Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Pressuring Therapists to Overwork, Telehealth, and Real Connections
Transcript
- 0:00So Bob emails, what do you say? Yes, So this email is
- 0:03from patron Christina who DM me on Patreon. She says, Hello, doctor
- 0:10Kirk. You talk about therapists having problems with paperwork, but you don't expand
- 0:15on that too much. I worked for a clinic that has lots of medical
- 0:20billing. I'm guessing that's like the Medicaid of California. Have you heard of
- 0:26that before? Medical? Okay? I worked for a clinic that had lots
- 0:29of medical billing requirements, and staff were not paid overtime but expected to bill
- 0:36up to one hundred percent of their work hours and incentivized to bill. Moore.
- 0:42Yeah, so let me sift through this. Okay. So I worked
- 0:45for a clinic that did lots of medical So I'm guessing the inclusion of the
- 0:50medical in there is that they're not getting reimbursed a lot for the services,
- 0:56typically from Medicare and Medicaid. And because we have legislators that don't allocate enough
- 1:03funds to reimburse mental health clinicians and other clinicians physicians for their work. Because
- 1:11we live in a country that has the most wealth that's ever been amassed in
- 1:18the entire known universe, and yet we don't give a shit about human beings,
- 1:23and we just keep funneling money into CEOs who can pay for millions of
- 1:30doctors to help millions of people, particularly we're talking about other countries, and
- 1:36we just keep voting for the same stupid politicians over and over again. You
- 1:41say it like it's a bad thing, and so anyway, so we have
- 1:46that it works for a clinic, and so what that does to a lot
- 1:49of these agencies is it strains things because they want to provide a service things.
- 1:55Sometimes they might be kind of required to provide a certain amount of service
- 1:59to a community, and so you, at least internally or externally, have
- 2:04this pressure on an agency to do a certain to have a certain amount of
- 2:07production, and then you don't pay them enough, and then what ends up
- 2:12happening is these agencies scramble to figure out how they're going to make it work.
- 2:16And one of the things they can one of the levers they can pull
- 2:20is to pressure labor to work harder, meaning that they, as Patron Christina
- 2:28is saying, is expected to build up to one hundred percent of their work
- 2:31hours. So for those who don't know, if you have forty hours in
- 2:36a week, and you work at it an ac as a therapist. The
- 2:39highest number of billable hours you could possibly eke out would I'm guessing would be
- 2:46thirty maybe thirty five out of forty, which would be pretty tough because if
- 2:51you have thirty five hours of therapy in a week, that's a lot.
- 2:54Yeah. And for people who might think, well, you know, hey,
- 2:59when I'm at my job, I'm working, I'm working all forty hours.
- 3:04Well, one, there's paperwork, but there's also a lot of meetings
- 3:08and a lot of things you have to do, especially when you're at an
- 3:12agency, there's like collaterals you have to call that aren't billable necessarily. Also
- 3:17there's going to the fucking bathroom. Like that takes time. Like one of
- 3:23the things I noticed about myself is that I'll have a day sixteen hours to
- 3:29work and I'm making content, and I'm thinking, Okay, i don't have
- 3:32anything to do, nothing's on calendar, and so I'm just going to for
- 3:37sixteen hours, I'm gonna make content. I've been doing that a lot lately,
- 3:39by the way, because I've just been trying to get a lot of
- 3:43content in the can. As they say, recorded and ready to schedule at
- 3:47a later date, and I will find that what ends up happening is I
- 3:54only end up actually getting done the amount of work that I think maybe eight
- 4:00or ten hours or to get and I think, well, what am I
- 4:02What's going on with this extra six hours? Because I feel like I'm working
- 4:06all day. But if I just observe myself, there are times when I
- 4:11might just take a break and look at a YouTube video for fifteen minutes,
- 4:15or I might want to play with the dogs for five minutes. Or I
- 4:17might have to go to the bathroom or eat lunch in there somewhere, or
- 4:23you might text me or yeah, I do that all the time, eating
- 4:26that sort of thing, or I don't know, there's a random utility bill
- 4:31that comes in and I'm like, what's going on with There's just there's so
- 4:34many things that can just get in the way. And people know this,
- 4:39But when you're a therapist at an agency, all those things happen, but
- 4:43it's within the agency. So your colleague says, oh, can you take
- 4:47a look at this, Or someone walks in with a dog and you pet
- 4:50the dog for five minutes or two minutes and you're thrown off, or there's
- 4:56a treatment plan that needs a little bit of doing, or someone stops in
- 5:00your office and socializes for five minutes, you know it. So to say
- 5:03that you're going to bill that these folks need to have one hundred percent of
- 5:10their payable hours basically means that they're saying, look, you have to have
- 5:15forty hours of billable hours, and you're going to have to figure it out
- 5:18beyond that, which probably means that they're working fifty five hours a week,
- 5:21you know what I mean. So anyway, going on, they began writing
- 5:29up people who did not and again I blame the politicians and secondarily the voters.
- 5:35These agencies are not It's not like Amazon. It's not like the CEO
- 5:41of these agencies has trillions of dollars oh and is taking a rocket into space.
- 5:47You know that the executive directors of these agencies, you know, sure
- 5:53they might have like a new Toyota or something, but these individ rules are
- 6:00not rolling in money. That tells you something about the problem. You know,
- 6:05I'm talking generally speaking. I'm sure there are some agencies where that happens.
- 6:10But anyway, so going on, they began writing up people who did
- 6:14not bill all of their time and some people lost their jobs or were pushed
- 6:17out. It is impossible work agreed. Yeah, yeah, that sounds awful.
- 6:24I mean did that around you at an agency where you were pressured to
- 6:30have a lot of billibis? Oh yeah, yeah, yeah yeah. The
- 6:33first job I got in Seattle, there was absolutely that pressure and then there
- 6:39was a there was actually a game plan about how to do it. So
- 6:43yeah. Then the second age was what was like, it was case management,
- 6:46so it's not therapy, and it was in the community, so it
- 6:49was mostly not in the office. In fact, they discouraged us from seeing
- 6:53clients in our office. We could see case management being even worse because in
- 6:58terms of billable hours, that's probably like client contact, right it is,
- 7:00And with case management there's a lot of things you're probably having to do out
- 7:05of those hours that are required to be the sort of helper that you're going
- 7:10to be when you're in person, right yep. So, but you can
- 7:13only build for this is thirty years ago, so you know it's not this
- 7:17way now. My case was eighteen when I started there. And the way
- 7:23the way they did it is if you saw it, they build by the
- 7:26quarter hour, and if you saw somebody for even two minutes of the quarter
- 7:31hour, you could build a whole quarter hour. So we would show up
- 7:34at appointments at twelve fifty eight, say for one o'clock appointment, and stay
- 7:39till two two, and we could build for ninety minutes instead of just the
- 7:43hour. And then that doesn't make any sense because it's only four minutes total,
- 7:48which would mean at the best you could rise it to fifteen plus,
- 7:53but not thirty plus. The way it worked, this is the way they
- 7:55told us to do it. This's the way it worked. And then you
- 7:58use your travel time as because the next client is at say two thirty,
- 8:03show up at eight. Now I've seen this before, and I do not
- 8:09support fraud, but I do support using the system to make it work because
- 8:15basically the case management is paid through the government. Correct, yeah, yeah,
- 8:18And so the individuals on the ground level, the labor and the managers
- 8:22of the label of the labor are saying, if we actually follow the payment
- 8:31schedule that the government and the legislators and supposedly the voters want, then we
- 8:37will not be able to do our jobs. So the only way to make
- 8:39this work is to fudge the numbers. So we have to over We have
- 8:43to over bill to actually get you paid so that you can actually get enough
- 8:52money to get through your life and also have a little bit extra time,
- 8:56because you know, if you bill for an hour and a half, for
- 8:58an hour or four minutes, that gives you twenty six minutes to do all
- 9:03the other things. It's not like you use that twenty six minutes to go
- 9:05to the casino. You were doing work, but it just wasn't considered billable
- 9:09because the legislatures didn't designate that as billable time. Because you know, just
- 9:13imagine that. You know, the government will designate that is billable, but
- 9:20that is not the government. I'm telling you people, they designate that,
- 9:24and they're doing it today. And when you have legislatures and also you have
- 9:31the voting public who ignore mental health and deprioritize it, and then you have
- 9:37whole political parties that also do the same, then you get squeezed out as
- 9:41labor. The easy solution is you just say, well, not only is
- 9:46your client time billable, but also other time that you spend away from clients
- 9:50that is in the service of the client. Because we all understand you don't
- 9:54have to be in front of a client, especially as a case manager.
- 9:56I mean I would assume most of your hours as a helpful case manager or
- 10:00were not in front of the client. It was talking to collaterals and building
- 10:03plans for them and connecting them with other people and figuring out how to solve
- 10:09their problems, you know, and networking yourself. So you know anyway,
- 10:16But so you were So was it a hardship pre you at the time?
- 10:22I was twenty how old? Same? I was twenty five years old.
- 10:24I had a lot of energy, okay, and I just gained it.
- 10:28Do you did your colleagues get upset about it at all? I think we
- 10:33all grumbled about it to a degree because it was it was constant pressure and
- 10:37it only got worse. Right, So you started with you when you got
- 10:41hired, there was a certain amount of hours that you probably could work in
- 10:46a week, say forty hours, right, and then the pressure comes up
- 10:48and now you're probably working forty five but being paid the same. Yeah,
- 10:52and then they put more pressure. Now you're looking at maybe forty eight hours,
- 10:56and it sucks because you're one overworking yourself during those forty eight right,
- 11:03But also you're probably having to do things that you wouldn't do normally if you
- 11:09were actually trying to help the clients, because you're now you know, Like
- 11:11one of the things that I would see is people would like force their clients
- 11:16into the office when they wouldn't have a you know, like say the contract
- 11:22states that if they get the clients in the office for five hours, they
- 11:24can build for all five of those hours, right, But the clinician,
- 11:28left of their own devices, would say, well, we only need three.
- 11:31But the therapist would be like, but I'm gonnet fired if I don't
- 11:35get them in the office. So there'd be all these like game playing from
- 11:39the therapist standpoint of just like, well, well how about you guys.
- 11:43God, this is all flooding back to me. I remember hearing colleagues talk
- 11:46about how I never had to do this, but I would hear colleagues talk
- 11:48about how they would they and they would give advice to each other. I
- 11:52remember there was this, you know, circle of therapists going here's what I
- 11:56do, And one therapist is like, what would I do? Is I
- 11:58have the kid come into my office do their homework and then I just do
- 12:01my paperwork and my client is in the office, And it totally counts.
- 12:05Yeah, I mean it's silly. Yeah, it's criminal. I mean you
- 12:09might as well not even bother having the kid come in because they're not getting
- 12:13anything that they need to get. You might as well just lie about it
- 12:16because well, so then you have that too, right, which essentially,
- 12:20when you have sixty four minutes of work and you bill for ninety's that's lying.
- 12:26Oh yeah, no, for sure, it was all gamy. And
- 12:30then the second job, I just I learned how to do the paperwork in
- 12:33such a way that it was minimally the paperwork was one of the it was
- 12:39minimally intrusive. I could kind of whip through it and know what I could
- 12:41pay attention to and what I could, you know, ignore, essentially.
- 12:46And my caseload, let's see, was twenty five. No, I actually
- 12:52don't remember what my case was, but it was still high pressure. I'm
- 12:58sure it's worse now. So you were a therapist at an agency and your
- 13:03first thought in your memory is that you had to have at least twenty five
- 13:09hours of client time that in that in those forty hours, Yeah, which
- 13:13is I think it's way worse now, but oh, I'm no doubt it's
- 13:18worse I don't know, it must be very hard to advise. Yeah,
- 13:20I would supervise interns who I think it was like thirty five. Yeah.
- 13:28Can you imagine when you're an intern. Yeah, because on paper, it's
- 13:31to the to the you know, to the politicians who run this show.
- 13:35It sounds reasonable. It's like, well, you're seeing thirty forty hours.
- 13:41You're a therapist, right, so that's all you do, so you have
- 13:43thirty five hours, you know, And the other thing is mental capacity.
- 13:46Oh yeah, Like when I was in private practice and I was seeing twenty
- 13:52five, twenty seven clients a week, it was hard mentally. Yeah.
- 13:58I mean I had time because I was a private practice, but it came
- 14:01to my house. So yeah, technically, I guess I only worked and
- 14:05I, you know, I've got my paperwork down pretty quick. So say
- 14:09I worked twenty eight hours a week and I didn't take on clients or it
- 14:13wasn't referred clients. Clients had come to me that needed a lot of case
- 14:16management outside. So I was basically just doing therapy in a little bit of
- 14:20paper. But it felt like I was working sixty hours a week. Yeah
- 14:24it is, yeah, yeah, it's there is a capacity problem. Yeah,
- 14:28so if you're forced to, you know, bill forty hours or see
- 14:33forty hours of forty hours of therapy, you probably by by hour twenty two
- 14:39that's Wednesday. Yeah, you're probably pretty much cooked. Yeah. Like an
- 14:43analogy to this that just popped into my head was I before I was a
- 14:48therapist, I worked at a shoe store foot locker for those familiar, at
- 14:54Westlake Mall in Seattle, and it was a terrible job. But the analogy
- 15:00is, if you know in retail, imagine if from the minute you showed
- 15:07up at work until the minute you left, customers are constantly coming at you
- 15:11and asking you to do something. You know, in foot locker, I
- 15:15would have been like, I want to see these shoes. And there's a
- 15:16line of people and there's literally no break, right. I mean, maybe
- 15:22technically you can go to the bathroom if you need to, and maybe there's
- 15:24a lunch break in the middle, But every second of your workday is spent
- 15:30doing even if it's a fairly mundane thing like selling shoes shoes and helping customers.
- 15:35Being a therapist, when you are sitting in that seat as a therapist
- 15:39for your client, you have to have all guns of blazing. You can't
- 15:43sit back. You have to be constantly paying attention and thinking, and sometimes
- 15:48it gets very emotionally draining and difficult, you know, because that's the gig,
- 15:52and it's not okay, you know, in terms of Einsteinian space time
- 15:58continue. Yes, it is a it is an hour of work if you
- 16:03clocked it, but it's not the same as you know. It's another analogy.
- 16:08You would be like, imagine if you were an auctioneer or some kind
- 16:11of uh person who gives ted talks or something. Oh and you you're a
- 16:18you give ted talks and inspirational speeches. Oh yeah, and you that's your
- 16:23job and that's and so you work forty hours a week. Okay, Well,
- 16:26obviously if we could cram in uh, you know, audiences that sort
- 16:30of rotate in and out of your ted talk arena, then you could do
- 16:34that for eight hours a day, four or five days a week. Right.
- 16:37And the person's like, uh no, no, after an hour and
- 16:44a half, I'm dead, Like my brain can't do anymore. That's what
- 16:48they're It's not maybe that bad, but it's in that direction. Oh,
- 16:51it's in that direction. Now your brain is working so hard and your heart
- 16:56is often working so hard that there's only so much you can hand. And
- 17:00I you know, it's a paternalistic idea as well, just like well,
- 17:03it's just talking, so you know, it's not hard like man's work like
- 17:07finances and brick laying. Yeah, that's real work. That's tiring, like
- 17:11you're just sitting there just lazy work, you know. And yeah, but
- 17:17first, Bob, we need to take another break, because this is going
- 17:18on all along. What do you say, it's take a break. Let's
- 17:21take a break. Gave her back from the break. Yeah, So that's
- 17:29the landscape that Christine is talking about. Yeah, and she's saying it's it
- 17:33is impossible work. So her question is about it is about paperwork. So
- 17:40she because she's like, how do I manage that now that I'm getting this
- 17:45pressure? I think basically what she's saying, if she's working in California,
- 17:48you know, forty hours a week, she's seeing clients forty hours a week,
- 17:53and then that means, you know, but she has ten minutes in
- 17:56between every client, right, so or five minutes, and so wouldn't it
- 18:00be nice if you could actually just get all of your paperwork done in that
- 18:04time? And you know, I don't know what Christina is saying as possible
- 18:08that in with the medic house system, they actually do pay for collateral contact
- 18:14and stuff. You know, so maybe it's not forty, But the point
- 18:17is that how do you get your paperwork time down? So our questions are,
- 18:21do you have any resources that can help therapists document more efficient more effect
- 18:25efficiently. Yeah, there are books that you can buy, workbooks that you
- 18:32just just google on Amazon or you know, any bookstore about therapist note taking
- 18:37guides. There are some pretty prevalent guides that I've used in the past,
- 18:42and you know, they're pretty broad. Have you seen these kind of guides
- 18:47before? But they definitely do give a direction to me. The best thing
- 18:52you can do is have a mentor that actually does the work that you're doing
- 18:55within the system that you're doing. Because for me, that's what I when
- 19:00I would help, you know, I knew the system of my mentees and
- 19:04my superviss whether it's private practice or an agency, and I would go through
- 19:11it line by line, you know, because it's changing sometimes, you know,
- 19:14the online forms that they have to fill out, and I would just
- 19:17go line by line. I'd be like, Okay, that box right there.
- 19:19You're putting in way too much information that you could cut that down to
- 19:25literally a phrase if you wanted to. That box needs to have that in
- 19:29it. That drop down menu will always be this, So don't just click
- 19:34that always. Don't think about it too much. Also, in the beginning
- 19:40of your career, everything takes longer because you don't know what the fuck you're
- 19:44doing. Yeah, Like when I started out and I would come to diagnosing
- 19:48a client, I would have to start from scratch as I was sitting there
- 19:52after the session. Now I can diagnose people in thirty seconds in the beginning
- 19:56of the first session, depending on what it is. You know, not
- 20:00a personal ice or but you know, because I'm always talking with them about
- 20:03medical necessity and insurance and stuff, and so in the very beginning, I'm
- 20:08not always talking and saying I always talk with them right up front so that
- 20:12we know that we can actually bill so that they don't have to pay out
- 20:17a pocket to the insurance company. I don't use insurance anymore, but back
- 20:21in the day, it's been a lot of time since I had to new
- 20:23clients. So anyway, point is is that I would have those conversations and
- 20:26if you're working in a place like this, that would be something you would
- 20:30do. And in the beginning of my career it would take me weeks to
- 20:36it to diagnose someone confidently. And now you know, you learn and you
- 20:41hear certain things the client says, and then you know not to go down
- 20:45roads. You can narrow down on it much faster, you know, And
- 20:51so that's another issue. But yeah, I find a mentor in your area,
- 20:56in maybe even your agency and say how long is it taking you to
- 21:02write a progress note or something or a treatment plan? Right, find the
- 21:06person that has it down very quick and say can I just watch you do
- 21:10it? Or could you give me some tips? That sort of thing.
- 21:15Also going on, why are there such requirements for billing and documentation? Well,
- 21:21I think I've already been over that. Do you have any huge amounts?
- 21:23Do you have any huge amounts for your private practice? Or do other
- 21:26therapists have this problem? Bob? What do you think huge amounts of documentation?
- 21:30Like? Yeah, problems? Yeah, No, describe what it's like.
- 21:34A progress note takes less than three minutes to write. I know you're
- 21:38faster than me. I think about you all the time and I am writing
- 21:41out my words now use you use pen and paper. I do use pen
- 21:45and paper. I can't type much faster than that anyway, But with typing
- 21:49on computer you can copy on paste. Because there are certain phrases, there
- 21:53are certain phrases with clients that, especially after seven years, it's not likely
- 21:57that we're you know, having a completely mind blowing you know, we can
- 22:03have mind blowing things in the session, but in terms of like what we're
- 22:06working on, it's not new. Yeah, you know, we've been working
- 22:10on that for a while, so you know, like the initial sentence could
- 22:12be so anyway you can save time, but three minutes is great. But
- 22:15anyway, go on, go on, And basically it has these criteria the
- 22:19date, how much they paid, who was there, and then what did
- 22:25they talk about? What did we do and how did it help or that
- 22:30it was helpful? So what'd be an example of that note? So what
- 22:36would it sound like? So John and Carol are present, we're present.
- 22:40These are fictional people. Yeah, yeah, yeah, I don't know John
- 22:42and Carol are. I'm sure they're love me. They wanted to talk about
- 22:47and the closer you get to John, he's kind of a dick. It's
- 22:49true because in this session. You know what he did. He's like trying
- 22:52to control the purse strings. You know. So like me and John,
- 22:56we didn't come to fisticuffs. But okay, so how do you describe that?
- 23:00Yeah, John and Carol came in or present. They wanted to talk
- 23:03about their financial arrangement. We discussed in terms of the attachment insecurities or meanings
- 23:10that are I might say insecurities, I might say meanings, I might say
- 23:12longings. That word can shift their attachment longings or meanings. And they indicated
- 23:18that this was helpful. That's it. That's it. That's great. So
- 23:23anything beyond that, it's you're either spinning your wheels or you have a bad
- 23:30supervisor that is pressuring you to do too much for no reason. It shouldn't
- 23:34have to be anything more than that. And unless it's suicide or whole,
- 23:41then you're writing pages potentially and you do it in session. That's what I
- 23:47do, like if I have a client that is suicidal, because it also
- 23:51helps me to make sure that I'm crossing all my t's right. That would
- 23:55so like, okay, so what you're saying is this, I need to
- 23:57write this down to make sure I got it. So okay, going on.
- 24:03Yeah, in private practice, for me, my notes I could take
- 24:07them. I also had my own system of taking when it was on the
- 24:11computer, so I could copy and paste some things. But also I type
- 24:15faster than I write. Also, I with my system, it wasn't one
- 24:22of those online systems. You know, the online systems. You click on
- 24:26the button, it takes about three seconds for it to load, you know,
- 24:29every time you do it. It takes a while you type, there's
- 24:32a number of boxes you have to fill out. Whereas for me, I
- 24:34streamlined it to you know, fit my taste such that I could. I
- 24:38could do it all the things like indicate the time and the charge and who
- 24:42was present and the note and potentially treatment plan comments I could. I can
- 24:49do it very quickly within the same field of view, if that makes any
- 24:53sense. Yeah, but I understand that for some people they have to exist
- 25:00in a certain system and by default, even if I were involved in that
- 25:04system, it would take me like five times longer because you have to click
- 25:08on this button and wait for that the load and deity. So yeah,
- 25:14well, the things that you get asked aren't the things that you have to
- 25:15document when you're in private practice. Yeah, like there's so much more that
- 25:19has to be justified or documented or whatever it is they do. I don't
- 25:22even know anymore, but yeah, so yeah, another thing to know for
- 25:27yourself is what's the landscape. Because you're writing the note. You know,
- 25:37we can assume you're writing a note for the client, that the note is
- 25:40for you and the client, but so many of us are writing the note
- 25:45for some other entity like an auditor or a supervisor, and of course they
- 25:49are overseeing the note that is used for you and the client. But so
- 25:55many times novice clinicians and otherwise they completely lose sight that an agency side of
- 26:00that, that the only reason why you're writing the note is for the auditor
- 26:06so that you can make sure that you continue to get a designation as a
- 26:10licensee or a certified provider for medical and thus you can you can still make
- 26:15your money because because these agencies you know, government agencies, WI occasionally audit
- 26:21uh uh, you know, mental health service agencies, and if you are
- 26:25out of compliance, they will pull contracts or penalize or something, and then
- 26:29your entire business goes out of business. And so the anxiety is there such
- 26:37that people start orning toward orienting towards the auditors. Okay, fine, what
- 26:41are the auditors looking for? What sort of requirements? What criteria are they
- 26:47following. If you don't know what that is, then people write everything because
- 26:51they're they're thinking, well, I don't know what I should be writing,
- 26:53so I'll write everything. The other person you should be getting to know their
- 26:59quirks and whatever is your supervisor or your boss, because that person has all
- 27:03the power over you. The auditor is a distant entity that will come into
- 27:07your life every once in a while, and technically your supervisor is actually responsible
- 27:11ultimately for that. So if ednyone would gets in trouble, it would be
- 27:15the supervisor potentially for not guiding you about this. But so I'd get to
- 27:21know your supervisor and what do they want. And it's possible that your supervisor
- 27:25is stupid, and in the case of that, you know, do your
- 27:27own research and maybe figure out and be like, So, I'm trying to
- 27:30save time because of this whole hundred percent thing, and I'm thinking I might
- 27:34be able to scale back on this or do what I did. I just
- 27:38scaled back my notes until someone yelled at me. I did this when I
- 27:42worked at an agency. I. You know, it was anxious. In
- 27:47the beginning. I would write a lot, a lot, and I was
- 27:48like, this is if I'm going to do this the rest of my career.
- 27:52This is miserable. So so I was like, I wonder if I'll
- 27:56get away with this, this this level of conciseness. And I did that
- 28:02for a couple of months, and all my at this agency, all of
- 28:06my notes were read thoroughly. It wasn't just a signing like it was required
- 28:11by a whole It wasn't just my supervisor, as a whole bunch of people,
- 28:15including the government stuff, would have to read everything. And I got
- 28:19no feedback. So I was like, Okay, let's see if I go
- 28:22a little bit more concise. No word more concise, No word more concise.
- 28:29Then there was a word, but it wasn't very pointed, and I
- 28:33was like, I wonder if I went even more concise. And then I
- 28:37basically learned that the word I was getting wasn't really a requirement, it was
- 28:45more an observation. And eventually I had a reputation for being very concise in
- 28:49my notes, which was appreciated by some and lamented by others, But ultimately
- 28:55nothing happened to me. So guess who won? Me and the client?
- 29:00I guess also, but me, I win because I saved all that time.
- 29:03And I also knew that they wouldn't fire me over it. So I
- 29:08don't know if everyone would know that, But I don't know. That's just
- 29:11kind of my style. Like it. It's like I'm not getting any clear
- 29:17answers from people, so let's just run some tests and see what happens.
- 29:22It happens anyway. Going on, Also, would you ever do a show
- 29:26on the impact of telehealth and the quality of services provided? Well, Bob,
- 29:30you're the expert on this in this room, so what are your thoughts?
- 29:33It works, it's not as good as in person. I don't have
- 29:37an office to see people in anymore. I let it go because I never
- 29:41go there. You have a home office, but you don't see clients physically.
- 29:45You couldn't do physical in person therapy if you wanted to at this point
- 29:49because the way my house is set up and it would interfere with Colleen's private
- 29:53life. So yeah, yeah, so we can't. But I have fantasized
- 29:59about putting an office in my backyard and have taken an informal poll. I've
- 30:03asked six or seven of my people, you know, if you could see
- 30:07me in person, would you want to? All of them said no,
- 30:11that they might like to do it occasionally, but the inconvenience of having to
- 30:17travel and that what they were doing they believed was sufficient. So and I
- 30:22happen to think that's true. If I didn't think it was sufficient, I
- 30:25probably go deliver pizza because everybody. Yeah, you have a lot of integrity
- 30:30and personal pride in your work. So if you're doing one hundred percent online
- 30:36and your practice is full, so you have like, how many clients do
- 30:40you have? Probably about thirty five how many hours a week, somewhere between
- 30:48twenty and twenty six, and that's it. I think that's a pretty common,
- 30:53robust private practice, especially couples. Most of your clients are couples.
- 30:56That's a lot more taxing than individuals. Right, So, yeah, I
- 31:00don't want to. I would want to do more. In fact, I
- 31:03would not want to do more. Now, I have a friend who,
- 31:08after the pandemic went back to seeing people almost exclusively in person, and I
- 31:18don't know, I mean, that's that's that's true. That's that's the thing
- 31:21I just saw my friend yesterday. I mentioned her earlier. She it's all
- 31:26virtual. She does she does DBT, she does it all virtually, so
- 31:30her group and her you know, one on one clients. Do you think
- 31:33it has impacted the quality of service? Yeah? So I think it's less
- 31:38because do you have less data? Do you have then there's a vibe that
- 31:42you can't get, like like with couples, I can't see what they're doing
- 31:47below their chests, so I don't know if they're holding hands. I don't
- 31:52know what's happening. So, you know, it's less data. And every
- 31:56now I'll be talking to them and they say, well, which one you
- 32:00talking to him? I'm like, oh, yeah, you can't read my
- 32:01mind. And you don't know where I'm looking because I'm just looking, you
- 32:04know. They see a face on the screen is all. So I have
- 32:07to yeah, sorry about that. Do you ever have to tell them to
- 32:09position the camera more better? So you could, because you know, the
- 32:15common way that people do this is they take their laptop and they put it
- 32:19on the coffee table right and they sit on the couch. And the way
- 32:23that the camera is and the angle and the lighting I find to be a
- 32:29very poor representation of the human being on the other side, you know,
- 32:32like a better angle, as if they can stack a bunch of books and
- 32:37put the laptop on top of that and maybe sit at like the dining table
- 32:43or something. Do you ever have to do that for people? My big
- 32:46problem I don't do that. But my big problem is sound quality. Like
- 32:51the microphones that are built into computers aren't very sensitive, so well, it's
- 32:55a trade off because if they're sensitive, then they pick up every everything,
- 33:00right, so I can't hear what people say when their voices get soft.
- 33:04And you know how people talk to each other, They talk to each other
- 33:06softly sometimes, and that's like totally appropriate. So lately, they could wear
- 33:09earbuds, but you'd have to have two sets of earbuds, which I don't
- 33:15think computers allow, but they should, Oh right, they could wear earbuds
- 33:20and yeah, hear them more. They would hear you easily, and you'd
- 33:22probably hear them more easily. Well, I have a very good microphone,
- 33:25so I can whisper and I'm heard right, but most people nobody does right,
- 33:32and so I miss stuff And I'm like, you know, can you
- 33:36I'll say, I'll say, I might say, can you can you say
- 33:38that again, I couldn't quite hear it, or I'll say, you know,
- 33:42it isn't necessary for me to hear every word. So if if you
- 33:45want me to hear it, you'll have to tell me. But if that's
- 33:49just you know, you don't have to if you don't want to. Yeah,
- 33:52it's just so interesting how I have just completely skipped this whole thing.
- 33:57Yeah, you use the phone. I use phone. Yeah. And do
- 34:00you think that you miss anything because you can't see well, yeah, obviously.
- 34:05But all these clients I've had for years and years, so I know
- 34:12their inflections and whatnot. Yeah, I don't, you know. I like,
- 34:15if I'm talking to you on the phone, I don't need to see
- 34:19you to understand you. If I don't know you, or I never saw
- 34:22you in person, then I would have no idea, I think, or
- 34:25maybe i'd get to know over time, you know. Another benefit is that
- 34:29the client could be on the phone with me and be laying in their bed
- 34:31in a dark room. They don't have to be sitting up erect you know,
- 34:37looking at a laptop. And for me, I like to pace.
- 34:42I have this little track around this office. I occasionally do phone sessions.
- 34:45I pace. Yeah, I'm a pacer, so yeah, yeah, I
- 34:51can't just stand there and talk or sit there and talk on that pace.
- 34:55So yeah, I completely just evaded because I use I would occasionally do phone
- 35:00sessions with clients if they were out of town or something, and so I
- 35:05was extremely familiar with that and just just did that. I mean even some
- 35:09of the clients that you know I had during the pandemic, I had done
- 35:15that before. So it was just a no brainer. Yeah, and yeah,
- 35:19it's just interesting to think, you know, like, because for you,
- 35:22you did you continued to do. Is it zoom or what do you
- 35:25use? Use zoom? Do you do you have like the the therapist's hip
- 35:32a compliant version of zoom I believe. So okay, yeah, I mean
- 35:38I don't know the current landscape, but I remember there was there was sure
- 35:43that at the beginning. Yeah, yeah, Okay, then for me I
- 35:49went phone. And then you have a colleague that's in person, and so
- 35:52as a as a client, you know, unless you started with the therapist
- 35:59in the beginning, and Chow was an online or an in person or a
- 36:00phone therapist, you're just as a client, You're just at your therapist whim
- 36:06in terms of what they want to do, right because the therapist your colleagues
- 36:09like, no, I forced them all to do in person, and I
- 36:14suspect a lot of them were like your clients, that were thinking, well,
- 36:17we would prefer not to because in the communities. Yeah. So in
- 36:22the beginning, and I've been studying this for a long time, this online
- 36:24tele health. I chose this as a project to investigate around the year twenty
- 36:30ten because it had already been around for a while, but it wasn't anything
- 36:35like it was today, and I thought I was going to find that it
- 36:40was ridiculous that even people were thinking about doing this, that they were thinking
- 36:45about doing it over the phone or email, or over video chat and or
- 36:50video conference. I just thought like, in terms of my principles and how
- 36:54I felt about things and my experience with phone therapy versus in person therapy,
- 37:00I just thought like this, this is stupid. But I looked into the
- 37:04research and there was enough at the time to demonstrate that online therapy telehealth can
- 37:10be just as effective. You have to be trained, and some clients might
- 37:15not be geared towards it. You know someone that doesn't work well with technology,
- 37:20you're someone that communicates in a way that you really do need to be
- 37:23in person. But you know, it's kind of like an option, I
- 37:28mean meaning it's kind of a lateral move and it really just depends on a
- 37:32lot of other factors. It's not inherently less quality. And that was surprising
- 37:37to me. And I also learned that there's a lot of ethics and standards
- 37:43of practice and competencies as a therapist that you need to have, Like you
- 37:47can't just do it. You have to learn how to do it, even
- 37:51if you've been doing therapy for a while, because there's specific things, even
- 37:55legal things, because you need to account. You know, normally when clients
- 38:00come into our office, well we make sure the office is hip a compliance
- 38:06and soundproof and safe. But for some clients wherever they're at, it's like
- 38:13you don't know, right, you can have a client that thinks I'm going
- 38:15to do therapy while I use heavy machinery or something and unless you say you
- 38:21can't do that, like that's an exaggeration, but you know something like that,
- 38:24and so there's all that, and so that was surprising to me.
- 38:30I continued to say, well, not for me from either direction, I
- 38:34don't want to be a client and online therapy, and I don't want to
- 38:37be a therapist with online therapy. Right, So then we see the pandemic
- 38:42and we see this massive shift, I mean, just a sea change.
- 38:45I can't I don't know if there's another industry that was more affected. I'm
- 38:49sure there are, but maybe no. Schools are all back in person again.
- 38:52Oh oh oh oh you mean oh permanent? Yeah, yeah, right,
- 38:54got it. Yeah, the therapy landscape is permanently changed. Yeah,
- 39:00because you're not going back to in person I think about it, but no,
- 39:04I'm not. There's a good chance you will never see another client in
- 39:07person again for the rest of your career. Here's one for you. All
- 39:09the men are five eight and all the women are five four. I have
- 39:13no idea, but in my head that's what they all are. And they
- 39:15all smell amazing. They do. So there's a chance that you and I
- 39:22know a lot of therapists that are like that. Yeah, not only because
- 39:27the clients consider it more convenient, but the therapist does too, of course,
- 39:30and it's less six you make more money as a therapist, don't pay
- 39:32office rant. Yeah, so a clients are more likely to show up,
- 39:38you know. Yeah, because of obvious reasons. So and it's better for
- 39:45the environments. You could argue pretty easily and dah dada safer because you're not
- 39:50on the roads. Did it? So? I wonder how it affected the
- 39:52traditional analysts. Good question. I don't know. Maybe they just do fun.
- 39:55I'm going to take a guess and say they were not a fan.
- 40:00Those folks, you know, just to be attracted to analysis, you're probably
- 40:04already a little bit of a luddite and you know, a stick in the
- 40:09mud when it comes to technology. So I'm going to take a guess and
- 40:13say they weren't a fan. In fact, you know Phil Cushman, my
- 40:15mentor who died tragically last year. He wasn't an analyst, but he was
- 40:22very close to an analyst and hung out with a lot of analysts, and
- 40:27he, I'm positive, was not a fan of online there, but he
- 40:31wasn't a fan of anything technologically related. He had a lot of opinions about
- 40:37it. That did he I don't know. I don't know what he did.
- 40:44I know he taught online because we had to at the university. I'm
- 40:49guessing we must have talked about it, but I don't remember he taught in
- 40:52the SID program. Yeah, all right, I'm gonna have to interrupt right
- 40:57here and take a break because we have to do that. What do you
- 41:00say, Bob, Yeah, let's take a break. All right, we're
- 41:06back from the break. So now it is interesting, as I say all
- 41:08this, because I am doing online therapy still to this day, and I
- 41:14could choose not to, but I have so few clients at this point,
- 41:21and the clients that I have, I think, and I've talked with them
- 41:25about this, that it is better for them. And like I said,
- 41:30I've had them for so long, I think it would be way different.
- 41:34I can't imagine, Bob, if I had a new client and I had
- 41:39to meet them and absorb their vibe through a webcam. I just can't.
- 41:46And now, of course, this technology is getting better. I don't know
- 41:50if you've seen some of the new stuff where eye contact as possible, Like
- 41:53one, they'll either put a camera in the middle of the screen so you
- 41:57can actually have eye contact, or AI will move your your eye your eyes
- 42:04to have eye contact, so you'll you're looking at a camera above the screen,
- 42:08but AI will move your pupils down so that it's looking straight into the
- 42:13camera. Is just completely weird. I said that backwards you're looking at the
- 42:16screen away from the camera, but then AI will move your pupils to look
- 42:21into the camera. Yeah, and it looks you know, AI is getting
- 42:23better and better, and I've seen demonstrations of it and and it you know,
- 42:29it looks real, and you know if it glitches occasionally. The benefit
- 42:34of having eye contact with your clients is so much. The benefit is so
- 42:39much. That's higher just way down deep in our DNA. Yeah. Yeah,
- 42:44yeah, So to have new clients over the phone, especially, but
- 42:51over video, you know, they'd be better than over the phone. But
- 42:55because I assume you've had a lot of new clients that you've never met in
- 42:59person, I have met most of my clients. Yeah, and you know
- 43:01they're all five eight and five four though. Yeah, but it's probably a
- 43:04lot of just lack of familiarity for me. I'm sure I'd get used to
- 43:08it to it. Yeah, And there's a way to convey feeling and communication
- 43:14and assessment through that medium, for sure. I'm not. I have to
- 43:20remind myself I don't have experience with that because I haven't had a DO client
- 43:23in five or six years. But I do worry and you even say,
- 43:30hey, I think this is this is not as high as a quality.
- 43:35Well so when you say that, do you say, like, how much
- 43:38of a lower quality? What's like why, Well, what's the consequence of
- 43:45it potentially having an average lower quality in your practice? What's the consequence to
- 43:51the clients? I think, Well, it's hard to say. I mean
- 43:55there's a couple factors. One is, if you're meeting at home versus coming
- 44:00into the therapist office, you don't have a transition. You're just moving.
- 44:05You know. Most people are like, Okay, work then therapy, then
- 44:08back to work, you know, or something like that, so there's no
- 44:12transition. Plus their kids are running around right or their cat comes in.
- 44:15Like I have a client every session their child walks into the room. I
- 44:21kind of think there must be something to that. But the child is anxious
- 44:25about something. Yeah, yeah, yeah, he's cute, little kid.
- 44:29He's like seven or something. Yeah, that's very normal. Yeah, just
- 44:32be like, I wonder how mom's doing right checking in. So you know,
- 44:37if we were in the office, they would be uninterrupted. I would
- 44:42be sitting close to them, so my proximity would be a treatment factor.
- 44:46Whereas you know, camera doesn't you know, I don't know does the body
- 44:51feel like the person is close depending on how much of them they see in
- 44:54the screen. I don't know how that works. I miss you know,
- 45:01all the cues that take place from the chest down. So if somebody knees
- 45:05degling, I don't know it. But also three D is important to our
- 45:13perception, you know, also like you of course can hear their voice,
- 45:19but it's processed through a compressor. It's delayed half a second usually, and
- 45:27it's being pumped into your ears through an artificial means, you know, a
- 45:31speaker that might be of varying quality or something right, and so you know
- 45:37there's some loss there, Yeah, there is. Yeah, So well if
- 45:40we put it into some kind of concrete form, and I could see just
- 45:45taking a number of different forms of consequence. One consequence is that instead of
- 45:52fixing your problems and nine sessions, you need ten sessions or something like that
- 45:57because of this loss of information. So it's one consequence to clients. Another
- 46:02consequence is you're never really going to get to that deeper material because it's for
- 46:09some client therapist combos, it's just not possible to go there given this other
- 46:17format. And I guess along those lines, like clients, I guess if
- 46:25we think about it from there and won't feel transformed in the way that they
- 46:30would being in person, even going to an office, right, there's a
- 46:36feeling that you feel when you walk into your therapist's space, and there's pros
- 46:40and cons to that, of course, because of course the other side is
- 46:45for some clients they're intimidated by the space and they are much more relaxed than
- 46:50able to go deeper when they're at home, sitting on their bed or something.
- 46:54But anyway, what kind of negative consequence do you think is happening to
- 46:59your clients? It's because of it. So like in terms of overall,
- 47:01I'm just therapy take longer online. I have no idea how to assess that
- 47:07are are problems not being worked on as fast because you're not assessing things fast
- 47:15enough because there's not enough information, or you're what what do you think is?
- 47:19What's the clients? I thought that was happening, I'd probably do something
- 47:22about it if I could, But I can't think of that happening. So
- 47:24you know, honestly, God, I actually can't answer this question. I
- 47:28don't know. I don't know. Maybe it's just a bias. You have
- 47:31this assumption. That's it is. It's definitely that. It's definitely a bias
- 47:35and assumption. And don't get me wrong, I love my commute. I
- 47:37just walk down the hall, right, Yeah, I always dress. I
- 47:40always wear pants. Nothing weird, right, I don't always wear shoes.
- 47:50They're assless pants, but they're still they're still pants. Pants, man,
- 47:52they count right, yeah. But but it's a but it's a bias.
- 48:00I you know, my all my training is in seeing people in person.
- 48:02Do you think it feels less warm? Maybe? Okay? Yeah? And
- 48:08is that does that have a consequence on the speed or effectiveness? I don't
- 48:15know because if anything, if I'd said something about myself personally, is I'm
- 48:17warmer than I was five years ago towards my people. So it's hard to
- 48:22know. You know, it's not apples and it's not apples and apples.
- 48:28We've talked briefly about this before. But why are you warmer now? What
- 48:32was preventing you from being warm in the past? Oh? I think just
- 48:38training. I mean you were warm in the past, but I'm not as
- 48:42training and so and hanging out with you and my personal counseling are and and
- 48:52then I got some really, really really good training when I was getting certified
- 48:57in the FT. I'd say it's a combination of all those factors that have
- 49:02slowed me down and made me more warm, and then the chipping away of
- 49:08my sense of responsibility for whether or not something happens in therapy, which is
- 49:15a chipping away, but I have chipped away at it, and so as
- 49:17a result, i'm much I say to my people, I'm cool in the
- 49:22gang. And it allowed your true self as a therapist to come out as
- 49:30a therapist. It's not like you adopted warmth. No, you were just
- 49:36suppressing it before things were getting in the way. Yeah, I'd say that
- 49:38things were getting in the way. So last week I saw this. A
- 49:42couple weeks ago, I saw this couple. They're really I love them.
- 49:44They're really lovely people, and one of them is very sort of rational or
- 49:49logical or whatever. And that's kind of his approach to his marriage is,
- 49:52you know, it's performance based, Like I'm a good guy if I perform
- 49:55well, so she's upset with me. I did not perform well. And
- 50:00they do have a big problem in their marriage that they're working on. They're
- 50:02doing great. But toward the end of our meeting, I said to him,
- 50:07do you ever have a sense of wonder anymore? And he asked me
- 50:09what that meant, and I'm like, you know, like when you're a
- 50:13kid and it's all new and you're just exploring it and you're learning whatever,
- 50:17Like, do you ever have a sense of wonder in your marriage that this
- 50:21is an area where you might be learning or exploring? And he said,
- 50:27I don't think I let her see me And that was really cool and important
- 50:32and also quite sad, but essential that he got to say and express to
- 50:40his wife, who you know, she doesn't know. I mean she's getting
- 50:45she's learning because we've been at it for a while, and that's bilateral.
- 50:51He's learning too about her. But I liked that question, and I was
- 50:55thinking when I asked him, I was thinking about that. You know,
- 50:58Goodwill Hunting. I really liked that movie. That has a nice portrayal of
- 51:00a therapy relationship. Aside from him strangling Matt Damon, Yeah, yeah,
- 51:07that aside, I've only done that twice, right, But the rest of
- 51:09it, I agree. It is one of the best depictions of a style
- 51:14of therapy that is close to you. And me, yeah, And he
- 51:17says to the kid, he's like, because he's moaning about this thing that
- 51:22happened to him that has nothing to do with their therapy. And he says
- 51:25to him, do you have a soulmate? And will says, I define
- 51:30that term? Oh oh in the movie? In the movie. Yeah,
- 51:34well, so start over what he Rob Williams says to him when he's moaning
- 51:39about this interview he had with the NSA and they wanted to hire him to
- 51:44do high level code breaking math, right, And he's moaning about why that's
- 51:49a bad idea, and he's kind of getting a little righteous, and so
- 51:52Rob Williams says to him, do you have a soulmate? And he says,
- 51:57well, define that term? And he said and mo says, someone
- 52:00challenges you. And he's like, yeah, I got Freud and Kant and
- 52:05and Kerguard and all these you know, these you know and he goes,
- 52:08well they're all dead. There's not a whole lot of dialogue with them.
- 52:13And well, yeah, I got Chucky. Well, Chucky doesn't count,
- 52:15Chuck. You laid down in traffic for you, right, Chucky's like your
- 52:19Chucky's family. He doesn't count. And they talked about, and they talk
- 52:23about this thing, but really what they're talking about is do you let anybody
- 52:27see you? Does anybody walk with you that close? We all go into
- 52:37we all go into our adult relationships with the template that we have, and
- 52:44it doesn't always include much intimacy because maybe that got discouraged, or maybe we
- 52:49had parents that were just as scared as we are, or who knows what
- 52:52I don't know. And to consider something outside of my my If you ask
- 53:04a fish what does we feel like, they just say, well, I
- 53:06don't know. It's Monday, right, But to actually consider that there's such
- 53:08a thing as air and an environment that you do not know that you might
- 53:14enjoy having never been seen, you might not know what you're missing. Yeah,
- 53:20when you tear up, are you sad for the world or for yourself?
- 53:27Both? I'm thinking about this couple's lovely people, and of course I'm
- 53:31thinking about me in the ways in which I hide from Colleen. Do you
- 53:37cry for wishing that you could be understood, safe, to be seen and
- 53:44be yourself? Well, you know it's kind of like that. You ever
- 53:46hear that Sam Kinnison joke, He's like they're all standing around Jesus on the
- 53:51cross and they're all saying, oh, poor Jesus, why does he have
- 53:52to die? And Jesus says, if you got a letter and a pair
- 53:57of pliers, right, So, Like, when I think about that,
- 54:00she's in the next room, literally and in what way could I approach her?
- 54:08And when I do, I'm often rewarded by her attention and her interests
- 54:14and care. But I'd say most of the time, I feel like it's
- 54:20insurmountable. Like the other day, I was laying in bed and I was
- 54:22upset about something in her marriage, and I said, I said, out
- 54:25loud, I exist. It seemed important just to acknowledge I do indeed exist.
- 54:30And also she's right there, like she's literally right there. So but
- 54:37that it's like she's but that undermines your trauma, as if you could just
- 54:44simply overcome it by banking a choice. Yeah, I don't think you can.
- 54:49But I do think that I way too often forego the possibility of contact.
- 54:57Yeah yeah, yeah, because I we don't need to be like lock
- 55:00step. No, you know, little space. The togetherness is fine,
- 55:04you know that's fine, But but you teared up also for your couple,
- 55:08and that it was suite of him to express that and long for that and
- 55:17long for that long time, and you want that for him? Yeah,
- 55:21I don't think he it's in his can his just his realm to consider anything
- 55:28other than I'm good enough if I perform good enough? What does it feel
- 55:31like? You know, if a client asked you, well, how do
- 55:36I know when I'm being understood and seen? What does it feel like?
- 55:40If a client asked me, how do I know? I mean, if
- 55:44a client asked you, what does it feel like? How do I know?
- 55:46You know that I've never had that before? What should I be looking
- 55:52for? And what would it what would it feel like? What benefit does
- 55:55it have? I'd probably say, hey, what do you think happens between
- 56:00us? Like? How much do I get to see you? In?
- 56:02What ways do you hide? Are there certain topics that you will not talk
- 56:06about because that's just not done, you know, like because that's a rule
- 56:09that the brain made somewhere along the way, Like in what way do I
- 56:14in? What way do I get to see you? Like? What are
- 56:17the limits? What do you perceive as the limits of our connection? And
- 56:22you know, most my people, if they're if it's not couple therapy,
- 56:27they're they're with they have a partner, and I always think, you know,
- 56:30what's happening here is going to mirror what happens in the relationship with the
- 56:32partner. So if they're a hider with me, they're going to be a
- 56:36hider with their partner. Or vice for if they're a hider with their partner,
- 56:38they're probably hiding from me too. They don't necessarily recognize it because it's
- 56:44Monday, right, But I am frequently wanting more contact with my individual clients
- 57:00and why why, Well, I like it. That's not the reason.
- 57:07I don't mean I do like it because I don't think most of us have
- 57:12a good model of what's possible. Yeah, but what's the benefit the potential
- 57:19that somebody could, as a result of learning in our efforts together, start
- 57:23to have that happen in their life. Though, I do think that there's
- 57:25something fundamentally helpful in that somebody loves you, somebody cares about you, and
- 57:31you know that I get to be that guy to the degree that they'll let
- 57:34me. But I like the idea that, oh, like my first therapist
- 57:42said to me one hundred years ago, Bob, the kind of inmacy that
- 57:45you have here with me. Now, I want you to go find that
- 57:49out there in the world. And I was like, are you fucking kidding?
- 57:52No way, you know, like that's not possible. So I was
- 57:58making a rule, was already subscrib having to a rule not useful. And
- 58:05you know, I moved to Seattle right then. That's when she said it.
- 58:07She's like, okay, go forth and across the country. And then
- 58:12we met and then I met you about what two years later, three years
- 58:15later, three years later, after you ran into an innocent Chinese couple.
- 58:20Man, oh, poor guy, oh poor people. Yeah, yeah,
- 58:27that's that's really beautiful. Thank you. I hope it inspires the listeners to
- 58:31think about that for themselves. We could all use more of that. Yeah.
- 58:36The way that the benefit that I would say, I guess is that
- 58:42I believe more and more that attachment, security, closeness, intimacy, being
- 58:51known, loyalty, dedication, long term relationships that are persistent and constant present
- 59:02not just a friend or even a spouse that is your person on paper,
- 59:07but they're literally right next to you, like for most of the time.
- 59:14That in the same way that we need water and food, we need that.
- 59:19It's not a spiritual thing. It could be, but I think it's
- 59:24a physical thing. It's harder to detect the neurological or the biological effects because
- 59:32it's more elusive. You know, when you don't have water, you can
- 59:37test this person doesn't have fluids in their veins, or their I don't know,
- 59:45their gutty works aren't working correctly or something. You know, you can
- 59:47measure those things. When you don't have food, you don't have this mineral,
- 59:52or you don't have this calorie that you can burn in certain areas of
- 59:58your body that you start to show effects. But when it comes to what
- 1:00:04you're talking about, I think it's it's just as detrimental and just as beneficial
- 1:00:12to us if we don't have it or we do. But it's it's hard
- 1:00:15to pinpoint exactly the physical effects. But there are physical effects, and they
- 1:00:24turn into chronic problems of loneliness and anxiety and isolation and conspiracy theories and suspicion
- 1:00:35of the other political party and drug abuse and workoholism and materialism and misery.
- 1:00:47And Andrew Tait, He's a toxic masculine prosthesizer, prosts, proselytizer, eleanor
- 1:01:02Rigby. That's a song about isolation, right, And I would say that
- 1:01:12the benefit is all encompassing on your biology in the same way that food and
- 1:01:15water is. So I think that's the benefit. And it feels good and
- 1:01:23it feels grounding and meaning focusing, you know, because without it, what
- 1:01:31do you focus on? You focus on whatever you whatever culture gives to you,
- 1:01:37materialism, wealth, fame, looking good, being smart, throwing the
- 1:01:47right parties, having the right point of view, having the most likes,
- 1:01:55whatever. But it doesn't feel a hole. It does not. So so
- 1:02:05you your tears are for him recognizing that he now knows that he wants it
- 1:02:13and misses it. He recognizes there's something he could be missing. Yeah,
- 1:02:16yeah, yeah, So think about it yourself, listener, where are you?
- 1:02:25What is that need? And we're all at somewhat of a deficit,
- 1:02:31I'm guessing because of our current society and lifestyle, you know, I think
- 1:02:36it was facilitated a couple of hundred even just one hundred years ago, even
- 1:02:39in other parts of the country or the world right now in the country,
- 1:02:43but you know, places that we consider to be really hard up right because
- 1:02:47they don't have cell phones or running water, and we look down to Oh,
- 1:02:53I'd hate to be in their shoes. But there is research demonstrating that
- 1:03:00although, yeah, let's try to give them running water and maybe cell phones,
- 1:03:04but the lifestyle they have looks deplorable to us with you know, they
- 1:03:09look poor. You know, there's eight people living in a small shack.
- 1:03:15There's no privacy, they poop in a hole in the ground. But research
- 1:03:21shows that a lot of these folks are happy and not lonely and don't have
- 1:03:27nearly the rates of suicide and anxiety and depression and PTSD and psychopathology and violence
- 1:03:35and anger and all those things. And you're thinking, well, why,
- 1:03:38well, because what's the difference. The difference is is from the day they're
- 1:03:43born until the day they die, they are within eyeshot and earshot of their
- 1:03:50kin, their people. I'm not saying we should ignore them and not give
- 1:03:54them medical care or whatever, but in our Western society, we've just completely
- 1:04:00lost sight of that importance, and we've been chasing this other thing that is
- 1:04:08killing us and making us miserable. And then therapy comes along to be,
- 1:04:15you know, a salve on the wound that continues to be damaged. And
- 1:04:20then telehealth comes out Oh, wow, here we go. I'm just joking
- 1:04:30and so you know, Well, let me ask you this final question over
- 1:04:38zoom. Do you feel like you can feel so you your client or your
- 1:04:44therapist that you see is that's also over online? Well, I guess that's
- 1:04:48the question when you you saw your therapist in person before. So do you
- 1:04:54feel like you can have the same deep because your therapist and you have a
- 1:04:57deep connection and you focus on in it every session? Does it feel as
- 1:05:01deep? Yeah? I think it would feel different if I was in person.
- 1:05:05I might have more fear, but it does feel deep, and I
- 1:05:09have plenty of plenty of stuff that comes up comes up? So does it
- 1:05:13help to feel less fear? Does it help your therapy to feel us fear?
- 1:05:16Oh that's a good question because you could imagine that. Yeah, takes
- 1:05:20the edge off so that you don't have to be preoccupied as much. But
- 1:05:28the con would be it's not intense enough to actually be a corrective experience,
- 1:05:30right right, Yeah, No, I haven't noticed that to be true.
- 1:05:33The corrective experiences that I have with him are as you know, I don't
- 1:05:39know how to measure that, just as robust as in person before. Yeah,
- 1:05:42I mean it's hard to know because there's a progression of the therapy.
- 1:05:45So yeah, if you're in personal old time, it might have been even
- 1:05:47more intense or something. But I think that's a that's a pretty pretty good
- 1:05:53indicatory. Yeah, because you're over zoom and you're connecting on you know,
- 1:06:00I'm going to put you in the top point zero one percent of therapy sessions
- 1:06:09in the Seattle area in terms of connection and depth and communication about emotion and
- 1:06:18humanness through a webcam without eye contact. Right. Yeah, you know that
- 1:06:25says something because in my head I'd be like, well, you know,
- 1:06:29you could do CBT over zoom, no problem, and I still believe that.
- 1:06:32But if you can do your style of therapy with your therapist over zoom
- 1:06:36and it still is as intense and deep, then I mean that's all you
- 1:06:41need to hear. Really, it just takes two people to be willing to
- 1:06:45go there. Really, as they put that's true, Well that doesn't for
- 1:06:51that episode of Psychology Seattle. Everyone out there, please take care of yourself
- 1:06:55because you deserve it.