Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / Managing the Employee Who Always Says I Need a Raise
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've covered a lot of employee types on this show, but today I want to talk about the conversation that makes most managers sweat more than any other: the employee who opens a one-on-one with 'I need a raise.' Luna: Oh, that's a tough one. I've been on both sides of that desk, and it never gets easier. Lucas: But it's also one of those moments where a manager can either build real trust or burn it down in about thirty seconds. The key is to be prepared, not defensive. And that starts with understanding what's really behind the request. Luna: Before we dive in, I'll say if today's episode gives you a useful frame for those conversations, the way we keep doing this ad-free is through listener support. So if you get something from this, you can buy us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: Yeah, that genuinely helps us keep the lights on, and it means a lot. Now, let's get into the meat of it. I read a case recently about a manager at a mid-sized tech firm who got blindsided by exactly this. An employee came in, mid-quarter, saying they needed a fifteen percent raise. Luna: Fifteen percent? That's bold. Lucas: And the manager's first instinct was to say that's not in the budget, which shut down the conversation. The employee left feeling unheard, and it poisoned the relationship for months. But if that manager had handled it differently, it could've been a real opportunity. Luna: What should they have done instead? Lucas: First, you never say yes or no on the spot. You buy yourself time to think, but you also set the frame: 'Let's talk about what you're seeing, and let's look at the data together.' That's the beginning of a constructive conversation. Luna: So the first step is to stay curious, not defensive. Ask them what's driving the request. Lucas: Exactly. And it might not be about the money at all. Maybe they've compared salaries with a friend, or they're feeling undervalued because they weren't recognized on the last project. You need to understand the 'why' before you can respond. Luna: I've seen that. Sometimes it's more about respect and recognition than the actual dollar figure. Lucas: Right. So in that case, the manager could have asked: 'What's changed for you recently?' and listened. The employee might have said they took on more responsibility or heard that a competitor pays more. That gives you something to work with. Luna: But what if they really do have a market offer? That changes the dynamic. Lucas: It does. But even then, you don't match it impulsively. You evaluate it against your comp philosophy and the employee's performance. If they're a top performer and the market rate is legitimately higher, you might make a case to HR. Luna: So you're not just saying 'we don't have budget,' you're saying 'let's look at the data.' Lucas: Exactly. And the data has two parts: the internal part, which is the employee's performance and contribution, and the external part, which is market salary data for their role and location. You want to anchor the conversation on both. Luna: Where do you get credible market data without spending a fortune? Lucas: There are free sources like salary surveys from professional associations, government labor statistics, and some job boards publish ranges. Your HR team probably has access to paid databases like Radford or Mercer. Use whatever you can, but make sure it's recent. Luna: And when you bring that data to the conversation, you need to be transparent about where the employee falls in the range. Lucas: That's the thing. If they're already at the top of the range, that's a different conversation than if they're below the midpoint. The manager needs to be honest about that, even if it's uncomfortable. Luna: So let's say the data shows they're underpaid. How do you respond? Lucas: If you have the authority, you adjust their pay. But if you don't, you commit to advocating for them with your leadership, and you set a specific timeline for when you'll bring an answer. You don't leave it vague. Luna: That's key. Vagueness kills trust. I've seen managers say 'I'll see what I can do' and then never follow up. Lucas: And the employee remembers that. On the flip side, if the data shows they're already paid fairly, you need to say that clearly, and you need to explain what they could do to earn more in the future. Luna: Like tying raises to specific achievements or skills. Lucas: Right. You might say, 'You're currently at the market rate for your role. If you want to move up, here are three things that would justify a higher salary: leading a major project, taking on mentorship, or developing a new skill that's in demand.' Luna: So you're giving them a roadmap, not a brick wall. Lucas: And that's respectful. You're treating them like a professional who can make their own choices. But you also need to be realistic about the company's budget cycles. If raises are only done annually, say that. Luna: And if it's truly impossible to give a raise right now, what's the best way to say no? Lucas: You say it directly, but you also acknowledge their value. Something like: 'I hear that you want a raise, and I appreciate the work you've been doing. Right now, I can't change your salary, but I want to make sure we set you up for success in the next review cycle.' Luna: That's honest, but it might still feel like a letdown. Lucas: It will, and you shouldn't pretend otherwise. But you can soften it by offering non-monetary benefits, like professional development opportunities, a flexible schedule, or more visibility with senior leadership. Those can be valuable too. Luna: But you also have to be careful not to promise anything you can't deliver. Lucas: Absolutely. And that's where the manager in that case study went wrong. They said 'we don't have budget' and stopped. They didn't offer any alternatives or a path forward. The employee felt like their work wasn't valued. Luna: So the lesson is to always leave the conversation with something concrete, even if it's not the raise. Lucas: Yes. And that could be a plan for revisiting the conversation in six months, or a commitment to review their job description if their responsibilities have changed. The key is to have a clear next step. Luna: You also mentioned earlier that you should set expectations early. How do you do that? Lucas: During onboarding and at performance reviews, be explicit about how compensation works. Explain the salary bands, the review cycle, and what criteria are used to determine increases. When employees know the rules, they're less likely to make unrealistic demands. Luna: And that also helps when you do say no, because it's not arbitrary. Lucas: Exactly. It becomes about the system, not about you as a manager. And that's easier for everyone to accept. Luna: So if I'm a first-time manager and someone asks for a raise next week, what's my immediate move? Lucas: Stay calm, thank them for bringing it up, and say you'd like to have a focused conversation about it. Set a meeting for within a few days, and ask them to bring their own list of accomplishments. That gives you time to gather data and them time to reflect. Luna: And then you actually have the conversation. You don't just cancel it. Lucas: Right. And when you do, you start by acknowledging their value, then you walk through the data, and you end with a clear next step. Whether that's a raise, a plan, or a timeline, you leave them with clarity. Luna: That sounds doable. It's not easy, but it's doable. Lucas: And that's the point. Managing compensation conversations is a skill, and it gets easier with practice. The more you prepare, the less intimidating it becomes. Luna: Do you have a favorite phrase to use when you need to buy time? Lucas: I like this one: 'I appreciate you sharing that with me. I want to give this the consideration it deserves, so let's schedule a time to discuss it properly.' That's polite, respectful, and it doesn't commit you to anything. Luna: That's a good one. I might use that. Lucas: Feel free. And remember, the conversation isn't a one-time thing. It's part of an ongoing dialogue about growth and value. If you're doing that well throughout the year, the raise conversation becomes just another discussion, not a showdown. Luna: So the takeaway is to be prepared, be transparent, and always give them a path forward. Lucas: Exactly. And if you do that, you'll earn their respect even when you can't give them everything they asked for. That's the mark of a good manager.