Latest / Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning / Kyle Orton: Muslims before Islam
Transcript
- 0:00SPEAKER_01: This podcast is brought to you by the Albany Public Library Main Branch and
- 0:03SPEAKER_01: the generosity of listeners like you.
- 0:09SPEAKER_01: What is a podcast?
- 0:16SPEAKER_01: God, Daddy, these people talk as much as you do.
- 0:26SPEAKER_01: Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning.
- 0:29SPEAKER_02: Hey everybody,
- 0:29SPEAKER_02: this is Razib Khan with the Unsupervised Learning Podcast,
- 0:32SPEAKER_02: and I am here today with Kyle Orton,
- 0:35SPEAKER_02: who is a fellow Substacker and quite active on social media.
- 0:40SPEAKER_02: Kyle, can you introduce yourself?
- 0:42SPEAKER_00: Sure, thanks for having me.
- 0:44SPEAKER_00: Basically,
- 0:44SPEAKER_00: my day job is a security analyst,
- 0:46SPEAKER_00: so I focus mostly on terrorism,
- 0:48SPEAKER_00: particularly in the Middle East, sometimes on domestic stuff, but jihadism.
- 0:53SPEAKER_00: I have done a lot of stuff on the PKK, which is this Kurdish group in Turkey.
- 0:59SPEAKER_00: So yeah, that's basically it.
- 1:01SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I think I originally heard about you or saw your content related a lot to Syria.
- 1:07SPEAKER_02: Yes, definitely.
- 1:08SPEAKER_02: I've still thought of that.
- 1:10SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:11SPEAKER_02: Well, maybe we can talk about that later.
- 1:12SPEAKER_02: But first of all,
- 1:13SPEAKER_02: I actually, so,
- 1:16SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:16SPEAKER_02: I think like I talked to you about doing a podcast a while ago and sometimes like,
- 1:20SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:20SPEAKER_02: especially with Twitter DMs and, you know, Elon's updates, like things get lost.
- 1:25SPEAKER_02: Let's just put it that way.
- 1:26SPEAKER_02: I do.
- 1:27SPEAKER_02: And so it got lost.
- 1:28SPEAKER_02: And then I saw something that just I realized.
- 1:30SPEAKER_02: I reposted it.
- 1:31SPEAKER_02: It was very interesting to me.
- 1:33SPEAKER_02: The sojourn of Arkolf, an eyewitness to early Islamic Jerusalem.
- 1:39SPEAKER_02: Frank Bishop shed some light on a historical dark age.
- 1:43SPEAKER_02: You posted this pretty recently, August 18th.
- 1:46SPEAKER_02: And so just in the context of some other posts you have had about the early history
- 1:55SPEAKER_02: of Islam and,
- 1:56SPEAKER_02: you know, talking about where revisionists took us and where we are today.
- 2:00SPEAKER_02: And this is something that a lot of people don't know about and it surprises them,
- 2:06SPEAKER_02: even people who are not Muslim themselves.
- 2:09SPEAKER_02: And so the way I'm going to set it up really is there's kind of
- 2:12SPEAKER_02: a traditional Islamic narrative of The origins of early Islam,
- 2:17SPEAKER_02: particularly of the first century,
- 2:19SPEAKER_02: particularly,
- 2:20SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:20SPEAKER_02: let's say before like the 690s and,
- 2:23SPEAKER_02: you know, we can maybe get into why the 690s are so important, you know, around 690.
- 2:27SPEAKER_02: But the first great dynasty,
- 2:29SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:30SPEAKER_02: hereditary The Umayyads in particular, there's a lot of confusion around them.
- 2:35SPEAKER_02: And, you know, we don't have that many early non-Islamic sources.
- 2:38SPEAKER_02: We have some, but we don't have that many early ones.
- 2:39SPEAKER_02: But this is a journey of someone from,
- 2:42SPEAKER_02: obviously,
- 2:43SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:43SPEAKER_02: the Merovingian domains of the Franks,
- 2:45SPEAKER_02: like modern-day France, probably, to Jerusalem during this early period.
- 2:51SPEAKER_02: Talk about why this is interesting and contextualize it in terms of what else we know.
- 2:56SPEAKER_00: Yeah, as you say, it basically is a dark age.
- 2:59SPEAKER_00: Obviously,
- 3:01SPEAKER_00: that term gets used usually when people don't like Christianity and they mean
- 3:05SPEAKER_00: the Middle Ages, basically.
- 3:07SPEAKER_00: But there are periods where we just don't know very much.
- 3:09SPEAKER_00: So Britain after the Roman collapse is one period from like 410 to 597.
- 3:14SPEAKER_00: We just basically don't know.
- 3:15SPEAKER_00: Historians have done great work often in kind of trying to reconstruct it,
- 3:19SPEAKER_00: but you're working from shreds of shreds of evidence and sometimes trying to pair it
- 3:23SPEAKER_00: with archaeology and things to get anywhere.
- 3:27SPEAKER_00: And the same is true basically of the first two centuries of Islam,
- 3:30SPEAKER_00: or what we now call Islam, so between the 630s roughly and about 800 AD.
- 3:37SPEAKER_00: And so you do have these Christian sources sometimes, so there are nearby sources.
- 3:41SPEAKER_00: There's one actually from during the invasion of whatever we want to call it,
- 3:45SPEAKER_00: Canaan, the land of Israel, former Mandate Palestine.
- 3:48SPEAKER_00: There is a source that comments on that invasion.
- 3:51SPEAKER_00: There are sources from near the time,
- 3:53SPEAKER_00: an Armenian bishop in particular called Sabeos,
- 3:55SPEAKER_00: who's quite detailed on these things.
- 3:57SPEAKER_00: And then you have these intermittent kind of shots of light on the picture.
- 4:02SPEAKER_00: But we have the only complete picture of what happened,
- 4:05SPEAKER_00: the only complete story we have of what happened is the Muslim account,
- 4:10SPEAKER_00: which is obviously a sacred account to them.
- 4:12SPEAKER_00: It was developed from the late 8th century,
- 4:16SPEAKER_00: but the extant material we actually have is post-8, 800, almost in its entirety.
- 4:22SPEAKER_00: So obviously,
- 4:23SPEAKER_00: if you use that material,
- 4:24SPEAKER_00: it'd be like using the Gnostic Gospels or something to try and reconstruct
- 4:28SPEAKER_00: the early part of the first century in Roman Jerusalem.
- 4:32SPEAKER_00: And you can't really map history onto that.
- 4:35SPEAKER_00: So you have to try and take these sources in their way and patch them together.
- 4:39SPEAKER_00: Obviously,
- 4:40SPEAKER_00: the difficulty is these Christian sources in particular don't know things
- 4:45SPEAKER_00: about what's happening either.
- 4:46SPEAKER_00: So in Christendom,
- 4:47SPEAKER_00: It took until the early modern period really to realize
- 4:50SPEAKER_00: that Islam is something completely separate.
- 4:51SPEAKER_00: Until then,
- 4:52SPEAKER_00: they either thought of it as a Jewish heresy or a Christian heresy or as paganism
- 4:57SPEAKER_00: of some kind.
- 4:57SPEAKER_00: So they're party-free as well,
- 4:59SPEAKER_00: which is why if you try and just use them, you can go astray as well.
- 5:04SPEAKER_02: Yeah, well,
- 5:05SPEAKER_02: one thing that I will say,
- 5:06SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 5:07SPEAKER_02: a lot of what we know as Islam,
- 5:12SPEAKER_02: in particular Sunni Islam,
- 5:13SPEAKER_02: which is,
- 5:13SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 5:14SPEAKER_02: probably like 85 to 90 percent of Muslims,
- 5:17SPEAKER_02: is actually something that arose,
- 5:20SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 5:20SPEAKER_02: during the second dynastic caliphate,
- 5:25SPEAKER_02: the Abbasids, after 750, in particular after 800, actually.
- 5:30SPEAKER_02: And there are features of the Islamic...
- 5:33SPEAKER_02: Practice and institutions that we take for granted,
- 5:35SPEAKER_02: like madrasas that are quite late,
- 5:37SPEAKER_02: centuries, centuries after the period we're talking about.
- 5:40SPEAKER_02: And then stuff like Hadith, the culture of Hadith, the emphasis on orthopraxy within Islam.
- 5:47SPEAKER_02: That was probably always there in some ways.
- 5:49SPEAKER_02: I mean, obviously Judaism had Halakha, the Talmud predates Islam.
- 5:53SPEAKER_02: But the compilations and whatnot, they did come later, like Bukhari and whatnot.
- 6:01SPEAKER_02: And so, you know, what was, you know, it's kind of a question here.
- 6:04SPEAKER_02: Well, I guess,
- 6:06SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 6:06SPEAKER_02: the Islamic perspective is like, well,
- 6:08SPEAKER_02: the sayings of Muhammad were,
- 6:11SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 6:11SPEAKER_02: already circulating in these early periods,
- 6:14SPEAKER_02: and so they didn't have to,
- 6:15SPEAKER_02: like, have Bukhari do the compilation and stuff like that.
- 6:17SPEAKER_02: That's the Orthodox, you know, whereas, you know, But that's not the only possibility.
- 6:23SPEAKER_02: It turns out that sometimes people – the past is not always what they reported.
- 6:29SPEAKER_02: Talk about what this Frankish bishop saw in Jerusalem and what might surprise the listener.
- 6:34SPEAKER_00: Okay.
- 6:35SPEAKER_00: I will just want to back up because I should have said in the previous answer,
- 6:37SPEAKER_00: you're exactly right about this, the development of the tradition.
- 6:40SPEAKER_00: So it's particularly the biographies of the Prophet and the military literature,
- 6:45SPEAKER_00: so the Seer and the Maghazi literature,
- 6:47SPEAKER_00: and then into the Hadith,
- 6:48SPEAKER_00: which are a major part of this,
- 6:49SPEAKER_00: which are the sayings and the example of the Prophet.
- 6:52SPEAKER_00: Obviously for Muslims,
- 6:54SPEAKER_00: it's the essence of your faith that those things are sacred
- 6:57SPEAKER_00: and there are supposedly chains of authentication.
- 7:01SPEAKER_00: So it's not the trace of back that so-and-so told so-and-so,
- 7:04SPEAKER_00: told so-and-so back to the prophet and the companions.
- 7:07SPEAKER_00: If you're a historian looking at that,
- 7:09SPEAKER_00: you can say, well,
- 7:10SPEAKER_00: some of this,
- 7:11SPEAKER_00: for instance,
- 7:11SPEAKER_00: is coming from the Jews or from Zoroastrians,
- 7:15SPEAKER_00: often who were converts,
- 7:16SPEAKER_00: because the tradition as it develops,
- 7:18SPEAKER_00: especially with the Hadith in the Abbasid period,
- 7:21SPEAKER_00: is developing in Mesopotamia,
- 7:23SPEAKER_00: in the heartlands of where the Jewish places of scholarship had been.
- 7:28SPEAKER_00: And a lot of this has been done by converted, conquered peoples.
- 7:32SPEAKER_00: And it would just be extraordinary if this was a coincidence.
- 7:35SPEAKER_00: So you have that element.
- 7:37SPEAKER_00: The issue when you try and look at this is how much of the later tradition
- 7:42SPEAKER_00: which tries to explain the Quran you allow into the picture and how much
- 7:47SPEAKER_00: of it you trust.
- 7:47SPEAKER_00: Because there is a question over the Quran itself,
- 7:49SPEAKER_00: which we can get into if you want to do separately.
- 7:51SPEAKER_00: But I think the Quran is legitimately or authentically late antique.
- 7:55SPEAKER_00: It is from the Prophet's time and probably was associated with Muhammad himself.
- 8:00SPEAKER_00: So I think you can use the Quran as a source for this early thing.
- 8:03SPEAKER_00: And the thing is,
- 8:04SPEAKER_00: if you detach the tradition from the Quran, You can see that they are different.
- 8:10SPEAKER_00: The Qur'an tells quite a different story in terms of doctrine.
- 8:14SPEAKER_00: It doesn't really tell stories,
- 8:17SPEAKER_00: but to the extent you can get anything from it, you get a different picture.
- 8:21SPEAKER_00: And what you get from the Qur'an is a blended monotheism of Jewish and Christian elements.
- 8:29SPEAKER_00: And it's basically as if the parting of the ways never happened.
- 8:33SPEAKER_00: It's as if it's one tapestry of kind of, it's one religious element.
- 8:39SPEAKER_00: And actually, I mean,
- 8:41SPEAKER_00: in the Quran,
- 8:42SPEAKER_00: it's basically calling Christians and Jews back
- 8:44SPEAKER_00: to this supposedly primordial Abrahamic faith.
- 8:47SPEAKER_00: It's not portraying itself as a new thing and calling on them to convert.
- 8:50SPEAKER_00: It's calling to return.
- 8:51SPEAKER_00: And when it criticizes Christians and Jews doctrinally,
- 8:55SPEAKER_00: it's often at the exact points where they diverge.
- 8:57SPEAKER_00: So for instance, over Jesus.
- 8:59SPEAKER_00: So the Jews are criticized for not accepting him as prophet.
- 9:02SPEAKER_00: And the Christians are criticized for saying he's divine.
- 9:05SPEAKER_00: And it said, like, you're both mistaken.
- 9:06SPEAKER_00: Just come back to our way,
- 9:07SPEAKER_00: which is the correct and original way that you all did believe
- 9:10SPEAKER_00: before you corrupted your text.
- 9:13SPEAKER_00: So if in that context,
- 9:15SPEAKER_00: and the Arabs have a special place in the biblical landscape because they descend
- 9:20SPEAKER_00: from Abraham through his son Ishmael,
- 9:22SPEAKER_00: which is why the people who encounter them, including Arkul, call them Ishmaelites.
- 9:26SPEAKER_00: And that's the kind of,
- 9:27SPEAKER_00: that's the creed you're working with,
- 9:29SPEAKER_00: I think,
- 9:29SPEAKER_00: until you get to the later point where it starts turning
- 9:32SPEAKER_00: into something we can recognize as Islam.
- 9:35SPEAKER_00: So when Arkul turns up in Jerusalem in 618s,
- 9:38SPEAKER_00: What he finds is a picture that looks, I mean,
- 9:41SPEAKER_00: the tradition says that Muslims start stamping the landscape immediately
- 9:45SPEAKER_00: with Islamic architecture and this kind of thing.
- 9:48SPEAKER_00: He finds it basically looks exactly the same as it had.
- 9:50SPEAKER_00: I mean, if he didn't know better,
- 9:52SPEAKER_00: he would think the Roman Byzantine Christians were still ruling in Jerusalem.
- 9:57SPEAKER_00: The money is still, some of it's still stamped with crosses.
- 10:00SPEAKER_00: His travel documents are in Greek.
- 10:03SPEAKER_00: He goes around all the holy sites, which are remarkably well upkept.
- 10:07SPEAKER_00: And then obviously the thing that has interested people most
- 10:10SPEAKER_00: about his account is he goes to the Temple Mount.
- 10:12SPEAKER_00: And on it,
- 10:13SPEAKER_00: there is large kind of wooden structure,
- 10:15SPEAKER_00: which he's slightly sniffy about and sort of describes it as a bit jerry-rigged
- 10:19SPEAKER_00: and sort of not very highly developed.
- 10:21SPEAKER_00: But he's also clearly quite impressed by it because it's said to be able to hold 3,000 people.
- 10:26SPEAKER_00: And so we don't really know what this is.
- 10:29SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 10:30SPEAKER_00: you could call it the first mosque in the sense that the mosque comes from Masjid,
- 10:33SPEAKER_00: which just means a place of prostration.
- 10:35SPEAKER_00: And presumably, I mean, they were praying at it.
- 10:37SPEAKER_00: So in that sense, it was.
- 10:39SPEAKER_00: But what they were praying to and for and about is open to interpretation.
- 10:47SPEAKER_02: Yeah, it would be, you know...
- 10:49SPEAKER_02: I think,
- 10:49SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 10:50SPEAKER_02: the implication here,
- 10:51SPEAKER_02: or not the implication, I think it's pretty clear in your post.
- 10:55SPEAKER_02: If we walked around this Jerusalem,
- 11:00SPEAKER_02: it would not feel quite like an Islamic city with,
- 11:06SPEAKER_02: you know, The architecture and the practices that we identify with modern Islam.
- 11:15SPEAKER_02: And, you know, this is not shocking.
- 11:16SPEAKER_02: I know I think—I forget which book I read this in.
- 11:20SPEAKER_02: Actually, it might be Hugh Kennedy, but maybe not.
- 11:23SPEAKER_02: But, you know,
- 11:23SPEAKER_02: from— The Umayyad,
- 11:27SPEAKER_02: the Arabs,
- 11:28SPEAKER_02: the Muslims,
- 11:28SPEAKER_02: you would call them Muslims today,
- 11:30SPEAKER_02: but they worshipped in the great church of Damascus until about like 700 in
- 11:37SPEAKER_02: a separate alcove.
- 11:38SPEAKER_02: So they were clearly distinct in some way.
- 11:41SPEAKER_02: But they didn't have their own house of worship for, I mean, like 65 years?
- 11:48SPEAKER_02: That's almost three generations?
- 11:52SPEAKER_02: That would be really surprising today.
- 11:55SPEAKER_00: It is.
- 11:55SPEAKER_00: And it's also interesting that Muhammad basically goes missing from the records.
- 12:00SPEAKER_00: He's not on official inscriptions.
- 12:01SPEAKER_00: He's not in official documents.
- 12:03SPEAKER_00: He's not on official coins or anything like this.
- 12:06SPEAKER_00: He gets revived basically in the Civil War in the 680s, later in the 680s.
- 12:12SPEAKER_00: But yes, I mean,
- 12:13SPEAKER_00: the elements that we,
- 12:14SPEAKER_00: and the Quran itself is not really very much in evidence in this period.
- 12:19SPEAKER_00: And it's, yeah,
- 12:21SPEAKER_00: it's mysterious and it's difficult to pin down and you can sort of see an outline
- 12:26SPEAKER_00: where things are, but trying to get the specifics is really difficult.
- 12:31SPEAKER_02: Yeah, so my understanding is there were some revisionists.
- 12:35SPEAKER_02: There's a whole scholarship that we're probably going to gloss over
- 12:38SPEAKER_02: because it's too deep to address in a podcast.
- 12:42SPEAKER_02: But basically,
- 12:42SPEAKER_02: there's a whole revisionist school with Patricia Crone and Wade Wright,
- 12:47SPEAKER_02: I think, that arose.
- 12:49SPEAKER_02: And the thing with a lot of these revisionists is they go towards extreme skepticism.
- 12:56SPEAKER_02: Which, you know,
- 12:56SPEAKER_02: within Christianity,
- 12:57SPEAKER_02: for example,
- 12:58SPEAKER_02: you know, the whole idea, well, the Jews didn't even exist at a really early date.
- 13:03SPEAKER_02: And then later you find, like,
- 13:04SPEAKER_02: you find coins or inscriptions,
- 13:06SPEAKER_02: you know, clearly to someone named King
- 13:08SPEAKER_00: David at approximately the right time.
- 13:09SPEAKER_02: So I think the revisionism and modernism,
- 13:13SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 13:14SPEAKER_02: which began earlier in Christianity in the 19th century,
- 13:16SPEAKER_02: and also expanded with Israel Finkelstein within Judaism,
- 13:20SPEAKER_02: within the Jewish tradition, it I think it clearly went a little too far.
- 13:24SPEAKER_02: I think archaeology and modern philology is indicating that actually,
- 13:30SPEAKER_02: whether you believe this is a divine revelation or not,
- 13:33SPEAKER_02: the Hebrew Bible has some deep layers within it that preserves You know,
- 13:38SPEAKER_02: some real history there that now is being validated through alternative methods,
- 13:42SPEAKER_02: alternative means.
- 13:43SPEAKER_02: And so it turns out the hyperskeptics were wrong.
- 13:46SPEAKER_02: It's not all just a myth.
- 13:47SPEAKER_02: It wasn't like created,
- 13:49SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 13:49SPEAKER_02: late in the kingdom of Judah,
- 13:52SPEAKER_02: right before the fall,
- 13:53SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 13:54SPEAKER_02: right before the Congress, whatever, all the extreme things that they were saying.
- 13:57SPEAKER_02: Okay, so with Islam,
- 13:59SPEAKER_02: obviously everything is a little bit more primitive,
- 14:02SPEAKER_02: and I think some of the revisionists went pretty extreme in terms of how late
- 14:05SPEAKER_02: the Quran was.
- 14:07SPEAKER_02: I had a podcast a couple years ago with Sean Anthony.
- 14:10SPEAKER_02: It seems like the Quran was extant actually pretty early, as early as 650 AD.
- 14:17SPEAKER_02: There are early copies.
- 14:19SPEAKER_02: And so I guess the question that I would have for you is maybe just a speculation.
- 14:23SPEAKER_02: Okay, there is a Quran.
- 14:25SPEAKER_02: It's around.
- 14:27SPEAKER_02: It's not really an evidence.
- 14:28SPEAKER_02: So, I mean, like, what's going on?
- 14:31SPEAKER_02: Was this basically an alternative tradition or a secondary tradition or
- 14:34SPEAKER_02: a minor tradition that was just glommed onto by a new faction or
- 14:40SPEAKER_02: an emergent faction,
- 14:41SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 14:42SPEAKER_02: proto what we would term like classically Muslim faction in the 680s, 690s?
- 14:47SPEAKER_02: I mean, what is your interpretation of this?
- 14:49SPEAKER_02: Because obviously for Muslim, for most Muslims, You cannot have Islam without the Quran.
- 14:55SPEAKER_02: That is what Islam really is.
- 14:58SPEAKER_00: The recitation...