Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Bringing the Pieces Together: Steps for Better Outcomes in Class and PAGA Mediations With Barbara DuVan-Clarke & Danielle GruppChang
Transcript
- 0:06I'm delighted to introduce you today to today's
- 0:08speakers, Barbajou Van Clark and Danielle Groupcheng.
- 0:13Barbajou Van Clark is a senior trial attorney
- 0:15and team lead at Blackstone Law, where she champions
- 0:18the rights of California employees and individual,
- 0:21class, and PAGA actions. She is a passionate
- 0:24advocate for women facing workplace discrimination
- 0:27and harassment. Notably, she served as co -counsel
- 0:31in the Young v. Department of Public Social Services,
- 0:35helping secure the seventh -highest employment
- 0:37law verdict in California in 2022 and continues
- 0:40to lead impactful litigation on behalf of thousands
- 0:43of workers. Danielle Gripchang is a senior associate
- 0:47attorney at Blackstone Law, where she specializes
- 0:50in wage and hour class actions and is a dedicated
- 0:52advocate for workers' rights. Coming from a family
- 0:55rooted in the restaurant industry, Ms. Gripchang
- 0:58brings a personal understanding of the challenges
- 1:01faced by the working class Californians. Her
- 1:05lived experiences fuel her commitment to ensuring
- 1:07employees are treated fairly and compensated
- 1:10lawfully under the law. We're so happy to have
- 1:13you both. Now let's get started. Thank you so
- 1:17much, Andy, for that wonderful introduction.
- 1:21Okay, so we are going to be bringing you our
- 1:25presentation. It is bringing the pieces together,
- 1:29pre -mediation steps for better outcomes. It
- 1:32is going to be a chronological step -by -step
- 1:35of the kind of tips and tricks that we like to
- 1:38utilize to really make the most out of our mediations
- 1:41and to ensure that you know, we can meaningfully
- 1:45use the time that we have with the mediator that
- 1:48we've, at that point, probably waited six to
- 1:50nine months to be in front of. So, Rhett, if
- 1:54we could have the next slide, please. Thank you.
- 1:59So, first... a mediation checklist. We have provided
- 2:03you with a mediation letter as well as with a
- 2:06timeline. And together, those two things can
- 2:08serve as a checklist to get yourself prepared
- 2:10for mediation. It contains general questions
- 2:13and specific questions. And while on the onset
- 2:18of your case, you don't necessarily need to know
- 2:21that information immediately. You do need to
- 2:24have that information handy prior to mediation.
- 2:27And so an attorney should plan to know the answers
- 2:31to all of those questions, even if the answer
- 2:34to that question is no, there are no CBAs, or
- 2:37no, there is no alternative workweek schedule.
- 2:40But you should make a plan to confirm that information,
- 2:45and whether that's utilizing some of the other
- 2:48resources that you might have or asking defendants
- 2:51directly, it's important information for you
- 2:54to have. Next slide, please, Rin. All right,
- 3:01so the first steps with regard to preparing for
- 3:06mediation and making sure that you have the best
- 3:08outcome possible starts months and months and
- 3:11months prior to your actual mediation. So you
- 3:14should, for both sides, both plaintiff side and
- 3:17defense, make sure that you are talking to your
- 3:19client and gathering all of the documents that
- 3:21you can possibly get that relate to the claims
- 3:25and defenses at issue. and having conversations
- 3:30with your clients as opposed to just sending
- 3:34emails or memos or things like that are very,
- 3:38very important. I think that one of the overarching
- 3:42themes for today really is establishing valid
- 3:48and open and frequent communication, not just
- 3:51with your own clients, but also with the other
- 3:53side. Because the more conversations that we
- 3:56have as opposed to emails that get exchanged,
- 4:00the better the outcome, the better the information,
- 4:03and sometimes talking through some of these issues
- 4:06is the best way to actually prepare. So with
- 4:11regard to the defense, make sure that you are
- 4:15having this conversation with your client, particularly
- 4:17if they are unsophisticated or if they've never
- 4:20been involved in litigation before, so that you
- 4:23can set their expectations regarding what settlement
- 4:26value range could look like, what exposure is,
- 4:30whether there's EPLI, the timelines of things
- 4:33that you will need to receive from them. And
- 4:36on the plaintiff's side, making sure that you
- 4:38are communicating with your client regarding
- 4:41their expectations as well. Because obviously,
- 4:44class and Paga recovery is very different than
- 4:46an individual case. Sometimes there are individual
- 4:51claims that are also going to be mediated alongside
- 4:53of a class and Paga, but we're not really delving
- 4:56into that today. But it is always very important
- 5:00to make sure that your client is on the same
- 5:02page in terms of expectations, timelines, communication.
- 5:08So that also involves making sure that you are
- 5:12using language that's appropriate for your client
- 5:14and making sure that you're making a connection
- 5:16with them. So that also involves frequent check
- 5:27-ins and making sure that your client is updated
- 5:30on a regular basis. if you are a firm that has
- 5:34support staff. And I know that there are solos
- 5:36and small firms that don't have as much support
- 5:39staff as larger firms. But if you are fortunate
- 5:43enough to have talented support staff, have them
- 5:47set a schedule and make sure that your client
- 5:51is receiving regular check -ins and that they
- 5:54are following up for information or answering
- 5:56questions and things like that. Also, with regard
- 6:00to the expectations, discuss early mediation
- 6:05with your clients. So I know that that is oftentimes
- 6:11looking toward the end of the case, but I think
- 6:13that the best way to approach any case is to
- 6:15look at the end from the very beginning. Okay,
- 6:19and the next slide, please. So this slide is
- 6:23with regards to client management. Client management
- 6:26is certainly one of the many things that could
- 6:28derail a mediation if you haven't been working
- 6:31on that from the outset of your case. On the
- 6:34plaintiff side, like Barbara's mentioned, one
- 6:37of the most important things is to set expectations
- 6:39regarding compensation. Nothing worse than mediating
- 6:44a whole day and then you come back to your clients.
- 6:48You know, you're kind of getting ready to discuss
- 6:50some, you know, tighter numbers and they are
- 6:53blown away. They have you know, they're so upset,
- 6:57they haven't expected that those that's what
- 6:59the numbers were going to come down to. And if
- 7:01you had worked on that client management aspect,
- 7:05if you had worked on kind of communicating to
- 7:07them as the case was going on different reasons
- 7:10why the exit your expectations for how the case
- 7:13might settle, you know, where it might settle,
- 7:16then then you've missed an opportunity to kind
- 7:20of nip that in the bud. And so another thing
- 7:23that's gonna help you with that is establish
- 7:25trust with your client, making sure that you
- 7:27have the settlement authority, making sure that
- 7:29they respect your opinion. And I think that the
- 7:32one of the best ways to establish that is for
- 7:34them to feel like you respect them in turn. Another
- 7:38thing that we like to do is from the offset.
- 7:41We ask our plaintiffs to start gathering contact
- 7:45information for possible declarants. This gives
- 7:47you contact information as you're ramping up
- 7:50your case, as you're getting ready for mediation
- 7:52for you to call those people, ask them what their
- 7:55experiences were. You can get declarations for
- 7:58mediation. You can have more than just... You
- 8:02know, according to my plaintiff, they work during
- 8:04their rest breaks. If you're able to back that
- 8:06up with declarations from third party witnesses,
- 8:10from other putative class members or grieved
- 8:12employees, that'll have a lot more weight when
- 8:14you get to mediation. It'll show the mediator
- 8:15not only have you done your homework, but that,
- 8:18you know, perhaps these, many of the violations
- 8:21that don't show on the records, that they will
- 8:23have more weight and more merit because you have
- 8:25the declarations to back them up. Another thing
- 8:29with plaintiffs is you want to discuss their
- 8:31timelines. You want to make sure that they know
- 8:34this is certainly a marathon, not a sprint, that
- 8:37this is something that's going to take a little
- 8:38bit of time. And I like to tell my plaintiffs,
- 8:43this is not something that you need to have at
- 8:44the forefront of your brain. You don't need to
- 8:47worry about this every day or think that something
- 8:50new is going to happen every day. This is something
- 8:53where we can connect once or twice a month. And
- 8:57like Barbara said, we can make sure that we have
- 8:59these regularly scheduled check -ins, and we
- 9:01love to utilize our support staff or some of
- 9:04our junior attorneys. It gives them great experience
- 9:06to start working on their skills to build those
- 9:09relationships. On the defense side, I think it's
- 9:13so important for attorneys to really determine
- 9:17who has that firsthand knowledge of an employee's
- 9:20day to day. Who is able to answer questions for
- 9:23you like, where do they take their rests? Where
- 9:27do they take their lunches? Where do they clock
- 9:29in? Where are their lockers? People who are really
- 9:33truly going to understand what the day -to -day
- 9:37work and what the experiences of employees are
- 9:39so that you can better advocate for your client.
- 9:44Another thing that you're going to want to do
- 9:45is identify who the decisions makers are and
- 9:48figure out what their natural inclinations are
- 9:50towards risk. are more risk adverse. If they're
- 9:56willing to take risks, you know, perhaps they
- 9:57want to see a little bit of litigation before
- 9:59they feel that they're ready to go to mediation.
- 10:02It's important for you to know those things.
- 10:06And kind of finally, on the defense side, I would
- 10:09urge you to kind of make sure that everyone,
- 10:12you know, these decision makers, the people who
- 10:14are going to be present at mediation, your point
- 10:16of contact, that they understand a lot of these
- 10:18key processes about, you know, approvals of a
- 10:23class repogas settlement, work we can pay period
- 10:25values, and why it's important for them to get
- 10:27those data points accurately, and escalator clauses.
- 10:32I think once you have that, those kind of concepts,
- 10:36explained to your client, then that gives them
- 10:38a little bit more buy -in and understanding as
- 10:41to why those data points are so crucial to you
- 10:44and why it's important for them to get them right.
- 10:49The next slide, please, Rin. That's fine. With
- 10:53regard to client management from both sides,
- 10:57the key theme, again, for both sides is really
- 11:00communication. having those conversations with
- 11:04your client and with the clearance and going
- 11:07to the site potentially as a defense lawyer and
- 11:12speaking with those key individuals that will
- 11:15facilitate you having a better and more informed
- 11:17conversation with your opposing counsel as well
- 11:20as with your mediator later on. So I think that
- 11:22it's not merely client management. It is also
- 11:27facilitating the road ahead. With regard to this
- 11:30slide, so engaging a right team. So with regard
- 11:35to your data and your documents, so I think that
- 11:42the proper thing to do is to engage a data analyst.
- 11:47And I think that there are firms that don't do
- 11:51that. They do the data analysis and document
- 11:53analysis in -house. The difficulty on that from
- 11:58a plaintiff's perspective is that that is attorney
- 12:02time that is taken up and it is time that is
- 12:05not necessarily separately compensable because
- 12:08the fees that are approved later on are on a
- 12:13percentage basis as opposed to on an hourly basis.
- 12:17Those countless hours of doing the math. would
- 12:23be counted in that percentage. Whereas if you
- 12:26send your data and documents to an analyst, someone
- 12:29who is qualified and trained to do this and does
- 12:32nothing but this, that is a recoverable case
- 12:36cost later on. So as a plaintiff's lawyer, I
- 12:38think that the proper thing to do is to send
- 12:42that out for analysis. And that will save you
- 12:46both on time and if we were good at math, we
- 12:50wouldn't have gone to law school. We would have
- 12:52done med school or engineering or something else.
- 12:56So certainly, there are those of us who are good
- 12:58at it. But send it to those who do this all day,
- 13:02every day. Also, when you file your complaint,
- 13:06I recommend sending your complaint to your data
- 13:09analyst or on the defense side, as soon as you
- 13:11get that complaint, send it to your data analyst
- 13:13as well. That secures your preferred data analyst
- 13:19for later on. And the great thing about that,
- 13:23you never need to tell a soul that they have
- 13:25already been retained, right? And so you're not
- 13:29tipping your hand. You're not doing any of those
- 13:31kinds of things. But you are retaining the right
- 13:34team, the people that you are familiar with,
- 13:37that you like working with, that you know you
- 13:39can count on to do your analysis the correct
- 13:42way. Second to that is something that you should
- 13:47be doing on the regular, both, again, on the
- 13:49plaintiff side and on the defense side. So building
- 13:52relationships and investing time and effort with
- 13:55the mediators and with their case managers. So
- 13:59the case managers are often unsung or forgotten
- 14:03heroes in our mediation story. And they are the
- 14:08ones that can tell you, oh, this person has a
- 14:10cancellation three months from now, instead of
- 14:12their availability being in April or May of the
- 14:16following year. And they are the ones that can
- 14:19help facilitate getting you in with the mediator
- 14:22of your choice. So I definitely think that it's
- 14:26worth investing in time with the support team
- 14:30for the mediators and the case managers over
- 14:32there. And building relationships with the mediators.
- 14:36So I firmly encourage that you attend things
- 14:40like the judicial events that the Beverly Hills
- 14:45Bar Association held earlier this year, where
- 14:47you can actually speak with a lot of these mediators
- 14:50and a lot of these very recently retired judges
- 14:54who are going into the mediation and arbitration
- 14:56practice. You want to find out about them, find
- 14:59out what they like, find out what they don't
- 15:00like, how they approach mediation, because there
- 15:03are mediators who have different approaches,
- 15:07right? Some of them nowadays are doing this kind
- 15:10of mediators proposed bracket to narrow the field
- 15:13and hopefully get to numbers quicker in the day.
- 15:18Some of them are old school and they like to
- 15:20have this back and forth on a factual analysis,
- 15:23and they don't even get to numbers until after
- 15:25lunch. Really, you have to know what your mediator's
- 15:29approach is. Some mediators still do an open
- 15:32session to start the day. So you have to be aware
- 15:36of what their preference is, how you are going
- 15:38to discuss the facts with them, and making sure
- 15:42that you're investing in those relationships
- 15:43as well. Again, Also a common theme throughout
- 15:47today is utilizing your support staff throughout
- 15:50the process. And it could be as simple as having
- 15:53them contact the mediators for availability,
- 15:58for making sure that they are scheduling these
- 16:00connections, or as we have on the timeline, making
- 16:04sure that those dates and deadlines are scheduled
- 16:06so that you can have these check -ins with your
- 16:10clients, with the other side, with your mediator,
- 16:12those kinds of things. And we can go to the next
- 16:15slide, please. So in terms of the timeline of
- 16:19where we are on our case, our case is still.
- 16:21recently filed. And so this first step is kind
- 16:25of figuring out whether or not it's appropriate,
- 16:27set a mediation. And I think the first step to
- 16:31that, and it's kind of underutilized, and it
- 16:33seems so obvious, is just have the conversation.
- 16:38You know, you're truly not putting yourself at
- 16:41a disadvantage by just opening up this channel
- 16:44of communication, having a conversation about
- 16:47it. And I would really encourage you, particularly
- 16:50if your case is a class action, it's likely in
- 16:52a complex court, there's probably a CMO. You're
- 16:55probably required to do a joint ISC statement.
- 16:59And many, many judges, many of CMOs require you
- 17:02to state whether or not you have considered early
- 17:05mediation or whether or not you're open to ADR.
- 17:08Make that more than just a throwaway sentence
- 17:11and a joint statement. If you see that the defense
- 17:14or that the plaintiff side, the opposing counsel
- 17:16has put that they're open to ADR, talk to them
- 17:19about it. Why not ask? You know, I noticed that
- 17:23you put that you're open to ADR. You know, what
- 17:26do you think about that? Do we want to see if
- 17:28we want to see what kind of availability there
- 17:31is for a mediator? You're not likely not going
- 17:34to see a mediator for six to nine months anyways.
- 17:37And in that time, you can still continue to build
- 17:39up your case. But I would encourage you to ask
- 17:44because you'll never get what you don't ask for.
- 17:46And what you're looking for here is not necessarily
- 17:48the mediation, but the information. You want
- 17:51to know if mediation isn't appropriate now, why?
- 17:55When will it be appropriate? That way you can
- 17:58adequately throw your resources into something
- 18:00that's going to meaningfully move your case forward
- 18:03as opposed to just litigating smaller issues
- 18:07just for the sake of litigating them. And I think,
- 18:10you know, if Opposing counsel isn't understanding
- 18:13why you're asking about early mediation. Don't
- 18:17shy away from explaining it to them. It saves
- 18:20all of the party's time. It saves everyone resources.
- 18:25In particular, for a defense counsel, it would
- 18:28save your client's work week accrual. The earlier
- 18:32you get into mediation, the smaller that work
- 18:34week or pay period number is going to be. And
- 18:37on the plaintiff's side, if the defendant is
- 18:41all of a sudden changing their policies in response
- 18:43to your lawsuit, then you're also going to save
- 18:46dilution. You're not going to have all of these
- 18:49work weeks and pay periods that are associated
- 18:51with new, better, stronger policies when you
- 18:54get to mediation. It's not going to dilute the
- 18:56violation rates. And I would also finally encourage
- 19:00you to have explicit conversations about the
- 19:02scope. In today's day and age, when we practice
- 19:06class actions in PAGA, we obviously are seeing
- 19:09a lot of arbitration agreements. Barbara's already
- 19:11mentioned that our clients may have individual
- 19:14claims. Why not be explicit about the possibilities
- 19:17of the scope of mediation so that you have? put
- 19:21that information out there so that you can say
- 19:23what you think the appropriate scope is, and
- 19:25you can have an appropriate conversation about
- 19:27why or why not. You know, what you've proposed
- 19:31is the appropriate scope. But I think if you
- 19:34don't, if you're not willing to have that conversation,
- 19:36it is certainly one of the other things that
- 19:38could just blow up your mediation and have wasted
- 19:40all of the party's time because you were unwilling.
- 19:43or maybe even apprehensive to have that discussion
- 19:49and to bring up some of these topics. And with
- 19:53regard to the scope specifically, if there are
- 19:57individual claims, like if your individual plaintiff
- 20:00has a FIHA or an 11 .025 or any other individualized
- 20:06claims that are not part of your class or Paga
- 20:08case, the scope absolutely needs to be very clear,
- 20:13clearly communicated to the other side, because
- 20:15as a defense counsel, you want to know from your
- 20:18client, is there EPLI? Is there separate coverage?
- 20:21Is there a separate counsel for these? individual
- 20:23claims. And so you have to be able to adequately
- 20:26prepare for mediation. So one of the things that
- 20:29Danielle and I believe is a best practice is
- 20:31when you are booking that mediation, you put
- 20:35it in that email and say explicitly, this mediation
- 20:38will be class, Paga, and individual, or if there
- 20:43has already been motion practice on an arbitration.
- 20:46and that was successful, then it's PAGA and individual
- 20:51wage and hour claims. Whatever it is, be explicit
- 20:54and be on the same page. And it's all about,
- 20:56again, communication. So if we could do the next
- 20:59slide, please. Selecting a mediator, again, this
- 21:04is where Having all of these networking events
- 21:06and meeting these mediators and judges who are
- 21:10going to be retiring and who are going to be
- 21:12engaging in mediation and arbitration, this is
- 21:14where this is very crucial. You need to develop
- 21:18these relationships so that you have an understanding
- 21:20of their approach to mediation, their valuation
- 21:23of cases. I had a mediator one time tell me that
- 21:26his favorite kind of cases were class actions
- 21:28because all he needed to do was get out his calculator.
- 21:32So that was quite interesting. That was a piece
- 21:34of information that I didn't have before. So
- 21:38you want to make sure that you are having a mediator
- 21:42who is the right fit for you and for your case.
- 21:46So there are mediators who are very aggressive.
- 21:50And that is how they practice. If that is not
- 21:53your style, if you have a client who is very
- 21:54sensitive or emotional, or if you're If your
- 21:59defense client is not sophisticated and has not
- 22:02been through this process before, that might
- 22:04not be the right fit for you or for this case.
- 22:07So you might want someone who has a little bit
- 22:10of a softer touch, whatever that is. So you also
- 22:16want to make sure that they are going to have
- 22:18availability. Most of the great mediators, again,
- 22:22they're currently booking somewhere between nine
- 22:24and 10 months out. That's not always a negative.
- 22:29Certainly work weeks and pay periods and things
- 22:31like that continue to accrue. However, you should
- 22:35never waste that time. You should always be making
- 22:38sure that you're making strides towards learning
- 22:40more information, having these regular check
- 22:42-ins, all of that kind of stuff. So even though
- 22:44availability is going to be an issue with the
- 22:46vast majority of quality mediators, it doesn't
- 22:50have to be. And again, Make sure that you are
- 22:53in with those case managers and that you are
- 22:54having these great check -ins with them, because
- 22:56they will let you know if there are cancellations.
- 22:59Cost. Cost is also another consideration. And
- 23:03some mediators now are $30 ,000 a day. Some of
- 23:06them are $10 ,000 a day. What is your budget
- 23:09for this case and what is appropriate for this
- 23:12case? So there are certainly mediators. who have
- 23:15better availability, who are less expensive.
- 23:17There are other mediators who are far more skilled,
- 23:20particularly in the class podcast space, that
- 23:23tend to be higher, tend to be further booked
- 23:26into the future. So evaluate all of those things.
- 23:30Effectiveness and prior experiences, I think,
- 23:32are hand in hand, right? So you understand. how
- 23:37effective a mediator can be by having either
- 23:39spoken with other members of your firm, spoken
- 23:42with the greater community, sending out an email
- 23:45to the listserv, hey, has anyone heard about
- 23:47this? Or your internal firm listserv. I know
- 23:52a lot of the large defense firms have that kind
- 23:55of banked information so that everyone can share
- 23:58in those resources. I think that's wonderful.
- 24:02And so there are additional things to consider
- 24:05with regard to these mediators. What is their
- 24:08follow up like? Are they booked for the eight
- 24:11hours of mediation and they charge for hours
- 24:14beyond six p .m.? Are they even willing to go
- 24:17beyond six p .m.? There are some mediators who
- 24:19have a hard cut off and will not mediate into
- 24:21the evening. Do they bill for hours beyond the
- 24:26eight or 10 hours of mediation itself? And if
- 24:29so, who's paying for that? Do you have an agreement
- 24:32with the other side to split those hours? Does
- 24:35it include phone calls or emails? And how are
- 24:37they billing that time? So that is something
- 24:40crucial for you to know before you book a mediator
- 24:42as well. Their approach to mediation. Again,
- 24:45some mediators have this mediator's proposed
- 24:47bracket that they like to do. Some mediators
- 24:51like to very, very heavily go through the facts
- 24:55and make sure that those are well developed and
- 24:58everybody is on the same page with regard to
- 25:00the facts before they get to numbers. Some mediators,
- 25:03if your briefing is robust, and particularly
- 25:08if you've had a pre -mediation call, they sometimes
- 25:11are willing to get to numbers a little bit more
- 25:13quickly because they've already vetted the factual
- 25:15information and the strengths and weaknesses
- 25:17of each of the claims. Lastly, do you trust that
- 25:22this mediator is going to effectively communicate
- 25:25your position? This is crucial. Some mediators
- 25:30make mistakes. We're all human. We all make mistakes.
- 25:34But sometimes they can convey something that
- 25:37they either weren't supposed to say or that is
- 25:41not truly what your position is. And so you need
- 25:45to make sure that you have this trust relationship.
- 25:48with your mediator so that you understand and
- 25:52developing those relationships with them, having
- 25:54these conversations outside of mediation, that
- 25:58helps you figure out what their language is and
- 25:59how they approach things generally. So I think
- 26:03that those are quite critical. Absolutely. Next
- 26:09slide, please, Rin. Thank you. So one of the
- 26:13handouts that we provided today is kind of a
- 26:16scrubbed version of our mediation letter. It's
- 26:20a mediation letter that we send kind of as soon
- 26:22as we start talking about mediation, perhaps
- 26:25sometimes even before the mediation itself has
- 26:27been booked. Because these are the crucial pieces
- 26:31of information that we need to have a meaningful
- 26:34mediation. For both parties, a mediation letter
- 26:38is your opportunity again to explicitly state
- 26:41the scope of mediation as you understand it.
- 26:44It also is your opportunity to clearly state
- 26:47the relevant time period, which I think is crucial
- 26:51in PAGA actions in particular, because some people
- 26:54count back from the PAGA notice, whereas others
- 26:57count back from the filing of the PAGA complaint.
- 27:01So we want to make sure that there's a level
- 27:02and clear understanding of what we consider to
- 27:05be the relevant time period. It also can set
- 27:08expectations for timing. It's so important that
- 27:11we discuss as plaintiff's counsel, when we need
- 27:14that data by. And for defense counsel, when you
- 27:18are able to provide that data, it is very rare
- 27:22to see a defendant who has the resources to be
- 27:25able to put multiple staff members towards the
- 27:28production of time and pay data that they would
- 27:31be able to gather it together in a matter of
- 27:34months. Instead, they're probably going to need
- 27:37half a year. or maybe later, maybe longer, depending
- 27:40on the size of the case. So being able to really
- 27:45clearly set expectations for that you're working
- 27:48on it, that this is when you think you'll have
- 27:50it prepared, this is when you'll have it ready
- 27:53to send over, it also establishes trust because
- 27:58there's that open level of communication between
- 28:01opposing counsel. We also use this as an opportunity
- 28:05to attach a draft MOU. It's one of our tips and
- 28:09tricks that makes mediations more effective.
- 28:13That way you don't have to waste time at the
- 28:15end of the day once you've already worked so
- 28:17hard to get a number that both sides have accepted.
- 28:20You don't have to argue over these tiny little
- 28:23things like what... percentage of attorney fees
- 28:27or if they're absolutely not okay with an escalator
- 28:31or the allocation between W2 and 1099, some of
- 28:37the smaller things that you could discuss prior
- 28:39to mediation and at least get that the dialogue
- 28:43about it going. In terms of party specific for
- 28:47the mediation letter, on the plaintiff side,
- 28:49this is your opportunity to have a data and document
- 28:52wishlist. We're going to ask for everything.
- 28:56And that's your chance to initially make that
- 28:59ask. It's also your chance to kind of mitigate
- 29:03any risks about being shocked if defendant brings
- 29:06financial difficulty into play at the mediation.
- 29:10We would encourage you to have these kind of
- 29:13discussions as soon and as kind of often as you
- 29:17can. But in the letter in particular, we use
- 29:21that as an opportunity to say, if defense If
- 29:24defendant is going to bring up an ability to
- 29:27pay, these are the documents that we need to
- 29:30be able to assess that. Because obviously, we're
- 29:33not willing to just give a discount at mediation
- 29:36if that's the first time we've heard that there
- 29:38is an ability to pay issue. We need verification.
- 29:41We need to do our due diligence to make sure
- 29:44that we agree that there is going to be an ability
- 29:47to pay. And oftentimes, that analysis needs to
- 29:51be backed up by documents. On the defense side,
- 29:55I think it gives you an opportunity to give data
- 29:58points that both sides can rely on because it
- 30:01will derail your mediation or you're at least
- 30:03going to spend a few hours up top if plaintiff
- 30:08side thinks there's 10 ,000 work weeks and defense
- 30:10side thinks there's 20 ,000. And so if you're
- 30:14able to kind of come to the mediation at nine
- 30:16o 'clock, 10 o 'clock with a set of data points
- 30:19that both sides can rely on, then you will have
- 30:22saved so much time that could have potentially
- 30:26been wasted. I think also defense counsel can
- 30:30use this as an opportunity to explicitly state
- 30:32what was produced, what will be produced. That
- 30:37way, there's no confusion. If your client only
- 30:40has one employee handbook, then you can say,
- 30:43we are producing our clients only employee handbook.
- 30:47That way, there is no possibility that at mediation
- 30:51plaintiffs council is going to say we got a handbook
- 30:54from 2020 you know they didn't give me a new
- 30:57one and there's no time wasted um kind of trying
- 31:02to untangle the unknown because we've been explicit
- 31:05with each other we've had these conversations
- 31:07um and kind of as we've been saying throughout
- 31:10this entire presentation We really stress this
- 31:15open communication, how important it is, and
- 31:18truly how the trust and communication can carry
- 31:21you through the mediation to a much better result
- 31:24and to a timely results. Barbara? As a tack on
- 31:30to that, with regard to the defense side, I encourage
- 31:33the defense to also send a mediation letter.
- 31:39It's actually pretty rare that we get on our
- 31:42in our practice, a defendant who says, here's
- 31:46a list of all of the information that I need
- 31:48answers for. But I think that that's great. I
- 31:52am more than happy to have these conversations
- 31:55with our clients, with our declarants, with other
- 31:58people, and find out this information and get
- 32:01that to them. And that sets up a more streamlined
- 32:06mediation. And it also sometimes raises things
- 32:10for the defense that they didn't know about.
- 32:13For example, if an off the clock theory is that
- 32:18the employees need to show up at a workplace
- 32:20and they didn't know that they needed to clock
- 32:25in, there's only one time clock and sometimes
- 32:27this time clock is broken and they have to go
- 32:29to a different time clock in a different building
- 32:31or whatever it is or if they have to open up
- 32:33the workspace before they're even able to turn
- 32:36on the computer or the time clock. Sometimes
- 32:40the defendant doesn't know about that because
- 32:41they haven't been given that information. So
- 32:44absolutely, ask those questions of your plaintiffs.
- 32:47Hold them accountable. They need to know their
- 32:49case as well. And you need to have this information
- 32:52as a defense lawyer so that you can prepare for
- 32:55mediation and set up these calls, which leads
- 33:00us to our next slide, which is, again, open.
- 33:06and regular communication. I tell, I'm a mom
- 33:10of two and I tell my kids that... Communication
- 33:14is the key to every successful relationship.
- 33:17And I believe that to be the case, not just in
- 33:20life kind of generally, but also in the practice
- 33:22of law. And what we do while we are adversarial
- 33:26in nature, it doesn't have to be antagonistic.
- 33:28And it doesn't have to be personal on any level.
- 33:32And so making sure that you have these open lines
- 33:35of communication are truly, truly the keys to
- 33:39making sure that there is a successful mediation
- 33:41before you ever get to the day. So setting up
- 33:46consistent reminders to follow up on the status
- 33:49of data and documents. Again, in the timeline
- 33:52that was provided, it talks about setting regular
- 33:56increments for having check -ins. So checking
- 33:59in at the 90 -day mark, hey, how's the status
- 34:01of that data and document production? Do you
- 34:04think that we're on track? Because again, Since
- 34:08mediators are booking out so far into the future,
- 34:11it would be great to know, hey, listen, at 90
- 34:13days, there is no possible way I'm going to have
- 34:15that data and document information to you in
- 34:19time for this mediation. You can look at rebooking.
- 34:22You can look at rescheduling. You can look at
- 34:24all of these things. But you can't do that if
- 34:27you're not having these conversations. And I
- 34:30think that it is crucially important to have
- 34:32these conversations. at regular intervals. So
- 34:35go ahead and, again, take a look at the timeline
- 34:38and make sure that you are scheduling these things.
- 34:44Just little tickler reminders. What we also encourage
- 34:49is having support staff or junior lawyers or
- 34:54law clerks involve them in these cases and rely
- 34:59on them. It gives them great experience. It also
- 35:01helps them being trained in the profession. We
- 35:06have a couple of great law clerks, some great
- 35:08juniors. It is wonderful to have them know that
- 35:12the best way to practice is to be organized and
- 35:15to focus on communication. So involve them in
- 35:18this process. Have them be the ones following
- 35:21up for data or sitting in on these conversations
- 35:25when you're discussing what the data means and
- 35:27what the documents are reflecting. With regard
- 35:30to your analyst, make sure that you are in communication
- 35:34about when you anticipate getting them all of
- 35:36the documents and data points. Also, if this
- 35:40is like an agro case and you've got handwritten
- 35:43time sheets, give them as much notice as possible,
- 35:47right? That they are going to have a devil of
- 35:50a time trying to get all of this into a spreadsheet
- 35:54and that they are going to need to do hand. that
- 35:58they're going to need to take handwritten records
- 36:00and put them into a form that is going to be
- 36:03usable. So again, you won't know if you're going
- 36:06to be getting handwritten time sheets or handwritten
- 36:09changes to time punches or those kinds of things
- 36:12unless you're having these communications with
- 36:14the other side. So definitely make sure that
- 36:17you are scheduling communications and communicating
- 36:20with everyone that's part of this team. That
- 36:28brings us to the step of we have our data, we've
- 36:31gotten it, and we're going to get it to our data
- 36:34analysts or in -house, whoever is going to do
- 36:36it for you. On the defense side, we would strongly
- 36:40encourage that you examine your own records.
- 36:44If you have produced a sampling, we would strongly
- 36:46encourage you to do an analysis of that sampling
- 36:49so that you can see what the violation rate that
- 36:51plaintiff is going to come to the table with.
- 36:55If you have all available data available for
- 36:59you to analyze and that comes up with a different
- 37:02violation rate, we would really encourage you
- 37:04to consider whether or not you want to share
- 37:06that with the plaintiff. Because if you come
- 37:09to mediation and you say, I know that the sampling
- 37:13has a 18 % violation rate, but I looked at all
- 37:16the data. It's actually only 6%. As plaintiffs'
- 37:20counsel, we can't take you at your word on that.
- 37:24However, if you have communicated that to me
- 37:27ahead of time, if you have told me that that's
- 37:30what's going on, if you've offered to get me
- 37:32the rest of the data ahead of time, then I'm
- 37:35able to verify that and then we can come to mediation
- 37:37again from a place of understanding and from
- 37:40a place of mutual understanding, which is going
- 37:43to save you so much time, especially with the
- 37:46mediator, because they won't be required to try
- 37:48to kind of communicate these different ideas
- 37:52to each other. So we would really encourage defendants
- 37:57to think of their information as a tool that
- 38:00could be used to kind of bring the parties together
- 38:02as opposed to something that you can use, a weapon
- 38:04that you're using against them. That brings us
- 38:09to our next point, which is that attorneys who
- 38:10attend the mediation should personally examine
- 38:13their records. While we are not saying that you
- 38:15need to do the data analysis yourself, no need
- 38:18to look through thousands of lines of Excel pay
- 38:20codes. You should look at the records because
- 38:23there are some things that you might see that
- 38:25your data analyst does not see immediately. For
- 38:28instance, rounding. You might see just by a cursory
- 38:32glance, all of these time punches are at the
- 38:35quarter hour. Or you might look at a wage statement
- 38:39and think to yourself, is there a regular rate
- 38:41issue here that perhaps your data analysts wasn't
- 38:44aware of? And so it's so important that you take
- 38:48your own look at that so you can understand what
- 38:51it looks like and so that you can see if there
- 38:53are any other issues that you want the data analysts
- 38:55to take a closer look at. Another thing that
- 38:58I would highly encouraged for both plaintiffs
- 39:01and defendants is to ask your data analyst for
- 39:04exemplars. If they're saying there's a high violation
- 39:08rate on late lunches, have them give you a handful
- 39:12of examples so that you can come to the mediation
- 39:14and tell the mediator. Here are 20 examples of
- 39:19late lunches. Here are 10 examples of regular
- 39:22rate issues. We really love to utilize a show
- 39:27as opposed to tell approach when it comes to
- 39:30mediations. Show the mediators the violations
- 39:32as opposed to just telling them it'll have so
- 39:35much more impact and buy you so much more credibility
- 39:38to be able to do something like that. A huge
- 39:42part of credibility is going to be looking at
- 39:44the data analysts findings yourself. And this
- 39:48should go without saying, but understanding them.
- 39:51You want to understand every single line on their
- 39:55finding sheet. You want to know what any of the
- 39:59underlying assumptions are going to be in that
- 40:01analysis. Did they assume that an alternative
- 40:03work week? applies. Did they assume that what
- 40:07is the violation rate they assumed on the rest
- 40:09periods? Did they assume that meal period waivers
- 40:16were valid? These are all things that you want
- 40:19to really understand so that when you are at
- 40:22mediation and advocating for your client, you
- 40:25can say things with confidence towards the mediator
- 40:28because particularly with class and Paga, when
- 40:31we're looking at time records, we're relying
- 40:33so much on these violation rates and these numbers.
- 40:36You truly need to understand what those numbers
- 40:40mean and how they were determined. I think that
- 40:47that's a great point. You have to obviously know
- 40:50what each of the analyst's lines mean. If you
- 40:54have questions, book some time with them, spend
- 40:56some time and invest in that. With regard to
- 41:00the first item that Daniel was talking about,
- 41:02with regard to a sampling, so oftentimes, we
- 41:05are able to utilize on both sides a sampling
- 41:08of data and document production. Our mediation
- 41:11letter indicates that we are willing to oftentimes
- 41:14work with a sampling. If however, from the defense
- 41:19perspective, you produce let's say a 33 percent
- 41:21sample, but you are also going to do an analysis
- 41:24of 100 percent of the data, I think that you're
- 41:26setting up a situation where you may have to
- 41:31turn over all of that information, because the
- 41:34entire point of mediation is exploring whether
- 41:36or not an appropriate and a resolution can be
- 41:40reached, right? And so if you are finding, in
- 41:44using Danielle's example, that the sampling indicates
- 41:48a 17 % violation rate on meal periods, but If
- 41:53you are looking at 100 % of the data, it's only
- 41:55a 6 % sample. That indicates that there's a problem
- 41:58with the sampling. And all of class settlements
- 42:04need to be approved by the court. The PAGA is
- 42:07going to have a little bit more flexibility,
- 42:09depending on what county you're in. Sometimes
- 42:11it can be done by stipulation, like in San Diego.
- 42:14But if you are finding that there's a problem
- 42:16with the data, you have to communicate that.
- 42:19And you have to be on the same page If there's
- 42:23a 1 % or 2 % difference, that's likely not going
- 42:26to be statistically significant. But again, have
- 42:28that conversation with your data analyst as well.
- 42:32Because if you are finding that there is a statistically,
- 42:34statistically significant, sorry, it's a tongue
- 42:38twister, difference in what 100 % of the data
- 42:42reveals versus what the sampling is that you've
- 42:45exchanged with plaintiff's counsel, you're going
- 42:48to have to explain that. and you're going to
- 42:50have to account for that in order to make sure
- 42:53that the court is 100 percent informed as to
- 42:56why this is an appropriate settlement value for
- 42:59the case. Next slide, please. Getting declarations.
- 43:06I think that what I'm about to say may be a little
- 43:10bit controversial, but I would encourage both
- 43:14sides to either agree to getting declarations,
- 43:18or not getting declarations. And regardless,
- 43:22you need to speak with people. You need to have
- 43:25this conversation. That is where, as a plaintiff's
- 43:28attorney, your best asset is your client. And
- 43:32especially if your client has a lot of phone
- 43:35numbers, a lot of colleagues that they used to
- 43:38work with, make those phone calls. Again, use
- 43:41those law clerks and junior lawyers to get experience.
- 43:44Have them talking to these people. Have them
- 43:47doing interviews. sit in on a couple of them
- 43:50so that they can understand, one, that you are
- 43:53there supporting them, and that is certainly
- 43:56of utmost importance, but also that you can ask
- 43:59some follow -up questions and give them a little
- 44:01bit of encouragement to do that and to explore
- 44:05a little bit more. Because certainly when a witness
- 44:08tells you something, there are follow -up questions
- 44:10that need to be asked. So the training on asking
- 44:13those follow -up questions is totally valuable
- 44:17and necessary for what it is that we do. So in
- 44:22that regard, I think that you should work on
- 44:24preparing a script and an outline for these kinds
- 44:26of calls. And again, if you have law clerks or
- 44:30junior lawyers, rely on them. Have them making
- 44:33these phone calls. Oftentimes, particularly in
- 44:37the class and Paga sense, and especially in agro
- 44:39cases, we're talking about people who are not
- 44:44necessarily English speakers. So make sure that
- 44:46you are engaging someone who does speak their
- 44:49language, literally, figuratively, all of the
- 44:51things so that they can feel as comfortable speaking
- 44:54with you as possible. And with regard to the
- 44:57declarations, if you are obtaining declarations
- 45:00on either side of the V, I encourage you, again,
- 45:04maybe controversial, But to exchange those, I
- 45:07know that sometimes on the plaintiff's side,
- 45:09we have declarants who don't want to have their
- 45:12names used at the time of mediation. And that's
- 45:15fine. You can scrub them. You can scrub them
- 45:17for identifying information. So job titles, names
- 45:20clearly, shifts sometimes is an identifier. So
- 45:25you can scrub those things. But what is important?
- 45:28is that you communicate to the other side, yes,
- 45:30this is not just happening with my one, two,
- 45:32three plaintiffs that are named in this case.
- 45:35This is happening on a broader scale. And the
- 45:37implication of that goes to, if the case doesn't
- 45:41settle, it goes to class certification issues,
- 45:44typicality, commonality, numerosity, all of those
- 45:46kinds of things. So just consider maybe exchanging
- 45:53some of those declarations. At minimum, share
- 45:55them with your mediator. On the defense side,
- 45:59if you are obtaining declarations, I think that
- 46:02what is important is sending, again, sending
- 46:04them to the plaintiff's side. And I certainly
- 46:06understand that you don't necessarily want their
- 46:08names disclosed, but what is important is how
- 46:11it is that they are experiencing or not experiencing
- 46:15these kinds of violations so that we have that
- 46:17information and we can value our case appropriately
- 46:19as well. Absolutely. And the next slide, please.
- 46:26So this all leads, again, to this on the timeline.
- 46:32We're at roughly two weeks prior to mediation.
- 46:36So ideally, in an ideal situation, you will have
- 46:39already gotten all of your documents to your
- 46:41analyst. You will have gotten your data points
- 46:43to your analyst. You will have gotten your beautiful
- 46:45model. Sometimes they're color -coded. I love
- 46:48that model back from your analyst. When you do
- 46:53that, you have to have sufficient time to ask
- 46:56your analyst, hey, what about this? Or did you
- 46:59consider this? And what is it that you're finding?
- 47:02And as Danielle mentioned, you will have your
- 47:04examples. You will have your listed sections
- 47:08that you could screenshot and you could share
- 47:10with the other side. These are the violation
- 47:13rates. And if you're on the defense side, you
- 47:15will have all of your pieces where you say penalties
- 47:19were paid. Sometimes there are more penalties
- 47:22paid than there were violations on the records.
- 47:25So if you have that, share that. So this, again,
- 47:28takes us to about two weeks before mediation.
- 47:30And when I'm encouraging you to have open and
- 47:33frank communication in a call, oftentimes I think
- 47:38the best thing to do that is face -to -face,
- 47:40right? Set a Zoom or a Teams where you are having
- 47:43this conversation across the table from the other
- 47:46side. and have this conversation about what the
- 47:50data is, what it reveals, and what it means.
- 47:53This is laying the groundwork for these important
- 47:57relationships with the defense counsel, with
- 47:59the plaintiff's counsel. We have had some mediations
- 48:03recently where both sides have gotten frustrated
- 48:06with the mediator. the parties want to have conversations
- 48:12with each other. And it yields great results
- 48:15because we have invested this time and effort
- 48:19and open communication with the other side. And
- 48:22I think that there is there's something truly
- 48:26valuable for your clients, for the defendants,
- 48:29for the plaintiffs, for everyone in having these
- 48:31open and often conversations. So. During this
- 48:36pre -mediation call, again, you're investing
- 48:38in the relationship. You are also giving information
- 48:40about your firm. You are talking about what your
- 48:43resources are, talking about what your strategies
- 48:46potentially might be if the case doesn't resolve,
- 48:49and letting them know that if you are, for example,
- 48:53a solo or a very small firm, that you handle
- 48:57a small amount of cases. And you are prepared
- 49:00to take all of them through certification and
- 49:03continue this litigation process if the other
- 49:06side doesn't want to come to a resolution. And
- 49:09that's fine, right? Everyone should be approaching
- 49:13mediation with a plan B, a plan C, a plan D,
- 49:17and be willing to roll with the punches. That's
- 49:21certainly something, as a litigator, that we
- 49:24need to do very well. Also, during this call
- 49:27with the defense counsel, plaintiff's counsel,
- 49:29make sure that you're asking questions and say
- 49:32things like, hey, I noticed that there's a 75
- 49:36% violation rate on these meal periods or it
- 49:39looks like there's an auto deduct going on because
- 49:41I'm not seeing time entries for these meal periods
- 49:44that were backed out. Can you explain that to
- 49:46me? What does that actually mean? What are you
- 49:49seeing on your side? What do your declarants
- 49:53have to say about that? Ask these questions.
- 49:56Your mediator is going to ask them. So why not
- 49:58have this conversation with the other side in
- 50:01advance of mediation? Also, setting expectations
- 50:05about what the settlement value is. So if you
- 50:08have a case where there's a 2 % meal period violation
- 50:11rate, or it's Paga only and there are more premiums
- 50:15paid than there were violations on this sampling,
- 50:18you can talk about what an appropriate value
- 50:22might be. You can say, listen, I understand that
- 50:25there are mitigating factors here because the
- 50:28facts, your client's pretty clean. I get it.
- 50:31That's a thing. But here's my counter to that.
- 50:36And that goes back to the beginning of our presentation
- 50:38when Danielle was talking about making sure that
- 50:40you are the factual expert in every aspect of
- 50:44your case. You need to be prepared to say, but
- 50:48Sure, you've paid these violations, but what
- 50:52about rest periods? There isn't a single rest
- 50:54period premium that was ever paid by anyone.
- 50:58You have all these shorts and there's a problem
- 51:00with your waiver or whatever it is, make sure
- 51:03that you're prepared to have those factual conversations
- 51:05because that all goes to settlement value and
- 51:08what's appropriate value for these cases. Again,
- 51:13at this two -week mark, It's a great time to
- 51:16raise again whether there is a financial wherewithal
- 51:20issue because no one wants to book a mediation,
- 51:23go through this process and spend all this time
- 51:26and money engaging an analyst and all these kinds
- 51:28of things to only find out that the defendant
- 51:31is going bankrupt. You don't want to hear that
- 51:35as a defense lawyer because you're not going
- 51:36to get paid. We don't want to hear that because
- 51:38the the. aggrieved employees and putative class
- 51:41members are not going to get appropriate value
- 51:44for their claims. And it will potentially be
- 51:47a large waste of everyone's time and money and
- 51:49resources. And no one wants that. So again, from
- 51:53the defense perspective, if you have information
- 51:56about financial ability to pay, make sure that
- 51:59you're raising that early and often. And plaintiff's
- 52:01side, don't be afraid to ask. You have to have
- 52:04these difficult conversations, because if you
- 52:07won't, no one will. And I think with that, we
- 52:10can go to the next slide, please. Okay. So we
- 52:15have all of our information. We've talked to
- 52:18defense counsel. We understand their point of
- 52:20view. And now we are preparing our mediation
- 52:22brief. You know, the first thing that I would
- 52:25ask you to consider is who is your mediator?
- 52:28You know, is it someone who does wage and hour
- 52:30class actions every day, five times a week? You
- 52:33probably don't need to put that much case law
- 52:35in. You could probably just rely on the facts
- 52:38of your case. Whereas if your mediator is a retired
- 52:42judge, maybe fresh off the bench, they probably
- 52:45want to see some case law. Maybe they want to
- 52:49see that you have an understanding of what the
- 52:51underlying case law is going to be before they
- 52:54get all of the facts thrown at them. So I think
- 52:57it really harkens back to having. relationships
- 53:00with these mediators and building upon how you
- 53:04know they operate. You want to write your brief
- 53:06for them. You want to write your brief for your
- 53:09audience. Some of the more practical tips that
- 53:12we would encourage you to consider is a highlights
- 53:16table. On our first page of our mediation brief,
- 53:20we put a highlights table. Our three or four
- 53:23best claims, we put our violation rates in there.
- 53:26It really gives the mediator that immediate understanding
- 53:31of how strong your case is and what you have
- 53:34to back it up. We truly do get complimented on
- 53:40this highlights table from various mediators.
- 53:44Really often, they love to have this information
- 53:46right at their fingertips. We would really encourage
- 53:49in the preparation of your brief for you to think
- 53:51about what your strong -list claims are and then
- 53:54why not put them front and center for the mediator
- 53:56to see immediately. Another practical tip would
- 54:00be to utilize the SNP tool. You know, this concept
- 54:05of show the mediator what's going on. Don't just
- 54:08tell them. So if we see that there is a problematic
- 54:12policy, if we have one of those exemplars for
- 54:15a late meal period with no corresponding premium,
- 54:19then we drop that directly into our brief. No
- 54:23need for the mediator to flip through and look
- 54:25at an exhibit. Or in this day and age, they have
- 54:27to click the arrow button to try to get to the
- 54:30exhibit on their PDF on their computer. No, it's
- 54:33right there. in the brief for them so that it
- 54:36catches their attention more. It allows them
- 54:38to really understand and see how strong that
- 54:42claim is because you're willing to show them
- 54:45the evidence of that claim upfront and immediately.
- 54:48And then I think I'm going to compete with Barbara
- 54:51for the least popular thing or controversial
- 54:53thing that anyone has saying. I would really
- 54:57strongly encourage, in the preparation of your
- 54:59mediation brief, not to over -rely on templates.
- 55:04I know that we're attorneys, love a good template.
- 55:07However, a mediation brief is really your opportunity
- 55:10to tell the story of your case to the mediator.
- 55:14And every case is different. Although the underlying
- 55:17claims might be rooted in the same California
- 55:19labor code sections, the facts of rap behind
- 55:23them are completely different. What makes one
- 55:26meal period violation and one case strong? could
- 55:29be completely different from what made a meal
- 55:32period violation strong in a different case.
- 55:35So I would encourage you instead to really look
- 55:38at your mediation brief as different pieces that
- 55:41can be rearranged and stacked in a different
- 55:46way to present your case to be kind of the strongest
- 55:50that it possibly can be. And when you overly
- 55:52rely on templates, I think it also It narrows
- 55:56your viewpoint. It narrows your focus into trying
- 55:59to get this case to squeeze into the template,
- 56:02as opposed to making the mediation brief work
- 56:04for your case. If we could have the next slide,
- 56:09please. And so finally, some tactics and tools
- 56:14that may not be appropriate in every case, but
- 56:17that you might want to consider in others. One
- 56:21is a site visit. I think it obviously really
- 56:24depends on who the defendant is, what kind of
- 56:27work sites we're talking about here. But for
- 56:30a plaintiff's attorney, it could be very much
- 56:33worth it. And for a defense attorney, so easy
- 56:35for you to arrange usually. But you are able
- 56:39to answer questions with such a level of confidence
- 56:42if you've done a site visit. If there is, for
- 56:46example, a donning and doffing issue. You can
- 56:50tell the mediator, I've seen the locker room.
- 56:53I know, you know, how it works. I've seen that
- 56:56it does actually take a good five minutes to
- 56:59get from the locker room to where you have to
- 57:01clock in. You know, if there, and this might
- 57:04be a little... but perhaps not relevant anymore.
- 57:07But if they're still doing temperature checks
- 57:09due to COVID, you know, try to get there in the
- 57:11morning. See how long it actually takes. Do people
- 57:14truly line up for temperature checks? If you've
- 57:17seen it with your own eyes, then you can explain
- 57:19to the mediator that this off -the -clock claim,
- 57:22it's not a throwaway claim. It's a real claim.
- 57:24I've seen it with my own eyes. I've seen the
- 57:26time spent. I've seen... You know, the people,
- 57:29the workers, the uncompensated time, I kept my
- 57:31eye on the watch. When you're able to answer
- 57:33those questions with that level of confidence,
- 57:36it really gives you so much credibility with
- 57:38the mediator. And it really puts some real weight
- 57:42behind some claims that, you know, generally
- 57:45are just purely based on testimony. Another tool
- 57:49that you might want to consider is having a third
- 57:52-party financial analysis either ordered or done.
- 57:56If you know that there is going to be some financial
- 57:59difficulty issue, it is our obligation, our duty
- 58:02to take a closer look at that. It is one of the
- 58:08things for you to consider whether or not you
- 58:10want to either order a financial analysis or
- 58:14if you have someone in house, CFO, an accountant,
- 58:18CPA, you know, it's one of the additional tools
- 58:21that you could use to kind of get you to the
- 58:23mediation with all of the information that you
- 58:26need. Another thing to consider, historical settlements.
- 58:31Has this defendant settled a case like this before?
- 58:35And if so, what were the circumstances around
- 58:37it? What were the claims? What is the relevant
- 58:39time period? Have they changed their policies
- 58:43since then or have they not changed their policies
- 58:45since then? You want to understand all of those
- 58:49things. Take a look at who. opposing counsel
- 58:53was in that historical settlement. What do you
- 58:55know about that firm? Look at their docket. Was
- 58:58there any motion practice? It's so important
- 59:00for you to really understand what, especially
- 59:02from a plaintiff's perspective, what the defendant
- 59:04has gone through before they've gotten to this
- 59:07point with you. Because obviously it'll inform
- 59:10the decisions that they're gonna make at your
- 59:12mediation. If they were just at a mediation and
- 59:14they paid $4 million two years ago, that is absolutely
- 59:18relevant to you. for you to consider. And then
- 59:23another thing, quite controversial I know, Barbara
- 59:26has some opinion about pick -up -sticks agreements.
- 59:29So kind of briefly, I'll say that pick -up -sticks
- 59:33agreements, you know, I think a lot of defendants
- 59:36might hear the siren call, you know, think about
- 59:39it. But for most class actions, I think it's
- 59:43really quite difficult to get enough pick -up
- 59:45-sticks agreements to make a dent and to really
- 59:49affect the outcome of the case. Another thing
- 59:53would be that the way that pick -up -sticks agreements
- 59:56are rolled out, you should expect if you're a
- 59:59defense counsel and you're rolling those out,
- 1:00:01that plaintiff's counsel is going to see a copy
- 1:00:03of it. They're going to see a copy of any accompanying
- 1:00:06letter of the release agreement. If they are
- 1:00:10able to invalidate it, you bet they're going
- 1:00:13to try. If you're considering doing something
- 1:00:18like that from a defense perspective, I think
- 1:00:20you really need to be careful and really consider
- 1:00:22what the risks are, the risk that your client
- 1:00:25is going to pay out some of these pick up six
- 1:00:27agreements and that perhaps the plaintiff could
- 1:00:30get them invalidated or that in making sure that
- 1:00:33people are making an informed decision. Did you
- 1:00:36have anything to add about the pick up six agreements?
- 1:00:41I've had, again, a lot of conversations with
- 1:00:44defense counsel who seem to share that sentiment
- 1:00:47that it is oftentimes not worth, the juice isn't
- 1:00:51worth the squeeze with regard to pick up sticks
- 1:00:53agreements because you might be able to save
- 1:00:5610%, 20 % of a potential class, but at what cost?
- 1:01:03Because you're still going to have the remaining
- 1:01:05claims and you're still going to have to litigate
- 1:01:07the case. it just doesn't seem that it makes
- 1:01:10a lot of financial sense for defendants. And
- 1:01:16that is one thing additionally that I wanted
- 1:01:18to flag that we put into our mediation letter
- 1:01:20is that we have, again, open communication with
- 1:01:23the other side. And we say, what we are going
- 1:01:25to want from you is an agreement that your client
- 1:01:28will not engage in a Pick Up Sticks campaign
- 1:01:30until at least 30 or 60 days or whatever it is
- 1:01:33after mediation. Because so many of these mediations
- 1:01:35are also going to proposals, and they need time
- 1:01:38to be considered. So that's why we give ourselves
- 1:01:42a little bit of additional time, because oftentimes
- 1:01:44these cases get settled later. And the only other
- 1:01:50thing that I wanted to flag was with regard to
- 1:01:52the prior slide with preparing the mediation
- 1:01:54brief. I'm so encouraged and so uplifted to see
- 1:01:57so many mediators in attendance today. And so
- 1:02:01thank you so much for being here. And we want
- 1:02:04to give them the tools that they need in order
- 1:02:08to have both sides be successful. They are working
- 1:02:14very, very hard. And they need the ammunition
- 1:02:17from both sides. So if you are a defense attorney,
- 1:02:22you absolutely need to... to have the information
- 1:02:27about violation rates and how many penalties
- 1:02:30were paid and things like that. I do apologize
- 1:02:34that we are two minutes over and I see that we
- 1:02:35have one question in the question and answer
- 1:02:38from Judge Kahn. Thank you so much, Your Honor.
- 1:02:41The question is, are other Paga class cases pending
- 1:02:45or may have been settled? Problem of reverse
- 1:02:48auctions when more than one case are pending.
- 1:02:52Talking about Torrieta. I think that that is
- 1:02:57a little bit of a longer answer than potentially
- 1:03:01that we have time for. However, I think that
- 1:03:04reverse auctions are certainly a problem for
- 1:03:08the industry. The problem overall is solved with
- 1:03:14open and honest and frank communication with
- 1:03:16the other side. So thank you, Your Honor, for
- 1:03:19bringing that full circle back. Exactly what
- 1:03:22I was going to say. I was going to say that while
- 1:03:24we don't have a magic solution to, you know,
- 1:03:28top filing or reverse auctions. One of the strongest
- 1:03:31tools against that is truly just having open
- 1:03:34communication, not just with defense counsel,
- 1:03:36but once you've found out that there is another
- 1:03:38case, let's reach out. Let's talk to other people
- 1:03:42of our community to see what we know about this
- 1:03:44firm. Do we already have a relationship with
- 1:03:46them? And all of those things are going to inform
- 1:03:49how you can meaningfully make a decision to move
- 1:03:52forward and to make sure that your case doesn't
- 1:03:54get derailed by someone else. And with that,
- 1:04:00I think that brings us to the end of our presentation.
- 1:04:03Thank you so much for everyone. There is a link.
- 1:04:06It's in the chat. To the materials. Thank you.
- 1:04:13Thank you so much for attending. We truly appreciate
- 1:04:17your attention and your last hour. Absolutely.
- 1:04:20Thank you so much. You may be eligible for CLE
- 1:04:22credit in your state. Visit bhba .org slash podcasts
- 1:04:26for more information. you