Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / Post-IPO Lockup Expirations Create Hidden Trading Opportunities
Transcript
- Lucas: Let's talk about lockup expirations. Specifically, why the big post ipo stock drop everyone expects doesn't always materialize — and when it does, why it might actually be an opportunity. Luna: Lockup expirations are those dates when early employees and VCs can finally sell their shares. They're usually 90 to 180 days after the IPO. And there's this conventional wisdom that the stock will crater. Lucas: Right. And sometimes it does crater. But if you look at what happened with Instacart in early May — their lockup expired on May 4th. Shares dropped about 12% over the next two weeks, which sounds like exactly the scenario people fear. Luna: But then what happened? Lucas: By late May, Instacart had recovered all of that and then some — up about 18% from the lockup low. So if you sold on the fear, you missed the bounce. And this pattern isn't unique to Instacart. Luna: I remember when Airbnb's lockup expired in early 2021. The stock dipped maybe 10% but then went on to hit new highs a few months later. But not every company bounces back that cleanly. Lucas: That's exactly the nuance. The key variable is whether the selling is driven by insiders who need liquidity — early employees who've been holding for years — or by venture funds that are under pressure to return capital to their LPs. Luna: VCs tend to sell more aggressively, right? They have a mandate to exit. Employees might hold on if they believe in the company. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why you see different outcomes. A company like Palantir, which had a direct listing with no lockup at all, never had this cliff. But for most IPOs, the lockup creates this artificial overhang of supply that gets priced in months before the actual date. Luna: So the market anticipates the selling. By the time lockup expires, the bad news might already be baked in. Lucas: Precisely. Studies have shown that on average, stocks fall about 2 to 3 percent on the lockup expiration day itself. But the really interesting move happens in the weeks after — often a recovery as the selling pressure subsides. Luna: What about May 2026? We've seen some interesting lockup events this month. Lucas: Yeah, let's look at a few. Rivian's lockup for its secondary offering shares expired around mid-May. The stock was up nearly 15% this week, which is the opposite of a crash. But Rivian is a special case — it's been volatile, and the lockup was for a relatively small tranche. Luna: And Coinbase? Their lockup expired back in 2021, but they had multiple tranches. I think the last major one was in 2022. Lucas: Coinbase is a good example of how staggered lockups can mitigate the cliff. They spread out the releases over several months, so you never got that single day of panic. Some companies are doing that now — Shopify did something similar after its 2015 IPO. Luna: So what should a retail investor do if they're holding a stock with an upcoming lockup? Sell before, hold through, or buy after? Lucas: If you already own the stock, I'd say don't panic-sell. The worst drop is usually the day before or the day of the expiration. If you're looking to buy, waiting a week or two after the expiration — when the forced selling is done — can be a good entry point. Luna: But you also have to check who's selling. If it's founders or the CEO, that's a different signal than if it's early employees. Lucas: That's the crucial distinction. Insider selling filings — Form 4s — are public. If you see the CEO selling a large chunk right after lockup, that's a red flag. But if it's rank and file employees, it's often just normal portfolio diversification. Luna: And sometimes companies put in place a 10b5-1 plan, which automates selling on a schedule. That can make the selling more predictable. Lucas: Right. So the takeaway here is: lockup expirations are not automatic sell signals. They're information events. The market already knows the date. The question is whether the selling will be heavier or lighter than expected. Luna: If today's episode gave you a practical way to think about lockups — maybe even saved you from selling into a dip — this is the part where we mention that the show stays ad-free because of listener support. Lucas: Yeah, if you found this useful, you can help keep it going. It's buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, but it does help us keep the conversations going. Luna: Exactly. So back to the data — one more example I want to look at is the recent Shopify run-up. They're up over 15% this week alone. Any lockup concerns there? Lucas: Shopify's major lockups were years ago. But their post ipo performance actually illustrates another point: companies that grow into their valuation tend to see less selling pressure at lockup expiration. Shopify's revenue grew tenfold in the first five years after going public, so early holders had no reason to dump. Luna: So the quality of the business matters more than the lockup mechanics. Lucas: Ultimately, yes. The lockup expiration is a one-time event. The business performance is ongoing. If the company is executing, the dip from lockup selling is just noise. Luna: What about companies that are still private but approaching a potential IPO? Do you think we'll see more creative lockup structures? Lucas: I think so. A lot of the AI startups are staying private longer, so by the time they do go public, the insider base is huge. I wouldn't be surprised if we see more staggered lockups or even lockup-free direct listings to avoid the cliff. Luna: That would change the game for retail investors who've been trained to expect a post ipo drop. Lucas: Exactly. The market evolves. And the smart money is already pricing in these structures. So for us, it's about understanding the mechanics — not just reacting to headlines. Luna: Alright, I think we've given people a lot to chew on. Next time you see a lockup expiration date, you'll know what to look for. Lucas: And maybe even see an opportunity. Thanks for listening, and we'll be back with another episode soon.