Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Promotion When Youre Already Doing the Job
Transcript
- Lucas: Luna, I want to start with a statistic that I think hits home for a lot of our listeners. A survey from the Corporate Executive Board — it's a few years old now but still cited — found that about 40 percent of employees who eventually get a promotion were already performing the duties of that higher-level role for six months or more before the title change actually came through. Luna: Forty percent — that's huge. And I bet the number's even higher if you count people who never got the promotion at all. Lucas: Exactly. That's the trap — the 'permanent interim' syndrome. You start covering for a departing colleague, or you step up during a crunch, and suddenly that's just your job now. But your title and your paycheck haven't caught up. Luna: So today's question is basically: how do you turn that informal expansion of duties into a formal promotion? Without sounding like you're threatening to walk? Lucas: Right. And the key is you have to build a case — a dossier, really — before you even schedule the conversation. Let's walk through what that looks like. Luna: Alright. So step one: what do you actually document? Lucas: You want to create what I call a 'portfolio of evidence.' Not a brag document — just a clear list of the responsibilities you've taken on that fall outside your current job description. For each one, note the impact. Not 'I led the project' but 'I led the project that increased client retention by 15 percent over two quarters.' Luna: So concrete numbers, not vague claims. And I'd add: include any people management or cross-functional coordination you've stepped into. That's often the biggest gap between levels. Lucas: Great point. Step two is benchmarking. You need to know what the target role actually pays and what the standard responsibilities are. Use sites like Levels.fyi, Glassdoor, or the Bureau of Labor Statistics for your industry. You want to walk in knowing that a senior analyst at a company our size typically earns between X and Y. Luna: And you should also find out if your company has formal promotion criteria. A lot of firms have a career ladder document — sometimes it's on the intranet. If you can show you meet the listed requirements for the next level, that's powerful. Lucas: Absolutely. Step three is timing. You don't want to ask the week after a layoff or during the final push of a quarter. Best moments are right after a successful project delivery, during performance review cycles, or when your manager is in budget planning for the next fiscal year. Luna: So you're aligning your ask with the company's natural decision-making rhythm. Makes sense. But what about the actual script? Should you say 'I'm already doing this job'? Lucas: I'd be careful with that exact phrase. It can sound like you're presenting a fait accompli — or worse, like you've been doing work that wasn't authorized. Instead, frame it as: 'Over the past six months, I've taken on these responsibilities that align with the senior analyst role. I'd like to discuss making that official.' Luna: That's a subtle but important reframe. You're not saying 'you owe me' — you're saying 'let's align expectations.' Lucas: Exactly. And then you hand them your portfolio. One page, bullet points, numbers. You're making it easy for them to say yes. Luna: But here's the thing — what if your manager doesn't have the authority? A lot of listeners write in saying 'my boss agrees I deserve it, but HR or their boss says no budget.' Lucas: That's a real risk. So before the meeting, you should ask a gentle discovery question: 'In your experience, what's the typical process for a promotion at this level? Who needs to sign off?' If your manager can't give you a clear path, that's a red flag. Luna: And if they say 'budget' — you can ask about alternative recognition. A title change now, with a commitment to revisit comp at the next review cycle. Or a one-time bonus. Lucas: Yes. But if they say no to everything — no title, no money, no timeline — then you have a decision to make. You're already doing the work. You now have evidence you can perform at that level. That portfolio is your resume for the external market. Luna: So the conversation is also a diagnostic. You're not just asking for a promotion — you're learning whether this company is a place where your growth will be recognized. Lucas: Exactly. And if you do get the promotion — congratulations, but also: don't stop documenting. Keep a running list of wins. You'll need it for the next conversation. Luna: That's smart. And I think a lot of people worry that asking feels pushy. But if you've done the work and you have the evidence, it's not pushy — it's professional. Lucas: Totally. Look, if this episode helped you think through a career move, you can support the show at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That link helps us keep the episodes ad-free and focused on real advice. Luna: Yeah, every little bit goes toward research time and production. We really appreciate it. Lucas: So to wrap up: build your portfolio, benchmark the role, time your ask, and frame it as alignment — not entitlement. And if the answer is no, you have clarity. Luna: And maybe a better resume. Thanks everyone — we'll see you next time.