Latest / Janoub Podcast / Sudan, Episode II — Maha Tambal (English)
Transcript
- Sherif Mansour: Hello, welcome to Janoub Podcast. This is Sharif Mansour. My guest today is a continuation for the first episode on Sudan, Maha Tambal. She is a Sudanese researcher, development professional, foreign policy expert. But most of all, she is a young Sudanese woman who is advocating for both democracy and peace in Sudan. She has done so inside Sudan, in Washington, in the UN, EU, and in so many ways resembles a continuation of the struggle that last episode Ilham Ibrahim described of what Sudanese women rights youth organizers are facing right now. And she also inspires me to do something different with Janoub, working to help and to work with partners in the global south who are supporting Sudanese women and Sudanese young people. right now. I hope we have enough time to discuss all the questions, but let me start with the first one. And it has to do with your work right now at the DT Institute, the programs that you're running, the initiative, the Sudanese Peace Network Initiative, and we'll take it from there. Thank you. Maha Tambal: Thanks a lot, Sharif, and hello everyone. It's always a pleasure. yeah, to be just of humble support for the cre the great work Junoob does and this platform, I think it's very incredible to make everyone's voices really very well heard in the arena where we wanted to ensure people's rights are very well heard and served. So our current work actually with Ditty Institute in establishing women led initiatives and youth led initiatives. has been characterized by too many factors. I don't wanna speak about the context in Sudan. Every audience in your platform is aware of that, but it's all about bringing locally led approaches where it could amplify the voices of marginalized groups, including women and youth, to be able to actively advocate for what they need given the very rapidly deteriorating context in Sudan given the very emerging conflict manifestations that continue to change and to develop. So establishment of these initiatives helped those stakeholders to adapt, to come up with locally solutions to eliminate in like you know the emergence of some localized rural causes for co conflict actually because really people needed to adopt in the absence of a durable political solution or a durable humanitarian truth, people they need to do their own localized peace building their own way. They need to find their own way. They need to find their own approaches. And so having that the capacity to establish those locally led those community led initiatives serves as as a platform for ambitions, for actions, for continuation. At the end of the day, someone should really continue to keep doing this work and it's just it couldn't stop. And so this this this is what these initiatives are doing now. Sherif Mansour: Thank you, Maha. And let me ask as well, because this initially builds on some of the work you have written and studied, including the work on Sudanese youth and the relationship to violence. Also, you were one of the people who early on in the revolution throw your bed on the Sudanese people. like Maha, our last guest, have said that she trusts that the Sudanese people will be able to build a democratic civil Sudan. Are you still optimistic? And where would you say local community lead? Where are those spaces? Where it happens? Maha Tambal: Yeah, I I echo your previous guest speaker. She's a very dear co worker and and then I'm glad that you are able to to have her. I think you know it's not about what we have done through the real evaluation in twenty eighteen and twenty nineteen or even in twenty thirteen. It's about the is the is the enroted beliefs that Sudanese this existing generations and the following generations They believe in their right to change. They believe in their capacities to topple dictatorship. so they were able to examine that belief in a moment. And the establishment of these initiatives is just a continuation of this established civic movement that they were fostering and they were creating this this incumbent for change. So when you look at the resistance committees, the neighborhood committees, the emergency response rooms and all these locally bodies who really supported the change, you see that the initiatives that now we are trying to keep up to keep them operating, they are just a continuation. They are inheriting this legacy from this genuine localized platform. And so yes, I am it's not about me be optimistic or pessimistic, but it's we believe that Sudan people were able to double dictatorship three times in their history since independence. And so in seventy years or so, that's like a legacy. It didn't happen in in too many countries. And so that it feels like this is something in in in to Sudanese people genetics. And so we believe that younger generations would be able to hold on these values and to keep them surviving so that it could inform their this their aspiration for change. There is one day that this conflict will stop. Before we know it, it will stop. We believe that this is this this this war would stop. And so now as the conflict continues, where are these platforms? They are existing in at local level. They are existing in the shelters where displaced people are receiving food and receiving receiving public service, they are existing in in the border across borders where people seeking refuge in refugee camps. They are existing among diaspora communities where civilian movement started to rebuild themselves in their exile in the exile. They are existing through the online spheres now. U most of the youth networks are coordinating coordinating together. They are establishing advocacy platforms to speak about Sudan, to speak about the importance to stop this conflict. So there is kind of decentralization. I I think the war, this new landscape resulted in a decentralization of how this civic movement and civil rights groups are the way that they are operate now is very decentralized and which is I think good. and that's really reflects their high level of flexibility and adaptability, which is why we believe they would be capable to continue until they get their aspired democratic transition. Sherif Mansour: Thank you. I want to ask next a little bit about the funding cuts and disruption that the field, the pro-democracy and pro-peace programs have witnessed since a year or more ago, and how did it impact the work that you and many others do, and how do you see the future in terms of... other funding possibilities and also other paradigm shifts that will define how this sector overall can build resilience. Maha Tambal: Yeah. Yeah, that's I think it's the a million dollar question that everyone really tried to f to find an answer to or to to familiarize themselves with. So I think of course from operational perspective in in international nonprofit organizations the cut the significant cuts since twenty twenty five impacted most of the operation. overseas, impacted access to local field, impacted humanitarian distribution, human rights documentation, creating space for women to support gender based violent women survivors and so on. So it it it impacted providing the support for these groups now, frontliner supporters, emergency response room and so on. But still I think Part of the ability to survive is the resilience. When you are resilient and you were able to adapt for s you know to to accommodate certain circumstances, I think this is what we are trying now to do with these diminished resources. I think there is a level of coordination between civil society, media, human rights defenders, lawyers and other frontline respondents. This level of increased coordination. really reflected on the type of the messages that public donors and private donors are receiving. And so it continues to shape their priorities. It continues to create pressure on public and private donors. So as long as we were able to keep our voices on the importance of providing additional resources or just the deserved resources, that's by itself is a success. And how are we adjusting to that? We are trying to change our operational modalities. So rather than spending on, you know, premises, vehicles and other logistical aspects, we would move to towards, you know, working remotely, pro providing small resources to local stakeholders because like, you know, when you when you share a small amount of money, it means a lot in the field. And so if we were able to continue that small amount, it's about the continuity. Also, it's about establishment of different cash delivery mechanisms. There are too many private donors and private sector organizations who continue to work with some public donors, money as public donors in providing humanitarian assistance through establishment of consortium of cash delivery mechanisms, of rapid response mechanisms, early warning system. And so on so these these systems are now in place. They are trying to uplift some of this burden on the development work. And I think also now the tendency to rely on private foundations, on academic institutions is also something that we are trying to shift to to to. And also when you look at humanitarian, we I I don't do humanitarian, we don't do humanitarian, but we know that there are still international donors who are pledging humanitarian support. And so if we were able to establish locally informed humanitarian mechanisms that is n humanitarian slash development, where it could establish that nexus, I think that also would provide a space where the people could utilize some of this humanitarian support, despite the humanitarian fund are very now very much dwindling, but still. I think that's also something we're trying to to to adopt or to utilize for now. Sherif Mansour: Thank you. Another question I asked my guest last time and it has to do with how Sudan is forgotten as a crisis, but also there is a lot missing about how the international community and the media coverage of what's happening is missing. Can you tell us from your perspective, what are people missing about what's happening? and what's important to focus on and who helps deliver those messages or those voices where it matters. Maha Tambal: Yeah, of course. I think Sudan crises are now, I think, coming in the fourth place, I would say, after Ukraine, Gaza, Iran and so on. but I think if you look at it from multisectoral perspective, first of all, Sudan as a country, it is unique. Geographic location, it resembles a level of entanglement where You can see why Sudan would matter to regional and international stakeholders and actors, just because of its geographic location. that could be the incentive where we need to utilize. Now, when you look at international venues like the UN General Assembly, like you know, the policy-making venues in the US or in the EU or in UK. Sudan is not a priority, so the question is what we need to do to ensure that Sudan is on top of their agenda. I think it's just it's about demonstrating the incentive. Like if you if you ask like a pol a US policymaker, they would say, Why would Sudan matter to US? I mean, you really need to make sure that your message is reflecting aspects related to the national security importance, the economic incentives. the commerce incentive, right? So I think what we need to do is we need to understand what level of incentives that we need to represent to stakeholders so that it could attract their interest. And it's not only about incentive but also about making your demand reasonable or doable. I mean you need to come up with a comprehensive proposal. If I was able to market Sudan crisis to stakeholders in the US or in the UE or in the EU sorry they believe that okay so that matters now. So what we need to do, we need to come up with a comprehensive package to market the whole problem. Why you need to to step in this, what cost will cost you to intervene in this? If they would ensure that their gains are higher than costs, you know, and if they would ensure that this won't impact their relationship with their allies in the region their national security priorities. So why not? Why not to give it a shot? So I think it's all about really agreeing on on a model for where we can market Sudan crisis. We need to have this model. This model should be flexible model where you create incentives, you show the cost, the gain, the losses. So that answers the question for why it matters. Once we get that answer, we could get some support. And now we see that I think the EU is now recognizing they will need to do some some more work on that. Even the US special advisor on the on the Middle East, Musat Polos, was just, you know, making some statements yesterday on humanitarian truths, on on a ceasefire process and so on. I think they started to re to realize the cost of continuing the conflict in Sudan is higher. For even for them, even for like the US people who are just sitting in Miami or in California minding their own business, they started to feel in the closure of Hurmuz, the Strait of Hurmons. What does that mean for the oil prices in here in the US? If they could be able to use Babel Mendab and the Red Sea, they will need to ensure this area is secured. And how would I ensure the security of this area is when Sudan is stabilized and when the whole region is stabilized? So It's it's a very connected chain of economic and security interests that we really need to understand, we need to analyze, we need to map, we need to create that incentive for everyone. Sherif Mansour: Thank you for raising the regional aspects and specifically right now what we see is the increasing role of Arab countries and Ethiopia in kind of using Sudan as a place where they settle their conflict. And I think if anything, a regional look should also include where The region can help Sudanese people with examples of resilience and success. And one of the things we discussed in the Sudan initiative was an Arabic model for accountability. Is there anything that you have in your work that you've seen lesson learned that also can be shared, not just? politics and negotiations to build people power. Maha Tambal: Yeah. So I think this is like a very I would say it's a it's a it's it's it's a complex question that has different elements but they they could meet in the middle. When you look at the role of external actors in Sudan, now given the so fragile political system in Sudan, it created the space like in the in the past three or four decades, Sudan has been a place for regional actors to demonstrate their geo geopolitical hegemony and demonstrate like a a route for them to access the depth of Central and West Africa, always Sudan is a gate to do that. And so now these regional actors not only engaged in activities that increase their geopolitical hegemony, but also they are engaged in economic activities. the s it's resource smuggling and they are just doing this and they continue to be out of accountability. So if we really didn't understand how much these regional actors are sabotaging the economy, the local economy, and how much gains that they are making out of their engagement in resource smuggling, in illicit financial flow, in many in money laundering. In even facilitating weapon trades, in covering up human rights violations, they are engaged in this all these issues. Now they have incentive. They continue to engage in these activities. Now the question is: are we gonna disengage them? Is accountability enough to disengage them? And when it comes to accountability, are we only speaking about Accountability for perpetrators inside Sudan who are involved in facilitating the role of external actors in smuggling, money laundering, and so on. Or we are seeking accountability for every perpetrator across the region. So I think these are the questions we need to discuss. So now given the political realities, those external actors are protected by great powers. And so That makes their the aspect to hold them accountable is so limited. It doesn't seem unfortunately it doesn't seem realistic. They would always find their way through a political bargain or a political deal. So now if we wanted to have a ceasefire, a like a permanent ceasefire, where we can tell external actors like, hey you guys, you need to keep your hands off Sudan. stop facilitating trade weapons, stop funding or financing these activities, legitimize or legalize your involvement in resource extractions and money laundering makes them accountable by law. If we were able to come into that agreement, that's well and good. That's part of it. Now we need to look at the accountability side of it. Now when you look at corruption for instance, we have been working on Corruption as a driver for conflict in Sudan. This conflict emerged in April twenty twenty three between two generals who were very good allies, but their political and their economic rivalries they just conflicted and they were able to gain support from regional actors. They gave them the money, the power, the weapon and everything. So how how are we gonna hold those stuff accounts those people accountable? That's the question. as I said, we were delivering this project where we are trying to identify accountability venues for corruption perpetrators for their engagement in human rights violations. So the thing is there is evidence connection between money laundering, resource smuggling, and human rights violations. And so that evidence is some of this evidence are really admissible evidence before international accountability mechanisms and systems. And so if we want to bring if we we couldn't have a durable peace solution where we can bring justice to victims without addressing the accountability issue. We just we can't do it. It's it's their rights. Victims they have the right for justice. And justice means accountability. Now the question is are the political powers, either the Sudanese political powers or Siberian powers or regional powers who are working on bringing a solution to Sudan, are they willing to include accountability at this stage or not? Is accountability gonna be part of of a political bargain or a political negotiation so that conflict perpetrators will find a safe exit in return of you know stopping the war and so on. I think we need to ask these questions and even victims they will really need to know their options. I can't imagine a woman who lost her kids or lost her husband in Darfur or in Kurdufan. They just tell her that, you know, the people who did that to you, they get their their way safe and now you need to go back home and to just to live your life normally. This can't happen. So it's it's it's a question about the willingness of everyone involved. in stabilizing situation in Sudan. And unfortunately, if the history is telling us anything, perpetrators always find their way to get away from accountability. And so the question is are we as part of a durable humanitarian truce, are we willing to discuss mechanisms for civilian protections? Because civilian protection could be the make the broad mechanism where accountability could be part of The negotiation. Are we willing to do that? Are there any resources to do that? Like, is the international community really willing to establish civilian protection mechanism? You know, these are UN mechanisms. They need a lot of money, they need political will, they need a lot of preps. are we guaranteeing that like the fact-finding mission or any other accountability mechanisms will be part of that? These are the questions we need to ask, and these are the questions we need to answer. And so do we need to do some reform for certain accountability mechanisms? Are like are we confident? Do we trust these mechanisms? What the history is telling us, what the experience is telling us, what the evidence suggests. So yeah, I think these are the questions maybe we need to think about. Sherif Mansour: Thank you, Maha. I think I do want to take a lot of your time. We have five more minutes. And Maha Tambal: Eso que Sherif Mansour: I want to give you a chance, if there was a question you expected me to ask, to answer it. And also tell us a little bit about what keeps you going and what are some of the examples that you see have real impact on people's life. if any of it is able to build on a national answer, a national agenda, like what Ilham discussed, a national agenda for women, is there a national agenda for youth or for accountability in Sudan? Maha Tambal: Well, I think what really keeps us doing what we do, I myself am a mission driven person and I believe in what I do. But when you look at I myself I'm in so inspired by the exemplary role, my colleague who is now based in Darfur in a very rural area that is called Sandikrau. I d I'm not really sure if anyone knows where that place in the map. But it's it's a very rural area in Darfur and he kept doing his work and shows every day for work. He doesn't have electricity, he need to drive like four miles to access internet so that he could show up for meetings, he have access to the online system to do the work he has to do. I am inspired by the commitment of that guy and there are millions of this guy, women, youth and men really. just believe in what they do and they keep doing it. So that's why we need to show up for them and we need to keep doing what we are doing now. when we when we are speaking about youth agenda and any accountability agenda, I I mean I'm I'm not youth, I'm not a youth person, but it's just from from my work as youth, I would say there is a representation issue. I think we need to speak about the representation issue. And By representation, I don't mean like the quota representation, quota for young women, or representation based on ethnic diversity or something. We need to come up with a more like a more vibrant or more more more robust representation criteria. So use really sh this is one of the aspects for them representation, engagement in decision making, engagement in negotiation. engagement in decision making. They couldn't, I mean, these are the people who will be leading this Sudan in future. They should have been involved in deciding what to do today because what they do today is gonna shape what they are going to be taking care of tomorrow. speaking of accountability, I think it's there is a consensus given given given our work with human rights defenders and lawyers who are working in human rights violations, I think there are some aspects related to reformation of the domestic accountability mechanism or the reformation of the domestic judiciary system. Because they collect evidence, those evidence are admissible in Sudanese judiciary system, but because the system is so corrupted and so politicized, I don't think it's it's a good venue for them to access justice. So there is a need to reform that. I think this is part of their agenda. I think also a protection is part of their agenda. They will really need to feel they are safe doing what they do. Now there is enforced disappearance, there is huge repression on them. it's part of their agenda. They will need to ensure that they have the freedom to do what they they have to do. I think also when when when we speak about protection, it's not only domestically but also The protection that guarantees them access to regional and international accountability mechanisms where they can present the cases that they are working on. but most importantly, I think the agenda they have I'm not speaking on behalf of them, but this is what we've witnessed from the work we do. they believe on decentralized leadership. so I think we need they they like this governance reformation for a decentralized leadership where they can you know share power between them as as human rights defenders, they would need mechanism to circulate power sharing between them. So I think these are the stuff they could from from the work that we have been doing, we we just witnessed those aspects. Sherif Mansour: Thank you again, Maha, for your time and for coming on this podcast. I wish you all the best Maha Tambal: Yeah, cara. Sherif Mansour: and hopefully all your projects will continue and not just survive, develop and succeed. Have a great rest of your day and weekend. Maha Tambal: Yeah, well we need we need a lot of prayers and best of luck wishes because we're barely surviving and we're just you know, it's it is the whole resources sustainability thing, but hopefully we would be able to identify additional resources to continue working with Sudanese people. Sherif Mansour: Yeah, my in Europe hang in there Shukran gazeta myself Maha Tambal: Yamuen, Yamwine. Chukran Chikran Lakshir. Yamalila.