Latest / Shiny New Object - a Marketing Podcast / You're optimising the story out of your ads - ft. Roey Franco
Transcript
- 0:00Tom Ollerton: Hello and welcome to the Shiny New Object Podcast.
- 0:03My name is Tom Ollerton. I'm the founder of Automated Creative,
- 0:06the fastest way to create scale and test performance ads, and
- 0:09this is a weekly podcast about the future of data-driven
- 0:13marketing. Every week or so, I have the pleasure and the
- 0:15privilege of interviewing one of our industry's leaders, and this
- 0:18week is no different. I'm on a call with Roey Franco, who is an
- 0:22ad industry consultant who I got to know quite recently. A lovely
- 0:25fella, and I said, "Please go on the podcast." And here he is. So
- 0:29Roey, for anyone who doesn't know who you are and what you
- 0:31do, can you give us a bit of background?
- 0:33Roey Franco: Of course. Hey, Tom, thanks for having me. So as
- 0:35you said, I'm Roey Franco. I've spent around 20 years in the
- 0:39advertising industry building ad products, I would say I crossed
- 0:43almost every seat at the table, from platforms side at Sizmek
- 0:47and Undertone and in between a founding member of a very, very
- 0:51small start-up that we launched, I would argue one of the first
- 0:54WYSIWYG type HTML5 ad builders into market. After that, I was
- 0:58on the agency side, Xaxis leading product and innovation,
- 1:02looking at the emerging channels, gaming, audio, digital
- 1:05out-of-home, built a... omni channel digital out-of-home
- 1:09platform and a solution suite within WPP called Sightline. And
- 1:12then I moved into the out-of-home space where I spent
- 1:16some time at Firefly, leading the product and marketing groups
- 1:19building out-of-home measurement solutions across mobility and
- 1:23beyond. Then I moved to a company named Publishers
- 1:26Clearing House, where I had the role of a Chief Product Officer,
- 1:30Sweepstake company, a very legacy name brand in the U.S.
- 1:34Millions of daily users across mobile apps, desktop
- 1:37environments, allowing users to engage with our content and in
- 1:40the exchange they get tokens and the chance to win millions of
- 1:44dollars. Company gave away 600 plus million dollars throughout
- 1:48its lifetime, and recently at Publicis running DCO.
- 1:51Tom Ollerton: Right, Roey, you've done everything, so
- 1:54you're going to get a grilling from me on this podcast, not
- 1:58really, but... So across all of those roles, what new belief or
- 2:04behaviour has made your work life better in the last five
- 2:08years or so?
- 2:09Roey Franco: Yeah, I think five years is very timely for this
- 2:12question because the new belief that I, helped me improve with
- 2:15my work is that I can build the thing, I can build it myself.
- 2:18I'm a product person. I'm not an engineer. I can do enough damage
- 2:21on the engineering side, but this is not my role where in the
- 2:24past five or six years ago, I used to build a deck and build
- 2:28the use case and the business case for your product. Now you
- 2:32can build it and you should be building it, whether it's a
- 2:35mock-up, whether it's MVP, whether it's a functional
- 2:38mock-up that actually shows a flow and not just a screenshot.
- 2:41It cuts through, I understand that dynamic of cutting through
- 2:45design and engineering sometimes, but obviously it
- 2:48doesn't cover that entire space. It's not a fully functional
- 2:51product. It's not secure yet. It's not integrated with
- 2:54whatever platforms you, it needs to be at the end, but I think it
- 2:57gives a very, very tangible way for whoever you're presenting
- 3:02this to and trying to get their buy-in, to see the actual vision
- 3:05that you had come to life without having them go through
- 3:08the practice of, I need to imagine what this would look
- 3:10like, go to a designer, and back and forth and this whole process
- 3:14takes months or weeks sometimes.
- 3:17Tom Ollerton: How are you finding the overwhelm of that?
- 3:19Because yes, you can build a prototype. You can vibe code a
- 3:23thing to make it look like a thing, an app, a website,
- 3:25whatever, but then all of those ideas that you ever had that you
- 3:29can just make up, you can make come to life to a degree are all
- 3:33there. So like, how then? Because I was talking to them
- 3:35about this and they said, "It's amazing. You can make anything
- 3:37you want." And they said, "But should you?" You know, but
- 3:40should you make that thing? Like, how do you decide what to
- 3:43make and what to think, well, may be leave?
- 3:46Roey Franco: Yeah. So I think, like I said, from buy-in within
- 3:50a company, when you build a specific or when you design or
- 3:54trying to pitch a specific product internally or
- 3:56externally, sometimes, there's a level of functionality, I think,
- 4:00and tangibility of the product that you can build that, again,
- 4:03is not production ready yet, but the client can now see it and
- 4:06imagine it. The trade-off is the client might say, "Great, I want
- 4:10access to this tomorrow. Can you do this?" And you need to be in
- 4:14a position where you can say, "Let's set expectations. This is
- 4:17not ready yet. This is a prototype." But making sure the
- 4:21engineering team is aware of these things and like I said,
- 4:23you might be able to be in a position now where you're
- 4:26essentially stepping on other disciplines' toes in the process
- 4:29and getting into realms that are not owned by you. I think it's,
- 4:34it's the type of friction that needs to happen, obviously in a
- 4:37respectful way. But at the same time, I would argue engineers
- 4:40can do the same thing. They can start building these prototypes
- 4:42and designers can now show you a functional mock-up of what they
- 4:47were thinking of and not just the Figma link. Even in Figma
- 4:50you can build, you know, dynamic or interactive elements for a
- 4:53couple, last couple of years. So that's kind of where I see it.
- 4:56Obviously, you can now build simultaneously multiple
- 4:59products, multiple versions of it, multiple UX versions of it.
- 5:03That I think, is where that experience comes from and common
- 5:06sense. And then the human touch, which is I'm going to focus on
- 5:09what needs to be done in this product, getting that client
- 5:12feedback and being able to now literally spend an hour and say,
- 5:16"Was this what you meant when you said you want X, Y and Z?"
- 5:20And then the client can give you the direction or kind of course
- 5:23correct through that.
- 5:24Tom Ollerton: So moving on from vibe coding your every thought
- 5:29into reality. When it comes to data driven marketing
- 5:32specifically, what is the best bit of advice that you find
- 5:36yourself sharing most often when it comes to that particular
- 5:40discipline?
- 5:40Roey Franco: Yeah, I mean, the one I would actually share was
- 5:44that I asked a lot of marketers was not to make any assumptions
- 5:47about who your customers are and what they want. I've seen a lot
- 5:50of brands and companies, sometimes justifiably, sometimes
- 5:54not like obsess over the here's the exact persona of the person
- 5:58who was buying this product at the end of the day based on
- 6:00assumptions we made or based on different data points that we
- 6:03were able to collect about, you know, historic purchase
- 6:05behaviour I would argue that at the end of the day, audience
- 6:08segmentation is obviously super important. But I... creative and
- 6:12again this is how we met, I think creative optimisation and
- 6:15being able to do creative level data driven assumptions is
- 6:20probably the key aspect to it. That said, now we have the
- 6:24technology and the capability of AB testing, not just different
- 6:27versions of creatives but every single element, taking the
- 6:30creative and breaking it into dozens of elements and trying to
- 6:34optimise each one of them. At the end of the day, it's not
- 6:37just looking at the data and saying this is what we should
- 6:39do, because again at the end, you will have an output which is
- 6:42a Frankenstein of a logo in this colour and the font this size.
- 6:48Just because the data showed it to you doesn't mean that this is
- 6:50what a human will actually enjoy or being persuaded by. So that's
- 6:54where the human touch comes in, which is first trying to filter
- 6:57out what's the noise even in the creative aspect, and then find
- 7:00what the actionable aspect of it. And I think that the bottom
- 7:04line is all the atoms or like atomised versions or elements
- 7:09within the ad should at the end of the day come up to add up to
- 7:11a story at the end of the day, even while you're optimising
- 7:14them. So I would argue that, I think, just to summarise, I
- 7:19think data or data driven marketers should look at the, at
- 7:22the creative at that level of granularity, but at the same
- 7:26time keep that story in mind of what the creative agency
- 7:29actually wanted to deliver and what the brand message needs to
- 7:32be.
- 7:33Tom Ollerton: We released a book last year called Using
- 7:37Creativity and Data in Marketing published by Kogan
- 7:40Page, and I was interviewing the name of the fellow, was it...
- 7:45but he said the interesting thing about multivariate
- 7:48retesting and personalisation is that unless everyone who sees
- 7:53the ad agrees what that brand is, then it's not doing the job.
- 7:57So if we all agree that Ferrari is what sexy people drive, as
- 8:02long as if everyone sees that, it gets that message, then if I
- 8:05buy that car, I must be by default a sexy guy for having
- 8:09that car by an example. But if you get an ad that says this is
- 8:12a reliable car and someone else gets an advert and this is an
- 8:15economical car, then everyone has a different idea of what a
- 8:18Ferrari is. So we might optimise to the click or the conversion
- 8:21or whatever, but in actual fact, a brand exists to represent a
- 8:25thing. So it's really interesting to hear you say
- 8:27that, yes, you can't optimise something into some horrible
- 8:30caricature of a logo, but you need to be able to remove the
- 8:33noise and find the creative element that works whilst
- 8:35preserving the central idea or the story, as you put it, that
- 8:39everyone agrees on.
- 8:41Roey Franco: Yep, exactly.
- 8:42Tom Ollerton: So we're going to move on now to your shiny new
- 8:45object, which is weird, right? I still don't understand why
- 8:48you've chosen this, and I want to find out. So your shiny new
- 8:51object is Capsule, right? Which I learnt about only very
- 8:54recently. What is Capsule and why have you chosen it as
- 9:00something that represents the future of the data-driven
- 9:02marketing?
- 9:03Roey Franco: Yeah. So Capsule, just to give the audience some
- 9:05context is a, is a company servicing the US, mostly in the
- 9:09health care industry, and the idea is that they replace your
- 9:12pharmacy. Sounds crazy. It's a digital product. They don't have
- 9:16physical places that you can go and pick up your prescription,
- 9:20but I'll tell the story kind of why I think it ties into
- 9:23marketing and why I think that marketing, the marketing tactic
- 9:26that they took was very interesting and appealing to me.
- 9:30And at the end of the day, I'm sold on it and I'm telling all
- 9:33my friends about it. I'm not sponsored by Capsule. I'm a very
- 9:37happy customer of them. In the U.S., you go to a doctor, they
- 9:40prescribe a drug for you. Usually they would ask you,
- 9:43where is your pharmacy? Which pharmacy is where you pick up
- 9:47your drugs? You give them an address and they tell you, okay,
- 9:50that your prescription is going to be ready in a couple of hours
- 9:54or days, and you can go pick it up. Then you're into this,
- 9:58that's like pretty old school version of, you know, you need
- 10:01to either take some time off work, do it before work, after
- 10:05work, go to your pharmacy, pick up your prescription. And then
- 10:08that's kind of how it goes. I think why they identify- One. A
- 10:12couple of things happened. You move between companies, your
- 10:15insurance changes, you move an apartment your closest pharmacy
- 10:19changes from an address perspective, I had cases where I
- 10:22accidentally sent prescriptions to older or closer to my older
- 10:26address' pharmacies, just a little bit of a hassle in that
- 10:29sense. Pharmacy I've seen ads for them all over, usually on
- 10:33subway cars in the city and all kinds of billboards in the city,
- 10:36didn't really pay attention to that until I switched to a new
- 10:40insurance that sent me a note and said, all you need to do in
- 10:43order to enable the service is next time you go to a doctor,
- 10:47and if they prescribe something for you and they ask you, where
- 10:51is your pharmacy? You just say Capsule. That's it. You don't
- 10:54have to do anything else beyond that. And I said, okay, I'm
- 10:58going to give it a try. Went to a doctor, prescribed me a
- 11:01medicine, I said, Capsule. The next thing that happened is I
- 11:04didn't have to download any app or any type of service. I got a
- 11:08text message because they have my phone number in the doctor's
- 11:12records and he said in a very kind of human voice, "Hi, this
- 11:15is X from Capsule. We have your address. Is this address, is
- 11:19this correct?" I said, "Yes." "Great. We have your
- 11:22prescription ready. When is a good time for us to come in? And
- 11:25here are some time frames today. Delivery is free." Someone
- 11:29knocks on your door and gives you the medicine. If you need to
- 11:32renew it, you can do it through the app super easily. And that's
- 11:36it. It solved a tiny inconvenience in my life
- 11:39personally, and I'm assuming other people as well, and the
- 11:42reason I thought it was tying really interestingly to
- 11:45marketing is that they doubled down on the, more of the
- 11:48experiential part of the, the marketing aspect of it. So, for
- 11:52example, if I comparing it to other brands that sell you a
- 11:55service from a digital marketing perspective, what I was sold on
- 11:59as the end of the funnel. I would say the bottom of the
- 12:02funnel, which is, which was in the past, was purchase. For me
- 12:06now it's advocacy. I'm telling all my friends about this. I'm
- 12:09telling my family, you should use this service now because it
- 12:13will improve your life in X percent of the time. Again, I
- 12:16found this whole path interesting because I was aware
- 12:19of the company that wasn't was driving me to download their app
- 12:23and test it. What happened was that my health insurance told me
- 12:27to use them, so they were pushing me from that direction
- 12:30and the friction was basically zero at the doctor's office.
- 12:34They said, "Okay, Capsule." That's it. So I think they did a
- 12:37really good job at educating the healthcare system as well as the
- 12:41healthcare providers or employers to basically just tell
- 12:44you, hey, this is what you should do.
- 12:46Tom Ollerton: How does it work, though, physically? Do they have
- 12:49like a warehouse of loads of pills in it?
- 12:51Roey Franco: I'm assuming so. I'm assuming either someone
- 12:53picks it up from, from a facility, but I didn't get
- 12:57marked up on the charge. I didn't get to pay any fee. You
- 13:01can tip the, the person who's providing you the medicine, but
- 13:05the whole experience was efficient. Cost-efficient.
- 13:07Tom Ollerton: So how do they make their money then if there's
- 13:09no markup?
- 13:10Roey Franco: So I'm assuming they do, they do have some
- 13:13mark-up on the- Either they get paid by the healthcare insurance
- 13:16company to deliver that. Yeah, it's a very interesting
- 13:19question. Again, I'm assuming some medicine that you take cost
- 13:22way more than what I generically use, but it's a very interesting
- 13:25business model, and like I said, the delivery is free so, and
- 13:28it's everywhere in the city assuming in the US and also
- 13:31multiple times during the day so...
- 13:33Tom Ollerton: We talk about this a lot at Automated Creative
- 13:35about like whenever we design our product so we're always
- 13:39trying to make sure that it's a painkiller and not a vitamin,
- 13:42right? Make it take away some friction, some money, some time,
- 13:46some whatever it is not happy like this kind of nice thing you
- 13:49sort out of on the top and I think that's what, that sounds
- 13:51like what they've done here, right? They've removed the pain,
- 13:53which is you having to take off one of your ten days holidays a
- 13:56year to go and pick up some drugs, right, you know, you guys
- 13:59get no holiday, I'm sorry about that. And so, so that's really
- 14:03hard. I do want to push you on it from a marketing perspective
- 14:06because I think there's two things that's happening here and
- 14:09I'm, I am guessing, right, so you are low hanging fruit,
- 14:13right? You're sick. Okay. So you have a need for this product
- 14:17whereas and currently there may well be the only provider of
- 14:20this kind of service. But when there's like another six of them
- 14:23or seven of them or ten of them or, do you know what I mean?
- 14:26Then and you're not ill then this kind of marketing won't
- 14:30work, right? Because you've talked about moving from
- 14:33purchase to advocacy, which is really interesting. But what
- 14:36they've done is it like an Uber or a Google Docs or an iPhone
- 14:39where the experience becomes the thing that drives advocacy and
- 14:44then the word of mouth which is brilliant, which is lovely. I
- 14:48mean, everyone, everyone wants to make that product, right?
- 14:50That it solves a pain point and everyone talks about it, but I
- 14:53wonder if it's being subsidised at this point in time, do you
- 14:57know what I mean? Like are they, are they running it at a loss in
- 15:00order to grow the numbers and to, to dominate the market? And
- 15:04at some point someone's going to want paying. It sounds
- 15:06brilliant, but I'm confused- there's some economics going on
- 15:10here I'm not sure about.
- 15:11Roey Franco: So two points. One, I can drill into that and follow
- 15:14up with you separately on the pricing model for that. But two,
- 15:17I think a lot of drugs also in the US are becoming generic
- 15:21these days or like you're able to buy equivalent of specific
- 15:25drugs. They just make it super, super easy for you to either
- 15:28renew your prescription very easily and have it delivered. If
- 15:32I have a condition that I need to take drugs every 30 days for
- 15:3630 days and I forget to renew my prescription, or I remember that
- 15:43on the last day, that means again, I need to get out of my
- 15:45way, find that pharmacy, make sure I have it ready in the
- 15:49pharmacy, and I'm there before they close the pharmacy section
- 15:52of the, of the store on time. Or if not, I'm missing a few doses
- 15:58that are important for me. They basically eliminated that
- 16:01problem almost instantly because you get it the same day in a
- 16:05matter of hours. To your first point, I agree it can be
- 16:09commoditized. And like you said, the experience here is what's
- 16:12sold. I'm using Uber, I'm using Lyft, I'm using any other
- 16:15services. I look at all of them when I need to book a drive or a
- 16:19ride, especially if it's raining in New York City. All the prices
- 16:22are crazy. Or if you go to the airport, you compare prices
- 16:24between all of them and you pick the one that fits you so yes,
- 16:28they will have competition but I think, if you're associated that
- 16:32experience with them, you might have a little bit more loyalty
- 16:36to them. So again, from a unit economics, they might be losing
- 16:39money over the long run, but if it's to get a loyal set of
- 16:44customers that will advocate for them in the future, I think that
- 16:47might be worth it.
- 16:48Tom Ollerton: Well, I think the lesson here is, is user
- 16:50experience as marketing, right? You know, like in this, there'll
- 16:53be, there'll be data-driven marketers listening to this
- 16:56podcast who are like, right, I need to reduce my customer
- 17:00acquisition cost and I'm going to optimise this and I'm going
- 17:02to like, you know, move budget from here to there. Optimise and
- 17:06optimise and optimise whereas actually really if the website
- 17:08worked better, will those less clicks to a conversion or the
- 17:12follow up email was p- do you know what I mean? There's all
- 17:14these, there's all these elements of user experience that
- 17:17make us feel something about that brand, right? Whereas I
- 17:20don't know if like, the text message hadn't come through or
- 17:23whatever, do you know what I mean? Or like it's a really good
- 17:26reminder that the experience of the product is as good as
- 17:29marketing as the marketing that sold it in the first place.
- 17:32Roey Franco: Exactly. And I think they looked at it and
- 17:35again, I think their tactic was interesting because the brand
- 17:37marketing that they did at the beginning was the logo, Capsule,
- 17:42and you know, your new pharmacy. It was pretty vague, I would
- 17:46argue, in my memory. They didn't give you instructions of what
- 17:50you need to do, etc.. Like I said, I think they spent a
- 17:53decent amount of time educating the markets and got to a point
- 17:56where you get a note in the mail that says, just do that, and
- 18:00that's it, and I tried it and it worked. It just worked. There's
- 18:02no friction whatsoever.
- 18:04Tom Ollerton: Like, the website, there's nothing to it. I would
- 18:06love to know how they started it. You know, they wouldn't have
- 18:09done all drugs everywhere for everyone. Do you know what I
- 18:11mean? They might have done like, you know, just taken, like, ten
- 18:15people and try, you know, to manage... A very interesting
- 18:18business, but Roey, unfortunately- Oh, sorry. No, go
- 18:21on. Finish that point.
- 18:22Roey Franco: No, I just want to add, like in their app, they are
- 18:25upselling you. So there is a business model, sort of like the
- 18:29Doordash's or Uber Eats of the world where they say, we're on
- 18:33our way to you. We can pick up Advil or any other generic
- 18:37medicine that you need or something for your child.
- 18:40Tom Ollerton: All pills. I love the Americans, man. Just more
- 18:44pills.
- 18:45Roey Franco: Exactly.
- 18:46Tom Ollerton: I've got you covered, guys. We're going to
- 18:47get you all of the pills that you need. Gosh. It doesn't, it
- 18:51doesn't offer to pick up some, like, organic broccoli or like
- 18:54some kimchi or something?
- 18:56Roey Franco: No, not yet.
- 18:57Tom Ollerton: Oh, there's an idea. Roey, it's lovely to see
- 19:00you, man. Thank you for your time. If someone wants to get in
- 19:02touch with you, where's a good place to do that? And what makes
- 19:05a message that you'll respond to?
- 19:07Roey Franco: LinkedIn is the best. I'm pretty confident I'm
- 19:09the only Roey Franco, the way I spell it on LinkedIn. So it's
- 19:12pretty easy to find it. Say hi, say, you know, if we know a- if
- 19:17we have a mutual contact. Amazing. You can name drop, you
- 19:20can have some gossip if you're interested. It'd be fun, but
- 19:23I'll just decide. I'm interested in building new things. I'm
- 19:25interested in talking to folks from the industry or adjacent
- 19:28industries and kind of cross-pollinate and share some
- 19:32of my experiences, and would love to meet new folks.
- 19:34Tom Ollerton: Roey, thank you so much for your time.
- 19:36Roey Franco: I appreciate you, Tom. Thank you.