you go, are
- 1:06:06you still actively doing do you do Bible
- 1:06:09studies?
- 1:06:09>> So, I'm not doing them live at the
- 1:06:11moment. There may be something coming up
- 1:06:12in the summer. And I do offer one-on-one
- 1:06:15conversations if there's anybody that
- 1:06:16wants to go deeper into some of these
- 1:06:18questions. And and of course, get the
- 1:06:20book. Like the book comes in all kinds
- 1:06:22of formats. And if you can't afford it,
- 1:06:24like this is I've I I offer a pay what
- 1:06:27you can as well because it's so
- 1:06:28important for me that people can have
- 1:06:30access to this this kind of teaching.
- 1:06:33>> Okay. Well, we will just see you next
- 1:06:35time then. Thank you.
- 1:06:36>> All right. I will look forward to it.
- 1:06:37Thanks for this conversation.