Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Data-Driven Supervision: What Your Call Report Tells NCUA Before an Examiner Arrives
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker: Hey, everyone.
- 0:00This is Mark Trakel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:04Last week, I did a training session, for a credit union, senior executives, but
- 0:09mostly for the supervisory committee and some board members about, the importance
- 0:13of the, 5300 and, the call report.
- 0:17When I prepped for that and I got done with it, I thought
- 0:19this would be a good podcast.
- 0:21So here it is.
- 0:22I've got the PowerPoint, edited a little bit no reference to who the client, was.
- 0:28Hey, everyone.
- 0:28This is Mark Trakel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:31Today, I'm gonna talk about the 5300 and the call report and why it matters
- 0:35to you, why it matters to NCUA.
- 0:38I did a presentation to a credit union last week on this topic, and after I was
- 0:44done, I thought, this would be something good to share via the podcast as well.
- 0:48So we're gonna talk about why the call report matters, and it's gonna present
- 0:52a risk view from the NCUA side of the table, what it means to NCUA, and why
- 0:58it's important for them, and again, why it should be important for you.
- 1:03So the, NCUA uses it as a risk supervision tool and a way of m-monitoring the
- 1:09financial health of credit unions.
- 1:11And I'm gonna quote some things from NCUA so you have specifics here.
- 1:15NCUA collects and analyzes information from credit unions to assess their
- 1:19financial condition and evaluate existing and potential risks to the National Credit
- 1:25Union Share Insurance Fund, also known as the NCUSIF, also known as The Fund.
- 1:32So a couple more quotes on financial health.
- 1:35Call report data is vital to assessing a credit union's financial health.
- 1:39Risk-focused exams.
- 1:40NCUA has risk-focused exams.
- 1:42By the way, I just did a podcast on the entry letter, for the NCUA exam, and
- 1:47if you didn't see that video or watched that, listened to that podcast, it's a
- 1:52very good one, in my opinion, because there's a lot of meat in that, the,
- 1:55the changes that NCUA made there that I think are gonna make exams better
- 1:58if they follow, what they've written.
- 2:00But anyway, risk-focused exams.
- 2:02NCUA's risk-focused exam program relies heavily on the
- 2:05accuracy of call report data.
- 2:08If they're gonna figure out where they're gonna spend their time, particularly
- 2:12in an era where they're down 27% of staff, having good data, is essential
- 2:16to them being able to make the best decisions on where to send staff.
- 2:20And then accuracy.
- 2:22Inaccurate information impairs an examiner's ability to properly
- 2:25identify and assess risk.
- 2:27That's why if you're listening to this and you've had errors in your 5300, you know
- 2:31that they, get pretty I don't wanna say aggressive, but they will, have findings
- 2:35or doors to make sure that you fix them.
- 2:37And, they also view that, and we'll get into that, they view that as a kind of a,
- 2:43a precursor on how your internal controls actually work at the credit union.
- 2:47And these come from, the various reports, the call report, NCUA
- 2:51examiner's guide, via NCUA's website.
- 2:54So this is, of all the slides, this is a little bit more opinion,
- 2:58than, than some of the other slides, but where is NCUA heading?
- 3:02It's, in my opinion, it's heading towards data-driven supervision.
- 3:06Now, earlier this year, they proposed their new strategic
- 3:09plan, and again, another quote.
- 3:11So the strategic plan says, "More closely integrating advanced
- 3:15analytical anal-analytics and enhanced decision-making supports tools into
- 3:20examination scoping, scheduling, and CAMEL's rating processes."
- 3:25That's NCUA's strategic objective one point three.
- 3:29Also, the 2024 annual report said, "By analyzing much of a credit
- 3:34union's financial and operational condition remotely, NCUA says it may
- 3:39be possible to reduce the frequency and scope of on-site examinations."
- 3:44And I know you're all for less frequent exams, and a, a shorter scope, right?
- 3:50And I see, NCUA, so they've said they're gonna use it on exam scope, exam timing,
- 3:55and it's gonna impact CAMEL ratings.
- 3:57Call report data is that main fuel, and errors in that can impact
- 4:01how you're supervised, right?
- 4:03A, if they think you have errors, they're gonna show up and, B, if you
- 4:05give them bad data, it could have them show up when they might not otherwise.
- 4:09All good reasons to, have an accurate 5300.
- 4:14that was all before artificial intelligence, AI, if you
- 4:17will, and, that has taken off.
- 4:19NCUA has talked about they want to tap into AI, and it is a great tool
- 4:25of leveraging, as in your credit union and perhaps personally if you use AI.
- 4:29It's a great tool to leverage.
- 4:31Eventually, I think NCUA will be going more towards, less on site, more virtual,
- 4:37and they need good data for that.
- 4:39I've also heard a rumor, and I will emphasize a rumor, that they may
- 4:42be looking at re- Redoing MERIT or adding some functions to MERIT.
- 4:48And when I think about that, why would they do that so
- 4:51soon after MERIT was launched?
- 4:53Perhaps to take advantage of artificial intelligence and have more off-site exams.
- 5:00So is the money slide if you're, in my opinion, if you're, watching
- 5:04this or if you're listening.
- 5:05I'll walk through it.
- 5:06But, there are six main reasons, why the 5300 program matters.
- 5:12Number one, it's NCUA's primary lens.
- 5:14You file it quarterly.
- 5:16It's how NCUA monitors you between exams and scopes the next one.
- 5:20It tells your story before an examiner arrives, and it tells that story
- 5:24all the way up the chain to the regional director and every level of
- 5:28supervisor in between, 'cause they run risk reports on it, and that, again,
- 5:33determines where, how risky they think you are without being there, and it
- 5:36determines when they might come back.
- 5:39It also plays a key role in setting a capital classification.
- 5:43So it determines what your prompt corrective action is.
- 5:45It determines what your risk-based capital calculations are.
- 5:50And it comes from that quarterly data.
- 5:53And then the act and the regulation drives, when, if you fall be- below seven,
- 5:59you're between six and seven, you've gotta request earnings, earnings waiver letters.
- 6:03If you fall below six, you have to have a, a, a capital restoration plan.
- 6:07And it's driven by the, those, those numbers, and it's, the dates
- 6:12that when you have to submit it are driven by when you submit that data.
- 6:15So it's also a legal filing.
- 6:17An officer declares it's true and correct.
- 6:20Late or false or misleading reports can carry civil money penalties,
- 6:24and errors must be corrected.
- 6:26Now, as it relates to civil money penalties, NCUA,
- 6:30doesn't do that very much.
- 6:31They'll do it if you're late or historically late, but they've, th-
- 6:34they're not aggressive as an agency as it relates to civil money penalties.
- 6:39It's also a public document.
- 6:40That's another thing, that makes it important.
- 6:42Anyone can pull it from NCUA's website, your members, your peer
- 6:47credit unions, banks, the media, analysts, or potential merger partners.
- 6:52So again, it kinda says, "Hey, here's what our numbers show we are."
- 6:56And it supports the insurance fund.
- 6:58Insured de- shares drive your 1% NCUSIF deposit and feed the
- 7:02fund's equity ratio, which decides whether NCUA charges a premium.
- 7:06Now, there's much debate, in my mind, on whether or not, all credit unions
- 7:11get that insurance calculation correct.
- 7:13Perhaps NCUA's enhanced their tools relative to, making sure that they get
- 7:19that correct, but it was always something that I think NCUA could have d- needed
- 7:23to take some actions, to try and improve the accuracy of what it is that you need
- 7:28to put on deposit in the insurance fund.
- 7:30And it's a, as I mentioned earlier, it's a proxy for internal controls.
- 7:33Accurate, on-time reports signal controls that work.
- 7:37Amendments and recurring errors i- invite a closer look, and
- 7:40indicates that there might be something wrong at the credit union.
- 7:43And if there's challenges getting the 5300 right, NCUA might have reason to
- 7:48believe that there are other issues that they should be looking at.
- 7:51So again, errors means they'll come back more often, another
- 7:54reason, to not make any.
- 7:56And a, an error on a 5300 might look like it's minor, but it
- 8:00does catch NCUA's attention.
- 8:03What NCUA's rules ask for of the supervisory committee as
- 8:07it relates to their operations.
- 8:09So now I'm pivoting away from just the 5300 and into the role of the supervisory
- 8:16committee, which was also part of what we chatted about, last week, in a credit
- 8:20union somewhere in the United States.
- 8:23So the rule tie- the rule ties controls to the call report.
- 8:27NCUA defines reliable financial reporting as preparing call
- 8:30reports that meet management's financial reporting and objective.
- 8:34And if you're looking at the PowerPoint, it lists the
- 8:36regulation here, that applies.
- 8:39The committee must ensure the credit union meets call report measurement and
- 8:43filing requirements, and that reports are promptly prepared and accurate.
- 8:47So management prepares them, the committee checks them.
- 8:52The committee owns the auditor relationship.
- 8:54The audit engagement is contracted directly with the
- 8:56committee, and the auditor reports internal control concerns to it.
- 9:02Total assets on the year-end call report determines which annual
- 9:05audit the credit union must obtain.
- 9:07And of course, if you're over $500 million, that's a CPA opinion audit.
- 9:11If you're under $500 million- it lays out agreed-upon
- 9:14procedures that must be included.
- 9:16And again, the rule's verb is to ensure that it's done, not prepare it.
- 9:22How oversight happens matters as much as whether it happens.
- 9:25The committee is the members' watchdog.
- 9:28It doesn't prepare the call report, it gets assurances that
- 9:31the process producing it is sound.
- 9:34And the NCUA's Examiner's guide says, "The supervisory committee
- 9:38is responsible for reviewing and monitoring internal controls,
- 9:41including reviewing and appraising the work of internal audit staff."
- 9:46Now, the internal audit is the committee's engine.
- 9:49You have risk-rated audit plan, enterprise risk management ranks
- 9:53audits areas, so attention goes where the risk is, and that's if you're
- 9:57big enough to have an enterprise risk management, tool or committee.
- 10:01It needs to be independent with recurring reviews or, a, a
- 10:05outsourced internal audit partner.
- 10:07You can hire them to have belts and suspenders so that they can take a
- 10:10look at it, a l- for the committee or it can be done by internal audit,
- 10:14but it can't be, the review process cannot be done by management itself.
- 10:19Another set of eyes on call reporting, if you have an outside firm or an
- 10:24outside or an int- internal auditor, they can look at it quarterly.
- 10:28Findings flow to the committee.
- 10:30NCUA expects internal audit and report to report all findings to
- 10:34the committee and follow up to make sure that they're resolved
- 10:41Where the committee adds the most value.
- 10:43Now, the committee's focus is in, is the process sound, preparation, independent
- 10:48review, reconciliation to the general ledger, whether internal audit risk-rated
- 10:53work is sound, audit and exam findings and whether or not they're resolved, so
- 10:57they should be following up on what NCUA asks to be done, and amended call reports.
- 11:02Why were they needed?
- 11:03Were there systems put in place to make sure it didn't happen again?
- 11:06The flip side of that is what management does, internal auditâ¦
- 11:10Management does, excuse me, internal audit tests.
- 11:13So line-by-line preparation and account mapping is management.
- 11:17Day-to-day reconciliation, management.
- 11:19Operational process design is a management issue.
- 11:23So for the call report, the committee's core question is simple: Is the
- 11:26process that produces the number sound?
- 11:32NCUA's recommended practices for the call report.
- 11:35Now, this is from the examiner's guide, and again, a guide is not a
- 11:38regulation, and they're doing less guide-type things under the Trump
- 11:43administration, across all agencies.
- 11:46But, this is still out there a- as of today's publication.
- 11:49So management owns it.
- 11:51Management is responsible for overseeing call report and profile reporting.
- 11:55Again, there's the profile which lists your field of membership, are
- 11:58you a low-income designation, dated, how many branches you have, who
- 12:02your board members are, et cetera, et cetera, and other things there.
- 12:04But that's a management responsibility.
- 12:06Documented review before submission.
- 12:09A written review process to detect and fix errors prior to filing.
- 12:13So you should have a file that shows that is support.
- 12:16So if NCUA comes in and says, "How did you get your, this number of HELOC loans?"
- 12:20Or, "How did you get this number of branches?"
- 12:23Or, "How did you get this number of delinquent loans?"
- 12:26There should be some sort of mapping, documentation that NCUA can review.
- 12:30There should be work papers behind every line, it should be reconciled
- 12:34to the general ledger, and the preparer and review, it should
- 12:37be a separation of, of duties.
- 12:40There should be a preparer and a reviewer that are different people.
- 12:43And vendors should be vetted.
- 12:45Any third party that helps prepare the report has its own review process, and
- 12:48the credit union does due diligence.
- 12:50By the way, the banking regulators, including NCUA, are looking
- 12:54at changing how they look at third-party due diligence.
- 12:57So the, for the committee, these are things that NCUA does, but these
- 13:00are questions to ask management.
- 13:02Again, not to perform So five questions from an e- examiner's perspective
- 13:08that they can look at every quarter.
- 13:10What changed the most this quarter and why?
- 13:12Did we report anyâ¦
- 13:13Did we, did the credit union, report anything different than last quarter?
- 13:18Are there any new services?
- 13:19Who reviewed it, and how was it reconciled to the general ledger?
- 13:23Are there any known errors or pending amendments?
- 13:26How do our key ratios compare to peers and our own policy limits?
- 13:29Because NCUA, i- is aggressively looking at what your policy limits are and
- 13:35making sure that you have good governance and don't violate your own policies.
- 13:39So again, the examiner looks for adverse trends, unusual
- 13:42growth, and unexplained changes.
- 13:44If management can answer these readily, that's a good sign
- 13:48that the process is working.
- 13:51And lastly, here's some citations on, the Federal Credit Union Act.
- 13:55Section 202,
- 13:58various sections of Section 202, discuss, the 5300 and ga- data gathering.
- 14:03For example, 202(6) is the regulation that says, that, if you're over 500
- 14:09million, you need a CPA, opinion audit, and, that if you're over
- 14:1310 million, you need to file GAAP.
- 14:15And then there's a few regulations, that apply to this.
- 14:19741.6,
- 14:19715.2,
- 14:22715.3,
- 14:24and 715, 715.4.
- 14:27I'm not gonna go into those specifics, but if you wanna go check them out,
- 14:30there's the numbers that tie to that.
- 14:32So that's the end of what I wanted to tell you here about the 5300, the call
- 14:36report, and the supervisory committee, responsibilities related to it.
- 14:40If you do it right, it helps you get a better exam.
- 14:43And I do believe that NCUA will be using this more and more as opposed
- 14:47to less and less over time, and that's because of the world we live in with AI.
- 14:51They're gonna wanna be able to be as efficient as they can.
- 14:54They're going to eventually want to be able to take advantage of AI tools,
- 14:58to do a lot of your exam off-site.
- 15:00And in the end, I think that works well for you.
- 15:02As always, I wanna thank you for watching or thank you for listening.
- 15:05Please, subscribe, on, on YouTube or Spotify or Apple, wherever you get this.
- 15:11It'll help my algorithms and get this message out to more
- 15:15credit union folks out there.
- 15:17Again, appreciate your time.
- 15:19This is Mark Trakel, signing off with flying colors.