Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Global Production Incentives Overview & Update
Transcript
- 0:03Good morning. I'm Randi Bandman. And on behalf
- 0:06of the entertainment law section of the Beverly
- 0:08Hills Bar Association, welcome you to Global
- 0:12Production Incentives Overview and Update. Our
- 0:16program today is sponsored by Lawyers Mutual
- 0:18Insurance Company. For five decades, Lawyers
- 0:22Mutual Insurance Company has been the only California
- 0:25-based company to continuously provide lawyers
- 0:27throughout the state with professional liability
- 0:30insurance coverage. Their experience and expertise
- 0:34are complemented by the fact that LMIC is directed
- 0:37by a group of dedicated lawyers. They offer special
- 0:40rates with competitive premiums for a wide range
- 0:43of areas of practice, including entertainment
- 0:46law. You can learn more at lawyersmutual .com.
- 0:52I am delighted to introduce our speaker, Joseph
- 0:55Chianese. Senior Vice President and Production
- 0:58Incentives Practice Leader at Entertainment Partners.
- 1:03Joseph, a licensed CPA, advises studios and producers
- 1:06on the financial, tax, and legislative side of
- 1:09film and television production incentives, both
- 1:13in the United States and internationally. He
- 1:16brings more than 30 years of experience across
- 1:18accounting, tax, government affairs, and production.
- 1:22Having held senior positions at major studios
- 1:24and entertainment companies, before concentrating
- 1:27his practice on incentives. Today he is widely
- 1:30recognized as a leading expert on production
- 1:33incentives for the global film industry. His
- 1:36work focuses on helping productions understand
- 1:39where and how to capture the value these programs
- 1:42offer, which is precisely the ground the session
- 1:45covers. Thank you very much, Joseph. Sorry, before
- 1:51you go ahead, I just wanted to let our attendees
- 1:53know that if you have questions for Joseph, you
- 1:56can post them in the Q &A, and they will be addressed
- 1:59by Joseph as much as they can before the end
- 2:01of the program. And if he does not get to them,
- 2:04he is kindly offered that you may email him directly.
- 2:07So thank you again, Joseph. My pleasure. I'm
- 2:10not sure if my email address has been sent around
- 2:12yet, but I'll make sure that happens. at the
- 2:15end of the webinar. So anyway, good morning,
- 2:18everyone, and thank you. And thank you to the
- 2:20Beverly Hills Association for allowing me to
- 2:22do this again. I think I did this about two years
- 2:25ago. So I'll do my best to make this as interesting
- 2:28as possible for those who were online two years
- 2:31ago. But my objective here is, again, to sort
- 2:34of outline sort of where incentives came from,
- 2:38what they are, how they work. And actually what's
- 2:43changed and then do my best and try to highlight
- 2:45where there could be legal exposures for those
- 2:49of you that are dealing with this and so legal
- 2:51exposures for your clients. So I don't know if
- 2:53we want to go to the next slide. I think it's
- 2:56my background slide, which we don't need to worry
- 2:58about. And then the next slide is just the agenda.
- 3:02As I said, we're just going to sort of walk through
- 3:04the history of incentives. So what they are.
- 3:07Now, what I really wanted to highlight is sort
- 3:09of where some of the exposures lie and highlight
- 3:11some of the key jurisdictions here in the US,
- 3:13as well as internationally. I think you all received
- 3:17the PowerPoint. It is around 49 pages long. We're
- 3:22only going to cover around 30 of those. The rest
- 3:24of that is in the appendix, and it's really just
- 3:27for your reference. If I'm not mistaken, it just
- 3:29summarizes a lot of the other incentive programs
- 3:31around the world, key terms, and other things.
- 3:34So it's a good tool to use. I don't know if it
- 3:37was in the slide or not, but one of the other
- 3:39things I like to highlight is entertainment partners.
- 3:42If you go to ep .com, we maintain a website that
- 3:45summarizes all the domestic and international
- 3:48incentives that are available. We also do a monthly
- 3:50or bi -monthly newsletter that we circulate.
- 3:53You can sign up for that online as well. There
- 3:55we sort of, again, highlight either proposed
- 3:57legislation or legislation that has passed both
- 4:00domestic and internationally. We have other things
- 4:02as well. We have an estimator that does sort
- 4:04of a very high level estimate. of what an incentive
- 4:07could be. And then lastly, we have a jurisdiction
- 4:10comparison tool. So we try our best to put as
- 4:13much information online for our clients and for
- 4:16the industry to use. So jumping to the next slide,
- 4:19please. So basically, this is sort of academics,
- 4:25but incentives basically are government subsidies,
- 4:28whether at a local level, state level, country
- 4:31level, province level that's offered to producers.
- 4:35either of making content, it could apply to pre
- 4:39-production, production, post -production, visual
- 4:41effects, animation, games, even live stage. Some
- 4:45jurisdictions even allow it for direct soundstage
- 4:49construction. You'll see as we talk about it
- 4:51later in my presentation, some states actually
- 4:54incentivize producers who have set up soundstages
- 4:59in states. Those states include New Jersey, New
- 5:02Mexico. And believe it or not, we actually even
- 5:05have that here in California. And these incentives
- 5:07can range for as low as 5 % to way, way above
- 5:1050%. When you start getting into Canada and bundle
- 5:13the federal incentive with the provincial incentives,
- 5:17these incentives can be quite significant. So
- 5:20a lot of times when you talk to producers, they
- 5:21sometimes think these are not big numbers, but
- 5:24they really can be not just significant percentages,
- 5:27but huge credits and rebates. So going to the
- 5:30next slide, because I just really did this the
- 5:32other day with a reporter from Politico. He was
- 5:35doing a piece on incentives. He was trying to
- 5:37get a sense of how this all began. And everyone
- 5:40sort of thinks it started here in the US as sort
- 5:43of a contest or a race between the states. But
- 5:46the reality is it started way, way back in the
- 5:50early 90s in Canada, when Canada was offering
- 5:54not direct incentives like credits and rebates.
- 5:58And I'll get to that in a second. But there were
- 6:00various different types of tax shelters that
- 6:02they offered. And it wasn't just unique to Canada.
- 6:05Similar things were offered in Germany and in
- 6:08the UK. But that all shifted. And then Canada
- 6:11basically created a incentive credit program,
- 6:15both federal. I think British Columbia was the
- 6:16first. And that was the first wave of what happened.
- 6:20The US reacted in 2001, I think, with New Mexico
- 6:25and Louisiana. And then from there, it sort of
- 6:28rolled out. And in 2026, we're sitting with approximately
- 6:3241 states with incentives in way over 100 countries.
- 6:36So it's one of these things where I've been doing
- 6:38this now for, gosh, well, probably focused on
- 6:43incentives, not just at EP, but in general, probably
- 6:45close to 27 years, because that's how long they've
- 6:48been around. So I've been here for about 27 years
- 6:51that incentives are going away. And the reality
- 6:53is they're not. They're an integral part of how
- 6:56production is done today. And over the years,
- 7:00the process has gotten more streamlined and cleaner.
- 7:03Going back to that point of tax shelter, there
- 7:06was more opportunity for abuse when it was these
- 7:10tax shelters. And that money actually didn't
- 7:12even sometimes go to the producer. It went to
- 7:14investors. So these incentives are now set up
- 7:17to incentivize the producer to subsidize costs.
- 7:20And again, with audit procedures and other things
- 7:23that are in place right now. There's a lot less
- 7:25risk that there used to be. Going to the next
- 7:29slide, please. So this is, again, I always say
- 7:33this is the most important slide because knowing
- 7:35what type of incentive really dictates how the
- 7:38money comes back to you. And there are four,
- 7:41technically four. The last one is the non -refundable,
- 7:44non -transferable, which in my mind is sort of
- 7:47an oxymoron, but I'll leave that one for last.
- 7:49But first, are rebates. Prebates are money that
- 7:53comes back directly from the government, either
- 7:55from a film office or from an economic development
- 7:58office. There isn't a tax return that needs to
- 8:00be filed or a tax return that needs to be sold.
- 8:04It's basically money that comes back directly
- 8:05to the producer. And just to step back for a
- 8:08second, the overall process to apply for these
- 8:12incentives are relatively the same. Most, if
- 8:15not all, jurisdictions require that you pre -apply.
- 8:18and any money spent prior to that free application
- 8:21and an approval typically does not qualify. That's
- 8:24something that I'll probably bring up again because
- 8:26it's something important to alert your clients.
- 8:29Never spend a penny in a jurisdiction until you
- 8:31know you've been approved. So again, you apply,
- 8:35you're approved, you spend, you get audited.
- 8:38Either you're audited by the state or you're
- 8:40audited by a third party CPA. Once the audit
- 8:43is done, starting with it's a rebate, the state,
- 8:47the country, the city, just cuts you a check.
- 8:50If it's a tax credit, it gets a little bit more
- 8:52complicated. If it's a refundable tax credit,
- 8:55you have to file a tax return. There is a timeline
- 8:59that comes with that. Typically, you're stuck
- 9:02with following the statutory due date of a tax
- 9:04return. So I like to use the example. It's an
- 9:08extreme example, but if you are filming in January
- 9:11of 2026, you are done by April of 2026. None
- 9:15of these timelines are hypothetical. You would
- 9:17never happen this quickly. But you film in 26
- 9:20January. You're done in April. Your audit's done
- 9:24in July. You get your credit certificate in August.
- 9:27You won't be able to file your tax return in
- 9:29that state, typically until the 15th day or either
- 9:34March or April of the following year. So you
- 9:36do have a bit of a tail on how quickly that money
- 9:39can come back. New York has a bit of a wrinkle
- 9:41that I'll get to later. There's actually a longer
- 9:43tail to the New York refundable credit. But you
- 9:46got to keep that in mind that with a refundable
- 9:48credit, especially if your client is financing
- 9:51the credit, there's a timeline attached to when
- 9:53that money can come back. Now, you can liquidate
- 9:56the company. By liquidating the company, it does
- 9:58expedite the filing of a tax return. But again,
- 10:01without going through that exercise, you would
- 10:03be required to file the statutory due date of
- 10:06that return. Once you get past refundable, the
- 10:09next type of credit is transferable. So same
- 10:12thing, pre -apply, spend, audit certificate.
- 10:16Once you're done, you have a certificate in your
- 10:18hand. You're allowed to either use that credit
- 10:20against your own taxes or sell it to a third
- 10:23party. There's probably around 13 states right
- 10:27now that offer transferable credits. And I also
- 10:31believe it's transferable credits are unique
- 10:33to the US. I do believe In northern Spain right
- 10:37now, there is an incentive program that's transferable.
- 10:40The key thing to keep in mind is that if you're
- 10:42selling the credit, you're not going to receive
- 10:45100 % of that credit you've earned. You're going
- 10:48to receive somewhere between 85 % and 95 % of
- 10:51that credit, depending on how much you're able
- 10:53to sell it for. And that price is dictated by
- 10:58buyer demand. So depending on how busy a state
- 11:00is or how much there is need for credits. Like,
- 11:03for example, here in California, there aren't
- 11:06a lot of credits that are available to be sold.
- 11:09So the film credit is pretty valuable and it
- 11:11typically is selling, this is gross now because
- 11:13typically brokers charge a fee, they're selling
- 11:16anywhere between 93 to 95 cents on the dollar.
- 11:18So they're pretty valuable. And then the last
- 11:21one is, as I said before, is a non -transferrable,
- 11:25non -refundable meeting. If you don't have a
- 11:27tax liability in that state, it's basically a
- 11:30worthless credit. California used to be a non
- 11:33-transferable, non -refundable. Last year, they
- 11:36have now allowed for an election for you to elect
- 11:39to be refundable. And we'll get more into California
- 11:42a little bit later. So if I take California off
- 11:45the table, I think there's only one other state
- 11:48right now. And I want to say it might be Indiana.
- 11:52I hate to throw them under the bus, but it could
- 11:54be Indiana that's basically offering a what on
- 11:58paper looks like a really generous incentive,
- 11:59but it's non -transferable, non -refundable.
- 12:02So if you were producing in Indiana without a
- 12:05tax liability in that state, that credit would
- 12:07be pretty much worthless. And it's not really
- 12:10a funny story, but it's sort of on point. When
- 12:13California first launched their incentive in
- 12:152010, everybody was rushing to get that credit,
- 12:20and a lot of people weren't paying attention
- 12:22to the fact that it was non -refundable, non
- 12:25-transferable. If you were not an independent
- 12:29producer, I'll come back to that as well. So
- 12:32if you were a larger producer here in California
- 12:34in the earlier days, you didn't have a tax liability
- 12:38and you earned that credit, it was relatively
- 12:40worthless. And I did have a handful of clients,
- 12:42not that many, but a few that earned some pretty
- 12:45significant credits that they weren't able to
- 12:48use. And the way California worked, and it still
- 12:51works, you're still allowed to offset the credit
- 12:52against either your income tax or your sales
- 12:54tax. So, again, the good news is the non -transferables
- 12:58have gone away, for the most part. Next slide,
- 13:02please. So, I think this is – I already covered
- 13:08this – the whole process of refundability. I
- 13:11think this is just an example of if you had a
- 13:13certain amount of tax liability, what would you
- 13:15net under each scenario, whether it was a rebate.
- 13:18a credit, a refundable credit or a transferable
- 13:22credit. One thing to highlight, I can't remember
- 13:24if it's in my presentation anywhere, and a lot
- 13:28of you probably already know this already if
- 13:29you're dealing in this area. When you're financing
- 13:32a credit, you want to make sure that you're financing
- 13:36it through an entity that does not have other
- 13:38tax liabilities, because if it's refundable,
- 13:41the state's going to give that money back to
- 13:43you, net of any taxes due. So if you barred against
- 13:47that money, and you're expecting to get back
- 13:49a million dollars, but you had a $300 ,000 tax
- 13:52liability, obviously you're only going to get
- 13:55back $700 ,000. So you're not going to be able
- 13:57to pay back that loan. So it's always important
- 13:59to make sure that the financing, the applicant
- 14:02and the financing entity doesn't have any tax
- 14:05liability. And you have to also pay attention
- 14:07to that if there is a pass -through model in
- 14:10your finance instruction that if the money passes
- 14:12back to the partners, you want to make sure that
- 14:14the money comes back ultimately at a gross amount.
- 14:16so you're able to pay back the loans. So again,
- 14:20I think if you look at slides seven and eight,
- 14:23I think those are the two areas that I covered.
- 14:25So I may have jumped ahead a little bit. I don't
- 14:28know if you want to jump ahead. So here we are
- 14:31on the slides right now. Okay. Why the map? Yeah,
- 14:34that's okay. So that's slide. Can't read the
- 14:37slide right now. What slide are we on right now?
- 14:39Sorry. Hold on one second. Yep. So again, I think
- 14:48we talked about the timing trap. So just coming
- 14:49back to timing for a second, as I mentioned,
- 14:52California and New York. So with regards to California
- 14:56and timing, as I mentioned, in California, it
- 15:00is now either a refundable credit. If you elect
- 15:04to make it refundable, that you have to keep
- 15:08in mind is that if you make that election, you're
- 15:10only going to get 90 % of that credit. and it's
- 15:13being paid back to you over five years. So again,
- 15:16another timing thing you have to keep in mind
- 15:18that you're not getting 100 % if you elect refundable
- 15:21in California and you'll get it paid back over
- 15:24five years. Now, if you are an independent producer
- 15:27here in California and that is a company that's
- 15:30not publicly traded or more than 25 % owned by
- 15:34a publicly traded company, you are allowed to
- 15:37sell that credit. As I mentioned to you before,
- 15:39you can sell that credit for as much as 95 cents
- 15:41on the dollar. And if you jump to New York, New
- 15:45York, as I mentioned, is a refundable credit
- 15:48state, and you are limited. You have to file
- 15:51your tax return on that statutory due date. The
- 15:53other thing that New York has is that money comes
- 15:57back to you in the allocation year. What that
- 16:00means is New York has $800 million a year that
- 16:05they give away. It's something that's ultimately
- 16:07built up to that, used to be much lower. But
- 16:09it's also a rolling tax credit. What that means
- 16:12is and every year or fiscal year when the state
- 16:16reaches their cap, they roll into the next year.
- 16:19So right now, New York is either in the allocation
- 16:23year is either 2028 or 2029. So if you are going
- 16:28for the New York credit, you have to keep in
- 16:30mind that more than likely, and that's not even
- 16:32factoring in the audit process and other things,
- 16:36that money isn't coming back to you until at
- 16:38least 2028 or 2029. So important to keep that
- 16:42in mind. Those are two things that jump out.
- 16:44Those are the two states that are the trickiest
- 16:46in terms of New York has that little wrinkle
- 16:49with regards to refundability and California
- 16:52has that wrinkle with regards to refundability
- 16:54because you're not getting a hundred percent.
- 16:56You're getting a payout. New York used to have.
- 16:58Somebody may be thinking, didn't New York have
- 17:00a similar three year payout as well? They used
- 17:02to. If your credit was five million or more,
- 17:06they used to pay it out over three years. That
- 17:07went away a few years ago. So. The other thing
- 17:11to highlight New York, which I think was a really
- 17:13smart move and a competitive move because countries
- 17:16like Ireland and the UK recently launched incentive
- 17:20as high as 40 % for the game to be independent
- 17:23projects. So New York launched just last year,
- 17:26it's been very successful, an independent credit.
- 17:30There's only a hundred, I always hate saying
- 17:32only a hundred, but there's only a hundred million
- 17:34dollars set aside for that program. It goes very,
- 17:37very quickly. The benefit of that program is
- 17:40unlike their general program where you have to
- 17:42wait to the allocation year, for the independent
- 17:45credit, you can get that money back the year
- 17:47the project is completed, which again, they understand
- 17:51the frustration and the needs of the independent
- 17:52producer and the need to pay back loans. So they've
- 17:55made it easier and quicker for that money to
- 17:57come back. The only issue there is that there's
- 18:00only 100 million. And there are application windows
- 18:03that New York has for the independent credit
- 18:06only, other than the independent credit in New
- 18:09York. You can apply at any time and also again,
- 18:13it may be later in the slide. California, I believe
- 18:16is the only other state that has our application
- 18:19windows. That started because originally California.
- 18:23Program only had a 100Million a year. We're now
- 18:25up to 750, I think a year. So there's 6. Application
- 18:30windows now here in California each set aside
- 18:34for a certain type of production each either
- 18:35for television or for film. So you're never competing
- 18:39with, you know, film is never competing with
- 18:42TV or vice versa. And then within that application
- 18:45window, California also has this job ratio formula.
- 18:49So that allows the state to assess programs at
- 18:55the same level. So if you're an independent,
- 18:59you're not going to be compared to a major. You're
- 19:01going to be compared to other independents. So
- 19:03that's a way to try to be fair in terms of how
- 19:06they're allocating out the money. I've always
- 19:08wondered with this. It's 750 ,000 ,000 California
- 19:12had nobody with these allocation windows go away.
- 19:16But right now, the California program is oversubscribed
- 19:20even with 750 ,000 ,000 a year. It's an oversubscribed
- 19:24program. So it's obviously more. Need want to
- 19:30look for that money then money that's available.
- 19:33So that's that's those are the timing traps to
- 19:36be aware of. Jumping to slide 10. These are just
- 19:42some compliance traps things for you all to keep
- 19:44in mind in terms of when you think about the
- 19:48incentive itself, it's all about what qualifies.
- 19:50Residency is a big issue to keep in mind, especially
- 19:54internationally. A lot of jurisdictions internationally
- 19:57only allow either residents of the country or
- 20:03within the EU. For example, here in the US, Most,
- 20:06if not all, states allow residents and non -residents.
- 20:11Some apply different percentages to residents
- 20:13versus non -residents, so it's always important.
- 20:16It's typically something that the payroll accountant
- 20:19and the production accountant will track, but
- 20:21residency issues are probably the biggest items
- 20:25that get tagged and disallowed in states where
- 20:29there are limitations applied to non -residents.
- 20:32One that comes to mind is New Mexico. The general
- 20:36credit is 25%, but I believe they only offer
- 20:4015 % to the non -residents. So I'm not saying
- 20:43people are aggressive, but at times people claim
- 20:46to be residents just to obtain that larger percentage.
- 20:50And each state has specific requirements to satisfy
- 20:53the residency, whether it's the filing of tax
- 20:55returns, demonstrating through utility bills
- 20:58that you actually live in the state. So that's
- 21:01one compliance trap to keep in mind. The other
- 21:04compliance trap is withholding tax on loan out
- 21:09corporations, which I believe most of you all
- 21:11know what that is. Personal service companies,
- 21:14whereby typically high paid talent, whether it's
- 21:16the actors, the producers, directors, they incorporate
- 21:19themselves and that's how they get employed through
- 21:21their own companies. Certain states, probably
- 21:24about close to a dozen now here in the US, have
- 21:27withholding requirements on the gross amounts.
- 21:29Again, that's handled by the payroll companies.
- 21:32It's just something to keep in mind. I always
- 21:34get the question, there's a fear that there's
- 21:36going to be a double taxation. But if these companies
- 21:39are modeled correctly, typically that tax gets
- 21:43passed back to that person as an individual if
- 21:45it's done right, and they're able to offset it
- 21:48against their home, state, individual income
- 21:51tax. So there's usually never a double taxation,
- 21:54but sometimes it happens. So it's always important
- 21:56to keep in mind, what was that withholding tax?
- 22:00What were we able to get back from that state
- 22:02in which you were produced? And how will that
- 22:04money flow back to the resident state that the
- 22:09person works out? So you can make sure you offset
- 22:10that tax. And the last thing that's probably
- 22:13less of an issue for lawyers is vendors. A lot
- 22:16of states are very keen on making sure that you
- 22:19are buying goods and inquiring services from
- 22:23local vendors. And again, that is really usually
- 22:26on the producer, the wine producer, and the accountant
- 22:28to make sure that happens. But those are some
- 22:30of the compliance traps to keep in mind. Just
- 22:34dumping into something that just happened recently
- 22:35in terms of deal traps. There's been two countries
- 22:39right now. One Czech Republic, the other were
- 22:42Hungary. Where earlier this year, they suspended
- 22:45their programs because they were both oversubscribed.
- 22:49So they suspended them, giving each country a
- 22:52chance to sort of catch up in terms of payments
- 22:54and other things. So it's really important going
- 22:57back to the application windows is understanding.
- 23:00which programs are still active, what might be
- 23:03suspended, how much money is left. These are
- 23:06key things to keep in mind, especially funding.
- 23:10I bring this up as if everyone knows what I'm
- 23:12talking about. But some programs here in the
- 23:15US, like Georgia, has no annual cap. So technically,
- 23:20they can give out an unlimited amount of money,
- 23:22although they don't typically advertise or broadcast
- 23:25how much they're giving away annually. I've heard
- 23:28they're typically giving away, at least over
- 23:30the last few years, in excess of a billion dollars
- 23:32a year. While here in California, we have $750
- 23:35million. New York has $800 million. So every
- 23:38jurisdiction has something to keep in mind. If
- 23:41there's no cap, the risk of not getting your
- 23:43money is less. But if you're dealing with a jurisdiction
- 23:48with a cap, you have to make sure there's still
- 23:50money left. And then when you think of the issue
- 23:52of cap, caps could also apply in terms of project
- 23:55caps. you know, how much a state or a country
- 23:58will give you for your project. You have to keep
- 24:00that in mind. And there's other, sometimes there's
- 24:03compensation caps as well. Jumping to the next
- 24:07slide. I bring this up because it's both an interesting,
- 24:11I think we should be on slide 12, I believe.
- 24:14I may be jumping ahead a bit if I am, I apologize.
- 24:17But this is something that I kind of find a little
- 24:19pet peeve because one, for those of you who have
- 24:22heard of section 181, It did expire at the end
- 24:26of 2025. Section 181 was a mechanism used by
- 24:32a lot of folks. The studios used it as a means
- 24:35of accelerating write -offs of their film and
- 24:39TV projects. Independence used it as a financing
- 24:42vehicle. Really quickly, what Independence would
- 24:46do is they would set up a limited liability company,
- 24:49basically offer let's say they were producing
- 24:54a $10 million project, they would offer that
- 24:57write -off to investors. And that would be a
- 25:00passive loss to investors. So basically, they
- 25:02were selling passive losses to investors. Again,
- 25:06that expired in 2025. And this talks of it coming
- 25:11back. I bring it up for two reasons. I wanted
- 25:13to make sure you all knew that it went away in
- 25:15case somebody brings it up, because they still
- 25:17get people talking about it as if it's still
- 25:19in existence. But the thing that really bugs
- 25:21me the most is a lot of people call it an incentive.
- 25:25It is not an incentive, meaning it is not a mechanism
- 25:29that causes producers to decide to stay and produce
- 25:33here in the U .S. It just isn't. And I think
- 25:36it's important to make sure that everybody understands
- 25:38this, especially as we're driving for hopefully
- 25:41a true incentive here in the U .S. There's probably
- 25:44never been more momentum right now for a federal
- 25:47incentive. whether a 10 to 15 % federal jobs
- 25:51credit. Senator Schiff has his proposal for a
- 25:5415 % credit. If there was a 10 to 15 % federal
- 25:59jobs credit that was bundled on top of what the
- 26:01states offered, we'd see a significant shift
- 26:04of production back here to the US. And I like
- 26:07to compare that to Canada, as I was saying before.
- 26:10Canada has sort of a two -pronged system. They
- 26:14have a 16 % federal credit, which is for labor
- 26:17only. then pretty much all the provinces have
- 26:20incentives, and they can range from as low as
- 26:2321 and a quarter percent to as high as 40 percent.
- 26:27So again, when you bundle that all up, again,
- 26:30sometimes you'd be way in excess of 50 percent.
- 26:33And off topic a little bit, but I bring it up,
- 26:37one of the other benefits of Canada is the foreign
- 26:39exchange rate benefit that still exists. So that
- 26:42also adds an additional benefit to the producer
- 26:45if they're producing in Canada. It could also
- 26:47be a detriment, depending on where you go and
- 26:50whether or not the exchange rate is in your favor
- 26:52or not. So, again, I wanted to highlight, again,
- 26:55Section 181 and the fact that the federal incentive
- 26:57is gone. I'm sorry, that 181 is gone, that there
- 27:01is hope and prayers for a federal incentive.
- 27:05I think we should be on slide 13. And here from
- 27:1013 forward, I'm just going to highlight some
- 27:14of the key incentive states, as I mentioned.
- 27:16You know, we've got California. So again, 41
- 27:20states with incentives. The key ones being California.
- 27:25No matter what you hear, California is still
- 27:28the leading state right now with production span.
- 27:32You hear about California a lot because they've
- 27:35lost a significant percentage of that production,
- 27:38but it's still the market leader in terms of
- 27:40production. Followed by, I would probably say
- 27:43right now, New York. New York is very busy right
- 27:46now, as I mentioned, New York has 800 million
- 27:48a year. It's a 30 to 40 percent incentive. It
- 27:53can go as high as 50 percent because they have
- 27:57a lot of various uplifts. The first uplift in
- 28:00New York comes if you film outside the New York
- 28:03City area. So the basic credit is 30 percent.
- 28:06But if you film in upstate New York, you get
- 28:08an additional 10. So that becomes 40. And then
- 28:11they have what they call their multi -production
- 28:14uplifts. If you're an independent producer, and
- 28:18you produce, I think, more than one 20 million
- 28:20dollar project, you can get a 5 % bump. So that,
- 28:23you know, that 30 % becomes anywhere from 35
- 28:26to 45%. And if you're a larger producer doing
- 28:30multiple projects of, I think, 100 million or
- 28:32more, that 30 % can go as high as 50%. So one
- 28:37of the reasons why New York is very busy, Georgia
- 28:39is still very, very busy. For one main reason,
- 28:43ATL, is not capped. ATL obviously above the line,
- 28:48so your actors, producers, directors are not
- 28:49capped. They're not capped in New York any longer.
- 28:51That's a recent change. Three years ago, New
- 28:55York did not allow ATL because of competition
- 28:59from New Jersey. They slowly introduced ATL as
- 29:02qualified spend. They expanded that definition
- 29:06last year to include everything with no cap.
- 29:10I think the only cap in New York right now is
- 29:11your ATL CAP is limited to 40 % of a New York
- 29:15spend. So we've got California very busy. The
- 29:20only thing is that California is still has working
- 29:23against it is, as I mentioned before, not enough
- 29:26money. California still does not allow ATL. I'm
- 29:31hearing that the unions are finally on board
- 29:34with potentially allowing ATL. That was one of
- 29:36the reasons it hadn't happened. So. If it doesn't
- 29:39happen sooner, I would imagine under the next
- 29:41governor administration, we will see ATL as qualified
- 29:45spend. We'll see again, production here in California
- 29:48continue to increase. I'm also hearing that Newsom
- 29:52might make one big final announcement before
- 29:54he leaves office. It could be ATL. It could be
- 29:58more money for the program. It also could be
- 30:00here in California, there are two pending bills.
- 30:03There's one, a post only credit bill is pending.
- 30:06So you can bring your post back to California
- 30:08right now. Post only qualifies. If it's part
- 30:11of your larger production, you can't film elsewhere
- 30:14and bring your post back. So they're hoping to
- 30:15change that. There's actually a post legislation
- 30:18for incentive for commercials. So we talked about
- 30:22California. We've talked about New York. We talked
- 30:25about Georgia. Georgia has seen a bit of a decline
- 30:29lately. I can't give you reasons other than.
- 30:32competition from other jurisdictions, but it's
- 30:35still a great program at 30 % transferable, no
- 30:39caps. So it's great. New Jersey seems to be the
- 30:44hot state of the moment. You know, it offers
- 30:46anywhere from 30 to 40%. Their funding is about
- 30:51$430 million a year. It's a pretty great program.
- 30:55They have something called Studio Partners and
- 30:58Lease Partners, meaning if you either constructed
- 31:01or lease studio space in the state, you get a
- 31:05higher percentage back from the state in terms
- 31:07of the credit. In addition, one of the things
- 31:11that New Jersey has, they do have a compensation
- 31:13cap at $750 ,000, which is pretty low. But if
- 31:18you are a studio partner or a lease partner,
- 31:22that cap goes away or increases it significantly,
- 31:25I think as high as $70 or $72 million. It's definitely
- 31:29very much in someone's benefit to be a studio
- 31:33partner or a studio or a lease partner. One thing
- 31:36I recently learned, I haven't done all the due
- 31:39diligence on it, but I heard that if you produce
- 31:42at a lease partner or studio partner facility,
- 31:46you might be able to tap into those same benefits.
- 31:50The other thing that New Jersey offers that's
- 31:53unique to New Jersey is they allow contingent
- 31:55compensation. So your residuals and participations
- 31:59qualify as qualified spend only if you are a
- 32:04studio or lease partner. The only other jurisdiction
- 32:07that I think offers that is the UK. UK also offers
- 32:11participations as qualified spend. So you can
- 32:14see New Jersey basic program, great. Studio partner,
- 32:19lease partner, it's super powered. Great program.
- 32:22So those are the key ones. New Mexico, also a
- 32:24great program. It's sort of been hindering a
- 32:27little bit, but it's a 25 to 45 % program, great
- 32:32infrastructure, great crew. And then the other
- 32:35state that made a big push last year is Texas,
- 32:40adding 300 million biannually to their program,
- 32:43significantly increasing their percentages. So
- 32:45we're seeing production slowly move back into
- 32:48the state, especially television. So if I highlight
- 32:51the top states, as I mentioned, California, New
- 32:54York, New Jersey, Georgia. But there are so many.
- 32:59I say that because I talk to dozens of clients
- 33:03a day. It sounds crazy, but I do. And they always
- 33:07ask about the same states. And I try to remind
- 33:09them that in going to these states, you are not
- 33:12only competing for money, but you're competing
- 33:14for crew and stage space. So I just make them
- 33:18aware of other states that are out there that
- 33:20have programs that they may not be aware of that
- 33:23could work for them. whether it's Oklahoma, Kentucky,
- 33:26there are a lot. So I try to highlight that for
- 33:29everybody. So I think we've probably covered
- 33:3213 through, I think, 16. Just jumping back to
- 33:42California for a second, I did mention the basic
- 33:46program, which is the $750 million I mentioned
- 33:50the positives and the negatives to the program,
- 33:53the biggest negative being ATL. There's also
- 33:55a soundstage credit. It's not a separate credit.
- 33:59It's a separate pool of money. There's actually
- 34:01an additional 150 million that's been set aside
- 34:03a couple of years ago. That money is allocable
- 34:07to the producer that films on what the state
- 34:11deems a qualified stage. There's only a handful
- 34:15of them right now. I think maybe only two or
- 34:16three in the state. they're either new or renovated
- 34:20stages that have spent at least 20, I think it's
- 34:22$20 million in build or renovation costs. So
- 34:26technically at the end of the day, I can't recall
- 34:28how much of that 150 has been used, but in California,
- 34:33there could be as much as 900 million available
- 34:37in total to producers. But again, still not enough
- 34:40to satisfy the need that's out there. So I think
- 34:46we might just jump into 18 and 19. I apologize
- 34:50if I'm jumping around a bit. This is going back
- 34:53to New Jersey. I mentioned the program in general,
- 34:56and I mentioned the studio partners. Right now,
- 34:59as far as I'm aware, there's only three studio
- 35:01partners in the state of New Jersey, Netflix
- 35:04being the biggest one. I think all of us have
- 35:06either heard or read about their leasing of a
- 35:10pretty large army base in the southern part of
- 35:12the state and the process of renovating. and
- 35:15what will be the largest soundstage and studio
- 35:18facility on the East Coast when it's done. So
- 35:21New Jersey is definitely becoming a big player
- 35:24in all this, which is interesting because it
- 35:26was one of the original states years ago. The
- 35:30program suspended under its old format a couple
- 35:33of years ago, came back in 2018, and here we
- 35:36are in 2026. And it's become one of the top five
- 35:41states. So it's really quickly come back. So
- 35:45I just wanted to highlight that the company is
- 35:48about our studio partners right now in New Jersey.
- 35:51Jumping to slide 20. Oh yeah, this is again,
- 35:56I touched on this already. This is the whole
- 35:58partner economics. I had mentioned the compensation
- 36:01cap in New Jersey in general being 750 ,000.
- 36:06But if you are a studio or lease partner, it
- 36:09could scale up to as high as 72 million. So again,
- 36:13Lots of benefits to being a studio release partner.
- 36:18Jumping to slide 21, this is the New York which
- 36:21you talked about. Again, the 700 million is the
- 36:25basic credit. As I said before, it's 30 to 40
- 36:29percent. It can go as high as 50 depending on
- 36:31whether you qualify for the uplifts. Again, the
- 36:35independent credit is the one I really want to
- 36:38bring up again because a lot of folks, one, weren't
- 36:40aware of it. too, weren't aware of the benefit
- 36:42that it offers, which, again, is money coming
- 36:45back quicker. The thing to keep in mind is, again,
- 36:48there's only $100 million. And there's two application
- 36:51windows. They're usually January and July. So
- 36:56I think, obviously, the July window passed. So
- 36:58the next application window won't be until January
- 37:01of next year, although there's hopes of adding
- 37:03more money to that program. The last thing on
- 37:07California, and some of you may have heard of
- 37:09this, Make sure I got the bill number. I think
- 37:13it's bill number. Right now, it's SB 122, which
- 37:20basically limits the ability of utilizing tax
- 37:24credits here in California. It's limiting it
- 37:26to five million a year, and I believe that's
- 37:29through 2029, if not beyond that. That applies
- 37:34to all credits. If you are a producer that earns
- 37:38a credit or trying to sell a credit in California,
- 37:41you're only going to be able to utilize five
- 37:43million a year. That obviously hurts the reputation
- 37:47and the overall net benefit to the California
- 37:49program. So there is a real push right now to
- 37:52get a carve out for the film credit because we
- 37:55have one side of the law boosting up this industry
- 37:59and improving the program and another side of
- 38:01the law really hurting it with this tax credit
- 38:05cap, so something to keep an eye on. And the
- 38:09slide 24, really quickly, is just highlighting
- 38:11states that have recent legislation. I pulled
- 38:14this because, again, we just finished doing a
- 38:16newsletter. Nothing huge here. Again, there's
- 38:20always something going on legislatively. You
- 38:22know, Delaware just recently launched a program.
- 38:25North Carolina's got legislation to tweak their
- 38:27program. And Michigan were, I think it was 2015
- 38:31or so years ago. offered a pretty generous 40
- 38:34to 42 percent incentive. It went away. There's
- 38:37legislation right now to try to bring it back.
- 38:41Like I said, that's what keeps me employed. The
- 38:43legislation changes. Jumping to slide 25, these
- 38:48are just highlighting international. It touched
- 38:52on the UK a little bit. Again, the key international
- 38:56jurisdictions are going to be obvious. It's going
- 38:58to be the UK. It's going to be Canada. it's going
- 39:01to be Ireland, it's going to be Australia, and
- 39:04it's going to also be countries like Hungary.
- 39:06I don't know if I can't remember if I have a
- 39:07separate slide on Hungary, but I'll come back
- 39:08to that. Australia, there's so many, Italy, France,
- 39:16Spain, all super busy right now, all recently
- 39:19modifying their programs over the last couple
- 39:21years to make it more inclusive, higher percentages.
- 39:25There was a point in time, maybe a year and a
- 39:27half ago, that there were no stages available
- 39:29at all in Italy. That's how busy Italy had gotten.
- 39:32But with regards to the UK, it is an incentive
- 39:36that used to be called a tax offset. It's now
- 39:39called the audiovisual expenditure credit. It's
- 39:42pretty much the exact same credit, except the
- 39:45former tax relief program was a flat 25%. Under
- 39:50the audiovisual credit, it's a larger percentage
- 39:53that gets taxed. So it nets down to 25 .5%. So
- 39:57you're in the same place. So as I was saying,
- 39:59the audio -visual credit in the UK starts as
- 40:02low as 25 .5 % and goes high as 39 .75%. And
- 40:08that's for their independence. They have visual
- 40:13effects that now qualify. And the big positive
- 40:17there on the visual effects in post is that the
- 40:20UK also has a rule where your overall UK expenditures
- 40:24are limited to 80%. That 80 % Haircut doesn't
- 40:28apply to digital effects, so that's important
- 40:30to keep in mind. But other than those little
- 40:33tweaks, the UK program, in my mind, is almost
- 40:36the perfect program. It allows residents, non
- 40:39-residents, above the line, below the line, no
- 40:42caps. As I mentioned before, participations qualify.
- 40:48They have something called used and consumed
- 40:50for products, so you don't necessarily have to
- 40:52buy something in the UK, as long as you use it
- 40:54in the UK as part of your production it qualifies.
- 40:59And again, very generous, and the money comes
- 41:01back very, very quickly in the UK. Ireland, I
- 41:05wouldn't say their model is exactly the same
- 41:07as the UK. Their program is 30 to 40%, 40 % applying
- 41:13to independent film. One of the things that is
- 41:16unique to Ireland and UK doesn't offer yet is
- 41:18that they now allow non -scripted to qualify.
- 41:21Some of you might recall a couple of months ago,
- 41:23it might be a year ago when Rob Lowe was bitching
- 41:26about having to go all the way to Ireland to
- 41:28do a game show, which probably prompted California
- 41:31to change their legislation last year to allow
- 41:34large competition shows to qualify. But, you
- 41:37know, Ireland is a very generous program, as
- 41:39I said. Over the last four to five years, the
- 41:42infrastructure in Ireland, both crew and stages,
- 41:45has really, really increased dramatically. And
- 41:48the other thing, I don't have all the requirements.
- 41:52in front of me, but I can send them to you or
- 41:55probably on our website. One of the things that
- 41:57Ireland also offers is you can get 90 % of your
- 42:01money from Ireland upfront. So it's almost like
- 42:05an industry loan, but you basically have to satisfy
- 42:08a bunch of conditions, one of which demonstrating
- 42:12you actually have the money. They're not going
- 42:14to give you money unless they know you have money.
- 42:17So, but, you know, great to know. And I'm seeing
- 42:20a big surge recently. in independent productions
- 42:24going to Ireland, probably one because of that
- 42:2690 % upfront that you can get, as well as the
- 42:2940 % credit. Jumping to slide 27, apologies to
- 42:37my slide master if I'm jumping around. 27 is
- 42:41really a really broad overview of Canada. As
- 42:44I mentioned, Canada has that base credit of 16%,
- 42:49but as I mentioned, all the provinces, have incentive
- 42:52programs themselves. So as I said, when you bundle
- 42:56them or stack them as it's called, it can go
- 42:58as high as 54%. They have separate programs for
- 43:01digital effects as well. The thing to keep in
- 43:05mind for Canada, one, the federal credit is labor
- 43:08only. The provincial credits usually include
- 43:12labor and spend. I think the only providence
- 43:15that's labor only is BC versus Columbia. It's
- 43:19also only Canadian spend. and Canadian labor.
- 43:23Unlike the UK and other countries, you're only
- 43:26going to get your Canadian labor to qualify.
- 43:29But again, it's been an infrastructure that's
- 43:32been in development since the mid 90s. As you
- 43:34can imagine, significantly huge crew base, significantly
- 43:37large soundstage structure. So definitely a great
- 43:42program. It's a refundable credit as well. The
- 43:45money comes back relatively quickly. So yeah,
- 43:48it's really a great program. There's also, I
- 43:51didn't put it on the slide because most U .S.
- 43:53producers don't do this. So you've got the production
- 43:56service company credit, which is the 16 % with
- 43:58the additional provinces. There's also the Canadian
- 44:01content credit that makes the percentages jump
- 44:05up quite a bit. The federal jumps from 16 to
- 44:0825 % and the provincial ones jump as well. Most
- 44:12U .S. producers don't use that because one of
- 44:15the requirements is the copyright for the project
- 44:17has to be held. In Canada, most producers don't
- 44:20want to do that. There's a lot of other significant
- 44:23requirements, including significant Canadian
- 44:26content for that to happen. But again, I would
- 44:30say Key Canada is close to a perfect program.
- 44:34The only thing that hinders it is that they don't
- 44:37include non -residents. If they included non
- 44:40-residents, I don't know if they could handle
- 44:42all the work that would come to Canada. Canada
- 44:45is significantly busy right now. for short, especially
- 44:48British Columbia. Czech Republic, I mentioned
- 44:52before, it's a good program. I mentioned Hungary
- 44:55before as well. I'm not sure I had the percentages
- 44:59lied out, but I mentioned them before because
- 45:01the programs were suspended, but they're now
- 45:03back online, accepting new applications. There
- 45:07could be a bit of a tell in terms of how quickly
- 45:10the money comes back. But I want to bring up
- 45:12Hungary because one of the things Hungary does
- 45:14is very unique. Hungary has a base credit of
- 45:1830%. It's a pretty inclusive program. But the
- 45:23other thing that Hungary does that I don't think
- 45:25any other jurisdiction does, you're allowed to
- 45:28spend 25 % of your Hungarian spend outside of
- 45:33Hungary, and it qualifies as Hungarian spend.
- 45:36So ultimately, that 30 % becomes closer to a
- 45:4037 .5 % effective rate. and it allows you really
- 45:45to double dip, right? You can basically, you
- 45:47have a, you know, I'll go crazy. You have a hundred
- 45:49million dollar production. You're spending a
- 45:52hundred million dollars in Hungary. You can then
- 45:55spend 25 million outside of Hungary. Let's say
- 45:58you want to do your post in the UK. All of a
- 46:01sudden your Hungarian spend becomes 125 million.
- 46:04So yeah, you're able to double dip. It's obviously
- 46:07working for them because although some of you
- 46:11may hear about Hungary a lot, Some may say Hungary.
- 46:14Hungary is a very, very, very busy country. It
- 46:17has been for quite a while. Let's see where we
- 46:20are. Let's see, slide 30. I think we're on 30
- 46:26already. Wow. Yeah, I guess this is really evaluating
- 46:31opportunities and really highlighting some more
- 46:33of the red flag. So jumping to 31. And I think
- 46:36some of these things that maybe have come up
- 46:38before. You know, as I mentioned, some of the
- 46:40green flags, these are obviously green meaning
- 46:43go. You know, some of the positives is that you
- 46:46want. And the center program is going to net
- 46:48you 25%. But to be honest, I think that's old
- 46:51news here in the U .S. The magic number right
- 46:54now for incentives, at least that's sort of larger
- 46:56programs is actually closer to 35 to 45%. Like
- 47:00you're in California, Georgia right now, as good
- 47:02as their program is, is actually behind everyone
- 47:06else from a percentage perspective. when they're
- 47:09being compared to New York, New Jersey, Illinois,
- 47:12California. So I think a net 25 is actually still
- 47:15really good. But the trend right now, at least
- 47:18here in the US, is much higher. And we'll see
- 47:20how much further that goes. Again, jurisdictions
- 47:24that have no caps, whether it's ATL, annual funding,
- 47:28compensation caps, are always good. The other
- 47:30thing to keep in mind is long sunset dates. You
- 47:33know all not all but some legislation has a sunset
- 47:36date attached to it when the program is technically
- 47:38Going to expire most get renewed the other big
- 47:42I hate the word trend But the other thing i'm
- 47:45seeing a lot of is these programs getting extended
- 47:48out many many years If i'm not mistaken, for
- 47:52example New jersey may have extended their program
- 47:55to sunset in 2049 So they do that because they're
- 47:58really trying to demonstrate to the industry
- 48:00that the state has a long -term investment in
- 48:06this industry, that they're not going to terminate
- 48:08their program anytime soon. The joke is they
- 48:11can, right? Even though they have a sunset date
- 48:13of 2049, they could decide tomorrow to eliminate
- 48:16the program. It's not going to happen. It hasn't
- 48:18happened as far as I can remember, but it's always
- 48:21good to know when you see a jurisdiction with
- 48:24a long sunset date, especially if you're dealing
- 48:26with television. And as I talked about before,
- 48:29the type of credit, whether it's refundable or
- 48:31transferable, is going to dictate how the money
- 48:34comes back and how quickly the money comes back.
- 48:36So those are key things to keep in mind. Jumping
- 48:40to 32, I guess these are more of the triggers.
- 48:45And again, this might be a repeat. But again,
- 48:48residency is important. Understanding, withholding
- 48:52obligations, especially as lawyers, if you're
- 48:55basically has clients, you want to make sure
- 48:58that they understand the withholding obligations.
- 49:01And one thing I didn't even put this in my note,
- 49:04but one thing that Massachusetts has, which I
- 49:06don't people are aware of, they have a millionaire
- 49:09surtax and it's pretty large. I think it might
- 49:12be an additional five percent. So in Massachusetts,
- 49:17if you're earning more than a million dollars,
- 49:19not only do you have to withhold normal income
- 49:21tax as a payroll company, I don't hold me to
- 49:25the percentage, but I think it could be five
- 49:26percent. There's an additional five percent.
- 49:29millionaire sole tax on top of that. So something
- 49:33to keep in mind when dealing with Massachusetts,
- 49:36I just help the client unwind that issue and
- 49:39help their loan house ultimately realize that
- 49:42they weren't going to be double taxed. Because
- 49:44luckily, even with the combined surtax and income
- 49:49tax rate in Massachusetts, if these people were
- 49:52living in California or New York, those state
- 49:55rates are so high, they were never in a situation
- 49:57where they weren't able to utilize those credits.
- 49:59So yeah, again, these are things we've talked
- 50:01about before. But yeah, residency, tax obligations.
- 50:07The other obligation that's out there domestically
- 50:10is in New Mexico. They have a gross receipts
- 50:13tax that's also applicable to talent working
- 50:16in the state. All the payroll companies have
- 50:19what's called a super loan out. It's a mechanism
- 50:21whereby The production pays that gross receipts
- 50:25tax in order to ensure that that compensation
- 50:30qualifies. That was done because in the very
- 50:33beginning of the program, the talent wasn't paying
- 50:36that gross receipts tax. So producers were losing
- 50:39out on a 25 % credit. Now they're paying that
- 50:43tax. It's 5. something percent. It becomes a
- 50:48qualified expense for them. So it may be 25%.
- 50:52less 5%, but then they're going to get 25 % of
- 50:55that 5%. So instead of losing 25 % on a total
- 51:00compensation amount, they're going to still get
- 51:03about 22 .5 % of it by paying the gross receipts
- 51:07tax. So again, something to keep in mind. So
- 51:10if you're dealing with talent, it's not ever
- 51:12going to be a cost to the talent. They will be
- 51:15obligated to pay the income tax, but that gross
- 51:18receipts tax is paid by the producer. And there's
- 51:21something similar in Hawaii, but there's called
- 51:23an excise tax that loanouts have to also pay
- 51:26a loan out tax. I'm sorry, an excise tax in Hawaii.
- 51:31So those are two jurisdictions have unique little
- 51:33tweaks. And then the last slide is sort of the
- 51:3710 questions that I always sort of highlight.
- 51:40And these are just sort of obvious things that
- 51:42again, we've talked about, you know, being aware
- 51:44of sunset dates, being pre -approval status,
- 51:47what qualifies, what doesn't qualify. A lot of
- 51:50this is in the appendix in terms of terms and
- 51:53things, but it's really important. And again,
- 51:55as lawyers, you're probably not dealing with
- 51:57this, but the accountants are and the production
- 51:59accountants are in terms of really breaking down
- 52:01the budgets to making sure that they identify
- 52:04everything that qualifies. And then once in production,
- 52:06it's obviously up to the line producer to make
- 52:08sure they stick to that and are spending accordingly.
- 52:13A lot of times I'm seeing it's changing, but
- 52:15I would say Years ago, maybe not that long ago,
- 52:19line producers would be in Georgia, for example.
- 52:22And instead of using a Georgia vendor, which
- 52:25they're required to, they would go to a vendor
- 52:27that they had worked with before. Luckily, especially
- 52:30those who hire entertainment partners, we do
- 52:32admin. We'll handle the whole administration
- 52:34process for our clients. And by doing that, a
- 52:37lot of times we've identified situations where,
- 52:40as we're tracking the incentive throughout the
- 52:42production, we're seeing the numbers aren't hitting.
- 52:44We found out that the line producer was not buying
- 52:47locally, they were buying outside the state.
- 52:49So we were able to fix it before it got too late.
- 52:52So I don't know for time purposes, because I
- 52:54want to leave time for Q &A. These are all laid
- 52:57out in terms of 10 questions to keep in mind
- 52:59when you're dealing with incentives. So I know,
- 53:03Randy, if you're still with us, if you wanted
- 53:05to jump to audience questions, I kind of feel
- 53:08I was talking a mile a minute. I apologize. But
- 53:12keep in mind, I only covered 30 slides. Could
- 53:14you imagine if I covered 49? That was fantastic.
- 53:19We definitely appreciate all of it. So thank
- 53:23you. All right. So the first note comes from
- 53:28Peter Deckham. It's more of a commentary, and
- 53:31perhaps you have some thoughts on it. Peter writes,
- 53:34since I created the New Mexico refundable tax
- 53:38credit in 2001, I have been approached by several
- 53:41jurisdictions to replicate that system. Red alert,
- 53:44if there aren't qualified crews, not recent film
- 53:47student grads already there, forget about it.
- 53:53Well, he makes a good point. I remember when
- 53:55the New Mexico program got launched, it was very
- 53:57unique that it was one of the few programs that
- 54:00limited the labor to residents only. Over the
- 54:04years, it's changed. It's definitely changed
- 54:06now to ensure that they could handle the volume
- 54:10that was coming into the state. It did accomplish
- 54:13one thing, which I believe it was their intent
- 54:14to remember these incentives are in place to
- 54:17incentivize the local economy. So hiring local
- 54:20is one of those things. It did, I can't give
- 54:23you numbers, but it did allow New Mexico to really
- 54:26increase their local crew base significantly,
- 54:29which I believe that was their intention. But
- 54:32again, in this day and age, if you're competing
- 54:34with what's out there, as I said, with 41 states
- 54:37and 100 plus countries, And I get these questions
- 54:40a lot from states and countries that are either
- 54:42looking to modify or create programs, you know,
- 54:45and I give them best practices. And I say, you
- 54:47know, the inclusion of residents and non -residents
- 54:50is critical. The inclusion of ATL is critical.
- 54:54You know, I didn't bring this up, and I should
- 54:56have, because I think it's also significant.
- 54:58Mexico, the country Mexico, just launched an
- 55:02incentive this year, 30%. It's a tax credit,
- 55:05I believe. It's generous on the surface. The
- 55:08only problem right now, and the industry are
- 55:11giving them comments, there's a project cap.
- 55:13It's pretty low. I think it's like $2 .5 million
- 55:16per project. So it's pretty low. It's not low,
- 55:19I guess, if you're an independent. But there's
- 55:22obviously a lot of interest with the studios
- 55:23wanting to go there. But with such a low cap
- 55:26right now, they might get a piece of a project,
- 55:29but not full project. So anyway, Brandy, I hope
- 55:32I answered that question. Absolutely. Moving
- 55:36on to Corey Saniga asks, what is the deadline
- 55:40to submit for 2027 LA rebates? Well, basically,
- 55:49there's no deadline per se. I'm not sure if he's
- 55:51asking about the application. So there are application
- 55:54windows. There are six a year. One just ended
- 55:57earlier this month. And the announcements will
- 56:00come out in early September. But earlier this
- 56:04week, they just announced, I think, nine TV projects.
- 56:06It just got announced under the allocation window
- 56:09that was in July. So again, if you go to the
- 56:14California Film Commission website, they have
- 56:16a calendar. And they typically post their application
- 56:19windows. We and entertainment partners usually
- 56:22try to post those as well in our newsletter to
- 56:25make people aware. But hopefully, that was his
- 56:28question. To give you a plug, I am signed up
- 56:31for your entertainment partners newsletter and
- 56:33it is awesome. So thank you. Well, thanks. Appreciate
- 56:36that. Next is Steven Lowy asks, can you explain
- 56:41California's music uplift? So again, in California,
- 56:46I don't have all the rules in front of me, but
- 56:47again, that's one of the uplifts that California
- 56:49offers that to the extent you're doing your music
- 56:52composition in the state. you are gonna get an
- 56:55additional bump on the basic credit. And I didn't
- 56:57go through California in a lot of detail. You
- 56:59can go to ep .com, but you know, there is a lot
- 57:02of uplifts that get you that 35 % to as high
- 57:06as 45%. And that music composition credit is
- 57:10one of them. You also get a bump if you do your
- 57:14post production here. But again, it's gotta be
- 57:16part of the production. You can't bring post
- 57:18only, but there are a variety of uplifts that
- 57:21California offers. In addition, there are a handful,
- 57:24probably about a half dozen local incentives.
- 57:27There's one in Sacramento now. San Francisco
- 57:30has one. I think Santa Clarita. There's a handful.
- 57:35Probably not enough. One of the things that I
- 57:38kind of keep whispering to people is I would
- 57:40love to see a Los Angeles incentive. There is
- 57:42an uplift here in California. If you film outside
- 57:46the 30 -mile zone, you get a bump. But if there
- 57:49was a Los Angeles incentive on top of the state
- 57:53incentive. I think it would help quite a bit.
- 57:55Georgia had that in Savannah. It offers a cash
- 58:01rebate on top of their state incentive. So, yeah.
- 58:05What a great idea. There's a lot of filming in
- 58:07my neighborhood and it's always exciting. So,
- 58:09cheers to that. Well, this talks, you know, that
- 58:11obviously we have a new mayor coming in, we have
- 58:12a new governor coming in and we've never, I've
- 58:15lived in California now 26 years. I don't ever
- 58:18recall this industry being on the tip of the
- 58:21tongue of our politicians as they run for office.
- 58:25Hopefully on this next go around, we'll see some
- 58:28significant more changes for the state and maybe
- 58:31some positive changes for the city as well. I
- 58:34lived in New York for quite a bit and it would
- 58:36always be fun to run into law and order on the
- 58:38street as they were always down there by the
- 58:42courthouse. Next is Daryl Thompson has a question.
- 58:46Do you have any thoughts on the UAE and specifically
- 58:50the Abu Dhabi incentive? I do. I mean, I think
- 58:55right now that region was definitely on the uptick,
- 59:01you know, whether it's Abu Dhabi, Saudi Arabia.
- 59:04They all offer, I think Saudi Arabia's credit
- 59:06is high as 50%, I think. So, you know, they were
- 59:09all offering very generous programs. I think
- 59:12without getting into specifics, they're good
- 59:14programs. I think the issues are infrastructure
- 59:17and cultural issues that they claim that, you
- 59:21know, especially Saudi Arabia claimed that if
- 59:22you came to Saudi Arabia, there would be this
- 59:24sort of entertainment bubble or this Western
- 59:27bubble that you'd be able to film and produce
- 59:29in a way that you wouldn't be subject to some
- 59:31of the religious and cultural restrictions that
- 59:35they might have in place. So I would say Those
- 59:38are things that come to mind. Obviously, what's
- 59:40going on in the region right now is hindering
- 59:42people wanting to go there. But it was definitely
- 59:45on the uptick. I remember being in Cannes. Gosh,
- 59:49I remember now it was before or after COVID.
- 59:51But when they made the big announcement in Saudi
- 59:53Arabia, it was pretty huge. It was pretty huge.
- 59:56But yeah, I think Qatar, there's a lot of countries
- 1:00:00that are just offered inside of it. I'm not sure
- 1:00:03if I even pronounced that correctly. I hear it
- 1:00:04pronounced so many different ways. But just as
- 1:00:07they were announcing their program, we had our
- 1:00:12issues with Iran, so it definitely got a little
- 1:00:15monkey wrench in their announcement. I had a
- 1:00:19question, and this might not be at issue yet,
- 1:00:22but something we've all been grappling with is
- 1:00:24AI. And I was wondering if it has come into the
- 1:00:27tax credit world at all yet in terms of application
- 1:00:30or accreditation, or have you seen anything?
- 1:00:34It hasn't yet. I am tracking it really closely.
- 1:00:37New York has, it's still pending legislation,
- 1:00:40has pending legislation where they would either
- 1:00:42disqualify a project or eliminate certain expenses
- 1:00:46if AI was used in a way where it eliminated a
- 1:00:50job. It didn't pass yet. So it was similar language
- 1:00:54in the UK as well. None of it has passed yet.
- 1:00:58And I mean, I think it's for a variety of reasons,
- 1:01:01I think, especially when you're thinking about
- 1:01:03post. It's a very blurry line between what is
- 1:01:07AI and what is typical post -production. I think
- 1:01:12as AI develops and as real jobs go away, I think
- 1:01:17it's going to have to play a factor because,
- 1:01:19again, the incentives only work in these states
- 1:01:22and countries if it creates the local economy
- 1:01:26uptick that they're looking for. So if you're
- 1:01:28not hiring locally, There's really not going
- 1:01:32to be a reason for the incentive to be there.
- 1:01:34So I am part of the ASCI, which is the Association
- 1:01:37of Film Commissions. I'm on their advisory board.
- 1:01:40And I bring that up quite a bit. I'm doing my
- 1:01:43best to track it, but I ask the other members.
- 1:01:45I think it's over 120, 130 members, which are
- 1:01:48different countries and states. So it's something
- 1:01:50that's being tracked. But as far as I know, I'd
- 1:01:52be interested if anybody listening is hearing
- 1:01:54any differently. But I have not seen anything
- 1:01:56officially approved. and attached to an incentive
- 1:02:01program as of yet. Thank you very much. Well,
- 1:02:04I think we've covered all the questions here,
- 1:02:07and I know that you've given us quite a bit to
- 1:02:09digest. So thank you, especially on behalf of
- 1:02:13the entertainment law section, for all of this
- 1:02:16incredible amount of knowledge that you shared
- 1:02:18with us today. And we definitely look forward
- 1:02:20to having you back as all of this continues to
- 1:02:23evolve and is very important to the industry.
- 1:02:26to support everyone's efforts here. So thank
- 1:02:29you very much, Joseph. My pleasure. Again, I
- 1:02:32hope I didn't talk too fast. I'm from New York,
- 1:02:34so never too fast. I'm a New Yorker as well.
- 1:02:37There you go. See, we're on the same wavelength
- 1:02:39there. Thank you.