Latest / Deep Dive / Beyond the Map: How Identity Is Forged in the In-Between
Transcript
- 0:00Usually when you unroll a map on a table, you you expect a
- 0:05certain comfort in its absolute precision.
- 0:07You know, there's this solid heavy black line that separates
- 0:12this territory from that territory.
- 0:13Right. It's very definitive.
- 0:14Exactly. You're either standing in one
- 0:17country, or you've crossed the line and you are in another.
- 0:21It's binary, it's safe. And I mean, it's how we're
- 0:24taught to view the world from childhood.
- 0:26We want things categorized. We want them boxed up, neatly
- 0:29labeled with a nice little bow on top, because it gives us a
- 0:32sense of control over what is essentially an otherwise totally
- 0:36chaotic reality. But then, you know, you take
- 0:38your eyes off the map and you step out into the actual world
- 0:41of human culture. You look at lived history and
- 0:43how people actually interact and suddenly that beautiful clean
- 0:47map is just completely useless. Yeah, it really falls apart.
- 0:50It does. We find ourselves looking at a
- 0:52landscape of human identity that is staggeringly messy.
- 0:56The lines don't just blur, they bleed into one another.
- 0:59The categories we rely on seem to overlap and like constantly
- 1:03rewrite each other. Which is incredibly disorienting
- 1:06if you're just looking for a simple answer to the question of
- 1:08who someone is, right? We are talking about spaces
- 1:11where identities are actively colliding.
- 1:14And that's really the focus of what we're digging into today.
- 1:17For our deep dive. We are looking at a stack of
- 1:20incredibly dense, paradigm shifting source material from
- 1:25Homie K Bob Has text The Location of culture.
- 1:29And to give you listening right now, a sense of where we're
- 1:33heading with this, this text argue something deeply
- 1:36counterintuitive. We tend to think of our
- 1:39identities like our race, our gender, our class, as fixed
- 1:42historical facts. Yeah, like they're locked in a
- 1:45vault somewhere and we just inherit.
- 1:47Them. That's a standard assumption,
- 1:48yeah. But Hava's argument is that real
- 1:50culture and real identity don't happen inside those safe,
- 1:53labeled boxes. They happen in what he calls the
- 1:55beyond. They happen, the messy,
- 1:58overlapping, sometimes violent borders between these neat
- 2:01categories. And before we get into the
- 2:03mechanics of how that actually works, we should probably layer
- 2:05cards on the table about the historical examples we're going
- 2:07to explore. Yeah, because to explain how
- 2:09identity works, this text uses some heavily politicized events.
- 2:14We'll be looking at Marxist analysis, the UK minor strike of
- 2:17the 1980s and the economic policies of Margaret Thatcher.
- 2:21Right. And just to be absolutely clear
- 2:23to everyone listening, we are not here to endorse any of those
- 2:27political positions today. Yeah, not at all.
- 2:29Left wing, right wing, pro union, anti union.
- 2:33We are leaving our own politics at the door.
- 2:36We are bringing these events up strictly to unpack the theories
- 2:39contained in the original text. Exactly.
- 2:41We want to objectively look at the mechanics of the author's
- 2:44arguments and figure out how they apply to cultural identity.
- 2:48We're treating these historical moments as data points to
- 2:50understand a larger theory. So if we're looking at that
- 2:53theory, we have to start with this concept of the beyond.
- 2:56The text uses a very specific word here.
- 2:58It calls them the interstices, the interstitial spaces.
- 3:01See, I hear that word and my mind immediately goes to like
- 3:04biology or construction, like the grout between the tiles or
- 3:09the space between the cells. But what's that actually mean
- 3:12for a human being walking around in the world?
- 3:15It's actually a really great analogy because the grout is the
- 3:18thing holding the structure together, right?
- 3:20Even though we only ever pay attention to the tiles.
- 3:22That's true. The interstices, in a cultural
- 3:25sense, are the overlapping displaced domains of difference.
- 3:29When most people hear the word beyond, they imagine a new
- 3:33horizon. Like a destination.
- 3:35Right. They think of a distant utopian
- 3:37future that society is slowly marching toward, but the text
- 3:41argues the exact opposite. Wait, so the beyond isn't the
- 3:44future? No, the beyond isn't the future
- 3:47at all. It is the restless, disorienting
- 3:49movement of the present. It is the friction of the here
- 3:53and now. OK.
- 3:54So it's not some destination we're trying to reach.
- 3:56It's it's the friction of the commute itself.
- 3:59Yes, and there's a quote from the philosopher Martin Heidegger
- 4:02here that perfectly captures this.
- 4:04He says that a boundary is not where something stops, but
- 4:07rather the boundary is that from which something begins its
- 4:11presencing. Hold on begins its presencing.
- 4:14That sounds like high level academic speak for this is where
- 4:18the action starts. Let me make sure I'm grasping
- 4:20this. Go for it.
- 4:21If I have a boundary, let's say the boundary between my identity
- 4:25as a professional in the workplace and my identity as a
- 4:27parent at home, how do you is saying my identity doesn't just
- 4:31halt at the office door and switch over to a new one?
- 4:33Exactly. The boundary itself is where the
- 4:35true messy version of me is actually generated.
- 4:39That's a very practical way to look at it, actually.
- 4:42We aren't just the sum of our demographic parts.
- 4:45Subjectivity is formed in between those parts.
- 4:48And to help visualize how this works on a larger cultural
- 4:50scale, the text points to of an architectural art installation
- 4:54by the African American artist Renee Green.
- 4:57It's called Sites of Genealogy. Well, I was reading about this
- 5:00installation and it's brilliant because she literally built out
- 5:02this concept using physical space.
- 5:05She did. She used the literal
- 5:07architecture of a museum building.
- 5:09She took the attic, the boiler room, and the stairwell and
- 5:12assigned the meaning the upper and lower areas.
- 5:15The attic and the boiler room represented binary divisions, so
- 5:19think heaven and hell or white and black or upper class and
- 5:23working class. These are the fixed historical
- 5:25boxes we talked about earlier. The.
- 5:27Solid territories on the map. Exactly.
- 5:29But the genius of Green's installation isn't the attic or
- 5:33the boiler room. It's the stairwell.
- 5:35Because the stairwell doesn't belong to the top floor or the
- 5:38bottom floor. Right.
- 5:39The stairwell acts as a liminal space, A connective tissue.
- 5:43But why does the physical act of moving up and down stairs
- 5:46translate to dismantling a racial or class binary?
- 5:50Like what is the actual mechanism there?
- 5:52Because when you are in the stairwell, you cannot settle.
- 5:55Oh right, you are in a state of transition.
- 5:58The stairwell prevents identity from settling into fixed
- 6:01primordial polarities. If you are constantly moving
- 6:04back and forth in that liminal space, you are forced to
- 6:07negotiate. Because you can't just be the
- 6:09attic person or the boiled loom person.
- 6:11Exactly. The back and forth movement
- 6:13opens up the possibility of cultural hybridity.
- 6:16It creates a space place that entertains a difference without
- 6:18instantly imposing a hierarchy. You aren't above or below, you
- 6:22are in the process of becoming. I'm trying to put myself in that
- 6:26stairwell and honestly it sounds exhausting.
- 6:29It is meet the stairwell is the modern condition and we are
- 6:33constantly commuting between all these fragmented identities.
- 6:36Migrant, local worker, parent, marginalized, privileged.
- 6:43Doesn't living in the stairwell just leave people feeling deeply
- 6:45rootless? Well, like how does a person
- 6:48little on a whole society function without a unified
- 6:51stable home to rest in? That tension you're pointing out
- 6:54is actually the driving force of the entire text.
- 6:56You're asking how people survive that rootlessness, and the text
- 7:00brings in the work of two artists, Papon Osorio and Alan
- 7:03Sekula, to explain how people make homes out of displacement.
- 7:06OK, let's start with Osorio because his work is so intensely
- 7:09personal. Yeah, Osorio creates these
- 7:11intricate art installations and the text focuses on one called
- 7:14La Coma, which translates to the bed.
- 7:17He takes a large 4 poster bed and intensely decorates it.
- 7:22It becomes this hyper visual hybrid cultural space merging
- 7:26Puerto Rican heritage and New York realities.
- 7:28It's a space covered capias, which are these traditional
- 7:32ribbon souvenirs, but it's also a memorial to a dead nanny.
- 7:36It represents the primal scene of childhood, but it's situated
- 7:40right in the middle of a displacement experience.
- 7:42So he's not trying to recreate a perfect replica of Puerto Rico
- 7:46in New York, No. And he's not fully assimilating
- 7:49into some generic New York aesthetic, either.
- 7:51He's taking the trauma of being uprooted and building a shelter
- 7:55out of it. He is forging a space
- 7:56contingently. He is making a home out of the
- 7:59sheer act of surviving the transit.
- 8:01Wow. And then you have Alan Sekula,
- 8:03who takes this feeling of displacement and expands it to a
- 8:05massive global scale with his photographic project Fish Story.
- 8:09This part blew my mind because it captures the absolute
- 8:12absurdity of the modern global economy.
- 8:14It really does. Secular documents the maritime
- 8:16world, so harbors, shipping lanes, the stock market.
- 8:20And the text describes this one specific scene he captures.
- 8:23A ship is being greeted at a harbor.
- 8:25It's flying a Bahamian flag of convenience, which is already a
- 8:29layer of legal camouflage. Right.
- 8:31The physical ship itself was built by Koreans.
- 8:34The crew manning the ship are Salvadoran and Filipino.
- 8:37Yeah. And as it arrives, A scratchy
- 8:39recording of the Norwegian national anthem is blaring from
- 8:43a loudspeaker on the bluff. That is just, I mean a total
- 8:46Babble of displaced identities. Exactly.
- 8:48It's transnational capitalism completely scrambling the map.
- 8:53If you ask where is this ship from, the question itself is
- 8:56broken. There is no home country.
- 8:58The ship is a floating stairwell.
- 9:00And in that global scramble, something very profound happens
- 9:03to the individual psyche. The border between the private,
- 9:06safe domestic sphere and the violent, chaotic public sphere
- 9:10of history completely collapses. The outside gets in.
- 9:13The world outside invades the home inside, and this brings us
- 9:17to a concept Freud called the unheimlich, which the text
- 9:20translates as the unhomely. See, usually when people talk
- 9:24about Freud's unheimlich, it gets translated into English as
- 9:26the uncanny, right? Like a creepy doll that looks a
- 9:29little too human, but Bob is using it much more literally
- 9:34here. Very literally, being unhomed is
- 9:37not the same as being physically homeless, like sleeping on the
- 9:40street. OK, what is it then?
- 9:42To be unhomed is the creeping, terrifying realization that the
- 9:47historical world has breached your walls.
- 9:49The trauma of the outside world is suddenly sitting at your
- 9:52kitchen table. Jeez.
- 9:53The text turns to literature to give us the best evidence for
- 9:56this, specifically looking at Toni Morrison's devastating
- 9:59novel Beloved. This is such a powerful example.
- 10:02For those who haven't read it, the story centers around 124
- 10:06Bluestone Rd. which is the house where the protagonist Seeth
- 10:09lives. Yeah, and the house is literally
- 10:11haunted. It is haunted by a ghost, but
- 10:14the ghost represents the unspoken, unrepresented history
- 10:17of slavery and infant mortality. Seeth is a former slave who
- 10:21escaped, but when the slave catchers came to drag her and
- 10:24her children back into the brutal machinery of the
- 10:26plantation economy, she committed an act of infanticide.
- 10:30She killed her own child rather than let her be taken back into
- 10:32slavery. It is the most horrific,
- 10:35unthinkable act a mother could commit, but the text frames it
- 10:39through this lens of the unhomely It's an assertion of
- 10:42ownership, isn't it? It is a tragic, desperate
- 10:46assertion of ownership. The public historical system of
- 10:49slavery viewed her child merely as property, as livestock.
- 10:53Seeth brings that horrific historical reality directly into
- 10:57the intimate private space of the home.
- 10:59The text argues that the public and the private become
- 11:02indistinguishable. The systemic violence of the
- 11:05outside world forces her to perform an act of ultimate
- 11:08violence inside just to reclaim the destiny of her own child
- 11:11from the state. The boundary is gone.
- 11:14The slave economy didn't respect her front door, so the horror of
- 11:18the outside world infected the inside world.
- 11:20Exactly. That is the ultimate unhomed
- 11:23experience. And the text pairs this with
- 11:25another novel, right? Nadine Gordimer's My Son's
- 11:28Story, which approaches the unhomely from a totally
- 11:30different angle. Yeah, Gordimer's novel is set in
- 11:33apartheid South Africa. It focuses on a character named
- 11:36Ayla, who is a colored South African.
- 11:38Initially, her domestic home is described as quiet, diminished
- 11:41and deeply private. But as the political reality of
- 11:45apartheid intensifies, Ayla quietly turns her domestic
- 11:48sanctuary into a front for revolutionary gun running.
- 11:52She hides weapons in the home. Yes, suddenly the domestic space
- 11:56is the frontline of a violent political struggle.
- 11:59The narrator of the novel notes that it was as if everyone found
- 12:02they had unnoticingly entered a strange house.
- 12:05The existence of colored S Africans in the novel is
- 12:08described as being halfway between, not defined.
- 12:11They don't fit the neat categories of the apartheid
- 12:14state. They inhabit the rim of an in
- 12:16between reality. So they are living in Renee
- 12:18Green's stairwell, but it's a stairwell patrolled by a
- 12:22violent, racist state apparatus. Exactly.
- 12:24And that leads us to a massive systemic.
- 12:26Problem, right? Let's look at the mechanics of
- 12:28this, because if people are this fractured that their homes were
- 12:31invaded by history, their identities are caught in the in
- 12:34between, and their realities are constantly shifting, how do they
- 12:38ever organize for political change?
- 12:40It's the big question. Like if I want to start a
- 12:43movement to fight the system, but everyone I'm trying to
- 12:46organize is living in the margins and dealing with their
- 12:49own highly specific fragmented reality, how do you build a
- 12:53coalition? You're hitting on the core
- 12:55problem of modern political organizing, and this brings us
- 12:58directly into the messy reality of political identity.
- 13:02Let's get into it. But first, the text has to
- 13:05dismantle a very specific, damaging assumption about how we
- 13:09even talk about politics. Assumption.
- 13:12There's a widespread belief that high minded theory, the kind of
- 13:16dense post structuralist academic language we are
- 13:20unpacking right now, is just an elite Eurocentric exercise
- 13:24totally disconnected from street level struggles.
- 13:27Oh yeah, the stereotype of the ivory tower, right?
- 13:29That theory is just out of touch.
- 13:31Academics writing papers for each other while actual
- 13:34marginalized people are out on the streets dealing with tear
- 13:36gas and police batons. Bob completely rejects that
- 13:39binary. The text argues that the
- 13:41commitment to theory is actually a vital, active form of
- 13:44political practice. Wait, really?
- 13:45Yeah, theoretical critique isn't just a commentary on politics,
- 13:49it is politics. The argument is that writing,
- 13:52textuality and the very language we use actually produce the
- 13:55social subject. Wait, I need you to break that
- 13:58down. How does language produce a
- 13:59social subject? Aren't people already who they
- 14:02are before someone writes a theory about them?
- 14:04It seems that way. But think about how we define
- 14:06groups. We use terms like the working
- 14:08class or women or minorities. We assume these groups have a
- 14:12singular, inherent agenda. Like they all want the exact
- 14:16same. Right, that all working class
- 14:18people share the exact same intrinsic goals simply by virtue
- 14:21of being working class. The text calls this the myth of
- 14:25the unified political subject. OK, and language.
- 14:28How politicians and leaders talk about these groups creates this
- 14:31myth. But in reality, there is no
- 14:33inherent unity. And the text uses a massive
- 14:36historical event to prove this right.
- 14:38The UK miners strike of 1984 and 85.
- 14:41Yes. Let's set the scene for that
- 14:44strike because it is crucial. This was a defining moment in
- 14:47modern British history. You had the Conservative
- 14:50government under Margaret Thatcher determined to break the
- 14:54power of the trade unions, specifically the National Union
- 14:58of Mineworkers, by shutting down coal pits.
- 15:01And the traditional narrative of this strike, the way it's
- 15:03usually taught or remembered, is a very simple, epic binary.
- 15:08Absolutely. It's the heroic, staunchly male
- 15:11working class miners battling against the cold, oppressive
- 15:14capitalist state to clean map. Good guys on the picket line,
- 15:18bad guys in parliament. That was the narrative.
- 15:20But Papa brings in the work of writer Beatrix Campbell, who
- 15:23actually went and interviewed the women involved in the
- 15:26strike, the wives, the mothers, the daughters of these miners.
- 15:29And what Campbell found completely shattered that clean
- 15:32map. Because the women didn't just
- 15:34sit at home waiting for the men to come back from the picket
- 15:36lines. Far from it.
- 15:37The women organized. They formed support groups.
- 15:40They ran massive logistical operations to feed entire
- 15:43communities when the paychecks stopped, and eventually they
- 15:46went out and joined the picket lines themselves.
- 15:49And through this process, their entire understanding of
- 15:52themselves changed. The experience fundamentally
- 15:56disrupted their traditional roles within the family and the
- 15:58patriarchal community. They realized their own power.
- 16:01Yeah. But that realization put them in
- 16:04direct conflict with the very men they were supposed to be
- 16:07supporting. Exactly.
- 16:09Their identities as women who had found political agency and
- 16:12their identities as members of a striking working class community
- 16:16were suddenly in deep tension. Because they were defending a
- 16:20culture that didn't really respect them.
- 16:21Right. They were fighting to defend a
- 16:23mining culture that was, at its core, heavily macho and
- 16:27patriarchal. So as they became more
- 16:29politically active, they were actively challenging the symbols
- 16:32of the very culture they were fighting to save.
- 16:35There was no going back to the good old days of being a quiet
- 16:37housewife. So the working class wasn't a
- 16:40unified political subject at all?
- 16:41Not at all. The moment you applied pressure
- 16:44to it, it fractured along gender lines.
- 16:46It proves you can't just stand on a podium and say the working
- 16:48class demands X, because the working class is internally
- 16:52negotiating its own conflicts. This is why the text brings in
- 16:56Stuart Halls critique of the British Labor Party during this
- 16:59era. Hall looked at this
- 17:01fragmentation and realized that a political party couldn't just
- 17:04rely on the old traditionalist image of its base to gain
- 17:09hegemony or dominance. So Labour couldn't just keep
- 17:13appealing to the image of the white male trade unionist with
- 17:17coal dust on his face because that guy didn't represent the
- 17:20whole picture anymore. Precisely.
- 17:22Hall argued that to win, a political movement must
- 17:25negotiate a new social bloc. It has to build an alliance
- 17:29made-up of overlapping fragmented identities, the
- 17:33unemployed, ethnic minorities, part time workers, politicized
- 17:36women. OK, let me play devil's advocate
- 17:38here for a second. Let's look at this
- 17:39pragmatically. Sure.
- 17:40Isn't this kind of fragmentation a political disaster for any
- 17:44movement trying to actually wield power?
- 17:46It can be seen that way. If your movement is just a
- 17:48patchwork of competing in between identities, all arguing
- 17:52with each other in the stairwell, how do you ever agree
- 17:56on a single demand? It's tough.
- 17:58Isn't a unified, simple message, even if it's a bit of a myth
- 18:02absolutely necessary for taking down an opponent like Thatcher's
- 18:06government? If everyone is constantly
- 18:08negotiating their own specific overlapping identity, doesn't
- 18:12the movement just eat itself? It's a very real fear, and it's
- 18:15the reason why so many political leaders hate dealing with
- 18:17nuance. Yeah, but the texts argument is
- 18:20that a unified message that erases the people it claims to
- 18:24represent is inherently unstable.
- 18:26It will eventually collapse. Because the people inside the
- 18:29movement will realize they're being erased.
- 18:30Exactly. Power and meaning cannot simply
- 18:33be dictated from the top down. They must be negotiated, and
- 18:37this negotiation happens through a process of translation.
- 18:40Meaning you have to adapt the message to the people receiving
- 18:42it. More than just adapting, the
- 18:44message itself changes when it meets the listener.
- 18:47Yeah, to explain the mechanics of this, the text provides A
- 18:51fascinating, almost comical historical example from 1839
- 18:55involving British Christian missionaries in India,
- 18:59documented by a man named A Duff.
- 19:01Oh I love this example. It perfectly illustrates how an
- 19:04oppressor's language completely backfires the second they try to
- 19:08use it to control people. Walk us through it.
- 19:11So you have these British missionaries, they represent the
- 19:15absolute authority of the colonial empire, and they're
- 19:18trying to teach the Hindu population a core foundational
- 19:23tenet of evangelical Christianity, which is that to
- 19:26be saved, a person must be born again.
- 19:29Seems straightforward enough. If you're a missionary, you
- 19:31think I'll just translate the words born again into the local
- 19:34language and they'll get it right?
- 19:35So they preach this message, but the Hindu locals listen, and
- 19:38they agree entirely. They do.
- 19:40Yeah, they say. Oh, there is nothing new here.
- 19:42Our own shastras, our sacred texts, tell us we must be born
- 19:45again and again. Because they're talking about
- 19:47reincarnation. Exactly.
- 19:48The missionaries say born again, meaning the spiritual awakening.
- 19:51And the Hindus say, yeah, transmigration of the soul.
- 19:54We've been doing that for centuries.
- 19:55We are already all over that. Which is absolutely horrifying
- 19:59to the Christian missionaries. Oh, I bet they realize their
- 20:02supposedly absolute divine truth is being absorbed and digested
- 20:07into a completely different competing religious framework.
- 20:10The. Got hacked.
- 20:12Precisely. Yeah.
- 20:13So the missionaries realized they need to fix the
- 20:15translation. They change their language to be
- 20:17more specific. They tell the Hindus that it
- 20:20isn't about being born endlessly.
- 20:22There must be a specific second birth.
- 20:24OK. They use the phrase you must be
- 20:26twice born. Let me guess, that didn't work
- 20:29either. It failed spectacularly because
- 20:32that specific phraseology twice born was already heavily
- 20:36occupied by the local Indian culture.
- 20:38How so? It referred specifically to the
- 20:39sons of Brahman who undergo pure figuratory rights and are
- 20:43invested with the sacred thread. That specific ceremony
- 20:46constituted their second birth. Oh wow, so by trying to clarify
- 20:50their Christian message, the missionaries accidentally told
- 20:53the local population that everyone had to convert into a
- 20:56high caste Hindu Brahman before they could see the Christian
- 21:00God. Exactly.
- 21:01The colonizer comes in with what they believe is the ultimate
- 21:05absolute authority, the literal word of God.
- 21:08But the second it hits the local culture, it is completely
- 21:11compromised. It is hybridized.
- 21:13That's amazing. The take away here is that
- 21:15political power or colonial authority isn't a magic wand.
- 21:19You can't just dictate meaning. It is always a process of
- 21:22translation, and in that translation the oppressive
- 21:25authority loses its purity at fractures.
- 21:28Let's flip the perspective here. We just saw how the oppressor's
- 21:32language fractures when it hits the colonized culture.
- 21:34But what happens in the reverse? What do you mean?
- 21:36What happens to the psychology of the colonized person when
- 21:39they are forced to look at themselves through the
- 21:41oppressor's fractured racist lens?
- 21:44Because earlier we talked about the trauma of the unhomely, but
- 21:46this sounds like an even deeper kind of psychological warfare.
- 21:50It is absolute psychological warfare.
- 21:52And this is where the text turns to the brilliant, harrowing work
- 21:56of France. Fanon Fanon was a Martinican
- 21:59psychoanalyst who actively participated in the Algerian
- 22:01revolution against the French. He wrote extensively on the
- 22:04psychology of colonialism. And Fanon asks a haunting
- 22:08foundational question. What's that?
- 22:09What does the black man want? And the way he answers that
- 22:12isn't by looking at inherent desires, right?
- 22:14Yeah, he looks at how the colonial subject is
- 22:16manufactured. Yes, Fanon shows that for the
- 22:19colonial subject, identity isn't some natural innate essence that
- 22:23grows from within. It is violently forged from the
- 22:26outside, specifically in the gaze of the oppressor.
- 22:29This brings us to what the text calls the primal scene of
- 22:32racism. Fanon details a visceral,
- 22:35traumatic anecdote from his own life to explain how this gaze
- 22:38operates. It's a famous and devastating
- 22:41passage. Fanon's on a train in France and
- 22:43a white child looks at him, points and says to his mother,
- 22:46look a Negro Mama, see the Negro.
- 22:48I'm frightened. Just sitting there, existing on
- 22:51a train, and suddenly you are weaponized by a child's gaze.
- 22:56What is the psychological mechanic of what happens to
- 22:58Fanna in that exact moment? Fanon describes it as a moment
- 23:02of total psychological devastation.
- 23:05He says his corporeal schema crumbles.
- 23:07Wait, corporeal schema? Let's translate that.
- 23:10Right. So to explain that jargon, your
- 23:12corporeal schema is your subconscious understanding of
- 23:15your own body in space. It's knowing where your limbs
- 23:18are, knowing how much space you take up, feeling whole and
- 23:20integrated. It's how you experience the
- 23:23world from the inside out. So it's just the basic feeling
- 23:26of being a human being walking down the street.
- 23:28Right. But when that child points at
- 23:30him, Fanon is abruptly amputated from that feeling.
- 23:33His physical internal reality is obliterated and replaced by what
- 23:37he calls a racial epidermal schema.
- 23:40Epidermal, meaning skin deep. Literally crushed into the
- 23:42surface of his skin. In that moment he is no longer a
- 23:45complex individual experiencing the world.
- 23:48He is forced into what he calls a triple person.
- 23:50Triple. Person.
- 23:51He suddenly becomes responsible for his physical body, his race,
- 23:56and his ancestors all at the exact same time.
- 23:59The white man's eyes literally break up the black man's body.
- 24:02He is robbed of his own internal self and forced to see himself
- 24:06entirely through the terrified, racist eyes of the child.
- 24:10I mean, I want you, the listener, to think about a time,
- 24:13maybe on a much smaller scale, where you walked into a room and
- 24:16instantly felt yourself being perceived not as you, but as a
- 24:20category, as a stereotype. It's a deeply paralyzing
- 24:23feeling. And that paralysis creates a
- 24:25profound crisis of representation.
- 24:28If the colonizer's gaze strips you of your humanity, reduces
- 24:31you to a flat stereotype, and controls how you are seen, how
- 24:35do you fight back? Right.
- 24:36If you can't be seen as human, what do you do?
- 24:38The text suggests A fascinating tactical response.
- 24:41The marginalized subject weaponizes their very erasure.
- 24:44They adopt A strategy of invisibility.
- 24:46They realize the oppressor can't actually see them, so they use
- 24:48the blind spot. The text brings in some really
- 24:50striking poetry to illustrate this tactic.
- 24:53It does. It points to a poem by Adil
- 24:56Juusawalla called Missing Person.
- 24:58Juusawalla describes the post colonial identity not as a bold
- 25:02defiance stance, but is something ghostly.
- 25:05He writes that it is faintly penciled behind a shirt.
- 25:08Fangs cancelled. The identity is barely there.
- 25:11It's an outline. Yeah, and then there's a
- 25:13diaspora poem by a mailing, Jinn, which features these
- 25:16incredible lines about learning the secret art of invisibleness,
- 25:20she writes. Only my eyes will remain to
- 25:23watch and to haunt and to turn your dreams to chaos.
- 25:26Only my eyes will remain to watch and to haunt.
- 25:29So they are taking the fact that the colonizer refuses to truly
- 25:33look at them as equals and turning it into a threat.
- 25:35The text refers to this as the evil eye.
- 25:38In psychoanalysis, there is a concept called the skepic Dr.
- 25:41The pleasure and power of seeing, analyzing, and
- 25:44controlling an object through surveillance.
- 25:45Like the urge to categorize. Exactly.
- 25:47The colonizer loves to look at the colonize, to study them, to
- 25:51categorize them. It's the map maker's obsession.
- 25:53But the evil eye is a disembodied gaze that stares
- 25:57back. It disrupts the colonizer's
- 25:59illusion of total control because the colonizer can no
- 26:02longer fix the marginalized subject in place.
- 26:05The subject slips away. The subject slips away into the
- 26:08background, into invisibility, leaving only this haunting
- 26:11retaliatory gaze. And Baba takes this highly
- 26:14theoretical, poetic concept and grounds it in a real world
- 26:19historical example. He returns to Fanon's analysis
- 26:22of the Algerian revolution, specifically looking at how the
- 26:26Algerian woman utilized the veil.
- 26:28This is a perfect example of weaponized invisibility.
- 26:31Fanon explains how the cultural meaning of the veil completely
- 26:34transformed during the conflict. Also, initially to the French
- 26:38colonizers, the veil was a symbol of archaic patriarchal
- 26:41tradition. They viewed it as a boundary
- 26:43that kept women locked in the private domestic home.
- 26:46Oh I see. The colonizers even had
- 26:48campaigns to unveil the women, framing it as a way to civilize
- 26:51and liberate them. But when the revelation kicked
- 26:53off, the women realized the French police didn't see them.
- 26:57The police only saw the veil and the stereotype attached to it.
- 27:00Precisely during the Revolution, the veil became a highly
- 27:03effective technique of urban camouflage.
- 27:06Wow. Because the French police saw a
- 27:08veiled woman as submissive, traditional and harmless, the
- 27:13women could easily cross the checkpoints from the Arab city
- 27:15into the European quarter. Oh my God.
- 27:18And beneath the veil, they were carrying hand grenades and bombs
- 27:21for the resistance. The colonial police look at a
- 27:24veiled woman and they just see nothing.
- 27:27They see a blank space on their cultural map and she uses that
- 27:31exact racist, sexist blind spot to become a walking arsenal.
- 27:36The police see everything and nothing at the same time.
- 27:38It's the ultimate subversion. Let's pull all this together
- 27:41with an analogy, because this flips everything we are taught
- 27:44about identity in traditional Western philosophy.
- 27:46Think of guys like John Locke. We are taught that identity is a
- 27:49deep, continuous well of consciousness.
- 27:52You look deep inside yourself and there, the bottom of the
- 27:54well is your true authentic self.
- 27:57The depth model of identity. Right.
- 27:58But what Papa and Fun are saying is that for colonized or
- 28:02marginalized people, identity isn't a deep, peaceful well, you
- 28:06look into. It's a crack, hostile mirror
- 28:10reflecting back the world's racism.
- 28:12Yeah, but by stepping into the cracks of that mirror, by
- 28:15becoming the faintly penciled missing person, they find a
- 28:19weird kind of tactical superpower.
- 28:23They give up on the depth and weaponize the surface.
- 28:26That is exactly the shift the text is describing.
- 28:28The traditional depth of identity is replaced by a
- 28:30strategic surface level doubling.
- 28:32It's camouflage, right? But as you can imagine, this
- 28:35tactic of slipping into the blind spots is incredibly
- 28:38threatening to the oppressor. I would assume it completely
- 28:41shatters their illusion of control.
- 28:43I mean, if the people you're trying to oppress keep ghosting
- 28:46you and staring back from the shadows, you will start to lose
- 28:48your mind. Which is exactly what happens
- 28:50because the colonized subject keeps slipping away, becoming
- 28:52the missing person. The colonizer desperately tries
- 28:55to freeze them in place. They need to nail them down to
- 28:57the map. And they do this using the most
- 28:59powerful tool of colonial discourse, the stereotype.
- 29:03Let's really dig into this because this is one of the most
- 29:05famous parts of babas work. When most of us hear the word
- 29:08stereotype, we just think of ignorance, right?
- 29:10We think all that person is uneducated.
- 29:12They have a false representation in their head.
- 29:14They just need to read a book. That is the common liberal view
- 29:17of stereotypes, that it's just a mistake waiting to be corrected
- 29:20by education. But Paaba argues that
- 29:23stereotypes are much more complex and sinister than simple
- 29:26ignorance. The text introduces a concept
- 29:29called the other question. It breaks down the colonial
- 29:32stereotype as a form of fixity. But this fixity isn't stable.
- 29:37It vacillates wildly between a desire for absolute order and a
- 29:41terrifying, paranoid fear of total chaos.
- 29:43So a stereotype isn't a static mistake.
- 29:46It's an active, ongoing, deeply anxious psychological process.
- 29:50Yes, and it contains a massive, glaring paradox.
- 29:54Think about how a racist stereotype is deployed.
- 29:57The colonizer claims it is an absolute permanent biological
- 30:01truth. For example, they invent the
- 30:03trope of the duplicitous Asiatic or the beastial African.
- 30:07The colonizer claims this is just how these people inherently
- 30:10biologically are. It's an undeniable fact of
- 30:14nature. But if it's an undeniable fact
- 30:16of nature, why do they never shut up about it?
- 30:19You've hit the nail on the head. Despite claiming it is a
- 30:22permanent self-evident truth. The colonizer requires anxious,
- 30:26compulsive repetition of the stereotype.
- 30:29Please stop you there because I want to make sure I understand
- 30:31the mechanics of this Anx If the colonizer has all the
- 30:35institutional power they have, the military, the banks, the
- 30:38government, the schools. And they truly believe their
- 30:41stereotype is an absolute biological fact, right?
- 30:44Why are they sweating? Why do they have to obsessively
- 30:46repeat it in their newspapers, their novels, their political
- 30:50speeches? Because of what the repetition
- 30:51masks. It sounds like someone sitting
- 30:53at a computer desperately hitting the refresh button on a
- 30:56frozen web page, terrified that if they stop clicking, the
- 31:00screen will go blank and they'll lose everything.
- 31:02The Frozen webpage is a brilliant way to understand it,
- 31:05actually, because the repetition is a symptom of a deep
- 31:08subconscious panic. The text answers your question
- 31:11by turning back to psychoanalysis.
- 31:13Back to Freud. Paba argues that the stereotype
- 31:16functions exactly like a fetish. Okay, when people hear fetish,
- 31:19they usually think of sexual kinks, but we're talking about
- 31:22the strict Freudian definition here.
- 31:24Right. Yes, the Freudian concept of the
- 31:26fetish. In psychoanalysis, a fetish is a
- 31:29psychological defense mechanism used to deal with the traumatic
- 31:33realization of lack or difference, right?
- 31:35It is a process of simultaneous recognition and disavowal.
- 31:40Let's breakdown how this maps onto colonialism.
- 31:42OK, take me through the steps. Step 1 The colonizer arrives in
- 31:45a new land and encounters the cultural and racial difference
- 31:48of the colonized people. Recognition.
- 31:51They see the difference. Right.
- 31:52But Step 2, This difference is a massive, traumatic threat to the
- 31:56colonizer's worldview. Why?
- 31:58Because the colonizer wants to believe their specific European
- 32:01culture is the absolute, unquestionable, divine truth of
- 32:05the universe. Encountering a complex, fully
- 32:08formed, completely different culture threatens to expose that
- 32:11European supremacy is a myth. It creates immense anxiety.
- 32:16It proves there are other ways of being human, which means the
- 32:18colonizer isn't the center of the universe.
- 32:20Exactly So Step 3. To cope with this terrifying
- 32:24anxiety, the colonizer creates a fetish.
- 32:27The stereotype becomes the fetish object.
- 32:30OK, I'm following. And the text notes that this
- 32:33fetish is usually focused on the epidermal schema, meaning skin
- 32:36color. They obsessively fixate on skin
- 32:39color to mask the threat of cultural complexity.
- 32:41Disavowal. Exactly.
- 32:43By saying look at their skin. They're all just this one simple
- 32:46stereotype. The colonizer disavows the
- 32:49threatening reality of the other culture.
- 32:51Wow stereotype acts as a psychological it allows the
- 32:54colonizer to return to a myth of pure, unquestionable origins.
- 32:58So racism isn't just hatred, it's a defense mechanism against
- 33:01an existential panic attack. Yes, and because it's a defense
- 33:05mechanism trying to hold back a flood of repressed anxiety, it
- 33:09has to be repeated compulsively. The fetish requires constant
- 33:13maintenance. The refresh button.
- 33:15Exactly, and the text outlines a four term strategy to show how
- 33:19this stereotype functions simultaneously in 2 completely
- 33:22opposing contradictory ways. Let's unpack this four term
- 33:25strategy because this explains so much about how racism
- 33:28actually sounds in practice. It operates on 2 poles.
- 33:32First you have the metaphoric or narcissistic pole.
- 33:35What does that look like? This is where the colonizer
- 33:37looks at the colonized and says they are all the same.
- 33:39They are simple innocent children.
- 33:41They are loyal, happy servants. We can easily know them and
- 33:44control them. That's the paternalistic weight
- 33:47savior side of the coin. It's condescending, but it
- 33:50frames the relationship as peaceful.
- 33:52Right. Operating on this pole provides
- 33:54the colonizer with delight, pleasure, and a comforting sense
- 33:57of absolute mastery. But operating at the exact same
- 34:01time in the colonizer psyche, you have the metonymic or
- 34:04aggressive pole. The dark side of the fetish.
- 34:07This is where the colonizer says they are unpredictable savages.
- 34:11They are hypersexual demons. They're going to up and eat me.
- 34:15They are a terrifying, chaotic threat.
- 34:18Total 180, yeah. This poll is driven by deep
- 34:21primal fear, paranoia and defensive aggression.
- 34:25So you're saying the colonizer's brain is just swinging wildly
- 34:28between these two poles? Between they are helpless, happy
- 34:31children and they are terrifying, bloodthirsty
- 34:34monsters. Constantly they swing back and
- 34:36forth between delight and fear, between narcissistic mastery and
- 34:39paranoid defense. The colonizer is completely
- 34:42trapped by the very stereotypes they created to control the
- 34:45natives. The stereotype gives them
- 34:48political power, but psychologically it locks them
- 34:51into a state of permanent vibrating anxiety.
- 34:54As Fanon famously pointed out, the racist is enslaved by his
- 34:57superiority, just as the colonize is enslaved by his
- 35:00inferiority. Both they're trapped.
- 35:01Both are caught in what he calls a Manichaean delirium.
- 35:04A Manichaean delirium, meaning a hallucinatory worldview where
- 35:08everything is split into absolute extremes of light and
- 35:10dark, good and evil, that is fascinating.
- 35:14The oppressor builds a conceptual cage to lock the
- 35:17oppressed inside, but accidentally locks themselves
- 35:20inside the cage too, terrified of the people they are
- 35:22subjugating. And because the colonizer is
- 35:24trapped in this anxious loop, they start looking for an escape
- 35:27hatch. What's the escape hatch?
- 35:28They enact systemic policies to try and relieve the anxiety and
- 35:32their main idea is let's make the colonized more like us.
- 35:36This is the foundation of the famous civilizing mission.
- 35:39The logic being, if we can just educate them to act European,
- 35:43dress European and speak European, they won't be
- 35:46different anymore and my anxiety will go away.
- 35:49That is the epic intention of the colonial mission.
- 35:51But as the text reveals, this leads to the final devastating
- 35:55irony of colonial discourse. Papa calls this concept mimicry.
- 36:00Mimicry. The colonial power sets out to
- 36:02civilize the other, aiming to create subjects that are, in
- 36:05Papa's most famous phrase, almost the same, but not quite.
- 36:09Let's linger on that phrase. Almost the same, but not quite.
- 36:13It's incredibly insidious. They want the colonized to adopt
- 36:18British manners, but they are terrified of them actually
- 36:21becoming British. Eager.
- 36:22Exactly. The colonizer wants a
- 36:24recognizable reflection of themselves to validate their
- 36:27superiority, but that reflection must remain permanently flawed
- 36:31and inferior. Right.
- 36:32If the colonized person became exactly the same, the whole
- 36:35justification for colonial rule would collapse.
- 36:38But this strategy exposes what the calls the forked tongue of
- 36:42colonialism. The grand, epic intention of the
- 36:45civilizing mission inevitably degrades into absolute farce.
- 36:49Because you can't teach someone your entire rule book and then
- 36:52expect them not to read it. Precisely.
- 36:54The text provides a brilliant piece of historical evidence to
- 36:57prove how badly this backfired. There's a quote from Sir Edward
- 37:00Kust, writing in 1839. Who was Kust and what was he
- 37:04panicking about? Kust was a British official
- 37:06writing to the Colonial Office, and he was complaining bitterly
- 37:09about the policy of Grant colonies, what he called a mimic
- 37:12representation of the British Constitution.
- 37:15Oh, this is going to be. Cust was absolutely horrified
- 37:18that the colonized subjects were actually using the bureaucratic
- 37:21forms, the titles of speakers, the ceremonial maces and the
- 37:25parliamentary procedures of the mother country to defy the
- 37:28British government. Oh, that's beautiful.
- 37:31He realizes the monster they created is using their own
- 37:34parliamentary rule book against them.
- 37:36He called it a mockery. Just realized quite astutely
- 37:40that giving a colony of the forms of independence was
- 37:42incredibly dangerous because they would eventually use those
- 37:45exact forms to demand actual independence.
- 37:49The British said play by our rules and the colonists said OK,
- 37:52checkmate. The text connects this back to
- 37:54the psychoanalyst Jacques Lacan's definition of
- 37:57camouflage. We brought up camouflage earlier
- 37:59with the veil. Right.
- 38:00Lacan says that in nature, camouflage isn't just about
- 38:03perfectly harmonizing with the background.
- 38:05So you completely disappear. That's an illusion.
- 38:08What is it then? True camouflage is about
- 38:10becoming modeled against a modeled background.
- 38:13Meaning you adopt the pattern of the environment, but you break
- 38:16up your outline. Yes, it's a form of visual
- 38:19warfare. Mimicry therefore isn't
- 38:21submission when the colonized subject mimics the colonizer.
- 38:25It is a kind of psychological camouflage used to mount an
- 38:28attack. So by putting on the British
- 38:30suit and speaking perfect English, they aren't bowing
- 38:33down, they are putting on camouflage to get close enough
- 38:36to strike. Yes, the threat of the copy is
- 38:38profound. By adopting the language, the
- 38:41dress, and the institutional forms of the colonizer, the
- 38:44colonized subject exposes the total artificiality of the
- 38:48colonizer's power. It proves that Western
- 38:50civilization isn't some divine, inherent biological right of the
- 38:54white man. It's just a set of behaviors,
- 38:57texts, and bureaucratic procedures that can be copied,
- 39:00learned, and turned right back against the Creator.
- 39:02It completely de mythologizes the colonizer's power.
- 39:05I mean it reminds me of a modern corporate scenario.
- 39:07So it's like a massive corporation demanding absolute
- 39:10cult like conformity from its lowest paid workers.
- 39:13They force everyone to read the exact same dense corporate
- 39:16handbook on synergy and optimization and workplace
- 39:19regulations. OK, Yeah.
- 39:21And then the workers use the exact legal language from that
- 39:24very handbook to form a union, corner the executives, and sue
- 39:29the company for labor violations.
- 39:31The system's obsessive demand for a perfect copy is exactly
- 39:35the mechanism that generates its own destruction.
- 39:37That's a perfect modern equivalent.
- 39:39The mimicry reveals the hypocritical gap between the
- 39:42colonizers lofty ideals of liberty and their brutal
- 39:46everyday practices of subjugation.
- 39:48The slippage. The native mimics the colonizer,
- 39:51but with a slight slippage. There is always a slight
- 39:54difference, and in that tiny gap the colonial authority is
- 39:57mocked, parodied and subverted. So the colonizer looks at the
- 40:00colonizer. And doesn't see a grateful
- 40:03subject, they see a distorted mocking funhouse mirror
- 40:06reflection of themselves. Exactly.
- 40:10We have covered an immense amount of ground today.
- 40:12Let's take a breath and try to trace the through line of the
- 40:14incredible, dizzying journey we've just been on through
- 40:16Papa's work. It is a dense map to navigate
- 40:19for sure. It really is.
- 40:21We started by throwing out the clean map entirely.
- 40:24We started in the physical stairwell of the in between
- 40:27looking at Renee Green's art, realizing that identities aren't
- 40:30fixed in boxes in the attic or the basement.
- 40:33They are constantly moving, negotiating and forming in the
- 40:36margins. We saw how that movement can be
- 40:38traumatic, leading to the unhomely reality where the
- 40:42violent history of the outside world invades the private
- 40:45sanctuary of the home, as we saw on Tony Morrison's beloved.
- 40:49From there, we looked at how this fragmentation effects
- 40:52politics. We learned the political
- 40:54movements like the UK miners strike can't just dictate a
- 40:57unified mythical message. The working class isn't one
- 41:00thing. Movements have to negotiate the
- 41:02messy reality of overlapping identities, gender, race, class,
- 41:06or they will fracture. We then dug into the deeply
- 41:08psychological warfare of colonialism.
- 41:11We witnessed the traumatic impact of the colonial gaze with
- 41:13Franz Font on on the train and how marginalized people like the
- 41:16veiled Algerian women weaponize their invisibility and the evil
- 41:20eye to fight back from the blind spots.
- 41:22And then we unpacked the terrified, paranoid anxiety
- 41:25hiding behind every single racist stereotype, realizing the
- 41:29oppressor is trapped in a loop of fetish and fear, endlessly
- 41:33hitting refresh on a frozen page.
- 41:34Yeah, and finally we saw how mimicking the oppressor, putting
- 41:38on the corporate camouflage and becoming the slightly flawed
- 41:41copy becomes the ultimate act of rebellion, tearing down the
- 41:44illusion of absolute authority from the inside.
- 41:47If we pull back from the dense theory and connect all of this
- 41:50directly back to you, the listener, the ultimate take away
- 41:53from the location of culture is actually deeply empowering.
- 41:57Really. How so?
- 41:58Your identity is not a locked vault of history that you simply
- 42:01inherit and have to defend. It is a live, ongoing
- 42:05negotiation. It's an action, not an object.
- 42:07Exactly. The moments in your life where
- 42:09you feel you don't neatly fit in the margins, the borders, those
- 42:13unhomely spaces where your private self and public reality
- 42:16awkwardly crashed together. Those are not places of weakness
- 42:19or failure. That's a relief to hear.
- 42:21According to this text, those interstitial spaces are actually
- 42:25the sites of your greatest creative, intellectual and
- 42:28subversive power. That is where new culture is
- 42:31actively born. I think that's a brilliant place
- 42:33to wrap up our analysis of the text, but I want to leave you,
- 42:36our listener, with a final, provocative thought to Mull over
- 42:39on your own. Go for it.
- 42:41We've spent this entire time talking about how our identities
- 42:44and our political power are forged in the physical and
- 42:47psychological in between spaces of cultural clash, the physical
- 42:51stairwells, the borders, the harbors, right?
- 42:54But what happens now, in our current era, where our primary
- 42:57space of human interaction isn't a physical stairwell at all, but
- 43:01the algorithmically sorted Internet?
- 43:03That's a whole different map. Think about how social media
- 43:06platforms are designed. They hate the in between
- 43:08algorithms demand absolute categorization to sell ads.
- 43:12Our digital echo chambers destroying the stairwell by
- 43:15forcing us into absolute polarized binary identities.
- 43:19That's a scary thought. Or, conversely, are our digital
- 43:23avatars giving us the ultimate form of Lacanian camouflage?
- 43:28Does the Internet allow us to be endlessly, subversively modeled,
- 43:31slipping past the gaze of modern authority?
- 43:34We started today by talking about how messy the map of human
- 43:37culture is compared to the clean lines of a geographic map.
- 43:41Maybe the digital world is just a brand new, highly contested
- 43:44map, and it's up to us to figure out how to navigate the blurry
- 43:46lines, find the blind spots, and keep moving in the stairwell.
- 43:50Something to think about.