Latest / MetroNews Talkline / Talkline LIVE From the WV Capitol Rotunda for Wednesday, January 24, 2024
Transcript
- 0:00Hmmm, you're up. Good morning. Welcome to talk Line on the Metro
- 0:14News Radio Network, broadcasting live from the aa ARP broadcast location at the West
- 0:19Virginia State Capital. The in COVID students the ENCOD Insurance studios have been moved
- 0:23here and we are underway. Do not attempt to change the station. You
- 0:29are surrounded. We gave a radio turned off from the studios of w v
- 0:39RC Media and the Metro News Radio Network. The voice of West Virginia comes
- 0:44the most powerful radio show in West Virginia. This is Metro News Talk Live
- 0:50with Activated. So it's network from Charles Stared by you, Hoppy. You're
- 0:59on Metro News Talk Line with Hoppy kerchival is brought to you by Incovia Insurance,
- 1:04encircling you with coverage to protect what you care about most. Visiting covid
- 1:10dot com to learn more. Good morning, Welcome to talk Line on Metro
- 1:14News, broadcasting from the upper rotunda of the West Virginia State Capital. We
- 1:18are at the AARP broadcast location. The Incovia Insurance studios have been moved to
- 1:25the state capital for the legislative session. A man, what a public hearing
- 1:30we had this morning on a particular House bill that aims to remove schools,
- 1:38museums, and public libraries from the exemption which protects these types of entities from
- 1:42prosecution for the distribution and display two minors of obscene matter. What that has
- 1:48to do with is really empowering prosecution of librarians, school teachers, etc.
- 1:57For posting or having in their libraries materials that are deemed obscene. And an
- 2:06incredible public hearing this morning never heard anything like it. We're going to talk
- 2:07more about that in just a few minutes. But first up, of course,
- 2:10the big story out of New Hampshire, big win for Donald Trump.
- 2:14Chris Stywalt there and joins us on Metro News talk line. Come on it,
- 2:17Chris, how are you living the dream? My friend? Greetings from
- 2:22a snowbound in New Hampshire. I hope you're able to hope your plane is
- 2:25able to get out of New Hampshire today. But what's your takeaway from last
- 2:29night? Well? I would say Donald Trump did what he needed to do,
- 2:36but Nikki Haley pretty well did what she needed to do as well.
- 2:39When you look at how they performed Donald Trump, if you taken independently,
- 2:46they both basically barely met the threshold that they needed and what I think a
- 2:54lot of Republicans had hoped would be a decisive end to the nominated in process
- 3:01sort of hangs at the margin. Right. If the pre election polls had
- 3:08been predicted and Trump had obliterated Nicky Haley and won by a similar margin that
- 3:15he had in Iowa, then you we'd be having a discussion about, Okay,
- 3:22it's onto the deepstakes, it's over, and how soon until Nicky Haley
- 3:25gets out. On the other hand, if Nicky Haley would have beaten Donald
- 3:30Trump or gotten within just a couple of points, we'd say, whoa Nelly,
- 3:34Like something's really happening here. But instead we are we are not rewarded
- 3:38with we got a blurry picture out of New Hampshire, which is to say,
- 3:46Donald Trump is in about as good a position as Bob Dole or Mitt
- 3:53Romney or others who came out of New Hampshire in lopsided contests and then go
- 4:00on into the rest of the country. On the other hand, Nicky Haley
- 4:06is in a better position than previous pursuers of front runners. Right, So
- 4:12we think about Rick Santorum, or we think about Mike Huckabee. We think
- 4:15about others who've gave chase in the past, even John McCain. Nicky Haley
- 4:21has a there's no competition. Ron defant has already dropped out, and she
- 4:28has supply lines in the sense that donors she can generate enough money that she
- 4:34can stay out. And the third advantage that she has over prior pursuers is
- 4:42she's got a month. So we've never had this before. The Iowa republic
- 4:46or the Nevada Republican Party is a mess, and they've ended up with a
- 4:50primary and a caucus, and Haley's in the primary but not the caucus,
- 4:56and Trump is in the caucus and not the primary. So that gives us
- 5:00a month until South Carolina. Now, the most likely scenario is that Donald
- 5:04Trump will obliterate Nicki Haley in her home state, and the argument for her
- 5:10to persist into Super Tuesday will be obliterated with that. On the other hand,
- 5:15if Nicky Haley can essentially do what she did in New Hampshire in South
- 5:19Carolina, which is harder from a demographic sense given the makeup of the Republican
- 5:27Party there versus New Hampshire, but easier in the sense that it's her home
- 5:30state, and she was a two term governor there and she knows how to
- 5:33work it. But if she could do that, then we look over the
- 5:39cliff into Super Tuesday, into Georgia, and we see that there are opportunities
- 5:45for Haley to continue to make it a race. Chris Diwald is with us,
- 5:47and I defer to you on all matters because of your political acumen.
- 5:53But what if I disagreed with you in said because I'm pretty good at stating
- 5:58the obvious and being a prisoner. The moment is that Nikki Haley staked a
- 6:01lot on New Hampshire, a lot campaign there, went everywhere, you know,
- 6:08did all the diner things, spend a lot of money, and still
- 6:12lost by eleven points and Trump got above fifty percent. And now there's a
- 6:15Nevada CAU because she's not participating in that. So that and then South Carolina,
- 6:19where the polls show that Trump has a big lead in South Carolina.
- 6:25So I see this as kind of over really, just that you're probably right
- 6:34right in the same way that it was probably over in twenty sixteen, and
- 6:40it was probably over in twenty twelve, and it was probably over in two
- 6:45thousand and eight, and it was probably over in two thousand. For Republicans,
- 6:48right, it's very hard to catch a front runner if somebody had because
- 6:54there's a strong impulse inside the party. We've talked about it before. It's
- 6:59true parties, but it's particularly true with Republicans. So you've got a third
- 7:02of the party that is gaga for Donald Trump in a sort of religious fervor.
- 7:11You have a quarter of the Republican Party that hates Donald Trump like God
- 7:15hates Sin, just hates him, and a bunch of them have made up
- 7:18their minds they won't vote for him in the general no matter what. The
- 7:23plurality remains what my friend the poster winners calls always Republicans, and the preference
- 7:30among those always Republicans is for the primaries to be over. They do not
- 7:34like internetine warfare. They do not like the party fighting with itself, which
- 7:40is why for the Huckabees and the Santra and the others, that the pendulum
- 7:47swings hard against them, and what was an interesting diversion in Iowa or New
- 7:55Hampshire becomes an intolerable division. Now where Haley is different from them, she
- 8:01has advantages and disadvantages what's your disadvantage. She doesn't have an ideological There isn't
- 8:09an ideological strain in her candidacy. Whereas the Pat Buchanans and the Huckabees and
- 8:15the Santorums, we're running send them a message. We have to let them
- 8:20know that the populous, nationalistic kind of wing of the Republican Party is demands
- 8:28to be heard. We want a slot at the convention. We want we
- 8:31want our jew So she doesn't have that because she's basically running an electability campaign.
- 8:37She's saying Donald Trump will lose the general election, I'll win it.
- 8:41She doesn't have that. On the other hand, what she does have is
- 8:46the if she can tap into it. She does have the advantage that she
- 8:54can plug in to what's left of the old mainstream Republican Party. Right.
- 9:00She can plug into those folks, the Mitch mcconnald's of the world who are
- 9:03in the past ready to absolutely kill a Rick Stain former, a Mike Cupadi
- 9:09or by the way, Donald Trump in twenty sixteen, and she does not
- 9:15have to compete for their attention. The Republican challengers in twenty sixteen, what
- 9:20was their problem? Remember the speech Mit Romney gave before the Michigan primary.
- 9:26He said, Donald Trump is a dirt bag. We hate Donald Trump.
- 9:30Okay, now what do you want us to do? Well, some of
- 9:33you should vote for Ted Cruz, others of you should vote for John Kasik,
- 9:37depending on your state. Check your local listings to see which candidate is
- 9:41best for you to support. To take Donald Trump to a brokered convention,
- 9:45which was a goofy, goofy thing to say. In this case. Basically,
- 9:50Republicans who are non Trump are going to face a difficult choice, which
- 9:56is Nikky Haley is what you say you wanted, Well you have and now
- 10:00she's in the race. Are you willing to suffer the wrath of Donald Trump?
- 10:03Which is as he said, very menacingly in New Hampshire. I don't
- 10:09get too mad. I get either. Yeah, I heard that last night.
- 10:13And it's gonna be the next month is going to be just hell on
- 10:16wheels for Nikki Haley. All right. They are gonna dump everything on her
- 10:20head. It is going to be a real nightmare. And by the way,
- 10:24all of the Republicans who are afraid of Donald Trump, I'm afraid of
- 10:26his voters are going to say, don't make me pick, don't make me
- 10:31pick. Can't this just you know, let this up ass from my lips?
- 10:35All right, I'm gonna leave it there. Chris Darwald's got to catch
- 10:37a plane. I appreciate your insights this morning. We're on this and later
- 10:39in the show. Chris Stirewald from New Hampshire. Thank you, Chris.
- 10:43Good to talk to you. Safe travels. When we come back on Metro
- 10:46News talk line. Oh my, there was an incredible public hearing this morning
- 10:50on a particular bill and the author of that particular bill, delicate Brandon Steele
- 10:56on set. Next when talk line continues from the AARP brought ask location,
- 11:00We'll be right back. West Virginia is home. It's where we work,
- 11:05live and raise our families. At the heart of our communities are West Virginia
- 11:09Hospitals and they're compassionate caregivers. From life saving treatments and emergency care to wellness
- 11:16support and screening services. We are improving your quality of life through extraordinary achievements
- 11:22and amazing results West Virginia Hospitals. Your health is the heartbeat of our communities.
- 11:30Are you worried about your cybersecurity? Are you tired of being bombarded with
- 11:33spam and phishing emails. Do you worry about your data being stolen? If
- 11:37so, you're not alone. Millions of people are victims of cyber attacks every
- 11:41year, and the problem is only getting worse. Inner City Net, as
- 11:45the region's trusted cybersecurity experts, we can help. We provide comprehensive cybersecurity solutions
- 11:52and training programs to protect your network and keep your employees safe online. Don't
- 11:56wait until it's too late. This us at City Net need help with your
- 12:01prescriptions. Tired of long wait times? Did your current pharmacy close or is
- 12:05moving? Give Fruth Pharmacy a try. We make it easy to transfer your
- 12:09prescriptions and we always welcome new patients. Fruth makes it easy to transfer.
- 12:15Call a local Fruth Pharmacy and they will handle the transferring process for you.
- 12:18We offer prescription rewards too. Give Fruth Pharmacy a call today for more details.
- 12:24Fruth makes it easy. Fruth your hometown family pharmacy. This is talk
- 12:30Line on Metro News, the voice of West Virginia. From a young age,
- 12:35Math influences our lives to create, to build from scratch. With math,
- 12:39I learned to persevere, I learned to try again. With math,
- 12:45I can move forward. I learned to identify problems in the real world around
- 12:48me and find unique solutions. With math, I succeed. With math,
- 12:54I succeed big, Confident, Take the pledge, mathe. When kids are
- 13:03small, we tend to spend most of our time saying no instead of yes.
- 13:07As our parents and grandparents' age, we sometimes say no to visits instead
- 13:11of yes. Life can be overwhelming, and sometimes it's nice to say yes
- 13:16to making memories and starting a future. By playing the West Virginia Lottery,
- 13:20you're saying yes to tomorrow's leaders and today's seniors, and furthering the beauty of
- 13:26the Mountain state. When you play, you say yes to West Virginia.
- 13:35From a young age, my passion for soccer was always greater than anything else
- 13:37I was doing. Knowing that it's a team effort to belong to something greater
- 13:41than yourself, I just love playing the game. My reason why is passion.
- 13:48West Virginia is home. It's where we work, live and raise our
- 13:54families. At the heart of our communities are West Virginia hospitals and their compassion
- 14:00caregivers from life saving treatments and emergency care to wellness support and screening services.
- 14:05We are improving your quality of life through extraordinary achievements and amazing results West Virginia
- 14:13Hospitals. Your health is the heartbeat of our communities. Ruth Pharmacy offers a
- 14:20local prescription delivery. Call your Fruth today and schedule your prescription delivery. You
- 14:24can also get items like milk, paper, towels, vitamins and more delivered
- 14:28right to your door. Ruth your hometown family Pharmacy Career. Metronews talk line
- 14:48with Hoppykerchible is brought to you by Incovia Insurance, encircling you with coverage to
- 14:52protect what you care about most. Visiting Coca dot com to learn more.
- 14:58The in COVID church studios have been moved to the ARP broadcast location here at
- 15:01the upper rotunda. So there is a house built forty six fifty four,
- 15:05and this thing is on fire right now. There's public ring about it this
- 15:09morning. And the bill would remove schools, museums, and public libraries from
- 15:16the exemption which currently protects these entities from prosecution for distribution and display to miners
- 15:24of obscene matter, which would if they displayed obscene matter which determined as obscene
- 15:28by definition and code would expose them to prosecution. The author of the bill
- 15:33is Delicate brand and Steel, Republican Raleigh County boy. You open to Canada
- 15:37Worm's brother. You know that. But I did it three years ago.
- 15:41The only reason we're talking about it now is because the bill was put on
- 15:43an agenda. Well yeah, well because it starts to move. When it
- 15:46starts to move, people start to pay attention to it. What are you
- 15:48trying to do here? Okay, So this actually came to me from some
- 15:50of my local librarians, and they'd come to me and talk to me about
- 15:56how this exception was being used kind of as to create a safe haven in
- 16:00public libraries and spaces, you know, like we're talking about in the bill,
- 16:06to display material to minors that would otherwise be unlawful. And so what
- 16:11I really look at, I think this whole conversation is getting couched in the
- 16:15wrong way. We've had a crime since the nineteen sixties or even before that,
- 16:19of displaying erotica or obscene material to minors. I mean, and that
- 16:23is the code section immediately preceding the one that my bill is dealing with,
- 16:30and we've had that as a feloning with up to five years in prison.
- 16:33Since back in the sixties, you know, you had a case that was
- 16:37a Jacoblist versus Ohio, jacob Endlist versus Ohio, in which the court,
- 16:45you know, dealt with obscene matters, and that's where the definitions of these
- 16:49crimes came about. And the test really it was the raw test that came
- 16:53from the nineteen fifties, but it said, is this a material that's of
- 17:00prurient nature? And what does that mean? As the US Supreme Court to
- 17:04find, you know, upwards to seventy years ago, what they're talking about
- 17:08there is something that has no value other than to be excessively sexual. Okay,
- 17:15So we have this crime that prevents people from displaying Eurotica to minors,
- 17:22and then we have the exceptions. And if you go through those exceptions,
- 17:23there's law enforcement exceptions, there's a psychiatrist, psychotherapists exceptions, there are media
- 17:30exceptions, there's media exceptions. And now that's because we're regulated by the fccite
- 17:34right, you know, so we have ubsidity standards that we have to meet.
- 17:37But so is this a problem? I mean, is it you said
- 17:41you talked a couple of librarians. But look, I heard at the public
- 17:42hereing this morning, I heard from librarians. The Library Association says, this
- 17:47is not an issue. We are not confronted by this. And if somebody
- 17:52delegate has an objection to a book, there's a process they can go through
- 17:57where the book could be removed. Correct well, and this is not about
- 18:02removing books. And that's how this thing got that got messed up. What
- 18:04this is about is what you're saying with this exception is if I was standing
- 18:11outside of the walls of the library and I presented this material to a miner,
- 18:15it would be a felony. By walking into the library and presenting this
- 18:18material to a minor, I'm now exempt from criminal liability. Well, that's
- 18:23what needs to be taken away. We're not saying take away your educational material,
- 18:27don't take away your artistic material. What we're saying is is we're not
- 18:30going to create a safe haven propruriant material to be presented to mind. There's
- 18:36going to be and look, you're a lawyer, you're a smart guy,
- 18:38you know this. There's going to be material. There's going to be a
- 18:41book. And I heard a couple read on the floor this morning at the
- 18:44public hearing where someone says this is strictly purre in interest, this has no
- 18:48value, and someone else is going to argue, no, actually that does.
- 18:52That has literary value. I mean, that's what's gonna happen here.
- 18:55Don't you think, well, it's something that's been well decided because this law
- 18:59has been on the books the sixties. Our court system and our West Virginia
- 19:03Supreme Court have had to go through this for over seventy years. You know
- 19:07they are already looking at this is if there is artistic value. And if
- 19:12you go back to the definition section in section one of this, it's that
- 19:17an average person would view this as prurient materials. So that's going to be
- 19:21a jury question that average applying community standards right would find depicts or describes in
- 19:27a patently offensive way sexually explicit conduct, and a reasonable person would find take
- 19:33it as a whole lack of serious literary, artistic, political, or scientific
- 19:36value. That's the definition, and that we have good case law that already
- 19:40defines that. The only thing this bill is saying is if you're not going
- 19:44to be we're not creating a safe haven for you to show porn to minors.
- 19:48That's all. It's saying, we're getting rid of that safe haven that
- 19:52has become the public libraries. And that's what my libraries, and it might
- 19:55not be the Library Association, but my librarians and my community and Raleigh County.
- 20:00I have four of them come to me and asked me to do this.
- 20:03Three years ago. Brandon Steele is with this delegate who's introduced the bill.
- 20:07Are you my mother used to say, are you straining in that?
- 20:10And swallowing a camel by that. If you're able to do this and there's
- 20:14a book that gets taken out of well okay, or a depiction that is
- 20:18not appropriate for the library, then the sixteen year old walks out and picks
- 20:22up this, picks up their phone. Right, Look, whatever I want,
- 20:25I can get I can get poorn right now within ten seconds. Absolutely,
- 20:29So what's why is there? Why are we worried about that? Why
- 20:33are we worried about that? When you can do this and I'm holding my
- 20:36head well when I talk to the public librarianes and you're absolutely right. I
- 20:40mean, our kids have access to things that I wish a hobby. I'm
- 20:44glad I grew up in the eighties and the nineties didn't have access. But
- 20:48what we're looking at there is we have our kids. If you look at
- 20:51those places, the public libraries, the schools, and places like this,
- 20:53this is a place where the parent has given control over to the state to
- 20:57say, take care of my kid, to educate my child. When we're
- 21:00talking about like the school, library and stuff like this, my child is
- 21:04in a place at that point where as a parent, I don't have a
- 21:07whole lot of control over what's being taught or shown or displayed to my child.
- 21:12And if that conduct would be unlawful outside of the school, then I
- 21:18think we have a higher calling to make sure that that unlawful conduct is still
- 21:25unlawful inside those schools. Let me carry this out to the extreme, which
- 21:29is what you have to do in these cases. You know that is that
- 21:32you're right, somebody's out in front of the library, they're distributing material that's
- 21:34deemed obscene to children. You cuff them and stuff them, right, I
- 21:37mean that would be what you do if if that same material or something similar
- 21:41as Dee deemed obscene. Do you want the librarian or whoever checked out the
- 21:47book to be arrested and face up to five years in prison and a twenty
- 21:49five thousand dollars five do what the same level of prosecution for them? If
- 21:53they are displaying obscene purient material to a minor, they should be charged the
- 21:57same way, whether they're inside those walls are out. Is this aimed at
- 22:02the LBGTQ community. No, this is aimed at displaying obscene material to minors.
- 22:07I mean, you know, if you look at the host of bills
- 22:10I've got, up in the penalty on human trafficking, up in the penalty
- 22:12on sex crimes, you know, taking care of some of this stuff that's
- 22:17going on in our communities. We have the most at risk population of foster
- 22:22children in the nation. You know, we have taken kids at a rate
- 22:26that is alarming compared to other states. We have a CPS system that's overrun.
- 22:32We have the family unit that's been overrun. You know, over fifty
- 22:34percent of kids in this state are born to single mothers, and people are
- 22:40trying to keep a hold of I have a right to raise my kid and
- 22:45show them what I think is the right thing to show them. What this
- 22:48bill is simply doing is saying, hey, let's not put the government in
- 22:52control of a place where they can allow someone to commit a crime that would
- 23:00result in five years in prison outside of these walls. It's not aimed at
- 23:04any groove. It's aimed at protecting our kids, is what it's all about.
- 23:08Brandon Steel, Republican Delegate from Raleigh County. This bill is House built
- 23:14forty six fifty four. There can be a lot of discussion about this.
- 23:18Brother, Ian is six years in and I guess I'm used to it.
- 23:25It'll be all right. I appreciate you coming by. Good discussion, and
- 23:29we'll have you back. There's other things to talk about. Appreciate you coming
- 23:30by. Hey, thanks a lot, Hobby. It's always good to see
- 23:33you. Thank you to see you. We'll take a break and come back
- 23:34more from talk Line, coming you away from the AARP broadcast location here at
- 23:40the Capitol. We'll be back here in three minutes. This is talk Line
- 23:42on Metro News. Metro News is the voice of West Virginia. It's ten
- 23:48thirty. Let's get a news update, checking with the Metro News Radio network.
- 23:52Final what's happening state wide this hour, all across the great state of
- 23:56West Virginia. West Virginia Metro News ign Kerry Huda seg rain begins to move
- 24:04across West Virginia later today, with a floodwatch set to take effect tonight through
- 24:08tomorrow night in the northwestern part of the state. Meteorologists say that snow melt
- 24:14could also lead to problems with flooding. State senators are advancing a bill to
- 24:18mandate viewing of a specific video in classrooms about conception. The bill would require
- 24:22a course in public schools on human development and would require students to watch a
- 24:26video about how a fetus grows in the womb. This is Olivia. There
- 24:32she has yet to greet the outside world. That's part of the video members
- 24:36of the Senate Education Committee watch Tuesday before sending the bill to the full Senate
- 24:40for consideration. Hundreds of West Virginia students are taking a stand against smoking.
- 24:45Nearly five hundred middle and high school students a part of the student led anti
- 24:48tobacco movement rays We're raising awareness of the dangers of using tobacco and vaping at
- 24:53the state capitol Tuesday and filling the legislatures in about their efforts to stop it
- 24:59in their school and communities. Freeing A Cutwright is a tenth grader at Liberty
- 25:03High School in Clarksburg. She said vaping is now by far the most addictive
- 25:07threat among young people who see it as a way to fit in. They're
- 25:10doing those things to be cool, but then they're damaging their like they're damaging
- 25:15theirself and they're hurting themselves for being cool. The one day event to inform
- 25:18the legislators about their efforts was Rais's twentieth annual Tobacco Free Day. I'm Kat
- 25:23Skeldon WV metronews dot com. You're listening to Metro News, the voice of
- 25:29West Virginia. Thanks to all who have sent in some fantastic pictures of your
- 25:33hunting and fishing adventures to our Hoodoo Sports Trophy photo contest. Check out the
- 25:37gallery at the Outdoors page of w D metronews dot com. Also, submit
- 25:41your pictures now and get in on the final monthly drawing, plus the grand
- 25:45prize drawing a Hoodoo Sports Fishing kayak, for which we'll draw during the month
- 25:48of February. Learn how to submit your pick by clicking the Hoodo Sports icon
- 25:52at the Outdoors page of w D metronews dot com. And remember, if
- 25:56it's a trophy to you, it's a trophy to US met cole makes steel.
- 26:02Did you know that metallurgical coal impacts our daily lives in many ways?
- 26:04It's the coal used in the steel making process. Driving over a bridge or
- 26:08loading your family into an automobile, you experienced the value of metallurgical coal.
- 26:12The most met coal produced in the United States is found right here in our
- 26:15Appalachian basins. Infrastructure, comfort, and convenience all made possible my metallurgical coal.
- 26:22Learn more about met coal and the impact of the Metallurgical Coal Producers Association
- 26:26at Metcoalproducers dot com, and remember, met coal makes steel. The race
- 26:30for state Attorney General is shaping up. State Auditor JB. McCuskey and State
- 26:34Senator Mike Stewart followed for the GOP primary election this week. While Wheeling Attorney
- 26:38Teresa Torresva says she plans to seek the Democratic nomination, Stuart says this is
- 26:44an important office. I just think it's critically important that we continue the aggressive
- 26:48work of the Attorney General and have somebody is ready to get to work day
- 26:52one to protect the people at West Virginia. The Canada filing deadline is this
- 26:56Saturday at midnight. From the Metro News anchors, Sky Kelly Huda sec Tungueline
- 27:14from the NCOVA Insurance Studios Welcome back. He's joined by Brad macilhenny. Good
- 27:18morning, Brad, Good morning and broadcasting from the AARP location. AARP's your
- 27:25ally for real possibilities in the Mountain State. Connect on social media at AARP
- 27:30West Virginia and learn more at AARP dot org slash WV. What a public
- 27:33hearing this morning? Been around a while, I don't think I've ever heard
- 27:37a public hearing like that fairly evenly spit split four and against this legislation that
- 27:42would open up librarians to prosecution if they allow obscene material to be accessed by
- 27:49minors. And what stood out was I think opposition by librarians to this because
- 27:55they said it would have a chilling effect. But also Brad that some people
- 27:59who support this bill actually referenced books, young adult books that they say came
- 28:06from their community libraries that and they read portions of them in the public hearing
- 28:11that were indeed very graphic. What was your takeaway? Yes, And you
- 28:15know, overall, I would say that this bill would remove exemptions for libraries
- 28:25to be protected against criminal prosecution for obscene material and I have wondered, well,
- 28:30give me some examples of what might be up for prosecution. The abstract
- 28:37concept is one thing, but specifically how do you feed it into the machine.
- 28:41So, as you referenced, what we got was some very specific and
- 28:47explicit readings of material I missed some of the titles. I'm going to have
- 28:52to go back because I need to feed them into my good Reads profile,
- 28:55but also examples of materials that defend of the current protections by libraries say would
- 29:04would potentially be up for grabs. So there were copies of Huckleberry Finn,
- 29:08a literary classic that has explicit race related language and race related situations, a
- 29:15book called How There was an opponent of this policy change who described Heather has
- 29:22two moms, which Heather has two mommies, I believe, which she said
- 29:27potentially could be considered offensive by some library patrons because it describes a non traditional
- 29:34household arrangement, but she said that reflects her household and that it could be
- 29:40helpful reading for a child in her house to work through how their household is
- 29:47different from others. So that's where I found it to be very very helpful,
- 29:52was realistic descriptions of what kinds of material is potentially up for prosecution.
- 30:00Yeah, and there were a couple of readings which and again I thought it
- 30:07was very very enlightening. I think, and I'll elaborate on this. I
- 30:10think it's a and I'm told the delegate this. I think it's a bad
- 30:11bill for a couple of reasons. I think it has this tremendous chilling effect.
- 30:15But there's certainly if those if those, in fact, the sections of
- 30:19the books that a couple of people read from are available to youth in the
- 30:25library, you would say, wow, that's really sort of penthouse material.
- 30:27I mean, very very graphic descriptions of sexual acts in some cases, you
- 30:33know, homosexual acts. And I'm not judging homosexual acts at all. I'm
- 30:37just saying that there was very very graphic and you know, you know just
- 30:42that. But librarians, Brad, I don't know about all, but many
- 30:48don't want to be in the first of all, they don't want to be
- 30:51they don't want to be in a position where they feel like they have to
- 30:52censor material. Number one and number two, they certainly don't want to be
- 30:59subject to prosecute if they have a book, if they're getting ready to put
- 31:03a book on the shelf and thinking, am I going to get cuffed and
- 31:07stuffed if somebody objects to this book? You know what, I did think
- 31:11this was very helpful. What I did feel in the moment it was missing
- 31:15was when advocates for this policy change cited passages and read them. I in
- 31:22the moment, really would have liked to have heard from librarians about, well,
- 31:27here's how we would treat that specific material. And you know, I
- 31:33wondered, in some cases, if it truly is upfront on display. There
- 31:37was a conversation with you yesterday about the relatively small size of libraries, but
- 31:41in some cases, if special care is taken to make to put that kind
- 31:45of material only in upper grade or late grade teen areas or behind the shelf,
- 31:53I just wondered, you know, that is the kind of material cited
- 31:57truly in a library in my community, and if so, how easy or
- 32:01hard is it for a kid to get Here's the other thing that stands out
- 32:07to me. And again I'm going to air all sides on this because I
- 32:13think it's very very important, but also I have my personal feelings about this,
- 32:16and that is that there is a procedure in place at all libraries in
- 32:22West Virginia where if you object to any material, you can it's called a
- 32:27reconsideration, and you can go through the process of reconsideration at the library and
- 32:31state why you think this is inappropriate, and then there is a deliberation and
- 32:38a decision. So there is an and you might not be pleased with the
- 32:42result, but there is a process to go through currently, which would seem
- 32:45to be start there rather than saying we're going to change the state law concerning
- 32:51this. Again, that's an opinion, that's not a question. So what
- 32:53do you think this is all headed? I you know, my immediate question
- 32:58is the House Judicial Committee, which has had this bill took it off a
- 33:02couple of agendas Friday because of snow and Monday because this public hearing was scheduled.
- 33:07They have a meeting this afternoon two o'clock, I believe, and my
- 33:13I naturally wonder is this bill going to be up on that committee now and
- 33:16will it advance? So unfortunately I have process questions, but that's kind of
- 33:22where I am. Yeah, it is, it is processed meantime. You
- 33:24know. The other the other, the other practical question I think is you
- 33:30would hope that of the of the examples that were potentially hyperbolic on both sides
- 33:37of this argument, this would eventually come to I think county prosecutors and circuit
- 33:44judges and communities. So you know, you would hope that there would be
- 33:50some discretion about not going wild with prosecution of library materials. But to game
- 33:59it out, I still think that you know you would you would worry as
- 34:02a librarian and not want to take a chance as a relatively low paid employee
- 34:07of having to hire a lawyer and getting legal costs paid for taking time off
- 34:12work being deposed, so having to pay more for liability insurance. So not
- 34:16only have I wondered, well, what kind of material are we even talking
- 34:21about, I've wondered, well, and when we game it out, how
- 34:23does it actually potentially as a law take place in communities. Arkansas passed a
- 34:30similar law, and I gathered some information on that today, and there's been
- 34:35some question about that. They passed it in twenty twenty three, and a
- 34:39judge there concluded that portions of the law are too vague to be understood and
- 34:45implemented effectively, and that if enacted, would permit, if not encourage,
- 34:52library committees and local government bodies to make censorship decisions based on content or viewpoint,
- 34:58which would be what a violates of the First Amendment if you're making any
- 35:01decision based on content. So this is not a simple matter. This is
- 35:07is as legal tentacles. It has moral tentacles, it has practical tentacles.
- 35:13It's got all kinds of things attached to it. I just want to add
- 35:16that. On the other side of the building down in the Senate, we
- 35:20are considering legislation to make eighth graders annually watch a video of sperm inseminating aname.
- 35:30Is it eighth graders and fifth graders or just eighth graders? Now the
- 35:32bill has changed to be eighth graders with a review in the tenth grade.
- 35:36Yeah, it's called the name of the Kid, Meet Baby Olivia, Meet
- 35:39Baby Olivia specific video, and it will show you happy little sperm in siminating
- 35:45anag. Yeah, I saw that last night. I watched it last night.
- 35:49So that's why I may be prosecuted for even mentioning that and describing.
- 35:52Well, you might be if if you described how that sperm got there.
- 35:55But I'll leave that. It leaves that up in the air. You have
- 35:59no idea all right, Brad Michaeliney. When we come back, another take
- 36:04on this Apologies everyone, yeah, exactly. Apologies from Doublegateshawn flu Hardy.
- 36:07It was opposed to this bill. That's when talk line continues from the Inclova
- 36:13Insurance Studios at the AARP Broadcast Location Network Security Series. Business sitting that is
- 36:17serious about protecting your business and your employees from today's constant barrage of cybersecurity threats.
- 36:22Let's sitting there be your cybersecurity hero when it comes to technology. Sitting
- 36:25in that connects, protects, and perfects. We'll be right back. Thanks
- 36:30to all who have sent in some fantastic pictures of your hunting and fishing adventures
- 36:34to our Hoodoo Sports Trophy photo contest. Check out the gallery at the Outdoors
- 36:37page of w b metronews dot com. Also, submit your pictures now and
- 36:42get in on the final monthly drawing plus the grand prize drawing a Hoodoo Sports
- 36:45Fishing kayak for which we'll draw during the month of February. Learn how to
- 36:50submit your pick by clicking the Hoodoo Sports icon at the Outdoors page of w
- 36:53B metronews dot com. And remember, if it's a trophy to you.
- 36:57It's a trophy to us. Despite the ill fated efforts of President Biden and
- 37:05his wealthy New York friends, West Virginia coal is thriving and being shipped to
- 37:08forty five countries worldwide. Given its high quality and clean burning properties, Countries
- 37:15across the globe are demanding and consuming it, and in state production continues to
- 37:20grow. With billions of dollars of recent investment in West Virginia mining operations,
- 37:23combined with the reliability of our coal fired electric manufacturing facilities, West Virginia coal
- 37:30is here to stay. No other fuel in the world matches West Virginia coal
- 37:34for baselow generation and steel making. Like a good friend, It's always been
- 37:39and always will be there, keeping the lights on and contributing greatly to our
- 37:45growing economy. In fact, coal continues to sustain fifty thousand plus West Virginia
- 37:50jobs, putting food on the table for Mountain State families. Visit Friends of
- 37:53Coal dot org to learn more. A message from the Friends of Coal.
- 38:00Every house tells a story, and that's where I come in. My name
- 38:01is Aaron Weston, and my husband and I in calendar construction in Charleston.
- 38:06I'm also a West Virginia Promise Scholarship recipient. After I graduated from WU,
- 38:09I knew I wanted to carve a career in West Virginia. Building a small
- 38:14business and helping people see the potential in their home. Now, that's a
- 38:16great story. Proceeds from the West Virginia Lottery have helped generate nearly eight hundred
- 38:22and seventy six million dollars to Promise scholarships since two thousand and two for students
- 38:27like Aaron West Virginia Lottery What if you play? It's good to have options
- 38:31when choosing health coverage for your family, your employees, and your company.
- 38:37You want to plan with people you know, like the Health Plan known for
- 38:44exceptional local customer service and are headquartered right here in West Virginia. We are
- 38:51families, we are businesses, and we are all moving forward together. We
- 38:57are here for you the health you're listening to Chalkline on Metro News the voice
- 39:02of West Virginia. West Virginia is home. It's where we work, live
- 39:08and raise our families. At the heart of our communities are West Virginia Hospitals
- 39:14and they're compassionate caregivers from life saving treatments and emergency care, to wellness support
- 39:20and screening services. We are improving your quality of life through extraordinary achievements and
- 39:25amazing results West Virginia Hospitals. Your health is the heartbeat of our communities.
- 39:34When it comes to vaping, the truth can get clouded. So let's make
- 39:37it clear. Vaping is not safe for youth because vaping can put microscopic particles
- 39:42into your lungs and dangerous things like metals into your body, and nicotine,
- 39:46which can harm a person's brain development through their mid twenties. With appealing flavors,
- 39:51high nicotine levels, and lots of promotion on social media, many kids
- 39:54think vaping is harmless, but it's not. So talk to your kids about
- 39:58the risks of vaping, because when you talk, they hear you. I'm
- 40:06rusty and I'm the owner of Mountain Erostling. I discovered a passion for coffee
- 40:10during a study broad trip to Nicaragua. I wanted to take that passion to
- 40:14grow the coffee industry here in my home state. A huge part of making
- 40:17that possible was the promised scholarship that I received. I'm really proud that our
- 40:21coffee is statewide and even in our state Parks. Proceeds from the West Virginia
- 40:25Lottery has helped generate more than three point seven billion in education for students like
- 40:30Rusty. When you play, you say yes to West Virginia. From a
- 40:35young age, math influences our lives to create, to build from scratch.
- 40:40With math, I learned to persevere. I learned to try again. With
- 40:45math, I can move forward. I learned to identify problems in the real
- 40:50world around me and find unique solutions. With math, I succeed. With
- 40:54math, I succeed Big. Confident, Take the pledge, not for a
- 41:00line. Metro News talk Line with Hoppy Kirchible is brought to you by Incoca
- 41:22Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what you care about most. Visiting
- 41:27Coca dot com to learn more. Talk Line from the ARP broadcast location at
- 41:31the ENCOD Insurance studios here at the Capitol West Virginia. All makers considering opening
- 41:37public and school libraries up to felony charges for the display or dissemination of obscene
- 41:43material. There's a big public hearing on it. This morning we heard from
- 41:45Delicate Brandon Steele, who is pushing the bill, and now we hear from
- 41:50Delaia. Shawn flu Hardy Democrat, Ohio County, very much against it,
- 41:52Shan, good morning, how a good morning, Hopey, how you been.
- 41:54I'm well, good to see you. Why are you against it?
- 41:58Up? Another propaganda bill? See, I'm glad we're tackling the big issues
- 42:01here early in session. Great economic is this is gonna create so many jobs.
- 42:06I mean, it's just we're gonna go from worse the first in a
- 42:07matter of no time. You're being sarcastic, of course, of course I
- 42:09am, because this is a nonsensical propaganda bill which we see during election season
- 42:15for political mailers and not good policy. And I don't think most of the
- 42:19support that I've seen for this bill, and the individual speaking this morning,
- 42:22have they even stepped foot in the library lately, Like I don't think they
- 42:24have a fundamental understanding of how libraries operate. But for us to put policy
- 42:29forward, it's gonna lock up librarians for five years for what is deemed to
- 42:31be obscene, which we don't even know the strategy on what that looks like
- 42:35yet. Hop we don't know what characterizes obscene. The Miller test is how
- 42:38we're gonna use Well, there is a week. I mean, there's state
- 42:39in state code, there's a legal definition the Miller test, which is an
- 42:43absolute gray area. And so what this is is big government. Let's get
- 42:47down to the fundamentals here. Hop Republicans have this incredible fetish here in Charleston,
- 42:53these days of big government, prying into your bedroom, prying into your
- 42:58doctor's office, and now prying into libraries. They want to control you from
- 43:00morning tonight on what you're doing. They're pushing political ideologies. That's what this
- 43:05is all about. This is about banning books that they deem to be improper.
- 43:08And it's not about children or pornography. It's about political ideologies. This
- 43:14is this type of stuff Hop, you would read in third world countries and
- 43:16we're reading it right here in West Virginia. Why do you think it's happening?
- 43:20Then it's political season? Why are half these bills running? We're talking
- 43:23You did a great piece I did you did? You did a great piece
- 43:29on intelligent design? And why are we talking about intelligent design? Let teachers
- 43:34teach, Let librarians control the library. The idea that children going to library
- 43:37all willy nilly and checking out books that are obscene is a falsehood. It's
- 43:40just not happening. But we create this background noise on purpose, hop so
- 43:45people can get angry at each other. You heard the testimony this morning,
- 43:47the public hearing people are fired up. They like having neighbors fired up at
- 43:52neighbors angry about something that's manufactured. We have manufactured outrage in this country and
- 43:57especially here in West Virginia right now. Sean Fluherd's this Democratic delegate from Ohio
- 44:00County very much against this bill. I did hear. I did hear though,
- 44:04from a number of people. You heard them too, who are upset,
- 44:07who are upset and say this, and they and in some instances read
- 44:10from books that are available at the library that that that are very very graphics
- 44:16the Bible. I don't hear anybody read from the Bible. Well, if
- 44:20I heard testimony today about depictions of the Bible that could be deemed to be
- 44:23inappropriate, are Republicans now banning the Bible? And that's what's going to happen
- 44:28here. It happened in Utah. A similar bill was passed in the state
- 44:30of Utah. And the first thing that was off the off the books the
- 44:35Bible. So Republicans are coming for your Bible, and a lot of people
- 44:37testify this morning reading scripture, but they omitted things that are rather you know,
- 44:43could be deemed obscene. Yeah, some of the Old Testament stuff.
- 44:45Sure, okay, So they're coming for your Bible. Is that where we're
- 44:47at now? Now, Look, I'm a Democrat. I thought Democrats were
- 44:51supposed to be the big government, overreached big brother. Turns out it's actually
- 44:54Republicans. They get a little power and they get a little overreach, and
- 44:59that's what we have now. It's it's insane to me that they're coming for
- 45:01your Bible. And listeners of your show need to understand the fundamental principles of
- 45:06this bill. They're coming for your Bible. That's how this works. Well,
- 45:09I what I heard was and and that that would be an extreme example,
- 45:15and I think there would be an exemption on that because wait, wait,
- 45:19wait, I think there would be an exemption because if something has artistic
- 45:23value, so it could be argued it certainly would be argued that the Bible
- 45:27has artistic value. Of the bill therefore as an exempt. I have read
- 45:30the bill. I have read the bill. I do not believe that is
- 45:31correct. Really, we cannot make an exception for just the Bible. Now,
- 45:36if you want to make an exception for all religious texts, maybe so.
- 45:38But if we mad an exception for just the Bible, it would violate
- 45:42this ablishment clause. Yeah, where the Constitution still stands for at least I
- 45:45thought so, you know, I thought Republicans cared about the Constitution. Turns
- 45:50turns out they care more about political power. And you know what this bill
- 45:52is all about. It'll be political mail or season. We're in an election
- 45:55year. That is what's happening. It'll be a flu hardy once children,
- 46:00you know, you'll see you'll see mailers go out and it'll have a legislator's
- 46:04name, it'll have it. And if you actually if you said you read
- 46:06the bill, you understand basically the underlying code here is talking about pictures.
- 46:13If you actually read it, so the underlying code talks about display material.
- 46:15It's like going into the gas station and how they used to cover up playboys.
- 46:20Right, that's if you get down to the weeds on this bill was
- 46:23the original intent. Where they want to go now is far beyond that?
- 46:27Well, it doesn't go And how will we monitor that. Our librarian is
- 46:30now going to have to read every page of a book that's in the library.
- 46:34If you go to the theater's hopy a movie is rated, it's rated
- 46:37R. It's in TV shows are NC seventeen, tvm A, whatever it
- 46:40may be. Our books like that, hoppy. Do we have rating systems
- 46:44for books? No, we don't. So now our librarian is going to
- 46:46have to go through every book, read every page and go, oh,
- 46:50well, put this one to the side, and not quite sure on that
- 46:51one. Do you think do you think this is Do you think this is
- 46:53also aimed at the LGBTQ community. I think they're always being aimed at here
- 46:58in Charleston because the easy pickings, and that's what they do. But I
- 47:01don't think it's the main target. I think it could be something that could
- 47:06be targeted based upon the books that I've seen there on the list that's been
- 47:07going around from these groups, but I don't think it's the essentially the main
- 47:12target here. I think the main target is political season, right, and
- 47:15it's getting people like us discussing it while they fail to pass bills to actually
- 47:19have good policy behind them. We're going to take valuable legislative time on an
- 47:22issue like this which has zero impact on our economy, zero impact on the
- 47:28state of West Virginia to bring it forward, and would you would you would
- 47:31you it's nonsensical legislation. Would you agree it could have potential impact on communities
- 47:37since you heard people from the community today speak in favor of it. I
- 47:39think the impact would be basically closing the door to the library, the access
- 47:45to the library, which is the one thing we have left in this country
- 47:47that politics hasn't ruined. It's the one thing government hasn't intruded on. And
- 47:52now today we're sitting here discussing it and saying they look through the list of
- 47:54well, you know what, we haven't quite gone after librarians enough yet,
- 47:58we haven't quite gone after the library. We want to control every facet of
- 48:00your life. Like I said earlier, they're in your bedroom, they're in
- 48:04the boardroom, they're in the doctor's office, and now they're in the library.
- 48:06Definitely get Sean flu Hardy, Democrat from Ohio County. We'll have you
- 48:10back because there's other bills you want to talk about. But it's good to
- 48:13talk to you today. Yeah, I appreciate it. Hop there's a DNA
- 48:15database being implemented today, so the government. Republicans want to put you to
- 48:19DNA database. All kind of the government stuff up. All right, we'll
- 48:22talk about that. We'll have you back. Thank you, Sean flu Hardy
- 48:23talk clink continues from the COVI Insurance studios in the AARP broadcast location. We'll
- 48:28be right back. Met Coal makes steel. Did you know that metallurgical coal
- 48:31impacts our daily lives in many ways? It's the coal used in the steel
- 48:36making process. Driving over a bridge or loading your family into an automobile,
- 48:39you experienced the value of metallurgical coal. Most met coal produced in the United
- 48:44States is found right here in our Appalachian basins. Infrastructure, comfort, and
- 48:47convenience all made possible my metallurgical coal. Learn more about met coal and the
- 48:52impact of the Metallurgical Coal Producers Association at Metcoal Producers dot com. And remember,
- 48:58met coal makes steel. Every house tells a story, and that's where
- 49:01I come in. My name is Aaron Weston, and my husband and I
- 49:04in calendar construction in Charleston. I'm also a West Virginia Promise Scholarship recipient.
- 49:08After I graduated from WU, I knew I wanted to carve a career in
- 49:12West Virginia. Building a small business and helping people see the potential in their
- 49:15home. Now, that's a great story. Proceeds from the West Virginia Lottery
- 49:20have helped generate nearly eight hundred and seventy six million dollars to promise scholarships since
- 49:24two thousand and two for students like Aaron West Virginia Lottery What if You play?
- 49:30It's good to have options when choosing health coverage for your family, your
- 49:35employees, and your company. You want to plan with people you know,
- 49:42like the Health Plan, known for exceptional local customer service and are headquartered right
- 49:49here in West Virginia. We are families, we are businesses, and we
- 49:54are all moving forward together. We are here for you, health Plan.
- 50:00West Virginia is home. It's where we work, live and raise our families.
- 50:06At the heart of our communities are West Virginia Hospitals and they're compassionate caregivers.
- 50:12From life saving treatments and emergency care to wellness support and screening services.
- 50:17We are improving your quality of life through extraordinary achievements and amazing results. West
- 50:23Virginia Hospitals. Your health is the heartbeat of our communities. This is talk
- 50:29Line on Metro News the voice of West Virginia. Ruth Pharmacy offers a local
- 50:34prescription delivery. Call your Fruth today and schedule your prescription delivery. You can
- 50:37also get items like milk, paper, towels, vitamins, and more delivered
- 50:42right to your door. Ruth your hometown family pharmacy. You know city met
- 50:47is West Virgina is leading technology company. Whether we're managing IT infrastructures, protecting
- 50:53the critical data and networks of our region's businesses, or providing fiber broadband,
- 50:59TV and phone services, we are your go to experts. We're also a
- 51:02strong partner in the communities in which we serve. City Net your trusted technology
- 51:09partner. Learn more about us visit citynet dot net. We don't have a
- 51:17voice outside of Farm Bureau for rural issues in West Virginia. There's no other
- 51:22organization that has the same capacity in the same dedication for property rights advocacy as
- 51:28West Virginia Farm Bureau. When kids are small, we tend to spend most
- 51:34of our time saying no instead of yes. As our parents and grandparents' age,
- 51:38we sometimes say no to visits instead of yes. Life can be overwhelming
- 51:44and sometimes it's nice to say yes to making memories and starting a future.
- 51:47By playing the West Virginia Lottery, you're saying yes to tomorrow's leaders and today's
- 51:52seniors, and furthering the beauty of the mountain state. When you play,
- 51:58you say yes to West Virginia. West Virginia is home. It's where we
- 52:06work, live and raise our families. At the heart of our communities are
- 52:10West Virginia Hospitals, and they're compassionate caregivers, from life saving treatments and emergency
- 52:16care to wellness support and screening services. We are improving your quality of life
- 52:22through extraordinary achievements and amazing results. West Virginia Hospitals. Your health is the
- 52:29heartbeat of our communities. All righty, talk line from the upper rotunda.
- 52:55We're at the ARP broadcast location, and a if you're a to a discussion
- 53:00this morning about this particular bill House built forty six point fifty four. As
- 53:06a Brad said earlier, it has not moved yet. It was on the
- 53:08Judiciary Committee agenda a couple of times, and Friday was a weather issue,
- 53:13and then yesterday it was pulled because of the upcoming public hearing and a spirited
- 53:19public hearing this morning, and so we'll just keep an eye on it.
- 53:22We'll see where this thing goes. But obviously its emotions are running very high
- 53:25on this. We'll take a break here. We'll be back in six minutes
- 53:29at the upper rotunda of the West Virginia State Capitol. And when we come
- 53:32back, Attorney General candidate JB. McCuskey joins us, I've gotten a ton
- 53:36of texts, haven't gotten to any of them. I'm sorry. This is
- 53:38talk Line on Metro News, the voice of West Virginia Already. Welcome back
- 1:00:13to talk Line on the Metro News Ready network across the great state of West
- 1:00:16Virginia, broadcasting from the Cove Insurance studios that have been moved to the AARP
- 1:00:23broadcast location here at the West Virginia State Capitol. So I have gosh a
- 1:00:30ton of texts about what we were talking about last hour, and that is
- 1:00:36House Bill forty six fifty four. And this is a bill that has been
- 1:00:39introduced in the House and sent to the Judiciary Committee. And what it does,
- 1:00:45if you listen last hour, you know. But what it does is
- 1:00:49right now, schools and museums and libraries are exempt from the law that prohibits
- 1:01:01the distribution of obscene matter to youth. And what this bill does is it
- 1:01:13removes that exemption, which would subject schools, school librarians, public librarians,
- 1:01:21maybe school officials, whomever would be directly responsible for that alleged distribution, would
- 1:01:29make them subject to criminal prosecution, which could be if found convicted, subjected
- 1:01:35to up to five years in prison at twenty five thousand dollars. Fine.
- 1:01:37Now, we heard last hour from Brandon Steel Delicate Brand and Steel, who's
- 1:01:40introduced the Billy says, look, if you have material that is by definition
- 1:01:47pornographic, and there are definitions by definition pornographic that is appeals only, it
- 1:01:52has no artistic value and appeals only to perian interests, and they were in
- 1:01:57front of the library and distributing that material, to my mind, they would
- 1:02:00be subject to arrest and prosecution. His argument is, you put that same
- 1:02:04material in a library and then they are exempt. The librarian is exempt from
- 1:02:09prosecution. The argument on the other side is that you're really you're creating a
- 1:02:16chilling effect for librarians that they would then look at a title and say,
- 1:02:23wow, this may have artistic value which would be exempt, or somebody might
- 1:02:30say, the prosecutor might say it doesn't or the judge might say it doesn't,
- 1:02:32and therefore I could be sent to jail and find twenty five thousand dollars,
- 1:02:37and so it would have a real chilling effect on what gets put in
- 1:02:42the library. You also heard from Delegate flu Hardy who said this is just
- 1:02:46red meat. This is right wing red meat for an election year. So
- 1:02:50let me do some of these texts to see where you are on this.
- 1:02:52I'm just going to start at the top. There's a ton of them happy
- 1:02:58kids in a library. Can't encourage that behavior. Not sure what that means.
- 1:03:01Text three oh four Talk three oh four happy. By the end of
- 1:03:06that interview, I thought you should call him sean Foolhardy says the texture not
- 1:03:10happy with Delegate Flo Hardy happy. Delegate Flo Hardy is delusional if he thinks
- 1:03:15West Virginia voters are going to believe him when he says they're coming after your
- 1:03:19Bible over and over, that's an insult to our intelligence. The reference there
- 1:03:23is that if you are going to because this did come up in Utah,
- 1:03:30but if you are going to single out printed materials that have very graphic descriptions
- 1:03:40of sexual behavior that you would also find that in the Bible. That's the
- 1:03:45extreme argument that's being used. Happy banning books from libraries with sexual content.
- 1:03:52Will they ban Trump since he's a sexual predator and Republicans need to take their
- 1:03:58playboys out of their bathrooms? Says the texture text Hoppy. Once again,
- 1:04:04a left wing liberal Democrat comes on and deflex, Deflex, deflex, which
- 1:04:12is why I will never again vote for his immoral and debased party, even
- 1:04:15after having been an ardent trade unionist, and why his party has all but
- 1:04:21been wiped out in West Virginia. Text Team, you want an adult section
- 1:04:28like the old time Blockbuster rental store in a library. It's funny. It's
- 1:04:31okay to censor Republicans on Facebook and Twitter, but we can't protect the kids
- 1:04:36from pornographic obscene crap, says the Texture. By the way, there was
- 1:04:43a Brad was telling me there were some concerns being expressed in the Capitol because
- 1:04:47there were individuals who support this bill who read portions of books that they say
- 1:04:54came from their local library that had very, very depiction of sexual activity and
- 1:05:01they didn't like that that was done. I thought it was completely appropriate because
- 1:05:05everybody there was an adult. And if you're going to object to certain materials
- 1:05:12that you say are in the local library, then it is appropriate to my
- 1:05:15opinion too. Excuse me, hear what those materials are here, or see
- 1:05:20what those materials are. Text Hopy, your current guest is giving away the
- 1:05:27Democratic playbook for the upcoming election cycle. Scare people into voting Democrat. Text
- 1:05:35Hoppy, what's next. Mothers can breastfeed because the child is seeing a pair
- 1:05:42of boobs. Let's charge all breastfeeding mothers with child molestation and lock them up
- 1:05:46for five years. Says the texture Hoppy. This is why people hate politics
- 1:05:54and dislike politicians. You are seeing in this session, and I think for
- 1:05:59a couple reasons. One is you're seeing a lot of these culture issues come
- 1:06:03up this session, and you're seeing that for a couple of reasons. One
- 1:06:08is a lot of these are being brought up by Republicans who are elected on
- 1:06:12these issues. Number one. Number two, there aren't any other gigantic overriding
- 1:06:16issues quite frankly, and then number three is that a lot of the issues
- 1:06:23that were typically associated with conservative Republicans, e. Taxes, judicial reform,
- 1:06:30those kinds of things have already been dealt with, have already been dealt with.
- 1:06:33So there's no need for Republicans to take on taxes. There's no need
- 1:06:38for Republicans to take on judicial reform. Been done, been done. So
- 1:06:43there's these cultural issues that are very emotional and really get people worked up,
- 1:06:49and so you're seeing a lot of that this session. Hoppy, for this
- 1:06:55line very issue. Perhaps parents should be responsible to watch what their kids look
- 1:06:59at while at a public library and get a parent's permission to go to the
- 1:07:03school library if it's that important text three oh four talk three to four,
- 1:07:11Happy to the blo to the blowhard who refused to let you speak. There
- 1:07:15was a time when we all agreed on leaving kids alone. Why are you
- 1:07:18left as loons so obsessed with sexualizing children? We used to call that a
- 1:07:24predator, Hoppy, Can he name any erotic material any libraries in West Virginia
- 1:07:30are displaying? There are some of this I think originates with the I think
- 1:07:38it's called Moms for Liberty, which is that Florida organization that got very very
- 1:07:42involved in the school board there in Florida with removing certain books from libraries.
- 1:07:49I think they ended up with maybe you know a couple hundred titles that they
- 1:07:53want to remove, and there is an ironic twist there because I think the
- 1:07:58woman's name is Ziggler, is that she was caught up in a embarrassing situation
- 1:08:03of a sexual tryst, allegations of a sexual tryst involving her husband and another
- 1:08:08woman. But that is where a lot of this originated with the Moms for
- 1:08:12Liberty, and it's spread across the country. And if you look at some
- 1:08:15of the titles that are being talked about, I mean, some of them
- 1:08:18are very graphic, and some of them are youth oriented, and then some
- 1:08:24are the classics, you know, Fahrenheit four fifty one, to Kill a
- 1:08:28Mockingbird, the Color Purple, those kinds of things. They have made it
- 1:08:30on lists two. So it's possible. I don't know, but it's possible
- 1:08:36that if this became law that you would see individuals in certain communities who would
- 1:08:42say, we have to take fair and height four fifty one, to kill
- 1:08:45a mockingbird, Slaughterhouse five, the color purple, along with the you know,
- 1:08:53hold gender stuff out of the libraries. Text so they read from young
- 1:09:01adult books that have adult themes. It's not like the target audience adults.
- 1:09:06Is the name of the is in the name of the genre. Hoppy.
- 1:09:13If I take my nephew to the Bridgeport pool this summer and I see butt
- 1:09:15cheeks hanging out like I did last year, I'm doing everything in my power
- 1:09:19to press charges against the city lifeguards and the parents. Hoppy. The Republicans
- 1:09:27are coming to get your bible. Come on, Hoppy, that guy needs
- 1:09:31to calm down, all right, A lot of people on flu hardy here
- 1:09:41happy. When I went to the library, all adult stuff was blocked off.
- 1:09:45You had to be of a certain age or of permission. Also,
- 1:09:46the material could not be checked out. That was fifty years ago, when
- 1:09:50there was little porn for the public to see. I think one of the
- 1:09:55issues is that. And I don't know. I haven't been I have a
- 1:09:59library car for the Morgantown Public Library, and I do online access my books
- 1:10:03online from the library. But I think what some of the people this morning
- 1:10:11who support the bill we're referencing was young adult books that are in the library.
- 1:10:15We're going to take a break and come back. When we come back
- 1:10:17on Metro News talk Line, We're going to talk with John Overington, former
- 1:10:23delegate, member of the Republican Executive Committee. He's among those that is pushing
- 1:10:28for restricting the Republican primary in West Virginia to Republicans only. That when talk
- 1:10:32line continues from the in COVID Insurance studios that are now at the AARP broadcast
- 1:10:40location here at the State Capitol, we'll be right back. As West Virginians,
- 1:10:44we are proud of the natural beauty of the mountain Stint and ATZMM Architects
- 1:10:47and Engineers. Our goal is to provide design solutions that give people the same
- 1:10:51pride in our built environments. That commitment to quality can be seen in recreational
- 1:10:57facilities throughout the state, from the Charleston College and Convention Center to the Valley
- 1:11:01Park Community Center, the Shawnee Sport Complex, and through the recent improvements to
- 1:11:05the lodges at Pipe Stem Resort at State Park. ZMM Architects and Engineers,
- 1:11:11you see us in your community every day. Thanks to all who have sent
- 1:11:15in some fantastic pictures of your hunting and fishing adventures to our Hoodoo Sports Trophy
- 1:11:18photo contest. Check out the gallery at the Outdoors page of wv metronews dot
- 1:11:23com. Also submit your pictures now and get in on the final monthly drawing,
- 1:11:28plus the grand prize drawing a Hoodoo Sports Fishing kayak, for which we'll
- 1:11:30draw during the month of February. Learn how to submit your pick by clicking
- 1:11:34the Hoodoo Sports icon at the outdoor page of wv Metronews dot com. And
- 1:11:39remember, if it's a trophy to you, it's a trophy to us.
- 1:11:44The Children's Neuroscience Center at WVU Medicine Children's has been nationally ranked in neurology and
- 1:11:49neurosurgery by US News and World Report. This means we provide the highest level
- 1:11:55of neurological, behavioral and psychiatric care all in one place. Or we use
- 1:12:00the latest technologies to treat epilepsy, traumatic brain injury, brain tumors, autism,
- 1:12:05and migraines, as well as muscle and nerve disorders. Visit WVU kids
- 1:12:12dot com. We get almost here. Pontoon boating is a great way to
- 1:12:19spend time with your family and friends, and the off season is a great
- 1:12:23time to buy blue. Wendell just received a new shipment of boats, so
- 1:12:27get in well. The selection is still good. Open Tuesday through Saturday,
- 1:12:30eight thirty to five four eighteen, First Avenue in Saint Albans. Come in
- 1:12:33and pick up your new pontoub boat. Today we begin almost blue Wendel Marine
- 1:12:40sales. We furnished family fun. You're listening to your talk line on Metro
- 1:12:45News the Voice of West Virginia. He name's Ron Timmins. I work in
- 1:12:57the Martins Perg West Virginia office for Good News down there Garad. We take
- 1:13:00in donated cars, We fix them up and give them out to needy families
- 1:13:04in New West Virginia. Usually I get calls from donors that's donating a car.
- 1:13:09I'll go pick up the car have it repaired. Once we receive a
- 1:13:12family information, we will match a car up to their information for a mouth
- 1:13:16they drive to work, daycare, doctor's appointments. Little match your car for
- 1:13:20that in their family size that helps them get the work or shop. We
- 1:13:24do look at the vehicles. Our job is to make sure it's a good
- 1:13:28quality card that we can use. I received my car from Canows Mountain,
- 1:13:31your garage in September of twenty sixteen. I found myself without health care,
- 1:13:38without a vehicle, essentially without a place to live, and without this car
- 1:13:45that I received from Gan News Mountain Garage. You know, I don't know
- 1:13:48where I would be or where my child would be. There is no reason
- 1:13:54why that you can't reach out and ask for help. That is what this
- 1:13:59program and once founded for and what it's meant to do. Or we all
- 1:14:03have abilities and we all are capable of doing great things. Sometimes we just
- 1:14:09need that step to get going in the right direction. West Virginia is home.
- 1:14:23It's where we live and raise our families. At the heart of our
- 1:14:28communities are West Virginia Hospitals and they're compassionate caregivers, from life saving treatments and
- 1:14:33emergency care to wellness support and screening services. We are improving your quality of
- 1:14:40life through extraordinary achievements and amazing results. West Virginia Hospitals, Your health is
- 1:14:45the heartbeat of our communities. Metro News talk Line with Hobby Kirchible is brought
- 1:15:03to you by Encoca Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what do you
- 1:15:08care about most? Visit in Coca dot com to learn more. Welcome back
- 1:15:12on talk Line on Metro News. From the Upper Roads hunt to the West
- 1:15:15Virginia State capital jackpots in the millions here in West Virginia. Who doesn't want
- 1:15:20to be a millionaire? Get in the Powerball drawings Mondays, Wednesdays and Saturdays
- 1:15:24and the Megamigon's drawings on Tuesdays and Fridays. Will you be the next big
- 1:15:27winner? Play today? The Popball jackpot is one hundred and forty five million
- 1:15:30dollars. The megaming is jackpot two hundred and eighty five million dollars. John
- 1:15:35Overington is a former longtime House of Delegates member Republican from Berkeley County. Is
- 1:15:41also a member of the State Republican part Executive Committee and he's on the resolution
- 1:15:45committee that proposed the resolution limiting the primary Republican primary to only registered Republican voters,
- 1:15:51and he joined us on Metro News talk line. John, great to
- 1:15:55talk to you again, Thanks for joining us. Why should your party's primary
- 1:16:00rule out independence and non party folks from voting as soon as May? Hoppy
- 1:16:08is great to be on with the mixed the legislative process, but it's great
- 1:16:11to be retired. Happy is probably about five reasons. One of the reasons
- 1:16:15is that in our primary election is when we determine our party leadership. We
- 1:16:20elect our executive committees that become and that in turn elects our leadership, our
- 1:16:26state chairwoman for the for the party, and I don't think we want the
- 1:16:31independent voters, the ones that are not not aligned with the Republican Party,
- 1:16:36to be determining who our leadership is. Elgin Riccardo is a great does a
- 1:16:42good job as our state chairwoman, and I don't think that we should be
- 1:16:45having the Democrats or independent voters making those types of decisions. One of the
- 1:16:53other one of the other reasons is I've chaired for the every four years we
- 1:16:57update our Republican platform. I've chaired that can be for a number of cycles
- 1:17:00over the last decade or two, and that in our platform we spell out
- 1:17:06exactly what we stand for. I mean, as a party, we are
- 1:17:10pro Second Amendment program, pro life, pro taxpayer, pro family, pro
- 1:17:15jobs, pro school choice. Those are the issues that we spell out that
- 1:17:18we stand for, and if not all Republicans may agree with every exact position,
- 1:17:26but it tell us what we stand for, and I think those are
- 1:17:29the people we want to be voting for our candidates. If we don't,
- 1:17:33we can have too much mischief if we allow non Republicans to be determining who
- 1:17:41are Republican nominees are going to be running in the fall, John, And
- 1:17:45look, those are all very valid points. In other words, Republicans should
- 1:17:50decide who the Republican nominees are going to be. I get that, But
- 1:17:55also, you've been around a long time. You were a member of this
- 1:17:58West Virginia Legislature, John, when there was just a handful of Republicans.
- 1:18:01Republicans did a couple things to expand their base and their reach, and one
- 1:18:08of the things was they opened up the primary to independent voters. So there
- 1:18:13was maybe some lifelong Democrats who said, you know what, I'm really kind
- 1:18:15of more of a Republican, but I don't want to choose a particular party.
- 1:18:18I'll be an independent, but I'll vote loyal Republican. For years,
- 1:18:21other people signed up party loyalty ain't what it used to be, but they
- 1:18:25vote Republican. So I ask you, do you feel like this is turning
- 1:18:30your back on some of those people who've been with the Republican Party as the
- 1:18:32party has grown, well, I think we would welcome those people to become
- 1:18:40registered Republicans. There's no reason if they believe in our platform, if they
- 1:18:43believe in what we stand for, why they shouldn't be Republicans. We now
- 1:18:47have a number of people that have lost because of mischief that has been and
- 1:18:53that has occurred in our Republican primary. For example, you probably remember people
- 1:18:58like Geryl Coles or Mitch Carmichael or so Cline. They were Republican legislators and
- 1:19:05in the primary groups decided that we were going to have independent voters affect the
- 1:19:12outcome, and they got defeated. So I think we need to make sure
- 1:19:15that what we stand for as a party is spelled out and that we had
- 1:19:19people that support the majority of those those positions. Hey, John, would
- 1:19:24you be And there's some concern that's also been raised that, wow, you're
- 1:19:28thinking about changing this now for the upcoming primary when people have already announced that
- 1:19:33they're running or signed up to run under a certain understanding of what the rules
- 1:19:36are going to be. This would change the rules kind of midstream. Really,
- 1:19:42would you be willing to accept a proposal that says, Okay, we'll
- 1:19:45do this but not until the twenty twenty sixth election, or do you definitively
- 1:19:49John, want to change it for the upcoming primary? Happy? I think
- 1:19:54it should be changed now if there's too much opportunity, I mean, you
- 1:19:57saw last night in New Hampshire, independent voters pretty overwhelmingly supported Nicki Haley.
- 1:20:04And you know that was why Trump was very adamant about making sure that we
- 1:20:09have just Republicans voting to select to our Republican leadership is going to be.
- 1:20:14I have talked to people like Alex Mooney and others that have said, we
- 1:20:16will make sure that each registered independent voter is contacted as a way to make
- 1:20:24sure that they are aware of this. They will be given an opportunity to
- 1:20:28switch, or you know, they can say and not be eligible to vote
- 1:20:33in the Republican primary. I mean, we want to keep our Republican issues
- 1:20:39alive and vital and well rather than having them diluted by non Republicans helping to
- 1:20:45determine the outcome. Hey, John Overington's with us. John Overington is a
- 1:20:49former long time delegate in a long time member of the Republican parties A remember
- 1:20:54the Executive Committee's a member of the Resolutions committee that crafted this resolution. John
- 1:20:59is this is one of the motivations here. The fact that Doug scaff who
- 1:21:03is relatively well known and a former member of the legislature and a longtime Democrat
- 1:21:09switched to the Republican Party to run for Secretary of State. Is some of
- 1:21:13this rooted in the concern that people like Doug scaff might win that job,
- 1:21:17might win secret of State's race even though he was just a Democrat not long
- 1:21:21ago. Is that part of your motivation? Well, I mean, that
- 1:21:25would be one of the cases that we might look at that could where the
- 1:21:30Act could be changed, especially when you consider that in West Virginia we have
- 1:21:34someone in the last in the two thousand election, we had one hundred and
- 1:21:39seventy two thousand Republican voters. We had thirty seven thousand non affiliated that voted.
- 1:21:45Some of those may have been for Democrats, but at the same time,
- 1:21:49it shows that we need to make sure that the principles that motivate people
- 1:21:56to become Republicans are maintained. And I think we have a number of republic
- 1:22:00a number of Democrats that have said, jeez, this is now a Republican
- 1:22:04state, and we need to make sure that I'm going to switch my registration
- 1:22:09from Democrats, independent because or Republican because that's an easier way to win.
- 1:22:14So I think we need to make sure that we maintain the integrity of the
- 1:22:17issues that we have on our platform. One of the things that we'll be
- 1:22:20doing later on this year, we'll be updating our platform. We'll be having
- 1:22:26sort of town hall meetings maybe across the state, and we'll be getting input
- 1:22:30and we want to make sure that those principles that motivate people to be Republicans
- 1:22:34are maintained. John Overrington, by the way, John, again, you're
- 1:22:39no longer the legislature, but for years you introduced the death penalty, never
- 1:22:42really got much traction. Guess what. There's going to be at least two
- 1:22:45death penalty bills this year, one by Center President Craig Blair for serious fentanyl
- 1:22:49offenders and one by Mike Stewart for those who would take the life of a
- 1:22:56law enforcement officers. So you may not be here, but your death penalty
- 1:22:59bill or efforts continue. FYI hopy. We have had this discussion many times,
- 1:23:04and it's rewarding to see that the one are two issues that I did
- 1:23:10not get past during my thirty four years in the House of Delegates is being
- 1:23:14resurrected, and it's it's great to see two positions. I think especially the
- 1:23:17one that merits is the idea of somebody that kills a law enforcement officer,
- 1:23:21that certainly would merit capital plank. Thank you, sir, Thank you.
- 1:23:27The Venerable John Overington, former longtime delegate, key member of the Executive Committee
- 1:23:32of the Republican Party and backer of the proposal to limit the primaries on the
- 1:23:38Republican side starting with dismay to Republicans only. The committee will meet on Saturday
- 1:23:44and make a decision on that. There is talk line on Metro News.
- 1:23:46Metro News is the voice of West Virginia. It's eleven thirty. Let's get
- 1:23:50a news update, checking with the Metro News radio network. Final what's happening
- 1:23:54in statewide? There's hour all across the great state of West Virginia, West
- 1:24:00Virginia, Metro and ne u Z. I'm Chris Lawrence and Mix the speakers
- 1:24:03in a public hearing earlier today at the Capital over a measure that we create
- 1:24:06following penalties including fines in jail time for libraries enabling obscene material to be accessible
- 1:24:13to minors in the state. The hearing opened up with the speaker reading straight
- 1:24:16from a book that graphically discussed oral sex. Parents. Sally Radabos's children shouldn't
- 1:24:20be exposed to that kind of material. This is not what I want my
- 1:24:25kids and my grandkids to find in libraries. I want my kids to know
- 1:24:30how my grandkids to know how to do math, writing, and arithmetic.
- 1:24:35Let's get real here. Robert Delly's president of the West Virginia Education Association.
- 1:24:41He also spoke in one this would actually deter children and families from the library.
- 1:24:45My fear is people will not want to be a part of the library
- 1:24:49anymore. People will not want to go, people will not want to work
- 1:24:54in the library, and will have those opportunities for our kids taken away.
- 1:24:59Several states, it's including Arkansas, fest similar laws opening libraries to obscenity laws
- 1:25:02in recent years. US Attorney Bill Elandfeld is expected to address reporters this hour
- 1:25:08talking more about what he describes as the dismantling of a significant fentanyl trafficking operation
- 1:25:13in the Eastern Manhandle. Jason Bolfs charges against a eighty two individuals from West
- 1:25:16Virginia, Virginia and Maryland Governor Justice to be in Jackson County today, delivering
- 1:25:21just over thirteen thousand dollars for editions and renovations at Ripley Middle School, one
- 1:25:26of eighteen counties approved for work by the SBA. You're listening to Metro News
- 1:25:30the Boye of West Virginia. Thanks to all who have sent in some fantastic
- 1:25:32pictures of your hunting and fishing adventures to our Hoodoo Sports Trophy photo contest.
- 1:25:36Check out the gallery at the Outdoors page of double D metro News dot com.
- 1:25:41Also, submit your pictures now and get in on the final monthly drawing
- 1:25:45plus the grand prize drawing a Hoodoo Sports Fishing kayak, for which we'll draw
- 1:25:48during the month of February. Learn how to submit your pick by clicking the
- 1:25:51Hoodoo Sports icon at the outdoors page of dul D metro News dot com.
- 1:25:56And remember, if it's a trophy to you, it's a trophy to us.
- 1:26:00Looking forward to relaxing on your holiday break, It's also a great time
- 1:26:03to explore college, and you can do it right from your phone. We
- 1:26:06invite you to explore Fairmont State University's low tuition, great majors, carrying down
- 1:26:12to earth teacher mentors, and our friendly, laid back campus vine like what
- 1:26:16you see. Remember, applying to Fairmont State is always free, Andy's and
- 1:26:21the best part, you don't even have to leave your pouch you were born
- 1:26:26to sort. Learn more at Fairmont State dot edu. Twenty seven individuals have
- 1:26:30indicated an interest in becoming Charleston's next police chief. Mayor Amy Goodwin's office says
- 1:26:34that's the number of applicants they've gotten, eight of them within the Charleston force
- 1:26:39in nineteenth other law enforcement, including ten from out of state. The mayor
- 1:26:43will select the chief to replace Ty Hunt, who stepped out as chief but
- 1:26:45remains a lieutenant on paid administrative leave for both medical issues and he's under investigation
- 1:26:51for allegations of sexual misconduct. From the Metro News anchored ask, I'm Chris
- 1:26:58Lawrence. Some mine from the Encode Insurance Studios that's been moved to the ARP
- 1:27:17broadcast location near at the capital. Network security is serious business. City net
- 1:27:20is serious about protecting your business and your employees from today's constant barrage and cybersecurity
- 1:27:26threats. Let's sitty that be your cybersecurity hero. When it comes to technology,
- 1:27:30city net connects, protects and perfects. Coming up Tony Credi on last
- 1:27:32night's a bad loss at UCF for West Virginian. Also coming up, JB.
- 1:27:38Mccusky, the state auditor and candidate for attorney. Gentlemen, right now,
- 1:27:41a couple quick minutes with Rob Rock, retired West Virginia Wesleyan political science
- 1:27:45professor in New Hampshire. Rob, You've had a night to contemplate what happened.
- 1:27:49So what happened? Well, first of all, have you ever been
- 1:27:55to a place where they keeps talking about how great it was four years ago
- 1:27:59or eight years ago? And I mean it was extremely subdued, basically just
- 1:28:03two candidates, and Haley lost by the expected double digits. So in a
- 1:28:13sense, I think we should tell our listeners that although she hasn't withdrawn,
- 1:28:17this is going to be the longest presidential campaign, the most expensive presidential campaign,
- 1:28:24and the most personal attack campaign presidential campaign that we have all seen.
- 1:28:31Hey, Rob, And also I had Chris Starnwald on earlier from News Nation,
- 1:28:38who was there, and he seemed to sort of say, well,
- 1:28:40there's still a route for Haley. She can do this, she can do
- 1:28:44that, And I don't see it. I mean again, I'm a bit
- 1:28:45of a prisoner of the moment, but I watched the results like everybody else,
- 1:28:49I do not see it, do you? No, this was the
- 1:28:54best chance because of the large number of independent or moderate voters that she had
- 1:29:00had to pull an upset, and although she pulled in moderates and independence,
- 1:29:06she basically lost three out of everybody's four mega supporters. So what that tells
- 1:29:14me is two things that Haley does not have a route forward, number one
- 1:29:18and number two. Though it also illustrates Donald Trump's challenge going forward is not
- 1:29:23winning the nomination, but winning the general election if in fact there is a
- 1:29:27high level of either soft support or even outright dissatisfaction with independence or some Republicans.
- 1:29:35Fair. Yeah, that's it's fair because in a sense, that's the
- 1:29:40downside of Trump's victory is that is her strength and her moderates and independence,
- 1:29:47and you're going to need those in November, although and if you don't have
- 1:29:51them in the primary, you're going to have to find them in the general
- 1:29:56elections. All right. Rob Rupp, retired West Virton, Wesley and Political
- 1:30:00science professor, Safe travels back to New Hampshire. Appreciate you having coming on
- 1:30:03this week. It's good to talk to you. Thanks, Rob, Take
- 1:30:05good care. I want to bring in state audit to JB. Mccusky,
- 1:30:10who is running for the Republican nomination for Attorney General. JB. Good morning,
- 1:30:13How are you? I'm good, hoppy. I think this election's about
- 1:30:16as over as the WVU game was at halftime yesterday, maybe before halftime.
- 1:30:20Are you a Trump guy? Yeah? I think at this moment, everyone
- 1:30:25who's committed to defeating Joe Biden in the November election needs to coalesce around the
- 1:30:30guy that's gonna win. What kind of go ahead? I'm sorry, no,
- 1:30:32I mean, if you're looking at the way that the country's going,
- 1:30:35I mean, my wife and I have a small business. And if you're
- 1:30:39somebody who is employing people and selling things in this country right now and you
- 1:30:45can't feel the inflation and you can't feel the trepidation and the consumers spending,
- 1:30:49you know you need to take a good, hard look at what's going on.
- 1:30:53And I think, you know Donald Trump's record of making sure that our
- 1:30:57economy was powerful and that our borders were secure, and that our country was
- 1:31:02safer than it is today, it matters, and it's time for us to
- 1:31:08coalesce around the guy that's going to beat Joe Biden. JB. Mccusky's with
- 1:31:12his auditor and candidate for the Republican nomination for Attorney general. What kind of
- 1:31:15ag would you be? Would you be a Morrissey attorney General who is very
- 1:31:19active in filing lawsuits and challenging a variety of public policies from various administrations,
- 1:31:27or would you be let's focus on what's happening in the state. Yeah,
- 1:31:30I mean, I think there's no reason to not be both. And the
- 1:31:32way that I look at being the attorney general is that we have this incredible
- 1:31:36opportunity in front of us right now. We have economic development happening like we
- 1:31:41haven't seen in my lifetime. We're cutting ribbons at a frenetic pace. But
- 1:31:45people want to be here, not because of the economic development opportunities necessarily,
- 1:31:50but because this is one of the last places in America where a young family
- 1:31:55who wants to live in relative freedom can move to right. And we have
- 1:32:00to be able to pretend, pretend, excuse me, protect what it means
- 1:32:03to be West Virginia. And that is one of the key things that the
- 1:32:08next Attorney General is going to have to do, because when you look at
- 1:32:11what Washington does, and you look at what New York and California are doing,
- 1:32:14people are fleeing those states, and they're fleeing them for a reason,
- 1:32:16and so we need to be able to grow by saying to people, West
- 1:32:19Virginia is a great place for a young family to come and live because we
- 1:32:24have an incredible value set that people want to be around, and a value
- 1:32:28set that doesn't really exist in the rest of the country anymore. JB.
- 1:32:30Mccuskey's with his auditor and Republican candidate for Attorney general, whoever the attorney general
- 1:32:35is, he or she would defend the state if the state gets sued there
- 1:32:41was a litigation. So there are at least two bills that would bring back
- 1:32:45the death penalty in West Virginia, one by Mike Stewart and one by the
- 1:32:48Center President Craig Blair. Haven't moved yet, but they're out there. So
- 1:32:51A, what is your position on the death penalty? And b would you
- 1:32:55be in a position would your office be in a position to defend this state
- 1:33:00because inevitably there would be a challenge to the death penalty. Sure, so
- 1:33:02the attorney general defends the legislature. Right, So, the legislature passes laws,
- 1:33:06and the attorney general's job is to make sure that those laws are defended
- 1:33:10against people who don't see them. The same way as the legislature. Right,
- 1:33:15And it's very obvious that the death penalty is constitutional. It's been held
- 1:33:17constitutional for years, it is being practiced in states all across the country.
- 1:33:23The trick to the death penalty's legality is it has to apply uniformly, and
- 1:33:28it has to apply fairly, and it has to apply in situations where the
- 1:33:32founders believed that it should. And I haven't poured through Senator Stuart or Senator
- 1:33:41Blair's bills, But if the majority of our legislators believe that that is the
- 1:33:46right way to go, then the Attorney General will absolutely defend their decision.
- 1:33:49Yeah, you would have to do that regardless of your personal belief. But
- 1:33:51do you have a personal belief on the issue. My personal belief on the
- 1:33:56issue is that it's sort of nuanced. But the death penalty works a lot
- 1:34:00better in a world where things are guaranteed right, and so we have a
- 1:34:05long history of unfortunately, certain people in law enforcement in West Virginia who have
- 1:34:12well, the Fred Zaane story, the Fred Zane story, right. I
- 1:34:15think we're in a better place than that now, but it's very difficult for
- 1:34:19my brain to get past the idea that one slip up in a death penalty
- 1:34:26case sort of negates the entire concept that certain people shouldn't be allowed to live
- 1:34:30after the crimes that they committed. Do I believe that absolutely there are certain
- 1:34:33people who should be put to death, but we need to make sure we
- 1:34:36have a system that is designed to get it right every single time. For
- 1:34:41those who don't remember. And it's been a while, Fred Zayne was a
- 1:34:45state police crime lab zerologist and the falsified evidence in cases and a lot of
- 1:34:48people just the cases. Lots of cases, Yeah, lots of cases and
- 1:34:51the state and people went to jail on evidence that was falsified by Zane and
- 1:34:59they have those people have got released. There were damages paid, et cetera,
- 1:35:01et cetera. So Fred Zanes for the poster child for what can go
- 1:35:04wrong in a judicial system. And if somebody was jailed improperly, they can
- 1:35:10be released, they can be compensated. You can't do that with the death
- 1:35:13penalty. You can't roll that back. Well, the compensation part can still
- 1:35:16exist if it was found to be improper and the compensation, my gut would
- 1:35:20be very very very large. Yeah, Okay. Also, just again I'm
- 1:35:25throwing stuff at you. They're hypotheticals, but there are there's consideration right now
- 1:35:31to criminalizing behavior by librarians if they would allow certain materials to be posted or
- 1:35:41be available in the library that miners would have access to. That would be
- 1:35:45another thing where the Attorney General may have to defend the state. Now I
- 1:35:48catch you off guard, because that is just starting to be talked about here.
- 1:35:51Yeah, I actually don't know what you're talking about. But isn't it
- 1:35:55already illegal to show illicit material to minors? It is, but there is
- 1:36:00an exemption. There's an exemption for public schools and libraries and museums. So
- 1:36:04this, this bill would take away that exemption. Well, the exemption couldn't
- 1:36:09possibly mean that you're allowed to do it. It must be in certain very
- 1:36:12limited circumstances. Yes, yes, okay, so yeah, I don't want
- 1:36:15people showing lude pictures to kids. No, I know, I know,
- 1:36:18So I just okay, okay, just keeping it that, sorry, keep
- 1:36:20an eye out for that. Hey, let me ask you a party issue.
- 1:36:24You're a Republican. I just talked to John Overington and he is a
- 1:36:30member of the party executive committee. The party executive committee is going to meet
- 1:36:31Saturday, and they're going to take up the proposal to limit the Republican primary
- 1:36:36to Republicans only starting with this primary, so that non affiliated voters and independents
- 1:36:44could not vote in the primary. Do you support or are you an executive
- 1:36:45committee? By the way, now, I'm not, and I'm going to
- 1:36:47let them do their thing. My opinion on the issue is is that I
- 1:36:51campaign on who I am about what my value said is now that you're a
- 1:36:56Republican I am, you're in a position where where you would be directly affected
- 1:37:00by that erectly affected. Yeah, I think I have an appeal that applies
- 1:37:04both to Republicans and independents. So I feel really really great about my electoral
- 1:37:09pathway either way. So you would want you would want independence to vote.
- 1:37:13I mean, that's the way it is now. You wouldn't want that.
- 1:37:15I would say that it feels like we're winning a lot right now, and
- 1:37:18winning isn't always, is that what you're saying? Yeah, Republicans are winning
- 1:37:24big lelys, as we might say in these days, and you know,
- 1:37:27if that's the way they want to go, I'll support their decision. And
- 1:37:30I'm not on the executive committee. SUD should the attorney general have prosecutoral powers.
- 1:37:34No. The reason the reason is is because I'm a constitutional conservative,
- 1:37:39and the people that drew up our constitution and founded this state believe that our
- 1:37:44local prosecutors and our local sheriffs and our local law enforcement had a much better
- 1:37:47way of prosecuting crimes that happened in their jurisdictions. And I'm I am fully
- 1:37:51supportive of the idea that the attorney general should be supportive and be an incredible
- 1:37:58support staff for our law enforcement and our prosecutors. But the system works,
- 1:38:01and our prosecutors are great, and our sheriffs are great, and our law
- 1:38:04enforcement throughout the state is great, and so for me, and we do
- 1:38:08this in the Auditor's office now. We created the Public Integrity and Fraud Unit.
- 1:38:11It's the most successful fraud fighting organization in the state. And we can't.
- 1:38:15I could prosecute cases right now. I'm the only constitutional officer that's allowed
- 1:38:18to, but I don't. And the reason is is because it works better
- 1:38:23when we support our local prosecute. JB McCuskey, currently the auditor, Republican
- 1:38:28candidate for Attorney General. JB. Good to see you. Good to see
- 1:38:30you too, Hoppy thank you, thank you, thanks for coming on.
- 1:38:32You know, the weekend's almost here and it would be great to relax on
- 1:38:35a pontoon boat from lou Wendell Marine this weekend. Check out through inventory at
- 1:38:41Louwindelmarne Sales dot com. We're coming right back. It's good to have options
- 1:38:45when choosing health coverage for your family, your employees, and your company.
- 1:38:53You want to plan with people you know, like The Health Plan, known
- 1:38:59for exceptional local customer service and are headquartered right here in West Virginia. We
- 1:39:05are families, we are businesses, and we are all moving forward together.
- 1:39:12We are here for you the Health Plan. As our beloved state gears out
- 1:39:16for another election, it's important to know who you were voting for. Just
- 1:39:19Tailey Bun is a multi generational West Virginia Coming from a family of coal miners,
- 1:39:25Justice Bun understands our West Virginian values. Her legal career include several years
- 1:39:29in private practice and seven years as a federal prosecutor fighting violent crime and the
- 1:39:33opioid epidemic. For being appointed to the Supreme Court in twenty twenty two,
- 1:39:38she has been her career fighting for the rule of law, faith and integrity.
- 1:39:41Vote Justice Hailey Bun for West Virginia Supreme Court, paid for by Hailey
- 1:39:44Bun for West Virginia. West Virginia is home. It's where we work,
- 1:39:48live and raise our families. At the heart of our communities are West Virginia
- 1:39:55Hospitals and very compassionate caregivers. From life saving treatments and emerging see care to
- 1:40:00wellness support and screening services. We are improving your quality of life through extraordinary
- 1:40:05achievements and amazing results West Virginia Hospitals. Your health is the heartbeat of our
- 1:40:13communities. This is talk Line on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia.
- 1:40:16When kids are small, we tend to spend most of our time saying
- 1:40:19no instead of yes. As our parents and grandparents' age, we sometimes say
- 1:40:25no to visits instead of yes. Life can be overwhelming, and sometimes it's
- 1:40:30nice to say yes to making memories and starting a future. By playing the
- 1:40:33West Virginia Lottery, you're saying yes to tomorrow's leaders and today's seniors and furthering
- 1:40:40the beauty of the Mountain State. When you play, you say yes to
- 1:40:44West Virginia. From a young age, math influences our lives to create,
- 1:40:51to build from scratch. With MATH, I'll learn to persevere. I learned
- 1:40:56to try again. With MATH, I can move. I learned to identify
- 1:41:00problems in the real world around me and find unique solutions. With MATH,
- 1:41:05I succeed. With math, I succeed. They confident. Take the pledge
- 1:41:13MATH for Life. Goalkeeper gives me a responsibility that I want to get anywhere
- 1:41:21else on the field. Nothing else is important except how you're going to help
- 1:41:25your team. I'll never get to win a game, but I'll keep us
- 1:41:27from losing a game. My reason why is competition. When it comes to
- 1:41:32vaping, the truth can get clouded. So let's make it clear. Vaping
- 1:41:36is not safe for youth because vaping can put microscopic particles into your lungs and
- 1:41:42dangerous things like metals into your body, and nicotine, which can harm a
- 1:41:45person's brain development. Through their mid twenties. With appeeling flavors, high nicotine
- 1:41:49levels, and lots of promotion on social media, many kids think vaping is
- 1:41:54harmless, but it's not. So talk to your kids about the risks of
- 1:41:57vaping, because when you talk, they hear you. From a young age,
- 1:42:04my passion for soccer was always greater than anything else I was doing,
- 1:42:09knowing that it's a team effort to belong to something greater than yourself. I
- 1:42:12just love playing the game. My reason why is passion. Metro News talk
- 1:42:31Line with Hoppy Kirchible is brought to you by Encovia Insurance, encircling you with
- 1:42:36coverage to protect what you care about most. Visiting covid dot com to learn
- 1:42:41more about ten Years Lost seventy two fifty nine to UCF. Last night,
- 1:42:45Tony Greedy, of course, had to play by play on Radio Tony Good
- 1:42:50Morning. How long did it take after that big game began for you to
- 1:42:56think, oh, oh, this is going to be bad. Oh I
- 1:43:00don't know how to be bad. But I thought when I watched UCF warm
- 1:43:04up that they were older, stronger, and I knew that they were going
- 1:43:11to be extremely physical. And then you throw in the size that they have
- 1:43:14six ten or six eleven and a seventh footer. I knew that was going
- 1:43:17to be a problem going into the game. And then when the game began,
- 1:43:21you know how these are kind of like prize fights. When the bell
- 1:43:25rings, it's on and there are no excuses. And I think that UCF,
- 1:43:30based upon its situation. Having just had its poorest game of the season
- 1:43:33against Houston on Saturday, they were ready to go. And as a result
- 1:43:39of that, I think a couple things. You know, we oftentimes talk
- 1:43:41about three guys before the game talked about the situational situation, and that's what
- 1:43:46Brad Howe talks about. Well, the situation was UCF just got embarrassed.
- 1:43:50They scored forty two points of Houston. West Virginia had a huge win against
- 1:43:55Kansas, and everyone was patting them on the back for three days. And
- 1:43:59when it got on and UCFS on its home court, they were going out
- 1:44:02there and bringing it right from the beginning. And I think it caught West
- 1:44:05Virginia. And this is not a physical West Virginia team, and as a
- 1:44:10result of that, they get bumped around, they get caught off their game,
- 1:44:14and before you know it, it's a problem. And so I think
- 1:44:16that was a lot of what happened last night. Yeah, West Virginia did
- 1:44:19not answer the bell. And as we've talked about many, many times,
- 1:44:23it is very hard to pick up a performance, because the Kansas game was
- 1:44:26their best performance of the season. To pick it up, take it someplace
- 1:44:30else on the road, and recreate that and it just didn't happen. I
- 1:44:33thought they would be better than that, but again bad situation did not answer
- 1:44:39the bell. Now what well, now what hopped is you got to go
- 1:44:44back on the road, unfortunately, and Oklahoma State is next, and they
- 1:44:47gave TCU a really good game last night. They led probably for more more
- 1:44:51time than they trailed in that game last night, the TCU prevailed, and
- 1:44:56so you got to try to find a way, you know, to go
- 1:44:58out onto the road and get it's something that you haven't gotten yet, and
- 1:45:00that's true road victory. And then you come home next week for Cincinnati and
- 1:45:03BYU. There's nothing easy. I mean, Cincinnati very similar in that line
- 1:45:10of being physical and big as UCF was, and BYU is playing really well.
- 1:45:16Also they did get beat last night at home against Houston, but Houston's
- 1:45:20a really really good team. So again, nothing that we don't know,
- 1:45:24not an easy league. One thing you do have going for you here is
- 1:45:28it looks as though we're really close to getting Jesse Edwards and Josh Eiler alluded
- 1:45:31to that that he might go on Saturday, and so at least that would
- 1:45:34give you some sense of a physical five man that at least will warrant opposing
- 1:45:41teams to defend, and then you kind of see what you have there.
- 1:45:44Tony Kreedy's with his last night seventy two to fifty nine loss to UCF.
- 1:45:48What was the double technical on Rayquan? Was that just a matter of saying
- 1:45:51things to the refs that run into his mouth? I mean, you were
- 1:45:55there, did you hear anything? So in that case, Hopy, I
- 1:46:00think it's the boiled water analogy. I think he was simmering at about two
- 1:46:03eight, two oh nine, frustrated that he was not getting calls, and
- 1:46:06then he reached over two eleven, got to two twelve, and he boiled
- 1:46:11over and he let the official know it. And you know, Josh I
- 1:46:15thought handled it well. Post game he said absolutely not acceptable. No one
- 1:46:18knows that's not acceptable. But I can understand. And he didn't make any
- 1:46:23excuses for him. I mean I can understand. I see what you had
- 1:47:10set and play the other way because you're not gonna get any benefits of the
- 1:47:13doubt. Tony. That's a really really great point, and especially with the
- 1:47:16way like ray Kwan plays, I mean he's gonna drive, he's gonna he's
- 1:47:19a score or so there's gonna be a lot of contact. And if you're
- 1:47:24not getting the calls or they're not gonna call it that way, they just
- 1:47:27aren't. And the more you complain, the less likely it is. I
- 1:47:30mean it's a real Yes, it's objective, but it's objective in a subjective
- 1:47:34way. I mean, you're just you're not gonna get it. You know,
- 1:47:38you're just you take a look at the free throw shooting and we kind
- 1:47:42of smile about it after the Kansas game that we made more free throws than
- 1:47:45Kansas attempted. Well, the opposite happened last night to dou wvu uh Uf
- 1:47:51made more free throws than West Virginia attempted. Because you know, we come
- 1:47:55to a lot of files because they've got bigs. They get their bigs inside,
- 1:47:58they turn, they post up with follow them. We send their big
- 1:48:00guy. Line Diallo is a less than sixty percent free throw shooter, and
- 1:48:04he looked like Steph Curry last night. Just kept raining him down. And
- 1:48:09so you had one of those nights. You know, it's pretty amazing,
- 1:48:12Bob score to take a look at it. They only met one more field
- 1:48:14goal than West Virginia. It was the free throw shooting. It was not
- 1:48:18getting back fast break points. It was like eighteen to two. Rebounding advantage
- 1:48:24was double figures. All of the things that you have to be able to
- 1:48:28do rebounding Kansas for West they were right there, Wilson. And last night
- 1:48:32you get beat by double figures on board, you can't win. Yeah,
- 1:48:36yeah, all very good points. All right, Tony, Tony coreedi on
- 1:48:40West Virginia seventy two to fifty nine loss last meeting last night, Thanks Tony.
- 1:48:44Talk line continues from the Upper Road ton of the State Capitol and the
- 1:48:46AARP broadcast location after this. Every house tells a story, and that's where
- 1:48:51I come in. My name is Aaron Weston, and my husband not in
- 1:48:55calendar construction in Charleston. I'm also a West Virginia Promise Scholarship recipient. After
- 1:48:59a from WU, I knew I wanted to carve a career in West Virginia,
- 1:49:02building a small business and helping people see the potential in their home.
- 1:49:06Now that's a great story. Proceeds from the West Virginia Lottery have helped generate
- 1:49:11nearly eight hundred and seventy six million dollars to Promise scholarships since two thousand and
- 1:49:15two for students like Aaron West Virginia Lottery. What if you play? It's
- 1:49:20good to have options when choosing health coverage for your family, your employees,
- 1:49:27and your company. You want to plan with people you know, like the
- 1:49:32Health Plan, known for exceptional local customer service and are headquartered right here in
- 1:49:40West Virginia. We are families, we are businesses, and we are all
- 1:49:45moving forward together. We are here for you a Health Plan. Golf Week
- 1:49:51called Pete Die Golf Club one of America's best modern courses. Digest recently called
- 1:49:57Pete Die one of America's one hundred greatest courses. Pete Dye calls at eighteen
- 1:50:00of the most exciting and memorable holes I've ever built on one course. Pete
- 1:50:05Die Golf Club invites you to join the only course named after the legendary designer
- 1:50:10himself. National, corporate and local memberships available now for a limited time.
- 1:50:15Visit Petdie dot com to learn more. Come play where the Mountaineers play at
- 1:50:18Pete Die Golf Club. You're listening to talk Line on Metro News, the
- 1:50:23Voice of West Virginia. It's the late nights, it's their early mornings.
- 1:50:30It's working in the sunshine and rain and snow. It's the dedication, the
- 1:50:40care, the hours of training that led to the Winner's circle. It's our
- 1:50:45job, our passion, our lives. We are the horsemen. Ruth Pharmacy
- 1:50:56offers a local prescription delivery. Call your Bruth today and prescription delivery. You
- 1:51:00could also get items like milk, paper, towels, vitamins and more delivered
- 1:51:04right to your door. Ruth your hometown Family Pharmacy. West Virginia is home.
- 1:51:12It's where we work, live and raise our families. At the heart
- 1:51:16of our communities are West Virginia Hospitals and they're compassionate caregivers, from life saving
- 1:51:23treatments and emergency care to wellness support and screening services. We are improving your
- 1:51:29quality of life through extraordinary achievements and amazing results. West Virginia Hospitals, Your
- 1:51:34health is the heartbeat of our communities. I'm Rusty and I'm the owner of
- 1:51:42Mountain A Rostlo. I discovered a passion for coffee during a study broad trip
- 1:51:46to Nicaragua. I wanted to take that passion to grow the coffee industry here
- 1:51:50in my home state. A huge part of making that possible was the promise
- 1:51:54scholarship that I received. I'm really proud that our coffee is statewide and even
- 1:51:58in our state parks. Proceeds from the West Virginia Lottery has helped generate more
- 1:52:02than three point seven billion in education for students like Rusty. When you play,
- 1:52:06you say yes to West Virginia. Ruth Pharmacy offers a local prescription delivery.
- 1:52:13Call your Fruth today and schedule your prescription delivery. You can also get
- 1:52:16items like milk, paper, towels, vitamins, and more delivered right to
- 1:52:19your door. Ruth your hometown family Pharmacy. Gotta keep them. It's online
- 1:52:41from AARP broadcast location in co Insurance Studios w give you Medicine Children for lots
- 1:52:47of most advanced surgical and non surgical solutions for chest wall problems. Their expert
- 1:52:55team creates a comprehensive customized care plan for your child and their pediatrics surgeons use
- 1:53:00the latest techniques in chest wall surgery that minimize pain and promote faster healing so
- 1:53:05your child can get back to being a kid again soon. Called eight five
- 1:53:10five WVU Care or visit WVU kids dot Com. Okay, fascinating show today.
- 1:53:15With some really interesting things happening here at the West Virginia State Capitol.
- 1:53:19We will keep an eye on them, and the plans are to return here
- 1:53:23tomorrow, broadcasting live from the upper Rotunda of the West Virginia State Capitol.
- 1:53:29Jeff, thank you, good job. Austin back in Morgantown along with Dave
- 1:53:31Wilson. I will see you tomorrow from the Capitol. This is talk Line
- 1:53:35on Metro News. Metro News is the voice of West Virginia.