Latest / The National Debt Podcast with Fexingo: Treasury, Borrowing, and Long-Term Fiscal Outlook / The July Jobs Miss and What It Means for the Debt
Transcript
- Lucas: So the headline from this morning's jobs report is a genuine surprise: the US economy lost 23,000 jobs in July, and forecasters were looking for something like 100,000 added. That's the kind of miss that makes you double-check the data. Luna: Yeah, I had to read that twice. When was the last time we saw outright negative payrolls? It's been a while. Lucas: Right, it's the first negative print since early 2021, I think. And it's not just the headline number. The prior two months were revised down by a combined 20,000 or so. So the trend is softer than we thought. Luna: And we got a hint earlier in the week from ADP. They said private companies added just 44,000 workers in July. That was already below expectations. So the official number kind of confirms the slowdown. Lucas: Exactly. Now, on this show, we care about the labor market not just because it tells us about the economy, but because it has a direct line to the federal budget. Two channels: tax revenues and interest costs. Luna: Let's start with the interest cost side. How does a weak jobs report feed into Treasury yields? Lucas: Well, the market's immediate reaction was to bid up Treasuries, pushing yields down. The 10-year is around 4.6 percent, and the 2-year fell a bit to 4.18. Because weaker job growth reduces the odds of the Fed needing to hike again, and increases the odds of cuts sooner. Luna: And lower yields mean lower borrowing costs for the government, at least on new debt. That's a direct relief for the deficit. Lucas: Right. But here's the twist: the interest cost channel might be positive, but the revenue channel is negative. Fewer jobs means slower income growth, less spending, and ultimately less tax revenue coming in. So the deficit could actually widen if the slowdown deepens. Luna: So it's a wash? Or which effect dominates? Lucas: That's the trillion-dollar question. Let's put some numbers on it. The federal deficit for fiscal 2025, which ended in September, was about 1.77 trillion dollars. That's actually down slightly from the prior year. But with debt service costs now over a trillion dollars a year, the interest expense is a huge chunk of that. Luna: And if rates come down, that interest expense could shrink. The 30-year is at 5.17, still elevated. But if the Fed starts cutting, the whole curve shifts lower. Lucas: Yes, but there's a lag. The Treasury has been refinancing a lot of maturing debt at higher rates. So even if new yields fall, the average cost of the existing debt keeps rising for a while. Luna: So we're looking at a scenario where weaker jobs might actually be good for the debt in the short run, if it leads to lower rates, but bad if it leads to a recession that craters tax revenues. Lucas: Exactly. And the bond market is trying to price that in. The 10-year yield at 4.63 percent is still above the 2-year at 4.18. That's a positive spread of about 44 basis points. Typically, when the market expects cuts, the curve steepens. So investors are betting that this is a soft patch, not a full-blown recession. Luna: But what if it is a recession? We've seen this movie before. Fingers crossed it's not, but if it is, what's the impact on the debt to gdp ratio? Lucas: Well, the debt to gdp ratio is already 122.6 percent. If GDP contracts, that ratio jumps. And if the government has to spend more on stimulus or unemployment benefits, the deficit balloons. We saw that in 2020. The debt went from 23 trillion to 27 trillion in a year. Luna: So this jobs report is not just a labor market story. It's a fiscal story too. Lucas: Right. And it feeds into what we've been talking about all year: the structural trajectory of the debt. The Congressional Budget Office projections show the debt to gdp ratio on a rising path regardless. But the pace depends on these cyclical factors. A recession would accelerate it. Luna: Let's talk about the Fed. The Fed funds rate is at 3.63 percent. With this jobs report, what's the market pricing for the September meeting? Lucas: Futures are now pricing in about a 70 percent chance of a cut in September, up from maybe 40 percent before the report. And that's a big swing. The Fed has been on hold for a while, but this kind of data forces their hand. Luna: And if they cut, that lowers the interest on reserves, which is currently 3.65 percent. That's a direct cost the Fed pays to banks, which ultimately flows to the Treasury as remittances decline. Lucas: Exactly. When the Fed pays more interest on reserves, it remits less to the Treasury. So lower rates actually help the government's bottom line in multiple ways. It's a bit counterintuitive, but it's true. Luna: So, silver lining in a bad jobs report? Maybe. Lucas: Maybe. But let's not get ahead of ourselves. One month doesn't make a trend. We need to see the next few reports. If July is a one-off, yields will probably drift back up. If it's the start of a pattern, we could see a more dramatic repricing. Luna: And that would have implications for the Treasury's borrowing plans. They've been issuing a lot of debt to fund the deficit. If yields fall, that's good for the cost of that new debt. Lucas: Right. The Treasury just announced its quarterly refunding last week, and they're still issuing significant amounts. But if the economy weakens, the deficit could actually get bigger, requiring even more issuance. So it's a double-edged sword. Luna: So the bond market is caught between lower rates and more supply. That's the classic supply-demand tension. Lucas: And that's why the 10-year yield hasn't plummeted despite the weak data. It's down, but not dramatically. The market is weighing the growth hit against the inflation implications. Lower growth means less inflation pressure, but also more risk of a recession that blows out the deficit. Luna: Interesting. So what should investors watch in the next few weeks? Lucas: I'd watch the CPI report later this month, and also jobless claims. If claims continue to rise, that's a red flag. And of course, the Jackson Hole symposium at the end of August. The Fed chair could signal a cut more explicitly. Luna: And on the fiscal side, any news on the budget negotiations? The government is funded through September, right? Lucas: Right, but the fiscal year ends September 30, and there's likely to be a showdown over the debt ceiling again. That's always a wildcard for Treasury issuance and yields. Luna: So between the Fed, the debt ceiling, and a softening labor market, it's a busy time for the debt team at Treasury. Lucas: No doubt. And that's why we keep a close eye on these numbers. You know, a lot of people ask us how we manage to do this every day. The truth is, it's listener support that keeps this show going. We don't have ads, and a small group of folks chip in through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That's literally what funds making this many episodes. Luna: Yeah, and we really appreciate it. It means we can keep digging into these topics without any corporate strings. Lucas: So if you value this kind of analysis, that's the way to keep it alive. No pressure, just if it's made something click for you. Now, back to the jobs report. One thing I want to highlight is the unemployment rate. It ticked up to 4.4 percent from 4.2. That's still low by historical standards, but the trend is moving in the wrong direction. Luna: And wage growth? We didn't talk about that. It usually comes in at around 4 percent annualized. Did that cool off too? Lucas: Year-over-year average hourly earnings rose 3.8 percent, which is a slight slowdown from last month. That's good news for the inflation side, but it also means workers have less purchasing power. It's a mixed bag. Luna: So if inflation cools and wages moderate, that gives the Fed more room to cut. But it also means consumers might pull back, which hits growth. Lucas: Exactly. It's the classic balancing act. And for the federal budget, the net effect is uncertain. Lower rates help with interest costs, but slower growth hurts revenues. The CBO will have to update their projections, and I wouldn't be surprised to see their baseline deficit numbers get a bit worse. Luna: So even in a good scenario where rates fall, the debt still grows because of the structural gap between spending and revenue. Lucas: Right. That's the lesson we keep coming back to. The debt to gdp ratio is on an upward path no matter what. The only question is the speed. And this jobs report might just make the ride a little bumpier.