Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / International Child Abduction Under the Hague Convention: Legal Framework and Return Proceedings
Transcript
- 0:01you Hello, everyone, and welcome to today's program,
- 0:07International Child Abduction Under the Hague
- 0:10Convention, Legal Framework and Return Proceedings.
- 0:13I'm Alla Poli Castro, Director of Education and
- 0:16Professional Development at Beverly Hills Bar
- 0:17Association. This program today is presented
- 0:20by our Family Law section, which is sponsored
- 0:22by White, Zuckerman, Warsowski, Luna Hunt, LLP,
- 0:26and SoberLink. White, Zuckerman provides a wide
- 0:30variety of resources to complete almost any project
- 0:32large. small. They also provide traditional accounting
- 0:35and tax practice services. We invite you to contact
- 0:38them to discuss your specific accounting needs
- 0:40and learn how they can be of service to you.
- 0:42You can contact them at WZWLH .com. SoberLink
- 0:47provides objective real -time data that can be
- 0:50used to reduce disputes over alcohol consumption,
- 0:52leading to less conflict in custody cases. With
- 0:55an unprecedented combination of features, including
- 0:58advanced reporting, facial recognition, tamper
- 1:01resistance, real -time results, and customized
- 1:04testing, the discrete system has been the leader
- 1:06in remote alcohol monitoring since 2011. You
- 1:10can learn more at soberlink .com. And now I am
- 1:13delighted to introduce our speakers for the day,
- 1:16Jeremy Morley, Anthony Storm, and the Honorable
- 1:19Scott M. Gordon. Jeremy Morley is an internationally
- 1:23recognized family law attorney focusing his practice
- 1:25on international family law from his New York
- 1:28-based firm with a global network of counsel.
- 1:31He is the author of International Family Practice,
- 1:34the leading US treatise in the field, and the
- 1:37Hague Abduction Convention, Practical Issues
- 1:40and Procedures for Family Lawyers. A former co
- 1:43-chair of the ABA International Family Law Committee
- 1:46and a member of the International Academy of
- 1:48Matrimonial Lawyers, Mr. Morley frequently lectures
- 1:51and serves as an expert witness and provides
- 1:53media commentary on international child abduction
- 1:56and related issues. The Honorable Scott M. Gordon
- 2:00is a mediator, arbitrator, and judge pro tem
- 2:03with signature resolution, bringing more than
- 2:0517 years of service on the Los Angeles Superior
- 2:09Court, including nine years in leadership roles
- 2:11as an assistant supervising and supervising judge
- 2:14of the Family Law and Criminal Divisions. During
- 2:16his judicial tenure, he handled thousands of
- 2:19matters, including complex, high -profile international
- 2:22child custody cases, and was appointed by the
- 2:25Chief Justice of California to serve on the judicial
- 2:28Council of California and to provide technical
- 2:30assistance on Hague Convention child abduction
- 2:33matters. And last but certainly not least is
- 2:36Anthony Storm, our president of the Beverly Hills
- 2:38Bar Association and founding partner at Storm
- 2:41Paley and LLP. He is known for his expertise
- 2:45overseeing electronic security issues related
- 2:48to divorce in public. for public figures. This
- 2:52includes taking steps to prevent disclosure of
- 2:54private information and minimizing the harm if
- 2:57disclosure occurs. Mr. Storm entered the family
- 3:01law arena following tenure as a clerk for the
- 3:03United States Attorney's Office, where he litigated
- 3:06criminal matters for the federal government.
- 3:10Recognized for outstanding service, Mr. Storm
- 3:12received an award from both the U .S. Attorney
- 3:14and from Los Angeles County District Attorney's
- 3:17Office. We can't wait to hear what they have
- 3:19to share with us today, so I'm going to turn
- 3:20it over to them now. Thank you so much, Ala.
- 3:23I apologize in advance. I have lost my voice,
- 3:26but I will do my best. Special thanks, BHBA has
- 3:29provided me with ginger, manuka honey, and lemon
- 3:33that I'm going to be sipping in hopes that I
- 3:35can make this happen for the next hour. We're
- 3:39so lucky to have with us two of the nation's
- 3:42leading expert on hay conduction cases. As Ala
- 3:45mentioned, Jeremy has literally written the go
- 3:48-to guide. Judge Gordon has presided over so
- 3:52many of these Hague cases. He's an expert in
- 3:54the field. They are both my go -to resources
- 3:58whenever I have a Hague issue in a case or a
- 4:01risk of a wrongful retention case. I feel very
- 4:08fortunate that both of them agreed to do this
- 4:10presentation today. I think that everybody's
- 4:13going to find it very informative. I know we've
- 4:16been working hard on the presentation, and I
- 4:18have found it informative. I'm constantly learning
- 4:20from these two experts and very, very proud to
- 4:24have them here today. So with that intro, I think
- 4:28I'm going to kick this off to Jeremy to give
- 4:31us an overview on what the Hague Convention is
- 4:35and what it does. Jeremy. Great. Thank you, Tony.
- 4:40So the Hague Convention is a very interesting
- 4:42treaty. It's quite short. It is probably, it
- 4:46is the most heavily litigated family law treaty
- 4:49in the world. It has spawned gigantic amounts
- 4:52of litigation. It is intended to deter international
- 4:58child abduction by securing the expeditious return
- 5:03to the country of a child's habitual residence
- 5:05of a child who's been taken away from the country
- 5:10of habitual residence without the consent of
- 5:13somebody who has a right of custody in respect
- 5:15of the child, or a child who's been kept or retained
- 5:18away from the habitual residence, but that child
- 5:21should have been returned to the country of habitual
- 5:24residence. It is intended to work expeditiously.
- 5:29It applies only between contracting parties.
- 5:32There are 103 countries or divisions of countries
- 5:37that have become parties to the Hague Convention.
- 5:42Only 88 of those countries have been accepted
- 5:45by the United States as treaty partners. So our
- 5:49State Department has the duty through its Office
- 5:51of Children's Issues of evaluating whether a
- 5:55new country that has signed the treaty has set
- 5:59up a system in its country to implement the treaty
- 6:04appropriately. expeditiously, appropriately,
- 6:07correctly, and has those procedures in place.
- 6:10For example, we have not accepted Russia as a
- 6:12treaty partner for reasons that you can imagine.
- 6:17Not every... Yes, Tony. No, go ahead, Jeremy.
- 6:21I heard a pause and I thought that maybe you
- 6:24were... Open your mouth. So there are many very
- 6:29important countries that are not hate countries.
- 6:31So just by way of example, India... purposefully
- 6:35decided that it would refuse to adopt the Hague
- 6:37Convention. China has not accepted the Hague
- 6:40Convention, although Hong Kong and Macau are
- 6:42both parties to it. And so with respect to abductions
- 6:46concerning those countries, be careful, because
- 6:49the normal Hague rules do not apply in those
- 6:51cases. So, Judge, the only, just very quick,
- 6:56to keep us going, is a wonderful explanation,
- 6:59and thank you for having us. It is truly a living
- 7:02document. And as Jeremy talked about, the State
- 7:05Department is working with countries all the
- 7:07time that are changing their policies, emerging,
- 7:12and the document itself is alive. Just about
- 7:16a year ago, I was part of the U .S. delegation
- 7:18in The Hague. We're literally went through four
- 7:22suggestions, wording changes and like. So it
- 7:26is very much a living document. We'll move to
- 7:29the next one. And we have, yeah, I was going
- 7:31to talk to you in particular about the justice
- 7:33partners. You, having been earlier in your career
- 7:36a member of the DA's office, might have some
- 7:39particular insights on how it's handled in California.
- 7:44It really is an operational litigation where
- 7:50there are different justice partners. As Jeremy
- 7:52said, the Department of State is a key and primary
- 7:55partner. It's called the central authority. Also
- 8:00out of the US Department of State, there is within
- 8:05the Hague Convention, there's an international
- 8:09network of Hague judges. Each country has, we
- 8:13have three United States, I have the honor of
- 8:15being one of the three. And by being a member,
- 8:19we provide technical assistance to other countries,
- 8:22to judges here, and the State Department. In
- 8:25California, We are very lucky the California
- 8:28Attorney General's Office acts as our central
- 8:30authority for the state and have some really
- 8:34distinguished experts working on this. District
- 8:38Attorney's Office. We're cutting out for a little
- 8:47bit. I'm sorry, is that working? I lost you at
- 8:50District Attorney's Office. Okay, so I just started
- 8:53in district attorney's office have responsibility.
- 8:58In Los Angeles County, there is actually a child
- 9:02abduction unit that works not only on domestic
- 9:05issues interstate, but also will represent in
- 9:08the Hague hearings, which in LA are all department
- 9:10to will represent the state, the central authority
- 9:15kind of as a neutral party and then in the federal
- 9:18courts and we're going to talk about. whether
- 9:20these should be brought in federal state court
- 9:22in a minute. Also within many agencies, the law
- 9:26enforcement offices, federal courts, some of
- 9:28the marshals' offices provide assistance, and
- 9:32law enforcement agencies. And that's something
- 9:34we'll get to in a little bit. California has
- 9:36some unique things with the Hague that are different
- 9:39from most states. With the DA, it's not something
- 9:42you find in other states. sort of signposting,
- 9:47we'll get to that in a little bit, but I wanted
- 9:49to just inquire a little bit with Jeremy. As
- 9:52we're going through the basics of the Hague,
- 9:54can you explain the two basic types of Hague
- 9:57cases that are seen? Well, the primary case is
- 10:03a case for the return of the child to the country
- 10:05of habitual residence. I think we do that on
- 10:07the next slide. And so a return case is A return
- 10:12case happens when a child has been either wrongfully
- 10:16removed from the country of habitual residence
- 10:19or has been wrongfully retained away from the
- 10:22country of habitual residence. And if that is
- 10:24in breach of the petitioning parents custody
- 10:27rights, then it is normally a wrongful removal
- 10:32or wrongful retention. The remedy for a return
- 10:35case is quite simple. the child must go back.
- 10:37The child needs to go back home. It needs to
- 10:39be done expeditiously. And that is the method
- 10:44that the community of nations adopted a long
- 10:50time ago as a means of not only returning abducted
- 10:54kids, but deterring parents from contemplating
- 11:00taking their child away from one country to another
- 11:02without the consent of the other parent or without
- 11:04a court order. that the Hay Convention also contains
- 11:08one provision, Article 21, about access cases.
- 11:12This means primarily we're referring now to visitation
- 11:17rights being frustrated. The Convention requires
- 11:20contracting states to ensure that these access
- 11:23rights are respected. And the remedy is to facilitate
- 11:27contact, not to physically return the child to
- 11:30the country of habitual residence. I need to
- 11:33say that for most of the world, the access provision
- 11:37set forth in article 21 of the convention is
- 11:41not anywhere near as important as the primary
- 11:44concern of a hate convention case, which is return.
- 11:47But it's useful to know and to understand that
- 11:50you can seek help, especially administrative
- 11:53help, in terms of trying to get visitation with
- 11:56a child who is overseas. There are intricacies
- 11:59involved with the access cases as well. For example,
- 12:02We'll hit this in a little bit. I'm just side
- 12:04-posting ahead. How does one, from a judge's
- 12:08perspective, there's a return and there's an
- 12:09issue of domestic violence. Can you remediate
- 12:11that with a supervised visit? We don't know how
- 12:15other jurisdictions are going to see that. That's
- 12:17something important that we will hit on later
- 12:19on when we talk more about these access issues
- 12:21and return issues. But for now, I want to talk
- 12:24to Judge Gordon a little bit. about how you even
- 12:27commence a hey -kate. Absolutely. Well, there's
- 12:30one thing I want to comment here on that last
- 12:32note about not determining the custody merits.
- 12:38When I teach this, I always say what we're picking
- 12:40out is a stadium where the game is going to be
- 12:42played, not calling balls and strikes or fouls,
- 12:46red cards and yellow cards. However, in one of
- 12:50the biggest challenges, as we work with other
- 12:52countries and other judiciaries, is in many countries,
- 12:56there is a desire, a policy, what do you want
- 12:59to say, to determine best interests, essential
- 13:02visitation within this, which really we shouldn't
- 13:04be doing at Hague, but that is a tension. So
- 13:07with regard to starting this, and I think that
- 13:10the last box is important to read first and last.
- 13:16You submit an application to central authority
- 13:19a great website you go on there's also On this
- 13:23that central authority website a place where
- 13:25attorneys can volunteer to assist on these cases
- 13:27pro bono. It's a great program Once that application
- 13:31is made and you have to attach the appropriate
- 13:33evidence and supporting documentation with declarations
- 13:38When we're going to talk about proof of habitual
- 13:41residence, we're going to talk about that in
- 13:42detail But that doesn't start the case. That's
- 13:45the application. They will issue letters and
- 13:48other issues, but a action, a petition must be
- 13:52filed in the appropriate court, federal or state.
- 13:56And we're going to talk about some of the decisions
- 13:58that lawyers make whether they want to go federal
- 14:01state as we go forward. And so I will always
- 14:10include in my initial Hague applications for
- 14:14the return of a child, I will always include
- 14:18voluminous evidence because the evidence that
- 14:22is attached to the Hague case A will be read
- 14:24by the judge up front and B is much easier to
- 14:28get into evidence. It's almost automatically
- 14:30in evidence if it's part of the Hague Convention
- 14:32application. So I get the ability to throw the
- 14:35kitchen sink in there and I believe that the
- 14:39Hague application should be drafted with extreme
- 14:42care, extreme caution, even though at first blush
- 14:45it looks as if it's very simple. So how do you
- 14:50pick where you're going to file, Jeremy? You
- 14:51can file in state or federal. We all learned
- 14:55in law school about the supremacy clause. We
- 14:58also learned as family law attorneys, the UCCJA.
- 15:02We know about concurrent jurisdiction. How do
- 15:05you choose and how do you keep it in the form
- 15:07that you want it? So I would normally go federal
- 15:12court if I'm the petitioner. I may remove the
- 15:16case if it's brought in the state court and I'm
- 15:18the respondent. I may, I have to decide whether
- 15:20I think I've got more chance of success in state
- 15:22or federal. As the petitioner, I don't want to
- 15:25have a case in state court usually because of
- 15:28a reason that the judge has stated before, which
- 15:30is a hate case is not a custody case. It is absolutely
- 15:34prohibited to treat a hate convention hearing
- 15:38as a custody hearing. A hate case is not a best
- 15:41interest case. So I'm always faced with the issue.
- 15:44How does, if I bring it in state court and family
- 15:46court, for example, before a judge who is trained
- 15:49in best interests and the supremacy of the best
- 15:53interest approach, I'm always concerned that
- 15:55such a judge might be tempted to veer into considering
- 16:00the case from a best interest analysis rather
- 16:03than apply the particular text of the treaty.
- 16:06Now, it may very well be that California is different.
- 16:10For the reason that the judge has already mentioned,
- 16:11which is that you get to go if you want to, you
- 16:14can go through the district attorney's office
- 16:16and they can provide tremendous assistance. And
- 16:18they will, as I understand it, usually bring
- 16:19the case in state court. If you want to remove
- 16:21it to federal court, you don't have that kind
- 16:24of assistance. But in the rest of America, I
- 16:27will invariably have the petitioner file in federal
- 16:31court and ask the federal judge to do something
- 16:35that's very unusual, which is actually to deal
- 16:37with matters concerning families. So they're
- 16:39usually intriguing cases to a federal judge and
- 16:42that we want the federal court to act quickly
- 16:45and not to consider best interests. And so I
- 16:49will usually find, I usually find that federal
- 16:52court works better for me. And most practitioners
- 16:55that I work with follow that same idea. And there's
- 17:00a simple procedure that we work for 28 USC 1446
- 17:04to remove a case that's filed in the state court
- 17:06if you want to do, but you need to do it properly
- 17:08within 30 days. So I'm going to do a East Coast,
- 17:11West Coast thing here. I agree and I respectfully
- 17:14disagree. Being on the network, I get the wonderful
- 17:21opportunity to talk to US judges all over the
- 17:23country. A lot of it, I think, depends on the
- 17:26jurisdiction where you are. There are certain
- 17:28jurisdictions, Florida, Texas, California, New
- 17:32York, where there are a lot of hate cases. And
- 17:34I'm going to agree with Jeremy, the fellow judges
- 17:36there have experience. I talk to judges from
- 17:40all over the country and many times it's, it's
- 17:44what's the Hague, you know, a great city in Holland
- 17:46that not, but it's what's the Hague. Other family
- 17:50law judges have done them. I really think you
- 17:52need to do some research in California and especially
- 17:56Los Angeles County. I do think it's different.
- 17:59One, we've got the California Department of Justice,
- 18:02which provides tremendous assistance. We have
- 18:04the district attorneys who provide tremendous
- 18:07assistance. And in LA, all of these bi -policy
- 18:11decisions go to one place. They go to Department
- 18:142, now with Shirley Kaufman, who has done many
- 18:18of these, is a fabulous judge, as you all know.
- 18:21So you have someone that has tremendous experience.
- 18:25I agree with Jerry, but I would do some looking
- 18:28to see what's the experience in that particular
- 18:30area, where they're done and who has the information.
- 18:35I have a question on that. So in California,
- 18:40Judge Gordon, say hypothetically, district attorney
- 18:43is assigned, they're prosecuting it, and Jeremy
- 18:46is on the other side, he wants it in federal
- 18:48court, and he tries to pull it out and have it
- 18:51removed to federal court. At that point, do you
- 18:53lose the district attorney or is the district
- 18:55attorney actually appearing in federal court
- 18:57on these da cases? I mean on these Normally it's
- 19:00state, but I think they will it depends what
- 19:02their policy is now, but normally their state
- 19:04but I think they do will will assist Interesting
- 19:08because I Normally it's state by 99. It's it's
- 19:13state. Yeah, they come over to department two
- 19:15Okay. Well then in talking about whether you're
- 19:20going with the in federal with the Hague Convention
- 19:22or the UCCJEA. And we've talked a little bit
- 19:26about, Jeremy brought up where to file. I know
- 19:29in California, yeah, you sort of, well, not actually
- 19:32everywhere, because I'm sorry, my bias is California,
- 19:35because I always think California, but UCCJEA
- 19:37is pretty much everywhere. So how are you really
- 19:42deciding? Our next slide is a critical comparison
- 19:46before the case is commenced. Yeah, I think I
- 19:52thought this was, oh, go ahead. Go ahead, Jeremy.
- 19:54I apologize. So you've got a choice. In fact,
- 19:58you can have two bites of the apple. You have
- 20:00to you have to determine whether, as the practitioner,
- 20:04you want to start a hate case or you want to
- 20:06start a UCCA registration case. By UCCA, I mean
- 20:10the system whereby if there is a foreign court
- 20:13order that's been issued or could quickly be
- 20:16issued by the foreign court, if that foreign
- 20:18court is the home state. so that under UCC -JEA,
- 20:22the foreign court has child custody jurisdiction
- 20:25as we in California or elsewhere in the United
- 20:28States would consider appropriate jurisdiction.
- 20:31If I have a custody order that's favorable or
- 20:34can get a custody order that's favorable, do
- 20:37I want to go that route and register, or do I
- 20:40want to instead go, hey, convention, and proceed
- 20:42that way? The reason that the professor who basically
- 20:49wrote the UCCGAA has written an article explaining
- 20:53why the UCCGAA might often be preferable is that
- 20:59there are only two defenses in a UCC registration
- 21:04case to register and enforce, which are did the
- 21:06foreign court have jurisdiction? And did the
- 21:09foreign court provide notice to the respondent?
- 21:12There are six affirmative defenses to any intervention
- 21:17case. which we will go through. And so if I'm
- 21:22worried, for example, that the other side is
- 21:25going to claim grave risk of harm as a defense
- 21:26because there's been claims of domestic violence,
- 21:29then I might well be better off not using Hague,
- 21:33but going through the state court and seeking
- 21:35registration. This is a critical decision that
- 21:38you have to make. I do have a case now where
- 21:41a Hague case was brought and the Hague case was
- 21:44the return to the foreign country was denied
- 21:48by the federal court. We are now seeking to register
- 21:54the foreign court order in the state court in
- 21:59New York. Even though the federal court has denied
- 22:01return, we say that we are entitled to the second
- 22:04of the two bites of the apple. And I think that
- 22:06we're taking the right approach in that regard.
- 22:09Judge Gordon, courts are overworked. They're
- 22:14impacted. There's a timeliness issue with these
- 22:18Hague cases. And Susan, we're moving on to the
- 22:21next slide about the hearing. How do you ensure
- 22:24you can really have a timely and expeditious
- 22:29Hague case in state court? This is a great question
- 22:33and a great issue. And I will tell you, in talking
- 22:37to other judiciaries from other countries, this
- 22:40is probably the biggest issue. In fact, I was
- 22:43just at a conference in Brazil about six months
- 22:46ago, and this was a huge issue where they were
- 22:49going to make a commitment to try to adhere to
- 22:52this. And a lot of the, especially Central America
- 22:54and South American countries, it's a real challenge.
- 22:57The convention notes all through, and specifically,
- 23:03these are kind of emergent hearings. It's about
- 23:05returning a child to their country of residence.
- 23:13Article 11 says it should be expeditious, and
- 23:16there is a six -week recommendation. It is not
- 23:19a six -week or dismiss, like the time limits
- 23:22we have in a criminal court, but there is a recommendation.
- 23:25I will tell you, when I do these cases, that
- 23:28is real important to me. And I try to adhere
- 23:34it. You hear the word try. We're going to talk
- 23:36in a second, Jeremy's in a second, going to talk
- 23:38about discovery. Those become issues. Availability
- 23:42of counsel. There are practical issues. But you
- 23:47really should score the six -week target. If
- 23:51you're working with a court in another country,
- 23:54be sure to check their appellate policies. Because
- 23:57in many countries, every single decision, every
- 24:01single thing that occurs can be appealed and
- 24:05delay it tremendously. So it's something you
- 24:07have to really be concerned about. Most judges,
- 24:11the federal judges I've talked to try to adhere
- 24:14to the six weeks. I know we do here, but I want
- 24:18to emphasize try with a capital T. So this is
- 24:22really a niche specialist area of family law.
- 24:25There are unique issues, for example, When you
- 24:28have these speedy trials, you have a right to
- 24:31discovery. But if there's a six -week recommendation,
- 24:35you don't have the normal discovery rules to
- 24:37try to get everything done in six weeks. So Jeremy,
- 24:41as the litigator, I want to talk to you about
- 24:43how you ensure you get your discovery in what's
- 24:47permitted, what is not permitted. How do you
- 24:50really strategically plan to get your case across
- 24:53the finish line quickly? Do you want to get the
- 24:58case across the finish line quickly? That depends
- 25:00on which side you're on, I think. In federal
- 25:04court, my cases are taking a year, which is an
- 25:08outrageous violation of the treaty. Our State
- 25:11Department is ordered by Congress to report on
- 25:14the compliance by other countries with the terms
- 25:16of the Hay Convention. The usual complaint that
- 25:18our State Department makes is that other countries
- 25:22are not acting fast enough. Why don't we look
- 25:24in the mirror and look at our own performance,
- 25:26which at least on the federal level is generally
- 25:29pretty terrible, starting with the U .S. Supreme
- 25:32Court, which in its recent cases have taken two
- 25:34to three years before they finally make a decision.
- 25:37Anyway, with respect to discovery, you asked
- 25:40for it, whether you will get it is discretionary
- 25:42with the court. There is no provision in the
- 25:46convention that authorizes discovery. There's
- 25:48no provision in the International Child Abduction
- 25:50Remedies Act, which brings the convention into
- 25:53US law that provides expressly for discovery.
- 25:56You ask the judge and you explain why it's needed.
- 25:58The judge will typically, at least federal court,
- 26:01will typically require you to expedite this and
- 26:04require you to meet a burden of establishing
- 26:06why in this case it really is necessary in these
- 26:10circumstances. The petitioner will, the respondent
- 26:14will usually ask for discovery. It can be about
- 26:17anything related to the expected defenses. that
- 26:20we're going to be looking at soon. Most judges
- 26:22do allow some discovery, in my experience, but
- 26:25they put you on a fast track usually. They should.
- 26:28So, you know, something you've said really is
- 26:31troubling a little bit. And I'm wondering how
- 26:33you deal with this. And Judge Gordon, you can
- 26:36opine too. Say you have a case that takes three
- 26:38years, like Jeremy's, and you have a 13 -year
- 26:40-old child. When the child becomes 16, does your
- 26:45case become moot? We're going to get to that
- 26:48in a second. There's a slide on... identified
- 26:51a really big challenge. I don't want to be a
- 26:54spoiler here, but it's a big challenge. I know
- 26:57I'm jumping ahead. You could be up the proverbial
- 27:04creek there. This is a very interesting question
- 27:09on the evidence. I'm addressing from the convention
- 27:13or from a judge's point of view. The convention
- 27:16talks about flexible evidentiary standards because
- 27:19you're talking about all different countries,
- 27:21right? Different lawyers from different countries,
- 27:24rules of command. I'm going to tell you that
- 27:26different countries conduct them differently.
- 27:29You know, here, the ones I've done, they're really
- 27:31kind of our typical adversarial. I was talking
- 27:34to a German judge a couple of months ago, and
- 27:37there, the judge does... all the inquiry. Lawyers
- 27:40don't ask questions. Judges ask all the questions.
- 27:42So it depends where you are. There are flexible
- 27:46evidentiary standards. It's up to the judge.
- 27:49I think you lean toward letting things in, especially
- 27:52if you're going to be dealing with foreign documents
- 27:54many times. The issue of foreign law is going
- 28:00to be an issue because as we're gonna see in
- 28:02a minute You have to determine about custody
- 28:04rights. So how you get that law whether it's
- 28:07through declarations an expert You have to be
- 28:11flexible and the court has broad discretion especially
- 28:15because of the The time and I agree with Jeremy
- 28:22I think these cases really need to be on a fast
- 28:25track and I cannot criticize one word he said
- 28:29with regard to that. Well, as a judge, as a bench
- 28:32officer, how do you deal with, so say the evidence
- 28:34is in a different country and you have a lot
- 28:37of hearsay issues. You do. And you have to be
- 28:40flexible about that. And I think it augurs to
- 28:43allowing relevant evidence in. And you have to
- 28:48be flexible. And whether hearsay is even recognized
- 28:52in different countries and what is hearsay or
- 28:54not is completely different. He is the key here
- 28:58to me as a judge leaning toward getting the appropriate
- 29:03and reasonable evidence that we need to get to
- 29:05make the appropriate determination. All right.
- 29:08Well, Jeremy, how do you really establish a prima
- 29:11facie case for a return? I'm talking now with
- 29:16my English accent. A prima facie case is for
- 29:20the petitioner to establish that the petitioner
- 29:28had a right of custody in respect of the child
- 29:32under the law of the country of the child's habitual
- 29:35residence as of the time that the wrongful removal
- 29:39or wrongful retention occurred. The burden is
- 29:45based on the preponderance of the evidence. And
- 29:50typically, that part of the prima facie case
- 29:55in many, many, many cases can be established
- 29:57very quickly. If they're married, they clearly
- 30:02have rights of custody under the foreign law.
- 30:06If the child was taken away without the permission
- 30:09of the left -hand parent, there's clearly a wrongful
- 30:14removal unless there's some kind of court order
- 30:16or clear agreement to the contrary. And the remedy
- 30:20you're seeking is simply the immediate return
- 30:23of the child to the country of habitual residence.
- 30:25It's got nothing to do with best interests. The
- 30:29burden then shifts to the respondent to establish
- 30:31one of the affirmative defenses. Most of the
- 30:33affirmative defenses actually are discretionary.
- 30:35They're not really defenses. They are recommendations.
- 30:42they are exceptions. And the burden of proof
- 30:47is upon the respondent to establish one of those
- 30:51exceptions and to convince the judge in the case
- 30:54of ones that are discretionary that it would
- 30:56be appropriate. I'm not using the word best interest,
- 30:59but it would be appropriate to return the child
- 31:02even though one of the defenses has been established
- 31:07or not. That's a question for the court to decide.
- 31:10So there are different burdens of proof. So Judge
- 31:12Gordon. Go ahead. Go ahead, Tony. I'm sorry.
- 31:17No, you got this. I think you're anticipating
- 31:19what I'm going to ask. So go ahead. As you go
- 31:22through this, and in your family in general,
- 31:26it shifts around to different sides. It's something
- 31:29we're used to as family lawyers. But here you
- 31:32have to be very mindful of who has the burden.
- 31:36And what is the burden? And as Jeremy said, it
- 31:39changes. And the petitioner has that preponderance
- 31:42evidence, preponderance burden. We have a slide
- 31:44on this, but everybody knows what that is. And
- 31:47that goes to those initial elements. And it's
- 31:50very elemental, habitual residents, the breach
- 31:55of those rights in the exercise. It then shifts
- 31:59the respondent. And these different defenses,
- 32:03just as Jeremy said, and we're going to talk
- 32:04about them in a minute, have different burdens
- 32:07of proof depending on the defense. The well -settled,
- 32:11consent, mature child are preponderance, the
- 32:15grave risk, which is where we get domestic violence
- 32:1713b, and the Human Rights Fund male freedoms
- 32:21are clear and convincing. Lawyers need to keep
- 32:23that in mind. Judges that are litigating these
- 32:26cases need to keep that in mind, especially when
- 32:28it comes to the different defenses. And I think
- 32:32everybody here knows what the meaning of the
- 32:34next slide is. What's the difference between
- 32:36a preponderance of evidence and clear and convincing
- 32:38evidence? I think we've covered this next slide
- 32:41well enough. So let's move on to the three required
- 32:44elements that we need to prove, habitual resonance,
- 32:48reach of custody rights, and the exercise of
- 32:51custody rights. I briefly mentioned each of these
- 32:57three elements. I think that the idea of them
- 32:59is pretty straightforward. Where was the habitual
- 33:01residence of the child at the time of the wrongful
- 33:05removal or retention? Was it a breach of custody
- 33:07rights? We'll discuss custody rights in a moment.
- 33:10And were those custody rights being exercised?
- 33:14To answer a question before about the age of
- 33:15the child, the child must be under 16 years of
- 33:17age at the time the petition is filed. But the
- 33:22minute the child turns 16, even if it is in the
- 33:25middle of a Hay Convention case, even if the
- 33:28child has not been returned yet, the Hay Convention
- 33:31case automatically ends. On the 16th birthday,
- 33:35there's no more case, which is another reason
- 33:38why a respondent wants to drag the case out sometimes
- 33:42and a petitioner is very, very anxious that the
- 33:46case proceed expeditiously. So what I'd like
- 33:49to do here We're going to take a deep dive into
- 33:53all these elements, whether it's the habitual
- 33:55resonance, wrongful removal or retention. Let's
- 33:59talk about a hypothetical and work our way through
- 34:01this hypo for the remainder of the presentation.
- 34:06So that hypo, you have a mom, she's a US citizen.
- 34:10You have a dad who's an Italian citizen. They
- 34:13were married here in Los Angeles where they had
- 34:16a baby. And after they had this baby, they decided
- 34:19to go live in Italy for two years. A couple years
- 34:23go by. They love their Italian lifestyle. They've
- 34:28now been there for five years. Their child is
- 34:31six years old. Their baby speaks Italian. She
- 34:34attends school in Italy. Her doctors are in Italy.
- 34:37Her friends are in Italy. She has a network in
- 34:41Italy. The mom has family in LA. There is an
- 34:45alleged domestic violence incident with the mom.
- 34:48She tells the dad, I wanna go for the summer,
- 34:51visit my parents and bring our child with us.
- 34:54The dad says, sure, go to LA over summer break,
- 34:58take our child with you. She buys a round trip
- 35:02ticket for the summer, but she never returns.
- 35:06There's no order in Italy. Nobody's filed for
- 35:09immigration status for either her mom or the
- 35:12child. There's no Italian citizenship for them.
- 35:15Mom says, I'm not coming back. She misses her
- 35:18flight home. She enrolls their child in school
- 35:22in Los Angeles without dad's consent. So given
- 35:27this hypothetical, I want to really start to
- 35:31dig into these factors. And maybe we can talk
- 35:33a little bit about what would be the habitual
- 35:35residence in this type of case. Who files? What
- 35:39if mom files first for custody in California
- 35:41and then dad files a Hague petition in federal
- 35:44court? Is there concurrent jurisdiction? What
- 35:47controls? Could it be removed under 1446? Let's
- 35:52start talking about all these different elements.
- 35:53And I'm gonna start with Judge Gordon. If you
- 35:56can talk a little bit about the habitual residence
- 35:58factor, that would be terrific. Thank you and
- 36:01great high points kind of great lawsuit you kind
- 36:03of hit everything but yes, absolutely habitual
- 36:06residence is probably What if the most the primary
- 36:11or most? Important things that occurs it is Contested
- 36:17it is complex. I will tell you it is very Factually
- 36:22intent intensive all those things that you talked
- 36:25about in your hypo about school language you
- 36:29know, friends, how long, jobs, where belongings
- 36:33are, have residents changed, what were the intent
- 36:36of the parents? All these factual things come
- 36:39into effect. It's going to be up for the court
- 36:41to decide, but it is a factual determination
- 36:45on totality, and the court needs to be mindful
- 36:49and really look at all of the facts that are
- 36:53appropriate to determine. It's not like the UCCJA
- 36:56where we have, you know, X number of months and,
- 36:59you know, kind of thing. This is a factual determination.
- 37:02Why does it matter? First element is huge. It's,
- 37:07it's, it's kind of the, it's, it's, it's the
- 37:10big, you know, which Jersey we were kind of thing.
- 37:12It's, it's, it's the first element. Um, it, it,
- 37:17it is going to govern us as we go through. And,
- 37:21you know, Jeremy initially talked about the intent
- 37:24of the convention was to basically return people
- 37:28return children to their uh the proper country
- 37:31that's that presumption so it's really important
- 37:34so you're the you're the bench officer judge
- 37:37cordon there's the monosky case you know what
- 37:42sort of circumstances are you looking at when
- 37:44you're analyzing where the child was the habitual
- 37:47residence and monosky is a great case a 2020
- 37:50case and it talks about i'm going to look at
- 37:53everything It's a totality of circumstances.
- 37:56I am going to look at everything that the parties
- 37:59present. How long have they been there? What
- 38:02were the circumstances of them going here or
- 38:04there? What was the circumstance to the residents?
- 38:08Was that purchased, rented? Was there communication
- 38:11between the parties about how long they stayed?
- 38:13What's the child's social kind of circle? What
- 38:17is education? What's the work? of the parties,
- 38:21are they employed there, are they not? Are there
- 38:27judicial orders or interventions in either of
- 38:30the countries? I'm gonna look at all of that.
- 38:33And Jeremy, you're the attorney here. How are
- 38:35you arguing this? Which is the country of habitual
- 38:38residence to you? The kid was born in that country.
- 38:41The country of habitual residence to me, the
- 38:43way you drafted the hypothetical is clearly Italy.
- 38:49So I hate to say anything clearly in the context
- 38:52of a convention case, especially habitual residents,
- 38:55but the kids been there since I think he was
- 38:58a sincere she was a little baby been there for
- 39:01five years. So under so if you were to look at
- 39:05the jurisprudence before 2020, you would see
- 39:10all kinds of conflicts about different. presumptions.
- 39:14You would see thousands of appellate cases on
- 39:17what is the meaning of the term habitual residence.
- 39:20The Supreme Court in Monaski Judge Ginsburg rendered
- 39:24a unanimous decision that the clear and specific
- 39:28test of habitual residence is the totality of
- 39:31the circumstances, whatever the heck that means.
- 39:34I mean, what that means is, as Judge Gordon said,
- 39:36you look at everything, but there are some teaching
- 39:39in Monaski that really helps. And that is fundamentally,
- 39:42as I read it, we're looking at the situation
- 39:46through the eyes of the child and assuming the
- 39:49child is not a mere infant. Where would it consider
- 39:53home to be? Where is the child's home looked
- 39:56at through the child's eyes? And since this child
- 39:59has been in Italy for a long time, speaks Italian,
- 40:02goes to school there, has doctors there, probably
- 40:05has friends there, and has had not many connections,
- 40:10I would suspect, with the United States. that
- 40:14I would say, even if there's going to be evidence
- 40:16that mom and dad agree that they're going to
- 40:18come back to America after a couple of years,
- 40:22I think that here you're going to look at the
- 40:24situation through the eyes of the child, and
- 40:27this child is home in Italy, the place where
- 40:31he's been living for the last several years.
- 40:32If we took the hypothetical and changed it so
- 40:36that the child had only been in Italy for two
- 40:38years, then you have a a tricky question that
- 40:43maybe could go either way. And the job of the
- 40:46litigator is to round up every bit of evidence
- 40:49that you can to show if you're representing the
- 40:53petitioning parent who wants a child back, then
- 40:55you round up every friend, every doctor, every
- 40:58school person to present evidence. to support
- 41:03the idea that this child was at home in Italy.
- 41:06You're on the other side, you're doing the opposite.
- 41:08You're showing how often the child came to the
- 41:11United States, how much time he spent with the
- 41:13grandparents, how young the child is when you
- 41:17build up the opposite case and the judge makes
- 41:19a decision. The judge's decision, by the way,
- 41:23and this is critical, will not be overturned
- 41:26on appeal, except as long as the Monaski is cited,
- 41:30the Monaski decision states that the determination
- 41:38is, I'm trying to find the exact language of
- 41:41it, but if the law is correctly cited, that issue
- 41:50is discretionary with the trial court. I've not
- 41:54seen any case since Monaski that has overturned
- 41:56a trial court's decision on habitual residence.
- 41:59But I think if I, my job really make my findings,
- 42:06sitemen ask, but also talk about what are the
- 42:08things I've considered to get there. Yep. Right.
- 42:12Exactly. And I think findings are something that
- 42:15the court really needs to really make very clear.
- 42:18If you're, if you're an attorney litigating this
- 42:20and the judge doesn't make the specific findings
- 42:22you need, you ask, you ask for them and request
- 42:26that they make the findings that you need for
- 42:27the case. Absolutely. Moving on, I want to talk
- 42:31a little bit about wrongful removal and retention.
- 42:35I'm going to turn to you, Judge Gordon, to talk
- 42:37about what these things are. And then, Jeremy,
- 42:40can you talk about the legal standard for them
- 42:43after we describe what they are? And in this
- 42:47hypo, if this hypo is a wrongful retention, did
- 42:52it occur when she missed her flight home? Did
- 42:55it occur? when she enrolled the kids in school,
- 42:57or did it occur when she said, hey, I'm not coming
- 43:01back? So you have to designate kind of which
- 43:05theory you're going under for return. You know,
- 43:08I'm going to start with retention and go to removal.
- 43:11And I think you see both. Retention is kind of
- 43:14like your hypo where I'm going to go home to
- 43:17visit the grandparents for a week and then I
- 43:20stay. You know, I'm going to go on vacation and
- 43:23I stay. It's the Leaving with an understanding
- 43:27of return However, you prove that whatever evidence
- 43:30like you put in here round -trip ticket great
- 43:32great fact But you refuse to come you come back
- 43:36Removal doesn't have those movies is taking removal
- 43:40doesn't have those agree to go. It's Herod a
- 43:44takes child to another country They're both again
- 43:51factually determinative but you have to designate
- 43:55which and then provide the appropriate evidence
- 43:57that supports it. So as far as the legal standard,
- 44:01I'm moving a little bit faster now. We have about
- 44:0415, 16 minutes left. So can you, Jeremy, can
- 44:08you talk to us a little bit about or talk to
- 44:10the audience about Article 3 and 5A? Yeah, so
- 44:13Article 3 says that the removal or retention
- 44:15of a child is wrongful if it's in breach of custody
- 44:17rights attributed to a person or an institution
- 44:21or another entity either jointly or alone under
- 44:24the law of the country in which the child was
- 44:27habitually resident immediately before the removal
- 44:30or retention. So if you're analyzing a hate case,
- 44:33the starting point actually is what is the relevant
- 44:36date? Then we have to look on that date where
- 44:39was the child habitually resident. If, as the
- 44:42judge was indicating, if it's a wrongful, if
- 44:44it's a removal of a child, allegedly without
- 44:47consent, then the date is easy. The date is the
- 44:51date the child was taken away. It's much more
- 44:53difficult often when it's a work from retention.
- 44:58In your scenario, you very appropriately talked
- 45:02about the round trip ticket. So if the child
- 45:04is kept without consent after the date of the
- 45:07return on the round trip ticket, normally that
- 45:10is the relevant time. However, sometimes we have
- 45:13situations, as in the one in your example, in
- 45:16which the taking parent has done something perhaps
- 45:19quite silly, which was start a case for custody
- 45:23in the place that has no jurisdiction, which
- 45:25is California, which endorses or corroborates
- 45:29the fact that the taking parent is choosing and
- 45:32is trying to select a better forum in direct
- 45:35violation of the principle underlying the Hay
- 45:38Convention. So there are recent cases which hold
- 45:42that an anticipatory breach of an obligation
- 45:46to return a child is also wrongful. And at the
- 45:50time of the statement by a parent that I'm not
- 45:54going back, even if before the date on the airline
- 45:57ticket, that could well be the relevant date.
- 46:01So then the petitioner has to establish that
- 46:04under the law of Italy, under your example, on
- 46:08the date that she started the case in California,
- 46:13what rights did she have under Italian law concerning
- 46:17custody. They're married, so presumably it's
- 46:19very easy. If they're not married, you get interesting
- 46:23questions and you will need to have either expert
- 46:26evidence as to the Italian law concerning the
- 46:29rights of a parent or you need to have the assistance
- 46:32of the Italian central authority who is allowed
- 46:35under the convention to provide that input as
- 46:38to what Italian law provides as to whether or
- 46:40not the parent had a right of custody over the
- 46:43child on the day the child was removed. Well,
- 46:45I'll say thank goodness for remote hearings,
- 46:48because prior to having Zoom and Los Angeles
- 46:52for the LA court connect, having these experts
- 46:55appear remotely from abroad must have been quite
- 46:59an undertaking. How does a parent exercise custodial
- 47:04rights at the time of the removal? So I think
- 47:08Jar made it right. There's kind of two different
- 47:13scenarios you see. The more common one is when
- 47:17there's been no court intervention in the other
- 47:19country, say the Italian court here. They're
- 47:21married, they're living, the parents together.
- 47:25The other is where there may be a order from
- 47:28that other country. There could be a custody
- 47:30order out of a divorce, parentage action, DV
- 47:34action out of the other court. So at first you
- 47:36have to make that determination. Is there a court
- 47:38order? Second, there is... What are that sackless?
- 47:42Jeremy said what are the custody rights to the
- 47:44inherent custody rights in that country? You
- 47:47have to be flexible in getting it and then you
- 47:49have to look under that law not here not what
- 47:52we would think unless it's you know American
- 47:57case, but if it's the the habitual residence
- 48:00is in Italy. What does that law say about? How
- 48:05is a parent exercising custody? Normally, it's
- 48:07factual. Are they seeing the child? They're living
- 48:09together. What are they doing? And you have to
- 48:12analyze those facts according to the law of that
- 48:15country. It is very factually distributive. And
- 48:20so if I may just chime in, you have to show that
- 48:24the petitioner had custodial rights. Right. If
- 48:28you're in a South American case, there have been
- 48:31many cases where Let's say one parent has received
- 48:34an order giving that parent sole custody. However,
- 48:37under the law of Mexico, a father automatically
- 48:40has what they call patria potestas rights, which
- 48:42is inherent rights of a parent. to supervise
- 48:47the life of a child. And there have been decisions,
- 48:50many decisions in the U .S. that hold that even
- 48:51if a parent has sole custody from such a country,
- 48:55the Patria Patestas right under Mexican law,
- 48:59which has to be established by a Mexican law
- 49:02expert, provides the left behind parent with
- 49:07custody rights for the purposes of the Hague
- 49:09Convention and therefore can pursue a Hague Convention
- 49:11case. The parent also, petitioner also has to
- 49:15establish that that parent was exercising the
- 49:19custodial rights. However, the law in the United
- 49:23States is that it's very easy to establish that
- 49:27the parent was exercising custodial rights. In
- 49:30fact, several cases have held that you need evidence
- 49:34of unequivocal abandonment of the custodial rights
- 49:39for the defense of non -exercise of those custodial
- 49:43rights to work. So it happens very, very, in
- 49:46very unusual cases only. Moving quickly through
- 49:49the next slide, we know a child has to be 16
- 49:52years old. Very quickly, let's change the fact
- 49:55pattern. Child is 15 years old and you have this
- 49:58expeditious, you're entitled to an expeditious
- 50:00hearing. We know these cases, they're supposed
- 50:03to take six weeks. Sometimes they take over a
- 50:06year. What happens? Case is dead on the day of
- 50:11the child's birthday, no more case. Automatically,
- 50:14the court has no power to do anything else. Judge
- 50:17Gordon, is there anything an attorney can do
- 50:21to red flag this issue to the court, saying,
- 50:24hey, our kid turned 16 in eight months. I need
- 50:28this adjudicated. I need a trial date quickly.
- 50:31Exactly that. Exactly what you've just said.
- 50:34Exactly. Just break. You know, the court should
- 50:35know, but exactly. Absolutely. So then for Let's
- 50:40move on quickly. I think this age eligibility
- 50:42requirement we talked about, it's pretty straightforward.
- 50:4616, and the case is done. Let's talk about affirmative
- 50:49defenses. Judge Gordon, can you briefly talk
- 50:55to us a little bit about the types of affirmative
- 50:57defenses that you have in this case? Absolutely.
- 51:00Can we go to the next slide? This is where really
- 51:05a lot of the meat is now on what's going on.
- 51:09You have the well -settled defense. If more than
- 51:13a year has passed since a wrongful removal, is
- 51:17the child well -settled in the country? And again,
- 51:21factual. Can't be raised if the petition is filed
- 51:24within the year. Consent. Like in your case,
- 51:28the case we have in the hypo. Mom says, Dad said
- 51:31I could move. There's a consent there. the acquiescence,
- 51:37which is, I think, very similar on a removal
- 51:41the pair agreed to. 13B. 13B, I think, is the
- 51:48hottest thing in the hate. There was just a huge
- 51:52conference in La Forte's in Brazil on this. This
- 51:55is if the return would place the child in a grave
- 52:01risk of psychological or physical harm, It's
- 52:05clear and convincing evidence. This is where
- 52:07DV comes in and I'm going to tell you that different
- 52:10countries how they look at this What's the level
- 52:13of DV is? broad and sweeping in different countries,
- 52:17but that's DV Mature child's objection. It's
- 52:21kind of like our 3042. It's something you take
- 52:23into account If a mature child what that means
- 52:27you have to again factual and then human rights
- 52:30if there's something going on in that country
- 52:33a war oppression of a certain group, whatever
- 52:37it is, that would expose that child to harm because
- 52:42of basic human rights and fundamental freedoms.
- 52:47It is not usually as successfully invoked. It's
- 52:52clearly convincing evidence. I've seen a couple
- 52:54in places where there's war and unrest. I'm going
- 52:57to say I think 13B and domestic violence is where
- 53:02the real, real issues are now. And we'll hit
- 53:05that. We'll spend a few minutes on that in a
- 53:08minute. I wanted you to also chat about, Judge
- 53:11Gordon, if you have a minute, is when the standard
- 53:14of proof, the burden of proof is a preponderance
- 53:16of evidence versus when it's clear and convincing.
- 53:20Great question. It's on the defense that the
- 53:24respondent is bringing. So well -settled consent
- 53:27or acquiescence, mature child is all preponderance.
- 53:32When we talk about grave risk, and the human
- 53:35rights and fundamental freedoms, it's clear and
- 53:37convincing. So it's respondent and depending
- 53:41on the defense raised. So changing our hypo,
- 53:45we're no longer in Italy, we're in the Sudan,
- 53:49for example, and somebody is making a grave risk
- 53:53defense saying, you know, there's risk to mom,
- 53:56risk to the child who's female upon return. Jeremy.
- 54:03How do you argue legal standard? How do you prove
- 54:07your 13B case if you need to? What qualifies?
- 54:12Is it the risk evaluated by the Sudan, or is
- 54:16it evaluated here in the United States? It's
- 54:20evaluated by the court in which the hate convention
- 54:23case is pending, which in your hypothetical would
- 54:25be the court in California or elsewhere in the
- 54:27United States. The judge in that case has to
- 54:30make a determination as to whether if the child
- 54:32is returned, the child will be at grave risk
- 54:35of harm or being put into an intolerable situation.
- 54:38There is substantial authority that the defense
- 54:42should be or exception should be interpreted
- 54:45narrowly. Otherwise, the hate convention would
- 54:50have little or no meaning. That is a reason that's
- 54:53often cited as to the narrow interpretation that's
- 54:56required. As the judge just indicated, grave
- 55:03risk is a critical issue in so many cases, partly
- 55:06because it's the exception that has the most
- 55:09ambiguous terminology. So you can always claim
- 55:12there'd be a risk if you're representing the
- 55:18respondent. You always can claim that it's grave.
- 55:21So you need to support that proposition by evidence,
- 55:24by evidence that bad things have happened, or
- 55:27bad things have been threatened, or bad things
- 55:29are likely to happen if the child is returned.
- 55:31I don't think you can guess that just because
- 55:34the country is a country that doesn't have such
- 55:37a great legal system that necessarily terrible
- 55:40things will happen. You have to prove that there
- 55:42is a grave and significant risk of danger to
- 55:46the child, which sometimes can be because of
- 55:49danger to the parent, the primary caregiving
- 55:52parent to a certain extent but you have to interpret
- 55:55it narrowly and you need to support it by clear
- 55:57proof both normally in the form of evidence by
- 56:01the respondent the taking parent that he or she
- 56:05has been in danger, has experienced terrible
- 56:08circumstances, and it is likely that those circumstances
- 56:11will continue. If you're representing the respondent,
- 56:15you often will bring in expert evidence, psychiatrists,
- 56:19psychological support to say that I've tested
- 56:22the child. The child is at grave risk. The child
- 56:24is suffering from PTSD as a result of something
- 56:27or another. In some cases, we are able to get
- 56:30the psychiatrist to to state, in my opinion,
- 56:36if the child is returned to that country where
- 56:38the PTSD facts occurred, then there will be an
- 56:43immediate recurrence of the problems that the
- 56:46child is clearly suffering from. So you try and
- 56:48line up your expert evidence and you try and
- 56:50present as strong a case as you can to support
- 56:53the serious claims that you're making. From the
- 56:56judge's perspective, you're dealing with so many
- 57:00different subjective facts based on different
- 57:04international standards. There are preventative
- 57:06measures that could be taken. I want to talk
- 57:09a little bit about that. But how do you really
- 57:10deal as a bench officer, deal with what might
- 57:13be normal in one culture versus what is acceptable
- 57:17here in your courtroom? You know, I think that
- 57:23if you're a judge doing a hate cases, one of
- 57:28the things that you really have to be mindful
- 57:33of is not become kind of let your biases about
- 57:40other countries. Every country think their system
- 57:42is the best. Central American countries think
- 57:47that DV is so bad in California that it's presumptively
- 57:50grave risk to come back to California. You have
- 57:54to not be paternal, maternal about the other
- 57:57country and respect the sovereignty of those
- 58:00courts. I think that's a very important thing
- 58:02to do. And you need to listen to the evidence,
- 58:06not based on your feelings, but the evidence
- 58:09that these wonderful lawyers have presented.
- 58:13Okay. Thank you, Judge Gordon. That's very insightful.
- 58:18There are so many other critical issues and hate
- 58:20cases that we haven't gotten at. Like, tell us
- 58:22a talk. Briefly about some practice pointers,
- 58:26what litigants can do in our last minute here,
- 58:30what litigants should be doing, disposition of
- 58:33passports, undertakings, how does the United
- 58:36States deal with findings and international recognition.
- 58:40Jeremy, can you close us out quickly and give
- 58:43us a few good practice tips? One thing that I'm
- 58:47always concerned about is that the taking parent
- 58:49who's run away from the country of habitual residence
- 58:51might do a do -over, might go somewhere else.
- 58:54So the first time I'm before the court, I'm asking
- 58:57the court to issue a temporary interim order,
- 58:59which the court is authorized to do, to require
- 59:04that the respondent to appear in court with the
- 59:07child, to deposit all passports and other travel
- 59:10documents with the court or with the... his or
- 59:14her counsel or the other party's counsel, and
- 59:17to order that there shall be no removal of the
- 59:19child from the United States. As you know, the
- 59:21United States does not have any exit controls
- 59:23in any case like this and in any case where we're
- 59:26trying to prevent any kind of an abduction is
- 59:28incumbent upon us to understand that we can,
- 59:34if we have a court order, ask the State Department
- 59:36to put the details of the child on the non -removal
- 59:40roster. that is maintained by the State Department
- 59:43with Department of Homeland Security. But I need
- 59:45an order from a court in order to do that. Otherwise,
- 59:48anybody can leave this country with a passport
- 59:51from somewhere or another that you can buy from
- 59:54some Caribbean country, perhaps, and then go
- 59:56to a third country. So I need to rush into court.
- 1:00:00The minute I'm filing the Hague petition to get
- 1:00:04appropriate input from the court to provide immediate
- 1:00:08protection and also to order that the Other parent,
- 1:00:12perhaps, shall stay away. I may need an interim
- 1:00:15stay away order, for example. And perhaps maybe
- 1:00:17notify the embassy so they just can't get a new
- 1:00:20passport reissued? With respect, that's very
- 1:00:25logical, but it doesn't work. So the other country
- 1:00:31may or may not choose to listen to what our costs
- 1:00:34request. And Judge Gordon, any other final thoughts,
- 1:00:38practice pointers that you'd recommend for practitioners?
- 1:00:41I think these are all, everything Jeremy raised
- 1:00:44is outstanding. I think the DA's office here
- 1:00:47comes into great use and I will make specific
- 1:00:52orders about visitation, about where the child
- 1:00:57resides during the, before the hearing, about
- 1:01:00as indicated documents, all of those things are,
- 1:01:03you have to be practical. We're out of time,
- 1:01:07but I'll add to that, make sure you ask for the
- 1:01:10findings you need. I'd like to thank Jeremy,
- 1:01:14Mr. Jeremy Morley and Judge Gordon for what I
- 1:01:17think was really insightful, valuable panel.
- 1:01:20I learned a lot from both of them and I always
- 1:01:24continue will. I mean, they're great resources
- 1:01:27for me personally in these areas. And I think
- 1:01:30we're lucky to have them both here today. So
- 1:01:32thank you both for thank you and handling it.
- 1:01:36And if anybody has any questions, they can always
- 1:01:39send me an email and I'll do my best to answer
- 1:01:41them. Thank you. Thank you, everybody.